Nikolich v. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company — Entry #26
Case: Nikolich v. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company wawd · 3:25-cv-05825
filed September 16, 2025
What this document is
Docket entry #26 · filed March 16, 2026
Who is involved
- Progressive Casualty Insurance Company
- Steven J Nikolich
- The Progressive Company
Why we have it
We follow this case because it names a company we track, although that company is not a party:
- Riot: its subsidiary “Block Mining, Inc.” appears in a filing in this case.
…individual claims in a motion to dismiss.” Block Mining, Inc. v. 13 Hosting Source, LLC, Case No. C24-0319JLR…
A free copy from the RECAP archive of federal court filings (mirrored at the Internet Archive), retrieved November 14, 2026. Federal court filings are public records.
Document text
11 page(s), 25,175 characters, converted from the PDF's text layer · plain text.
Full text
Case 3:25-cv-05825-JNW Document 26 Filed 03/16/26 Page 1 of 11
1 THE HONORABLE JAMAL N WHITEHEAD
2
3
4
5
6
7 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
WESTERN DISTRICT OF WASHINGTON
8 AT TACOMA
9
10 STEVEN J. NIKOLICH, both individually Case No.: 3:25-cv-05825-JNW
and upon behalf of the community property
11 marital estate of STEVEN J. NIKOLICH DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO
and MARCIA A. NIKOLICH, DISMISS PLAINTIFFS’ AMENDED
12 COMPLAINT
Plaintiffs,
13 NOTE ON MOTION CALENDAR:
v. APRIL 13, 2026
14
PROGRESSIVE CASUALTY
15 INSURANCE COMPANY, an Ohio
corporation; and, THE PROGRESSIVE
16 COMPANY, 1 an Ohio corporation,
17 Defendants.
18 INTRODUCTION
19 This is Plaintiffs’ second attempt to manufacture a series of RICO claims against
20 Progressive Casualty and its parent company based on monthly insurance premiums Plaintiffs
21 admittedly authorized for a vehicle Plaintiffs added to their policy after it was involved in an
22 accident.
23
1
According to their Amended Complaint, Plaintiffs seek to sue Progressive Casualty
24 Insurance Company and its parent corporation (Am. Compl. ¶ 6) which Plaintiffs misidentify
as “The Progressive Company.” “The Progressive Company” does not exist—instead, The
25 Progressive Corporation is Progressive Casualty Insurance Company’s corporate parent. For
26 purposes of this Motion, Defendants treat all references to the erroneously named
“Progressive Company” as references to “The Progressive Corporation.”
27
DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS 1 BAKER & HOSTETLER LLP
PLAINTIFFS’ AMENDED COMPLAINT 999 Third Avenue, Suite 3900
CASE NO.: 3:25-CV-05825-JNW Seattle, WA 98104-4076
Telephone: (206) 332-1380
Case 3:25-cv-05825-JNW Document 26 Filed 03/16/26 Page 2 of 11
1 The Court dismissed Plaintiffs’ original complaint as time-barred and because
2 Plaintiffs failed to adequately plead the existence of a RICO enterprise or a pattern of
3 racketeering. The Court granted Plaintiffs leave to amend to “cure the significant deficiencies
4 in their complaint” by “pleading more facts and fewer legal conclusions” but expressed
5 skepticism that Plaintiffs would be able to do so. Order on Motion to Dismiss (“Order”), Dkt.
6 # 24 at p. 8–9.
7 The Court’s skepticism was well-founded. Plaintiffs’ Amended Complaint does not
8 cure any of the deficiencies in their original complaint and instead continues to rely on
9 voluminous and unsupported legal conclusions. In fact, the most prominent changes appear
10 to be the removal of Plaintiffs’ state-law RICO claims and the addition of a second list of each
11 monthly payment with a parenthetical listing the date of the payment and the date four years
12 after the payment (those payments were already listed by date in the original complaint).
13 Compare Dkt. # 1, Compl. at p. 18 of 119 to 22 of 119 with Dkt. # 25, Am. Compl. at p. 19 of
14 153 to 30 of 153. Other changes are merely cosmetic, such as expanding the description of the
15 refund Progressive issued to Plaintiffs as an “offensively, insulting, paltry sum” to an
16 “offensively, perniciously, perfidiously, ignominiously, insulting, de minimis, niggardly and
17 paltry sum.” Compare Dkt. # 1, Compl. ¶ 18B with Dkt. # 25, Am. Compl. ¶ 18B.
18 What the Amended Complaint lacks entirely, however, is any new factual allegation
19 that would establish a plausible RICO enterprise or pattern of racketeering activity, or that
20 would render Plaintiffs’ RICO claims timely. Accordingly, the Court should again dismiss
21 Plaintiffs’ complaint, this time without further leave to amend.
22 STATEMENT OF FACTS
23 On September 24, 2020, Plaintiffs’ daughter, Danica Nikolich, was involved in an
24 accident while driving Plaintiffs’ 2013 Ford Fusion, rendering that vehicle “inoperable and
25 unrepairable.” Am. Compl. ¶ 12.
26 Plaintiffs allege that, at some point “in 2020,” they had contracted with Progressive
27
DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS 2 BAKER & HOSTETLER LLP
PLAINTIFFS’ AMENDED COMPLAINT 999 Third Avenue, Suite 3900
CASE NO.: 3:25-CV-05825-JNW Seattle, WA 98104-4076
Telephone: (206) 332-1380
Case 3:25-cv-05825-JNW Document 26 Filed 03/16/26 Page 3 of 11
1 Casualty to obtain insurance “for a certain motor vehicle owned by plaintiffs”—presumably
2 referring to the 2013 Ford Fusion. Am. Compl. ¶ 11. Plaintiffs admit that they “expressly
3 consented to and authorized Progressive Casualty to withdraw monies by electronic funds
4 transfer from plaintiffs’ bank account” to pay the policy premiums. Id.
5 Following the September 24, 2020 accident, Plaintiffs submitted an insurance claim,
6 which Progressive Casualty denied. Am. Compl. ¶¶ 13–14. Specifically, Progressive Casualty
7 denied the claim because, at the time of the accident, Danica Nikolich was not a listed driver
8 on the policy, and because the 2013 Ford Fusion was not a listed vehicle on the policy. See
9 Dkt. # 18, Declaration of D. Kavouras (“Kavouras Decl.”), Ex. A, February 17, 2022 Ltr.
10 from Progressive Casualty to Danica Nikolich. 2
11 After Plaintiffs added the 2013 Ford Fusion to the policy effective September 25, 2020,
12 it remained on the policy and Plaintiffs continued to pay the associated monthly premiums
13 until they cancelled the policy in February 2024. Am. Compl. ¶¶ 15, 18; see also e Dkt. # 18,
14 Kavouras Decl., Ex. B.
15 Several months after cancelling their policy, Plaintiffs—through counsel—sent a
16 demand to Progressive Casualty for a refund of the premiums paid for the 2013 Ford Fusion.
17 Am. Compl. ¶ 18A. Plaintiffs’ counsel alleges that he subsequently called Progressive
18 Casualty, and that a company representative stated during that call that Progressive Casualty
19 would issue the requested refund. Id. ¶¶ 18AA–18AAA. Nevertheless, Plaintiffs allege
20 Progressive Casualty issued only a partial refund and Plaintiffs’ subsequent demands for a
21 larger refund were rejected. Id. ¶¶ 18B, 18E.
22
23
2
Although Plaintiffs allege the 2013 Ford Fusion relevant to this litigation was a “covered
vehicle” at the time of the accident on September 24, 2020, their policy documents show that
24 they added the 2013 Ford Fusion to their policy on September 25, 2020—the day after the
accident—and it remained on the policy through multiple policy renewals through February
25 2024. See Dkt. # 18, Kavouras Decl., Ex. B, Plaintiffs’ Policy Records. See Univ. Ins., LLC v.
Allstate Ins. Co., 564 F. Supp. 3d 934, 938 (W.D. Wash. 2021) (on a motion to dismiss, the
26 Court can consider a document not attached to the complaint if the complaint “refers
extensively” to that document, or the document “forms the basis of” a claim asserted in the
27 complaint).
DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS 3 BAKER & HOSTETLER LLP
PLAINTIFFS’ AMENDED COMPLAINT 999 Third Avenue, Suite 3900
CASE NO.: 3:25-CV-05825-JNW Seattle, WA 98104-4076
Telephone: (206) 332-1380
Case 3:25-cv-05825-JNW Document 26 Filed 03/16/26 Page 4 of 11
1 Plaintiffs filed a complaint under both the federal and Washington’s “little RICO”
2 statute which the Court dismissed as untimely and because Plaintiffs failed to plead the most
3 basic elements of a RICO claim—a RICO enterprise and a pattern of racketeering activity.
4 Order, Dkt. # 24. On March 1, 2026, Plaintiffs filed this Amended Complaint Dkt. # 25
5 seeking the same relief under the same RICO statutes. And because Plaintiffs have not
6 provided the Court with any new facts that would render its claim timely or meritorious, the
7 same result is warranted.
8 LAW AND ARGUMENT
9 I. Plaintiffs’ RICO Claims Are Barred By The Statute of Limitations.
10 The statute of limitations for a federal RICO claim is four years, and begins to run
11 when “a plaintiff knows or should know of the injury that underlies his cause of action.”
12 Order, Dkt.# 24 at 3 (citing Grimmett v. Brown, 75 F.3d 506, 510-11 (9th Cir. 1996) (internal
13 quotations omitted)). A new cause of action accrues and restarts the statute of limitations only
14 if the defendant engages in “a new and independent act that is not merely a reaffirmation of
15 a previous act.” Id. at 3 (citing Grimmett, 75 F.3d at 510) (internal quotations omitted)).
16 Here, Plaintiffs allege that Progressive Casualty began wrongfully collecting monthly
17 insurance premiums after the accident in September 2020, but they did not file their complaint
18 until five years later, in September 2025. Dkt. # 25, Am. Compl. ¶ 18. Plaintiffs’ Amended
19 Complaint argues that “each and every individual electronic monetary transfer constitutes an
20 independent, separate contravention” of RICO, and therefore the fact that those automatic
21 monthly payments continued until January 2024 renders at least some of their RICO claims
22 timely. Id. ¶¶ 18A, 24. But as this Court has already held, the “passive receipt of payments,
23 without more, is not an overt act that restarts the limitations period.” Dkt. # 24, Order at 3
24 (collecting cases).
25 Plaintiffs offer no new facts to refute that fundamental flaw. Nor have Plaintiffs alleged
26 any facts suggesting they were prevented from discovering the monthly premium payments
27
DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS 4 BAKER & HOSTETLER LLP
PLAINTIFFS’ AMENDED COMPLAINT 999 Third Avenue, Suite 3900
CASE NO.: 3:25-CV-05825-JNW Seattle, WA 98104-4076
Telephone: (206) 332-1380
Case 3:25-cv-05825-JNW Document 26 Filed 03/16/26 Page 5 of 11
1 or filing this lawsuit before September 2025. Indeed, Plaintiffs freely admit that they
2 “expressly consented to and authorized Progressive Casualty to withdraw monies by
3 electronic funds transfer from plaintiffs’ bank account” to pay those premiums. Am. Compl.
4 ¶ 11.
5 Because Plaintiffs did not file their complaint until five years after the transfers began,
6 Plaintiffs’ RICO claims fall outside the applicable limitations period and should be dismissed
7 with prejudice on that basis alone.
8 II. Plaintiffs’ RICO Claims Fail.
9 Even if Plaintiffs had managed to plead new facts to render their claim timely, their
10 claims would still fail because Plaintiffs cannot plead the most basic elements of a RICO cause
11 of action—a RICO enterprise and a pattern of racketeering activity.
12 A. Plaintiffs failed to plead the existence of a RICO enterprise.
13 To state a civil RICO claim, a plaintiff must allege “that one or more defendant
14 ‘persons’ conducted or participated in the activities of an ‘enterprise’ through a pattern of
15 racketeering activity.” Capitol West Appraisals v. Countrywide Fin. Corp., 2009 WL 10677052, at
16 *2 (W.D. Wash. Sept. 30, 2009). In other words, the plaintiff must prove “the existence of
17 two distinct entities: (1) a ‘person’; and (2) an ‘enterprise’ that is not simply the same ‘person’
18 referred to by a different name.” Cedric Kushner Promotions, Ltd. v. King, 533 U.S. 158, 161
19 (2001).
20 Plaintiffs assert that Progressive Casualty and its parent corporation constitute a RICO
21 enterprise. But where, as here, an alleged enterprise “consists of a parent corporation and its
22 subsidiary, the plaintiff must plead facts showing activity beyond the normal corporate
23 relationship; otherwise, every corporation that has subsidiaries and commits fraud is an
24 enterprise for RICO purposes.” Dkt. # 24, Order at 6 (citing Chagby v. Target Corp., No. CV
25 08-4425-GHK (PJWx), 2009 WL 398972, at *1 n.2 (C.D. Cal. Feb. 11, 2009)). Here, the
26 Court dismissed Plaintiffs’ original complaint because, although it “list[ed] dozens of
27
DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS 5 BAKER & HOSTETLER LLP
PLAINTIFFS’ AMENDED COMPLAINT 999 Third Avenue, Suite 3900
CASE NO.: 3:25-CV-05825-JNW Seattle, WA 98104-4076
Telephone: (206) 332-1380
Case 3:25-cv-05825-JNW Document 26 Filed 03/16/26 Page 6 of 11
1 Progressive subsidiaries, [Plaintiffs] allege[d] no facts showing these entities acted outside
2 their ordinary corporate structure to pursue an unlawful purpose.” Id. at 6. Plaintiffs’
3 Amended Complaint fails for the same reason. Indeed, there are no new facts pled in
4 Plaintiffs’ Amended Complaint demonstrating that any of the Progressive entities did
5 anything more than act within their ordinary corporate structure to collect insurance
6 premiums on a policy that was never cancelled. See Lee v. General Nutrition Cos., Inc., 2001 WL
7 34032651, at *14 (C.D. Cal. Nov. 26, 2001) (dismissing RICO claim because plaintiff failed
8 to show an enterprise where “each of the persons pled operated within a unified corporate
9 structure and were guided by a single corporate consciousness”); Moran v. Entrust Grp., 675 F.
10 App’x 641, 645 (9th Cir. 2017) (dismissing RICO claim where plaintiff failed to explain “how
11 The Entrust Group and Entrust Administration are separate and distinct from the alleged
12 enterprise, consisting only of members of the same corporate family”).
13 Accordingly, the Court should again dismiss Plaintiffs’ RICO claims for failure to
14 establish the existence of a RICO enterprise.
15 B. Plaintiffs failed to plead a pattern of racketeering activity.
16 To state a RICO claim, a plaintiff must demonstrate that the defendant “(1)
17 participated in (2) an enterprise (3) through a pattern (4) of racketeering activity that (5)
18 proximately caused the claimant’s harm.” Lang v. Strange, 2022 WL 168698, at *8 (W.D.
19 Wash. Jan. 19, 2022).
20 Here, Plaintiffs allege that Progressive Casualty engaged in a pattern of racketeering
21 activity—specifically mail and wire fraud—by collecting (via electronic funds transfers)
22 insurance premium payments from Plaintiffs for a vehicle that was totaled in an accident. But
23 those allegations do not establish a pattern of racketeering activity sufficient to state a RICO
24 claim. This Court has already found that “the collection of premiums on one policy, from one
25 policyholder, under one accident [where] subsequent monthly payments were involved does
26 not transform a single billing dispute into a RICO pattern.” Dkt.# 24, Order at 6 (citing Sever
27
DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS 6 BAKER & HOSTETLER LLP
PLAINTIFFS’ AMENDED COMPLAINT 999 Third Avenue, Suite 3900
CASE NO.: 3:25-CV-05825-JNW Seattle, WA 98104-4076
Telephone: (206) 332-1380
Case 3:25-cv-05825-JNW Document 26 Filed 03/16/26 Page 7 of 11
1 v. Alaska Pulp Corp., 978 F.2d 1529, 1535 (9th Cir. 1992)). And Plaintiffs’ Amended Complaint
2 has not identified any new facts demonstrating anything more than a single billing dispute
3 between Plaintiffs and Progressive regarding a single totaled vehicle.
4 Moreover, Plaintiffs have not pled the predicate acts of racketeering with any
5 particularity. Here, Plaintiffs’ RICO claims are based on allegations of mail and wire fraud—
6 both of which require Plaintiffs to demonstrate that Progressive not only “form[ed] a scheme
7 to defraud” Plaintiffs but also that Progressive had “the specific intend to defraud.” Dkt. #
8 24, Order at 6 (citing Eclectic Props. E., LLC v. Marcus & Millichap Co., 751 F.3d 990, 997 (9th
9 Cir. 2014)). The Court found that the facts alleged in Plaintiffs’ original complaint—namely,
10 that Progressive continued to withdraw insurance premiums from Plaintiffs after their car was
11 totaled—do not demonstrate a scheme or specific intent to defraud. Id. at 7. Plaintiffs’
12 Amended Complaint similarly fails to identify facts that rise to the level of a scheme or specific
13 intent to defraud. Instead, the majority of Plaintiffs’ amendments are nothing more than bare
14 legal conclusions. But legal conclusions do not satisfy Plaintiffs’ pleading burden. Id. at 7
15 (rejecting Plaintiffs’ characterizations of Defendants’ conduct as “wrongful, criminal, and
16 fraudulent” as legal conclusions that need not be accepted as true).
17 Because Plaintiffs again failed to plead, with particularity, a pattern of racketeering
18 activity for purposes of their RICO claims, these claims should again be dismissed.
19 III. Plaintiffs’ Declaratory Judgment Claim Fails.
20 The Declaratory Judgment Act “does not provide a cause of action when a party . . .
21 lacks a cause of action under a separate statute and seeks to use the Act to obtain affirmative
22 relief.” City of Reno v. Netflix, Inc., 52 F.4th 874, 878 (9th Cir. 2022). Because Plaintiffs’
23 Amended Complaint does not state a RICO claim under either the federal or Washington
24 statutes, their Declaratory Judgment Act claim, too, must fail.
25 IV. Dismissal Should Be Without Leave to Amend.
26 The Court should again dismiss Plaintiffs’ Complaint, this time without leave to
27
DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS 7 BAKER & HOSTETLER LLP
PLAINTIFFS’ AMENDED COMPLAINT 999 Third Avenue, Suite 3900
CASE NO.: 3:25-CV-05825-JNW Seattle, WA 98104-4076
Telephone: (206) 332-1380
Case 3:25-cv-05825-JNW Document 26 Filed 03/16/26 Page 8 of 11
1 amend. Indeed, “where the plaintiff has previously been granted leave to amend and has
2 subsequently failed to add the requisite particularity to its claims, the district court’s discretion
3 to deny leave to amend is particularly broad.” Nguyen v Endologix, Inc., 962 F3d 405, 420 (9th
4 Cir. 2020) (internal quotations and citation omitted). And where, as here, Plaintiffs have
5 already “made [their] best case” and it is still “wanting,” there is no abuse of discretion in
6 denying leave to amend. Id.
7 CONCLUSION
8 For the foregoing reasons, each of Plaintiffs’ claims for relief should be dismissed with
9 prejudice.
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS 8 BAKER & HOSTETLER LLP
PLAINTIFFS’ AMENDED COMPLAINT 999 Third Avenue, Suite 3900
CASE NO.: 3:25-CV-05825-JNW Seattle, WA 98104-4076
Telephone: (206) 332-1380
Case 3:25-cv-05825-JNW Document 26 Filed 03/16/26 Page 9 of 11
1 CERTIFICATE OF CONFERRAL
2 Pursuant to Section 5.6 of the Court’s Chamber Procedures, I certify that counsel for
3 Defendants attempted to confer with counsel for Plaintiffs multiple times regarding this
4 Motion, but were unable to do so. Defendants’ counsel will update the Court if the parties are
5 able to reach an agreement on the above motion.
6 Daniel M. Kavouras
Daniel M. Kavouras
7 Counsel for Defendants
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS 9 BAKER & HOSTETLER LLP
PLAINTIFFS’ AMENDED COMPLAINT 999 Third Avenue, Suite 3900
CASE NO.: 3:25-CV-05825-JNW Seattle, WA 98104-4076
Telephone: (206) 332-1380
Case 3:25-cv-05825-JNW Document 26 Filed 03/16/26 Page 10 of 11
1 DATED: March 16, 2026 BAKER & HOSTETLER LLP
2 s/ Logan F. Peppin
Logan F. Peppin, WSBA #55704
3 999 Third Avenue, Suite 3900
Seattle, WA 98104
4 Tel: (206) 332-1380
Email: lpeppin@bakerlaw.com
5
6 Daniel M. Kavouras (admitted pro hac vice)
Brittany N. Lockyer (admitted pro hac vice)
7 BAKER & HOSTETLER LLP
Key Tower
8 127 Public Square, Suite 2000
Cleveland, OH 44114-1214
9 Tel: (216) 861-7099
Emails: dkavouras@bakerlaw.com
10 blockyer@bakerlaw.com
11 Attorneys for Defendants Progressive Casualty
Insurance Company and The Progressive
12 Company
13 I certify that this memorandum contains
2,200 words, in compliance with the Local
14 Civil Rules.
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS 10 BAKER & HOSTETLER LLP
PLAINTIFFS’ AMENDED COMPLAINT 999 Third Avenue, Suite 3900
CASE NO.: 3:25-CV-05825-JNW Seattle, WA 98104-4076
Telephone: (206) 332-1380
Case 3:25-cv-05825-JNW Document 26 Filed 03/16/26 Page 11 of 11
1 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
2 I hereby certify that on March 16, 2026, I electronically filed the foregoing with the
3 Clerk of the Court using the CM/ECF system and/or e-mailed to counsel below:
4 Dean Browning Webb, WSBA #10735
5 5515 N.W. Pacific Rim Boulevard Apt. #103
Camas, Washington 98607
6 Tel: (360) 241-1656
E-mail: ricoman1968@ao1.com
7
8
s/ Cheryl A. Phillips
9 Cheryl A. Phillips, Legal Assistant
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS 11 BAKER & HOSTETLER LLP
PLAINTIFFS’ AMENDED COMPLAINT 999 Third Avenue, Suite 3900
CASE NO.: 3:25-CV-05825-JNW Seattle, WA 98104-4076
Telephone: (206) 332-1380