jain.com
Public record. We host this document directly; the copy served here does not depend on any third party. Retrieved November 18, 2026.
Read the documentAlso at archive.org ↗

Hangzhou Sanuoge Trading Co Ltd v. Sportspower Ltd — Entry #1

Case: Hangzhou Sanuoge Trading Co Ltd v. Sportspower Ltd txnd · 3:26-cv-02604

filed August 06, 2026

What this document is

Docket entry #1 · filed August 06, 2026

Who is involved

Why we have it

We follow this case because it names a company we track, although that company is not a party:

A free copy from the RECAP archive of federal court filings (mirrored at the Internet Archive), retrieved November 18, 2026. Federal court filings are public records.

URL
https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.txnd.424444/gov.uscourts.txnd.424444.1.0.pdf
Kind
court_filing
Publisher
RECAP
Published
2026-08-06 00:00:00-04:00
Retrieved
2026-11-18 06:51:45.776619-05:00
HTTP status
200
MIME
application/pdf
Bytes
507994
SHA-256
4a408ffa8b6938c8ffd05bad20083ecd821aaca99e5988ea94b283fa69878402

Document text

12 page(s), 19,395 characters, converted from the PDF's text layer · plain text.

Full text
Case 3:26-cv-02604-E        Document 1      Filed 08/06/26      Page 1 of 12     PageID 1


                      IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
                      FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
                                DALLAS DIVISION

 HANGZHOU SANUOGE TRADING CO.
 LTD. aka FASHIONSPORT-OUTFITTERS,
                                                        Civil Action No. 3:26-cv-2604
                       Plaintiff,
               v.
                                                               JURY DEMAND
 SPORTSPOWER LTD.,

                       Defendant.


                                    ORIGINAL COMPLAINT

       Plaintiff Hangzhou Sanuoge Trading Co. Ltd. aka Fashionsport-Outfitters (“Fashionsport-

Outfitters”) files this complaint against Defendant Sportspower Ltd. (“Sportspower”) seeking a

declaratory judgment of patent non-infringement against U.S. Patent No. 7,909,738 (“the ‘738

Patent”).

                                      INTRODUCTION

       1.     Over the past twenty years, online retailing has revolutionized how foreign

companies reach American consumers. The rise of electronic marketplaces combined with a

dramatic increase in transport speed and improved logistic networks have allowed even relatively

small companies to compete globally. These developments have generally increased competition

and lowered prices.

       2.     An increasingly popular online marketplace is the Walmart Marketplace, where

each week more than 270 million estimated customers shop. The Walmart Marketplace helps e-

commerce sellers reach Walmart customers to grow and increase their sales.

       3.     Facing the considerable challenges of managing a growing Walmart Marketplace,

Walmart established intellectual property complaint and enforcement systems. These include an
                                             -1-


  Case 3:26-cv-02604-E          Document 1        Filed 08/06/26       Page 2 of 12      PageID 2


online intellectual property claim form for owners of intellectual property rights to report claims

of infringements as to items listed on Walmart.com, including claims of copyright, trademark,

patent, publicity and counterfeit. Walmart processes and investigates such claims and takes

responsive actions, including the removal of product listings that are found to infringe the rights

of a patent owner. When a patent infringement claim is made, Walmart notifies the accused seller

that it must provide one of the following to continue selling: a letter of authorization, a licensing

agreement, a default judgment of non-infringement, or invalidity proceedings.

       4.      In sum, after Walmart receives a patent infringement claim, it may unilaterally

remove the accused listings as a violation of their policies. Once this happens, accused sellers are

left with limited options to appeal or overturn the removal. The result is an extra-judicial injunction

that greatly harms the accused sellers with little to no chance to defend themselves on the merits

of the infringement claim.

       5.      It is against this backdrop that Sportspower reported to Walmart a meritless and

bad faith patent infringement claim against Fashionsport-Outfitters’s trampoline swing set product

(Product ID: 19260766807) (“Accused Product”), specifically alleging infringement of the ‘738

Patent, and resulting in the delisting of the Accused Product.

                                   NATURE OF THE ACTION

       6.      This is an action for Declaratory Judgment of patent non-infringement and

invalidity arising under the Declaratory Judgment Act, 28 U.S.C. § 2201 et seq., and the United

States Patent Laws, 35 U.S.C. § 101 et seq. Fashionsport-Outfitters further brings a related state

law claim for tortious interference.


                                                 -2-


  Case 3:26-cv-02604-E         Document 1        Filed 08/06/26       Page 3 of 12      PageID 3


       7.      As explained in detail herein, Sportspower is asserting meritless patent

infringement claims on Walmart, thereby causing significant harm to Fashionsport-Outfitters’

business.

                                             PARTIES

       8.      Fashionsport-Outfitters is a Chinese business entity with a place of business in

Hangzhou, Zhejiang, China.

       9.      Upon information and belief, Sportspower is a Hong Kong business entity with a

place of business in Hong Kong.

                                 JURISDICTION AND VENUE

       10.     This Court has jurisdiction over the subject matter of this action pursuant to 28

U.S.C. §§ 1331, 1338(a) because it arises under the Patent Laws of the United States, 35 U.S.C.

§§ 101 et. seq. Jurisdiction over the subject matter of this action is further provided under the

Declaratory Judgment Act, 28 U.S.C. §§ 2201 and 2202. This Court further has supplemental

jurisdiction of the state law claim of tortious interference as part of the same case or controversy.

       11.     Sportspower is subject to this Court’s personal jurisdiction pursuant to the due

process clause of the Constitution and/or the Texas Long Arm Statute, due at least to Sportspower’s

substantial business in this State and District, including: regularly conducting and soliciting

business, engaging in other persistent conduct, and/or deriving substantial revenue from Texas

residents.

       12.     Alternatively, Sportspower is subject to this Court’s personal jurisdiction pursuant

to Fed. R. Civ. P. 4(k)(2).

       13.     Venue is proper in this District pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1391(c)(3) as Sportspower

is not believed to reside in the United States and therefore may be sued in any judicial district.


                                                -3-


  Case 3:26-cv-02604-E         Document 1        Filed 08/06/26      Page 4 of 12       PageID 4


             FASHIONSPORT-OUTFITTERS & THE ACCUSED PRODUCT

       14.     Fashionsport-Outfitters is an outdoor sports brand focused on trampolines and

backyard play equipment. The company produces round trampolines in sizes from 8-16 feet with

safety enclosures, galvanized steel frames, and anti-rust features, sold primarily through Walmart,

Amazon, and its own website https://www.fashionsport-outfitters.com/. Products also include

heavy-duty metal swing sets with saucer swings, slides and basketball hoops for young children.

       15.     Fashionsport-Outfitters believes that every family deserves safe, affordable, and

exciting outdoor fun. Specializing in high-quality trampolines, Fashionsport-Outfitters design

products that combine safety, durability, and performance, making backyard play both enjoyable

and worry-free. Fashionsport-Outfitters emphasizes safety and durability in its designs, with

specifications like 36 galvanized springs, UV-resistant jumping mats, and W-shaped legs for

stability. Fashionsport-Outfitter markets itself as integrating design, production, and inspection to

deliver fashionable sports products.

       16.     Fashionsport-Outfitters further sells combined swing set and trampoline units, such

as the Accused Products (Product ID: 19260766807), as popular outdoor recreation options for

families.


                                                -4-


  Case 3:26-cv-02604-E         Document 1        Filed 08/06/26      Page 5 of 12       PageID 5


       17.     In the Accused Product, the trampoline swing set has a trampoline member H that

has its own set of legs that are totally distinct from the support legs of the swing set D1-D4.


       18.     Sportspower’s ability to use the meritless Walmart infringement notice as an

inequitable injunction significantly harms Fashionsport-Outfitters. In addition to the direct effects

of lost sales, the delisting of products immediately results in lost product reviews and product

ratings, which are all important factors in determining their listing ranking. Listing ranking is in

turn important to product visibility in consumer searches.

                          UNITED STATES PATENT NO. 7,909,738

       19.     Based on statements made in previous litigation, Sportspower is believed to be the

owner of the ‘738 Patent by assignment, although no assignment has ever been recorded with the

United States Patent and Trademark Office.

       20.     The ‘738 Patent is entitled “Trampoline Set” and generally discloses: “A trampoline

swing has a swing assembly, a trampoline assembly and a trampoline to swing connection member

connecting the horizontally oriented trampoline frame to a trampoline connection end of the swing

assembly. The trampoline swing has a top bar having a pair of apexes, namely a left apex and a

right apex. The left apex is at a left side of the swing assembly and the right apex is at the right

                                                -5-


  Case 3:26-cv-02604-E          Document 1        Filed 08/06/26       Page 6 of 12       PageID 6


side of the swing assembly. There are four main body leg supports, namely a front left leg support,

a front right leg support, a rear left leg support, and a rear right leg support. The left apex receives

the front left leg support and the rear left leg support. The right apex receives the front right leg

support and the rear right leg support. A plurality of swing connectors are mounted on the top bar.”

Exhibit A at Abstract.

        21.     The sole named inventor of the ‘738 Patent is Samuel Chen of Hong Kong. Id.

        22.     The ‘738 Patent was filed on April 11, 2008 with no priority claim. Id.

        23.     The ‘738 Patent was issued on March 22, 2011. Id.

        24.     The ‘738 Patent is expected to expire by its own terms on or around April 11, 2028.

        25.     The ‘738 Patent contains a total of 19 claims, of which claims 1 and 10 are

independent.

        26.     On or around July 31, 2009, the inventor, Samuel Chen, filed an affidavit with the

USPTO in support of his patent application of the ‘738 Patent. Therein the inventor stated that the

novel feature of the ‘738 Patent is “a trampoline swing set with the trampoline member having an

outside pair of legs and the inside legs being shared with the swing set.” Exhibit B; see Exhibit A

at Fig. 1 (shared-leg element 132).


                                                 -6-


  Case 3:26-cv-02604-E           Document 1       Filed 08/06/26       Page 7 of 12      PageID 7


                                         SPORTSPOWER

       27.     Sportspower produces and distributes outdoor play products to major retails in the

Unites States. Typical items include trampolines, swing sets, water slides, playhouses, and all in

one play centers.

       28.     On or around July 6, 2026, Sportspower, in bad faith, lodged a meritless Walmart

patent infringement notice against Fashionsport-Outfitters and the Accused Products (Product ID:

19260766807).

       29.     Therein, Sportspower identified the ‘738 Patent as the intellectual property

asserted.

       30.     Sportspower further identified a Mr. Clement Cheng as the claimant and provided

their email as <sportspower_enforce@opsecsecurity.com>.

       31.     Walmart responded by removing or delisting the Accused Products.

            CLAIM I: DECLARATORY JUDGMENT OF NON-INFRINGEMENT

       32.     Fashionsport-Outfitters incorporates by reference the preceding paragraphs as

though fully set forth herein.

       33.     An actual, continuing, and justiciable controversy exists between Fashionsport-

Outfitters and Sportspower as to the infringement of the ‘738 Patent by the Accused Products, as

evidenced by Sportspower’s allegations of infringement on Walmart, as set forth above.

       34.     Pursuant to the Declaratory Judgment Act, Fashionsport-Outfitters requests a

judicial determination and declaration that the Accused Product does not infringe and has not

infringed, either directly or indirectly, literally or under the doctrine of equivalents, any claims of

the ‘738 Patent.


                                                 -7-


     Case 3:26-cv-02604-E      Document 1        Filed 08/06/26      Page 8 of 12       PageID 8


         35.   The Accused Product does not comprise each and every element of independent

claim 1 of the ‘738 Patent. For example, claim 1 recites in part: “a pair of connectors connected to

two of the four main body leg supports of a trampoline connection end of the swing assembly.”

This element is not met in the Accused Product because in the Accused Product the trampoline is

connected to the top bar B through connectors G and is not connected to any of the four main body

leg supports D1-D4. Claim 1 expressly requires that, at the trampoline connection end, the

connector be connected to two of the four main body leg supports D1–D4. In the Accused Product,

the trampoline is connected to the top bar B through connectors G. After connection, the

trampoline is not supported by any of the main body leg supports D1–D4. Moreover, the

trampoline can be detached from the top bar B, and such detachment does not affect the normal

operation of either the trampoline or the swing assembly A. Accordingly, the Accused Product

does not satisfy the foregoing claim limitation and therefore does not fall within the scope of claim

1.

         36.   As another example, claim 1 recites in part: “a horizontally oriented trampoline

frame, supported by at least two of the four main body leg supports.” This element is not met in

the Accused Product because in the Accused Product the trampoline frame H is not supported by

any of the four main body leg supports D1-D4.


                                                -8-


  Case 3:26-cv-02604-E         Document 1      Filed 08/06/26      Page 9 of 12     PageID 9


       37.       Furthermore, the Accused Product does not comprise each and every element of

independent claim 10 of the ‘738 Patent. For example, claim 10 recites in part: “a horizontally

oriented trampoline frame, supported by at least two of the four main body leg supports.” This

element is not met in the Accused Product because in the Accused Product the trampoline frame

is not supported by any of the four main body leg supports. The trampoline frame H of the Accused

Product has its own four supporting legs and does not rely on the legs D1-D4 of swing assembly

A for support.


                                              -9-


Case 3:26-cv-02604-E             Document 1   Filed 08/06/26      Page 10 of 12       PageID 10


       38.     Because independent claims 1 and 10 are not infringed upon, there can likewise be

no infringement of any of the dependent claims 2-9 and 11-19.

       39.     Therefore, Fashionsport-Outfitters requests a judicial declaration that the Accused

Product does not infringe any claims of the ‘738 Patent.

     CLAIM II: TORTIOUS INTERFERENCE WITH CONTRACT AND BUSINESS
                             RELATIONSHIP

       40.     Fashionsport-Outfitters incorporates by reference the preceding paragraphs as

though fully set forth herein.

       41.     By lodging the meritless patent infringement claim in bad faith with knowledge that

the Accused Product does not infringe based on the inventors previous and limiting statements to

the USPTO during prosecution, Sportspower caused Walmart, who is and was in a contractual

relationship with Fashionsport-Outfitters, to delist or remove the Accused Product in error.

       42.     Sportspower knew that Fashionsport-Outfitters and Walmart had and have a

contractual relationship related to the sale of the Accused Product on the Walmart Marketplace.

       43.     Sportspower willfully and intentionally committed acts, namely lodging the patent

infringement claim in bad faith, calculated to cause damage to Fashionsport-Outfitters in their

lawful business, namely the sale of the Accused Product on the Walmart Marketplace.

       44.     Sportspower had actual knowledge of the existence of the contract and of

Fashionsport-Outfitters’ interest in it, or knowledge of facts and circumstances that would lead a

reasonable person to believe in their existence. For example, Sportspower knew that Fashionsport-

Outfitters operates and sells the Accused Product via the Walmart Marketplace.

       45.     Sportspower’s acts were the proximate cause of the harm as Walmart removed the

Accused Product in direct response to the bad faith patent infringement claim.


                                              - 10 -


Case 3:26-cv-02604-E           Document 1          Filed 08/06/26    Page 11 of 12      PageID 11


        46.     As a result of Sportspower’s actions in asserting the bad faith claim, Fashionsport-

Outfitters has suffered damages in the form of lost sales, harm to business reputation, and harm to

its Walmart health ranking.

        47.     Fashionsport-Outfitters prays for a finding and judgment against Sportspower for

tortious interference with contract and business relationship and an award of damages thereon.

                                          JURY DEMAND

        Fashionsport-Outfitters, under Rule 38 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, demands a

trial by jury of any issues so triable by right.

                                      PRAYER FOR RELIEF

WHEREFORE, Fashionsport-Outfitters respectfully request that this Court enter the following in

favor of Fashionsport-Outfitters:

        A. Preliminary and permanent injunctions ordering Sportspower to withdraw all Walmart

infringement claims lodged against the Accused Product regarding the ‘738 Patent, and to refrain

from lodging any further infringement claims or complaints regarding the same;

        B. A finding and declaratory judgment that the Accused Product does not infringe any

claim of the ‘738 Patent;

        C. A finding and judgment that Sportspower tortiously interfered with Fashionsport-

Outfitters’ contract and business relationship with Walmart and an award of damages thereon;

        D. A finding and judgment that this case is exceptional and an award to Fashionsport-

Outfitters of its costs, expenses, and reasonable attorney fees incurred in this action pursuant to 35

U.S.C § 285; and

        E. Such further and additional relief as the Court deems just and proper.


                                                   - 11 -


Case 3:26-cv-02604-E    Document 1   Filed 08/06/26        Page 12 of 12     PageID 12


Dated: August 6, 2026                         Respectfully submitted,

                                              /s/ Nicholas Najera
                                              Nicholas Najera
                                              Texas Bar No.: 24127049

                                              Ni, Wang & Massand, PLLC
                                              8140 Walnut Hill Lane, Suite 615
                                              Dallas, TX 75231
                                              972-325-2220
                                              nnajera@nilawfirm.com


                                              Counsel for Plaintiff Fashionsport-
                                              Outfitters


                                     - 12 -