Sheresky v. United States of America — Entry #80: NOTICE of Filing of Administrative Record
Case: Sheresky v. United States of America nysd · 1:25-cv-08935
filed October 28, 2025
What this document is
Docket entry #80 · filed September 18, 2026
NOTICE of Filing of Administrative Record. Document filed by Daniel Aronowitz, Lori Chavez-DeRemer, Janet Dhillon, United States of America. (Attachments: (1) Exhibit Certification of Administrative Record, (2) Exhibit Index to Administrative Record, (3) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 1, (4) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 2, (5) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 3.1, (6) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 3.2, (7) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 3.3, (8) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 3.4, (9) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 3.5, (10) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 3.6, (11) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 3.7, (12) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 4, (13) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 5.1, (14) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 5.2, (15) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 6).(Yalen, Robert)
Who is involved
- Daniel Aronowitz
- Janet Dhillon
- Jeffrey Samsen
- Lori Chavez-DeRemer
- Nicholas Sutro
- Steve Sheresky
- UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Why we have it
We follow this case because it names a company we track, although that company is not a party:
- Riot: its former name “Riot Blockchain, Inc.” appears in a filing in this case.
…Lead counsel in Takata v. Riot Blockchain, Inc., et al., No. 3:18- CONSUMER PROTECTION…
A free copy from the RECAP archive of federal court filings (mirrored at the Internet Archive), retrieved November 14, 2026. Federal court filings are public records.
Document text
194 page(s), 713,492 characters, converted from the PDF's text layer · plain text.
Full text
Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG Document 80-15 Filed 09/18/26 Page 1 of 194
68736 Federal Register/Vol. 84, No. 241/Monday, December 16, 2019/Rules and Regulations
DEPARTMENT OF LABOR I. Executive Summary Today, such benefits make up
The FLSA generally requires covered approximately one-third of total
Wage and Hour Division employers to pay nonexempt employees compensation. 5 Many employers,
overtime pay of at least one and one-half moreover, now offer various wellness
29 CFR Parts 548 and 778 times their regular rate for hours worked benefits or perks, such as fitness classes,
in excess of 40 per workweek. The nutrition classes, weight loss programs,
RIN 1235-AA24 FLSA defines the regular rate as "all smoking cessation programs, health risk
remuneration for employment paid to, assessments, vaccination clinics, stress
Regular Rate Under the Fair Labor or on behalf of, the employee" -subject reduction programs, and training or
Standards Act to eight exclusions established in coaching to help employees meet their
section 7(e). 1 Part 778 ofCFR title 29 health goals.
AGENCY: Wage and Hour Division, Both law and practice concerning
contains the regulations addressing the
Department of Labor. calculation of the regular rate of pay for more traditional benefits, such as sick
ACTION: Final rule. overtime compensation under section 7 leave, have likewise evolved in the
of the FLSA. decades since the Department first
SUMMARY: The Fair Labor Standards Act The Department promulgated the promulgated part 778. For example,
(FLSA or Act) generally requires that majority of part 778 of CFR title 29 more instead of providing separate paid time
covered, nonexempt employees receive than 60 years ago, when typical off for illness and vacation, many
overtime pay of at least one and one-half compensation often consisted employers now combine these and other
times their regular rate of pay for time predominantly of traditional wages, types of leave into paid time off plans.
worked in excess of 40 hours per paid time off for holidays and vacations, Moreover, in recent years, a number of
workweek. The regular rate includes all and contributions to basic medical, life state and local governments have passed
remuneration for employment, subject insurance, and disability benefits laws requiring employers to provide
to the exclusions outlined in section plans. 2 Since that time, the workplace paid sick leave. In 2011, for example,
7(e) of the FLSA. In this final rule, the and the law have evolved, but the Connecticut became the first state to
Department of Labor (Department) Department has only made minor require private-sector employers to
updates a number of regulations on the updates to part 778 since 1950. 3 provide paid sick leave to their
calculation of overtime compensation First, employee compensation employees. 6 Today, several states, the
both to provide clarity and to better packages, including employer-provided District of Columbia,7 and various cities
reflect the 21st-century workplace. benefits and "perks," have expanded and counties 8 require paid sick leave,
These changes will promote compliance significantly. The Bureau of Labor and many other states are considering
with the FLSA, provide appropriate and Statistics (BLS) estimated that fringe similar requirements.
updated guidance in an area of evolving benefits comprised only 5 percent of Recently, several states and cities
law and practice, and encourage employees' total compensation in 1950. 4 have also begun considering and
employers to provide additional and implementing scheduling laws. In the
innovative benefits to workers without 1 See 29 U.S.C. 207(e). last 5 years, for example, New York, San
fear of costly litigation. 2 See U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, An Overview
Francisco, Seattle, and other cities have
of Employee Benefits. Occupational Outlook enacted laws imposing penalties on
DATES: This final rule is effective on Quarterly (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics), Summer
January 15, 2020. 2005, at 20, available at https://www.bls.gov/ employers who change employees'
careeroutlook/2005/summer/arto2.pdf schedules without the requisite notice,
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: 3 See, e.g .. 33 FR 986 (Jan. 26, 1968) (codified at and various state governments are
Amy DeBisschop, Division of 29 CFR 778.0 through 778.603); 36 FR 4699 (Mar. considering and beginning to pass
Regulations, Legislation, and 11, 1971) (updating 29 CFR 778.214 to clarify that
advance approval by the Department is not required
Interpretation, Wage and Hour Division, for plans providing benefits within the meaning of 95 percent in 1950, to 92.2 percent in 1960, 89.7
U.S. Department of Labor, Room S- 29 U.S.C. 207(e)(4)); 36 FR 4981 (Mar. 16, 1971) percent in 1970, and 84.2 percent in 1980° 0).
5 Bureau of Labor Statistics News Release,
3502, 200 Constitution Avenue NW, (updating 29 CFR 7 78.117 to clarify commission
Employer Cost for Employee Compensation-March
Washington, DC 20210; telephone: (202) payments that must be included in the regular rate);
2019, June 18, 2019, ("Wages and salaries cost
46 FR 7308 (Jan. 23, 1981) (updating 29 CFR part
693-0406 (this is not a toll-free 778 to increase the dollar amounts used as employers $25.22 [per hour] while benefit costs
number). Copies of this final rule may examples in the regulations, to respond to statutory were $11.55.""), https://www.bls.gov/news.release/
be obtained in alternative formats (Large amendments affecting other parts of the FLSA, and pdflecec.pdf
6 See 2011 Conn. Legis. Serv. P.A. 11-52 (West).
Print, Braille, Audio Tape or Disc), upon to modify§ 778.320 to clarify that pay for
7 See Ariz. Rev. Stat. secs. 23-364, 23-371 et seq.;
nonworking time does not automatically convert
request, by calling (202) 693-0675 (this such time into hours worked); 46 FR 33515-2 (June Cal. Lab. Code secs. 245, 2810.5; 2011 Conn. Legis.
is not a toll-free number). TTY/TDD 30, 1981) (correcting errors in the January 1981 Serv. P.A. 11-52 (West); D.C. Code sec. 32-131.01
callers may dial toll-free 1-877-889- update in 29 CFR 778.323, 778.327, 778.501, et seq.; Me. Rev. Stat. Ann. tit. 26, sec. 636 (2019)
5627 to obtain information or request 778.601); 56 FR 61100 (Nov. 29, 1991) (updating 29 (effective Jan. 1, 2021); Md. Code Ann., Lab. &
CFR 778.603 to address statutory amendment Empl. section 3-1301 et seq. (West 2019); Mass.
materials in alternative formats. adding section 7(q) regarding maximum-hour Gen. Laws ch. 149, sec. 148C, 148D; Mich. Comp.
Questions of interpretation and/or exemption for employees receiving remedial Laws secs. 408.961-974; 2019 Nev. Legis. Serv. 592
enforcement of the agency's regulations education); 76 FR 18832 (Apr. 5, 2011) (updating (West) (to be codified at Nev. Rev. Stat. Ch. 608
§§ 778.110, 778.111, 778.113, and 778.114 to reflect (2019) (effective Jan. 1, 2020); N.J. Stat. Ann. sec.
may be directed to the nearest WHD statutory changes to the minimum wage; updating 34:11D-1 et seq.; Or. Rev. Stat. sec. 653.601 et seq.;
district office. Locate the nearest office § 7 78.200 to reflect amendments made by the 28 R.I. Gen. Laws sec. 28-57-1 et seq.; 21 Vt. Stat.
by calling WHD's toll-free help line at Worker Economic Opportunity Act; updating secs. 384, 481-485, 345; Wash. Rev. Code secs.
(866) 4US-WAGE ((866) 487-9243) § 778.208 from "seven•• to "eight"" types of 49.46.005, 49.46.020, 49.46.090, 49.46.100.
between 8 a.m. and 5 p.m. in your local remuneration excluded when computing the regular 8 See, e.g .. Austin, Tex., City Code ch. 4-19
rate). (2018); Chi., Ill., Code ch. 1-24 (2017); Minneapolis,
time zone, or visit WHD's website for a 4 Yung-Ping Chen, The Growth of Fringe Benefits Minn., Admin. Code title 2, sec. 40.10 et seq.
nationwide listing of WHD district and Implications for Social Security, Monthly Labor (2016); Phila., Pa., Code ch. 9-4100 (2015); N.Y.C.,
area offices at http://www.dol.gov/whd/ Review Vol. 104 No. 11, November 1981, https:// N.Y., Admin. Code sec. 20-911 (2013); Seattle,
america2.htm. www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/1981/11/artl full. pdf (" cash Wash., Mun. Code ch. 14.16 (2011); Westchester
payroll as a percentage of total compensation County, N.Y., Laws of Westchester County ch. 585
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: declined steadily over the last 30 years, falling from (2018).
DOLAR0910
Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG Document 80-15 Filed 09/18/26 Page 2 of 194
Federal Register/Vol. 84, No. 241/Monday, December 16, 2019/Rules and Regulations 68737
similar scheduling legislation. 9 Some of determine whether a bonus is work in regular rate calculations. 14 It
these laws expressly exclude these discretionary or nondiscretionary; also specified that the regular rate must
penalties from the regular rate under revising language at§§ 778.202 and be "the rate at which the employee is
state law, 10 but questions remain for 778.205 to reflect that excludable actually employed and paid and not
employers determining how these and overtime premium payments may be . . . a fictitious rate which the employer
other penalties may affect regular rate made pursuant to a "written or adopts solely for bookkeeping
calculations under federal law. unwritten employment contract, purposes." 15
The Department published a notice of agreement, understanding, handbook, In 1948, the Supreme Court in Bay
proposed rulemaking (NPRM) in the policy, or practice"; and referencing Ridge Operating Co. v. Aaron, 334 U.S.
Federal Register on March 29, 2019 (84 state or local minimum wage laws as 446, addressed whether specific types of
FR 11888 (Mar. 29, 2019)), inviting well as Federal law in the regulations at compensation may be excluded from the
comments about proposed updates to its part 548 of title 29 discussing the basic regular rate, or even credited towards an
regulations in part 778 to reflect changes rate. employer's overtime payment
in the modern workplace and to provide The Department's estimated economic obligations. The Court held that an
clarifications that reflect the statutory impact of this final rule follows below. overtime premium payment, which it
language and WHD's enforcement The Department qualitatively estimates defined as "[e]xtra pay for work because
practices. Additionally, the Department the potential benefits associated with of previous work for a specified number
proposed minor clarifications and reduced litigation at $281 million over of hours in the workweek or workday
updates to part 548 of title 29, which 10 years, or $28.1 million per year. The whether the hours are specified by
implements section 7(g)(3) of the FLSA. Department quantitatively estimates the contract or statute," could be excluded
Section 7(g)(3) permits employers, one-time regulatory familiarization cost from the computation of the regular
under specific circumstances, to use a of this final rule at $30.5 million, whichrate. 16 Permitting an "overtime
basic rate to compute overtime results in a 10-year annualized cost of premium to enter into the computation
compensation rather than a regular $3.6 million at a discount rate of 3 of the regular rate would be to allow
rate. 11 Comments were initially due on percent or $4.3 million at a discount overtime premium on overtime
or before May 28, 2019. In response to rate of 7 percent. premium-a pyramiding that Congress
a request for an extension of the time could not have intended." 17 The Court
period for filing written comments, the This final rule is considered an
Executive Order (E.O.) 13771 also held that "any overtime premium
Department extended the deadline to paid, even if for work during the first
June 12, 2019 (84 FR 21300 (May 14, deregulatory action. Details on the
forty hours of the workweek, may be
2019)). The Department received estimated reduced burdens and cost
savings of this final rule can be found credited against any obligation to pay
approximately 80 timely comments. statutory excess compensation." 18 By
After considering the comments, the in the rule's economic analysis.
contrast, the Court noted, "[w]here an
Department has decided to adopt the II. Background employee receives a higher wage or rate
NPRM's proposed changes with some because of undesirable hours or
modifications. The final rule clarifies A. The FLSA and Regular Rate
disagreeable work, such wage represents
when payments for forgoing unused Regulatory History
a shift differential or higher wages
paid leave, payments for bona fide meal Congress enacted the FLSA in 1938 to because of the character of work done or
periods, reimbursements, benefit plan remedy "labor conditions detrimental to the time at which he is required to labor
contributions, and certain ancillary the maintenance of the minimum rather than an overtime premium. Such
benefits may be excluded from the standard ofliving necessary for health, payments enter into the determination
regular rate. The final rule also revises efficiency, and general well-being of of the regular rate of pay." 19
certain sections of the existing workers[,]" which burdened commerce Following the Bay Ridge decision, in
regulation to more closely align with the and constituted unfair methods of 1948, the Department promulgated 29
Act. Additionally, the final rule competition. 12 In relevant part, section CFR part 778, concerning the regular
incorporates, with modification, the 7(a) of the FLSA requires employers to rate. 20 This regulation codified the
proposed clarifications and updates to pay their employees overtime at one and principles from Bay Ridge that extra
part 548. The final rule incorporates one-half times their "regular rate" of payments for hours worked in excess of
numerous suggestions from pay for time worked in excess of 40 a daily or weekly standard established
commenters, including adding examples hours per workweek. 13 When enacted, by contract or statute may be excluded
of excludable state and local scheduling however, the FLSA did not define the from the regular rate and credited
law payments to § 778.222, which term "regular rate." toward overtime compensation due, and
addresses "other payments similar to that extra payments for work on
call-back pay"; providing additional Later that year, WHD issued an
interpretive bulletin addressing the Saturdays, Sundays, holidays, or at
guidance in the preamble about how to night that are made without regard to
meaning of "regular rate," which WHD
later revised and updated in 1939, and the number of hours or days previously
9 See Chi., Ill., Fair Workweek Ordinance (July 24,
again in 1940. The 1940 version of the worked in the day or workweek must be
2019) (effective July 1, 2020); N.Y.C., N.Y., Admin.
Code 20-1222 (2017); Phila., Pa., Code ch. 9-4600 bulletin stated, among other things, that included in the regular rate and may not
(2018) (effective Jan. 1, 2020); Seattle, Wash., Mun. an employer did not need to include be credited toward the overtime owed. 21
Code ch. 14.22.050 (2017); SB 828, 79th Leg.
Assemb., 2017 Reg. Sess. (Or. 2017); see also
extra compensation paid for overtime
14 See Interpretive Bulletin No. 4 'II 13 (Nov.
Emeryville, Cal., Mun. Code 5-39.01 (2017); S.F., 1940).
Cal., Police Code art. 33G (2015), 12 29 U.S.C. 202(a); see Fair Labor Standards Act
15 Id. 'II 18.
10 See, e.g., Or. Rev. Stat. Ann. sec. 653.412(7)(d) of 1938, Public Law 75-718, ch. 676, 52 Stat. 1060 16 334 U.S. at 450 n.3, 465-66.
("Regular rate of pay•• does not include "[a]ny (codified as amended at 29 U.S.C. 201-219).
17 Id. at 464.
additional compensation an employer is required to 13 29 U.S.C. 207(a). The statutory maximum in
1 3 Id. at 464-65.
pay an employee under ORS 653.442 [right to rest 1938 was 44 hours per workweek; in 1939, it was
between work shifts] or 653.455 [compensation for 19 Id. at 468-69.
42 hours per workweek; and in 1940, it was 40
work schedule changes].""). 20 See 13 FR 4534 (Aug. 6, 1948).
hours per workweek. See Public Law 75-718, 52
1 1 See 29 U.S.C. 207(g)(3). Stat. at 1063. 21 See 29 CFR 778.2 (1948).
DOLAR0911
Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG Document 80-15 Filed 09/18/26 Page 3 of 194
68738 Federal Register/Vol. 84, No. 241/Monday, December 16, 2019/Rules and Regulations
It noted, however, that when extra occasional periods when no work is In 1961 and 1966, Congress made a
payments for work on Saturdays, performed such as vacation or sick pay, few minor, non-substantive language
Sundays, holidays, or nights are reimbursements for work-related changes and redesignated certain
contingent on the employee having expenses, and other similar payments sections. 37 In 1968, the Department
previously worked a specified standard that are not compensation for hours of updated part 778, principally to clarify
number of hours or days, such payments employment; (3) discretionary bonuses, the statutory references, update the
are true overtime premium payments payments to profit-sharing or thrift or amounts used to illustrate pay
that may be excluded from the regular savings plans that meet certain computations, and reorganize the
rate and credited toward overtime requirements, and certain talent fees; (4) provisions in part 778. 38 Over the next
compensation due. 22 The Department contributions to a bona fide plan for several decades, the Department
also explained that payments "that are retirement, or life, accident, or health periodically made minor changes and
not made for hours worked, such as insurance; (5) extra compensation updates to part 778. 39
payments . . . for idle holidays or for provided by a premium rate for certain In 2000, Congress added another
occasional absences due to vacation or hours worked in excess of eight in a category of payments that could be
illness or other similar cause" may be day, 40 hours in a workweek, or the excluded from the regular rate, currently
excluded from the regular rate, but employee's normal working hours; (6) contained in section 7(e)(8). 40 This
could not be credited against statutory extra compensation provided by a amendment permitted an employer to
overtime compensation due. 23 premium rate for work on Saturdays, exclude from the regular rate income
In 1949, Congress responded to the Sundays, regular days of rest, or the derived from a stock option, stock
Bay Ridge decision by amending the sixth or seventh days of the workweek; appreciation right, or employee stock
FLSA to identify two categories of and (7) extra compensation provided by purchase plan, provided certain
payments that could be both excluded a premium rate pursuant to an restrictions were met. 41 Congress also
from the regular rate and credited employment contract or collective amended section 7(h) to state that,
toward overtime compensation due. 24 bargaining agreement for work outside except for the types of extra
The first category was extra of the hours established therein as the compensation identified in sections
compensation for work on Saturdays, normal workday (not exceeding eight 7(e)(5), (6), and (7), sums excluded from
Sundays, holidays, or the sixth or hours) or workweek (not exceeding 40 the regular rate are not creditable
seventh day of the workweek paid at a hours). 30 The October 1949 toward minimum wage or overtime
premium rate of one and one-half times amendments also added a provision compensation due. 42 In 2011, the
the rate paid for like work performed in specifying that the last three of these Department updated part 778 to reflect
nonovertime hours on other days. The categories are creditable against the 2000 statutory amendments and to
second category was extra compensation overtime compensation due. 31 modify the wage rates used as examples
paid pursuant to an applicable In 1950, the Department updated part to reflect the current minimum wage. 43
employment contract or collective 778 to account for the 1949 amendments Currently, the FLSA's definition of
bargaining agreement for work outside to the FLSA. 32 These regulations "regular rate" and the eight categories of
of the hours established therein as the explained general principles regarding 37 1n 1961, Congress made non-substantive
normal workday (not exceeding eight overtime compensation and the regular language changes to sections (d)(5) and (7). See Fair
hours) or workweek (not exceeding 40 rate, including the principle that each Labor Standards Amendments of 1961, Public Law
hours) at a premium rate of one and workweek stands on its own for 87-30, sec. 6, 75 Stat. 65, 70. In 1966, Congress
purposes of determining the regular rate redesignated section 7(d) as section 7(e). See Fair
one-half times the rate paid for like Labor Standards Amendments of 1966, Public Law
work performed during the workday or and overtime due. 33 The regulations 89-601, Title II, sec. 204(d)(1), 80 Stat. 830, 836.
workweek. 25 also provided methods for calculating Additionally, section 7(g), which provided that
On October 26, 1949, Congress again the regular rate under different extra compensation paid pursuant to sections
7(d)(5), (6), and (7) could be credited against
amended the FLSA. 26 The amendments compensation systems, such as salary
overtime compensation due under section 7(a), was
added, among other things, a and piecework compensation. 34 They moved to section 7(h). See id.
comprehensive definition of the term further elaborated on the seven 38 See 33 FR 986 (Jan. 26, 1968) (29 CFR 778.0
"regular rate." 27 "Regular rate" was categories of payments that are through 778.603).
defined to include "all remuneration for excludable from regular rate 39 See 36 FR 4699 (Mar. 11, 1971) (updating
calculations, and provided several § 778.214 to clarify that advance approval by the
employment paid to, or on behalf of, the Department is not required for plans providing
employee[,]" 28 with the exception of an examples. 35 The regulations also benefits within the meaning of section 7(e)(4)); 36
exhaustive list of seven specific addressed special problems and pay FR 4981 (Mar. 16, 1971) (updating§ 778.117 to
categories of payments that could be plans designed to circumvent the clarify commission payments that must be included
in the regular rate); 46 FR 7308 (Jan. 23, 1981)
excluded from the regular rate. 29 Those FLSA.36
(updating part 778 to increase the dollar amounts
categories of excludable payments were: used as examples in the regulations, to respond to
30 See id. The excludable categories of payments
(1) Gifts and payments on special statutory amendments affecting other parts of the
in sections 7(d)(6) and (7) in the October 1949
occasions; (2) payments made for amendments were essentially the same as those that
FLSA, and to modify§ 778.320 to clarify that pay
for nonworking time does not automatically convert
had been added in the July 1949 amendments as such time into hours worked); 46 FR 33515-02
22 See id. sections 7(e)(1) and (2); the October 1949 (June 30, 1981) (correcting errors in the January
23 Id. amendments eliminated them from section 7(e). 1981 update in§§ 778.323, 778.327, 778.501,
24 See Public Law 81-177, ch. 352, 63 Stat. 446 31 See id. Public Law 81-393, 63 Stat. at 915. This
778.601); 56 FR 61100 (Nov. 29, 1991) (updating
(July 20, 1949). These provisions are currently provision is currently codified at 29 U.S.C. 207(h) § 778.603 to address statutory amendment adding
codified at 29 U.S.C. 207(e)(6)-(7). (payments described in sections 7(e)(5)-(7) are section 7(q) regarding maximum-hour exemption
25 See id. creditable). for employees receiving remedial education).
26 See Fair Labor Standards Amendments of 1949, 32 See 15 FR 623 (Feb. 4, 1950) (codified at 29 40 See Worker Economic Opportunity Act, Public
Public Law 81-393, ch. 736, 63 Stat. 910. CFR 778.0 through 778.27). Law 106-202, sec. 2(a)(3), 114 Stat. 308 (2000).
27 Id. Sec. 7, 63 Stat. at 913-14. This provision is 33 See 29 CFR 778.2 (1950). 41 See id.
currently codified at 29 U.S.C. 207(e). 34 See 29 CFR 778.3(b) (1950). 42 See id.
28 Id. 35 See 29 CFR 778.5 through 778.8 (1950). 43 See 76 FR 18832 (Apr. 5, 2011) (updating
29 See id. 63 Stat. at 913-14. These provisions are 36 See 29 CFR 778.9.17, 778.21 through 778.23 §§ 778.110, 778.111, 778.113, 778.114, 778.200,
currently codified at 29 U.S.C. 207(e)(1)-(7). (1950). 778.208).
DOLAR0912
Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG Document 80-15 Filed 09/18/26 Page 4 of 194
Federal Register/Vol. 84, No. 241/Monday, December 16, 2019/Rules and Regulations 68739
excludable payments are contained in on retail goods and services, and compensation by more than $0.50 per
section 7(e) of the Act. 44 The payments for tuition programs, such as week on average for overtime
Department's regulations concerning the reimbursement programs or repayment workweeks in the period for which the
regular rate requirements are contained of educational debt, may be excluded employer makes the payment. The
in 29 CFR part 778. As noted above, the from an employee's regular rate of pay. Department proposed to update this
last comprehensive revision to part 778 The Department also proposed to clarify regulation to change the $0.50 limit to
was in 1968. 45 that payments for unused paid leave, 40 percent of the Federal minimum
While section 7(a) defines the general including paid sick leave, may be wage-currently $2. 90.
overtime entitlement in terms of an excluded from an employee's regular In developing this rule, the
employee's regular rate, under certain rate of pay; that reimbursed expenses Department was mindful of the
circumstances, the FLSA permits need not be incurred "solely" for the Supreme Court's recent guidance that,
employers to use a "basic rate," rather employer's benefit for the to determine the scope of an exemption
than the regular rate as defined in reimbursements to be excludable from under the FLSA, the statutory text must
section 7(e), to calculate overtime an employee's regular rate and that be given a "fair reading" rather than a
compensation. 46 Congress added this reimbursed travel expenses that do not narrow reading because the FLSA's
provision, currently contained in exceed the maximum travel exemptions are "as much a part of the
section 7(g), in 1949-at the same time reimbursement permitted under the FLSA's purpose as the [minimum wage
that Congress added the definition of Federal Travel Regulation System and and] overtime-pay requirement[s]."
"regular rate" to the FLSA. 47 The meet other regulatory requirements may Encino Motorcars, LLC v. Navarro, 138
requirements an employer must meet to be excluded from an employee's regular S. Ct. 1134, 1142 (2018). As the Third
use a basic rate are set forth in that same rate of pay; that employers do not need Circuit recently noted in a regular rate
section 7(g). 48 a prior formal contract or agreement case, "that is as should be expected,
In 1955, the Department promulgated with the employee(s) to exclude certain because employees' rights are not the
29 CFR part 548 to establish the overtime premiums described in only ones at issue and, in fact, are not
requirements for authorized basic rates sections 7(e)(5) and (6) of the FLSA; and always separate from and at odds with
under section 7(g)(3). 49 It amended that pay for time that would not their employers' interests." U.S. Dep't of
various sections of the part 548 otherwise qualify as "hours worked," Labor v. Bristol Excavating, Inc., 935
regulations several times over the next including bona fide meal periods, may F.3d 122,135 (3d Cir. 2019).
12 years to reflect statutory amendments be excluded from an employee's regular
to other parts of the FLSA, including Approximately 80 individuals and
rate unless an agreement or established organizations timely commented on the
increases to the minimum wage. 50 The practice indicates that the parties have
Department has not updated any of the NPRM during the 75-day extended
treated the time as hours worked. comment period that ended on June 12,
regulations in part 548 since 1967, more Additionally, the Department proposed
than a half-century ago. 2019. The Department received
to provide examples of discretionary comments from a broad array of
B. The Department's Proposal bonuses that may be excluded from an constituencies, including small business
On March 29, 2019, the Department employee's regular rate of pay under owners, employer and industry
issued its proposal to update and revise section 7(e)(3) of the FLSA and to clarify associations, individual workers, worker
a number of regulations in parts 548 and that the label given to a bonus does not advocacy groups, unions, non-profit
778. 51 The Department's proposal determine whether it is discretionary. organizations, law firms, professional
focused primarily on clarifying whether The Department also proposed to associations, and other interested
certain kinds of "perks," benefits, or provide additional examples of benefit members of the public. The majority of
other miscellaneous payments must be plans, including accident, comments supported the Department's
included in the regular rate. These unemployment, and legal services, that efforts to clarify the regular rate
clarifications included confirming that may be excluded from an employee's regulations. All timely received
the cost of providing wellness programs, regular rate of pay under section 7(e)(4) comments may be viewed on
onsite specialist treatment, gym access of the FLSA. www.regulations.gov, docket ID WHD-
and fitness classes, employee discounts The Department proposed two 2019-0002.
substantive changes to the existing Some commenters appear to have
44 See 29 U.S.C. 2O7(e). Additionally, section 7(h) regulations. First, the Department mistakenly filed comments intended for
states that only payments excludable from the proposed to eliminate the restriction in this rulemaking into the dockets for the
regular rate pursuant to sections 7(e)(5), (6), and (7)
may be credited against the employer"s overtime 29 CFR 778.221 and 778.222 that "call- Department's rulemakings concerning
obligation and that all other excludable payments back" pay and other payments similar to overtime (docket ID WHD-2019-0001)
(i.e .. payments that qualify as excludable under call-back pay must be "infrequent and or joint employer status (docket ID
sections 7(e)(1), (2), (3), (4), and (8)) are not sporadic" to be excludable from an WHD-2019-0003) under the FLSA. The
creditable). See 29 U.S.C. 2O7(h).
45 See 33 FR 986 (29 CFR 778.O through 778.603). employee's regular rate, while Department did not consider these
46 29 u.s.c. 2O7(g). maintaining that such payments must misfiled comments in this rulemaking.
47 See Public Law 81-393, 63 Stat. at 914-15. In not be so regular that they are The Department has carefully
1966, Congress redesignated section 7(f) as section essentially prearranged. Second, the considered the timely-submitted
7(g), with section numbers (1)-(3) remaining the Department proposed to update its comments on the proposed changes.
same; no substantive changes were made. See
Public Law 89-601, 80 Stat. at 836. "basic rate" regulations, which are Some of the comments were general
47 29 u.s.c. 2O7(g)(1)-(3). authorized under section 7(g)(3) of the statements of support or opposition. See
48 See id. FLSA, as an alternative to the regular Bloomin' Brands; International
49 See 20 FR 5678 (Aug. 6, 1955). The regulations rate under specific circumstances. Bancshares Corporation (IBC);
interpreting sections 7(g)(1)-(2) are at 29 CFR Under the current regulations, Independent Bakers Association (IBA);
778.415 through 778.421.
50 See 21 FR 338 Uan. 18, 1956); 26 FR 7730 (Aug. employers using an authorized basic National Demolition Association (NDA);
18, 1961); 28 FR 11266 (Oct. 22, 1963); 31 FR 6769 rate may exclude from the overtime National Federation oflndependent
(May 6, 1966); 32 FR 3293 (Feb. 25, 1967). computation any additional payment Businesses (NFIB); International
5184 FR 11888. that would not increase total overtime Association of Firefighters (Association
DOLAR0913
Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG Document 80-15 Filed 09/18/26 Page 5 of 194
68740 Federal Register/Vol. 84, No. 241/Monday, December 16, 2019/Rules and Regulations
of Firefighters); and various individual of compensation that is excludable from regular rate. 57 In other words, when an
commenters. the regular rate under FLSA section employee works instead of taking a
The Department received a number of 7(e)(2). Section 7(e)(2) permits an holiday or using vacation leave, and
comments that are beyond the scope of employer to exclude from the regular receives pay for both the hours of work
this rulemaking. These include, for rate three distinct categories of payment: performed as well as the holiday or
example, a request to address whether First, "payments made for occasional vacation leave that he or she did not
restricted stock units are excludable periods when no work is performed due take, the amount paid for the forgone
under 29 U.S.C. 207(e)(8) of the Act, to vacation, holiday, illness, failure of holiday or vacation leave may be
which permits an employer to exclude the employer to provide sufficient work, excluded from the regular rate. In its
from the regular rate income derived or other similar cause"; second, current form,§ 778.219 addresses only
from a stock option, stock appreciation "reasonable payments for traveling pay for forgoing holidays and vacation
right, or employee stock purchase plan. expenses, or other expenses, incurred by leave but does not address sums paid for
See Semiconductor Industry an employee in the furtherance of his forgoing the use of other forms of leave,
Association (SIA); National Association employer's interests and properly such as leave for illness. As explained
of Manufacturers (NAM); the Chamber reimbursable by the employer"; and in the NPRM, WHD has addressed
of Commerce (Chamber); Partnership to third, "other similar payments to an payments for forgoing sick leave in its
Protect Workplace Opportunity (PPWO); employee which are not made as Field Operations Handbook (FOH). The
ERISA Industry Committee (ERIC); compensation for his hours of FOH states that the same rules
American Benefits Council. Similarly, employment." 53 In this Preamble, these governing exclusion of payments for
some commenters urged the Department clauses are referred to as: The unused vacation leave also apply to
to require that any payment that must be "occasional periods when no work is payments for unused sick leave. 58
included in the regular rate must count performed" clause; the "reimbursable Therefore, when "the sum paid for
towards the overtime salary threshold expenses" clause; and the "other similar unused sick leave is the approximate
under 29 CFR part 541. See American payments" clause. The Department's equivalent of the employee's normal
Hotel and Lodging Association (AHLA); regulations interpreting section 7(e)(2) earnings for a similar period of working
PPWO; College and University are contained in§§ 778.216 through time," such payments are excludable
Professional Association for Human 778.224. from the regular rate. 59
Resources (CUP A-HR). The Department To clarify and modernize the
did not raise these issues in its proposal, 1. Pay for Forgoing Holidays or Leave regulations, the Department proposed to
and they are therefore out of scope of The initial clause of section 7(e)(2) of update§ 778.219 to address payments
this rulemaking. the FLSA permits an employer to for forgoing both holidays and other
Some commenters raised issues that exclude "payments made for occasional forms of leave. The Department noted in
are the subject of other on-going periods when no work is performed due the NPRM that it is aware that many
rulemaking efforts by the Department. to vacation, holiday, illness, failure of employers no longer provide separate
For example, commenters raised the employer to provide sufficient work, categories of leave based on an
concerns regarding the fluctuating or other similar causes" from the regular employee's reason for taking leave-
workweek regulation at 29 CFR 778.114. rate. 54 Section 778.218 addresses this such as sick leave and vacation leave.
See Associated Builders and statutory provision and provides that Instead, employers provide one category
Contractors; AHLA; Chamber. The of leave, which is commonly called paid
payments for such time that "are in time off. The Department explained that
Department is currently engaged in amounts approximately equivalent to
rulemaking to revise this specific it saw no reason to distinguish between
the employee's normal earnings" are not the types of leave when determining
regulation. 52 Therefore, the Department compensation for hours of employment
does not address these issues in this whether payment for forgoing use of the
and are therefore excludable from the leave is excludable from the regular rate.
final rule. regular rate. 55
Significant issues raised in the Rather, the central issues are whether
Section 778.219 addresses a related the amount paid is approximately
comments on the Department's proposal issue: The exclusion of payments for
are discussed below, along with the equivalent to the employee's normal
working on a holiday or forgoing earnings for a similar period of time,
Department's response to those vacation leave, as distinct from the
comments. and whether the payment is in addition
exclusion of payments for using leave. 56 to the employee's normal compensation
III. Final Regulatory Provisions It explains that if an employee who is for hours worked.
entitled to "a certain sum as holiday or Accordingly, the Department
The Department finalizes its vacation pay, whether he works or not,"
proposals to update the regulations in proposed to clarify that occasional
receives additional pay for each hour payments for forgoing the use of leave
parts 778 and 548 to clarify the worked on a holiday or vacation day,
Department's interpretation in light of are treated the same regardless of the
the sum allocable as the holiday or type of leave. The Department therefore
modern compensation and benefits vacation pay is excluded from the
practices. The sections below discuss, in proposed to revise the title of§ 778.219,
turn, each category of excludable clarify in§ 778.219(a) that payments for
compensation that the Department has
53 29 U.S.C. 207(e)(2). all forms of unused leave are treated the
54 See id. same for purposes of determining
addressed in this final rule. 55 29 CFR 778.218; see FOH 32d03g ("Payment
for absences charged against leave under a bona fide
whether they may be excluded from the
A. Excludable Compensation Under plan granting the employee a specified amount of regular rate, and add an example
Section 7(e)(2) annual, vacation, or sick leave with pay need not concerning payment for forgoing the use
Many of the Department's regulatory be included in the regular rate of pay, if the sum of paid time off. The NPRM noted that
paid is the approximate equivalent of the
updates in this final rule clarify the type employee"s normal earnings for a similar period of
the proposed changes reflected the
working time. Payments for such absences may be
52 See Fluctuating Workweek Method of excluded regardless of when or how the leave is 57 29 CFR 778.219(a).
Computing Overtime, Notice of Proposed taken.""). 58 See FOH 32d03e(b).
Rulemaking, 84 FR 59590 (Nov. 5, 2019), 56 See 29 CFR 778.219. 59 Id.
DOLAR0914
Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG Document 80-15 Filed 09/18/26 Page 6 of 194
Federal Register/Vol. 84, No. 241/Monday, December 16, 2019/Rules and Regulations 68741
Department's longstanding practice of basis (e.g., per pay-period), WFCA noted employee to expect such payments[.]" 63
applying the same principles to that many employees accrue leave based An important distinction between an
payments of unused holiday, vacation, on the number of hours worked and that excludable leave buy-back payment and
and sick leave. 60 The NPRM stated that some states require the calculation of a non-excludable attendance bonus is
the proposed changes would ensure the leave to be based on hours worked. In that an excludable buy-back payment
consistent application of the same response to this comment, the results in the employee no longer
principles across differing leave Department notes that neither WHD in having that leave available to use, i.e.,
arrangements. 61 The Department also its guidance, nor the courts that have the employee's leave balance is
proposed to clarify that payments for addressed this issue, have determined diminished by the amount of leave
forgoing the use of leave are excludable that pay for forgoing leave is excludable "bought back." In contrast, where an
from the regular rate regardless of or not excludable on the basis of how employee receives an additional
whether they are paid during the same the paid leave was accrued. payment that does not affect his or her
pay period in which the previously Additionally, the Department recognizes leave balance, or the payment is
scheduled leave is forgone or during a that employers may use a variety of otherwise tied to factors that are not
subsequent pay period as a lump sum. bases for determining leave amounts, related to the holiday, vacation, or
A number of commenters representing such as hours or days worked or length illness period, such payment may be an
both employers and employees of service. Therefore, the Department attendance bonus that is not excludable
addressed this proposal. See, e.g., has concluded that the proposed from the regular rate. As ewe noted in
Center for Workplace Compliance regulatory language need not be its comment, the distinction between an
(CWC); International Municipal Lawyers modified as suggested. The method of excludable payment for forgoing leave
Association (IMLA); Wood Floor computation or accrual of paid leave is and an attendance bonus is usually very
Covering Association (WFCA); National not determinative. Under the language fact specific. 64 Because this issue is
Public Labor Employer Relations in the regulation finalized in this rule, more appropriately addressed through
Association (NPELRA); Chamber; the fact that paid leave may be accrued subregulatory guidance, the Department
National Employment Law Project on an hourly basis would not disqualify declines to amend the regulation as
(NELP); Association of Firefighters; the pay for forgoing such leave from being suggested. The Department notes,
American Federation of Labor and excludable from the regular rate. however, that§ 778.219(a), as adopted
Congress of Industrial Organizations NELP, while generally agreeing with in this final rule, does not affect
(AFL----CIO). Many supported the the Department's proposed amendments § 778.211(c), which addresses the
changes as proposed. See, e.g., to§ 778.219, requested clarification that exclusion of discretionary bonuses from
Associated Builders and Contractors; regardless of the type of leave, it still the regular rate pursuant to FLSA
Seyfarth Shaw (Seyfarth); PPWO; must comply with the statutory section 7(e)(3)(a). 65
Society for Human Resource requirements that it be "occasional" and A few commenters addressed the
Management (SHRM); National "similar to vacation, holiday or illness" requirement that the pay for forgoing the
Automobile Dealers Association in order to be excluded from the regular leave be approximately equivalent to the
(NADA); Society of Independent rate. The Department acknowledges employee's normal earnings. See
Gasoline Marketers of America NELP's concern but does not believe Chamber; NPELRA; Association of
(SIGMA); NDA. SHRM stated that the that any modification to the proposed Firefighters. The Chamber asserted that
proposal harmonizes the regulation regulatory text in§ 778.219 is necessary. there was no statutory basis for
"with the realities of the modern Given the statutory language in section requiring that the payment for the
workplace" by treating all forms ofleave 7(e)(2) that, to be excludable, this form forgone leave be approximately
in the same manner. NPELRA of payment must be made "for equivalent to the employee's normal
occasional periods when no work is earnings for the amount of time covered
commented that the proposal "makes performed due to vacation, holiday, by the forgone leave and therefore
common sense." NELP expressed
illness, . . . or other similar cause," 62 argued that this requirement be removed
general agreement with the proposal. the Department believes that this is entirely. NPELRA requested that the
WFCA asked that the regulation already clear and therefore further proposed regulatory language in
specify that the payout of unused leave clarification in the regulation is § 778.219 be modified to permit
is still excludable from the regular rate unnecessary. exclusion of a payment for an
even if the amount of leave accrued is ewe suggested that the Department employee's unused leave where that
based on the number of hours worked. add an example illustrating the
Rather than accruing leave on a periodic difference between attendance-based 63 29 U.S.C. 207(e)(3); see 29 CFR 778.211(c); see
incentive bonuses, which must be also 84 FR 11888, 11892 n. 57.
60 See FOH 32d03e. 64 See WHD Opinion Letter FLSA2009-19, 2009
61 See, e.g .. Balestrieri v. Menlo Park Fire Prat.
included in the regular rate, and valid
WL 649021 at *4 (Jan. 16, 2009) (concluding that
Dist .. 800 F.3d 1094, 1103-04 (9th Cir. 2015) payments for forgoing leave, which can vacation buy-back payments were excludable, but
(holding that annual leave comprised of both sick be excluded. The Department declines stipends for nonuse of sick leave encouraged
and vacation leave need not be included in the to modify the regulatory text as employees not to use or abuse sick leave and
regular rate under section 7( e )(2)). The NPRM suggested. As discussed in the NPRM, therefore were a form of attendance bonus that was
explained that such payments need not be included not excludable); WHD Opinion Letter FLSA2006-
in the regular rate under section 7(e)(2) for the same in some situations, employers may make 18NA, 2006 WL 4512960, at *2 (July 24, 2006)
reason that payments for unused vacations or payments to encourage attendance at (holiday payments made to employees when they
holidays need not be included; it makes no work rather than compensating forgo holidays need not be included in the regular
difference that payments for unused annual leave employees for forgoing the use of leave. rate because the employees continued to receive
or paid time off may include unused sick leave. See compensation at their customary rate for hours
also WHD Opinion Letter FLSA2006-18NA, 2006 Attendance bonuses are typically non- worked in addition to receiving holiday pay); WHD
WL 4512960 (July 24, 2006) (holiday payments discretionary bonuses that must be Opinion Letter FLSA2004-2NA (April 5, 2004)
made to employees when they forgo holidays need included in the regular rate because (cashed-out accrued vacation time need not be
not be included in the regular rate pursuant to they are made "pursuant to [a] contract, included in the regular rate because such payments
section 7(e)(2)); WHD Opinion Letter FLSA2004- were made at employees• applicable hourly rate and
2NA, 2004 WL 5303030 (Apr. 5, 2004) (cashed-out agreement, or promise causing the in addition to receiving their customary payment
accrued vacation time need not be included in for hours worked).
regular rate pursuant to section 7(e)(2)). 62 29 U.S.C. 207(e)(2); see also 29 CFR 778.218. 65 See 29 U.S.C. 207(e)(3)(a); 29 CFR 778.211(c).
DOLAR0915
Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG Document 80-15 Filed 09/18/26 Page 7 of 194
68742 Federal Register/Vol. 84, No. 241/Monday, December 16, 2019/Rules and Regulations
payment is a percentage of the amount attendance bonuses, which are generally period of an employee's work tenure. 71
that would normally be paid to the considered to be non-discretionary Thus, the court's decision in Acton does
employee when using the leave. bonuses that must be included in the not inform the proper interpretation of
NPELRA stated that instead of paying regular rate. The example provided by the statutory exclusion of payments for
100 cents on the dollar, employers NPELRA, which results in buying back occasional periods when no work is
should be permitted to pay a percentage sick leave in amounts that are not performed due to vacation, holiday, or
of accrued leave, which is often based approximately equivalent to the illness contained in section 7(e)(2) and
on a calculation negotiated with union employee's normal earnings for a explained in§ 778.219. 72 Contrary to
representatives and takes into account similar period of working time, these two cases, the Department agrees
time-in-service and the total amount of illustrates why this requirement is with both the conclusion and
sick leave that an employee has accrued. necessary. In that example, some of the underlying reasoning in Balestrieri v.
NPELRA provided an example in which forgone sick leave is "bought back" at Menlo Park Fire Protection District. 73
an employee with 20 or more years of only 20 percent of the dollar value of There, the court held that buy back
service would be paid out for his or her that leave. For these reasons, the payments for annual leave, which
unused sick leave at 20 percent if the Department has decided to adopt included both sick and vacation leave,
employee had accrued between 1 and § 778.219 as proposed. need not be included in the regular rate.
125 hours of leave, 40 percent for 126 Association of Firefighters and the While acknowledging that some sick-
to 255 hours, 60 percent for 256-380 AFL-CIO contended that the leave buy-back programs, such as the
hours, and 80 percent for 381-607 Department's proposal to permit the one at issue in the 2009 WHD opinion
hours. By contrast, Association of exclusion of pay for forgoing sick leave letter, could function like an attendance
Firefighters commented that the is contrary to two appellate cases. 67 bonus and therefore require their
Department did not provide any First, the court in Chavez relied on inclusion in the regular rate, the annual
definition of what constitutes an § 778.219-and in particular, its explicit leave that was bought back in Balestrieri
"approximate equivalent" amount and reference to pay for vacation leave but did not differentiate between sick leave
expressed concern that buy-back lack of reference to pay for sick leave- and vacation leave. As a result, any
payments at "sub-premium" rates will to conclude that vacation-leave buy- portion of the annual leave that could be
now be permitted. back payments were excludable, but attributed to sick leave did not function
The Department declines to modify that sick-leave buy-back payments must as an attendance bonus. 74
the language in proposed§ 778.219 to be included in the regular rate. 68 In Lastly, IMLA requested that the
either remove the requirement that characterizing the Department's position Department provide an additional
payments be made in amounts on this issue, however, the court did not example to§ 778.219(a) concerning the
"approximate[ly] equivalent" or to acknowledge WHD's statement in the excludability of "holiday-in-lieu" pay
provide a formulaic definition as to FOH that the same rules governing from the regular rate. IMLA notes that
what constitutes an "approximate exclusion of payments for unused some employees, particularly public
equivalent." As an initial matter, the vacation leave also apply to payments sector emergency response personnel,
Department notes that this requirement for unused sick leave. 69 Moreover, in work a set schedule without regard to
is currently required under§ 778.218, citing a 2009 WHD opinion letter, 70 the holidays. Due to the nature of their
which addresses the statutory provision court did not consider the fact-specific work, such employees may be called
providing for exclusion of payments for nature of the buy-back program at issue upon to forgo a recognized holiday if
occasional periods when no work is there, which, as discussed above, their schedule requires them to work
performed due to vacation, holiday, and functioned as an attendance bonus. that day or if an emergency arises. IMLA
illness. Section 778.218 has long Nothing in the current language in states that the current regulations permit
provided that payments for such time § 778.219 or the 2009 opinion letter the excludability of such payments, but
that "are in amounts approximately state that a sick-leave buy-back payment that several courts have nevertheless
equivalent to the employee's normal can never be excluded from the regular held that similar forms of "holiday-in-
earnings," are not compensation for rate. In the second case, Acton, the court lieu" payments must be included in the
hours of employment and are therefore neither cited nor discussed the language regular rate. 75
excludable from the regular rate. 66 in section 7(e)(2) that permits exclusion Current Department regulations
Given that§ 778.219's exclusion of pay of payments for occasional periods support excluding holiday-in-lieu pay
for forgoing leave is derived from when no work is performed due to from the regular rate. Under 29 CFR
§ 778.218, the well-established vacation, holiday, or illness, or 778.219, where an employee forgoes his
inclusion of this requirement in the § 778.219, which interprets this 71 See 436 F.3d at 977.
latter warrants its inclusion in the statutory provision. Instead, the court 72 See 29 U.S.C. 207(e)(2); 29 CFR 778.219.
former. Additionally, requiring mistakenly applied§ 778.223 to 73 See 800 F.3d 1094, 1103 (9th Cir. 2015).
excludable payments for forgoing leave determine whether buy-back payments 74 See 800 F.3d at 1102-04.
to be approximately equivalent to the were similar to call-back pay, and 75 See Hart v. City of Alameda, No. C-07-
employee's normal earnings helps ultimately concluded that the sick-leave 5845MMC, 2009 WL 1705612, at *3 (N.D. Cal. June
ensure that the payments are true leave buy back must be included in the 17, 2009) (holiday pay received by city police
officers every pay period must be included in the
buy-back payments rather than regular rate as it constitutes regular rate); Lewis v. County of Colusa, No. 2:16-
compensation for the general work duty cv-01745-VC, 2018 WL 1605754, at *3 (E.D. Cal.
66 29 CFR 778.218; see FOH 32d03g ("Payment of regular attendance over a significant Apr. 3, 2018) (defendant did not meet burden to
for absences charged against leave under a bona fide show that biannual lump-sum holiday in-lieu
plan granting the employee a specified amount of 67 See Chavez v. City of Albuquerque, 630 F.3d
payments to safety officers and dispatchers fall
annual, vacation, or sick leave with pay need not squarely within section 7(e)(2)); McKinnon v. City
be included in the regular rate of pay, if the sum 1300, 1309 (10th Cir. 2011); Acton v. City of of Merced, No. 118CV01124LJOSAB, 2018 WL
paid is the approximate equivalent of the Columbia, 436 F.3d 969, 977-78 (8th Cir. 2006). 6601900, at *5-8 (E.D. Cal. Dec. 17, 2018) (finding
68 See 630 F.3d at 1308-09.
employee"s normal earnings for a similar period of that payments are not excludable where it was "not
69 See FOH 32d03e.
working time. Payments for such absences may be apparent that Plaintiffs are in fact entitled to paid
excluded regardless of when or how the leave is 70 WHD Opinion Letter FLSA2009-19, 2009 WL time off at the holidays which they are able to
taken.""). 649021 (Jan. 16, 2009). forego"").
DOLAR0916
Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG Document 80-15 Filed 09/18/26 Page 8 of 194
Federal Register/Vol. 84, No. 241/Monday, December 16, 2019/Rules and Regulations 68743
or her holiday and works, and is paid Section 778.320 addresses "[h]ours establish that the parties have treated
for his or her normal work plus an that would not be hours worked if not the time as hours worked. The
additional amount for the holiday, the paid for," and identifies "time spent in Department explained in the NPRM
additional amount paid for working the eating meals between working hours" as that, in the Department's enforcement
holiday is not included in the regular an example. 80 Section 778.320(b) experience, the treatment of bona fide
rate. The Department applied this further states that even when such time meal breaks is frequently not subject to
principle in a 2006 opinion letter is compensated, the parties may agree formal agreement and is often
concluding that holiday-in-lieu pay that the time will not be counted as established by informal policy or course
could be excluded from the regular rate hours worked. of conduct. Payments for such periods
where the employer provided nine The Department proposed to remove need only be included in the regular
"recognized" holidays and two the reference to "lunch periods" in rate when it appears from all the
"floating" holidays paid in a lump sum, § 778.218(b) to eliminate any pertinent facts that the parties have
and on occasion when employees forgo uncertainty about its relation to treated compensated bona fide meal
a holiday and work they received both § 778.320 concerning the excludability periods as hours worked. The NPRM
pay for the hours worked and holiday of payments for bona fide meal periods noted that the proposal would clarify
pay. 76 The Department notes that it does from the regular rate. As one court the existing requirements and not
not matter whether the employee noted, the existing regulations in substantively change either the
voluntarily forgoes the holiday to work §§ 778.218 and 778.320 "appear calculation of the regular rate or the
or is required to work the holiday by the somewhat inconsistent" on the determination of hours worked.
schedule set for the employee. Nothing excludability from the regular rate of The Department received many
in this regulation makes the compensation for bona fide meal comments supporting these changes and
excludability of such payments periods. 81 In 1986, WHD acknowledged no comments opposed to the changes.
dependent on the employee having the in an opinion letter "that the reference See, e.g., NDA; Associated Builders and
option to work or not work on the to meal periods in section 778.218(b) of Contractors; NADA; CWC; SHRM;
holiday. All that is required for the Part 778 may not be compatible with the PPWO. Accordingly, the Department
holiday-in-lieu pay to be excludable is position which is contained in section adopts the changes to§§ 778.218(b) and
that the employee is paid an amount for 778.320(b)," and indicated that the issue 778.320 as proposed.
the holiday, in addition to being paid was under review. 82 The Department 3. Additional Examples of "Other
for his hours worked on the holiday. 77 subsequently clarified in a 1996 opinion Similar Causes"
In response to IMLA's comments, the letter that pay provided for a bona fide
Department has added an additional meal period is excludable from the As noted above,§ 778.218 addresses
example to§ 778.219(a) involving regular rate under§ 778.320(b). 83 As the clause of FLSA section 7(e)(2) that
employees who work a set schedule explained in the NPRM, while the permits employers to exclude certain
irrespective of holidays to clarify the Department clarified its position in an payments for occasional periods when
regulation. opinion letter more than 20 years ago, no work is performed "due to vacation,
it is nonetheless concerned that the holiday, illness, failure of the employer
2. Exclusion of Compensation for Bona to provide sufficient work, or other
Fide Meal Periods language in§ 778.218(b) may cause
confusion concerning the excludability similar cause." 85 Section 778.218(d)
Section 778.218 addresses the clause of pay for bona fide meal periods. Thus, lists examples that qualify as "other
of FLSA section 7(e)(2) concerning to remove any ambiguity and to codify similar causes," including "absences
payments made for occasional periods its interpretation in regulation, the due to jury service, reporting to a draft
when no work is performed and Department proposed to delete the board, attending a funeral of a family
provides that when payments for such reference to "lunch periods" from member, [and] inability to reach the
time "are in amounts approximately § 778.218(b). workplace because of weather
equivalent to the employee's normal Bona fide meal periods are not condition."
earnings," they are not compensation considered "hours worked" for The Chamber requested that the
for hours of employment and may be purposes of the FLSA's minimum wage Department "add paid family medical
excluded from the regular rate. 78 or overtime requirements, and leave as an example in§ 778.218(d), and
Section 778.218(b) states that this clause employers are not required to pay for paid leave for military service; voting;
"deals with the type of absences which such time. 84 The Department proposed attending child custody or adoption
are infrequent or sporadic or changing§ 778.320 to clarify that the hearings; attending school activities;
unpredictable" and "has no relation to payment of compensation for bona fide donating organs, bone marrow, or blood;
regular 'absences' such as lunch periods meal periods alone does not convert voluntarily serving as a first responder;
nor to regularly scheduled days of such time to hours worked unless and any other paid leave required under
rest." 79 agreement or actual course of conduct state or local laws." Upon review, the
Department believes these are all
76 FLSA2006-18NA, 2006 WL 4512960 (July 24,
80 See 29 CFR 778.320. examples of non-routine absences that
2006). Cf. WHD Opinion Letter FLSA, 1999 WL fall within the meaning of "other similar
1788163, at *2 (Sept. 30, 1999) (payments received
81 Smiley v. E.I. Dupont De Nemours & Co., 839
by employees were required to be included in the F.3d 325, 331 n.5 (3d Cir. 2016). causes" in FLSA section 7(e)(2).
regular rate where employees were not entitled to 82 WHD Opinion Letter FLSA-937 (July 22, 1986).
Accordingly, the Department is adding
take leave on holidays and instead received an 83 See WHD Opinion Letter FLSA, 1996 WL
these causes for absences in the list of
additional 5 percent of base pay each pay period 1031805 (Dec. 3, 1996); see also Ballaris v. Wacker
as "in lieu of holiday pay.""), Siltronic Corp., 370 F.3d 901, 909 (9th Cir. 2004)
examples of "other similar causes." The
77 Thus, the Department disagrees with the (holding that pay for a bona fide lunch period was Department further believes that
McKinnon court"s reliance on the word "forgo•• in "properly excluded from the calculation of the attending any funeral, not just the
§ 778.219 to mean that the employee must have the regular rate under 29 U.S.C. 207(e)(2) as interpreted funeral of a family member, is an "other
option of not working on the holiday for the by revised§ 778.320° 0); WHD Opinion Letter FLSA,
holiday-in-lieu pay to be excludable. See 1997 WL 998021 (July 21, 1997) (stating that pay
similar cause" under FLSA section
McKinnon, 2018 WL 6601900 at *5, for bona fide meal periods need not be included in 7(e)(2). Therefore, the Department is
78 29 CFR 778.218; see 29 U.S.C. 207(e)(2). the regular rate).
79 29 CFR 778.218(b), 84 See 29 CFR 785.19. 85 29 CFR 778.218; see 29 U.S.C. 207(e)(2).
DOLAR0917
Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG Document 80-15 Filed 09/18/26 Page 9 of 194
68744 Federal Register/Vol. 84, No. 241/Monday, December 16, 2019/Rules and Regulations
deleting "of a family member" from the traveling to and from work, buying All of the comments regarding this
text of§ 778.218(d). lunch, paying rent, and the like," are proposal were supportive and agreed
not excluded from the regular rate under that the limitation imposed by the word
4. Reimbursable Expenses the "reimbursable expenses" clause of "solely" in the current regulation could
The second clause of section 7(e)(2) section 7(e)(2). 90 be overly restrictive and is not required
excludes from the regular rate Similarly, as the NPRM explained, the by the FLSA. See Associated Builders
"reasonable payments for traveling Department's opinion letters do not and Contractors; CWC; Chamber; Fisher
expenses, or other expenses, incurred by analyze whether an expense is incurred Phillips; NADA; PPWO; Seyfarth;
an employee in the furtherance of his solely for the employer's convenience SHRM; SIGMA. Two of these
employer's interests and properly when discussing whether it may be commenters also asked that the
reimbursable by the employer[.]" 86 excluded from the regular rate. Instead, Department add a new sentence
Section 778.217 currently states that the opinion letters analyze simply explicitly stating that "business
"[w]here an employee incurs expenses whether expenses benefit the expenses need not be solely or primarily
on his employer's behalf or where he is employer. 91 Furthermore, since 1955, incurred for the employer's benefit."
required to expend sums solely by the Department's policy in WHD's FOH See Associated Builders and
reason of action taken for the has mirrored the statutory requirement Contractors; Chamber.
convenience of his employer, section that "expenses incurred by an employee The Department has decided to
7(e)(2) is applicable to reimbursement in furtherance of his/her employer's finalize its proposal to remove the word
for such expenses." 87 The Department interests" may be excluded from the "solely" from§ 778.217(a) to better align
promulgated this section in February regular rate, regardless of whether they the regulations with the FLSA. As
1950. 88 "solely" benefit one party or the other. 92 explained above, the FLSA does not
While§ 778.217, in its current form, In the NPRM, the Department pointed impose a limitation on the proportion of
limits reimbursable expenses to those out that, consistent with the benefit to the employer in order for
"solely" in the interest of the employer, Department's practice and guidance, reimbursed expenses to be excludable.
the statutory language does not include courts have not analyzed whether the The Department does not believe it is
this limitation. Instead, the FLSA expenses at issue were incurred solely necessary to further add a sentence
simply excludes all expenses incurred for the employer's convenience when stating that business expenses need not
"in the furtherance of [the] employer's determining whether they are be "solely or primarily incurred for the
interests[,]" 89 and, as explained further excludable from the regular rate. employer's benefit" in order to be
below, neither the Department nor the Instead, courts have emphasized the excludable. The removal of the term
courts have since restricted excludable statutory requirement that the expenses "solely" adequately aligns the
expenses to only those that "solely" need only benefit the employer. 93 regulations with the statute.
benefit the employer. As explained in The Department also proposed to
the NPRM, the Department is concerned 90 29 CFR 778.217(d). The NPRM noted that this
clarify section 7(e)(2)'s requirement that
is consistent with the illustrative examples in
that this single use of the word "solely" § 778.217(b) only "reasonable" and "properly
ofreimbursable expenses that may be
in§ 778.217 may be interpreted as more excluded from the regular rate, which include reimbursable" expenses may be
restrictive than what the FLSA actually "purchasing supplies, tools, materials, or excluded from the regular rate when
requires. The Department therefore equipment on behalf of his employer,"" travel reimbursed. Current§ 778.217(b)(3)
expenses, including living expenses away from permits employers to exclude from the
proposed to remove the word "solely" home, incurred while traveling for work for the
from§ 778.217(a) to clarify its employer"s benefit, and the cost of" supper money•• regular rate "[t]he actual or reasonably
interpretation of the reimbursable to an employee in a situation where "he or she approximate amount expended by an
expenses clause of section 7(e)(2). The would ordinarily leave work in time to have supper employee who is traveling 'over the
at home, but instead must remain to work road' on his employer's business, for
Department noted that this proposed additional hours for the employer"s benefit."" See 29
clarification was consistent with the CFR 778.217(b)(1), (2), (4). transportation . . . and living expenses
other subsections of§ 778.217, as well 91 For example, the cost of food for eating meals away from home, [or] other [such] travel
as court rulings and the Department's during travel out of town for work is for the expenses[.]" Section 778.217(c) cautions
opinion letters-which have not employer"s benefit; therefore, such reimbursement that "only the actual or reasonably
may be excluded from the regular rate. See WHD approximate amount of the expense is
required that excludable expenses solely Opinion Letter FLSA2004-3, 2004 WL 2146923
benefit the employer. (May 13, 2004); see also WHD Opinion Letter excludable from the regular rate. If the
Section 778. 217( d) also discusses FLSA-828 (July 19, 1976) ("[r]eimbursement to an amount paid as 'reimbursement' is
expenses that are excludable from the employee for expenses incurred on behalf of an disproportionately large, the excess
employer•• would not become part of the regular
regular rate. The Department explained rate); WHD Opinion Letter FLSA-940 (Mar. 9, 1977)
amount will be included in the regular
in the NPRM that this paragraph (regular rate shall not include "reimbursement for rate."
emphasizes only whether such expenses where an employee incurs out of pocket Two commenters asked the
payments benefit the employer or the expenses on the employer"s behalf""); WHD Opinion Department to clarify that specific
Letter FLSA, 1985 WL 1087356, at *2 (July 12, reimbursable expenses are excludable
employee; it does not require them to 1985) (reimbursement must be for "expenses
"solely" benefit one party or the other. incurred by the employee on the employer"s behalf from the regular rate. See NADA; AHLA.
Thus, payments for expenses that are or convenience''). These requests included "cell phone
"incurred by the employee on the 92 FOH 32d05a(a). reimbursement," "non-mandatory
employer's behalf or for his benefit or 93 See, e.g., Berryv. Excel Grp., Inc., 288 F.3d 252,
credentialing exam fees," "organization
253-54 (5th Cir. 2002) (concluding that membership dues," and reimbursements
convenience" merit exclusion from the reimbursements of travel expenses were primarily
regular rate, but reimbursements for for the employer"s benefit; therefore, such expenses for the cost of tools. These are clearly
expenses "incurred by the employee for were excluded from the regular rate); see also Sharp not compensation for hours of
his own benefit," such as "expenses in v. CGGLand, Inc., 840 F.3d 1211, 1215 (10th Cir. employment, but instead are expenses
2016) ("[T]he proper focus under§ 778.217(b)(3) is taken on by employees for the
whether the $35 payments are for reimbursement of
86 29 U.S.C. 207(e)(2). travel expenses incurred in furtherance of the employer's convenience or benefit.
8 7 29 CFR 778.217(a).
employer"s interests . . . .""); Brennan v. Padre
88 See 15 FR 623.
Drilling Co., Inc., 359 F. Supp. 462, 465 (S.D. Tex. by the employee in the furtherance of his
8 9 29 U.S.C. 207(e)(2). 1973) (per diem for traveling expenses is "expended employer"s interest"").
DOLAR0918
Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG Document 80-15 Filed 09/18/26 Page 10 of 194
Federal Register/Vol. 84, No. 241/Monday, December 16, 2019/Rules and Regulations 68745
Because "[t]he actual amount expended necessarily unreasonable. As the NPRM rates set by the IRS on travel expenses
by an employee in purchasing . . . explained, a payment may be more than are per se unreasonable. 99
tools" is already included in the that required "to minimize
5. Other Similar Payments
regulation's illustrations of excludable administrative costs" yet still within the
reimbursements, the Department realm of reasonable business and Section 7(e) requires "all
believes sufficient guidance is available industry norms. remuneration for employment" be
regarding tool reimbursements. 94 A number of commenters supported included in the regular rate, subject to
However, to provide additional clarity the Department's proposal to state in the that section's eight listed exclusions.
regarding cell phone reimbursement, regulatory text that reimbursements for Section 7(e)(2) consists of three clauses,
exam fees, and membership dues, the travel expenses are per se reasonable if each of which address a distinct
Department has decided to revise the they do not exceed the rates in the category of excludable compensation.
language of the illustration provided at Federal Travel Regulation. See, e.g., As discussed above, the first excludes
§ 778.217(b)(1) to make clear that these NDA; PPWO; SIGMA; SHRM; Chamber. "payments made for occasional periods
too are excludable reimbursements. Several commenters noted that the when no work is performed due to
The NPRM proposed additional Federal Travel Regulation rates are vacation, holiday, illness, failure of the
explanation of what is "reasonable"- below market rate, and that in many employer to provide sufficient work, or
and thus not "disproportionately cases expenses exceeding that amount other similar cause." The second
large"-by referring to the Federal may still be reasonable. To address this excludes "reasonable payments for
Travel Regulation. The Department issue, some commenters recommended traveling expenses, or other expenses,
explained that it believes that the that the Department finalize proposed incurred by an employee in the
amounts set in the Federal Travel paragraph (c)(3) stating that costs furtherance of his employer's interests
Regulation are not excessive and are exceeding the Federal Travel Regulation and properly reimbursable by the
easily ascertained, given its "two may still be reasonable, and two employer." The third clause of section
principal purposes" of "balanc[ing] the recommended that the Department 7(e)(2) excludes from the regular rate
need to assure that official travel is develop additional guidance about the "other similar payments to an employee
conducted in a responsible manner with Federal Travel Regulations after which are not made as compensation for
the need to minimize administrative issuance of the final rule. See AHLA; his hours of employment."
costs" and "communicat[ing] the CWC; Chamber; SIGMA; SHRM. Two As explained in the NPRM, "[o]ther
resulting policies in a clear manner to commenters noted that many employers . . . payments" are "similar" to those in
Federal agencies and employees." 95 use Internal Revenue Service (IRS) the first two clauses of section 7(e)(2)
The Department thus proposed to add guidelines for reimbursement of because they are "not made as
regulatory text explaining that a employee travel expenses, and compensation for [an employee's] hours
payment for an employee traveling on suggested that the final rule also state of employment." The first two clauses
his or her employer's business is per se that expenses not exceeding the IRS's share the essential characteristic of
reasonable if it is at or beneath the guidelines for reimbursement of having no connection to the quantity or
maximum amounts reimbursable or employee travel expenses are per se quality of work performed. The "other
allowed for the same type of expense reasonable. See NDA; PPWO. similar payments" clause thus excludes
under the Federal Travel Regulation and payments not tied to an employee's
The Department has decided to
meets§ 778.217's other requirements. hours worked, services rendered, job
modify the language in proposed
Those other requirements include that § 778.217(c)(2) to state that payments performance, or other criteria linked to
the reimbursement be for the "actual or the quality or quantity of the employee's
equal to or less than the Federal Travel
reasonably approximate amount" 96 of work. 100
Regulation rates or the substantiation
the expense, that the expense be amounts for travel expenses permitted The NPRM explained that, in a sense,
incurred on the employer's behalf, and every benefit or payment that an
by the IRS under 26 CFR 1.274-5(g) and
that the expense not vary with hours employer gives an employee is
(j) are per se reasonable and not
worked. 97 The proposed regulatory text disproportionately large. 98 The
also clarified that a reimbursement for See id.
Department has also decided to finalize 99
an employee traveling on his or her 100 See Reich v. Interstate Brands Corp., 57 F.3d
the regulatory language in proposed
employer's business exceeding the § 778.217(c)(3) noting that
574, 578 (7th Cir. 1995) ("The word 'similar" then
Federal Travel Regulation limits is not refers to other payments that do not depend at all
§ 778.217(c)(2) does not create an on when or how much work is performed."");
94 See 29 CFR 778.217(b)(1). inference that amounts in excess of the Minizza v. Stone Container Corp., 842 F.2d 1456,
Federal Travel Regulation rates or the 1461 (3d Cir. 1988) ("[W]e interpret the phrase
95 41 CFR 300-1.2. Those amounts are published 'other similar payments• by reading each clause of
online annually by the General Services section 207(e)(2) separately. The phrase 'other
Administration. See Plan and Book, GSA, 98 Under the authority of 26 U.S.C. 274(d), 26 CFR similar payments . . . not made as compensation
www.gsa.gov/travel/plan-and-book (last visited 1.274-5(g) and 26 CFR 1.274-5(j), the IRS for hours of employment" does not mean just other
Aug. 23, 2019). Commissioner has prescribed special per diem payment for idle hours or reimbursements, the two
96 Gagnon v. United Technisource, Inc., 607 F.3d
methods under which a taxpayer may use a types of payments set forth in the two preceding
1036, 1041-42 (5th Cir. 2010), provides a helpful specified amount in lieu of substantiating the actual clauses of the section, but payments not tied to
contrast to a properly excludable reimbursement. costs of certain travel while away from home. IRS hours of compensation, of which payments for idle
There, multiple facts indicated that the employee"s guidelines regarding special per diem and meals hours and reimbursements are only two
purported "per diem•• was simply a scheme to and incidental expenses (M&IE) methods are set examples. 00
But see Flores v. City of San Gabriel,
).
avoid paying overtime. Those facts included the per forth in Revenue Procedure 2011-47, 2011-42 I.R.B. 824 F.3d 890, 899 (9th Cir. 2016) ("the 'key point"••
diem's rise over time without any clear connection 520, 2011 WL 4503974 (Oct. 17, 2011). The IRS for exclusion under the third clause "is whether the
to travel or other expenses, its variance by the hour, publishes the special per diem rates in an annual payment is 'compensation for work"•• (quoting
its cap at 40 hours per week, and its payment in notice. See Notice 2019-55 (2019-42 !RB 937) (or Local 246 Utility Workers Union of Am. v. S. Cal.
combination with a well-below-market wage. successor), available at: https://www.irs.gov/pub/ Edison Co., 83 F.3d 292, 295 (9th Cir. 1996)); Acton,
97 See, e.g., Baouch v. Werner Enters., Inc., 908 irs-drop/n-19-55.pdf. Revenue Procedure 2011-47 436 F.3d at 976 ("Section 207(e)(2), properly
F.3d 1107, 1116 (8th Cir. 2018) ("Per diem provides optional substantiation methods (for understood, operates not as a separate basis for
payments that vary with the amount of work example, meal and incidental expenses only per exclusion, but instead clarifies the types of
performed are part of the regular rate.""), petition for diem allowance, special rules for the transportation payments that do not constitute remuneration for
cert. filed, (U.S. June 13, 2019) (No. 18-1541). industry, and the high-low substantiation method). employment for purposes of section 207."").
DOLAR0919
Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG Document 80-15 Filed 09/18/26 Page 11 of 194
68746 Federal Register/Vol. 84, No. 241/Monday, December 16, 2019/Rules and Regulations
"remuneration for employment." 101 similar payments" cannot be simply Second, the Seventh Circuit espoused
Certainly benefits like paid vacation or wages in another guise. When a a similar understanding in Reich v.
sick leave are seen as such by many payment is a wage supplement, even if Interstate Brands Corp. 110 There, the
employers and employees. But the not tied directly to employee court held that regular, planned $12
section 7(e)(2) exclusions make clear performance or hours worked, it is still payments to bakers who worked weeks
that whether or not they are compensation for "hours of without two consecutive days off could
remuneration, they are "not made as employment." For example, payments not be excluded from the regular rate
compensation for [the employee's] such as production bonuses, 103 and the under section 7(e)(2). The court
hours of employment" because they cost of furnished board, lodging, or reasoned that the payments were
have no relationship to the employee's facilities, 104 which "though not directly materially no different from a higher
hours worked or services rendered. This attributable to any particular hours of base rate to compensate the bakers for
interpretation gives meaning to the third work are, nevertheless, clearly taking on an unpleasant schedule. 111
clause. It allows employers to provide understood to be compensation for "Other similar payments" are different,
benefits unconnected to the quality or services" 105 are not excludable under wrote the court. "The word 'similar'
quantity of work, even if those benefits this provision. Similarly, payments that . . . refers to other payments that do not
are remuneration of a sort. differ only in form from regular wages depend at all on when or how much
The NPRM further explained that by, for instance, being paid in a monthly work is performed." 112
interpreting the third clause as simply a lump sum or as hardship premiums, are Similarly, the Sixth Circuit has held
restatement of the "remuneration" better characterized as wages or bonuses that pay differentials based on
requirement would contravene basic than as "other similar payments" employees' education level, shift
principles of statutory interpretation. excludable from the regular rate. The differentials, and hazardous pay are
Such an interpretation would equate the other similar payments clause cannot be compensation for services rendered,
unique phrases "all remuneration for interpreted so broadly as to "obliterate[] unlike payments that "are unrelated to
employment" and "compensation for the qualifications and limitations" [employees'] compensation for services
[the employee's] hours of employment," placed on excludable payments and hours of service." 113 Some circuit
even though Congress used different specifically addressed in section 7(e)'s courts have interpreted the "other
words and thus, presumably, meant various other sections, which could similar payments" not to exclude
different things. This is especially so render such limits "superfluous." 106 payments that are "compensation for
when considering that one phrase uses The NPRM stated that the work." 114 The Department concurs with
the word "employment" when the other Department's interpretation has these courts to the extent that they have
uses the term "hours of employment." considerable support in the case law, used these or similar phrases to capture
Such an interpretation would also citing multiple decisions. First, the the idea that the regular rate includes
render the third clause redundant, Third Circuit held in Minizza v. Stone payments tied to work performance or
another disfavored result. And it would Container Corp. that two lump sums that function as a wage supplement. But
be difficult to reconcile with the first paid to select employees to induce them insofar as these courts have equated
clause of section 7(e)(2), in which the to agree to a collective-bargaining "compensation for work" with
payments are clearly remuneration yet agreement were excludable as an "other "remuneration for employment," 115
excludable from the regular rate. similar payment" because they were not that is difficult to reconcile with the text
The NPRM also explained that compensation for hours worked or of the FLSA. As explained above, the
payments to employees are not services rendered. 107 The court FLSA uses two different phrases,
excludable under the "other similar interpreted the clause to exclude "remuneration for employment" and
payments" clause merely because the "payments not tied to hours of "compensation for hours of
payments are not specifically tied to an compensation, of which payments for employment," each of which should be
employee's hours of work. 102 "Other idle hours and reimbursements are only given distinct content. And just as
two examples." 108 The court's decision importantly, the first clause of section
101 Cf. Minizza, 842 F.2d at 1460 ("Employers that these payments were not 7(e)(2) excludes vacation and sick leave,
have a finite amount to spend for the labor compensation for employment rested in which is clearly remunerative; "other
component of their product or service. This sum part on the fact that the "eligibility similar payments" to employees can be
can be allocated solely as compensation on an
hourly basis (in which event the payment would be requirements were not meant to serve as remunerative too.
fully includable in the 'regular rate"), or it can compensation for service, but rather to Accordingly, the NPRM explained,
assume any number of other forms . . . (in which reduce the employers' costs," but also in the proposed clarifications would
case the payments may or may not be includable ), part on the fact that "the eligibility promote a clear yet flexible standard for
in any ratio the parties care to set.""); Sec'y U.S. employers and employees to order their
Dep't of Laborv. Bristol Excavating, Inc., No. 17- terms themselves [for the lump sums]
3663, 2019 WL 3926937, at *3 (3d Cir. Aug. 20, [did] not require specific service"-it affairs. Payments are "other similar
2019) (clarifying that not all payments relating to did "not matter how many hours an payments" when they do not function
employment, regardless of source, qualify as employee worked during that period, as formulaic wage supplements and are
remuneration for employment and that, in the not tied to hours worked, services
context of third-party payments, a "payment nor how many hours he might work in
qualifies as remuneration for employment only the future." 109
when the employer and employee have effectively have been conditioned on a certain number of hours
agreed it will."). worked or on an amount of services provided.").
possibly exclude every payment that is not 110 57 F.3d 574.
102 See Local 246, 83 F.3d at 295 n.2 ("Even if
measured by the number of hours spent at work."). 111 See id. at 578-79.
payments to employees are not measured by the 103 See 29 CFR 778.21 l(c).
112 Id. at 578.
number of hours spent at work, that fact alone does 104 See 29 CFR 778.116.
113 Featsent, 70 F.3d at 904-06.
not qualify them for exclusion under section 105 29 CFR 778.224(a).
207(e)(2)."); Featsent v. City of Youngstown, 70 F.3d 114 See, e.g., Flores, 824 F.3d at 899.
106 Reich, 57 F.3d at 578.
900, 904 (6th Cir. 1995) ("7(e)(2) does not exclude 115 See Acton, 436 F.3d at 976 ("the language 'not
107 Minizza, 842 F.2d at 1461-62.
every payment not measured by hours of made as compensation for [the employee's] hours
108 Id. at 1461.
employment from the regular rate."); Reich, 57 F.3d of employment' posited in§ 207(e)(2) is but a mere
at 577 ("We cannot read§ 7(e)(2) in isolation . . . . 109 Id. at 1460-61; see also id. at 1462 ("If the re-articulation of the 'remuneration for
It is one among many exemptions, and a glance at payments were made as compensation for hours employment' requirement set forth in the
a few of the others shows that § 7( e )(2) cannot worked or services provided, the payments would preambulary language of§ 207(e)").
DOLAR0920
Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG Document 80-15 Filed 09/18/26 Page 12 of 194
Federal Register/Vol. 84, No. 241/Monday, December 16, 2019/Rules and Regulations 68747
rendered, job performance, or other added this set of examples in 1950. rate the cost of providing certain health
criteria linked to the quality or quantity Therefore, the Department proposed promotion and disease prevention
of the employee's work, but are clarifying in§ 778.224(b) that the activities, often known as wellness
conditioned merely on one being an following items may be excluded from programs. The NPRM noted that
employee. Conditions not tied to the an employee's regular rate under the examples of some common wellness
quality or quantity of work performed, "other similar payments" clause of programs include health risk
such as a reasonable waiting period for section 7(e)(2). assessments, biometric screenings,
eligibility 116 or the requirement to
a. Specialist Treatment Provided Onsite; vaccination clinics (including annual
repay benefits as a remedy for employee Gym Access, Gym Memberships, and flu vaccinations), nutrition classes,
misconduct, are permitted. This Fitness Classes; Wellness Programs; weight loss programs, smoking cessation
standard also clarifies that there is space
for a variety of creative benefits Discounts on Retail Goods and Services programs, stress reduction programs,
offerings, and encourages their The Department proposed clarifying exercise programs, and coaching to help
provision to wide groups of employees in§ 778.224(b)(3) that employers may employees meet health goals. 125
instead of reserving them only for exclude from the regular rate the cost of Wellness programs are often provided to
FLSA-exempt employees. providing onsite treatment from employees enrolled in an employer-
Section 778.224 addresses specialists such as chiropractors, sponsored health insurance plan, but
miscellaneous items that are excludable massage therapists, personal trainers, some employers offer wellness programs
from an employee's regular rate under counselors, Employment Assistance to employees regardless of their health
the "other similar payments" clause of Programs, or physical therapists. 121 As insurance coverage. The NPRM stated
section 7(e)(2) because they are "not explained in the NPRM, such specialist that workplace wellness programs are
made as compensation for . . . hours of treatment resembles "on-the-job medical similar to "on-the-job medical care" and
employment[.]" 117 Section 778.224(b) care," which§ 778.224(b)(3) already "recreational facilities," conveniences
currently provides a brief, identifies as an excludable that the regulations already specify are
nonexhaustive set of examples of "other "convenience furnished to the excludable from an employee's regular
similar payments" excludable from an employee." 122 Employers that provide rate. 126 Employers may provide such
employee's regular rate: "(1) Sums paid onsite specialist treatment do so for a programs to, for example, reduce health
to an employee for the rental of his variety of reasons, including to raise care costs, reduce health-related
truck or car[;] (2) Loans or advances workplace morale, promote employee
health, and reduce healthcare costs. absenteeism, and improve employee
made by the employer to the health and morale.
employee[;] [and] (3) The cost to the The Department also proposed
employer of conveniences furnished to clarifying in§ 778.224(b)(3) that the cost The Department also proposed adding
the employee such as parking space, of providing employees with gym an example in§ 778.224(b)(5) to confirm
restrooms, lockers, on-the-job medical access, gym memberships, and fitness that discounts on retail goods and
care and recreational facilities." 118 The classes, whether onsite or offsite, is services may be excluded from the
NPRM noted that the Department added excludable from the regular rate. 123 regular rate of pay as long as they are
this set of examples to the part 778 These fitness benefits, the Department not tied to an employee's hours worked
regulations in 1950, 119 and has not explained, resemble "recreational or services rendered. The NPRM cited a
substantively amended them since. The facilities," which§ 778.224(b)(3) already survey that indicated that many
regulation makes clear that "it was not identifies as an excludable convenience employers provide employees with an
considered feasible" to provide an provided to employees. According to option to purchase these types of goods
exhaustive list of excludable "other one survey, a substantial number of or services at a discounted price relative
similar payments" given the "variety of employers provided fitness benefits. 124
to their full retail value. 127 Such
miscellaneous payments [that] are paid Employers may provide such
discounts are commonly available to
by an employer to an employee under conveniences for many reasons,
including to raise workplace morale, employees regardless of their quality or
peculiar circumstances." 120 quantity of work, and it is solely the
The Department explained in the promote employee health, and reduce
NPRM that it continues to believe that healthcare costs. employees' choice whether to purchase
providing a comprehensive list of all The Department proposed adding an anything under the discount. When
"other similar payments" excludable example in§ 778.224(b)(4) to clarify that these discounts are available to
under section 7(e)(2)'s third clause is employers may exclude from the regular employees regardless of their hours
infeasible. Nonetheless, the Department worked or services rendered, and are
recognized that an updated list would 121 This proposal is not intended to affect the not tied to any duties performed, they
further help employers understand their circumstances under which receiving medical qualify as "other similar payments"
attention at the direction of the employer is
legal obligations by addressing some of considered to be hours worked. See 29 CFR 785.43. 125 See, e.g., Soc"y for Human Res. Mgmt., "How
the innovative changes in compensation 122 29 CFR 778.224(b)(3).
to Establish and Design a Wellness Program,""
practices and workplace environments 123 In circumstances where maintaining a certain
h ttps ://www.shrm.org/resourcesandtool s/hr-top ics/
that have occurred since the Department level of physical fitness is a requirement of the pages/howtoestablishanddesignawellness
employee"s job, the cost to the employer of program.aspx (last accessed Aug. 26, 2019).
providing exercise opportunities is a facility
116 See Minizza, 842 F.2d at 1460 ("A review of 12 5 29 CFR 778.224(b)(3).
furnished "primarily for the benefit or convenience
127 See Soc"y for Human Res. Mgmt., "2018
the eligibility terms reflects a requirement only that of the employer,"" as described in § 531.3( d).
a payee achieve the status of an active employee for Facilities furnished for the employer"s benefit do Employee Benefits: The Evolution of Benefits,"" at
a specified period of time prior to receipt. It does not qualify as wages or remuneration for 31 (June 2018), https://www.shrm.org/hr-today/
not matter how many hours an employee worked employment and thus need not be included in the trends-and-forecasting/research-and-surveys!
during that period, nor how many hours he might regular rate. Documents/201 B%20Employee %20Benefits%
work in the future.""). 124 See Soc"y for Human Res. Mgmt., 2018 20Report.pdf(from 2014 to 2018, employers
1 17 29 U.S.C. 207(e)(2). offering an employee discount on company services
Employee Benefits: The Evolution of Benefits 23
1 13 29 CFR 778.224(b). ranged from 31 percent to 34 percent, and
(2018), available at https://www.shrm.org/hr-today/
119 See 15 FR 623 (1950) (codified at 29 CFR employers offering employer-sponsored personal
trends-and-forecasting/research-and-surveys!
778.7(g); relocated in 1968 to 29 CFR 778.224(b)). Documents/2018%20Employee%20Benefits% shopping (e.g., retail) discounts ranged from 11
120 29 CFR 778.224(a). 20Report.pdf. percent to 19 percent).
DOLAR0921
Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG Document 80-15 Filed 09/18/26 Page 13 of 194
68748 Federal Register/Vol. 84, No. 241/Monday, December 16, 2019/Rules and Regulations
under section 7(e)(2). 128 The NPRM § 778.224(a): "Payments are 'similar' § 778.224(a) so as to avoid duplicative
pointed out that more than 50 years ago, when the amount of the payment is not text.
the Department stated that such dependent on hours worked, To provide additional clarity, the
employee discounts are not included in production, or efficiency and when the Department is adding to § 778.224(a)
the regular rate of pay. In a 1962 amount of the payment is unaffected by two examples of conditions identified in
opinion letter, the Department found the quantity or quality of work the NPRM as being unconnected to the
that the value of "concessions granted to performed." The Department agrees that quality or quantity of work performed:
employees . . . on charges for telephone such a statement would provide further "reasonable waiting period for
service" was "not part of wages clarity and notes that the NPRM defined eligibility" and "the requirement to
includible in the regular rate of pay"- "other similar payments" in a repay benefits as a remedy for employee
in part because "[s]uch concessions comparable manner as "payments not misconduct." 133 The Department is also
appear to be similar to discounts on tied to an employee's hours worked, adding an additional example of a
merchandise offered by many retail services rendered, job performance, condition that is unconnected to the
establishments to their employees credentials, or other criteria linked to quality or quantity of work to
which [the Department] do[es] not the quality or quantity of the employee's § 778.224(a): "limiting eligibility on the
regard as wages." 129 The NPRM work." 130 Three items in the NPRM's basis of geographic location or job
explained that discounts like these are list of criteria not linked to the quality position." Payments that depends on
not fungible cash but merely a lower or quantity of work-"hours worked, location-for instance, offering benefits
price on the employer's offerings. They services rendered, [and] job for employees in certain states or
appeal only to the employees who want performance"-closely correspond with cities-are not related to work quality or
to use them and are limited to the "hours worked, production, or quantity. Nor do payments that depend
offered selection of goods or services. efficiency" from the Chamber's on an employee's job position-for
Employees must expend their own proposal. The NPRM also listed instance, offering a signing bonus to
funds to avail themselves of the "credentials." But upon further engineers but not salespersons.
discounts. The discounts are reflection, the Department believes that, Relatedly, in response to NELA's and
presumably limited in their value, since unlike the other listed criteria, NELP's comments, the Department
employers likely do not offer discounts credentials are not necessarily linked to believes that the addition of the above
that would materially harm their the quality or quantity of an employee's language to § 778.224(a) makes clear
business. And employers may also place work. that the proposed examples in
conditions on the discounts to protect Additional pay for education § 778.224(b) do not change the existing
their interests by, for instance, requiring credentials is generally connected with statutory analysis that the Department
that discounted restaurant meals be work quality or quantity, and therefore uses for determining whether a payment
eaten on the premises to prevent abuse. not excludable under§ 778.224, as is properly excluded, but instead simply
The Department received numerous "education advancement . . . enhances add examples of categories of payments
comments in support of these the quality of an employee's job that may be excluded as "other similar
clarifications, with many commenters performance." 131 However, because the payments." The Department will still
noting that the additional clarity connection between an employee's look to see if a benefit plan labeled a
provided by the additional examples in education credentials and his or her "wellness plan," for example, meets the
§ 778.224(b) will allow employers to quality or quantity of work may vary, statutory requirements of section 7(e)(2)
provide these types of benefits to the Department declines to include and corresponding regulatory
employees more frequently. See, e.g., "credentials" in the regulatory text as an requirements to determine whether the
Chamber; National Association of example of a criterion inextricably benefit is tied to hours worked, services
Health Underwriters (NAHU); HR Policy linked to the quality or quantity of the rendered, job performance, or other
Association (HR Policy); SHRM; employee's work. 132 In contrast, hours criteria linked to the quality or quantity
Seyfarth; NFIB. By contrast, a few worked, services rendered, and job of the employee's work. The benefit
commenters expressed concerns with performance are necessarily linked to must be conditioned only on being an
this proposed clarification. See, e.g., work quality or quantity, and therefore, employee, although conditions
National Employment Lawyers these are appropriate examples for the unconnected to the quality or quantity
Association (NELA); NELP. NELA regulatory text. Accordingly, the of work, such as a reasonable waiting
opposed this proposed clarification, Department has revised§ 778.224(a) period for eligibility, are permissible.
suggesting that the Department instead using language adapted from the NPRM Furthermore, as explained in the NPRM,
state that such payments "may be to clarify that "other similar payments" the benefit cannot be simply wages in
excluded from the regular rate only after are "payments that do not depend on another guise. When a payment is a
hours worked, services rendered, job wage supplement, even if not tied
a case by case analysis using applicable
principles." NELP similarly expressed performance, or other criteria that directly to employee performance or
depend on the quality or quantity of the hours, it is still compensation for "hours
concern that the added examples
employee's work." The Department has of employment." The additional
created per se categorical exclusions of
types of benefits. also revised§ 778.224(b)(5) to remove examples that the Department has
The Chamber asked the Department to language similar to that added in added to§ 778.224(b) do not change
add the following language to these requirements or the Department's
130 84 FR 11894. analysis regarding the appropriate
131 See Featsent v. City of Youngstown. 70 F.3d treatment of these benefits.
128 See Reich. 57 F.3d at 578 (payments under
900, 904 (6th Cir. 1995) (additional pay for
section 7(e)(2) are those "that do not depend at all education degrees was not excludable under
Commenters also identified numerous
on when or how much work is performed""); § 778.224). commonly provided employee perks
Minizza. 842 F.2d at 1462 (payments under section 132 See, e.g .. Duplesse v. Cty. of Los Angeles. 714 and asked the Department to clarify
7(e)(2) all "share the essential characteristic . . . of F. Supp. 2d 1045, 1053-54 (C.D. Cal. 2010)
not being compensation for hours worked or
whether these items would be
(additional pay for credentials were excludable
services rendered""). from the regular rate for firefighters who were not
excludable under section 7(e)(2). The
129 WHD Opinion LShowing the first 150,000 of 713,492 characters. Full text.