Case 2:26-cv-00284-KKE Document 119 Filed 08/28/26 Page 1 of 8 1 THE HONORABLE KYMBERLY K. EVANSON 2 3 4 5 6 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 7 WESTERN DISTRICT OF WASHINGTON AT SEATTLE 8 9 G.P., an individual, Case No. 2:26-cv-00284-KKE 10 11 Plaintiff, PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF 12 SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY IN 13 v. OPPOSITION TO THE MOTIONS 14 TO DISMISS OF DEFENDANTS 15 JOSE HERNANDEZ AREVALO, an individual; META PLATFORMS, INC., 16 MARICELA JIMENEZ, an individual; REDDIT, INC., AND YOUTUBE, 17 TURO, INC., a Delaware corporation; et al., LLC 18 19 Defendants. 20 21 I. INTRODUCTION 22 23 Pursuant to the Court's inherent authority to consider intervening authority bearing on pending 24 motions, and consistent with the practice of this District, Plaintiff G.P. respectfully submits this 25 Notice of Supplemental Authority to bring to the Court's attention three decisions and one 26 statutory provision that bear directly on the Section 230 defenses raised in the pending motions NOTICE OF SUPPL. AUTHORITY – 1 ROSSI & CO., P.C. 616 33rd Ave NW, Gig Harbor, WA 98335 Case No. 2:26-cv-00284-KKE Tel: 303.222.0300 Case 2:26-cv-00284-KKE Document 119 Filed 08/28/26 Page 2 of 8 1 to dismiss of Defendants Meta Platforms, Inc. (“Meta”), Reddit, Inc. (“Reddit”), and YouTube, 2 LLC (“YouTube”) (collectively, the “Platform Defendants”). 3 4 Plaintiff submits this Notice for the limited purpose of identifying authority, and does not argue 5 matters already briefed. The most significant of the authorities identified below is a decision of 6 the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit issued on August 10, 2026 — after the 7 close of briefing on each of the pending motions — holding that Section 230 of the 8 Communications Decency Act provides a defense to liability rather than an immunity from suit. 9 Because each of the pending motions is premised on the contrary characterization, and because 10 that decision is binding on this Court, Plaintiff respectfully submits that it warrants the Court's 11 attention before any ruling issues. 12 13 Plaintiff advises the Court that she intends to file, in the near term, a motion for leave to file a 14 short supplemental opposition addressing two further post-briefing developments that require 15 argument rather than mere notice: the multistate settlement announced by Meta on August 26, 16 2026, and the findings of the Federal Trade Commission's September 2024 staff report concerning 17 platform data and advertising practices. Plaintiff does not present those matters here, and reserves 18 them for that motion. 19 20 II. SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY 21 A. California v. Meta Platforms, Inc., Nos. 24-7032 et al. (9th Cir. Aug. 10, 2026) 22 23 On August 10, 2026, the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit dismissed, for lack 24 of appellate jurisdiction, interlocutory appeals taken by Meta Platforms, Inc. and by the 25 ByteDance and TikTok entities from the district court’s rulings on their Section 230 defenses in 26 the social-media adolescent-addiction multidistrict litigation, No. 4:22-md-03047-YGR (N.D. NOTICE OF SUPPL. AUTHORITY – 2 ROSSI & CO., P.C. 616 33rd Ave NW, Gig Harbor, WA 98335 Case No. 2:26-cv-00284-KKE Tel: 303.222.0300 Case 2:26-cv-00284-KKE Document 119 Filed 08/28/26 Page 3 of 8 1 Cal.). California v. Meta Platforms, Inc., Nos. 24-7032, 24-7037, 24-7265, 24-7300, 24-7304 & 2 24-7312, ___ F.4th ___, 2026 WL 2292281 (9th Cir. Aug. 10, 2026) (Nguyen, J.). The appeals 3 were argued and submitted January 6, 2026, and the opinion was filed August 10, 2026. The slip 4 opinion is publicly available at https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2026/08/10/24- 5 7300.pdf. Because the opinion has not yet been assigned a Federal Reporter citation, page 6 references below are to the slip opinion. 7 8 The Court of Appeals held: “Because section 230 merely provides a defense to liability — not 9 immunity from suit — we lack appellate jurisdiction to review the district court’s rulings on an 10 interlocutory basis.” Slip op. at 15. It restated that holding at the conclusion of its analysis: 11 “Therefore, we hold that section 230 provides a defense to liability, not immunity from suit, and 12 an order denying this defense can be effectively reviewed on appeal from a final judgment.” Slip 13 op. at 27. 14 15 The panel grounded that conclusion in the Supreme Court’s decision in Geo Group, Inc. v. 16 Menocal, 607 U.S. 438 (2026), explaining that “it is important to distinguish between immunity 17 from suit and ‘immunity’ that is a mere defense to liability.” Slip op. at 20. Addressing Section 18 230(c)(1) specifically, the panel held that “[t]his substantive protection ‘describes a defense, not 19 an immunity.’” Slip op. at 24. It reaffirmed that “[a]bsent a final judgment, we generally lack 20 jurisdiction to review the denial of a Rule 12(b)(6) motion.” Slip op. at 17 (quoting Boshears v. 21 PeopleConnect, Inc., 76 F.4th 858, 860 (9th Cir. 2023)). 22 23 The panel further held that the Court of Appeals’ own prior references to Section 230 “immunity” 24 are not controlling. Acknowledging that “we sometimes describe it as ‘immunity from suit,’” the 25 panel stated: “But none of this usage is binding, because we have never addressed whether the 26 denial of a section 230 defense is a collateral order.” Slip op. at 26. Among the decisions the panel NOTICE OF SUPPL. AUTHORITY – 3 ROSSI & CO., P.C. 616 33rd Ave NW, Gig Harbor, WA 98335 Case No. 2:26-cv-00284-KKE Tel: 303.222.0300 Case 2:26-cv-00284-KKE Document 119 Filed 08/28/26 Page 4 of 8 1 identified as containing that non-binding usage is Doe 1 v. Meta Platforms, Inc., 174 F.4th 1159, 2 1166–67 (9th Cir. 2026). Id. 3 4 Scope of the decision. In candor to the Court, Plaintiff states plainly what this decision does and 5 does not hold. It is a decision about appellate jurisdiction under the collateral-order doctrine. The 6 panel observed that the Court of Appeals had “never addressed whether the denial of a section 7 230 defense is a collateral order,” and it resolved that question. Slip op. at 26. The panel held that 8 Section 230(e)(3) and Section 230(c)(1) each provide a defense to liability rather than immunity 9 from suit, and that the district court’s orders did not “conclusively determine the disputed 10 question” under the first Cohen requirement. Slip op. at 27. The appeals were dismissed. The 11 panel did not reach the merits of any Section 230 ruling below, did not address the allocation of 12 the burden of proof, and did not decide the scope of Section 230 as applied to conduct of the kind 13 alleged in this action. Plaintiff does not suggest otherwise. 14 15 Relevance. Two consequences follow, and Plaintiff presses only those two. First, 16 characterization. Each of the three pending motions proceeds from the premise that Section 230 17 confers an immunity entitling the Platform Defendants to be relieved of this litigation at the 18 pleading stage. The Ninth Circuit has now held, in terms binding on this Court, that Section 230 19 is a defense to liability and not an immunity from suit. Whatever the ultimate merits, the Platform 20 Defendants are not entitled to be spared the burdens of litigation as such; they are entitled to the 21 benefit of a defense, established in the ordinary course. 22 23 Second, remedy and prejudice. The panel held that an order denying the Section 230 defense “can 24 be effectively reviewed on appeal from a final judgment.” Slip op. at 27. Any error in declining 25 to dismiss at the pleading stage is therefore fully correctable later, and at no cost to the Platform 26 Defendants beyond the ordinary burdens of defending a suit. The converse is not true for Plaintiff: NOTICE OF SUPPL. AUTHORITY – 4 ROSSI & CO., P.C. 616 33rd Ave NW, Gig Harbor, WA 98335 Case No. 2:26-cv-00284-KKE Tel: 303.222.0300 Case 2:26-cv-00284-KKE Document 119 Filed 08/28/26 Page 5 of 8 1 a dismissal at the pleading stage of claims arising from the amplification and monetization of an 2 unlawfully intercepted recording of her private communications forecloses development of the 3 very record on which the defense depends. That asymmetry matters here, because Plaintiff’s First 4 Amended Complaint does not allege merely that the Platform Defendants hosted a video uploaded 5 by Defendant Arevalo. It alleges affirmative, self-interested conduct by each: that Meta’s systems 6 identified Plaintiff’s nonconsensually recorded footage and selected it for amplification to a mass 7 audience; that Reddit’s moderators curated and promoted that footage to positions of maximum 8 visibility; and that YouTube matched the footage through its Content ID system and monetized it 9 through advertising revenue in which YouTube itself shared. Whether that conduct is passive 10 publication of another’s content or the Platform Defendants’ own conduct is a genuinely disputed 11 question, and one that the Court of Appeals has now confirmed may be tested without any loss of 12 the Platform Defendants’ appellate rights. 13 14 B. Commonwealth v. Meta Platforms, Inc. (Mass. Apr. 10, 2026) 15 On April 10, 2026, the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts unanimously affirmed the denial 16 of Meta's motion to dismiss premised on Section 230(c)(1), holding that Section 230 did not 17 immunize Meta against claims directed at the design of its own platform features, as distinguished 18 from claims directed at content authored by third parties. Commonwealth v. Meta Platforms, Inc. 19 (Mass. Apr. 10, 2026). 20 21 Relevance. Plaintiff cites this decision for one point only: the distinction between a platform’s 22 liability as the publisher of another’s content, which Section 230 addresses, and its liability for its 23 own design, curation, and monetization conduct, which Section 230 does not. In candor to the 24 Court, Plaintiff discloses that on the separate question of whether Section 230 confers a right to 25 be free of suit, the Supreme Judicial Court took a view different from the one the Ninth Circuit 26 adopted on August 10, 2026, and declined to follow the Tenth Circuit’s contrary analysis. That NOTICE OF SUPPL. AUTHORITY – 5 ROSSI & CO., P.C. 616 33rd Ave NW, Gig Harbor, WA 98335 Case No. 2:26-cv-00284-KKE Tel: 303.222.0300 Case 2:26-cv-00284-KKE Document 119 Filed 08/28/26 Page 6 of 8 1 divergence is now academic in this Court, because California v. Meta Platforms, Inc. is binding 2 here and Commonwealth is not. Plaintiff relies on the Ninth Circuit for the characterization 3 question and on Commonwealth solely for the design-versus-content distinction. 4 5 C. Bouck v. Meta Platforms, Inc. (N.D. Cal. Mar. 24, 2026), and the Material- 6 Contribution Line 7 In Bouck v. Meta Platforms, Inc., 2026 WL 810036 (N.D. Cal. Mar. 24, 2026), appeal filed (9th 8 Cir. July 23, 2026), the district court rejected Meta’s Section 230 defense at the pleading stage 9 where the plaintiffs alleged that Meta’s own tools had materially contributed to the alleged 10 unlawfulness of the content at issue, applying Fair Housing Council of San Fernando Valley v. 11 Roommates.com, LLC, 521 F.3d 1157, 1167–68 (9th Cir. 2008) (en banc). 12 13 In candor to the Court, Plaintiff notes that a companion decision issued the same day reached the 14 opposite result on different allegations. Suddeth v. Meta Platforms, Inc., 2026 WL 810252 (N.D. 15 Cal. Mar. 24, 2026), sustained a Section 230 defense where the plaintiffs alleged only that 16 content-neutral advertising tools had disseminated fraudulent advertisements authored entirely by 17 third parties, a theory the court characterized as “nothing more than an averment of facilitation.” 18 Plaintiff further notes the Ninth Circuit's decision in Doe 1 v. Meta Platforms, Inc., 174 F.4th 19 1159 (9th Cir. 2026) (No. 24-1672, decided Apr. 28, 2026), in which the Court of Appeals applied 20 Section 230 to claims premised on algorithmic content delivery, and in which two members of 21 the panel filed separate concurring opinions questioning the breadth of publisher immunity as 22 applied to algorithm-driven recommendation. 23 24 Plaintiff notes that the August 10, 2026 opinion itself confirms this line. Surveying its own 25 precedent, the panel observed that Section 230 “does not ‘declare a general immunity from 26 liability deriving from third-party content,’” that “[s]ervice providers continue to face liability for NOTICE OF SUPPL. AUTHORITY – 6 ROSSI & CO., P.C. 616 33rd Ave NW, Gig Harbor, WA 98335 Case No. 2:26-cv-00284-KKE Tel: 303.222.0300 Case 2:26-cv-00284-KKE Document 119 Filed 08/28/26 Page 7 of 8 1 ‘the creation of content’” and that courts must “examine each claim to determine whether a 2 plaintiff’s ‘theory of liability would treat a defendant as a publisher or speaker of third-party 3 content.’” California v. Meta Platforms, Inc., slip op. at 24 (quoting Calise v. Meta Platforms, 4 Inc., 103 F.4th 732, 740 (9th Cir. 2024); Barnes v. Yahoo!, Inc., 570 F.3d 1096, 1100, 1101 (9th 5 Cir. 2009); and Fair Hous. Council of San Fernando Valley v. Roommates.com, LLC, 521 F.3d 6 1157, 1163 (9th Cir. 2008) (en banc)). Notably, the panel paired the observation that service 7 providers “continue to face liability for ‘the creation of content’” with a citation to 47 U.S.C. § 8 230(e) — the subsection that contains the communications-privacy carve-out discussed in Part 9 II.D below. Slip op. at 24. Claim-by-claim examination, not a global immunity, is what the Ninth 10 Circuit requires. 11 12 Relevance. Read together, these decisions mark the operative line rather than obscure it. Section 13 230 protects the content-neutral dissemination of third-party material; it does not protect a 14 provider's material contribution to the unlawfulness. Plaintiff's claims fall on the unprotected side 15 of that line, and are not facilitation claims. Plaintiff does not seek to hold the Platform Defendants 16 liable for the content of Arevalo's recording, or for the fact that it existed on their services. She 17 seeks to hold them liable for their own subsequent, revenue-generating acts of identifying, 18 ranking, promoting, and monetizing a recording of her private oral communications that was 19 unlawfully intercepted — acts each Platform Defendant performed for its own commercial 20 account, after and independent of any third-party authorship. 21 22 D. 47 U.S.C. § 230(e)(4) 23 Finally, Plaintiff notes a provision of the statute itself. Section 230(e)(4) provides: “Nothing in 24 this section shall be construed to limit the application of the Electronic Communications 25 Privacy Act of 1986 or any of the amendments made by such Act, or any similar State law.” 47 26 U.S.C. § 230(e)(4). NOTICE OF SUPPL. AUTHORITY – 7 ROSSI & CO., P.C. 616 33rd Ave NW, Gig Harbor, WA 98335 Case No. 2:26-cv-00284-KKE Tel: 303.222.0300 Case 2:26-cv-00284-KKE Document 119 Filed 08/28/26 Page 8 of 8 1 2 Relevance. Plaintiff's claims under 18 U.S.C. § 2511 arise under Title I of the Electronic 3 Communications Privacy Act itself, and her claims under RCW 9.73.030 arise under a “similar 4 State law” — Washington's all-party-consent statute. By the express terms of Section 230(e)(4), 5 the Platform Defendants' Section 230 arguments cannot limit the application of those provisions, 6 and therefore cannot support dismissal of the counts arising under them, irrespective of how the 7 Court resolves the questions addressed in Parts A through C above. 8 9 III. CONCLUSION 10 11 Plaintiff respectfully submits the foregoing authority for the Court's consideration in connection 12 with the pending motions to dismiss of Defendants Meta, Reddit, and YouTube. Plaintiff does 13 not by this Notice seek any relief, and stands ready to address any of the foregoing authority at 14 the Court's convenience, whether by further briefing on such schedule as the Court may direct or 15 at oral argument. 16 17 Respectfully submitted this 28th day of August, 2026. 18 ROSSI & CO., P.C. 19 20 By: /s/ Ronald G. Rossi 21 Ronald G. Rossi, WSBA No. 54720 22 616 33rd Ave NW | Gig Harbor, Washington 98335 23 Tel: 1.303.222.0300 | Fax: 1.206.274.6401 24 RGR@vihc.com 25 Attorney for Plaintiff G.P. 26 NOTICE OF SUPPL. AUTHORITY – 8 ROSSI & CO., P.C. 616 33rd Ave NW, Gig Harbor, WA 98335 Case No. 2:26-cv-00284-KKE Tel: 303.222.0300