jain.com
Public record. We host this document directly; the copy served here does not depend on any third party. Retrieved November 15, 2026.
Read the documentAlso at archive.org ↗

Sun v. Bloomberg, L.P. — Entry #41: OPENING BRIEF in Support re 40 MOTION to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim [DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF'S AMENDED COMPLAINT] filed by Bloomberg…

Case: Sun v. Bloomberg, L.P. ded · 1:25-cv-01007

filed August 11, 2025

What this document is

Docket entry #41 · filed October 09, 2025

OPENING BRIEF in Support re 40 MOTION to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim [DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF'S AMENDED COMPLAINT] filed by Bloomberg, Inc., Bloomberg, L.P..Answering Brief/Response due date per Local Rules is 10/23/2025. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5)(Vrana, Robert) (Entered: 10/09/2025)

Who is involved

Why we have it

We follow this case because it names a company we track, although that company is not a party:

A free copy from the RECAP archive of federal court filings (mirrored at the Internet Archive), retrieved November 15, 2026. Federal court filings are public records.

URL
https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.ded.90290/gov.uscourts.ded.90290.41.0.pdf
Kind
court_filing
Publisher
RECAP
Published
2025-10-09 00:00:00-04:00
Retrieved
2026-11-15 07:41:42.225346-05:00
HTTP status
200
MIME
application/pdf
Bytes
623444
SHA-256
0b79be2c434fba8adf8d0eb720371edf257ecc09996442d2267f34fa368f4a10

Document text

31 page(s), 51,667 characters, converted from the PDF's text layer · plain text.

Full text
Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC   Document 41   Filed 10/09/25   Page 1 of 31 PageID #: 427


               IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
                  FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE
                                       )
 SUN, YUCHEN JUSTIN,                   )
                                       )
                  Plaintiff(s),        )
                                       )
      v.                               ) C.A. No. 25-1007-CFC
                                       )
 BLOOMBERG L.P. and                    )
 BLOOMBERG INC.,                       )
                                       )
                  Defendant(s).        )


                  DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS
                  PLAINTIFF’S AMENDED COMPLAINT


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC                Document 41            Filed 10/09/25         Page 2 of 31 PageID #: 428


                                         TABLE OF CONTENTS

 INTRODUCTION AND SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT ........................................ 1

 FACTUAL BACKGROUND & NATURE AND STAGE OF
     PROCEEDINGS .............................................................................................. 2
 LEGAL STANDARD ................................................................................................ 5

 ARGUMENT ............................................................................................................. 6

 I.       NEW YORK LAW GOVERNS SUN’S CLAIMS. ........................................ 6

 II.      THE COMPLAINT FAILS TO STATE A CLAIM FOR PUBLIC
          DISCLOSURE OF PRIVATE FACTS. ........................................................ 11

 III.     THE COMPLAINT FAILS TO STATE A CLAIM FOR
          PROMISSORY ESTOPPEL. ........................................................................ 16
 CONCLUSION ........................................................................................................ 21


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC                 Document 41            Filed 10/09/25          Page 3 of 31 PageID #: 429


                                       TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

                                                        CASES
 374-76 Prospect Place Tenants Ass’n, Inc. v. City of New York, 222
    N.Y.S.3d 477 (2d Dep’t 2024)............................................................................ 17

 Barbieri v. News-J. Co., 189 A.2d 773 (Del. 1963) .................................................. 6
 Bell Atl. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544 (2007) ...................................................... 5

 Benak ex rel. All. Premier Growth Fund v. All. Cap. Mgmt. L.P., 435
   F.3d 396 (3d Cir. 2006) ...................................................................................... 16

 Boring v. Google Inc., 362 F. App’x 273 (3d Cir. 2010) ..................................14, 16

 Brooks v. Fiore, 2001 WL 1218448 (D. Del. Oct. 11, 2001) .................................. 21

 Buck v. Hampton Twp. Sch. Dist., 452 F.3d 256 (3d Cir. 2006) ...................3, 15, 19
 Chisholm v. Foothill Cap. Corp., 3 F. Supp. 2d 925 (N.D. Ill. 1998) ..................... 16
 Chrysler Corp. (Delaware) v. Chaplake Holdings, Ltd., 822 A.2d
   1024 (Del. 2003) ................................................................................................. 16

 Daly v. Viacom, Inc., 238 F. Supp. 2d 1118 (N.D. Cal. 2002) ................................ 15
 Davis v. Abington Mem’l Hosp., 765 F.3d 236 (3d Cir. 2014).................................. 5
 Deuley v. DynCorp Int’l, Inc., 8 A.3d 1156 (Del. 2010) ......................................... 17

 Essick v. Barksdale, 882 F. Supp. 365 (D. Del. 1995) .............................................. 6

 Evans v. TheHuffingtonPost.com, Inc., 2023 WL 5275383 (D. Del.
   Aug. 16, 2023) .................................................................................................... 10

 Fisher v. Perron, 30 F.4th 289 (6th Cir. 2022)........................................................ 15

 Frey v. Minter, 829 F. App’x 432 (11th Cir. 2020) ................................................... 9
 Ganske v. Mensch, 480 F. Supp. 3d 542 (S.D.N.Y. 2020) ........................................ 3

 Grubbs v. Univ. of Del. Police Dep’t, 174 F. Supp. 3d 839 (D. Del.
   2016) .............................................................................................................12, 14


                                                             ii


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC                  Document 41             Filed 10/09/25          Page 4 of 31 PageID #: 430


 Howell v. New York Post Co., 81 N.Y.2d 115 (1993) ............................................. 11

 In re Morrow Park Holding LLC, 2020 WL 3415649 (Del. Ch. June
     22, 2020) ............................................................................................................. 19

 James Cable, LLC v. Millennium Digit. Media Sys., L.L.C., 2009
   WL 1638634 (Del. Ch. June 11, 2009) ............................................................... 18
 Jenkins v. Dell Pub. Co., 251 F.2d 447 (3d Cir. 1958)......................................13, 14

 Jewell v. NYP Holdings, Inc., 23 F. Supp. 2d 348 (S.D.N.Y. 1998) ....................... 11

 JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. v. Nowak, 2025 WL 1938541
   (S.D.N.Y. July 15, 2025) .................................................................................... 11

 Kinsey v. New York Times Co., 991 F.3d 171 (2d Cir. 2021) ................................ 8, 9

 Lee ex rel. Lee v. Choice Hotels Int’l Inc., 2006 WL 1148737 (Del.
    Super. Ct. Mar. 21, 2006) ................................................................................... 11
 Levin v. McPhee, 917 F.Supp. 230 (S.D.N.Y. 1996)................................................. 9

 Lowe v. Hearst Commc’ns, Inc., 487 F.3d 246 (5th Cir. 2007)............................... 13

 Martin v. Widener Univ. Sch. of Law, 1992 WL 153540 (Del. Super.
   Ct. June 4, 1992) ................................................................................................. 13
 McKenzie v. Navy Fed. Credit Union, 760 F. Supp. 3d 146 (D. Del.
   2024) ............................................................................................................... 3, 20

 Metro. Convoy Corp. v. Chrysler Corp., 208 A.2d 519 (Del. 1965) ....................... 18
 Neuberger v. Gordon, 567 F. Supp. 2d 622 (D. Del. 2008) ...................................... 3

 Paucek v. Shaulis, 349 F.R.D. 498 (D.N.J. 2025) ................................................... 10

 Prince v. Intercept, 634 F. Supp. 3d 114 (S.D.N.Y. 2022) ....................................... 8
 Ramsey v. Fox News Network, L.L.C., 351 F. Supp. 2d 1145 (D.
   Colo. 2005) ........................................................................................................... 8

 Reardon v. News-J. Co., 164 A.2d 263 (Del. 1960) ................................................ 12


                                                              iii


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC                   Document 41             Filed 10/09/25           Page 5 of 31 PageID #: 431


 Sabby Volatility Warrant Master Fund Ltd. v. Jupiter Wellness, Inc.,
    2025 WL 1363171 (2d Cir. May 12, 2025) ........................................................ 19
 Sarver v. Chartier, 813 F.3d 891 (9th Cir. 2016) ...................................................... 8

 Spilfogel v. Fox Broad. Co., 433 F. App’x 724 (11th Cir. 2011) ............................ 14

 Sweigert v. Goodman, 2024 WL 4493768 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. 11, 2024) ....................... 6
 Territory of U.S. V.I. v. Goldman, Sachs & Co., 937 A.2d 760 (Del.
    Ch. 2007).................................................................................................17, 19, 20

 Turner v. Lipschultz, 619 A.2d 912 (Del. 1992) ........................................................ 7

 UbiquiTel Inc. v. Sprint Corp., 2005 WL 3533697 (Del. Ch. Dec. 14,
   2005) ................................................................................................................... 10

 Unsworth v. Musk, 2019 WL 5550060 (N.D. Cal. Oct. 28, 2019) ............................ 3
 Vichi v. Koninklijke Philips Electronics, N.V., 85 A.3d 725 (Del. Ch.
    2014) ..................................................................................................................... 6

 VonFeldt v. Stifel Fin. Corp., 714 A.2d 79 (Del. 1998) .......................................... 21

 Vorchheimer v. Philadelphian Owners Ass’n, 903 F.3d 100 (3d Cir.
   2018) ..................................................................................................................... 6
 Weinstein v. Friedman, 1996 WL 137313 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 26, 1996) .................... 10

 Wilcher v. City of Wilmington, 60 F. Supp. 2d 298 (D. Del. 1999)......................... 13

 Wolf v. Regardie, 553 A.2d 1213 (D.C. 1989) ........................................................ 13
                                            OTHER AUTHORITIES

 Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6) .........................................................passim

 Restatement (Second) of Conflict of Laws (1971) ...........................................passim
 Restatement (Second) of Torts (1979) ..................................................................... 13


                                                               iv


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC      Document 41    Filed 10/09/25   Page 6 of 31 PageID #: 432


             INTRODUCTION AND SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT

       Plaintiff Justin Sun sued Defendants Bloomberg L.P. and Bloomberg Inc.

 (“Bloomberg”), and sought emergency relief, over two sentences in a Bloomberg

 Billionaires Index profile that listed approximate amounts of his holdings of three

 types of cryptocurrency. On September 22, 2025, this Court rejected Sun’s TRO

 motion based on his failure to show either likelihood of success on the merits or

 irreparable harm. D.I. 39 (TRO Order) at 4-10. Bloomberg now moves to dismiss

 the Amended Complaint (“Am. Compl.”) under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure

 12(b)(6) because Sun’s two claims, for public disclosure of private facts and

 promissory estoppel, both fail to state a claim upon which relief can be granted.

       First, Sun’s public disclosure of private facts claim fails because New York

 law, which applies under Delaware’s choice of law rules, does not recognize that

 tort. And Sun in any event cannot satisfy the elements of the claim under Delaware

 law. See infra at 11-16.

       Second, Sun’s promissory estoppel claim fails because he does not and cannot

 plausibly allege that Bloomberg made a reasonably definite and certain promise not

 to publish the cryptocurrency breakdown, that Bloomberg made such a promise with

 the intent to induce Sun to provide his financial data to Bloomberg, or that Sun

 reasonably relied on such a promise in producing his financial data. See infra at 16-

 20.


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC      Document 41     Filed 10/09/25   Page 7 of 31 PageID #: 433


       Even when taken as true, the facts as alleged by Sun in a complaint and an

 amended complaint cannot satisfy the requirements for a public disclosure of private

 facts or promissory estoppel claim. The Complaint should be dismissed with

 prejudice.

 FACTUAL BACKGROUND & NATURE AND STAGE OF PROCEEDINGS

       Sun “is a successful entrepreneur in the blockchain and cryptocurrency

 industry,” who is known as the founder of TRON, “one of the most active open

 blockchain platforms in the world with over 300 million accounts.” Am. Compl.

 ¶ 2. Sun was “interested in being featured” in the Billionaires Index (“Index”) a

 series of “profiles for each of the world’s 500 richest people” published by

 Bloomberg at its principal place of business in New York. Id. ¶¶ 7-8, 15 n.1, 17. To

 be considered for inclusion in the Index, individuals must give Bloomberg “financial

 information regarding the value of specific assets” for “verification purposes.” Id.

 ¶ 16. The Index profiles include “a detailed analysis” of how each individual’s

 “fortune is tallied.” Id. n.1.1 Sun alleges that he “carefully reviewed” these profiles

 and then agreed to be featured in the Index. Id. ¶ 20.


 1
    See Ex. 1 at 38, Bloomberg Billionaires Index, Bloomberg, available at
 https://www.bloomberg.com/billionaires/ and incorporated by reference in Sun’s
 Complaint n.1 (“each individual billionaire profile contains a detailed analysis of
 how that person’s fortune is tallied”). The following documents are properly before
 the Court on a Rule 12(b)(6) motion to dismiss: (1) documents incorporated into the
 Complaint by reference, such as the Billionaire’s Index, see McKenzie v. Navy Fed.


                                           2


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC     Document 41      Filed 10/09/25   Page 8 of 31 PageID #: 434


       On February 28, 2025, Timothy Chung, Sun’s representative for Bloomberg’s

 wealth verification process, provided Bloomberg reporter Dylan Sloan with Sun’s

 financial information. See Am. Compl. ¶¶ 23-24; D.I. 23-2 (Wang Declaration Ex.

 B).   Sun now alleges that conversations with Bloomberg reporters about his

 “confidentiality and data security concerns” as well as his “careful[] review[]” of

 “other profiles on the Billionaire’s Index” led him to believe that Bloomberg would

 only report on “the total value of his cryptocurrency holdings, and the general asset

 types and sources of his wealth,” such that “his cryptocurrency holdings would be

 reported as a single lump sum amount.” Am. Compl. ¶¶ 18-20. Sun further alleges

 that after his team shared the financial data on February 28, 2025, his team sought

 additional assurances about the use and confidentiality of that data. Am. Compl.

 ¶¶ 25-28; see also D.I. 23-2.


 Credit Union, 760 F. Supp. 3d 146, 150 (D. Del. 2024); (2) documents subject to
 judicial notice, including public records such as court filings, see Buck v. Hampton
 Twp. Sch. Dist., 452 F.3d 256, 260 (3d Cir. 2006); and (3) the existence of public
 social media posts, see Ganske v. Mensch, 480 F. Supp. 3d 542, 546 (S.D.N.Y.
 2020); Unsworth v. Musk, 2019 WL 5550060, at *4 (N.D. Cal. Oct. 28, 2019). On
 a motion to dismiss, the court may take judicial notice of the existence of public
 records in a legal proceeding, and it may take notice of public articles “to indicate
 what was in the public realm at the time,” but not for the truth of the facts therein.
 Neuberger v. Gordon, 567 F. Supp. 2d 622, 631 (D. Del. 2008).


                                           3


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC      Document 41     Filed 10/09/25   Page 9 of 31 PageID #: 435


       “On August 11, 2025, after months of working to verify Sun’s assets,

 Bloomberg published Sun’s profile in its Billionaires Index.” TRO Order at 1; Am.

 Compl. ¶ 36; Ex. 2 (Sun profile).

       After the Index article was published, Sun filed this lawsuit and his original

 motion for emergency relief on August 11, 2025. D.I. 3. Sun takes issue with two

 sentences of the Billionaires Index profile:

      Sun owns more than 60 billion Tronix (also referred to as TRON or
      TRX), the cryptocurrency native to Tron, according to an analysis of
      financial information provided by representatives of Sun in February
      2025. . . . Sun also owns about 17,000 Bitcoin, 224,000 Ether, and 700
      million Tether, according to the same analysis.

 TRO Order at 2.

       Sun voluntarily withdrew this motion three days later while the parties

 discussed Sun’s correction request. TRO Order at 2. On September 11, 2025, Sun

 renewed the motion, which asked that the Court compel Bloomberg to “remove the

 amounts of any specific cryptocurrency owned by Mr. Sun from any of its online

 publications,” “retract its claim that Mr. Sun owns 60 billion Tronix,” and enjoin

 Bloomberg from “publishing the amounts of any specific cryptocurrency owned by

 Mr. Sun in any future publication.”2 D.I. 18 at 1-2. On September 22, 2025, the


 2
   In his Complaint, Sun also identifies a forthcoming Bloomberg Businessweek
 article it he alleges will “include the Cryptocurrency Breakdown” and will increase
 the risk of harm he might suffer. Am. Compl. ¶¶ 39-41. The article was published
 on September 26, 2025. Zeke Faux & Muyao Shen, A Crypto Billionaire’s Path


                                           4


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC     Document 41    Filed 10/09/25   Page 10 of 31 PageID #: 436


 Court denied Sun’s request for a temporary restraining order and his request for a

 preliminary injunction. The Court found that Sun failed to make a clear showing of

 (1) likelihood of success on the merits on his promissory estoppel claim and his

 public disclosure of private facts claim and (2) irreparable harm. TRO Order at 4,

 9-10.

                                LEGAL STANDARD
         A party may move to dismiss for “failure to state a claim upon which relief

 can be granted.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(6). “Though detailed factual allegations are

 not required, a complaint must do more than simply provide labels and conclusions

 or a formulaic recitation of the elements of a cause of action.” Davis v. Abington

 Mem’l Hosp., 765 F.3d 236, 241 (3d Cir. 2014) (quotation marks omitted). A Rule

 12(b)(6) motion should be granted if, accepting the well-pleaded allegations in the

 complaint as true and viewing them in the light most favorable to the plaintiff, a

 court concludes that those allegations “could not raise a claim of entitlement to

 relief.” Bell Atl. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544, 558 (2007).         In addition,

 allegations need not be accepted as true where they are contradicted by exhibits or

 documents incorporated into the complaint. Vorchheimer v. Philadelphian Owners

 Ass’n, 903 F.3d 100, 111-12 (3d Cir. 2018).


 From Pariah to Trump Moneyman, Bloomberg Businessweek (Sept. 26, 2025),
 https://tinyurl.com/bdfua2rz.


                                          5


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC     Document 41      Filed 10/09/25   Page 11 of 31 PageID #: 437


                                     ARGUMENT

       New York law has the more significant relation to Sun’s lawsuit and should

 be applied in lieu of Delaware law. But under either New York or Delaware law,

 Sun’s allegations fail to state a claim for either public disclosure of private facts or

 promissory estoppel.3

 I.    NEW YORK LAW GOVERNS SUN’S CLAIMS.

       Although Sun applied Delaware law in his TRO briefing without addressing

 choice of law, such analysis is necessary here. D.I. 19 at 12-16. In a suit based on

 diversity of citizenship, federal courts apply the forum’s choice of law doctrine.

 Essick v. Barksdale, 882 F. Supp. 365, 369 (D. Del. 1995). Delaware courts begin

 by comparing the laws of the competing jurisdictions to determine whether the laws

 conflict, and apply Delaware law where no conflict exists. Vichi v. Koninklijke

 Philips Electronics, N.V., 85 A.3d 725, 773 (Del. Ch. 2014). The most significant

 conflict here is that Delaware recognizes the claim of public disclosure of private

 facts, but no such claim exists under New York state law. Compare Barbieri v.

 News-J. Co., 189 A.2d 773, 774 (Del. 1963) with Sweigert v. Goodman, 2024 WL

 4493768, at *6 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. 11, 2024).


 3
   Although the Complaint alleges that purportedly false statements about Sun’s
 TRON holdings harmed him, Am. Compl. ¶¶ 37, 52, 55-59, “Sun did not sue
 Bloomberg for defamation or any other claim premised on the publication of false
 information,” TRO Order at 9.


                                            6


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC    Document 41     Filed 10/09/25   Page 12 of 31 PageID #: 438


       For conflict of law in torts, Delaware courts apply the “most significant

 relationship” test from the Restatement (Second) of Conflict of Laws (1971)

 (“Restatement”). Turner v. Lipschultz, 619 A.2d 912, 914-15 (Del. 1992). Tort

 claims premised on an aggregate communication published in multiple states, such

 as multistate defamation or invasion of privacy, carry a presumption that the law of

 plaintiff’s domicile should govern because that is “usually” where the plaintiff

 suffers the greatest injury. Restatement § 153 cmt. (d).4 However, this presumption

 is rebutted where, “with respect to the particular issue, some other state has a more

 significant relationship to the occurrence and the parties.” Restatement § 153 cmt.

 (b). To make this determination, courts consider factors such as the state where

 plaintiff suffered his greatest injury, the state where defendant did his “acts of

 communication, such as assembling, printing, and distributing a magazine or book,”

 and “the state or states of the defendant’s domicile, incorporation or organization

 and principal place of business.” Restatement § 153 cmt. (d). Finally, courts

 consider the interests of the states and “the purpose sought to be achieved by their

 relevant local law rules.” Restatement § 153 cmt. (b). Application of these factors

 demonstrates that New York law should apply.


 4
  The choice of law rules for multi-state defamation claims and multi-state invasion
 of privacy claims are the same. See Restatement § 153 cmt. (d).


                                          7


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC      Document 41     Filed 10/09/25    Page 13 of 31 PageID #: 439


          First, Sun’s domicile is not a significant factor here.      The Restatement

 acknowledges that when injury is alleged due to a multistate communication, there

 is “little reason in logic or persuasiveness to say that one state rather than another is

 the place of injury.”      Restatement § 145 cmt. (e).        In such cases of mass

 dissemination, “the tort essentially lacks a locus” because it “injures plaintiff

 everywhere at once.” Kinsey v. New York Times Co., 991 F.3d 171, 178 (2d Cir.

 2021) (quotation marks omitted); see also Sarver v. Chartier, 813 F.3d 891, 899 (9th

 Cir. 2016) (plaintiff’s injuries occurred in multiple states because allegedly

 defamatory film was distributed nationwide, therefore his domicile state did not have

 the most significant relationship to the claim); Prince v. Intercept, 634 F. Supp. 3d

 114, 133 (S.D.N.Y. 2022) (similar).

          That is the case here: Sun alleges broad harms to his physical safety and

 professional reputation that are global in nature, and does not allege that he suffered

 specific injury in his domicile of Hong Kong, in the state of Delaware, or any other

 state.     Am. Compl. ¶¶ 6, 56-59.           Because the Article “was distributed

 nationwide . . . ‘the place of injury will not play an important role in the selection of

 the state of applicable law.’” Sarver, 813 F.3d at 897 (quoting Restatement § 145

 cmt. (e)); Ramsey v. Fox News Network, L.L.C., 351 F. Supp. 2d 1145, 1149 (D.


                                            8


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC       Document 41      Filed 10/09/25   Page 14 of 31 PageID #: 440


 Colo. 2005) (declining to apply law of plaintiff’s domicile state because plaintiff

 failed to allege specific injury in that state).5

        The second and third factors strongly favor the application of New York law,

 because the newsgathering and publication actions at the center of Sun’s complaint

 took place in New York, which is also Bloomberg’s principal place of business. Am.

 Compl. ¶¶ 7-8, 15 n.1. In Kinsey, the Second Circuit affirmed the district court’s

 holding that New York had the most significant relationship to the defamation claim

 because defendant, the New York Times, had its principal place of business in New

 York, meaning the “alleged defamatory statement emanated from New York.” 991

 F.3d at 178; see also Levin v. McPhee, 917 F.Supp. 230, 236 (S.D.N.Y. 1996)

 (applying New York law under the most significant relationship test because the

 publication of allegedly libelous statements “took place in New York, where the

 author reside[d] and where both publishers [were] headquartered”). Because the

 statements at issue in Sun’s complaint emanated from New York, New York law

 should apply to his claims. See, e.g., Frey v. Minter, 829 F. App’x 432, 434-36 (11th

 Cir. 2020) (the state where the challenged statement was published had the most

 significant relationship to the multistate defamation claim).


 5
  Notably, in his TRO papers, Sun asserts that Delaware law, not Hong Kong law,
 applies. D.I. 19 at 12-16.


                                              9


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC     Document 41      Filed 10/09/25   Page 15 of 31 PageID #: 441


       Moreover, Bloomberg’s strong New York connections outweigh its formation

 in Delaware because, “[at] least with respect to most issues, a corporation’s principal

 place of business is a more important contact than the place of incorporation,”

 especially when “the corporation does little, or no, business in the latter place.”

 Restatement § 145 cmt. (e); see also UbiquiTel Inc. v. Sprint Corp., 2005 WL

 3533697, at *4 (Del. Ch. Dec. 14, 2005) (similar); Paucek v. Shaulis, 349 F.R.D.

 498, 523-24 (D.N.J. 2025) (defendant’s state of incorporation was “a relatively weak

 factor for purposes of the most significant relationship test”).

       Finally, the last factor also weighs heavily in favor of New York law. New

 York is “the national center of the publishing industry,” and has a strong interest in

 protecting the free speech rights of those publishers, like Bloomberg. Weinstein v.

 Friedman, 1996 WL 137313, at *7 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 26, 1996), aff’d, 112 F.3d 507

 (2d Cir. 1996) (applying New York law due to the state’s interest in “provid[ing] a

 hospitable climate for the free exchange of ideas”) (quotation marks omitted).

 Relatedly, “New York has a strong interest in enforcing its anti-strategic litigation

 against public participation (‘anti-SLAPP’) statute,” which was designed “to provide

 the utmost protection for the free exercise or [sic] speech, petition, and association

 rights, particularly where such rights are exercised in a public forum with respect to

 issues of public concern.”      Evans v. TheHuffingtonPost.com, Inc., 2023 WL


                                           10


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC      Document 41   Filed 10/09/25   Page 16 of 31 PageID #: 442


 5275383, at *4 (D. Del. Aug. 16, 2023) (quotation marks omitted), aff’d, 2024 WL

 3949070 (3d Cir. Aug. 27, 2024).

       Delaware on the other hand, has a much weaker policy interest in enforcing

 its privacy tort brought by a Hong Kong citizen against a Delaware corporation with

 its principal place of business in New York. See, e.g., Lee ex rel. Lee v. Choice

 Hotels Int’l Inc., 2006 WL 1148737, at *2 (Del. Super. Ct. Mar. 21, 2006) (rejecting

 the argument that Delaware law should apply simply due to its interest in “governing

 franchisors which are corporate registrants of the State”); Jewell v. NYP Holdings,

 Inc., 23 F. Supp. 2d 348, 359-60 (S.D.N.Y. 1998) (applying New York law even

 though defendant was incorporated in Delaware).

       Because the first factor is neutral and the second, third, and fourth factors

 support the application of New York law, the state with the most significant

 relationship to the case is New York.

 II.   THE COMPLAINT FAILS TO STATE A CLAIM FOR PUBLIC
       DISCLOSURE OF PRIVATE FACTS.

       Sun’s “public disclosure of private fact claim necessarily fails because New

 York common law does not recognize privacy torts such as public disclosure of

 private fact.” See JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. v. Nowak, 2025 WL 1938541, at *7

 (S.D.N.Y. July 15, 2025) (citing Howell v. New York Post Co., 81 N.Y.2d 115, 124

 (1993)); see supra at 6.


                                          11


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC      Document 41     Filed 10/09/25    Page 17 of 31 PageID #: 443


       Even if Delaware law were applied, Sun’s claim would still fail. In Delaware,

 a claim for the public disclosure of private facts requires proof of four elements: (1)

 public disclosure, (2) of a private fact, (3) which would be offensive and

 objectionable to the reasonable person, and (4) which is not of a legitimate public

 concern. Grubbs v. Univ. of Del. Police Dep’t, 174 F. Supp. 3d 839, 861 (D. Del.

 2016). “A failure to prove any of these elements is a complete bar to liability.” Id.

 Here, Sun’s claim fails because he fails to sufficiently allege that the information is

 not of legitimate public concern, and he does not sufficiently plead that the published

 information would be offensive to a reasonable person. See TRO Order at 8 (holding

 that Sun “failed to show clearly that he is likely to succeed on the merits of his public

 disclosure of private facts claims”).

       First, Sun’s claim should be dismissed because the information published by

 Bloomberg is newsworthy material of legitimate public concern, which is not

 actionable under Delaware law. See Reardon v. News-J. Co., 164 A.2d 263, 267

 (Del. 1960) (claims for invasion of privacy are limited by “the freedom of the press,

 matters of legitimate public interest, matters involving public figures, the

 ‘newsworthiness’ of the article”); Grubbs, 174 F. Supp. 3d at 861 (dismissing private

 facts claim under Rule 12(b)(6) because press release reflected matter of public

 concern). When, as here, an invasion of privacy claim is brought against a news

 publication, it is “so dangerous to circumscribe” the public’s “unimpeded access to


                                            12


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC     Document 41     Filed 10/09/25    Page 18 of 31 PageID #: 444


 news” that courts will dismiss such claims unless “the lack of any meritorious public

 interest in disclosure is very clear and its offensiveness to ordinary sensibilities is

 equally clear.” Jenkins v. Dell Pub. Co., 251 F.2d 447 at 450, 452 (3d Cir. 1958);

 see also Lowe v. Hearst Commc’ns, Inc., 487 F.3d 246, 250-51 (5th Cir. 2007)

 (affirming Rule 12(b)(6) dismissal of public facts claim because “newsworthiness is

 to be construed broadly” to prevent “excessive judicial intervention” that could

 deprive the public of critical information);6 Martin v. Widener Univ. Sch. of

 Law,1992 WL 153540, at *18 (Del. Super. Ct. June 4, 1992) (“The media has the

 right, guaranteed by the federal and state constitutions, to publish news and all

 matters of public concern”).

       Here, there is strong public interest in the net worth of the high-profile

 individuals featured in Bloomberg’s Index, which covers other famous figures. See

 Am. Compl. n.2; see also Wolf v. Regardie, 553 A.2d 1213, 1220 n.12 (D.C. 1989)

 (there is legitimate public concern in the breakdown of an individual’s financial

 assets). Indeed, Sun admits that he chose to participate based upon his review of

 other profiles. Am. Compl. ¶ 20. Sun cannot possibly show a “very clear” “lack of


 6
   Defendants cite to jurisdictions outside of Delaware because the Court may look to
 the law of other states that have similarly adopted the claim of public disclosure of
 private facts from the Restatement. See, e.g., Wilcher v. City of Wilmington, 60 F.
 Supp. 2d 298, 302 (D. Del. 1999) (stating that Delaware courts are like “other courts
 that have adopted the Restatement (Second) of Torts for invasion of privacy claims”
 and looking to case law from those other jurisdictions).

                                           13


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC     Document 41      Filed 10/09/25   Page 19 of 31 PageID #: 445


 any meritorious public interest in disclosure,” given that he was aware of and chose

 to participate in the series. Jenkins, 251 F.2d at 450.

       In addition, there is a legitimate public interest in Sun’s financial assets

 because he is a globally recognized cryptocurrency entrepreneur and the founder of

 TRON, “one of the most active open blockchain networks in the world.” Am.

 Compl. ¶ 2. And given increased public scrutiny of cryptocurrency, there is also

 legitimate public interest in the approximate amount of TRON held by its founder,

 which may shed light on the currency’s stability. Am. Compl. ¶¶ 56-58. Because

 the published information easily surpasses the low bar for newsworthy information

 that is guaranteed by the First Amendment, Sun’s claim should be dismissed.

 Jenkins, 251 F.2d at 452; Grubbs, 174 F. Supp. 3d at 861 (granting motion to

 dismiss).

       Second, Sun’s claim should be dismissed for the additional reason that

 Bloomberg’s high-level estimates of Sun’s assets are not highly offensive to a

 reasonable person. Courts routinely dismiss private facts claims where the plaintiff

 has not alleged that the disclosure involved information that could meet this

 demanding test. See, e.g., Boring v. Google Inc., 362 F. App’x 273, 280 (3d Cir.

 2010) (affirming Rule 12(b)(6) dismissal of private facts claim because plaintiff

 failed to allege that publicity was “highly offensive,” making it unnecessary to

 address the other elements); Spilfogel v. Fox Broad. Co., 433 F. App’x 724, 726


                                           14


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC      Document 41     Filed 10/09/25    Page 20 of 31 PageID #: 446


 (11th Cir. 2011) (similar); Daly v. Viacom, Inc., 238 F. Supp. 2d 1118, 1125 (N.D.

 Cal. 2002) (“plaintiff cannot, as a matter of law, demonstrate that the disclosure of

 the fact . . . is ‘beyond the limits of decency’”) (citation omitted); see also Fisher v.

 Perron, 30 F.4th 289, 297-98 (6th Cir. 2022) (conclusory allegation regarding

 disclosure of plaintiff’s personal financial information was not sufficient to state a

 claim).

       Although Sun alleges that the disclosure was uncomfortably specific, Am.

 Compl. ¶ 21, that allegation is hard to square with the Article itself, which included

 only numbers rounded to the nearest thousand tokens for Bitcoin and Ether, the

 nearest hundred thousand tokens for Tether, and the nearest billion tokens for

 Tronix. In addition, as the Court noted in its Opinion denying Sun’s motion for a

 TRO, “Sun himself has disclosed far more specific information about his Bitcoin

 holdings than what Bloomberg published.” TRO Order at 8.7 And other entities


 7
   See Ex. 3, Justin Sun (@justinsuntron), X.com (Feb. 27, 2024, 9:53 AM),
 https://x.com/justinsuntron/status/1762491124692795709. Courts can take judicial
 notice of public social media posts at the motion to dismiss stage. See supra n.1. In
 the alternative, the Court may take judicial notice of the existence of Sun’s post as a
 matter of public record as part of court filings in this case. See D.I. 37, 39; Buck,
 452 F.3d at 260 (in evaluating a motion to dismiss, a court may consider “matters of
 public record, orders, [and] items appearing in the record of the case”) (internal
 quotation omitted) (alteration in original).


                                            15


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC      Document 41     Filed 10/09/25    Page 21 of 31 PageID #: 447


 have also published “similar (if not more detailed) estimates of Sun’s assets.” TRO

 Order at 8 citing D.I. 37 ¶¶ 15-16.8

        Given that Sun and others have widely published more specific information

 about his cryptocurrency holdings, he cannot plausibly allege that Bloomberg’s

 Index was “highly offensive” because such disclosures risk theft or bodily harm.

 Am. Compl. ¶ 64. Boring, 362 F. App’x at 280; see Chisholm v. Foothill Cap. Corp.,

 3 F. Supp. 2d 925, 941 (N.D. Ill. 1998) (disclosure of fact could not be highly

 offensive since plaintiff made no effort to conceal the fact previously).

 III.   THE COMPLAINT FAILS TO STATE A CLAIM FOR PROMISSORY
        ESTOPPEL.

        A plaintiff asserting a claim for promissory estoppel must plausibly allege

 that: “(i) a promise was made; (ii) it was the reasonable expectation of the promisor

 to induce action or forbearance on the part of the promisee; (iii) the promisee

 reasonably relied on the promise and took action to his detriment; and (iv) such

 promise is binding because injustice can be avoided only by enforcement of the

 promise.” Chrysler Corp. (Delaware) v. Chaplake Holdings, Ltd., 822 A.2d 1024,


 8
   See, e.g., Ex. 4, Justin Sun, Arkham, https://intel.arkm.com/explorer/entity/justin-
 sun (last visited Oct. 9, 2025); Ex. 5, Justin Sun’s Crypto Net Worth: A Look Into
 TRON CEO’s Portfolio, Nansen, https://www.nansen.ai/post/justin-suns-crypto-net-
 worth (last visited Oct. 9, 2025). This prior coverage is also subject to judicial notice
 for the fact of prior publication (the truth of the publications is not pertinent to
 Bloomberg’s argument). See supra n.1; Benak ex rel. All. Premier Growth Fund v.
 All. Cap. Mgmt. L.P., 435 F.3d 396, n.15 (3d Cir. 2006).


                                            16


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC     Document 41      Filed 10/09/25   Page 22 of 31 PageID #: 448


 1032 (Del. 2003) (citation omitted).9 “The promise must also be reasonably definite

 and certain.” Territory of U.S. V.I. v. Goldman, Sachs & Co., 937 A.2d 760, 804

 (Del. Ch. 2007), aff’d, 956 A.2d 32 (Del. 2008). “[M]ere expressions of expectation,

 opinion, or assumption are insufficient.” Id. This claim fails for three reasons.

       First, although Sun makes three factual allegations regarding a supposed

 promise—his communications with Shen, his review of past Index profiles, and his

 Telegram messages with Bloomberg—he fails to identify any “reasonably definite

 and certain” promise not to publish a breakdown of his cryptocurrency holdings.

 Territory of U.S. V.I., 937 A.2d at 804.

       Sun alleges he “communicated his significant confidentiality and data security

 concerns” to Shen, and Shen told him the information “provided to Bloomberg for

 the purpose of verifying his personal wealth would be kept strictly confidential and

 would only be used to verify his personal assets for the Billionaires Index profile.”

 Am. Compl. ¶ 18. It is clear that Sun understood that Bloomberg would publish

 some information about his cryptocurrency holding in the Index profile. Id. ¶ 19.

 And while Sun alleges Bloomberg made certain promises about how Bloomberg


 9
  The elements of promissory estoppel are the same in New York and Delaware. See
 374-76 Prospect Place Tenants Ass’n, Inc. v. City of New York, 222 N.Y.S.3d 477,
 481 (2d Dep’t 2024). Because there is no conflict, “the Court should avoid the
 choice-of-law analysis altogether” and apply Delaware law. Deuley v. DynCorp
 Int’l, Inc., 8 A.3d 1156, 1161 (Del. 2010).


                                            17


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC    Document 41     Filed 10/09/25   Page 23 of 31 PageID #: 449


 would secure his financial data, id. ¶¶ 18, 22, Sun does not plausibly allege

 Bloomberg made any promises regarding the detail with which Bloomberg would

 publish his cryptocurrency holdings. Even if Shen’s “assurances” could be read as

 a promise of some confidentiality with respect to his cryptocurrency holdings, Am.

 Compl. ¶ 19, Sun’s “extremely vague” description of Shen’s alleged representations

 about what Bloomberg would publish in the Index does not “amount to a real

 promise” enforceable in court, James Cable, LLC v. Millennium Digit. Media Sys.,

 L.L.C., 2009 WL 1638634, at *5 (Del. Ch. June 11, 2009).

       To bolster his vague allegations, Sun further alleges that, “[b]ased on Ms.

 Shen’s assurances,” he “understood . . . that his cryptocurrency holdings would be

 reported as a single lump sum amount and identified generally as ‘cryptocurrency’

 holdings.’” Id. ¶ 19. But Sun’s “assumption” or “expectation” regarding what

 Bloomberg would publish is insufficient to support a promissory estoppel claim.

 TRO Order at 7. See also Metro. Convoy Corp. v. Chrysler Corp., 208 A.2d 519,

 521 (Del. 1965).

       Beyond his inadequate allegations regarding Shen, Sun alleges that based on

 his review of other profiles on the Index “he determined that the Billionaires Index

 does not generally disclose specific cryptocurrency holdings beyond bitcoin.” Am.


                                         18


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC    Document 41    Filed 10/09/25   Page 24 of 31 PageID #: 450


 Compl. ¶ 20.10 As the Court held in its TRO Opinion, “to the extent Sun relied on

 the contents of other Bloomberg profiles of billionaires, he at most made an

 assumption or formed an expectation. Those profiles—even when coupled with

 Sun’s communications with Bloomberg—do not amount to a ‘reasonably definite

 and certain’ promise of confidentiality.” TRO Order at 7 (citing Territory of U.S.

 V.I., 937 A.2d at 804); see also In re Morrow Park Holding LLC, 2020 WL 3415649,

 at *19 (Del. Ch. June 22, 2020); Sabby Volatility Warrant Master Fund Ltd. v.

 Jupiter Wellness, Inc., 2025 WL 1363171, at *3 (2d Cir. May 12, 2025) (applying

 Delaware law).

       Sun also cites messages between his team and Bloomberg as evidence of

 further assurances of confidentiality. Am. Compl. ¶¶ 22-30. The Court may

 consider them here because they are “matters incorporated by reference [and]

 integral to the claims,” Buck, 452 F.3d at 260. As the Court already noted, the

 messages in the Telegram chat “appear to concern data security,” and do not show

 “that Bloomberg made a promise to refrain from publishing details about Sun’s

 cryptocurrency holdings.” TRO Order at 6.


 10
     But see supra, n.1 citing Bloomberg Billionaires Index (“each individual
 billionaire profile contains a detailed analysis of how that person’s fortune is
 tallied”) (emphasis added).


                                        19


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC    Document 41     Filed 10/09/25   Page 25 of 31 PageID #: 451


       Second, Sun does not plausibly allege that Bloomberg reasonably expected to

 induce Sun’s action or forbearance. Sun merely recites the legal standard for

 promissory estoppel, Am. Compl. ¶¶ 72-74, which the Court need not credit. See

 McKenzie v. Navy Fed. Credit Union, 760 F. Supp. 3d 146, 151 (D. Del. 2024)

 (“When a plaintiff essentially repeats statutory language” or “invokes legal terms”

 the Court is “faced with conclusions and no facts.” (quotation marks omitted)). His

 allegations regarding what he “understood,” e.g., Am. Compl. ¶ 19, do not address

 what Bloomberg intended.

       Third Sun does not allege that he reasonably relied to his detriment—as noted

 above, Sun does not plausibly allege Bloomberg made a “reasonably definite and

 certain” promise regarding how it would publish his cryptocurrency holdings,

 Territory of U.S. V.I., 937 A.2d at 804. Bloomberg’s alleged promises concern how

 Bloomberg would secure Sun’s data. See Am. Compl. ¶¶ 18, 22; D.I. 23-2. Sun

 does, however, allege that he “carefully reviewed other profiles on the Billionaires

 Index to see the extent of personal financial details published by Bloomberg,

 particularly as it related to cryptocurrency holdings.” Am. Compl. ¶ 20. “Based on

 [this] review” Sun “determined that the Billionaires Index does not generally

 disclose specific cryptocurrency holdings beyond bitcoin.” Id. But Sun’s decision

 to proceed was based on his independent investigation, not what Bloomberg

 promised. Because Sun did not “actually rel[y] on [a] promise” by Bloomberg not


                                         20


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC     Document 41     Filed 10/09/25   Page 26 of 31 PageID #: 452


 to publish the cryptocurrency breakdown when Sun provided his financial data, his

 claim fails. VonFeldt v. Stifel Fin. Corp., 714 A.2d 79, 87 (Del. 1998); Brooks v.

 Fiore, 2001 WL 1218448, at *6 (D. Del. Oct. 11, 2001), aff’d, 53 Fed. App’x 662

 (3d Cir. 2002).11

                                  CONCLUSION

       For the reasons stated, the Complaint should be dismissed with prejudice.

  Dated: October 9, 2025                 YOUNG CONAWAY STARGATT
                                         & TAYLOR, LLP
                                         /s/ Robert M. Vrana
                                         James M. Yoch, Jr. (Bar No. 5251)
                                         Robert M. Vrana (Bar No. 5666)
                                         Rodney Square
                                         1000 North King Street
                                         Wilmington, DE 19801
                                         (302) 571-6726
                                         jyoch@ycst.com
                                         rvrana@ycst.com

                                         Thomas G. Hentoff (pro hac vice)
                                         Nicholas G. Gamse (pro hac vice)
                                         Tiffany Keung (pro hac vice)
                                         Ian M. Swenson (pro hac vice)
                                         WILLIAMS & CONNOLLY LLP
                                         680 Maine Avenue, SW
                                         Washington, DC 20024
 11
    The Complaint alleges that “[a]n additional article featuring Mr. Sun’s
 Cryptocurrency Breakdown” is forthcoming, Am. Compl. ¶¶ 39-41, but asserts no
 specific claims as to the then-unpublished article. Bloomberg Businessweek
 subsequently published that article on September 26, 2025. See supra n.2. It
 included the same cryptocurrency breakdown as the Index profile, which, for the
 reasons stated above, does not support a claim for public disclosure of private facts
 or promissory estoppel.


                                          21


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC   Document 41     Filed 10/09/25   Page 27 of 31 PageID #: 453


                                       (202) 434-5000
                                       thentoff@wc.com
                                       ngamse@wc.com
                                       tkeung@wc.com
                                       iswenson@wc.com

                                       Counsel for Defendants


                                        22


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC     Document 41    Filed 10/09/25   Page 28 of 31 PageID #: 454


                IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
                   FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE

                              )
 SUN, YUCHEN JUSTIN,          )
                              )
               Plaintiff(s),  )
                              )
       v.                     ) C.A. No. 25-1007-CFC
                              )
 BLOOMBERG L.P. and BLOOMBERG )
 INC.,                        )
                              )
               Defendant(s).  )


                  CERTIFICATION OF COMPLIANCE
              WITH TYPE, FONT, AND WORD LIMITATIONS

       This brief complies with the Court’s Standing Order Regarding Briefing in

 All Cases. It has been prepared in Times New Roman 14-point type, and contains

 4,998 words, which were counted by Microsoft Word.

  Dated: October 9, 2025                 YOUNG CONAWAY STARGATT
                                         & TAYLOR, LLP

                                         /s/ Robert M. Vrana
                                         James M. Yoch, Jr. (Bar No. 5251)
                                         Robert M. Vrana (Bar No. 5666)
                                         Rodney Square
                                         1000 North King Street
                                         Wilmington, DE 19801
                                         (302) 571-6726
                                         jyoch@ycst.com
                                         rvrana@ycst.com
                                         Thomas G. Hentoff (pro hac vice)
                                         Nicholas G. Gamse (pro hac vice)


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC   Document 41    Filed 10/09/25   Page 29 of 31 PageID #: 455


                                       Tiffany Keung (pro hac vice)
                                       Ian M. Swenson (pro hac vice)
                                       WILLIAMS & CONNOLLY LLP
                                       680 Maine Avenue, SW
                                       Washington, DC 20024
                                       (202) 434-5000
                                       thentoff@wc.com
                                       ngamse@wc.com
                                       tkeung@wc.com
                                       iswenson@wc.com

                                       Counsel for Defendants


                                        2


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC    Document 41    Filed 10/09/25   Page 30 of 31 PageID #: 456


                         CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
       The undersigned hereby certifies that on October 9, 2025, a copy of the

 foregoing document was served on the counsel listed below in the manner

 indicated:

  BY EMAIL                              Isabelle Corbett Sterling
  Jeffrey J. Lyons                      BAKER & HOSTETLER LLP
  BAKER & HOSTETLER LLP                 Transamerica Pyramid Center
  1201 N. Market Street, Suite 1407     600 Montgomery Street, Suite 3100
  Wilmington, DE 19801                  San Francisco, CA 94111
  jjlyons@bakerlaw.com                  isterling@bakerlaw.com

                                        Teresa Goody Guillen
                                        Katherine L. McKnight
                                        BAKER & HOSTETLER LLP
                                        1050 Connecticut Avenue, NW
                                        Suite 100
                                        Washington, D.C. 20036
                                        tgoodyguillen@bakerlaw.com
                                        kmcknight@bakerlaw.com

                                        YOUNG CONAWAY STARGATT
                                        & TAYLOR, LLP

                                        /s/ Robert M. Vrana
                                        James M. Yoch, Jr. (Bar No. 5251)
                                        Robert M. Vrana (Bar No. 5666)
                                        Rodney Square
                                        1000 North King Street
                                        Wilmington, DE 19801
                                        (302) 571-6726
                                        jyoch@ycst.com
                                        rvrana@ycst.com
                                        Thomas G. Hentoff (pro hac vice)
                                        Nicholas G. Gamse (pro hac vice)
                                        Tiffany Keung (pro hac vice)


Case 1:25-cv-01007-CFC   Document 41    Filed 10/09/25   Page 31 of 31 PageID #: 457


                                       Ian M. Swenson (pro hac vice)
                                       WILLIAMS & CONNOLLY LLP
                                       680 Maine Avenue, SW
                                       Washington, DC 20024
                                       (202) 434-5000
                                       thentoff@wc.com
                                       ngamse@wc.com
                                       tkeung@wc.com
                                       iswenson@wc.com

                                       Counsel for Defendants


                                        2