jain.com
Public record. We host this document directly; the copy served here does not depend on any third party. Retrieved November 13, 2026.
Read the documentAlso at archive.org ↗

Perfect 10, Inc. v. <mark>Yandex N.V</mark>. — Entry #232: AMENDED ORDER GRANTING PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Case: Perfect 10, Inc. v. <mark>Yandex N.V</mark>. cand · 3:12-cv-01521

filed March 27, 2012

What this document is

Docket entry #232 · filed September 06, 2013

AMENDED ORDER GRANTING PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT. Signed by Judge Alsup on September 6, 2013. (whalc1, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 9/6/2013) (Entered: 09/06/2013)

Who is involved

Why we have it

We follow this case because a company we track is a party: Nebius (listed as “Yandex Inc”, “Yandex LLC”, “Yandex N.V.”). We checked the full party list on September 29, 2026 and confirmed the match.

A free copy from the RECAP archive of federal court filings (mirrored at the Internet Archive), retrieved November 13, 2026. Federal court filings are public records.

URL
https://www.archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.cand.253123/gov.uscourts.cand.253123.232.0.pdf
Kind
court_filing
Publisher
RECAP
Published
2013-09-06 00:00:00-04:00
Retrieved
2026-11-13 06:51:22.130217-05:00
HTTP status
200
MIME
application/pdf
Bytes
76044
SHA-256
40b4dbb12a5c6449430538533db18bbb89dc8ac4147d49c41738c789bdce6f5f

Document text

16 page(s), 80,274 characters, converted from the PDF's text layer · plain text.

Full text
Case3:12-cv-01521-WHA Document232 Filed09/06/13 Page1 of 16


                                                                          1
                                                                          2
                                                                          3
                                                                          4
                                                                          5
                                                                          6                                IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
                                                                          7
                                                                                                    FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
                                                                          8
                                                                          9
                                                                         10   PERFECT 10, INC.,                                             No. C 12-01521 WHA
                                                                         11


United States District Court
                                                                                              Plaintiff,


                               For the Northern District of California
                                                                         12     v.                                                          AMENDED ORDER
                                                                         13                                                                 GRANTING PARTIAL
                                                                              YANDEX N.V., et al.,                                          SUMMARY JUDGMENT
                                                                         14                   Defendants.
                                                                         15                                                 /

                                                                         16                                              INTRODUCTION
                                                                         17           In this copyright infringement action involving thumbnail images of nude models,
                                                                         18   defendants move for partial summary judgment. For the reasons stated below, the motion is
                                                                         19   GRANTED.
                                                                         20                                                STATEMENT
                                                                         21           1.      THE PARTIES.
                                                                         22           Plaintiff Perfect 10, Inc., a California corporation, creates copyrighted adult
                                                                         23   entertainment products, including photographs. Perfect 10 owns and operates the subscription-
                                                                         24   based internet website perfect10.com. For the purposes of this motion, Perfect 10’s ownership of
                                                                         25   all copyrights at issue in this action is not contested (Br. 10 n.5).
                                                                         26           Defendant Yandex N.V., a Dutch holding company headquartered in the Netherlands,
                                                                         27   owns a family of companies under the “Yandex” brand. It does not itself own or operate any
                                                                         28   internet search engines or websites that host user-generated content. It manages its investments,
                                                                              including its subsidiaries, defendants Yandex LLC and Yandex Inc. (id. at 2). Subsidiary


                                                                                Case3:12-cv-01521-WHA Document232 Filed09/06/13 Page2 of 16


                                                                          1   Yandex LLC is a Russian technology company which operates yandex.ru, Russia’s most popular
                                                                          2   search engine. Subsidiary Yandex Inc., a Delaware corporation located in Palo Alto, provides
                                                                          3   software-development services to Yandex LLC. Yandex Inc. does not own or operate any search
                                                                          4   engines or websites that host user-generated content. It does, however, own servers in Nevada,
                                                                          5   which hosted the search index for Yandex LLC’s international version of its search engine
                                                                          6   (yandex.com) for nine months in 2012–2013 (ibid).
                                                                          7                     A.      Yandex LLC’s Search Engines.
                                                                          8                            (1)     Yandex.ru.
                                                                          9              The yandex.ru search engine is Russia’s most popular search engine and the fourth
                                                                         10   largest search engine worldwide. It functions as follows. A user can query either a web or
                                                                         11   image search. When a user types in a query, the search engine references a search index, which


United States District Court
                               For the Northern District of California
                                                                         12   is a database of all the words or images known to the search engine and their locations. When a
                                                                         13   user searches for an image by typing in text, the search engine analyzes the text and then
                                                                         14   determines whether a given image in its search index fits the user query (id. at 3).
                                                                         15              Yandex.ru’s image search index is compiled by “crawlers” that periodically canvas the
                                                                         16   world-wide internet for images. It does not copy and store full-sized copies of the images it
                                                                         17   finds but rather distills and stores smaller, lower-resolution thumbnail-sized copies. The storage
                                                                         18   occurs on its servers. It reproduces its thumbnail copies on search results pages so that the user
                                                                         19   can determine which, if any, thumbnails are hits. The user can then click through to the third-
                                                                         20   party website that hosts the full-sized image. Yandex.ru also allows users to place ads and click
                                                                         21   on ads. (This is also the way crawlers work for popular search engines based in the United
                                                                         22   States.)
                                                                         23              Because yandex.ru is a Cyrillic-language search engine, it typically crawls Russian-
                                                                         24   language websites, which are normally hosted outside of the United States. The yandex.ru index
                                                                         25   has always been hosted on Russian servers. Yandex.ru does not save data regarding where a
                                                                         26   user goes next after leaving the search-results page.
                                                                         27
                                                                         28


                                                                                                                                 2


                                                                                Case3:12-cv-01521-WHA Document232 Filed09/06/13 Page3 of 16


                                                                          1                          (2)      Yandex.com.
                                                                          2          Yandex.com is a search engine that provides English and other Latin-alphabet based
                                                                          3   search results. Like yandex.ru, it offers both an image search and a web search and generates its
                                                                          4   search results in the same manner. It does not store full-sized copies of its images on its server
                                                                          5   but rather thumbnail copies. Like yandex.ru, yandex.com does not save data regarding where a
                                                                          6   user goes after leaving the yandex.com search-results page. But there are differences. Unlike
                                                                          7   yandex.ru, yandex.com crawls for internet content using Latin-alphabet based terms, has no
                                                                          8   advertising anywhere on its site, and was physically hosted in the United States for a period of
                                                                          9   nine months, between June 2012 and March 2013 (whereas yandex.ru has always been
                                                                         10   physically hosted on servers in Russia). Outside of that nine-month window, yandex.com was
                                                                         11   hosted in Russia like yandex.ru. This civil action was commenced in March 2012.


United States District Court
                               For the Northern District of California
                                                                         12                  B.      Yandex LLC’s User-Generated Content Services.
                                                                         13          Yandex LLC hosts several popular Russian-language services that host user-generated
                                                                         14   content. Narod.ru is a Russian-language site-hosting service where users can build and host their
                                                                         15   own websites (like Wordpress). Fotiki.ru is a Russian-language photo-hosting service and online
                                                                         16   community similar to Shutterfly. Ya.ru is a blog-hosting service. Moikrug.ru is a social network
                                                                         17   for professionals. All of these services are hosted entirely on servers located in Russia. Yandex
                                                                         18   does not track the IP addresses associated with user uploads or downloads on any of these
                                                                         19   services and so it does not know where — geographically — uploads are coming from or
                                                                         20   downloads are going to. Yandex LLC also does not track “right-click” user activity data on any
                                                                         21   of its user-generated content services, so Yandex LLC does not know if users right-click on
                                                                         22   images and save them on their computers, and thus does not know if users in the United States
                                                                         23   download the images it hosts.
                                                                         24          2.      PERFECT 10’S CLAIMS.
                                                                         25          Perfect 10 has brought direct, contributory, and vicarious copyright infringement claims
                                                                         26   against Yandex N.V., Yandex Inc., and Yandex LLC. Perfect 10’s first amended complaint
                                                                         27   refers to them collectively as “Yandex” because “they are inextricably involved in the operation
                                                                         28   of yandex.com and yandex.ru” (Dkt. No. 88 at 2).


                                                                                                                               3


                                                                                Case3:12-cv-01521-WHA Document232 Filed09/06/13 Page4 of 16


                                                                          1           Perfect 10’s direct copyright infringement claims are as follows: (1) narod.ru (site-
                                                                          2   hosting) and fotki.ru (photo-hosting) services hosted full-sized copies of user-uploaded
                                                                          3   infringing Perfect 10 images; (2) yandex.ru and yandex.com hosted infringing thumbnail-sized
                                                                          4   copies of Perfect 10 images and linked them to Yandex-created pages that display similar full-
                                                                          5   sized versions of the images often adjacent to Yandex ads (First Amd. Compl. ¶¶ 23–27; Br.
                                                                          6   2–3; Opp. 5–6).
                                                                          7           Perfect 10’s contributory copyright infringement claims are as follows: (1) yandex.ru
                                                                          8   linked to third-party sites that hosted full-sized infringing copies of Perfect 10’s images; (2)
                                                                          9   Yandex.com linked to third-party websites that hosted full-sized infringing copies of Perfect 10’s
                                                                         10   images; (3) Yandex LLC’s user-generated content sites allowed users to upload and download
                                                                         11   infringing copies of Perfect 10’s images.


United States District Court
                               For the Northern District of California
                                                                         12           Perfect 10’s vicarious copyright infringement claims against Yandex N.V. are based on
                                                                         13   the allegations of direct and contributory infringement purportedly committed by Yandex LLC
                                                                         14   and Yandex Inc.
                                                                         15           According to defendants, in a series of DMCA notices sent to Yandex Perfect 10
                                                                         16   identified 63,756 URLs from Yandex search results pages linking to allegedly infringing Perfect
                                                                         17   10 images hosted on third-party websites. Perfect 10 furthermore asserted 1,474 acts of direct
                                                                         18   infringement based on Narod, Fotki, Ya.ru, and Moikrug.ru’s hosting of Perfect 10 images
                                                                         19   uploaded by third-parties (Br. at 6).
                                                                         20           During discovery in this action, both Perfect 10 and Yandex have used widely-available
                                                                         21   geo-location tools. These software tools obtain IP addresses (the numeral labels assigned to
                                                                         22   computing devices) which can then be used to determine, among other things, the country in
                                                                         23   which a device is located. This is important because legal liability is tied to the location of
                                                                         24   servers and storage media used to capture the images. Perfect 10 has used geo-location tools to
                                                                         25   determine the owners and hosts of various websites that display allegedly infringing Perfect 10
                                                                         26   images. Yandex used geo-location tools to obtain IP addresses and corresponding geo-locations
                                                                         27   of all 63,756 allegedly infringing URLs which Perfect 10 alleged yandex.com and/or yandex.ru
                                                                         28   linked to in their search results.


                                                                                                                                4


                                                                                Case3:12-cv-01521-WHA Document232 Filed09/06/13 Page5 of 16


                                                                          1             Of the 63,756 alleged infringements to which yandex.com and/or yandex.ru linked in
                                                                          2   search results, Yandex contends that 51,959 of them were hosted on servers located outside of
                                                                          3   the United States and 50,485 concerned content hosted by third-party websites. The remaining
                                                                          4   1,474 of the 51,959 URLs located outside of the United States concern content uploaded by
                                                                          5   Yandex users to Narod.ru, Fotki.ru, Ya.ru, and Moikrug.ru accounts hosted by Yandex LLC, all
                                                                          6   of which are located on servers in Russia (id. at 7).
                                                                          7             Yandex served discovery requests asking Perfect 10 to produce all documents showing
                                                                          8   the location of the direct infringements on which the contributory and vicarious claims are based.
                                                                          9   Perfect 10 directed Yandex to documents that claimed to show infringement hosted in the United
                                                                         10   States. Perfect 10 did not, however, produce evidence of direct infringement in the United States
                                                                         11   relevant to the location of the 51,959 alleged infringements hosted on servers outside the United


United States District Court
                               For the Northern District of California
                                                                         12   States. Furthermore, Perfect 10 did not provide evidence of direct infringement in the United
                                                                         13   States relevant to the 1,474 alleged infringements based on user-generated content hosted by
                                                                         14   Yandex (id. at 7–8).
                                                                         15             Yandex now moves for partial summary judgment on the issues of (1) whether Perfect 10
                                                                         16   images hosted on Yandex services located abroad are direct infringements; (2) whether Yandex’s
                                                                         17   thumbnail versions of Perfect 10 images hosted on servers in the United States for a nine-month
                                                                         18   period in 2012–13 constituted fair use; (3) whether Yandex is contributorily liable for linking to
                                                                         19   Perfect 10 images hosted by extraterritorial third parties; and (4) vicarious liability. Both parties
                                                                         20   have submitted briefing on the motion, and oral argument was held on July 11, 2013.
                                                                         21                                                ANALYSIS
                                                                         22             Summary judgment is proper when the pleadings and the evidence in the record “show
                                                                         23   that there is no genuine dispute as to any material fact and that the moving party is entitled to
                                                                         24   judgment as a matter of law.” FRCP 56(a). A dispute is genuine only if there is sufficient
                                                                         25   evidence for a reasonable fact-finder to find for the non-moving party, and material only if the
                                                                         26   fact may affect the outcome of the case. Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc., 477 U.S. 242, 248–49
                                                                         27   (1986).
                                                                         28


                                                                                                                                5


                                                                                Case3:12-cv-01521-WHA Document232 Filed09/06/13 Page6 of 16


                                                                          1          1.       DIRECT INFRINGEMENT CLAIM.
                                                                          2          It is a well-established principle that, as a general rule, the Copyright Act has no
                                                                          3   extraterritorial application. Minden Pictures, Inc. v. Pearson Educ., Inc., No. 11-5385-WHA,
                                                                          4   2013 WL 71774, at *1 (N.D. Cal. Jan 7, 2013), citing L.A. News Serv. v. Reuters Television Int’l,
                                                                          5   Ltd., 149 F.3d 987, 990 (9th Cir. 1998). “Because the copyright laws do not apply
                                                                          6   extraterritorially, each of the rights conferred under the five section 106 categories must be read
                                                                          7   as extending no farther than the United States’ borders. . . . [They] do not reach acts of
                                                                          8   infringement that take place entirely abroad.” Subafilms Ltd. v. MGM-Pathe Comm’n Co., 24
                                                                          9   F.3d 1088, 1094, 1098 (9th Cir. 1994).
                                                                         10          To present a prima facie case of direct infringement, a plaintiff:
                                                                         11                   (1) . . . must show ownership of the allegedly infringed material


United States District Court
                                                                                              and (2) they must demonstrate that the alleged infringers violate at


                               For the Northern District of California
                                                                         12                   least one exclusive right granted to copyright holders under 17
                                                                                              U.S.C. § 106. Even if a plaintiff satisfies these two requirements
                                                                         13                   and makes a prima facie case of direct infringement, the defendant
                                                                                              may avoid liability if it can establish that its use of the images is a
                                                                         14                   “fair use” as set forth in 17 U.S.C. § 107.
                                                                         15   Perfect 10, Inc. v. Amazon.com, Inc., 508 F.3d 1146, 1159 (9th Cir. 2007).
                                                                         16                   A.      Servers Outside the United States.
                                                                         17          Yandex moves for summary judgment on Perfect 10’s direct infringement claims
                                                                         18   “premised on the 1,474 acts of alleged infringement concerning user-generated content [i.e. user-
                                                                         19   uploaded Perfect 10 images] hosted on Yandex’s narod.ru, fotki.ru, ya.ru, and moikrug.ru
                                                                         20   services.” Yandex argues that the evidence is undisputed that these Yandex services are, and
                                                                         21   have always been, hosted on servers in Russia. The “server test” applied by our court of appeals
                                                                         22   makes the hosting website’s computer, rather than the search engine’s computer, the situs of
                                                                         23   direct copyright infringement liability. Amazon, 508 F.3d at 1159–60. Therefore, Yandex
                                                                         24   argues, these foreign-hosted images are extraterritorial and not actionable under the Act. This
                                                                         25   order agrees.
                                                                         26          Perfect 10 does not contest that the servers for these Yandex services are located in
                                                                         27   Russia. Rather, Perfect 10 objects that fotki.ru and narod.ru (and presumably Yandex’s other,
                                                                         28   similar sites) commit “direct infringement by display.” According to Perfect 10, when its images


                                                                                                                                 6


                                                                                Case3:12-cv-01521-WHA Document232 Filed09/06/13 Page7 of 16


                                                                          1   are hosted on servers located in Russia, Yandex violates Perfect 10’s “exclusive display right”
                                                                          2   because users in the United States could download them. Perfect 10 supplies declarations
                                                                          3   establishing that a United States user could download Perfect 10 images from a Yandex server in
                                                                          4   Russia, but no evidence of actual downloads in the United States.
                                                                          5          This theory of liability is rejected. Although Perfect 10 cites Amazon in support of its
                                                                          6   argument, nowhere in that decision did our court of appeals endorse the idea that display of a
                                                                          7   copyrighted image anywhere in the world creates direct copyright liability in the United States
                                                                          8   merely because the image could be downloaded from a server abroad by someone in the United
                                                                          9   States. Such a principle would destroy the concept of territoriality inherent in the Copyright Act
                                                                         10   for works on the internet.
                                                                         11          In a more plausible variation of this argument, Perfect 10 points out that when Yandex’s


United States District Court
                               For the Northern District of California
                                                                         12   servers were located in the United States for a nine-month period, a Yandex.com image search
                                                                         13   performed by a server in the United States could have linked to a Perfect 10 image hosted on a
                                                                         14   Yandex server in Russia. Perfect 10 argues that Yandex should not escape direct copyright
                                                                         15   liability by international distribution of its hosting and searching servers.
                                                                         16          It is not necessary to address the validity of this theory’s merits. It fails for lack of proof.
                                                                         17   Perfect 10 does not demonstrate that Yandex in fact stored or displayed full-sized copies of the
                                                                         18   Perfect 10 images on Yandex’s United States servers. (The issue of thumbnail versions of
                                                                         19   Perfect 10 images stored on Yandex servers in the United States will be addressed below.)
                                                                         20   Perfect 10 only submits that “Yandex suggests it keeps duplicate copies of images on all of its
                                                                         21   servers . . . so full-size Perfect 10 images may very well have been stored on yandex.com’s U.S.
                                                                         22   servers” (Dkt. No. 167 at 24 (citation omitted, emphasis added)). Perfect 10’s speculation that
                                                                         23   full-size image storage may have occurred in the United States is insufficient at the summary
                                                                         24   judgment stage, which is the point in litigation to stand and deliver on admissible evidence. Nor
                                                                         25   is there any evidence of an effort by Yandex to intentionally circumvent copyright liability
                                                                         26   through clever placement of its servers or through manipulation of the corporate form.
                                                                         27
                                                                         28


                                                                                                                                7


                                                                                 Case3:12-cv-01521-WHA Document232 Filed09/06/13 Page8 of 16


                                                                          1              This order accordingly holds that Yandex’s hosting of full-sized Perfect 10 images on
                                                                          2   servers in Russia does not constitute direct copyright infringement in the Untied States. To this
                                                                          3   extent, Yandex’s motion for partial summary judgment is GRANTED.1
                                                                          4                     B.      Servers Inside the United States.
                                                                          5              Yandex concedes that during the nine-month period from June 2012 to March 2013 when
                                                                          6   yandex.com servers were located in the United States, Yandex stored thumbnail versions of
                                                                          7   Perfect 10 images within the territorial reach of the Copyright Act. Yandex does not dispute that
                                                                          8   Perfect 10 owned (and owns still) the copyrights in the images it asserts, nor the basic
                                                                          9   proposition that Yandex’s use of the thumbnails violated Perfect 10’s display and distribution
                                                                         10   rights in these images. Thus, this order assumes that Perfect 10 can make out a prima facie case
                                                                         11   of direct infringement based on these thumbnails. The burden then shifts to Yandex to show that


United States District Court
                               For the Northern District of California
                                                                         12   its thumbnail copies constituted fair use. See Amazon, 508 F.3d at 1158. This order holds that
                                                                         13   Yandex has met its burden.2
                                                                         14              The fair use defense is codified in 17 U.S.C. 107, which states:
                                                                         15                     Notwithstanding the provisions of sections 106 and 106A,
                                                                                                the fair use of a copyrighted work, including such use by
                                                                         16                     reproduction in copies . . . for purposes such as criticism,
                                                                                                comment, news reporting, teaching (including multiple
                                                                         17                     copies for classroom use), scholarship, or research, is not an
                                                                                                infringement of copyright. In determining whether the use
                                                                         18                     made of a work in any particular case is a fair use the factors
                                                                                                to be considered shall include—
                                                                         19
                                                                                                (1) the purpose and character of the use, including whether
                                                                         20                     such use is of a commercial nature or is for nonprofit
                                                                                                educational purposes;
                                                                         21
                                                                         22
                                                                                     1
                                                                                         There is a split in authority as to whether the extraterritoriality question is
                                                                         23   jurisdictional in nature, or should instead be analyzed in terms of whether the extraterritorial
                                                                              acts state a claim for infringement. Litecubes, LLC v. Northern Light Prods., Inc., 523 F.3d
                                                                         24   1353, 1367–68 (Fed. Cir. 2008). Our court of appeals has not ruled on the issue, and it is
                                                                              only mentioned in a footnote in the parties’ briefs. This order assumes without deciding that
                                                                         25   the issue should be analyzed in terms of whether the extraterritorial acts state a claim.
                                                                         26
                                                                                      2
                                                                                         Perfect 10 devotes a section of its opposition to arguing that Perfect 10 thumbnails
                                                                         27   on Yandex’s fotki.yandex.ru search engine are not fair use (Dkt. No. 167 at 13–14). This
                                                                              issue is outside the scope of Yandex’s motion for partial summary judgment. Moreover, the
                                                                         28   fotki.yandex.ru servers are extraterritorial and therefore not susceptible of a claim of direct
                                                                              infringement.

                                                                                                                              8


                                                                                Case3:12-cv-01521-WHA Document232 Filed09/06/13 Page9 of 16


                                                                          1                  (2) the nature of the copyrighted work;
                                                                          2                  (3) the amount and substantiality of the portion used in
                                                                                             relation to the copyrighted work as a whole; and
                                                                          3
                                                                                             (4) the effect of the use upon the potential market for or
                                                                          4                  value of the copyrighted work.
                                                                          5          This order is guided by the decision of our court of appeals in Amazon (which involved
                                                                          6   the same plaintiff, similar facts, and itself relied on an analogous fact pattern in Kelly v. Arriba
                                                                          7   Soft, 336 F.3d 811 (9th Cir. 2003)).
                                                                          8          Regarding the first factor, “[t]he central purpose of this inquiry is to determine whether
                                                                          9   and to what extent the new work is ‘transformative.’” Amazon, 508 F.3d at 1164. Our court of
                                                                         10   appeals found in Amazon (and Kelly) that using a thumbnail image as a pointer to a source of
                                                                         11   information is highly transformative. So too here. Yandex’s thumbnail versions served a


United States District Court
                               For the Northern District of California
                                                                         12   different function than Perfect 10’s use: “improving access to information on the Internet versus
                                                                         13   artistic expression.” Id. at 1165.
                                                                         14          Perfect 10 objects that, unlike the Google search function at issue in Amazon, the
                                                                         15   yandex.com image search linked the thumbnail directly to a larger version of the image, without
                                                                         16   including parts of the surrounding third-party web page, concentrating its fire on a technique
                                                                         17   known as “in-line linking.” When a user of the yandex.com search service clicked on one of the
                                                                         18   thumbnails, the full-size source image appeared in the same browser window. Significantly,
                                                                         19   although it appeared as an integrated page, the full-size image was actually transmitted from the
                                                                         20   third-party website directly to the user’s computer — no copy was ever stored on yandex.com’s
                                                                         21   servers. Put differently, the user would continue to see the Yandex logo near the top of the
                                                                         22   screen (which came from the United States-based server) and would see on the rest of the screen
                                                                         23   a full-size image of the nude model (which came from the third-party server).
                                                                         24          It is true that this integrated composite screen left the impression that the nude model
                                                                         25   image emanated from Yandex, but this objection fails for three reasons. First, our court of
                                                                         26   appeals expressly held that in-line linking to a full-size image does not constitute direct
                                                                         27   infringement. Id. at 1159–60. Without a direct infringement of the full-size image, the fair use
                                                                         28   defense does not come into play — at least as to that full-size image. Second, whether a browser


                                                                                                                                9


                                                                                Case3:12-cv-01521-WHA Document232 Filed09/06/13 Page10 of 16


                                                                          1   window shows only the thumbnail and the full-size image — instead of the full-size image along
                                                                          2   with part of the surrounding web page — does not affect whether the use of the thumbnail has
                                                                          3   been transformed. Third, even if yandex.com’s use of the thumbnail were broadly described as
                                                                          4   an ‘in-line link connected to a full-size image,’ that use remains highly transformative.
                                                                          5          Perfect 10 also objects that when the yandex.com thumbnail images in-line linked to full-
                                                                          6   size versions, the full-size images were displayed beside commercial advertising. These
                                                                          7   objections are not supported by competent evidence. The summary judgment record does not
                                                                          8   show that any of the yandex.com thumbnails (as opposed to thumbnails from Yandex services in
                                                                          9   Russia) were used in connection with advertising. The storage of full-size images and use of
                                                                         10   advertising on the yandex.ru website in Russia is irrelevant here.
                                                                         11          Perfect 10 next argues that Yandex should not be permitted to benefit from the fair use


United States District Court
                               For the Northern District of California
                                                                         12   defense because Yandex has acted in bad faith. Specifically, Perfect 10 contends that because
                                                                         13   Yandex has objected to certain DMCA notices sent by Perfect 10, Yandex should be precluded
                                                                         14   from relying on the fair use defense generally. This argument fails both because Perfect 10 has
                                                                         15   not adduced evidence substantiating its allegation of bad faith, and because Perfect 10 fails to
                                                                         16   explain the connection between its DMCA notices and Yandex’s decision to use thumbnails in
                                                                         17   its search engine. Nor is there any evidence that Yandex’s use of Perfect 10 images for its
                                                                         18   thumbnails was targeted or pretextual.
                                                                         19          Perfect 10 attempts to distinguish this action from Amazon by arguing that Yandex’s
                                                                         20   search service (which was directed towards English-speaking internet users in Russia) did not
                                                                         21   provide a public benefit for “Americans” (Dkt No. 167 at 10–11). This argument is not
                                                                         22   persuasive. Amazon’s discussion of the public benefit from internet search engines was not
                                                                         23   constrained by whether they provided a particular benefit to the United States. Moreover,
                                                                         24   Perfect 10’s argument is contradicted by its own efforts to show that the Yandex’s search service
                                                                         25   reached users in the United States (see Opp. at 19 (stating that .5% of the traffic to yandex.ru
                                                                         26   currently comes from the United States, which means that “yandex.ru receives approximately
                                                                         27   750,000 queries from U.S. users each day, or 22.5 million queries each month.”)).
                                                                         28


                                                                                                                               10


                                                                                Case3:12-cv-01521-WHA Document232 Filed09/06/13 Page11 of 16


                                                                          1          Regarding the second factor, Yandex argues that the nature of the copyrighted works is
                                                                          2   comparable to the images in Amazon and in keeping with that decision should only slightly favor
                                                                          3   Perfect 10. Perfect 10 does not dispute this contention, and this order agrees.
                                                                          4          Regarding the third factor, Perfect 10 argues that the “amount and substantiality” analysis
                                                                          5   should favor Perfect 10 because Yandex allegedly used 40,000 Perfect 10 thumbnails, compared
                                                                          6   to approximately 1,500 used by Google in the Amazon action. Perfect 10 confuses the nature of
                                                                          7   the substantiality analysis. It proceeds, like the concept of infringement, on a copyright-by-
                                                                          8   copyright basis. Thus, the number of allegedly infringed images is not relevant. And, as noted
                                                                          9   above, there is no evidence in the record that Yandex’s enterprise was dedicated to
                                                                         10   circumvention of the Act. As in Amazon and Kelly, this order concludes that the third factor
                                                                         11   favors neither party because the Yandex’s transformative use required use of the entire image,


United States District Court
                               For the Northern District of California
                                                                         12   albeit in much reduced size. See Amazon, 508 F.3d at 1167–68; Kelly, 336 F.3d at 821.
                                                                         13          As for the effect on the market for the original, Perfect 10 first contends that market harm
                                                                         14   should be presumed. In light of Amazon, this argument is rejected because Yandex’s use is
                                                                         15   transformative. See Amazon, 508 F.3d at 1168.
                                                                         16          Perfect 10 next contends that Yandex is responsible for “billions of unauthorized views
                                                                         17   and downloads of its images from websites to which Yandex links Perfect 10 thumbnails” (Opp.
                                                                         18   12 (emphasis removed)). Put differently, Perfect 10 is arguing that Yandex causes it market
                                                                         19   harm because Yandex provides a search service that links to third-party infringers. This
                                                                         20   argument is not substantiated by competent evidence. Perfect 10’s putative support for this
                                                                         21   contention consists of screen shots from third-party websites showing that links on those
                                                                         22   websites leading to Perfect 10 images had been viewed approximately 3.8 million times as of
                                                                         23   December 2012 (which was within the nine-month period that yandex.com servers were located
                                                                         24   in the United States). Perfect 10 does not, however, provide evidence that any of those views
                                                                         25   were the result of yandex.com users clicking on thumbnails stored on yandex.com servers in the
                                                                         26   United States during that nine-month period. The simple fact that the thumbnail links were
                                                                         27   stored in yandex.com’s index and accessible on the internet does not compel a finding that those
                                                                         28   links were actually viewed or used.


                                                                                                                              11


                                                                                Case3:12-cv-01521-WHA Document232 Filed09/06/13 Page12 of 16


                                                                          1          Perfect 10 also theorizes that user views of the 40,000 Perfect 10 thumbnails that were on
                                                                          2   the yandex.com site could have been tracked by Yandex and then compared to statistics for users
                                                                          3   joining perfect10.com as paying members. Perfect 10 claims that such data “would likely show
                                                                          4   that millions of Yandex users have viewed Perfect 10 images at Yandex and none have
                                                                          5   subscribed to Perfect 10” (Opp. 13). This is speculation, not proof.
                                                                          6          Similarly, Perfect 10 contends that in Amazon our court of appeals recognized that there
                                                                          7   was a market for cell phone downloads of reduced-size versions of Perfect 10 images back in
                                                                          8   2007, but that the harm to this market was hypothetical at the time. 508 F.3d at 1168. Pointing
                                                                          9   to the alleged loss of its cell phone download business in the ensuing years, Perfect 10 cries foul.
                                                                         10   Perfect 10 reasons that the market for reduced-size images has dried up since 2007, and Yandex
                                                                         11   has began providing a thumbnail search service since 2007; ergo, Perfect 10 has been harmed by


United States District Court
                               For the Northern District of California
                                                                         12   Yandex. This simple correlation, without more, does not constitute sufficient evidence that
                                                                         13   Yandex’s use of 40,000 thumbnail images between June 2012 and March 2013 affected Perfect
                                                                         14   10’s market. Significantly, in a prior litigation against Google, Perfect 10’s president stated in a
                                                                         15   sworn declaration that Perfect 10’s cell phone download business “effectively ended in 2006.”
                                                                         16   Perfect 10, Inc. v. Google Inc., No. 2:04-cv-9484 (C.D. Cal.) (Dkt. No. 438, filed July 5, 2009).
                                                                         17          In sum, there is no evidence in the record that Yandex.com’s use of thumbnail versions of
                                                                         18   Perfect 10’s image during a nine-month period had any effect on the market for those same
                                                                         19   images. This order therefore concludes that this factor favors neither party.
                                                                         20          Taking a step back, this order must now consider the above factors together “in light of
                                                                         21   the purposes of copyright.” Amazon, 508 F.3d at 1168. As in Amazon, Yandex’s significant
                                                                         22   transformative use must be weighed against the nature of the work, which weighs slightly in
                                                                         23   favor of Perfect 10, and the neutral third and fourth factors. Upon due consideration, this order
                                                                         24   holds that yandex.com’s thumbnails stored on its servers in the United States for a nine-month
                                                                         25   period were fair use.
                                                                         26
                                                                         27
                                                                         28


                                                                                                                               12


                                                                                Case3:12-cv-01521-WHA Document232 Filed09/06/13 Page13 of 16


                                                                          1              2.     CONTRIBUTORY INFRINGEMENT CLAIM.
                                                                          2              Now this order will return to the servers overseas, as well as those in the United States,
                                                                          3   and consider the claim of contributory infringement, that is, the claim that those servers
                                                                          4   contributed to direct infringement by others within the United States.
                                                                          5              “One infringes contributorily by intentionally inducing or encouraging direct
                                                                          6   infringement.” Id. at 1169, citing Metro–Goldwyn–Mayer Studios, Inc. v. Grokster, Ltd., 545
                                                                          7   U.S. 913, 930 (2005). To establish contributory liability, Perfect 10 must first establish direct
                                                                          8   infringement by third parties because secondary liability otherwise cannot exist. Amazon, 508
                                                                          9   F.3d at 1169. For contributory infringement, the servers that matter are the servers where the
                                                                         10   underlying direct infringement occurred. As our court of appeals stated in Subafilms, “a primary
                                                                         11   activity outside the boundaries of the United States, not constituting an infringement cognizable


United States District Court
                               For the Northern District of California
                                                                         12   under the Copyright Act, cannot serve as the basis for holding liable under the Copyright Act
                                                                         13   one who is merely related to that activity within the United States.” Subafilms, 24 F.3d at 1093,
                                                                         14   quoting 3 David Nimmer & Melville B. Nimmer, NIMMER ON COPYRIGHT § 12.04[A][3][b], at
                                                                         15   12-86. Thus, contributory liability can exist regardless of the location of the defendant’s servers
                                                                         16   as long as the underlying direct infringements occurred in the United States.
                                                                         17              Yandex moves for summary judgment on approximately 50,000 yandex.com and
                                                                         18   yandex.ru links identified in Perfect 10’s DMCA notices. The links connect to full-size versions
                                                                         19   hosted on third-party websites. Using the same geo-location tools used by Perfect 10, Yandex
                                                                         20   demonstrates that the third-parties hosting the 50,000 full-sized images are extraterritorial, and
                                                                         21   Perfect 10 does not provide any evidence to the contrary.3 Therefore, Yandex argues, the full-
                                                                         22   size images cannot constitute direct infringement under the Copyright Act, and the yandex.com
                                                                         23   links to them cannot contributorily infringe. This order agrees. To this extent, summary
                                                                         24   judgment is GRANTED.
                                                                         25              Perfect 10 argues that our court of appeals held in Amazon that “a search engine like
                                                                         26   google.com or yandex.com should be held contributorily liable under U.S. law when it provides
                                                                         27
                                                                                     3
                                                                                       Following the submission by Perfect 10 of evidence that 23 of the links connected
                                                                         28   to domestic websites, Yandex withdrew its motion as to those 23 and now only seeks
                                                                              summary judgment on those links for which the extraterritorial situs is uncontested.

                                                                                                                                  13


                                                                                Case3:12-cv-01521-WHA Document232 Filed09/06/13 Page14 of 16


                                                                          1   links and user traffic to infringing websites regardless of their ‘geographical location’ because it
                                                                          2   assists U.S. users in gaining access to the infringing materials offered by those websites” (Opp.
                                                                          3   15). This interpretation of Amazon is incorrect. Implicit in the passage in Amazon cited by
                                                                          4   Perfect 10 was the notion that the prerequisite for contributory infringement — an act of direct
                                                                          5   infringement in the United States — was satisfied. Amazon does not change the view adopted by
                                                                          6   our court of appeals in Subafilms: if third-party activity is extraterritorial, it cannot directly
                                                                          7   infringe, and in turn there can be no contributory infringement. For the same reason, Perfect
                                                                          8   10’s insistence that the Yandex.com servers were located in the United States for a nine-month
                                                                          9   period does not change the contributory liability analysis. Again, it must also be emphasized
                                                                         10   that there is no evidence that Yandex is or has been intentionally attempting to circumvent
                                                                         11   copyright liability by funneling internet users to Perfect 10 images.


United States District Court
                               For the Northern District of California
                                                                         12           Perfect 10 also invokes the predicate act doctrine, “whereby a plaintiff can collect
                                                                         13   damages for foreign copyright violations that are directly linked to the domestic copyright
                                                                         14   violation. Minden, 2013 WL 71774 at *1, citing L.A. News Serv. v. Reuters Television Int’l, Ltd.,
                                                                         15   149 F.3d 987, 991–92 (9th Cir. 1998). Perfect 10’s argument that a contributory infringement
                                                                         16   could constitute a predicate violation still presupposes a territorial direct infringement to support
                                                                         17   contributory liability. For the 50,000 links at issue, no territorial direct infringement exists.
                                                                         18           Perfect 10 further argues that the 40,000 yandex.com thumbnails that were stored in the
                                                                         19   United States for nine months could constitute predicate direct infringements, notwithstanding
                                                                         20   Yandex’s fair use defense. This theory of liability ends where it starts. Because (as explained
                                                                         21   above) those yandex.com thumbnails constituted fair use, they did not infringe, and there is no
                                                                         22   predicate violation.
                                                                         23           3.      VICARIOUS LIABILITY CLAIM.
                                                                         24           Amazon sets out the test for vicarious liability:
                                                                         25                   One infringes vicariously by profiting from direct infringement
                                                                                              while declining to exercise a right to stop or limit it. As this
                                                                         26                   formulation indicates, to succeed in imposing vicarious liability, a
                                                                                              plaintiff must establish that the defendant exercises the requisite
                                                                         27                   control over the direct infringer and that the defendant derives a
                                                                                              direct financial benefit from the direct infringement.
                                                                         28


                                                                                                                                14


                                                                                Case3:12-cv-01521-WHA Document232 Filed09/06/13 Page15 of 16


                                                                          1   508 F.3d at 1173. Like contributory liability, vicarious liability requires an underlying act of
                                                                          2   direct infringement. Yandex’s websites in Russia do not directly infringe because they are
                                                                          3   beyond the territorial reach of the Copyright Act. Yandex’s thumbnails that were stored on
                                                                          4   servers in the United States for a nine-month period did not infringe because they were fair use.
                                                                          5   This order has also determined that Yandex is not contributorily liable based on extraterritorial
                                                                          6   third-party infringement. Thus, for these issues specifically within the scope of Yandex’s
                                                                          7   motion for partial summary judgment, there can be no vicarious liability. To this extent,
                                                                          8   Yandex’s motion for summary judgment is GRANTED.
                                                                          9          4.      UNITED STATES DOWNLOADS.
                                                                         10          Finally, Perfect 10 contends that it has “demonstrated that the U.S. Copyright Act applies
                                                                         11   by presenting evidence of downloads in the United States” (Opp. 17). It is not clear from Perfect


United States District Court
                               For the Northern District of California
                                                                         12   10’s opposition whether it makes this argument in the context of its allegations of direct
                                                                         13   infringement, contributory infringement, jurisdiction, or something else. Regardless, the same
                                                                         14   result pertains. Whether the alleged infringing United States downloads are analyzed as a basis
                                                                         15   for direct or contributory liability, at the summary judgment stage Perfect 10 must adduce
                                                                         16   evidence that such downloads occurred. It has not done so.
                                                                         17          Perfect 10 asserts that at “least 40 Perfect 10 images were likely uploaded to Yandex-
                                                                         18   hosted websites” (Dkt. No. 167 at 19 (emphasis added)). As explained above, it is not contested
                                                                         19   that the Yandex websites that host images are extraterritorial, which precludes direct
                                                                         20   infringement for hosting the uploaded images.
                                                                         21          Perfect 10 submitted declarations from a private investigator, a web developer, and a
                                                                         22   graphic designer (Dkt. Nos. 167-28–30). In each one, the declarant states they were asked by
                                                                         23   Perfect 10 to use various Yandex services to download Perfect 10 images to computers located
                                                                         24   within the United States. Each declarant confirms that this is “possible” and then explains the
                                                                         25   process by which they each accomplished the task. These declarations do not change any of the
                                                                         26   conclusions herein. Perfect 10’s own downloads (and downloads by its agents) conducted as
                                                                         27   part of its investigation do not constitute direct infringements because Perfect 10 cannot infringe
                                                                         28   its own copyrights. Nor do any of the declarations rise to the level of expert testimony showing


                                                                                                                              15


                                                                                Case3:12-cv-01521-WHA Document232 Filed09/06/13 Page16 of 16


                                                                          1   that any particular quantity of such downloads have in fact occurred. This order agrees that it is
                                                                          2   possible for someone in the United States to download infringing copies of Perfect 10 images
                                                                          3   using Yandex’s search engine. The summary judgment record does not establish, however, that
                                                                          4   any such downloading has actually occurred.
                                                                          5             In its opposition brief, Perfect 10 claims that “it is a foregone conclusion that U.S. users
                                                                          6   will download [copyrighted] images” and “the enormous traffic to Yandex search engines
                                                                          7   statistically guarantees that downloads of Perfect 10 images . . . by U.S. users have taken place”
                                                                          8   (Dkt. No. 167 at 19). These claims are not supported by expert testimony, documents, or other
                                                                          9   evidence. Thus, on the present record, they are speculative and unsubstantiated. In sum,
                                                                         10   Perfect 10’s assertions regarding United States downloads do not change any of the conclusions
                                                                         11   herein.


United States District Court
                               For the Northern District of California
                                                                         12                                                CONCLUSION
                                                                         13             For the reasons stated above, Yandex’s motion for partial summary judgment is
                                                                         14   GRANTED. This order disposes of Perfect 10’s direct infringement claims in their entirety. A
                                                                         15   portion of Perfect 10’s claims for contributory and vicarious liability remain in the case and shall
                                                                         16   proceed to trial.
                                                                         17
                                                                         18             IT IS SO ORDERED.
                                                                         19
                                                                         20   Dated: September 6, 2013.
                                                                                                                                      WILLIAM ALSUP
                                                                         21                                                           UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE
                                                                         22
                                                                         23
                                                                         24
                                                                         25
                                                                         26
                                                                         27
                                                                         28


                                                                                                                                 16