jain.com
Public record. We host this document directly; the copy served here does not depend on any third party. Retrieved November 21, 2026.
Read the documentAlso at archive.org ↗

Sterrenberg v. Willow Bridge Property Company — Entry #34: MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER: The Court DENIES Plaintiff's motion for substituted service on Defendant Crystal Garvin (Dkt

Case: Sterrenberg v. Willow Bridge Property Company txnd · 3:26-cv-01419

filed May 01, 2026

What this document is

Docket entry #34 · filed September 21, 2026

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER: The Court DENIES Plaintiff's motion for substituted service on Defendant Crystal Garvin (Dkt. No. 23 ) and GRANTS Plaintiff's motion for substituted service on Defendant Sam Kennedy (Dkt. No. 21 ) as set f orth in this order. The Court GRANTS Plaintiffs motion for extension of time to serve Defendants Garvin and Kennedy. (Dkt. No. 25 .) Plaintiff shall show proof of service on all Defendants no later than November 18, 2026. Plaintiff's motion to expedite consideration of pending motions (Dkt. No. 29 ) is DENIED as moot. (Ordered by US Magistrate Judge Brian McKay on 9/21/2026) (mcrd)

Who is involved

Why we have it

We follow this case because it names a company we track, although that company is not a party:

A free copy from the RECAP archive of federal court filings (mirrored at the Internet Archive), retrieved November 21, 2026. Federal court filings are public records.

URL
https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.txnd.419112/gov.uscourts.txnd.419112.34.0.pdf
Kind
court_filing
Publisher
RECAP
Published
2026-09-21 00:00:00-04:00
Retrieved
2026-11-21 06:53:50.270672-05:00
HTTP status
200
MIME
application/pdf
Bytes
135927
SHA-256
25db97f872c330e24fe0c3c2109afcf9cc15265136cb262b68c9a5231948676d

Document text

10 page(s), 17,895 characters, converted from the PDF's text layer · plain text.

Full text
Case 3:26-cv-01419-E-BW       Document 34      Filed 09/21/26     Page 1 of 10     PageID 842


                   IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
                   FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
                             DALLAS DIVISION

 MARK STERRENBERG,                            §
         Plaintiff,                           §
                                              §
 v.                                           §           No. 3:26-CV-1419-E-BW
                                              §
 WILLOW BRIDGE PROPERTY                       §
 COMPANY, et al.,                             §
         Defendants.                          §       Referred to U.S. Magistrate Judge 1

                     MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

        Pending before the Court are motions pertaining to Plaintiff Mark

 Sterrenberg’s efforts to effect service on certain of the defendants in this case. (See

 Dkt. Nos. 21, 23, 25, 29.) For reasons that follow, the Court grants Sterrenberg

 additional time to effect service, denies his request to serve Defendant Garvin by

 alternative methods, and grants his motion for substituted service on Defendant

 Kennedy. 2


        1
         This pro se action has been automatically referred to the undersigned magistrate
 judge for case management by Special Order 3-251. (See Dkt. No. 1.)
        2
          The Court also cautions Sterrenberg as to his litigation practices. After a long
 period in which he took no action to serve any defendants in this action, he has filed
 motions for substituted service, filed supplements to one of those motions, and filed a
 motion requesting that the Court expedite its consideration of his motions. As to his
 “supplements,” the court’s rules provide for a motion, response, and reply. Sterrenberg has
 no right to supplements, notices, or other documents supporting a motion. In the event
 compelling circumstances arise after filing a motion that he strongly believes merits Court
 attention, he should either file an amended motion or seek leave of court to file the
 additional information. And he should be judicious in either of those options.

                                             -1-


Case 3:26-cv-01419-E-BW       Document 34      Filed 09/21/26     Page 2 of 10    PageID 843


                                   I. BACKGROUND

        Sterrenberg has sued the corporate owner of Loft+Row—an apartment

 complex where he and his wife formerly lived—a company that provided waste

 services at the apartment complex, and a manager at each of those companies. His

 deadline to effect service on the defendants is currently September 25. (See Dkt. No.

 20 at 1-2.) On September 10, Sterrenberg filed a motion to extend his deadline to

 show proof of service stating that he has yet to serve Defendants Crystal Garvin and

 Sam Kennedy despite diligent efforts to do so. (Dkt. No. 25.)

        Sterrenberg also requests court authorization to serve Garvin and Kennedy by

 alternative means. (Dkt. Nos. 21, 23.) He states that he has retained a processes

 server who has been unable to serve either of these defendants in person and has not

 effectively served them through certified mail.

                               II. LEGAL STANDARDS

 A.     Deadline to show proof of service

        Fed. R. Civ. P. 4 provides that “[t]he plaintiff is responsible for having the

 summons and complaint served within the time allowed by Rule 4(m) and must

 furnish the necessary copies to the person who makes service.” Fed. R. Civ. P.

 4(c)(1). After effecting service, a plaintiff must file proof of service with the court.

 Fed. R. Civ. P. 4(l)(1). If the plaintiff fails to serve a defendant “within 90 days after

 the complaint is filed, the court—on motion or on its own after notice to the

 plaintiff—must dismiss the action without prejudice against that defendant,” unless

 the plaintiff shows both (1) good cause for his failure to timely and properly effect

                                             -2-


Case 3:26-cv-01419-E-BW       Document 34      Filed 09/21/26     Page 3 of 10     PageID 844


 service and (2) good cause for the court to extend the time for service for an

 appropriate period. Fed. R. Civ. P. 4(m); Lewis v. Sec’y of Pub. Safety & Corr., 870

 F.3d 365, 369 (5th Cir. 2017).

 B.     Substitute service

        Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 4(e) provides that “an individual . . . may be

 served in a judicial district of the United States by . . . delivering a copy of the

 summons and of the complaint to the individual personally; [or] leaving a copy of

 each at the individual’s dwelling or usual place of abode with someone of suitable

 age and discretion who resides there[.]” Fed. R. Civ. P. 4(e)(2)(A)-(B).

 Additionally, a plaintiff may also effectively serve an individual defendant under

 Rule 4 by “following state law for serving a summons in an action brought in courts

 of general jurisdiction in the state where the district court is located or where service

 is made.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 4(e)(1).

        This Court is located in the state of Texas, and Tex. R. Civ. P. 106 provides

 the methods for service in a state court. Rule 106 provides:

        (a) Unless the citation or court order otherwise directs, the citation must
        be served by:

               (1) delivering to the defendant, in person, a copy of the
               citation, showing the delivery date, and of the petition; or

               (2) mailing to the defendant by registered or certified mail,
               return receipt requested, a copy of the citation and of the
               petition.

        (b) Upon motion supported by a statement—sworn to before a notary or
        made under penalty of perjury—listing any location where the
        defendant can probably be found and stating specifically the facts

                                             -3-


Case 3:26-cv-01419-E-BW      Document 34       Filed 09/21/26    Page 4 of 10     PageID 845


        showing that service has been attempted under (a)(1) or (a)(2) at the
        location named in the statement but has not been successful, the court
        may authorize service:

               (1) by leaving a copy of the citation and of the petition
               with anyone older than sixteen at the location specified in
               the statement; or

               (2) in any other manner, including electronically by social
               media, email, or other technology, that the statement or
               other evidence shows will be reasonably effective to give
               the defendant notice of the suit.

 Tex. R. Civ. P. 106.

        Under Texas Rule 106(b), if a plaintiff’s attempts to serve a defendant in

 person or by registered or certified mail are unsuccessful, a court may authorize

 substituted service only after receiving the required sworn statement and only in a

 manner that is reasonably calculated to provide notice. See Tex. R. Civ. P. 106(b);

 State Farm Fire & Cas. Co. v. Costley, 868 S.W.2d 298, 299 (Tex. 1993). If a defendant

 is absent or a nonresident of Texas, that defendant still may be served in the same

 manner as a resident defendant. See Tex. R. Civ. P. 108.

        As to the sworn statement requirement, “[t]he court may authorize substituted

 service pursuant to Rule 106(b) only if the plaintiff’s supporting affidavit strictly

 complies with the requirements of the Rule.” Mockingbird Dental Group, P.C., 2015

 WL 4231746, at *1 (citing Wilson v. Dunn, 800 S.W.2d 833, 836 (Tex. 1990)). The

 supporting sworn statement must state (1) “the location of the defendant’s usual

 place of business or usual place of abode or other place where the defendant can

 probably be found” and (2) “specifically the facts showing that” traditional service


                                             -4-


Case 3:26-cv-01419-E-BW      Document 34     Filed 09/21/26     Page 5 of 10    PageID 846


 under Rule 106(a) has been attempted “at the location named in the statement but

 has not been successful.” Tex. R. Civ. P. 106(b). The plaintiff also must explain

 how the requested method of alternative service is likely to give the defendant actual

 notice of the lawsuit. See Tex. R. Civ. P. 106(b)(2) (authorizing method that “the

 statement or other evidence shows will be reasonably effective to give the defendant

 notice of the suit”).

                                    III. ANALYSIS

 A.     The Court extends Sterrenberg’s deadline to show proof of service as
        required by Rule 4(m).

        The Court finds good cause to extend Sterrenberg’s deadline to file proof of

 service on Defendants Garvin and Kennedy. The record reflects that Sterrenberg

 delayed considerably before initiating efforts to serve the defendants. (See Dkt. No.

 18 at 3-4.) And the Court has already extended his deadline once. (See id.)

 Nonetheless, Sterrenberg has demonstrated diligent—albeit tardy—efforts to serve

 the defendants and chooses, in this instance, to extend Sterrenberg’s deadline to give

 him a final opportunity to serve these two defendants.

 C.     The Court grants in part and denies in part Sterrenberg’s motions for
        substituted service.

        1.     Sterrenberg has not demonstrated that the proposed methods of
               service are likely to give Garvin actual notice of this lawsuit.

        The Court next considers Sterrenberg’s requests to serve Garvin and Kennedy

 by alternative methods. As to Garvin, Sterrenberg states that an attempt was made

 to serve her by certified mail, return receipt requested, but that the green card proving


                                            -5-


Case 3:26-cv-01419-E-BW     Document 34     Filed 09/21/26   Page 6 of 10     PageID 847


 delivery was never returned. (Dkt. No. 23 at 2.) A professional process server then

 attempted to serve Garvin in person at her last known address, an apartment at

 Loft+Row, on September 7 but that an individual who said she was a resident but

 refused to give her name stated she did not know who Garvin is. (Id. at 2.) In a

 supplement to his motion, Sterrenberg states that a property manager at Loft+Row

 stated that Garvin was evicted from the apartment complex on February 11, 2026.

 (Dkt. No. 26.) Sterrenberg states, however, that mail addressed to Garvin was

 delivered at the Loft+Row address in August 2026. (Id. at 1-2.) In a second

 supplement to his motion, Sterrenberg asserts that a second attempt at in-person

 delivery was made at the same Loft+Row apartment on September 18, during which

 a resident of the apartment said she did not know Garvin, a property manager stated

 Garvin does not reside at the complex, and a “worker” stated that Garvin moved out

 in April 2026. (Dkt. No. 33.)

       Sterrenberg states that Willow Ridge is Garvin’s last known place of

 employment and believes Garvin has been made aware of this lawsuit. (Dkt. No. 23

 at 2-3.) He seeks court authorization to serve Garvin through Willow Ridge’s

 registered agent, CT Corporation. (Id. at 5.) In his September 11 supplement, he

 also seeks authorization to serve Garvin at the Loft+Row apartment by leaving the

 summons and amended complaint with a person over 16 years old at that apartment.

 (Dkt. No. 26 at 3.)

       The Court DENIES without prejudice Sterrenberg’s motion to serve Garvin

 by alternative methods under Tex. R. Civ. P. 106(b). As to Sterrenberg’s request to
                                          -6-


Case 3:26-cv-01419-E-BW       Document 34       Filed 09/21/26     Page 7 of 10     PageID 848


 serve Garvin by leaving a copy of the summons and amended complaint at Garvin’s

 dwelling with a person of suitable age and discretion who resides there, he is already

 permitted by Fed. R. Civ. P. 4(e)(2)(B) to do so and does not need Court

 authorization. The issue—which precludes the Court from authorizing other means

 of service at the Loft+Row apartment—is that it is Sterrenberg’s certainty that

 Garvin lives at the Loft+Row apartment is not supported the facts presented.

 Process servers have attempted twice to locate Garvin at the apartment and have

 been told that she no longer lives there, and there is no evidence that the woman who

 answered the door on the two attempts was Garvin or knows Garvin. 3 To authorize

 substituted service, the Court must be shown that the alternative method of service is

 likely to give Garvin actual notice of the lawsuit. Without more, the Court does not

 have the requisite confidence that delivering documents to the Loft+Row apartment

 is likely to apprise Garvin of the lawsuit. And while Sterrenberg infers that Willow

 Bridge or its employees are acting in concert with Garvin to frustrate his attempts to

 server her, that inference is not strongly supported by the evidence presented.

        The Court also declines Sterrenberg’s request to serve Garvin through CT

 Corporation, which is Willow Bridge’s registered agent. Sterrenberg seemingly

 acknowledges that he is unaware whether Garvin remains employed by Willow

 Bridge and, even if she is, CT Corporation is not her registered agent. The onus is on


        3
          Sterrenberg contends that an “innocent” person would have identified herself when
 asked her name. The Court disagrees that a person’s refusal to identify herself to a stranger
 at her door by itself suggests something nefarious or suggests that the person was Garvin.

                                              -7-


Case 3:26-cv-01419-E-BW      Document 34     Filed 09/21/26    Page 8 of 10       PageID 849


 Sterrenberg to locate and serve Garvin, and he cannot offload that responsibility to

 her employer’s (or former employer’s) registered agent.

        2.    The Court grants in part Sterrenberg’s motion for substituted service
              on Defendant Kennedy.

        In his motion for substitute service as to Defendant Kennedy, Sterrenberg

 states that he first attempted to serve Kennedy by certified mail, returned receipt

 requested. (See Dkt. No. 21.) He received the green delivery confirmation card,

 which showed it was delivered on August 24 and signed by Tiffany Kennedy. (Dkt.

 No. 21 at ECF p. 11.) Sterrenberg alleges, however, that the sticker with the article

 number was removed from the receipt and avers that its removal manifests an

 intentional effort to frustrate service. That attempt at service, however, was

 ineffective for reasons the Court has already addressed. (See Dkt. No. 20.)

 Sterrenberg’s process server also attempted personal service of documents at

 Kennedy’s address on September 1, 3, 4, and 5, and was unable to get an answer at

 the door each time. (Dkt. No. 21 at 4.) Sterrenberg requests authorization to serve

 Kennedy by leaving the documents at his listed residential address with a person over

 16 years old, by securing the documents to the front door of that address, or by

 leaving the documents with someone over the age of 16 at the business address of

 Defendant Valet Living, LLC, which is Kennedy’s last known employer. (Dkt. No.

 21 at 8.)

        Sterrenberg has demonstrated diligent efforts to serve Kennedy through

 personal delivery. And, although his effort to serve Kennedy by certified mail was


                                            -8-


Case 3:26-cv-01419-E-BW       Document 34      Filed 09/21/26     Page 9 of 10    PageID 850


 ineffective, the fact that Tiffany Kennedy signed for the item provides some

 verification that Defendant Kennedy resides that the listed address and that delivery

 of the documents there is reasonably likely to give Defendant Kennedy notice of this

 lawsuit. The Court therefore GRANTS in part Sterrenberg’s motion (Dkt. No. 21)

 to serve Defendant Sam Kennedy by alternative methods. Courts have allowed

 substituted service by attaching a copy of the summons and operative complaint on

 the front door of a defendant’s residence. See, e.g., Nat’l Specialty Ins. Co. v. Hope Trans

 LLC, No. 3:25-CV-2791-L-BW, 2026 WL 183778, at *2 (N.D. Tex. Jan. 23, 2026).

 Pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 4(e)(1) and Tex. R. Civ. P. 106(b), the Court authorizes

 Sterrenberg to serve Defendant Sam Kennedy by both (1) affixing the summons, a

 copy of the operative complaint, and a copy of this order in a prominent place on the

 front door of the residence at 3205 Meadowood Drive, Garland, Texas 75040 and

 also (2) mailing the summons, a copy of the operative complaint, and a copy of this

 order to Defendant Kennedy at 3205 Meadowood Drive, Garland, Texas 75040 via

 first class mail.

                                   IV. CONCLUSION

        The Court GRANTS Plaintiff’s motion for extension of time to serve

 Defendants Garvin and Kennedy. (Dkt. No. 25.) Plaintiff shall show proof of

 service on all Defendants no later than November 18, 2026. No additional extension

 will be granted absent extraordinary and compelling circumstances.


                                             -9-


Case 3:26-cv-01419-E-BW    Document 34     Filed 09/21/26   Page 10 of 10    PageID 851


        The Court DENIES Plaintiff’s motion for substituted service on Defendant

  Crystal Garvin (Dkt. No. 23) and GRANTS Plaintiff’s motion for substituted service

  on Defendant Sam Kennedy (Dkt. No. 21) as set forth in this order.

        Plaintiff’s motion to expedite consideration of pending motions (Dkt. No. 29)

  is DENIED as moot.

        SO ORDERED on September 21, 2026.


                                        __________________________
                                        BRIAN McKAY
                                        UNITED STATES MAGISTRATE JUDGE


                                          -10-