jain.com
Public record. We host this document directly; the copy served here does not depend on any third party. Retrieved November 15, 2026.
Read the documentAlso at archive.org ↗

Compass, Inc. v. Zillow, Inc. — Entry #194: SUPPLEMENTAL AMICUS CURIAE OF GREGORY V

Case: Compass, Inc. v. Zillow, Inc. nysd · 1:25-cv-05201

filed June 23, 2025

What this document is

Docket entry #194 · filed April 20, 2026

SUPPLEMENTAL AMICUS CURIAE OF GREGORY V. ALKEMA, PRO SE, IN SUPPORT OF REOPENING THE CASE UNDER FRCP 60(b) FOR FRAUD ON THE COURT AND NEWLY DISCOVERED EVIDENCE. (jjc) (Entered: 04/22/2026)

Who is involved

Why we have it

We follow this case because it names a company we track, although that company is not a party:

A free copy from the RECAP archive of federal court filings (mirrored at the Internet Archive), retrieved November 15, 2026. Federal court filings are public records.

URL
https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.nysd.644627/gov.uscourts.nysd.644627.194.0.pdf
Kind
court_filing
Publisher
RECAP
Published
2026-04-20 00:00:00-04:00
Retrieved
2026-11-15 07:41:58.805468-05:00
HTTP status
200
MIME
application/pdf
Bytes
666457
SHA-256
95a8dc21ed539f41edb0bafc366198e769b93b6e98a63206675ed8965e99f8e6

Document text

7 page(s), 10,182 characters, read from page images by OCR, so expect some character errors · plain text.

Full text
PA at SARS ORLA »~ aa Ss eens Sot A Pe Pe ~~ x Fa
as TAA S ~ ; ee ns | Senedd EN A PSUIN IO RS re ~ TN
Bea ke ake RA NN Neneh Rat OD Ra APMP EER TR wd PORERS LA A Ce fle? g Calg ade NE

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURTSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
| In Pro Per, White Plains Division

COMPASS, INC.,
Plaintiff,

V.

ZILLOW, INC., et al,

Defendants. Case No. 1:25-cv-05201-JAV-SDA

SUPPLEMENTAL AMICUS CURIAE OF GREGORY V. ALKEMA, PRO SE, IN SUPPORT OF
REOPENING THE CASE UNDER FRCP 60(b) FOR FRAUD ON THE COURT AND NEWLY
DISCOVERED EVIDENCE

Submitted by:

Gregory V. Alkema, Pro Se
REALTOR®, CRB

California DRE #01915968
81 Hancock Drive
Roseville, CA 95678
Telephone: (916) 626-9464 ay
Email: Greg@GregAlkema.com Date: April 13, 2026 = =

l-INTRODUCTION

|, Gregory V. Alkema, appearing pro se, respectfully submit this Supplemental Amicus
Curiae to request that the Court reopen this case under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure
60(b)(3) (fraud, misrepresentation, or misconduct) and the Court’s inherent authority to
address fraud on the court.

The record now shows a clear contradiction: Defendant Zillow argued in this Court that off-
MLS and pre-market practices harm consumers and transparency. Immediately after the
preliminary injunction was denied — and after my Amicus Curiae evidence of massive
seller harm was filed — Zillow launched the very product it had opposed. Zitlow’s own
Chiet Operating Officer later admitted the idea had been in development for approximately
two years.


oss,

This is not speculation. It is supported by court dates, public announcements, and Zillow’s
own words. The voluntary dismissal should not shield this conduct from judicial review.

ll. UNDISPUTED TIMELINE

e June 23, 2025: Compass files the antitrust complaint. Zillow defends its Listing
Access Standards as necessary to protect buyers and transparency.

e November 2025: Preliminary injunction hearing. Zillow argues against off-MLS /
delayed-visibility practices.

e February 6, 2026: This Court denies the preliminary injunction.

e March 17, 2026: Zillow launches Zillow Preview, a pre-marketing product providing
early visibility.

« March 18, 2026: Compass voluntarily dismisses the lawsuit.

e April11, 2026: Zillow COO Jun Choo states publicly that the Preview concept had
been under development since Zillow Showcase “two years ago” and that Zillow
“needed a version” of a pre-marketing product.

fll-“PRE-MARKETING” IS A FRAUDULENT TERM AND BREACH OF FIDUCIARY DUTY

“Pre-marketing” is a misleading and fraudulent term. True marketing means exposing the
property to the whole market — the broadest possible audience through full MLS listing
from Day One — to achieve the highest and best price via open competition.

Any deliberate restriction of visibility (whether called Preview, Coming Soon, Private
Reserve, or 3-Phase) without a clear, prominent, data-backed written warning to the seller
is sandbagging and a breach of fiduciary duty.

The San Francisco Association of REALTORS® / RealReports study shows that off-MLS or
restricted-visibility sales cause sellers an average loss of $302,000 (18.6% equity reduction
on $1.4 million homes), with heavy impact on seniors.

In California, this systematic practice constitutes elder financial exploitation under Welfare
& Institutions Code 815610.30, carrying treble damages and, in many cases, no statute of
limitations.

IV. ZILLOW’S CONDUCT CONSTITUTES FRAUD ON THE COURT

Zillow took one position before this Court while the case was active. After the injunction
was denied and after my Amicus evidence was filed, Zillow immediately implemented the


A E, APNEA A OS AA ET MESA ~ aN A ers Sot ete oe -_ ~ :
Case P:?5-cy-O5207-JAV-SDA Macmeant 104 ifm? AIO ALS Dana 2 ot
we CRE be de UP LLP, LALLEP EE ER ee PUREED Ui OU gk Prehuts 2

opposite practice. Its COO’s admission confirms this was not a sudden reactive change
but a planned initiative withheld or downplayed during litigation.

This prevented a full merits determination and deprived the Court and the public of
material facts. The voluntary dismissal shoutd not prevent the Court from addressing this
inconsistency.

V. REQUESTED RELIEF
The Court should:
1. Reopen this case under FRCP 60(b).
2. Allow supplemental briefing on the new evidence and admissions.

3. Inits discretion, make findings on the apparent fraud or inconsistency, or refer
related issues (including patterns of elder financial exploitation) to appropriate
authorities.

4. Grant any other relief the Court deems just.

Respectfully submitted,
Q

/s/ Gregory V. Alkema
Gregory V. Alkema, Pro Se
REALTOR®, CRB

California DRE #01915968
April 13, 2026


ENP S90

a

io

it

eelvert

fy

%.
i
ry

first

&a

ae

cy

Re

=
ae
oa)
Fs!

4/13/26, 2

seis

aoe

Sena

me

a

Bee

eat
ee

Ce

SS

ae

shea

HOLS TRY

i

fferent from other “Coming Soon” products

and

.

d
re not backtrack

iS

i@w i

how Prev

INS.

*

Jun Choo expla

ing on any of our philosophy.”

I

"We

dedly pro-consumer.

*

dec

ui
°
9
a
c
o
£
sa)
®
=

“eet

ief Operating Officer Jun Choo is making

Ch

_

A few weeks afte

the new pre-marketing product doesn't

consumer values.

t

tha

iZe&

podcasts to emphas

o>)
c
iS)
—_
G
a
Ww
a)
=
O
x
= @
oo ¢
Oy tet
2 oO
ew
a
cH)
Cc
Oo
c
O
oO

ine

he rounds oni

E
LS

'§ pro-

t

lan

signa

maybe sellers do need more choices and more

ing that,

in say

ttle bi

inga

ift

"We are sh

aprort
Cc
@M
©
am
_
iv)
CF
=
ra
am
7o)
oO
ay
uf}
Oo
oO
s
>
io
ice)
[> a
adi
con
2
com
=
143;
&
oO
=
os
a9)
a ont
tot
S saall
@M
al
—
an)
=
oO
pa
Cal
Cc
a8)
=
=
DM
f=
rhe!
=
Oo
com
Cc
°
(4
Cc
oO
2
oO
©

qdoes

product “that

IS a

i
a
oO
=
-
or
w"
3)
2)
xo)
=
2
N
a
a
=

ii

s experience.

that at the expense of a buyer'

-2-years-ago

ve

com/2026/04/11/zillow-coo-preview-idea-firsit-conce

iw. realestatenews.

hitps


a aye

4/13/26, 2:58 PM Case 1:25-cv-05201-JAV-SDA Zio OOGr Remit Gd firstietkpsledlz VENT a0 Page 5 af?

Instead, “we built our own version" that helps buyers, sellers and listing agents, Choc
explained. “We're not backtracking on any of our philosophy."

Zillow Preview's beginnings: The company had been considering an offering like -reyiew
long before the mcusiry ce ul Ofe-m mo and private listings = ratcheted up in
recent months, Choo said.

"The product team had actually been thinking about this from the time we launched 4) ow
Showcase two years ago," he explained. Zillow “listened to the marketplace" and realized it
"needed a version" of a pre-marketing product — one that will work with MLSs and “within
whatever rules are out there in the market.”

"One thing we can do at Zillow with any listing product is make sure it gets the broadest
exposure possible, which is really what sellers care about," he addec.

Preview isn't a ‘bait-and-switch:: In February, Compass announced 4 partnership wih
cocket to display the brokerage’s “Coming Soon” and "Private Exclusive" listings on Redfin.
So how is Preview different?

"From the consumer angle, we're not hiding anything behind a [registration] wail. We're not
using this as a bait-and-switch to try and get people to work with our agents, because
we're working with partner agents anyway," Choo said.

Another notable difference is "Preview listings actually have two ways that a consumer can
contact the agent," he added. "They can contact the listing agent, in which case the lead
will go to the listing agent. But if they want to schedule a tour of the home, that goes into
our Preferred program and goes to one of our Preferred partners.”

Aside from Preview listings appearing on Zillow before they are active on the MLS, “there
are almost no similarities to the other 'Coming Soon’ products.”

What Zillow doesn't want to become: The industry may be starting to fragment, but Zillow
is determined “to try to find some way for consumers to have a place to go where they can
see all of those things" available to them, Choo said.

But Zillow is, first and foremost, a tech company, he emphasized. "We don't want to be a
compliance-enforcing body — it's not what we're built for, and we don't enjoy doing it,"
Choo said. "Hopefully we're able to maintain a set of rules and standards here that work for
everybody.”

Ultimately, Zillow's goal is “to make sure that the consumers have choice,” he added. "We're
going to continue to create more options for sellers to market their homes on Zillow, and
we're going to find every avenue to make sure that all the available inventory is there for
buyers to see."

hitps:/Awww.realestatenews.com/2026/04/1 1/zillow-coo-preview-idea-first-conceived-2-years-ago 2/5


aye

4/13/26, 2:58PM Case 1:25-cy-05201-JAV-SDA Zio GOOrRevitwl eb firsticoneelvetg Years igo Page 6 a

=F

oe

The ‘frustrating’ side of innovation: Choo's approach for product development is "to build a
prototype quickly and get it in market quickly" because "you could sit there and do focus
groups and research and try to get it perfect — and it won't be, no matter how long you
take."

For Choo, the "frustrating part" is building around constraints. Instead, he prefers to
"imagine that there are no rules or regulations" — "just build the thing, and then we'll figure
out how to make it fit the rules." It's the approach his team took when developing what
became Zillow Showcase.

"As long as we can continue to build and innovate, we're happy to comply with a complex
set of rules. But we can't start building with those rules in mind," he said.

How Al is improving home search: Choo also made an appearance on Vike Oeivrete’s
C Context podcast, where he referenced. Zillow's new Al moce as an ample 0 of how Al can

seit MET NE BrP ee aT OPS Oe

make the home search process a bit easier.

Zillow “kind of Knew what homes you looked at” based on saved searches and likes, but
“we didn't know what you were thinking,” Choo said.

With conversational! Al tools, Zillow can "understand what your situation is in a way that,
when you come back, you're not starting from scratch."

Viore Industry News

httos:/Awww.realestatenews.com/2026/04/1 1/zillow-coo-preview-idea-first-concelyed-2-years-ago 3/5


Grag Alkema, CRB
81 Hancock Drive:
Roseville, CA 95678

.
"

ot
fo:
wae