jain.com
Public record. We host this document directly; the copy served here does not depend on any third party. Retrieved November 14, 2026.
Read the documentAlso at archive.org ↗

Sheresky v. United States of America — Entry #80: NOTICE of Filing of Administrative Record

Case: Sheresky v. United States of America nysd · 1:25-cv-08935

filed October 28, 2025

What this document is

Docket entry #80 · filed September 18, 2026

NOTICE of Filing of Administrative Record. Document filed by Daniel Aronowitz, Lori Chavez-DeRemer, Janet Dhillon, United States of America. (Attachments: (1) Exhibit Certification of Administrative Record, (2) Exhibit Index to Administrative Record, (3) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 1, (4) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 2, (5) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 3.1, (6) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 3.2, (7) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 3.3, (8) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 3.4, (9) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 3.5, (10) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 3.6, (11) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 3.7, (12) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 4, (13) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 5.1, (14) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 5.2, (15) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 6).(Yalen, Robert)

Who is involved

Why we have it

We follow this case because it names a company we track, although that company is not a party:

A free copy from the RECAP archive of federal court filings (mirrored at the Internet Archive), retrieved November 14, 2026. Federal court filings are public records.

URL
https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.nysd.651997/gov.uscourts.nysd.651997.80.14.pdf
Kind
court_filing
Publisher
RECAP
Published
2026-09-18 00:00:00-04:00
Retrieved
2026-11-14 06:50:56.537284-05:00
HTTP status
200
MIME
application/pdf
Bytes
13644661
SHA-256
b6ca90eb26e2f3b424c5f101753e2302db3c3ffe12c941f4cdfb1e7210b80e3b

Document text

82 page(s), 205,801 characters, converted from the PDF's text layer · plain text.

Full text
Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG          Document 80-14         Filed 09/18/26       Page 1 of 82


Jon,

Following up on our call, please find attached Morgan Stanley's pending opinion letter request (A01533).

EBSA's Office of Regulations and Interpretations agreed after we met with Jeff Turner and Wayne Berry back
in December 2024 that this request was meritorious, and Eric Berger told me two weeks ago that getting this
letter out is now the office's top interpretive priority. What we're hoping for is a little Front Office nudge to get
this really important "tort reform" type letter over the finish line and out. The timing is getting increasingly
important given the confusion sown by a very sloppy district court in Shafer v. Morgan Stanley, 2023 WL
8100717 (S.D.N.Y. Nov. 21, 2023), and the industry really needs DOL to speak clearly and promptly, as they
are planning their go-forward compensation structures at the halfway point into 2025; Shafer would require the
entire industry to redo everything in ways that would materially hurt the interests of employees, as well as good
governance principles articulated by the industry's financial regulators.

Best,
Greg


Gregory F. Jacob
qiacob@omm.com
0: +1-202-383-5110
O'Melveny
O'Melveny & Myers LLP
1625 Eye Street, NW
Washington, DC 20006
Website I Linkedln I Twitter


                                                                                                           DOLAR0828


              Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG             Document 80-14           Filed 09/18/26           Page 2 of 82


From:   Jacob, Greg [gjacob@omm.com]
        7/22/2025 9:08:05 AM
        Snare, Jonathan - SOL [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
                                                                                       You don't often get email from
        (FYDI BOH F23SPDLT)/ cn=Reci pi ents/cn=3d84103 7413b4e3e8684ed76a6c4a b 71-
                                                                                       gjacob@omm.com. Learn why this is
        2559c53f-60]                                                                   lmportant
 ubject:RE: Morgan Stanley Opinion Letter (drafting already underway)


Jon,

Thanks so much again for looking into this. I know you've got a rolling avalanche on your desk!

If you've heard anything further, I'd love to get a status update. I plan to check in again with Eric/Jeff in the
Office of Regulations and Interpretations later this week, and it would be helpful to know if they've been up
through the front office yet, as they indicated last month was in the works. Also, of course, if the EBSA front
office would benefit from a briefing or from any materials on how necessary and helpful this opinion letter will
be from both a business and anti-frivolous-litigation perspective, we'd be very happy to provide that.

Greg


Gregory F. Jacob
qiacob@omm.com
0: +1-202-383-5110
O'Melveny
O'Melveny & Myers LLP
1625 Eye Street, NW
Washington, DC 20006
Website I Linkedln I Twitter


From: Snare, Jonathan - SOL <Snare.Jonathan@dol.gov>
Sent: Tuesday, July 1, 2025 12:01 PM
To: Jacob, Greg <gjacob@omm.com>
Subject: RE: Morgan Stanley Opinion Letter (drafting already underway)

Greg:

Confirming receipt. Great to catch up with you this morning. I will follow up on this matter and we will get
back to you.

Jonathan L. Snare, Deputy Solicitor
S-2002


                                                                                                                    DOLAR0829


              Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG          Document 80-14         Filed 09/18/26       Page 3 of 82
(office direct) 202-693-5263
(work cell) 771-241-2914
Snare. jonatha n@dol .gov


From: Jacob, Greg <gjacob@omm.com>
Sent: Tuesday, July 1, 2025 11:02 AM
To: Snare, Jonathan - SOL <Snare.Jonathan@dol.gov>
Subject: Morgan Stanley Opinion Letter (drafting already underway)


Jon,

Following up on our call, please find attached Morgan Stanley's pending opinion letter request (A01533).

EBSA's Office of Regulations and Interpretations agreed after we met with Jeff Turner and Wayne Berry back
in December 2024 that this request was meritorious, and Eric Berger told me two weeks ago that getting this
letter out is now the office's top interpretive priority. What we're hoping for is a little Front Office nudge to get
this really important "tort reform" type letter over the finish line and out. The timing is getting increasingly
important given the confusion sown by a very sloppy district court in Shafer v. Morgan Stanley, 2023 WL
8100717 (S.D.N.Y. Nov. 21, 2023), and the industry really needs DOL to speak clearly and promptly, as they
are planning their go-forward compensation structures at the halfway point into 2025; Shafer would require the
entire industry to redo everything in ways that would materially hurt the interests of employees, as well as good
governance principles articulated by the industry's financial regulators.

Best,
Greg


Gregory F. Jacob
qiacob@omm.com
0: +1-202-383-5110
O'Melveny
O'Melveny & Myers LLP
1625 Eye Street, NW
Washington, DC 20006
Website I Linkedln I Twitter


                                                                                                           DOLAR0830


            Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG            Document 80-14             Filed 09/18/26   Page 4 of 82

From:         Snare, Jonathan - SOL [/O=EXCHANGELABS/OU=EXCHANGE ADMINISTRATIVE GROUP
              (FYDIBOHF23SPDLT)/CN=RECIPIENTS/CN=3D841037413B4E3E8684ED76A6C4AB71-2559C53F-60]
Sent:         7/22/2025 7:07:27 PM
To:           Jacob, Greg [gjacob@omm.com]
Subject:      RE: Morgan Stanley Opinion Letter (drafting already underway)


Hi Greg:

I understand this AO request is in the decision queue and the EBSA Front office is aware of this request.
have also been told the EBSA Front Office is navigating a number of priorities so not sure when this will be
done. I will be happy to keep you posted. I also touched base briefly with Janet Dhillon and she told me that
she would be happy to discuss this with you as well.

Thanks

Jonathan L. Snare, Deputy Solicitor
S-2002
(office direct) 202-693-5263
(work cell) 771-241-2914
Sna re.jonatha n@dol .gov


From: Jacob, Greg <gjacob@omm.com>
Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:08 AM
To: Snare, Jonathan - SOL <Snare.Jonathan@dol.gov>
Subject: RE: Morgan Stanley Opinion Letter (drafting already underway)


Jon,

Thanks so much again for looking into this. I know you've got a rolling avalanche on your desk!

If you've heard anything further, I'd love to get a status update. I plan to check in again with Eric/Jeff in the
Office of Regulations and Interpretations later this week, and it would be helpful to know if they've been up
through the front office yet, as they indicated last month was in the works. Also, of course, if the EBSA front
office would benefit from a briefing or from any materials on how necessary and helpful this opinion letter will
be from both a business and anti-frivolous-litigation perspective, we'd be very happy to provide that.

Greg


Gregory F. Jacob
qiacob@omm.com
0: 202-383-5110


                                                                                                         DOLAR0831


              Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG          Document 80-14             Filed 09/18/26   Page 5 of 82

O'Melveny & Myers LLP
1625 Eye Street, NW
Washington, DC 20006
Website I Linkedln I Twitter


From: Snare, Jonathan - SOL <Snare.Jonathan@dol.gov>
Sent: Tuesday, July 1, 2025 12:01 PM
To: Jacob, Greg <gjacob@omm.com>
Subject: RE: Morgan Stanley Opinion Letter (drafting already underway)

Greg:

Confirming receipt. Great to catch up with you this morning. I will follow up on this matter and we will get
back to you.

Jonathan L. Snare, Deputy Solicitor
S-2002
(office direct) 202-693-5263
(work cell) 771-241-2914
Snare. jonatha n@dol .gov


From: Jacob, Greg <gjacob@omm.com>
Sent: Tuesday, July 1, 2025 11:02 AM
To: Snare, Jonathan - SOL <Snare.Jonathan@dol.gov>
Subject: Morgan Stanley Opinion Letter (drafting already underway)


Jon,

Following up on our call, please find attached Morgan Stanley's pending opinion letter request (A01533).

EBSA's Office of Regulations and Interpretations agreed after we met with Jeff Turner and Wayne Berry back
in December 2024 that this request was meritorious, and Eric Berger told me two weeks ago that getting this
letter out is now the office's top interpretive priority. What we're hoping for is a little Front Office nudge to get
this really important "tort reform" type letter over the finish line and out. The timing is getting increasingly
important given the confusion sown by a very sloppy district court in Shafer v. Morgan Stanley, 2023 WL
8100717 (S.D.N.Y. Nov. 21, 2023), and the industry really needs DOL to speak clearly and promptly, as they
are planning their go-forward compensation structures at the halfway point into 2025; Shafer would require the
entire industry to redo everything in ways that would materially hurt the interests of employees, as well as good
governance principles articulated by the industry's financial regulators.

Best,
Greg


                                                                                                           DOLAR0832


              Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG   Document 80-14   Filed 09/18/26   Page 6 of 82


Gregory F. Jacob
qiacob@omm.com
0: 202-383-5110
O'Melveny
O'Melveny & Myers LLP
1625 Eye Street, NW
Washington, DC 20006
Website I Linkedln I Twitter


                                                                                        DOLAR0833


             Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                 Document 80-14             Filed 09/18/26         Page 7 of 82


From:       Kent A. Mason [kamason@davis-harman.com]
 ent:       7/25/2025 12:25:51 PM
 o:         Dhillon, Janet L - EBSA [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
            (FYDI BO HF23SPDLT)/ cn=Recip ients/cn=c31 fbd84ce034a5a8ebcad30dde9b06f-
            ec453f43-32]; Lund, Jack G - EBSA [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange
            Administrative Group
            (FYDI BO HF23SPDLT)/ cn=Recip ients/cn=e0df3 7983cc6407 495edcf1634411cf7-
            63fb2472-e8]                                                                        You don't often get email from
            Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com; 'PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com'                      kamason@davis-harman.com.
            [PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com]; Chris Gaston [CGaston@davis-harman.com]              Learn why this is important
            Meeting request regarding pending Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion request
            submitted a year ago on critical issue needing fast resolution to clarify the law
 ttachments:Morgan Stanley Letter to DOL Requesting Advisory Opinion (8-1-24) -
            CONFIDENTIAL. pdf;
            2025.04.05.Ltr.from.G.Jacob.to.Deputy.Director.Turner.pdf


Janet and Jack, we wanted to touch base on a pending request for an Advisory Opinion from Morgan Stanley
(copied on this email). We were hoping to have a chance to talk to you about the status of this request if you
have time next week.

We were thrilled about the Department's June 2 announcement launching its opinion letter program, quoting
Deputy Secretary Sonderling regarding the importance of such letters.
https://www.dol.gov/newsroom/releases/osec/osec20250602 Advisory Opinions have historically played a
critical role in facilitating compliance, but their frequency has dropped off dramatically in recent years. We
applaud the new program.

We note that EBSA's first two Opinions of 2025 were issued earlier this week. We are hoping that Morgan
Stanley's request could be addressed in the coming few weeks, as the pressure on this issue has become intense.
We have heard informal reports that our Advisory Opinion is done and is simply waiting for clearance, but that
could take time. We are not sure how accurate those informal reports are.

The original request and a follow-up letter are attached. Here is the issue in a nutshell. It is very common in the
financial services industry and in many other industries to have long-term incentive plans. (My guess is that
both of you are familiar with these programs.) Under Morgan Stanley's plans, which are very similar to
common industry practices, employees who stay for 4 to 6 years after the beginning of the incentive period can
earn retention/performance awards at the end of the period. Again, under a standard industry practice, Morgan
Stanley does not require employees to stay the whole period if the termination is based on death, disability,
retirement, not-for-cause termination, or government service. The vast majority of the awards are paid to current
employees but a small portion are paid under these exceptions.

To my knowledge, no one in the country has ever treated these arrangements as pension plans subject to ERISA
(due to how clear the law is), and similar plans are simply everywhere in my experience. But one district court


                                                                                                                         DOLAR0834


              Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                  Document 80-14              Filed 09/18/26          Page 8 of 82
(referenced in the request) ruled, without even a response from Morgan Stanley, that ERISA applied to these
incentive arrangements (contrary to the law and other court holdings) and sent them to arbitration. The court's
strange reasoning was based on the fact that a few payments are made after termination of employment, due to
the exceptions noted above. This ruling triggers huge problems due to, for example, ERISA's vesting rules,
which the program does not comply with. The problems with the court's ruling are evidenced by the fact that
four amicus briefs were filed on behalf of Morgan Stanley's appeal in this case by (1) the American Benefits
Council, (2) the US Chamber of Commerce and The ERISA Industry Committee, (3) SIFMA, and (4) the
Society for Human Resource Management.

Dozens of very expensive claims have been filed against Morgan Stanley since this strange district court ruling.
The law really needs to be clarified quickly, which is why we are reaching out to you and also, on a very limited
basis, to the Hill for help to expedite this matter. Thanks so much.
Kent A. Mason
Davis & Harman LLP


            DAVIS
            f;ARMANuP
                           &48'"
The Willard
1455 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, Suite 1200
Washington, DC 20004

Main: 202-34 7-2230 Direct: 202-662-2288
Fax: 202-393-3310 kamason@davis-harman.com


LIMITATIONS ON ADVICE. Any advice in this communication and any attachments: (i) is limited to the conclusions specifically set
forth herein and is based on the completeness and accuracy of the stated facts, assumptions and/or representations included
herein; (ii) was prepared for the sole benefit of Davis & Harman LLP's client and may not be relied upon by any other person or
entity; and (iii) is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, by the recipient(s) or any other person or entity, for the
purposes of promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any matters addressed herein.

NOTICE OF CONFIDENTIALITY. The information contained in this message from Davis & Harman LLP and any attachments is
confidential and intended only for the named recipient(s). This message and any attachments may be an attorney-client
communication and as such privileged and confidential. If you have received this message in error, you are prohibited from copying,
distributing or using the information. Please contact the sender immediately by telephone or return e-mail and delete the original
message. We apologize for any inconvenience, and thank you for your prompt attention.


                                                                                                                              DOLAR0835


            Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG              Document 80-14           Filed 09/18/26        Page 9 of 82

From:         Dhillon, Janet L - EBSA [/O=EXCHANGELABS/OU=EXCHANGE ADMINISTRATIVE GROUP
              (FYDI BO HF 23SPDLT)/CN =RE Cl Pl ENTS/CN =C31 FBD84CE034A5A8EBCAD30DDE9B06F-EC453F43-32]
Sent:         7/25/2025 2:06:58 PM
To:           Kent A. Mason [kamason@davis-harman.com]; Lund, Jack G - EBSA [/o=Exchangelabs/ou=Exchange Administrative
              Group (FYDI BO HF23SPDLT)/ cn=Recipi ents/cn=e0df3 7983cc6407 495edcf1634411cf7-63fb24 72-e8]
CC:           Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com; 'PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com' [PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com]; Chris Gaston
              [CGaston@davis-harman.com]
Subject:      RE: Meeting request regarding pending Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion request submitted a year ago on critical
              issue needing fast resolution to clarify the law


Kent

Happy to set up time to discuss. I'll have Glenda reach out on Monday to set up a mutually convenient time.

Have a nice weekend.

Janet

Janet Dhillon
Acting Assistant Secretary
Employee Benefits Security Administration
U.S. Department of Labor


From: Kent A. Mason <kamason@davis-harman.com>
Sent: Friday, July 25, 2025 12:26 PM
To: Dhillon, Janet L - EBSA <Dhillon.Janet.L@dol.gov>; Lund, Jack G - EBSA <Lund.Jack.G@dol.gov>
Cc: Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com; 'PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com' <PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com>; Chris Gaston
<CGaston@davis-harman.com>
Subject: Meeting request regarding pending Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion request submitted a year ago on critical
issue needing fast resolution to clarify the law


Janet and Jack, we wanted to touch base on a pending request for an Advisory Opinion from Morgan Stanley
(copied on this email). We were hoping to have a chance to talk to you about the status of this request if you
have time next week.

We were thrilled about the Department's June 2 announcement launching its opinion letter program, quoting
Deputy Secretary Sonderling regarding the importance of such letters.
https://www.dol.gov/newsroom/releases/osec/osec20250602 Advisory Opinions have historically played a
critical role in facilitating compliance, but their frequency has dropped off dramatically in recent years. We
applaud the new program.


                                                                                                                  DOLAR0836


             Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                  Document 80-14              Filed 09/18/26          Page 10 of 82
We note that EBSA's first two Opinions of 2025 were issued earlier this week. We are hoping that Morgan
Stanley's request could be addressed in the coming few weeks, as the pressure on this issue has become intense.
We have heard informal reports that our Advisory Opinion is done and is simply waiting for clearance, but that
could take time. We are not sure how accurate those informal reports are.

The original request and a follow-up letter are attached. Here is the issue in a nutshell. It is very common in the
financial services industry and in many other industries to have long-term incentive plans. (My guess is that
both of you are familiar with these programs.) Under Morgan Stanley's plans, which are very similar to
common industry practices, employees who stay for 4 to 6 years after the beginning of the incentive period can
earn retention/performance awards at the end of the period. Again, under a standard industry practice, Morgan
Stanley does not require employees to stay the whole period if the termination is based on death, disability,
retirement, not-for-cause termination, or government service. The vast majority of the awards are paid to current
employees but a small portion are paid under these exceptions.

To my knowledge, no one in the country has ever treated these arrangements as pension plans subject to ERISA
(due to how clear the law is), and similar plans are simply everywhere in my experience. But one district court
(referenced in the request) ruled, without even a response from Morgan Stanley, that ERISA applied to these
incentive arrangements (contrary to the law and other court holdings) and sent them to arbitration. The court's
strange reasoning was based on the fact that a few payments are made after termination of employment, due to
the exceptions noted above. This ruling triggers huge problems due to, for example, ERISA's vesting rules,
which the program does not comply with. The problems with the court's ruling are evidenced by the fact that
four amicus briefs were filed on behalf of Morgan Stanley's appeal in this case by (1) the American Benefits
Council, (2) the US Chamber of Commerce and The ERISA Industry Committee, (3) SIFMA, and (4) the
Society for Human Resource Management.

Dozens of very expensive claims have been filed against Morgan Stanley since this strange district court ruling.
The law really needs to be clarified quickly, which is why we are reaching out to you and also, on a very limited
basis, to the Hill for help to expedite this matter. Thanks so much.
Kent A. Mason
Davis & Harman LLP


                                     l"\'"
            DAVIS & ·\)
            f;ARMANuP
The Willard
1455 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, Suite 1200
Washington, DC 20004

Main: 202-34 7-2230 Direct: 202-662-2288
Fax: 202-393-3310 kamason@davis-harman.com


LIMITATIONS ON ADVICE. Any advice in this communication and any attachments: (i) is limited to the conclusions specifically set
forth herein and is based on the completeness and accuracy of the stated facts, assumptions and/or representations included
herein; (ii) was prepared for the sole benefit of Davis & Harman LLP's client and may not be relied upon by any other person or
entity; and (iii) is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, by the recipient(s) or any other person or entity, for the
purposes of promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any matters addressed herein.

NOTICE OF CONFIDENTIALITY. The information contained in this message from Davis & Harman LLP and any attachments is
confidential and intended only for the named recipient(s). This message and any attachments may be an attorney-client


                                                                                                                              DOLAR0837


            Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                 Document 80-14            Filed 09/18/26         Page 11 of 82
communication and as such privileged and confidential. If you have received this message in error, you are prohibited from copying,
distributing or using the information. Please contact the sender immediately by telephone or return e-mail and delete the original
message. We apologize for any inconvenience, and thank you for your prompt attention.


                                                                                                                        DOLAR0838


            Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                 Document 80-14        Filed 09/18/26         Page 12 of 82

From:          Kent A. Mason [kamason@davis-harman.com]
Sent:          7/25/2025 2:15:46 PM
To:            Dhillon, Janet L - EBSA [/o=Exchangelabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
               (FYDIBOHF23SPDLT)/cn=Recipients/cn=c31fbd84ce034a5a8ebcad30dde9b06f-ec453f43-32]; Lund, Jack G - EBSA
               [/o=Exchangelabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
               (FYDI BO HF 23SPDLT)/ cn=Recip ients/cn=e0df3 7983cc6407 495edcf1634411cf7-63fb24 72-e8]
CC:            Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com; 'PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com' [PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com]; Chris Gaston
               [CGaston@davis-harman.com]
Subject:       RE: Meeting request regarding pending Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion request submitted a year ago on critical
               issue needing fast resolution to clarify the law


Thanks very much. You have a great weekend too.

From: Dhillon, Janet L - EBSA <Dhillon.Janet.L@dol.gov>
Sent: Friday, July 25, 2025 2:07 PM
To: Kent A. Mason <kamason@davis-harman.com>; Lund, Jack G - EBSA <Lund.Jack.G@dol.gov>
Cc: Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com; 'PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com' <PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com>; Chris Gaston
<CGaston@davis-harman.com>
Subject: RE: Meeting request regarding pending Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion request submitted a year ago on
critical issue needing fast resolution to clarify the law


Kent

Happy to set up time to discuss. I'll have Glenda reach out on Monday to set up a mutually convenient time.

Have a nice weekend.

Janet

Janet Dhillon
Acting Assistant Secretary
Employee Benefits Security Administration
U.S. Department of Labor


From: Kent A. Mason <kamason@davis-harman.com>
Sent: Friday, July 25, 2025 12:26 PM
To: Dhillon, Janet L - EBSA <Dhillon.Janet.l@dol.gov>; Lund, Jack G - EBSA <Lund.Jack.G@dol.gov>
Cc: Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com; 'PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com' <PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com>; Chris Gaston
<CGaston@davis-harman.com>
Subject: Meeting request regarding pending Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion request submitted a year ago on critical
issue needing fast resolution to clarify the law


                                                                                                                   DOLAR0839


           Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG           Document 80-14         Filed 09/18/26      Page 13 of 82


Janet and Jack, we wanted to touch base on a pending request for an Advisory Opinion from Morgan Stanley
(copied on this email). We were hoping to have a chance to talk to you about the status of this request if you
have time next week.

We were thrilled about the Department's June 2 announcement launching its opinion letter program, quoting
Deputy Secretary Sonderling regarding the importance of such letters.
https://www.dol.gov/newsroom/releases/osec/osec20250602 Advisory Opinions have historically played a
critical role in facilitating compliance, but their frequency has dropped off dramatically in recent years. We
applaud the new program.

We note that EBSA's first two Opinions of 2025 were issued earlier this week. We are hoping that Morgan
Stanley's request could be addressed in the coming few weeks, as the pressure on this issue has become intense.
We have heard informal reports that our Advisory Opinion is done and is simply waiting for clearance, but that
could take time. We are not sure how accurate those informal reports are.

The original request and a follow-up letter are attached. Here is the issue in a nutshell. It is very common in the
financial services industry and in many other industries to have long-term incentive plans. (My guess is that
both of you are familiar with these programs.) Under Morgan Stanley's plans, which are very similar to
common industry practices, employees who stay for 4 to 6 years after the beginning of the incentive period can
earn retention/performance awards at the end of the period. Again, under a standard industry practice, Morgan
Stanley does not require employees to stay the whole period if the termination is based on death, disability,
retirement, not-for-cause termination, or government service. The vast majority of the awards are paid to current
employees but a small portion are paid under these exceptions.

To my knowledge, no one in the country has ever treated these arrangements as pension plans subject to ERISA
(due to how clear the law is), and similar plans are simply everywhere in my experience. But one district court
(referenced in the request) ruled, without even a response from Morgan Stanley, that ERISA applied to these
incentive arrangements (contrary to the law and other court holdings) and sent them to arbitration. The court's
strange reasoning was based on the fact that a few payments are made after termination of employment, due to
the exceptions noted above. This ruling triggers huge problems due to, for example, ERISA's vesting rules,
which the program does not comply with. The problems with the court's ruling are evidenced by the fact that
four amicus briefs were filed on behalf of Morgan Stanley's appeal in this case by (1) the American Benefits
Council, (2) the US Chamber of Commerce and The ERISA Industry Committee, (3) SIFMA, and (4) the
Society for Human Resource Management.

Dozens of very expensive claims have been filed against Morgan Stanley since this strange district court ruling.
The law really needs to be clarified quickly, which is why we are reaching out to you and also, on a very limited
basis, to the Hill for help to expedite this matter. Thanks so much.
Kent A. Mason
Davis & Harman LLP


                                                                                                         DOLAR0840


             Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                  Document 80-14              Filed 09/18/26          Page 14 of 82


            DAVIS
            f;ARMANuP
                           &48'"
The Willard
1455 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, Suite 1200
Washington, DC 20004

Main: 202-347-2230 Direct: 202-662-2288
Fax: 202-393-3310 kamason@davis-harman.com


LIMITATIONS ON ADVICE. Any advice in this communication and any attachments: (i) is limited to the conclusions specifically set
forth herein and is based on the completeness and accuracy of the stated facts, assumptions and/or representations included
herein; (ii) was prepared for the sole benefit of Davis & Harman LLP's client and may not be relied upon by any other person or
entity; and (iii) is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, by the recipient(s) or any other person or entity, for the
purposes of promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any matters addressed herein.

NOTICE OF CONFIDENTIALITY. The information contained in this message from Davis & Harman LLP and any attachments is
confidential and intended only for the named recipient(s). This message and any attachments may be an attorney-client
communication and as such privileged and confidential. If you have received this message in error, you are prohibited from copying,
distributing or using the information. Please contact the sender immediately by telephone or return e-mail and delete the original
message. We apologize for any inconvenience, and thank you for your prompt attention.


                                                                                                                              DOLAR0841


            Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG              Document 80-14           Filed 09/18/26        Page 15 of 82


From:        Kent A. Mason [kamason@davis-harman.com]
 ent:        7/31/2025 2:55:01 PM
 o:          Dhillon, Janet L - EBSA [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
             (FYDI BO HF23SPDLT)/ cn=Recip ients/cn=c31 fbd84ce034a5a8ebcad30dde9b06f-
             ec453f43-32]; Lund, Jack G - EBSA [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange
             Administrative Group
             (FYDI BO HF23SPDLT)/ cn=Recip ients/cn=e0df3 7983cc6407 495edcf1634411cf7-
             63fb2472-e8]; Lund, Jack G - EBSA [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange
             Administrative Group
             (FYDI BO HF23SPDLT)/ cn=Recip ients/cn=e0df3 7983cc6407 495edcf1634411cf7-    You don't often get email from
             63fb2472-e8]; Killmond, James J - SOL [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange            kamason@davis-harman.com.
             Administrative Group
             (FYDI BO HF23SPDLT)/ cn=Recip ients/cn=278d 14e522be4bfb90clbde 7 e5329685-
             bf713f10-1b]
-CC:         Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com; PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com;
             Mark.Greenfield@morganstanley.com; Chris Gaston [CGaston@davis-
             harman.com]
  ubject:    Thank you and attached court case
  ttachments:Milligan v. Merrill Lynch - Dkt. 7X - MSJ Order (3.11.2025).pdf


Thanks so much for the excellent meeting earlier today. We so appreciated being able to meet with the team so
quickly, and how much work you all had clearly done in advance. As I mentioned (too many times I am sure),
there is a real urgency on this issue for two reasons, one being the growing amount of litigation/arbitration
spurred by the strange decision in New York (literally hundreds of individual disputes filed not just against
Morgan Stanley but others in the industry as well). The other is the fact that long-term incentive plans are
typically reviewed and decided on in early fall for the following year. So, ifthere need to be material changes
(such as eliminating some humanitarian exceptions to the forfeiture on termination of employment), those
decisions are going to be made in the next six to eight weeks in many cases. There are many reasons no one
wants to eliminate those exceptions, but employers are now in a period of uncertainty over whether they can
maintain longstanding, carefully crafted incentive compensation structures. An Advisory Opinion in the
immediate future would provide really useful guidance at a really important time.

As discussed, attached is the district court decision in the Fourth Circuit, which ruled favorably on the same
issue.

I don't have all the DOL email addresses, so sorry for leaving some of the team off this email. Thanks again.


Kent A. Mason
Davis & Harman LLP


                                                                                                                     DOLAR0842


             Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                  Document 80-14              Filed 09/18/26          Page 16 of 82


         DAVIS&
         HAR.M.AN llf'
The Willard
1455 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, Suite 1200
Washington, DC 20004

Main: 202-34 7-2230 Direct: 202-662-2288 Cell: 240-418-9813
Fax: 202-393-3310 kamason@davis-harman.com


LIMITATIONS ON ADVICE. Any advice in this communication and any attachments: (i) is limited to the conclusions specifically set
forth herein and is based on the completeness and accuracy of the stated facts, assumptions and/or representations included
herein; (ii) was prepared for the sole benefit of Davis & Harman LLP's client and may not be relied upon by any other person or
entity; and (iii) is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, by the recipient(s) or any other person or entity, for the
purposes of promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any matters addressed herein.

NOTICE OF CONFIDENTIALITY. The information contained in this message from Davis & Harman LLP and any attachments is
confidential and intended only for the named recipient(s). This message and any attachments may be an attorney-client
communication and as such privileged and confidential. If you have received this message in error, you are prohibited from copying,
distributing or using the information. Please contact the sender immediately by telephone or return e-mail and delete the original
message. We apologize for any inconvenience, and thank you for your prompt attention.


                                                                                                                              DOLAR0843


   Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG             Document 80-14       Filed 09/18/26      Page 17 of 82


                          IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
                     FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF NORTH CAROLINA
                                  CHARLOTTE DIVISION
                         CIVIL ACTION NO. 3:24-CV-00440-KDB-DCK

        KELLY MILLIGAN,

                Plaintiff,

                v.                                               ORDER

        BANK OF AMERICA
        CORPORATION,
        MERRILL LYNCH, PIERCE,
        FENNER & SMITH, INC., AND
        JOHN/JANE DOE 1,

                Defendants.


       THIS MATTER is before the Court on Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc.

No. 41). The Court has carefully considered this motion, the parties' briefs and exhibits and oral

argument on the motion from the parties' counsel on March 4, 2025. For the reasons discussed

below, the Court will GRANT the motion.

                                 I.      LEGAL STANDARD

       Summary judgment is appropriate "if the movant shows that there is no genuine dispute as

to any material fact and the movant is entitled to judgment as a matter of law." United States v.

8.929 Acres of Land in Arlington Cnty., Virginia, 36 F.4th 240,252 (4th Cir. 2022) (quoting Fed.

R. Civ. P. 56(a)); see United States,jlulb Modern Mosaic, LTD v. Turner Construction Co., et al.,

946 F.3d 201,206 (4th Cir. 2019). A factual dispute is considered genuine "if the evidence is such

that a reasonable jury could return a verdict for the nonmoving party." Anderson v. Liberty Lobby,

Inc., 477 U.S. 242,248 (1986); 8.929 Acres ofLand, 36 F.4th at 252. "A fact is material if it might

affect the outcome of the suit under the governing law." Id. (quoting Libertarian Party of Va. v.

                                                    1

    Case 3:24-cv-00440-KDB-DCK            Document 82        Filed 03/11/25     Page 1 of 12


                                                                                                DOLAR0844


   Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG            Document 80-14         Filed 09/18/26       Page 18 of 82


Judd, 718 F.3d 308, 313 (4th Cir. 2013)). In determining if summary judgment is appropriate,

"courts must view the evidence in the light most favorable to the nonmoving party and refrain

from weigh[ing] the evidence or mak[ing] credibility determinations." Variety Stores, Inc. v. Wal-

Mart Stores, Inc., 888 F.3d 651, 659 (4th Cir. 2018) (internal quotation marks omitted) (quoting

Lee v. Town ofSeaboard, 863 F.3d 323,327 (4th Cir. 2017)).

       The party seeking summary judgment bears the initial burden of demonstrating the absence

of a genuine issue of material fact through citations to the pleadings, depositions, answers to

interrogatories, admissions, or affidavits in the record. See Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317,

323 (1986) (when the nonmoving party "has failed to make a sufficient showing on an essential

element of [his] claim with respect to which [he] has the burden of proof," summary judgment is

warranted); United States ex rel. Gugenheim v. Meridian Senior Living, LLC, 36 F.4th 173, 178

(4th Cir. 2022). If the movant satisfies his initial burden to demonstrate "an absence of evidence

to support the nonmoving party's case," the burden shifts to the nonmovant to "present specific

facts showing that there is a genuine issue for trial." 8.929 Acres ofLand, 36 F.4th at 252 (quoting

Humphreys & Partners Architects, L.P. v. Lessard Design, Inc., 790 F.3d 532, 540 (4th Cir.

2015)). "The mere existence of some alleged factual dispute between the parties will not defeat an

otherwise properly supported motion for summary judgment. Hixson v. Moran, 1 F.4th 297, 302

(4th Cir. 2021). Rather, the nonmoving party must establish that a material fact is genuinely

disputed by, inter alia, "citing to particular parts of the materials of record" and cannot rely only

on "conclusory allegations, mere speculation, the building of one inference upon another, or the

mere existence of a scintilla of evidence." Fed. R. Civ. P. 56(c)(l)(A); 8.929 Acres of Land, 36

F.4th at 252 (quoting Dash v. Mayweather, 731 F.3d 303, 311 (4th Cir. 2013)). In the end, the

relevant inquiry on summary judgment is "whether the evidence presents a sufficient disagreement


                                                     2

   Case 3:24-cv-00440-KDB-DCK              Document 82        Filed 03/11/25      Page 2 of 12


                                                                                                  DOLAR0845


   Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG            Document 80-14         Filed 09/18/26       Page 19 of 82


to require submission to a jury or whether it is so one-sided that one party must prevail as a matter

oflaw." Anderson, 477 U.S. at 251-52.

                       II.     FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

       Plaintiff Kelly Milligan worked as a financial advisor ("FA") for Merrill Lynch, Pierce,

Fenner & Smith Inc. ("Merrill"), a wholly owned subsidiary of Bank of America (collectively,

"Defendants") from 2000-2021, at which point he voluntarily departed to start his own company

and compete with Merrill. Doc. No. 1 at~~ 1, 11. During his tenure, Plaintiff participated in the

"Financial Advisor Incentive Compensation Plan" ("FAICP"). 1 Doc. No. 42-10 at 2. As outlined

in the FAICP, FAs are paid a guaranteed monthly salary and are eligible to earn monthly incentive

compensation. Id. In addition, Defendants offer "Long-Term Contingent Awards" which include

restricted stock units (RSUs) and the WealthChoice Award ("WCA"). Id. at 10. FAs receive RSUs

under this award scheme unless they elect to allocate a portion of their long-term contingent award

in the form of a WCA. Id.

       Over his tenure, Plaintiff elected and earned several WCAs. Plaintiff alleges that by

departing, he forfeited over $500,000 in "deferred compensation" because he and others similarly

situated were forced to forfeit the value of their WCAs when they voluntarily left Merrill before

their plans vested. Doc. No. 1 at~~ 1, 11. Plaintiff further asserts that the WCA program is subject

to the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 ("ERISA") because it "provides for

deferred commissions." Doc. No. 54-2 at 5. More specifically, Plaintiff argues that each WCA is

subject to ERISA because it is an "employee pension benefit plan" that "results in a deferral of

income." Doc. No. 1 at~ 3. The deferral of income allegedly results when FAs are "paid for the


       1
         Plaintiff states that the FAICPs issued each year were substantively identical (Doc. No.
54-2 at 5), so the Court will primarily reference the 2020 guide (Doc. No. 42-10).
                                                     3

    Case 3:24-cv-00440-KDB-DCK             Document 82        Filed 03/11/25      Page 3 of 12


                                                                                                  DOLAR0846


   Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG            Document 80-14         Filed 09/18/26       Page 20 of 82


work years after they perform it." Id. at~ 4. These payments occur for "periods extending to the

termination of covered employment or beyond," because in certain circumstance-such as death

or retirement-participants receive the value of their plan after their employment ends. Id.

       In Plaintiff's view, this means that the plan violates ERISA's vesting schedule, and he has

filed a proposed class action suit against Defendants seeking declaratory and equitable relief, along

with reformation of the compensation plan. In response, Defendants filed the pending motion for

summary judgment, asserting that the WCA is not an employee pension benefit plan because it

does not, by design, defer compensation to the end of covered employment or beyond, and because

it is a bonus plan that is exempt from ERISA. Doc.No. 42-2 at 5. The motion has been fully briefed

and argued and is now ripe for the Court's ruling.

                                          III.    DISCUSSION

       Congress passed ERISA in 1974, in an era when many long-term employees were not

getting the pension benefits their employers promised would be there when they retired. See

Lockheed Corp. v. Spink, 517 U.S. 882,887 (1996) (ERISA "seek[s] to ensure that employees will

not be left empty-handed once employers have guaranteed them certain benefits."); see also

Murphy v. Inexco Oil Co., 611 F.2d 570, 574 (1980) (noting that ERISA was enacted to protect

the retirement assets of workers). Congress sought to ensure that if employees were promised a

benefit at retirement-and "fulfilled whatever conditions are required to obtain a vested benefit"-

they "actually will receive it." Nachman Corp. v. PBGC, 446 U.S. 359, 375 (1980). The Supreme

Court and others have cautioned, however, that ERISA does not dictate what benefits employers

must offer, Spink, 517 U.S. at 887, nor is it intended to hamstring or dissuade an employer in

designing other compensation programs, such as retention or other bonus programs, tailored to

their particular workforce or industry. See, e.g., Conkrightv. Frommert, 559 U.S. 506,517 (2010).


                                                     4

   Case 3:24-cv-00440-KDB-DCK              Document 82        Filed 03/11/25      Page 4 of 12


                                                                                                  DOLAR0847


   Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG            Document 80-14         Filed 09/18/26      Page 21 of 82


       "To state a claim under ERISA, a plaintiff must allege and establish the existence of an

'employee [pension] benefit plan' that is governed by ERISA." Albers v. Guardian Life Ins. Co.,

No. 98 Civ. 6244, 1999 WL 228367, at *2 (S.D.N.Y. Apr. 19, 1999). An employee pension benefit

plan is defined under ERISA as:

       any plan, fund, or program ... established or maintained by an employer ... to the
       extent that by its express terms or as a result of surrounding circumstances such
       plan, fund, or program--

               (i) provides retirement income to employees, or

               (ii) results in a deferral of income by employees for periods extending to
               the termination of covered employment or beyond,

       regardless of the method of calculating the contributions made to the plan, the
       method of calculating the benefits under the plan or the method of distributing
       benefits from the plan.

29 U.S.C. § 1002(2)(A). However, even if an employee pension benefit plan can be established,

the Department of Labor ("DOL") carves out an exception excluding bonus payments from

ERISA's definition of an employee pension benefit plan unless the payments are "systematically

deferred to the termination of covered employments or beyond" or are designed for the purpose of

providing retirement income. 29 C.F.R. § 2510.3-2( c). It is within this framework that the Court

must consider the compensation structure at Merrill.

       As previously noted, a FA's income is comprised of a guaranteed monthly salary, monthly

cash compensation, and long-term contingent incentive awards such as a WCA. Doc. Nos. 54-2 at

5; 42-2 at 8. The monthly cash compensation, which is akin to a commission, is calculated and

paid monthly, using a "cash" grid that represents a percentage of "production credits" or revenue

generated. Doc. No. 42-2 at 9. These percentages substantially increase as "production" or revenue

generated increases. In contrast, the WCA program utilizes a separate "long-term" grid that reflects

a much smaller percentage of production credits (starting at less than 10% of the "cash" grid


                                                     5

   Case 3:24-cv-00440-KDB-DCK              Document 82       Filed 03/11/25      Page 5 of 12


                                                                                                 DOLAR0848


   Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG           Document 80-14         Filed 09/18/26      Page 22 of 82


percentage) and is calculated only after a full performance year. Id. Also, unlike the cash

compensation that begins with the first dollar of revenue generated, WCA eligibility does not begin

until after a threshold amount of revenue is generated. Doc. No. 42-10 at 2. Significantly, FAs

must also remain employed with the company until the vesting date for the award to become

"earned and payable." Doc. No. 42-2 at 19.

       During oral argument, Defendants noted that, like Callan v. Merrill Lynch & Co., Inc., No.

09 CV 0566 BEN (BGS), 2010 WL 3452371, at *8 (S.D. Cal. Aug. 30, 2010), which addressed

Merrill's predecessor plan to the WCA, there is nothing in the WCA that "would allow a

reasonable person to calculate or determine the benefits of the plan or the procedure for receiving

[them], as those matters are left to the sole discretion" of Defendants. In its FAICP, the WCA is

described as:

       The [WCA], as in effect from time to time, is intended to be unfunded and
       maintained primarily for the purpose of providing long-term contingent
       incentive compensation, subject to certain conditions, to a select group of
       Financial Advisors. By awarding a portion of a Financial Advisor's incentive
       compensation in the form of a cash award which becomes earned and payable over
       time, the Company intends to encourage the Financial Advisor to remain
       employed by the Company and its Subsidiaries and to further align the interests
       of the Financial Advisor with the Company's business objectives.

Doc. No. 41-3 at 3 (emphasis added). The final amount of each WCA award is further determined

by "the Administrator" and "subject to the review and approval by the Company." Id. at 6. Also,

the company retains the right to adjust the amount of any award to align with the performance of

both the company and individual lines or sub-lines of business. Doc. No. 41-10 at 39.

       When a WCA is calculated, a notional account is created and the FA can select mutual

funds or other investments to benchmark against. Doc. No. 41-1 at 11. The value of the account is

indexed to the performance of the chosen fund or benchmark investment. Id. at 12. Both the FAICP

and the A ward Agreement state that the "Account Balance represents an unsecured, unfunded,


                                                    6

   Case 3:24-cv-00440-KDB-DCK             Document 82        Filed 03/11/25     Page 6 of 12


                                                                                                DOLAR0849


   Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG            Document 80-14          Filed 09/18/26     Page 23 of 82


contingent promise ... to pay the value of the account [] after the Vesting date." Id. Again, the

FAICP makes clear that the WCA becomes earned and payable only after an eight-year vesting

period, and where the FA remains employed through the payment date. Id. at 11. After vesting,

the FA is paid "as soon a[s] practicable ... but in no event later than 2½ months following such

vesting date" and there is no option to defer it. Doc. No. 41-3 at 8.

         In most cases, when employment ends, the balance of any unvested accounts is cancelled,

unless the employee dies, retires, or is involuntarily terminated. Doc. Nos. 41-7 at 7, 42-2 at 12-

13. During oral argument, Defendant asserted that not cancelling WCAs in those relatively

uncommon situations 2 upholds the purpose of the plan, which is, in large part, to reward company

loyalty and longevity. FAs who depart under one of these circumstances (which are largely out of

a FA's control) must generally covenant to not compete in order to attain their WCA. Doc. No.

41-1 at 13. Involuntary terminations (with a non-competition agreement), death, and retirement do

not render an employee adverse to the company the way a FA leaving to work for a competitor

might.

         The specific circumstances of the departure determine how and when a WCA vests. In the

event of death, the FA's estate is paid promptly. Doc. No. 41-1 at 12. If the termination is related

to a workforce reduction, divestiture or disability, the award will "continue to become earned and

payable on the stated vesting schedule," so long as the FA agrees to certain covenants, including

to not solicit clients and employees. Id. at 13. For changes in control, awards become immediately

earned as of the termination date. Id. Finally, for retirement, WCAs become earned and payable in


         2
        According to the parties, 18% of WCA recipients received some payment after their
employment ended and 92.6% of the FAs who received WCAs between 2018 and 2024 were active
employees, both of which demonstrate that receiving a WCA payment post-employment is
uncommon. Doc. Nos. 42-2 at 13, 54-2 at 8.

                                                      7

    Case 3:24-cv-00440-KDB-DCK             Document 82         Filed 03/11/25    Page 7 of 12


                                                                                                 DOLAR0850


   Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG             Document 80-14          Filed 09/18/26       Page 24 of 82


two installments: first, after the end of the year the FA retires, and second, after the end of the next

year. As a condition of payment, retiring FAs must also covenant to not solicit employees or clients

and must not engage in competition. Id. According to Defendants, spacing retirement payments

out this way gives the company some recourse in the event that the FA resumes working and

engages in competition. Somewhat paradoxically, it is these unique circumstances that, in

Plaintiff's view, bring WCAs under ERISA's narrow ambit.


A. Employee Pension Benefit Plan

        Because it is possible for a WCA to be paid out, in certain limited circumstances, after the

end of covered employment, the central dispute requires interpretation of subsection (ii) of the

ERISA statute. Subsection (ii) addresses whether a plan's express terms or circumstances result in

deferrals of income to or beyond the termination of employment. See 29 U.S.C. § 1002(2)(A)(ii).

Plaintiff urges the Court to use a "results-based" test when considering whether the plan defers

income to the end of employment or beyond, which at least one other court has considered. See

Pasternack v. Shrader, 863 F.3d 162, 171 n.5 (2d Cir. 2017) (noting that the "word 'results' calls

for an effects-based inquiry rather than one based on purpose"). However, adopting Plaintiff's

view would mean that virtually any plan that allows for income to be paid after employment ends,

even incidentally, could fall under ERISA's purview.

        The Court disagrees with Plaintiff's interpretation. ERISA's "definition is not algorithmic"

and its words should not be "read as an elastic girdle that can be stretched to cover any content

that can conceivably fit within its reach." Murphy, 611 F.2d at 575. Plaintiff's expansive

interpretation reaches far beyond Congress' intent and ignores ERISA's fundamental premise,


                                                       8

    Case 3:24-cv-00440-KDB-DCK              Document 82         Filed 03/11/25      Page 8 of 12


                                                                                                     DOLAR0851


   Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG            Document 80-14         Filed 09/18/26       Page 25 of 82


both of which are rooted in protecting the retirement assets of workers. 3 See Pilot Life Ins. Co. v.

Dedeaux, 481 U.S. 41, 51 (1987) ("i]n expounding a statute, we must not be guided by a single

sentence or member of a sentence, but look to the provisions of the whole law, and to its object

and policy") (quotations and citations omitted).

       Indeed, courts routinely find, as the Court does here, that "the purpose of the plan must be

to provide retirement income or to defer income until termination or beyond." Juric v. USALCO,

LLC, 659 F. Supp. 3d 619, 633 (D. Md. 2023). See also Depew v. MNC Fin., Inc., 819 F. Supp.

492, 495 (D. Md. 1993) (finding no employee pension benefit plan under ERISA when the plans

did not "require[ ] deferral of income until the termination of employment or thereafter"); Rich v.

Shrader, 823 F.3d 1205, 1210 (9th Cir. 2016) ("[W]e agree with our sister circuits that have

determined that the paramount consideration is whether the primary purpose of the plan is to

provide deferred compensation or other retirement benefits."). And the "mere fact that some

payments under a plan may be made after an employee has retired or left the company does not

result in ERISA coverage." Murphy, 611 F.2d at 575. See also Juric, 659 F. Supp. 3d at 633

(finding the fact that some income "can or may be deferred" insufficient to sustain an ERISA

claim); Rich, 823 F.3d at 1211 (finding the same).

       The express purpose of the WCA program is to reward employees for performance and

tenure, and both the plan structure and administration are tailored to achieve those ends. While the

WCA contemplates rare situations under which an award might be paid after the end of

employment, as is the case with retirement, in most circumstances, once the award is earned, it is


       3
          See U.S. Department of Labor, ERISA, https://www.dol.gov/general/topic/health-
plans/erisa (last accessed January 30, 2025).
                                                     9

    Case 3:24-cv-00440-KDB-DCK             Document 82        Filed 03/11/25      Page 9 of 12


                                                                                                  DOLAR0852


   Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG              Document 80-14          Filed 09/18/26       Page 26 of 82


promptly paid out. In sum, this is the type of scenario around which the Court will decline to stretch

the "elastic girdle." Murphy, 611 F.2d at 575.


B. Department of Labor Bonus Plan Exemption

        Even if the Court were to adopt Plaintiff's results-based test and find that the WCA could

be an employee pension benefit plan under ERISA, it is still subject to the Department of Labor's

("DOL") exemption for bonus plans, unless payments under the plan are "systematically deferred

to the termination of covered employment or beyond." 29 C.F.R. § 2510.3-2(c). By definition,

"[a] bonus is ' [a] premium paid in addition to what is due or expected[,] [especially] a payment by

way of division of a business's profits, given over and above normal compensation.'" Shafer v.

Stanley, No. 20 CIV. 11047 (PGG), 2024 WL 4697235, at *7 (S.D.N.Y. Nov. 5, 2024) (quoting

Bonus, Black's Law Dictionary (11th ed. 2019)).

        According to the DOL, a bonus plan "in operation," must not be "a vehicle for the provision

of retirement income," DOL Advisory Op. 89-07A at 2, and a "significant operative factor" when

considering whether a plan is a bonus plan under the regulation, is whether an "inordinate

percentage of the bonus recipients were at ... retirement age." Id. See also Oatway v. Am. Int'!

Grp., Inc., 325 F.3d 184, 188-89 (3d Cir. 2003) (holding a plan was not subject to ERISA "because

its purpose was to operate as an incentive and bonus program, and not as a means to defer

compensation or provide retirement benefits"); Emmenegger v. Bull Moose Tube Co., 197 F.3d

929, 931-34 (8th Cir. 1999) ("Though the [plan's] vesting requirement could result in the deferral

of a portion of any earned incentive until a participant's termination or retirement, ... such a deferral

would only occur by happenstance. In fact, the stated purpose of the vesting requirement reinforces

our conclusion that the [plan] is a non-ERISA bonus plan.").


                                                       10

   Case 3:24-cv-00440-KDB-DCK               Document 82         Filed 03/11/25       Page 10 of 12


                                                                                                      DOLAR0853


   Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG           Document 80-14         Filed 09/18/26      Page 27 of 82


       Here, the WCA is an unfunded, discretionary plan, devised for the express purpose of

rewarding long-term FAs who also help the company meet financial goals. Awards are not

guaranteed (the way salary and commission are); the employee must meet a minimum production

threshold and stay at the company until the award vests, eight years later. Also, the award, while

based on a small percentage of the FA's revenue generated over a performance year, is subject to

adjustments by the company based on company and business line performance. Thus, the WCA is

clearly a bonus plan, paid over and above normal compensation, and its intent and operation are

not designed to provide retirement income.

       Finally the plan does not "systematically defer income to the termination of covered

employment or beyond." 29 C.F.R. § 2510.3-2( c). Generally, neither the company nor the FA may

defer award payouts, and the few exceptions are intended to deter workforce reentry (in the case

of retirement) and competition. Again, the vast majority of award payouts are to actively employed

FAs. Thus, while it is possible in certain circumstances to receive a WCA payout after the end of

employment, it is both limited in scope and uncommon in occurrence. It is, as the Emmenegger

Court stated, "happenstance," 197 F.3d at 933, and plainly not systematic.

       Consistent with the two courts that have found Defendants' functionally identical

predecessor plans to be bonus plans exempt from ERISA,4 the Court finds that the WCA is not an


       4
           See Mullett v. Merrill, Lynch, Pierce, Fenner & Smith, No. CIV.A. 01-CV-2118, 2002
WL 32298599, at *2 (E.D. Pa. Feb. 26, 2002) (finding a bonus program exempt from ERISA
where the plan was implemented to "establish and retain a strong salesforce," subject to a ten-year
vesting period and paid promptly once vested; also concluding that the plan "provides neither
'retirement income' nor 'systematically deferred compensation until the termination of
employment' merely because an employee might receive the benefits after he or she has retired or
terminated employment"); Callan, WL 3452371, at *7-8 (finding a similar plan with similar
criteria, vesting periods, and payment practices to be a bonus plan exempt from ERISA).
                                                    11

   Case 3:24-cv-00440-KDB-DCK            Document 82        Filed 03/11/25      Page 11 of 12


                                                                                                DOLAR0854


   Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG           Document 80-14       Filed 09/18/26      Page 28 of 82


employee pension benefit plan; it is a bonus plan exempt from ERISA, and the Court will grant

Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment.

                                           IV.   ORDER

       NOW THEREFORE IT IS ORDERED THAT:

          1. Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc. No. 41) is GRANTED; and

          2. The Clerk is directed to close this matter in accordance with this Order.

       SO ORDERED ADJUDGED AND DECREED.
                  Signed: March 10, 2025


                   Kenneth D. Bell
                   United States District Judge


                                                  12

   Case 3:24-cv-00440-KDB-DCK              Document 82     Filed 03/11/25     Page 12 of 12


                                                                                              DOLAR0855


           Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG               Document 80-14           Filed 09/18/26       Page 29 of 82


From:   Kent A. Mason [kamason@davis-harman.com]
 ent:   8/12/2025 1:03:08 PM
 o:     Dhillon, Janet L - EBSA [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
        (FYDI BOH F23SPDLT)/ cn=Reci pi ents/cn=c31 fbd84ce034a5a 8ebcad30dde9b06f-
        ec453f43-32]; Lund, Jack G - EBSA [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange
        Administrative Group
        (FYDI BOH F23SPDLT)/ cn=Reci pi ents/cn=e0df3 7983cc6407 495edcf1634411cf7-
        63fb2472-e8]; Bolton, Charles H - EBSA [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange
        Administrative Group
                                                                                      You don't often get email from
        (FYDI BOH F23SPDLT)/ cn=Reci pi ents/cn=8dd803ddc9944aef996104828a461721-
                                                                                      kamason@davis-harman.com. Learn
        2b288c21-a5 ]; Danhof, Justin G - EBSA [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange
                                                                                      why this is important
        Administrative Group
        (FYDI BOH F23SPDLT)/ cn=Reci pi ents/cn=da4143a3e 1dc4c60ba6482fff09a44e9-
        52a5df72-e5]
CC:     'Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com' [Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com];
        'PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com' [PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com]; Chris Gaston
        [CGaston@davis-harman.com]
 ubject:Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion -- New Amicus Brief and Question


Thanks again for meeting with us on Morgan Stanley's request for an advisory opinion on its long-term
incentive program. We wanted to provide two updates in case they are helpful. First, the American Benefits
Council, the US Chamber of Commerce, and The ERISA Industry Committee (ERIC) filed an arnicus
brief supporting Merrill Lynch in the plaintiffs' appeal to the Fourth Circuit from a decision of the District
Court for the Western District of North Carolina regarding a program virtually identical to Morgan Stanley's.
We thought that the amicus brief linked above might be of interest.

Second with such strong support from trade associations on this issue, we are considering asking the trades to
weigh in with EBSA with a brief letter on the importance of this issue and the need for fast and clear
confirmation of DO L's longstanding position that such long-term incentive programs are not subject to ERISA.
If you have any concerns with us doing that, please let us know. We just want to provide you with as much
information as we can about the critical nature of this issue for a very wide range of businesses across the
country, making this an ideal candidate for DOL's expanded and revived Advisory Opinion program.

The trades' amicus brief provides some insights into how important this issue is:

Distorting ERISA so that it reaches those [long-term incentive] programs would have destructive effects.
Making those programs subject to ERISA's strict vesting and anti-forfeiture rules would expose employers to
potentially astronomical liability for unexceptional cancellations of incentive awards that have not vested under
those programs' terms. See 29 U.S.C. § 1053; 29 C.F.R. § 2530. That result would undermine employers'
justifiable reliance on nearly fifty years of case law and regulatory guidance concluding that such programs fall
outside ERISA's scope, making it more difficult for businesses to offer their employees attractive and flexible
compensation programs. Indeed, it would induce some employers to eliminate their long-term incentive or


                                                                                                                DOLAR0856


             Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                  Document 80-14              Filed 09/18/26          Page 30 of 82
deferred incentive compensation programs altogether, stripping them of a valuable tool with which to retain
talented employees and denying employees access to a widely desired compensation arrangement. Nothing in
ERISA requires such an unfortunate outcome ....

Employers across a variety of industries use these arrangements "to further enhance retention." ... And
employers are increasingly starting to offer long-term incentive awards to employees below the executive level.


Plaintiff's theory is worse than legally wrong: if adopted, it would have enormously destructive practical
consequences, harming both employers and employees. To begin, that approach, if valid, certainly would
encourage a wave oflitigation against employers in all sectors of the economy that use long-term incentive or
deferred incentive compensation arrangements ....

And if their theory succeeds, these plaintiffs' firms will have no reason to stop with the financial services
industry. It is not difficult for a single firm or set of firms to bring dozens of cookie-cutter lawsuits-that is
already par for the course in ERISA litigation ....

Defending against such lawsuits challenging commonplace and useful compensation arrangements would
impose substantial costs on employers in virtually all cases and sometimes would extract strike-suit settlements,
as the prospect of "asymmetric" discovery for defendants in ERISA actions comes at an "ominous" price,
entailing "probing and costly inquiries."
Kent A. Mason
Davis & Harman LLP


                                     l"\'"
            DAVIS & ·\J
            f;ARMANuP
The Willard
1455 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, Suite 1200
Washington, DC 20004

Main: 202-347-2230 Direct: 202-662-2288
Fax: 202-393-3310 kamason@davis-harman.com


LIMITATIONS ON ADVICE. Any advice in this communication and any attachments: (i) is limited to the conclusions specifically set
forth herein and is based on the completeness and accuracy of the stated facts, assumptions and/or representations included
herein; (ii) was prepared for the sole benefit of Davis & Harman LLP's client and may not be relied upon by any other person or
entity; and (iii) is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, by the recipient(s) or any other person or entity, for the
purposes of promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any matters addressed herein.

NOTICE OF CONFIDENTIALITY. The information contained in this message from Davis & Harman LLP and any attachments is
confidential and intended only for the named recipient(s). This message and any attachments may be an attorney-client
communication and as such privileged and confidential. If you have received this message in error, you are prohibited from copying,
distributing or using the information. Please contact the sender immediately by telephone or return e-mail and delete the original
message. We apologize for any inconvenience, and thank you for your prompt attention.


                                                                                                                              DOLAR0857


                           Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                    Document 80-14           Filed 09/18/26    Page 31 of 82

From:                              Dhillon, Janet L - EBSA [/O=EXCHANGELABS/OU=EXCHANGE ADMINISTRATIVE GROUP
                                   (FYDI BO HF 23SPDLT)/CN =RE Cl Pl ENTS/CN =C31 FBD84CE034A5A8EBCAD30DDE9B06F-EC453F43-32]
Sent:                              8/12/2025 5:56:57 PM
To:                                Kent A. Mason [kamason@davis-harman.com]
Subject:                           RE: Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion -- New Amicus Brief and Question


Kent

As is our usual practice, we send a draft of the statement of facts of an advisory opinion to the requester for
review. We are ready to proceed to that step. Should the draft be directed to you, Greg Jacob, or both of you?

Best,

Janet

Janet Dhillon
Acting Assistant Secretary
Employee Benefits Security Administration
U.S. Department of Labor
Dh ii Ion.Janet. L@g.9-Lg_Q.y


       l.\. Jll"'ITlllfl'H 0,1,.1,101


From: Kent A. Mason <kamason@davis-harman.com>
Sent: Tuesday, August 12, 2025 1:03 PM
To: Dhillon, Janet L - EBSA <Dhillon.Janet.L@dol.gov>; Lund, Jack G - EBSA <Lund.Jack.G@dol.gov>; Bolton, Charles H -
EBSA <Bolton.Charles.H@dol.gov>; Danhof, Justin G - EBSA <Danhof.Justin.G@dol.gov>
Cc: 'Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com' <Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com>; 'PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com'
<PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com>; Chris Gaston <CGaston@davis-harman.com>
Subject: Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion -- New Amicus Brief and Question


Thanks again for meeting with us on Morgan Stanley's request for an advisory opinion on its long-term
incentive program. We wanted to provide two updates in case they are helpful. First, the American Benefits
Council, the US Chamber of Commerce, and The ERISA Industry Committee (ERIC) fiJc:gan an1i(211~
brief supporting Merrill Lynch in the plaintiffs' appeal to the Fourth Circuit from a decision of the District


                                                                                                                                DOLAR0858


           Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG             Document 80-14         Filed 09/18/26       Page 32 of 82
Court for the Western District of North Carolina regarding a program virtually identical to Morgan Stanley's.
We thought that the amicus brief linked above might be of interest.

Second with such strong support from trade associations on this issue, we are considering asking the trades to
weigh in with EBSA with a brief letter on the importance of this issue and the need for fast and clear
confirmation of DO L's longstanding position that such long-term incentive programs are not subject to ERISA.
If you have any concerns with us doing that, please let us know. We just want to provide you with as much
information as we can about the critical nature of this issue for a very wide range of businesses across the
country, making this an ideal candidate for DOL's expanded and revived Advisory Opinion program.

The trades' amicus brief provides some insights into how important this issue is:

Distorting ERISA so that it reaches those [long-term incentive] programs would have destructive effects.
Making those programs subject to ERISA's strict vesting and anti-forfeiture rules would expose employers to
potentially astronomical liability for unexceptional cancellations of incentive awards that have not vested under
those programs' terms. See 29 U.S.C. § 1053; 29 C.F.R. § 2530. That result would undermine employers'
justifiable reliance on nearly fifty years of case law and regulatory guidance concluding that such programs fall
outside ERISA's scope, making it more difficult for businesses to offer their employees attractive and flexible
compensation programs. Indeed, it would induce some employers to eliminate their long-term incentive or
deferred incentive compensation programs altogether, stripping them of a valuable tool with which to retain
talented employees and denying employees access to a widely desired compensation arrangement. Nothing in
ERISA requires such an unfortunate outcome ....

Employers across a variety of industries use these arrangements "to further enhance retention." ... And
employers are increasingly starting to offer long-term incentive awards to employees below the executive level.


Plaintiff's theory is worse than legally wrong: if adopted, it would have enormously destructive practical
consequences, harming both employers and employees. To begin, that approach, if valid, certainly would
encourage a wave oflitigation against employers in all sectors of the economy that use long-term incentive or
deferred incentive compensation arrangements ....

And if their theory succeeds, these plaintiffs' firms will have no reason to stop with the financial services
industry. It is not difficult for a single firm or set of firms to bring dozens of cookie-cutter lawsuits-that is
already par for the course in ERISA litigation ....

Defending against such lawsuits challenging commonplace and useful compensation arrangements would
impose substantial costs on employers in virtually all cases and sometimes would extract strike-suit settlements,
as the prospect of "asymmetric" discovery for defendants in ERISA actions comes at an "ominous" price,
entailing "probing and costly inquiries."
Kent A. Mason
Davis & Harman LLP


          DAVIS
          f;ARMANuP
                       &48'"
The Willard
1455 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, Suite 1200
Washington, DC 20004


                                                                                                            DOLAR0859


             Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                  Document 80-14              Filed 09/18/26          Page 33 of 82
Main: 202-34 7-2230 Di rcct: 202-662-2288
Fax: 202-393-3310 kamason@davis-harman.com


LIMITATIONS ON ADVICE. Any advice in this communication and any attachments: (i) is limited to the conclusions specifically set
forth herein and is based on the completeness and accuracy of the stated facts, assumptions and/or representations included
herein; (ii) was prepared for the sole benefit of Davis & Harman LLP's client and may not be relied upon by any other person or
entity; and (iii) is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, by the recipient(s) or any other person or entity, for the
purposes of promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any matters addressed herein.

NOTICE OF CONFIDENTIALITY. The information contained in this message from Davis & Harman LLP and any attachments is
confidential and intended only for the named recipient(s). This message and any attachments may be an attorney-client
communication and as such privileged and confidential. If you have received this message in error, you are prohibited from copying,
distributing or using the information. Please contact the sender immediately by telephone or return e-mail and delete the original
message. We apologize for any inconvenience, and thank you for your prompt attention.


                                                                                                                              DOLAR0860


           Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG             Document 80-14          Filed 09/18/26       Page 34 of 82

From:         Kent A. Mason [kamason@davis-harman.com]
Sent:         8/12/2025 6:05:53 PM
To:           Dhillon, Janet L - EBSA [/o=Exchangelabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
              (FYDI BO HF 23SPDLT)/ cn=Recip ients/cn=c31 fbd84ce034a5a8ebcad30dde9b06f-ec453f43-32]
CC:           'Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com' [Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com]; 'PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com'
              [P J.Austin@morganstanley.com]
Subject:      RE: Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion -- New Amicus Brief and Question


Thanks so much. We so appreciate the fast consideration and work on this. I checked with Morgan Stanley
(copied here) and the draft should come to me. Have a great night.


From: Dhillon, Janet L - EBSA <Dhillon.Janet.L@dol.gov>
Sent: Tuesday, August 12, 2025 5:57 PM
To: Kent A. Mason <kamason@davis-harman.com>
Subject: RE: Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion -- New Amicus Brief and Question


Kent

As is our usual practice, we send a draft of the statement of facts of an advisory opinion to the requester for
review. We are ready to proceed to that step. Should the draft be directed to you, Greg Jacob, or both of you?

Best,

Janet

Janet Dhillon
Acting Assistant Secretary
Employee Benefits Security Administration
U.S. Department of Labor


From: Kent A. Mason <kamason@davis-harman.com>
Sent: Tuesday, August 12, 2025 1:03 PM
To: Dhillon, Janet L - EBSA <Dhillon.Janet.L@dol.gov>; Lund, Jack G - EBSA <Lund.Jack.G@dol.gov>; Bolton, Charles H -
EBSA <Bolton.Charles.H@dol.gov>; Danhof, Justin G - EBSA <Danhof.Justin.G@dol.gov>


                                                                                                              DOLAR0861


           Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG             Document 80-14         Filed 09/18/26       Page 35 of 82
Cc: 'Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com' <Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com>; 'PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com'
<PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com>; Chris Gaston <CGaston@davis-harman.com>
Subject: Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion -- New Amicus Brief and Question


Thanks again for meeting with us on Morgan Stanley's request for an advisory opinion on its long-term
incentive program. We wanted to provide two updates in case they are helpful. First, the American Benefits
Council, the US Chamber of Commerce, and The ERISA Industry Committee (ERIC) filed an arnicus
brief supporting Merrill Lynch in the plaintiffs' appeal to the Fourth Circuit from a decision of the District
Court for the Western District of North Carolina regarding a program virtually identical to Morgan Stanley's.
We thought that the amicus brief linked above might be of interest.

Second with such strong support from trade associations on this issue, we are considering asking the trades to
weigh in with EBSA with a brief letter on the importance of this issue and the need for fast and clear
confirmation of DO L's longstanding position that such long-term incentive programs are not subject to ERISA.
If you have any concerns with us doing that, please let us know. We just want to provide you with as much
information as we can about the critical nature of this issue for a very wide range of businesses across the
country, making this an ideal candidate for DOL's expanded and revived Advisory Opinion program.

The trades' amicus brief provides some insights into how important this issue is:

Distorting ERISA so that it reaches those [long-term incentive] programs would have destructive effects.
Making those programs subject to ERISA's strict vesting and anti-forfeiture rules would expose employers to
potentially astronomical liability for unexceptional cancellations of incentive awards that have not vested under
those programs' terms. See 29 U.S.C. § 1053; 29 C.F.R. § 2530. That result would undermine employers'
justifiable reliance on nearly fifty years of case law and regulatory guidance concluding that such programs fall
outside ERISA's scope, making it more difficult for businesses to offer their employees attractive and flexible
compensation programs. Indeed, it would induce some employers to eliminate their long-term incentive or
deferred incentive compensation programs altogether, stripping them of a valuable tool with which to retain
talented employees and denying employees access to a widely desired compensation arrangement. Nothing in
ERISA requires such an unfortunate outcome ....

Employers across a variety of industries use these arrangements "to further enhance retention." ... And
employers are increasingly starting to offer long-term incentive awards to employees below the executive level.


Plaintiff's theory is worse than legally wrong: if adopted, it would have enormously destructive practical
consequences, harming both employers and employees. To begin, that approach, if valid, certainly would
encourage a wave oflitigation against employers in all sectors of the economy that use long-term incentive or
deferred incentive compensation arrangements ....

And if their theory succeeds, these plaintiffs' firms will have no reason to stop with the financial services
industry. It is not difficult for a single firm or set of firms to bring dozens of cookie-cutter lawsuits-that is
already par for the course in ERISA litigation ....


                                                                                                            DOLAR0862


             Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                  Document 80-14              Filed 09/18/26          Page 36 of 82


Defending against such lawsuits challenging commonplace and useful compensation arrangements would
impose substantial costs on employers in virtually all cases and sometimes would extract strike-suit settlements,
as the prospect of "asymmetric" discovery for defendants in ERISA actions comes at an "ominous" price,
entailing "probing and costly inquiries."
Kent A. Mason
Davis & Harman LLP


                                     l"\'"
            DAVIS & ·\)
            f;ARMANuP
The Willard
1455 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, Suite 1200
Washington, DC 20004

Main: 202-347-2230 Direct: 202-662-2288
Fax: 202-393-3310 kamason@davis-harman.com


LIMITATIONS ON ADVICE. Any advice in this communication and any attachments: (i) is limited to the conclusions specifically set
forth herein and is based on the completeness and accuracy of the stated facts, assumptions and/or representations included
herein; (ii) was prepared for the sole benefit of Davis & Harman LLP's client and may not be relied upon by any other person or
entity; and (iii) is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, by the recipient(s) or any other person or entity, for the
purposes of promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any matters addressed herein.

NOTICE OF CONFIDENTIALITY. The information contained in this message from Davis & Harman LLP and any attachments is
confidential and intended only for the named recipient(s). This message and any attachments may be an attorney-client
communication and as such privileged and confidential. If you have received this message in error, you are prohibited from copying,
distributing or using the information. Please contact the sender immediately by telephone or return e-mail and delete the original
message. We apologize for any inconvenience, and thank you for your prompt attention.


                                                                                                                              DOLAR0863


            Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG            Document 80-14          Filed 09/18/26       Page 37 of 82

From:         Dhillon, Janet L - EBSA [/O=EXCHANGELABS/OU=EXCHANGE ADMINISTRATIVE GROUP
              (FYDI BO HF 23SPDLT)/CN =RE Cl Pl ENTS/CN =C31 FBD84CE034A5A8EBCAD30DDE9B06F-EC453F43-32]
Sent:         8/12/2025 6:07:35 PM
To:           Kent A. Mason [kamason@davis-harman.com]
CC:           'Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com' [Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com]; 'PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com'
              [P J.Austin@morganstanley.com]
Subject:      RE: Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion -- New Amicus Brief and Question


Thank you

Janet Dhillon
Acting Assistant Secretary
Employee Benefits Security Administration
U.S. Department of Labor


From: Kent A. Mason <kamason@davis-harman.com>
Sent: Tuesday, August 12, 2025 6:06 PM
To: Dhillon, Janet L - EBSA <Dhillon.Janet.L@dol.gov>
Cc: 'Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com' <Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com>; 'PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com'
<PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com>
Subject: RE: Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion -- New Amicus Brief and Question


Thanks so much. We so appreciate the fast consideration and work on this. I checked with Morgan Stanley
(copied here) and the draft should come to me. Have a great night.


From: Dhillon, Janet L - EBSA <Dhillon.Janet.L@dol.gov>
Sent: Tuesday, August 12, 2025 5:57 PM
To: Kent A. Mason <kamason@davis-harman.com>
Subject: RE: Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion -- New Amicus Brief and Question

Kent

As is our usual practice, we send a draft of the statement of facts of an advisory opinion to the requester for
review. We are ready to proceed to that step. Should the draft be directed to you, Greg Jacob, or both of you?


                                                                                                              DOLAR0864


            Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG            Document 80-14          Filed 09/18/26       Page 38 of 82


Best,

Janet

Janet Dhillon
Acting Assistant Secretary
Employee Benefits Security Administration
U.S. Department of Labor
Dh ii Ion.Janet. L@g.9-Lg_Q.y


From: Kent A. Mason <kamason@davis-harman.com>
Sent: Tuesday, August 12, 2025 1:03 PM
To: Dhillon, Janet L - EBSA <Dhillon.Janet.L@dol.gov>; Lund, Jack G - EBSA <Lund.Jack.G@dol.gov>; Bolton, Charles H -
EBSA <Bolton.Charles.H@dol.gov>; Danhof, Justin G - EBSA <Danhof.Justin.G@dol.gov>
Cc: 'Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com' <Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com>; 'PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com'
<PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com>; Chris Gaston <CGaston@davis-harman.com>
Subject: Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion -- New Amicus Brief and Question


Thanks again for meeting with us on Morgan Stanley's request for an advisory opinion on its long-term
incentive program. We wanted to provide two updates in case they are helpful. First, the American Benefits
Council, the US Chamber of Commerce, and The ERISA Industry Committee (ERIC) filed an arnicus
!?.rjg_f supporting Merrill Lynch in the plaintiffs' appeal to the Fourth Circuit from a decision of the District
Court for the Western District of North Carolina regarding a program virtually identical to Morgan Stanley's.
We thought that the amicus brief linked above might be of interest.

Second with such strong support from trade associations on this issue, we are considering asking the trades to
weigh in with EBSA with a brief letter on the importance of this issue and the need for fast and clear
confirmation of DO L's longstanding position that such long-term incentive programs are not subject to ERISA.
If you have any concerns with us doing that, please let us know. We just want to provide you with as much
information as we can about the critical nature of this issue for a very wide range of businesses across the
country, making this an ideal candidate for DOL's expanded and revived Advisory Opinion program.

The trades' amicus brief provides some insights into how important this issue is:


                                                                                                             DOLAR0865


             Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                  Document 80-14              Filed 09/18/26          Page 39 of 82
Distorting ERISA so that it reaches those [long-term incentive] programs would have destructive effects.
Making those programs subject to ERISA's strict vesting and anti-forfeiture rules would expose employers to
potentially astronomical liability for unexceptional cancellations of incentive awards that have not vested under
those programs' terms. See 29 U.S.C. § 1053; 29 C.F.R. § 2530. That result would undermine employers'
justifiable reliance on nearly fifty years of case law and regulatory guidance concluding that such programs fall
outside ERISA's scope, making it more difficult for businesses to offer their employees attractive and flexible
compensation programs. Indeed, it would induce some employers to eliminate their long-term incentive or
deferred incentive compensation programs altogether, stripping them of a valuable tool with which to retain
talented employees and denying employees access to a widely desired compensation arrangement. Nothing in
ERISA requires such an unfortunate outcome ....

Employers across a variety of industries use these arrangements "to further enhance retention." ... And
employers are increasingly starting to offer long-term incentive awards to employees below the executive level.


Plaintiff's theory is worse than legally wrong: if adopted, it would have enormously destructive practical
consequences, harming both employers and employees. To begin, that approach, if valid, certainly would
encourage a wave oflitigation against employers in all sectors of the economy that use long-term incentive or
deferred incentive compensation arrangements ....

And if their theory succeeds, these plaintiffs' firms will have no reason to stop with the financial services
industry. It is not difficult for a single firm or set of firms to bring dozens of cookie-cutter lawsuits-that is
already par for the course in ERISA litigation ....

Defending against such lawsuits challenging commonplace and useful compensation arrangements would
impose substantial costs on employers in virtually all cases and sometimes would extract strike-suit settlements,
as the prospect of "asymmetric" discovery for defendants in ERISA actions comes at an "ominous" price,
entailing "probing and costly inquiries."
Kent A. Mason
Davis & Harman LLP


                                     l"\'"
            DAVIS & ·\)
            f;ARMANuP
The Willard
1455 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, Suite 1200
Washington, DC 20004

Main: 202-34 7-2230 Direct: 202-662-2288
Fax: 202-393-3310 kamason@davis-harman.com


LIMITATIONS ON ADVICE. Any advice in this communication and any attachments: (i) is limited to the conclusions specifically set
forth herein and is based on the completeness and accuracy of the stated facts, assumptions and/or representations included
herein; (ii) was prepared for the sole benefit of Davis & Harman LLP's client and may not be relied upon by any other person or
entity; and (iii) is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, by the recipient(s) or any other person or entity, for the
purposes of promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any matters addressed herein.

NOTICE OF CONFIDENTIALITY. The information contained in this message from Davis & Harman LLP and any attachments is
confidential and intended only for the named recipient(s). This message and any attachments may be an attorney-client


                                                                                                                              DOLAR0866


            Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                 Document 80-14            Filed 09/18/26         Page 40 of 82
communication and as such privileged and confidential. If you have received this message in error, you are prohibited from copying,
distributing or using the information. Please contact the sender immediately by telephone or return e-mail and delete the original
message. We apologize for any inconvenience, and thank you for your prompt attention.


                                                                                                                        DOLAR0867


              Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                  Document 80-14     Filed 09/18/26       Page 41 of 82


From:            Berger, Eric - EBSA [/O=EXCHANGELABS/OU=EXCHANGE ADMINISTRATIVE GROUP
                 (FYDI BO HF 23SPDLT)/CN =RE Cl Pl ENTS/CN =652F46F 1F32 B4363926E49C4E D696AFA-BE RG ER, ERi]
Sent:            8/12/2025 6:38:20 PM
To:              kamason@davis-harman.com
CC:              Turner, Jeffrey - EBSA [/o=Exchangelabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
                 (FYDIBOHF23SPDLT)/cn=Recipients/cn=6f1450e69eb24e6a9cb105d821a7eaf3-Turner, Jef]; Lund, Jack G - EBSA
                 [/o=Exchangelabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
                 (FYDI BO HF 23SPDLT)/ cn=Recip ients/cn=e0df3 7983cc6407 495edcf1634411cf7-63fb24 72-e8]
Subject:         Draft Facts Supporting Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion Request
Attachments:     Morgan Stanley Factual Representations 081225.docx


Dear Mr. Mason:

Attached for your review are draft facts supporting the advisory opinion requested on behalf of Morgan Stanley.

Under Advisory Opinion Procedure 76-1 the parties described in an advisory opinion "may rely on the opinion only to
the extent that the request fully and accurately contains all the material facts and representations necessary to issuance
of the opinion and the situation conforms to the situation described in the request for opinion." Accordingly, as a
routine matter, we ask opinion requesters to review and confirm the facts in support of the opinion. A red line of
changes, if any, would be most helpful. We would appreciate a quick turnaround. We, of course are happy to chat by
phone if you would like.

Thanks,

Eric Berger
Chief, Division of Coverage, Reporting & Disclosure
Office of Regulations and Interpretations
Employee Benefits Security Administration
U.S. Department of Labor


                                                                                                                 DOLAR0868


    Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                 Document 80-14             Filed 09/18/26          Page 42 of 82
Draft 8.12.25


                          Draft Supporting Representations (Case No. A01533)


The following srnnn1ary is based on the materials and representations provided in support of the
request and should not be treated as factual findings by the Department.

You represent that the Firm's financial advisors receive a guaranteed base salary and are eligible
to earn cash incentive compensation which is paid throughout the year. In addition, financial
advisors are eligible to earn deferred incentive compensation, with twenty-five percent issued as
an unsecured deferred stock award under the EICP and the remaining seventy-five percent as an
unsecured deferred cash-based award under the MSCIP. 1 The deferred stock units are converted
to shares of Morgan Stanley common stock and deposited into a brokerage account, while cash-
based awards are deposited into the financial advisors' payroll accounts, on the "scheduled
vesting date" only when all conditions are met, as described below.

All incentive compensation is calculated based on "Total Credits". The financial advisor's Total
Credits for each month are determined by the applicable "Credit Rate" multiplied by the
creditable revenue generated by the financial advisor. The Credit Rate is a percentage between
28% and 55.5% that increases with the financial advisor's revenue and length of service with the
Firm. A portion of the Total Credits is allocated to "Deferred Credits" (between 1.5% and 15% of
the financial advisor's total incentive compensation), based on the level ofrevenue the financial
advisor generates. The cumulative value of the monthly Deferred Credits for the year is granted
to the financial advisor in the form of deferred incentive compensation (deferred stock and cash
awards) shortly after the year-end. Deferred incentive compensation awards are generally
contingent, among other things, upon the advisor remaining continuously employed through the
grant and vesting dates. Accordingly, if the financial advisor terminates employment during the
year, there is no award of the Deferred Credits granted for that year. The rest (between 84.5%
and 98.5%) of the Total Credits are allocated to "Cash Credits", which are used to calculate and
pay cash incentive compensation monthly.

Both cash and deferred incentive compensation reward good performance by calculating the
amount, in part, based on a financial advisor's generation ofrevenue for the Firm. Deferred
incentive compensation, however, serves additional purposes: to reward financial advisors for
their "continued employment and service to the Firm in the future and [advisor] compliance with
the Firm's policies (Including the Code of Conduct)." In this regard, you represent that by
conditioning payment on continuous employment and good guardianship, the deferred
compensation awards are designed to motivate advisors to stay with the Firm and to comply with
firm policies that require advisors to act as good stewards of client assets. Accordingly, other
than as described below, financial advisors are generally eligible for payment of the deferred
incentive compensation awards only if they remain continuously employed and in good standing
on the "scheduled vesting date," which occurs after four years (for stock awards) or six years (for
cash awards) of continuous service.

1
  The advisors have individual, notional accounts in the MSCIP, and they can invest their account in notional
investments, with the value of their accounts tracking the performance of the selected investments.


                                                                                                                DOLAR0869


    Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                  Document 80-14             Filed 09/18/26          Page 43 of 82
                                                          2


With certain exceptions, the deferred incentive compensation awards are canceled if a financial
advisor: (1) terminates employment before the scheduled vesting date; or (2) engages in
prohibited activity, such as violating securities rules and regulations, engaging in dishonest or
fraudulent conduct, disclosing privileged or confidential information or trade secrets, making
disparaging or defamatory comments about the Firm before the scheduled award distribution
date, soliciting customers the financial advisor serviced while employed by the Firm for a
competitor without the Firm's consent before the earlier of the three years after termination or
the scheduled award distribution date, taking employment with a competitor within 100 miles
without the Firm's consent before the earlier of one year after termination or the scheduled award
distribution date, or engaging in other conduct that is cause for termination. The awards are not
cancelled if a financial advisor's employment terminates due to: (1) death; (2) disability; (3)
retirement; (4) involuntary termination not involving any prohibited activity; or (5) termination
due to government service not involving any prohibited activity. In these cases, the payment
schedule depends on the exception clause under which the awards are paid. 2 You represent that
payments under these relatively uncommon situations are designed to uphold the awards'
primary purposes of encouraging long-term retention of financial advisors and promoting good
conduct.

Financial advisors do not have the option to extend or delay the distribution date. From 2009-
2019 3 , 89.9% to 95.2% of deferred incentive stock awards issued under EICP were awarded to
current employees (compared to 8.2% for former employees). Similarly, from 2009 to 2017,
85.3% of deferred incentive cash awards issued under the MSCIP were awarded to current
employees (compared to 14.7% for former employees). 4

The award conditions are disclosed annually in the award certificates, summary descriptions and
other communications. These disclosures also clearly state that the deferred incentive
compensation awards are "contingent and unsecured" and that the program is a:


         " ... bonus program and not a retirement plan. Its purposes are to reward and retain key
         employees of the Firm and to align their interests with those of the shareholders.
         Participants should not look to this bonus program as a source of retirement income. This
         bonus program is not subject to the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974." 5


2
  For the exception due to death, the award is paid to a designated beneficiary upon notification to the Firm. For the
exception due to retirement, 50% of the award is paid on the first anniversary after retirement, with the remaining
50% paid on the second anniversary, if the retiree does not engage in specified prohibited activity. For the exception
due to governmental service termination, the award is paid on the date of termination. For the exception due to
disability or involuntary termination by the Firm, the award is paid on the scheduled vesting date (four years for
stock awards and six years for cash awards).
3
  You represent that for stock awards issued under the EICP, the most recent plan year to have vested was the 2019
plan year.
4
  You represent that for cash awards issued under the MSCIP, the most recent plan year to have vested was the 2017
plan year.
5
  See e.g., EICP 2021 Discretionary Retention Awards Stock Unit Summary Description and MSCIP 2021
Discretionary Retention Awards Summary Descriptions.


                                                                                                                    DOLAR0870


    Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                 Document 80-14             Filed 09/18/26          Page 44 of 82
                                                         3


You also state that the awards are structured to meet the expectations of the Firm's financial
regulators regarding the use of deferred compensation to motivate good conduct and penalize
bad conduct. 6

Financial advisors earn the right to award payments only upon satisfying the award conditions,
which require them to remain continuously employed and in good standing through the
scheduled vesting date (four or six years of continuous service after the end of the year for which
the Deferred Credits are granted in the form of deferred stocks and cash awards). On the
scheduled vesting date, the award payments are made automatically, and financial advisors are
not permitted to defer the payments to a later date. If a financial advisor terminates employment
or engages in prohibited activities before vesting, the awards are cancelled, except under limited
circumstances. These conditions are disclosed annually to the financial advisors. These annual
disclosures also expressly state that financial advisors "have no right to ... [the] award until it is
'earned,"' the awards are "contingent upon the [financial advisor] remaining employed through
the grant and vesting dates of the award," the awards are "not intended to provide for retirement
income," and that the program is "not a retirement plan subject to [ERISA]."

The express purposes of the deferred incentive compensation program are to reward financial
advisors for their long-term tenure and incentivize good behaviors desired by the Firm. The
program's design and administration are tailored to achieve those goals and meet the financial
regulatory requirements regarding using deferred compensation to motivate good conduct and
penalize bad conduct. The deferred incentive compensation awards are unsecured and not
guaranteed, there is no accrual (i.e., no partial payouts before the scheduled vesting date) and
financial advisors are notified annually about the express purposes and conditions of the program
and informed that it is not a retirement plan subject to ERISA.


6
  You note that financial regulators, including Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, the Federal Reserve Board of
Governors, the Securities and Exchange Commission, and the office of the Comptroller of the Currency, have issued
and proposed guidance advising regulated entities to defer portions of employee incentive compensation, and to
make that compensation contingent and cancelable, to address risk-taking and other behaviors that may be harmful
to customers and the public markets.


                                                                                                                  DOLAR0871


              Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                  Document 80-14         Filed 09/18/26         Page 45 of 82


From:            Kent A. Mason [kamason@davis-harman.com]
Sent:            8/12/2025 6:42:46 PM
To:              Berger, Eric - EBSA [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
                 (FYDI BO HF 23SPDLT)/ cn=Recip ients/cn=652f46f1f32b4363926e49c4ed696afa-Berger, Eri]
CC:              Turner, Jeffrey - EBSA [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
                 (FYDIBOHF23SPDLT)/cn=Recipients/cn=6f1450e69eb24e6a9cb105d821a7eaf3-Turner, Jef]; Lund, Jack G - EBSA
                 [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
                 (FYDI BO HF 23SPDLT)/ cn=Recip ients/cn=e0df3 7983cc6407 495edcf1634411cf7-63fb24 72-e8]
Subject:         RE: Draft Facts Supporting Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion Request


Thanks very much. We will review this quickly and get back to you.

From: Berger, Eric - EBSA <Berger.Eric@dol.gov>
Sent: Tuesday, August 12, 2025 6:38 PM
To: Kent A. Mason <kamason@davis-harman.com>
Cc: Turner, Jeffrey - EBSA <Turner.Jeffrey@dol.gov>; Lund, Jack G - EBSA <Lund.Jack.G@dol.gov>
Subject: Draft Facts Supporting Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion Request


Dear Mr. Mason:

Attached for your review are draft facts supporting the advisory opinion requested on behalf of Morgan Stanley.

Under Advisory Opinion Procedure 76-1 the parties described in an advisory opinion "may rely on the opinion only to
the extent that the request fully and accurately contains all the material facts and representations necessary to issuance
of the opinion and the situation conforms to the situation described in the request for opinion." Accordingly, as a
routine matter, we ask opinion requesters to review and confirm the facts in support of the opinion. A red line of
changes, if any, would be most helpful. We would appreciate a quick turnaround. We, of course are happy to chat by
phone if you would like.

Thanks,


Eric Berger
Chief, Division of Coverage, Reporting & Disclosure
Office of Regulations and Interpretations
Employee Benefits Security Administration
U.S. Department of Labor


LIMITATIONS ON ADVICE. Any advice in this communication and any attachments: (i) is limited to the conclusions specifically set


                                                                                                                        DOLAR0872


             Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                  Document 80-14              Filed 09/18/26          Page 46 of 82
forth herein and is based on the completeness and accuracy of the stated facts, assumptions and/or representations included
herein; (ii) was prepared for the sole benefit of Davis & Harman LLP's client and may not be relied upon by any other person or
entity; and (iii) is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, by the recipient(s) or any other person or entity, for the
purposes of promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any matters addressed herein.

NOTICE OF CONFIDENTIALITY. The information contained in this message from Davis & Harman LLP and any attachments is
confidential and intended only for the named recipient(s). This message and any attachments may be an attorney-client
communication and as such privileged and confidential. If you have received this message in error, you are prohibited from copying,
distributing or using the information. Please contact the sender immediately by telephone or return e-mail and delete the original
message. We apologize for any inconvenience, and thank you for your prompt attention.


                                                                                                                              DOLAR0873


              Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                  Document 80-14     Filed 09/18/26        Page 47 of 82


From:            Kent A. Mason [kamason@davis-harman.com]
Sent:            8/13/2025 2:13:46 PM
To:              Berger, Eric - EBSA [/o=Exchangelabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
                 (FYDI BO HF 23SPDLT)/ cn=Recip ients/cn=652f46f1f32b4363926e49c4ed696afa-Berger, Eri]
CC:              Turner, Jeffrey - EBSA [/o=Exchangelabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
                 (FYDIBOHF23SPDLT)/cn=Recipients/cn=6f1450e69eb24e6a9cb105d821a7eaf3-Turner, Jef]; Lund, Jack G - EBSA
                 [/o=Exchangelabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
                 (FYDIBOHF23SPDLT)/cn=Recipients/cn=e0df37983cc6407495edcf1634411cf7-63fb2472-e8]; Dhillon, Janet L - EBSA
                 [/o=Exchangelabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
                 (FYDI BO HF 23SPDLT)/ cn=Recip ients/cn=c31 fbd84ce034a5a8ebcad30dde9b06f-ec453f43-32];
                 'Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com' [Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com]; PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com;
                 Mark.Greenfield@morganstanley.com; Chris Gaston [CGaston@davis-harman.com]
Subject:         RE: Draft Facts Supporting Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion Request
Attachments:     AO facts (00577832) (003).docx


Thanks for sending us the draft facts to review. The draft looks great. We suggest minor clarifications in the
attached for your consideration. We so appreciate all the work on this matter.


From: Berger, Eric - EBSA <Berger.Eric@dol.gov>
Sent: Tuesday, August 12, 2025 6:38 PM
To: Kent A. Mason <kamason@davis-harman.com>
Cc: Turner, Jeffrey - EBSA <Turner.Jeffrey@dol.gov>; Lund, Jack G - EBSA <Lund.Jack.G@dol.gov>
Subject: Draft Facts Supporting Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion Request


Dear Mr. Mason:

Attached for your review are draft facts supporting the advisory opinion requested on behalf of Morgan Stanley.

Under Advisory Opinion Procedure 76-1 the parties described in an advisory opinion "may rely on the opinion only to
the extent that the request fully and accurately contains all the material facts and representations necessary to issuance
of the opinion and the situation conforms to the situation described in the request for opinion." Accordingly, as a
routine matter, we ask opinion requesters to review and confirm the facts in support of the opinion. A red line of
changes, if any, would be most helpful. We would appreciate a quick turnaround. We, of course are happy to chat by
phone if you would like.

Thanks,

Eric Berger
Chief, Division of Coverage, Reporting & Disclosure
Office of Regulations and Interpretations


                                                                                                                 DOLAR0874


             Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                  Document 80-14              Filed 09/18/26          Page 48 of 82
Employee Benefits Security Administration
U.S. Department of Labor


LIMITATIONS ON ADVICE. Any advice in this communication and any attachments: (i) is limited to the conclusions specifically set
forth herein and is based on the completeness and accuracy of the stated facts, assumptions and/or representations included
herein; (ii) was prepared for the sole benefit of Davis & Harman LLP's client and may not be relied upon by any other person or
entity; and (iii) is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, by the recipient(s) or any other person or entity, for the
purposes of promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any matters addressed herein.

NOTICE OF CONFIDENTIALITY. The information contained in this message from Davis & Harman LLP and any attachments is
confidential and intended only for the named recipient(s). This message and any attachments may be an attorney-client
communication and as such privileged and confidential. If you have received this message in error, you are prohibited from copying,
distributing or using the information. Please contact the sender immediately by telephone or return e-mail and delete the original
message. We apologize for any inconvenience, and thank you for your prompt attention.


                                                                                                                              DOLAR0875


    Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                 Document 80-14             Filed 09/18/26          Page 49 of 82
Draft 8.12.25


                          Draft Supporting Representations (Case No. A01533)


The following summary is based on the u , .. ...,,,u... and representations provided in support of the
                                                         <.,


request and should not be treated as factual findings by the Department.

You represent that the Firm's financial advisors receive a guaranteed base salary and are eligible
to earn cash incentive compensation which is paid throughout the year. In addition, financial
advisors are eligible to earn deferred incentive compensation, with twenty-five percent issued as
an unsecured deferred stock award under the EICP and the remaining seventy-five percent as an
unsecured deferred cash-based award under the MSCIP. 1 The deferred stock units are converted
to shares of Morgan Stanley common stock and deposited into a brokerage account, while cash-
based awards are deposited into the financial advisors' payroll accounts, on the "scheduled
vesting date" only when all conditions are met, as described below.

All incentive compensation is calculated based on "Total Credits". The financial advisor's Total
Credits for each month are determined by the applicable "Credit Rate" multiplied by the
creditable revenue generated by the financial advisor. The Credit Rate is a percentage between
28% and 55.5% that increases with the financial advisor's revenue and length of service with the
Firm. A portion of the Total Credits is allocated to "Deferred Credits" (between 1.5% and 15 j_%
of the financial advisor's total incentive compensation), based on the level ofrevenue the
financial advisor generates.

The cumulative value of the monthly Deferred Credits for the year is granted to the financial
advisor in the form of deferred incentive compensation (deferred stock and cash awards) shortly
after the year-end. Deferred incentive compensation awards are generally contingent, among
other things, upon the advisor remaining continuously employed through the grant and vesting
dates. Accordingly, if the financial advisor terminates employment during the year, there is no
award of the Deferred Credits granted for that year. The rest (between 84.5% and 98.5%) of the
Total Credits are allocated to "Cash Credits", which are used to calculate and pay cash incentive
compensation monthly.

Both cash and deferred incentive compensation reward good performance by calculating the
amount, in part, based on a financial advisor's generation ofrevenue for the Firm. Deferred
incentive compensation, however, serves additional purposes: to reward financial advisors for
their "continued employment and service to the Firm in the future and [advisor] compliance with
the Firm's policies (Including the Code of Conduct)." In this regard, you represent that by
conditioning payment on continuous employment and good guardianship, the deferred
compensation awards are designed to motivate advisors to stay with the Firm and to comply with
firm policies that require advisors to act as good stewards of client assets. Accordingly, other
than as described below, financial advisors are generally eligible for payment of the deferred
incentive compensation awards only if they remain continuously employed and in good standing

1
  The advisors have individual, notional accounts in the MSCIP, and they can invest their account~ in notional
investments, with the value of their accounts tracking the performance of the selected investments.


                                                                                                                 DOLAR0876


    Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                  Document 80-14             Filed 09/18/26          Page 50 of 82
                                                          2


on the "scheduled vesting date," which occurs after four years (for stock awards) or six years (for
cash awards) of continuous service.

With certain exceptions, the deferred incentive compensation awards are canceled if a financial
advisor: (1) terminates employment before the scheduled vesting date; or (2) engages in
prohibited activity, such as violating securities rules and regulations, engaging in dishonest or
fraudulent conduct, disclosing privileged or confidential information or trade secrets, making
disparaging or defamatory comments about the Firm before the scheduled award distribution
date, soliciting customers the financial advisor serviced while employed by the Firm for a
competitor without the Firm's consent before the earlier of the three years after termination or
the scheduled award distribution date, taking employment with a competitor within 100 miles
without the Firm's consent before the earlier of one year after termination or the scheduled award
distribution date, or engaging in other conduct that is cause for termination. The awards are not
cancelled if a financial advisor's employment terminates due to: (1) death; (2) disability; (3)
retirement; (4) involuntary termination not involving any prohibited activity; or (5) termination
due to government service not involving any prohibited activity. In these cases, the payment
schedule depends on the exception clause under which the awards are paid. 2 You represent that
payments under these relatively uncommon situations are designed to uphold the awards'
primary purposes of encouraging long-term retention of financial advisors and promoting good
conduct.

Financial advisors do not have the option to extend or delay the distribution date. From 2009-
2019 3 , 89.9% to 95.2% of deferred incentive stock awards issued under EICP were awa-Fa-oo
distributed to current employees (compared to 8.2% for former employees). Similarly, from 2009
to 2017, 80.1 % to 92.6% of cash distributions were ultimately paid to current employees; in the
(:!ggr:~ ate over that period current employees were paid 85.3% of deferred incentive cash awards
issued under the MSCIP wero--awa-Faee--te-&UFFffit-em13-l-o-yees-{compared to 14. 7% for former
employees). 4

The award conditions are disclosed annually in the award certificates, summary descriptions and
other communications. These disclosures also clearly state that the deferred incentive
compensation awards are "contingent and unsecured" and that the program is a:


         " ... bonus program and not a retirement plan. Its purposes are to reward and retain key
         employees of the Firm and to align their interests with those of the shareholders.


2
  For the exception due to death, the award is paid to a designated beneficiary upon notification to the Firm. For the
exception due to retirement, 50% of the award is paid on the first anniversary after retirement, with the remaining
50% paid on the second anniversary, if the retiree does not engage in specified prohibited activity. For the exception
due to governmental service termination, the award is paid on the date of termination. For the exception due to
disability or involuntary termination by the Firm, the award is paid on the scheduled vesting date (four years for
stock awards and six years for cash awards).
3
  You represent that for stock awards issued under the EICP, the most recent plan year to have vested (as of Au 6ust
20242 was the 2019 plan year.
4
  You represent that for cash awards issued under the MSCIP, the most recent plan year to have vested (as of August
2024) was the 2017 plan year.


                                                                                                                    DOLAR0877


    Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                    Document 80-14              Filed 09/18/26           Page 51 of 82
                                                             3


         Participants should not look to this bonus program as a source of retirement income. This
         bonus program is not subject to the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974." 5

You also state that the awards are structured to meet the expectations of the Firm's financial
regulators regarding the use of deferred compensation to motivate good conduct and penalize
bad conduct. 6

Financial advisors earn the right to award payments only upon satisfying the award conditions,
which require them to remain continuously employed and in good standing through the
scheduled vesting date (four or six years of continuous service after the end of tho year for which
the--Q.efer-ree---G-red-its--a-Fc-g-ra-nted---i-R-the--fo-rm-e-fd-eforred--stesks---a-ne---sash--awa-Fd-sa ward is g anted).
On the scheduled vesting date, the award payments are made automatically, and financial
advisors are not permitted to defer the payments to a later date. If a financial advisor terminates
employment or engages in prohibited activities before vesting, the awards are cancelled, except
under limited circumstances. These conditions are disclosed annually to the financial advisors.
These annual disclosures also expressly state that financial advisors "have no right to ... [the]
award until it is 'earned,"' the awards are "contingent upon the [financial advisor] remaining
employed through the grant and vesting dates of the award," the awards are "not intended to
provide for retirement income," and that the program is "not a retirement plan subject to
[ERISA]."

The express purposes of the deferred incentive compensation program are to reward financial
advisors for their long-term tenure and incentivize good behaviors desired by the Firm. The
program's design and administration are tailored to achieve those goals and meet the financial
regulatory requirements regarding using deferred compensation to motivate good conduct and
penalize bad conduct. The deferred incentive compensation awards are unsecured and not
guaranteed, there is no accrual (i.e., no partial payouts before the scheduled vesting date) and
financial advisors are notified annually about the express purposes and conditions of the program
and informed that it is not a retirement plan subject to ERISA.


5
  See e.g., EICP 2021 Discretionary Retention Awards Stock Unit Summary Description and MSCIP 2021
Discretionary Retention Awards Summary Descriptions. Per our submission. the exact lan 6ua 6c in the description
of this pro 6ram has chan 6cd over the cars but the substance of the pro 6ram has not chanbc..<cL
6
  You note that financial regulators, including Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, the Federal Reserve Board of
Governors, the Securities and Exchange Commission, and the office of the Comptroller of the Currency, have issued
~-guidance advising and proposed rqulations re 1uirin 6 regulated entities to defer portions of employee
incentive compensation, and to make that compensation contingent and cancelable, to address risk-taking and other
behaviors that may be harmful to customers and the public markets.


                                                                                                                         DOLAR0878


           Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG               Document 80-14          Filed 09/18/26         Page 52 of 82


From:       Kent A. Mason [kamason@davis-harman.com]
 ent:       8/13/2025 2:13:46 PM
 o:         Berger, Eric - EBSA [/o=Exchangelabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
            (FYDI BO HF23SPDLT)/ cn=Recip ients/cn=652f46f1f32b4363926e49c4ed696afa-
            Berger, Eri]
            Turner, Jeffrey - EBSA [/o=Exchangelabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
            (FYDI BO HF23SPDLT)/ cn=Recip ients/cn=6f1450e69eb24e6a9cb 105d821a 7 eaf3-
            Turner, Jef]; Lund, Jack G - EBSA [/o=Exchangelabs/ou=Exchange
            Administrative Group
            (FYDI BO HF23SPDLT)/ cn=Recip ients/cn=e0df3 7983cc6407 495edcf1634411cf7-    You don't often get email from
            63fb2472-e8]; Dhillon, Janet L - EBSA [/o=Exchangelabs/ou=Exchange            kamason@davis-harman.com.
            Administrative Group
            (FYDI BO HF23SPDLT)/ cn=Recip ients/cn=c31 fbd84ce034a5a8ebcad30dde9b06f-
            ec453f43-32]; 'Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com'
            [Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com]; PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com;
            Mark.Greenfield@morganstanley.com; Chris Gaston [CGaston@davis-
            harman.com]
 ubject:    RE: Draft Facts Supporting Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion Request
 ttachments:AO facts (00577832) (003 ).docx


Thanks for sending us the draft facts to review. The draft looks great. We suggest minor clarifications in the
attached for your consideration. We so appreciate all the work on this matter.


From: Berger, Eric - EBSA <Berger.Eric@dol.gov>
Sent: Tuesday, August 12, 2025 6:38 PM
To: Kent A. Mason <kamason@davis-harman.com>
Cc: Turner, Jeffrey - EBSA <Turner.Jeffrey@dol.gov>; Lund, Jack G - EBSA <Lund.Jack.G@dol.gov>
Subject: Draft Facts Supporting Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion Request


Dear Mr. Mason:

Attached for your review are draft facts supporting the advisory opinion requested on behalf of Morgan Stanley.

Under Advisory Opinion Procedure 76-1 the parties described in an advisory opinion "may rely on the opinion only to
the extent that the request fully and accurately contains all the material facts and representations necessary to issuance
of the opinion and the situation conforms to the situation described in the request for opinion." Accordingly, as a
routine matter, we ask opinion requesters to review and confirm the facts in support of the opinion. A red line of


                                                                                                                   DOLAR0879


              Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                  Document 80-14             Filed 09/18/26          Page 53 of 82
changes, if any, would be most helpful. We would appreciate a quick turnaround. We, of course are happy to chat by
phone if you would like.


Thanks,


Eric Berger
Chief, Division of Coverage, Reporting & Disclosure
Office of Regulations and Interpretations
Employee Benefits Security Administration
U.S. Department of Labor


LIMITATIONS ON ADVICE. Any advice in this communication and any attachments: (i) is limited to the conclusions specifically set
forth herein and is based on the completeness and accuracy of the stated facts, assumptions and/or representations included
herein; (ii) was prepared for the sole benefit of Davis & Harman LLP's client and may not be relied upon by any other person or
entity; and (iii) is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, by the recipient(s) or any other person or entity, for the
purposes of promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any matters addressed herein.

NOTICE OF CONFIDENTIALITY. The information contained in this message from Davis & Harman LLP and any attachments is
confidential and intended only for the named recipient(s). This message and any attachments may be an attorney-client
communication and as such privileged and confidential. If you have received this message in error, you are prohibited from copying,
distributing or using the information. Please contact the sender immediately by telephone or return e-mail and delete the original
message. We apologize for any inconvenience, and thank you for your prompt attention.


                                                                                                                              DOLAR0880


    Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                  Document 80-14             Filed 09/18/26         Page 54 of 82
Draft 8.12.25


                          Draft Supporting Representations (Case No. A01533)


The following summary is based on the u , .. ...,,,u... and representations provided in support of the
                                                          <.,


request and should not be treated as factual findings by the Department.

You represent that the Firm's financial advisors receive a guaranteed base salary and are eligible
to earn cash incentive compensation which is paid throughout the year. In addition, financial
advisors are eligible to earn deferred incentive compensation, with twenty-five percent issued as
an unsecured deferred stock award under the EICP and the remaining seventy-five percent as an
unsecured deferred cash-based award under the MSCIP. 1 The deferred stock units are converted
to shares of Morgan Stanley common stock and deposited into a brokerage account, while cash-
based awards are deposited into the financial advisors' payroll accounts, on the "scheduled
vesting date" only when all conditions are met, as described below.

All incentive compensation is calculated based on "Total Credits". The financial advisor's Total
Credits for each month are determined by the applicable "Credit Rate" multiplied by the
creditable revenue generated by the financial advisor. The Credit Rate is a percentage between
28% and 55.5% that increases with the financial advisor's revenue and length of service with the
Firm. A portion of the Total Credits is allocated to "Deferred Credits" (between 1.5% and 15,:;i¾
of the financial advisor's total incentive compensation), based on the level ofrevenue the
financial advisor generates.

The cumulative value of the monthly Deferred Credits for the year is granted to the financial
advisor in the form of deferred incentive compensation (deferred stock and cash awards) shortly
after the year-end. Deferred incentive compensation awards are generally contingent, among
other things, upon the advisor remaining continuously employed through the grant and vesting
dates. Accordingly, if the financial advisor terminates employment during the year, there is no
award of the Deferred Credits granted for that year. The rest (between 84.5% and 98.5%) of the
Total Credits are allocated to "Cash Credits", which are used to calculate and pay cash incentive
compensation monthly.

Both cash and deferred incentive compensation reward good performance by calculating the
amount, in part, based on a financial advisor's generation ofrevenue for the Firm. Deferred
incentive compensation, however, serves additional purposes: to reward financial advisors for
their "continued employment and service to the Firm in the future and [advisor] compliance with
the Firm's policies (Including the Code of Conduct)." In this regard, you represent that by
conditioning payment on continuous employment and good guardianship, the deferred
compensation awards are designed to motivate advisors to stay with the Firm and to comply with
firm policies that require advisors to act as good stewards of client assets. Accordingly, other
than as described below, financial advisors are generally eligible for payment of the deferred
incentive compensation awards only if they remain continuously employed and in good standing

1
  The advisors have individual, notional accounts in the MSCIP, and they can invest their account'! in notional
investments, with the value of their accounts tracking the performance of the selected investments.


                                                                                                                  DOLAR0881


    Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                  Document 80-14             Filed 09/18/26          Page 55 of 82
                                                          2


on the "scheduled vesting date," which occurs after four years (for stock awards) or six years (for
cash awards) of continuous service.

With certain exceptions, the deferred incentive compensation awards are canceled if a financial
advisor: (1) terminates employment before the scheduled vesting date; or (2) engages in
prohibited activity, such as violating securities rules and regulations, engaging in dishonest or
fraudulent conduct, disclosing privileged or confidential information or trade secrets, making
disparaging or defamatory comments about the Firm before the scheduled award distribution
date, soliciting customers the financial advisor serviced while employed by the Firm for a
competitor without the Firm's consent before the earlier of the three years after termination or
the scheduled award distribution date, taking employment with a competitor within 100 miles
without the Firm's consent before the earlier of one year after termination or the scheduled award
distribution date, or engaging in other conduct that is cause for termination. The awards are not
cancelled if a financial advisor's employment terminates due to: (1) death; (2) disability; (3)
retirement; (4) involuntary termination not involving any prohibited activity; or (5) termination
due to government service not involving any prohibited activity. In these cases, the payment
schedule depends on the exception clause under which the awards are paid. 2 You represent that
payments under these relatively uncommon situations are designed to uphold the awards'
primary purposes of encouraging long-term retention of financial advisors and promoting good
conduct.

Financial advisors do not have the option to extend or delay the distribution date. From 2009-
2019 3 , 89.9% to 95.2% of deferred incentive stock awards issued under EICP were awaFded
distributed to current employees (compared to 8.2% for former employees). Similarly, from 2009
to 2017, 80. I% to 92.6°/ii of cash distributions were ultimately paid to current emr lo) ees; in the
13,ggregate over that period current emr loyecs were paid 85.3% of deferred incentive cash awards
issued under the MSCIP wernawaFde010€1±rrOHtemp1eyoes-(compared to 14.7% for former
employees). 4

The award conditions are disclosed annually in the award certificates, summary descriptions and
other communications. These disclosures also clearly state that the deferred incentive
compensation awards are "contingent and unsecured" and that the program is a:


         " ... bonus program and not a retirement plan. Its purposes are to reward and retain key
         employees of the Firm and to align their interests with those of the shareholders.


2
  For the exception due to death, the award is paid to a designated beneficiary upon notification to the Firm. For the
exception due to retirement, 50% of the award is paid on the first anniversary after retirement, with the remaining
50% paid on the second anniversary, if the retiree does not engage in specified prohibited activity. For the exception
due to governmental service termination, the award is paid on the date of termination. For the exception due to
disability or involuntary termination by the Firm, the award is paid on the scheduled vesting date (four years for
stock awards and six years for cash awards).
3
  You represent that for stock awards issued under the EICP, the most recent plan year to have vested (as of August
2024} was the 2019 plan year.
4
  You represent that for cash awards issued under the MSCIP, the most recent plan year to have vested (as of Au,rnst
2024) was the 2017 plan year.


                                                                                                                    DOLAR0882


    Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                 Document 80-14             Filed 09/18/26          Page 56 of 82
                                                         3


         Participants should not look to this bonus program as a source of retirement income. This
         bonus program is not subject to the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974." 5

You also state that the awards are structured to meet the expectations of the Firm's financial
regulators regarding the use of deferred compensation to motivate good conduct and penalize
bad conduct. 6

Financial advisors earn the right to award payments only upon satisfying the award conditions,
which require them to remain continuously employed and in good standing through the
scheduled vesting date (four or six years of continuous service after the ooe-ef.tlt0-j'08-f-fef--wlH-elt
t-i:1-eQof-err-ea <;;roe its-amgra-Atea i-Rtlrnfen-R-e-~a-ef-erroe stBBk--s-ane t,ash-aw-ara-s-a Ward iS -, an tcd).
On the scheduled vesting date, the award payments are made automatically, and financial
advisors are not permitted to defer the payments to a later date. If a financial advisor terminates
employment or engages in prohibited activities before vesting, the awards are cancelled, except
under limited circumstances. These conditions are disclosed annually to the financial advisors.
These annual disclosures also expressly state that financial advisors "have no right to ... [the]
award until it is 'earned,"' the awards are "contingent upon the [financial advisor] remaining
employed through the grant and vesting dates of the award," the awards are "not intended to
provide for retirement income," and that the program is "not a retirement plan subject to
[ERISA]."

The express purposes of the deferred incentive compensation program are to reward financial
advisors for their long-term tenure and incentivize good behaviors desired by the Firm. The
program's design and administration are tailored to achieve those goals and meet the financial
regulatory requirements regarding using deferred compensation to motivate good conduct and
penalize bad conduct. The deferred incentive compensation awards are unsecured and not
guaranteed, there is no accrual (i.e., no partial payouts before the scheduled vesting date) and
financial advisors are notified annually about the express purposes and conditions of the program
and informed that it is not a retirement plan subject to ERISA.


5
  See e.g., EICP 2021 Discretionary Retention Awards Stock Unit Summary Description and MSCIP 2021
Discretionary Retention Awards Summary Descriptions. Per our submit>t>ion. the exact lan,wa;.c in the dc~cription
of this pro.Iram has chan.Icd over the cars. but the ~ub~tancc of the pro;.ram has not chan.Icd.
6
  You note that financial regulators, including Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, the Federal Reserve Board of
Governors, the Securities and Exchange Commission, and the office of the Comptroller of the Currency, have issued
arulfffif!e-soo--guidance advising and proposed rqulatiom, rcguirinb regulated entities to defer portions of employee
incentive compensation, and to make that compensation contingent and cancelable, to address risk-taking and other
behaviors that may be harmful to customers and the public markets.


                                                                                                                  DOLAR0883


            Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                Document 80-14       Filed 09/18/26       Page 57 of 82


From:          Berger, Eric - EBSA [/O=EXCHANGELABS/OU=EXCHANGE ADMINISTRATIVE GROUP
               (FYDI BO HF 23SPDLT)/CN =RE Cl Pl ENTS/CN =652F46F 1F32 B4363926E49C4E D696AFA-BE RG ER, ERi]
Sent:          8/18/2025 3:11:00 PM
To:            Kent A. Mason [kamason@davis-harman.com]
CC:            Turner, Jeffrey - EBSA [/o=Exchangelabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
               (FYDIBOHF23SPDLT)/cn=Recipients/cn=6f1450e69eb24e6a9cb105d821a7eaf3-Turner, Jef]; Lund, Jack G - EBSA
               [/o=Exchangelabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
               (FYDI BO HF 23SPDLT)/ cn=Recip ients/cn=e0df3 7983cc6407 495edcf1634411cf7-63fb24 72-e8];
               'Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com' [Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com]; PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com;
               Mark.Greenfield@morganstanley.com; Chris Gaston [CGaston@davis-harman.com]
Subject:       RE: Draft Facts Supporting Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion Request


Thanks so much to you and the Morgan Stanley people for the fast response. Can we have a very short call to clarify one
factual issue?

Eric


From: Kent A. Mason <kamason@davis-harman.com>
Sent: Wednesday, August 13, 2025 2:14 PM
To: Berger, Eric - EBSA <Berger.Eric@dol.gov>
Cc: Turner, Jeffrey - EBSA <Turner.Jeffrey@dol.gov>; Lund, Jack G - EBSA <Lund.Jack.G@dol.gov>; Dhillon, Janet L - EBSA
<Dhillon.Janet.L@dol.gov>; 'Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com' <Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com>;
PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com; Mark.Greenfield@morganstanley.com; Chris Gaston <CGaston@davis-harman.com>
Subject: RE: Draft Facts Supporting Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion Request


Thanks for sending us the draft facts to review. The draft looks great. We suggest minor clarifications in the
attached for your consideration. We so appreciate all the work on this matter.


From: Berger, Eric - EBSA <~~sger.Eric@_c!_Q1_g_~y_>
Sent: Tuesday, August 12, 2025 6:38 PM
To: Kent A. Mason <karnason@davis-harman.com>
Cc: Turner, Jeffrey - EBSA <Turner.Jeffrey@dol.gov>; Lund, Jack G - EBSA <Lund.Jack.G@dol.gov>
Subject: Draft Facts Supporting Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion Request


                                                                                                               DOLAR0884


              Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                  Document 80-14             Filed 09/18/26          Page 58 of 82
Dear Mr. Mason:


Attached for your review are draft facts supporting the advisory opinion requested on behalf of Morgan Stanley.


Under Advisory Opinion Procedure 76-1 the parties described in an advisory opinion "may rely on the opinion only to
the extent that the request fully and accurately contains all the material facts and representations necessary to issuance
of the opinion and the situation conforms to the situation described in the request for opinion." Accordingly, as a
routine matter, we ask opinion requesters to review and confirm the facts in support of the opinion. A red line of
changes, if any, would be most helpful. We would appreciate a quick turnaround. We, of course are happy to chat by
phone if you would like.


Thanks,


Eric Berger
Chief, Division of Coverage, Reporting & Disclosure
Office of Regulations and Interpretations
Employee Benefits Security Administration
U.S. Department of Labor


LIMITATIONS ON ADVICE. Any advice in this communication and any attachments: (i) is limited to the conclusions specifically set
forth herein and is based on the completeness and accuracy of the stated facts, assumptions and/or representations included
herein; (ii) was prepared for the sole benefit of Davis & Harman LLP's client and may not be relied upon by any other person or
entity; and (iii) is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, by the recipient(s) or any other person or entity, for the
purposes of promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any matters addressed herein.

NOTICE OF CONFIDENTIALITY. The information contained in this message from Davis & Harman LLP and any attachments is
confidential and intended only for the named recipient(s). This message and any attachments may be an attorney-client
communication and as such privileged and confidential. If you have received this message in error, you are prohibited from copying,
distributing or using the information. Please contact the sender immediately by telephone or return e-mail and delete the original
message. We apologize for any inconvenience, and thank you for your prompt attention.


                                                                                                                              DOLAR0885


            Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG              Document 80-14           Filed 09/18/26        Page 59 of 82


From:         Kent A. Mason [kamason@davis-harman.com]
Sent:         8/18/2025 3:34:18 PM
To:           Berger, Eric - EBSA [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
              (FYDI BO HF 23SPDLT)/ cn=Recip ients/cn=652f46f1f32b4363926e49c4ed696afa-Berger, Eri]
CC:           Turner, Jeffrey - EBSA [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
              (FYDIBOHF23SPDLT)/cn=Recipients/cn=6f1450e69eb24e6a9cb105d821a7eaf3-Turner, Jef]; Lund, Jack G - EBSA
              [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
              (FYDI BO HF 23SPDLT)/ cn=Recip ients/cn=e0df3 7983cc6407 495edcf1634411cf7-63fb24 72-e8];
              'Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com' [Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com]; PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com;
              Mark.Greenfield@morganstanley.com; Chris Gaston [CGaston@davis-harman.com]
Subject:      RE: Draft Facts Supporting Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion Request


Of course. Do you want to send us some times that work for the DOL team? We will do what we can to adjust
our schedule to yours. Thanks very much.


From: Berger, Eric - EBSA <Berger.Eric@dol.gov>
Sent: Monday, August 18, 2025 3:11 PM
To: Kent A. Mason <kamason@davis-harman.com>
Cc: Turner, Jeffrey - EBSA <Turner.Jeffrey@dol.gov>; Lund, Jack G - EBSA <Lund.Jack.G@dol.gov>;
'Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com' <Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com>; PJ.Austin@morganstanley.com;
Mark.Greenfield@morganstanley.com; Chris Gaston <CGaston@davis-harman.com>
Subject: RE: Draft Facts Supporting Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion Request

Thanks so much to you and the Morgan Stanley people for the fast response. Can we have a very short call to clarify one
factual issue?

Eric


From: Kent A. Mason <karnason davis--harrnan.corn>
Sent: Wednesday, August 13, 2025 2:14 PM
To: Berger, Eric - EBSA <i?~Jger.Eric(cvdol.go_y_>
Cc: Turner, Jeffrey - EBSA <Turner.Jeffrey@dgl,g_Qy_>; Lund, Jack G - EBSA <Lund.Jack.Ga dol.go_y_>; Dhillon, Janet L - EBSA
<Dhillon.Janet.L@dol:RQ_y_>; 'Michael.Stein@morganstanley.com' <Michael.Stein@rnorganstanley.com>;
PJ.Austin@rnorganstanley.com; Mark.Greenfield@rnorganstanley.com; Chris Gaston <CGaston@davis-harrnan.com>
Subject: RE: Draft Facts Supporting Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion Request


                                                                                                                  DOLAR0886


              Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                  Document 80-14             Filed 09/18/26          Page 60 of 82


Thanks for sending us the draft facts to review. The draft looks great. We suggest minor clarifications in the
attached for your consideration. We so appreciate all the work on this matter.


From: Berger, Eric - EBSA <~.!?Jger.Eric(@dol.gq_y_>
Sent: Tuesday, August 12, 2025 6:38 PM
To: Kent A. Mason <karnason wdavis-harrnan.corn>
Cc: Turner, Jeffrey - EBSA <Turner.Jeffrey@ dol.gov>; Lund, Jack G - EBSA <Lund.Jack.G@dol.gov>
Subject: Draft Facts Supporting Morgan Stanley Advisory Opinion Request


Dear Mr. Mason:

Attached for your review are draft facts supporting the advisory opinion requested on behalf of Morgan Stanley.

Under Advisory Opinion Procedure 76-1 the parties described in an advisory opinion "may rely on the opinion only to
the extent that the request fully and accurately contains all the material facts and representations necessary to issuance
of the opinion and the situation conforms to the situation described in the request for opinion." Accordingly, as a
routine matter, we ask opinion requesters to review and confirm the facts in support of the opinion. A red line of
changes, if any, would be most helpful. We would appreciate a quick turnaround. We, of course are happy to chat by
phone if you would like.

Thanks,


Eric Berger
Chief, Division of Coverage, Reporting & Disclosure
Office of Regulations and Interpretations
Employee Benefits Security Administration
U.S. Department of Labor


LIMITATIONS ON ADVICE. Any advice in this communication and any attachments: (i) is limited to the conclusions specifically set
forth herein and is based on the completeness and accuracy of the stated facts, assumptions and/or representations included
herein; (ii) was prepared for the sole benefit of Davis & Harman LLP's client and may not be relied upon by any other person or
entity; and (iii) is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, by the recipient(s) or any other person or entity, for the
purposes of promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any matters addressed herein.

NOTICE OF CONFIDENTIALITY. The information contained in this message from Davis & Harman LLP and any attachments is
confidential and intended only for the named recipient(s). This message and any attachments may be an attorney-client
communication and as such privileged and confidential. If you have received this message in error, you are prohibited from copying,
distributing or using the information. Please contact the sender immediately by telephone or return e-mail and delete the original
message. We apologize for any inconvenience, and thank you for your prompt attention.


                                              

Showing the first 150,000 of 205,801 characters. Full text.