jain.com
Public record. We host this document directly; the copy served here does not depend on any third party. Retrieved November 15, 2026.
Read the documentAlso at archive.org ↗

Sun v. Bloomberg, L.P. — Entry #43: REPLY BRIEF re 40 MOTION to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim [DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF'S AMENDED COMPLAINT] filed by Bloomberg, Inc.…

Case: Sun v. Bloomberg, L.P. ded · 1:25-cv-01007

filed August 11, 2025

What this document is

Docket entry #43 · filed October 30, 2025

REPLY BRIEF re 40 MOTION to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim [DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF'S AMENDED COMPLAINT] filed by Bloomberg, Inc., Bloomberg, L.P.. (Yoch, James) (Entered: 10/30/2025)

Who is involved

Why we have it

We follow this case because it names a company we track, although that company is not a party:

A free copy from the RECAP archive of federal court filings (mirrored at the Internet Archive), retrieved November 15, 2026. Federal court filings are public records.

URL
https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.ded.90290/gov.uscourts.ded.90290.43.0.pdf
Kind
court_filing
Publisher
RECAP
Published
2025-10-30 00:00:00-04:00
Retrieved
2026-11-15 07:41:38.252443-05:00
HTTP status
200
MIME
application/pdf
Bytes
410197
SHA-256
1f642d753d902b8c5e77292ecda2d14a2bbdec23f04cfb412f5988c5f4059b55

Document text

18 page(s), 28,877 characters, converted from the PDF's text layer · plain text.

Full text
Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC   Document 43   Filed 10/30/25   Page 1 of 18 PageID #: 552


               IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
                  FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE
                                       )
 SUN, YUCHEN JUSTIN,                   )
                                       )
                  Plaintiff(s),        )
                                       )
      v.                               ) C.A. No. 25-1007-CFC
                                       )
 BLOOMBERG L.P. and                    )
 BLOOMBERG INC.,                       )
                                       )
                  Defendant(s).        )


           DEFENDANTS’ REPLY IN SUPPORT OF THEIR
      MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S AMENDED COMPLAINT


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC                Document 43            Filed 10/30/25         Page 2 of 18 PageID #: 553


                                         TABLE OF CONTENTS


 INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................................... 1
 ARGUMENT ............................................................................................................. 1
 I.       NEW YORK LAW GOVERNS SUN’S CLAIMS. ........................................ 1
 II.      THE COMPLAINT FAILS TO STATE A CLAIM FOR PUBLIC
          DISCLOSURE OF PRIVATE FACTS. .......................................................... 5
 III.     THE COMPLAINT FAILS TO STATE A CLAIM FOR
          PROMISSORY ESTOPPEL. .......................................................................... 8
 CONCLUSION ........................................................................................................ 10


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC                   Document 43             Filed 10/30/25           Page 3 of 18 PageID #: 554


                                         TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

                                                          CASES
 Barker v. Huang, 610 A.2d 1341 (Del. 1992) ........................................................... 6

 Barrera v. Monsanto Co., 2016 WL 4938876 (Del. Super. Ct. Sept. 13,
   2016) ..................................................................................................................... 5
 Bloom v. A360 Media LLC, 735 F. Supp. 3d 466 (S.D.N.Y. 2024) .......................... 4

 CAE Inc. v. Gulfstream Aerospace Corp., 203 F. Supp. 3d 447 (D. Del.
   2016) ..................................................................................................................... 2

 Franklin Prescriptions, Inc. v. The New York Times Co., 267 F. Supp. 2d
    425 (E.D. Pa. 2003) .............................................................................................. 3

 Frey v. Minter, 829 F. App’x 432 (11th Cir. 2020) ................................................... 4
 Germaninvestments AG v. Allomet Corp., 225 A.3d 316 (Del. 2020) .................. 2, 5
 James Cable, LLC v. Millennium Digit. Media Sys., 2009 WL 1638634 (Del.
   Ch. June 11, 2009) ................................................................................................ 9

 Jenkins v. Dell Pub. Co., 251 F.2d 447 (3d Cir. 1958).............................................. 6
 Kinsey v. N.Y. Times Co., 991 F.3d 171 (2d Cir. 2021)......................................... 3, 4
 Levin v. McPhee, 917 F.Supp. 230 (S.D.N.Y. 1996)................................................. 4

 Lowe v. Hearst Commc’ns, Inc., 487 F.3d 246 (5th Cir. 2007)................................. 7

 McKenzie v. Navy Fed. Credit Union, 760 F. Supp. 3d 146 (D. Del. 2024) ............. 9

 N. Am. Phillips Corp. v. Aetna Cas. & Sur. Co., 1991 WL 190305 (Del.
    Super. Ct. Aug. 30, 1991) ..................................................................................... 2

 Powell v. Subaru of America, Inc., 502 F. Supp. 3d 856 (D. N.J. 2020)................... 2
 Reardon v. News-J. Co., 164 A.2d 263 (Del. 1960) .................................................. 4

 Territory of U.S. V.I. v. Goldman, Sachs & Co., 937 A.2d 760 (Del. Ch.
    2007) ..................................................................................................................... 8
 Triestman v. Slate Grp., LLC., 2020 WL 1450562 (D. Del. Mar. 25, 2020) ............ 3

                                                               ii


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC                 Document 43            Filed 10/30/25          Page 4 of 18 PageID #: 555


 VonFeldt v. Stifel Fin. Corp., 714 A.2d 79 (Del. 1998) .......................................... 10

 Vorchheimer v. Philadelphian Owners Ass’n, 903 F.3d 100 (3d Cir. 2018) ............ 7
 Whitwell v. Archmere Acad., Inc., 463 F. Supp. 2d 482 (D. Del. 2006) ................... 2

                                     OTHER AUTHORITIES

 Fed. R. Civ. P. 44.1 .................................................................................................... 2
 Restatement (Second) of Conflict of Laws (1971) .................................................... 4

 Restatement (Second) of Torts (1979) ....................................................................... 6


                                                            iii


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC     Document 43      Filed 10/30/25     Page 5 of 18 PageID #: 556


                                 INTRODUCTION

       Plaintiff Justin Sun’s Opposition brief underscores the multiple reasons why

 the Complaint fails to state a claim and should be dismissed.

       Sun does not contest that his public disclosure of private facts claim fails

 under New York law because New York does not recognize the tort. And his

 Opposition makes plain that even if Delaware law applies, his claim should still be

 dismissed, both because, as a matter of law, the information in the Index was a matter

 of legitimate public interest and also not highly offensive to a reasonable person.

       Sun’s promissory estoppel claim also fails. His Opposition does not identify

 any “reasonably definite and certain” promise that went beyond Bloomberg’s

 commitment to secure his data. Nor does it point to any non-conclusory allegations

 to establish that Bloomberg intended to induce him to provide his confidential

 financial information, or that he relied on such a promise.

                                    ARGUMENT

 I.    NEW YORK LAW GOVERNS SUN’S CLAIMS.
       To begin, Sun argues that it would be “premature” to undertake a choice of

 law analysis on a 12(b)(6) record. Opp. 4, 7-8, 11. But he fails to cite any case from

 this District that has declined to resolve choice of law on this basis. This is no

 surprise, since courts in this District and elsewhere routinely decide choice of law

 issues at the motion to dismiss stage. See, e.g., CAE Inc. v. Gulfstream Aerospace


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC     Document 43     Filed 10/30/25   Page 6 of 18 PageID #: 557


 Corp., 203 F. Supp. 3d 447, 456-57 n.10 (D. Del. 2016); Whitwell v. Archmere

 Acad., Inc., 463 F. Supp. 2d 482, 488 (D. Del. 2006).1

       Although Sun suggests that Hong Kong law might apply, he has no basis to

 criticize Bloomberg for not analyzing Hong Kong law; he did not assert a substantive

 argument for its application, either in his injunction papers, which applied Delaware

 law, or in his Opposition. Thus, he failed to carry his burden “of establishing the

 substance of the foreign law to be applied.” See Germaninvestments AG v. Allomet

 Corp., 225 A.3d 316, 333 (Del. 2020); see also Fed. R. Civ. P. 44.1.

       Furthermore, Sun acknowledges that the most significant relationship test

 controls the choice of law analysis. Opp. 4. Its application squarely indicates that

 New York law should apply here.

       For the first factor, Sun fails to address that courts do not automatically find

 that a plaintiff suffered the greatest harm in his domicile when he has been harmed

 in multiple jurisdictions by publication of allegedly injurious statements. See Opp.

 4-11. Because Sun does not claim any specific injury in Hong Kong, instead


 1
   Sun cites Powell v. Subaru of America, Inc., but ignores the court resolved choice
 of law on a 12(b)(6) motion. 502 F. Supp. 3d 856, 875-881 (D. N.J. 2020). And
 North American Phillips Corporation. v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Company
 concerned whether summary judgment briefing should be stayed pending discovery
 into the drafting and interpretation of a contract. 1991 WL 190305, at *1-3 (Del.
 Super. Aug. 30, 1991).


                                           2


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC       Document 43      Filed 10/30/25   Page 7 of 18 PageID #: 558


 referring to broad harms experienced around the globe, the law of his domicile

 carries little weight. MTD 8.2

       The second and third factors support application of New York law because

 the published statements “emanated” from Bloomberg’s headquarters in New York.

 MTD 9-10; Am. Compl. ¶¶ 7-8; see Kinsey v. N.Y. Times Co., 991 F.3d 171, 178 (2d

 Cir. 2021). Sun’s response that he needs discovery to test “the scope of Bloomberg’s

 business and connections in Delaware, New York, and Hong Kong,” Opp. 8, is

 unavailing; the Complaint alleges that New York is Bloomberg’s “principal” place

 of business, Am. Compl. ¶¶ 7-8, and Sun cites no competing allegation to suggest

 otherwise.

       Sun’s efforts to distinguish the multiple cases Bloomberg cites as applying

 New York law under similar circumstances fall short. His primary response is that

 Bloomberg’s cases were defamation cases, rather than private facts cases. But the

 choice of law rules for multi-state defamation claims and multi-state invasion of


 2
   While Sun cites Franklin Prescriptions, Inc. v. N.Y. Times Co., the plaintiff there
 was “a small, solely owned pharmacy” located in Pennsylvania, with “its
 professional reputation and business contacts . . . based in that state[,]” so plaintiff’s
 injury was locally concentrated. 267 F. Supp. 2d 425, 429, 432-33 (E.D. Pa. 2003).
 This is in stark contrast to Sun, whose global blockchain platform is “one of the most
 active … in the world.” Am. Compl. ¶ 2. And in Triestman v. Slate Group, the court
 focused on plaintiff’s domicile state because neither party proposed applying law
 from the state of publication. 2020 WL 1450562, at *3 (D. Del. Mar. 25, 2020).


                                             3


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC     Document 43      Filed 10/30/25   Page 8 of 18 PageID #: 559


 privacy claims are the same. See Restatement (Second) of Conflict of Laws § 153

 cmt. (d) (1971).3

       As for the final factor, Sun’s opposition leaves little doubt that New York has

 a strong public policy interest in protecting the free speech rights of its publishers

 like Bloomberg. See MTD 10-11. Sun claims that such “free speech interests” are

 only present “in cases alleging defamation,” and “have no relevance in a case

 alleging promissory estoppel and public disclosure of private facts such as those

 pleaded here.” Opp. 10. Not true. Both “defamation and privacy claims . . .

 implicate first amendment concerns.” Bloom v. A360 Media LLC, 735 F. Supp. 3d

 466, 478 (S.D.N.Y. 2024) (quotation marks omitted); see also, e.g., Reardon v.

 News-J. Co., 164 A.2d 263, 267 (Del. 1960) (emphasizing that claims for invasion

 of privacy are limited by “the freedom of the press”). In addition, Sun does not

 dispute that New York has expressed its policy of press protection with a particularly

 robust anti-SLAPP law that would apply here.


 3
   The cases cited by Bloomberg are thus all pertinent here. In Kinsey, the court
 applied New York law due to its “strong policy interests in regulating the conduct
 of its citizens and its media,” even while acknowledging that plaintiff lived in
 Maryland and was employed in D.C. 991 F.3d at 178. The court in Levin v. McPhee
 applied New York law because most significant relationship factors—the state of
 publication and defendant’s headquarters—pointed to New York. 917 F. Supp. 230,
 236 (S.D.N.Y. 1996). So too here. And in Frey v. Minter, the court assumed that
 plaintiff suffered greater injury in Florida, his domicile state, but still applied
 Georgia law in part because the challenged statements were made in Georgia to a
 Georgia newspaper. 829 F. App’x 432, 435-36 (11th Cir. 2020).


                                           4


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC     Document 43      Filed 10/30/25   Page 9 of 18 PageID #: 560


       As for Delaware, the only limited interest Sun notes is that Bloomberg is

 incorporated in the state. See MTD 11 (citing several cases declining to apply

 Delaware law merely because a party was incorporated in that state).4 But Sun fails

 to explain how this could overcome New York’s interest, particularly given that Sun

 does not allege that any of the alleged conduct took place in Delaware.

       To the extent the Court disagrees with the application of New York law, the

 law of the forum state would apply. Cf. Germaninvestments, 225 A.3d at 337

 (applying Delaware law where the party asserting foreign law had failed to carry its

 burden). As Bloomberg explained in its Motion to Dismiss and again below, Sun’s

 claims should be dismissed under the law of either jurisdiction.

 II.   THE COMPLAINT FAILS TO STATE A CLAIM FOR PUBLIC
       DISCLOSURE OF PRIVATE FACTS.

       Sun does not contest that if New York law applies, his claim for public

 disclosure of private facts must be dismissed. MTD 11.

       Even if Delaware law applies, Sun still fails to state a claim, for four reasons.

       First, Sun repeatedly emphasizes his allegation that Bloomberg’s reporting of

 his Tronix holdings was false. See, e.g., Opp. 13-14, 17. This undermines his claim,


 4
   The Opposition cites one case about Delaware’s general interest in regulating
 entities incorporated under its laws, but that case is inapposite because it concerns
 forum non conveniens, which requires a movant to show it will experience
 “overwhelming hardship” if required to defend itself in the forum state. Barrera v.
 Monsanto Co., 2016 WL 4938876, at *4 (Del. Super. Ct. Sept. 13, 2016).


                                           5


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC     Document 43     Filed 10/30/25   Page 10 of 18 PageID #: 561


 because the public-disclosure tort concerns publication of true information. See

 Barker v. Huang, 610 A.2d 1341, 1350 (Del. 1992) (“Barker’s pleadings complain

 only of false accusations by Huang and therefore fail to state a cognizable claim

 under the ‘unwanted publicity’ variety of the tort of invasion of privacy.”); see also

 Restatement (Second) of Torts § 652D (1979). Sun cannot sustain a private facts

 claim based on his allegations that Bloomberg published inaccurate information on

 his Tronix assets. See also MTD 6 n.3.

       Second, Sun’s own Opposition actually supports that the cryptocurrency

 estimates published by Bloomberg are a matter of legitimate public concern. Sun

 argues that the disclosed information “erodes TRON users’ trust in the blockchain,”

 because it suggests that Sun “can exert significant influence over the price of the

 cryptocurrency.” Opp. 14. His argument is fatal to his claim; it underscores

 precisely why the publication is newsworthy. The interest of the cryptocurrency

 community and investing public in the Index easily surpasses the low bar required.

 See Jenkins v. Dell Pub. Co., 251 F.2d 447 at 450, 452 (3d Cir. 1958) (courts should

 dismiss private fact claims unless “the lack of any meritorious public interest in

 disclosure is very clear”); see also MTD 12-13. Sun also claims there cannot be a

 legitimate public concern where the media allegedly obtains information under false

 pretenses, Opp. 16, but cites no legal authority and does not explain how the alleged


                                           6


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC    Document 43     Filed 10/30/25   Page 11 of 18 PageID #: 562


 means of reporting—which are not public—could undermine the public’s interest in

 the published facts.

       Third, Sun does not dispute that courts afford significant deference to

 journalistic judgments of newsworthiness. MTD 12-13. Where, as here, an invasion

 of privacy claim is brought against a news publication, courts are wary of “excessive

 judicial intervention” in reporting and editorial decision-making. Lowe v. Hearst

 Commc’ns, Inc., 487 F.3d 246, 251 (5th Cir. 2007)

       Fourth, Bloomberg’s summary of Sun’s cryptocurrency assets as a matter of

 law is not highly offensive to a reasonable person. Sun contends that Bloomberg’s

 high-level estimate of his cryptocurrency assets was offensive because it allegedly

 placed him at risk of kidnapping and hacking, Opp. 13, but this is speculative and

 implausible.   The Opposition makes plain that more than two months after

 publication, Sun still cannot identify any harm that he actually experienced. In

 addition, as the Court acknowledged in its TRO Order, any such allegation is

 undermined by the fact Sun voluntarily disclosed “far more specific information

 about his Bitcoin holdings[.]” D.I. 39 at 8; D.I. 41-3.5 The Court need not accept

 Sun’s allegations as true where they are plainly contradicted by exhibits or facts

 subject to judicial notice. See Vorchheimer v. Philadelphian Owners Ass’n, 903


 5
  Sun does not contest that he disclosed his precise Bitcoin holdings on X.com on
 February 27, 2024. See D.I. 41-3; Opp. 12 n.3.


                                          7


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC     Document 43     Filed 10/30/25    Page 12 of 18 PageID #: 563


 F.3d 100, 111-12 (3d Cir. 2018). Sun’s argument that his Bitcoin disclosure was in

 2024 doesn’t help him; if anything, it shows that he cannot point to any actual harm

 that he has experienced, even after a year of publication of specific cryptocurrency

 holdings.

 III.   THE COMPLAINT FAILS TO STATE A CLAIM FOR PROMISSORY
        ESTOPPEL.

        There is no conflict between Delaware and New York law, see MTD 17 n.9,

 and the parties agree “that Delaware law applies to Mr. Sun’s promissory estoppel

 claim.” Opp. 17. The Opposition underscores that there are three reasons why the

 claim fails.

        First, Sun does not plausibly allege Bloomberg made him a “reasonably

 definite and certain” promise that Bloomberg would not publish the cryptocurrency

 breakdown. Territory of U.S. V.I. v. Goldman, Sachs & Co., 937 A.2d 760, 804

 (Del. Ch. 2007), aff’d, 956 A.2d 32 (Del. 2008). Sun points to his allegation that a

 Bloomberg reporter told him that his financial information “would be kept strictly

 confidential and would only be used to verify his personal assets for the Billionaire’s

 Index profile.” Opp. 16 (quoting Am. Compl. ¶ 18). At most, these were statements

 about how Bloomberg would secure Sun’s financial data. Am. Compl. ¶¶ 18, 22.

 But Sun does not plausibly allege Bloomberg made any promises regarding the detail

 it would use when describing his cryptocurrency holdings. Even if Bloomberg’s

 “assurances” could be read as a promise of some confidentiality, Am. Compl. ¶ 19,


                                           8


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC      Document 43     Filed 10/30/25   Page 13 of 18 PageID #: 564


 Sun’s “extremely vague” description of Bloomberg’s alleged representations about

 what Bloomberg would publish in the Index does not “amount to a real promise”

 enforceable in court, James Cable, LLC v. Millennium Digit. Media Sys., 2009 WL

 1638634, at *5 (Del. Ch. June 11, 2009).

          In a footnote, Sun contends that other written communications the Court

 previously reviewed and found to “concern data security,” are now “sufficient to

 support [Sun’s] assertions.” Opp. 19 n.4 (quoting TRO Op. at 6). Sun does not even

 attempt to explain why those communications support his promissory estoppel

 claim.      See id.   In any event, because the Complaint incorporates those

 communications, see MTD n.1, the Court can review them at this stage and again

 conclude that they are not “a promise to refrain from publishing details about Sun’s

 cryptocurrency holdings.” TRO Op. at 6 (reviewing D.I. 23-2).

          Second, Sun does not plausibly allege that Bloomberg reasonably expected to

 induce Sun’s action or forbearance. In his opposition, Sun does not point to any

 allegations in his Complaint that support this element. Opp. 17-21. That is because

 Sun’s allegations merely recite the legal standard for promissory estoppel. Am.

 Compl. ¶¶ 72-74. The Court need not credit such conclusory allegations and should

 dismiss Sun’s claim. See McKenzie v. Navy Fed. Credit Union, 760 F. Supp. 3d 146,

 151 (D. Del. 2024).


                                            9


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC    Document 43      Filed 10/30/25   Page 14 of 18 PageID #: 565


       Third, Sun does not plausibly allege that he reasonably relied to his detriment.

 In his opposition, Sun cites only one paragraph in his Complaint to support his claim

 of reasonable reliance. Opp. 20 (citing Am. Compl. ¶ 24). But that paragraph quotes

 communications between Sun’s representatives and a Bloomberg reporter in which

 one of Sun’s representatives asks for “protection of our data” and the Bloomberg

 reporter confirms such data security. Am. Compl. ¶ 24. That paragraph has nothing

 to do with Sun’s purported reliance on a promise by Bloomberg to refrain from

 publishing details about his cryptocurrency holdings. The remainder of Sun’s

 Complaint shows that his decision to provide his financial information to Bloomberg

 was “[b]ased on” his “careful[] review” of other Index profiles. Am. Compl. ¶ 20.

 Because Sun did not “actually rel[y] on [a] promise” by Bloomberg not to publish

 the cryptocurrency breakdown when Sun provided his financial data, his claim fails.

 VonFeldt v. Stifel Fin. Corp., 714 A.2d 79, 87 (Del. 1998).

                                  CONCLUSION
       New York does not recognize Sun’s public disclosure of private facts claim,

 which would also be dismissed with prejudice under Delaware law based on public

 interest analysis. And while Sun has had multiple opportunities—in his initial TRO

 motion, his Complaint, his renewed TRO motion, and his Amended Complaint—to

 state a claim for promissory estoppel based on communications he personally had


                                          10


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC       Document 43     Filed 10/30/25   Page 15 of 18 PageID #: 566


 with Bloomberg, Sun has proven incapable of doing so. Sun’s Complaint should be

 dismissed with prejudice.

  Dated: October 30, 2025                  YOUNG CONAWAY STARGATT
                                           & TAYLOR, LLP

                                           /s/ James M. Yoch, Jr.
                                           James M. Yoch, Jr. (Bar No. 5251)
                                           Robert M. Vrana (Bar No. 5666)
                                           Rodney Square
                                           1000 North King Street
                                           Wilmington, DE 19801
                                           (302) 571-6726
                                           jyoch@ycst.com
                                           rvrana@ycst.com

                                           Thomas G. Hentoff (pro hac vice)
                                           Nicholas G. Gamse (pro hac vice)
                                           Tiffany Keung (pro hac vice)
                                           Ian M. Swenson (pro hac vice)
                                           WILLIAMS & CONNOLLY LLP
                                           680 Maine Avenue, SW
                                           Washington, DC 20024
                                           (202) 434-5000
                                           thentoff@wc.com
                                           ngamse@wc.com
                                           tkeung@wc.com
                                           iswenson@wc.com

                                           Counsel for Defendants


                                            11


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC   Document 43    Filed 10/30/25   Page 16 of 18 PageID #: 567


                IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
                   FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE

                              )
 SUN, YUCHEN JUSTIN,          )
                              )
               Plaintiff(s),  )
                              )
       v.                     ) C.A. No. 25-1007-CFC
                              )
 BLOOMBERG L.P. and BLOOMBERG )
 INC.,                        )
                              )
               Defendant(s).  )


                  CERTIFICATION OF COMPLIANCE
              WITH TYPE, FONT, AND WORD LIMITATIONS

       This brief complies with the Court’s Standing Order Regarding Briefing in

 All Cases. It has been prepared in Times New Roman 14-point type, and contains

 2,498 words, which were counted by Microsoft Word.

  Dated: October 30, 2025              YOUNG CONAWAY STARGATT
                                       & TAYLOR, LLP

                                       /s/ James M. Yoch, Jr.
                                       James M. Yoch, Jr. (Bar No. 5251)
                                       Robert M. Vrana (Bar No. 5666)
                                       Rodney Square
                                       1000 North King Street
                                       Wilmington, DE 19801
                                       (302) 571-6726
                                       jyoch@ycst.com
                                       rvrana@ycst.com
                                       Thomas G. Hentoff (pro hac vice)
                                       Nicholas G. Gamse (pro hac vice)


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC   Document 43    Filed 10/30/25   Page 17 of 18 PageID #: 568


                                       Tiffany Keung (pro hac vice)
                                       Ian M. Swenson (pro hac vice)
                                       WILLIAMS & CONNOLLY LLP
                                       680 Maine Avenue, SW
                                       Washington, DC 20024
                                       (202) 434-5000
                                       thentoff@wc.com
                                       ngamse@wc.com
                                       tkeung@wc.com
                                       iswenson@wc.com

                                       Counsel for Defendants


                                        2


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC   Document 43     Filed 10/30/25   Page 18 of 18 PageID #: 569


                         CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

       The undersigned hereby certifies that on October 30, 2025, a copy of the

 foregoing document was served on the counsel listed below in the manner

 indicated:

  BY EMAIL
  Jeffrey J. Lyons                         Isabelle Corbett Sterling
  BAKER & HOSTETLER LLP                    BAKER & HOSTETLER LLP
  1201 N. Market Street, Suite 1407        Transamerica Pyramid Center
  Wilmington, DE 19801                     600 Montgomery Street, Suite 3100
  jjlyons@bakerlaw.com                     San Francisco, CA 94111
                                           isterling@bakerlaw.com

                                           Teresa Goody Guillen
                                           Katherine L. McKnight
                                           BAKER & HOSTETLER LLP
                                           1050 Connecticut Avenue, NW
                                           Suite 100
                                           Washington, D.C. 20036
                                           tgoodyguillen@bakerlaw.com
                                           kmcknight@bakerlaw.com

                                           YOUNG CONAWAY STARGATT
                                           & TAYLOR, LLP

                                           /s/ James M. Yoch, Jr.
                                           James M. Yoch, Jr. (No. 5251)
                                           Robert M. Vrana (No. 5666)
                                           Rodney Square
                                           1000 North King Street
                                           Wilmington, DE 19801
                                           (302) 571-6600
                                           jyoch@ycst.com
                                           rvrana@ycst.com

                                           Attorneys for Defendants