jain.com
Public record. We host this document directly; the copy served here does not depend on any third party. Retrieved November 15, 2026.
Read the documentAlso at archive.org ↗

Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC v. Paxton — Entry #111

Case: Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC v. Paxton txwd · 1:25-cv-01153

filed July 24, 2025

What this document is

Docket entry #111 · filed October 26, 2026

Who is involved

Why we have it

We follow this case because it names a company we track, although that company is not a party:

A free copy from the RECAP archive of federal court filings (mirrored at the Internet Archive), retrieved November 15, 2026. Federal court filings are public records.

URL
https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.111.1.pdf
Kind
court_filing
Publisher
RECAP
Published
2026-10-26 00:00:00-04:00
Retrieved
2026-11-15 07:41:50.676908-05:00
HTTP status
200
MIME
application/pdf
Bytes
1182119
SHA-256
4b47849ee2c59315fde22c6fbd398b2730f0d88b57c3eccdb74011586013f181

Document text

119 page(s), 294,727 characters, converted from the PDF's text layer · plain text.

Full text
Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA         Document 111-1        Filed 10/26/26      Page 1 of 119


                       IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
                        FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
                                  AUSTIN DIVISION
 GLASS, LEWIS & CO., LLC                         §
      Plaintiff,                                 §
                                                 §
 v.                                              §
                                                 §
 KEN PAXTON, in his Official Capacity as         §
                                                                Civil Action No.
 Attorney General of Texas                       §
                                                              1:25-cv-01153-ADA
        Defendant,                               §
                                                 §
 THE TEXAS STOCK EXCHANGE LLC                    §
 and THE TEXAS ASSOCIATION OF                    §
 BUSINESS,                                       §
       Intervenor-Defendants.                    §


 DECLARATION OF JOE NWAOKORO IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT ATTORNEY
 GENERAL’S OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF’S MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY
                           RESPONSES


        I, Joe Nwaokoro, declare under penalty of perjury pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1746 that the

following is true and correct:

        1.     I am an Assistant Attorney General in the Office of the Attorney General of Texas

and counsel of record for Defendant Ken Paxton, in his official capacity as Attorney General of

Texas (the “Attorney General”), in this action. I submit this Declaration in support of the Attorney

General’s Response to Plaintiff Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC’s (“Glass Lewis”) Motion to Compel

Discovery Responses (the “Response”). The statements below are based on my personal

knowledge and my review of the files maintained by the Office of the Attorney General in the

ordinary course of this litigation. If called as a witness, I could and would testify competently to

these facts.


    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26     Page 2 of 119


       2.      This Declaration authenticates the exhibits cited in the Response and describes the

Attorney General’s written-discovery responses, privilege log, and the parties’ communications

after Glass Lewis filed its Motion on October 19, 2026. I incorporate by reference my prior

Declaration filed with the Attorney General’s Reply in support of his Motion for Protective Order

(Dkt. 110-1) (the “Nwaokoro Reply Declaration”) and its exhibits, my Declaration filed with the

Attorney General’s Motion for Protective Order (Dkt. 101-1), and the Declaration of Division

Chief Johnathan Stone (Dkt. 101-2).

       3.      As set forth in the Nwaokoro Reply Declaration, the Attorney General served

amended objections and responses, a document production, and an itemized privilege log on

October 16, 2026, and served his Second Amended Objections and Responses, a supplemental

production, and a supplemental privilege log on October 20, 2026.

       4.      On October 22, 2026, at 2:35 p.m., Jared LeBrun, counsel for Glass Lewis, sent me

and co-counsel an email identifying what Glass Lewis contended were deficiencies in the Attorney

General’s privilege log and discovery responses, including claimed internal inconsistencies

regarding the Alliance for Corporate Excellence, objections to the common-interest and work-

product designations, and a contention that the log was incomplete. The email demanded that the

Attorney General confirm by the end of the following day that he would produce certain

communications, withdraw his work-product assertions, and individually log each withheld

document. A true and correct copy of that email, and the email thread that followed, is attached as

Exhibit C.

       5.      On October 23, 2026, the Attorney General responded to each of Glass Lewis’s

points and served supplemental discovery materials. At 3:38 p.m., I sent Mr. LeBrun a written

response addressing his concerns item by item and stating that the Attorney General remained


    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 111-1        Filed 10/26/26      Page 3 of 119


available to confer. At 5:56 p.m., the Attorney General served, by email, the Attorney General’s

Supplemental Objections and Responses to Plaintiff’s Second Set of Interrogatories and Second

Set of Requests for Production, the Attorney General’s Second Amended Privilege Log, and a

chart identifying deficiencies in Glass Lewis’s own privilege log. Both emails are included in

Exhibit C.

       6.      The Attorney General’s Supplemental Objections and Responses, served October

23, 2026, conformed the objections to Interrogatories 14 and 20 and supplemented the responses

to Requests for Production 24 and 27. A true and correct copy is attached as Exhibit A.

       7.      The Attorney General’s Second Amended Privilege Log, served October 23, 2026,

lists each withheld item separately, with its author, date, and recipients. In preparing it, the

Attorney General located the first two drafts of the document logged as DOC000001 and logged

those drafts individually. On October 26, 2026, after Glass Lewis’s counsel advised that several

cells had been truncated when the log was converted to PDF for service on October 23, 2026, the

Attorney General re-served the Second Amended Privilege Log in corrected form so that each

entry displays in full. The corrected log is identical in substance to the version served on October

23, 2026; no entry, description, or privilege assertion was changed. A true and correct copy of the

corrected Second Amended Privilege Log is attached as Exhibit B.

       8.      As reflected in the Supplemental Objections and Responses and the Second

Amended Privilege Log, after a diligent search, the Attorney General has no responsive, non-

privileged documents concerning the Alliance for Corporate Excellence to produce. The Attorney

General’s communications with the United States Department of Justice, the Office of the Indiana

Attorney General, and counsel for the Alliance are withheld as attorney work product, and the

Second Amended Privilege Log states that basis and the grounds for each entry. The Attorney


    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26      Page 4 of 119


General does not assert common interest as an independent ground for withholding any document;

the designation is on the log to explain why sharing these materials with aligned, non-adverse

counsel did not waive the work-product protection.

       9.      Attached as Exhibit D is a true and correct copy of a chart showing the

comprehensive deficiencies in Glass Lewis’s October 19, 2026 privilege log.

       10.     The chart the Attorney General served on October 23, 2026 identifies entries in

Glass Lewis’s October 19, 2026 privilege log that reflect the same categories of deficiency Glass

Lewis attributes to the Attorney General (automated notifications, public-statute attachments,

business emails with no attorney on them, communications sent to outside domains and personal

accounts, work-product claims unsupported by any anticipated litigation, drafts meant for

publication or clients and factual status emails, and entries too thin to evaluate under Rule

26(b)(5)(A)) and states, for each, the specific deficiency and the requested cure. A true and correct

copy of the chart is attached as Exhibit E.

       11.     Attached as Exhibit F is a true and correct copy of a chart that matches, request by

request, each challenged request in Glass Lewis’s second set to the request in its first set that it

duplicates, drawn from the Attorney General’s cumulativeness objections. The Attorney General

answered Glass Lewis’s first set of discovery on October 31, 2025.

       12.     Attached as Exhibit G is a true and correct copy of a chart that pairs each of the

Attorney General’s Second-Set Interrogatories 14-25 and Requests for Production 22-36, the

requests Glass Lewis’s Motion claims were refused, with the Attorney General’s actual responses,

served October 16 and superseded and supplemented on October 20 and 23, 2026, identifying for

each the substantive answer, the answer by reference, or the responsive, non-privileged documents

produced at Bates range AG 002090-AG 003289.


    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26     Page 5 of 119


       13.     Attached as Exhibit H is a true and correct copy of the State’s verified Second

Amended Petition in the State DTPA Action, State v. Glass, Lewis & Co., No. 471-04895-2026

(471st Dist. Ct., Collin County), which pleads the State’s deceptive-trade-practices claim against

Glass Lewis in detail, drawn from Glass Lewis’s own public statements and admissions.

       14.     The following exhibits are attached to this Declaration:

               a.     Exhibit A: Attorney General’s Supplemental Objections and Responses to

                      Plaintiff’s Second Set of Interrogatories and Second Set of Requests for

                      Production (served October 23, 2026);

               b.     Exhibit B: Attorney General’s Second Amended Privilege Log (served

                      October 23, 2026; re-served in corrected form October 26, 2026);

               c.     Exhibit C: Email thread between Jared LeBrun and Joe Nwaokoro, dated

                      October 22-23, 2026, including the Attorney General’s October 23, 2026

                      transmittal of the materials in Exhibits A, B, and E;

               d.     Exhibit D: Comprehensive Deficiencies in Glass Lewis’s October 19, 2026

                      Privilege Log (chart);

               e.     Exhibit E: Deficiencies in Glass Lewis’s October 19, 2026 Privilege Log

                      (chart) (served October 23, 2026);

               f.     Exhibit F: Chart matching each challenged second-set discovery request to

                      the duplicative first-set request;

               g.     Exhibit G: Chart pairing Glass Lewis’s challenged second-set requests

                      (Interrogatories 14-25 and Requests for Production 22-36) with the

                      Attorney General’s actual responses and production; and


    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26      Page 6 of 119


              h.      Exhibit H: State’s verified Second Amended Petition in State v. Glass,

                      Lewis & Co., No. 471-04895-2026 (471st Dist. Ct., Collin County).

       I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.


Executed on October 26, 2026, in Houston, Texas.


                                             /s/ Joe Nwaokoro
                                             JOE NWAOKORO
                                             Texas Bar No. 24032916
                                             Assistant Attorney General
                                             General Litigation Division
                                             Office of the Attorney General of Texas


Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA   Document 111-1   Filed 10/26/26   Page 7 of 119


                    EXHIBIT A


      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA         Document 111-1        Filed 10/26/26        Page 8 of 119


                            UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
                             WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
                                   AUSTIN DIVISION

 GLASS, LEWIS & CO., LLC                 §
      Plaintiff,                         §
                                         §
 v.                                      §
                                         §
 KEN PAXTON, in his Official Capacity as §
                                                  Civil Action No.
 Attorney General of Texas               §
                                                1:25-cv-01153-ADA
        Defendant,                       §
                                         §
 THE TEXAS STOCK EXCHANGE LLC            §
 and THE TEXAS ASSOCIATION OF            §
 BUSINESS,                               §
        Intervenor-Defendants.           §
______________________________________________________________________________

 DEFENDANT THE ATTORNEY GENERAL’S SUPPLEMENTAL OBJECTIONS AND
       RESPONSES TO PLAINTIFF’S SECOND SET OF INTERROGATORIES AND
        SECOND SET OF REQUESTS FOR THE PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS
______________________________________________________________________________

TO:     Plaintiff, Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC, through its counsel of record, Bryce L. Callahan, Yetter
        Coleman LLP, 600 Travis Street, Suite 5400, Houston, Texas 77002.

        Defendant Ken Paxton, in his official capacity as Attorney General of Texas (“Defendant”

or the “Office”), submits these Supplemental Objections and Responses to Plaintiff Glass, Lewis

& Co., LLC’s (“Glass Lewis”) Second Set of Interrogatories and Second Set of Requests for

Production.


Dated: October 23, 2026.                      Respectfully submitted,

                                              KEN PAXTON
                                              Attorney General of Texas

                                              BRENT WEBSTER
                                              First Assistant Attorney General

                                              RALPH MOLINA
                                              Deputy First Assistant Attorney General


Defendant AG’s Supplemental Objections & Responses to Plaintiff’s 2nd ROGs & RFPs                1


    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 111-1       Filed 10/26/26     Page 9 of 119


                                            WILLIAM D. WASSDORF
                                            Deputy Attorney General for Civil Litigation

                                            KIMBERLY GDULA
                                            Chief, General Litigation Division
                                            /s/ Joe Nwaokoro
                                            JOE NWAOKORO
                                            Attorney-in-Charge
                                            Texas Bar No. 24032916
                                            Assistant Attorney General
                                            P.O. Box 12548, Capitol Station
                                            Austin, Texas 78711-2548
                                            (512) 979-5382 | FAX: (512) 477-2348
                                            Joe.Nwaokoro@oag.texas.gov

                                            Defendant Ken Paxton, in his official capacity as
                                            Attorney General of Texas


                                 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

       I certify that on October 23, 2026, a true and correct copy of the foregoing was served on

all counsel of record by electronic mail.


                                            /s/ Joe Nwaokoro
                                            JOE NWAOKORO
                                            Assistant Attorney General


Defendant AG’s Supplemental Objections & Responses to Plaintiff’s 2nd ROGs & RFPs              2


   Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26      Page 10 of 119


                          DEFENDANT’S GENERAL OBJECTIONS

    Each of these general objections is deemed incorporated into Defendant’s specific objections
to each individual request:
        1.      Defendant objects to each request for production and interrogatory to the extent that
it seeks materials protected from discovery by the attorney-client privilege, the work product
doctrine, the common-interest doctrine, the investigative privilege, the law-enforcement privilege,
the informer's privilege, the deliberative process privilege, or any other applicable privilege or
protection. To the extent that each request seeks such privileged or protected material, Defendant
claims such privilege and invokes such protection. Defendant does not intend to waive, and shall
not be construed as having waived, any such privilege or protection by failing to make a specific
objection.

        2.     Defendant objects to each request for production and interrogatory to the extent that
it is vague, overly broad, and fails to specify the materials sought with reasonable particularity.
Defendant will attempt to construe the request in a reasonable manner in providing a response.

       3.      Defendant objects to the definitions and instructions to Plaintiff’s Second Request
for Production and Second Set of Interrogatories on the grounds that they are overly broad, render
the requests unduly burdensome, and exceed what is required by the Federal Rules of Civil
Procedure. See Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(1), 34.

        4.      Defendant objects to each request for production to the extent it seeks documents
not in Defendant’s possession, custody, or control. Defendant can only produce those documents
in his possession, custody, or control.

       5.      Defendant objects to each request to the extent it seeks information that is irrelevant
to any party’s claim or defense or not proportional to the needs of the case. See Fed. R. Civ. P.
26(b)(1).

        6.     Defendant incorporates by reference his objections and preliminary statement in
his prior responses to Plaintiff’s Second Request for Production and Second Set of
Interrogatories.

                                              SCOPE

       These Supplemental Objections and Responses supplement and supersede only the
responses to Interrogatory Nos. 14 and 20 and Requests for Production Nos. 24 and 27 in
Defendant’s Second Amended Objections and Responses served October 20, 2026. Otherwise,
the October 20, 2026 service remains in effect and is incorporated by reference.


Defendant AG’s Supplemental Objections & Responses to Plaintiff’s 2nd ROGs & RFPs                  3


   Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26     Page 11 of 119


       SUPPLEMENTAL OBJECTIONS AND RESPONSES TO SECOND SET OF
                         INTERROGATORIES


       INTERROGATORY NO. 14: Identify each Texas resident, consumer, customer,
company, or shareholder that You contend has been deceived or misled by any statement made by
Glass Lewis in connection with its provision of proxy advisory services, and for each, describe the
statement and the manner in which You contend that person was deceived or misled.
         OBJECTIONS: Defendant objects that identification of persons deceived in the State
DTPA Action is not relevant to whether S.B. 2337 is unconstitutional as applied to Glass Lewis
and is not proportional to the needs of this case. Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(1). Defendant objects that
the identity of persons, other than the Alliance for Corporate Excellence, whose identity Defendant
has disclosed, who furnished information to the Consumer Protection Division (the "Division") is
protected by the informer's privilege (Decl. of Johnathan Stone, Dkt. 101-2 ("Stone Decl.") 4);
Defendant's disclosure of the Alliance's identity does not waive that privilege as to any other
source. The content of the information furnished to the Division, and the Division's evaluation of
it, is protected by the law-enforcement privilege, the deliberative-process privilege, and the work-
product doctrine (Stone Decl. 2-3, 5). Defendant objects that the interrogatory is cumulative of
First Set Interrogatory No. 11, answered October 31, 2025. Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(2)(C)(i). Subject
to these objections, Defendant answers as follows:

        ANSWER: Defendant's contentions concerning Glass Lewis's statements are pleaded in
the verified petition in the State DTPA Action (Dkt. 101-1) ("Pet.") 13-38 and the statements are
identified in the Answer to Interrogatory No. 17. Defendant refers Glass Lewis to its prior
identification of the Alliance for Corporate Excellence as a person who furnished information to
the Division, and to Defendant's Answer to First Set Interrogatory No. 11. As stated there, counsel
for the Alliance identified only, and generally, the Alliance's belief that Glass Lewis makes false
or misleading statements to its customers. Besides the Alliance for Corporate Excellence, no other
person furnished information to the Division concerning Glass Lewis's statements.

      INTERROGATORY NO. 20: Identify each Texas-based client of Glass Lewis that has
complained to You about Glass Lewis, and for each, state the date of the complaint, the person
who made it, the manner in which it was communicated, and its substance.

       OBJECTIONS: Defendant objects that the interrogatory seeks information that is not
relevant to the as-applied challenge or proportional to the needs of this case. Fed. R. Civ. P.
26(b)(1). Defendant objects that the identity of persons, other than the Alliance for Corporate
Excellence, whose identity Defendant has disclosed, who furnished information to the Division,
and documents tending to reveal their identity, are protected by the informer's privilege (Stone
Decl. 4); Defendant's disclosure of the Alliance's identity does not waive that privilege as to any
other source. The content of the information furnished, and the Division's evaluation of it, is


Defendant AG’s Supplemental Objections & Responses to Plaintiff’s 2nd ROGs & RFPs                4


   Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26      Page 12 of 119


protected by the law-enforcement privilege, the deliberative-process privilege, and the work-
product doctrine (Stone Decl. 2-3, 5). Defendant objects that the interrogatory is cumulative and
duplicative of First Set Interrogatory No. 11 and of Interrogatory No. 14 of this Set. Fed. R. Civ.
P. 26(b)(2)(C)(i). Subject to these objections, Defendant answers as follows:

       ANSWER: Defendant has not received a complaint about Glass Lewis from any person it
knows to be a Texas-based client of Glass Lewis. Defendant is not aware that the Alliance for
Corporate Excellence, identified in Defendant's answer to First Set Interrogatory No. 11, is a client
of Glass Lewis, and does not have information regarding its state of organization or principal place
of business.


Defendant AG’s Supplemental Objections & Responses to Plaintiff’s 2nd ROGs & RFPs                 5


   Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26      Page 13 of 119


SUPPLEMENTAL OBJECTIONS AND RESPONSES TO SECOND SET OF REQUESTS
                       FOR PRODUCTION


        REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION NO. 24: All documents concerning any complaint,
report, or communication received by the Office of the Attorney General from any consumer,
customer, company, or shareholder asserting that Glass Lewis made a false or misleading
statement, and all documents sufficient to show any deception or harm You contend resulted.

        OBJECTIONS: Defendant objects that the Division's complaint intake is not relevant to
the as-applied challenge or proportional to the needs of this case. Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(1).
Defendant objects that the identity of any person, other than the Alliance for Corporate Excellence,
who furnished such information is protected by the informer's privilege, and that the content of
any such materials and the Division's evaluation of them are protected by the law-enforcement
privilege, the deliberative-process privilege, and the work-product doctrine as part of the Division's
confidential DTPA investigative file (Stone Decl. 2-5). Defendant objects that the request is
cumulative of First Set Request Nos. 11, 12, and 13. Defendant refers Glass Lewis to the Answers
to Interrogatory Nos. 14 and 17. Subject to these objections, Defendant responds as follows:

        RESPONSE: Defendant refers Glass Lewis to its prior identification of the Alliance for
Corporate Excellence and to the Answer to Interrogatory No. 14. Other than the Alliance for
Corporate Excellence, Defendant has identified no other person who furnished such information.
After a diligent search, Defendant has no documents to produce.

       REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION NO. 27: All communications and documents
exchanged between You and the Alliance for Corporate Excellence, Foley & Lardner LLP, or
Peter Loh concerning Glass Lewis, proxy advisors, or S.B. 2337.

        OBJECTIONS: Defendant objects that communications between Office counsel and
counsel for the Alliance for Corporate Excellence, which has since appeared as amicus curiae in
this action, Dkt. 26, were exchanged in furtherance of a common legal interest in defending S.B.
2337 and are protected work product. Defendant further objects that the informer's privilege
protects the identity of any source other than the Alliance, whose identity Defendant has disclosed,
and that communications reflecting the motive behind S.B. 2337's enactment are not relevant to
the as-applied challenge. Subject to these objections, Defendant responds as follows:
        RESPONSE: Defendant is withholding the communications with counsel for the Alliance
identified on its privilege log and has located no other responsive communications.


Defendant AG’s Supplemental Objections & Responses to Plaintiff’s 2nd ROGs & RFPs                  6


   Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26     Page 14 of 119


                                        VERIFICATION

       I, Assistant Attorney General Joe Nwaokoro, am authorized to make this verification on

behalf of Defendant. I have read the foregoing answers to Plaintiff’s Second Set of Interrogatories,

and the factual statements in them are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information,

and belief, based on information assembled by authorized personnel of the Office of the Attorney

General.


Executed on October 23, 2026.
                                              /s/ Joe Nwaokoro
                                              JOE NWAOKORO
                                              Assistant Attorney General


Defendant AG’s Supplemental Objections & Responses to Plaintiff’s 2nd ROGs & RFPs                7


Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA   Document 111-1   Filed 10/26/26   Page 15 of 119


                    EXHIBIT B


DEFENDANT'S SECOND AMENDED PRIVILEGE LOG — Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC v. Paxton, No. 1:25-cv-01153-ADA (W.D. Tex.); Oct. 23, 2026
Key: AC = attorney-client privilege; WP = work product (Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(3)); DPP = deliberative-process privilege; CI = common-interest doctrine (asserted only as the basis on which disclosure to an aligned, non-adversary third party did not waive work product; not an independent ground of withholding); * =
attorney. This log amends and replaces the previous privilege logs dated October 16 and October 20, 2026, and is supported by the Declaration of Johnathan Stone (Dkt. 101-2).


 No.    Doc. ID / Bates            Date(s)                             Type                          Author (* = attorney)                          Recipients (To / CC)                                            Description and basis                           Protection                       Treatment
  1 DOC000051 (version 1 of 8/11/2025                          Word memorandum                Christopher Molak*                         CPD management and executive,                   First draft of the internal memorandum from a Division attorney to       AC; WP; DPP                 Withhold
     3)                                                                                                                                  including Johnathan Stone (Division             Division management providing legal analysis and enforcement
                                                                                                                                         Chief) and Jerry Bergman (Deputy                recommendations concerning proxy advisors under the DTPA,
                                                                                                                                         Division Chief); Clayton Watkins*               prepared in anticipation of enforcement litigation. Predecisional draft
                                                                                                                                         (Assistant Attorney General); Jennifer          reflecting counsel's mental impressions; the later versions are withheld
                                                                                                                                         Roscetti* (Deputy Chief)                        at Entries 2 and 3.
  2    DOC000052 (version 2 of 8/14/2025                       Word memorandum                Christopher Molak*                         CPD management and executive,                   Second draft of the same internal memorandum (see Entries 1 and 3) AC; WP; DPP                       Withhold
       3)                                                                                                                                including Johnathan Stone (Division             reflecting counsel's continued revisions, legal analysis, and mental
                                                                                                                                         Chief) and Jerry Bergman (Deputy                impressions concerning proxy advisors under the DTPA, prepared in
                                                                                                                                         Division Chief); Clayton Watkins*               anticipation of enforcement litigation. Predecisional draft.
                                                                                                                                         (Assistant Attorney General); Jennifer
                                                                                                                                         Roscetti* (Deputy Chief)
  3    DOC000001 (version 3 of 8/14/2025                       Word memorandum                Christopher Molak*                         CPD management and executive,                   Final version of the internal memorandum concerning proxy advisors               AC; WP; DPP         Withhold
       3)                                                                                                                                including Johnathan Stone (Division             under the DTPA (see Entries 1 and 2).
                                                                                                                                         Chief) and Jerry Bergman (Deputy
                                                                                                                                         Division Chief); Clayton Watkins*
                                                                                                                                         (Assistant Attorney General); Jennifer
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA

                                                                                                                                         Roscetti* (Deputy Chief)
  4    AG_002098 (email 1 of 2) 9/10/2025                      Email                          Lee Winkelman*                             Christopher Molak*; Gina McDonald               Internal Division email seeking legal input on the Office's response to   AC; WP                     Produce w/ redaction
                                                                                                                                         (Division investigator)                         Glass Lewis counsel's 9/10/2025 CID email. Glass Lewis counsel's
                                                                                                                                                                                         own quoted text is produced; the request for legal input and the Office's
                                                                                                                                                                                         internal analysis are redacted.
  5    AG_002098 (email 2 of 2) 9/11/2025                      Email                          Gina McDonald (Division                    Jennifer Roscetti*; Clayton Watkins*;           Internal email within the OAG's confidential consultation on its          AC; WP                     Withhold
                                                                                              investigator); forwarded by                Scott Froman*                                   response to the Glass Lewis CID, forwarded among Division counsel.
                                                                                              Christopher Molak*
  6    AG_002108                      9/10/2025                Email                          Jerry Bergman* (Deputy Chief,              Christopher Molak*; cc Jennifer Roscetti*, Internal Division email routing the CID inquiry to the assigned Division              WP; DPP             Produce w/ redaction
                                                                                              Division)                                  Clayton Watkins*, Scott Froman*            team. Glass Lewis counsel's quoted CID text is produced; the OAG's
                                                                                                                                                                                    internal case-handling comment is redacted.

  7    AG_002110 (email 1 of 2) 9/10/2025                      Email                          Lee Winkelman*                             Jerry Bergman*                                  Forward of Glass Lewis counsel's 9/10/2025 email with the forwarding             AC; WP              Produce w/ redaction
                                                                                                                                                                                         attorney's comments. Glass Lewis counsel's text is produced; OAG
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Document 111-1
                                                                                                                                                                                         attorney's comments are redacted.
  8    AG_002110 (email 2 of 2) 9/10/2025                      Email                          Jerry Bergman*                             Lee Winkelman*; Jennifer Roscetti*; cc          Same-day reply among OAG attorneys routing the CID inquiry to the                AC; WP              Produce w/ redaction
                                                                                                                                         Clayton Watkins*, Scott Froman*                 assigned team; the internal comment is redacted; remaining text is
                                                                                                                                                                                         produced.
  9    DOC000022                      10/28/2025 (filed        Word memorandum                Jennifer Roscetti* (Deputy Chief)          Division attorneys and management               Internal memorandum reflecting OAG attorney's legal analysis and                 AC; WP; DPP         Withhold
                                      10/29/2025)                                             (author); Clayton Watkins* (listed in      within the Office of the Attorney General       mental impressions concerning S.B. 2337 and Glass Lewis, prepared
                                                                                              the document's metadata as                                                                 in anticipation of litigation.
                                                                                              custodian (document owner/last-
                                                                                              saved-by))
 10    DOC000023                      10/28/2025 (filed        Word memorandum                Jennifer Roscetti* (Deputy Chief)          Division attorneys and management               Annotated iteration of the memorandum at Entry 9, bearing                        AC; WP; DPP         Withhold
                                      10/30/2025)              (annotated)                    (author); Clayton Watkins* (listed in      within the Office of the Attorney General       interlineated comments and edits (in red and blue) from multiple
                                                                                              the document's metadata as                                                                 Division attorneys reflecting their legal feedback and mental
                                                                                              custodian (document owner/last-                                                            impressions, and incorporating supporting case-law research by Scott
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Filed 10/26/26
                                                                                              saved-by))                                                                                 Froman* (Division attorney). Opinion work product.
 11    DOC000025                      8/25/2025 (filed         Microsoft Teams                William Wassdorf* (Associate               Same participants                               Internal OAG conversation among an Associate Deputy Attorney                     DPP                 Withhold
                                      9/22/2025)               conversation                   Deputy Attorney General); Rebecca                                                          General and Office staff deliberating how OAG would implement S.B.
                                                                                              Cabrera (Compliance Analyst);                                                              2337's reporting mechanism. Predecisional and deliberative agency
                                                                                              Michael O'Leary (Data Analyst)                                                             decision-making.

 12    DOC000029                      9/14/2026                Email string                   Joe Nwaokoro*; H. Christopher              Each other; cc Stephanie Freudenberg*           Communications between OAG counsel and outside counsel for the          WP; CI                       Withhold
                                                                                              Bartolomucci* (Schaerr Jaffe,              (Schaerr Jaffe)                                 Indiana Attorney General concerning the parallel litigation defending
                                                                                              outside counsel for the Indiana                                                            similar statutes (ISS & Glass Lewis v. Rokita), exchanged in
                                                                                              Attorney General)                                                                          furtherance of a common legal interest.
 13    DOC000030                      9/15, 9/17, 9/24,        Email string                   Troy Sager (paralegal, Office of the       Each other                                      Cover emails between OAG counsel's staff and counsel for the Indiana WP; CI                          Withhold cover emails;
                                      9/28/2026                                               Attorney General); John Lowrey*,                                                           Attorney General coordinating the exchange of deposition transcripts in                              attachments are public
                                                                                              James Barta* (Indiana Attorney                                                             the parallel Indiana (Rokita) litigation defending similar statutes, in                              record
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Page 16 of 119
                                                                                              General's Office)                                                                          furtherance of a common legal interest. The attached Wieck and
                                                                                                                                                                                         Goldstein deposition transcripts and the Seventh Circuit appendix have
                                                                                                                                                                                         been produced.


14   DOC000031 (email 1 of 3) 8/4/2025               Email (PDF)                John Sepehri* (Foley & Lardner,     William Wassdorf*; Lee Winkelman*;        Originating email coordinating the defense of S.B. 2337 among Office          WP; CI   Withhold
                                                                                counsel for the Alliance for        Abhishek Kambli* (U.S. DOJ); cc Ketan     counsel, U.S. Department of Justice counsel, and the Alliance's
                                                                                Corporate Excellence)               Bhirud* (U.S. DOJ), Austin Kinghorn*,     counsel (Foley), concerning potential federal participation in the
                                                                                                                    and other Foley & Lardner personnel       litigation and the timing of the State's responsive filings, in furtherance
                                                                                                                    (Converse, Babcock, Burbach, Cabrales)    of a common legal interest.

15   DOC000031 (email 2 of 3) 8/5/2025               Email (PDF)                Lee Winkelman*                   John Sepehri* (Foley); William            Reply to the aligned-counsel group regarding the timing of the State's WP; CI             Withhold
                                                                                                                 Wassdorf*; Abhishek Kambli* (U.S. DOJ); responsive filings in the defense of S.B. 2337.
                                                                                                                 cc Ketan Bhirud* (U.S. DOJ), Austin
                                                                                                                 Kinghorn*, and other Foley & Lardner
                                                                                                                 personnel
16   DOC000031 (email 3 of 3) 8/6/2025 (two          Email (PDF)                John Sepehri* (Foley); Lee       Each other; cc Laura Hendrix (Office of   8/6/2025 exchange among aligned counsel regarding the timing of the WP; CI                Withhold
                              messages)                                         Winkelman*                       the Attorney General staff)               State's response to the preliminary-injunction motions, in furtherance of
                                                                                                                                                           the joint defense.
17   DOC000032                8/6–8/11/2025          Email string (PDF)         Lee Winkelman*; John Sepehri*    Each other; cc Laura Hendrix (Office of   Continuation of the OAG/ DOJ / Foley coordination thread regarding        WP; CI          Withhold
                                                                                (Foley & Lardner)                the Attorney General staff)               the schedule for, and the State's response to, the preliminary-injunction
                                                                                                                                                           motions, in furtherance of the joint defense.
18   DOC000038                8/4–8/13/2025          Email string (PDF)         John Sepehri* (Foley & Lardner,  Each other; cc Laura Hendrix (Office of   OAG / DOJ / Foley coordination thread arranging a call among aligned WP; CI               Withhold
                                                                                counsel for the Alliance for     the Attorney General staff); the 8/4/2025 defense counsel to coordinate the joint defense of S.B. 2337 and the
                                                                                Corporate Excellence); Lee       originating email also to William         preliminary-injunction response, in furtherance of a common legal
                                                                                Winkelman*                       Wassdorf* and Abhishek Kambli* (U.S.      interest.
                                                                                                                 DOJ), cc Ketan Bhirud* (U.S. DOJ),
                                                                                                                 Austin Kinghorn*, and other Foley &
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA

                                                                                                                 Lardner personnel
19   DOC000036                8/8–8/12/2025          Email string (PDF)         Mark W. Rasmussen*, Sidney Smith Among the same OAG and Jones Day          Email thread between OAG counsel and Jones Day exchanged after            WP; CI          Withhold
                                                                                McClung* (Jones Day); Lee        counsel; cc other Jones Day attorneys     Glass Lewis filed suit, conveying counsel's mental impressions and
                                                                                Winkelman*, William Wassdorf*    (Ferrell Keel, Charlotte Taylor, A.J.     litigation strategy for the defense and coordinating the joint defense.
                                                                                (Office of the Attorney General) Jeffries, John Henry Thompson, Hannah Opinion work product exchanged in furtherance of a common legal
                                                                                                                 Templin) and Laura Hendrix (Office of the interest.
                                                                                                                 Attorney General staff)
20   DOC000036.0001           8/12/2025              Word memorandum            Mark W. Rasmussen* (Jones Day) Office counsel (as attachment to Entry      Counsel's memorandum conveying preliminary legal analysis of              WP; CI          Withhold
                                                     (attachment to Entry 19)                                    19)                                       defenses to S.B. 2337; opinion work product.
21   DOC000037                8/8–8/12/2025          Email string (PDF)         Office counsel (Lee Winkelman*,  Among the same counsel; cc Ferrell        Joint-defense email thread with Jones Day conveying counsel's             WP; CI          Withhold
                                                                                William Wassdorf*) and Jones Day Keel* (Jones Day) and Laura Hendrix       litigation strategy for the S.B. 2337 defense; Counsel's mental
                                                                                counsel (Mark W. Rasmussen*,     (Office of the Attorney General staff)    impressions and strategy; opinion work product exchanged in
                                                                                Sidney Smith McClung*)                                                     furtherance of a common legal interest.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Document 111-1
22   DOC000039                8/8–8/14/2025          Email string (PDF)         Same participants as Entry 19       Same participants as Entry 19; cc         Joint-defense email thread with Jones Day conveying counsel's            WP; CI        Withhold
                                                                                (Office and Jones Day counsel)      additional Jones Day counsel              assessment of defenses. Core opinion work product (counsel's mental
                                                                                                                                                              impressions and legal theories) exchanged in furtherance of a common
                                                                                                                                                              legal interest.
23   DOC000041                8/8–8/14/2025 (filed   Email string (PDF)         Same participants as Entry 19       Same participants as Entry 19             Continuation of the same joint-defense thread (same participants)        WP; CI        Withhold
                              8/19/2025)                                        (Office and Jones Day counsel)                                                conveying counsel's litigation strategy and legal analysis. Opinion work
                                                                                                                                                              product exchanged in furtherance of a common legal interest.


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Filed 10/26/26


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Page 17 of 119


Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA   Document 111-1   Filed 10/26/26   Page 18 of 119


                    EXHIBIT C


  Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                 Document 111-1                Filed 10/26/26           Page 19 of 119


From:           Troy Sager
To:             LeBrun, Jared; Villari, Timothy M.; Rasmussen, Mark W.; McClung, Sidney Smith
Cc:             Callahan, Bryce; Martinez, Grant; Hann, Lily; Brumbaugh, Austin; Joe Nwaokoro
Subject:        RE: Glass Lewis v. Paxton - Defendants" Privilege Log
Date:           Friday, October 23, 2026 5:56:31 PM
Attachments:    20261023_ AG"s Supplemental Responses.pdf
                20261023_AG"s Second Amended Privilege Log.pdf
                20261023_Deficiencies in Glass Lewis" Privilege Log.pdf


Good afternoon,

Please see the attached Defendant Ken Paxton, in his official capacity as Attorney
General of Texas Supplemental Objections and Responses to Plaintiff Glass,
Lewis & Co., LLC’s Second Set of Interrogatories and Second Set of Requests for
Production.

Please see the attached 2nd Amended Privilege Log.

Finally, please see the attached Deficiencies in Glass Lewis's October 19, 2026
Privilege Log/Chart.

Please let us know if you're unable to view all three PDF files.


Thank you,

                 Troy Sager
                 Legal Assistant
                 Office of the Attorney General of Texas
                 P.O. Box 12548
                 Austin, TX 78711-2548
                 (512) 475-4263


From: Joe Nwaokoro
Sent: Friday, October 23, 2026 3:38 PM
To: LeBrun, Jared <jlebrun@yettercoleman.com>; Villari, Timothy M. <tvillari@jonesday.com>;
Rasmussen, Mark W. <mrasmussen@jonesday.com>; McClung, Sidney Smith
<smcclung@jonesday.com>
Cc: Callahan, Bryce <bcallahan@yettercoleman.com>; Martinez, Grant
<gmartinez@yettercoleman.com>; Hann, Lily <lhann@yettercoleman.com>; Brumbaugh, Austin
<abrumbaugh@yettercoleman.com>
Subject: RE: Glass Lewis v. Paxton - Defendants' Privilege Log

Good afternoon, Jared,

Thanks for your email below. I have reviewed and offer the following response:

   1. We will serve an amended privilege log this afternoon to address the concerns you raised,


  Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26         Page 20 of 119


      with each withheld item listed separately with its author, date, and recipients.
   2. We researched further and were able to locate the first two drafts of DOC000001 and have
      logged them individually.
   3. We have conformed our Interrogatories 14 and 20 objections and supplemented our
      responses to RFPs 24 and 27. We will serve our supplemental responses this afternoon.
   4. Our supplemental responses and amended log also address the specific items you raised. On
      the Alliance for Corporate Excellence, after a diligent search, we have no responsive, non-
      privileged documents to produce. Our communications with the Department of Justice, the
      Indiana Attorney General's office, and the Alliance's counsel are attorney work product, and
      the amended log reflects that basis and provides the grounds for each. Regarding the
      common-interest point you raised, we are not asserting it as a standalone privilege. It is on
      the log to explain why sharing these materials with aligned, non-adverse counsel did not
      waive the work-product protection, not as an independent ground for withholding.
   5. Turning to Glass Lewis’s own privilege log, we have identified several entries that raise the
      same issues cited in your email. These include automated system notices, the public text of
      S.B. 2337, an employee-only thread with no attorney on it, communications sent to outside
      domains and personal accounts, and entries described too generally to assess. We will
      provide, alongside our supplemental responses and amended privilege log, a chart listing the
      entry numbers, specific deficiencies, and requested cures (produce where the material is
      plainly not privileged; otherwise, substantiate or provide a fuller description).

We remain available to confer. Thanks, and have a nice weekend.
Joe


From: LeBrun, Jared <jlebrun@yettercoleman.com>
Sent: Thursday, October 22, 2026 2:35 PM
To: Joe Nwaokoro <Joe.Nwaokoro@oag.texas.gov>; Villari, Timothy M. <tvillari@jonesday.com>;
Rasmussen, Mark W. <mrasmussen@jonesday.com>; McClung, Sidney Smith
<smcclung@jonesday.com>
Cc: Callahan, Bryce <bcallahan@yettercoleman.com>; Martinez, Grant
<gmartinez@yettercoleman.com>; Hann, Lily <lhann@yettercoleman.com>; Brumbaugh, Austin
<abrumbaugh@yettercoleman.com>
Subject: Glass Lewis v. Paxton - Defendants' Privilege Log

  CAUTION - EXTERNAL EMAIL: This message originated from outside the OAG. Do not click links, open
  attachments, or act on requests unless you recognize the sender and can verify the request is legitimate.
  Report suspicious emails using the Phishing Button.

Joe, Mark, Tim,

We are writing to identify deficiencies in your privilege log.

Starting with Intervenors, you did not serve a log at all. You claimed associational
privilege over whole categories of documents, but discovery closed on October 20


  Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA        Document 111-1       Filed 10/26/26     Page 21 of 119


and you have not logged any of those withheld documents. See LUPE v. Abbott,
2022 WL 17574079, at *9 (W.D. Tex. Dec. 9, 2022) (ordering Defendant Intervenors
to produce a document-by-document privilege log for associational privilege claims).
Please confirm by the end of tomorrow that you will be serving a privilege log by
Tuesday, October 27.

For the Attorney General, we will not repeat the log issues that overlap with your
deficient production and are the subject of our motion to compel. But we reiterate that
it is wholly improper to assert a blanket privilege over the investigative file, and there
is no reason those documents could not (at a minimum) be individually logged. Even
setting aside those deficiencies, there are four issues with your log:

  1. Your privilege claims are internally inconsistent. You say that the Alliance for
     Corporate Excellence is an informant (Rog 14), but then you state that you have
     no responsive documents other than emails about this lawsuit (RFPs 24, 27).
     Those cannot both be true. You also invoke the informer’s privilege (Rogs 14,
     20), but then you name the Alliance, which renders the privilege inapplicable.
     Your log claims attorney-client privilege over emails with the Alliance, but your
     discovery responses state that these emails are work product and common
     interest.
  2. Your assertion of common interest contravenes Fifth Circuit precedent.
     Common interest applies only to “potential co-defendants.” In re Santa Fe Int’l
     Corp., 272 F.3d 705, 710 (5th Cir. 2001). The Alliance, DOJ, and the Indiana
     Attorney General are not and never have been co-defendants. In fact, the
     Alliance explicitly told the Court that it “does not seek leave to have the Alliance
     become a party to the litigation” and Indiana has disclaimed that its law targets
     ESG.
  3. Your assertions of work product are improper. To start, your log never explains
     how most documents qualify as work product. Many are routine emails about
     scheduling and have nothing to do with attorney impressions.
  4. Your privilege log is incomplete. It lists 17 items, but many of those appear to be
     logging an entire email chain with multiple parts. For example, on DOC000038,
     your October 16 log lists at least six different exchanges. DOC000001 lists
     “version 3” of a memo, but you never logged previous versions. It does not give
     the author, date, and recipients of each email. It is improper to only log the last
     message in an email chain or the final version of a document. Each responsive,
     withheld document must be separately logged.

Please confirm by the end of tomorrow that you will: (1) produce your
communications with the Alliance for Corporate Excellence; (2) produce your
communications with the Department of Justice and the Indiana Attorney General’s
office; and (3) withdraw your unsupported assertions of attorney work product; and (4)
individually log each document that is being withheld.

Best,
Jared

Jared LeBrun | Associate | Yetter Coleman


    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                              Document 111-1                       Filed 10/26/26                  Page 22 of 119


600 Travis Street, Suite 5400, Houston, Texas 77002
(D) 713.457.3093 | (O) 713.632.8000
Bio | vCard | www.yettercoleman.com
This transmission is confidential and intended solely for the person or organization to which it is addressed. It may contain privileged and confidential
information. If you are not the intended recipient, you should not copy, distribute, or take any action in reliance on it. If you have received this
transmission in error, please notify the sender at the e-mail address above.


Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA   Document 111-1   Filed 10/26/26   Page 23 of 119


                    EXHIBIT D


                           Comprehensive Deficiencies in Glass Lewis's October 19, 2026 Privilege Log


        Category                     Entries (by Glass Lewis's Log No.)                                 Deficiency


Boilerplate, uniform          Substantially all 109 entries; e.g., 1, 2, 4–7, 29–37,   Nearly every entry recites one of a handful of
"reasons"                     41–51, 58–65, 101                                        canned descriptions ("Privileged communication
                                                                                       to in-house counsel seeking legal advice";
                                                                                                                                        Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA

                                                                                       "...providing legal advice"; "Attorney work
                                                                                       product ... regarding regulatory updates"),
                                                                                       without the subject matter needed to test the
                                                                                       claim. Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(5)(A).


No attorney identified /      1, 2, 4–7, 11, 14, 15, 66, 70                            The From/To fields show only Glass Lewis
employee-to-employee                                                                   business personnel, with no attorney named;
                                                                                                                                        Document 111-1
                                                                                       entries 14–15 are expressly logged as a
                                                                                       "communication between employees regarding
                                                                                       review by in-house counsel." A communication
                                                                                       among non-lawyers is not privileged merely
                                                                                       because it mentions counsel.
                                                                                                                                        Filed 10/26/26
Automated system              26, 82, 85, 86                                           Machine-generated alerts logged as privileged—
notifications                                                                          a Slack "You've got 3 unread messages" notice
                                                                                       (26) and SharePoint "Administrator has
                                                                                       responded"/"replied to a comment" notices (82,
                                                                                       85, 86). These carry no legal advice and no
                                                                                       attorney input.
                                                                                                                                        Page 24 of 119


Public statute attachment   53, 55, 72                                       "Texas Bill_SB02337F.pdf"—the enacted public
                                                                             text of S.B. 2337—withheld as attorney-client
                                                                             privileged. Attaching a public statute to an email
                                                                             does not make it privileged.


Work product with no        3, 8, 9, 10, 16–25                               Materials from November 2020, October 2021,
litigation anticipated                                                       March 2024, and April 2025—all predating the
                                                                             CID (August 2025) and the State DTPA Action
                                                                             (July 2026)—logged as "attorney work product,"
                                                                                                                                  Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA

                                                                             several as routine "regulatory update" briefings.
                                                                             Work product requires that the document be
                                                                             prepared because of anticipated litigation.


Disclosure to outside       16, 18, 24, 40, 104, 106, 107                    Materials sent to non-Glass Lewis domains
domains / personal                                                           (firstnational.ca, smithfc.ca, pelotoncm.com)
accounts                                                                     and personal accounts (kcameron@gmail.com; a
                                                                                                                                  Document 111-1
                                                                             yahoo.com account), with nothing on the log
                                                                             showing a common interest or that
                                                                             confidentiality was maintained. Disclosure to
                                                                             third parties ordinarily waives the privilege.


Drafts for publication or   27–45 (incl. "GL Blog Post – DRAFT.docx," 39),   Press-query, blog-post, and client-                  Filed 10/26/26
client distribution         73–81, 87–104                                    communication drafts ("Draft response for client
                                                                             inquiries," "Client Communication Pertaining to
                                                                             Texas Legislation," "Glass Lewis Client
                                                                             Communication: Texas Senate Bill 2337").
                                                                             Material prepared for public or client
                                                                             dissemination is not privileged as to its
                                                                             intended-to-be-disclosed content.                    Page 25 of 119


 Factual status broadcast to   52, 54, 56–66                                           "Texas Proxy Advisor Bill – Final Legislative
 wide internal lists                                                                   Step Completed," a factual status email blasted
                                                                                       to eleven-plus executives, logged as privileged
                                                                                       along with its public-statute attachment.


 Missing metadata (Rule        e.g., 3, 9, 10, 27, 63, 67–69, 74, 77–80, 90, 92, 94,   Numerous entries omit author, recipients, and/or
 26(b)(5)(A))                  95, 98, 99                                              Bates numbers, making it impossible to assess
                                                                                       the claim or even confirm the document's
                                                                                       participants.
                                                                                                                                          Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA


       Note: This exhibit shows the deficiencies in Glass Lewis's own log comprehensively. Exhibit ( is the narrower, category-

by-category deficiency chart the Attorney General served on Glass Lewis on October 23, 2026.

                                                                                                                                          Document 111-1


                                                                                                                                          Filed 10/26/26


                                                                                                                                          Page 26 of 119


Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA   Document 111-1   Filed 10/26/26   Page 27 of 119


                    EXHIBIT E


ENCLOSURE — Deficiencies in Glass Lewis's October 19, 2026 Privilege Log
Glass, Lewis & Co. v. Paxton, No. 1:25-cv-01153-ADA (W.D. Tex.)
The entries are grouped by the problems they share. The OAG asks Glass Lewis to produce each document or back up the claim, entry by entry, as Glass Lewis has asked of the OAG. Where the

Category 1 — Automated notifications (Produce)
Entry No(s).      Document / Subject                                        Problem                                                Our ask
26                Slack alert, "You've got 3 unread messages," from         A system-generated alert is not a request for or a     Produce. If any attorney text is embedded, redact and
                  notification@slack.com to C. Gustitus; logged             delivery of legal advice, and it carries no attorney   produce the rest.
                  Attorney-Client                                           input.
82, 85, 86        SharePoint "no-reply@sharepointonline.com"                Machine-generated access and comment alerts are        Produce. Redact any embedded attorney comment rather
                  notices ("Administrator has responded to your             not privileged communications.                         than withhold the entire notice.
                  request"; "Gordon Seymour replied to a comment");
                  logged Work Product and Attorney-Client
                                                                                                                                                                                                  Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA


Category 2 — Public statute attachments (Produce)
Entry No(s).         Document / Subject                                     Problem                                                Our ask
53, 55, 72           "Texas Bill_SB02337F.pdf"; logged Attorney-Client      This is the enacted text of S.B. 2337. Attaching a     Produce, or stipulate that the attachment is the public bill
                                                                            public statute to an email does not make it            and drop it from the log.
                                                                            privileged.

Category 3 — Business emails with no lawyer on them (Produce)
Entry No(s).        Document / Subject                                      Problem                                             Our ask
                                                                                                                                                                                                  Document 111-1

14, 15              "Tesla Response to Proxy Paper" (Lili Mehta and         Both are employees, no lawyer is on the thread, and Produce. If attorney text was added later in the chain, redact.
                    Brianna Castro); logged Attorney-Client / Privileged-   the log itself calls them a "communication between
                    Redacted                                                employees regarding review by in-house counsel."


Category 4 — Sent to outside domains and personal accounts
Entry No(s).         Document / Subject                                     Problem                                              Our ask
16, 18               "Regulatory Update" from N. Garzon to outside          Sent to non-Glass Lewis domains (firstnational.ca,   Identify who each outside recipient is and why they are inside
                                                                                                                                                                                                  Filed 10/26/26
                    recipients; logged Attorney Work Product and            smithfc.ca, pelotoncm.com) and a personal account, the privilege, or produce.
                    Attorney-Client                                         with nothing in the log showing a common interest or
                                                                            that confidentiality was kept.

106, 107             "FW: Glass Lewis Client Communication: Texas Senate Forwarded to pelotoncm.com, firstnational.ca,             Same: identify the recipients and the basis, or produce.
                     Bill 2337" from B. Mann to outside recipients       smithfc.ca, a yahoo.com account, and
                     (PLF0010753-56, PLF0010765-68); logged Attorney- kcameron@gmail.com, again with no common-
                     Client / Privileged-Redacted                        interest or confidentiality showing.
                                                                                                                                                                                                  Page 28 of 119
24, 25               "FW: Regulatory Update" and its attachment, from       Counsel's analysis was forwarded to an executive's     Confirm that the account belongs to Kevin Cameron and that
                     President C. Busch to kcameron@gmail.com; logged       personal Gmail account.                                the personal account was used consistent with Glass Lewis's
                     Attorney-Client                                                                                               confidentiality practices. If not, produce.


Category 5 — Work product with no litigation in sight
Entry No(s).       Document / Subject                                        Problem                                                 Our ask
3, 8, 9            "GL RAC Policy Meeting" materials about regulatory        These are from 2020 and 2021, well before any           Withdraw the work-product claim, or produce the factual
                   updates (Nov. 2020 and Oct. 2021); logged Work            litigation, and read as routine regulatory briefings.   portions.
                   Product                                                   Work product requires that the document be
                                                                             prepared because of litigation.
16-23                April 2025 "Regulatory Update" and "Regulatory          The log does not show that these were prepared          Establish that litigation was anticipated (dates, the claims
                     Updated.pptx" to the board and executive team;          because of anticipated litigation.                      expected, and that the documents were prepared because of
                     logged Work Product and Attorney-Client                                                                         it), or drop the work-product claim and produce the factual
                                                                                                                                     portions.

Category 6 — Drafts for publication or clients, and status emails
Entry No(s).         Document / Subject                                      Problem                                               Our ask
                                                                                                                                                                                                     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA

27-45                "press query - Texas SB 2337" chain and the "Blog       These look like public-relations and drafting work,   State whether the drafts were meant for publication or for
                     Post on Texas Proxy Advisor Bill?" thread and draft     and some of the drafts appear meant for publication. clients, and produce the business and PR text with narrow
                     ("GL Blog Post - DRAFT.docx," #39); logged Attorney-                                                          redactions for actual legal advice.
                     Client, some Work Product
73-81; 89-97; 102- "Texas write up," "Client note," "Client                  These read as client-facing material, where privilege Segregate and produce the parts meant for clients; log
104                  Communication Pertaining to Texas Legislation," and is thin as to what was meant to go out.                   counsel's input separately with a real basis.
                     "Draft response for client inquiries"; logged Attorney-
                     Client / Work Product
52-65                "Texas Proxy Advisor Bill - Final Legislative Step   This is a factual status email to a wide internal list,    Produce the status text and the public attachment; redact any
                                                                                                                                                                                                     Document 111-1

                     Completed" broadcast and its bill attachment; logged and the attachment is public.                              attorney opinion.
                     Attorney-Client, some Work Product


Category 7 — Entries too thin to evaluate (Rule 26(b)(5)(A))
Entry No(s).         Document / Subject                                      Problem                                                 Our ask
4-7; 12-13; 105-109 Repeated one-liners such as "Privileged                  These say nothing about the subject, so we cannot       Add the subject of the advice (for example, "legal advice on
                     communication to in-house counsel seeking legal         test the claim; some leave out the attorney's role.     S.B. 2337 compliance as to [topic]") and name the attorney by
                                                                                                                                                                                                     Filed 10/26/26
                     advice" and "Privileged-Redacted"                                                                               role. We are not asking you to combine duplicates.


                                                                                                                                                                                                     Page 29 of 119


Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA   Document 111-1   Filed 10/26/26   Page 30 of 119


                    EXHIBIT F


                        Glass Lewis's Second-Set Discovery Requests That Duplicate Its First Set

                                                                                               Nature of Duplication (per the
 Second-Set                                          Duplicative First-Set Request
                           Subject                                                              Attorney General's served
  Request                                           (served/answered Oct. 31, 2025)
                                                                                                         objection)


                Identify each Texas person
                                                                                             Objected as "cumulative of First Set
                the Attorney General              First Set Interrogatory No. 11 (persons
Interrogatory                                                                                Interrogatory No. 11, answered
                contends Glass Lewis              who complained about Glass Lewis's
                                                                                                                                    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA

No. 14                                                                                       October 31, 2025," citing Rule
                "deceived or misled," and         statements)
                                                                                             26(b)(2)(C)(i).
                describe the statement.


                Identify communications
                                                  First Set Request for Production No.       Objected as cumulative of First Set
                with other States' attorneys
                                                  21 (communications with other state        RFP No. 21; the answer expressly
Interrogatory   general, the SEC, FTC, or
                                                  attorney general offices re S.B. 2337,     "supplements Defendant's October
                                                                                                                                    Document 111-1
No. 16          DOL concerning proxy
                                                  Glass Lewis, or proxy advisory             31, 2025 response to First Set
                advisors, Glass Lewis, ESG,
                                                  services)                                  Request for Production No. 21."
                DEI, or S.B. 2337.


                Identify each statement by                                                   Objected as "cumulative of First Set
                                                  First Set Interrogatory No. 1 (all false
Interrogatory   which Glass Lewis represents                                                 Interrogatory No. 1, answered
                                                                                                                                    Filed 10/26/26
                                                  or misleading statements the Attorney
No. 17          its advice is made in its                                                    October 31, 2025," citing Rule
                                                  General asserts Glass Lewis made)
                customers' financial interests.                                              26(b)(2)(C)(i).


Interrogatory   Identify each Texas-based         First Set Interrogatory No. 11 (persons    In the Oct. 23 Supplemental
No. 20          Glass Lewis client that           who complained about Glass Lewis's         Response, objected as "cumulative
                complained to the Attorney        statements, with dates and                 and duplicative of First Set
                                                                                                                                    Page 31 of 119


                                                                                            Nature of Duplication (per the
 Second-Set                                         Duplicative First-Set Request
                           Subject                                                           Attorney General's served
  Request                                          (served/answered Oct. 31, 2025)
                                                                                                      objection)


                General, with date, person,      descriptions); and Second-Set            Interrogatory No. 11 and of
                manner, and substance.           Interrogatory No. 14                     Interrogatory No. 14 of this Set,"
                                                                                          citing Rule 26(b)(2)(C)(i) — i.e.,
                                                                                          duplicative of both a first-set
                                                                                          request and another second-set
                                                                                                                                  Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA


                                                                                          request.


                Identify each investigative or                                            Objected that, as to S.B. 2337, the
                                                 First Set Interrogatory Nos. 7 and 8
Interrogatory   enforcement step concerning                                               interrogatory is "cumulative of First
                                                 (steps taken before and after Sept. 1,
No. 22          Glass Lewis between Jan. 1,                                               Set Interrogatory Nos. 7 and 8,
                                                 2025 to enforce S.B. 2337)
                2023 and July 24, 2026.                                                   answered October 31, 2025."
                                                                                                                                  Document 111-1


                Identify each Texas
                                                 First Set Request for Production No.
                consumer or company that
Interrogatory                                    13 (documents showing harm to Texas      Objected as "cumulative of First Set
                allegedly suffered monetary
No. 24                                           companies/shareholders from Glass        Request for Production No. 13."
                harm from a Glass Lewis
                                                 Lewis's statements)
                                                                                                                                  Filed 10/26/26
                statement.


                                                 First Set Requests Nos. 3, 11, and 12
Request for     All documents concerning         (CIDs to proxy advisors; documents       Objected as "cumulative of First Set
Production      any investigation, CID, or       evidencing Glass Lewis's alleged false   Request Nos. 3, 11, and 12."
No. 22          inquiry concerning Glass         statements)                                                                      Page 32 of 119


                                                                                        Nature of Duplication (per the
 Second-Set                                     Duplicative First-Set Request
                        Subject                                                          Attorney General's served
  Request                                      (served/answered Oct. 31, 2025)
                                                                                                  objection)


              Lewis, including the
              investigative file.


              All documents concerning
                                                                                                                             Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA

              any complaint or               First Set Requests Nos. 11, 12, and 13
Request for
              communication that Glass       (documents evidencing                    Objected as "cumulative of First Set
Production
              Lewis made a false or          false/misleading statements and          Request Nos. 11, 12, and 13."
No. 24
              misleading statement, and      resulting harm)
              resulting harm.


              All documents supporting the
                                                                                                                             Document 111-1
                                             First Set Requests Nos. 9, 10, 11, and
              contention that Glass Lewis
Request for                                  12 (documents supporting the
              represents its                                                          Objected as "cumulative of First Set
Production                                   "maximize returns / minimize risks"
              recommendations are made                                                Request Nos. 9, 10, 11, and 12."
No. 30                                       assertions and the false-statement
              in its customers' financial
                                             contentions)
              interests.                                                                                                     Filed 10/26/26


Request for   All documents prepared by      First Set Requests Nos. 1, 5, and 6      Objected that, as to S.B. 2337, the
Production    Division investigators         (documents re S.B. 2337 and its          request is "cumulative of First Set
No. 32        McDonald, Hanlan, or           interpretation/enforcement)              Request Nos. 1, 5, and 6."
              Vasquez concerning proxy
                                                                                                                             Page 33 of 119


                                                                                      Nature of Duplication (per the
 Second-Set                                   Duplicative First-Set Request
                        Subject                                                        Attorney General's served
  Request                                    (served/answered Oct. 31, 2025)
                                                                                                objection)


              advisors, Glass Lewis, or
              S.B. 2337.


              All documents reviewed by    First Set Requests Nos. 3, 11, and 12
Request for
                                                                                                                           Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA

              McDonald, Hanlan, or         (CIDs to proxy advisors; documents       Objected as "cumulative of First Set
Production
              Vasquez in investigating     evidencing Glass Lewis's alleged false   Request Nos. 3, 11, and 12."
No. 34
              Glass Lewis.                 statements)


              All documents concerning
              any statement of intent to
Request for                                First Set Request No. 18 (documents
              investigate, sue, or take                                             Objected as "cumulative of First Set
                                                                                                                           Document 111-1
Production                                 showing statements of any intent to
              enforcement action against                                            Request No. 18."
No. 36                                     enforce against proxy advisors)
              Glass Lewis or any proxy
              advisor.

                                                                                                                           Filed 10/26/26


                                                                                                                           Page 34 of 119


Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA   Document 111-1   Filed 10/26/26   Page 35 of 119


                    EXHIBIT G


       The Requests Glass Lewis Claims the Attorney General “Refused,” and the Attorney General’s Actual Responses

       Glass Lewis’s Motion color-codes the Attorney General’s Second-Set Interrogatories 14–25 and Requests for Production 22–36

as “substantive refusal[s]” and claims that he “substantively answered none” of his interrogatories and produced only Glass Lewis’s and

ISS’s own documents. Dkt. 109 at 2–4.

       The chart below pairs each request with the Attorney General’s operative responses: his First Amended Objections and

Responses served October 16, 2026, as superseded by his Second Amended Responses on October 20 and supplemented on October 23,
                                                                                                                                          Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA


2026. Dkt. 109-3 (Ex. 2); Nwaokoro Resp. Decl. Ex. A (Oct. 23 Supplemental Responses). The rows for Interrogatories 14 and 20 and

Requests for Production 24 and 27 reflect the October 23 Supplemental Responses, which supersede those four responses; the remaining

rows reflect the October 16 responses carried forward on October 20. Together they answer the relevant interrogatories, state for each
                                                                                                                                          Document 111-1
request whether material is withheld and why, and produce responsive, non-privileged documents at Bates range AG 002090–AG

003289 (the ~1,200-page October 16 production). Only the separate DTPA investigative file and enforcement-motive material is

withheld, on stated grounds.

                                   Glass Lewis’s       The Attorney General’s Operative Response (Second              Answered /
                                                                                                                                          Filed 10/26/26
           Request
                                      Claim                  Amended, Oct. 20; Supplemented Oct. 23)                  Produced
 Interrog. 14 (persons             “Substantively      (Oct. 23 Suppl.) Identifies the Alliance for Corporate          Answered
 deceived)                        answered none.”      Excellence and states that, besides the Alliance, no other
                                                       person furnished the Division information about Glass
                                                       Lewis’s statements; refers to the verified DTPA petition
                                                       ¶¶ 13–38 and the thirteen statements quoted in
                                                                                                                                          Page 36 of 119
                                                       Interrogatory 17. Suppl. Resp.; Resp. Decl. Ex. A.


Interrog. 15 (decision to file   Refusal   States the fact and date of filing on the public Collin    Answered, in part
DTPA suit)                                 County docket; withholds only privileged charging
                                           deliberations. Ex. 2 at 4.
Interrog. 16                     Refusal   States that a diligent search identified no responsive,       Answered
(communications with other                 non-privileged SEC, FTC, or DOL communications and
AGs/SEC/FTC/DOL)                           that none are known; any AG-to-AG coordination is
                                           withheld as work product/common-interest. Ex. 2 at 5.
Interrog. 17 (statements re      Refusal   Identifies thirteen specific, quoted Glass Lewis public    Answered in full
financial-interest                         statements. Ex. 2 at 5–6.
                                                                                                                          Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA

representations)
Interrog. 18 (Texas-directed     Refusal   States the contention is at issue in the Collin County      Answered by
conduct)                                   DTPA action (personal jurisdiction). Ex. 2 at 7.               reference
Interrog. 19 (investigative      Refusal   Withholds the Division’s DTPA investigative steps as       Withheld, grounds
steps)                                     privileged and outside scope. Ex. 2 at 7.                        stated
Interrog. 20 (Texas clients      Refusal   (Oct. 23 Suppl.) States the Attorney General has not       Answered in full
who complained)                            received a complaint about Glass Lewis from any
                                                                                                                          Document 111-1

                                           person he knows to be a Texas-based client of Glass
                                           Lewis. Suppl. Resp.; Resp. Decl. Ex. A.
Interrog. 21 (acts violating     Refusal   States the contentions are set out in the State’s Collin    Answered by
DTPA)                                      County petition. Ex. 2 at 8.                                  reference
Interrog. 22                     Refusal   States the Office has taken no step to enforce S.B. 2337   Answered, in part
(investigative/enforcement                 since the injunction; withholds DTPA-matter steps as
                                                                                                                          Filed 10/26/26

steps 2023–2026)                           privileged/outside scope. Ex. 2 at 8.
Interrog. 23 (timing of the      Refusal   States the CID’s issuance and date appear in the CID          Answered
CID)                                       itself, which Glass Lewis already introduced into the
                                           record; Division’s CID authority predates S.B. 2337.
                                           Ex. 2 at 8–9.
Interrog. 24 (monetary           Refusal   States DTPA harm and damages are at issue in Collin        Withheld, grounds
                                                                                                                          Page 37 of 119

harm)                                      County, not in the as-applied challenge. Ex. 2 at 9.            stated


Interrog. 25 (basis for          Refusal          Declines a narrative of enforcement/political motive as           Answered by
public statements)                                irrelevant to the as-applied challenge; any factual basis          reference
                                                  is in the public record. Ex. 2 at 9.
RFP 22 (investigative          “Withholds         Produces responsive non-privileged documents at AG                Produced +
file/CID)                   investigative file    002090–AG 003289; states it is withholding the DTPA              withhold stated
                            wholesale … does      investigative file and CID materials on scope grounds.
                             not list it on his   Ex. 2 at 10.
                             privilege log.”
RFP 23 (ISS investigative        Refusal          States it will not produce; the ISS file belongs to the         Withheld, grounds
                                                                                                                                      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA

file)                                             separate DTPA matter and a co-plaintiff, and is not the              stated
                                                  Office’s to produce absent consent/order under §
                                                  17.61(f). Ex. 2 at 10.
RFP 24 (consumer                 Refusal          (Oct. 23 Suppl.) Refers to the Alliance and to                  Answered (none
complaints)                                       Interrogatory 14; states that, after a diligent search, there       exist)
                                                  are no documents to produce. Suppl. Resp.; Resp. Decl.
                                                  Ex. A.
                                                                                                                                      Document 111-1

RFP 25 (public statements        Refusal          Produces post-June 20, 2025 public statements at AG                 Produced
re Glass Lewis)                                   002090–AG 003289; notes they are public and already
                                                  in the record. Ex. 2 at 11.
RFP 26 (pre-suit                 Refusal          Produces responsive non-privileged documents at AG                  Produced
communications with                               002090–AG 003289. Ex. 2 at 11–12.
TAB/TXSE/Jones Day)
                                                                                                                                      Filed 10/26/26

RFP 27 (communications           Refusal          (Oct. 23 Suppl.) States it is withholding the logged            Withhold stated +
with the                                          communications with counsel for the Alliance and has                logged
Alliance/Foley/Loh)                               located no other responsive communications. Suppl.
                                                  Resp.; Resp. Decl. Ex. A & Ex. B (log).
RFP 28 (June 23, 2026            Refusal          Refers to the public hearing record, equally available to         Answered by
Senate hearing)                                   Glass Lewis. Ex. 2 at 12.                                          reference
                                                                                                                                      Page 38 of 119


RFP 29 (campaign               Refusal   States public campaign-finance filings are equally         Withheld, grounds
contributions)                           available; will not produce (political motive,                  stated
                                         irrelevant/overbroad). Ex. 2 at 12–13.
RFP 30 (financial-interest-    Refusal   States the documents are equally available in Glass          Answered by
representation documents)                Lewis’s own materials and website; refers to the              reference
                                         statements identified in Interrogatory 17. Ex. 2 at 13.
RFP 31 (Texas-contacts         Refusal   Refers to the record, including Glass Lewis’s own            Produced by
documents)                               Second Amended Complaint ¶¶ 33–34; produces any               reference
                                         additional responsive non-privileged documents at AG
                                                                                                                        Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA

                                         002090–AG 003289. Ex. 2 at 13.
RFP 32 (investigator-          Refusal   Withholds the DTPA investigative file on scope;            Produced, in part
prepared documents)                      produces responsive non-privileged S.B. 2337
                                         documents, if any, at AG 002090–AG 003289. Ex. 2 at
                                         14.
RFP 33 (investigator           Refusal   Will not produce; directed at the separate Collin County   Withheld, grounds
documents re the DTPA                    action and privileged. Ex. 2 at 14.                             stated
                                                                                                                        Document 111-1

suit)
RFP 34 (documents              Refusal   Produces responsive non-privileged S.B. 2337               Produced, in part
investigators reviewed)                  documents, if any, at AG 002090–AG 003289;
                                         withholds the DTPA investigative file. Ex. 2 at 14.
RFP 35 (press/social-media     Refusal   Produces responsive documents at AG 002090–AG                  Produced
re Glass Lewis)                          003289; notes they are public and already in the record;
                                                                                                                        Filed 10/26/26

                                         duplicative of RFP 25. Ex. 2 at 15.
RFP 36 (statements of intent   Refusal   Produces responsive documents at AG 002090–AG                  Produced
to investigate/sue)                      003289; notes public statements already in the record.
                                         Ex. 2 at 15.
                                                                                                                        Page 39 of 119


Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA   Document 111-1   Filed 10/26/26   Page 40 of 119


                    EXHIBIT H


         Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA             Document 111-1          Filed 10/26/26       Page 41 of 119


                                             CAUSE NO: 471-04895-2026

    STATE OF TEXAS,                                      §               IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF
                                                         §
                        Plaintiff,                       §
                                                         §
    v.                                                   §                   COLLIN COUNTY, TEXAS
                                                         §
    GLASS, LEWIS & CO., LLC,                             §
                                                         §
                        Defendant.                       §                   471ST JUDICIAL DISTRICT

                  TEXAS’S SECOND AMENDED VERIFIED PETITION AND
              APPLICATION FOR TEMPORARY AND PERMANENT INJUNCTION

             “[R]eflects broad investor opinion and widely accepted governance principles . . . .”

             “[R]eflects the current, predominant views of our institutional investor clients on corporate
             governance best practices.”

             “[I]ndependent corporate governance research.”

             “[O]bjective, reliable, and timely advice.” 1

             Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC (“Glass Lewis”) makes these types of representations about itself

and its Benchmark Policy, the ready-made voting rules it sells to investors. 2 Yet they are all false,

deceptive, and misleading.

             Glass Lewis is one of two firms that dominate the business of advising big investors how to

vote at shareholder meetings. Its clients include pension plans and mutual funds that hold the

savings of ordinary Texans. It sends Benchmark recommendations to every client that receives its

research. 3


1
         See infra ¶¶ 58, 60, 95.
2
         See infra ¶¶ 49–50, 58.
3
         See infra ¶¶ 38, 42, 50.


                                                             1


    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 111-1        Filed 10/26/26      Page 42 of 119


        But the Benchmark Policy did not reflect broad investor opinion. For years, its rules called

for recommending votes against directors because of a board’s gender makeup. Other rules turned

on whether a board had a director “from an underrepresented community,” or on a company’s

climate or social-oversight disclosures. Its 30% gender threshold was the same one Glass Lewis

used in its separate ESG and Climate policies. Year after year, shareholders voted down almost

every environmental and social proposal. And Glass Lewis admitted that the evidence “cannot

determine the effect” of the climate and diversity proposals it backed on any individual company. 4

        Glass Lewis knew its statements were false, deceptive, and misleading. In a January 2023

letter to the attorneys general of Texas and other States, Glass Lewis claimed the Benchmark

Policy reflects its clients’ “predominant views.” But in the same letter it said that “a significant

majority of our clients have elected to simply not follow any Glass Lewis policy.” Then in October

2025, Glass Lewis admitted that “the traditional one-size-fits-all model of proxy advice no longer

meets the needs of a diverse client base.” It then published new Benchmark guidelines claiming

the policy “reflects broad investor opinion.” 5 Both things cannot be true.

        Glass Lewis also told investors its advice was independent. Its October 2025 report on

Tesla, a Texas company, listed Glass Lewis’s “Potential Conflicts.” The list left out that Glass

Lewis was then suing the Texas Attorney General over a Texas law that regulates proxy advisors.

In 2026, Glass Lewis urged the shareholders of Exxon Mobil Corporation (“Exxon”) to vote

against making Texas the company’s legal home. Exxon publicly said that Glass Lewis “failed to

disclose an obvious conflict of interest resulting from its ongoing litigation with the Texas Attorney


4
    See infra ¶¶ 64–69, 102.
5
    See infra ¶¶ 58, 61, 83, 85–86.


                                                  2


     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26       Page 43 of 119


General.” 6 Exxon’s shareholders approved the move anyway, as Tesla’s had in 2024 over Glass

Lewis’s opposition. 7

         Glass Lewis made these statements to Texans on its website, in its reports, and to the Texas

investors who pay for its services. Glass Lewis may hold any view it wants about board diversity,

climate change, or anything else. But when a business tells customers what its product is and whose

views it reflects, those statements must be true. 8

         The Texas Deceptive Trade Practices–Consumer Protection Act (“DTPA”) forbids

“[f]alse, misleading, or deceptive acts or practices in the conduct of any trade or commerce.” 9 The

State of Texas, acting through Attorney General Ken Paxton, brings this suit to stop Glass Lewis’s

deception.

                              I.      DISCOVERY CONTROL PLAN

         1.      The State intends to conduct discovery under Level 3 and asks the Court to enter a

Level 3 discovery control plan. Tex. R. Civ. P. 190.4. The expedited-actions process does not apply

because the State does not seek only monetary relief of $325,000 or less. Tex. R. Civ. P. 169(a).

                                           II.     PARTIES

         2.      Defendant Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC is a Delaware limited liability company with its

principal place of business in California. 10 Glass Lewis has been registered with the Texas Secretary


6
     See infra ¶¶ 77, 99.
7
     See infra ¶¶ 74, 77, 99, 101.
8
     See infra ¶¶ 134–137.
9
     Tex. Bus. & Com. Code § 17.46(a).
10
     Decl. of John Wieck ¶ 4 (Aug. 9, 2026), filed with Def. Glass Lewis’ Verified Special Appearance and,
     Alternatively, Mot. to Transfer Venue (Aug. 10, 2026) [hereinafter Wieck Decl.].


                                                    3


     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26         Page 44 of 119


of State to do business in Texas since November 19, 2003. 11 It applied for its certificate of authority

to pursue the “[t]ransaction of lawful business” in Texas, and it appointed a registered agent in

Austin. 12 It has filed public information reports with the State, most recently for 2024. 13

         3.       Glass Lewis has appeared in this suit through counsel, subject to its special

appearance, and may be served through its attorneys of record. Tex. R. Civ. P. 21a.

                                 III.     JURISDICTION AND VENUE

A.       The DTPA authorizes this suit.

         4.       The Attorney General brings this suit through the Consumer Protection Division,

in the name of the State and in the public interest. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code § 17.47(a). The DTPA

allows the Division to sue whenever it has reason to believe two things. First, a person “is engaging

in, has engaged in, or is about to engage in” an unlawful act or practice. Second, the suit would be

in the public interest. Id. The State alleges that Glass Lewis is engaging in, has engaged in, and is

about to engage in false, misleading, or deceptive acts or practices in trade and commerce. Id. §§

17.46(a)–(b), 17.47(a).

         5.       In a suit under section 17.47, the Court may grant temporary and permanent

injunctions that restrain unlawful acts and practices. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code § 17.47(a)–(b). The

trier of fact may award civil penalties of up to $10,000 for each violation. Id. § 17.47(c)(1). It may

award up to $250,000 more for each violation when the act or practice was calculated to acquire

or deprive money or other property from a consumer 65 or older. Id. § 17.47(c)(2). The Court may


11
     Wieck Decl. ¶ 11; Tex. Sec’y of State, Business Organizations Inquiry, Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC, File No.
     800270189, Filing History (viewed Apr. 24, 2026).
12
     Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC, Application for Certificate of Authority 1–2 (filed Nov. 19, 2003), Tex. Sec’y of State
     File No. 800270189.
13
     Tex. Sec’y of State, Filing History, supra.


                                                          4


     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26         Page 45 of 119


also award civil penalties against a defendant that violates an injunction. Id. § 17.47(e). And the

State may recover reasonable attorney’s fees and court costs. Tex. Gov’t Code § 402.006(c).

B.        Glass Lewis is subject to personal jurisdiction in Texas.

          6.      A Texas court may exercise personal jurisdiction over a nonresident when the

Texas long-arm statute allows it and doing so is consistent with due process. 14 A nonresident does

business in Texas if it contracts with a Texas resident and either party is to perform the contract

in whole or in part in Texas. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 17.042(1). It also does business in

Texas if it commits a tort in whole or in part here. Id. § 17.042(2). That list is not exclusive. Id. §

17.042.

          7.      Due process requires that the nonresident have minimum contacts with Texas, and

that the suit not offend traditional notions of fair play and substantial justice. 15 Purposeful

availment asks whether the nonresident sought “some benefit, advantage, or profit” by availing

itself of Texas. 16 Sellers that “reach out beyond one state and create continuing relationships and

obligations with citizens of another state” may be sued there on claims based on those activities. 17

The United States Supreme Court has listed soliciting business “through advertising reasonably

calculated to reach the State” among the “affiliating circumstances” that support jurisdiction. 18

          8.      Targeting Texas is the touchstone. 19 “[A] nonresident that directs marketing

efforts to Texas in the hope of soliciting sales is subject to suit here in disputes arising from that


14
     Moki Mac River Expeditions v. Drugg, 221 S.W.3d 569, 574 (Tex. 2007); State v. Yelp, Inc., 725 S.W.3d 170, 176,
     180 (Tex. App.—15th Dist. 2025, pet. denied).
15
     Int’l Shoe Co. v. Washington, 326 U.S. 310, 316 (1945).
16
     Michiana Easy Livin’ Country, Inc. v. Holten, 168 S.W.3d 777, 784–85 (Tex. 2005).
17
     Id. (quoting Burger King Corp. v. Rudzewicz, 471 U.S. 462, 473 (1985)).
18
     Id. at 786–87 (quoting World-Wide Volkswagen Corp. v. Woodson, 444 U.S. 286, 295 (1980)).
19
     BRP-Rotax GmbH & Co. KG v. Shaik, 716 S.W.3d 98, 108 (Tex. 2025).


                                                         5


     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26         Page 46 of 119


business.” 20 “[C]ertain activities over the Internet” meet that standard. 21 A defendant “need not

single Texas out in some unique way to satisfy constitutional dictates.” 22 This is so because

directing activity to every State “is no less a targeting of Texas as to whatever activity occurred

within Texas.” 23 That rule has added force when the State sues to enforce its own law. 24 And “a

truly interstate business may not shield itself from suit by a careful, but formalistic structuring of

its business dealings.” 25 That includes “explicitly structuring its transactions with Texans to take

place outside Texas while directly marketing those transactions inside Texas to Texans.” 26

Conduct that shows an intent to serve the Texas market includes “establishing channels for

providing regular advice to customers in the forum State.” 27

         9.       Glass Lewis has purposeful contacts with Texas, and the State’s claims arise out of

and relate to them. ¶¶ 10–19. The State adopts and incorporates by reference into this section the

facts alleged in Sections V and VI, which describe what Glass Lewis sold and what it told Texans.

¶¶ 30–138.


20
     Michiana, 168 S.W.3d at 785.
21
     Id.
22
     State v. Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft, 669 S.W.3d 399, 420 (Tex. 2023); Yelp, 725 S.W.3d at 185 (applying that
     rule in the State’s DTPA suit).
23
     BRP-Rotax, 716 S.W.3d at 110.
24
     See id. (contrasting a case “where no sovereign is prosecuting any case against [the defendant] for purposefully
     violating Texas law inside Texas”); Volkswagen, 669 S.W.3d at 432 (relying on “Texas’s strong interest in
     protecting its regulatory scheme, which includes ensuring faithful observance by nonresidents and vindicating
     violations of its own laws in its own courts”).
25
     BRP-Rotax, 716 S.W.3d at 107 (quoting Siskind v. Villa Found. for Educ., Inc., 642 S.W.2d 434, 437 (Tex. 1982)).
26
     Id.
27
     TV Azteca, S.A.B. de C.V. v. Ruiz, 490 S.W.3d 29, 54 (Tex. 2016) (quoting Spir Star AG v. Kimich, 310 S.W.3d
     868, 873 (Tex. 2010)).


                                                          6


     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26         Page 47 of 119


                i.          Glass Lewis markets and advertises its services to Texans.

         10.         Glass Lewis advertises its services on its website to investors across the United

States, including in Texas. 28 Its web pages are sales pages. They invite visitors to “Request More

Information,” “Download Brochure,” and “Contact Us.” 29 One tells visitors, “Contact us to

learn how we can help you make informed decisions with confidence.” 30


                         Figure 1: Glass Lewis web page inviting visitors to contact Glass Lewis

         11.         Glass Lewis asks visitors to fill out forms to download some of its materials or to

have its team contact them. 31 Its privacy statement says it may collect a visitor’s name, email

address, employer’s name, and title when the visitor contacts it or completes a registration form. 32

It may also collect visitors’ IP addresses and “geolocation information,” and it uses cookies to

learn “where a user is located.” 33 Its marketing cookies “track your activity on Our Platforms and


28
     Glass Lewis, Proxy Voting Policies, https://www.glasslewis.com/investor-solutions/proxy-voting-policies (last
     visited Oct. 18, 2026); Glass Lewis, Thematic Voting Policies, https://www.glasslewis.com/investor-
     solutions/thematic-voting-policies (last visited Oct. 18, 2026); Glass Lewis, Corporate Governance and ESG Data,
     https://www.glasslewis.com/investor-solutions/corporate-governance-and-esg-data (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).
29
     Glass Lewis, Proxy Voting Policies, supra; Glass Lewis, About Us, https://www.glasslewis.com/about-us (last
     visited Oct. 18, 2026).
30
     Glass Lewis, Corporate Governance and ESG Data, supra.
31
     Glass Lewis, Download Your Copy of the Proxy Season Briefing for the United States,
     https://grow.glasslewis.com/download-season-briefing-us-0 (last visited Oct. 18, 2026); Glass Lewis, Contact Us,
     https://www.glasslewis.com/contact-us (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).
32
     Glass Lewis, Privacy Statement (eff. June 1, 2026), https://www.glasslewis.com/privacy (last visited Oct. 18,
     2026).
33
     Id.


                                                          7


     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26        Page 48 of 119


other websites you visit.” 34 Glass Lewis says the traffic data it gathers “may be helpful for

marketing purposes.” 35 It uses personal information for “[p]roviding promotional material or

other marketing materials.” 36 Glass Lewis can thus tell when Texans visit its website, and it

markets to them. On information and belief, visitors from Texas, including from Collin County,

have visited Glass Lewis’s website and read and downloaded its guidelines, reports, and marketing

materials.

         12.      Glass Lewis currently has at least 27 clients with billing addresses in Texas. 37 On

information and belief, it has had other Texas clients in past years. It told the federal district court

in Austin that it “serves over a dozen institutional investors in Texas.” 38 Glass Lewis did not

identify those clients in the declaration it filed with its special appearance. 39 Texas public funds

buy proxy advice. ¶ 37. A Texas Senate committee has reported that Glass Lewis and one other

firm “control an estimated 97% of the market” for that advice. 40 On information and belief, Texas

public funds use, or have used, Glass Lewis’s services. ¶¶ 37, 42. Glass Lewis says that 95% of its

institutional clients renew each year. 41 Each renewal is a new sale that Glass Lewis solicits and

makes to a Texas client.


34
     Id.
35
     Id.
36
     Id.
37
     Wieck Decl. ¶ 22.
38
     First Am. Compl. ¶ 33, Glass, Lewis & Co. v. Paxton, No. 1:25-cv-01153-ADA (W.D. Tex. Sept. 9, 2025), ECF No.
     40 [hereinafter Glass Lewis Am. Compl.].
39
     Wieck Decl. ¶ 22.
40
     S.     Comm.       on     State     Affs.,    Tex.     Senate,      Interim  Report    34      (Jan.    2025),
     https://senate.texas.gov/cmtes/89/c570/c570_InterimReport_2024.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).
41
     Glass Lewis, About Us, supra.


                                                         8


     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1             Filed 10/26/26   Page 49 of 119


               ii.           Glass Lewis contracts with Texans and profits from Texas.

         13.          Glass Lewis has contracts with its Texas clients to provide its proxy advisory

services. 42 Those clients pay Glass Lewis by ACH transfer, an electronic payment drawn from the

client’s bank account. 43 Each payment moves money from a Texas client to Glass Lewis for the

services this suit concerns. Through these contracts and payments, Glass Lewis has created

continuing relationships and obligations with Texas residents, and it profits from Texas year after

year.

         14.          Glass Lewis says it did not sign these contracts in Texas, that its bank accounts are

elsewhere, and that its online systems are hosted in Virginia and Iowa. 44 That is the kind of

“formalistic structuring” that cannot shield a business that markets its services to Texans. 45

               iii.          Glass Lewis delivers its reports and recommendations into Texas.

         15.          Glass Lewis’s chief operating officer has sworn that its advice “comes in the form

of a detailed report sent to clients before a shareholder meeting.” He has also sworn that every

client who receives research gets a “Proxy Paper,” Glass Lewis’s report on a shareholder meeting.

Each Proxy Paper “sets out voting recommendations under Glass Lewis’ Benchmark Policy.” 46

Each of Glass Lewis’s Texas clients that receives research thus receives the Benchmark

recommendations this suit concerns. Those clients receive the reports and recommendations by


42
     Wieck Decl. ¶ 18 (describing “its contracts with Texas-based clients”).
43
     Id. ¶ 20.
44
     Id. ¶¶ 16, 18–20.
45
     BRP-Rotax, 716 S.W.3d at 107.
46
     Wieck Decl. ¶ 7.


                                                          9


     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 111-1           Filed 10/26/26        Page 50 of 119


accessing Glass Lewis’s online systems from Texas. 47 Glass Lewis also casts votes for clients who

ask it to, under the voting policy each client chooses. 48

         16.         Glass Lewis issues advice on the shareholder meetings of “hundreds of companies”

organized under Texas law or based in Texas. 49 In September 2025 alone, it expected to send its

more than 1,300 clients about 10 reports on Texas companies’ meetings. 50 Glass Lewis knows its

work reaches Texas. It told the federal district court in Austin that it had “accelerated the issuance

of reports into August” because of a Texas law. 51

               iv.          Glass Lewis works with Texas investment firms and directs its
                            statements to Texas.

         17.         Charles Schwab Investment Management, part of The Charles Schwab

Corporation of Westlake, Texas, has retained Glass Lewis for research, voting recommendations,

and vote execution. 52 Schwab lets shareholders of its Schwab 1000 Index Fund choose to have their

shares voted under the “Glass Lewis Benchmark” policy. 53

         18.         A Dallas investment firm, Westwood Holdings Group, says it uses Glass Lewis’s

guidelines and “generally follow[s]” Glass Lewis’s recommendations when it votes its clients’


47
     Id. ¶¶ 16, 18.
48
     Compl. ¶ 38, Glass, Lewis & Co. v. Paxton, No. 1:25-cv-01153-ADA (W.D. Tex. July 24, 2025), ECF No. 1
     [hereinafter Glass Lewis Compl.].
49
     Glass Lewis Am. Compl. ¶ 34.
50
     Id. ¶ 71.
51
     Id. ¶ 73.
52
     Schwab Asset Mgmt., Proxy Voting Policy Options, https://www.schwabassetmanagement.com/proxy-
     voting/policy-options (last visited Oct. 18, 2026); Charles Schwab Corp., Annual Report (Form 10-K) (Feb. 25,
     2026), https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/316709/000031670926000009/schw-20251231.htm (last
     visited Oct. 18, 2026).
53
     Schwab Asset Mgmt., Proxy Voting Choice FAQ, https://www.schwabassetmanagement.com/proxy-voting/faq
     (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).


                                                        10


     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 111-1           Filed 10/26/26        Page 51 of 119


shares. 54 Westwood has also adopted the Glass Lewis voting guidelines for a mutual fund it helps

manage for American Beacon Funds, a fund company based in Irving, Texas. 55

         19.      Glass Lewis has directed statements about its Benchmark Policy to the Texas

Attorney General, and it posted those statements on its website for investors to read. 56

               v.         The State’s claims arise from these contacts.

         20.      Specific jurisdiction requires “a substantial connection between [the defendant’s]

contacts and the operative facts of the litigation.” 57 It “does not necessarily require proof of

causation.” 58 The United States Supreme Court asks whether a suit “arise[s] out of or relate[s] to

the defendant’s contacts with the forum.” 59 The back half of that test, after the “or,”

“contemplates that some relationships will support jurisdiction without a causal showing.” 60

When all claims arise from the same forum contacts, a court need not analyze them claim by

claim. 61 The operative facts here are what Glass Lewis told people in Texas about its services and

its sale of those services to Texas clients. ¶¶ 56–138. The statements describe the very product

that Glass Lewis markets in Texas, sells in Texas, and delivers to each of its Texas clients. ¶¶ 10–

19. When a nonresident’s actionable statements are received and cause harm in Texas, the


54
      Westwood        Holdings     Grp.,    Inc.,     Annual     Report     (Form  10-K)     (Mar.     4,   2026),
     https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1165002/000116500226000020/whg-20251231.htm (last visited
     Oct. 18, 2026).
55
     Am. Beacon Funds, Supplement to Statement of Additional Information (Form 497) app. B, at B-43 (Mar. 7,
     2025),       https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/809593/000113322825002276/abscf-efp14988_497.htm
     (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).
56
     Letter from Kevin Cameron, Exec. Chair, Glass Lewis, to State Attorneys General 1–2 (Jan. 31, 2023),
     https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/Compliance/2023%20Letter%20to%20State%20AGs.pdf (last visited
     Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter Glass Lewis Reply to Attorneys General].
57
     Moki Mac, 221 S.W.3d at 585.
58
     Volkswagen, 669 S.W.3d at 431; Luciano v. SprayFoamPolymers.com, LLC, 625 S.W.3d 1, 16–17 (Tex. 2021).
59
     Ford Motor Co. v. Mont. Eighth Jud. Dist. Ct., 592 U.S. 351, 362 (2021).
60
     Id.
61
     Moncrief Oil Int’l Inc. v. OAO Gazprom, 414 S.W.3d 142, 150–51 (Tex. 2013); Luciano, 625 S.W.3d at 18.


                                                        11


     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1             Filed 10/26/26         Page 52 of 119


actionable conduct occurs in Texas, even if the statements come from elsewhere. 62 By enacting the

DTPA, Texas “has demonstrated a special interest in protecting its citizens from the sort of

activity” alleged here. 63 Texas has a “strong interest in exercising jurisdiction to protect its citizens

from activities that may violate the Deceptive Trade Practices Act.” 64

               vi.          In the alternative, Glass Lewis is subject to general jurisdiction in
                            Texas.

         21.         In the alternative, the Court has general jurisdiction over Glass Lewis. General

jurisdiction exists when a defendant’s contacts with Texas are so “continuous and systematic”

that it is “essentially at home” here. 65 Glass Lewis has marketed, offered, and sold its proxy

advisory services to Texans for decades. ¶¶ 10–19. It also consented to general jurisdiction in Texas

by registering with the Texas Secretary of State to do business here. ¶ 2. 66

C.       Venue is proper in Collin County.

         22.         Venue is proper in Collin County. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code § 17.47(b); Tex. Civ.

Prac. & Rem. Code § 15.002(a)(1). The DTPA allows the State to sue in any county where the

defendant “has done business” or “where the transaction occurred.” Tex. Bus. & Com. Code §

17.47(b).

         23.         Glass Lewis has done business in Collin County. It markets its services to investors

there through its website. On information and belief, Collin County residents and businesses visit

that website and read the statements alleged in this petition there and in Glass Lewis’s guidelines,

reports, and marketing materials. ¶ 11. On information and belief, Glass Lewis has clients or


62
     TV Azteca, 490 S.W.3d at 54.
63
     Siskind, 642 S.W.2d at 437.
64
     Yelp, 725 S.W.3d at 187.
65
     Yelp, 725 S.W.3d at 176 (quoting Volkswagen, 669 S.W.3d at 412).
66
     See Mallory v. Norfolk S. Ry. Co., 600 U.S. 122, 134–36 (2023); Acacia Pipeline Corp. v. Champlin Expl., Inc., 769
     S.W.2d 719, 720 (Tex. App.—Houston [1st Dist.] 1989, no writ).


                                                          12


     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA              Document 111-1           Filed 10/26/26        Page 53 of 119


subscribers in Collin County, who receive its reports and Benchmark recommendations there. ¶¶

12, 15. On information and belief, Collin County residents also receive those reports and

recommendations indirectly, through the funds, advisers, and voting-choice programs that use

them. ¶¶ 17–18, 134–135. And on information and belief, Collin County residents invest in funds

and plans, wherever based, that receive Glass Lewis’s reports or vote on its recommendations. ¶¶

36, 44–45. Each of these is an act or practice in Collin County and business Glass Lewis has done

there. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code §§ 17.45(6), 17.46(a), 17.47(b). On information and belief,

transactions at issue occurred there. ¶ 12. A substantial part of the events giving rise to the State’s

claims occurred in Collin County. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 15.002(a)(1).

         24.     Glass Lewis also issues reports and recommendations on the shareholder meetings

of public companies based in Collin County, and its clients use them to vote at those meetings. For

example, Glass Lewis issued reports recommending how to vote at the 2018, 2019, and 2021 annual

meetings of Denbury Inc., an oil company then based in Plano. 67 In 2017, Glass Lewis

recommended that shareholders of Rent-A-Center, Inc., a Plano company, elect two directors

nominated by an activist investor. Shareholders elected both. 68 Tyler Technologies, Inc., also


67
     Denbury      Res.    Inc.,  Additional   Proxy    Materials    (Schedule     14A)   (May     16,   2018),
     https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/945764/000094576418000069/dnr-2018xproxyamiss.htm             (last
     visited Oct. 18, 2026); Denbury Res. Inc., Additional Proxy Materials (Schedule 14A) (May 14, 2019),
     https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/945764/000094576419000063/dnr-2019xproxysupplementam.htm
     (last visited Oct. 18, 2026); Denbury Inc., Additional Proxy Materials (Schedule 14A) (May 13, 2021),
     https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/945764/000094576421000070/den-2021xproxysupplement.htm
     (last visited Oct. 18, 2026); Denbury Inc., Annual Report (Form 10-K) (Mar. 5, 2021),
     https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/945764/000094576421000022/den-20201231.htm (last visited Oct.
     18, 2026).
68
     Press Release, Rent-A-Center, Inc., Rent-A-Center Comments on Glass Lewis Report (June 1, 2017),
     https://investor.upbound.com/node/10946/pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026); Engaged Capital, LLC, Additional
     Proxy             Materials         (Schedule           14A)            (June          1,          2017),
     https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/0000933036/000092189517001689/dfan14a09455023_06012017.h
     tm (last visited Oct. 18, 2026); Rent-A-Center, Inc., Current Report (Form 8-K) ex. 99.1 (June 8, 2017),
     https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/933036/000119312517202205/d404599dex991.htm (last visited
     Oct. 18, 2026).


                                                       13


     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 111-1          Filed 10/26/26       Page 54 of 119


based in Plano, told its shareholders that votes on two of its directors in 2023 “were influenced by

commentary from Glass Lewis.” 69 Cinemark Holdings, Inc., another Plano company, has met with

representatives of Glass Lewis. 70 Glass Lewis also sells services to public companies, including

consulting and the right to send “Report Feedback Statements” to its clients. ¶¶ 47, 101, 104. On

information and belief, public companies based in Collin County have been solicited for Glass

Lewis’s services and some have purchased them. Each such solicitation and sale is business Glass

Lewis has done in Collin County. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code § 17.47(b).

                   IV.     PUBLIC INTEREST, TRADE, AND COMMERCE

         25.     The State adopts and incorporates by reference all preceding paragraphs and

allegations of this petition.

         26.     The Consumer Protection Division has reason to believe that Glass Lewis is

engaging in, has engaged in, or is about to engage in acts and practices the DTPA forbids. Tex. Bus.

& Com. Code § 17.47(a). They are false, misleading, or deceptive acts or practices in the conduct

of trade and commerce. Id. § 17.46(a). Those acts and practices have directly or indirectly affected

the people of Texas. See id. § 17.45(6). The Division believes that this suit is in the public interest.

Id. § 17.47(a). The State may bring it whether or not any consumer has complained or been injured.

See id. § 17.47(a), (c); ¶ 187.

         27.     The DTPA defines “trade” and “commerce” this way. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code §

17.45(6).


69
     Tyler      Techs.,      Inc.,      Proxy     Statement     (Schedule    14A)    (Mar.   29,    2024),
     https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/860731/000086073124000015/tyl-20240329.htm (last visited Oct.
     18, 2026).
70
     Cinemark       Holdings,      Inc.,    Proxy     Statement    (Schedule    14A)   (Apr.  6,    2022),
     https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1385280/000114036122013386/ny20002675x1_def14a.htm       (last
     visited Oct. 18, 2026).


                                                    14


     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                  Document 111-1             Filed 10/26/26          Page 55 of 119


         “Trade” and “commerce” mean the advertising, offering for sale, sale, lease, or
         distribution of any good or service, of any property, tangible or intangible, real,
         personal, or mixed, and any other article, commodity, or thing of value, wherever
         situated, and shall include any trade or commerce directly or indirectly affecting the
         people of this state.

         28.       Glass Lewis advertises, offers for sale, sells, and distributes proxy research, voting

recommendations, voting policies, and vote-casting services. 71 Its website is a place where it

advertises and offers those services. That is why its pages invite visitors to “Request More

Information” and to “Download Brochure.” ¶¶ 10–11. Glass Lewis has engaged in trade and

commerce directly and indirectly affecting the people of Texas at all times relevant to this suit.

         29.       The DTPA defines a “consumer” as one who “seeks or acquires by purchase or

lease, any goods or services.” Tex. Bus. & Com. Code § 17.45(4). A consumer may be an

individual, partnership, or corporation. It may also be this State or a subdivision or agency of this

State. Id. The term excludes a “business consumer” with assets of $25 million or more. Id. That

limit governs who may sue under section 17.50. It does not limit the State’s power to sue over “any

act or practice declared to be unlawful” by the DTPA. 72 Nor does it limit the civil penalties that

section 17.47(c)(1) allows. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code § 17.47(c)(1). Where a DTPA provision itself

uses the word “consumer,” the State pleads consumers who meet the definition. ¶¶ 129, 152. A

person who acquires services that someone else buys for that person’s benefit is a consumer. 73


71
     Glass Lewis, About Us, supra; Glass Lewis, Proxy Voting Policies, supra; Glass Lewis Compl. ¶ 38.
72
     Tex. Bus. & Com. Code § 17.47(a); Cameron v. Terrell & Garrett, Inc., 618 S.W.2d 535, 541 (Tex. 1981) (explaining
     that section 17.45(4) “does nothing more than describe the class of persons who can bring a suit for treble damages
     under section 17.50”); Flenniken v. Longview Bank & Tr. Co., 661 S.W.2d 705, 706 (Tex. 1983) (explaining that
     section 17.45(4) “only describes the class of persons entitled to bring suit under section 17.50”); Bourland v. State,
     528 S.W.2d 350, 358 (Tex. Civ. App.—Austin 1975, writ ref’d n.r.e.) (explaining that private suits, not the State’s,
     restrict claimants to “consumers”); Texas v. Colony Ridge, Inc., No. H-24-0941, 2024 WL 4553111, at *7 n.4 (S.D.
     Tex. Oct. 11, 2024), report and recommendation adopted, No. H-24-0941 (S.D. Tex. Nov. 26, 2024).
73
     Kennedy v. Sale, 689 S.W.2d 890, 892 (Tex. 1985) (holding that an employee covered by a group policy his
     employer bought was a consumer); Arthur Andersen & Co. v. Perry Equip. Corp., 945 S.W.2d 812, 815 (Tex. 1997)


                                                            15


     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1           Filed 10/26/26         Page 56 of 119


Glass Lewis’s Texas consumers still include individuals who seek or acquire its services through

funds, advisers, and others who buy them. ¶¶ 10–19, 135. This State and its agencies are never

“business consumers” subject to exclusion from the DTPA’s protections. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code

§ 17.45(10). So a state pension fund that buys proxy advice, as the Teacher Retirement System’s

policy requires, is a consumer of that advice. ¶¶ 36–37. On information and belief, such funds are

or have been among Glass Lewis’s Texas clients. ¶ 12.

               V.      BACKGROUND: HOW SHAREHOLDER VOTING WORKS

         30.        The State adopts and incorporates by reference all preceding paragraphs and

allegations of this petition.

A.       Shareholders own public companies and vote on how they are run.

         31.        A share of stock is a piece of ownership in a company. As the investor website of

the Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) puts it, “When you own a share of stock, you

own part of a company.” 74 Large companies whose shares anyone can buy on a stock exchange are

called public companies. Their owners are called shareholders. Shareholders do not run the

company day to day. Under Texas law, a corporation’s board of directors directs “the management

of the business and affairs of the corporation.” 75 Shareholders elect the directors, usually at an


     (holding that a buyer that required an audit was a consumer of the auditor’s services, though the company being
     sold paid for them).
74
     Investor.gov, U.S. Sec. & Exch. Comm’n, Stocks FAQs, https://www.investor.gov/introduction-
     investing/investing-basics/investment-products/stocks (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).
75
     Tex. Bus. Orgs. Code § 21.401(a)(2).


                                                         16


     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26          Page 57 of 119


annual meeting. 76 Each share usually carries one vote, so the more shares an investor owns, the

more votes it casts. 77

         32.      Voting gives shareholders the power to elect directors and to make their views

known “on significant issues that may affect the value of [their] shares.” 78 Shareholders may also

put their own proposals on a company’s ballot. A shareholder “owning a relatively small amount

of a company’s securities” can have a proposal “placed alongside management’s proposals” for a

vote. 79 Some proposals deal with how a company is run, such as proposals to elect all directors

every year or to make it easier for shareholders to call a special meeting. 80 Other proposals push a

company on environmental or social issues. At Amazon’s 2025 annual meeting, for example,

shareholders voted on proposals asking for reports on plastic packaging, greenhouse-gas emissions,

and warehouse working conditions. 81

         33.      The number of these votes has exploded. Elizabeth Ising, a securities lawyer,

testified to Congress that “the number of items voted on increased approximately 730% between

2000 and 2024 at Russell 3000 companies.” 82 The Russell 3000 is a stock index made up of


76
     Tex. Bus. Orgs. Code § 21.405(a); Investor.gov, U.S. Sec. & Exch. Comm’n, Annual Meeting (glossary),
     https://www.investor.gov/introduction-investing/investing-basics/glossary/annual-meeting (last visited Oct.
     18, 2026).
77
     Tex. Bus. Orgs. Code § 21.366(a).
78
     Investor.gov, U.S. Sec. & Exch. Comm’n, Shareholder Voting, https://www.investor.gov/research-before-you-
     invest/research/shareholder-voting (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).
79
     U.S. Sec. & Exch. Comm’n, Div. of Corp. Fin., Staff Legal Bulletin No. 14, § B.1 (July 13, 2001),
     https://www.sec.gov/interps/legal/cfslb14.htm (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).
80
     Investor.gov, U.S. Sec. & Exch. Comm’n, Investor Bulletin: Voting in Annual Shareholder Meetings—What’s New
     in 2012 (Mar. 28, 2012), https://www.investor.gov/news-alerts/investor-bulletins/voting-annual-shareholder-
     meetings-what-s-new-2012 (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).
81
     Glass        Lewis,      Proxy        Paper:      Amazon.com,        Inc.      2       (May        1,      2025),
     https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/Northern%20Trust/Amazon_PP25.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026)
     [hereinafter Amazon Proxy Paper]; Amazon.com, Inc., Current Report (Form 8-K) Item 5.07 (May 22, 2025),
     https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1018724/000110465925052014/tm2515134d1_8k.htm (last visited
     Oct. 18, 2026).
82
     Exposing the Proxy Advisory Cartel: How ISS & Glass Lewis Influence Markets: Hearing Before the Subcomm. on Cap.
     Mkts. of the H. Comm. on Fin. Servs., 119th Cong. (2025) (statement of Elizabeth A. Ising, Partner, Gibson, Dunn
     & Crutcher LLP), reprinted in Harv. L. Sch. F. on Corp. Governance (May 5, 2025),


                                                          17


     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA             Document 111-1           Filed 10/26/26       Page 58 of 119


roughly the 3,000 largest U.S. public companies. The 1,000 largest of them make up the “Russell

1000.” These votes matter to every investor. They decide who sits on a company’s board, and they

tell directors what shareholders want the company to do with its money.

         34.     Environmental and social issues, together with governance, are often called

“ESG,” short for “environmental, social, and governance.” A related term, “DEI,” stands for

“diversity, equity, and inclusion.” The President’s December 2025 order on proxy advisors treats

both as “non-pecuniary factors in investing.” 83 It states that some proxy advisors use their power

to advance DEI and ESG agendas “even though investor returns should be the only priority.” 84

B.       Institutional investors cast most of the votes.

         35.     Millions of Americans hold stock through mutual funds and exchange-traded

funds. 85 The pension plans, mutual funds, and asset managers that invest other people’s money

are called institutional investors. 86 They vote the shares they hold, and many of them owe a

“fiduciary duty to cast informed votes.” 87 Institutional investors hold most of the stock in

America. The SEC has cited an estimate that they “hold around 72% of the domestic stock market

value.” 88 In other words, about $7 of every $10 invested in U.S. stocks is held by institutional

investors. Because each share carries a vote, they cast most of the votes at shareholder meetings.


     https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2025/05/05/testimony-in-house-hearing-exposing-the-proxy-advisory-cartel-
     how-iss-glass-lewis-influence-markets-3/ (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter Ising Testimony].
83
     Exec. Order No. 14,366, 90 Fed. Reg. 58,503, 58,504 (Dec. 16, 2025).
84
     Id. at 58,503.
85
     Exec. Order No. 14,366, 90 Fed. Reg. at 58,503.
86
     Glass Lewis Compl. ¶ 32; Def. Glass Lewis’ Mot. to Dismiss Am. Pet. Under Rule 91a 1–2 (Sept. 14, 2026)
     [hereinafter Glass Lewis Rule 91a Mot.].
87
     Glass Lewis Compl. ¶ 30.
88
     Exemptions From the Proxy Rules for Proxy Voting Advice, 85 Fed. Reg. 55,082, 55,085 n.36 (Sept. 3, 2020)
     (quoting A. De La Cruz et al., OECD, Owners of the World’s Listed Companies 22 (2019)).


                                                      18


     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1             Filed 10/26/26         Page 59 of 119


         36.      Texas is home to some of the largest institutional investors in the country. The

Teacher Retirement System of Texas managed a fund worth about $225 billion as of August 2025,

and it serves more than two million Texans. 89 The Employees Retirement System of Texas

managed a fund worth about $40 billion as of August 2024. It serves more than 400,000 members,

retirees, and beneficiaries. 90 The Texas Permanent School Fund, which helps pay for Texas public

schools, has more than $64 billion in investments. It calls itself “the nation’s oldest and largest

educational endowment.” 91 The University of Texas/Texas A&M Investment Management

Company (“UTIMCO”) manages about $92 billion for the University of Texas and Texas A&M

systems. 92

         37.      Texas public funds buy proxy advice. The Teacher Retirement System’s policy

requires its board to “retain a reputable, independent proxy advisory service.” 93 The Texas

Permanent School Fund uses an “external proxy voting manager,” and its “ESG skeptical” voting

policy “is offered through Institutional

Showing the first 150,000 of 294,727 characters. Full text.