jain.com
Public record. We host this document directly; the copy served here does not depend on any third party. Retrieved November 14, 2026.
Read the documentAlso at archive.org ↗

Plus One Robotics, Inc. v. Artificial Intelligence Industry Association, Inc. — Entry #95: REPLY to Response to Motion, filed by Artificial Intelligence Imaging Association, Inc., Artificial Intelligence Industry Association, Inc., re 79 MOTION for…

Case: Plus One Robotics, Inc. v. Artificial Intelligence Industry Association, Inc. txwd · 5:25-cv-01197

filed September 23, 2025

What this document is

Docket entry #95 · filed November 04, 2026

REPLY to Response to Motion, filed by Artificial Intelligence Imaging Association, Inc., Artificial Intelligence Industry Association, Inc., re 79 MOTION for Confidentiality/Protective Order Enforcement and Disqualify Expert filed by Defendant Artificial Intelligence Industry Association, Inc., Defendant Artificial Intelligence Imaging Association, Inc. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit, # 2 Exhibit, # 3 Exhibit, # 4 Exhibit, # 5 Exhibit, # 6 Exhibit)(Ramachandran, Vivek) (Entered: 11/04/2026)

Who is involved

Why we have it

We follow this case because it names a company we track, although that company is not a party:

A free copy from the RECAP archive of federal court filings (mirrored at the Internet Archive), retrieved November 14, 2026. Federal court filings are public records.

URL
https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172865943/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172865943.95.0.pdf
Kind
court_filing
Publisher
RECAP
Published
2026-11-05 00:00:00-05:00
Retrieved
2026-11-14 06:51:13.373344-05:00
HTTP status
200
MIME
application/pdf
Bytes
208582
SHA-256
d488bb36d89039388795e54a290bbe0b4d569e5d4a113029f3b95c1429707fbb

Document text

12 page(s), 24,111 characters, converted from the PDF's text layer · plain text.

Full text
Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB            Document 95      Filed 11/04/26      Page 1 of 12


                       IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
                        FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
                               SAN ANTONIO DIVISION


 PLUS ONE ROBOTICS, INC.,                                 Case No. 5:25-CV-01197-OLG-HJB
 Plaintiff / Counter-Defendant,
 v.
 ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE INDUSTRY
 ASSOCIATION, INC., and ARTIFICIAL
 INTELLIGENCE IMAGING ASSOCIATION,
 INC.,
 Defendants / Counter-Plaintiffs.


   DEFENDANTS' REPLY IN SUPPORT OF THEIR EMERGENCY MOTION TO
 ENFORCE THE PROTECTIVE ORDER AND DISQUALIFY PLAINTIFF'S EXPERT
                             (DKT. 79)

        Defendants and Counter-Plaintiffs Artificial Intelligence Industry Association, Inc. and

Artificial Intelligence Imaging Association, Inc. (together, "AIIA") submit this reply in support of

their Emergency Motion to Enforce the Protective Order and Disqualify Plaintiff's Expert (Dkt.

79) ("Motion"), and in response to the Omnibus Response (Dkt. 90) of Plaintiff/Counter-

Defendant Plus One Robotics, Inc. ("Plus One"). Record citations are to the Declaration of Vivek

Ramachandran (Dkt. 81) ("Decl."), the September 10, 2026 hearing transcript (Dkt. 73) ("Tr."),

and the exhibits to Dkts. 90, 92, and 94.

I. Plus One does not dispute the facts of the October 14 disclosure.
        Plus One does not deny any fact on which the Motion rests. It gave AIIA's sealed,

Attorneys' Eyes Only Fourth Amended Preliminary Infringement Contentions to Prof. Bretl on

October 14, 2026; it did so one minute after AIIA objected ("We need the 10 days to vet your

expert for conflicts."); no Appendix A Undertaking had been served; and the Undertaking was first


                                                 1


    Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB              Document 95        Filed 11/04/26      Page 2 of 12


served two days later, at 6:38 p.m. on October 16. (Decl. ¶¶ 12, 14, 15, 23.) Plus One confirms the

sequence itself: it "specifically identified Prof. Bretl to AIIA by name and CV, gave notice, and

then shared the contentions," and served the Undertaking afterward. (Dkt. 90 at 11.) Paragraph

5(e) permits access to an expert only after the Undertaking and CV are served "at least ten (10)

days before access," and it provides that "[n]o disclosure shall occur until all such objections are

resolved by agreement or Court order." (Dkt. 27-1 ¶ 5(e).) Measured from the October 16 service,

the earliest permissible access was October 26; AIIA's objection remains unresolved; and Plus One

has still not identified what it gave Prof. Bretl, certified destruction or non-use, or stopped. (Decl.

¶ 34; Dkt. 94-1 at 3.) Plus One calls this receiving the contentions "a few days too soon." (Dkt. 90

at 11.) It was access with no Undertaking at all, over a written objection. The day after, Plus One

invoked the same Paragraph 5(e) to bar AIIA's expert from Plus One's designated material until

AIIA served a CV and Undertaking. (Decl. ¶ 16.) Both experts' Undertakings were served on

October 16; the only difference is that Plus One's expert has had AIIA's theories since October 14,

and AIIA's expert has had nothing. (Decl. ¶¶ 12, 16, 23.)

II. The September 10 sharing ruling covered Amazon, Intel, and RealSense, not a retained
expert.
       Plus One's defense is that "[t]he Sharing Order, not the Protective Order, has governed

AIIA's contentions since the September hearing." (Dkt. 90 at 11.) The record shows what the ruling

addressed. Plus One asked to "share them with third parties who are implicated by the contentions,

right. So Intel, RealSense, Amazon, their products are accused." (Tr. 15:11–14.) The Court asked

whether it was "okay for them to talk to Amazon or talk to Google or people like that with this,"

and AIIA agreed as to "only those particular specific parties." (Tr. 16:11–12, 16:19–20.) The ruling

permitted sharing "with the appropriate third parties" on notice (Tr. 82:24–83:1), and the written

order limits it to "specific third parties where doing so is necessary to prepare their defense to


                                                  2


    Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB             Document 95        Filed 11/04/26      Page 3 of 12


Defendants' infringement contentions." (Dkt. 71 ¶ 3.) Nothing in the colloquy, the ruling, or Dkt.

71 mentions experts or the Protective Order, and the Court told the parties to "seek clarification"

if there was "any question about it." (Tr. 83:12–14.) Plus One's September 11 notice named

"Amazon," "Intel," and "RealSense," and no one else (Decl. ¶ 3); that is why AIIA had no objection

to it, and that is the only inference Plus One's "AIIA did not object" argument supports. (Dkt. 90

at 11.) The accommodation AIIA gave at the hearing was for those three vendors, whose

components are accused; it has served its purpose and confers no continuing license to share AIIA's

designated material with anyone else. Disclosure to a retained expert is governed exclusively by

Paragraph 5(e). Plus One's own October 15 email applied Paragraph 5(e) to AIIA's expert. (Decl.

¶ 16.) A party that reads a ruling to displace the specific provision governing retained experts, for

itself alone, and acts on that reading without asking the Court, acts "at [its] peril." McComb v.

Jacksonville Paper Co., 336 U.S. 187, 192 (1949). Plus One sought clarification on October 20,

six days after it had made the disclosure. (Dkt. 74.)

III. "Not confidential" is no defense; the designation stands until Paragraph 18 is used.
       Plus One's final argument is that AIIA "has not shown that its contentions are confidential."

(Dkt. 90 at 12.) That is an argument for a different motion. The Protective Order sets the procedure

for challenging a designation: a written request, a meet-and-confer within five business days, and

a motion within ten days thereafter, on which "the burden shall be on the designating Party to show

why its classification is proper." (Dkt. 27-1 ¶ 18.) Plus One has never used it; it now says it "seeks

a finding that AIIA's contentions contain nothing confidential" so that it may "post the contentions

online and share them without any restriction" (Ex. E at 8–9), which is the relief Paragraph 18

exists to channel. Until Plus One uses that procedure, the designation stands, and the Order governs

disclosure: it applies to "all documents … designated," and "[a]ll copies, reproductions, extracts,


                                                  3


    Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB              Document 95        Filed 11/04/26       Page 4 of 12


digests and complete or partial summaries prepared from any DESIGNATED MATERIALS" are

themselves designated. (Id. ¶ 3.) A receiving party may not decide for itself that designated

material is public and hand it to an unapproved expert. The Court has already ruled that the

contentions remain "under seal until the Markman hearing." (Dkt. 71 ¶ 3.) Its authorities are about

something else: June Medical, as Plus One quotes it, concerns public access to "the judicial

record," and Patterson denied entry of a protective order. (Dkt. 90 at 12–13.) Here a protective

order was entered on the parties' stipulation (Dkt. 28), and the question is compliance with it. Nor

is AIIA's burden under Paragraph 5(e) a burden to prove trade secrets; it is the burden to show "the

need for a protective order" as to a proposed disclosure to a particular expert (Dkt. 27-1 ¶ 5(e)),

and the need is shown by the disclosure itself: the material is AIIA's element-by-element claim

mapping across 27 asserted claims (Decl. ¶ 36), given to the expert retained to attack those claims

on claim construction and indefiniteness (Decl. ¶ 6), before any vetting. Wapp Tech, which Plus

One cites, recognizes that a party's "strategies in the litigation" are confidential (Dkt. 79 at 13–14);

its result turned on a conflict the movant could not prove, not on a disclosure the receiving party

admits.

IV. AIIA stated its objections to Prof. Bretl in writing within the ten days; Plus One has never
answered them.
          Plus One says AIIA "identifies no conflict" and "has had every opportunity to vet him."

(Dkt. 90 at 10–11.) AIIA stated its objections in writing, within the ten days Paragraph 5(e)

provides, and Plus One has answered none of them. On October 14, AIIA asked for the ten days

"to vet your expert for conflicts" and for the expert's complete CV and information. (Decl. ¶ 12 &

Ex. A, Tabs 19, 22.) On October 15, it asked for his prior engagements and his Undertaking. (Decl.

¶ 16.) On October 19, in the letter Plus One itself cites, AIIA objected to Prof. Bretl serving as an

expert in this case and stated why: his CV lists him as "Co-Founder, Chief Innovation Officer, and


                                                   4


    Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB             Document 95        Filed 11/04/26      Page 5 of 12


Secretary, Reconstruct Inc," a computer-vision and artificial-intelligence company and a

competitor of AIIA; Paragraph 5(e)(2) bars disclosure to an expert "presently employed (directly

or indirectly) by a competitor of a Party"; Plus One had not disclosed whether Prof. Bretl, as a co-

founder, retains any equity, advisory, or other continuing relationship with Reconstruct; his

published and current research, including vision-based six-dimensional pose estimation, structure-

from-motion evaluation, and three-dimensional visual representations for robotic manipulation,

lies in the field of the patents-in-suit and in areas AIIA continues to research; and the CV served

on October 9 omits the list of "all current and past expert engagements with any parties in the past

five years" that Paragraph 5(e) requires. (Dkt. 84-6 at 12; Decl. ¶ 7; Dkt. 27-1 ¶ 5(e).) Plus One’s

lightning disclosure left no opportunity for AIIA to seek answers before disclosure. AIIA reserved

further objections pending the information Plus One had not provided. (Id.; Dkt. 79 at 15.)

       Plus One's only answer, sent at 1:35 a.m. on October 20 and repeated in Dkt. 90, is that a

role that ended "a decade ago" is not "present" employment, and that AIIA has not shown that

Prof. Bretl "owes Reconstruct any duty of loyalty." (Decl. ¶ 30; Dkt. 90 at 10.) That answers a

question AIIA did not ask. Paragraph 5(e)(2) reaches employment "directly or indirectly," and

Paragraph 9 bars access by "employees, affiliates, or directors" of "a competitor of a Party." (Dkt.

27-1 ¶¶ 5(e), 9.) The question AIIA asked is whether a co-founder, chief innovation officer, and

secretary of a competitor retains any continuing interest in it. Plus One has never said, and a "duty

of loyalty" test appears nowhere in the Order. The ten-day period exists so that the producing party

can ask that question and have it answered before access. It was not "fully served" (Dkt. 90 at 11)

by a disclosure made before the question could be asked and a refusal to answer it afterward; under

Paragraph 5(e), "[n]o disclosure shall occur until all such objections are resolved by agreement or

Court order," and they have been resolved by neither. Plus One applied the opposite standard to


                                                 5


    Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB              Document 95        Filed 11/04/26      Page 6 of 12


AIIA's expert: in March 2026 it objected to Dr. Janét "based at least on his relationship with"

Applied Research Associates, citing the "overlap" in "areas of focus and business," and AIIA

withdrew him. (Dkt. 84-6 at 12.) An overlap in fields disqualified AIIA's expert; the same overlap,

with a co-founder's role at a competitor and an unanswered question about whether it continues, is

said to raise nothing.

V. Plus One demanded the same protocol from AIIA in March 2026, and said there was no
prejudice until AIIA moved.
       Plus One's own Exhibit A answers its "no harm" argument. (Dkt. 90 at 11.) In March 2026,

when AIIA's counsel mentioned that an expert had reviewed what Plus One had provided, Plus

One wrote: "Please immediately identify the expert in question and all the Plus One documents

that AIIA allowed its undisclosed expert to review before Plus One was allowed to consider

conflicts." (Dkt. 90-2 at 4.) The next day it added: "We also await confirmation that the expert has

destroyed all copies that they received of such files, as well as any related notes or other derivative

materials prepared." (Id. at 2.) Plus One did not ask whether the material was confidential or

whether the expert had a conflict; it demanded identification, a list of documents reviewed, and

certified destruction, because the vetting had not occurred. AIIA complied then, and has said so to

Plus One. (Dkt. 90-3 at 3; Dkt. 94-1 at 3.) Plus One now says that identification, destruction, and

non-use are a "drastic remedy with no corresponding harm to cure," and that AIIA "has suffered

no prejudice." (Dkt. 90 at 11, 12.) Those statements were made while Plus One's expert had AIIA's

theories and AIIA had none of Plus One's. The protocol Plus One demanded in March is the

minimum relief AIIA asks for now. (Decl. ¶¶ 4, 12, 14, 16.) The pattern is not new: in July Plus

One moved on two days' notice to unseal AIIA's contentions, bypassing the ten-day procedure of

Paragraph 18. (Dkt. 43; Dkt. 48 at 1–3.)


                                                  6


    Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB             Document 95        Filed 11/04/26       Page 7 of 12


VI. The remedy.
        At a minimum, the Court should order what Plus One itself demanded in March:

identification of each AIIA document provided to Prof. Bretl and the date of each disclosure; a

certification of destruction and non-use signed by Prof. Bretl and counsel; an order that no AIIA-

designated material or anything derived from it be used pending compliance with Paragraph 5(e);

a substitute expert, if Plus One wishes one, disclosed under Paragraph 5(e) with the ten-day period

and objection procedure honored; and the expenses caused by the breach, limited to the fees the

breach caused. Fed. R. Civ. P. 16(f)(2), 37(b)(2)(C); Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co. v. Haeger, 581

U.S. 101, 108–09 (2017). None of this requires a finding of willfulness or contempt. Smith &

Fuller, P.A. v. Cooper Tire & Rubber Co., 685 F.3d 486, 488, 490 (5th Cir. 2012). The Court

should also order that Prof. Bretl is subject to the Protective Order, and to the Court's jurisdiction

to enforce it, as to every item of AIIA-designated material disclosed to him on or after October 14,

2026, so that whatever else the Court decides, the material he holds is held under the Order and

not outside it.

        Disqualification remains warranted. Plus One frames the question as whether AIIA has

proved a conflict. (Dkt. 90 at 10–11.) The Motion does not rest on a conflict; it rests on the breach,

and on what the breach gave Plus One. Pre-access procedures are enforced as written, and after-

the-fact compliance does not cure them. Demodulation, Inc. v. United States, 122 Fed. Cl. 652,

660–61 (2015); Allergan, Inc. v. Sandoz Inc., No. 2:09-cv-97, 2011 WL 2563238, at *2–3 (E.D.

Tex. June 28, 2011). Plus One distinguishes Allergan on the ground that it "timely disclosed Prof.

Bretl." (Dkt. 90 at 12.) It did not: an October 9 identification of a claim-construction witness with

no Undertaking is not a Paragraph 5(e) disclosure, and the Undertaking came two days after access.

(Decl. ¶¶ 6, 15, 23.) The Allergan defendants pleaded an "inadvertent oversight"; Plus One acted

over a written objection, and the next day enforced the same paragraph against AIIA. (Decl. ¶¶


                                                  7


    Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB              Document 95        Filed 11/04/26      Page 8 of 12


12–16.) The record reasons for disqualification are these: the disclosure was deliberate and made

while AIIA's meet-and-confer request was pending (Decl. ¶¶ 11, 15); Plus One has refused every

request to identify, certify, or stop, on October 14, 16, 19, 20, 28, and 30 (Decl. ¶¶ 13, 17, 25, 32–

34; Dkt. 90-3 at 2; Dkt. 94-2 at 2); and Plus One filed Dkt. 74 to obtain approval of the disclosure

after the fact rather than cure it. The Court has "the inherent power to disqualify experts" to protect

"the integrity of the judicial process." Koch Ref. Co. v. Jennifer L. Boudreaux M/V, 85 F.3d 1178,

1181–82 (5th Cir. 1996). If the party that bypasses Paragraph 5(e) keeps the expert and the

material, the ten-day period becomes optional for anyone willing to disclose first and serve the

Undertaking later. A protective order that can be breached and cured at the breaching party's

convenience protects nothing. Opening briefs are not yet due, so substitution now imposes a

modest burden; an unvetted expert holding the other side's sealed theories imposes a permanent

one.

VII. The prejudice is continuing, and no change to the schedule cures it.
       Plus One says AIIA "has suffered no prejudice." (Dkt. 90 at 12.) The prejudice is of three

kinds, and each is continuing. First, what was disclosed cannot be recalled. AIIA's contentions

chart 86 claim elements across 27 asserted claims; they are AIIA's claim mapping and infringement

theories, its "strategies in the litigation." (Decl. ¶ 36; Dkt. 79 at 13–14.) Once read, "it is very

difficult for the human mind to compartmentalize and selectively suppress information once

learned, no matter how well-intentioned the effort may be to do so." FTC v. Exxon Corp., 636 F.2d

1336, 1350 (D.C. Cir. 1980); accord In re Deutsche Bank Tr. Co. Ams., 605 F.3d 1373, 1378 (Fed.

Cir. 2010). The reader here is the expert retained to attack those claims on claim construction and

indefiniteness, whose current research lies in the same field. (Decl. ¶¶ 6–7.) Second, the asymmetry

grows every day. Plus One's expert has held AIIA's element-by-element theories since October 14;


                                                  8


       Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB           Document 95        Filed 11/04/26      Page 9 of 12


AIIA's expert, barred by Plus One under the same paragraph, has seen none of Plus One's

designated material; and Plus One's invalidity, Section 112, and Section 101 positions, due October

7, are still unserved. (Decl. ¶¶ 5, 16, 34.) AIIA made its October 9 expert disclosure "being made

to respond to indefiniteness contentions it has not yet seen" (Decl. ¶ 9), and every claim-

construction position Plus One takes from here forward will be taken with AIIA's theories in its

expert's hands and none of Plus One's in AIIA's. Third, the disclosure impairs the value of AIIA's

patent assets. The Court sealed the contentions until the Markman hearing (Dkt. 71 ¶ 3), so AIIA

controls when, to whom, and on what terms its claim mapping is revealed; Plus One now asserts

the right to "post the contentions online and share them without any restriction." (Ex. E at 8–9.)

The value of AIIA's patents depends in part on that control over its enforcement and licensing

positions, and disclosure outside the Order impairs it in a way no later award repairs. (Dkt. 79 at

14.)

         At the Dkt. 89 conference, AIIA proposed an amended schedule and the withdrawal of its

own motions without prejudice, with two provisions: that Plus One's expert use AIIA's materials

only subject to the Protective Order, whose protection extends to the October 14 disclosure, and

that Plus One provide access to AIIA's materials only under the Order, each until the Court orders

otherwise. (Exs. A–D; Ex. E at 12–13.) Plus One accepted the dates and refused both provisions,

stating that AIIA "has never served proper infringement contentions," that it "seeks a finding that

AIIA's contentions contain nothing confidential," that it may "post the contentions online," and

that "this is a risk Plus One is willing to take." (Ex. E at 3, 8–9, 11.) After that email, Plus One

circulated a revised two-section Joint Advisory with its own positions "already filled in," stated

that "most (if not all) of these issues were already addressed in Docket No. 93," directed AIIA to

"fill in AIIA's portion" by 11 a.m. CT, and at 10:04 p.m. stated that it had "nothing further to send."


                                                  9


   Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB             Document 95         Filed 11/04/26      Page 10 of 12


(Ex. F at 1, 3.) AIIA responded that the Court ordered a joint filing, that Plus One's draft is not

one, and that AIIA will note that and send its position. (Ex. F at 1.) Plus One's position is that it

may disclose AIIA's Attorneys' Eyes Only material outside the Order's procedure, bring the

recipient under the Order afterward, and treat the Order's limits on further disclosure as

inapplicable to it. A change to the Scheduling Order does not cure a breach from which Plus One

continues to gain an advantage, and the breach was willful: made one minute after a written

objection, with the transcript in hand, and with the ten-day requirement in mind, as Plus One's

invocation of it against AIIA the next day shows. (Decl. ¶¶ 12–16.)

                                          CONCLUSION
       AIIA respectfully requests that the Court sustain AIIA's objection and grant a protective

order under Paragraph 5(e); disqualify Prof. Bretl, or, at a minimum, bar any further access to or

use of AIIA-designated material by him; order Plus One, within three days, to identify each item

disclosed and when and to serve a certification of destruction and non-use signed by Prof. Bretl

and counsel; order that Prof. Bretl is subject to the Protective Order and to the Court's jurisdiction

to enforce it as to all AIIA-designated material disclosed to him on or after October 14, 2026;

confirm that the accommodation reflected in Dkt. 71 ¶ 3 was limited to the three vendors identified

at the September 10 hearing and that any disclosure of AIIA-designated material to any other

person, including any retained expert or consultant, is governed by the Protective Order; require

any substitute expert to comply with Paragraph 5(e); award the expenses caused by the breach

under Rules 16(f) and 37(b); and grant such other relief as the Court deems just.


Dated: November 4, 2026

Respectfully submitted,

                                                   /s/ Robert E. Golden
                                                   Robert E. Golden


                                                 10


Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB   Document 95    Filed 11/04/26    Page 11 of 12


                                  Texas Bar No. 08085560
                                  ROBERT E. GOLDEN, P.C.
                                  14100 San Pedro Ave., Suite 611
                                  San Antonio, TX 78232-4363
                                  (210) 495-0900
                                  golden@goldenlaw.net

                                  Vivek Ramachandran (admitted pro hac vice)
                                  DHAMMA LAW PLLC
                                  418 Broadway, Suite N
                                  Albany, NY 12207
                                  (202) 860-4084
                                  vramachandran@dhammalaw.com

                                  Counsel for Defendants/Counter-Plaintiffs


                                 11


   Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB             Document 95        Filed 11/04/26    Page 12 of 12


                                 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

       I certify that on November 4, 2026, the foregoing was filed through the Court's CM/ECF

system, which will send notification of the filing to all counsel of record.


                                                  /s/ Robert E. Golden
                                                  Robert E. Golden


                                                 12