jain.com
Public record. We host this document directly; the copy served here does not depend on any third party. Retrieved November 14, 2026.
Read the documentAlso at archive.org ↗

Plus One Robotics, Inc. v. Artificial Intelligence Industry Association, Inc. — Entry #98: ADVISORY TO THE COURT by Plus One Robotics, Inc

Case: Plus One Robotics, Inc. v. Artificial Intelligence Industry Association, Inc. txwd · 5:25-cv-01197

filed September 23, 2025

What this document is

Docket entry #98 · filed November 05, 2026

ADVISORY TO THE COURT by Plus One Robotics, Inc. . (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit)(Sood, Udit) (Entered: 11/05/2026)

Who is involved

Why we have it

We follow this case because it names a company we track, although that company is not a party:

A free copy from the RECAP archive of federal court filings (mirrored at the Internet Archive), retrieved November 14, 2026. Federal court filings are public records.

URL
https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172865943/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172865943.98.1.pdf
Kind
court_filing
Publisher
RECAP
Published
2026-11-05 00:00:00-05:00
Retrieved
2026-11-14 06:51:07.846335-05:00
HTTP status
200
MIME
application/pdf
Bytes
450037
SHA-256
341303e76fb417a4913198d83b506c11c5a1e23635fa7dd37b60f64b516653ef

Document text

7 page(s), 37,136 characters, converted from the PDF's text layer · plain text.

Full text
Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB             Document 98-1         Filed 11/05/26      Page 1 of 7


                                         EXHIBIT A
                                       AIIA'S POSITION

The parties conferred on November 3 and 4, 2026. AIIA proposed an amended schedule that
reproduces every event of the Scheduling Order (Dkt. 25) and moves dates only, together with
two Protective Order provisions, and offered to withdraw its own motions without prejudice if
that proposal were adopted. Plus One accepted the dates only on condition that AIIA withdraw
the Protective Order provisions, stated that otherwise it "will oppose any adjustments to the case
schedule besides those already stipulated in Dkt. 93," and stated that it "seeks a finding that
AIIA's contentions contain nothing confidential," that it may "post the contentions online and
share them without any restriction," and that "this is a risk Plus One is willing to take." Under the
Protective Order, a party that disputes a designation requests redesignation in writing, meets and
confers within five business days, and then moves the Court within ten days, the motion being
treated as one under Rule 37; designated material remains protected unless and until it is
redesignated. (Dkt. 27-1 ¶¶ 2, 18.) Plus One has not taken those steps. The four motions, and the
application of the Protective Order to AIIA's Attorneys' Eyes Only material, therefore require
resolution by the Court.
AIIA's position on the matters requiring resolution, and AIIA's proposed schedule, are set out in
this Exhibit A, which AIIA incorporates by reference, together with Dkts. 79, 82, and 84, its
opposition to Dkt. 74 (Dkt. 92), and its replies filed November 4, 2026. Nothing in this Advisory
is a joint position. On November 3, 2026, AIIA proposed that the parties report to the Court issue
by issue rather than motion by motion, and repeated that request through the evening of
November 4; Plus One did not agree, circulated a motion-by-motion draft, and stated that it had
"nothing further to send" and that AIIA should "just fill in AIIA's portion." (Reply ISO Dkt. 84,
Exs. D, E.) AIIA reserves all rights, including as to fees and any motion that the case is
exceptional.


                                   Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB                                  Document 98-1                    Filed 11/05/26                Page 2 of 7


                                                                        AIIA'S POSITION (Joint Advisory, Dkt. 89)
Why we are here
Plus One Robotics, Inc. v. AIIA, No. 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB (W.D. Tex.) — hearing Nov. 6, 2026, on Dkts. 74, 79, 82, 84
1. The sequence the Scheduling Order set (Dkt. 25, Dec. 11, 2025 — Judge Albright's model), with the two contention dates as reset by the Order
Regarding Contentions (Dkt. 31, Mar. 31, 2026)
         AIIA                       Plus One
      preliminary             invalidity / § 112 / §                                                                                    Both
                                                                        Both                        Both                                                               Both                           Briefs
     infringement
                           → 101II(b)
                                  contentions and §                                                                             extrinsic evidence &
      contentions                     documents            →     exchange claim terms     → exchange constructions        →            experts           → narrowing conference         → Dec. 11 → Markman
                                                                       Aug. 10                     Sept. 9                                                            Oct. 30                     Feb. 26, 2027
 May 8, 2026 (Dkt. 31;       Aug. 6, 2026 (Dkt. 31;                                                                                     Oct. 9
 Feb. 9 under Dkt. 25)       May 11 under Dkt. 25)

The accused infringer discloses its theories and the documents showing how its products work before anyone takes a claim-construction position. Dkt. 31 moved the two contention dates and nothing else: Plus One's
theories (Aug. 6) still preceded the claim-terms exchange (Aug. 10).

2. The position after the May 8, 2026 Text Order (Dkt. 33) — only two dates moved, the rest stayed; a change pressed by Plus One's counsel
(Udit Sood) at the last minute, after Plus One had disqualified AIIA's expert and so prevented AIIA from complying with the May 8, 2026
deadline
                                                                                                       Plus One
          AIIA                       Both                             Both                       invalidity / § 112 / §                 Both
                                                                                                                                                                       Both                           Briefs
      infringement           exchange claim terms
                                                           → exchange  constructions            101 contentions and §           extrinsic evidence &
       contentions         → Aug. 10 — before Plus            Sept. 9 — before Plus       →      II(b) documents and      →            experts           → narrowing conference         → Dec. 11 → Markman
                                                                                                                                                              Oct. 30 — 23 days later             Feb. 26, 2027
      July 8, 2026              One's theories                   One's theories                         software                Oct. 9 — 2 days later
                                                                                                Oct. 7 (from Aug. 6)

How the two dates moved. On April 20, 2026 Plus One's objection forced the withdrawal of AIIA's expert and a certification of destruction and non-use — eighteen days before AIIA's May 8 contentions were due,
leaving AIIA no expert to review Plus One's designated material and no way to comply. Then, in the days before that deadline, Plus One's counsel (Udit Sood) conditioned a routine extension on AIIA's claims being
"dropped with prejudice" if AIIA did not inspect Plus One's source code within fifteen days — a dismissal with prejudice by private condition, without the Court's involvement, and impossible in any event given the
ten-day expert-vetting period and the expert AIIA had just been made to withdraw. (Dkt. 50 at 5–6; Decl. ¶¶ 36–37.) AIIA refused the condition; the only dates that moved were AIIA's contentions (May 8 to July 8)
and Plus One's contentions and § II(b) production (Aug. 6 to Oct. 7) — the second, for the first time, past both claim-construction exchanges. The result. Plus One's theories now follow the two exchanges instead of
preceding them. AIIA's claim terms and constructions are exchanged before AIIA has seen one page of Plus One's § 101, non-infringement or invalidity theory. The joint motion, signed by Plus One: the change "will
not impact any other deadlines." Twenty-three days remained between Plus One's theories and AIIA's final positions.

3. The sequence that exists today because of Plus One's breaches of October 7 and October 14, 2026
                                                                                                   Plus One
                                                                                             serves nothing on Oct.                                                                                 AIIA
                                                                                                                                 Plus One's expert                Plus One
          AIIA                       AIIA                                AIIA               7 — contentions, § II(b)                                                                       opening brief Dec. 11,
                                                                                                                                receives AIIA's AEO        invalidity / § 101 / non-
      infringement           exchanges claim terms                     exchanges              documents, software;
                                                                                                                                                                                        → two9 exchange
                                                                                                                                                                                               days after the Dec.
       contentions         → (Aug. 10) — no Plus           →         constructions        → then 3,006 pp. of claim-      →       theories (Oct. 14);    → infringement theories                         — "no
                                                                                                                                AIIA's expert barred           — Nov. 9, still
    (May 8 → July 8)            One theory seen                  (Sept. 9) — still none     construction evidence +                                                                            further change
                                                                                                                                      (Oct. 15)                    unserved
                                                                                             expert, no theory (Oct.                                                                             warranted"
                                                                                                       9)

Because Plus One served nothing on October 7, 2026, the accused infringer takes every claim-construction step after seeing the patent owner's theories, and the patent owner takes every step before seeing the
accused infringer's. Plus One's position is that none of this should change.


                                    Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB                                   Document 98-1                     Filed 11/05/26                 Page 3 of 7


 4. What Plus One did to get there
Mar. 20 → Apr. 20, 2026      Objects to AIIA's expert under the Protective Order; demands identification and certified destruction. By Apr. 20 AIIA withdraws the expert, certifies destruction and non-use — the
                             full remedy Plus One demanded, and the one it refuses to give now.
May 1–8, 2026                Conditions a routine extension on AIIA's claims being "dropped with prejudice" if AIIA did not inspect Plus One's source code within fifteen days — impossible under the ten-day
                             expert-vetting period. AIIA refuses and pivots: removes every software reservation and maps 82 of 86 elements to documentary and public evidence. (Dkt. 50 at 5–6; Decl. ¶¶ 36–37)
May 8, 2026                  Inverts the sequence. The extension forced by that objection moves only Plus One's contentions — to Oct. 7 — and leaves the Aug. 10 and Sept. 9 exchanges in place. AIIA's claim
                             terms now come before AIIA has seen one page of Plus One's § 101, non-infringement or invalidity theory. (Dkt. 33: "will not impact any other deadlines.")
Sept. 10, 2026               Declines the Court's offer of more time; obtains the vendor-sharing accommodation on "Amazon, Intel, RealSense … their products are accused." Court: propose changes by Oct. 1.
                             (Tr. 15, 75, 80, 82–83)
Oct. 1 / Oct. 7              Proposes nothing. Serves nothing — zero pages of invalidity, § 112, § 101 or non-infringement contentions, no prior art, no § II(b) documents. Invalidity and § 101 need nothing from
                             AIIA; Plus One has had the patents since before it sued.
Oct. 9, 2026                 Serves 3,006 pages of extrinsic evidence chosen to support theories it has not disclosed — and still has not — plus an indefiniteness expert. AIIA must disclose its expert blind.
Oct. 14, 2026                Gives AIIA's AEO contentions to its expert one minute after AIIA objects, with no Undertaking, under cover of the three-vendor accommodation — twelve days before access could
                             lawfully occur.
Oct. 15, 2026                Invokes the same Protective Order paragraph to bar AIIA's expert. AIIA's expert has seen nothing since.
Oct. 20 / Oct. 28            Files Dkt. 74 to approve the disclosure after the fact, presenting its own redline as AIIA's proposal; Dkt. 90: AIIA "surrendered" its rights; disclosure "a few days too soon"; contentions
                             "not confidential."
Nov. 3–4, 2026               Accepts AIIA's dates only if AIIA drops the Protective Order provisions; otherwise "will oppose any adjustments" — leaving the opening brief due two days after the Dec. 9 exchange.
                             "May post the contentions online … a risk Plus One is willing to take." First claims its products "do not use" SageMaker — contrary to its CTO's public statement. "Nothing further to
                             send."

5. Why a scheduling-order fix does not change the                                         6. What AIIA asks
position                                                                                   Dkt. 84 — strike and preclude. A finding that Plus One missed Oct. 7 without good cause; strike and preclude every
• The disclosure cannot be recalled. Plus One's expert has held AIIA's complete           invalidity, § 112 and § 101 contention and every prior-art item not served by Oct. 7 (Rule 16(f)(1)(C)). If the Court
     claim mapping since Oct. 14; no date undoes what he has read. AIIA's expert has      determines otherwise and rules that the Nov. 9 contentions are Plus One's preliminary contentions in full — not to be
     seen nothing of Plus One's.                                                          amended before final contentions without leave on good cause — AIIA's Dkt. 93 ¶ 4 right to supplement by Nov. 30
                                                                                          (positions, extrinsic evidence, expert topics) is preserved; expenses and fees under Rule 16(f)(2).
• Steps taken blind cannot be retaken. AIIA's Oct. 9 expert disclosure and its Oct.
     30 positions were taken without one page of Plus One's theories; a supplement         Dkt. 82 — compel and re-sequence. (1) Enter the stipulation (Dkt. 93). (2) By Nov. 9, compel technical documents other
     adds to them, it does not redo them.                                                 than source code sufficient to show how each accused product operates as to each charted element — the Attachment A
                                                                                          categories, ¶¶ 16–22 (SageMaker) among them — certified by Bates number, with a statement for any category Plus One
• Plus One has had AIIA's contentions since July 8, 2026. Four months to the Nov.
                                                                                          lacks that the documents do not exist; source code alone does not satisfy the obligation. (3) Move each date that depends on
     9 date it proposes, and the original contentions since Feb. 9 — nine months — to
                                                                                          the Dec. 9 exchange by 42 days, every event's Dkt. 25 text unchanged; AIIA's revised claim terms Nov. 30. (4) Source-code
     form its § 101, invalidity and non-infringement positions. The amendments after
                                                                                          review begins at a mutually agreed time after AIIA's expert is disclosed and approved under ¶ 5(e).
     July 8, made in response to Plus One's letters, changed minor portions of the
     charts and in every case expanded on the links and public sources already cited;      Dkt. 79 — Prof. Bretl. Sustain the objection and enter a ¶ 5(e) protective order; disqualify him or, at a minimum, bar any
     none changed the accused products or the theory of infringement. (Dkt. 67.)          further access to or use of AIIA-designated material; within three days, Plus One identifies each item disclosed and when,
• The theories are still missing. Even Nov. 9 leaves AIIA 21 days (to Nov. 30) with       and serves a certification of destruction and non-use signed by Prof. Bretl and counsel; he is bound by the Order and the
     Plus One's theories, against the months the order gave; six months from the May      Court's jurisdiction as to all AIIA material disclosed on or after Oct. 14; any substitute expert complies with ¶ 5(e);
     11 date Dkt. 25 set, and three from the Aug. 6 date Dkt. 31 set, are gone.           expenses under Rules 16(f) and 37(b).
• Plus One's own schedule locks the gain in. "No further change warranted":                Dkt. 74 — deny. The Dkt. 71 ¶ 3 accommodation was for the three vendors named on Sept. 10 (Amazon, Intel, RealSense;
     opening brief Dec. 11, two days after the Dec. 9 exchange.                           Tr. 15:11–14, 16:19–20); disclosure to anyone else, including any retained expert or consultant, is governed by the
• A breach cured at the breacher's convenience is no cure. The Oct. 14 disclosure         Protective Order.
     was willful — one minute after objection, with the transcript in hand, the ten-day    Protective Order. Confirm the Order governs AIIA's AEO material, including what was disclosed Oct. 14; AIIA's expert
     rule invoked against AIIA the next day. Moving dates rewards it.                     reviews Plus One's AEO production on the same ¶ 5(e) terms Plus One's expert enjoyed.
• The one-sided accommodation persists. AIIA's expert stays barred under ¶ 5(e)           Today: Plus One's expert has both sides' theories; AIIA has none of Plus One's; Plus One's § 101, invalidity and non-
     while Plus One's keeps AIIA's material, until the Court acts.                        infringement positions, due Oct. 7, are still unserved. A schedule change does not cure a breach from which Plus One
                                                                                          continues to gain an advantage.


                              Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB                        Document 98-1               Filed 11/05/26            Page 4 of 7


7. Why AIIA has been forced to go back and forth with Plus One — the pattern
Each negotiation has begun with a Plus One proposal that drops events the Court's existing Scheduling Order (Dkt. 25) already provides — AIIA's contentions row struck, the §
II(b) production rewritten as "supplemental … (if any)", the Oct. 7 date relabeled "Disputed" — so that AIIA must first negotiate back to the order already entered before any new
date is discussed, followed by the same proposition: the breaching party will move dates only if the other party gives up rights — or else it will "oppose any adjustments" and hold
AIIA to a claim-terms exchange and a Dec. 11 brief without having served one document. The conference the Court ordered (Dkt. 89) ended with "nothing further to send."

The two-day squeeze, twice. Under the May 8, 2026 order, two days separated Plus One's disclosure of its § 101, invalidity and non-infringement positions (Oct. 7) from
AIIA's disclosure of its experts and the topics of their testimony (Oct. 9) — disclosures that depend on knowing Plus One's positions. Under Plus One's opposition to moving the
remaining dates by forty-two days, two days again separate the Dec. 9 exchange, at which Plus One may add new claim terms and constructions, from AIIA's opening claim-
construction brief on Dec. 11. Each time, the deadline that depends on Plus One's disclosure is set two days after it; each time Plus One holds the disclosure and AIIA bears the
deadline. And, to boot, Plus One then produced nothing on Oct. 7 and told the Court AIIA "would suffer no prejudice." (Dkt. 90 at 7.) This needs to stop.

The pattern is the same one Plus One has followed with the Protective Order:
 1. Moving to unseal AIIA's AEO material without following the Order's procedure — a two-day motion (Dkt. 43, July 29, 2026) instead of the ten-day designation challenge
     of ¶ 18. (Dkt. 48 at 1–3.)
 2. Willfully disclosing AIIA's AEO contentions to its expert outside the Order — no Undertaking, no ten-day period, one minute after objection (Oct. 14) — to short-circuit
     the timeline and lock in an advantage before the Oct. 30 exchange. (Decl. ¶¶ 12–15.)
 3. Claiming the Protective Order does not apply to its expert at all — "the Sharing Order, not the Protective Order, has governed AIIA's contentions since the September
     hearing" (Dkt. 90 at 11) — while invoking ¶ 5(e) against AIIA's expert the next day. (Decl. ¶ 16.)
 4. Refusing to abide by the Order once told a dispute required the Court to act — ¶ 24 requires the party alleged to be in violation to discontinue the challenged conduct
     pending the ruling; Plus One has not, and still has not said what was disclosed to Prof. Bretl, when, or whether he has shared it or discussed it with anyone. (Dkt. 27-1 ¶ 24;
     Decl. ¶¶ 32–34.)
 5. Seeking after-the-fact "clarification" only when it became clear AIIA would protect its rights — Dkt. 74, filed Oct. 20, six days after the disclosure and without notice,
     presenting Plus One's own redline as AIIA's proposal. (Dkt. 74 at 2, 4; Decl. ¶ 30.)
 6. Seeking again, on Nov. 3–4, 2026, to unseal AIIA's AEO material without the ¶ 18 process — Plus One's price for agreeing to any date: that AIIA drop the Protective
     Order provisions; it "seeks a finding that AIIA's contentions contain nothing confidential," may "post the contentions online and share them without any restriction," and calls
     this "a risk Plus One is willing to take" — with no written redesignation request, no meet-and-confer, and no Rule 37 motion. (Dkt. 27-1 ¶¶ 2, 18; Reply Exs. D, E.)


                                   Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB                                 Document 98-1                     Filed 11/05/26                   Page 5 of 7


8. Plus One's obligation on October 7, 2026 — reproduced in full
Scheduling Order (Dkt. 25 at 2), deadline moved to October 7, 2026 by the Text Order of May 8, 2026 (Dkt. 33):
 "Plus One Robotics, Inc. serves preliminary invalidity contentions in the form of (1) a chart setting forth where in the prior art references each element of the asserted claim(s)
are found, (2) an identification of any limitations Plus One Robotics, Inc. contends are indefinite or lack written description under section 112, and (3) an identification of any
claims Plus One Robotics, Inc. contends are directed to ineligible subject matter under section 101. If AIIA amend their infringement contentions to address source code, Plus
One Robotics, Inc. may serve, within 30 days of receipt of such amended contentions, supplemental invalidity contentions that amend only those claim elements amended by
AIIA. Plus One Robotics, Inc. shall also produce (1) all prior art referenced in the invalidity contentions, and (2) technical documents, including software where applicable,
sufficient to show the operation of the accused product(s)."


Against that requirement, what Plus One has produced                                                      What AIIA asked for — and the SageMaker record
Jan. 16, 2026 — PLUSONE_000001–000793 (about 150 documents, all designated AEO). On Oct. 16               AIIA's listing of what is missing (Oct. 19, 2026, Attachment A, forty-five numbered categories keyed
AIIA identified, by Bates number, the only twelve that touch the electronic components at all:            to the charted claim elements; Dkt. 81, Ex. E at E-016–23): product and software manuals; system
PLUSONE_000001–000010 · 000013–000037 · 000082–000241 · 000244–                                           design documents and specifications; schematics and circuit diagrams; sensor and camera integration
000281 · 000358 · 000359–000365 · 000377–000379 · 000464–000474 ·                                         documents; documents showing how camera and sensor data is captured, processed and used to drive the
000475–000480 · 000485–000488 · 000489–000501 · 000541–000552                                             robot; and, for the '272 patent (¶¶ 16–22), documents sufficient to show Plus One's use of Amazon
                                                                                                          SageMaker Ground Truth "or any comparable service or tool" to generate synthetic image data, the
 Nine of them bear on operation — three camera manufacturers' published datasheets, one sales             pipelines, background-image and 3D-object databases, camera settings, labeling, and the models trained
presentation, and drawings showing how components are powered, wired and connected — and every            on that data (model versions, training logs). Plus One has had AIIA's discovery requests since March
one is a public document AIIA had already cited in its claim charts. The remaining ~138 documents are     2026 (id. at E-009).
drawings of mechanical hardware (conveyors, frames, camera mounts, servos, power-distribution
                                                                                                          The SageMaker record. Plus One's CTO and co-founder, Shaun Edwards, at Amazon re:MARS 2022:
panels) and marketing materials. No source code and no AI/ML training material were produced;
                                                                                                          "We use Amazon SageMaker Ground Truth to generate tens of thousands of labeled photorealistic
inspection was offered by appointment in San Francisco. (Decl. ¶ 17; Dkt. 81, Ex. A at A-006–07; Dkt.
                                                                                                          images of packages from various carriers, modeling pose, placement, and even surface variations like
50 ¶¶ 6–7.)
                                                                                                          stickers or labels. ... This data is used in real-life induction applications to facilitate over 1 million picks
Oct. 9, 2026 — PLUSONE_000794–003799 (117 documents, 3,006 pages), served two days after the              per day for our customers." (Dkt. 9-1 at 2; Dkt. 49 at 10–11; Dkt. 50 at 16.) AIIA's '272 chart maps each
default and reviewed by AIIA in full before the Oct. 16 conference: 17 technical publications and         element to that public record. On Sept. 10 Plus One told the Court AIIA would learn "we don't use the
textbooks on steganography, information hiding, digital watermarking and video stabilization (1,591       Amazon SageMaker" only "when they finally come and look at the source code" (Tr. 47:10–13); on
pp.); 3 video-coding and file-format standards (881 pp.); 31 dictionary and glossary definitions (187     Nov. 4 it asserted for the first time that its products "do not use" SageMaker or the RealSense ROS
pp.); 51 Apple QuickTime, file-format and codec documents (186 pp.); 7 metadata reference articles (47    drivers (Reply Ex. F at 2).
pp.); 5 ROS-bag export items including one code file (17 pp.); 2 Python/NumPy references (96 pp.). All
                                                                                                          What shows what was and was not used — documents, not code: any framework or agreement under
of it is extrinsic evidence chosen to support Plus One's own undisclosed theories; the one code file is
                                                                                                          which Plus One and Amazon collaborated to reach the re:MARS event; the SageMaker documentation
from the public GitHub repository AIIA had already cited in its contentions. Not one page shows how an
                                                                                                          Plus One received before and after the presentation; what was demonstrated, the photographs and images
accused product operates. (Decl. ¶ 10; Reply Ex. E at 2.)
                                                                                                          from those demonstrations and their documentation; the emails exchanged with Amazon about the
Nov. 9, 2026 — Plus One's position: "any additional non-cumulative documents it locates." (Dkt. 90 at     demonstration; the developers who did the work; and the model used. It is Plus One's burden to prove its
5, 10; Dkt. 90-1 ¶ 4.)                                                                                    officer's public statement untrue, with documents; the same facts are available by subpoena to Amazon;
                                                                                                          whether the public record is true is for the jury. Source code fills gaps; it does not replace the documents,
                                                                                                          and "technical documents, including software where applicable" does not read as "source code alone."
                                                                                                          (Reply ISO Dkt. 82, Part II.)


                                  Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB                                Document 98-1                  Filed 11/05/26                Page 6 of 7


9. Plus One's SageMaker use
"Creating high-quality training sets for machine learning models," AWS re:MARS 2022 (ROB225), published by Amazon Web Services at d1.awsstatic.com; 32 slides. Slide 28 is the statement quoted at Dkt. 9-1 at
2, Dkt. 49 at 10–11 and Dkt. 50 at 16. The deck is available for the Court on request.


Slide 27 — "Assembly automation": "Our synthetic data is used for robotics 'pick and place' by         Slide 28 — Shaun Edwards, CTO and co-founder, Plus One Robotics: "We use Amazon
Plus One Robotics and Amazon Robotics."                                                                SageMaker Ground Truth to generate tens of thousands of labeled photorealistic images of
                                                                                                       packages from various carriers … This data is used in real-life induction applications to facilitate
                                                                                                       over 1 million picks per day for our customers."
Plus One's position, first stated on November 4, 2026, is that its products "do not use" SageMaker (Reply Ex. F at 2). Its own officer said the opposite, in Amazon's deck, at
Amazon's conference. Which is true is a question of fact for the jury, and it is Plus One's burden to prove its officer's public statement untrue — with the documents listed in
Attachment A (Dkt. 81, Ex. E at E-016–23, ¶¶ 16–22). SageMaker is one example. Attachment A lists, element by element, the documents sufficient to show how each accused
product operates as charted — forty-five categories keyed to each charted claim element, from system architecture, software documentation and schematics to sensor integration,
calibration data, per-frame metadata and stereoscopic processing. (Dkt. 81, Ex. E at E-016–23.)
SageMaker is one example. AIIA's October 16 and 19, 2026 correspondence identified, category by category, the documents that § II(b) requires and that Plus One has not
produced: operator and user manuals, installation and commissioning guides, and maintenance and troubleshooting guides; software user manuals, configuration guides and HMI
operating guides (documentation, not source code); architecture documents, functional specifications, design documents, and block or data-flow diagrams; schematics and circuit
diagrams showing signal and data flow between the cameras, sensors, controllers and robot; documents showing how camera and sensor data is captured, processed and used to
drive the robot's actions; technical specifications, training materials, white papers and internal product presentations; and, for the '272 patent, the synthetic-image pipelines,
background-image and 3D-object databases, camera settings, labeling, and the models trained on that data (model versions, training logs). (Decl. ¶ 21; Dkt. 81, Ex. E, Attach. A ¶¶
1–45 at E-016–23 and Attach. B ¶ 1.) Plus One has had AIIA's discovery requests for these categories since March 2026 (id. at E-009). Making source code available does not
satisfy the obligation.


                                    Case 5:25-cv-01197-OLG-HJB                                     Document 98-1                     Filed 11/05/26                 Page 7 of 7


10. AIIA's position on each motion
Dkt.      Motion                                           Status                     AIIA's position
84        AIIA's Motion to Strike and Preclude             Unresolved                 Not moot (Dkt. 93 ¶ 7). Strike and preclude all invalidity, § 112 and § 101 contentions and prior art not served by
                                                                                      Oct. 7, 2026; expenses under Rule 16(f)(2). Alternatively, complete service by Nov. 9 with AIIA's Nov. 30
                                                                                      supplement preserved.
74        Plus One's Motion to Clarify                     Unresolved                 Deny. The Sept. 10 ruling covered Amazon, Intel and RealSense (Tr. 15:11–14, 16:19–20, 82:24–83:1; Dkt. 71 ¶
                                                                                      3); the Protective Order governs any other disclosure, including to a retained expert. See Dkt. 92.
82        AIIA's Motion to Compel, Modify Case Partially resolved                     Compel the § II(b) production (Attachment A), certified by Bates number, by Nov. 9, 2026; move each date
          Schedule, Stay                       (stay moot)                            dependent on the Dec. 9 exchange by 42 days; AIIA's revised terms Nov. 30; source-code review after AIIA's
                                                                                      expert is disclosed and approved under ¶ 5(e).
79        AIIA's Motion re Prof. Bretl                     Unresolved                 Sustain AIIA's objection; disqualify or bar further use; identification and certified destruction and non-use; Prof.
                                                                                      Bretl bound by the Protective Order; substitute expert under ¶ 5(e); expenses.
PO        Protective Order                                 Unresolved                 Confirm that the Order governs AIIA's AEO material, that its protection extends to the material disclosed Oct. 14,
                                                                                      2026, and that Plus One provides access to AIIA's materials only under the Order. Plus One's position: it may
                                                                                      "post the contentions online … a risk Plus One is willing to take."

11. AIIA's proposed schedule
• Every date in the Scheduling Order (Dkt. 25), as modified by the parties' stipulation (Dkt. 93), that falls after December 9, 2026 is moved by forty-two days — the interval
   Dkt. 25 itself set between the narrowing exchange and the opening claim-construction brief.
• The dates fixed by Dkt. 93 — November 9, November 30, December 7 and December 9, 2026 — do not change.
• A date that falls on a weekend or federal holiday moves to the next business day.
• Reservation 1 (Dkt. 93 ¶ 4): AIIA's November 30, 2026 supplement may include revised claim terms made necessary by Plus One's November 9 contentions, within the 15-
   term limit per side.
• Reservation 2 (Dkt. 93 ¶ 4): Plus One's December 7, 2026 supplement may include proposed constructions for those terms, and any terms necessary because of AIIA's
   November 30 additions, but may not otherwise add new claim terms.
• No changes to the text of the current Scheduling Order (Dkt. 25, as modified by Dkt. 93) other than as set forth herein.

AIIA's positions are set out in Dkts. 79, 82 and 84, its opposition to Dkt. 74 (Dkt. 92), and its replies filed Nov. 4, 2026, each incorporated by reference. Nothing in this Advisory is a joint position; AIIA reserves all
rights, including as to fees and any motion that the case is exceptional.
Record: Decl. = Dkt. 81; Tr. = Dkt. 73; Reply Exs. = exhibits to AIIA's Nov. 4, 2026 replies.