Case 1:23-cv-00079-ABJ         Document 388        Filed 10/15/24     Page 1 of 3
                                                                                              FILED


                        "
 "
"



"


"
"
                                                                                           1:40 pm, 10/15/24
                             "
 "


"" ! "
                                                                                       Margaret Botkins
[
8+,[''[< : 9[ 3/+[                       
                                  Clerk of Court
(/&
 ,[9[7YOKGLD[IGKGT>=[HG9:GHGTY[            
[
OKP9MY[                                           

                                                    

         0H9GLTGA[                                 
[
                                                    [

                                                 
[      GVGH[-O[6[
                                                    
[
) ,/+[78/)#
[4[+51[                        
[
(([9[>H9X9Q>[HGKGT><[HG9:GJGTY[;OKP9LY[         
[
)$/+[015+13[''[9[>H9X9Q>[                    

HGKGT><[HG9:GHGTY[;OKP9LY[522[1[804/[           

 +[9[>H9X9Q>[;OQPOQ9TGOL[ 4[/1!
 ,[          
[
(5[9[9YK9L[ SH9L<[OKP9LY[                      
[
3/+ 3
[(([9[>H9X9R>[HGKGT><[                  
[
HG9:GHGTY[;OKP9NZ[ 5*#[                          
[
4
./'/
 3[
/($
[/*0+8[                       

[9YK9L[ SH9L<[OKP9LY[ 5* +[                   

4+/'/
 3[
/1
 [( )!4[                      

9[
>OQDG9[;OQPOQ9TGOL[9L<[%/
+[/3[  [         
[
Q>H9T><[P>QSONS[9L<[;OKP9LG>S[XEO[;OLTQOH[          

OQ[<GQ>;T[SOK>[OQ[9HH[O?[TE>[L9K>=[>?>L<9LTS[     
[
                                                    [
         >@L<9LTS[                                
[


      "

 "
 """
 "


"
"
"


"
      ""
 "

 "
"""


" " "!"

 """
 "


"
"

"
"
 
"


"
      " 
" 

""

 
"" 
 
"


         4 3[)[4"1[;OK>S[:>BQ>[TE>[OUQT[OL[TE>[
-0$ .4+$)04
)40$,2'
0 4+0$+)4 +4

$.0-$
20 4 ''4 !4# 4 00

# 4 2)/4 )4

-2 4 )0 - .04    $)"4  '4 34 # 4 ' -&4 !4# 4

$.0-$
04 +2-04 2-.2
)04 +4 #$.4 +2-0.4 ( ) 4 - %2"( )04 -$0.4 !4 10

#( )04 )4


-)$/#( *04
0$,2'
0 4+0$+)4

                 5F>[OUQT[E9S[;9Q>CHHY[Q>WG>X><[TE>[0$,2'
0 4+0$+)


     Case 1:23-cv-00079-ABJ             Document 388           Filed 10/15/24        Page 2 of 3
       '


              .<4XFQINX=MX0CMFX03S=M43XN<0NX0CCXF5XN<4X*0KP=4MX<0S4XEFTXI402<43X0E3XM=;E43XN<4=I

               TI=NO4EX -4NNC4D4ENX ;I44D4ENX 0E3X &QNQ0CX ,4C40M4MX 
-4NOC4D4ENX ;I44D4EN

               *QIMQ0ENX NGX N<4=IX -4NNC4D4ENX ;I44D4ENX N<4X *0IO=4MX T=CCX MFFEX 14X 7C=E;X N<4=I

               -N>HQC0N=FEXF5X
=MD=MM0CXT=N<X*I4?Q3=24X0E3X0M@=E;XN<4X
GQJNXNGX4EN4IX=NMX)I34IXG5


=MD=MM0CXT=N<X*I4?Q3=24

            .<4XFQKNX=MX:JP<4IX03S=M43XN<0NXN<4X*0KO=4MX<0S4XEFTX0;I443X0E3XD4DGI>0C>W43X>E

               N<4=IX -4NNC4D4ENX ;I44D4ENXN<0NX N<4XHI4?Q3;D4ENX0NN02<43X :E3MX 14=E;X <4C3X 0E3

               =ES4MN43X1VXN<4XC4I@XF5XN<4X
=MNI=2NX FQKPXHQIMQ0ENXNGXN<>MXFQINMX40IC=4IXFI34IM

               M<FQC3XEFTX14X3=MNI>1QN43X1VXN<4X
C4IAXF5XN<4X
=MNI=2NXGQINXNGX&=E4)E4X/VFD=E;


0N0X
4EN4IX$$X0E3XX<4V4EE4X$$XI4MH42N=S4CVX0MX8CCFTM

                   0   .GX&=E4)E4X/VFD=E;X
0N0X
4EN4IX$%XN<4XMQDXG5 X0E3

                   1 .GXX<4V4EE4X%%XN<4XMQDXG5X  

               EVXI4D0=E=E;X10C0E24X<4C3X=EX N<4X
GQINMX,4;=MNLX094IXN<4X3=MNI=1QN=GEMX01GS4X

               M<0CCX14XQM43XNFXM0N=M5VX0EVX=EN4I4MNX0E3GIX64MXGT=E;XNGXN<4X
FQINX0E3X0EVX10C0E24X

               I4D0=E=E;X 05N4IX M0N=M5V=E;X 0EVX =EN4I4MNX 0E3GIX 544MX FT=E;X NFX N<4X
FQINX M<0CCX 14X

               3>MNI=1QN43XNGX&=E4)E4X/VFD=E;X
0N0X4EN4IX$$ X

            .<4X
GQIOX 4UHJ4MMCVX 0HHIGS4MX N<4X +0IN=4MX -N=HQC0N43X 'FN=FEX 8IX N<4X =DD43=0N4

               3=M1QIM4D4ENXG5XN<4X0NN02<43XHI4?Q3;D4ENX:E3MX0MX34M2I=143X01GS4

              .<4X
GQIOX!#(
-XN<0NXN<4I4X=MX;FG3X20QM4XM<FTEX0E3XN<4X=EN4I4MNMXG5X?QMN=24X0I4

               14MNX M4IS43X 1VX <0S=E;X N<4X
C4I@X F5XN<4X
=MNI=2NX
FQIOX =DD43=0N4CVX 3=MH4IM4X NF

               &=E4)E4X/VFD=E;X
0N0X4EN4IX$$
X0E3X
X
<4V4EE4X$$
XN<4X0NN02<43X:E3M

               14=E;X<4C3X0E3X=ES4MN43X1VXN<4XC4I@XF5XN<4X
=MNI=2NX
GQKNX0MX34M2I=143X01GS4

       #.X#-X .",!),X),
 ,
XN<0NX N<4X
C4IBXF5XN<4X
=MNI=2NX
GRINX 8IX N<4X
=MNI=2NX F5X

/VGD=E;X M<0CCX =DD43=0N4CVX 3=M1QIM4XN<4X0NN02<43X:E3MX14=E;X<4C3X1VXN<4X
C4I@X F5XN<4X
>MNI=2NX


                                                   X


     Case 1:23-cv-00079-ABJ           Document 388        Filed 10/15/24       Page 3 of 3
       %


 QXSU_ RXSTY:PU_ UQ_ UEHT_ QXSUT_ QSHDHP:L_ :P=_ :N>P=>=_ 2S>JX=DN>PU_ 8SHUT_ Q@_
UU:<FN>PU_ :P=_

&:SPHTEN>PU_:T_BLLQ]T_


 5Q_0HP>1P>_8^QOHPD_":U:_ >PU>S_.. _VG>_TZN_Q@_
 _:P=

        5Q_ _ G>^>PP>_.. _UG>_TXN_Q@_
_)_ 


P^_S>N:IPHPD_;:L:P<>_E>L=_IP_UG>_ QXSUT_3>DITUS^_:@U>S_UG>_=ITUSI;YUIQPT_:;Q[>_TE:LM_;>_XT>=_UQ_

T:UHT@^_:P^_IPU>S>TU_:P=QS_A>T_Q]IPD_UQ_UE>_ QXSU_:P=_:P^_;:L:P<>_S>N:HPHPD_:C>S_T:UIT@^IPD_:P^_

HPU>S>TU_:P=QS_@>>T_Q]IPD_ UQ_UG>_ QXSU_TG:LL_ ;>_ =ITUSH;XU?=_ UQ_0IP>1P>_ 8^QNIPD_":U:_ >PU>S_

// _:P=_

       *5_+4_%635(#3_13"$3$"_UE:U_QP<>_:LL_Q@_UE>_:WU:<E>=_@YP=T_F:\>_;>>P_=ITUSH;XU>=_;^_

UE>_ L>SK_ Q@_ UE>_ "HTUSH<U_ !QXSU_ :;Q[>_ UGHT_ QXSVT_ 2S>JX=DN>PU_ 8SIUT_ Q@_
UU:<FN>PU_ :P=_

':SPITEN>PU_TE:LL_;>_<QPTH=>S>=_=ITTQL[>= _


                           

       "
_5$"_UGHT_ =:^_Q@_1<UQ;>S_ _


                                     9_5($_ 1735_

L:P_ _,QGPTQP_
                                                            6PIU>=_4U:U>T_"ITU_ <U_-X=D>_


                                                _