jain.com
Public record. We host this document directly; the copy served here does not depend on any third party. Retrieved November 14, 2026.
Read the documentAlso at archive.org ↗

Sheresky v. United States of America — Entry #80: NOTICE of Filing of Administrative Record

Case: Sheresky v. United States of America nysd · 1:25-cv-08935

filed October 28, 2025

What this document is

Docket entry #80 · filed September 18, 2026

NOTICE of Filing of Administrative Record. Document filed by Daniel Aronowitz, Lori Chavez-DeRemer, Janet Dhillon, United States of America. (Attachments: (1) Exhibit Certification of Administrative Record, (2) Exhibit Index to Administrative Record, (3) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 1, (4) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 2, (5) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 3.1, (6) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 3.2, (7) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 3.3, (8) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 3.4, (9) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 3.5, (10) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 3.6, (11) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 3.7, (12) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 4, (13) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 5.1, (14) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 5.2, (15) Exhibit Administrative Record Vol. 6).(Yalen, Robert)

Who is involved

Why we have it

We follow this case because it names a company we track, although that company is not a party:

A free copy from the RECAP archive of federal court filings (mirrored at the Internet Archive), retrieved November 14, 2026. Federal court filings are public records.

URL
https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.nysd.651997/gov.uscourts.nysd.651997.80.3.pdf
Kind
court_filing
Publisher
RECAP
Published
2026-09-03 00:00:00-04:00
Retrieved
2026-11-14 06:50:28.631874-05:00
HTTP status
200
MIME
application/pdf
Bytes
530335
SHA-256
8a21226912765db7679b27833bfd59cf29e690be02842587675e6febb66a276a

Document text

6 page(s), 21,931 characters, converted from the PDF's text layer · plain text.

Full text
Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                 Document 80-3            Filed 09/18/26          Page 1 of 6
U.S. Department of Labor                    Employee Benefits Security Administration
                                            Washington, D.C. 20210


September 9, 2025

Kent A. Mason                                                                            2025-03A
Davis & Harmon LLP                                                                       3(2)
1455 PennsylvaniaAvenue
Suite 1200
Washington, DC 20004


Dear Mr. Mason:

This is in response to your request on behalf of Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC (Morgan
Stanley or the Firm) for an advisory opinion from the Department of Labor (Depm1ment)
regarding the applicability of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, as
amended (ERISA), Specifically, you ask whether the Finn's deferred incentive compensation
program, comprised of the Equity Incentive Compensation Plan (EICP) and Morgan Stanley
Compensation Incentive Plan (MSCIP), (i) is not an "employee pension benefit plan" under
section 3(2)(A) of Title I of ERISA; and (ii) qualifies as an exempt "bonus program" under 29
C.F.R. § 2510.3-2(c).

You represent that the Firm's financial advisors receive a guaranteed base salary and are eligible
to earn cash incentive compensation which is paid throughout the year. In addition, financial
advisors are eligible to earn deferred incentive compensation, with 25% issued as an unsecured
deferred stock award under the EICP and the remaining 75% percent as an unsecured deferred
cash-based award under the MSCIP. 1 The deferred stock units are converted to shares of Morgan
Stanley common stock and deposited into a brokerage account, while cash-based awards are
deposited into the financial advisors' payroll accounts, on the ''scheduled vesting date' only
when all conditions are met, as described below.

All incentive compensation is calculated based on ''Total Credits." The financial advisor's Total
Credits for each month are determined by the applicable "Credit Rate" multiplied by the
creditable revenue generated by the financial advisor. The Credit Rate is a percentage between
28% and 55.5% that increases with the financial advisor's revenue and length of service with the
Firm. A portion of the Total Credits is allocated to "Defened Credits" (between 1.5% and 15.5%
of the financial advisor's total incentive compensation), based on the level of revenue the
financial advisor generates. The cumulative value of the monthly Deferred Credits for the year is
granted to the financial advisor in the form of deferred incentive compensation (deferred stock
and cash awards) shortly after the year-end. Deferred incentive compensation awards are
generally contingent, among other things, upon the advisor remaining continuously employed
through the grant and vesting dates. Accordingly, if the financial advisor terminates employment


1
 The advisors have individual, notional accounts in the MSCIP, and they can invest their accounts in notional
investments, with the value of their accounts tracking the performance of the selected investments.


                                                                                                                DOLAR000I


        Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                   Document 80-3             Filed 09/18/26          Page 2 of 6


during the year, there is no award of the Deferred Credits granted for that year. The rest (between
84.5% and 98.5%) of the Total Credits are allocated to "Cash Credits," which are used to
calculate and pay cash incentive compensation monthly.

Both cash and deferred incentive compensation reward good performance by calculating the
amount, in part, based on a :financial advisor's generation of revenue for the Firm, Deferred
incentive compensation, however, serves additional purposes: to reward financial advisors for
their ''continued employment and service to the Firm in the future and [advisor] compliance with
the Firm's policies (including the Code of Conduct)," In this regard, you represent that by
conditioning payment on continuous employment and good guardianship, the deferred
compensation awards are designed to motivate advisors to stay with the Firm and to comply with
firm policies that require advisors to act as good stewards of client assets. Accordingly, with five
exceptions described below, financial advisors are generally eligible for payment of the deferred
incentive compensation awards only if they remain continuously employed and in good standing
on the "scheduled vesting date," 2 which occurs after four years (for stock awards) or six years
(for cash awards) of continuous service following the grant date of such awards,

The deferred incentive compensation awards are canceled if a financial advisor: (1) terminates
employment before the scheduled vesting date; or (2) engages in prohibited activity, such as
violating securities rules and regulations, engaging in dishonest or fraudulent conduct, disclosing
privileged or confidential information or trade secrets, making disparaging or defamatory
comments about the Firm before the scheduled award distribution date, soliciting customers the
financial advisor serviced while employed by the Firm for a competitor without the Firm's
consent before the earlier of the three years after termination or the scheduled award distribution
date, taking employment with a competitor within 100 miles without the Firm's consent before
the earlier of one year after termination or the scheduled award distribution date, or engaging in
other conduct that is cause for termination. 3 The awards are not cancelled if a financial advisor's
employment terminates due to: (1) death~ (2) disability; (3) retirement; (4) involuntmy
termination not involving any prohibited activity; or (5) termination due to govermnent service
not involving any prohibited activity. In these cases, the payment schedule depends on the
exception clause under which the awards are paid.4 You represent that payments under these
relatively uncommon situations are designed to uphold the awards' primmy purposes of
encouraging long-term retention of financial advisors and promoting good conduct.


2
  Except as noted in footnote 4, the terms "scheduled vesting date," "distribution date," and "award distribution
date" all refer to the same date on which, after meeting all conditions of the program, the benefits are paid to the
financial advisors (payment is typically made within a matter of days due to administrative processing times).
3
  The Department does not express any view on whether the non-disparagement, non-compete, and non-solicitation
provisions under the program are reasonable.
4 For the exception
                      due to death, the award is paid to a designated beneficiaiy upon notification to the Finn. For the
exception due to retirement, 50% of the award is paid on the first anniversaiy after retirement, with the remaining
50% paid on the second anniversary, if the retiree does not engage in specified prohibited activity. For the exception
due to governmental service termination, the award is paid on the date of termination. For the exception due to
disability or involuntary termination by the Finn, the award is paid on the scheduled vesting date (four years for
EICP and six years for MSCIP).

                                                           2


                                                                                                                       DOLAR0002


       Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                 Document 80-3            Filed 09/18/26         Page 3 of 6


Financial advisors do not have the option to extend or delay the distribution date. From 2009-
2019 5, 89.9% to 95.2% of deferred incentive stock awards issued under EICP were distributed to
current employees; in the aggregate over that period 91.8% of such distributions were made to
current employees (compared to 8.2% for former employees). Similarly, from 2009 to 2017,
80.1 % to 92.6% of cash distributions were ultimately paid to current employees; in the aggregate
over that period current employees were paid 85.3% of deferred incentive cash awards issued
under the MSCIP (compared to 14.7% for former employees). 6

The award conditions are disclosed annually in the award certificates, smmnaiy descriptions and
other communications. These disclosures also clearly state that the deferred incentive
compensation awards are "contingent and unsecured'' and that the program is a:

        bonus program and not a retirement plan. Its purposes are to reward and retain key
        employees of the Firm and to align their interests with those of the shareholders.
        Participants should not look to this bonus program as a source of retirement income.
        This bonus program is not subject to the Employee Retirement Income Security Act
        of 1974. 7               •


You also state that the awards are structured to meet the expectations of the Firm's financial
regulators regarding the use of deferred compensation to motivate good conduct and penalize
bad conduct. 8

Section 3(2)(A) of ERISA defines the terms "employee pension benefit plan" and "pension plan"
as follows:

        [T]he terms "employee pension benefit plan" and "pension plan" means any plan,
        fund, or program established or maintained by an employer to the extent that by its
        express terms or as a result of surrounding circumstances such plan, fund or
        program-(i) provides retirement income to employees, or (ii) results in a deferral
        of income by employees for periods extending to the termination of covered
        employment or beyond, regardless of the method of calculating the contributions
        made to the plan, the method of calculating the benefits under the plan 01· the
        method of distributing benefits from the plan.


5
  You represent that for stock awards issued under the EICP, the most recent plan year to have vested (as of August
2024) was the 2019 plan year.
6 You represent that for cash awards issued under the MSCIP, the most recent plan year to have vested (as of August

2024) was the 2017 plan year.
7
  See, e.g., EICP 2021 Discretionaiy Retention Awards Stock Unit Summary Description and MSCIP 202 l
Discretionary Retention Awards Summmy Description. Per your submission, the exact language in the description of
this program has changed over the years, but the substance of the program has not changed.
8
  You noted that financial regulators, including Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, the Federal Reserve Board
of Governors, the Securities and Exchange Commission, and the office of the Comptroller of the Currency, have
issued guidance advising and proposed regulations requiring regulated entities to defer pmtions of employee
incentive compensation, and to make that compensation contingent and cancelable, to address risk•taking and other
behaviors that may be harmful to customers and the public markets.

                                                        3


                                                                                                                 DOLAR0003


       Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG            Document 80-3         Filed 09/18/26      Page 4 of 6


The Department's regulation at 29 C.F.R. § 2510 .3-2( c) "clarifies the limits" of the term pension
plan for purposes of Title I of ERISA by describing certain arrangements that will not constitute
an employee pension benefit plan within the meaning ofERISA section 3(2), Specifically, 29
C.F.R. § 2510.3-2(c) provides:

       For purposes of Title I of [ERISA], the term ... "pension plan;' shall not include
       payments made by an employer to some or all its employees as bonuses for work
       performed, unless such payments are systematically deferred to the termination of
       covered employment or beyond, or so as to provide retirement income to
       employees,

The EICP and MSCIP do not, by their express terms, make payment of deferred incentive
compensation awards contingent on termination of employment or retirement. Financial advisors
earn the right to award payments only upon satisfying the award conditions, which require them
to remain continuously employed and in good standing tlu·ough the scheduled vesting date (four
or six years of continuous service after the award is granted). On the scheduled vesting date, the
award payments are made automatically, and financial advisors are not permitted to defer the
payments to a later date. If a financial advisor terminates employment or engages in prohibited
activities before vesting, the awards are cancelled, except under limited circumstances. These
conditions are disclosed annually to the financial advisors. These annual disclosures also
expressly state that financial advisors "have no right to .. , [the] award until it is 'earned,"' the
awards are "contingent upon the [financial advisor] remaining employed through the grant and
vesting dates of the award/' the awards are "not intended to provide for retirement income," and
that the program is "not a retirement plan subject to [ERISA]." Accordingly, we find the
program, by its express terms, not to be an employee pension benefit plan within the meaning of
£RISA section 3(2)(A).

Although the deferred incentive compensation program does not, by its express terms, defer
income to termination of employment or beyond or provide retirement income, awards may be
paid after the end of employment in limited circumstances where financial advisors are unable to
remain employed through the awards' vesting dates due to death, disability, retirement,
involuntary termination or govenunent service. The Department has previously expressed the
view that, even though a program allows payments, which would otherwise be made on a
specified date, to be paid earlier in the event an employee terminates employment, allowing such
earlier payment does not automatically mean that the arrangement is a pension plan. Instead, the
Department considers such provisions as one factor to be considered along with other
surrounding circumstances in determining whether the program may be providing retirement
income or results in a deferral of income for periods extending to the termination of covered
employment or beyond. Advisory Opinion 83-46A (Sept. 8, 1983 ). See also Advisory Opinion


                                                  4


                                                                                                    DOLAR0004


        Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG                  Document 80-3            Filed 09/18/26          Page 5 of 6


2002-13A(Dec. 6, 2002); Advisory Opinion 82-29A (July 8, 1996); Advisory Opinion 81-74A
(Sep. 29, 1981). 9

The question of whether a plan, fund, or program is a pension plan within the meaning of ERISA
section 3(2)(A) "as a result of surrounding circumstances;" is inherently factual in nature and the
Department generally does not issue advisory opinions on purely factual questions under ERISA.
See Section 5.01 ofERISAProcedure 76-1, 41 Fed. Reg. 36281 (Aug. 27, 1976). In this case,
however, the materials you submitted do not appear to indicate the existence of any of the
surrounding circumstances that the Department has previously said would tend to support the
finding that an arrangement constitutes a pension plan. For example, there is no evidence
suggesting any of the following: (i) an inordinate percentage of the award recipients were at or
near retirement age when the benefits were to be paid; (ii) distributions were skewed toward the
last years of the participants' careers; (iii) amounts were distributed with a relatively long payout
schedule; (iv) individuals not otherwise eligible were selected to receive the award based on
being at or near retirement age; (v) participation was limited to individuals ineligible for the
Firm's retirement plan (which might suggest that the program is meant to replace the Firm's
retirement plan); or (vi) the program was communicated to participants in a manner that caused
them to defer income until retirement. See Advisory Opinion 98-02A (Mar. 6, 1998); Advisory
Opinion 83-46A (Sept. 8, 1983 ); Advis01y Opinion 83-42A (Sept. 8, 1983 ); Adviso1y Opinion
81-27A (Mar. 9, 1981). Taking into account both the program's design and operative provisions,
its annual disclosures, the data on when most awards were received, and all other materials you
provided, in the Department's view, the mere fact that the terms of the program contemplate
limited situations where an award could be paid after termination of employment does not
implicate a deferral of income of the kind contemplated by ERISA section 3(2)(A). Thus, the
Department has no reason to believe that the deferred incentive compensation program is an
employee benefit pension plan under ERISA section 3(2)(A) as a result of such surrounding
circumstances.

At any rate, the deferred incentive compensation program qualifies as an exempt "bonus
program" under 29 C.F.R. § 2510.3-2( c), which clarifies the definition of the term employee
benefit pension plan for purpose of Title I of ERISA by describing certain arrangements that will
not constitute an employee pension benefit plan within the meaning of ERISA section 3(2)(A).
The Department has applied the "bonus program" regulation to programs that calculate bonuses
in diverse ways, including an incentive plan that calculates bonus as a percentage of revenue


9
 The courts have similarly rejected the notion that all post-employment payments trigger ERISA coverage under
ERISA section 3(2)(A). See e.g., Murphy v. Inexco Oil Co., 61 l F.2d 570, 574-75 (5th Cir. 1980) ("[ERISA] does
not embrace all plans that may incidentally result in the payment of benefits after death or disability but only plans
established for the purpose of providing those benefits .... Under the statutory definition, the mere fact that some
payments under a plan may be made after an employee has retired or left the company does not result in EH.ISA
coverage."); Wilson v. Sa/elite Grp., Inc., 930 F.3d 429, 436 (6th Cir.2019) (''[t]o determine if the Safelite Plan is
covered, we look to its design and administration, applying the language of the statute to the Plan's express terms
and/or its surrounding circumstances"); Oahi'a)~ Inc. v. Am. Int'! G,p., Inc., 325 F.Jd 184, 189 (3d Cir, 2003)
("post-retirement payments were only incidental to the goal of providing current compensation"); Milligan v. Bank
ofAmerica C01p., 2025 WL 892972, *5 (W.D.N.C March 11, 2025) (In interpreting ERISA section 3(2)(A), the
"mere fact that some payments under a plan may be made after an employee has retired or left the company docs not
result in ERISA coverage").

                                                          5


                                                                                                                     DOLAR0005


        Case 1:25-cv-08935-PGG          Document 80-3         Filed 09/18/26      Page 6 of 6


generated by the participants, much like the Firm's deferred incentive compensation program, as
well as a percentage of revenue generated by the Company, a percentage of a company's net
revenue interest, royalties from oil and gas leases and the safe conduct of an employer's
business. See e.g., Advisory Opinion 2002-BA (Dec. 6, 2002); Advisory Opinion 98-02A
(March 6, 1998); Advisory Opinion 83-42A (Aug. 17, 1983 ); Advisory Opinion 82-29A (Jul. 2,
1982).

The express purposes of the deferred incentive compensation program are to reward financial
advisors for their long-term tenure and incentivize good behaviors desired by the Firm, The
prngram's design and administration are tailored to achieve those goals and to meet the financial
regulat01y requirements regarding using deferred compensation to motivate good conduct and
penalize bad conduct. 10 The awards are unsecured and not guaranteed, unlike salaiy and
commissions, there is no accrual (i.e., no partial payouts for partial periods of perfonnance) and
financial advisors are notified annually about the express purposes and conditions of the program
and informed that it is not a retirement plan subject to ERISA. Accordingly, the program's
express purposes, design, administration and the conditions on the award payments support the
conclusion that the awards are bonuses. Moreover, the proportion of payments to current
employees (over 85% for cash awards, over 91.8% for stock conversions) compared to former
employees, clearly demonstrate that such payments are only incidental and not "systematically
deferred" to termination of covered employment or beyond, or so as to provide retirement
income. See Advisory Opinion 2002-13A (Dec. 6, 2002).

Accordingly, it is the Department's view that the deferred incentive compensation program
appears to be a bonus program within the meaning of29 C.F.R. § 2510.3-2(c). The payment of a
small percentage of awards to financial advisors who terminated employment before the awards'
vesting dates due to death, disability, involuntaty termination or govenm1ent service, is not the
sort of deferral of income contemplated by ERISA section 3(2)(A), As described above, the
program does not involve the systematic deferral of payments to the termination of covered
employment or beyond, which would preclude the deferred incentive compensation program
from being a bonus program.

This letter constitutes an advisory opinion under ERISA Procedure 76-1 and is issued subject to
the provisions of that procedure, including section 10 thereof relating to the effect of an advis01y
opinion.


rn See footnote 8.

                                                 6


                                                                                                   DOLAR0006