jain.com
Public record. We host this document directly; the copy served here does not depend on any third party. Retrieved November 14, 2026.
Read the documentAlso at archive.org ↗

Plus One Robotics, Inc. v. Artificial Intelligence Industry Association, Inc. — Entry #98: ADVISORY TO THE COURT by Plus One Robotics, Inc

Case: Plus One Robotics, Inc. v. Artificial Intelligence Industry Association, Inc. txwd · 5:25-cv-01197

filed September 23, 2025

What this document is

Docket entry #98 · filed November 05, 2026

ADVISORY TO THE COURT by Plus One Robotics, Inc. . (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit)(Sood, Udit) (Entered: 11/05/2026)

Who is involved

Why we have it

We follow this case because it names a company we track, although that company is not a party:

A free copy from the RECAP archive of federal court filings (mirrored at the Internet Archive), retrieved November 14, 2026. Federal court filings are public records.

URL
https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172865943/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172865943.98.0.pdf
Kind
court_filing
Publisher
RECAP
Published
2026-11-05 00:00:00-05:00
Retrieved
2026-11-14 06:51:05.000485-05:00
HTTP status
200
MIME
application/pdf
Bytes
235828
SHA-256
9206f4fb4df86d570fd061320bcdfbc76f1bd76e1119589bd9bf56f110f22373

Document text

7 page(s), 13,507 characters, converted from the PDF's text layer · plain text.

Full text
Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB       Document 98   Filed 11/05/26   Page 1 of 7


                         IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
                          FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
                                 SAN ANTONIO DIVISION


PLUS ONE ROBOTICS, INC.

            Plaintiff,                        Case No. 5:25-CV-01197-OLG-HJB

       v.

ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION, INC., and
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IMAGING
ASSOCIATION, INC.

            Defendants.

ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION, INC., and
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IMAGING
ASSOCIATION, INC.,

            Counter-Plaintiffs,
v.

PLUS ONE ROBOTICS, INC.

            Counter-Defendant.


               JOINT ADVISORY PURSUANT TO THE COURT’S ORDER
                     SETTING IN-PERSON HEARING [DKT. 89]


    Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB             Document 98        Filed 11/05/26      Page 2 of 7


                                I.      PLUS ONE’S POSITION

       1.      The Court ordered the Parties to confer in good faith regarding the pending motions

and file a Joint Advisory “specifying those matters which, even after conference, require

resolution” by the Court. (Dkt. 89 (“Order”) at 2.) Although the parties were able to narrow their

disputes, some unfortunately remain unresolved.

       2.      Primarily, the parties dispute the case schedule. Despite AIIA’s significant delays,

Plus One worked to preserve the Markman hearing date, even agreeing to serve its preliminary

invalidity contentions in 60 days rather than the originally allocated 90 days. AIIA imperiled the

schedule by serving its infringement contentions seven months after they were originally due and

now seeks a new case schedule that delays the Markman hearing. AIIA cannot show good cause.

The prejudice AIIA alleged was having to serve revised claim terms and constructions on October

30, 2026, before receiving Plus One’s preliminary invalidity contentions on November 9, 2026.

That problem is already resolved: the parties stipulated to move AIIA’s deadline to November 30,

2026, without otherwise delaying the case schedule. (Dkt. 93 ¶ 6.) AIIA’s attempts now to delay

the Markman hearing are unsupported and unreasonable and should be denied. The Court should

enter Plus One’s proposed schedule, as detailed in paragraph 6 below.

       3.      Second, the parties dispute whether Plus One should be compelled to provide

additional discovery before claim construction. It should not. Plus One long ago provided

materials sufficient to show the operation of each accused instrumentality.           AIIA alleges

deficiencies without having inspected those materials and without specifically identifying any

relevant information it cannot obtain from them. Indeed, had AIIA inspected those materials, it

would have seen that Plus One’s accused products do not use the third-party tools (Amazon

SageMaker and certain RealSense ROS drivers) that AIIA is accusing in this case. The Court

should deny AIIA’s motion and hold AIIA to its representations during the September 10, 2026,

hearing that it needs no additional technical documentation until after claim construction.

       4.      Finally, the parties dispute whether Prof. Bretl may access AIIA’s operative

contentions. AIIA identifies no conflict or plausible objection to Prof. Bretl, but remains unwilling


                                               -1-


    Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB              Document 98        Filed 11/05/26      Page 3 of 7


to withdraw its motion to disqualify him.         The Court should dismiss the motion without

reconsidering its prior ruling that Plus One may share the contentions with necessary third parties

after providing AIIA notice.

       5.      For the Court’s convenience, Plus One’s positions on each of the four motions

addressed in the Order are summarized in the following chart.

  Dkt.     Motion            Status                         Plus One’s Position
  84   AIIA’s Motion        Resolved       The parties’ stipulation (Dkt. 93) confirms November
       to Strike                           9, 2026, as Plus One’s deadline to serve preliminary
                                           invalidity contentions, and thus moots AIIA’s motion
                                           seeking to enforce an earlier October 7, 2026, deadline.
                                           The Court should deny AIIA’s motion as moot.

  74     Plus    One’s         Partially   The parties’ stipulation (Dkt. 93) resolves one of two
         Motion     to         resolved    issues in the motion, namely, confirming November 9,
         Clarify                           2026, as Plus One’s deadline to serve preliminary
         Rulings                           invalidity contentions. The other issue concerning
                                           disclosure of AIIA’s operative contentions to Prof.
                                           Bretl remains unresolved. The Court should grant Plus
                                           One’s motion, clarifying that Prof. Bretl properly
                                           received and may review AIIA’s operative contentions.

  82     AIIA’s                Partially   The parties’ stipulation (Dkt. 93) confirms November
         Emergency             resolved    9, 2026, as Plus One’s deadline to produce materials
         Motion       to                   sufficient to show operation of the accused products, to
         Compel,                           the extent not already produced. Plus One long ago
         Modify Case                       provided materials sufficient to show operation of each
         Schedule, etc.                    accused product and instrumentality. AIIA should
                                           review the materials provided before alleging that they
                                           are insufficient. As to the case schedule, the Court
                                           should refuse to delay the Markman hearing.

  79     AIIA’s            Unresolved AIIA has no legitimate objection to Prof. Bretl that
         Emergency                    could warrant disqualification, nor can substantiate its
         Motion                       work product claim, and yet refuses to withdraw its
         Regarding                    motion. The Court should deny AIIA’s motion.
         Prof. Bretl


       6.      To the extent the Court is inclined to further adjust any case deadlines, Plus One

respectfully asks that the Court enter the following schedule, which addresses all alleged prejudice


                                                -2-


    Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB              Document 98        Filed 11/05/26    Page 4 of 7


to AIIA while also avoiding unwarranted delays in adjudicating Plus One’s rights.


                       Event                          Current Deadline   Plus One Proposal
    Plus One preliminary invalidity / § 112 / §         Nov. 9, 2026      No further change
    101 contentions                                     (see Dkt. 93)        warranted
    Plus One’s supplemental technical                   Nov. 9, 2026      No further change
    documents (if any) sufficient to show the           (see Dkt. 93)        warranted
    operation of the accused instrumentalities
    in AIIA’s 4th Amended Infringement
    Contentions

    Meet-and-confer; exchange revised terms             Dec. 9, 2026      No further change
    / constructions                                     (see Dkt. 93)        warranted

    Parties’ supplemental disclosure of                Nov. 30, 2026      No further change
    extrinsic evidence and experts, with scope            (AIIA);            warranted
    of topics                                          Dec. 7, 2026
                                                        (Plus One)
                                                       (see Dkt. 93)

    Mediation                                          Nov. 20, 2026        Feb. 23, 2026
    Opening claim-construction briefs                  Dec. 11, 2026      No further change
                                                                         warranted (otherwise
                                                                            Jan. 13, 2027)

    Responsive claim-construction briefs                Jan. 15, 2027     No further change
                                                                         warranted (otherwise
                                                                            Feb. 5, 2027)

    Joint Claim Construction Statement                  Jan. 29, 2027     No further change
                                                                         warranted (otherwise
                                                                           Feb. 12, 2027)

    Technical tutorials (optional)                      Feb. 19, 2027    No delay warranted
    Markman hearing                                     Feb. 26, 2027    No delay warranted


                                        *         *       *


                                              -3-


    Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB             Document 98        Filed 11/05/26      Page 5 of 7


                                   II.     AIIA’S POSITION

       1.      The parties conferred on November 3 and 4, 2026, in writing and by telephone, as

the Court directed. (Dkt. 89.) AIIA's position on each of the matters that require resolution by the

Court—Dkts. 74, 79, 82, and 84, the application of the Protective Order to AIIA's Attorneys' Eyes

Only material, and the schedule—is set forth in detail in Exhibit A attached to this Advisory, which

AIIA incorporates by reference, together with Dkts. 79, 82, and 84, its opposition to Dkt. 74 (Dkt.

92), and its replies filed November 4, 2026. AIIA reserves all rights, including as to fees and any

motion that the case is exceptional.

       2.      AIIA regrets to inform the Court that this Advisory is far from a joint position.

AIIA tried to reach one, as Exhibit A describes, even at the cost of substantial rights: it went back

to Plus One on multiple occasions, each time placing more and more of its substantive rights on

the line to resolve a breach it did not cause. AIIA regrets that it has not been able to deliver the

joint report the Court ordered, and respectfully seeks the Court's leave to present its position

separately, in Exhibit A.


                                               -4-


    Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB   Document 98    Filed 11/05/26     Page 6 of 7


Date: November 5, 2026               /s/ Udit Sood
                                     Udit Sood

                                     RYAN TYZ (CA Bar No. 234895)
                                     Admitted Jan. 30, 2025
                                     ryan@tyzlaw.com
                                     UDIT SOOD (CA Bar No. 308476)
                                     Admitted pro hac vice
                                     udit@tyzlaw.com
                                     SEAN APPLE (CA Bar No. 305692)
                                     Admitted pro hac vice
                                     sapple@tyzlaw.com
                                     TYZ LAW GROUP
                                     1 Embarcadero Center, Suite 1200
                                     San Francisco, CA 94111
                                     Telephone: 415.868.6900

                                     Counsel for Plaintiff/Counter-Defendant


Date: November 5, 2026               /s/ Vivek Ramachandran
                                     Vivek Ramachandran

                                     DHAMMA LAW PLLC
                                     418 Broadway, Suite N
                                     Albany, NY 12207
                                     vramachandran@dhammalaw.com

                                     Robert E. Golden
                                     GOLDEN LAW, P.C.
                                     Independence Plaza II, Suite 250
                                     14350 Northbrook Drive
                                     San Antonio, TX 78232
                                     (210) 495-0900
                                     (210) 495-0997 (fax)
                                     golden@goldenlaw.net

                                     Counsel for Defendants/Counter-Plaintiffs


                                   -5-


    Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB            Document 98       Filed 11/05/26      Page 7 of 7


                             CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
      I certify that a true and correct copy of the foregoing document was served on all counsel of

record via CM/ECF according to the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure on this 5th day
of November, 2026.

      Vivek Ramachandran
      DHAMMA LAW PLLC
      418 Broadway, Suite N
      Albany, NY 12207
      vramachandran@dhammalaw.com

      Robert E. Golden
      GOLDEN LAW, P.C.
      Independence Plaza II, Suite 250
      14350 Northbrook Drive
      San Antonio, TX 78232
      (210) 495-0900
      (210) 495-0997 (fax)
      golden@goldenlaw.net

                                                    /s/ Udit Sood
                                                    Udit Sood


                                              -1-