jain.com
Public record. We host this document directly; the copy served here does not depend on any third party. Retrieved November 14, 2026.
Read the documentAlso at archive.org ↗

Plus One Robotics, Inc. v. Artificial Intelligence Industry Association, Inc. — Entry #97: REPLY to Response to Motion, filed by Artificial Intelligence Imaging Association, Inc., Artificial Intelligence Industry Association, Inc., re 84 MOTION to…

Case: Plus One Robotics, Inc. v. Artificial Intelligence Industry Association, Inc. txwd · 5:25-cv-01197

filed September 23, 2025

What this document is

Docket entry #97 · filed November 04, 2026

REPLY to Response to Motion, filed by Artificial Intelligence Imaging Association, Inc., Artificial Intelligence Industry Association, Inc., re 84 MOTION to Strike and Preclude Plaintiff's Untimely Invalidity Contentions filed by Defendant Artificial Intelligence Industry Association, Inc., Defendant Artificial Intelligence Imaging Association, Inc. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit, # 2 Exhibit, # 3 Exhibit, # 4 Exhibit, # 5 Exhibit, # 6 Exhibit)(Ramachandran, Vivek) (Entered: 11/04/2026)

Who is involved

Why we have it

We follow this case because it names a company we track, although that company is not a party:

A free copy from the RECAP archive of federal court filings (mirrored at the Internet Archive), retrieved November 14, 2026. Federal court filings are public records.

URL
https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172865943/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172865943.97.0.pdf
Kind
court_filing
Publisher
RECAP
Published
2026-11-05 00:00:00-05:00
Retrieved
2026-11-14 06:51:10.744663-05:00
HTTP status
200
MIME
application/pdf
Bytes
208224
SHA-256
5e2fc422048b99c9ed2a957efee80d6ac088b7b03697d8b0fa3e7f229706a9a5

Document text

11 page(s), 25,120 characters, converted from the PDF's text layer · plain text.

Full text
Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB             Document 97         Filed 11/04/26       Page 1 of 11


                          IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
                           FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
                                  SAN ANTONIO DIVISION


 PLUS ONE ROBOTICS, INC.,                                      Case No. 5:25-CV-01197-OLG-HJB
 Plaintiff / Counter-Defendant,
 v.
 ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE INDUSTRY
 ASSOCIATION, INC., and ARTIFICIAL
 INTELLIGENCE IMAGING ASSOCIATION, INC.,
 Defendants / Counter-Plaintiffs.


DEFENDANTS' REPLY IN SUPPORT OF THEIR MOTION TO STRIKE AND PRECLUDE
     PLAINTIFF'S UNTIMELY INVALIDITY, SECTION 112, AND SECTION 101
                  CONTENTIONS AND PRIOR ART (DKT. 84)

        Defendants and Counter-Plaintiffs Artificial Intelligence Industry Association, Inc. and

Artificial Intelligence Imaging Association, Inc. (together, "AIIA") submit this reply in support of their

Motion to Strike and Preclude Plaintiff's Untimely Invalidity, Section 112, and Section 101

Contentions and Prior Art (Dkt. 84) ("Motion"), and in response to the Omnibus Response (Dkt. 90)

of Plaintiff/Counter-Defendant Plus One Robotics, Inc. ("Plus One"). Record citations are to the

Declaration of Vivek Ramachandran (Dkt. 81) ("Decl."), the September 10, 2026 hearing transcript

(Dkt. 73) ("Tr."), and the exhibits to Dkts. 90, 92, and 94.

I. The deadline was October 7; the colloquy Plus One quotes is not the ruling.
        Plus One's deadline was set by its own joint motion (Dkt. 33) and the Court's order that the

Dkt. 31 deadline "is EXTENDED to OCTOBER 7, 2026." (Text Order of May 8, 2026.) That joint

motion, signed by Plus One's counsel, moved Plus One's contentions from August 6 to October 7 and

represented to the Court that "[t]he relief sought by this motion will not impact any other deadlines

specified in the Scheduling Order or in the Order Regarding Contentions." (Dkt. 33 at 1.) This deadline

movement gave Plus One 30 days after AIIA’s contentions, and skipped over dates for claim


                                                    1


    Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB               Document 97         Filed 11/04/26       Page 2 of 11


construction, aimed at prejudicing AIIA via the May 8, 2026 order. Forced onto AIIA Counsel Robert

Golden at the last minute, when Robert Golden had proposed going to the Judge alone. Plus One

refused to accommodate a provision on a meet and confer, willfully changing the sequence. This willful

misuse of procedure is not new. Plus One wrote a letter 15 days before AIIA’s contentions were due

to then claim 15 days later that AIIA has breached its source code reservation. An expert could not

even have been qualified in 10 days. Indeed, when one was qualified, Plus One then sought to

disqualify the expert. Then forced the extension while moving only Plus One’s own theories and

forcing AIIA to provide its claim terms without having access to Plus One’s theories. This is the exact

gamesmanship Plus One chose to repeat on October 7, 2026 by skipping that date and then producing

all documents on October 9, 2026 to prejudice AIIA. Such gamesmanship will continue, unless this

court ends it once and for all.

        Plus One says the Court moved the deadline again on September 10, citing Tr. 74:11–14, 75:7–

15, and 80:22–25. (Dkt. 90 at 3–4, 6.) Read in full, those passages show the Court raising the subject,

offering time, and then deciding not to set any date. The Court said it was "concerned that you-all need

more time" (Tr. 74:11–14) and offered it: "If you need more time, I'm good -- I'm happy to give you

more time." Plus One's counsel answered, "I think we're okay." (Tr. 75:2–4.) He then said that "under

the order, we get 60 days," asked the Court to "correct me if I'm wrong," and said Plus One would "live

with that deadline." (Tr. 75:7–15.) The order he was describing set a date, October 7, not a period, and

he told the Court minutes later that the deadline "is due pretty early in October." (Tr. 80:13–15.) Before

that, the Court had already ruled on how deadlines would change: "I'm not going to set those deadlines

now. I'll let you confer," with proposals due "the 1st of October," to which Plus One's counsel replied,

"That should be sufficient, Your Honor." (Tr. 79:16–80:8.) When counsel raised the October date

again, the Court said the contentions "would be due way in November … 60 days effectively from

today," and in the same breath that "you-all can change those deadlines or whatever you needed to by

way of conference before -- a month before that time." (Tr. 80:22–81:3.) When AIIA asked the Court


                                                    2


    Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB               Document 97         Filed 11/04/26       Page 3 of 11


to "schedule all of the dates," the Court declined: "I want you-all to talk it all the way through

yourselves and then propose something to me. I don't want to try to do it off-the-cuff now." (Tr. 81:8–

14.) The Court then announced "the ruling": "The parties will, by October 1st, propose any changes to

the scheduling order they think is appropriate." (Tr. 82:9–18.) The written order says the same and

nothing about sixty days or November. (Dkt. 71 ¶ 2.) The Court added: "If there's any question about

it, please seek clarification, because it's the oral order that controls." (Tr. 83:12–14.) Plus One relies

on that sentence (Dkt. 90 at 6), but the oral order is the ruling at 82:9–83:3, not the exchange that

preceded it, which the Court closed by refusing to set dates. Remarks from the bench "in no way bind

the judge" to a particular ruling. Gray v. WinCo Foods, LLC, 683 F. Supp. 3d 571, 582–83 (E.D. Tex.

2023). The sixty-day figure was the Court's description of what the parties could reach "by way of

conference" and propose by October 1. Plus One concedes that "[n]either party sought by October 1,

2026, to change the schedule." (Dkt. 74 at 2.) A change the Court directed the parties to propose, and

that no one proposed, was never made. Fed. R. Civ. P. 16(b)(4). Plus One's own October 13 email read

the ruling the same way: it told AIIA that the Court "ordered the parties to meet and confer before

making any such requests and to make any such requests by no later than October 1, 2026," and

demanded that AIIA show good cause for any change. (Decl. ¶ 11.) It cannot hold AIIA to October 1

and exempt itself.

II. AIIA's October 9 email did not change a court-ordered deadline.
        Plus One's remaining support is one sentence from AIIA's October 9, 6:17 p.m. email: "Your

deadline was moved from 7th October only to help with that review not prejudice AIIA with jumping

the dates today." (Dkt. 90 at 4, 6.) Three things about that email dispose of the argument. First, it was

sent two days after October 7. It cannot have induced a default that had already occurred, and Plus One

does not claim it did; Plus One says it did not serve "because it understood that the Court had allowed

it '60 days from today.'" (Dkt. 90 at 6.) Second, it states its own condition in the preceding sentence:


                                                    3


    Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB               Document 97         Filed 11/04/26       Page 4 of 11


"The court gave you time to review the claims charts and then meet and confer." That conference and

proposal, due by October 1, never happened. (Decl. ¶ 4; Dkt. 74 at 2.) The email was sent thirty-five

minutes after AIIA objected that Plus One "did not provide us with anything on the 7th which precedes

this disclosure deadline," and eighteen minutes after AIIA disclosed its expert under protest because

"nothing was served on October 7, 2026." (Decl. ¶¶ 8–9.) Third, AIIA did not have the transcript. Plus

One ordered it on September 11 and had it from September 23; AIIA first obtained access on October

16. (Dkt. 72; Dkt. 73; Decl. ¶ 4.) A party that holds the transcript cannot rely on its adversary's

understanding of a ruling the adversary had not read. Correspondence does not amend a scheduling

order in any event; only the Court does, "for good cause and with the judge's consent." Fed. R. Civ. P.

16(b)(4). A party unsure of an order "could have petitioned the District Court for a modification,

clarification or construction of the order"; one that instead "undert[akes] to make [its] own

determination of what the decree meant" acts "at [its] peril." McComb v. Jacksonville Paper Co., 336

U.S. 187, 192 (1949). Plus One's statement that "both sides understood" the deadline had moved (Dkt.

90 at 6) is refuted by AIIA's objection on October 9, its October 16 working schedule ("Not present in

written order, and no clarification was sought"), and its October 19 letter ("Plus One violated the

Court's October 7, 2026 deadline"). (Decl. ¶¶ 8, 18, 25; Dkt. 81, Ex. E at 1.) Plus One sought

clarification on October 20, thirteen days after the deadline. (Dkt. 74.)

III. The stipulation moved the date only; the consequence of the default is for the Court, not for
AIIA to excuse.
        After Plus One filed its response, the parties filed a stipulation (Dkt. 93), which the Court has

not entered. It extends Plus One's October 7 obligations to November 9, 2026, and states that this

"changes only the date; it does not modify the substance of those obligations." (Dkt. 93 ¶ 2.) It is

"without prejudice to, and does not waive, any Party's rights, claims, objections, positions, or defenses,

including those raised in the Parties' pending motions" (id. ¶ 7), and it reserves "any additional

unaddressed items relating to the October 7, 2026 and October 9, 2026 deadlines" (id. ¶ 8), language


                                                    4


    Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB                Document 97       Filed 11/04/26       Page 5 of 11


AIIA insisted on and Plus One accepted on October 30. (Dkt. 94-1 at 1–2, 6; Dkt. 94-3.) AIIA expressly

reserved this Motion in writing before the stipulation was filed (Dkt. 94-1 at 4; Dkt. 94-2 at 2) and in

its withdrawal of Dkt. 91 (Dkt. 94 ¶ 3). The stipulation gives Plus One a date going forward so that the

December 9 exchange can proceed with Plus One's theories in hand. It does not find good cause, it

does not make October 7 something other than the deadline Plus One missed, and it does not resolve

the consequence of the default. Nor is that consequence AIIA's to waive: a party that fails to obey a

scheduling order answers to the Court under Rule 16(f), and Plus One has filed no motion under Rule

6(b)(1)(B) and has shown neither excusable neglect nor good cause. What follows from the October 7

default is before the Court on this Motion.

IV. The prejudice is real and is not cured by later service.
        Plus One says AIIA "would suffer no prejudice" from November 9. (Dkt. 90 at 7.) The

Scheduling Order answers that. As entered, it placed Plus One's invalidity contentions on May 11,

2026, before the August 10 exchange of claim terms and the September 9 exchange of proposed

constructions. (Dkt. 25 at 1–2.) The May 8 text order, on the parties' joint motion, moved Plus One's

date to October 7, after both exchanges, so that the only steps left to follow Plus One's contentions

were AIIA's October 9 extrinsic-evidence and expert disclosure and the October 30 narrowing

conference: twenty-three days in which AIIA's counsel and expert would have Plus One's charts and

prior art before taking final positions. (Dkt. 25 at 2–3; Dkt. 94-2 at 1.) Plus One's default consumed

that window. AIIA made its October 9 disclosure blind, "being made to respond to indefiniteness

contentions it has not yet seen," and it had to identify the scope of its expert's topics without knowing

which limitations Plus One would attack under § 112. (Decl. ¶ 9.) Two days later Plus One disclosed

a claim-construction and indefiniteness expert and 3,006 pages of extrinsic evidence selected to support

positions it had not served, and on October 14 it gave that expert AIIA's Attorneys' Eyes Only

contentions. (Decl. ¶¶ 6, 10, 12, 14.) Plus One could not have selected those 3,006 pages without its


                                                   5


    Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB                Document 97         Filed 11/04/26       Page 6 of 11


theories. AIIA has reviewed all of the documents produced on October 9, 2026, and all of them relate

to Plus One's theories, which Plus One had not disclosed on October 7, 2026, and still has not. On

October 30, AIIA told Plus One in writing that it "must enter today's claim-terms meet-and-confer

blind," that it "cannot meaningfully participate -- yet is forced to do so under threat of permanent

prejudice," and that it "expressly reserves all rights as to its claim-construction positions, its extrinsic

evidence, and its expert's topics under the October 9 provisions, pending receipt of Plus One's

invalidity, non-infringement, and Section 101 positions." (Dkt. 94-1 at 3–4; Dkt. 94-2 at 1.) The

sequence has been inverted: Plus One's expert holds both sides' theories and AIIA's expert holds none

of Plus One's, and that lead continues today. A single construction governs both infringement and

validity, and claim-construction positions "as a practical matter would be influenced by the scope and

combination of the specific prior arts disclosed in invalidity contentions." Innovative Display Techs.

LLC v. Acer Inc., No. 2:13-cv-00522-JRG, 2014 WL 2796555, at *2 (E.D. Tex. June 19, 2014).

"Amendments to invalidity contentions after parties have disclosed and argued for their claim

constructions positions are prejudicial." Tech Pharmacy Servs., LLC v. Alixa Rx LLC, No. 4:15-cv-

766, 2017 WL 2833460, at *5 (E.D. Tex. Jan. 18, 2017). Service on November 9 does not restore the

October 9 disclosure AIIA made without Plus One's positions, and it does not take AIIA's contentions

back from Plus One's expert. Nor does any change to the Scheduling Order: moving dates does not

cure a breach from which the breaching party continues to gain an advantage, and the default here was

willful. Measured against the Scheduling Order as entered, the parties will have gone six months, May

11 to November 9, without Plus One's contentions, and the claim-construction work the order allowed

from May 11 to October 30 is compressed into the three weeks between November 9 and November

30. Plus One's "27-day turnaround" (Dkt. 90 at 1, 5) is also wrong: it has had AIIA's contentions since

February 2026, and the Court observed that the Fourth Amended contentions would be "very similar."

(Tr. 68:18–21, 81:20–21.)


                                                     6


    Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB               Document 97          Filed 11/04/26       Page 7 of 11


V. Rule 16(f) applies, Plus One has not shown good cause, and the untimely contentions should
be struck.
        A party that "fails to obey a scheduling or other pretrial order" is subject to sanctions, including

an order "prohibiting that party from introducing designated matters in evidence," and "must" pay the

reasonable expenses caused by the noncompliance unless it was substantially justified. Fed. R. Civ. P.

16(f)(1)(C), (2); O2 Micro Int'l Ltd. v. Monolithic Power Sys., Inc., 467 F.3d 1355, 1363 (Fed. Cir.

2006). The good-cause factors favor AIIA. S&W Enters., L.L.C. v. SouthTrust Bank of Ala., NA, 315

F.3d 533, 535–36 (5th Cir. 2003). Explanation: Plus One offers its reading of the colloquy. It had the

transcript from September 23, declined the Court's offer of more time, described the deadline to the

Court as "early in October," proposed nothing by October 1, and asked for nothing until October 20.

(Tr. 75:2–4, 80:13–15; Decl. ¶ 4.) "A simple communication or motion to extend deadlines could have

prevented the current conflict." Tech Pharmacy, 2017 WL 2833460, at *4. "The burden is on the

movant to establish diligence." O2 Micro, 467 F.3d at 1366; Squyres v. Heico Cos., L.L.C., 782 F.3d

224, 237 (5th Cir. 2015). Importance: validity matters in every patent case; that does not excuse a

default, and the theories were in hand on October 9. (Dkt. 90 at 7; Decl. ¶¶ 6, 10.) Prejudice: Part IV.

Continuance: the stipulation has already moved the dates that could be moved; it cannot restore the

October 9 disclosure or undo the October 14 disclosure to Plus One's expert. Plus One's "death penalty"

argument (Dkt. 90 at 5) mislabels the relief. Striking contentions that were not served by a court-

ordered deadline is the consequence Rule 16(f)(1)(C) names, and Plus One keeps its non-infringement

defense and may move for leave on a showing of good cause. The default was not inadvertent: Plus

One had the transcript, declined more time, told the Court the deadline was "due pretty early in

October," proposed nothing by October 1, served nothing on October 7, served 3,006 pages two days

later, and gave AIIA's contentions to its expert five days after that. (Tr. 75:2–4, 80:13–15; Decl. ¶¶ 4–

6, 10, 12, 14.) A party that knows the deadline, declines more time, and serves everything except what

was due has made a choice, and the Court should hold it to it: every invalidity, Section 112, and Section


                                                     7


    Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB               Document 97         Filed 11/04/26       Page 8 of 11


101 contention and every item of prior art that Plus One did not serve by October 7, 2026 should be

struck and precluded. The same goes for non-infringement positions. In the draft Joint Advisory it

circulated on November 4, Plus One asserted for the first time that its "accused products do not use the

third-party tools (Amazon SageMaker and certain RealSense ROS drivers) that AIIA is accusing." (Ex.

G at 2.) Plus One's own Chief Technology Officer has said publicly: "We use Amazon SageMaker

Ground Truth to generate tens of thousands of labeled photorealistic images of packages from various

carriers, modeling pose, placement, and even surface variations like stickers or labels. ... This data is

used in real-life induction applications to facilitate over 1 million picks per day for our customers."

(Dkt. 9-1 at 2 (Shaun Edwards, CTO and co-founder); Dkt. 49 at 10–11.) AIIA's contentions rest on

that documentary evidence. Plus One's answer is that its CTO's statement is untrue and that its source

code would show it. (Tr. 47:10–13; Ex. G at 2.) It is Plus One's burden to prove that its Chief

Technology Officer lied, and the proof is documentary: its relationship with Amazon, the SageMaker

documentation it received, the slide deck of the presentation, emails exchanged with reference to the

presentation, what it demonstrated and the images and documentation of those demonstrations, its

emails with Amazon, and the developers who did the work. The same facts are available by subpoena

to Amazon; the contention that AIIA must Marshall everything other than these documents, emails,

presentations, notes exchanged, the developer documentation exchanged, the developers involved and

depositions of these developers, etc., to prove a public statement is baseless, and whether that statement

is true is for the jury. A contrary position was due October 7 with these documents and none was

provided by PlusOne. The expenses requested are limited to the fees the default caused. Goodyear Tire

& Rubber Co. v. Haeger, 581 U.S. 101, 108–09 (2017).

VI. The prejudice is continuing, and no change to the schedule cures it.
        Four weeks after October 7, Plus One has still served no invalidity, Section 112, or Section

101 contention and no prior art, while its claim-construction and indefiniteness expert has held AIIA's


                                                    8


    Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB               Document 97         Filed 11/04/26       Page 9 of 11


Attorneys' Eyes Only contentions since October 14 and AIIA's expert has seen none of Plus One's

designated material. (Decl. ¶¶ 5, 12, 14, 16, 34.) Every claim-construction step AIIA has taken since

October 9 has been taken without the positions the Scheduling Order required Plus One to disclose

first, and none can be retaken. The contention rules "require parties to crystallize their theories of the

case early in the litigation," O2 Micro, 467 F.3d at 1364, and check "the natural desire of litigants to

attain important tactical advantages by delaying disclosure of key elements of their case." Finisar Corp.

v. DirecTV Grp., Inc., 424 F. Supp. 2d 896, 898 (E.D. Tex. 2006). The party that does not disclose its

prior art in time "risks exclusion of that evidence," id. at 901–02, and "[t]he importance of such

proposed testimony cannot singularly override the enforcement of local rules and scheduling orders."

Geiserman v. MacDonald, 893 F.2d 787, 792 (5th Cir. 1990). The prejudice also reaches the value of

AIIA's patent assets, which depends on timely enforcement and on the confidentiality of AIIA's

enforcement positions; every week of delay to claim construction impairs it, and the disclosure of those

positions to an unvetted expert impairs it further. (Dkt. 82, Part IV.)

        At the Dkt. 89 conference, AIIA proposed that schedule and the withdrawal of its own motions

without prejudice, on two conditions: that Plus One's expert use AIIA's materials only subject to the

Protective Order, including the October 14 disclosure, and that Plus One provide access to AIIA's

materials only under the Order. (Exs. A–D; Ex. E at 12–13.) Plus One refused both conditions. A

change to the Scheduling Order does not cure a breach from which Plus One continues to gain an

advantage, and the default was willful. (Tr. 75:2–4, 80:13–15; Decl. ¶¶ 4–6, 10, 12, 14.)

                                            CONCLUSION
        AIIA respectfully requests that the Court find that Plus One failed to comply with the October

7, 2026 deadline without good cause, and (a) strike and preclude every invalidity, Section 112, and

Section 101 contention and every item of prior art that Plus One did not serve by October 7, 2026, Fed.

R. Civ. P. 16(f)(1)(C); (b) in the alternative, if the Court permits service on November 9, 2026 under


                                                    9


   Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB               Document 97          Filed 11/04/26       Page 10 of 11


the parties' stipulation, order that the contentions served that day are Plus One's preliminary invalidity,

Section 112, and Section 101 contentions in full, not to be amended or supplemented before the

deadline for final contentions without leave on a showing of good cause, and that AIIA's right under

Dkt. 93 ¶ 4 to supplement its October 9 disclosures by November 30, 2026, including its claim-

construction positions, extrinsic evidence, and expert topics, is preserved; (c) award AIIA, under Rule

16(f)(2), the reasonable expenses, including attorney's fees, caused by Plus One's noncompliance; and

(d) grant such other relief as the Court deems just. AIIA reserves the identification and briefing of any

Section 112 contention under the Scheduling Order.


Dated: November 4, 2026

Respectfully submitted,

                                                     /s/ Robert E. Golden
                                                     Robert E. Golden
                                                     Texas Bar No. 08085560
                                                     ROBERT E. GOLDEN, P.C.
                                                     14100 San Pedro Ave., Suite 611
                                                     San Antonio, TX 78232-4363
                                                     (210) 495-0900
                                                     golden@goldenlaw.net

                                                     Vivek Ramachandran (admitted pro hac vice)
                                                     DHAMMA LAW PLLC
                                                     418 Broadway, Suite N
                                                     Albany, NY 12207
                                                     (202) 860-4084
                                                     vramachandran@dhammalaw.com

                                                     Counsel for Defendants/Counter-Plaintiffs


                                                    10


   Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB               Document 97         Filed 11/04/26   Page 11 of 11


                                   CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

        I certify that on November 4, 2026, the foregoing was filed through the Court's CM/ECF

system, which will send notification of the filing to all counsel of record.


                                                     /s/ Robert E. Golden
                                                     Robert E. Golden


                                                   11