{"cached_at":"2026-11-16T21:36:48.783635+00:00","cl_docket_id":"69604143","docket":{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","id":69604143,"court":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/courts/cod/","court_id":"cod","original_court_info":null,"idb_data":null,"clusters":[],"audio_files":[],"assigned_to":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/people/9117/","referred_to":null,"bankruptcy_information":null,"absolute_url":"/docket/69604143/skrypski-v-sampson/","date_created":"2025-02-02T16:40:45.607036-08:00","date_modified":"2026-11-11T01:53:50.140921-08:00","source":1,"appeal_from_str":"","assigned_to_str":"Gordon P. Gallagher","referred_to_str":"Kathryn A. Starnella","panel_str":"","date_last_index":null,"date_cert_granted":null,"date_cert_denied":null,"date_argued":null,"date_reargued":null,"date_reargument_denied":null,"date_filed":"2025-01-29","date_terminated":null,"date_last_filing":"2026-11-10","case_name_short":"Skrypski","case_name":"Skrypski v. Sampson","case_name_full":"","slug":"skrypski-v-sampson","docket_number":"1:25-cv-00306","docket_number_core":"2500306","docket_number_raw":"1:25-cv-00306","docket_number_source":0,"federal_dn_office_code":"1","federal_dn_case_type":"cv","federal_dn_judge_initials_assigned":"GPG","federal_dn_judge_initials_referred":"KAS","federal_defendant_number":null,"pacer_case_id":"240886","cause":"15:78 Securities Exchange Act","nature_of_suit":"850 Securities, Commodities, Exchange","jury_demand":"Plaintiff","jurisdiction_type":"Federal Question","appellate_fee_status":"","appellate_case_type_information":"","mdl_status":"","filepath_ia":"","filepath_ia_json":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"ia_needs_upload":true,"ia_date_first_change":"2025-02-02T16:40:45.597000-08:00","date_blocked":null,"blocked":false,"appeal_from":null,"parent_docket":null,"tags":[],"panel":[]},"parties":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/17125902/","id":17125902,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11170904/","attorney_id":11170904,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":10}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"name":"Movant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2026-01-13T01:10:36.108402-08:00","date_modified":"2026-01-13T01:10:36.108416-08:00","name":"LeKesh Pettis","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/16380388/","id":16380388,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10727207/","attorney_id":10727207,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"name":"Movant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2025-09-23T20:50:04.862958-07:00","date_modified":"2025-09-23T20:50:04.862983-07:00","name":"Matt Rose","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/16380387/","id":16380387,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10727206/","attorney_id":10727206,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"name":"Movant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2025-09-23T20:50:04.769289-07:00","date_modified":"2025-09-23T20:50:04.769308-07:00","name":"Irving Firemens Relief and Retirement Fund","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/16380386/","id":16380386,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10727202/","attorney_id":10727202,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10727203/","attorney_id":10727203,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10727204/","attorney_id":10727204,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10727205/","attorney_id":10727205,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"name":"Movant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"name":"Plaintiff","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"Lead Plaintiff","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2025-09-23T20:50:03.986597-07:00","date_modified":"2025-09-23T20:50:03.986616-07:00","name":"Christopher Skrypski","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/15033343/","id":15033343,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10727198/","attorney_id":10727198,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10727199/","attorney_id":10727199,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10727200/","attorney_id":10727200,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10727201/","attorney_id":10727201,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2025-02-02T16:40:46.082415-08:00","date_modified":"2025-02-02T16:40:46.082424-08:00","name":"Barbara K. Gutierrez","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/15033342/","id":15033342,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10727198/","attorney_id":10727198,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10727199/","attorney_id":10727199,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10727200/","attorney_id":10727200,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10727201/","attorney_id":10727201,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2025-02-02T16:40:46.074704-08:00","date_modified":"2025-02-02T16:40:46.074715-08:00","name":"Kenneth Shepard","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/15033341/","id":15033341,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10727198/","attorney_id":10727198,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10727199/","attorney_id":10727199,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10727200/","attorney_id":10727200,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10727201/","attorney_id":10727201,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2025-02-02T16:40:46.064543-08:00","date_modified":"2025-02-02T16:40:46.064555-08:00","name":"L. Heath Sampson","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/15033340/","id":15033340,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10727198/","attorney_id":10727198,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10727199/","attorney_id":10727199,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10727200/","attorney_id":10727200,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10727201/","attorney_id":10727201,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":"2026-01-09","extra_info":"TERMINATED: 01/09/2026","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2025-02-02T16:40:46.053982-08:00","date_modified":"2025-02-02T16:40:46.053990-08:00","name":"ModivCare, Inc.","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/15033339/","id":15033339,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10727197/","attorney_id":10727197,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10093281/","attorney_id":10093281,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"role":1}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","docket_id":69604143,"name":"Plaintiff","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"Individually and on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2025-02-02T16:40:46.020346-08:00","date_modified":"2025-02-02T16:40:46.020357-08:00","name":"Dinesh Kalera","extra_info":""}],"entries":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/485185915/","id":485185915,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/501048539/","id":501048539,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"","date_created":"2026-11-10T15:35:08.386575-08:00","date_modified":"2026-11-10T15:35:08.386593-08:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Memorandum","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-11-10T15:35:08.376806-08:00","date_modified":"2026-11-10T15:35:08.376818-08:00","date_filed":"2026-11-10","time_filed":"16:06:23","entry_number":null,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-11-10.001","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/485178826/","id":485178826,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/501041342/","id":501041342,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69604143/86/skrypski-v-sampson/","date_created":"2026-11-10T15:03:59.519013-08:00","date_modified":"2026-11-10T15:03:59.535529-08:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"86","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"039013100143","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Order","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-11-10T15:03:59.481050-08:00","date_modified":"2026-11-10T15:03:59.490607-08:00","date_filed":"2026-11-10","time_filed":"15:31:33","entry_number":86,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-11-10.001","pacer_sequence_number":267,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/484342089/","id":484342089,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/500179383/","id":500179383,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"","date_created":"2026-11-04T07:34:59.572028-08:00","date_modified":"2026-11-04T07:34:59.572049-08:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Memorandum","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-11-04T07:34:59.551408-08:00","date_modified":"2026-11-04T07:34:59.551434-08:00","date_filed":"2026-11-04","time_filed":"08:12:21","entry_number":null,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-11-04.001","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/484316887/","id":484316887,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/500153480/","id":500153480,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69604143/83/skrypski-v-sampson/","date_created":"2026-11-03T20:35:47.973829-08:00","date_modified":"2026-11-03T20:35:47.982733-08:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"83","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"039013081100","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Protective Order","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-11-03T20:35:47.955170-08:00","date_modified":"2026-11-03T20:35:47.960618-08:00","date_filed":"2026-11-03","time_filed":"21:00:18","entry_number":83,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-11-03.001","pacer_sequence_number":260,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/483094331/","id":483094331,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/498895467/","id":498895467,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69604143/82/skrypski-v-sampson/","date_created":"2026-10-27T15:00:20.828481-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-27T15:00:20.839678-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"82","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"039013060485","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Scheduling Order","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-27T15:00:20.801594-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-27T15:00:20.809141-07:00","date_filed":"2026-10-27","time_filed":"15:41:59","entry_number":82,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-10-27.001","pacer_sequence_number":258,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/481958316/","id":481958316,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497722999/","id":497722999,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69604143/79/skrypski-v-sampson/","date_created":"2026-10-19T09:50:46.058635-07:00","date_modified":"2026-11-13T09:24:19.675264-08:00","sha1":"5a755a5177515defdf13bd4b323934d0ac109249","page_count":269,"file_size":2207071,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.cod.240886/gov.uscourts.cod.240886.79.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.cod.240886/gov.uscourts.cod.240886.79.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":" Case No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79   filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 1 of 269\n\n\n\n\n                          UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                          FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO\nCivil Action No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS\n\nCHRISTOPHER SKRYPSKI, individually\nand on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated,\n              Plaintiff,\nv.\nL. HEATH SAMPSON, KENNETH\nSHEPARD, and BARBARA K.\nGUTIERREZ,\n              Defendants.\n\n  DEFENDANTS\u2019 ANSWER TO THE AMENDED CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT FOR\n        VIOLATIONS OF THE FEDERAL SECURITIES LAWS (DKT. 54)\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 2 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       Defendants L. Heath Sampson, Kenneth Shepard, and Barbara K. Gutierrez\n\n(collectively, \u201cDefendants\u201d) submit this Answer to Plaintiff Christopher Skrypski\u2019s\n\nAmended Class Action Complaint for Violations of the Federal Securities Laws (the\n\n\u201cAmended Complaint\u201d; Dkt. 54), filed on January 9, 2026.\n\n       The Court\u2019s August 7, 2026 Order only addressed and allowed Plaintiff\u2019s claims to\n\nproceed with respect to the risk factor allegations found in Paragraphs 169\u2013173, 177\u2013\n\n180, 184, 225, 244, and 278\u2013281.* Defendants are not required to respond to allegations\n\nthat the Court has not determined are adequately alleged under the Private Securities\n\nLitigation Reform Act of 1995, Abdo v. United States, 2024 WL 6473903, at *2 (D. Colo.\n\nDec. 5, 2024) (citing Nat\u2019l Credit Union Admin. Bd. v. RBS Sec., Inc., 2013 WL 11332740,\n\nat *5 (D. Kan. Oct. 24, 2013)), and, on that basis, deny those allegations. Except as\n\notherwise expressly stated herein, Defendants deny each and every claim, theory, and\n\nallegation asserted in the Amended Complaint, and specifically deny liability under \u00a7 10(b)\n\nand \u00a7 20(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and U.S. Securities and Exchange\n\nCommission (\u201cSEC\u201d) Rule 10b-5 promulgated thereunder. Pursuant to Rule 8(b)(6) of the\n\nFederal Rules of Civil Procedure, averments in the Amended Complaint to which no\n\nresponsive pleading is required shall be deemed denied. Defendants expressly reserve\n\nthe right to amend and/or supplement this Answer as may be necessary.\n\n\n\n\n*\n Defendants understand that Plaintiff disagrees with this interpretation of the Court\u2019s\nAugust 7, 2026 Order. Defendants have filed a motion seeking clarification of the Court\u2019s\nOrder. See Dkt. 74. Should answers to these allegations be required, Defendants have\nprovided them below. Defendants will also amend this Answer if the Court\u2019s order on their\nMotion for Clarification renders it necessary.\n\n                                            2\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 3 of 269\n\n\n\n\nRESPONSE TO HEADINGS AND FOOTNOTES\n\n      The Amended Complaint contains several headings, which Defendants have\n\nincluded in this Answer. The headings are not properly pleaded allegations requiring a\n\nresponse, and Defendants do not adopt the characterizations set forth in those headings.\n\nTo the extent any headings contain allegations requiring a response, Defendants deny\n\nthe allegations set forth therein. Defendants also deny the allegations contained in the\n\nfootnotes from Lead Plaintiff\u2019s Amended Complaint, except where they explicitly note\n\notherwise.\n\n      In answer to the Amended Complaint, Defendants state as follows:\n\nRESPONSE TO INDIVIDUAL PARAGRAPHS IN THE AMENDED COMPLAINT\n\n1. Lead Plaintiff Christopher Skrypski (\u201cLead Plaintiff\u201d or \u201cPlaintiff\u201d) brings this class\n   action against Defendants (defined below) pursuant Sections 10(b) and 20(a) of the\n   Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (the \u201cExchange Act\u201d), 15 U.S.C. \u00a7\u00a7 78j(b) and 78t(a)\n   and Rule 10b-5, 17 C.F.R. \u00a7 240.10b-5, promulgated thereunder by the U.S.\n   Securities and Exchange Commission (\u201cSEC\u201d), individually and on behalf of himself\n   and all persons and entities similarly situated who purchased or otherwise acquired\n   ModivCare Inc. (\u201cModivCare\u201d or the \u201cCompany\u201d) securities between November 3,\n   2022 to September 15, 2024, inclusive (the \u201cClass Period\u201d).\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 1 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit that the\n\nCourt appointed Christopher Skrypski as Lead Plaintiff. Defendants further admit that this\n\nis a putative class action lawsuit purporting to bring claims against L. Heath Sampson,\n\nBarbara K. Gutierrez, and Kenneth Shepard under Sections 10(b) and 20(a) of the\n\nExchange Act and Rule 10b-5 promulgated thereunder. Except as expressly admitted,\n\nDefendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 1.\n\n\n\n\n                                            3\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79      filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 4 of 269\n\n\n\n\n2. Plaintiff alleges the following based upon personal knowledge as to himself and his\n   own acts, and upon information and belief as to all other matters. Plaintiff\u2019s information\n   and belief is based on the investigation of his undersigned attorneys (\u201cLead Counsel\u201d),\n   which included, among other things, review and analysis of: (i) public documents,\n   public filings, and wire and press releases published by and regarding ModivCare; (ii)\n   Defendants\u2019 other public statements, including transcripts of interviews Defendants\n   participated in; (iii) interviews with individuals who are former employees of ModivCare;\n   (iv) reports of securities and financial analysts, news articles, and other commentary\n   and analysis concerning ModivCare and the industry in which the Company operates;\n   and (v) pertinent court filings.\n       ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the allegations regarding Plaintiff\u2019s purported investigation described in\n\nParagraph 2, and deny them on that basis. Defendants further deny that any alleged\n\nstatement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to one\n\ndefendant is attributable to another.\n\n3. Lead Counsel\u2019s investigation into the matters alleged herein is continuing, and many\n   relevant facts are known only to, or are exclusively within, the custody or control of\n   Defendants. Plaintiff believes that substantial additional evidentiary support will exist\n   for the allegations set forth herein after a reasonable opportunity for discovery.\n       ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the allegations regarding Lead Counsel\u2019s investigation and \u201cbeliefs\u201d\n\ndescribed in Paragraph 3, and deny them on that basis.\n\nI.     NATURE OF THE ACTION\n\n4. Plaintiff brings this securities fraud class action alleging that, throughout the Class\n   Period, ModivCare\u2019s Chief Executive Officer (\u201cCEO\u201d) L. Heath Sampson (\u201cSampson\u201d),\n   the Company\u2019s Chief Financial Officer (\u201cCFO\u201d) Barbara Guiterrez (\u201cGuiterrez\u201d), and\n   the CFO for the Company\u2019s core non-emergency medical transport (\u201cNEMT\u201d)\n   business Kenneth Shepard (\u201cShepard\u201d) knowingly or severely recklessly made\n   material misrepresentations to investors concerning the Company\u2019s shared risk\n   capitated contracts\u2019 ability to offset ModivCare\u2019s increased transportation costs from\n\n\n\n                                             4\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 5 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   higher NEMT utilization by members. Defendants likewise made material\n   misrepresentations that overstated the quality of ModivCare\u2019s NEMT services and\n   their cost-effectiveness for the Company, including with respect to a \u201cmulti-modal\n   strategic initiative\u201d that was intended to diversify the transportation methods available\n   to members.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 4 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. Defendants also need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph\n\n4 to the extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-\n\nK and 10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court\n\naddressed in its August 7, 2026 Order (see Dkt. 67 at 5; see also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133), and\n\nDefendants deny them on that basis. Defendants deny that any alleged statement,\n\nknowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is\n\nattributable to another. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit that Heath\n\nSampson served as ModivCare\u2019s Chief Executive Officer, that Barbara Gutierrez served\n\nas ModivCare\u2019s Chief Financial Officer beginning September 18, 2023, and that Kenneth\n\nShepard served as Chief Financial Officer of ModivCare\u2019s NEMT segment. Except as\n\nexpressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 4.\n\n5. ModivCare is a healthcare services company whose core business entails\n   coordinating and managing non-emergency medical transportation in the United\n   States for individuals who ModivCare refers to as \u201cmembers.\u201d The Company is paid\n   primarily by its members\u2019 insurers, which ModivCare calls \u201cpayors\u201d and who are state\n   Medicaid programs and managed care organizations (\u201cMCOs\u201d).\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare is a healthcare services company\n\nthat provides non-emergency medical transportation (\u201cNEMT\u201d) services; that the\n\nindividuals who use ModivCare\u2019s services are referred to as \u201cmembers\u201d; and that\n\nModivCare is paid by \u201cpayors\u201d that include private healthcare insurers, state Medicaid\n\n\n                                             5\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79      filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 6 of 269\n\n\n\n\nprograms, and managed care organizations. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 5.\n\n6. During the COVID-19 pandemic, ModivCare\u2019s members utilized fewer NEMT services\n   due to stay at home orders and a rise in telehealth. Despite this drop-off in utilization\n   (i.e., the rate at which ModivCare\u2019s members use its NEMT services), the Company\u2019s\n   profits soared as a result of how its contracts with payors were structured. Namely,\n   ModivCare\u2019s contracts were predominantly full-risk capitated contracts that provided\n   the Company with a fixed per-member per-month (\u201cPMPM\u201d) fee for each of the payors\u2019\n   eligible members irrespective of whether those members were utilizing the Company\u2019s\n   services.\n       ANSWER: Defendants admit that, during the COVID-19 pandemic, ModivCare\u2019s\n\nmembers utilized fewer NEMT services due to stay at home orders and a rise in telehealth.\n\nDefendants further admit that, both before, during, and after the COVID-19 pandemic,\n\nModivCare had full-risk capitated contracts that provided that payors pay a fixed amount\n\nper member per month, and ModivCare assumes the responsibility of meeting the\n\ncovered healthcare-related transportation requirements for the eligible members in the\n\ncustomer\u2019s program, regardless of how many or how few times the member utilizes\n\nModivCare\u2019s services (usage) or how much cost is incurred in providing those services\n\n(fulfillment costs). Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 6.\n\n7. Given that under the full-risk contracts ModivCare would receive the same PMPM if\n   the Company was experiencing a surge in utilization from members (which had the\n   effect of reducing the profit margin considerably as transportation costs increased),\n   the Company began renegotiating to shift its full-risk contracts to shared risk contracts\n   as pandemic restrictions eased and ModivCare anticipated that payors\u2019 members\n   would begin to increase their use of the Company\u2019s NEMT services.\n\n\n\n\n                                             6\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 7 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants admit and allege that, after the COVID-19 pandemic,\n\nModivCare anticipated that utilization and costs for providing NEMT services would\n\nincrease. Defendants further admit that ModivCare and certain payors renegotiated\n\ncertain contracts from full-risk capitated contracts to shared-risk capitated contracts.\n\nExcept as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 7.\n\n8. ModivCare claimed that, under the shared risk contracts, the Company\u2019s PMPM would\n   be adjusted upward or downward (depending on the actual realized transportation\n   volumes or costs). The purpose of these adjustments was to purportedly guarantee\n   that the Company would earn a certain profit level regardless of how much payors\u2019\n   members were using the services or how much transportation costs increased.\n   Conversely, ModivCare\u2019s profits were also capped under these shared risk contracts,\n   meaning if the Company reached the profit threshold, it would rebate its payors for\n   such overages.\n       ANSWER: Defendants admit that certain shared-risk contracts include provisions\n\nfor reconciliations, risk corridors, and/or profit rebates, which allow for periodic\n\nreconciliations between ModivCare and the payors based on actual costs and/or trip\n\nvolumes and may result in refunds to the payor (contract payables) if utilization and costs\n\nare low, or additional payments due from the payor (contract receivables) if utilization or\n\ncosts are high. To the extent that Paragraph 8 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s\n\npublic filings, Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete documents, which\n\nspeak for themselves, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as\n\nexpressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 8.\n\n9. Thus, during the adjustment process for shared risk contracts, ModivCare determined\n   whether the profit threshold had been met or exceeded. If the profit threshold had not\n   been met, then the Company would generally record an asset (i.e., contract receivable)\n   for which it would seek additional payment from the payor. On the other hand, if the\n\n\n\n\n                                            7\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 8 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   profit threshold was exceeded, then ModivCare would record a liability (i.e., contract\n   payable) that would need to be paid to the payor.\n       ANSWER: Defendants admit that accrued contract payables primarily represent\n\noverpayments and liability reserves on certain risk corridor, profit rebate and reconciliation\n\ncontracts, and contract receivables primarily represent underpayments and receivables\n\non certain risk corridor, profit rebate, and reconciliation contracts. Except as expressly\n\nadmitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 9.\n\n10. Throughout the Class Period, which begins on November 3, 2022, Sampson\n    relentlessly touted the shared risk contracts\u2019 purported benefits for ModivCare and its\n    customers. Indeed, Sampson assured investors that, \u201cbecause of\u201d ModivCare\u2019s\n    shared risk \u201ccontracts, we\u2019re able to pass [increased transportation costs]\n    through to a lot of our customers\u201d and further claimed \u201cif utilization goes way up,\n    we\u2019re going to share in that. If costs go up, we\u2019re going to share in that. And\n    that\u2019s the way these contracts work.\u201d Sampson further vowed that ModivCare was\n    \u201cgoing to get paid on\u201d instances where \u201cutilization is going up and we\u2019re doing\n    more trips and... it\u2019s more expensive to us[.]\u201d Indeed, Sampson assured \u201cit gets\n    put on the balance sheet, and then we\u2019ll collect it over the next 3 to 6 months.\u201d\n    As such, Sampson represented that ModivCare\u2019s shared risk contracts were\n    \u201cstructured so we have a win-win[.]\u201d\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 10 to the\n\nextent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. Paragraph 10 also states legal conclusions to which no response\n\nfrom Defendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 10\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s November 3, 2022 earnings call and Deutsche\n\nBank\u2019s 31st Annual Leveraged Finance Conference on October 3, 2023. Defendants\n\n\n\n\n                                              8\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79      filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 9 of 269\n\n\n\n\nrespectfully refer the Court to the complete recordings from those events, which speak\n\nfor themselves, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 10.\n\n11. Defendant Sampson repeated this mantra on at least 15 occasions during the Class\n    Period, and detailed exactly what \u201cwin-win\u201d meant (i.e., ModivCare would \u201cshare in []\n    increased [transportation] costs\u201d which would thereby \u201callow[] [the Company] to\n    really have stable rigid margins regardless of utilization and cost[,]\u201d \u201cadd[] [an]\n    additional layer of predictability to [its] cash flow[,]\u201d and create \u201cmore normalized\n    working capital[.]\u201d).\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 11 to the\n\nextent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. Paragraph 11 also states legal conclusions to which no response\n\nfrom Defendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 11\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from Defendant\u2019s public statements, and Defendants respectfully\n\nrefer the Court to the complete recordings from those events, which speak for themselves,\n\nand deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 11.\n\n12. In addition, every quarterly report filed with the SEC on behalf of ModivCare, falsely\n    represented that \u201c[t]here have been no material changes\u201d to the Company\u2019s\n    previously issued risk factors in addition to containing purported risk disclosures that\n    speculatively cautioned that, inter alia, \u201cimplementation of alternative payment\n    models[,]\u201d changes in payment levels from ... third-party payors[,]\u201d and \u201c[d]elays\n    in collection, or non-collection, of our accounts receivable\u201d \u201ccould adversely\n    affect\u201d revenues[,]\u201d \u201coperations[,]\u201d or \u201cfinancial condition[.]\u201d\n\n\n\n\n                                             9\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 10 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 12 to the\n\nextent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 12 characterizes\n\nor quotes from ModivCare\u2019s Forms 10-Q or 10-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the\n\nCourt to the complete documents, which speak for themselves, and deny any allegations\n\ninconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 12.\n\n13. In reality, unbeknownst to investors, ModivCare\u2019s true-up process under the shared\n    risk contracts persistently caused disputes with customers. For instance, CW2,\n    ModivCare\u2019s Vice President (\u201cVP\u201d) of Transportation, confirmed that mismatches\n    between ModivCare\u2019s internal utilization data and payors\u2019 actual \u201cencounter data\u201d\n    caused payors to contend that they owed ModivCare far less than the Company\n    claimed. Rather than sharing in higher costs as Defendants\u2019 claimed, ModivCare was\n    locked in disputes about how many trips members actually took, which had a\n    significant financial impact. Indeed, CW2 explained that such utilization discrepancies\n    could result in PMPM rates fluctuating $3 or more and would be multiplied across large\n    membership populations. According to CW2, ModivCare was subjected to monthly\n    liquidated damages for rejected encounter data and routinely forced to accept partial\n    payments as settlements as a result of the encounter related true-up disputes.\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the confidential witness (\u201cCW\u201d) allegations in Paragraph 13 and deny them\n\non that basis. Defendants further deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct,\n\ndocument, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 13.\n\n14. CW3 likewise stated that ModivCare faced significant disputes over risk corridors and\n    profits. CW3 provided an example where New Jersey\u2014one of the Company\u2019s largest\n    contracts\u2014asserted that ModivCare had exceeded its profit cap and sought\n\n\n                                            10\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79     filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 11 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   repayment. CW3 confirmed that ModivCare was required to return a portion of those\n   profits to the state.\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 14 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 14.\n\n15. ModivCare not only experienced disputes with customers concerning what was owed\n    to the Company under the shared risk contracts but also faced significant challenges\n    collecting new monthly PMPM payments from payors that ModivCare was in arrears\n    for as a result of previous utilization and mounting contract payables. For instance,\n    CW2 confirmed that such payors withheld monthly payments to offset the balance that\n    ModivCare owed to the payor. According to CW2, even where ModivCare conveyed\n    that payors needed to continue making monthly payments, payors refused\u2014 resulting\n    in disputes that dragged on for \u201ca very long time.\u201d\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 15 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 15.\n\n16. Despite ModivCare\u2019s claims that its cash flow would become more normalized and\n    predictable through the shared risk contracts, the Company faced a significant cash\n    crunch. ModivCare\u2019s working capital was affected by the rampant collectability issues\n    stemming from its true-up disputes as well as \u201crepayments\u201d that ModivCare elected to\n    make to payors who had paid hefty PMPMs during the Covid-19 pandemic despite\n    members\u2019 low utilization. Indeed, ModivCare was shelling out hundreds of millions of\n    dollars in cash and drawing down on its revolving credit facility to pay down its\n    contracts payables balance while simultaneously facing a mounting contracts\n    receivables balance that was not coming in the door.\n      ANSWER: To the extent Paragraph 16 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s\n\npublic statements and disclosures regarding its cash flow, working capital, contracts\n\nreceivables and contracts payables balances, Defendants respectfully refer the Court to\n\nthe complete statements and documents, which speak for themselves, and deny any\n\n\n\n                                           11\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 12 of 269\n\n\n\n\nallegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 16.\n\n17. ModivCare\u2019s collectability issues under the shared risk contracts were also\n    exacerbated by payors who, dissatisfied with the Company\u2019s service and\n    technological shortcomings, placed the Company on performance improvement plans,\n    delayed payments, sought monthly liquidated damages, and canceled contracts.\n    Indeed, CWs confirmed that, prior to and continuing through the Class Period,\n    ModivCare received increasing complaints about its NEMT service, including driver\n    no shows and on-time performance issues, and about promised technological\n    enhancements, aimed at reducing those very complaints, that ModivCare had not\n    delivered.\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 17 to the\n\nextent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the allegations concerning\n\nwhether payors were \u201cdissatisfied\u201d with ModivCare and the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n17 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph\n\n17.\n\n18. For instance, CW3 stated ModivCare consistently failed to provide payors with the\n    technology and system maintenance offerings that the Company committed to\n    delivering in contracts, including ride scheduling, real-time reporting, GPS tracking,\n    and dynamic trip reassignment for medical appointments. As a result, according to\n    CW3, missed appointments and no-shows were significant service issues that\n    ModivCare had throughout CW3\u2019s tenure that did not improve. CW3 further recalled\n    that ModivCare consistently failed to meet key performance indicators (\u201cKPIs\u201d),\n    including on-time performance, no vehicle available (\u201cNVAs\u201d) (which caused missed\n\n\n\n\n                                           12\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS           Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 13 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      rides), and call center complaints regarding delayed call answer, which affected most\n      payors.\n         ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 18 to the\n\nextent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n18 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph\n\n18.\n\n19. CW3 also stated that ModivCare\u2019s poor service delivery, long-standing weaknesses\n    in technology, and reliance on an outdated platform caused major contracts to be\n    under threat throughout September 2023 (i.e., the end of CW3\u2019s tenure). Likewise,\n    CW2 stated that, beginning around the second quarter of 2022 (\u201c2Q2022\u201d) and\n    continuing throughout CW2\u2019s tenure, ModivCare\u2019s poor operational performance\n    (such as call center failures) led to client dissatisfaction and monthly liquidated\n    damages of hundreds of thousands of dollars. CW1 also stated that, during CW1\u2019s\n    last year with ModivCare, the Company began losing NEMT contracts because\n    service levels \u201cwere way down\u201d due to poor service quality and high employee\n    turnover. Indeed, CW1 stated during this time, payors were \u201cliterally cancelling\n    contracts because the service, and the people trying to perform the services, kept\n    changing so much. The service levels were way down.\u201d\n         ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 19 to the\n\nextent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\n\n\n\n                                             13\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 14 of 269\n\n\n\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n19 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph\n\n19.\n\n20. Customers were also dissatisfied with ModivCare\u2019s multi-modal strategic initiative,\n    which was intended to reduce transportation costs and offset the impacts of increased\n    utilization. CWs confirmed that ModivCare\u2019s multi-modal strategic initiative was\n    disliked by users and as a result, \u201cfared very poorly\u201d and failed to achieve forecasted\n    cost savings.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 20 to the\n\nextent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the allegations concerning\n\nunidentified \u201ccustomers.\u201d Defendants further lack knowledge or information sufficient to\n\nform a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 20 and deny them on that\n\nbasis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 20.\n\n21. Nevertheless, Defendant Sampson professed that ModivCare was \u201cmeeting or\n    exceeding all [its] customers\u2019 quality and service level requirements[,]\u201d including \u201con-\n    time performance and reduced miss trips[,]\u201d and touted that \u201c[o]ur multimodal\n    transportation partnership strategy has led to increased customer satisfaction and\n    reduced costs.\u201d\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 21 to the\n\nextent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\n\n                                             14\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79      filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 15 of 269\n\n\n\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 21 characterizes\n\nor quotes from ModivCare\u2019s August 4, 2023 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully\n\nrefer the Court to the complete recording from that earnings call, which speaks for itself,\n\nand deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 21.\n\n22. Importantly, Defendants knew or recklessly disregarded that payors were dissatisfied\n    with ModivCare\u2019s NEMT services and technological shortcomings, as well as the\n    shared risk contract disputes. For instance, during a May 2023 Summit, CW3\n    presented competitive analyses that showed, inter alia, long-standing weaknesses in\n    technology and poor service delivery, to Sampson and others in leadership. Likewise,\n    between March and May of 2023 and continuing throughout the Class Period,\n    Defendant Shepard (who was Defendant Sampson\u2019s direct report) participated in\n    customer dispute calls regarding the shared risk contract that had escalated to a point\n    where such customers requested Shepard\u2019s involvement. CWs also confirmed that\n    Defendants Sampson and Shepard attended regular meetings where rising service\n    complaints, contract de-implementations, missed KPIs, and results of the strategic\n    initiatives were discussed in detail, and received presentations regarding de-\n    implementations (which Defendants could also access \u201cwhenever they wanted\u201d).\n    Defendants also admittedly monitored NEMT service data and regularly reported on\n    such information and the shared risk contracts in detail during public earnings calls\n    with investors. Moreover, as a result of his admittedly close relationships and frequent\n    discussions with payors\u2019 executives regarding contracting and repricing, Sampson\n    also knew that payors were dissatisfied with ModivCare\u2019s service levels and\n    technology offerings, were refusing to pay, delaying payments, and seeking liquidated\n    damages, refusing to share in increased costs under the shared risk contracts, and\n    cancelling contracts as a result of service and technology issues.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 22 to the\n\nextent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 22 states legal\n\n\n                                            15\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79      filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 16 of 269\n\n\n\n\nconclusions to which no response is required. Defendants further lack knowledge or\n\ninformation sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the allegations concerning\n\nunidentified \u201cpayors\u201d and the CW allegations in Paragraph 22 and deny them on that\n\nbasis. Defendants further deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct,\n\ndocument, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 22.\n\n23. The truth about ModivCare\u2019s shared risk contracts and NEMT services issues was\n    gradually revealed to investors through a series of partial disclosures during the Class\n    Period, often as Defendants continued to simultaneously mislead investors. First, on\n    May 4, 2023, Defendants Sampson and Shepard revealed that ModivCare had a net\n    loss of $4.0 million for the first quarter of 2023 and had expended nearly $3 million in\n    cash as a result of a $7 million reduction in contract payables and $31 million increase\n    in contract receivables during the quarter. On this news, ModivCare\u2019s common stock\n    price fell sharply, declining $11.30 per share, or approximately 16%, from $69.30 per\n    share on May 3, 2023 to $58.00 per share on May 4, 2023.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 23 states legal conclusions to which no response is required.\n\nTo the extent a response is required, Defendants admit and allege that ModivCare\u2019s\n\nearnings and stock prices at various times are matters of public record and deny any\n\nallegations inconsistent therewith. Paragraph 23 also characterizes or quotes from\n\nModivCare\u2019s May 4, 2023 press release and earnings call. Defendants respectfully refer\n\nthe Court to the complete document or recording thereof, which speak for themselves,\n\nand deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny that any alleged\n\nstatement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to one\n\ndefendant is attributable to another. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 23.\n\n\n\n\n                                            16\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79      filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 17 of 269\n\n\n\n\n24. Next, on August 3, 2023 while reporting second quarter 2023 financials, ModivCare\n    slashed 2023 full-year Adjusted Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, and\n    Amortization (\u201cEBITDA\u201d) guidance due to, inter alia, \u201cincreased utilization and related\n    higher call volumes in NEMT,\u201d and disclosed that the Company had used $108.2\n    million in cash and drew $126.5 million on its revolving credit facility due to \u201ca\n    temporary timing mismatch between [NEMT] payments and collections\u201d and $65\n    million in accelerated payments made to \u201ca few large state clients\u201d that \u201coccurred\n    earlier than anticipated[.]\u201d In response to this news, ModivCare\u2019s common stock price\n    declined $2.86, or approximately 7%, from $38.24 per share on August 3, 2023, to\n    close at $35.38 per share on August 4, 2023.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 24 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit and allege\n\nthat ModivCare\u2019s stock price at various times is a matter of public record and deny any\n\nallegations inconsistent therewith. Paragraph 24 also characterizes or quotes from\n\nModivCare\u2019s August 3, 2023 press release. Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the\n\ncomplete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph\n\n24.\n\n25. Then, on February 22, 2024, after the market closed, Defendants disclosed that\n    ModivCare\u2019s free cash flow for fourth quarter 2023 and full year 2023 were negative\n    $36.8 million and negative $125.3 million, respectively, and the Company had drawn\n    $113.8 million from its revolving credit facility. ModivCare\u2019s dismal financials stemmed\n    from NEMT \u201cmargin pressure\u201d related to several contract losses, \u201csooner than\n    anticipated, large COVID-related working capital needs[,]\u201d and a ~$35.9 million\n    delayed payment from a client. On this news, ModivCare\u2019s common stock price fell\n    $17.25 per share, or approximately 39%, from a close of $43.87 on February 22, 2024\n    to a close of $26.62 on February 23, 2024 on heavy trading volume.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 25 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit and allege\n\nthat ModivCare\u2019s stock price at various times is a matter of public record and deny any\n\n\n                                            17\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS           Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 18 of 269\n\n\n\n\nallegations inconsistent therewith. Paragraph 25 also characterizes or quotes from\n\nModivCare\u2019s February 22, 2024 press release and Form 8-K. Defendants respectfully\n\nrefer the Court to the complete documents, which speak for themselves, and deny any\n\nallegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny that any alleged statement,\n\nknowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is\n\nattributable to another. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 25.\n\n26. Analysts were caught off guard by Defendants\u2019 contract loss disclosures. For instance,\n    in two reports issued on February 23, 2024 Deutsche Bank initially noted that the\n    \u201ccontract losses in NEMT\u201d as \u201cnew information\u201d while the later report noted that it was\n    \u201c[m]ake or break time\u201d for the Company. The analyst also stated in the first report that\n    \u201c[w]ith several bumps on the road over the past year and struggles with FCF\n    generation, we are unable to continue recommending MODV and downgrade to a\n    Hold.\u201d In the second report, the analyst added the \u201c[m]ismatch between receivables\n    and payables has been a persistent cash flow headwind for MODV over the last year\u201d\n    and the \u201clack of visibility into quarter to quarter performance of the shared risk contract\n    book and the aggressive operating leverage implied in the 2H quarters is likely to\n    result in investors taking a wait-and-see approach.\u201d\n       ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the allegations concerning the reaction of unidentified analysts in Paragraph\n\n26 and deny them on that basis. Paragraph 26 characterizes or quotes from a Deutsche\n\nBank analyst report dated February 23, 2024, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court\n\nto the complete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 26.\n\n27. Nevertheless, even as late as August 8, 2024, when Defendants were already\n    renegotiating prepayment terms with its shared risk NEMT customers in an desperate\n    effort to bring cash in the door, Defendants Sampson and Guiterrez assured investors\n    that ModivCare\u2019s shared risk contracts were \u201cwin-win ... from a margin and P&L\n\n\n                                              18\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79      filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 19 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   perspective[,]\u201d and \u201cworking as designed and protecting the downside [risk] and\n   protecting the P&L[.]\u201d\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 27 to the\n\nextent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 27 characterizes\n\nor quotes from ModivCare\u2019s August 8, 2024 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully\n\nrefer the Court to the complete recording, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations\n\ninconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny that any alleged statement, knowledge,\n\nconduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to\n\nanother. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 27.\n\n28. Only one month later, on September 12, 2024, contrary to Defendants\u2019 misstatements\n    during the Class Period, Defendants revealed that \u201cthe Company has not offset the\n    existing and continued accumulation of receivables during the period\u201d and though\n    \u201ccollection and mitigation efforts continue, there remains the possibility that the\n    Company will not achieve full resolution in a timely manner or at all if unforeseen\n    circumstances arise.\u201d The Company\u2019s further revealed that its annual report for the\n    year ended December 31, 2023, which was filed with the SEC on Form 10-K on\n    February 26, 2024 (\u201cFY2023 10K\u201d), was updated to reflect a \u201cgoing concern.\u201d In\n    response to this news, ModivCare\u2019s common stock price declined $18.43, or\n    approximately 59%, from $31.19 per share on September 11, 2024 to $12.76 per\n    share on September 12, 2024 on heavy trading volume.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 28 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit and allege\n\nthat ModivCare\u2019s stock price at various times is a matter of public record and deny any\n\nallegations inconsistent therewith. Paragraph 28 also characterizes or quotes from\n\n\n\n                                            19\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 20 of 269\n\n\n\n\nModivCare\u2019s September 12, 2024 Form 8-K. Defendants respectfully refer the Court to\n\nthe complete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants further deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct,\n\ndocument, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another.\n\nExcept as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 28.\n\n29. Then, on September 16, 2024, Defendants revealed that ModivCare had \u201cexperienced\n    delays in the timely collection of approximately $60 million of its outstanding $159.3\n    million in NEMT segment current contract receivables, primarily from MCO customers,\n    as of June 30, 2024\u201d (i.e., over a month before Defendants\u2019 August 8, 2024\n    misstatements) and Defendants also slashed the Company\u2019s 2024 Adjusted EBITDA\n    guidance range \u201cprimarily due to NEMT segment pricing accommodations made to\n    strategically retain and expand key customer relationships.\u201d In response, ModivCare\u2019s\n    common stock price fell $1.40, or nearly 10%, from a close of $14.12 per share on\n    September 13, 2024 to a close of $12.72 per share on September 16, 2024.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 29 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit and allege\n\nthat ModivCare\u2019s stock price at various times is a matter of public record and deny any\n\nallegations inconsistent therewith. Paragraph 29 characterizes or quotes from\n\nModivCare\u2019s September 16, 2024 Form 8-K. Defendants respectfully refer the Court to\n\nthe complete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants further deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct,\n\ndocument, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another.\n\nExcept as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 29.\n\n30. Analysts were shocked, particularly given the Company\u2019s previous reticence to\n    provide details around the delayed payment dispute. For instance, a September 17,\n    2024 Barrington Research reduced its price target by $16, expressly highlighted that\n    the collectability concerns were \u201cparticularly troubling since the company had\n\n\n                                           20\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS           Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 21 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   explicitly stated in prepared remarks on its Q2 conference call in early August that it\n   had visibility into $60 million of near-term cash collections from a couple of its large\n   customers.\u201d The report added that such \u201ccommentary contributed materially to our\n   decision to upgrade the shares six weeks ago and probably served as similar\n   comfort to many investors.\u201d\n       ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the allegations concerning the reaction of unidentified analysts in Paragraph\n\n30 and deny them on that basis. Paragraph 30 characterizes or quotes from a Barrington\n\nResearch analyst report dated September 17, 2024, and Defendants respectfully refer\n\nthe Court to the complete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations\n\ninconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 30.\n\n31. Defendants would later admit after the Class Period on November 7, 2024, ModivCare\n    planned to shift its shared risk contracts and the majority of the Company\u2019s revenue\n    to fee-for-service (\u201cFFS\u201d) arrangements because the shared risk contracts were not\n    offering the Company or its customers a win-win but instead, because ModivCare had\n    been paid lower under the shared risk contacts and the true-up \u201ccosts were higher\n    than a lot of [ModivCare\u2019s customers] expected[,]\u201d \u201csurprise[d] ... a lot of our payers\u201d\n    \u201c[a]nd that was painful.\u201d\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 31 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s November 7,\n\n2024 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\nfurther deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission\n\nallegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 31.\n\n32. Defendants\u2019 fraudulent and misleading statements served to artificially inflate the price\n    of ModivCare\u2019s common stock throughout the Class Period, causing massive investor\n    losses when the price of the stock precipitously declined with each disclosure about\n\n\n\n\n                                             21\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS           Document 79      filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 22 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ModivCare\u2019s shared risk contracts and service issues. Lead Plaintiff hereby seeks\n      damages individually and on behalf of the Class.\n         ANSWER: Paragraph 32 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 32.\n\nII.      JURISDICTION AND VENUE\n\n33. The claims asserted herein arise under \u00a7\u00a7 10(b) and 20(a) of the Exchange Act, 15\n    U.S.C. \u00a7 78j(b) and \u00a7 78t(a), and Rule 10b-5 promulgated thereunder by the SEC, 17\n    C.F.R. \u00a7 240.10b-5.\n         ANSWER: Paragraph 33 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required.\n\n34. This Court has subject matter jurisdiction over this action pursuant to 28 U.S.C. \u00a7 1331\n    and \u00a7 27 of the Exchange Act, 15 U.S.C. \u00a7 78aa.\n         ANSWER: Paragraph 34 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required.\n\n35. This Court has jurisdiction over each Defendant named herein because each\n    Defendant is an individual who has sufficient minimum contacts with this District to\n    render the exercise of jurisdiction by the District Court permissible under traditional\n    notions of fair play and substantial justice.\n         ANSWER: Paragraph 35 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required.\n\n36. Venue is proper in this Court pursuant to 28 U.S.C. \u00a7 1391(b) and \u00a7 27 of the\n    Exchange Act because many of the false and misleading statements were made in or\n    issued from this District. ModivCare is headquartered in this District, with its principal\n    place of business located at 6900 Layton Avenue, 12th Floor, Denver, Colorado 80237.\n         ANSWER: Paragraph 36 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent that these allegations are deemed to be factual,\n\n\n\n                                             22\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS           Document 79     filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 23 of 269\n\n\n\n\nDefendants admit that ModivCare\u2019s principal place of business was located at 6900 E\n\nLayton Avenue, 12th Floor, Denver, Colorado 80237, and that venue is proper in this Court.\n\nExcept as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 36.\n\nIII.   PARTIES\n\n       A.     Plaintiff\n\n37. Court-appointed Lead Plaintiff Christopher Skrypski (\u201cLead Plaintiff\u201d or \u201cPlaintiff\u201d)\n    purchased ModivCare common stock during the Class Period, as set forth in his\n    previously filed certification (ECF No. 17-1) and incorporated by reference herein, and\n    suffered damages as set forth herein.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 37 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit that the\n\nCourt appointed Christopher Skrypski as Lead Plaintiff. Defendants lack knowledge or\n\ninformation sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the remaining allegations in\n\nParagraph 37 and deny them on that basis. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 37.\n\n       B.    Defendants\n\n38. At all relevant times, Defendant L. Heath Sampson served as ModivCare\u2019s President\n    and CEO as well as a Director on the Company\u2019s Board of Directors (\u201cBoard\u201d). Prior\n    to his appointment to such positions, Sampson was ModivCare\u2019s Interim CEO\n    between August 1, 2022 and November 1, 2022 and its CFO between February 26,\n    2021 and September 18, 2023. Defendant Barbara Gutierrez succeeded Sampson as\n    ModivCare\u2019s CFO. Sampson also led ModivCare\u2019s Mobility (i.e., NEMT) business\n    between January 2022 and April 12, 2022, when he was succeeded by Ilias Simpson\n    as President of the Company\u2019s Mobility division.\n       ANSWER: Defendants admit that Mr. Sampson served as ModivCare\u2019s President\n\nand Chief Executive Officer and as a member of ModivCare\u2019s Board of Directors during\n\nthe alleged Class Period; that Mr. Sampson previously served as ModivCare\u2019s Interim\n\n\n                                            23\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79      filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 24 of 269\n\n\n\n\nChief Executive Officer; and that Mr. Sampson served as ModivCare\u2019s Chief Financial\n\nOfficer prior to and for part of the alleged Class Period. Defendants further admit that Mr.\n\nSampson previously led ModivCare\u2019s Mobility division, and that he was succeeded by\n\nIlias Simpson as President of ModivCare\u2019s Mobility division. Defendants also admit that\n\nMs. Gutierrez succeeded Mr. Sampson as Chief Financial Officer. Except as expressly\n\nadmitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 38.\n\n39. At all relevant times, Defendant Kenneth Shepard served as ModivCare\u2019s CFO for the\n    Company\u2019s NEMT business.\n       ANSWER: Defendants admit that Mr. Shepard served as Chief Financial Officer of\n\nModivCare\u2019s NEMT segment during the alleged Class Period. Except as expressly\n\nadmitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 39.\n\n40. Defendant Barbara Gutierrez joined ModivCare on September 18, 2023 as the\n    Company\u2019s CFO and held this position throughout the remainder of the Class Period.\n    On May 5, 2025, ModivCare announced Gutierrez\u2019s employment was being\n    terminated effective May 31, 2025.\n       ANSWER: Defendants admit that Ms. Gutierrez was ModivCare\u2019s Chief Financial\n\nOfficer from September 18, 2023 until May 31, 2025. Defendants further admit that, on\n\nMay 5, 2025, ModivCare filed a Form 8-K with the SEC announcing that Ms. Gutierrez\n\nwould depart the Company effective May 31, 2025. Except as expressly admitted,\n\nDefendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 40.\n\n41. Defendants Sampson, Shepard, and Gutierrez are collectively referred to herein as\n    the \u201cDefendants.\u201d\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 41 does not contain any factual allegations requiring a\n\nresponse. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit that the Amended\n\nComplaint refers to Mr. Sampson, Mr. Shepard, and Ms. Gutierrez collectively as the\n\n\n                                            24\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 25 of 269\n\n\n\n\n\u201cDefendants.\u201d Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 41.\n\n42. The Defendants, by virtue of their high-level positions at ModivCare, directly\n    participated in the management of ModivCare and were directly involved in the day-\n    to-day operations of ModivCare at the highest levels. As such, they were privy to\n    confidential, proprietary information concerning the Company and its business\n    operations, growth, and financial condition. As set forth below, the materially misstated\n    information conveyed to the public was the result of the individual and collective\n    actions of these individuals.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 42 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 42.\n\n43. As senior executives at a publicly held company with securities registered with the\n    SEC and, throughout the Class Period, traded on the Nasdaq Global Select Market\n    (\u201cNASDAQ\u201d), the Defendants each had a duty to disseminate prompt, accurate, and\n    truthful information with respect to the Company\u2019s business, operations, financial\n    statements, and internal controls, and to correct any previously issued statements that\n    were or had become materially misleading or untrue, so that the market price of\n    ModivCare\u2019s publicly traded securities would be based on accurate information. Each\n    Defendant violated these requirements and obligations during the Class Period.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 43 contains legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit that\n\nModivCare\u2019s common stock was registered with the SEC and traded on the Nasdaq\n\nGlobal Select Market during the alleged Class Period. Except as expressly admitted,\n\nDefendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 43.\n\n44. As a result of their positions of control and authority as senior executives, the\n    Defendants were able to and did control the content of the public statements issued\n    by the Company during the Class Period. Each Defendant had the ability to correct\n    the statements or prevent them from being released into the public sphere.\n\n\n\n                                             25\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 26 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   Accordingly, the Defendants are responsible for the accuracy of the materially false\n   and misleading public statements detailed in this complaint.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 44 contains legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. Defendants deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct,\n\ndocument, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another.\n\nTo the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 44.\n\n45. As a result of their positions of control and authority as senior executives, the\n    Defendants had access to adverse, undisclosed information about the Company\u2019s\n    business, operations, financial statements, and internal controls through their access\n    to internal corporate documents and conversations with other corporate officers and\n    employees. Defendants knew or recklessly disregarded that the positive\n    representations they made about the Company were materially false and misleading\n    and material facts omitted from positive representations made by Defendants about\n    the Company rendered those representations materially false and misleading, as\n    detailed herein.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 45 contains legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. Defendants deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct,\n\ndocument, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another.\n\nTo the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 45.\n\n      C.     Relevant Non-Parties\n\n46. At all times relevant to this action, ModivCare was a public corporation, organized and\n    existing under the laws of the State of Delaware with its principal place of business\n    and principal executive offices located at 6900 Layton Avenue, 12th Floor, Denver,\n    Colorado 80237. Throughout the Class Period, the Company\u2019s securities were traded\n    on the NASDAQ, a national exchange, under the ticker symbol \u201cMODV.\u201d On August\n    20, 2025, ModivCare filed for voluntary Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. On August\n    28, 2025, the Company\u2019s common stock was suspended from trading on the NASDAQ\n    and delisted. Thereafter, ModivCare\u2019s common stock began trading on the over-the-\n    counter markets (\u201cOTCMKTS\u201d) under the ticker MODVQ.\n\n\n\n\n                                            26\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79     filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 27 of 269\n\n\n\n\n         ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare was a corporation organized under\n\nthe laws of the State of Delaware with its principal place of business and principal\n\nexecutive offices located at 6900 E Layton Avenue, 12th Floor, Denver, Colorado 80237;\n\nthat ModivCare\u2019s common stock traded on the NASDAQ under the ticker symbol \u201cMODV\u201d\n\nduring the alleged Class Period; that ModivCare filed for voluntary protection under\n\nChapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code on August 20, 2025; that ModivCare\u2019s common stock\n\nwas delisted from trading on the NASDAQ on August 28, 2025; and that ModivCare\u2019s\n\ncommon stock thereafter traded on OTCMKTS under the ticker symbol \u201cMODVQ.\u201d Except\n\nas expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 46.\n\n47. CW1 was a ModivCare employee from before the Class Period until Q3 2023. As part\n    of CW1\u2019s responsibilities, CW1 managed the Company\u2019s multi-million-dollar NEMT\n    contracts to provide transportation to payors\u2019 members. CW1 was also responsible for\n    de-implementations, which refers to ending payors\u2019 contracts with ModivCare.\n         ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the allegations concerning CW1 in Paragraph 47 and deny them on that\n\nbasis.\n\n48. In CW1\u2019s role, CW1 had access to all of the information regarding the Company\u2019s\n    NEMT contracts, including the payors, the contracts\u2019 dollar amount, the members, the\n    number of members for each contract, \u201cand basically everything in the contract, to\n    understand what it would take for us to provide the service.\u201d\n         ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the allegations concerning CW1 in Paragraph 48 and deny them on that\n\nbasis.\n\n49. CW1 was responsible for coordinating with upper management, including senior vice\n    presidents and presidents, at insurance and healthcare companies to set those payors\n    up on ModivCare\u2019s system, help them understand the technology, and set the payor\n\n\n                                           27\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79     filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 28 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   up with the transportation providers that ModivCare works with in the states applicable\n   to the payors\u2019 contract. According to CW1, ModivCare\u2019s implementation phase for a\n   new payor typically lasted between 90 and 120 days but could last up to 9 months,\n   depending on the payor.\n         ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the allegations concerning CW1 in Paragraph 49 and deny them on that\n\nbasis.\n\n50. CW1 also worked on ModivCare\u2019s strategic initiatives with the Company\u2019s operations\n    teams across the country to improve operational performance, start new initiatives to\n    improve operational efficiencies, and help the Home Health and NEMT divisions.\n         ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the allegations concerning CW1 in Paragraph 50 and deny them on that\n\nbasis.\n\n51. CW2 served as ModivCare\u2019s VP of Transportation before the Class Period and into\n    2024. CW2 was also responsible for overseeing profit and loss performance for all the\n    contracts in CW2\u2019s region.\n         ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the allegations concerning CW2 in Paragraph 51 and deny them on that\n\nbasis.\n\n52. CW2\u2019s daily responsibilities included maintaining customer relationships, meeting\n    regularly with health plans, and ensuring that the Company was meeting contractual\n    metrics by reducing missed rides, increasing on-time performance, and improving\n    service delivery. CW2 also managed the network development team, which was\n    tasked with expanding provider networks and improving service delivery. As of\n    September 2022, CW2 reported to Senior VP of Transportation, Chris Heine, who\n    reported to the President of ModivCare\u2019s Mobility Division, Illias Simpson. In CW2\u2019s\n    role, CW2 had \u201ctons\u201d of meetings with the Senior VP of Transportation that were\n    largely focused on operations but occasionally involved financial discussions focused\n    on customers\u2019 outstanding balances. CW2 also participated in Monthly Leadership\n\n\n\n                                           28\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS           Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 29 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      Meetings with the President of ModivCare\u2019s Mobility Division and in general leadership\n      meetings with Defendant Sampson.\n         ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the allegations concerning CW2 in Paragraph 52 and deny them on that\n\nbasis.\n\n53. CW3 was employed by ModivCare as a Director of Proposal Management and\n    Marketing Communication prior to the Class Period through April 2023 and as a Senior\n    Director of Proposal Management from April 2023 through September 2023. CW3\n    oversaw a team of approximately 12 employees who were responsible for identifying\n    and pursuing new contract opportunities nationwide, monitoring aggregated bid sites\n    for solicitations, preparing and submitting proposals, supporting the sales team with\n    pipeline and reporting information, and coordinating with other departments to develop\n    implementation plans for awarded contracts. CW3 initially reported to Senior VP of\n    Government Affairs Robert Pittman, then to Senior VP of Strategic Solutions Seth\n    Ravine.\n         ANSWER: Defendants admit and allege that CW3 is LeKesh Pettis. Dkt. 55.\n\nDefendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the\n\nremaining allegations in Paragraph 53 and deny them on that basis. Except as expressly\n\nadmitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 53.\n\nIV.      SUBSTANTIVE ALLEGATIONS\n\n         A.     ModivCare is a Healthcare Services Company Whose Core Business\n                is Providing Non-Emergency Medical Transportation\n\n54. ModivCare purports to be a technologically-enabled healthcare services company that\n    offers NEMT services, personal care services (\u201cPCS\u201d) and remote patient monitoring\n    solutions (\u201cRPM\u201d) throughout the United States. During the Class Period, ModivCare\n    had four reportable business segments: NEMT, PCS, RPM, and Corporate and Other.\n    The Company and its employees would sometimes refer to its NEMT business\n    segment as its Mobility division, and its PCS and RPM businesses as its Home division.\n         ANSWER: Defendants admit that, during the alleged Class Period, ModivCare\n\nwas a technology-enabled healthcare services company that provided non-emergency\n\n\n                                              29\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 30 of 269\n\n\n\n\nmedical transportation, personal care services, and remote patient monitoring solutions\n\nin the United States; that ModivCare had four reportable segments: NEMT, Personal Care\n\nServices, Remote Patient Monitoring, and Corporate and Other; and that ModivCare\n\nreferred to its NEMT segment as its Mobility division and to its Personal Care Services\n\nand Remote Patient Monitoring segments collectively as its Home division. To the extent\n\nParagraph 54 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s public statements or other SEC\n\nfilings, Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete documents, which speak\n\nfor themselves, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly\n\nadmitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 54.\n\n55. ModivCare\u2019s core business is NEMT, which consists of coordinating and managing\n    non-emergency medical transportation services. The Company generates the vast\n    majority of its revenue from NEMT services. For instance, in its financial and\n    operational report for the fourth quarter and full year ended December 31, 2024, which\n    was filed with the SEC on March 6, 2025 on Form 10-K (the \u201cFY2024 Form 10-K\u201d),\n    ModivCare reported the following net service revenues:\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that, during the alleged Class Period, NEMT was one\n\nsegment of ModivCare\u2019s business and that ModivCare filed its FY2024 Form 10-K with\n\nthe SEC on March 6, 2025. Paragraph 55 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s\n\nFY2024 Form 10-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete\n\ndocument, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith.\n\nExcept as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 55.\n\n\n\n\n                                           30\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 31 of 269\n\n\n\n\n56. The Company purports to be the largest manager of NEMT programs for state\n    governments and managed care organizations in the United States. During the Class\n    Period, ModivCare provided NEMT services in 48 states and the District of Columbia\n    to approximately between 33.6 and 36 million members. To facilitate this, ModivCare\n    partners with credentialed transportation providers, including third-party transportation\n    providers, on-demand transportation companies, mass transit entities, mileage\n    reimbursement programs, taxis, and county-based emergency medical service\n    providers, to supply transportation tailored to members individualized health needs.\n    The members are typically Medicaid or Medicare eligible and have limited mobility or\n    financial resources.\n       ANSWER: Defendants admit that, during the alleged Class Period, ModivCare\n\nwas the United States\u2019s largest manager of NEMT programs for state governments and\n\nmanaged care organizations; that ModivCare provided NEMT services in 48 states and\n\nthe District of Columbia; that ModivCare provided NEMT services through a network of\n\ncredentialed third-party transportation providers using a variety of transportation modes;\n\nand that members were typically eligible for Medicaid or Medicare. Paragraph 56\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s public statements and SEC filings, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recordings or documents, which\n\nspeak for themselves, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as\n\nexpressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 56.\n\n       B.     ModivCare\u2019s NEMT Customers Largely Consists of State Medicaid\n              Programs and MCOs\n\n57. For its NEMT business, ModivCare\u2019s customers primarily consist of state Medicaid\n    programs and MCOs, the latter of which are health plans (such as Medicare\n    Advantage) or healthcare companies that manage the delivery of healthcare services\n    to its members while aiming to balance costs with maintaining quality service. The\n    Company contracts with these customers (sometimes referred to as \u201cpayors\u201d) to\n    provide NEMT services to the payors\u2019 members. The Company\u2019s top 6 payors\n    included UnitedHealthcare, Aetna, Humana, Anthem, Health Care Service\n    Corporation (\u201cHCSC\u201d) and Centene.\n\n\n                                             31\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 32 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that, during the alleged Class Period, ModivCare\u2019s\n\nNEMT customers included state Medicaid programs, managed care organizations, and\n\nhealthcare companies; that ModivCare\u2019s customers were referred to as payors; and that\n\nModivCare contracted with those payors to provide NEMT services to their members.\n\nExcept as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 57.\n\n58. According to the Company\u2019s FY2024 Form 10-K, ModivCare enters contracts with\n    state Medicaid contracts that generally cover a three-to-five-year period and contain\n    \u201cmultiple renewal options.\u201d By contrast, ModivCare\u2019s contracts with MCOs typically\n    continue until either party, with reasonable notice, terminates the agreement, and\n    purportedly \u201callow for regular price adjustments based upon utilization and\n    transportation cost.\u201d Utilization refers to the rate at which ModivCare\u2019s customers\u2019\n    members use the Company\u2019s NEMT services. The Company reports utilization as a\n    monthly average and on a quarterly basis.\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that, during the alleged Class Period, certain of\n\nModivCare\u2019s state Medicaid contracts generally covered a three-to-five-year period and\n\nthat certain of ModivCare\u2019s contracts with MCOs continued until either party terminated\n\nthe contract. Defendants further admit and allege that utilization referred to the rate at\n\nwhich members used ModivCare\u2019s NEMT services and that ModivCare disclosed\n\nutilization quarterly. Paragraph 58 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s FY2024\n\nForm 10-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly\n\nadmitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 58.\n\n59. ModivCare overwhelmingly derived its NEMT revenue from Medicaid contracts.\n    Indeed, according to the Company\u2019s February 22, 2024 investor presentation (the\n    \u201c4Q2023 Investor Presentation\u201d) and March 6, 2025 investor presentation (the\n    \u201c4Q2024 Investor Presentation\u201d), approximately 83%, 82% and 85% of NEMT\n    revenue in 2022, 2023 and 2024, respectively, was attributable to Medicaid contracts.\n\n\n                                           32\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 33 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   The remaining revenue was generated from Medicare contracts. This revenue\n   breakdown remained consistent throughout the Class Period.\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that, during the alleged Class Period, ModivCare\n\nreceived revenue from its Medicaid contracts. Paragraph 59 characterizes or quotes from\n\nModivCare\u2019s February 22, 2024 and March 6, 2025 investor presentations, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete documents, which speak for\n\nthemselves, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly\n\nadmitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 59.\n\n60. ModivCare also earns a significant portion of its NEMT revenue from a small number\n    of key customers. For instance, according to ModivCare\u2019s FY2024 Form 10-K, a single\n    state Medicaid agency accounted for around 10.9%, 11.2%, and 10.9% of the\n    Company\u2019s NEMT revenue in 2022, 2023, and 2024, respectively. ModivCare earned\n    approximately 19.8%, 19.8%, and 22.4% of its NEMT revenue in 2022, 2023, and\n    2024 from its next four largest NEMT customers combined.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 60 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s FY2024 Form\n\n10-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly\n\nadmitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 60.\n\n      C.     ModivCare Primarily Utilizes Three Contract Structures for its NEMT\n             Customers\n\n61. ModivCare primarily utilizes three contract structures for its NEMT customers: (i)\n    capitated full-risk; (ii) capitated shared risk; and (iii) fee-for-service.\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that, during the alleged Class Period, ModivCare\n\nused capitated full-risk contracts, capitated shared-risk contracts, and fee-for-service\n\ncontracts with its NEMT customers. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 61.\n\n\n\n                                          33\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79      filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 34 of 269\n\n\n\n\n62. Under both capitated contracts and fee-for-service structures, ModivCare arranges for\n    transportation of members through its network of independent transportation providers,\n    whereby ModivCare negotiates rates and remits payment to the transportation\n    providers. According to the Company\u2019s FY2024 Form 10-K, to determine the per ride\n    or per mile rates paid under its transportation service contracts, ModivCare purports\n    to use pricing models for specific populations that \u201ctake into account factors such as\n    estimated utilization, state specific data, previous experience in the state or with\n    similar services, the medically covered programs outlined in the contract, identified\n    populations to be serviced, estimated volume, estimated transportation provider rates\n    and availability of mass transit.\u201d\n       ANSWER: Defendants admit that, during the alleged Class Period, under either\n\ncapitated or fee-for-service contracts, ModivCare arranged transportation through a\n\nnetwork of independent transportation providers with which it negotiated rates and to\n\nwhich it remitted payment. Defendants further admit and allege that, during the alleged\n\nClass Period, ModivCare used pricing models that considered specific factors for specific\n\npopulations to determine applicable contract rates. Paragraph 62 characterizes or quotes\n\nfrom ModivCare\u2019s FY2024 Form 10-K, and Defendants refer the Court to the complete\n\ndocument, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith.\n\nExcept as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 62.\n\n              1.     Full-Risk and Shared Risk Capitated Contracts\n\n63. Capitation refers to \u201ca health care payment method in which medical providers or\n    health plan administrators are paid a pre-determined dollar amount for each patient\n    assigned to them, regardless of how much medical care they provide to that patient.\u201d1\n    Under this payment method, providers are incentivized to provide all of the necessary\n    care to a patient for a total cost under the capitated rate for said patient so that the\n    provider can retain difference in cost as profit.\n\n\n\n1\n        [Footnote     1      in      Complaint]         \u201cWhat       is      capitation?\u201d,\nhttps://www.healthinsurance.org/glossary/capitation/ (last accessed Jan. 9, 2026).\n\n                                            34\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 35 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 63 and footnote 1 state legal conclusions to which no\n\nresponse from Defendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants\n\nadmit that, during the alleged Class Period, under ModivCare\u2019s capitated contracts,\n\npayors paid a fixed amount per eligible member. Defendants lack knowledge or\n\ninformation sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the allegations regarding the\n\nincentives of unidentified providers, and deny them on that basis. Except as expressly\n\nadmitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 63 and footnote 1.\n\n64. For both its full-risk and shared risk capitated contracts, ModivCare receives a fixed\n    PMPM for eligible members in a specific geography. ModivCare negotiates the fixed\n    PMPM fee with its customers during the bidding process, and purports to base this\n    figure on \u201cactual historical transportation data for the subject geographic region as\n    provided by the payor, actuarial work performed in-house as well as by third party\n    actuarial firms and actuarial analysis provided by the payor.\u201d\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that, during the alleged Class Period, for both its\n\ncapitated full-risk and capitated shared risk contracts, ModivCare received a fixed per-\n\nmember per-month fee for eligible members in a specified geography. Defendants further\n\nadmit that, during the alleged Class Period, ModivCare determined the per-member per-\n\nmonth fee with payors during the bidding process, and the fee was based on actual\n\nhistorical transportation data for the subject geographic region as provided by the payor,\n\nactuarial work performed in-house as well as by third party actuarial firms, and actuarial\n\nanalysis provided by the payor. Paragraph 64 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s\n\nFY2024 Form 10-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete\n\ndocument, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith.\n\nExcept as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 64.\n\n\n\n\n                                           35\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 36 of 269\n\n\n\n\n65. For its capitated full-risk contracts, ModivCare receives a pre-negotiated, fixed fee\n    from a payor for each of the payor\u2019s eligible members per month and is responsible\n    for providing NEMT services to each of those members, regardless of the actual cost\n    of care. This means that, under capitated full-risk contracts, ModivCare receives the\n    same PMPM fee for a member who does not use any NEMT services during the month\n    as it does for a member who frequently uses NEMT services during the month. As\n    such, ModivCare\u2019s revenue under its full-risk contracts fluctuates based on costs and\n    utilization. (i.e., the rate at which members use ModivCare\u2019s NEMT services, or paid\n    trips per member).\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that, during the alleged Class Period, under its\n\ncapitated full-risk contracts, ModivCare received a pre-negotiated, fixed per-member per-\n\nmonth fee for each eligible member and assumed responsibility for the cost of service.\n\nExcept as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 65.\n\n66. With capitated shared risk contracts, the Company also receives an upfront fixed fee\n    from a payor for each of the payor\u2019s eligible members per month, but after the monthly\n    ridership per member is determined, the PMPM fee adjusted through a true-up\n    process to account for the actual realized transportation volumes or costs that may\n    result in refunds to the payor (contract payables), or additional payments due from the\n    payor (contract receivables) based on the contractually agreed upon provisions. As\n    such, the PMPM fee obtained by ModivCare increases or decreases based on\n    transportation costs and utilization. CW3 explained that ModivCare\u2019s capitated shared\n    risk contracts varied by customer and used historical utilization data as the basis to\n    structure each agreed upfront payment by mapping out a risk-sharing plan tied to\n    those past trends.\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that, during the alleged Class Period, under\n\nModivCare\u2019s capitated shared risk contracts, the per-member per-month fee was subject\n\nto a process that adjusted the fee based on actual realized transportation volumes or\n\ncosts and may have resulted in a contract payable or a contract receivable. Defendants\n\nlack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW\n\n\n\n\n                                            36\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 37 of 269\n\n\n\n\nallegations in Paragraph 66 and deny them on that basis. Except as expressly admitted,\n\nDefendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 66.\n\n67. ModivCare offered three different reconciliations provisions for its capitated shared\n    risk contracts: (i) reconciliation; (ii) risk corridor; and (iii) profit rebate.\n       ANSWER: Defendants admit that, during the alleged Class Period, ModivCare\u2019s\n\ncapitated shared risk contracts may have contained reconciliation, risk corridor, or profit\n\nrebate provisions. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 67.\n\n68. For capitated contracts with reconciliation provisions, ModivCare receives a partial\n    payment as prepayment during the month that the service is provided. The\n    prepayments are periodically reconciled against actual trip volume and costs. Thus,\n    under a reconciliation provision, ModivCare could either issue a refund to customers\n    or receive additional payments depending on a comparison of the PMPM fee with the\n    actual cost and/or utilization.\n       ANSWER: Defendants admit that, during the alleged Class Period, under its\n\ncapitated contracts with reconciliation provisions, ModivCare received monthly capitation\n\npayments as prepayments that were periodically reconciled against actual trip volume\n\nand costs, which may have resulted in a refund to the customer or an additional payment\n\nto ModivCare. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 68.\n\n69. With capitated contracts that contain a risk corridor provision, ModivCare and a payor\n    negotiate and agree to allow profit within a certain corridor and once those thresholds\n    are met, the Company stops recognizing revenue.2 Therefore, through this provision,\n\n2\n  [Footnote 2 in Complaint] \u201c\u2018Risk corridors\u2019 set limits on the dollar amount of risk or gain\nthat may be experienced for individual patients, e.g., 10% to 20% above or below\ncapitation payments.\u201d Goodson et al., The Future of Capitation, J Gen Intern Med. 2001\nApr;16(4):250\u2013256, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1495203/#ref-list1 (last\naccessed Jan. 9, 2026).\n\n                                             37\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 38 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   ModivCare may record an asset (i.e., contract receivable) or liability (i.e., contract\n   payable). For instance, if the Company fails to meet the minimum profit established in\n   the corridor, it records a contract receivable and should receive additional payment\n   from the customer to reach that minimum threshold. On the other hand, if the\n   Company reaches the threshold or maximum, then ModivCare will not recognize any\n   additional revenue but instead, records a contract payable and will either reduce that\n   amount via future increases in trip volume or periodic settlements with the customer.\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that, during the alleged Class Period, under its\n\ncapitated contracts with risk corridor provisions, ModivCare and the customer agreed to\n\nallow profit within a certain corridor, and that ModivCare ceased recognizing revenue\n\nonce the threshold had been met. Defendants further admit that, during the alleged Class\n\nPeriod, such contracts may have resulted in ModivCare recording a contract receivable\n\nor a contract payable. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 69 and footnote 2.\n\n70. For capitated contracts with profit rebate provision, ModivCare and a payor negotiate\n    and agree to a maximum profit and once that threshold is met, the Company stops\n    recognizing revenue. Thus, a profit rebate provision can only result in ModivCare\n    recording a contract payable.\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that, during the alleged Class Period, under its\n\ncapitated contracts with profit rebate provisions, ModivCare and the payor may have\n\nagreed to a maximum profit threshold, and ModivCare ceased recognizing revenue once\n\nthat threshold had been reached. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 70.\n\n71. Accordingly, depending on the contract\u2019s true-up provisions, ModivCare\u2019s capitated\n    shared risk contracts purportedly allowed the Company and its payor to share the risk\n    of increases in costs and utilization, and featured the lowest gross margin variance of\n    the Company\u2019s contracts. Indeed, the Company claimed that the shared risk contracts\n\n\n\n\n                                            38\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79     filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 39 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   would result in margin stabilization since the PMPM fee received would be adjusted\n   for the costs to provide the transportation services (see Figure 1 infra).\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that, during the alleged Class Period, the structure\n\nof ModivCare\u2019s shared-risk capitated contracts allowed for margin stabilization as\n\ngenerally the amount received per-member, per-month was adjusted for the costs to\n\nprovide the transportation services. Paragraph 71 and Figure 1 characterize or quote from\n\nModivCare\u2019s public statements and SEC filings, including its February 22, 2024 investor\n\npresentation, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recordings or\n\ndocuments, which speak for themselves, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith.\n\nExcept as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 71.\n\n             2.     Fee-for-Service Contracts\n\n72. ModivCare also utilizes fee-for-service (\u201cFFS\u201d) contracts in its NEMT business,\n    wherein the Company charges specific fees for each NEMT service that it provides to\n\n\n                                           39\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS           Document 79    filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 40 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   a payor\u2019s members. Under this contract structure, the Company agrees to provide\n   services based on costs incurred plus a negotiated margin. Similar to capitated full-\n   risk contracts, the Company is entirely responsible for the costs associated with\n   providing the services and must estimate its costs when determining fees. The fees\n   are based on billing rates for specific services or defined membership populations.\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that, during the alleged Class Period, ModivCare\n\nutilized fee-for-service contracts where ModivCare payors paid a pre-arranged specified\n\namount for each service that ModivCare provided, and these specified amounts were\n\nbased on billing rates for specific services or defined membership populations. Except as\n\nexpressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 72.\n\n73. ModivCare bills and collects a specified amount for each service provided. The FFS\n    revenue is recognized during the period in which the services are rendered and is\n    reduced by the estimated impact of contractual allowances and policy discounts for\n    certain third-party payors.\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that, during the alleged Class Period, under its fee-\n\nfor-service contracts, ModivCare billed and collected a specified amount for each service\n\nprovided, and that revenue under the fee-for-service contracts was recognized in the\n\nperiod in which the services were rendered. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 73.\n\n      D.     After ModivCare Secures a NEMT Contract, the                    Company\u2019s\n             Implementations Team Handles Customer Onboarding\n\n74. ModivCare\u2019s Implementations Team managed customer onboarding after the\n    Company obtained a new NEMT customer contract. CW1 provided an example of the\n    implementation process using Cigna Healthcare, explaining that if Cigna needed to\n    have transportation set up in Sacramento, California for 2,000 members by November\n    1st, then the Implementation team would \u201cdo everything it takes\u201d to have\n    transportation arranged for those members, including setting up metrics that the payor\n    and ModivCare would track in connection with ModivCare providing the payors\u2019\n    members transportation services, including member satisfaction, responsiveness to\n\n\n                                            40\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 41 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   complaints, how quickly transportation providers pick up the phone, length of time\n   members remained on the phone with transportation providers, response times, and\n   other KPIs. According to CW1, ModivCare\u2019s implementation phase for a new payor\n   typically lasted between 90 and 120 days but could last up to 9 months, depending on\n   the payor.\n       ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 74 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 74.\n\n75. According to CW1, the Implementation team tracked utilization during the first 30 days\n    after a payor\u2019s implementation was complete after which the responsibility for tracking\n    utilization transitioned to the Operations team. CW1 explained that utilization was\n    definitely a metric that ModivCare tracked carefully.\n       ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 75 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 75.\n\n       E.    During the COVID-19 Pandemic, ModivCare Experienced a Boon from\n             Full Risk Contracts with Low Utilization Which Spurred a Series of\n             Costly Acquisitions\n\n76. Prior to the Class Period, in 2020, ModivCare\u2019s contracts were predominantly\n    capitated full-risk with approximately 60% of its NEMT revenue derived from such\n    contracts. During this time, ModivCare experienced low utilization rates due to the\n    COVID-19 pandemic because its customers\u2019 members were making less trips as a\n    result of the mandated stay at home orders and rise in telehealth visits.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 76 characterizes ModivCare\u2019s contracts and public\n\ndisclosures regarding its NEMT revenue, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to\n\nthe complete documents, which speak for themselves, and deny any allegations\n\ninconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 76.\n\n77. For instance, CW2 explained that ModivCare\u2019s full-risk contracts were extremely\n    lucrative during the COVID-19 pandemic because the Company collected millions of\n\n\n                                            41\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79      filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 42 of 269\n\n\n\n\n    dollars in PMPM payments but had virtually no transportation costs due to decreased\n    utilization as members remained at home. As a result, according to CW2, ModivCare\n    experienced a financial boon during the first approximately two years of the COVID-\n    19 pandemic.\n       ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 77 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 77.\n\n78. Indeed, according to the Company\u2019s financial report for the fourth quarter and full year\n    ended December 31, 2020, which was filed with the SEC on March 1, 2021 on Form\n    10-K (the \u201cFY2020 Form 10-K\u201d), ModivCare reported that its 2020 NEMT operating\n    income totaled approximately $120,689,000, which was an approximately 488%\n    increase from the $24,732,000 reported for its 2019 NEMT operating income. The\n    Company primarily attributed the massive increase in NEMT operating income to\n    significantly lower service expenses, which were approximately $1,036,288,000 in\n    2020 as compared to approximately $1,401,152,000 in 2019.\n       ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare filed its FY2020 Form 10-K with the\n\nSEC on March 1, 2021. Paragraph 78 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s FY2020\n\nForm 10-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly\n\nadmitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 78.\n\n79. ModivCare\u2019s NEMT operating income remained elevated during 2021 as compared to\n    2019 pre-COVID levels. For instance, according to the Company\u2019s financial report for\n    the fourth quarter and full year ended December 31, 2021, which was filed with the\n    SEC on March 1, 2021 on Form 10-K (the \u201cFY2021 Form 10-K\u201d), ModivCare reported\n    that its 2021 NEMT operating income totaled approximately $73,121,000, which was\n    an approximately 196% increase from the $24,732,000 reported for its 2019 NEMT\n    operating income:3\n\n\n3\n  [Footnote 3 in Complaint] ModivCare\u2019s increased net service revenues also included\n$110.0 million of revenue related to contracts from the National MedTrans, LLC\nacquisition that took place in the second quarter of 2020.\n\n                                            42\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS            Document 79   filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                         pg 43 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare filed its FY2021 Form 10-K with the\n\nSEC on March 1, 2022. Paragraph 79, footnote 3, and Plaintiff\u2019s chart characterize or\n\nquote from ModivCare\u2019s FY2021 Form 10-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court\n\nto the complete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph\n\n79, footnote 3, and Plaintiff\u2019s chart.\n\n80. Indeed, ModivCare\u2019s executives would later acknowledge that the COVID-19\n    pandemic provided a financial windfall to the Company. For example, at the 2023\n    Deutsche Bank Conference on October 3, 2023, Defendant Sampson stated:\n              [D]uring COVID, obviously, there wasn\u2019t a lot of trips \u2026 So we\n              benefited heavily from increased cash coming into our\n              balance sheet as well as on the P&L as well, but the big\n              bolus was on our balance sheet.\n\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 80 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s October 3,\n\n2023 Deutsche Bank conference transcript, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court\n\nto the complete recording from that conference, which speaks for itself, and deny any\n\nallegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 80.\n\n\n\n\n                                             43\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 44 of 269\n\n\n\n\n81. ModivCare utilized its cash surplus along with a series of private senior note\n    placements to make a number of acquisitions between 2020 through 2022 that totaled\n    over a billion dollars. For instance, according to ModivCare\u2019s FY2024 Form 10-K: (i)\n    in 2020, the Company acquired National MedTrans, LLC for $80 million and OEP AM,\n    Inc. (\u201cSimplura\u201d) for $575 million; (ii) in 2021, ModivCare spent over $650 million on\n    acquisitions, purchasing WellRyde, Care Finders Total Care, and VRI Intermediate\n    Holdings; and (iii) in 2022, the Company purchased personal care customer contracts\n    from another entity for $7.6 million and also acquired Guardian Medical Monitoring for\n    $71.6 million. These acquisitions were intended to grow ModivCare\u2019s Mobility and\n    Home divisions while creating opportunities for cross-selling services and meeting\n    payor\u2019s desires for a one-stop shop.\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare acquired National MedTrans, LLC\n\nand OEP AM, Inc. in 2020; WellRyde, Care Finders Total Care, and VRI Intermediate\n\nHoldings in 2021; and personal care customer contracts and Guardian Medical Monitoring\n\nin 2022, in each case for the amount reported in ModivCare\u2019s SEC filings. Paragraph 81\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s FY2024 Form 10-K. Defendants respectfully\n\nrefer the Court to the complete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any\n\nallegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 81.\n\n      F.     Leading Up to the Class Period, ModivCare Shifts from Capitated Full-\n             Risk Contracts to Primarily Capitated Shared Risk Contracts\n\n82. After the COVID-19 lockdowns, the Company began to renegotiate its NEMT\n    contracts to shift away from capitated full-risk to capitated shared risk.\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare and certain payors renegotiated\n\ncertain NEMT contracts from full-risk capitated contracts to shared-risk capitated\n\ncontracts. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph\n\n82.\n\n\n\n\n                                           44\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 45 of 269\n\n\n\n\n83. Prior to that shift, the Company\u2019s revenue from full-risk and shared risk capitated\n    contracts was approximately 60% and 25%, respectively. By 2Q 2021, ModivCare\n    reported that, of the approximately 85% of NEMT revenue that was capitated (with the\n    remaining 15% of NEMT revenue being FFS), approximately 44% and 41% were\n    attributable to full-risk and shared risk, respectively. ModivCare\u2019s capitated NEMT\n    revenue remained divided roughly in half between full-risk and shared risk capitated\n    contracts, respectively, until the beginning of the Class Period. By 1Q 2023,\n    ModivCare reported that, of the approximately 85% of NEMT revenue that was\n    capitated, approximately 20% and 65% were attributable to full-risk and shared risk,\n    respectively.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 83 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s public\n\nstatements and SEC filings regarding its NEMT revenue, and Defendants respectfully\n\nrefer the Court to the complete recordings or documents, which speak for themselves,\n\nand deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 83.\n\n84. This transition from capitated full-risk to shared risk contracts had significant\n    implications for ModivCare\u2019s balance sheet because, as described in \u00a7IV.C.1 supra,\n    those contracts contained reconciliation, risk corridor, or profit rebate provisions that\n    could result in the Company booking a contract receivable or contract payable\n    depending on service costs and member utilization. For instance, prior to the Class\n    Period during the Company\u2019s June 23, 2022 inaugural Investor Day (the \u201c2022\n    Investor Day\u201d), Sampson explained that ModivCare \u201cexpect[ed]\u201d contracts payable\n    and contracts receivable to \u201cgo up, go down\u201d because it would reflect that \u201cthe\n    contracts are operating as designed\u201d and added that the Company would \u201cexplain that\n    on a quarterly basis how it\u2019s fluctuating[.]\u201d\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 84 states a legal conclusion to which no response is\n\nrequired. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 84 characterizes or quotes from\n\nModivCare\u2019s June 23, 2022 Investor Day presentation, and Defendants respectfully refer\n\nthe Court to the complete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations\n\ninconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 84.\n\n\n\n                                             45\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS           Document 79      filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 46 of 269\n\n\n\n\n85. Despite the fluctuation, Defendants claimed that the shift to capitated shared risk\n    contracts would protect ModivCare\u2019s margins and provide more stability, including by\n    normalizing working capital and thereby cash flow. 4 Given that the shared risk\n    contracts\u2019 structure purportedly allowed ModivCare to pass through increased costs\n    to its customers (thereby protecting ModivCare\u2019s downside risk) while limiting the\n    Company\u2019s ability to profit from unused services (thereby protecting payors\u2019 downside\n    risks), Defendants\u2019 characterized its shared risk contracts as \u201cwin-win\u201d throughout the\n    Class Period.\n       ANSWER: Defendants admit that, during the alleged Class Period, shared-risk\n\ncapitated contracts were structured to allow for margin stabilization because generally the\n\namount of the per-member, per-month fee would be adjusted for the costs to provide the\n\ntransportation services. Paragraph 85 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s public\n\nstatements and SEC filings. Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete\n\nrecordings and documents, which speak for themselves, and deny any allegations\n\ninconsistent therewith. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 85 and footnote 4.\n\n86. Indeed, during the Company\u2019s earnings call for the third quarter of 2022 on November\n    3, 2022 (the \u201c3Q2022 Earnings Call\u201d), Defendant Sampson explained that\n    ModivCare\u2019s shared risk contracts allowed the Company to \u201cpass a large chunk\u201d of\n    \u201chigher cost[s] in [] mobility\u201d onto customers, \u201cprotecting the downside in the event that\n    there\u2019s some volatility in costs or utilization.\u201d Likewise, during the May 10, 2023 Bank\n    of America Securities Health Care Conference and earnings call for the third quarter\n    of 2023 on November 3, 2023 (the \u201c3Q2023 Earnings Call\u201d), Sampson explained that\n    the shared risk contracts\u2019 win-win nature provided ModivCare with \u201cstable rigid\n\n\n\n\n4\n   [Footnote 4 in Complaint] Working capital is the amount of money a company has\navailable to operate after deducting its current liabilities (i.e., accounts payable and debt)\nfrom its current assets (i.e., cash, accounts receivable, etc.). See Jason Fernando,\nWorking Capital: Formula Components, and Limitations, Investopedia (June 17, 2025),\nhttps://www.investopedia.com/terms/w/workingcapital.asp (last accessed Jan. 9, 2026).\n\n\n                                             46\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS           Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 47 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   margins regardless of utilization and cost\u201d and \u201cprotect[ed] the downside to [the\n   Company\u2019s] cash flow,\u201d respectively.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 86 to the\n\nextent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. Paragraph 86 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s\n\nNovember 3, 2022, May 10, 2023, and November 3, 2023 earnings call and conference\n\ntranscripts, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recordings of\n\nthose earnings calls, which speak for themselves, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 86.\n\n87. Defendants also provided insight into the mechanics of the shared risk true- up\n    process. For instance, in a slide from ModivCare\u2019s August 2023 investor presentation\n    (\u201c2Q2023 Investor Presentation\u201d), the Company represented that shared risk\n    contracts maintained the same net cash flow regardless of utilization due to the\n    contracts \u201cbuilt-in corridors[,]\u201d which allowed ModivCare to make profit up to a certain\n    threshold. After that threshold is met, ModivCare stops recognizing revenue and\n    records a liability within the accrued contract payable account.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 87 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s Q2 FY2023\n\ninvestor presentation. Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\nfurther deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission\n\nallegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 87.\n\n88. To demonstrate how the corridors function, the Company modeled three utilization\n    scenarios in the slide. In the low utilization scenario, transportation costs decrease by\n\n\n                                             47\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 48 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   $4 per member with ModivCare recording $2 in a contract payable that it will eventually\n   repay the customer due to lower costs than anticipated. In the high utilization scenario,\n   transportation costs increase by $4 per member with ModivCare recording $2 in a\n   contract receivable that it will eventually receive from the customer to share the higher\n   than anticipated costs. Based on this, ModivCare represented that the \u201c[s]hared risk\n   structure reduce[d] income statement impact from changes in costs with the built-in\n   corridors\u201d (see Figure 2 infra).\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 88 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s Q2 FY2023\n\ninvestor presentation, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete\n\ndocument, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 88.\n\n      G.     During the Class Period, ModivCare\u2019s Free Cash Flow Plummets and\n             Debt Balloons Due to COVID-19 Rebates, Loss of Customers due to\n             Service Issues, Increased Utilization, and Collectability Issues\n\n             1.     ModivCare Reimburses Customers Hundreds of Millions of\n                    Dollars for Low Utilization During COVID-19\n\n\n\n\n                                            48\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS           Document 79     filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 49 of 269\n\n\n\n\n89. Though ModivCare\u2019s NEMT operating income and cash position benefited\n    significantly from low utilization during the COVID-19 pandemic, those financial\n    windfalls were offset by swelling contract payables balances leading up to the Class\n    Period.\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that utilization of NEMT services declined during the\n\nCOVID-19 pandemic, and that ModivCare\u2019s contract payables balances increased prior\n\nto the start of the alleged Class Period. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny\n\nthe allegations in Paragraph 89.\n\n90. For instance, according to the FY2020 Form 10-K, ModivCare\u2019s total accrued and\n    long-term contract payable balances for 2020 was $173,778,000. These balances\n    represented overpayments and liability reserves related to lower activity due to\n    COVID-19 and corresponded to ModivCare\u2019s reconciliation and risk corridor contracts\n    (i.e., ModivCare\u2019s shared risk contracts). In other words, although ModivCare\u2019s shared\n    risk contracts represented only a portion of ModivCare\u2019s contract mix in 2020, the\n    Company was responsible for repaying a significant sum as a result of lower utilization\n    during COVID-19.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 90 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s FY2020 Form\n\n10-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 90.\n\n91. By 1Q 2021, ModivCare\u2019s total accrued contract payable balance related to shared\n    risk contracts had surged to $245,386,000. Given the true-up aspect of its shared risk\n    contracts, ModivCare anticipated continuing to reimburse those customers for COVID-\n    19 under-utilization. By contrast, ModivCare did not expect to repay most of its full-\n    risk customers for COVID-19 related under-utilization. However, according to CW2,\n    some of ModivCare\u2019s health plan customers requested refunds due to the inactivity\n    and in some cases, the Company partially refunded payments \u201cin the spirit of good\n    partnership.\u201d\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 91 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s public\n\nstatements or SEC filings, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete\n\n\n                                            49\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 50 of 269\n\n\n\n\ndocuments, which speak for themselves, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith.\n\nDefendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the\n\nCW allegations in Paragraph 91 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny\n\nthe allegations in Paragraph 91.\n\n92. Indeed, during the Company\u2019s earnings call for the first quarter of 2021 on May 7,\n    2021 (\u201c1Q2021 Earnings Call\u201d), Defendant Sampson confirmed that ModivCare had\n    reimbursed some of its full risk customers, stating:\n              As a reminder, our full risk contracts are structured, so we\n              bear all the expense management and market fluctuation risk.\n              Our customers with full risk contract models are fully aware of\n              the performance during the pandemic.\n\n              For some, we have provided or expect to provide\n              retroactive monetary rebates or prospective rate\n              concessions. However, for the majority, we do not expect to\n              provide any concessions.\n\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 92 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s May 7, 2021\n\nearnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from\n\nthat earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 92.\n\n93. As such, throughout 2021 and leading up to the beginning of the Class Period on\n    November 3, 2022, ModivCare\u2019s total contracts payable exceeded its net accounts\n    receivable, as depicted in Figure 3:\n\n\n\n\n                                             50\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 51 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 93 and Figure 3 characterize or quote from ModivCare\u2019s\n\npublic statements and SEC filings describing its contracts payables and contracts\n\nreceivables balances, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete\n\nrecordings and documents, which speak for themselves, and deny any allegations\n\ninconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 93 and\n\nFigure 3.\n\n94. At the start of the Class Period, ModivCare began to pay down its massive contract\n    payables balance. For instance, during the 3Q2022 Earnings Call on November 3,\n    2022, Defendant Sampson stated that ModivCare \u201creduced [its] contract payable\n    balance, net of our contract receivables, by $51 million to a net balance of $184 million\u201d\n    and added that the Company \u201cexpect[ed] to reduce this net balance by an additional\n    $40 million to $60 million during the fourth quarter\u201d of 2022.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 94 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s November 3,\n\n2022 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording\n\n\n\n                                             51\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 52 of 269\n\n\n\n\nfrom that call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 94.\n\n95. By the end of the fourth quarter of 2022 (\u201c4Q2022\u201d), according to its financial and\n    operational report for the fourth quarter and full year ended December 31, 2022, which\n    was filed with the SEC on March 7, 2023 on Form 10-K (the \u201cFY2022 Form 10-K\u201d),\n    the Company reduced its contract payables to $194.3 million.\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare filed its FY2022 Form 10-K with the\n\nSEC on March 7, 2023. Paragraph 95 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s FY2022\n\nForm 10-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly\n\nadmitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 95.\n\n96. These payments decimated ModivCare\u2019s cash position. Indeed, after paying $134\n    million to reduce its contracts payables balance in 2022, the Company ended the\n    fourth quarter of 2022 with $14.5 million in cash. Nevertheless, Defendants assured\n    investors that the Company\u2019s cash position would normalize.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 96 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s FY2022 Form\n\n10-K. Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which speaks\n\nfor itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny that\n\nany alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable\n\nto one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 96.\n\n97. For instance, during the Company\u2019s February 23, 2023 fourth quarter and full-year\n    2022 earnings call (\u201cFY2022 Earnings Call\u201d), Defendant Shepard stated: \u201cAs a\n    reminder, we expect a more normalized level of activity for these contracts payable\n    moving forward and, therefore, a more normalized environment for our free cash flow\n    in 2023.\u201d\n\n\n\n\n                                           52\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79     filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 53 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 97 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23,\n\n2023 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording\n\nfrom that earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 97.\n\n98. Likewise, during the same earnings call, Defendant Sampson represented the\n    3Q2022 and 4Q2022 payments were the final ones to pay off the balances incurred\n    under the Company\u2019s shared risk contracts during the COVID-19 pandemic, stating in\n    relevant part: \u201c2022 involves us paying off the cash that we accumulated on our\n    balance sheet through COVID in 2020 and 2021 and the bulk of accumulation -- or a\n    disproportional amount of that accumulation was all paid off in 2022. So the COVID\n    payoff was finished in 2022.\u201d With COVID-19 payments purportedly complete,\n    Defendants assured that ModivCare\u2019s working capital fluctuations would normalize\n    under the shared risk contracts and as a result, the Company would generate more\n    free cash flow each quarter going forward.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 98 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23,\n\n2023 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording\n\nfrom that earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants further deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct,\n\ndocument, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 98.\n\n             2.     ModivCare\u2019s NEMT Service Quality Issues and Outdated\n                    Technologies Cause a Swell of Member Complaints, Significant\n                    Customer Issues, and Contract Losses\n\n99. Prior to and throughout the Class Period, ModivCare received increasing complaints\n    about its NEMT service and technological platforms, which caused payors to be\n    dissatisfied and led them to place the Company on performance improvement plans\n    and to delay payments, seek liquidated damages, and cancel contracts.\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 99 to the\n\nextent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n\n                                           53\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 54 of 269\n\n\n\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the allegations concerning\n\nunidentified payors\u2019 states of mind in Paragraph 99 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 99.\n\n100. For instance, around 1Q2022, CW1 began hearing that account managers had\n   \u201cstruggles to keep the payors happy.\u201d According to CW1, beginning around May or\n   June 2022 and continuing throughout CW1\u2019s tenure, ModivCare received increasing\n   complaints from payors\u2019 members, including reports that drivers were not showing up\n   on time and of miscommunications between drivers and payors. CW1 recalled that\n   account managers\u2019 challenges and the increase in member complaints coincided with\n   Simpson\u2019s appointment as President of the Mobility Division in April 2022, and\n   explained that with his appointment ModivCare\u2019s NEMT operations changed\n   dramatically. According to CW1, Simpson began terminating the employment of senior\n   employees who knew the business really well.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 100 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n100 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 100.\n\n101. CW1 stated that ModivCare\u2019s service quality declined because employees with\n   \u201ccore competencies\u201d \u2013 the core leaders who really knew the NEMT business and how\n   to manage that side of the business \u2013 were fired or laid off. CW1 added that payors\n\n\n                                             54\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 55 of 269\n\n\n\n\n    knew and trusted the core leaders, but when they were let go, service quality started\n    to decline, complaints from payors increased steadily, until the payors decided to quit\n    ModivCare.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 101 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n101 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 101.\n\n102. Corroborating CW1, CW3 explained that ModivCare laid off approximately 80% of\n   its customer advocate team and implemented major cost reductions for the operations\n   team when Simpson arrived at the Company. ModivCare\u2019s customer advocate team\n   was responsible for supporting the Company\u2019s transportation providers by answering\n   inquiries, documenting and resolving complaints, and supporting scheduling,\n   modifying, and canceling reservations.5\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 102 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n\n5\n  [Footnote 5 in Complaint] See e.g., FlexJobs, Customer Advocate I ModivCare,\nhttps://www.flexjobs.com/gjw/ModivCare/customer-advocate-i/publicjobs?id=a34c3ad3-\n4080-47ef-889c-ae5150395f54 (last accessed Jan. 9, 2026).\n\n\n                                             55\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 56 of 269\n\n\n\n\n102 and footnote 5 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 102 and footnote 5.\n\n103. According to CW3, these staffing cuts eliminated the customer advocate team\u2019s\n   capability of working with dispatchers to monitor the NEMT trips live and, as a result,\n   ModivCare\u2019s ability to address service issues was diminished. For example, CW3\n   described that certain technologies of ModivCare\u2019s software, such as GPS tracking\n   and dynamic reassignment (meaning a NEMT trip would be automatically re-booked\n   if a driver was unavailable), required dedicated staff advocates because the electronic\n   systems were \u201cplagued by bugs\u201d throughout CW3\u2019s tenure and could not fulfill these\n   capabilities without human intervention.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 103 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n103 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 103.\n\n104. Accordingly, when CW3 heard that the advocate team was eliminated entirely,\n   CW3 knew ModivCare did not have the resources to deliver technological\n   enhancements that the Company promised to payors. As a result, CW3 stated that\n   payors began to consistently express dissatisfaction with ModivCare\u2019s service and\n   inquire about no shows and on-time performance issues. CW3 confirmed ModivCare\u2019s\n   payors continued to express their dissatisfaction throughout CW3\u2019s tenure.\n   Specifically, CW3 recalled that ModivCare\u2019s local Operations teams in Virginia and\n   Florida lacked capabilities to address service issues, and that no-shows, on-time\n   performance, and overall declining performance were issues in New Jersey.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 104 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n\n                                             56\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 57 of 269\n\n\n\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n104 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 104.\n\n105. When asked whether payors refused to pay or delayed payment due to service\n   issues, CW1 responded \u201cabsolutely\u201d and explained that if service levels were not met,\n   ModivCare would bear the cost. CW1 added that, throughout the last year of CW1\u2019s\n   employment, ModivCare was failing to meet targets for member satisfaction KPIs,\n   including on-time performance, no-show rates, cancellation ratios, and call-center\n   responsiveness KPIs.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 105 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n105 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 105.\n\n106. CW3 likewise explained that KPIs, such as on time performance, NVA (no vehicle\n   available), and complaint volume, were important to ModivCare\u2019s payors. CW3 added\n   that ModivCare consistently failed to meet KPIs, including on-time performance and\n   NVAs (which caused missed rides), throughout CW3\u2019s tenure.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 106 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n\n                                             57\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 58 of 269\n\n\n\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n106 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 106.\n\n107. CW1 recounted three key trends during CW1\u2019s tenure with ModivCare: payors\n   cancelling contracts; leadership getting concerned with revenue coming in, because\n   contracts were being cancelled; and increased concern with operational performance.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 107 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n107 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 107.\n\n108. CW1 explained that, during CW1\u2019s last year with ModivCare, the Company began\n   losing NEMT contracts due to service complaints. CW1 added that ModivCare\u2019s\n   service levels \u201cwere way down\u201d due to poor service quality and high employee\n   turnover. Indeed, CW1 stated during this time, payors were \u201cliterally cancelling\n   contracts because the service, and the people trying to perform the services, kept\n   changing so much. The service levels were way down.\u201d CW1 specifically recalled that\n   payors, such as UnitedHealthcare and HCSC, cancelled services due to ModivCare\u2019s\n   failure to meet member satisfaction KPIs.\n\n\n\n\n                                             58\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 59 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 108 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n108 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 108.\n\n109. CW1 also described attending a standing, direct report staff meeting with leaders\n   from Operations, Client Services, Process Optimization, Human Resources, Finance,\n   Project Management, and Strategy during the summer of 2022 where the rise in\n   service complaints and payors\u2019 disappointment over the rise in service complaints\n   were being discussed. CW1 explained that meeting attendees were specifically\n   discussing members not feeling comfortable with drivers, increased member\n   complaints including those about vehicle conditions, member satisfaction concerns,\n   and service level agreements.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 109 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n109 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 109.\n\n110. During the meeting, according to CW1, Simpson told attendants that ModivCare\n   only owned \u201cpicking up and dropping\u201d off the member and specifically did not \u201cown the\n\n\n                                             59\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 60 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   customer experience.\u201d According to CW1, Simpson likened transporting members to\n   Amazon\u2019s process for getting packages where they need to go during the meeting. It\n   was at this time, according to CW1, that it became clear to CW1 that ModivCare could\n   be headed for financial troubles since member experience was critical to the NEMT\u2019s\n   business\u2019 success, but was specifically de-prioritized. CW1 described Simpson\u2019s\n   directive to ModivCare\u2019s operational leaders as \u201cshocking\u201d and said, \u201cthat was the\n   moment in time I realized we could be in trouble.\u201d\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 110 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n110 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph\n\n110.\n\n111. CW1 explained that Simpson\u2019s stance that ModivCare was not responsible for\n   members\u2019 experience \u201c100%\u201d contributed to the loss of business. CW1 explained that\n   running the company became very difficult, as employees with knowledge about\n   operations were pushed out, and payors became increasingly dissatisfied. CW1\n   added that ModivCare\u2019s abandonment of its core values, such as serving members\n   and firing NEMT experts, and the subsequent rise in complaints, all resulted in the\n   loss of contracts.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 111 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\n\n\n\n                                             60\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 61 of 269\n\n\n\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n111 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph\n\n111.\n\n112. Corroborating CW1, CW2 attributed ModivCare\u2019s damaged payor relationships to\n   ModivCare\u2019s new leadership, after former-CEO Daniel Greenleaf departed the\n   Company in August 2022, treating the Company as a logistics operation\u2014 focusing\n   narrowly on financials and prioritizing profit over customer service\u2014despite it being a\n   people-driven service business.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 112 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit that\n\nDaniel Greenleaf was ModivCare\u2019s former CEO. Defendants lack knowledge or\n\ninformation sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n112 and deny them on that basis. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 112.\n\n113. CW1 also recounted that ModivCare\u2019s service issues resulted in a lot of problems\n   with the Big 6, which included UnitedHealthcare, among others. CW1 recalled, during\n   the last year of CW1\u2019s tenure, that the payors\u2019 executives would bring concerns to\n   ModivCare\u2019s operations team but the operations team was often unprepared to\n   respond to their concerns. CW1 said that this \u201cabsolutely\u201d contributed to the loss of\n   contracts.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 113 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\n\n\n                                             61\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 62 of 269\n\n\n\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n113 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph\n\n113.\n\n114. When asked whether payors raised these service issues with CW1, CW1 replied\n   \u201call the time.\u201d CW1 also heard about the service issues, including drivers not picking\n   members up on time and miscommunications between drivers and members, from the\n   operations team, executive teams, and \u201ceveryone across the country, weekly.\u201d CW1\n   confirmed that the service issues were 100% on Shepard\u2019s and Sampson\u2019s radars.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 114 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n114 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph\n\n114.\n\n115. CW2 also confirmed that ModivCare quantified its customer service failures,\n   explaining that call center performance was tracked. CW2 stated that, beginning\n   around 2Q2022 and continuing throughout CW2\u2019s tenure, ModivCare\u2019s poor\n   operational performance (such as call center failures) led to payor dissatisfaction and\n   monthly liquidated damages of hundreds of thousands of dollars. CW2 stated that\n   these service issues were discussed frequently during Monthly Leadership Meetings.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 115 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n\n\n                                             62\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 63 of 269\n\n\n\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n115 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph\n\n115.\n\n116. Similarly, CW3 stated ModivCare consistently failed to provide payors with the\n   technology and system maintenance offerings that the Company committed to\n   delivering in contracts, including ride scheduling, real-time reporting, GPS tracking,\n   and dynamic trip reassignment for medical appointments. Indeed, according to CW3,\n   by the end of CW3\u2019s tenure at ModivCare, the Company still remained dependent on\n   the outdated LogistiCare platform,6 despite spending millions of dollars, over an eight-\n   year period, on supposed upgrades.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 116 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit that on\n\nJanuary 6, 2021, ModivCare changed its name from Providence Service Corporation to\n\nModivCare, Inc. Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 116 and deny them on that basis. Except\n\nas expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 116 and footnote 6.\n\n\n6\n  [Footnote 6 in Complaint] On January 6, 2021, the Company was rebranded from\nProvidence Service Corporation to ModivCare Inc. and as a part of this rebrand, the\nCompany\u2019s wholly-owned NEMT subsidiary, LogistiCare Solutions, LLC, was rebranded\nto ModivCare Solutions, LLC.\n\n\n                                             63\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 64 of 269\n\n\n\n\n117. CW3 learned about payors\u2019 complaints that ModivCare was not fulfilling its\n   commitments from interactions with ModivCare\u2019s local Operations Managers or\n   Regional Vice Presidents when the Company began preparations to respond to a new\n   request for proposal (\u201cRFP\u201d). CW3 provided an example where ModivCare promised\n   Virginia-based payors certain technological enhancements, such as a new user\n   interface for the call center, in connection with a 2018 RFP. According to CW3,\n   between 2020 and 2023 while preparing for the next rounds of RFPs, the local\n   Operations Manager raised that these 2018 promises remained unfulfilled, and that\n   the client had complained about the lack of enhancements previously guaranteed\n   during the earlier RFP.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 117 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n117 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph\n\n117.\n\n118. CW3 also explained that missed appointments and no-shows were significant\n   service issues that ModivCare had throughout CW3\u2019s tenure but did not improve on.\n   Indeed, CW3 participated in series of communications with Simpson, the President of\n   Mobility, during the Spring of 2022 to create a roadmap with technology\n   enhancements as part of ModivCare\u2019s RFPs to state MCO clients, specifically in\n   response to complaints. Specifically, the roadmap contemplated: GPS tracking with\n   real-time trip assignment to reduce no-shows or late arrivals by transportation\n   providers; improvements to claims so providers could process payments instantly or\n   within 7\u201314 days; and real- time reporting that would have allowed payors to view on-\n   time performance, complaints, and vehicle availability. Yet, despite promising payors\n   that the Company had such capabilities in its RFPs during the Class Period, the\n   Company never delivered on providing these technological enhancements\n   during CW3\u2019s tenure. Indeed, CW3 stated that the technological enhancements in\n\n\n\n                                             64\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 65 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   the roadmap never materialized and instead, the Company\u2019s systems had not been\n   improved since 2016 and were pieced together with no enhancements.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 118 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n118 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph\n\n118.\n\n119. As a result, CW3 likewise stated that ModivCare\u2019s poor service delivery, long-\n   standing weaknesses in technology, and reliance on an outdated platform caused\n   major contracts to be under threat throughout CW3\u2019s tenure. Indeed, between\n   November 2022 and the end of CW3\u2019s tenure in September 2023, CW3 held several\n   meetings with ModivCare\u2019s leadership, including Defendant Sampson, during which\n   CW3 warned leadership that the Company\u2019s contracts were at risk because they were\n   failing to keep up with their competitors.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 119 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n119 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph\n\n119.\n\n\n\n\n                                             65\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 66 of 269\n\n\n\n\n120. Specifically, CW3 issued such a warning to Defendant Sampson during a week-\n   long, in-person Summit in May 2023 at ModivCare\u2019s Denver headquarters, which was\n   attended by CW3, Defendant Sampson, the President of ModivCare\u2019s Mobility\n   Division Simpson, the Senior VP/Head of Mobility Product Edward Hoffman, and \u201cthe\n   full c-suite\u201d (the \u201cMay 2023 Summit\u201d). During the May 2023 Summit, CW3\u2019s team\n   presented competitive analyses that compared ModivCare\u2019s offerings to competitors\n   and emphasized long-standing weaknesses in technology, poor service delivery, and\n   a disjointed operational model based on the outdated LogistiCare platform.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 120 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n120 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 120.\n\n121. CW3 explained that Senior VP of Government Affairs Robert Pittman, Senior VP\n   of Mobility Edward Hoffman, and Defendant Sampson instructed CW3 to highlight\n   capabilities to customers in RFPs that did not exist, including technology platforms the\n   company had long promised but never delivered. Indeed, CW3 stated that the\n   guidance to CW3\u2019s team was to continue to falsely represent ModivCare\u2019s capabilities\n   in RFP even when the technology was not yet implemented or would never be. CW3\n   added the RFPs were essentially highlighting vaporware.7\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 121 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n\n\n7\n [Footnote 7 in Complaint] Vaporware refers to \u201ca computer-related product that has\nbeen widely advertised but has not and may never become available.\u201d See Merriam-\nWebster, vaporware, https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/vaporware (last\naccessed Jan. 9, 2026).\n\n                                             66\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 67 of 269\n\n\n\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n121 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 121 and footnote 7.\n\n122. CW3 recalled that ModivCare\u2019s local Operations Mangers did not want these\n   capabilities listed in the RFP if they could not be delivered but due to executive\n   mandates from then-Senior VP of Strategic Solutions Seth Ravine, Pittman and\n   Sampson, such requirements were included in the RFPs. CW3 further confirmed that\n   Sampson and leadership were aware of ModivCare\u2019s technological shortcomings and\n   that representing the Company had such capabilities in the RFPs was not truthful.\n   CW3 further stated that clients repeatedly complained about ModivCare\u2019s\n   technological systems, and some states placed ModivCare on performance\n   improvement plans (\u201cPIPs\u201d) during 2022 and 2023. According to CW3, ModivCare\u2019s\n   leadership often ignored the impact of the PIPs and instead, operated with the mindset\n   that the Company was largest provider and industry leader, and as a result of this\n   position, payors needed to align with ModivCare\u2019s direction. CW3 added that\n   ModivCare developed a poor reputation that made it increasingly difficult to win\n   contracts.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 122 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n122 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 122.\n\n\n                                             67\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 68 of 269\n\n\n\n\n123. CW3 also explained that customers in New York had major complaints centered\n   on technology, call center performance (such as delays in answering calls, extended\n   hold times, the interactive voice response failing to recognize natural language,\n   problematic translation services, and similar matters), and lack of responsiveness\n   from the executive team. Specifically, CW3 stated that New York State expressed\n   concerns regarding the timeliness of local call teams and took issue with the Company\n   transferring call centers overseas. CW3 also stated ModivCare made unilateral\n   program changes without client approval, and failed to deliver GPS tracking and\n   claims systems that had been promised. Further, CW3 recalled that ModivCare\n   consistently failed to meet KPIs, including on-time performance, NVAs (which caused\n   missed rides), and the call center answering calls within 30 seconds or 4 rings, which\n   affected most payors.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 123 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n123 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 123.\n\n124. As a result, according to CW3, ModivCare lost clients during CW3\u2019s tenure with\n   the Company and after CW3\u2019s departure. For instance, according to CW3, the\n   Company: (i) lost the majority of its NEMT business in New York in 2022; (ii) was\n   informed by Virginia during 2022 \u2013 2023 that the Company would not be considered\n   for upcoming RFPs because of their low performance; (iii) ModivCare lost the\n   Elevance contract, other minor player contracts in NEMT, MCOs, and large\n   organizations like UHC and Humana withdrew; and (iv) lost all of the business with\n   Florida in 2024.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 124 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n\n\n                                             68\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 69 of 269\n\n\n\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n124 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 124.\n\n125. Corroborating CW1 and CW3, CW2 confirmed that contract attrition was an issue\n   in multiple regions and remained an issue through CW2\u2019s tenure. Indeed, CW2\n   recalled that ModivCare lost MCO Medicaid contracts in New York that were valued\n   at $100 million annually during CW2\u2019s tenure due, in part, to New York State\n   transitioning members to its state Medicaid program.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 125 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n125 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 125.\n\n126. CW1 explained that de-implementations were \u201ca huge, huge concern, probably\n   across the entire company, but certainly the transportation division.\u201d CW1 added that\n   the majority of concerns about lost business were NEMT-related. CW1 stated that\n   Sampson and Shepard were \u201cdefinitely\u201d concerned about the increase in de-\n   implementations. CW1 added that when ModivCare was losing more business, and\n   utilization was increasing, the implementations team was given a \u201cspotlight.\u201d Indeed,\n   CW1 participated in a meeting with Sampson regarding de-implementations where he\n\n\n\n\n                                             69\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 70 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   asked questions about why ModivCare was losing business and for dollar amounts\n   related to the same.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 126 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n126 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 126.\n\n127. CW1 estimated that de-implementations represented more than $10 million during\n   CW1\u2019s last year but added that this was \u201cprobably a low-ball number.\u201d CW1 also\n   observed that implementations declined to about 10 or 15, at most, during the last\n   year of CW1\u2019s tenure. By contrast, according to CW1, the average for new payor\n   implementations for the prior two years was 30 to 40, some of which related to\n   ModivCare\u2019s acquisition of another NEMT company. CW1 added that, during the last\n   year of CW1\u2019s employment, de-implementations were adeptly managed because they\n   were so common.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 127 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n127 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 127.\n\n\n                                             70\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 71 of 269\n\n\n\n\n             3.     Utilization Increases Driving Up ModivCare\u2019s NEMT Expenses\n\n128. Beginning in 2Q2021, as the COVID-19 restrictions eased and payors\u2019 customers\n   resumed in-person health care appointments, the Company experienced increasing\n   utilization rates and anticipated further increases. For instance, during the 2022\n   Investor Day, Defendant Sampson disclosed that monthly utilization was 7.6% in 2021\n   but remained below pre-pandemic levels, which neared 13% in 2019. Going forward\n   in 2022 and 2023, the Company expected utilization to increase from 7.6% to\n   approximately 9-10%.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 128 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s June 23,\n\n2022 Investor Day call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete\n\nrecording from that call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 128.\n\n129. As a result of the increased utilization, ModivCare\u2019s profits began to shrink. For\n   instance, CW2 stated that, as the pandemic waned and members began using\n   transportation services again, ModivCare\u2019s profits slimmed.\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 129 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 129.\n\n130. CW1 also recalled hearing that ModivCare\u2019s profits were declining because payors\u2019\n   members were using ModivCare\u2019s NEMT services more as the pandemic waned and\n   as payors encouraged their members to use the NEMT services. CW1 explained that\n   member utilization was growing each year but the Company\u2019s ability to provide\n   efficient, cost-effective transportation services significantly declined due to constant\n   senior leadership turnover, mass layoffs every three months to meet quarterly\n   earnings, and actions by senior leadership that were detrimental to operational\n   performance. CW1 added that the constant loss of people with NEMT expertise,\n   structural operational changes, and poor operational performance led to a loss of\n   payor confidence which led to fewer contracts each year.\n\n\n\n\n                                           71\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 72 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 130 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 130.\n\n131. CW1 further explained that, during CW1\u2019s last year with ModivCare, everyone was\n   \u201ctrying to figure out how to manage\u201d members\u2019 increased NEMT utilization. CW1\n   added that utilization was a constant topic of discussion because it was \u201cthrowing off\n   the KPIs,\u201d including cost per trip, service level agreements, and member satisfaction\n   KPIs. According to CW1, when member utilization was on the increase, ModivCare\n   \u201cbecame upside-down\u201d on their contracting.\n       ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 131 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 131.\n\n132. CW1 recalled that, around the first quarter of 2022, ModivCare began introducing\n   initiatives to have members use other transportation modes, such as using public\n   transportation, using ride-share, or relying on family members and friends. CW1\n   explained that then-Vice President of Transportation Insights and Strategy Ross\n   Peterson was responsible for and introduced goals to reduce ModivCare\u2019s\n   transportation costs through these initiatives. According to CW1, ModivCare tracked\n   these initiatives \u201cto the nth degree.\u201d CW1 confirmed that Sampson had access to the\n   data related to these initiatives through an application.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 132 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n\n\n\n                                             72\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79      filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 73 of 269\n\n\n\n\n132 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 132.\n\n133. In line with this, Sampson publicly assured the market that ModivCare\u2019s cost\n   savings initiatives would offset the increased utilization and the increased costs of\n   inflation and driver wage pressure. For instance, during the earnings call for the\n   second quarter of 2022 on August 4, 2022 (the \u201c2Q2022 Earnings Call\u201d), Defendant\n   Sampson explained that ModivCare\u2019s multi-modal strategies\u2014initiatives to have\n   payor\u2019s customers use mass transit, receive mileage reimbursement for transport\n   provided by family or friends, or use ride-sharing services\u2014would temper the impacts\n   of utilization, wage pressure, and inflation, stating in relevant part:\n      And really, for the last 3 quarters, consistent with everything that\u2019s\n      happening across the globe, and specifically even in the U.S., there has\n      been the inflation and wage pressures. And you see that in our stats. Likely,\n      we\u2019re hitting the peak on the wage, the wage pressures in there and then\n      the initiatives that we have, primarily that are in our multimodal strategies.\n      Those will take hold and hopefully bring those down. We expect in the\n      numbers that we\u2019ve given and the guidance we\u2019ve given, we don\u2019t expect\n      material decrease in that for the rest of the year. So very comfortable with\n      the guidance we\u2019ve given on that side. And then utilization, we expect that\n      nominal uptick to continue for the rest of this year.\n\n      So long story short, basically, the margins are relatively consistent for Q3\n      and Q4. The changes that will come in utilization, which will continue\n      to happen will be offset by these strategies that were articulated on\n      the mobility side, again, primarily the multimodal, but also the\n      partnership model that really ensures that our transportation\n      providers are making the right level of money, getting the consistent\n      volume. And then we ourselves will ensure that we get the right quality at\n      a lower price. So all those together, we feel really confident in our ability\n      to offset any increases in utilization that we expect over the couple of\n      years.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 133 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\n\n\n\n                                           73\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS           Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 74 of 269\n\n\n\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 133\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s August 4, 2022 earnings call, and Defendants\n\nrespectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that call, which speaks for itself,\n\nand deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 133.\n\n134. CW1 explained that the initiatives to decrease utilization by encouraging members\n   to use public transportation, use ride-share, or rely on family members were unrealistic.\n   Indeed, according to CW1, members disliked these initiatives. As such, according to\n   CW1, these initiatives \u201cfared very poorly\u201d and the cost savings that the Company\n   forecasted to achieve through these initiatives \u201cnever really transpired.\u201d CW1 added\n   that the Company also fell far short of achieving the metrics associated with the\n   initiatives to reduce ModivCare\u2019s transportation costs, including reducing utilization\n   overall, reducing ride share utilization, increasing use of public transportation, and\n   increasing reliance on members\u2019 friends/family members.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 134 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n134 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 134.\n\n135. Likewise, CW3 explained that some customers reported that that multi- modal trips\n   were generally more expensive. For instance, according to CW3, ModivCare relied\n   more on Uber Health and Lyft as Transport Network Companies (\u201cTNCs\u201d), which\n   increased costs per trip and particularly for interstate trips, such as those in between\n   New York and New Jersey, which could be $300 to $400 or more. CW3 added that\n   other cost- saving initiatives were not pursued because ModivCare was facing on-time\n\n\n                                              74\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 75 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   performance issues that led to cost overrides, meaning ModivCare would pay\n   transportation providers 2-3 times more for trip acceptance.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 135 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n135 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 135.\n\n136. Accordingly, as a result of the higher utilization rates and inability to reduce\n   transportation costs, ModivCare\u2019s NEMT service expense generally increased\n   throughout the Class Period. The Company\u2019s NEMT service expense consists of\n   purchased services as well as payroll and other service expenses. Purchased\n   services account for transportation costs for NEMT services and these costs are\n   affected by trip volumes, service levels, and contract rates. Payroll and other service\n   expenses include costs for ModivCare\u2019s contact center operations, customer\n   advocacy, and transportation network teams as well as facility overhead costs.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 136 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit that\n\nModivCare\u2019s NEMT service expense consists of purchased services and payroll and other\n\nservice expenses, and that purchased services reflect transportation costs that are\n\n\n\n\n                                             75\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 76 of 269\n\n\n\n\naffected by trip volumes, service levels, and contract rates. Except as expressly admitted,\n\nDefendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 136.\n\n137. As depicted below in Figure 4, NEMT service expense increased by over 10%\n   between 3Q2022 and 3Q2024. The increase was almost entirely driven by an increase\n   in purchased services during the same period of almost 13%.\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 137 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 137 and Figure\n\n4 characterize or quote from ModivCare\u2019s public statements and SEC filings, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recordings and documents, which\n\nspeak for themselves, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 137 and Figure 4.\n\n\n\n                                            76\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 77 of 269\n\n\n\n\n138. As indicated above, ModivCare largely correctly estimated the increase in\n   utilization and, by its own assurances, should have been able to offset some of the\n   costs through its initiatives or share the predicted increase in purchased services costs\n   with customers. Indeed, ModivCare\u2019s shift to capitated shared risk contracts should\n   have allowed the Company to protect and improve NEMT margins by sharing\n   increased costs from higher utilization with customers. However, despite that close\n   estimation, capitated shared risk contracts were not \u201cwin-win\u201d and did not improve\n   NEMT financial results because, as discussed more thoroughly below, ModivCare\u2019s\n   customers frequently disputed the increased costs that the Company sought through\n   the true-up process and delayed payments or refused to pay.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 138 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 138.\n\n139. As a result, in part due to higher service expense, utilization, and inability to offset\n   higher costs by shifting them to payors, throughout the Class Period, ModivCare\u2019s\n   NEMT margins decreased substantially. As illustrated by Figure 5, ModivCare\u2019s\n   NEMT adjusted EBITDA margin declined by around 28% between 3Q2022 and\n   3Q2024:\n\n\n\n\n                                             77\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79      filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 78 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 139 and Figure 5 characterize or quote from ModivCare\u2019s\n\npublic statements and SEC filings, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the\n\ncomplete recordings and documents, which speak for themselves, and deny any\n\nallegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 139 and Figure 5.\n\n140. Nevertheless, as a result of Defendants\u2019 Class Period misstatements, analysts\n   expected that ModivCare restructuring its contract mix would lead to less volatility. For\n   example, a January 3, 2023 report by Barrington Research indicated that \u201cModivCare\n   has made great efforts to restructure many of its NEMT contracts to smooth volatility\n   in operating results.\u201d An August 4, 2023 Jefferies report that discussed the Company\u2019s\n   second quarter 2023 (\u201c2Q2023\u201d) financial results included that \u201c[m]ost of MODV\u2019s\n   contracts are \u2018shared risk\u2019 deals that limit (but not eliminate) downside caused by\n   increased service utilization, so we believe we\u2019re now seeing the bottoming of MODV\u2019s\n   earnings/margins as the risk-sharing aspect of these contracts kicks in.\u201d\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 140 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the allegations concerning\n\n\n\n                                            78\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79     filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 79 of 269\n\n\n\n\nanalysts\u2019 expectations in Paragraph 140 and deny them on that basis. Paragraph 140\n\nalso characterizes or quotes from a Barrington Research analyst report dated January 3,\n\n2023 and a Jefferies analyst report dated August 4, 2023, and Defendants respectfully\n\nrefer the Court to the complete documents, which speak for themselves, and deny any\n\nallegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 140.\n\n             4.     Contrary to Defendants\u2019 Claims, ModivCare\u2019s Shared Risk\n                    Contracts Did Not Mitigate Financial Impacts or Create Payment\n                    Predictability\n\n141. Contrary to Defendants\u2019 assurances that ModivCare\u2019s shared risk contracts\n   allowed the Company to pass higher mobility costs including those related to\n   increased utilization through to payors, protected against downside risk to cash flow,\n   and provided financial predictability and stable rigid margins, CWs confirmed that\n   ModivCare\u2019s true-up process under the shared risk contracts caused disputes with\n   payors. As a result, payors frequently refused to pay for the higher costs, negotiated\n   settlements that were detrimental to ModivCare\u2019s financial position, and delayed\n   payments.\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 141 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 141.\n\n142. For instance, CW2 stated that, under the shared risk contracts, ModivCare\n   reconciled utilization in a true-up every six months and depending on the actual ride\n   volume, payors either owed the Company money or vice versa. CW2 added that the\n   true- up process caused regular disputes between ModivCare and payors because\n   the Company\u2019s internal utilization data and claims data did not match the payors\u2019\n   \u201cencounter data.\u201d Indeed, CW2 explained that ModivCare billed payors based on rides\n   provided by third-party drivers, but payors based their payments to the Company only\n   on the actual claims submitted by those providers, which frequently led to payment\n   disputes between ModivCare and payors.\n\n\n\n\n                                           79\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 80 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 142 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 142.\n\n143. CW2 provided an example, stating if ModivCare calculated utilization at 175% but\n   the encounter data only showed 150% utilization, then the payor would rely on the\n   encounter data as authoritative and would refuse to pay the Company\u2019s higher figures.\n   CW2 added that the utilization discrepancy could result in PMPM rates fluctuating $3\n   or more and would be multiplied across large membership populations.\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 143 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 143.\n\n144. CW2 explained that ModivCare wanted payors to pay the Company for authorized\n   rides in real time but, because ModivCare\u2019s service providers had 120 days to submit\n   claims and sometimes submitted those claims late, payors disagreed with paying in\n   real time and would only reimburse paid authorizations. This, according to CW2,\n   created a persistent timing and data mismatch. As a result, according to CW2, payors\n   contended that they owed ModivCare far less than the Company claimed.\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 144 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 144.\n\n145. CW2 also stated that ModivCare\u2019s payor payment disputes often forced the\n   Company to expend considerable effort to chase contracts receivables and ended in\n   a settlement where the Company accepted partial payment. For instance, CW2\n   explained that ModivCare would tell a payor: \u201cPay me $50 million, and we\u2019ll write off\n   the other $10 million.\u201d\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 145 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 145.\n\n\n\n                                          80\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 81 of 269\n\n\n\n\n146. CW2 also stated that, beginning around 2Q2022 and continuing throughout CW2\u2019s\n   tenure, ModivCare\u2019s failure to provide accurate encounter data (along with the\n   Company\u2019s poor operational performance) led to payor dissatisfaction and monthly\n   liquidated damages of hundreds of thousands of dollars for rejected encounters.\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 146 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 146.\n\n147. CW2 further stated that ModivCare\u2019s payors paid on a monthly basis but\n   sometimes those payments were late. For instance, CW2 explained that if a payor\n   believed that ModivCare owed it money as a result of the true-up process, then that\n   payor might withhold its monthly payments to offset the balance that ModivCare owed\n   to the payor. According to CW2, ModivCare would tell payors that they needed to\n   continue making their monthly payments even while disputing the true-ups because\n   the true-up balances could later change but payors refused. CW2 confirmed that these\n   disputes dragged on for \u201ca very long time.\u201d\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 147 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 147.\n\n148. Corroborating CW2, CW3 stated that ModivCare faced significant disputes over\n   risk corridors and profits. CW3 added that ModivCare experienced payor collectability\n   issues under Sampson due to the Company charging more for trips despite service\n   and technological shortcomings. CW3 confirmed that payors grew dissatisfied and\n   sought to renegotiate with ModivCare and pushed for increased clarity regarding trip\n   costs and for the Company to fulfill promised capabilities.\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 148 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 148.\n\n149. For instance, CW3 explained that complaints about the shared risk contracts\n   resulted in payors refusing to pay for trips, delayed payments from UnitedHealthcare\n   (\u201cUHC\u201d) and New Jersey, and some states capping profits. For example, CW3 stated\n\n\n                                          81\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 82 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   that UHC demanded repayment or repricing, but ModivCare care resisted, expecting\n   UHC to comply due to the size of the ModivCare organization. However, according to\n   CW3, this dispute caused ModivCare to lose to a $100 million contract loss in 2023.\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 149 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 149.\n\n150. Likewise, CW3 stated that ModivCare had a dispute with its New Jersey payors,\n   one of the Company\u2019s largest contracts, because the Company reinvested\n   repayments into transportation providers to manage profit risks rather than pay those\n   funds back to the payor. According to CW3, New Jersey reported that ModivCare\n   performed outside the profit cap, and they sought to recoup the funds from the\n   Company. According to CW3, such disputes were on both Sampson and Shephard\u2019s\n   radar.\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 150 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 150.\n\n151. CW3 added that, in New Jersey and Virginia, there were instances where\n   ModivCare was required to return a portion of profits to the state, but due to prior\n   spending, the Company was unable to repay these funds on time and delayed\n   payment.\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 151 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 151.\n\n152. CW2 also participated in calls with Shepard between March and May of 2023\n   where payor disputes had escalated to a point where the payor requested Shepard\u2019s\n   involvement. CW2 confirmed that these negotiation calls were ongoing conversations\n   that occurred weekly throughout 2023.\n\n\n\n\n                                          82\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 83 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 152 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 152.\n\n153. CW2 provided an example where a Florida-based customer, Sunshine Health,\n   withheld payments for an extended period of time, leading to a $60 million receivable\n   dispute. CW2 first learned about ModivCare\u2019s dispute with Sunshine Health in October\n   2023 when the Company\u2019s Florida market leadership, including the Vice President\n   and Senior Director for that region, discussed Sunshine Health\u2019s refusal to pay with\n   CW2. CW2 confirmed that ModivCare\u2019s receivables balance was large and\n   unresolved in October 2023. CW2 stated that ModivCare\u2019s dispute with Sunshine\n   Health ultimately became public and caused the Company\u2019s stock price to decline\n   approximately 30%.\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 153 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 153.\n\n154. CW2 learned about the true-up dispute settlements from leadership because some\n   of the disputed accounts were CW2\u2019s customers. CW2 also learned about the\n   settlements through conversations with peers responsible for other regions and in\n   Monthly Leadership Meetings attended by Market Leaders, Regional VPs, the\n   Underwriting Department, and Financial Planning, some of whom directly reported to\n   Defendant Shepard. CW2 stated that encounter data rejected by payors was\n   frequently discussed during Monthly Leadership Meetings. CW2 also explained that\n   receivable disputes were a standing agenda item during Monthly Leadership Meetings\n   and included regular updates such as, \u201cHealth plan X is only paying us Y, or 30% of\n   what\u2019s owed.\u201d CW2 added that the receivable disputes were \u201cdefinitely a hot topic\u201d\n   that occurred \u201cmonth after month\u201d at every monthly meeting between 2023 and 2024.\n   CW2 confirmed that ModivCare delayed recognition of receivables until settlements\n   were reached because the negotiations were protracted and outcomes uncertain.\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 154 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 154.\n\n\n                                          83\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79     filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 84 of 269\n\n\n\n\n             5.     ModivCare\u2019s Contract Payables and Contract Receivables\n                    Balances Fluctuate Dramatically Quarter-to-Quarter and Cash\n                    Plummets\n\n155. Despite Defendants\u2019 assurances that the shared risk contracts would result in\n   greater predictability and stability, the Company\u2019s contract payables and contract\n   receivables balances fluctuated significantly throughout the Class Period. For\n   instance, as illustrated in Figure 6, ModivCare\u2019s total contract payables decreased by\n   14.8%, on average, between 2Q2022 and 3Q2024. Over the same period, the\n   Company\u2019s total reconciliation contract receivables increased 17%, on average, as\n   indicated by Figure 7.\n\n\n\n\n                                           84\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79     filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 85 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 155 and Figures 6 and 7 characterize or quote from\n\nModivCare\u2019s public statements or other SEC filings, and Defendants respectfully refer the\n\nCourt to the complete recordings or documents, which speak for themselves, and deny\n\nany allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 155 and Figures 6 and 7.\n\n156. Although Defendants\u2019 claimed that ModivCare\u2019s cash flow would become more\n   normalized and predictable through the shared risk contracts after the Company\n   completed its COVID-19 payments, contracts payables and contracts receivables\n   continued to fluctuate significantly as did the timing of when the Company paid and\n   received payments from payors, all of which contributed to ModivCare\u2019s cash flow\n   crunch. For instance, the Company\u2019s contracts receivables balance increased each\n   quarter during the Class Period (except in 3Q2024) (see Figure 7 supra) as a result\n   of the Company\u2019s inability to collect payments from its customers. On the other hand,\n   ModivCare\u2019s contract payables balance decreased each quarter during the Class\n   Period (except for 3Q2023 and 1Q2024) (see Figure 6 supra), indicating the\n   Company was paying its customers the cash owed from true-ups under their shared\n   risk contracts.\n\n\n                                           85\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 86 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 156 and Figures 6 and 7 characterize or quote from\n\nModivCare\u2019s public statements and SEC filings, and Defendants respectfully refer the\n\nCourt to the complete recordings or documents, which speak for themselves, and deny\n\nany allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny that any alleged\n\nstatement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to one\n\ndefendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 156 and Figures 6 and 7.\n\n157. This combination of increasing contract receivables and decreasing contract\n   payables created a cash flow nightmare. As evidenced by Figure 8, ModivCare had\n   a precipitous decline in cash and cash equivalents during the Class Period that never\n   recovered. Similarly, ModivCare\u2019s free cash flow (i.e., the Company\u2019s cash flow from\n   operations less applicable capital expenditures included in purchase of property and\n   equipment) also declined and never stabilized, as illustrated by Figure 9.\n\n\n\n\n                                          86\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 87 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 157 and Figures 8 and 9 characterize or quote from\n\nModivCare\u2019s public statements and SEC filings, and Defendants respectfully refer the\n\nCourt to the complete recordings or documents, which speak for themselves, and deny\n\nany allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 157 and Figures 8 and 9.\n\n158. As a result of ModivCare\u2019s inability to manage its cash flow from NEMT contracts,\n   the Company had to pursue less favorable avenues to obtain cash. For example,\n   ModivCare amended credit agreements to access additional financing during the\n   Class Period. Around August 2024, according to a report published by J.P. Morgan\n   on August 9, 2024, the Company also \u201cfactored\u201d or, sold, the right to collect some of\n   its receivables to another party at a discount as a result of \u201cthe [Company\u2019s] possible\n   risks/delays to realizing its contract assets or facing any contract payable\n   accelerations[.]\u201d Factoring is used by companies to obtain cash, rather than waiting to\n   collect payment from customers.8\n\n\n8\n [Footnote 8 in Complaint] \u201cFactoring can help companies improve their short-term cash\nneeds by selling their receivables in return for an injection of cash from the factoring\ncompany.\u201d See Factor Definition: Requirements, Benefits, and Example, Investopedia\n\n                                           87\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 88 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare amended certain credit agreements\n\nduring the alleged Class Period. Paragraph 158 characterizes or quotes from\n\nModivCare\u2019s credit agreements and a J.P. Morgan analyst report dated August 9, 2024,\n\nand Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete documents, which speak for\n\nthemselves, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly\n\nadmitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 158 and footnote 8.\n\nV.    DEFENDANTS MADE MATERIALLY FALSE AND MISLEADING STATEMENTS\n      AND OMISSIONS THROUGHOUT THE CLASS PERIOD AND GRADUALLY\n      REVEALED THE TRUTH THROUGH MULTIPLE PARTIAL DISCLOSURES\n\n159. Throughout the Class Period, Defendants made materially misleading statements\n   and omissions relating to ModivCare\u2019s NEMT shared risk contracts, service offerings,\n   and multi-modal initiatives. These material misstatements and omissions created a\n   false impression that: (i) ModivCare\u2019s shared risk contracts were structured to create\n   a \u201cwin-win\u201d for the Company and its customers, including by allowing ModivCare to\n   pass increased costs through to ModivCare\u2019s NEMT customers; (ii) ModivCare\u2019s\n   shared risk contracts would protect against downside risk and volatility in costs and\n   utilization, achieve long-term margin objectives, normalize its contracts payables, free\n   cash flow, or working capital, and thereby create more predictable cash flow; (iii)\n   ModivCare was providing high quality care or services to its members in a cost-\n   effective manner through its NEMT offerings; and (iv) ModivCare\u2019s multi-modal\n   initiative was working to improve member experience and to reduce transportation\n   costs.\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 159 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\n\n\n\n(Jan. 25, 2025), https://www.investopedia.com/terms/f/factor.asp (last accessed Jan. 9,\n2026).\n\n\n                                            88\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79     filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 89 of 269\n\n\n\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 159 states legal\n\nconclusions to which no response from Defendants is required. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 159.\n\n160. All the statements that Plaintiffs allege are false and/or misleading are bolded and\n   underlined (example) within this Section (V). All other statements are included for\n   context.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 160 does not contain any factual allegations requiring a\n\nresponse.\n\n      A.     ModivCare\u2019s 3Q2022 Earnings Call on November 3, 2022\n\n161. On November 3, 2022, ModivCare held an earnings call at 8:00 a.m. E.T., before\n   the stock market opened for trading, wherein Defendant Sampson reported on the\n   Company\u2019s financial and operational results for its third quarter ended September 30,\n   2022 (\u201c3Q2022 Earnings Call\u201d).\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 161 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit that\n\nModivCare held an earnings call on November 3, 2022 for its third quarter 2022 earnings\n\nresults and Mr. Sampson participated in that call. Paragraph 161 characterizes or quotes\n\nfrom ModivCare\u2019s November 3, 2022 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the\n\nCourt to the complete recording from that call, which speaks for itself, and deny any\n\nallegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 161.\n\n\n\n\n                                           89\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 90 of 269\n\n\n\n\n162. During his prepared remarks on the 3Q2022 Earnings Call, Defendant Sampson\n   touted ModivCare\u2019s ability to pass on increased transportation costs to its customers\n   under its shared risk capitated contracts, which he claimed reduced fluctuations\n   between PMPM revenue recognition and costs and enabled the Company to achieve\n   its long-term NEMT margins:\n      The macro environment remains capricious, primarily due to inflation and\n      the labor market. That said, we have received favorable reimbursement\n      rates for our personal care business, which has helped with caregiver\n      recruitment and retention. And we have been able to pass through\n      higher transportation costs in our mobility business.\n\n      ...\n\n      I\u2019ll now provide some operational highlights for our business segments,\n      starting with Mobility or NEMT segment. During the third quarter, strong\n      NEMT revenue was driven by increased trip growth as membership grew to\n      approximately 36 million members. Although we continue to experience\n      higher transportation cost per trip due to driver shortages and higher fuel\n      prices, we\u2019ve been able to contractually share these costs with many\n      of our customers.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 162 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 162\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s November 3, 2022 earnings call, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that earnings call,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 162.\n\n163. Defendant Sampson further reiterated that Defendants were pleased with\n   ModivCare\u2019s ability to recoup increased costs under its shared risk contracts, stating\n   in relevant part: \u201cWhile we continue to experience transportation cost pressures, we\n\n\n\n                                           90\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 91 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   are pleased with our recovery of the costs through contractual pass-through\n   and contract repricing.\u201d\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 163 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 163\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s November 3, 2022 earnings call, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that earnings call,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 163.\n\n164. During the question and answer portion of the 3Q2022 Earnings Call, in response\n   to an analyst\u2019s question seeking clarity on what the Company was seeing with respect\n   to \u201creimbursement related to fuel costs and labor issues on the Mobility business[,]\u201d\n   Sampson represented that the Company\u2019s shared risk capitated contracts were \u201cwin-\n   win[,]\u201d stating in relevant part:\n      On the transportation side, as you know, most of our -- 85% of our contracts\n      are capitated. So there\u2019s really no kind of reimbursement change in the\n      NEMT side. It is really about how we manage through that. In addition, and\n      this is also something we\u2019ve done over the last 12 to 18 months, is ensuring\n      our contracts have been structured so we have a win-win, and able to\n      share in these increased costs that are currently happening primarily\n      in the transportation with the driver. So that\u2019s been beneficial to us.\n      So those costs have come up that our transportation providers\n      actually have to bear.\n\n      At the same time, we want to make sure that they are making money, and\n      most importantly, ensuring that we are picking people up on time and having\n      a great member experience because that is the most important thing for our\n      customers. And therefore, because of our contracts, we\u2019re able to pass\n      those through to a lot of our customers as well, or call it share in those\n      costs. So that\u2019s the differences between what\u2019s happening on the\n      reimbursement rate on the personal care side, specifically in the home\n\n\n                                           91\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 92 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      business. And then the higher cost in the mobility, we\u2019re able to pass a\n      large chunk of those through based on the way we\u2019ve developed our\n      contracts.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 164 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 164\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s November 3, 2022 earnings call, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that earnings call,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants lack\n\nknowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the allegations\n\nregarding the purpose of the unidentified analyst\u2019s question in Paragraph 164 and deny\n\nthem on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 164.\n\n165. During the same call, another analyst pressed Defendant Sampson for additional\n   details regarding contract repricing and whether such actions were related to declining\n   contracts, to which he responded:\n      How much was declining? So our contracts have not been declining. What\n      the point of the contract discussion was to show that we have been, over\n      the last 18 months, renegotiating contracts to ensure that they are a\n      win-win, and in essence, protecting the downside in the event that\n      there\u2019s some volatility in costs or utilization. So our contracts are\n      working, which is why I feel really good about the margins that we\n      have been articulating. That was the whole point of the contract discussion,\n      to ensure that we\u2019re doing the right stuff and our numbers have rigid\n      earnings as opposed to maybe the volatility that was -- that happened pre-\n      COVID.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 165 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n\n                                           92\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79     filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 93 of 269\n\n\n\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 165\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s November 3, 2022 earnings call, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that call, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 165.\n\n166. The statements identified in \u00b6\u00b6162-165 above were each materially false and\n   misleading, lacked any reasonable basis and/or omitted material facts necessary to\n   make the statements therein not false or misleading when made because ModivCare\u2019s\n   shared risk capitated contracts were not \u201cwin-win\u201d and the Company was not passing\n   increased costs through to ModivCare\u2019s NEMT customers such that it was able to\n   mitigate fluctuations in membership and costs and protect against downside risk and\n   volatility in costs and utilization. Nor did Defendant Sampson have a reasonable basis\n   to be pleased with ModivCare\u2019s purported ability to recover costs through pass-\n   through provisions or the margins that the Company was articulating.\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 166 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 166 states legal\n\nconclusions to which no response from Defendants is required. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 166.\n\n167. The material falsity of Defendant Sampson\u2019s statements is supported by evidence.\n   CW2 confirmed, for example, that ModivCare\u2019s true-up process for the shared risk\n   contracts caused regular disputes with payors that dragged on for \u201ca very long time\u201d\n   because the Company billed payors based on internal projections of utilization and\n\n\n                                           93\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79      filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 94 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   claims data that did not match the payors\u2019 \u201cencounter data\u201d (i.e., actual claims). As a\n   result, CW2 confirmed ModivCare often was forced to expend considerable efforts to\n   chase contract receivables, subjected to monthly liquidated damages of hundreds of\n   thousands of dollars, and/or forced to accept partial payment as a settlement for true-\n   up disputes with payors. Further, CW2 confirmed that in other instances payors would\n   withhold monthly payments that ModivCare was expecting to offset the balance that\n   ModivCare owed to the payor by ModivCare as a result of the true-up process.\n   Corroborating CW2, CW3 stated ModivCare experienced significant disputes over risk\n   corridors and profits, and collectability issues related to the Company charging more\n   for trips despite service and technological shortcomings. CW3 explained that\n   complaints about the shared risk contracts resulted in payors refusing to pay for trips,\n   delayed payments, states capping profits, and lost contracts.\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 167 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 167 contains a\n\nlegal conclusion to which no response from Defendants is required. Defendants further\n\nlack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW\n\nallegations in Paragraph 167 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny\n\nthe allegations in Paragraph 167.\n\n      B.     ModivCare\u2019s 3Q2022 Form 10-Q on November 8, 2022\n\n168. On November 8, 2022, before the stock market opened for trading that day,\n   ModivCare filed with the SEC a Form 10-Q to report on the Company\u2019s financial and\n   operational results for its third quarter ended September 30, 2022 (the \u201c3Q2022 Form\n   10- Q\u201d), which was signed by Defendant Sampson.\n\n\n\n\n                                           94\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 95 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare filed its Q3 FY2022 Form 10-Q with\n\nthe SEC on November 8, 2022, and that Mr. Sampson signed the Form 10-Q. Except as\n\nexpressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 168.\n\n169. The 3Q2022 Form 10-Q also contained a section titled \u201cRisk Factors\u201d wherein the\n   Company represented that the risk factors enumerated in ModivCare\u2019s FY2021 Form\n   10-K, which was filed with the SEC on March 1, 2023, to report on the Company\u2019s\n   financial and operational results for its fourth quarter ended December 31, 2021 (the\n   \u201cFY2021 Form 10-K\u201d), \u201cremain[ed] current in all material respects\u201d and affirmed that\n   \u201cthere have been no material changes from the risk factors disclosed in the Annual\n   Report[,]\u201d stating in relevant part:\n       The risks described under the caption \u201cRisk Factors\u201d in our Annual Report\n       on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2021 (the \u201cAnnual Report\u201d)\n       could materially and adversely affect our business, financial condition, and\n       results of operations, and could cause the trading price of our common\n       stock to decline. The discussion of the risks included under that caption\n       in our Annual Report remains current in all material respects, and\n       there have been no material changes from the risk factors disclosed\n       in the Annual Report. The risk factors that we have discussed do not\n       identify all risks that we face; our operations could also be affected by\n       factors that are not presently known to us or that we currently consider to\n       be immaterial to our operations. Due to risks and uncertainties, known and\n       unknown, our past financial results may not be a reliable indicator of future\n       performance and historical trends should not be used to anticipate results\n       or trends in future periods.\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare filed its FY2021 Form 10-K with the\n\nSEC on March 1, 2022. Paragraph 169 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s\n\nNovember 8, 2022 Form 10-Q, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the\n\ncomplete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph\n\n169.\n\n\n\n\n                                            95\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 96 of 269\n\n\n\n\n170. ModivCare\u2019s FY2021 Form 10-K, which as a result of the statements in the 3Q2022\n   Form 10-Q referenced in \u00b6169, supra., incorporated by reference the following\n   purported risks, including in relevant part:\n      The implementation of alternative payment models and the transition of\n      Medicaid and Medicare beneficiaries to MCOs may limit our market share\n      and could adversely affect our revenues.\n\n      ...\n\n      We may be similarly impacted by increased enrollment of Medicare and\n      Medicaid beneficiaries in managed care plans, shifting away from traditional\n      fee-for-service models.\n\n      ...\n\n      Difficulties with operational processes may negatively affect our revenue\n      growth rates, cash flow and profitability for services provided. Other\n      alternative payment models, such as value-based billing, capitated rates\n      and per member per month pricing, may be required by the government,\n      MCOs and other commercial payors to control their costs while shifting\n      financial risk to us, which could also materially affect our operations and\n      financial condition.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 170 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s FY2021\n\nForm 10-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 170.\n\n171. Another risk factor in ModivCare\u2019s FY2021 Form 10-K discussed changes to the\n   Company\u2019s ability to timely collect from payors, stating in relevant part:\n      Future cost containment initiatives undertaken by private third-party payors\n      may limit our future revenue and profitability.\n\n      Our commercial payor and managed Medicaid revenue and profitability are\n      affected by continuing efforts of third-party payors to maintain or reduce\n      costs of healthcare by lowering payment rates, narrowing the scope and\n      utilization of covered services, increasing case management review of\n      services and negotiating pricing. There can be no assurance that third-\n      party payors will make timely payments for our services, and there is\n      no assurance that we will continue to maintain our current payor or revenue\n\n\n                                          96\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 97 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      mix. We will continue our efforts to develop our commercial payor and\n      managed Medicaid sources of revenue and any changes in payment\n      levels from current or future third-party payors could have a material\n      adverse effect on our business and consolidated financial condition,\n      results of operations and cash flows.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 171 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s FY2021\n\nForm 10-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 171.\n\n172. ModivCare\u2019s FY2021 Form 10-K also included a risk factor that discussed the\n   Company\u2019s ability to time collect its accounts receivable related to NEMT, which stated:\n      Delays in collection, or non-collection, of our accounts receivable,\n      particularly during any business integration process, could adversely\n      affect our business, financial position, results of operations and\n      liquidity.\n\n      Prompt billing and collection are important factors in our liquidity. Billing and\n      collection of our accounts receivable are subject to the complex regulations\n      that govern Medicare and Medicaid reimbursement and rules imposed by\n      nongovernment payors. Our inability to bill and collect on a timely basis\n      pursuant to these regulations and rules could subject us to payment delays\n      that could have a material adverse effect on our business, financial position,\n      results of operations and liquidity. It is possible that documentation\n      support, system problems, Medicare, Medicaid or other payor issues,\n      particularly in markets transitioning to managed care for the first time, or\n      industry trends may extend our collection period, which may materially\n      adversely affect our working capital, and our working capital management\n      procedures may not successfully mitigate this risk.\n\n      ...\n\n      In addition, we may experience delays in reimbursement as a result of the\n      failure to receive prompt approvals related to change of ownership\n      applications for acquired or other facilities or from delays caused by our or\n      other third parties\u2019 information system failures. We may also experience\n      delayed payment of reimbursement rate increases that are subject to the\n      approval of the CMS and/or various state agencies before claims can be\n      submitted or paid at the new rates. Any delays experienced for the\n\n\n\n                                             97\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 98 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      foregoing or other reasons could have a material adverse effect on our\n      business, results of operations and financial condition.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 172 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s FY2021\n\nForm 10-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 172.\n\n173. ModivCare\u2019s FY2021 Form 10-K included a risk factor that discussed utilization,\n   which stated:\n      If we fail to estimate accurately the cost of performing certain\n      contracts, we may experience reduced or negative margins and our\n      results of operations could be materially adversely affected.\n\n      ...\n\n      If the utilization of our services is more than we estimated, the contract\n      may be less profitable than anticipated, or may not be profitable at all.\n\n      ...\n\n      Revenue under certain contracts may be adjusted prospectively if client\n      volumes are below expectations. If we are unable to adjust our costs\n      accordingly, our profitability may be negatively affected. In addition,\n      certain contracts with state Medicaid agencies are renewable or extended\n      at the state\u2019s option without an adjustment to pricing terms. If such renewed\n      contracts require us to incur higher costs, including inflation or regulatory\n      changes, than originally anticipated, our results of operations and financial\n      condition may be adversely affected.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 173 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s FY2021\n\nForm 10-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 173.\n\n174. The statements identified in \u00b6\u00b6169-173 above was materially false, and misleading\n   when made, because the risks included in the FY2021 Form 10-K had actualized and\n\n\n\n                                           98\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 99 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   therefore, \u201cmaterial changes\u201d had occurred. ModivCare and Defendant Sampson had\n   a duty to update the Company\u2019s risk factors in the 3Q2022 Form 10-Q to reflect those\n   material changes. Indeed, the FY2021 Form 10-K risk factors were posed as mere\n   hypotheticals, when those risk had actualized given that: (i) ModivCare\u2019s shift to\n   entering into more shared risk contracts was already negatively, materially impacting\n   the Company\u2019s operations and financial condition; (ii) ModivCare was experiencing\n   delays in payments and collecting its accounts receivable that were already extending\n   the Company\u2019s collection period and having a materially adverse impact on the\n   Company\u2019s business and consolidated financial condition; and (iii) ModivCare was\n   already experiencing an inability to adjust costs under its shared risk contracts,\n   utilization increases, and increased costs that were having a materially adverse impact\n   on the Company\u2019s results of operations and profitability.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 174 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 174.\n\n175. The material falsity of Defendant Sampson\u2019s statements is supported by evidence.\n   CW2 confirmed, for example, that ModivCare\u2019s true-up process for the shared risk\n   contracts caused regular disputes with payors that dragged on for \u201ca very long time\u201d\n   because the Company billed payors based on internal projections of utilization and\n   claims data that did not match the payors\u2019 \u201cencounter data\u201d (i.e., actual claims). As a\n   result, CW2 confirmed ModivCare often was forced to expend considerable efforts to\n   chase contract receivables, subjected to monthly liquidated damages of hundreds of\n   thousands of dollars, and/or forced to accept partial payment as a settlement for true-\n   up disputes with payors. Further, CW2 confirmed that in other instances payors would\n   withhold monthly payments that ModivCare was expecting to offset the balance that\n   ModivCare owed to the payor by ModivCare as a result of the true-up process.\n   Corroborating CW2, CW3 stated ModivCare experienced significant disputes over risk\n   corridors and profits, and collectability issues related to the Company charging more\n   for trips despite service and technological shortcomings. CW3 explained that\n   complaints about the shared risk contracts resulted in payors refusing to pay for trips,\n   delayed payments, states capping profits, and lost contracts.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 175 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\n\n\n                                            99\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 100 of 269\n\n\n\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n175 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 175.\n\n       C.     ModivCare\u2019s FY2022 Form 10-K on March 7, 2023\n\n176. On March 7, 2023, before the stock market opened for trading that day, ModivCare\n   filed its Form 10-K with the SEC to report on the Company\u2019s financial and operational\n   results for its fourth quarter ended December 31, 2022 (the \u201cFY2022 Form 10-K\u201d).9\n   The FY2022 10-K was signed by Sampson.\n       ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare filed its FY2022 Form 10-K with the\n\nSEC on March 7, 2023, and that Mr. Sampson signed the FY2022 Form 10-K. Except as\n\nexpressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 176 and footnote 9.\n\n177. ModivCare\u2019s FY2022 Form 10-K contained a section describing risk factors that\n   \u201ccould materially and adversely affect [ModivCare\u2019s] business, financial condition and\n   results of operations.\u201d One such risk factor discussed fee models that were alternative\n   to FFS, stating in relevant part:\n       The implementation of alternative payment models and the transition of\n       Medicaid and Medicare beneficiaries to MCOs may limit our market share\n       and could adversely affect our revenues.\n\n       ...\n\n       We may be similarly impacted by increased enrollment of Medicare and\n       Medicaid beneficiaries in managed care plans, shifting away from traditional\n       fee-for-service models.\n\n       ...\n\n       Difficulties with operational processes may negatively affect our revenue\n       growth rates, cash flow and profitability for services provided. Other\n       alternative payment models, such as value-based billing, capitated rates\n\n9\n [Footnote 9 in Complaint] According to ModivCare\u2019s Form 12b-25 Notification of Late\nFiling filed with the SEC on March 2, 2023, the FY2022 10-K was filed late due to\nCompany\u2019s expectation that it would report material weaknesses related to its Information\nTechnology systems and the revenue and payroll processes in its business units.\n\n                                            100\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 101 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      and per member per month pricing may be required by the government,\n      MCOs and other commercial payors to control their costs while shifting\n      financial risk to us, which could also materially affect our operations and\n      financial condition.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 177 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s FY2022\n\nForm 10-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 177.\n\n178. Another risk factor in ModivCare\u2019s FY2022 Form 10-K discussed changes to the\n   Company\u2019s ability to timely collect from payors, stating in relevant part:\n      Future cost containment initiatives undertaken by private third-party payors,\n      especially if we are unable to maintain or reduce our cost of services below\n      rates set forth by payors, may limit our future revenue and profitability and\n      cause us to experience reduced or negative margins and our results of\n      operations could be materially adversely affected.\n\n      Our commercial payor and managed Medicaid revenue and profitability are\n      affected by continuing efforts of third-party payors to maintain or reduce\n      costs of healthcare by lowering payment rates, narrowing the scope and\n      utilization of covered services, increasing case management review of\n      services and negotiating pricing. There can be no assurance that third-\n      party payors will make timely payments for our services, and there is\n      no assurance that we will continue to maintain our current payor or revenue\n      mix. We will continue our efforts to develop our commercial payor and\n      managed Medicaid sources of revenue and any changes in payment\n      levels from current or future third-party payors could have a material\n      adverse effect on our business and consolidated financial condition,\n      results of operations and cash flows.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 178 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s FY2022\n\nForm 10-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 178.\n\n\n\n\n                                          101\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79        filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 102 of 269\n\n\n\n\n179. ModivCare\u2019s FY2022 Form 10-K also included a risk factors that discussed the\n   Company\u2019s ability to time collect its accounts receivable related to NEMT, which stated:\n      Delays in collection, or non-collection, of our accounts receivable,\n      particularly during any business integration process, could adversely\n      affect our business, financial position, results of operations and\n      liquidity.\n\n      Prompt billing and collection are important factors in our liquidity. Billing and\n      collection of our accounts receivable are subject to the complex regulations\n      that govern Medicare and Medicaid reimbursement and rules imposed by\n      nongovernment payors. Our inability to bill and collect on a timely basis\n      pursuant to these regulations and rules could subject us to payment delays\n      that could have a material adverse effect on our business, financial position,\n      results of operations and liquidity. It is possible that documentation\n      support, system problems, Medicare, Medicaid or other payor issues,\n      particularly in markets transitioning to managed care for the first time, or\n      industry trends may extend our collection period, which may materially\n      adversely affect our working capital, and our working capital management\n      procedures may not successfully mitigate this risk.\n\n      ...\n\n      In addition, we may experience delays in reimbursement as a result of the\n      failure to receive prompt approvals related to change of ownership\n      applications for acquired or other facilities or from delays caused by our or\n      other third parties\u2019 information system failures. We may also experience\n      delayed payment of reimbursement rate increases that are subject to the\n      approval of the CMS and/or various state agencies before claims can be\n      submitted or paid at the new rates. Any delays experienced for the\n      foregoing or other reasons could have a material adverse effect on our\n      business, results of operations and financial condition.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 179 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s FY2022\n\nForm 10-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 179.\n\n180. ModivCare\u2019s FY2022 Form 10-K included a risk factor that discussed utilization,\n   which stated:\n      If we fail to estimate accurately the cost of performing certain\n\n\n                                            102\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 103 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      contracts, we may experience reduced or negative margins and our\n      results of operations could be materially adversely affected.\n\n      ...\n\n      If the utilization of our services is more than we estimated, the contract\n      may be less profitable than anticipated, or may not be profitable at all.\n\n      ...\n\n      Revenue under certain contracts may be adjusted prospectively if client\n      volumes are below expectations. If we are unable to adjust our costs\n      accordingly, our profitability may be negatively affected. In addition,\n      certain contracts with state Medicaid agencies are renewable or extended\n      at the state\u2019s option without an adjustment to pricing terms. If such renewed\n      contracts require us to incur higher costs, including inflation or regulatory\n      changes, than originally anticipated, our results of operations and financial\n      condition may be adversely affected.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 180 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s FY2022\n\nForm 10-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 180.\n\n181. The statements identified in \u00b6\u00b6177-180 above each were materially false, and\n   misleading when made, because the risks included in the FY2022 Form 10-K were\n   posed as mere hypotheticals, when those risk had actualized given that: (i)\n   ModivCare\u2019s shift to entering into more shared risk contracts was already negatively,\n   materially impacting the Company\u2019s operations and financial condition; (ii) ModivCare\n   was experiencing delays in payments and collecting its accounts receivable that were\n   already extending the Company\u2019s collection period and were having a materially\n   adverse impact on the Company\u2019s business and consolidated financial condition; and\n   (iii) ModivCare was already experiencing an inability to adjust costs under its shared\n   risk contracts, utilization increases, and increased costs that were having a materially\n   adverse impact on the Company\u2019s results of operations and profitability.\n\n\n\n\n                                           103\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 104 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 181 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 181.\n\n182. The material falsity of Defendant Sampson\u2019s statements is supported by evidence.\n   CW2 confirmed, for example, that ModivCare\u2019s true-up process for the shared risk\n   contracts caused regular disputes with payors that dragged on for \u201ca very long time\u201d\n   because the Company billed payors based on internal projections of utilization and\n   claims data that did not match the payors\u2019 \u201cencounter data\u201d (i.e., actual claims). As a\n   result, CW2 confirmed ModivCare often was forced to expend considerable efforts to\n   chase contract receivables, subjected to monthly liquidated damages of hundreds of\n   thousands of dollars, and/or forced to accept partial payment as a settlement for true-\n   up disputes with payors. Beginning in 2023 and continuing throughout CW2\u2019s tenure,\n   CW2 confirmed that Monthly Leadership Meetings included regular updates \u201cmonth\n   after month\u201d regarding receivable dispute settlements that resulted in ModivCare\n   receiving a fraction of what was owed. Further, CW2 confirmed that in other instances\n   payors would withhold monthly payments that ModivCare was expecting to offset the\n   balance that ModivCare owed to the payor by ModivCare as a result of the true-up\n   process. Corroborating CW2, CW3 stated ModivCare experienced significant disputes\n   over risk corridors and profits, and collectability issues related to the Company\n   charging more for trips despite service and technological shortcomings. CW3\n   explained that complaints about the shared risk contracts resulted in payors refusing\n   to pay for trips, delayed payments, states capping profits, and lost contracts.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 182 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n182 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 182.\n\n       D.     ModivCare\u2019s 1Q2023 Form 10-Q on May 4, 2023\n\n183. On May 4, 2023, before the stock market opened for trading that day, ModivCare\n   filed with the SEC a Form 10-Q to report on the Company\u2019s financial and operational\n\n\n\n                                            104\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 105 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   results for its first quarter ended March 31, 2023 (the \u201c1Q2023 Form 10-Q\u201d), which\n   was signed by Defendant Sampson.\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare filed its Q1 FY2023 Form 10-Q with\n\nthe SEC on May 4, 2023, and that Mr. Sampson signed the Q1 FY2023 Form 10-Q.\n\nExcept as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 183.\n\n184. The 1Q2023 Form 10-Q contained a section titled \u201cRisk Factors\u201d wherein the\n   Company represented that the risk factors enumerated in the ModivCare\u2019s FY2022\n   Form 10-K \u201cremain[ed] current in all material respects\u201d and affirmed that \u201cthere have\n   been no material changes from the risk factors disclosed in the Annual Report[,]\u201d\n   stating in relevant part:\n      The risks described under the caption \u201cRisk Factors\u201d in our Annual Report\n      on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2022 (the \u201cAnnual Report\u201d)\n      could materially and adversely affect our business, financial condition, and\n      results of operations, and could cause the trading price of our common\n      stock to decline. The discussion of the risks included under that caption\n      in our Annual Report remains current in all material respects, and\n      there have been no material changes from the risk factors disclosed\n      in the Annual Report. The risk factors that we have discussed do not\n      identify all risks that we face; our operations could also be affected by\n      factors that are not presently known to us or that we currently consider to\n      be immaterial to our operations. Due to risks and uncertainties, known and\n      unknown, our past financial results may not be a reliable indicator of future\n      performance and historical trends should not be used to anticipate results\n      or trends in future periods.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 184 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s Q1 FY2023\n\nForm 10-Q, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 184.\n\n185. The statement identified in \u00b6184 above was materially false, and misleading when\n   made, because, for the reasons outlined in \u00b6\u00b6181-182 above, the risks included in the\n   FY2022 Form 10-K had actualized and therefore, material changes had occurred.\n   Defendant Sampson had a duty to update the Company\u2019s risk factors in the 1Q2023\n   Form 10-Q to reflect material changes to its risk factors.\n\n\n                                          105\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 106 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 185 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 185.\n\n      E.     Defendants Partially Disclosed the Truth on May 4, 2023 in\n             ModivCare\u2019s 1Q2023 Press Release and Earnings Call but Continue\n             Making False and Misleading Statements\n\n             1.     Defendants Partially Disclosed the Truth on May 4, 2023\n\n186. On May 4, 2023, before the stock market opened for trading, ModivCare published\n   a press release announcing the Company\u2019s financial results for the three months\n   ended March 31, 2023 on its website and concurrently filed it with the SEC on Form\n   8-K, signed by Defendant Sampson (\u201c1Q2023 Press Release\u201d). In the 1Q2023 Press\n   Release, ModivCare reported a net loss of $4.0 million, that the Company expended\n   approximately $2.7 million in cash for operating activities, and that the NEMT Adjusted\n   EBITDA margin decreased from 9.3% in 1Q2022 to 7.5% in 1Q2023.\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare issued a press release announcing\n\nits financial results for Q1 FY2023 on May 4, 2023, and filed a Form 8-K with the SEC\n\nthat was signed by Mr. Sampson. Paragraph 186 characterizes or quotes from\n\nModivCare\u2019s May 4, 2023 press release and Form 8-K, and Defendants respectfully refer\n\nthe Court to the complete documents, which speak for themselves, and deny any\n\nallegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 186.\n\n187. That same day, ModivCare also held an earnings call at 8:00 a.m. E.T., before the\n   market opened for trading, to report on the Company\u2019s financial and operational\n   results for its first quarter ended March 31, 2023 (\u201c1Q2023 Earnings Call\u201d), which\n   Defendants Sampson and Shepard participated in.\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare held an earnings call on May 4, 2023\n\nregarding Q1 FY2023, and that Mr. Sampson and Mr. Shepard participated in the May 4,\n\n\n\n                                           106\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 107 of 269\n\n\n\n\n2023 earnings call. Paragraph 187 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s May 4,\n\n2023 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording\n\nfrom that earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants further deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct,\n\ndocument, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another.\n\nExcept as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 187.\n\n188. Despite previous assurances that ModivCare\u2019s shared risk contracts represented\n   a \u201cwin-win\u201d for ModivCare and were allowing the Company to share in its costs with\n   customers, during the call, Defendant Shepard revealed that ModivCare used $3\n   million in cash related to a $7 million reduction in contract payables and incurred \u201c$31\n   million increase in contract receivables[,]\u201d stating in relevant part:\n      Turning to our cash flow and balance sheet. Consolidated cash-flow from\n      operations in the first quarter of 2023 was the use of approximately $3\n      million due to a $7 million reduction in contract payables and $31\n      million increase in contract receivables. Excluding these items, our cash\n      flow from operation would have been better in the first quarter by $38 million.\n      The increase in contract receivables, which represent under payments\n      and receivables on certain contracts with reconciliation or risk corridor\n      provisions was higher than our expectations in the first quarter.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 188 contains a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 188\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s May 4, 2023 earnings call, and Defendants\n\nrespectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that earnings call, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 188.\n\n189. Shepard\u2019s statements revealed that ModivCare\u2019s shared risk customers had paid\n   less than what the Company anticipated through the reconciliation or risk corridor\n   provisions. As such, Shepard\u2019s statements partially corrected the misimpression\n   created by Defendants\u2019 previous statements representing that ModivCare was\n\n\n                                           107\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 108 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   \u201ccontractually shar[ing]\u201d its \u201chigher transportation costs\u201d with its customers, that\n   Defendants were \u201cpleased with [their] recovery of the costs\u201d through the same, and\n   that the negative impacts to the Company\u2019s financials from the shared risk contracts,\n   and untimely payments and delayed collections were mere hypotheticals.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 189 contains a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 189\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s May 4, 2023 earnings call. Defendants\n\nrespectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that earnings call, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny\n\nthat any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly\n\nattributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 189.\n\n190. Nevertheless, Shepard\u2014speaking jointly on behalf of himself and Sampson\u2014\n   attempted to ally investor concerns by assuring that \u201cwe will be collecting on these\n   receivables later this year, which will contribute to stronger cash flow in the second\n   half of 2023.\u201d Indeed, with respect to contract payables, Shepard explained that\n   ModivCare had anticipated receiving a payment in 2Q2023 that would purportedly be\n   \u201cspread throughout the year[:]\u201d\n       Our contract payables, which primarily relate to overpayments and contract\n       liabilities on certain NEMT contracts were in line with expectations in Q1 at\n       a $7 million reduction. However, we have 1 large settlement during the\n       second quarter that we previously expected, will be spread throughout\n       the year. This will likely result in cash flow from operations in Q2 being\n       in a similar range as the first quarter. For all of 2023, we continue to\n       expect our contract payables and receivables will be much less impactful\n       compared to last year. However, our cash flow generation will be more\n       second half weighted due to these timing issues.\n\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 190 contains a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 190\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s May 4, 2023 earnings call. Defendants\n\n\n                                           108\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS           Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 109 of 269\n\n\n\n\nrespectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that call, which speaks for itself,\n\nand deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny that any alleged\n\nstatement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to one\n\ndefendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 190.\n\n191. Upon the news, ModivCare\u2019s stock price declined $11.30, or approximately 16%,\n   from $69.30 per share on May 3, 2023 to $58.00 per share on May 4, 2023.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 191 contains a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit and allege\n\nthat ModivCare\u2019s earnings and stock prices at various times are matters of public record\n\nand deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly admitted,\n\nDefendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 191.\n\n              2.     Defendants Continue Making False and Misleading Statements\n                     on May 4, 2023\n\n192. Still, Defendants Sampson and Shepard continued making false and misleading\n   statements in the 1Q2023 Press Release and during the 1Q2023 Earnings Call. For\n   instance, the 1Q2023 Press Release included a quote from Defendant Sampson,\n   stating:\n       Our offerings provide high quality care and services to our members\n       in a cost-effective manner, aligning with the evolving needs of the\n       healthcare landscape. Our focus for 2023 remains steadfast to build for\n       scale and grow our business. We are confident that the initiatives\n       implemented over the past few quarters will drive efficiencies and\n       operating leverage throughout the year.\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 192 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\n\n\n                                             109\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 110 of 269\n\n\n\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. Paragraph 192 contains a legal conclusion to which no response\n\nfrom Defendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 192\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s Q1 FY2023 press release or the May 4, 2023\n\nearnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document and\n\nearnings call recording, which speak for themselves, and deny any allegations\n\ninconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny that any alleged statement, knowledge,\n\nconduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to\n\nanother. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 192.\n\n193. Also, during his prepared remarks on the 1Q2023 Earnings Call, Defendant\n   Sampson, speaking jointly on behalf of himself and Shepard, emphasized the\n   purported benefits of the Company\u2019s multi-modal partnership model, stating in\n   relevant part:\n      Our multimodal partnership model is expected to drive lower\n      transportation cost per trip throughout the year as we narrow our\n      network of transportation providers and we continued to shift more trips\n      to our preferred providers matching the right type of ride with the\n      members needs.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 193 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 193 contains a\n\nlegal conclusion to which no response from Defendants is required. Paragraph 193 also\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s May 4, 2023 earnings call. Defendants\n\nrespectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that earnings call, which\n\n\n                                          110\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 111 of 269\n\n\n\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny\n\nthat any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly\n\nattributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 193.\n\n194. During the question-and-answer portion of the 1Q2023 Earnings Call, in response\n   to an analyst\u2019s question about what mechanisms were present to protect ModivCare\n   from higher utilization, Defendant Sampson\u2014again speaking jointly on behalf of\n   himself and Shepard\u2014 represented that the Company\u2019s margins were being protected\n   by ModivCare\u2019s initiatives to reduce costs through its multi-modal partnerships, stating\n   in relevant part:\n       The one thing that we have to do and have been doing to ensure that we\n       can make sure that our margins get back to where we want and at the higher\n       range in Mobility side, it\u2019s two-fold. It\u2019s the transportation costs, and\n       those initiatives are taking hold. That\u2019s again narrowing the network and\n       ensuring that we are with our most -- the partners that match what we need\n       for that specific member. Those initiatives are taking hold and that cost\n       will come down. And then the other item, well, there\u2019s 3 items.\n\n       ...\n\n       So the contracts, the way we\u2019ve restructured them, coupled with these\n       initiatives that are taking hold, coupled with where we think utilization has\n       been, all those together are showing that it\u2019s working, and our plans are\n       taking hold. So again, we feel really good about that business.\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 194 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 194 contains a\n\nlegal conclusion to which no response from Defendants is required. Paragraph 194 also\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s May 4, 2023 earnings call. Defendants\n\n\n\n                                           111\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 112 of 269\n\n\n\n\nrespectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that earnings call, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny\n\nthat any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly\n\nattributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 194.\n\n195. In response to an analyst\u2019s question regarding the expectation for operating cash\n   flow in FY2023, Sampson again assured that ModivCare\u2019s multi-modal initiative was\n   working, stating in relevant part:\n       From a margin perspective on mobility side, it\u2019s two-fold. It\u2019s the cost per\n       trip that we pay. That has improved, and I expect that to accelerate\n       throughout the year. And that, again, that\u2019s on getting the right members\n       and the right modality to our members at the right cost, and that\u2019s\n       working. And I expect that to be kind of ramping throughout the year at the\n       current pace that it is.\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 195 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 195\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s May 4, 2023 earnings call. Defendants\n\nrespectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that earnings call, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny\n\nthat any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly\n\nattributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 195.\n\n\n\n\n                                           112\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 113 of 269\n\n\n\n\n196. The statements identified in \u00b6\u00b6192-195 above were each materially false and\n   misleading and/or omitted material facts necessary to make the statements therein\n   not false or misleading when made because they generated a misimpression\n   regarding customer satisfaction with ModivCare\u2019s service and related cost savings\u2014\n   indeed, ModivCare was not providing high quality care or services to its members in\n   a cost- effective manner through its offerings nor was the Company\u2019s multi-modal\n   initiative \u201ctaking hold\u201d and working to reduce transportation costs. Defendants\n   Sampson and Shepard also did not have a reasonable basis to: (i) be confident that\n   the Company\u2019s multi-modal partnership initiative would drive efficiencies, operating\n   leverage, or lower transportation costs throughout the year; (ii) suggest that said\n   initiative would continue to improve performance and increase member satisfaction;\n   or (iii) feel really good about the Company\u2019s NEMT business. The material falsity of\n   Defendants Sampson\u2019s and Shepard\u2019s statements is supported by ample evidence\n   given that:\n       a.     CW1 stated that ModivCare\u2019s service quality started to decline around April\n2022. CW1 also confirmed that ModivCare had \u201cstruggles to keep the payors happy\u201d\nbeginning around 1Q2022 and the Company received an increase in complaints,\nincluding driver miscommunications and untimely pickups, from payors\u2019 members around\nMay or June 2022. As a result, CW1 confirmed that, throughout the last year of CW1\u2019s\nemployment, ModivCare was failing to meet targets for its member satisfaction KPIs.\nCW1 further confirmed that service issues resulted in a lot of problems with the Big 6 and\npayors \u201cabsolutely\u201d refused to pay or delayed payments due to ModivCare\u2019s service\nissues.\n\n       b.     CW1 stated that, during the last year of CW1\u2019s tenure, ModivCare began\nlosing NEMT customers due to service complaints. CW1 also confirmed that NEMT de-\nimplementations were \u201ccommon\u201d during the last year of CW1\u2019s tenure due to poor service\nquality and service complaints. Corroborating CW1, CW2 confirmed that contract attrition\nwas an issue in multiple regions and remained an issue throughout CW2\u2019s tenure.\n\n      c.     CW3 stated that customer advocate staffing cuts greatly diminished\nModivCare\u2019s ability to address service issues because the Company\u2019s GPS tracking and\ndynamic reassignment technologies \u201cwere plagued by bugs\u201d throughout CW3\u2019s tenure\nand could not fulfill these capabilities without human intervention. As a result, according\nto CW3, payors consistently expressed dissatisfaction, particularly around no shows and\non-time performance, which continued throughout CW3\u2019s tenure.\n\n      d.     CW3 stated that missed appointments and no-shows were significant\n\n\n                                           113\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 114 of 269\n\n\n\n\nservice issues that ModivCare had throughout CW3\u2019s tenure but did not improve on. CW3\nadded that ModivCare consistently failed to meet KPIs, including on-time performance\nand NVAs (which caused missed rides), throughout CW3\u2019s tenure.\n\n        e.     CW1 confirmed that ModivCare\u2019s multi-modal initiative \u201cfared very poorly\u201d\nbecause payors\u2019 members disliked them. As a result, according to CW1, the Company\nfell far short of achieving the stated metrics associated with the initiative, including\nforecasted cost savings that \u201cnever really transpired.\u201d\n\n         f.    CW3 explained that that multi-modal trips with ride-share TNCs were\ngenerally more expensive than traditional transportation providers, and other cost-saving\ninitiatives were hampered by on-time performance issues that resulted in the Company\npaying its transportation providers 2-3 times more for trip acceptance.\n\n       g.     CW1 confirmed that ModivCare\u2019s decision to de-prioritize members\u2019\nexperience \u201c100%\u201d contributed to the loss of business. CW2 corroborated that\nDefendants\u2019 decision to treat ModivCare as a logistics company rather than a people-\ndriven service business damaged customer relationships.\n\n        h.     CW2 confirmed that, beginning around 2Q2022 and continuing throughout\nCW2\u2019s tenure, ModivCare\u2019s poor operational performance (such as call center failures)\nled to client dissatisfaction and monthly liquidated damages of hundreds of thousands of\ndollars.\n\n       i.      CW3 stated that ModivCare instructed CW3 to highlight technological\ncapabilities that the Company did not have to customers and never delivered on providing\nduring CW3\u2019s tenure, which caused customers to repeatedly complain and place\nModivCare on PIPs during 2022 and 2023. CW3 confirmed that ModivCare\u2019s poor service\ndelivery, long-standing weaknesses in technology, and reliance on an outdated platform\ncaused major contracts to be under threat.\n\n      j.      CW3 confirmed that New York-based customers had major complaints\ncentered on technology, call center performance, and lack of responsiveness from the\nexecutive team. CW3 confirmed that ModivCare consistently failed to meet call center\nKPIs related to answering-time during CW3\u2019s tenure.\n\n       k.     CW3 confirmed that ModivCare lost the majority of its New York NEMT\nbusiness in 2022 and the Elevance contract, was not considered for an RFP re-bid in\nVirginia in 2022-2023, and had withdrawals from minor NEMT player contracts, MCOs,\nUHC, and Humana due to its poor service delivery and long-standing weaknesses in\n\n\n                                          114\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 115 of 269\n\n\n\n\ntechnology.\n\n       l.      CW2 confirmed that ModivCare lost MCO Medicaid contracts in New York\nthat were valued at $100 million annually during CW2\u2019s tenure due, in part, to New York\nState transitioning members to its state Medicaid program.\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 196 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 196, including\n\nsubparagraphs (a) through (l), states legal conclusions to which no response is required.\n\nDefendants further lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth\n\nof the CW allegations in Paragraph 196, including in subparagraphs (a) through (l), and\n\ndeny them on that basis. Defendants further deny that any alleged statement, knowledge,\n\nconduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to\n\nanother. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 196, including in\n\nsubparagraphs (a) through (l).\n\n197. During his prepared remarks on the 1Q2023 Earnings Call, Defendant Sampson\n   also discussed ModivCare\u2019s intentional shift from capitated full-risk to capitated shared\n   risk and FFS contracts and how the shift would protect the Company and its customers,\n   including from the effects of redetermination, stating in relevant part:\n       When we exit the pandemic in 2020 and 2021, we made a conscious effort\n       to effectively and efficiently transition, a large portion of our previous full-\n       risk contracts to contracts that are shared risk or fee-for-service\n       arrangements, protecting ourselves and our customers. These shared risk\n       contracts significantly derisk the financial impact from\n       redetermination by setting contractual revenue rates, primarily based\n       on trip volumes as opposed to membership. In many situations, we\n       can fully offset the gross profit impact from lower membership from\n\n\n                                            115\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS           Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 116 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       re-determination as these contracts reset monthly.\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 197 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 197\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s May 4, 2023 earnings call, and Defendants\n\nrespectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that call, which speaks for itself,\n\nand deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 197.\n\n198. During the question-and-answer portion of the 1Q2023 Earnings Call, in response\n   to an analyst\u2019s question about what mechanisms were present to protect ModivCare\n   from higher utilization, Defendant Sampson\u2014speaking jointly on behalf of himself and\n   Shepard\u2014emphasized the Company\u2019s shift toward capitated shared risk contracts:\n       Yes. So the utilization increases like we\u2019ve been saying for a while, have\n       been steady increases as we come out of COVID, and more normal trip\n       volume takes hold and that continues to happen. The other thing -- and we\n       talked about this today, primarily we\u2019re talking around redetermination. But\n       in general, our contracts that we have reset, renegotiated to ensure that\n       it\u2019s a win-win for us and the customer as well, as you see that now full-\n       risk is down to 20% of our mix versus pre-COVID 60%. So those structural\n       changes in our contracts allow us to grow with our customers and\n       utilization being as planned. So, that\u2019s a good thing from a structural\n       perspective.\n\n       ...\n\n       So the contracts, the way we\u2019ve restructured them, coupled with these\n       initiatives that are taking hold, coupled with where we think utilization\n       has been, all those together are showing that it\u2019s working, and our\n       plans are taking hold. So again, we feel really good about that\n       business.\n\n\n\n                                             116\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 117 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 198 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 198\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s May 4, 2023 earnings call, and Defendants\n\nrespectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that earnings call, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny\n\nthat any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly\n\nattributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 198.\n\n199. Later, during the same call, in response to an analyst\u2019s question regarding how\n   capitated shared risk contracts were different from and purportedly more beneficial\n   than the company\u2019s previous contracts, Defendant Sampson\u2014again speaking jointly\n   on behalf of himself and Shepard\u2014characterized capitated shared risk contracts as\n   \u201cwin- win\u201d and that they would provide rigid NEMT margins:\n       Yes. And so COVID and really when I got here a couple of years ago, really\n       highlighted that we had a misbalance in these contracts. We did very well\n       at the expense of our customers in 2020 and 2021. Even before that, by the\n       way, in 2018 and 2019, it was the opposite. Our customers did very well,\n       and we didn\u2019t. So when I got here, this doesn\u2019t make sense, right? This win-\n       lose relationship that was anchored on this kind of capitation that happened\n       5, 6 years ago. The business in transportation and NEMT changed over\n       these last 10 years. We were not kind of caught up to this win-win\n       relationship. And you couple that with what has happened really over the\n       last couple of years in COVID, and continues to accelerate.\n\n       I touched on this a little bit with Brian\u2019s question, Healthcare now realizes or\n       has realized, but now it\u2019s an important focus because we were able to track\n       and have data. Transportation matters. It matters to people\u2019s clinical\n       outcomes eventually. So you put all that together, we have been enabled\n       to change the contract, where we actually have a win-win relationship.\n\n\n                                            117\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 118 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       And as, whether or not utilization or cost fluctuations happen, we\n       share in the upside and downside for that. So the change to where we\n       are today, I expect that to continue.\n\n       So 60% pre-COVID on full-risk, which full-risk, again, is we get a PMPM.\n       And then we\u2019re responsible for everything regardless of cost of utilization.\n       Now the contract has worked where there is a sharing within that utilization\n       change or cost change. Again, I expect that to continue, and that\n       contributes again to the rigidness in our margin profile, especially when\n       we get to the high-end, when we finish off with these initiatives like I\n       articulated a little bit earlier.\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 199 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 199\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s May 4, 2023 earnings call, and Defendants\n\nrespectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that earnings call, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny\n\nthat any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly\n\nattributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 199.\n\n200. In response to another analyst\u2019s question regarding ModivCare\u2019s contract\n   receivables and contract payables balances, Defendant Sampson stated that\n   ModivCare\u2019s shift toward capitated shared risk contracts had normalized contract\n   receivables and contract payables:\n       And then on the redetermination, and the -- our disclosure around the\n       redetermination is primarily people that aren\u2019t utilizers. The reason why we\n       disclosed that is similar to the question that Pito had. It explains why from a\n       utilization perspective, you could see that being higher because that\u2019s the\n       phenomenon with people -- people going away, they don\u2019t take trips. But\n\n\n                                            118\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79        filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 119 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      the reason why we also talked about our contract mix, you see that\n      being shared. So even though utilization is up, you\u2019re seeing that\n      being shared in the way our contracts are structured.\n\n      So it\u2019s helping you model the coming out of COVID with\n      redetermination and showing that our contracts actually work. So,\n      even on what Ken just talked about, the increase in receivables is right\n      in line with how we\u2019ve organized these contracts. And they -- out of the\n      -- we had a lot of noise with paying back COVID expenses in 2022. Those\n      now are done. Now you see the normal fluctuations between\n      receivables and payables that are happening here in 2023. We still have\n      a little bit of noise that\u2019s happening in Q1 and Q3 on COVID stuff, but the\n      majority of our working capital fluctuations, as evidenced by what Ken just\n      talked about have to do with the way our contracts are set up.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 200 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 200\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s May 4, 2023 earnings call, and Defendants\n\nrespectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that earnings call, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 200.\n\n201. In response to another analyst\u2019s question regarding the Company\u2019s free cash flow,\n   Defendant Shepard\u2014speaking jointly on behalf of himself and Sampson\u2014 responded\n   that ModivCare\u2019s capitated shared risk contracts with customers were working as\n   expected:\n      But then, as we think about the second half of the year, we\u2019ll also benefit\n      from the reversal of some of these build and receivables, we\u2019re going to be\n      collecting on these receivables in the second half of this year. And so that\u2019s\n      going to be from a working capital perspective, a benefit. And then, you also\n      have the typical -- I think, what Heath is referring to in terms of normalization\n      is that you\u2019ll also have this benefit of just, EBITDA less CapEx and interest\n\n\n                                            119\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS            Document 79    filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                         pg 120 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       in the second half of the year.\n\n       And so I think to that range that you\u2019ve given of like the $80 million to $100\n       million, it\u2019s probably going to be in that range, depending on how working\n       capital really shakes out through the rest of the year. But yes, like we\u2019re\n       feeling very confident that, as Heath has alluded to, the contracts are\n       working as they should be. And really, the cash flow generation is going\n       to be accelerating. So that\u2019s all good stuff.\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 201 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 201\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s May 4, 2023 earnings call, and Defendants\n\nrespectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that earnings call, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny\n\nthat any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly\n\nattributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 201.\n\n202. The statements identified in \u00b6\u00b6197-201 above were each materially false and\n   misleading and/or omitted material facts necessary to make the statements therein\n   not false or misleading when made because ModivCare\u2019s shared risk contracts were\n   not \u201cwin-win\u201d and did not enable the Company to share in cost fluctuations, \u201cfully offset\n   the gross profit impact from lower membership[,]\u201d or have rigid margins and\n   normalized contract receivable and payables fluctuations. Sampson and Shepard also\n   had no reasonable basis to be confident that ModivCare\u2019s contracts were working as\n   they should be.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 202 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n\n                                             120\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 121 of 269\n\n\n\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 202 also states\n\nlegal conclusions to which no response from Defendants is required. Defendants further\n\ndeny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly\n\nattributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 202.\n\n203. The material falsity of Defendants Sampson\u2019s and Shepard\u2019s statements is\n   supported by evidence. CW2 confirmed, for example, that ModivCare\u2019s true-up\n   process for the shared risk contracts caused regular disputes with payors that dragged\n   on for \u201ca very long time\u201d because the Company billed payors based on internal\n   projections of utilization and claims data that did not match the payors\u2019 \u201cencounter\n   data\u201d (i.e., actual claims). As a result, CW2 confirmed ModivCare often was forced to\n   expend considerable efforts to chase contract receivables, subjected to monthly\n   liquidated damages of hundreds of thousands of dollars, and/or forced to accept\n   partial payment as a settlement for true-up disputes with payors. Beginning in 2023\n   and continuing throughout CW2\u2019s tenure, CW2 confirmed that Monthly Leadership\n   Meetings included regular updates \u201cmonth after month\u201d regarding receivable dispute\n   settlements that resulted in ModivCare receiving a fraction of what was owed. Further,\n   CW2 confirmed that in other instances payors would withhold monthly payments that\n   ModivCare was expecting to offset the balance that ModivCare owed to the payors by\n   ModivCare as a result of the true-up process. Corroborating CW2, CW3 stated\n   ModivCare experienced significant disputes over risk corridors and profits, and\n   collectability issues related to the Company charging more for trips despite service\n   and technological shortcomings. CW3 explained that complaints about the shared risk\n   contracts resulted in payors refusing to pay for trips, delayed payments, states\n   capping profits, and lost contracts.\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 203 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\n\n\n                                          121\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 122 of 269\n\n\n\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 203 states legal\n\nconclusions to which no response from Defendants is required. Defendants further lack\n\nknowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations\n\nin Paragraph 203 and deny them on that basis. Defendants further deny that any alleged\n\nstatement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to one\n\ndefendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 203.\n\n      F.     Bank of America Securities\u2019 2023 Health Care Conference on May 10,\n             2023\n\n204. On May 10, 2023, Defendant Sampson participated in the Bank of America\n   Securities\u2019 2023 Health Care Conference on behalf of ModivCare. Notably, no oral\n   statement was made to warn investors that Sampson may make forward-looking\n   statements or to direct investors to any cautionary language.\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 204 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit that Mr.\n\nSampson participated in the Bank of America Securities 2023 Health Care Conference\n\non May 10, 2023 on behalf of ModivCare. Paragraph 204 states a legal conclusion to\n\nwhich no response from Defendants is required. Except as expressly admitted,\n\nDefendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 204.\n\n\n\n\n                                           122\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 123 of 269\n\n\n\n\n205. During the question-and-answer portion of the conference session, Defendant\n   Sampson touted the Company\u2019s transition to capitated shared risk contracts as\n   purportedly guarding against Medicaid redetermination impacts, stating in relevant\n   part:\n      Yes. So the good thing for us is we have been planning for this for multiple\n      years. So it\u2019s just going to hit everybody in the face these last couple of\n      months. For us, we\u2019ve been planning for this for the last number of years. It\n      benefits us coming out of COVID and also it allows us to be proactive in\n      Medicaid redetermination that\u2019s happening now. So the good thing of this\n      for us, we\u2019re aligned with all our specific states and understand what needs\n      to happen. So part of what we prepared for is changing how we\n      contract with our states and our payers. And that primary is a move to\n      a kind of win-win relationship.\n\n      So when there is a fluctuation in utilization, which redetermination\n      would be, the cost, which could relate to redetermination, those we\n      share. So we\u2019re protected from a margin perspective on the P&L. So\n      that\u2019s an important point. So that has happened and some of the stuff that\n      we talked about prior to COVID, we would have had a lot more exposure.\n      About 60% of our contracts plus we\u2019re exposed in the event that this\n      happened. Benefitted us during COVID, now we\u2019re down to 20%. And that\n      20%, we know where they are. We have relationships with them. based\n      on historically how we have reset and redone pricing, we feel really\n      good our ability to partner and manage through that with each of the\n      areas.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 205 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 205\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from the May 10, 2023 Bank of America Securities conference,\n\nand Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that conference,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 205.\n\n\n                                          123\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 124 of 269\n\n\n\n\n206. Later during the conference, when asked by an analyst about challenges with the\n   Company\u2019s contract payables, Defendant Sampson touted how ModivCare\u2019s\n   capitated shared risk contracts protected the Company\u2019s margins and cash flow,\n   stating in relevant part:\n      Well, it\u2019s a really important point, and you really have to dive into our\n      contracts to look it as simple as possible. Starting off the bat again, with\n      the changes we\u2019ve made, the margin in the P&L is protected with these\n      changes.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 206 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 206\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from the May 10, 2023 Bank of America Securities conference,\n\nand Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that conference,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 206.\n\n207. Defendant Sampson also reiterated that ModivCare\u2019s shared risk contracts were\n   \u201cwin-win\u201d and stabilizing the Company\u2019s margins, stating in relevant part:\n      Yes. So the way we contract, again, that\u2019s mobility-centric, which is mobility\n      and EMT, which is 60% of our business. The other 45% is the home\n      business. So this is centered on mobility. And then within that, the big\n      change that we have made is moving to this win-win relationship with our\n      payers, which gets to moving from a fully capitated full-risk contract to a\n      shared risk contract. And that moving to 20% is allowing us to really\n      have stable rigid margins regardless of utilization and cost because it\n      really is about the member experience. So that\u2019s -- though, again, from a\n      working capital and timing paying that back because the payables and\n      receivables range from anywhere from 6 to 18 months. Yes, that\u2019s a near-\n      term capital issue but we are aligned now. And based on that contract\n      structure, we feel really good about our future and even managing\n      through determination.\n\n\n                                           124\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 125 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 207 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 207\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from the May 10, 2023 Bank of America Securities conference,\n\nand Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that conference,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 207.\n\n208. Sampson\u2019s point landed with analyst Kalle J. Ahl, who repeated Sampson\u2019s\n   statement, stating in relevant part: \u201cWe\u2019re moving away from that full capitation, if you\n   will, that mitigates the risk of that. The volatility around the payables and receivables.\u201d\n   In response, Sampson agreed, stating that the Company\u2019s shared risk contracts\n   demonstrated \u201c[t]he true win-win relationship that we have\u201d with payors.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 208 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. Paragraph 208 characterizes or quotes from the May 10, 2023\n\nBank of America Securities conference, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to\n\nthe complete recording from that conference, which speaks for itself, and deny any\n\nallegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants further lack information sufficient to admit\n\nor deny the impact of alleged statements on analysts. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 208.\n\n\n\n                                            125\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 126 of 269\n\n\n\n\n209. The statements identified in \u00b6\u00b6205-208 above were each materially false and\n   misleading and/or omitted material facts necessary to make the statements therein\n   not false or misleading when made because ModivCare\u2019s shared risk contracts were\n   not \u201cwin-win\u201d and did not enable the Company to share cost fluctuations with clients\n   such that the Company\u2019s margins were protected, stable, or rigid. Defendant Sampson\n   also had no reasonable basis to feel really good about the Company\u2019s ability to\n   manage through cost fluctuations with the shared risk contracts or to feel good about\n   the Company\u2019s future.\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 209 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 209 states legal\n\nconclusions to which no response from Defendants is required. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 209.\n\n210. The material falsity of Defendant Sampson\u2019s statements is supported by evidence.\n   CW2 confirmed, for example, that ModivCare\u2019s true-up process for the shared risk\n   contracts caused regular disputes with payors that dragged on for \u201ca very long time\u201d\n   because the Company billed payors based on internal projections of utilization and\n   claims data that did not match the payors\u2019 \u201cencounter data\u201d (i.e., actual claims). As a\n   result, CW2 confirmed ModivCare often was forced to expend considerable efforts to\n   chase contract receivables, subjected to monthly liquidated damages of hundreds of\n   thousands of dollars, and/or forced to accept partial payment as a settlement for true-\n   up disputes with payors. Beginning in 2023 and continuing throughout CW2\u2019s tenure,\n   CW2 confirmed that Monthly Leadership Meetings included regular updates \u201cmonth\n   after month\u201d regarding receivable dispute settlements that resulted in ModivCare\n   receiving a fraction of what was owed. Further, CW2 confirmed that in other instances\n   payors would withhold monthly payments that ModivCare was expecting to offset the\n   balance that ModivCare owed to the payor by ModivCare as a result of the true-up\n   process. Corroborating CW2, CW3 stated ModivCare experienced significant disputes\n   over risk corridors and profits, and collectability issues related to the Company\n   charging more for trips despite service and technological shortcomings. CW3\n\n\n                                           126\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 127 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   explained that complaints about the shared risk contracts resulted in payors refusing\n   to pay for trips, delayed payments, states capping profits, and lost contracts.\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 210 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 210 states a\n\nlegal conclusion to which no response from Defendants is required. Defendants further\n\nlack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW\n\nallegations in Paragraph 210 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny\n\nthe allegations in Paragraph 210.\n\n211. During the same conference, in response to a question about ModivCare\u2019s NEMT\n   cost savings initiatives, Defendant Sampson emphasized that those initiatives,\n   including the multi-modal initiative, were \u201ctaking hold\u201d and members were satisfied\n   with them, stating in relevant part:\n      Yes. So from a cost perspective, yes, the initiatives are taking hold. You\n      can see that in the numbers, and I expect that to continue. It\u2019s tangible items\n      that we\u2019ve implemented now it\u2019s just about scaling them. So the team has\n      done an amazing job. And the initiatives that we can go through probably\n      at a later date are showing high member satisfaction as well as\n      allowing us to take out costs as well which is why we reaffirmed our\n      guidance and reaffirmed our long-term margin targets as well.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 211 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 211 characterizes\n\n\n\n                                           127\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 128 of 269\n\n\n\n\nor quotes from the May 10, 2023 Bank of America Securities conference, and Defendants\n\nrespectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that conference, which speaks\n\nfor itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 211.\n\n212. Later during the conference, in response to a question about ModivCare\u2019s margin\n   opportunity as it related to the Company\u2019s \u201cmulti-partnership model and the\n   transportation side[,]\u201d Defendant Sampson doubled down on the initiative\u2019s ability to\n   lower costs and improve member service quality, stating in relevant part:\n      It is. Yes. It\u2019s that multimodal partnership model, which is really the\n      people and owners of these cars, ensuring that they\u2019re partners of ours, and\n      we ensure they make money \u2026 Just by doing that, ensuring partnership\n      and coordination is a critical part of how we have \u2013 we\u2019re able to lower\n      the cost and also increase the quality. That also includes Uber and Lyft,\n      that also includes mass transit, that also includes driving yourself and\n      getting reimbursed. So it depends on the member and how to fit that\n      member to the type of transportation we have.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 212 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 212\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from the May 10, 2023 Bank of America Securities conference,\n\nand Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that conference,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 212.\n\n213. The statements identified in \u00b6\u00b6211-212 above were each materially false and\n   misleading and/or omitted material facts necessary to make the statements therein\n   not false or misleading when made because they generated a misimpression\n\n\n                                           128\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 129 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   regarding customer satisfaction with ModivCare\u2019s service and related cost savings\u2014\n   indeed, ModivCare\u2019s multi-modal initiative was not \u201ctaking hold[,]\u201d \u201cshowing high\n   member satisfaction\u201d or \u201callowing [the Company] to take out costs[,]\u201d \u201clower the cost\u201d\n   or \u201cincrease the quality.\u201d The material falsity of Defendant Sampson\u2019s statements is\n   supported by ample evidence given that:\n       a.     CW1 stated that ModivCare\u2019s service quality started to decline around April\n2022. CW1 also confirmed that ModivCare had \u201cstruggles to keep the payors happy\u201d\nbeginning around 1Q2022 and the Company received an increase in complaints,\nincluding driver miscommunications and untimely pickups, from payors\u2019 members around\nMay or June 2022. As a result, CW1 confirmed that, throughout the last year of CW1\u2019s\nemployment, ModivCare was failing to meet targets for its member satisfaction KPIs.\nCW1 further confirmed that service issues resulted in a lot of problems with the Big 6 and\npayors \u201cabsolutely\u201d refused to pay or delayed payments due to ModivCare\u2019s service\nissues.\n\n       b.    CW1 stated that, during the last year of CW1\u2019s tenure, ModivCare began\nlosing NEMT customers around August 2022 due to service complaints. CW1 also\nconfirmed that NEMT de-implementations were \u201ccommon\u201d during the last year of CW1\u2019s\ntenure due to poor service quality and service complaints. Corroborating CW1, CW2\nconfirmed that contract attrition was an issue in multiple regions and remained an issue\nthroughout CW2\u2019s tenure.\n\n      c.     CW3 stated that customer advocate staffing cuts greatly diminished\nModivCare\u2019s ability to address service issues because the Company\u2019s GPS tracking and\ndynamic reassignment technologies \u201cwere plagued by bugs\u201d throughout CW3\u2019s tenure\nand could not fulfill these capabilities without human intervention. As a result, according\nto CW3, payors consistently expressed dissatisfaction, particularly around no shows and\non-time performance, which continued throughout CW3\u2019s tenure.\n\n       d.     CW3 stated that missed appointments and no-shows were significant\nservice issues that ModivCare had throughout CW3\u2019s tenure but did not improve on. CW3\nadded that ModivCare consistently failed to meet KPIs, including on-time performance\nand NVAs (which caused missed rides), throughout CW3\u2019s tenure.\n\n        e.     CW1 confirmed that ModivCare\u2019s multi-modal initiative \u201cfared very poorly\u201d\nbecause payors\u2019 members disliked them. As a result, according to CW1, the Company\nfell far short of achieving the stated metrics associated with the initiative, including\nforecasted cost savings that \u201cnever really transpired.\u201d\n\n\n\n                                           129\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 130 of 269\n\n\n\n\n         f.    CW3 explained that that multi-modal trips with ride-share TNCs were\ngenerally more expensive than traditional transportation providers, and other cost-saving\ninitiatives were hampered by on-time performance issues that resulted in the Company\npaying its transportation providers 2-3 times more for trip acceptance.\n\n       g.     CW1 confirmed that ModivCare\u2019s decision to de-prioritize members\u2019\nexperience \u201c100%\u201d contributed to the loss of business. CW2 corroborated that\nDefendants\u2019 decision to treat ModivCare as a logistics company rather than a people-\ndriven service business damaged customer relationships.\n\n        h.     CW2 confirmed that, beginning around 2Q2022 and continuing through\nCW2\u2019s tenure, ModivCare\u2019s poor operational performance (such as call center failures)\nled to client dissatisfaction and monthly liquidated damages of hundreds of thousands of\ndollars.\n\n       i.     CW3 confirmed that ModivCare lost the majority of its New York NEMT\nbusiness in 2022 and the Elevance contract, was not considered for an RFP re-bid in\nVirginia in 2022-2023, and had withdrawals from minor NEMT player contracts, MCOs,\nUHC, and Humana due to its poor service delivery and long-standing weaknesses in\ntechnology.\n\n       j.      CW2 confirmed that ModivCare lost MCO Medicaid contracts in New York\nthat were valued at $100 million annually during CW2\u2019s tenure due, in part, to New York\nState transitioning members to its state Medicaid program.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 213 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 213, including\n\nsubparagraphs (a) through (j), states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. Defendants further lack knowledge or information sufficient to\n\nform a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 213, including in\n\n\n\n\n                                          130\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 131 of 269\n\n\n\n\nsubparagraphs (a) through (j), and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny\n\nthe allegations in Paragraph 213, including in subparagraphs (a) through (j).\n\n       G.     Defendants Partially Disclosed the Truth on August 3, 2023 during\n              ModivCare\u2019s 2Q2023 Press Release and on August 4, 2023 during the\n              Company\u2019s 2Q2023 Earnings Call but Continue Making False and\n              Misleading Statements\n\n              1.     Defendants Partially Disclosed the Truth on August 3, 2023 and\n                     August 4, 2023\n\n214. On August 3, 2023, ModivCare issued a press release disclosing its 2Q2023\n   financial results (the \u201c2Q2023 Press Release\u201d). The Company disclosed that it was\n   lowering its 2023 full-year Adjusted EBITDA guidance from a range of $225 million to\n   $235 million to a range of $200 million to $210 million due to \u201cincreased utilization and\n   related higher call volumes in NEMT, along with new contract win implementation\n   delays, and contract attrition from prior years . . .\u201d ModivCare also disclosed that it\n   used $108.2 million in cash from operating activities, drew $126.5 million on its\n   revolving credit facility, and amended the 2022 Credit Agreement\u2019s maximum Total\n   Net Leverage Ratio.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 214 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit that\n\nModivCare issued a press release on August 3, 2023 announcing its financial results for\n\nQ2 FY2023. Paragraph 214 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s August 3, 2023\n\npress release, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as\n\nexpressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 214.\n\n\n\n\n                                            131\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 132 of 269\n\n\n\n\n215. The following day, on August 4, 2023 at 8:30 am, the Company held an earnings\n   call to report on the Company\u2019s financial and operational results for its second quarter\n   ended June 30, 2023 (the \u201c2Q2023 Earnings Call\u201d) wherein Defendants Sampson and\n   Shepard participated. During the 2Q2023 Earnings Call, Defendants further\n   elaborated that ModivCare\u2019s use of $108 million in cash flow and $111.5 million credit\n   draw stemmed from \u201ca temporary timing mismatch between payments and collections\u201d\n   related to the Company\u2019s shared risk NEMT contracts and accelerated payments\n   made to \u201ca few large state clients\u201d that \u201coccurred earlier than anticipated[.]\u201d Indeed,\n   ModivCare chalked the approximately $65 million accelerated payments up to\n   \u201c[p]rioritizing long-term customer relationships[.]\u201d\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 215 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit that\n\nModivCare held an earnings call on August 4, 2023 to report its financial and operating\n\nresults for Q2 FY2023, and that Mr. Sampson and Mr. Shepard participated in that call.\n\nParagraph 215 characterizes or quotes from that August 4, 2023 earnings call, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that earnings call,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\nfurther deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission\n\nallegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Except as expressly\n\nadmitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 215.\n\n216. In response to Defendants\u2019 corrective disclosures in the 2Q2023 Press Release\n   and the 2Q2023 Earnings Call, ModivCare\u2019s common stock price declined $2.86, or\n   approximately 7%, from $38.24 per share on August 3, 2023, to close at $35.38 per\n   share on August 4, 2023.\n\n\n\n                                           132\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 133 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 216 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit and allege\n\nthat ModivCare\u2019s stock price at various times is a matter of public record and deny any\n\nallegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny that any alleged statement,\n\nknowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is\n\nattributable to another. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 216.\n\n             2.     Defendants Continue Making False and Misleading Statements\n                    During the 2Q2023 Earnings Call\n\n217. During the 2Q2023 Earnings Call, Defendant Sampson jointly presented with\n   Defendant Shepard and while speaking on behalf of \u201cwe\u201d \u2014i.e., both himself and\n   Shepard\u2014continued to make materially misleading statements. During his prepared\n   remarks during the 2Q2023 Earnings Call, Defendant Sampson affirmed that\n   ModivCare\u2019s NEMT cost reduction initiatives were working, stating in relevant part:\n      Our focus on centralization and operational excellence facilitated by\n      technology has considerably improved our NEMT services, We\u2019re meeting\n      or exceeding all our customers\u2019 quality and service level requirements\n      as seen in our key performance indicators, such as on-time\n      performance and reduced miss trips. Our multimodal transportation\n      partnership strategy has led to increased customer satisfaction and\n      reduced costs.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 217 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 217 states legal\n\nconclusions to which no response from Defendants is required. Defendants admit that\n\nModivCare held an earnings call on August 4, 2023, and that Mr. Sampson and Mr.\n\n\n                                          133\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 134 of 269\n\n\n\n\nShepard each participated. Paragraph 217 characterizes or quotes from that August 4,\n\n2023 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording\n\nof that earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants further deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct,\n\ndocument, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another.\n\nExcept as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 217.\n\n218. The statement identified in \u00b6217 above was materially false and misleading and/or\n   omitted material facts necessary to make the statements therein not false or\n   misleading when made because ModivCare was not \u201cmeeting or exceeding all our\n   customers\u2019 quality and service level requirements[,]\u201d seeing improved on-time\n   performance and reduced missed trips, nor was the Company\u2019s multi-modal\n   transportation partnership strategy increasing customer satisfaction or reducing costs.\n   The material falsity of Defendants Sampson\u2019s and Shepard\u2019s statements is supported\n   by ample evidence given that:\n\n       a.     CW1 stated that ModivCare\u2019s service quality started to decline around April\n2022. CW1 also confirmed that ModivCare had \u201cstruggles to keep the payors happy\u201d\nbeginning around 1Q2022 and the Company received an increase in complaints,\nincluding driver miscommunications and untimely pickups, from payors\u2019 members around\nMay or June 2022. As a result, CW1 confirmed that, throughout the last year of CW1\u2019s\nemployment, ModivCare was failing to meet targets for its member satisfaction KPIs.\nCW1 further confirmed that service issues resulted in a lot of problems with the Big 6 and\npayors \u201cabsolutely\u201d refused to pay or delayed payments due to ModivCare\u2019s service\nissues.\n\n       b.     CW1 stated that, during the last year of CW1\u2019s tenure, ModivCare began\nlosing NEMT customers due to service complaints. CW1 also confirmed that NEMT de-\nimplementations were \u201ccommon\u201d during the last year of CW1\u2019s tenure due to poor service\nquality and service complaints. Corroborating CW1, CW2 confirmed that contract attrition\nwas an issue in multiple regions and remained an issue throughout CW2\u2019s tenure.\n\n     c.     CW3 stated that customer advocate staffing cuts greatly diminished\nModivCare\u2019s ability to address service issues because the Company\u2019s GPS tracking and\ndynamic reassignment technologies \u201cwere plagued by bugs\u201d throughout CW3\u2019s tenure\n\n\n\n                                           134\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 135 of 269\n\n\n\n\nand could not fulfill these capabilities without human intervention. As a result, according\nto CW3, payors consistently expressed dissatisfaction, particularly around no shows and\non-time performance, which continued throughout CW3\u2019s tenure.\n\n       d.     CW3 stated that missed appointments and no-shows were significant\nservice issues that ModivCare had throughout CW3\u2019s tenure but did not improve on. CW3\nadded that ModivCare consistently failed to meet KPIs, including on-time performance\nand NVAs (which caused missed rides), throughout CW3\u2019s tenure.\n\n        e.     CW1 confirmed that ModivCare\u2019s multi-modal initiative \u201cfared very poorly\u201d\nbecause payors\u2019 members disliked them. As a result, according to CW1, the Company\nfell far short of achieving the stated metrics associated with the initiative, including\nforecasted cost savings that \u201cnever really transpired.\u201d\n\n         f.    CW3 explained that that multi-modal trips with ride-share TNCs were\ngenerally more expensive than traditional transportation providers, and other cost-saving\ninitiatives were hampered by on-time performance issues that resulted in the Company\npaying its transportation providers 2-3 times more for trip acceptance.\n\n       g.     CW1 confirmed that ModivCare\u2019s decision to de-prioritize members\u2019\nexperience \u201c100%\u201d contributed to the loss of business. CW2 corroborated that\nDefendants\u2019 decision to treat ModivCare as a logistics company rather than a people-\ndriven service business damaged customer relationships.\n\n        h.     CW2 confirmed that, beginning around 2Q2022 and continuing throughout\nCW2\u2019s tenure, ModivCare\u2019s poor operational performance (such as call center failures)\nled to client dissatisfaction and monthly liquidated damages of hundreds of thousands of\ndollars.\n\n       i.      CW3 stated that ModivCare instructed CW3 to highlight technological\ncapabilities that the Company did not have to customers and never delivered on providing\nduring CW3\u2019s tenure, which caused customers to repeatedly complain and place\nModivCare on PIPs during 2022 and 2023. CW3 confirmed that ModivCare\u2019s poor service\ndelivery, long-standing weaknesses in technology, and reliance on an outdated platform\ncaused major contracts to be under threat.\n\n      j.      CW3 confirmed that New York-based customers had major complaints\ncentered on technology, call center performance, and lack of responsiveness from the\nexecutive team. CW3 confirmed that ModivCare consistently failed to meet call center\nKPIs related to answering-time during CW3\u2019s tenure.\n\n\n                                           135\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 136 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       k.     CW3 confirmed that ModivCare lost the majority of its New York NEMT\nbusiness in 2022 and the Elevance contract, was not considered for an RFP re-bid in\nVirginia in 2022-2023, and had withdrawals from minor NEMT player contracts, MCOs,\nUHC, and Humana due to its poor service delivery and long-standing weaknesses in\ntechnology.\n\n       l.      CW2 confirmed that ModivCare lost MCO Medicaid contracts in New York\nthat were valued at $100 million annually during CW2\u2019s tenure due, in part, to New York\nState transitioning members to its state Medicaid program.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 218 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 218, including\n\nsubparagraphs (a) through (l), states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. Defendants further lack knowledge or information sufficient to\n\nform a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 218, including in\n\nsubparagraphs (a) through (l), and deny them on that basis. Defendants further deny that\n\nany alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable\n\nto one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 218, including in subparagraphs (a) through (l).\n\n219. In his prepared remarks during the 2Q2023 Earnings Call, Defendant Sampson\n   (again speaking on behalf of himself and Shepard, who jointly presented with\n   Sampson) assured investors that ModivCare\u2019s shared risk contracts were yielding\n   positive results, adding predictability to cash flow, providing long-term stability, and\n   balancing profitability with customer satisfaction, stating in relevant part:\n      The second quarter of 2023 marks a notable shift in our working capital.\n      We\u2019ve resolved pandemic era balance sheet disparities, transitioning into a\n\n\n\n                                           136\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 137 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      net receivable position where our contract receivables surpass our contract\n      payables. This occurred earlier than anticipated, largely due to accelerate\n      payments from a few large state clients. Furthermore, these clients now\n      have established clear time lines for reconciliation, adding additional layer\n      of predictability to our cash flow.\n\n      We anticipate the collection of these receivables to balance out, if not\n      surpass payable repayments for the rest of the year, positively impacting\n      our cash flow in the second half of 2023. Our effort to realign contracts\n      with our customers\u2019 needs is yielding positive results. We\u2019ve\n      safeguarded our margins, trading some pandemic era upside for long-\n      term stability. Now our cash flow mirrors our P&L more closely, indicating\n      improved financial management and a balance between profitability and\n      customer satisfaction.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 219 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 219 states legal\n\nconclusions to which no response from Defendants is required. Defendants admit that\n\nModivCare held an earnings call on August 4, 2023, and that Mr. Sampson and Mr.\n\nShepard each participated. Paragraph 219 characterizes or quotes from that August 4,\n\n2023 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording\n\nfrom that earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants further deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct,\n\ndocument, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another.\n\nExcept as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 219.\n\n220. Analysts drilled into ModivCare\u2019s contracts payable and receivables during the\n   question-and-answer portion of the call. For instance, CJS Securities, Inc. analyst\n   Robert James Labick questioned whether ModivCare was \u201cat a normalized level\n\n\n                                          137\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 138 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   overall?\u201d Defendant Sampson unequivocally stated \u201cYes, yes\u201d and affirmed on behalf\n   of himself and Shepard that the shared risk contracts were working, stating in relevant\n   part:\n       Basically, our contracts are working post COVID. So the contracts that\n       we\u2019ve restructured primarily around really implementing these shared\n       risk contracts have been very helpful for us and help protect our kind\n       of long-term margin. So that\u2019s -- you will see fluctuations as we move\n       through the years going in quarters. Those will still fluctuate.\n\n       So the good thing now though, because of the COVID benefits, now the\n       contracts are going to work how they are. And I think they\u2019ll bump around.\n       But the good thing is we have the receivables and the payables. And\n       because we have so many contracts, we expect that to be kind of a\n       normalized working capital fluctuations in and out, not the big swings like\n       we\u2019ve seen over the last couple of quarters.\n\n       And then the other item coming out of COVID now, all the states or MCOs,\n       we have more predictable and rigid time frames for when we pay this\n       back. So it really is kind of a 3- to 6-month time frame. So this\n       predictability and normalization coming out of COVID allows us to\n       have a more predictable cash flow and then a more normalized\n       working capital. So which is why we have a lot of confidence in the\n       back part of this year that we will generate cash flow in accordance\n       with how our P&L works. And I expect that to continue throughout the\n       quarter into 2024.\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 220 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 220 states legal\n\nconclusions to which no response from Defendants is required. Paragraph 220 also\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s August 4, 2023 earnings call, and Defendants\n\nrespectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that earnings call, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny\n\n\n                                           138\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 139 of 269\n\n\n\n\nthat any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly\n\nattributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 220.\n\n221. In response to another analyst\u2019s question regarding \u201cthe cadence\u201d of the\n   Company\u2019s payables, Defendant Sampson again affirmed, speaking on behalf of\n   himself and Shepard, that they had \u201ca lot of predictability\u201d with ModivCare\u2019s customers,\n   stating in relevant part:\n       No, that is exactly -- during COVID, it was -- the time lines were all over the\n       place. And as recently as 90 days ago, and this is why it was explicit, I\n       wanted to give data around really, it was 2 large customers that had this\n       lack of time line, that is cleared up. We have the time line. We\u2019re out of\n       COVID, and we\u2019re aligned with them and now we have a lot of\n       predictability.\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 221 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 221 also states\n\nlegal conclusions to which no response from Defendants is required. Paragraph 221 also\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s August 4, 2023 earnings call. Defendants\n\nrespectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that earnings call, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny\n\nthat any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly\n\nattributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 221.\n\n\n\n\n                                            139\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS           Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 140 of 269\n\n\n\n\n222. The statements identified in \u00b6\u00b6219-221 above were each materially false and\n   misleading and/or omitted material facts necessary to make the statements therein\n   not false or misleading when made because ModivCare\u2019s contracts were not\n   \u201csafeguard[ing]\u201d or \u201cprotect[ing]\u201d the Company\u2019s margins, \u201cadding additional layer of\n   predictability to [the Company\u2019s] cash flow[,]\u201d \u201cyielding positive results[,]\u201d or creating\n   \u201ca balance between profitability and customer satisfaction.\u201d Defendants Sampson and\n   Shepard had no reasonable basis to suggest that ModivCare had \u201cmore predictable\n   and rigid time frames\u201d or \u201ca lot of predictability\u201d for collecting its receivables such that\n   the Company would have \u201cmore predictable cash flow and then a more normalized\n   working capital.\u201d Nor did Defendants Sampson and Shepard have a reasonable basis\n   to \u201chave a lot of confidence\u201d that ModivCare would \u201cgenerate cash flow\u201d \u201cin the back\n   part of [the] year[.]\u201d\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 222 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 222 states legal\n\nconclusions to which no response from Defendants is required. Defendants further deny\n\nthat any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly\n\nattributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 222.\n\n223. The material falsity of Defendant Sampson\u2019s and Shepard\u2019s statements is\n   supported by evidence. CW2 confirmed, for example, that ModivCare\u2019s true-up\n   process for the shared risk contracts caused regular disputes with payors that dragged\n   on for \u201ca very long time\u201d because the Company billed payors based on internal\n   projections of utilization and claims data that did not match the payors\u2019 \u201cencounter\n   data\u201d (i.e., actual claims). As a result, CW2 confirmed ModivCare often was forced to\n   expend considerable efforts to chase contract receivables, subjected to monthly\n   liquidated damages of hundreds of thousands of dollars, and/or forced to accept\n   partial payment as a settlement for true-up disputes with payors. Beginning in 2023\n   and continuing throughout CW2\u2019s tenure, CW2 confirmed that Monthly Leadership\n\n\n                                             140\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 141 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   Meetings included regular updates \u201cmonth after month\u201d regarding receivable dispute\n   settlements that resulted in ModivCare receiving a fraction of what was owed. Further,\n   CW2 confirmed that in other instances payors would withhold monthly payments that\n   ModivCare was expecting to offset the balance that ModivCare owed to the payor by\n   ModivCare as a result of the true-up process. Corroborating CW2, CW3 stated\n   ModivCare experienced significant disputes over risk corridors and profits, and\n   collectability issues related to the Company charging more for trips despite service\n   and technological shortcomings. CW3 explained that complaints about the shared risk\n   contracts resulted in payors refusing to pay for trips, delayed payments, states\n   capping profits, and lost contracts.\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 223 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 223 states legal\n\nconclusions to which no response from Defendants is required. Defendants further lack\n\nknowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations\n\nin Paragraph 223 and deny them on that basis. Defendants further deny that any alleged\n\nstatement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to one\n\ndefendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 223.\n\n      H.     ModivCare\u2019s 2Q2023 Form 10-Q on August 4, 2023\n\n224. On August 4, 2023, before the stock market opened for trading that day,\n   ModivCare filed with the SEC a Form 10-Q to report on the Company\u2019s financial and\n   operational results for its second quarter ended June 30, 2023 (the \u201c2Q2023 Form 10-\n   Q\u201d), which was signed by Defendant Sampson.\n\n\n\n\n                                           141\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 142 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare filed its Q2 FY2023 Form 10-Q with\n\nthe SEC on August 4, 2023, and that Mr. Sampson signed the filing. Except as expressly\n\nadmitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 224.\n\n225. The 2Q2023 Form 10-Q contained a section titled \u201cRisk Factors\u201d wherein the\n   Company represented that the risk factors enumerated in the ModivCare\u2019s FY2022\n   Form 10-K \u201cremain[ed] current in all material respects\u201d and affirmed that \u201cthere have\n   been no material changes from the risk factors disclosed in the Annual Report[,]\u201d\n   stating in relevant part:\n      The risks described under the caption \u201cRisk Factors\u201d in our Annual Report\n      on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2022 (the \u201cAnnual Report\u201d)\n      could materially and adversely affect our business, financial condition, and\n      results of operations, and could cause the trading price of our common\n      stock to decline. The discussion of the risks included under that caption\n      in our Annual Report remains current in all material respects, and\n      there have been no material changes from the risk factors disclosed\n      in the Annual Report. The risk factors that we have discussed do not\n      identify all risks that we face; our operations could also be affected by\n      factors that are not presently known to us or that we currently consider to\n      be immaterial to our operations. Due to risks and uncertainties, known and\n      unknown, our past financial results may not be a reliable indicator of future\n      performance and historical trends should not be used to anticipate results\n      or trends in future periods.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 225 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s Q2 FY2023\n\nForm 10-Q, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 225.\n\n226. The statement identified in \u00b6225 above was materially false, and misleading when\n   made, because, for the reasons outlined in \u00b6\u00b6181-182 above, the risks included in the\n   FY2022 Form 10-K had actualized and therefore, material changes had occurred.\n   Defendant Sampson had a duty to update the Company\u2019s risk factors in the 2Q2023\n   Form 10-Q to reflect material changes to its risk factors.\n\n\n\n\n                                          142\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 143 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 226 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 226.\n\n      I.     Deutsche Bank\u2019s 31st Annual Leveraged Finance Conference on\n             October 3, 2023\n\n227. On October 3, 2023, Defendant Sampson participated in the Deutsche Bank\u2019s 31st\n   Annual Leveraged Finance Conference on behalf of ModivCare. Notably, no oral\n   statement was made to warn investors that Sampson may make forward-looking\n   statements or to direct investors to any cautionary language.\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 227 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit that Mr.\n\nSampson participated in Deutsche Bank\u2019s 31st Annual Leveraged Finance Conference\n\non October 3, 2023 on behalf of ModivCare. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 227.\n\n228. During the conference session, Defendant Sampson responded to a question\n   about when risk sharing kicked in to address increased utilization, stating in relevant\n   part:\n      \u2026 And then this middle part, the 65% is the shared risk contract. And that\u2019s\n      the way actually I expect things to continue to move, more in line with\n      managed Medicaid, definitely in line with MA, is to have this focus on the\n      member and therefore these shared risk contracts. And the way these\n      shared risk contracts work are exactly that. Utilization and cost, no one\n      should be burdened in the wrong way, us or the customer. That\u2019s the\n      purpose of that. So if utilization goes way up, we\u2019re going to share in\n      that. If costs go up, we\u2019re going to share in that. And that\u2019s the way\n      these contracts work. And it\u2019s a good thing that we did that, especially\n      coming out of COVID, it really allows us to protect the downside that\n\n\n                                           143\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 144 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      we\u2019ve limited the upside if there\u2019s, God forbid, another COVID situation to\n      ensure that we are in a win-win relationship. So those are allowing us\n      to ensure that we -- as we come out of COVID, we\u2019re in a great space\n      to grow and maintain our margins on top of that.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 228 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 228\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from the October 3, 2023 Deutsche Bank conference, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that conference,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 228.\n\n229. Unsatisfied with Defendant Sampson\u2019s non-answer, the analyst pressed him again\n   on precisely when risk-sharing was triggered:\n                                  Philip Chickering\n                         Deutsche Bank AG, Research Division\n\n      And so you indicated that utilization was sort of a driver of the risk sharing\n      kicking in. Can you just confirm that? And then maybe can you just talk to\n      us about when do they kick in? Does utilization have to get to 12%, like it\n      was pre-COVID, before this sharing kicks in? Or where does that start to\n      have an impact?\n\n                                  L. Heath Sampson\n           CEO, President, Interim President of ModivCare Home & Director\n\n      . . . So it really is \u2013 there\u2019s no really big thresholds. We\u2019re asset thresholds\n      right now. So if utilization is going up on those shared risk contracts,\n      we\u2019re passing that through.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 229 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n\n                                           144\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 145 of 269\n\n\n\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 229\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from the October 3, 2023 Deutsche Bank conference, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that conference,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\nfurther lack information sufficient to admit or deny the reason for analyst questions.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 229.\n\n230. The analyst then pressed Sampson on whether the shared risk contracts protected\n   ModivCare at any utilization increase, regardless of magnitude. In response,\n   Defendant Sampson assured that the Company was protected under its shared risk\n   contracts, stating in relevant part: \u201cYes. So on the utilization, we\u2019re protected, right?\n   It\u2019s not going to be 25%. But yes, we\u2019re protected right now on all those shared\n   risk contracts and fee-for-service contracts.\u201d\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 230 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 230\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from the October 3, 2023 Deutsche Bank conference, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that conference,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 230.\n\n\n\n\n                                           145\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 146 of 269\n\n\n\n\n231. In response to the analyst\u2019s next question regarding \u201chow does the actual hedge\n   accrue to you[,]\u201d Defendant Sampson explained that the Company received true- up\n   payments within 3 to 6 month[s], stating in relevant part:\n      Yes. So it is. It\u2019s an increase in that PMPM. It basically is if utilization is\n      going up and we\u2019re doing more trips and we thought it\u2019s more\n      expensive to us, we\u2019re going to get paid on that. The reality is, and this\n      is one of the things, how it works is when that situation happens, it gets put\n      on the balance sheet, and then we\u2019ll collect it over the next 3 to 6\n      months. And the inverse is there. The other side, if it\u2019s too low, and this\n      was a big part of COVID, it actually gets put on the balance sheet as a\n      payable\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 231 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 231\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from the October 3, 2023 Deutsche Bank conference, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that conference,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 231.\n\n232. Again, the analyst pressed Sampson on whether there would \u201cbe an actual hedge\u201d\n   with the shared risk contracts. Sampson unequivocally stated \u201cyes\u201d:\n      Yes. No, exactly. That\u2019s the whole purpose of the contracts. Where it gets\n      to -- so an increase in utilization or trip volume for that matter, we\u2019re\n      protected on our contracts, the big dollars.\n\n      And that\u2019s -- and then as utilization goes up, our estimates on what we\u2019ve\n      given for \u2013 what\u2019s happening in 2024 assume that higher utilization, assume\n      that redetermination happen. So we feel really good about our initiatives\n      to have in place to offset those as well as get back to the strong\n      margins.\n\n\n\n                                           146\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 147 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 232 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 232\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from the October 3, 2023 Deutsche Bank conference, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that conference,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 232.\n\n233. The statements identified in \u00b6\u00b6228-232 above were each materially false and\n   misleading and/or omitted material facts necessary to make the statements therein\n   not false or misleading when made because ModivCare\u2019s shared risk contracts were\n   not \u201cwin-win\u201d and did not protect the Company\u2019s downside from increases in utilization\n   or costs such that the Company could grow and maintain its margins. ModivCare was\n   also not passing through increased utilization costs to customers. Defendant\n   Sampson also had no reasonable basis to suggest that the Company would collect its\n   contracts receivable balance \u201cover the next 3 to 6 months\u201d or to suggest he felt \u201creally\n   good about [ModivCare\u2019s] initiatives\u201d to offset costs and \u201cget back to the strong\n   margins.\u201d\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 233 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. Paragraph 233 also states legal conclusions to which no\n\nresponse from Defendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 233.\n\n\n\n                                           147\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 148 of 269\n\n\n\n\n234. The material falsity of Defendant Sampson\u2019s statements is supported by evidence.\n   CW2 confirmed, for example, that ModivCare\u2019s true-up process for the shared risk\n   contracts caused regular disputes with payors that dragged on for \u201ca very long time\u201d\n   because the Company billed payors based on internal projections of utilization and\n   claims data that did not match the payors\u2019 \u201cencounter data\u201d (i.e., actual claims) that\n   customers reported to the payors. As a result, CW2 confirmed ModivCare often was\n   forced to expend considerable efforts to chase contract receivables, subjected to\n   monthly liquidated damages of hundreds of thousands of dollars, and/or forced to\n   accept partial payment as a settlement for true-up disputes with payors. Beginning in\n   2023 and continuing throughout CW2\u2019s tenure, CW2 confirmed that Monthly\n   Leadership Meetings included regular updates \u201cmonth after month\u201d regarding\n   receivable dispute settlements that resulted in ModivCare receiving a fraction of what\n   was owed. Further, CW2 confirmed that in other instances payors would withhold\n   monthly payments that ModivCare was expecting to offset the balance that ModivCare\n   owed to the payor by ModivCare as a result of the true-up process. CW2 also added\n   that, at least as early as October 2023, Sunshine Health refused to pay ModivCare its\n   large receivables balance and withheld payments from the Company. Corroborating\n   CW2, CW3 stated ModivCare experienced significant disputes over risk corridors and\n   profits, and collectability issues related to the Company charging more for trips despite\n   service and technological shortcomings. CW3 explained that complaints about the\n   shared risk contracts resulted in payors refusing to pay for trips, delayed payments,\n   states capping profits, and lost contracts.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 234 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. Paragraph 234 also states legal conclusions to which no\n\nresponse from Defendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants\n\nlack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW\n\nallegations in Paragraph 234 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny\n\nthe allegations in Paragraph 234.\n\n\n\n                                            148\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 149 of 269\n\n\n\n\n235. Defendant Sampson\u2019s statement purporting to \u201cfeel really good about\n   [ModivCare\u2019s] initiatives\u201d ability to offset higher utilization and \u201cget back to the strong\n   margins\u201d (identified in \u00b6232 above) was also materially false and misleading, omitted\n   material facts necessary to make the statements therein not false or misleading when\n   made, and/or lacked a reasonable basis because, CW1 confirmed that ModivCare\u2019s\n   multi-modal initiative \u201cfared very poorly\u201d because payors\u2019 members disliked them. As\n   a result, according to CW1, the Company fell far short of achieving the stated metrics\n   associated with the initiative, including forecasted cost savings that \u201cnever really\n   transpired.\u201d CW3 likewise explained that multimodal trips with ride-share TNCs were\n   generally more expensive than traditional transportation providers, and other cost-\n   saving initiatives were hampered by on-time performance issues that resulted in the\n   Company paying its transportation providers 2-3 times more for trip acceptance.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 235 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. Paragraph 235 also states legal conclusions to which no\n\nresponse from Defendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants\n\nlack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW\n\nallegations in Paragraph 235 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny\n\nthe allegations in Paragraph 235.\n\n       J.     ModivCare\u2019s 3Q2023 Earnings Call on November 3, 2023\n\n236. On November 3, 2023, ModivCare held the 3Q2023 earnings call at 7:30 a.m. E.T.,\n   before the stock market opened for trading that day, to report on the Company\u2019s\n   financial and operational results for its third quarter ended September 30, 2023.\n   Defendant Sampson jointly presented with Defendant Gutierrez, and while speaking\n   on behalf of \u201cwe\u201d was referring to both himself and Gutierrez.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 236 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n\n                                            149\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 150 of 269\n\n\n\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 236 also states\n\nlegal conclusions to which no response from Defendants is required. Defendants admit\n\nthat ModivCare held an earnings call on November 3, 2023, and that Mr. Sampson and\n\nMs. Gutierrez participated in that call. Paragraph 236 characterizes or quotes from the\n\nNovember 3, 2023 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the\n\ncomplete recording of that earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations\n\ninconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny that any alleged statement, knowledge,\n\nconduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to\n\nanother. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph\n\n236.\n\n237. During his prepared remarks on the 3Q2023 Earnings Call, Defendant Sampson\n   emphasized the benefits of shared risk contracts, stating in relevant part: \u201cOur shared\n   risk contracts are operating effectively and as intended, safeguarding our gross\n   margins against the backdrop of increasing utilization and costs.\u201d\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 237 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 237\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s November 3, 2023 earnings call, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that earnings call,\n\n\n\n\n                                           150\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 151 of 269\n\n\n\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 237.\n\n238. When discussing the NEMT segment results in more detail during his prepared\n   remarks, Sampson stated that shared risk contracts allowed ModivCare to pass\n   through trip volume and costs as well as protect cash flow:\n      Over the past year, as we frequently pointed out, our mobility revenue has\n      been grossed up by passthrough trip volume and costs. This trend has\n      become increasingly evident as health care utilization returns to an\n      expected and normalized level. Although this may make challenge to\n      understand our percent margins within this pass-through revenue, our\n      shared risk contracts with the customers are protecting the downside\n      to our cash flow, creating a win-win situation for us and our customers.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 238 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 238\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s November 3, 2023 earnings call, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that earnings call,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 238.\n\n239. During the question-and-answer portion of the 3Q2023 Earnings Call, in response\n   to another analyst\u2019s question seeking clarity on ModivCare\u2019s contract payables,\n   contract receivables, and collection timing, Sampson represented that the Company\n   would have more normal variations between contract payables and receivables,\n   stating in relevant part:\n      But unlike in the past where we had to -- had a lot of payables because of\n      COVID, now they\u2019re at a more matching level.\n\n\n\n\n                                          151\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 152 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 239 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 239\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s November 3, 2023 earnings call, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that earnings call,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 239.\n\n240. Another analyst pressed Sampson on his confidence in ModivCare\u2019s ability to\n   sustainably deliver positive free cash flow, to which he responded by emphasizing the\n   \u201cwin-win\u201d nature of capitated shared risk contracts and the margin protection they\n   provide:\n      So really the item that all of you are looking at and that we should\n      continue to pay attention going forward, it\u2019s the mobility or an NEMT\n      margins. So the good thing for us because of all the work we\u2019ve done over\n      the last 18 months, 2 years, we have these contracts where we have a\n      win-win with our customers.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 240 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 240\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s November 3, 2023 earnings call, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that earnings call,\n\n\n\n\n                                          152\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 153 of 269\n\n\n\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 240.\n\n241. The statements identified in \u00b6\u00b6237-240 above were each materially false and\n   misleading and/or omitted material facts necessary to make the statements therein\n   not false or misleading when made because ModivCare\u2019s capitated shared risk\n   contracts were not: (i) \u201cwin-win[;]\u201d (ii) \u201coperating effectively and as intended[;]\u201d (iii)\n   \u201csafeguarding\u201d the Company\u2019s gross margins; or (iv) \u201cprotecting the downside to our\n   cash flow, creating a win-win situation for us and our customers.\u201d ModivCare was also\n   not passing increased costs through to its NEMT customers through its shared risk\n   contracts such that the Company\u2019s cash flow was protected from downside risk.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 241 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. Paragraph 241 also states legal conclusions to which no\n\nresponse from Defendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 241.\n\n242. The material falsity of Defendants Sampson\u2019s and Gutierrez\u2019s statements is\n   supported by evidence. CW2 confirmed, for example, that ModivCare\u2019s true-up\n   process for the shared risk contracts caused regular disputes with payors that dragged\n   on for \u201ca very long time\u201d because the Company billed payors based on internal\n   projections of utilization and claims data that did not match the payors\u2019 \u201cencounter\n   data\u201d (i.e., actual claims). As a result, CW2 confirmed ModivCare often was forced to\n   expend considerable efforts to chase contract receivables, subjected to monthly\n   liquidated damages of hundreds of thousands of dollars, and/or forced to accept\n   partial payment as a settlement for true-up disputes with payors. Beginning in 2023\n   and continuing throughout CW2\u2019s tenure, CW2 confirmed that Monthly Leadership\n   Meetings included regular updates \u201cmonth after month\u201d regarding receivable dispute\n   settlements that resulted in ModivCare receiving a fraction of what was owed. Further,\n   CW2 confirmed that in other instances payors would withhold monthly payments that\n   ModivCare was expecting to offset the balance that ModivCare owed to the payor by\n\n\n                                            153\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 154 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   ModivCare as a result of the true-up process. CW2 also added that, at least as early\n   as October 2023, Sunshine Health refused to pay ModivCare its large receivables\n   balance and withheld payments from the Company. Corroborating CW2, CW3 stated\n   ModivCare experienced significant disputes over risk corridors and profits, and\n   collectability issues related to the Company charging more for trips despite service\n   and technological shortcomings. CW3 explained that complaints about the shared risk\n   contracts resulted in payors refusing to pay for trips, delayed payments, states\n   capping profits, and lost contracts.\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 242 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. Paragraph 242 also states legal conclusions to which no\n\nresponse from Defendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants\n\nlack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW\n\nallegations in Paragraph 242 and deny them on that basis. Defendants further deny that\n\nany alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable\n\nto one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 242.\n\n      K.     ModivCare\u2019s 3Q2023 Form 10-Q on November 3, 2023\n\n243. On November 3, 2023, before the stock market opened for trading that day,\n   ModivCare filed with the SEC a Form 10-Q to report on the Company\u2019s financial and\n   operational results for its third quarter ended September 30, 2023 (the \u201c3Q2023 Form\n   10- Q\u201d). The 3Q2023 Form 10-Q was signed was signed by Sampson and Gutierrez.\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare filed its Q3 FY2023 Form 10-Q with\n\nthe SEC on November 3, 2023, and that Mr. Sampson and Ms. Gutierrez signed the filing.\n\nDefendants deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission\n\n\n                                          154\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 155 of 269\n\n\n\n\nallegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Except as expressly\n\nadmitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 243.\n\n244. The 3Q2023 Form 10-Q contained a section titled \u201cRisk Factors\u201d wherein the\n   Company represented that the risk factors enumerated in the ModivCare\u2019s FY2022\n   Form 10-K \u201cremain[ed] current in all material respects\u201d and affirmed that \u201cthere have\n   been no material changes from the risk factors disclosed in the Annual Report[,]\u201d\n   stating in relevant part:\n      The risks described under the caption \u201cRisk Factors\u201d in our Annual Report\n      on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2022 (the \u201cAnnual Report\u201d)\n      could materially and adversely affect our business, financial condition, and\n      results of operations, and could cause the trading price of our common\n      stock to decline. The discussion of the risks included under that caption\n      in our Annual Report remains current in all material respects, and\n      there have been no material changes from the risk factors disclosed\n      in the Annual Report. The risk factors that we have discussed do not\n      identify all risks that we face; our operations could also be affected by\n      factors that are not presently known to us or that we currently consider to\n      be immaterial to our operations. Due to risks and uncertainties, known and\n      unknown, our past financial results may not be a reliable indicator of future\n      performance and historical trends should not be used to anticipate results\n      or trends in future periods.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 244 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s Q3 FY2023\n\nForm 10-Q, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 244.\n\n245. The statement identified in \u00b6244 above was materially false, and misleading when\n   made, because the risks included in the FY2022 Form 10-K had actualized and\n   therefore, \u201cmaterial changes\u201d had occurred. Defendants Sampson and Gutierrez had\n   a duty to update the Company\u2019s risk factors in the 3Q2023 Form 10-Q to reflect\n   material changes to its risk factors. Indeed, at the time of the 3Q2023 Form 10-Q\n   statements: (i) ModivCare\u2019s shift to entering into more shared risk contracts was\n   already negatively, materially impacting the Company\u2019s operations and financial\n   condition; (ii) ModivCare was experiencing delays in payments and collecting its\n   accounts receivable that were extending the Company\u2019s collection period and already\n\n\n                                          155\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79      filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 156 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   having a materially adverse impact on the Company\u2019s business and consolidated\n   financial condition; and (iii) ModivCare was already experiencing an inability to adjust\n   costs under its shared risk contracts, utilization increases, and increased costs that\n   were having a materially adverse impact on the Company\u2019s results of operations and\n   profitability.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 245 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny that any\n\nalleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to\n\none defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 245.\n\n246. The material falsity of Defendants Sampson\u2019s and Gutierrez\u2019s statements is\n   supported by evidence. CW2 confirmed, for example, that ModivCare\u2019s true-up\n   process for the shared risk contracts caused regular disputes with payors that dragged\n   on for \u201ca very long time\u201d because the Company billed payors based on internal\n   projections of utilization and claims data that did not match the payors\u2019 \u201cencounter\n   data\u201d (i.e., actual claims). As a result, CW2 confirmed ModivCare often was forced to\n   expend considerable efforts to chase contract receivables, subjected to monthly\n   liquidated damages of hundreds of thousands of dollars, and/or forced to accept\n   partial payment as a settlement for true-up disputes with payors. Beginning in 2023\n   and continuing throughout CW2\u2019s tenure, CW2 confirmed that Monthly Leadership\n   Meetings included regular updates \u201cmonth after month\u201d regarding receivable dispute\n   settlements that resulted in ModivCare receiving a fraction of what was owed. Further,\n   CW2 confirmed that in other instances payors would withhold monthly payments that\n   ModivCare was expecting to offset the balance that ModivCare owed to the payor by\n   ModivCare as a result of the true up process. CW2 also added that, at least as early\n   as October 2023, Sunshine Health refused to pay ModivCare its large receivables\n   balance and withheld payments from the Company. Corroborating CW2, CW3 stated\n   ModivCare experienced significant disputes over risk corridors and profits, and\n   collectability issues related to the Company charging more for trips despite service\n   and technological shortcomings. CW3 explained that complaints about the shared risk\n   contracts resulted in payors refusing to pay for trips, delayed payments, states\n   capping profits, and lost contracts.\n\n\n\n\n                                           156\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 157 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 246 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n246 and deny them on that basis. Defendants further deny that any alleged statement,\n\nknowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is\n\nattributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 246.\n\n       L.     Bank of America Securities\u2019 2023 \u2013 Leveraged Finance Conference on\n              November 28, 2023\n\n247. On November 28, 2023, Defendants Sampson and Gutierrez participated in the\n   Bank of America Securities\u2019 2023 Leveraged Finance Conference on behalf of\n   ModivCare. Defendant Sampson jointly presented with Defendant Gutierrez, and\n   while speaking on behalf of \u201cwe\u201d was referring to both himself and Gutierrez. Notably,\n   no oral statement was made to warn investors that Sampson may make forward-\n   looking statements or to direct investors to any cautionary language.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 247 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. Paragraph 247 also states legal conclusions to which no\n\nresponse from Defendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants\n\nadmit that Mr. Sampson and Ms. Gutierrez participated in the Bank of America Securities\n\n2023 Leveraged Finance Conference on November 28, 2023 on behalf of ModivCare.\n\nParagraph 247 characterizes or quotes from the November 28, 2023 Bank of America\n\nSecurities conference, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete\n\nrecording from that conference, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations\n\n\n\n                                            157\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS           Document 79        filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 158 of 269\n\n\n\n\ninconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny that any alleged statement, knowledge,\n\nconduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to\n\nanother. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph\n\n247.\n\n248. During the question-and-answer portion of the conference session, when asked by\n   an analyst about ModivCare\u2019s NEMT contract mix and the impact on margins,\n   Defendant Sampson touted the Company\u2019s shift toward capitated shared risk\n   contracts and its overall contract mix:\n       Yes. So the NEMT or nonemergency medical transportation or mobility\n       business segment, which is just over 60% of our EBITDA is a critical part\n       for our business, and there -- over these last 24 months and really over the\n       last 12 months, there\u2019s been a shift in how we engage with our customers\n       and how we contract with our customers. And it really gets back in line with\n       the strategy of where our customers want to go. It really is, the trip is\n       important, critically important to health care. So ensuring that we do that\n       with the right quality is important, but really, it\u2019s what you do more. And that\u2019s\n       what we\u2019re doing now.\n\n       And that\u2019s why we\u2019re able to move these contracts to where 20% are full\n       risk, so more of the traditional capitated model, 15% are fee-for-service.\n       And in the middle of that is the shared risk or win-win, where utilization\n       or costs we share in that with our customers. And that\u2019s the common\n       way now of contracts we do primarily with managed Medicaid. So that mix,\n       I expect to stay -- it shifted a lot over the last 12 months. I expect it to be in\n       line for at least the next, call it, 12 to 24 months. So we\u2019re at the right\n       structure. We have the right profile. We have the right relationships in\n       all our contracts that we have, whether that\u2019s full risk fee-for-service\n       or managed Medicaid, all in line with our expectations now. Now that\n       we\u2019re through COVID. That was a bigger push, right?\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 248 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 248\n\n\n                                             158\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 159 of 269\n\n\n\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from the November 28, 2023 Bank of America Securities\n\nconference, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from\n\nthat conference, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 248.\n\n249. At the same conference, an analyst asked (as stated below in pertinent part)\n   whether, based on almost even contract receivables and payables, ModivCare\u2019s cash\n   flow structure was normalized after COVID-19:\n                           Bank of America Securities Analyst\n\n      \u2026I think contracts, receivables, payables netting to zero more or less now.\n      So would we see a more normalized cash flow structure if -- the way we\n      think about it into \u201824 and beyond? Kind of that COVID, I don\u2019t call it COVID,\n      but the bubble, if you will.\n\n                                  L. Heath Sampson\n           CEO, President, Interim President of ModivCare Home & Director\n\n      Yes. And so the bubble is behind us. It really was Q2 for us, right?\n      From a COVID -- paying off COVID payables, that was a big driver as well\n      as our contracts were structured the right way and receivables up. So\n      it was a -- Q2 was the bubble.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 249 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 249\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from the November 28, 2023 Bank of America Securities\n\nconference, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from\n\nthat conference, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 249.\n\n\n                                           159\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 160 of 269\n\n\n\n\n250. The statements identified in \u00b6\u00b6248-249 above were each materially false and\n   misleading and/or omitted material facts necessary to make the statements therein\n   not false or misleading when made because ModivCare\u2019s shared risk contracts were\n   not \u201cwin-win\u201d nor was the Company sharing utilization and costs with its customers.\n   Defendants Sampson and Gutierrez also had no reasonable basis to suggest that the\n   Company\u2019s contracts were \u201cstructured the right way\u201d and with \u201creceivables up[,]\u201dor that\n   the COVID-19 bubble was limited to Q2 and \u201cbehind\u201d ModivCare.\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 250 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. Paragraph 250 also states legal conclusions to which no\n\nresponse from Defendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants\n\ndeny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly\n\nattributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 250.\n\n251. The material falsity of Defendants Sampson\u2019s and Gutierrez\u2019s statements is\n   supported by evidence. CW2 confirmed, for example, that ModivCare\u2019s true-up\n   process for the shared risk contracts caused regular disputes with payors that dragged\n   on for \u201ca very long time\u201d because the Company billed payors based on internal\n   projections of utilization and claims data that did not match the payors\u2019 \u201cencounter\n   data\u201d (i.e., actual claims). As a result, CW2 confirmed ModivCare often was forced to\n   expend considerable efforts to chase contract receivables, subjected to monthly\n   liquidated damages of hundreds of thousands of dollars, and/or forced to accept\n   partial payment as a settlement for true-up disputes with payors. Beginning in 2023\n   and continuing throughout CW2\u2019s tenure, CW2 confirmed that Monthly Leadership\n   Meetings included regular updates \u201cmonth after month\u201d regarding receivable dispute\n   settlements that resulted in ModivCare receiving a fraction of what was owed. Further,\n   CW2 confirmed that in other instances payors would withhold monthly payments that\n   ModivCare was expecting to offset the balance that ModivCare owed to the payor by\n   ModivCare as a result of the true up process. CW2 also added that, at least as early\n\n\n                                           160\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 161 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   as October 2023, Sunshine Health refused to pay ModivCare its large receivables\n   balance and withheld payments from the Company. Corroborating CW2, CW3 stated\n   ModivCare experienced significant disputes over risk corridors and profits, and\n   collectability issues related to the Company charging more for trips despite service\n   and technological shortcomings. CW3 explained that complaints about the shared risk\n   contracts resulted in payors refusing to pay for trips, delayed payments, states\n   capping profits, and lost contracts.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 251 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. Paragraph 251 also states legal conclusions to which no\n\nresponse from Defendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants\n\nlack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW\n\nallegations in Paragraph 251 and deny them on that basis. Defendants further deny that\n\nany alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable\n\nto one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 251.\n\n       M.     Defendants\u2019 Partially Reveal the Truth in ModivCare\u2019s FY2023 Press\n              Release and During the FY2023 Earnings Call on February 23, 2024\n              But Continue Making False and Misleading Statements\n\n              1.     Defendants\u2019 Partially Reveal the Truth in ModivCare\u2019s FY2023\n                     Press Release and During the FY2023 Earnings Call\n\n252. On February 22, 2024, after the market closed, ModivCare published a press\n   release announcing the Company\u2019s financial results for the three months and full year\n   ended December 31, 2023 on its website and concurrently filed it with the SEC on\n   Form 8-K, signed by Defendant Sampson (the \u201cFY2023 Press Release\u201d). The FY2023\n   Press Release disclosed disappointing financial results, including: (i) a net loss of $5.3\n\n\n\n                                            161\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 162 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   million and $2,751.2 million for 4Q2023 and FY2023, respectively; (ii) negative free\n   cash flow of $36.8 million for 4Q2023 \u201cprimarily related to a delayed payment from a\n   single client\u201d and negative free cash flow of $125.3 million for FY2023; and (iii) that\n   contract receivables increased by $14.7 million to $144.0 million and contract\n   payables decreased by $16.1 million to $117.5 million, resulting in net contract\n   receivables of $26.5 million as of December 31, 2023.\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare issued a press release on February\n\n22, 2024 and filed a Form 8-K with the SEC announcing its financial results for Q4 FY2023\n\nand FY2023, and that Mr. Sampson signed the Form 8-K. Paragraph 252 characterizes\n\nor quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 22, 2024 press release and Form 8-K, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete documents, which speak for\n\nthemselves, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly\n\nadmitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 252.\n\n253. In another press release filed with the SEC on Form 8-K on the same day,\n   ModivCare announced that it entered into a second amendment to its February 3,\n   2022 credit agreement. The Company further revealed in the FY2023 Press Release\n   that ModivCare drew $113.8 million on its revolving credit facility. ModivCare added\n   in the FY2023 Press Release that it had encountered \u201csome near-term financial\n   headwinds, due to sooner than anticipated, large COVID-related working capital\n   needs and margin pressure in our NEMT segment.\u201d\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare issued press releases on February\n\n22, 2024 regarding its second amendment to its February 3, 2022 credit agreement and\n\nregarding its financial results for Q4 FY2023 and FY2023. Paragraph 253 characterizes\n\nor quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 22, 2024 press releases, and Defendants\n\nrespectfully refer the Court to the complete documents, which speak for themselves, and\n\ndeny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 253.\n\n\n\n                                          162\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 163 of 269\n\n\n\n\n254. On February 23, 2024, ModivCare held an earnings call at 8:30 a.m. E.T., before\n   the stock market opened for trading that day, to report on the Company\u2019s financial and\n   operational results for its fourth quarter and full year ended December 31, 2023\n   (\u201cFY2023 Earnings Call\u201d), in which Defendants Sampson and Gutierrez participated.\n   Defendants Sampson and Gutierrez jointly presented the FY2023 Earnings Call, and\n   while speaking on behalf of \u201cwe\u201d were each referring to both themself and the other.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 254 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit that\n\nModivCare held an earnings call on February 23, 2024 and that Mr. Sampson and Ms.\n\nGutierrez participated in that call. Paragraph 254 characterizes or quotes from\n\nModivCare\u2019s February 23, 2024 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court\n\nto the complete recording from that earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any\n\nallegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny that any alleged statement,\n\nknowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is\n\nattributable to another. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 254.\n\n255. During the FY2023 Earnings Call, Defendant Sampson elaborated further as to the\n   Company\u2019s \u201cchallenges...stemming from the recovery period following the pandemic[,]\u201d\n   stating in relevant part:\n      Before addressing the transformation progress we\u2019ve made, I\u2019d like to\n      address some of the challenges we\u2019ve encountered primarily\n      stemming from the recovery period following the pandemic. Firstly,\n      our free cash flow for the fourth quarter was negative $37 million,\n      which was below expectations, primarily due to delay in payment from\n      an MCO client within a specific contract in Florida. Looking ahead, and\n      primarily to us managing redetermination and the increased healthcare\n      utilization environment, we anticipate our free cash flow for the first half of\n      the year will be constrained to the ongoing build in contract receivables and\n      the settlement of several large payables expected in the second quarter.\n\n\n\n\n                                           163\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 164 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 255 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23,\n\n2024 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording\n\nfrom that earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 255.\n\n256. Sampson nevertheless assured that ModivCare would collect its contract\n   receivables balance over time and revealed that the Company had been renegotiating\n   prepayment terms on certain shared risk contracts, stating in relevant part:\n      It\u2019s important to note that our $144 million balance in contract receivables is\n      an asset that we aim to collect in 6 months to 9 months. Consistent with\n      what we have been doing the last several months, we are proactively\n      working to renegotiate the prepayment terms on a number of our\n      shared risk contracts. This realigns the payments we eventually\n      reconcile as redetermination unfolds and utilization and cost\n      normalize higher, post the pandemic. This will improve our working\n      capital by securing more cash upfront. For the second half of 2024, our free\n      cash flow will begin to normalize as redetermination ends.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 256 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23,\n\n2024 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording\n\nfrom that earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 256.\n\n257. Sampson next discussed ModivCare\u2019s 2024 adjusted EBITDA guidance and\n   revealed that the Company had lost contracts, stating in relevant part:\n      Next, I want to share our 2024 adjusted EBITDA guidance, which we expect\n      will be in a range of $190 million to $210 million, and our first quarter 2024\n      adjust EBITDA guidance in a range of $28 million to $33 million. We are\n      guiding first quarter EBITDA to help explain the ramp in the second half of\n      the year. During the first quarter, we are addressing headwinds from a\n      couple of contracts and membership losses prior to the 2023 contract\n      wins starting implementation in the second quarter. These front loaded\n      challenges are further impacted by the ongoing normalization of healthcare\n      utilization and Medicaid redetermination.\n\n      The root causes of these contract losses include a few MCO clients not\n\n\n                                           164\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 165 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      securing their state contracts. A state health department\u2019s decision to\n      transition to a full broker model favoring an incumbent competitor,\n      and a client\u2019s decision to diversify volume away from us due to legacy\n      issues. However, it\u2019s important to note that these legacy issues have been\n      addressed through our transformation, and I\u2019m proud of my team for doing\n      that.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 257 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23,\n\n2024 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording\n\nfrom that earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 257.\n\n258. In her prepared remarks, Defendant Gutierrez also partially revealed the truth that\n   capitated shared risk contracts did not protect NEMT margins or provide the Company\n   with more predictable cash flow, stating in relevant part:\n      Full year 2023 adjusted EBITDA was $204 million and adjusted EBITDA\n      margin was 7.4%, a 140 basis point year-over-year decline, primarily due\n      to higher service expense partially offset by lower G&A related to our cost\n      saving initiatives. Full year gross margin decreased 270 basis points to\n      16.4%, primarily attributable to higher NEMT purchase services\n      expense driven by higher utilization and the normalizing healthcare\n      utilization environment.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 258 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 258\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23, 2024 earnings call, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that earnings call,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 258.\n\n259. Defendant Gutierrez also reiterated that, for 4Q2023, ModivCare\u2019s \u201cnet cash used\n   in operating activities was approximately $26 million and free cash flow was negative\n   $37 million as quarter-over-quarter contract receivables increased approximately $15\n   million and contract payables decreased $16 million.\u201d Gutierrez added that:\n\n\n\n                                           165\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 166 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      Our free cash flow for the fourth quarter of 2023 was less than we\n      originally anticipated, primarily attributable to delayed payments\n      under multiple contracts from one of our large MCO clients, which we\n      expect to collect in the coming months.\n\n      The net contract receivable and payable balance at the end of the fourth\n      quarter was $27 million, which was in line with our previously stated range\n      of $20 million to $30 million. The primary fluctuations in our quarterly\n      working capital are driven by the shared risk contracts with our NEMT\n      clients, with payments and reconciliations occurring over varying time\n      periods.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 259 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23,\n\n2024 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording\n\nfrom that earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 259.\n\n260. Guiterrez\u2019s statements disclosing that decreasing gross margins related to\n   increased NEMT purchase services expense, delayed payments, and fluctuations in\n   the working capital due to the shared risk contracts partially corrected Defendants\u2019\n   misstatements representing that ModivCare\u2019s shared risk contracts were protecting\n   the Company against downside risk of higher costs, contributing to the rigidness of\n   ModivCare\u2019s margin profile, and that the NEMT strategic initiatives, specifically the\n   multi- modal transportation partnership, were reducing costs.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 260 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 260\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23, 2024 earnings call, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that earnings call,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\nfurther deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission\n\nallegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 260.\n\n\n\n                                           166\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 167 of 269\n\n\n\n\n261. Gutierrez continued to provide additional detail on the Company\u2019s lower than\n   anticipated cash flow, noting that \u201c[t]he confluence of increasing utilization, Medicaid\n   redetermination and higher shared risk revenue is creating a temporary challenge in\n   working capital\u201d (i.e., ModivCare\u2019s capitated contracts were heavily weighted towards\n   shared risk and the variability in timing of payments and reconciliations was pressuring\n   the Company\u2019s financials):\n       Since our business has undergone a significant transformation, coupled\n       with the impact of redetermination and a normalizing healthcare utilization\n       backdrop, we expect continued variability in our quarterly cash flow with\n       improvement occurring in the second half of 2024. While free cash flow is\n       expected to improve meaningfully in 2024, going from negative $125 million\n       in 2023 to a range of $40 million to $60 million in 2024, we expect that free\n       cash flow in the first half of 2024 will be negative with a positive exit rate\n       into 2025.\n\n       The confluence of increasing utilization, Medicaid redetermination\n       and higher shared risk revenue is creating a temporary challenge in\n       working capital. As we work with clients to reset the contractual\n       prepayments to more closely align with recent utilization trends, we\n       are continuing to build contract receivables. We also expect to repay\n       certain contract payables in the second quarter of 2024. The tension on\n       free cash flow will be partially offset by collections on contract receivables\n       and improvements from resetting prepayment rates. However, we expect\n       the full benefit of these items to be weighted in the second half of the year.\n\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 261 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23,\n\n2024 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording\n\nfrom that earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 261.\n\n262.   Gutierrez then summarized ModivCare\u2019s FY2023 results, stating in relevant part:\n       In summary, our fourth quarter revenue and adjusted EBITDA results were\n       in line with our expectations. However, free cash flow was lower than we\n       expected due to the timing of collections under multiple contracts\n       from one of our MCO clients. To reiterate what Heath said, we expect to\n       exit 2024 with a run rate for adjusted EBITDA between $220 million to $230\n       million, and free cash flow will improve materially in the second half of 2024\n       with a high cash flow conversion rate.\n\n\n\n                                            167\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 168 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 262 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23,\n\n2024 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording\n\nfrom that earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 262.\n\n263. In providing further detail on ModivCare\u2019s purportedly temporary working capital\n   challenges and collection issues, Gutierrez\u2019s statements partially corrected\n   Defendants\u2019 statements assuring that the Company\u2019s cash flow was more predictable,\n   working capital had normalized, and that collection of receivables and payables were\n   fluctuating normally in 2023.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 263 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 263\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23, 2024 earnings call, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that earnings call,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\nfurther deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission\n\nallegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 263.\n\n264. During the question-and-answer portion of the FY2023 Earnings Call, in response\n   to an analyst\u2019s questions about ModivCare\u2019s contracts losses, Sampson assured that\n   legacy issues were resolved through the Company\u2019s multi-modal transformation,\n   stating in relevant part:\n                                Brooks Gregory O\u2019Neil\n                  Lake Street Capital Markets, LLC, Research Division\n\n      That\u2019s helpful. So let\u2019s just talk briefly about the NEMT, really, in\n      particular the contract losses, which I think are relatively unexpected.\n      Obviously, some factors are beyond your control, but if you could highlight\n      nicely on the factors you see or have heard from customers that are driving\n      contract losses? And then just highlight quickly, what do you think you could\n\n\n\n                                           168\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 169 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      do to fix those problems?\n\n                                  L. Heath Sampson\n           CEO, President, Interim President of ModivCare Home & Director\n\n      Well, so since I took over in November of 2022, the focus quickly shifted to\n      our customers. And our customers that are specific to MA that are managed\n      Medicaid and of course our state customers. And they actually all have\n      different needs. And then you layer on what they\u2019re actually going through,\n      whether that\u2019s because of the RADV rules that CMS came out with on\n      Medicare, or whether that\u2019s the increased focus of SDoH within Medicaid\n      and then even within the state related bids, the requirement of innovation to\n      do more free members.\n\n      My point on that is what was in the past is different now from a customer\n      expectation. For sure, you need to have the right quality, pick people up on\n      time, have lower complaints, but you need to do more than that. And then\n      you even need to start integrating with the customer to ensure that they can\n      properly manage the member experience or integrate with a facility so they\n      can book the trip on behalf. All those items have been part of our\n      transformation.\n\n      You look back a year ago, even 2 years ago, some of that, we weren\u2019t\n      -- we weren\u2019t where we needed it to be. And that gets to -- and this is why\n      I have a lot of conviction around what we\u2019ve done, because of what the team\n      has done. Those issues that we had around quality are gone. In fact, we\u2019re\n      back to best-in-class. Integrating with our customers so they can control the\n      membership. Member experience is happening now. Having an\n      understanding of that member, so you know that whether they made their\n      dialysis trip 3 times, so we can communicate that, we\u2019re doing that now. So\n      all the stuff that we are in the place that we\u2019re in now, we didn\u2019t have before.\n      And that\u2019s a big reason why some of our competitors were able to get\n      in. And it\u2019s a driver for one of the reasons why we lost part of that\n      contract before.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 264 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23,\n\n2024 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording\n\nfrom that earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 264.\n\n\n\n\n                                           169\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 170 of 269\n\n\n\n\n265. Defendant Sampson\u2019s statements starkly contrasted Defendants\u2019 prior statements\n   representing that ModivCare was \u201cmeeting or exceeding all our customers\u2019 quality and\n   service levels\u201d and that its strategic initiatives had already \u201cled to increased customer\n   satisfaction[.]\u201d\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 265 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 265\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23, 2024 earnings call, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that earnings call,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\nfurther deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission\n\nallegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 265.\n\n266. Another analyst pressed Sampson on whether there was a \u201cmaterial disagreement\n   between the parties in terms of what\u2019s actually owed\u201d during the FY2023 Earnings\n   Call. Defendant Sampson punted on the question and instead pointed to the purported\n   complexity of the shared risk contracts, stating in relevant part:\n       Well, so, it\u2019s -- all of our contracts that are with shared risk, this is why\n       they reconcile over many months. So it\u2019s complicated. But we\u2019ve been\n       under this contract with this customer. Well, one, they\u2019ve been a longtime\n       customer of ours many, many years. And this contract structure started in\n       late 2022. So we feel really good about the math and the collection of the\n       entire amount. It\u2019s in line with the requirements of the contract. So we\u2019ll\n       collect it within the next 60 days or so.\n\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 266 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 266\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23, 2024 earnings call, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that earnings call,\n\n\n\n\n                                            170\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 171 of 269\n\n\n\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 266.\n\n267. Upon the news, ModivCare\u2019s stock price declined approximately 39% from $43.87\n   per share at close on February 22, 2024 to $26.62 per share at close on February 23,\n   2024 on heavy trading volume of approximately 1.75 million shares, as compared to\n   the previous day of 86,499 shares.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 267 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit and allege\n\nthat ModivCare\u2019s earnings and stock prices at various times are matters of public record\n\nand deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly admitted,\n\nDefendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 267.\n\n             2.     Defendants Continue Making False and Statements During the\n                    FY2023 Earnings Call\n\n268. During the FY2023 Earnings Call, Defendants Sampson and Gutierrez, who were\n   jointly presenting and referring to both themselves and the other when speaking on\n   behalf of \u201cwe,\u201d continued to make materially misleading statements.\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 268 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 268 states legal\n\nconclusions to which no response from Defendants is required. Paragraph 268 also\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23, 2024 earnings call, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that earnings call,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\n\n\n                                          171\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 172 of 269\n\n\n\n\nfurther deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission\n\nallegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 268.\n\n269. For instance, during her prepared remarks on the FY2023 Earnings Call,\n   Defendant Gutierrez assured investors that, in addition to producing higher NEMT\n   revenue, capitated shared risk contracts protected NEMT margins from higher\n   utilization and redetermination, stating:\n      As a reminder, our margins are protected from increased utilization\n      from redetermination on our shared risk contracts. Our shared risk\n      Medicaid contracts accounted for approximately 60% of our NEMT revenue\n      in 2023. Even though we\u2019ll lose some Medicaid members in these contracts,\n      we expect higher pass through revenue under our shared risk contracts.\n      Finally, the remainder of NEMT revenue, approximately 20% is generated\n      from Medicaid advantage and fee-for-service arrangements.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 269 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 269\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23, 2024 earnings call. Defendants\n\nrespectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that earnings call, which speaks\n\nfor itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 269.\n\n270. During the question-and-answer portion of the FY2023 Earnings Call, in response\n   to an analyst\u2019s question regarding the \u201cthe shortfall on the NEMT outlook\u201d and whether\n   there was a \u201ccost issue\u201d influencing it, Defendant Sampson stated that capitated\n   shared risk contracts would not only protect, but improve ModivCare\u2019s NEMT margins:\n      \u2026So, which gets to why I have a lot -- why we gave the guidance as an exit.\n      A lot of it has to do with our conviction around the cost and we\u2019re seeing in\n\n\n                                           172\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 173 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      the data, and I expect to continue. Just to summarize again that the\n      headwinds were in the short-term are to do with redetermination and\n      utilization, and then those mismatching of the contract losses to the\n      onboarding of the win. So with that clarity and with the cost structure that\n      we\u2019re taking out, you put that to our scale, we\u2019re in a really good spot as\n      we exit this year.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 270 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 270\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23, 2024 earnings call, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that earnings call,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 270.\n\n271. The statements identified in \u00b6\u00b6269-270 above were each materially false and\n   misleading and/or omitted material facts necessary to make the statements therein\n   not false or misleading when made because ModivCare\u2019s shared risk contracts did\n   not protect the Company from increased utilization and redetermination. Defendants\n   Gutierrez and Sampson also had no reasonable basis to suggest that ModivCare\u2019s\n   \u201cheadwinds\u201d were \u201cshort-term\u201d and only related to \u201credetermination and utilization\u201d or\n   that the Company was \u201cin a really good spot as we exit this year.\u201d\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 271 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. Paragraph 271 also states legal conclusions to which no\n\n\n\n\n                                          173\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 174 of 269\n\n\n\n\nresponse from Defendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants\n\ndeny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly\n\nattributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 271.\n\n272. The material falsity of Defendants Sampson\u2019s and Gutierrez\u2019s statements is\n   supported by evidence. CW2 confirmed, for example, that ModivCare\u2019s true-up\n   process for the shared risk contracts caused regular disputes with payors that dragged\n   on for \u201ca very long time\u201d because the Company billed payors based on internal\n   projections of utilization and claims data that did not match the payors\u2019 \u201cencounter\n   data\u201d (i.e., actual claims). As a result, CW2 confirmed ModivCare often was forced to\n   expend considerable efforts to chase contract receivables, subjected to monthly\n   liquidated damages of hundreds of thousands of dollars, and/or forced to accept\n   partial payment as a settlement for true-up disputes with payors. Beginning in 2023\n   and continuing throughout CW2\u2019s tenure, CW2 confirmed that Monthly Leadership\n   Meetings included regular updates \u201cmonth after month\u201d regarding receivable dispute\n   settlements that resulted in ModivCare receiving a fraction of what was owed. Further,\n   CW2 confirmed that in other instances payors would withhold monthly payments that\n   ModivCare was expecting to offset the balance that ModivCare owed to the payor by\n   ModivCare as a result of the true-up process. CW2 also added that, at least as early\n   as October 2023, Sunshine Health refused to pay ModivCare its large receivables\n   balance and withheld payments from the Company. Corroborating CW2, CW3 stated\n   ModivCare experienced significant disputes over risk corridors and profits, and\n   collectability issues related to the Company charging more for trips despite service\n   and technological shortcomings. CW3 explained that complaints about the shared risk\n   contracts resulted in payors refusing to pay for trips, delayed payments, states\n   capping profits, and lost contracts.\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 272 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. Paragraph 272 also states legal conclusions to which no\n\n\n\n                                          174\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 175 of 269\n\n\n\n\nresponse from Defendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants\n\nlack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW\n\nallegations in Paragraph 272 and deny them on that basis. Defendants further deny that\n\nany alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable\n\nto one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 272.\n\n273. During his prepared remarks on the FY2023 Earnings Call, Defendant Sampson\n   assured investors that NEMT contract losses were due to legacy issues that were no\n   longer present:\n      The root causes of these contract losses include a few MCO clients not\n      securing their state contracts. A state health department\u2019s decision to\n      transition to a full broker model favoring an incumbent competitor, and a\n      client\u2019s decision to diversify volume away from us due to legacy issues.\n      However, it\u2019s important to note that these legacy issues have been\n      addressed through our transformation, and I\u2019m proud of my team for\n      doing that.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 273 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 273\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23, 2024 earnings call, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that earnings call,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 273.\n\n\n\n\n                                          175\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 176 of 269\n\n\n\n\n274. Another analyst questioned what factors were driving the Company\u2019s contract\n   losses. In response, Sampson represented that ModivCare\u2019s quality issues were\n   \u201cgone[,]\u201d stating in relevant part:\n                               Brooks Gregory O\u2019Neil\n                 Lake Street Capital Markets, LLC, Research Division\n\n      That\u2019s helpful. So let\u2019s just talk briefly about the NEMT, really, in particular\n      the contract losses, which I think are relatively unexpected. Obviously,\n      some factors are beyond your control, but if you could highlight nicely on\n      the factors you see or have heard from customers that are driving\n      contract losses? And then just highlight quickly, what do you think you\n      could do to fix those problems?\n\n                                  L. Heath Sampson\n           CEO, President, Interim President of ModivCare Home & Director\n\n      \u2026My point on that is what was in the past is different now from a customer\n      expectation. For sure, you need to have the right quality, pick people up on\n      time, have lower complaints, but you need to do more than that. And then\n      you even need to start integrating with the customer to ensure that they can\n      properly manage the member experience or integrate with a facility so they\n      can book the trip on behalf. All those items have been part of our\n      transformation.\n\n      You look back a year ago, even 2 years ago, some of that, we weren\u2019t -- we\n      weren\u2019t where we needed it to be. And that gets to -- and this is why I have\n      a lot of conviction around what we\u2019ve done, because of what the team has\n      done. Those issues that we had around quality are gone. In fact, we\u2019re\n      back to best-in-class. Integrating with our customers so they can control\n      the membership. Member experience is happening now. Having an\n      understanding of that member, so you know that whether they made their\n      dialysis trip 3 times, so we can communicate that, we\u2019re doing that now. So\n      all the stuff that we are in the place that we\u2019re in now, we didn\u2019t have before.\n      And that\u2019s a big reason why some of our competitors were able to get in.\n      And it\u2019s a driver for one of the reasons why we lost part of that contract\n      before.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 274 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\n\n\n\n                                           176\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 177 of 269\n\n\n\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 274\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23, 2024 earnings call, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that earnings call,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 274.\n\n275. During the same call, in response to an analyst\u2019s question regarding the timing for\n   collecting a delayed payment and whether there were any issues between what the\n   customer thought it \u201cshould pay versus what you guys have recognized[,]\u201d Defendant\n   Sampson\u2014speaking on behalf of himself and Defendant Guiterrez\u2014 assured that\n   ModivCare would be paid and that its relationship was on solid ground, stating in\n   relevant part:\n      Yes. We wanted to be specific that it was one contract and one area\n      because we have a lot of relationships with that payer across the country,\n      which we are in great standing. This specific issue has not been paid at\n      the same time, why I said the next couple of months is because we will\n      get it paid because it\u2019s contractually owed. So I wanted to make sure I set\n      it because it was the main driver for the cash flow change in Q4. But I also\n      wanted to be explicit about it and give the amount because it\u2019s contractually\n      owed and we\u2019ll get it paid within the next kind of 60 days.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 275 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. Paragraph 275 also states legal conclusions to which no\n\nresponse from Defendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph\n\n275 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23, 2024 earnings call, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that earnings call,\n\n\n\n                                          177\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 178 of 269\n\n\n\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\nfurther deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission\n\nallegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 275.\n\n276. The statements identified in \u00b6\u00b6273-275 above were each materially false and\n   misleading and/or omitted material facts necessary to make the statements therein\n   not false or misleading when made because ModivCare\u2019s \u201clegacy issues\u201d had not\n   been \u201caddressed through [the Company\u2019s] transformation[.]\u201d The Company\u2019s service\n   levels were also not back to best in class nor were the quality issues gone. Defendants\n   Sampson and Guiterrez also had no reasonable basis to suggest that ModivCare\n   would receive payment from the Florida-based client \u201cwithin the next kind of 60 days.\u201d\n   The material falsity of Defendant Sampson\u2019s statements is supported by ample\n   evidence given that:\n\n       a.     CW1 stated that ModivCare\u2019s service quality started to decline around April\n2022. CW1 also confirmed that ModivCare had \u201cstruggles to keep the payors happy\u201d\nbeginning around 1Q2022 and the Company received an increase in complaints,\nincluding driver miscommunications and untimely pickups, from payors\u2019 members around\nMay or June 2022. As a result, CW1 confirmed that, throughout the last year of CW1\u2019s\nemployment, ModivCare was failing to meet targets for its member satisfaction KPIs.\nCW1 further confirmed that service issues resulted in a lot of problems with the Big 6 and\npayors \u201cabsolutely\u201d refused to pay or delayed payments due to ModivCare\u2019s service\nissues.\n\n       b.    CW1 stated that, during the last year of CW1\u2019s tenure, ModivCare began\nlosing NEMT customers around August 2022 due to service complaints. CW1 also\nconfirmed that NEMT de-implementations were \u201ccommon\u201d during the last year of CW1\u2019s\ntenure due to poor service quality and service complaints. Corroborating CW1, CW2\nconfirmed that contract attrition was an issue in multiple regions and remained an issue\nthroughout CW2\u2019s tenure.\n\n      c.     CW3 stated that customer advocate staffing cuts greatly diminished\nModivCare\u2019s ability to address service issues because the Company\u2019s GPS tracking and\ndynamic reassignment technologies \u201cwere plagued by bugs\u201d throughout CW3\u2019s tenure\nand could not fulfill these capabilities without human intervention. As a result, according\nto CW3, payors consistently expressed dissatisfaction, particularly around no shows and\n\n\n                                           178\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 179 of 269\n\n\n\n\non-time performance, which continued throughout CW3\u2019s tenure.\n\n       d.     CW3 stated that missed appointments and no-shows were significant\nservice issues that ModivCare had throughout CW3\u2019s tenure but did not improve on. CW3\nadded that ModivCare consistently failed to meet KPIs, including on-time performance\nand NVAs (which caused missed rides), throughout CW3\u2019s tenure.\n\n        e.     CW1 confirmed that ModivCare\u2019s multi-modal initiative \u201cfared very poorly\u201d\nbecause payors\u2019 members disliked them. As a result, according to CW1, the Company\nfell far short of achieving the stated metrics associated with the initiative, including\nforecasted cost savings that \u201cnever really transpired.\u201d\n\n         f.    CW3 explained that that multi-modal trips with ride-share TNCs were\ngenerally more expensive than traditional transportation providers, and other cost-saving\ninitiatives were hampered by on-time performance issues that resulted in the Company\npaying its transportation providers 2-3 times more for trip acceptance.\n\n       g.     CW1 confirmed that ModivCare\u2019s decision to de-prioritize members\u2019\nexperience \u201c100%\u201d contributed to the loss of business. CW2 corroborated that\nDefendants\u2019 decision to treat ModivCare as a logistics company rather than a people-\ndriven service business damaged customer relationships.\n\n        h.     CW2 confirmed that, beginning around 2Q2022 and continuing throughout\nCW2\u2019s tenure, ModivCare\u2019s poor operational performance (such as call center failures)\nled to client dissatisfaction and monthly liquidated damages of hundreds of thousands of\ndollars.\n\n       i.      CW3 stated that ModivCare instructed CW3 to highlight technological\ncapabilities that the Company did not have to customers and never delivered on providing\nduring CW3\u2019s tenure, which caused customers to repeatedly complain and place\nModivCare on PIPs during 2022 and 2023. CW3 confirmed that ModivCare\u2019s poor service\ndelivery, long-standing weaknesses in technology, and reliance on an outdated platform\ncaused major contracts to be under threat.\n\n      j.     CW3 confirmed that New York-based customers had major complaints\ncentered on technology, call center performance, and lack of responsiveness from the\nexecutive team. CW3 confirmed that ModivCare consistently failed to meet call center\nKPIs related answering-time during CW3\u2019s tenure.\n\n      k.     CW3 confirmed that ModivCare lost the majority of its New York NEMT\n\n\n                                          179\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 180 of 269\n\n\n\n\nbusiness in 2022 and the Elevance contract, was not considered for an RFP re-bid in\nVirginia in 2022-2023, and had withdrawals from minor NEMT player contracts, MCOs,\nUHC, and Humana due to its poor service delivery and long-standing weaknesses in\ntechnology.\n\n       l.      CW2 confirmed that ModivCare lost MCO Medicaid contracts in New York\nthat were valued at $100 million annually during CW2\u2019s tenure due, in part, to New York\nState transitioning members to its state Medicaid program.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 276 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. Paragraph 276, including subparagraphs (a) through (l), also\n\nstates legal conclusions to which no response from Defendants is required. To the extent\n\na response is required, Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a\n\nbelief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 276, including in subparagraphs\n\n(a) through (l), and deny them on that basis. Defendants further deny that any alleged\n\nstatement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to one\n\ndefendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 276, including in subparagraphs (a) through (l).\n\n      N.     ModivCare\u2019s FY2023 Form 10-K on February 26, 2024\n\n277. On February 26, 2024, before the stock market opened for trading that day,\n   ModivCare filed its Form 10-K with the SEC to report on the Company\u2019s financial and\n   operational results for its fourth quarter ended December 31, 2023 (the FY2023 Form\n   10- K. The FY2023 10-K was signed by Sampson and Gutierrez.\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare filed its FY2023 Form 10-K with the\n\nSEC on February 26, 2024, and that Mr. Sampson and Ms. Gutierrez signed the filing.\n\n\n                                          180\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 181 of 269\n\n\n\n\nDefendants deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission\n\nallegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Except as expressly\n\nadmitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 277.\n\n278. ModivCare\u2019s FY2023 Form 10-K contained a section describing risk factors that\n   \u201ccould materially and adversely affect [ModivCare\u2019s] business, financial condition and\n   results of operations.\u201d One such risk factor discussed fee models that were alternative\n   to FFS, stating in relevant part:\n      The implementation of alternative payment models and the transition of\n      Medicaid and Medicare beneficiaries to MCOs may limit our market share\n      and could adversely affect our revenues.\n\n      ...\n\n      We may be similarly impacted by increased enrollment of Medicare and\n      Medicaid beneficiaries in managed care plans, shifting away from traditional\n      fee-for-service models.\n\n      ...\n\n      Difficulties with operational processes may negatively affect our revenue\n      growth rates, cash flow and profitability for services provided. Other\n      alternative payment models, such as value-based billing, capitated rates\n      and per member per month pricing, may be required by the government,\n      MCOs and other commercial payors to control their costs while shifting\n      financial risk to us, which could also materially affect our operations and\n      financial condition.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 278 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s FY2023\n\nForm 10-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 278.\n\n279. Another risk factor in ModivCare\u2019s FY2023 10-K discussed changes to the\n   Company\u2019s ability to timely collect from payors, stating in relevant part:\n      Our commercial payor and managed Medicaid revenue and profitability are\n      affected by continuing efforts of third-party payors to maintain or reduce\n\n\n\n                                           181\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79        filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 182 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      costs of healthcare by lowering payment rates, narrowing the scope and\n      utilization of covered services, increasing case management review of\n      services and negotiating pricing. There can be no assurance that third-\n      party payors will make timely payments for our services, and there is\n      no assurance that we will continue to maintain our current payor or revenue\n      mix. We will continue our efforts to develop our commercial payor and\n      managed Medicaid sources of revenue and any changes in payment\n      levels from current or future third-party payors could have a material\n      adverse effect on our business and consolidated financial condition,\n      results of operations and cash flows.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 279 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s FY2023\n\nForm 10-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 279.\n\n280. ModivCare also included a risk factor that discussed the Company\u2019s ability to\n   timely collect its accounts receivable related to NEMT, which stated:\n      Delays in collection, or non-collection, of our accounts receivable,\n      particularly during any business integration process, could adversely\n      affect our business, financial position, results of operations and\n      liquidity.\n\n      Prompt billing and collection are important factors in our liquidity. Billing and\n      collection of our accounts receivable are subject to the complex regulations\n      that govern Medicare and Medicaid reimbursement and rules imposed by\n      nongovernment payors. Our inability to bill and collect on a timely basis\n      pursuant to these regulations and rules could subject us to payment delays\n      that could have a material adverse effect on our business, financial position,\n      results of operations and liquidity. It is possible that documentation\n      support, system problems, Medicare, Medicaid or other payor issues,\n      particularly in markets transitioning to managed care for the first time, or\n      industry trends may extend our collection period, which may materially\n      adversely affect our working capital, and our working capital management\n      procedures may not successfully mitigate this risk.\n\n      ...\n\n      In addition, we may experience delays in reimbursement as a result of the\n      failure to receive prompt approvals related to change of ownership\n\n\n\n                                            182\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 183 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      applications for acquired or other facilities or from delays caused by our or\n      other third parties\u2019 information system failures. We may also experience\n      delayed payment of reimbursement rate increases that are subject to the\n      approval of the CMS and/or various state agencies before claims can be\n      submitted or paid at the new rates. Any delays experienced for the\n      foregoing or other reasons could have a material adverse effect on our\n      business, results of operations and financial condition.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 280 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s FY2023\n\nForm 10-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 280.\n\n281. ModivCare\u2019s FY2023 10-K also included a risk factor that discussed utilization,\n   which stated:\n      If we fail to estimate accurately the cost of performing certain\n      contracts, we may experience reduced or negative margins and our\n      results of operations could be materially adversely affected.\n\n      ...\n\n      If the utilization of our services is more than we estimated, the contract\n      may be less profitable than anticipated, or may not be profitable at all.\n\n      ...\n\n      Revenue under certain contracts may be adjusted prospectively if client\n      volumes are below expectations. If we are unable to adjust our costs\n      accordingly, our profitability may be negatively affected. In addition,\n      certain contracts with state Medicaid agencies are renewable or extended\n      at the state\u2019s option without an adjustment to pricing terms. If such renewed\n      contracts require us to incur higher costs, including inflation or regulatory\n      changes, than originally anticipated, our results of operations and financial\n      condition may be adversely affected.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 281 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s FY2023\n\nForm 10-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which\n\n\n\n\n                                          183\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 184 of 269\n\n\n\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 281.\n\n282. The statements identified in \u00b6\u00b6278-281 above each were materially false, and\n   misleading when made, because the risks included in the FY2023 Form 10-K were\n   posed as mere hypotheticals, when those risk had actualized given that: (i)\n   ModivCare\u2019s shift to entering into more shared risk contracts was already negatively,\n   materially impacting the Company\u2019s operations and financial condition; (ii) ModivCare\n   was experiencing delays in payments and collecting its accounts receivable that were\n   extending the Company\u2019s collection period and were already having a materially\n   adverse impact on the Company\u2019s business and consolidated financial condition; and\n   (iii) ModivCare was already experiencing an inability to modify and reprice its contracts,\n   utilization increases, and increased costs that were having a materially adverse impact\n   on the Company\u2019s results of operations and profitability.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 282 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 282.\n\n283. The material falsity of Defendants Sampson\u2019s and Gutierrez\u2019s statements is also\n   supported by evidence. CW2 confirmed, for example, that ModivCare\u2019s true-up\n   process for the shared risk contracts caused regular disputes with payors that dragged\n   on for \u201ca very long time\u201d because the Company billed payors based on internal\n   projections of utilization and claims data that did not match the payors\u2019 \u201cencounter\n   data\u201d (i.e., actual claims). As a result, CW2 confirmed ModivCare often was forced to\n   expend considerable efforts to chase contract receivables, subjected to monthly\n   liquidated damages of hundreds of thousands of dollars, and/or forced to accept\n   partial payment as a settlement for true-up disputes with payors. Beginning in 2023\n   and continuing throughout CW2\u2019s tenure, CW2 confirmed that Monthly Leadership\n   Meetings included regular updates \u201cmonth after month\u201d regarding receivable dispute\n   settlements that resulted in ModivCare receiving a fraction of what was owed. Further,\n   CW2 confirmed that in other instances payors would withhold monthly payments that\n   ModivCare was expecting to offset the balance that ModivCare owed to the payor by\n   ModivCare as a result of the true-up process. CW2 also added that, at least as early\n   as October 2023, Sunshine Health refused to pay ModivCare its large receivables\n   balance and withheld payments from the Company. Corroborating CW2, CW3 stated\n   ModivCare experienced significant disputes over risk corridors and profits, and\n\n\n                                            184\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 185 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   collectability issues related to the Company charging more for trips despite service\n   and technological shortcomings. CW3 explained that complaints about the shared risk\n   contracts resulted in payors refusing to pay for trips, delayed payments, states\n   capping profits, and lost contracts.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 283 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n283 and deny them on that basis. Defendants further deny that any alleged statement,\n\nknowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is\n\nattributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 283.\n\n       O.     ModivCare\u2019s 2Q2024 Earnings Call on August 8, 2024\n\n284. On August 8, 2024, ModivCare held an earnings call at 7:30 a.m. E.T., before the\n   stock market opened for trading that day, to report on the Company\u2019s financial and\n   operational results for its first quarter ended June 30, 2024 (\u201c2Q2024 Earnings Call\u201d),\n   in which Sampson and Gutierrez participated. Sampson jointly presented with\n   Defendant Gutierrez and while speaking on behalf of \u201cwe\u201d was speaking on behalf of\n   both himself and Gutierrez. During the question-and-answer portion of the 2Q2024\n   Earnings Call, in response to an analyst\u2019s question regarding $60 million in contract\n   receivables the Company planned to collect and how ModivCare would achieve strong\n   free cash flow in the second half of FY2024, Defendant Sampson again emphasized\n   the importance of shared risk contracts and the predictability they provided, stating:\n       Yes. I\u2019ll start here and Barb can add some color. And we did in the investor\n       deck, I think Slide 18, we gave a lot of disclosure and even some disclosure\n       of what we expect for contracts payable and contracts receivable for Q3 and\n       Q4. So, it really gives a good kind of picture of what we expect.\n\n       So, the main driver for us, because the businesses are performing on our\n       working capital, is the contracts, right? And again, the contracts,\n       especially over the last 2 years, 18 months, have been redesigned to\n       ensure that we\u2019re in this win-win relationship from a margin and P&L\n       perspective. But where we\u2019re hit, just as a reminder, you know very well,\n       but many other people, with redetermination and then utilization with the\n       settlement times within our shared risk contracts, that goes on the balance\n       sheet, mainly in AR. And then we have from the past being below that, we\u2019re\n\n\n                                            185\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 186 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      at the same time paying contracts payable.\n\n      So that the contracts are working as designed and protecting the\n      downside and protecting the P&L, but there\u2019s no question there is a\n      working capital challenge that we\u2019ve been working through. So, within\n      those contracts, we know the timing and when those happen. They\u2019re\n      written down. Unlike it was in the past, they were a little more ambiguous\n      because COVID was new and wasn\u2019t contemplated. But now they\u2019re all\n      contemplated in the contract. So, that\u2019s the general statement.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 284 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 284 states legal\n\nconclusions to which no response from Defendants is required. Defendants admit that\n\nModivCare held an earnings call on August 8, 2024 to report its earnings results for Q2\n\nFY2024, and that Mr. Sampson and Ms. Gutierrez participated in that call. Paragraph 284\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from that August 8, 2024 earnings call, and Defendants\n\nrespectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of the earnings call, which speaks\n\nfor itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny that\n\nany alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable\n\nto one defendant is attributable to another. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 284.\n\n285. During the same call, Defendant Sampson engaged in the following exchange with\n   an analyst regarding collection timing for capitated shared risk contracts:\n                                 Philip Chickering\n                        Deutsche Bank AG, Research Division\n\n\n\n                                          186\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 187 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      Just going back to the timing of cash flows from NEMT risk contracting.\n      Medicaid liquid determination and liquidation has been hot the last sort of 2\n      years. So why is this happening this quarter versus other quarters? Is there\n      any debate around how much is owed on these contracts? Have you had\n      any issues collecting revenue from these risk-sharing contracts in the last\n      12 months?\n\n                                   L. Heath Sampson\n            CEO, President, Interim President of ModivCare Home & Director\n\n      Yes. So you\u2019re on it, and you\u2019ve covered the payors and I think many people\n      on this phone know what\u2019s happening. It\u2019s pretty clear that utilization has\n      been hot and it continues really to be hot.\n\n      ...\n\n      Yes. And just a little bit on that because what does that mean? Just -- so\n      let\u2019s just say it\u2019s 12 months and we\u2019re halfway through and we\u2019re knowing -\n\n      - and we and the client are knowing that utilization is going up. So we know,\n      I don\u2019t know, 6 months from now we\u2019re going to have a large true-up or\n      settlement that.\n\n      So we go to the client and say, hey, it\u2019s going to be so large, you can see\n      this, you see the data, which is why we\u2019ve been, oh, okay, let\u2019s kind of\n      reset that line, so we don\u2019t have a big growing receivable and payment\n      at the end. And our clients, again, are in a win-win relationship with us\n      to ensure that we\u2019re doing that. And that\u2019s why, as Barb articulated, we\u2019ve\n      been successful in a few of those large contracts to do that ahead of time.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 285 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 285\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s August 8, 2024 earnings call, and Defendants\n\nrespectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of the earnings call, which speaks\n\n\n\n\n                                          187\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 188 of 269\n\n\n\n\nfor itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 285.\n\n286. In response to another analyst\u2019s question, Sampson again assured that the shared\n   risk contracts were \u201cwin-win\u201d and ModivCare was meeting service expectations,\n   stating in relevant part:\n                               Rishi Surendra Parekh\n                       JPMorgan Chase & Co, Research Division\n\n      First, on the contract renegotiations that you were referring to earlier, I get\n      that as a win-win, or at least you note it as a win-win with the payers. But\n      can you just help me better understand, how is it a win for the actual payer?\n      I mean, I get that you\u2019re getting paid earlier, but are you giving up price, or\n      are you reducing price, or what are the economics that you\u2019re changing to\n      make sure that the payers are paying you early? And what does this also\n      mean for payables? Are you going to also have to pay those out faster?\n\n                                  L. Heath Sampson\n           CEO, President, Interim President of ModivCare Home & Director\n\n      Yes. No, on the payable side. But the win-win, yes, the payer wants the\n      best price. So we\u2019re able to offer the best price because of what we\u2019ve done\n      with our platform. But we\u2019ve estimated that. So it\u2019s not different than what\n      we thought. They are getting a better price as we re-underwrite these deals.\n      For us, just in general, because of the other item, we need to perform. So\n      you need to ensure that on NEMT that, of course, you\u2019re picking\n      people up on time. There\u2019s no complaints.\n\n      And then you\u2019re starting to do more at the individual population. A dialysis\n      member is very different than a mental health member. So we are doing\n      all that. So that is really the main reason why our customer status is high.\n      Layer on that we can be the lowest cost, even better. So that\u2019s what I mean\n      by win-win.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 286 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\n\n\n\n                                           188\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 189 of 269\n\n\n\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 286\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s August 8, 2024 earnings call, and Defendants\n\nrespectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of the earnings call, which speaks\n\nfor itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 286.\n\n287. The statements identified in \u00b6\u00b6284-286 above were each materially false and\n   misleading and/or omitted material facts necessary to make the statements therein\n   not false or misleading when made because ModivCare\u2019s shared risk contracts were\n   not \u201cwin-win ... from a margin and P&L perspective[,]\u201d did not produce \u201cwin-win\u201d\n   customer relationships, or provide predictable collection timelines. The material falsity\n   of Defendants Sampson\u2019s and Gutierrez\u2019s statements is supported by ample evidence\n   given that Defendants admitted on September 16, 2024, that, as of June 30, 2024,\n   ModivCare had \u201cexperienced delays in the timely collection of approximately $60\n   million of its outstanding $159.3 million in NEMT segment current contract receivables,\n   primarily from MCO customers[.]\u201d\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 287 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 287 states legal\n\nconclusions to which no response from Defendants is required. Paragraph 287\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s August 8, 2024 earnings call and its September\n\n16, 2024 Form 8-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording\n\nof the earnings call and document, which speak for themselves, and deny any allegations\n\ninconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny that any alleged statement, knowledge,\n\n\n\n\n                                            189\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 190 of 269\n\n\n\n\nconduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to\n\nanother. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 287.\n\n288. The material falsity of Defendants Sampson\u2019s and Gutierrez\u2019s statements is also\n   supported by evidence. CW2 confirmed, for example, that ModivCare\u2019s true-up\n   process for the shared risk contracts caused regular disputes with payors that dragged\n   on for \u201ca very long time\u201d because the Company billed payors based on internal\n   projections of utilization and claims data that did not match the payors\u2019 \u201cencounter\n   data\u201d (i.e., actual claims). As a result, CW2 confirmed ModivCare often was forced to\n   expend considerable efforts to chase contract receivables, subjected to monthly\n   liquidated damages of hundreds of thousands of dollars, and/or forced to accept\n   partial payment as a settlement for true-up disputes with payors. Beginning in 2023\n   and continuing throughout CW2\u2019s tenure, CW2 confirmed that Monthly Leadership\n   Meetings included regular updates \u201cmonth after month\u201d regarding receivable dispute\n   settlements that resulted in ModivCare receiving a fraction of what was owed. Further,\n   CW2 confirmed that in other instances payors would withhold monthly payments that\n   ModivCare was expecting to offset the balance that ModivCare owed to the payor by\n   ModivCare as a result of the true-up process. CW2 also added that, at least as early\n   as October 2023, Sunshine Health refused to pay ModivCare its large receivables\n   balance and withheld payments from the Company. Corroborating CW2, CW3 stated\n   ModivCare experienced significant disputes over risk corridors and profits, and\n   collectability issues related to the Company charging more for trips despite service\n   and technological shortcomings. CW3 explained that complaints about the shared risk\n   contracts resulted in payors refusing to pay for trips, delayed payments, states\n   capping profits, and lost contracts.\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 288 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 288 states legal\n\nconclusions to which no response from Defendants is required. Defendants further lack\n\nknowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations\n\n\n\n                                           190\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 191 of 269\n\n\n\n\nin Paragraph 288 and deny them on that basis. Defendants further deny that any alleged\n\nstatement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to one\n\ndefendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 288.\n\n289. Defendant Sampson\u2019s statement claiming that ModivCare was \u201censur[ing] that on\n   NEMT that ...you\u2019re picking people up on time[,]\u201d that \u201c[t]here\u2019s no complaints[,]\u201d and\n   that ModivCare was \u201cdoing all that\u201d (identified in \u00b6286 above) was also materially false\n   and misleading, omitted material facts necessary to make the statements therein not\n   false or misleading when made, and/or lacked a reasonable basis because ModivCare\n   was not \u201cpicking people up on time\u201d or ensuring \u201cno complaints.\u201d The material falsity\n   of Defendant Sampson\u2019s statements is supported by ample evidence given that:\n\n       a.     CW1 stated that ModivCare\u2019s service quality started to decline around April\n2022. CW1 also confirmed that ModivCare had \u201cstruggles to keep the payors happy\u201d\nbeginning around 1Q2022 and the Company received an increase in complaints,\nincluding driver miscommunications and untimely pickups, from payors\u2019 members around\nMay or June 2022. As a result, CW1 confirmed that, throughout the last year of CW1\u2019s\nemployment, ModivCare was failing to meet targets for its member satisfaction KPIs.\nCW1 further confirmed that service issues resulted in a lot of problems with the Big 6 and\npayors \u201cabsolutely\u201d refused to pay or delayed payments due to ModivCare\u2019s service\nissues.\n\n       b.    CW1 stated that, during the last year of CW1\u2019s tenure, ModivCare began\nlosing NEMT customers around August 2022 due to service complaints. CW1 also\nconfirmed that NEMT de-implementations were \u201ccommon\u201d during the last year of CW1\u2019s\ntenure due to poor service quality and service complaints. Corroborating CW1, CW2\nconfirmed that contract attrition was an issue in multiple regions and remained an issue\nthroughout CW2\u2019s tenure.\n\n      c.     CW3 stated that customer advocate staffing cuts greatly diminished\nModivCare\u2019s ability to address service issues because the Company\u2019s GPS tracking and\ndynamic reassignment technologies \u201cwere plagued by bugs\u201d throughout CW3\u2019s tenure\nand could not fulfill these capabilities without human intervention. As a result, according\nto CW3, payors consistently expressed dissatisfaction, particularly around no shows and\non-time performance, which continued throughout CW3\u2019s tenure.\n\n\n\n                                           191\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 192 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       d.     CW3 stated that missed appointments and no-shows were significant\nservice issues that ModivCare had throughout CW3\u2019s tenure but did not improve on. CW3\nadded that ModivCare consistently failed to meet KPIs, including on-time performance\nand NVAs (which caused missed rides), throughout CW3\u2019s tenure.\n\n        e.     CW1 confirmed that ModivCare\u2019s multi-modal initiative \u201cfared very poorly\u201d\nbecause payors\u2019 members disliked them. As a result, according to CW1, the Company\nfell far short of achieving the stated metrics associated with the initiative, including\nforecasted cost savings that \u201cnever really transpired.\u201d\n\n         f.    CW3 explained that that multi-modal trips with ride-share TNCs were\ngenerally more expensive than traditional transportation providers, and other cost-saving\ninitiatives were hampered by on-time performance issues that resulted in the Company\npaying its transportation providers 2-3 times more for trip acceptance.\n\n       g.     CW1 confirmed that ModivCare\u2019s decision to de-prioritize members\u2019\nexperience \u201c100%\u201d contributed to the loss of business. CW2 corroborated that\nDefendants\u2019 decision to treat ModivCare as a logistics company rather than a people-\ndriven service business damaged customer relationships.\n\n        h.     CW2 confirmed that, beginning around 2Q2022 and continuing throughout\nCW2\u2019s tenure, ModivCare\u2019s poor operational performance (such as call center failures)\nled to client dissatisfaction and monthly liquidated damages of hundreds of thousands of\ndollars.\n\n       i.      CW3 stated that ModivCare instructed CW3 to highlight technological\ncapabilities that the Company did not have to customers and never delivered on providing\nduring CW3\u2019s tenure, which caused customers to repeatedly complain and place\nModivCare on PIPs during 2022 and 2023. CW3 confirmed that ModivCare\u2019s poor service\ndelivery, long-standing weaknesses in technology, and reliance on an outdated platform\ncaused major contracts to be under threat.\n\n      j.     CW3 confirmed that New York-based customers had major complaints\ncentered on technology, call center performance, and lack of responsiveness from the\nexecutive team. CW3 confirmed that ModivCare consistently failed to meet call center\nKPIs related answering-time during CW3\u2019s tenure.\n\n       k.     CW3 confirmed that ModivCare lost the majority of its New York NEMT\nbusiness in 2022 and the Elevance contract, was not considered for an RFP re-bid in\nVirginia in 2022-2023, and had withdrawals from minor NEMT player contracts, MCOs,\n\n\n                                          192\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 193 of 269\n\n\n\n\nUHC, and Humana due to its poor service delivery and long-standing weaknesses in\ntechnology.\n\n       l.      CW2 confirmed that ModivCare lost MCO Medicaid contracts in New York\nthat were valued at $100 million annually during CW2\u2019s tenure due, in part, to New York\nState transitioning members to its state Medicaid program.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 289 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 289, including\n\nsubparagraphs (a) through (l), states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. Defendants further lack knowledge or information sufficient to\n\nform a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 289, including in\n\nsubparagraphs (a) through (l), and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny\n\nthe allegations in Paragraph 289, including in subparagraphs (a) through (l).\n\n      P.     Defendants Partially Revealed the Truth in ModivCare\u2019s Form 8-K Filed\n             with the SEC on September 12, 2024\n\n290. ModivCare filed a Form 8-K with the SEC on September 12, 2024 (the \u201cSeptember\n   12, 2024 Form 8-K\u201d). The Company announced it added Note 19 (Events Subsequent\n   to the Date of the Issuance of the Financial Statements (Unaudited)) to its FY2022\n   and FY2023 Form 10-Ks. The September 12, 2024 Form 8-K provided the following\n   explanation for the update to the FY2023 Form 10-K:\n      As previously disclosed, the Company continues to pursue collection of\n      outstanding contract receivables for services rendered. While a portion of\n      these receivables has been collected, the Company has not offset the\n      existing and continued accumulation of receivables during the period.\n      Management believes it has made substantial progress in reaching oral and\n      written assurances and agreements from its customers related to collecting\n      these outstanding receivables. However, various factors beyond the\n\n\n                                          193\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 194 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      Company\u2019s control have delayed and extended the timeline beyond\n      original expectations. Although these collection and mitigation efforts\n      continue, there remains the possibility that the Company will not\n      achieve full resolution in a timely manner or at all if unforeseen\n      circumstances arise.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare filed a Form 8-K with the SEC on\n\nSeptember 12, 2024 announcing the addition of Note 19 to its FY2022 and FY2023 Forms\n\n10-K. Paragraph 290 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s September 12, 2024\n\nForm 8-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which\n\nspeaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly\n\nadmitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 290.\n\n291. ModivCare further disclosed that \u201c[t]he accompanying consolidated financial\n   statements for the year ended December 31, 2023 were prepared assuming the\n   Company will continue as a going concern\u201d and provided the following admission:\n      Since February 26, 2024, the date the consolidated financial statements\n      were previously issued, the Company has faced delays in collecting\n      receivables under outstanding contracts with customers due to\n      complexities in Medicare, Medicaid, and nongovernmental payor\n      arrangements. These delays, which the Company has not historically\n      experienced, have extended the Company\u2019s collection periods and\n      increased the uncertainty concerning the timing of the collection of\n      these outstanding contract receivables.\n\n      As of the date hereof, the Company has reassessed its financial condition\n      and determined that the extended collection periods and uncertainty\n      concerning the timing of the collection of outstanding contract receivables\n      has changed the Company\u2019s projections of its ability to meet certain\n      financial covenants in its debt instruments. As a result, it has been\n      determined that substantial doubt exists about the Company\u2019s ability\n      to meet its obligations as they come due within one year from the date\n      of issuance of the consolidated financial statements.\n\n      While the Company continues to monitor cash generated from operations,\n      available credit, and other liquid assets, sustaining operations relies heavily\n      on the timely collection of contract receivables and compliance with the\n      Total Net Leverage Ratio covenant in our New Credit Facility, as amended\n\n\n                                           194\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 195 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      to date. Failure to meet this covenant or others could cause our obligations\n      under the New Credit Facility, as amended to date, and the Company\u2019s\n      Notes due 2029, to become immediately due and payable, and we may not\n      have sufficient liquidity to satisfy such obligations. In such event, we\n      would expect to be required to restructure our existing debt or seek\n      additional equity or debt financing to meet our obligations and\n      maintain our existence as a going concern.\n\n      Management intends to undertake actions to seek additional capital,\n      including filing a shelf registration statement with the SEC, and take other\n      available measures to further address these issues, support the funding of\n      our operations and improve our liquidity. There can be no assurance,\n      however, that these or other funds will be available when needed on terms\n      acceptable to the Company, or at all, or in an amount sufficient to enable\n      the Company to satisfy its obligations or sustain operations in the future.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 291 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 291\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s September 12, 2024 Form 8-K, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which speaks for itself,\n\nand deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 291.\n\n292. The September 12, 2024 Form 8-K partially corrected Defendants\u2019 prior false\n   statements assuring that the Company would be able to recoup delayed payments\n   within 60 days of the FY2023 Earnings Call.\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 292 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 292 states legal\n\nconclusions to which no response from Defendants is required. Defendants further deny\n\n\n\n                                           195\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 196 of 269\n\n\n\n\nthat any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly\n\nattributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 292.\n\n293. Upon the news, ModivCare\u2019s stock price declined $18.43, or approximately 59%,\n   from a close of $31.19 per share on September 11, 2024 to a close of $12.76 per\n   share on September 12, 2024 on heavy trading volume of 3.59 million shares,\n   compared with the previous day\u2019s volume of 93,892 shares.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 293 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit and allege\n\nthat ModivCare\u2019s earnings and stock prices at various times are matters of public record\n\nand deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly admitted,\n\nDefendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 293.\n\n       Q.     Defendants Partially Revealed the Truth in ModivCare\u2019s Form 8-K Filed\n              with the SEC on September 16, 2024\n\n294. On September 16, 2024 at 6:30 a.m. ET, before the market opened, ModivCare\n   filed an 8-K with the SEC (\u201cSeptember 16, 2024 Form 8-K\u201d) \u201cProvid[ing] Financial\n   Update\u201d wherein the Company clarified that it did \u201cnot plan to issue equity at this time\u201d\n   but instead, was \u201cfocused on seeking near-term covenant relief under its revolving\n   credit facility to address potential delays in contract receivable collections.\u201d\n       ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare filed a Form 8-K with the SEC on\n\nSeptember 16, 2024. Paragraph 294 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s\n\nSeptember 16, 2024 Form 8-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the\n\ncomplete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph\n\n294.\n\n\n\n\n                                            196\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 197 of 269\n\n\n\n\n295. Defendants disclosed that \u201cthe Company has experienced delays in the timely\n   collection of approximately $60 million of its outstanding $159.3 million in NEMT\n   segment current contract receivables, primarily from MCO customers, as of June 30,\n   2024[.]\u201d The September 16, 2024 Form 8-K added that \u201c[t]his situation is primarily\n   driven by the impacts of Medicaid redeterminations and the resulting increase in\n   utilization under its shared risk contracts.\u201d\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 295 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s September\n\n16, 2024 Form 8-K. Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\nfurther deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission\n\nallegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 295.\n\n296. The September 16, 2024 Form 8-K provided \u201cAdjusted Guidance[,]\u201d \u201crevis[ing] its\n   2024 Adjusted EBITDA guidance range from $185\u2013$195 million to $170\u2013 $180 million,\n   primarily due to NEMT segment pricing accommodations made to strategically retain\n   and expand key customer relationships.\u201d It also \u201cprovided guidance for Adjusted\n   EBITDA growth in excess of 10% in 2025, based on the updated 2024 guidance.\u201d\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 296 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s September\n\n16, 2024 Form 8-K. Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 296.\n\n297. The September 16, 2024 Form 8-K partially corrected Defendants\u2019 prior false\n   statements assuring that the shared risk contracts were protecting ModivCare\n   \u201cdownside and protecting the P&L[,]\u201d and that collectability timing was clear. The\n   September 16, 2024 Form 8-K also partially corrected Defendants\u2019 statements\n   representing that the Company expected to recoup \u201chigher pass through revenue\n   under [its] shared risk contracts\u201d and that Company\u2019s utilization headwinds were\n   \u201cshort-term.\u201d\n\n\n\n\n                                          197\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 198 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 297 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 297 states legal\n\nconclusions to which no response from Defendants is required. Defendants further deny\n\nthat any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly\n\nattributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 297.\n\n298. Upon the news, ModivCare\u2019s stock price declined $1.40, or nearly 10%, from a\n   close of $14.12 per share on September 13, 2024 to a close of $12.72 per share on\n   September 16, 2024.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 298 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit and allege\n\nthat ModivCare\u2019s earnings and stock prices at various times are matters of public record\n\nand deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly admitted,\n\nDefendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 298.\n\n299. Analysts voiced concerns about ModivCare\u2019s representations regarding the\n   collectability of the $60 million in outstanding contract receivables. For example, a\n   September 17, 2024 Barrington Research report stated that news of the collection\n   delays and potential violation of debt covenants \u201cwas particularly troubling since the\n   company had explicitly stated in prepared remarks on its Q2 conference call in early\n   August that it had visibility into $60 million of near-term cash collections from a couple\n   of its large customers.\u201d The report added \u201c[t]hat commentary contributed materially to\n   our decision to upgrade the shares six weeks ago and probably served as similar\n   comfort to many investors.\u201d\n\n\n\n\n                                            198\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 199 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 299 characterizes or quotes from a Barrington Research\n\nanalyst report dated September 17, 2024, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to\n\nthe complete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 299.\n\nVI.   POST-CLASS PERIOD EVENTS\n\n      A.     ModivCare\u2019s Form 8-K Filed with the SEC on October 1, 2024\n\n300. On October 1, 2024, ModivCare filed a Form 8-K (\u201cOctober 1, 2024 Form 8-K\u201d)\n   with the SEC announcing that the Company had \u201csuccessfully collected all of the\n   approximately $60 million in contract receivables that were previously reported as\n   delayed[.]\u201d The October 1, 2024 Form 8-K also disclosed that the Company entered\n   into its Fourth Amendment to its Credit Agreement that raised the Company\u2019s leverage\n   limit and reduced its interest ratio.\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare filed a Form 8-K with the SEC on\n\nOctober 1, 2024. Paragraph 300 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s October 1,\n\n2024 Form 8-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as\n\nexpressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 300.\n\n      B.     ModivCare\u2019s 3Q2024 Earnings Call on November 7, 2024\n\n301. On November 7, 2024, ModivCare held an earnings call with analysts and\n   investors to discuss the Company\u2019s third quarter 2024 results (\u201c3Q2024 Earnings\n   Call\u201d). During the 3Q2024 Earnings Call, despite assuring investors that ModivCare\u2019s\n   shared risk contracts were a \u201cwin-win relationship from a margin and P&L perspective\u201d\n   and that \u201cthe contracts are working as designed and protecting the downside and\n   protecting the P&L\u201d only one quarter earlier, Defendants abruptly changed its\n   characterizations of the capitated shared risk, further confirming that ModivCare\u2019s\n   contracts had not produced the predictability and protection management promised.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 301 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s November 7,\n\n2024 earnings call. Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of\n\n\n                                          199\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 200 of 269\n\n\n\n\nthat earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith.\n\nDefendants deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission\n\nallegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another. To the extent a response\n\nis required, Defendants admit that ModivCare held an earnings call on November 7, 2024\n\nto discuss its results for the quarter ending September 30, 2024. Except as expressly\n\nadmitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 301.\n\n302. During the 3Q2024 Earnings Call, Defendant Sampson acknowledged that\n   ModivCare had been working to reset the payment provisions for some of its shared\n   risk contracts \u201c[o]ver the last several quarters\u201d and \u201cworking to address [its] remaining\n   shared risk contracts through further prepayment updates and in many cases, shifting\n   to fee-for- service arrangements, which will have monthly and quarterly payments.\u201d\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 302 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s November 7,\n\n2024 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording\n\nfrom that earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 302.\n\n303. Analysts pressed Defendants Sampson and Guiterrez on \u201cwhy\u201d ModivCare was\n   switching to fee-for-service during the 3Q2024 Earnings Call, what customers would\n   be impacted, and on the implications to the Company\u2019s margins. In response,\n   Sampson disclosed that changes predominantly related to the shared risk contracts\n   and that the change was intended to \u201censure that we can get paid on a monthly basis\n   or a quarterly basis[:]\u201d\n       \u2026So the state Medicaid, the contracts will likely remain full risk. We\u2019re\n       seeing that. And so I don\u2019t expect those to move from where they are. And\n       again, we\u2019ve seen our renewals in that space and those continue to be at\n       the full risk side of things, which is, again, 40%-ish of our revenue. And\n       then the shared risk is definitely where you\u2019ll see the change. And this\n       is a change that we are supportive of and pushing towards to ensure that\n       we can get paid on a monthly basis or a quarterly basis.\n\n\n\n\n                                            200\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 201 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 303 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s November 7,\n\n2024 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording\n\nfrom that earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants further deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct,\n\ndocument, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 303.\n\n304. During the 3Q2024 Earnings Call, in response to an analyst\u2019s question about the\n   Company\u2019s cash flow, accounts receivable and accounts payable in the back half or\n   mid-2025, Defendant Sampson explicitly acknowledged what Defendants had\n   revealed in their previous partial disclosures\u2014that the shared risk contracts were not\n   actually as beneficial for the Company as management had previously presented,\n   stating in relevant part:\n      Yes. So we couldn\u2019t be more proud of the team and actually the partnership\n      with all our clients out there to get through this -- the health care industry\n      and specifically our clients that we\u2019re managing on the shared risk side\n      with redetermination coupled with higher utilization, the costs were\n      higher than a lot of them expected. And that was painful, which is why\n      these last couple of quarters, we\u2019ve been disclosing these items. But it\u2019s --\n      and that was \u201823 cycle as well as \u201824 because, again, most of these\n      contracts, especially in a weighted perspective are 12 months and then you\n      have a quarter after that a reconciliation.\n\n      So we\u2019re through that tough period, which is why we gave so much\n      disclosure on how much we have collected and where we are. But we still\n      have the \u201824 contracts to roll off. And that\u2019s why we\u2019ve given that -- and why\n      we\u2019ve given the information around mid-2025, why we have a lot of clarity\n      around the timing and the amount is because we\u2019re through that.\n\n      But we do have to roll off these shared risk contracts through 2024 and that\n      will take time through the middle of 2025. And a lot of those contracts as\n      well in the middle part or early part of next year will be switched to that\n      fee-for-service as well. But again, we\u2019ve got to roll off the remaining 2024\n      contracts that are shared risk.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 304 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s November 7,\n\n2024 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording\n\n\n                                           201\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 202 of 269\n\n\n\n\nfrom that earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 304.\n\n305. In response to another analyst\u2019s question about the transition to fee-for- service,\n   Defendant Sampson acknowledged that the shared risk contracts had resulted in\n   margin compression and lower payments over the last couple of years, stating in\n   relevant part:\n      Yes. So the full risk model, primarily in the state business and those are\n      large contracts, there really is only a couple of people now that can do that\n      work and which is why you have seen the benefit of us continuing to extend\n      that. So we feel really good about those and those are at full risk contracts\n      and they\u2019ll remain there, which are at the appropriate risk-adjusted margin,\n      which is obviously higher. Where the margin compression is, again, is in\n      that shared risk component. And really from a shared risk component,\n      what we\u2019ve been getting paid over the last couple of years anyway,\n      has been lower.\n\n      So moving to fee-for-service, again, the cost to capital far outweighs any\n      additional margin compression that is happening. But where the\n      competitors are and this has been consistent, is in that individual -- maybe\n      there\u2019s a small part of a state plan -- I mean, sorry, in a state where there\u2019s\n      an MCO, it\u2019s primarily MCO and it\u2019s primarily smaller sections that the\n      competition has been.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 305 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s November 7,\n\n2024 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording\n\nfrom that earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 305.\n\n306. Analysts also pressed Defendant Sampson on the expectation that the \u201cevolution\n   of [ModivCare\u2019s] contract structure and the potential to improve reconciliation be paid\n   faster[.]\u201d Defendant Sampson\u2019s response starkly contrasted Defendants\u2019 Class Period\n   statements regarding predictability of payments, stating in relevant part:\n      \u2026Hopefully, it was in the comments and I\u2019ll kind of double-down on, I think\n      the thing that I\u2019m most positive on is the clarity we have and what the\n      amounts are going to be and the timing is going to be. As we didn\u2019t have\n      that clarity 2 quarters ago or even a quarter ago because we were all -\n      - the industry was kind of caught flat-footed.\n\n\n                                           202\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 203 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      And we were making assumptions on what we could settle early on or what\n      we could get changes on. That noise is through the system.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 306 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 306\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s November 7, 2024 earnings call, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that earnings call,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 306.\n\n307. Another analyst sought to pin down Defendant Sampson on whether ModivCare\n   was entirely shifting away from shared risk contracts, stating in relevant part:\n                                     Scott J. Fidel\n                            Stephens Inc., Research Division\n\n      So basically, just to simplify it, we should think about NEMT ultimately\n      exiting \u201825 at sort of 60% fee-for-service relating to the -- basically the\n      managed care business and then around 40% full risk relating to the\n      state business. Is that a fair assumption?\n\n                                  L. Heath Sampson\n           CEO, President, Interim President of ModivCare Home & Director\n\n      Yes. Yes. But I want to give one clarity on fee-for-service. And it kind of also\n      is to the point of Pito\u2019s question, are we kind of having a -- is there \u2013 what\u2019s\n      the competitive advantage? I think with some of our large payers, we\u2019re\n      going to have and this is what we want, kickers to do with cost and quality.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 307 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s November 7,\n\n2024 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording\n\nfrom that earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 307.\n\n308. During the same call, another analyst pressed Sampson on how many contracts\n   had already been switched from shared risk to fee-for-service. In response, Sampson\n\n\n                                           203\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79        filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 204 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   acknowledged that ModivCare transitioning the majority of its revenue to fee- for-\n   service was the \u201cright thing to do\u201d given how, contrary to their Class Period statements\n   suggesting the shared risk contracts were a win-win, customers were surprised by the\n   pricing under those agreements:\n      So the move to fee-for-service in our numbers right now and in the near\n      term, you won\u2019t see the -- any material change in fee-for-service because\n      we\u2019re still on the contracts that we have set for 2024. The fee-for-service\n      revenue and related margin will start coming on in 2025 as we are\n      renegotiating these contracts. But maybe underneath your question, we\u2019re\n      in discussions with the majority of our revenue to move to fee-for-\n      service. So that\u2019s why I have a lot of conviction around that in 2025, but it\u2019s\n      not hitting our financial statements, it will hit in 2025. And then the -- to your\n      question around compression and that\u2019s to -- I do expect that to be\n      compression across the board. But again, it\u2019s the right thing to do.\n\n      And again, we\u2019re able to manage that because of the quickness in getting\n      the cash as well as the cost out. We\u2019re really competitively advantaged to\n      win there. And then the specific items that we talked about last quarter\n      had to do with the surprise that a lot of our payers had, really in some\n      of in 2023 in their 2024 contracts.\n\n      Those are where the price -- the lumpy price compressions have been\n      given. So -- and then for those specific companies that we\u2019ve given that\n      price compression in their 2024 contracts, the go-forward contracts after\n      that are in line with the estimates that I talked about in the normal price\n      compression again, which we\u2019ll be able to manage through at the right level.\n      So if you\u2019re \u2013 there\u2019s no need to kind of extrapolate or annualize these lumpy\n      price compressions that we gave because those are isolated to the 2024\n      contracts. The go forward is as I articulated.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 308 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s November 7,\n\n2024 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording\n\nfrom that earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 308.\n\n      C.     ModivCare\u2019s Late Quarterly Filing, Bankruptcy, and De-Listing\n\n309. On August 12, 2025, ModivCare filed a Notification of Late Filing on Form 12b-25\n   with the SEC, stating that the Company was \u201cunable [to] file its Quarterly Report on\n   Form 10-Q for the quarter ended June 30, 2025 (the \u201cForm 10-Q\u201d) by the prescribed\n\n\n                                            204\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 205 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   due date without unreasonable effort or expense because the Company requires\n   additional time to complete its ongoing assessment of goodwill for potential\n   impairment and to report the results of such analysis in its consolidated interim\n   unaudited financial statements.\u201d The Notice further revealed that \u201cthe Company\n   require[d] additional time to complete an investigation being conducted by the\n   Company\u2019s outside counsel at the direction of the Audit Committee of the Company\u2019s\n   Board of Directors with respect to compliance hotline allegations, including matters\n   related to the Company\u2019s culture.\u201d\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare filed a Notification of Late Filing on\n\nForm 12b-25 with the SEC on August 12, 2025. Paragraph 309 characterizes or quotes\n\nfrom ModivCare\u2019s August 12, 2025 Form 12b-25, and Defendants respectfully refer the\n\nCourt to the complete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations\n\ninconsistent therewith. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 309.\n\n310. On August 20, 2025, ModivCare published a press release, titled \u201cModivCare\n   Enters into Comprehensive Restructuring Agreement to Strengthen its Future,\n   Reduce Debt and Inject Capital[,]\u201d announcing that the Company had \u201cfiled for\n   voluntary Chapter 11 protection in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District\n   of Texas to implement a comprehensive restructuring transaction with the support of\n   a supermajority of its key stakeholders.\u201d The following day, August 21, 2025,\n   ModivCare filed a Form 8-K with the SEC, reiterating that the Company had filed for\n   Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection and publishing, inter alia, the Restructuring Support\n   Agreement entered with its creditors.\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare issued a press release on August 20,\n\n2025 and filed a Form 8-K on August 21, 2025 with the SEC. Paragraph 310 characterizes\n\nor quotes from ModivCare\u2019s August 20, 2025 press release and August 21, 2025 Form 8-\n\nK, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete documents, which speak\n\nfor themselves, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly\n\nadmitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 310.\n\n\n                                          205\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 206 of 269\n\n\n\n\n311. Then, on August 22, 2025, ModivCare filed another Form 8-K with the SEC,\n   disclosing that, on August 21, 2025, the Company had received a letter from the\n   Listing Qualifications Department of NASDAQ notifying the Company that the\n   NASDAQ \u201chad determined to commence proceedings to delist the Company\u2019s\n   common stock\u201d because \u201cthe Company [was] no longer suitable for listing ... as a\n   result of the Company\u2019s commencement of voluntary proceedings under Chapter 11\n   of the United States Bankruptcy Code on August 20, 2025.\u201d \u201cNasdaq [also] informed\n   the Company that the Common Stock would be suspended at the opening of business\n   on August 28, 2025.\u201d ModivCare did not appeal the de-listing.\n       ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare filed a Form 8-K with the SEC on\n\nAugust 22, 2025, and that ModivCare did not appeal its delisting from Nasdaq. Paragraph\n\n311 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s August 22, 2025 Form 8-K, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document, which speaks for itself,\n\nand deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly admitted,\n\nDefendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 311.\n\n312. On August 28, 2025, the Company\u2019s common stock was suspended from trading\n   on the NASDAQ and delisted. Thereafter, ModivCare\u2019s common stock began trading\n   on OTCMKTS.\n       ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare\u2019s common stock was delisted from\n\nthe NASDAQ on August 28, 2025, and thereafter traded on OTCMKTS. Except as\n\nexpressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 312.\n\nVII.   ADDITIONAL SCIENTER ALLEGATIONS\n\n313. As alleged herein, Defendants acted with scienter in that they knew, or recklessly\n   disregarded, that the public documents and statements they issued and disseminated\n   to the investing public in the name of the Company, or in their own name, during the\n   Class Period were materially false and misleading when made. The Defendants\n   knowingly and substantially participated or acquiesced in the issuance or\n   dissemination of such statements and documents as primary violations of the federal\n   securities laws. The Defendants, by virtue of their receipt of information reflecting the\n   true facts regarding ModivCare, and their control over and/or receipt and/or\n\n\n                                            206\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 207 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   modification of ModivCare\u2019s allegedly materially misleading misstatements, were\n   active and culpable participants in the fraudulent scheme alleged herein.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 313 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny that any\n\nalleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to\n\none defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 313.\n\n       A.     CWs Confirmed Defendants Accessed Real-Time KPIs Related to\n              NEMT Service Issues, and Attended Meetings Discussing the Same\n\n314. CWs confirmed that the Defendants accessed, reviewed, and discussed detailed\n   data regarding NEMT performance metrics and service issues.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 314 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n314 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 314.\n\n315. For instance, CW1 explained that ModivCare tracked certain metrics in connection\n   with the Company providing the payors\u2019 members transportation services, including\n   member satisfaction, responsiveness to complaints, how quickly transportation\n   providers pick up the phone, length of time members remained on the phone with\n   transportation providers, response times, and other KPIs. CW2 also confirmed that\n   ModivCare quantified its customer service failures, explaining that call center\n   performance was tracked.\n\n\n\n                                            207\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 208 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 315 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n315 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 315.\n\n316. CW1 confirmed that Shepard regularly attended meetings where the NEMT\n   initiatives and metrics were discussed. Specifically, CW1 explained that Shepard,\n   Shepard\u2019s team, and the team upon which CW1 worked were considered \u201cbusiness\n   partners\u201d that supported Simpson and his direct reports. As such, according to CW1,\n   Shepard was a \u201cstanding member\u201d at regular meetings with Simpson\u2019s direct reports,\n   Shepard\u2019s team, and CW1\u2019s team. CW1 likewise briefed Sampson and Shepard on\n   strategy, modes of transportation, KPI reviews, financials, services levels, and\n   implementations, and provided Sampson with updates in response to his periodic\n   requests about specific contracts.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 316 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n316 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 316.\n\n\n\n\n                                            208\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 209 of 269\n\n\n\n\n317. CW1 also described attending a standing, direct report staff meeting with\n   operational leaders during the summer of 2022 where the rise in service complaints\n   and payors\u2019 disappointment over the rise in service complaints were being discussed.\n   During the meeting, according to CW1, Simpson told attendants that ModivCare only\n   owned \u201cpicking up and dropping\u201d off the member and specifically did not \u201cown the\n   customer experience.\u201d It was at this time, according to CW1, that it became clear to\n   CW1 that ModivCare could be headed for financial troubles since member experience\n   was critical to the NEMT\u2019s business\u2019 success, but was specifically de-prioritized. CW1\n   described Simpson\u2019s directive as \u201cshocking\u201d and said, \u201cthat was the moment in time I\n   realized we could be in trouble.\u201d\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 317 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n317 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 317.\n\n318. When asked whether payors raised these service issues with CW1, CW1 replied\n   \u201call the time.\u201d CW1 also heard about the service issues, including drivers not picking\n   members up on time and miscommunications between drivers and members, from the\n   operations team, executive teams, and \u201ceveryone across the country, weekly.\u201d\n   Accordingly, CW1 confirmed that the service issues were 100% on Shepard\u2019s and\n   Sampson\u2019s radars. CW2 also stated that service issues, including rejected encounters\n   and call center failures, were discussed frequently during Monthly Leadership\n   Meetings.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 318 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\n\n\n                                            209\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 210 of 269\n\n\n\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n318 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 318.\n\n319. Between November 2022 and the end of CW3\u2019s tenure in September 2023, CW3\n   held several meetings with ModivCare\u2019s leadership, including Defendant Sampson,\n   during which CW3 warned leadership that the Company\u2019s contracts were at risk\n   because they were failing to keep up with their competitors.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 319 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n319 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 319.\n\n320. CW3\u2019s team also presented competitive analyses that compared ModivCare\u2019s\n   offerings to competitors and emphasized long-standing weaknesses in technology,\n   poor service delivery, and a disjointed operational model based on the outdated\n   LogistiCare platform to Sampson, the President of ModivCare\u2019s Mobility Division\n   Simpson, the Senior VP/Head of Mobility Product Edward Hoffman, and \u201cthe full c-\n   suite\u201d during the May 2023 Summit.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 320 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\n\n                                            210\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 211 of 269\n\n\n\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n320 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 320.\n\n321. Nevertheless, according to CW3, Senior VP of Government Affairs Robert Pittman,\n   Senior VP of Mobility Edward Hoffman, and Defendant Sampson instructed CW3 to\n   highlight capabilities to customers in RFPs that did not exist, including technology\n   platforms the company had long promised but never delivered. CW3 further confirmed\n   that Sampson and leadership were aware of ModivCare\u2019s technological shortcomings\n   and that representing the Company had such capabilities in the RFPs was not truthful.\n       ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 321 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph\n\n321 and deny them on that basis. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 321.\n\n       B.     CWs Confirmed That Defendants Received Regular Reports and\n              Participated in Regular Meetings Regarding Contract De-\n              Implementation and Receivable Disputes\n\n322. CW1 prepared regular reports related to ModivCare\u2019s implementations, which\n   included information about members, contract size, and data from a utilization\n   forecasting tool. CW1 stated that Sampson and Shepard received this information\n   twice a month at the very least, and that Simpson received this information on a weekly\n\n\n\n\n                                            211\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 212 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   basis. CW1 added these reports were \u201cwell distributed\u201d to ModivCare\u2019s upper\n   management.\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 322 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 322.\n\n323. CW1 tracked the dollar amounts related to implementations and de-\n   implementations closely. According to CW1, this information was also shared with vice\n   presidents, senior vice presidents, and the executive team. CW1 also prepared\n   presentations, similar to PowerPoint slides shows, related to ModivCare\u2019s\n   implementations and de-implementations that were submitted to the executive team,\n   including Sampson. CW1 added that any leader could access these reports,\n   \u201cwhenever they wanted.\u201d\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 323 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 323.\n\n324. CW1 confirmed that Shepard, Simpson and Simpson\u2019s operational vice presidents\n   received briefings on contract implementations and de-implementations during bi-\n   monthly meetings, which were held over Microsoft Teams. During these meetings, a\n   report was displayed, which was a shared document that attendees could access, to\n   walk the attendees through various data points concerning implementations and\n   contracts lost, including contract sizes, dollar amounts, and number of members\n   served. CW1 confirmed that these reports were sent to Simpson.\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 324 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 324.\n\n325. CW1 confirmed that Shepard, Shepard\u2019s team, Simpson, Simpson\u2019s direct reports\n   received bi-weekly oral reports on all projects, which were documented in the meeting\n   minutes. CW1 stated that Shepard received these implementation updates bi- weekly,\n   at the very least. According to CW1, the information from the implementation updates\n\n\n\n                                          212\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 213 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   was sometimes presented in a \u201chigher-level update to the executive team\u201d in which\n   Sampson participated.\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 325 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 325.\n\n326. CW1 attended regular meetings with Shepard, Shepard\u2019s team, Simpson, and\n   Simpson\u2019s direct reports wherein ModivCare\u2019s strategic initiatives and metrics related\n   to implementation of those strategic initiatives were discussed. CW1 explained that\n   concerns related to the NEMT contracts were discussed during these regular\n   meetings. For instance, CW1 stated these meetings involved regular discussions\n   about the rise in de-implementations, the reasons for the increase, and \u201cwhy are we\n   losing business.\u201d\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 326 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 326.\n\n327. CW1 confirmed that Sampson and Shepard were \u201cdefinitely\u201d concerned about the\n   increase in de-implementations. CW1 added that when ModivCare was losing more\n   business, and utilization was increasing, the implementations team was given a\n   \u201cspotlight.\u201d\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 327 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 327.\n\n328. CW1 participated in a meeting with Sampson regarding de-implementations where\n   he asked questions about why ModivCare was losing business and for dollar amounts\n   related to the same. CW1 explained that de-implementations were \u201ca huge, huge\n   concern, probably across the entire company, but certainly the transportation division.\u201d\n   CW1 added the majority of concerns about lost business were NEMT-related.\n\n\n\n\n                                           213\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 214 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 328 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 328.\n\n329. Similarly, CW2 participated in calls with Shepard between March and May of 2023\n   where payor disputes had escalated to a point where the payor requested Shepard\u2019s\n   involvement. CW2 confirmed that these negotiation calls were ongoing conversations\n   that occurred weekly throughout 2023.\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 329 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 329.\n\n330. CW2 also stated that encounter data rejected by payors was frequently discussed\n   during Monthly Leadership Meetings. CW2 also explained that receivable disputes\n   were a standing agenda item during Monthly Leadership Meetings and included\n   regular updates such as, \u201cHealth plan X is only paying us Y, or 30% of what\u2019s owed.\u201d\n   CW2 added that the receivable disputes were \u201cdefinitely a hot topic\u201d that occurred\n   \u201cmonth after month\u201d at every monthly meeting between 2023 and 2024.\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the CW allegations in Paragraph 330 and deny them on that basis.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 330.\n\n      C.     Defendants Were Personally Involved in Contract Negotiations with\n             Payors and Touted Relationships with Payors\u2019 Executives as a Means\n             to Reprice Contracts and Protect Contract Margin\n\n331. Prior to and during the Class Period, Defendant Sampson touted his direct\n   involvement with contract negotiations and the benefits that his close working\n   relationships with payors\u2019 executives had on the same. For instance, prior to the Class\n   Period during the Company\u2019s 2022 Investor Day presentation, Sampson emphasized\n   his close working relationships with payors\u2019 CEOs afforded ModivCare with the ability\n   to engage in contemporaneous re-pricing discussions to address NEMT costs\n   fluctuations. Indeed, during that same presentation, Sampson stated that \u201cthe beauty\u201d\n   is that \u201cwe can get meetings with the CEO[.]\u201d Defendant Sampson then provided an\n\n\n                                           214\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 215 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   example where he personally met with a payor\u2019s CEO just the month prior and\n   highlighted the importance of that relationship for future contract negotiations:\n      \u2026I was with a payer. We were doing [a] planning session on how to\n      grow their MA business nationally, 8-hour working session with them.\n      And it was primarily around transportation. The other thing they said, \u201cIf we\n      do what we\u2019re planning to do, Heath, we\u2019re just going to give you everything\n      else.\u201d\n\n      My point there is, is that the relationships to the CEO level is enabling\n      us to make sure that we increase the pricing. So if utilization was to\n      increase another 1%, the amount of negotiation that I need to increase\n      on our contracts is in the single-digit range. First lever to pull, and we\u2019re\n      doing it today. So that\u2019s why I feel really good.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 331 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s June 23,\n\n2022 Investor Day presentation, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the\n\ncomplete recording of that presentation, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations\n\ninconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 331.\n\n332. Likewise, during the Company\u2019s 2Q2022 Earnings Call on August 4, 2022,\n   Defendant Sampson again emphasized close payor relationships and the significance\n   of those relationships for contracting:\n      \u2026In addition, and this relates to the out of period, we are very close to our\n      clients. And as we\u2019re moving through what has changed, costs are up, and\n      you can see that in our metrics and we are appropriately getting the\n      pricing change to reflect that increase in cost and also reflect the\n      services that we provide.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 332 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s August 4,\n\n2022 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording\n\nof that earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 332.\n\n333. Defendant Sampson also admitted that he was personally involved with NEMT\n   contract negotiations during the Deutsche Bank\u2019s 30th Annual Leveraged Finance\n   Conference on September 20, 2022:\n\n\n                                           215\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 216 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       \u2026If it gets a little bit where it\u2019s too imbalanced, we\u2019ll restructure the\n       contract. And we\u2019ve been doing that for the last 12 months very\n       successfully because it makes sense. The margins that we have in that\n       business, and I\u2019m not apologetic about it, and I say this directly to our\n       customers, a 10% EBITDA margin to ensure that we pick your members\n       up on time is the right margin.\n\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 333 characterizes or quotes from the September 20, 2022\n\nDeutsche Bank conference, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete\n\nrecording of that conference, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations\n\ninconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 333.\n\n334. Defendant Sampson also touted the benefits of working closely with payors\u2019\n   executives during that same conference call, stating in relevant part: \u201c[w]e have senior\n   relationships at the C level and down ... how valuable it is that a company like ours\n   has senior level relationships at the highest level.\u201d\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 334 characterizes or quotes from the September 20, 2022\n\nDeutsche Bank conference, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete\n\nrecording of that conference, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations\n\ninconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 334.\n\n335. Sampson also stressed the benefits of its payor relationships during the Class\n   Period. For instance, on December 6, 2022, during Bank of America Securities\u2019 Home\n   Care Conference, Sampson emphasized consistent contact with ModivCare\u2019s\n   customers regarding NEMT contract re-pricing:\n       So contract repricing and engagement on our customers\u2019 populations\n       happen all the time. Even though we may have a 3- to 5-year contract, our\n       methodology and approach is to stay engaged with our customers.\n       And we\u2019re really looking at that. And if you look about -- since -- kind of I\u2019ve\n       been here in the last 2 years. We have appropriately increased pricing or\n       decreased pricing to ensure it\u2019s aligned with that mix of population. That will\n       always continue.\n\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 335 characterizes or quotes from the December 6, 2022\n\nBank of America Securities conference, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to\n\n\n                                            216\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 217 of 269\n\n\n\n\nthe complete recording of that conference, which speaks for itself, and deny any\n\nallegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 335.\n\n336. Defendant Sampson reiterated ModivCare\u2019s unique relationships with payors\n   during J.P. Morgan\u2019s 41st Annual Healthcare Conference on January 11, 2023, stating:\n   \u201c[a]nd really over these last couple of years, we are contracting in each state, but our\n   relationship is at the highest level of these large players, the C-level\n   relationships. This is really unusual in healthcare services. So that really matters.\u201d\n   He added that:\n      And then lastly, and this is something that\u2019s happened over the last couple\n      of years since I\u2019ve been here, and it gets to our strong relationships. And\n      I like this. So our strong partnerships will reprice, if appropriate. We\u2019ve\n      proven to do that up or down over these last couple of years.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 336 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s January 11,\n\n2023 J.P. Morgan conference, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete\n\nrecording of that conference, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations\n\ninconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 336.\n\n337. Similarly, during J.P. Morgan\u2019s 42nd Annual Healthcare Conference on January\n   11, 2024, when an analyst asked about investments ModivCare was making to\n   automate the NEMT segment, Sampson provided another example of personally\n   interacting with a payor:\n      So change to transportation typically means a challenge. So how do you\n      get ahead of that? You integrate and allow that facility to manage and book\n      and really API into our modern technology to ensure that they manage that.\n      Critical component. I was with another large payer and he was saying,\n      with our dialysis facilities, we spend about an extra $50 million that we\n      shouldn\u2019t spend because transportation is hard.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 337 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s January 11,\n\n2024 J.P. Morgan conference, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete\n\n\n\n\n                                           217\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 218 of 269\n\n\n\n\nrecording of that conference, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations\n\ninconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 337.\n\n338. Because Defendant Sampson had close relationships and frequent discussions\n   with payors\u2019 executives regarding contracting and repricing due to utilization and cost\n   increases, he either knew or should have known that payors were dissatisfied with\n   ModivCare\u2019s service levels and technology offerings, were refusing to pay, delaying\n   payments, and seeking liquidated damages, refusing to share in increased costs\n   under the shared risk contracts, and cancelling contracts as a result of service and\n   technology issues. Thus, Defendant Sampson\u2019s misleading representations\n   throughout the Class Period were made with knowledge or reckless disregard for the\n   fact that ModivCare\u2019s shared risk contracts were not win-win and did not protect the\n   Company\u2019s financials.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 338 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 338.\n\n      D.     Defendants Frequently Discussed ModivCare\u2019s NEMT Performance\n             Data During Earnings Calls\n\n339. Defendants also discussed service performance in granular detail during earnings\n   calls, which evidences that they were closely tracking NEMT performance metrics. For\n   example, during the FY2022 Earnings Call, Sampson jointly presented with Defendant\n   Shepard and while speaking on behalf of \u201cwe\u201d \u2014 i.e., both himself and Shepard\u2014\n   affirmed that they were closely monitoring and knowledgeable of ModivCare\u2019s NEMT\n   performance. There, Defendant Sampson stated that \u201cour fourth quarter on time\n   performance was at its highest level in two years. We also exceeded service level\n   expectations in our contact centers and reduce[d] missed trips by about a third.\u201d\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 339 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 339 states legal\n\n\n                                           218\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 219 of 269\n\n\n\n\nconclusions to which no response from Defendants is required. Defendants admit that Mr.\n\nSampson and Mr. Shepard each participated in the February 23, 2023 earnings call.\n\nParagraph 339 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23, 2023 earnings\n\ncall, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that\n\nearnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith.\n\nDefendants further deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or\n\nomission allegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Except as\n\nexpressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 339.\n\n340. Defendants likewise admitted that ModivCare shared data concerning NEMT\n   performance metrics with their customers. For instance, during J.P. Morgan\u2019s 41st\n   Annual Healthcare Conference on January 11, 2023, Defendant Sampson elaborated\n   on the data partnership and how it was used to establish NEMT contract prices. He\n   stated that \u201c[s]o when we go in and if we\u2019re on a full-risk state and the mix is 25%\n   dialysis, our data people know that, their data people know that, and we price\n   appropriately. So it\u2019s the same, it\u2019s been, and it\u2019s working well.\u201d\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 340 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 340\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s January 11, 2023 J.P. Morgan conference, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that conference,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\nfurther deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission\n\n\n\n\n                                          219\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 220 of 269\n\n\n\n\nallegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 340.\n\n341. During the Deutsche Bank\u2019s 30th Annual Leveraged Finance Conference on\n   September 20, 2022, Defendant Sampson described the Company\u2019s partnership with\n   state customers and stated that \u201c[s]o I love that they\u2019re in that dialogue that we\u2019re\n   sharing data, and that\u2019s where the conversation and contracting is going.\u201d\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 341 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 341\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s September 20, 2022 Deutsche Bank\n\nconference, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording of that\n\nconference, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 341.\n\n342. Defendant Gutierrez likewise admitted that ModivCare was heavily focused on\n   utilizing data analytics to drive decision making. For example, during Bank of America\n   Securities\u2019 2023 Leveraged Finance Conference on November 28, 2023, Gutierrez\n   stated that there was \u201ca big focus on data analytics to help the company really make\n   good data- driven decisions. You ask questions about our contracts and the\n   profitability, and just really continuing to refine that focus on that process.\u201d\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 342 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 342\n\n\n                                          220\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 221 of 269\n\n\n\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s November 28, 2023 Bank of America\n\nSecurities conference, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete\n\nrecording of that conference, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations\n\ninconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 342.\n\n343. Given Defendants\u2019 focus on sharing data with customers and making data-\n   informed decisions, Defendants knew or should have known that ModivCare\u2019s NEMT\n   service levels were declining, payors were dissatisfied with ModivCare\u2019s service levels\n   and technology offerings, were refusing to pay, delaying payments, and seeking\n   liquidated damages, refusing to share in increased costs under the shared risk\n   contracts, and cancelling contracts as a result of service and technology issues.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 343 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants otherwise deny\n\nthe allegations in Paragraph 343.\n\n      E.     Defendants Evasive Answers to Analysts\u2019 Questions about the\n             Capitated Shared Risk Contracts Supports Scienter\n\n344. Throughout the Class Period, Defendants evaded questions about contract\n   receivable collectability under the Company\u2019s capitated shared risk contracts. For\n   instance, during the FY2023 Earnings Call, Sampson jointly presented with Defendant\n   Gutierrez and while speaking on behalf of \u201cwe\u201d \u2014 i.e., both himself and Gutierrez \u2014\n   affirmed that they were involved with and knowledgeable of ModivCare\u2019s outstanding\n   delayed payment dispute. Nevertheless, Defendant Sampson dodged an analyst\u2019s\n   question about why ModivCare did not collect from a managed care contract in Florida\n   and instead, insisted that the Company would collect the funds:\n                                  Philip Chickering\n                         Deutsche Bank AG, Research Division\n\n      A couple for me here. For the managed care contract in [ Florida\u2019s ]\n      revenues, you guys didn\u2019t collect this quarter. I believe you said you collect\n      them in the next few months. Can I ask sort of why you didn\u2019t collect it\n      in the time period that you thought you would? Is there any issue on\n      what they think they should pay versus what you guys have\n      recognized?\n\n\n\n                                           221\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 222 of 269\n\n\n\n\n                                  L. Heath Sampson\n           CEO, President, Interim President of ModivCare Home & Director\n\n      Yes. We wanted to be specific that it was one contract and one area\n      because we have a lot of relationships with that payer across the country,\n      which we are in great standing. This specific issue has not been paid at\n      the same time, why I said the next couple of months is because we will\n      get it paid because it\u2019s contractually owed. So I wanted to make sure I\n      set it because it was the main driver for the cash flow change in Q4. But I\n      also wanted to be explicit about it and give the amount because it\u2019s\n      contractually owed and we\u2019ll get it paid within the next kind of 60 days.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 344 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 344\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23, 2024 earnings call, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that earnings call,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\nfurther deny that any alleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission\n\nallegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 344.\n\n345. Another analyst, picking up on Defendant Sampon\u2019s non-answer regarding\n   whether there was a material disagreement between ModivCare and the Florida\n   customer, pressed on whether such a disagreement existing during FY2023 Earnings\n   Call. Again, Sampson punted:\n                                Michael John Petusky\n                Barrington Research Associates, Inc., Research Division\n\n      So appreciate the commentary around your confidence in the collectability\n      of the delayed payment and the possible timing. I didn\u2019t catch, though, if you\n      commented on it. Is there a material disagreement between the parties\n      in terms of what\u2019s actually owed?\n\n                                  L. Heath Sampson\n           CEO, President, Interim President of ModivCare Home & Director\n\n\n\n                                           222\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79        filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 223 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      Well, so, it\u2019s -- all of our contracts that are with shared risk, this is why they\n      reconcile over many months. So it\u2019s complicated. But we\u2019ve been under\n      this contract with this customer. Well, one, they\u2019ve been a longtime\n      customer of ours many, many years. And this contract structure started in\n      late 2022. So we feel really good about the math and the collection of\n      the entire amount. It\u2019s in line with the requirements of the contract. So we\u2019ll\n      collect it within the next 60 days or so.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 345 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 345\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23, 2024 earnings call, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from that earnings call,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 345.\n\n346. In a report published on February 26, 2024, Barrington commented on the\n   Company\u2019s evasive answers, stating:\n      The company\u2019s decision not to answer certain questions during its\n      conference call frankly rattled us a bit. Historically, management has\n      seemed largely forthcoming. Questions that were specifically asked but\n      not clearly answered or items which could have given clarity but\n      seemed to be left intentionally murky included 1) expectations for the\n      likely cash flow deficit in Q1 and Q2 \u2013 this could have provided an\n      insight into exactly how back-end loaded FCF guidance actually is; 2)\n      the actual adjusted EBITDA generated at Matrix in 2023 - this is simply a\n      number and would have been an easy question to have answered and; 3)\n      whether or not there is a \u201cmaterial disagreement\u201d regarding the $35.9\n      million that ModivCare believes it is contractually owed \u2013 an answer\n      such as \u201cYes, clearly a disagreement, but not one of significant size\u201d would\n      have provided some comfort that this issue will probably not drag out\n      beyond management\u2019s 30-60 day forecast for resolution and, in a worst\n      case scenario, could be quickly settled for a figure close to the estimated\n      amount.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 346 characterizes or quotes from a Barrington Research\n\nanalyst report dated February 26, 2024, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to\n\n\n\n                                            223\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 224 of 269\n\n\n\n\nthe complete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 346.\n\n347. Defendant Sampson\u2019s evasive answers suggest that he and Gutierrez were aware\n   of the material dispute that ModivCare and its Florida-based customer had regarding\n   the true-up provisions of the shared risk contracts but wanted to avoid discussing it or\n   otherwise downplay the significance of the true-up dispute.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 347 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny that any\n\nalleged statement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to\n\none defendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 347.\n\n348. Indeed, after the Class Period, Defendant Sampson (again speaking on behalf of\n   himself and Gutierrez, who jointly presented the call) admitted that the shared risk\n   contracts and their true-up provisions were painful stating in relevant part during the\n   3Q2024 Earnings Call: \u201cthe health care industry and specifically our clients that we\u2019re\n   managing on the shared risk side with redetermination coupled with higher utilization,\n   the costs were higher than a lot of them expected. And that was painful.\u201d\u201c\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 348 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. Paragraph 348 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s\n\nNovember 7, 2024 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the\n\ncomplete recording of that earnings call, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations\n\ninconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny that any alleged statement, knowledge,\n\nconduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to one defendant is attributable to\n\nanother. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 348.\n\n\n\n\n                                           224\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 225 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      F.     Defendants\u2019 Statements Concerned ModivCare\u2019s Primary Source of\n             Revenue and Core Operation, Further Supporting Scienter\n\n349. Defendants\u2019 scienter is further supported by the fact that the NEMT was\n   ModivCare\u2019s \u201ccore\u201d operation. Indeed, the NEMT segment made up the overwhelming\n   majority of ModivCare\u2019s total revenue, accounting for approximately 70% of the\n   Company\u2019s total revenue during the Class Period. The shared risk contracts also\n   represented the largest component of those revenues during the Class Period.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 349 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 349\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s public statements or SEC filings describing its\n\nNEMT revenue, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recordings\n\nor documents, which speak for themselves, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 349.\n\n350. Defendants also consistently indicated that the NEMT or Mobility segment\n   constituted ModivCare\u2019s core operation, indicating Defendants monitored the segment\n   closely. During the January 11, 2023 JPMorgan Healthcare Conference, Defendant\n   Sampson confirmed that ModivCare\u2019s \u201ctransportation is our largest segment, about\n   $1.7 billion in revenue, close $170 million, $175 million adjusted EBITDA, again, 36\n   million lives.\u201d Defendant Sampson confirmed that ModivCare\u2019s \u201cmobility business . . .\n   is our core business\u201d at the Deutsche Bank\u2019s 31st Annual Leveraged Finance\n   Conference on October 3, 2023.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 350 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 350\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from the January 11, 2023 J.P. Morgan conference and the\n\nOctober 3, 2023 Deutsche Bank conference, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court\n\nto the complete recordings from those conferences, which speak for themselves, and\n\ndeny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants further deny that any alleged\n\nstatement, knowledge, conduct, document, or omission allegedly attributable to one\n\n\n                                          225\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 226 of 269\n\n\n\n\ndefendant is attributable to another. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in\n\nParagraph 350.\n\n351. Thus, the NEMT division\u2019s critical importance to ModivCare\u2019s core operations\n   raises a strong inference that the Defendants made their false and misleading\n   statements throughout the Class Period with scienter. Moreover, as ModivCare\u2019s\n   senior officers and/or directors, who had continuous access to NEMT service data and\n   KPIs, participated in meeting wherein service KPIs and issues were discussed, and\n   were in frequent communication with its NEMT customers, it strains credulity to\n   suggest that Defendants were unaware of the negative impact of the service and\n   relations technology issues and customers pushback on paying increased cost for\n   service under the shared risk contracts, when those issues concerned the services\n   and contract structure that made up the vast majority of the Company\u2019s NEMT\n   revenue. In the alternative, Defendants acted with reckless disregard for the truth\n   when they failed to ascertain and disclose the readily available facts regarding service\n   and relations technology issues and shared risk contracts disputes affecting the\n   Company\u2019s core business.\n        ANSWER: Paragraph 351 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 351.\n\nVIII.   LOSS CAUSATION\n\n352. During the Class Period, as detailed herein, Defendants materially misled the\n   investing public, thereby inflating the price of ModivCare securities and/or maintaining\n   the artificial inflation in ModivCare securities and, by publicly issuing materially false\n   and/or misleading statements and omitting to disclose material facts necessary to\n   make those statements, as set forth herein, not materially false or misleading. Said\n   statements and omissions were materially false and/or misleading in that they failed\n   to disclose materially adverse information and/or misrepresented the truth about\n   ModivCare\u2019s NEMT shared risk contracts, NEMT services, and NEMT strategic\n   initiatives, thus causing ModivCare\u2019s securities to be overvalued and artificially inflated\n   at all relevant times.\n        ANSWER: Paragraph 352 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants otherwise deny\n\nthe allegations in Paragraph 352.\n\n\n                                            226\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS           Document 79        filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 227 of 269\n\n\n\n\n353. At all relevant times, the material misrepresentations and omissions particularized\n   in this Complaint directly or proximately caused or were a substantial contributing\n   cause of the damages sustained by Plaintiff and other members of the Class. As\n   described herein, during the Class Period, Defendants made or caused to be made a\n   series of materially false and/or misleading statements concerning the Company\u2019s\n   business prospects. These material misstatements and/or omissions had the cause\n   and effect of creating in the market an unrealistically positive assessment of the\n   Company and its well-being and prospects, thus causing the Company\u2019s securities to\n   be overvalued and artificially inflated at all relevant times and resulting in Plaintiff and\n   other members of the Class purchasing ModivCare\u2019s securities at artificially inflated\n   prices, thus causing the damages complained of herein.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 353 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants otherwise deny\n\nthe allegations in Paragraph 353.\n\n354. When Defendants\u2019 prior misrepresentations and fraudulent conduct were\n   disclosed and became apparent to the market, the price of ModivCare\u2019s common\n   stock declined significantly as the prior, artificial inflation came out of the prices of the\n   common stock as follows:\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 354 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants otherwise deny\n\nthe allegations in Paragraph 354.\n\n       A.     On May 4, 2023, ModivCare Issued the First Set of Corrective\n              Disclosures\n\n355. On May 4, 2023, in response to Defendants\u2019 corrective disclosures in the 1Q2023\n   Press Release and 1Q2023 Earnings Call which revealed the Company had a net loss\n   of $4.0 million for the quarter and had expended nearly $3 million in cash as a result\n   of a $7 million reduction in contract payables and $31 million increase in contract\n   receivables, ModivCare\u2019s common stock price fell sharply, declining $11.30 per share,\n   or approximately 16%, from $69.30 per share on May 3, 2023 to $58.00 per share on\n   May 4, 2023, thereby removing the artificial inflation caused and/or maintained by\n   Defendants\u2019 false and misleading statements and causing economic loss to investors\n   who had purchased ModivCare\u2019s securities during the Class Period.\n\n\n                                             227\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 228 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 355 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit and allege\n\nthat ModivCare\u2019s stock prices at various times are matters of public record and deny any\n\nallegations inconsistent therewith. Paragraph 355 also characterizes or quotes from\n\nModivCare\u2019s May 4, 2023 press release and earnings call, and Defendants respectfully\n\nrefer the Court to the complete document and recording of the earnings call, which speak\n\nfor themselves, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly\n\nadmitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 355.\n\n356. Analysts were concerned by the Company\u2019s reported cash flow and NEMT\n   performance. For instance, on May 5, 2023, Barrington Research issued a report\n   reducing its price target from $143 to $92 \u201cdue to the uncertainties currently\n   overhanging both NEMT and personal care\u201d and \u201cless debt reduction in FY/23 than ...\n   previously envisioned due to Q1\u2019s weak FCF performance.\u201d\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the allegations concerning analysts\u2019 states of mind, and deny them on that\n\nbasis. Paragraph 356 characterizes or quotes from a Barrington Research analyst report\n\ndated May 5, 2023, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 356.\n\n357. The May 5, 2023 Barrington report also expressed disappointment with the\n   Company\u2019s NEMT\u2019s Adjusted EBITDA margin, stating in relevant part:\n      NEMT\u2019s 7.5% adjusted EBITDA margin in the quarter was\n      disappointing and was down 180 bps versus the comparable quarter a\n      year ago. This result was due to increased service expense per trip and\n      increased trips per member.\n\n\n\n\n                                           228\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 229 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the allegations concerning analysts\u2019 states of mind, and deny them on that\n\nbasis. Paragraph 357 characterizes or quotes from a Barrington Research analyst report\n\ndated May 5, 2023, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 357.\n\n       B.     On August 3, 2023 and August 4, 2023, ModivCare Issued the Second\n              Set of Corrective Disclosures\n\n358. On August 3, 2023, after the market closed, Defendants disclosed in the 2Q2023\n   Press Release that ModivCare slashed 2023 full-year Adjusted EBITDA guidance due\n   to \u201cincreased utilization and related higher call volumes in NEMT,\u201d \u201cnew contract win\n   implementation delays, and contract attrition from prior years[,]\u201d and that the Company\n   had used $108.2 million in cash and drew $126.5 million on its revolving credit facility.\n   The following day, during the 2Q2023 Earnings Call, Defendants further elaborated\n   that ModivCare\u2019s use of $108 million in cash flow and $111.5 million credit draw\n   stemmed from \u201ca temporary timing mismatch between payments and collections\u201d\n   related to the Company\u2019s shared risk NEMT contracts and accelerated payments\n   made to \u201ca few large state clients\u201d that \u201coccurred earlier than anticipated.\u201d Indeed,\n   ModivCare chalked the approximately $65 million accelerated payments up to\n   \u201c[p]rioritizing long-term customer relationships[.]\u201d\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 358 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s August 3,\n\n2023 press release and August 4, 2023 earnings call, and Defendants respectfully refer\n\nthe Court to the complete document and recording of the earnings call, which speak for\n\nthemselves, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants otherwise deny\n\nthe allegations in Paragraph 358.\n\n359. In response to Defendants\u2019 corrective disclosures in the 2Q2023 Press Release\n   and the 2Q2023 Earnings Call, ModivCare\u2019s common stock price declined $2.86, or\n   approximately 7%, from $38.24 per share on August 3, 2023, to close at $35.38 per\n   share on August 4, 2023.\n\n\n                                            229\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 230 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 359 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit and allege\n\nthat ModivCare\u2019s earnings and stock prices at various times are matters of public record\n\nand deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly admitted,\n\nDefendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 359.\n\n360. Analysts were alarmed by ModivCare\u2019s reported cash flow and debt. For instance,\n   in an August 4, 2023 report published by Deutsche Bank (the \u201cAugust 2023 Deutsche\n   Bank Report\u201d), the analyst noted that 2Q fell short of expectations and \u201cthe forward\n   outlook deteriorated more materially[,]\u201d stating in relevant part:\n       While 2Q came in short of expectations, the forward outlook\n       deteriorated more materially and resulted in MODV cutting FY23\n       EBITDA guidance by 11% at the mid-point. The lower EBITDA outlook\n       alongside an acceleration in the balancing of COVID-era payables and\n       receivables forced MODV to draw down further on its revolver and seek an\n       amendment to increase the leverage covenant with FCF coming in at\n       negative $117m for the quarter.\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the allegations concerning analysts\u2019 states of mind, and on that basis deny\n\nthem. Paragraph 360 characterizes or quotes from a Deutsche Bank analyst report dated\n\nAugust 4, 2023, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 360.\n\n361. The August 2023 Deutsche Bank report attributed the lowered outlook to NEMT\n   service expenses costs, stating in relevant part: \u201cthe cut to the outlook clearly indicates\n   that the elevated service expense cost pressures will remain in place through at least\n   the rest of the year.\u201d\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 361 characterizes or quotes from a Deutsche Bank analyst\n\nreport dated August 4, 2023, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete\n\n\n\n                                            230\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 231 of 269\n\n\n\n\ndocument, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 361.\n\n362. The August 2023 Deutsche Bank report further noted ModivCare\u2019s \u201cunexpected\n   acceleration\u201d of payments to NEMT customers that pressured cash flow, stating in\n   relevant part:\n      Separately, MODV experienced an unexpected acceleration in the\n      balancing of its contract payables and receivables in 2Q that created\n      a $96m drag on cash from operations. The unexpected cash flow\n      pressure forced MODV to draw another $112m on its revolver in 2Q,\n      ending with ~$6m in cash on the balance sheet. The intra-quarter\n      increase in the revolver\u2019s leverage covenant has had MODV\u2019s bonds under\n      pressure over the last month, with the 2025 issue now trading at about ~\n      $0.89 on the dollar and the 2029\u2019s trading down to ~$0.66.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 362 characterizes or quotes from a Deutsche Bank analyst\n\nreport dated August 4, 2023, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete\n\ndocument, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 362.\n\n363. In an August 7, 2023 report, Barrington Research noted that ModivCare\u2019s \u201cCash\n   Flow Concerns, Leverage & Operational Risks Overshadow[ed]\u201d the Company\u2019s\n   2Q2023 performance, stating in relevant part:\n      ModivCare ended the quarter with $7.0 million in cash and equivalents and\n      about $1.1 billion in total debt. Cash flows from operations in the quarter\n      were around -$108.2 million largely due to the material impact from the\n      COVID-related reconciliation and refunding actions in certain contracts\n      with profit corridors. Management stated that a couple of customers\n      received accelerated payments of around $65 million in aggregate that\n      were not anticipated a few months ago in terms of the timing. The\n      quarter\u2019s cash flows were also negatively impacted by a $17 million growth\n      in receivables and a $9.6 million settlement with the company\u2019s former CEO.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 363 characterizes or quotes from a Barrington Research\n\nanalyst report dated August 7, 2023, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the\n\n\n\n\n                                          231\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 232 of 269\n\n\n\n\ncomplete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 363.\n\n364. As a result, Barrington Research reduced its price target for ModivCare\u2019s stock\n   from $92 to $58, stating in relevant part:\n      We are maintaining an OUTPERFORM investment rating on MODV but are\n      materially reducing our price target to $58 (from $92 previously) due\n      to the difficult macro backdrop as well as the lower-than-anticipated cash\n      flow outlook in FY/23 and high balance sheet leverage.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 364 characterizes or quotes from a Barrington Research\n\nanalyst report dated August 7, 2023, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the\n\ncomplete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 364.\n\n      C.     On February 22, 2024 and February 23, 2024, ModivCare Issued the\n             Third Set of Corrective Disclosures\n\n365. On February 22, 2024, after the market closed, Defendants disclosed in the\n   FY2023 Press Release that ModivCare\u2019s free cash flow for 4Q2023 and FY2023 were\n   negative $36.8 million and negative $125.3 million, respectively, the Company had\n   drawn $113.8 million from its revolving credit facility, had encountered NEMT margin\n   pressure as well as \u201csooner than anticipated, large COVID-related working capital\n   needs[,]\u201d and had not recouped an anticipated ~$35.9 million payment from a client.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 365 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 22,\n\n2024 press release, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete\n\ndocument, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 365.\n\n366. In analyst reports published prior to the Company\u2019s FY2023 Earnings Call the\n   following day, analysts once again expressed concern about ModivCare\u2019s cash flow\n   and debt. For instance, a February 23, 2024 Deutsche Bank report, titled \u201cFirst blush\n   \u2014 another bump in the road, downgrade to Hold[,]\u201d (the \u201cDB Pre-EC Report\u201d)\n   acknowledged the Company\u2019s guidance miss, stating: \u201cMODV is guiding 1Q24\n\n\n                                          232\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 233 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   EBITDA to be $30.5m, which is 36% below consensus.\u201d The report attributed the miss\n   to \u201cseveral reasons[,]\u201d stating in relevant part:\n       There are several reasons to this miss. The one we were expecting was\n       around redetermination, which MODV sizes up at $6 - $8m and believes we\n       are now 70% through the process. However, the new information was\n       around contract losses in NEMT.\n\n       These contract losses make up $10 - $12m of the miss versus consensus\n       and are made up of three components: (1) Some of MODV customers lost\n       state RFPs, so MODV lost that business and we estimate this headwind at\n       ~$4m; (2) MODV used to have a carve out with the NY Health\n       Department, which no longer exists, and we estimate this as a ~$4m\n       headwind; (3) One of MODV\u2019s largest customers, which we believe is\n       UNH, has transitioned some of the business away from MODV to a\n       competitor and we believe this is about $9m of the impact.\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the allegations concerning analysts\u2019 states of mind, and on that basis deny\n\nthem. Paragraph 366 characterizes or quotes from a Deutsche Bank analyst report dated\n\nFebruary 23, 2024, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 366.\n\n367. The DB Pre-EC Report also noted that \u201c[c]ash flows are once again an issue for\n   MODV, which could attract some unpleasant attention.\u201d The report elaborated, stating\n   in relevant part:\n       After struggling for FCF over the past few years, investors were optimistic\n       that normalized earnings could lead to cash flows returning. In 4Q, MODV\n       had a $31m use of cash due to contract payables and receivables and\n       another $6m from restructuring costs and had to draw on its revolver for\n       $31m in order to finish the year with $2m of cash on the BS. Equity\n       investors typically view companies drawing on the revolver to fund\n       operations as a red flag.\n\n       Management is guiding FCF to be $40 - $60m in 2024 which will, once again,\n       be back end loaded. The pressure is coming from $20 - $30m working\n       capital due to redetermination and utilization returning and another\n\n\n                                           233\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 234 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       $10 - $20m of restructuring costs.\n\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 367 characterizes or quotes from a Deutsche Bank analyst\n\nreport dated February 23, 2024, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the\n\ncomplete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 367.\n\n368. In its conclusion, the DB Pre-EC Report downgraded ModivCare to hold, stating in\n   relevant part:\n       With several bumps on the road over the past year and struggles with\n       FCF generation, we are unable to continue recommending MODV and\n       downgrade to a Hold. Our new price target is $40, which is based on 8.4x\n       2024 EV/EBITDA (vs 8.3x previously). Our target multiple is moderately\n       below MODV\u2019s historical average, which we believe is justified due to\n       the uncertainty surrounding redetermination/ utilization risks in NEMT,\n       cash flow issues, and high leverage. We continue to like this company\n       and management team and hope that the hockey stick of both EBITDA and\n       FCF materialize in 2H:24, for us to view the stock more positively.\n\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 368 characterizes or quotes from a Deutsche Bank analyst\n\nreport dated February 23, 2024, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the\n\ncomplete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 368.\n\n369. Then, on February 23, 2024, before the market opened, Defendants further\n   disclosed that ModivCare\u2019s shared risk contracts were not serving to normalize the\n   Company\u2019s cash flow or working capital. Instead, Defendant Gutierrez disclosed that\n   ModivCare\u2019s cash flow was negative $37 million because a large MCO customer\n   \u201cdelayed payments under multiple contracts\u201d and that \u201c[t]he primary fluctuations in [the\n   Company\u2019s] quarterly working capital [were] driven by the shared risk contracts with\n   our NEMT clients, with payments and reconciliations occurring over varying time\n   periods.\u201d Defendants also disclosed that ModivCare was facing headwinds due to\n   several contract losses, including \u201ca few MCO clients not securing their state\n   contracts[,]\u201d a state health department\u2019s decision to transition business to a competitor,\n\n\n\n\n                                            234\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 235 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   and another payor\u2019s decision to allocate business volume away from ModivCare due\n   to the Company\u2019s purported legacy service issues.\n      ANSWER: Defendants need not respond to the allegations in Paragraph 369 to\n\nthe extent they are unrelated to the alleged misstatements in ModivCare\u2019s Form 10-K and\n\n10-Q risk disclosures, which are the only alleged misstatements that the Court addressed\n\nin its August 7, 2026 Order, and Defendants deny them on that basis. See Dkt. 67 at 5;\n\nsee also Dkt. 74 at 2\u20133. To the extent a response is required, Paragraph 369\n\ncharacterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s February 23, 2024 earnings call, and\n\nDefendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete recording from the earnings call,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 369.\n\n370. In response to Defendants\u2019 corrective disclosures in the FY2023 Press Release\n   and FY2023 Earnings Call, ModivCare\u2019s common stock price fell $17.25 per share, or\n   approximately 39%, from a close of $43.87 on February 22, 2024 to a close of $26.62\n   on February 23, 2024 on heavy trading volume.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 370 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit and allege\n\nthat ModivCare\u2019s earnings and stock prices at various times are matters of public record\n\nand deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly admitted,\n\nDefendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 370.\n\n371. Analysts were exasperated about the Company\u2019s dismal financial results, focusing\n   on the unexpected loss of customers and delayed payments. For instance, a February\n   23, 2024 Deutsche Bank report, titled \u201cMake or break time, need to execute\u201d (\u201cDB\n   Post-EC Report\u201d) noting that the Company\u2019s \u201cinitial 2024 EBITDA guidance of $190m\n   to $210m disappointed street expectation of $211m.\u201d The DB Post-EC Report\n   elaborated on ModivCare\u2019s \u201c1Q Miss and Contract Issues[,]\u201d stating in relevant part:\n\n\n\n                                          235\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 236 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      The 36% miss on the 1Q EBITDA outlook relative to consensus is mainly\n      driven by lost contracts and wallet share with a key client. These items are\n      expected to be a combined $11m drag on 1Q EBITDA at the mid-point (we\n      had previously assumed $17m due to including restructuring charges),\n      though we suspect some of the $5m headwind from G&A could be related\n      to the lower fixed cost leverage as a result of the lost revenues.\n\n      25% of this headwind is due to MODV customers losing state RFPs and,\n      hence, no longer requiring MODV\u2019s services. While this is an unfortunate\n      development, it is largely out of the company\u2019s control and is likely more 1x\n      in nature.\n\n      Another 25% is driven by a lost contract with the NY Health\n      Department. MODV lost the contract because the dept. had been\n      operating under a carve out but transitioned to a full-broker model,\n      opening up competition and resulting in MODV losing the deal. While\n      we don\u2019t know exactly why MODV didn\u2019t win the new contract, it could\n      be related to the legacy technology and quality issues that impacted\n      the third item.\n\n      The third and largest headwind in this bucket is business that MODV\n      lost to a competitor at one of its largest customers, which we believe\n      to be UNH. MODV didn\u2019t lose the entire contract and is still the largest\n      vendor for this customer, but the previously mentioned tech/quality\n      issues, specifically around integration into the payors systems, cost\n      MODV a material chunk of business with this payor.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the allegations concerning analysts\u2019 state of mind, and on that basis deny\n\nthem. Paragraph 371 characterizes or quotes from a Deutsche Bank analyst report dated\n\nFebruary 23, 2024, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document,\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 371.\n\n372. The DB Post-EC Report elaborated on the largest headwind, stating in relevant\n   part:\n      While the first item is out of MODV\u2019s control and the NY contract loss is a\n      relatively unique situation given the previous carve out, we retain some\n\n\n\n                                           236\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 237 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      concern around the loss of wallet share with the large customer.\n      Management indicated that tech. improvements have been\n      implemented and MODV can now integrate payors\u2019 systems with its own,\n      which it believes will protect its remaining business with this client and drive\n      future contract wins. But we believe the potential of further losses with\n      this customer or others needs to be monitored given the recent\n      developments, which could offset the net new business tailwinds\n      slated to start coming through in 2Q that are required to stabilize the\n      business. We also note that all MCO contracts here are evergreen \u2013 so\n      when the vendor performs well, it typically retains the business, but it works\n      the same way going the other direction which can result in abrupt losses\n      like this.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 372 characterizes or quotes from a Deutsche Bank analyst\n\nreport dated February 23, 2024, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the\n\ncomplete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 372.\n\n373. The DB Post-EC Report also addressed ModivCare\u2019s \u201cFL Payment Delay and\n   FCF[,]\u201d recognizing that Defendant Sampson dodged providing specifics for the\n   delayed payment, stating in relevant part:\n      4Q FCF came in at -$37m on -$25.6m of cash from operations as one of\n      MODV\u2019s clients in Florida delayed a payment, driving a $15m increase in\n      receivables as payables declined $16m. Mismatch between receivables\n      and payables has been a persistent cash flow headwind for MODV\n      over the last year. While much of the 2023 headwind was driven by the\n      broad-based increase in utilization, this 4Q headwind is related to this\n      one specific client. Commentary around why the payment was not\n      made was light, and while MODV sounded confident it would receive\n      payment in the next six months as the contract states, the continued\n      volatility in and unpredictability of cash flows is both pressuring\n      leverage levels and results in investors ascribing a lower multiple to\n      MODV\u2019s FCF, even when it does improve. With FCF projected negative in\n      1H but at $40-$60m for the full-year and MODV already raising its covenant\n      leverage limits, we look for manageable burn levels in 2Q ahead of the 2H\n      inflection as well as improved visibility and consistency here.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 373 characterizes or quotes from a Deutsche Bank analyst\n\nreport dated February 23, 2024, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the\n\n\n                                           237\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 238 of 269\n\n\n\n\ncomplete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 373.\n\n374. The DB Post-EC Report next commented on ModivCare\u2019s \u201cNEMT margins and\n   back half ramp[,]\u201d noting that there was a \u201clack of visibility into quarter to quarter\n   performance of the shared risk contract book[:]\u201d\n      MODV expects to see strong sequential growth in paid trips throughout the\n      year as the impact from redetermination crests in 2Q as the company brings\n      on new contract wins. The strong volume growth outlook, combined with\n      ongoing cost savings initiatives, drives the company\u2019s view that NEMT\n      margins can exit 2024 in the 8-8.5% range, which we estimate represents\n      350-400 bps of expansion from 1Q->4Q. While trip growth has been solid\n      and MODV should have reasonable visibility into \u201824 volume growth given\n      the new contracts are coming online in the next couple months, we are\n      more cautious on the margin side. MODV has pointed toward an easing\n      labor market recently, and the company\u2019s efficiency initiatives should\n      continue to drive service expense per trip lower. But lack of visibility into\n      quarter to quarter performance of the shared-risk contract book and\n      the aggressive operating leverage implied in the 2H quarters is likely\n      to result in investors taking a wait-and-see approach. Longer-term,\n      MODV targets a 9-12% EBITDA margin for NEMT vs 7.1% in FY23. While\n      we continue to see this level of profitability as achievable, we see\n      significant uncertainty around the timing of when NEMT can\n      consistently run in the targeted range.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 374 characterizes or quotes from a Deutsche Bank analyst\n\nreport dated February 23, 2024, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the\n\ncomplete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 374.\n\n375. The DB Post-EC report remarked on the uncertainties surrounding the Company,\n   stating in relevant part:\n      We continue to like the MODV management team and its plans to stabilize\n      the business, but the combination of headwinds and uncertainties\n      around lost contracts, NEMT margins, cash flow generation and\n      leverage, we simply see too much risk to recommend the stock at\n      current levels. If MODV is able to get through 1H and execute the guided\n      2H ramp on margins and cash flows, the stock should bounce back and the\n\n\n                                          238\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 239 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      company can start to position its messaging around improved margins and\n      consistency in 2025. But given the several false starts over the last few\n      years and the pertinent near-term items discussed above, we remain Hold\n      rated.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 375 characterizes or quotes from a Deutsche Bank analyst\n\nreport dated February 23, 2024, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the\n\ncomplete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 375.\n\n376. In a February 26, 2024 report, titled \u201cQ4 Results OK but Multiple Operational\n   Uncertainties Plus High Leverage is Too Much; Reduce to MARKET PERFORM with\n   New Speculative Suitability Rating\u201d (the \u201cFebruary 2024 Barrington Report\u201d),\n   Barrington Research downgraded its rating of ModivCare\u2019s stock from \u201coutperform\u201d to\n   \u201cmarket perform\u201d due to \u201cthe near-term operational uncertainties plus a massively\n   leveraged balance sheet[.]\u201d The report added that the Company\u2019s FY2024 initial\n   guidance was \u201cwell below what we had previously been modeling.\u201d\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 376 characterizes or quotes from a Barrington Research\n\nanalyst report dated February 26, 2024, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to\n\nthe complete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 376.\n\n377. The February 2024 Barrington Report also noted that material impact of the NEMT\n   delayed payments and lost contracts, stating in relevant part:\n      On the other hand, the company also disclosed that one of its clients\n      (\u201can MCO client with a specific contract in Florida\u201d) had not paid $35.9\n      million that ModivCare believes is owed contractually. Management is\n      hopeful that a successful resolution (i.e. a full payment) will be forthcoming\n      over the next 30-60 days. In addition, the company stated that a large\n      client had recently decided to diversify volume away from ModivCare\n      and that this would materially impact Q1/24 results in NEMT. In addition,\n      a few MCO clients were not able to secure their state contracts thereby\n      negatively impacting MODV. Finally, a state health department also made\n      a decision to transition to a full broker model favoring an incumbent\n      competitor.\n\n\n\n                                          239\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS       Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                    pg 240 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 377 characterizes or quotes from a Barrington Research\n\nanalyst report dated February 26, 2024, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to\n\nthe complete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 377.\n\n378. Like the DB Post-EC report, the February 2024 Barrington Report expressly noted\n   Defendants\u2019 elusive responses to questions concerning whether the delayed payment\n   concerned \u201cmaterial disagreements\u201d regarding the balance owed, stating in relevant\n   part:\n      The company seems to anticipate negative free cash flow in 1H/24 and\n      materially positive free cash generation in 2H/24 as new contract starts and\n      cost savings initiatives start to impact in a meaningful way. That said, the\n      company\u2019s forecast of $40-60 million in FCF in FY/24 is largely fueled\n      by collecting the $35.9 million receivable it believes is owed by a client\n      in Florida.\n\n      \u2026\n\n      The company\u2019s decision not to answer certain questions during its\n      conference call frankly rattled us a bit. Historically, management has\n      seemed largely forthcoming. Questions that were specifically asked but\n      not clearly answered or items which could have given clarity but\n      seemed to be left intentionally murky included 1) expectations for the\n      likely cash flow deficit in Q1 and Q2 \u2013 this could have provided an\n      insight into exactly how back-end loaded FCF guidance actually is; 2)\n      the actual adjusted EBITDA generated at Matrix in 2023 - this is simply a\n      number and would have been an easy question to have answered and; 3)\n      whether or not there is a \u201cmaterial disagreement\u201d regarding the $35.9\n      million that ModivCare believes it is contractually owed \u2013 an answer\n      such as \u201cYes, clearly a disagreement, but not one of significant size\u201d would\n      have provided some comfort that this issue will probably not drag out\n      beyond management\u2019s 30-60 day forecast for resolution and, in a worst\n      case scenario, could be quickly settled for a figure close to the estimated\n      amount.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 378 characterizes or quotes from a Barrington Research\n\nanalyst report dated February 26, 2024. Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the\n\n\n\n\n                                          240\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 241 of 269\n\n\n\n\ncomplete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 378.\n\n       D.     On September 12, 2024, ModivCare Issued the Fourth Corrective\n              Disclosure\n\n379. On September 12, 2024, ModivCare filed a Form 8-K with the SEC disclosing that\n   the Company was still facing collectability and cash flow issues, despite most of the\n   Company\u2019s NEMT contracts being capitated shared risk contracts. In the Form 8-K,\n   Defendants disclosed that ModivCare added a note disclosing events subsequent to\n   the issuance of its FY2023 Form 10-K regarding the Company\u2019s collectability issues.\n   The note explained that \u201cthe Company has not offset the existing and continued\n   accumulation of receivables during the period\u201d and though \u201ccollection and mitigation\n   efforts continue, there remains the possibility that the Company will not achieve full\n   resolution in a timely manner or at all if unforeseen circumstances arise.\u201d\n       ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare filed a Form 8-K with the SEC on\n\nSeptember 12, 2024. Paragraph 379 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s\n\nSeptember 12, 2024 Form 8-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the\n\ncomplete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the allegations in Paragraph\n\n379.\n\n380. The Form 8-K further revealed that the Company\u2019s \u201caccompanying consolidated\n   financial statements for the year ended December 31, 2023 were prepared assuming\n   the Company will continue as a going\u201d and as of September 12, 2024, due to\n   uncertainty around the \u201ctiming of the collection of outstanding contract receivables[,]\u201d\n   \u201csubstantial doubt exists about the Company\u2019s ability to meet its obligations as they\n   come due within one year from the date of issuance of the consolidated financial\n   statements.\u201d\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 380 characterizes or quotes from ModivCare\u2019s September\n\n12, 2024 Form 8-K, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete document,\n\n\n\n\n                                           241\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 242 of 269\n\n\n\n\nwhich speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants\n\notherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 380.\n\n381. In response to Defendants\u2019 corrective disclosure in the September 12, 2024 Form\n   8-K, ModivCare\u2019s common stock price declined $18.43, or approximately 59%, from\n   $31.19 per share on September 11, 2024 to $12.76 per share on September 12, 2024\n   on heavy trading volume.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 381 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit and allege\n\nthat ModivCare\u2019s earnings and stock prices at various times are matters of public record\n\nand deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly admitted,\n\nDefendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 381.\n\n382. Analysts were dismayed and expressed significant concern about the Company\u2019s\n   ability to collect on its contracts and the lack of visibility regarding the same. For\n   instance, a September 12, 2024 Deutsche Bank report, titled \u201cCash is king, and\n   without cash things become tricky\u201d (the \u201cSeptember 2024 Deutsche Bank Report\u201d)\n   stated:\n      MODV filed an 8-K this morning and stated: (1) There is now risk that\n      previously recognized revenues could be uncollectable; (2) If that was\n      to occur the Total Net Leverage Ratio covenant in the New Credit facility\n      could be breached and become immediately due and payable and MODV\n      doesn\u2019t have sufficient liquidity to satisfy such obligations. If that occurs,\n      MODV will seek to restructure the existing debt or raise equity or raise debt\n      to meet those obligations.\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the allegations concerning analysts\u2019 state of mind, and on that basis deny\n\nthem. Paragraph 382 characterizes or quotes from a Deutsche Bank analyst report dated\n\nSeptember 12, 2024, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete\n\n\n\n\n                                           242\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 243 of 269\n\n\n\n\ndocument, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 382.\n\n383. The September 2024 Deutsche Bank report explained that the \u201cissue keeps going\n   back to NEMT[,]\u201d stating in relevant part:\n       The issue keeps going back to NEMT. Looking at 2019, pre-COVID, the\n       segment ran at a 3.4% margin on a targeted 10% margin. Because the\n       contracts were per member per month (PMPM) when COVID hit margins\n       spiked to 20% in 2Q:20 as utilization dropped dramatically as 66% of the\n       business was full risk, 10% shared risk and 13% fee for service. As of last\n       quarter, this had shifted to 49% shared risk, 20% full risk and 14% fee\n       for service, which in theory protects NEMT margins as utilization\n       creeps up. In 2022 when 45% [o]f the business was shared risk the margins\n       were 9.6%, but as utilization continued to rebound margins were 7.1% in\n       2023 and guided to be relatively flat in 2024. Our understanding was that\n       these shared risk contacts would protect those margins as utilization\n       continued to rebound post COVID.\n\n       MODV talked about issues collecting from a contact in Florida early this\n       year where they only collected 75% of what they expected to on these\n       shared risk arrangements. We asked three questions on this topic on last\n       quarter\u2019s conference call, but it now looks like the confidence around\n       collecting those receivables has collapsed.\n\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 383 characterizes or quotes from a Deutsche Bank analyst\n\nreport dated September 12, 2024, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the\n\ncomplete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 383.\n\n384. The September 2024 Deutsche Bank report further highlighted that ModivCare\u2019s\n   collectability issues contradicted Defendants\u2019 prior statements, stating in relevant part:\n       What to do from here? The quick answer is we don\u2019t know. When\n       companies have revenue recognition issues, it[\u2018]s very challenging for an\n       outsider to assess probabilities on those collections, especially as\n       management expressed high level of confidence on collecting those\n       60 days ago. Our default scenario is to go to the worst case scenario and\n       find a baseline and if the news is better than expected, allow upside from\n       that baseline.\n\n\n                                            243\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 244 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 384 characterizes or quotes from a Deutsche Bank analyst\n\nreport dated September 12, 2024, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the\n\ncomplete document, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent\n\ntherewith. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 384.\n\n385. A September 12, 2024 Jefferies report, titled \u201cA/R Collection Issues Persist, Driving\n   Liquidity Concerns and Stock Pressure\u201d (the \u201cSeptember 2024 Jefferies Report\u201d)\n   shared similar concerns, stating in relevant part:\n       MODV shares are down ~60% today after mgmt announced through\n       an 8-k filing that A/R collections are behind schedule, which could\n       cause the company to trip debt covenants. Given MODV\u2019s inability to\n       collect on ~$60MM of A/R previously expected to drive cash inflows in Q3,\n       the company also filed a shelf registration that would allow it to raise up to\n       $200MM. Given continued A/R and working capital challenges, we maintain\n       our Hold, reduce PT to $14.\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the allegations concerning analysts\u2019 states of mind, and on that basis deny\n\nthem. Paragraph 385 characterizes or quotes from a Jefferies analyst report dated\n\nSeptember 12, 2024, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete\n\ndocument, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 385.\n\n386. The September 2024 Jefferies report further commented on ModivCare\u2019s lack of\n   visibility into payment collections under a section titled, \u201cInability to Collect Adequate\n   A/R Leads to Debt Covenant Issues and Liquidity Squeeze[:]\u201d\n       As the company has struggled to collect receivables from its payor clients,\n       MODV is now facing the prospects of tripping its credit covenants. At the\n       same time, the lack of visibility into the timing of cash collections and\n       ongoing cash burn caused by lengthening A/R cycles is impairing\n       MODV\u2019s liquidity position, forcing mgmt to seek to raise fresh capital. The\n       prospects of technical default (that could cost the company as they seek\n       covenant waivers from lenders) and the need to raise fresh capital to plug\n       the cash hole that the A/R collection issue has caused, which could\n\n\n                                            244\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 245 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      potentially dilute existing investors, has understandably put meaningful\n      pressure on the stock.\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 386 characterizes or quotes from a Jefferies analyst report\n\ndated September 12, 2024, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete\n\ndocument, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 386.\n\n      E.     On September 16, 2024, ModivCare Issued the Fifth Corrective\n             Disclosure\n\n387. On September 16, 2024, Defendants filed another Form 8-K with the SEC to\n   \u201cProvide[ a] Financial Update[,]\u201d which revealed that ModivCare had \u201cexperienced\n   delays in the timely collection of approximately $60 million of its outstanding $159.3\n   million in NEMT segment current contract receivables, primarily from MCO customers,\n   as of June 30, 2024[.]\u201d The September 16, 2024 Form 8-K added that \u201c[t]his situation\n   is primarily driven by the impacts of Medicaid redeterminations and the resulting\n   increase in utilization under its shared risk contracts.\u201d Defendants also issued\n   \u201cAdjusted Guidance\u201d in the September 16, 2024 Press Release, \u201crevis[ing] its 2024\n   Adjusted EBITDA guidance range from $185\u2013$195 million to $170\u2013$180 million,\n   primarily due to NEMT segment pricing accommodations made to strategically retain\n   and expand key customer relationships.\u201d\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare filed a Form 8-K with the SEC and\n\nissued a press release on September 16, 2024. Paragraph 387 characterizes or quotes\n\nfrom ModivCare\u2019s September 16, 2024 Form 8-K and press release, and Defendants\n\nrespectfully refer the Court to the complete documents, which speak for themselves, and\n\ndeny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 387.\n\n388. In response to Defendants\u2019 corrective disclosure in the September 12, 2024 Form\n   8-K, ModivCare\u2019s common stock price fell $1.40, or nearly 10%, from a close of $14.12\n   per share on September 13, 2024 to a close of $12.72 per share on September 16,\n   2024.\n\n\n                                          245\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 246 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 388 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants admit and allege\n\nthat ModivCare\u2019s earnings and stock prices at various times are matters of public record\n\nand deny any allegations inconsistent therewith. Except as expressly admitted,\n\nDefendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 388.\n\n389. Analysts continued to be shocked by ModivCare\u2019s about-face regarding its visibility\n   into the collectability of the $60 million. For instance, a September 17, 2024 Barrington\n   Research report, titled \u201cModivCare Cash Collection Struggles Wreck Stock but No\n   Plan to Issue Equity Currently & Will Seek Near-Term Covenant Relief from Lenders;\n   Maintain OUTPERFORM Rating; Price Target Reduced to $19 to $35\u201d recapped the\n   Company\u2019s contract delays as \u201cLast week\u2019s bombshell\u201d and stated:\n       ModivCare announced late last week that it had experienced delays in\n       collecting outstanding receivables from a couple of key payor customers\n       and that, as a result, it would likely be in violation of its debt covenants by\n       the end of the current quarter (September). This news was particularly\n       troubling since the company had explicitly stated in prepared remarks\n       on its Q2 conference call in early August that it had visibility into $60\n       million of near-term cash collections from a couple of its large\n       customers. That commentary contributed materially to our decision to\n       upgrade the shares six weeks ago and probably served as similar\n       comfort to many investors. Shares declined approximately 60% last\n       Thursday due to this disappointing news and there was certainly intense\n       speculation last week (due to a $200 million mixed shelf filing) that equity in\n       some form would need to be issued to bridge the gap created by the\n       receivables\u2019 shortfall.\n\n       ANSWER: Defendants lack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as\n\nto the truth of the allegations concerning analysts\u2019 state of mind, and on that basis deny\n\nthem. Paragraph 389 characterizes or quotes from a Barrington Research analyst report\n\ndated September 17, 2024, and Defendants respectfully refer the Court to the complete\n\ndocument, which speaks for itself, and deny any allegations inconsistent therewith.\n\nDefendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 389.\n\n\n\n                                            246\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 247 of 269\n\n\n\n\nIX.    CLASS ALLEGATIONS\n\n390. Plaintiff brings this action pursuant to Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 23(a) and\n   (b)(3) on behalf of a class of all persons or entities that purchased or otherwise\n   acquired ModivCare securities between November 3, 2022 and September 15, 2024,\n   inclusive, seeking to pursue remedies under the Exchange Act. Excluded from the\n   Class are ModivCare and its subsidiaries and affiliates, and their respective officers\n   and directors at all relevant times, and any of their immediate families, legal\n   representatives, heirs, successors, or assigns, and any entity in which any Defendant\n   has or had a controlling interest.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 390 does not allege facts to which a response from\n\nDefendants is required. Paragraph 390 further states legal conclusions to which no\n\nresponse from Defendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants\n\ndeny the allegations in Paragraph 390, and further deny that certification of any proposed\n\nclass is appropriate.\n\n391. Because ModivCare had approximately 14 million shares of common stock\n   outstanding during the Class Period, which actively traded on the NASDAQ, the\n   members of the Class are so numerous that joinder of all Class members is\n   impracticable. While the exact number of Class members is unknown at this time and\n   can only be ascertained through discovery, Plaintiff believes that there are hundreds\n   or thousands of Class members. Members of the Class may be identified from records\n   maintained by ModivCare or its transfer agent and may be notified of the pendency of\n   this action by mail, using forms of notice customarily used in securities class actions.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 391 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent Paragraph 391 states factual allegations,\n\nDefendants admit and allege that the number of ModivCare\u2019s shares of stock outstanding\n\nat various times during the alleged Class Period is a matter of public record and deny any\n\nallegations inconsistent therewith. Defendants further admit that ModivCare\u2019s common\n\n\n\n\n                                           247\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 248 of 269\n\n\n\n\nstock traded on NASDAQ during the alleged Class Period. Except as expressly admitted,\n\nDefendants deny the allegations in Paragraph 391.\n\n392. Plaintiff\u2019s claims are typical of those of the members of the Class, as all Class\n   members have been similarly affected by Defendants\u2019 wrongful conduct as alleged\n   herein. Moreover, Plaintiff will fairly and adequately protect the interests of the Class\n   and have retained competent counsel who are experienced in class action and\n   securities litigation.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 392 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 392.\n\n393. Common questions of law and fact exist as to all Class members and predominate\n   over any questions solely affecting individual Class members. These common\n   questions include:\n       \uf0b7      Whether Defendants violated the federal securities laws as alleged\n              herein;\n\n       \uf0b7      Whether Defendants\u2019 statements to the investing public during the\n              Class Period misrepresented material facts about ModivCare\u2019s\n              business and operations;\n\n       \uf0b7      Whether Defendants\u2019 public statements to the investing public during\n              the Class Period omitted material facts necessary to make the\n              statements made, in light of the circumstances under which they\n              were made, not misleading;\n\n       \uf0b7      and misleading public statements during the Class Period; and\n\n       \uf0b7      Whether the members of the Class have sustained damages and, if\n              so, the proper measure of damages.\n\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 393 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 393.\n\n\n\n\n                                            248\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 249 of 269\n\n\n\n\n394. A class action is superior to all other available methods for the fair and efficient\n   adjudication of this matter as joinder of all Class members is impracticable.\n   Furthermore, as the damages suffered by individual Class members may be relatively\n   small, the expense and burden of individual litigation make it impossible for Class\n   members to individually redress the wrongs done to them. There will be no difficulty\n   in the management of this action as a class action.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 394 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 394.\n\nX.    PRESUMPTION OF RELIANCE\n\n395. Plaintiff is presumed to have relied on Defendants\u2019 misrepresentations and\n   omissions under the fraud-on-the-market doctrine. At all times, the market for\n   ModivCare\u2019s securities was an efficient market that promptly digested current\n   information related to the Company from all publicly available sources and reflected\n   such information in the prices of the Company\u2019s common stock. Throughout the Class\n   Period:\n      \uf0b7      ModivCare\u2019s securities were actively traded on the NASDAQ;\n\n      \uf0b7      The market price of ModivCare securities reacted promptly to the\n             dissemination of public information regarding the Company;\n\n      \uf0b7      ModivCare\u2019s stock was followed by several financial analysts,\n             including those cited in this Complaint;\n\n      \uf0b7      The average weekly trading volume for ModivCare stock during the\n             Class Period was approximately 223,000 shares;\n\n      \uf0b7      As a regulated issuer, ModivCare filed with the SEC periodic public\n             reports during the Class Period;\n\n      \uf0b7      ModivCare regularly communicated with public investors via\n             established market communication mechanisms; and\n\n      \uf0b7      During the Class Period, ModivCare had over 14 million shares in\n             the public float and the Company\u2019s market capitalization ranged\n             between approximately $1.56 billion and $181.14 million.\n\n\n\n\n                                          249\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 250 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Defendants admit that ModivCare common stock traded on the\n\nNASDAQ during the alleged Class Period. Defendants further admit that ModivCare filed\n\nperiodic public reports with the SEC, communicated with investors, and was followed by\n\ncertain financial analysts. Defendants admit and allege that ModivCare\u2019s market\n\ncapitalization, average weekly trading volume of its stock, and the number of shares of\n\nModivCare stock outstanding at various points in time are matters of public record, and\n\ndeny any allegations inconsistent therewith. The allegations in Paragraph 395 that\n\nPlaintiff is invoking the fraud-on-the-market doctrine, that the market for ModivCare\u2019s\n\nsecurities was efficient, and that the market price for ModivCare securities reacted\n\npromptly to the dissemination of public information are legal conclusions to which no\n\nresponse from Defendants is required. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny\n\nthe allegations in Paragraph 395.\n\n396. Throughout the Class Period, ModivCare was consistently followed by the market,\n   including securities analysts and the media. The market relies upon ModivCare\u2019s\n   financial results and management to accurately present the Company\u2019s financial\n   results. During the Class Period, Defendants continued to pump materially false and\n   misleading information into the marketplace regarding ModivCare and material facts\n   concerning the status and capability of ModivCare\u2019s NEMT shared risk contracts and\n   NEMT services. This information was promptly reviewed and analyzed by analysts\n   and institutional investors and assimilated into the price of ModivCare\u2019s securities.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 396 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent Paragraph 396 contains factual allegations,\n\nDefendants admit that ModivCare was followed by certain securities analysts during the\n\nalleged Class Period, but deny that Defendants \u201ccontinued to pump materially false and\n\nmisleading information into the marketplace\u201d regarding ModivCare. Defendants further\n\n\n\n                                          250\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 251 of 269\n\n\n\n\nlack knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the allegations\n\nconcerning whether analysts and institutional investors promptly reviewed and analyzed\n\ninformation about ModivCare. Except as expressly admitted, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 396.\n\n397. As a result of the misconduct alleged herein, including Defendants\u2019 false and\n   misleading statements and omissions, the market for ModivCare securities was\n   artificially inflated. Under such circumstances, the presumption of reliance available\n   under the \u201cfraud-on-the-market\u201d theory applies. Thus, Class members are presumed\n   to have indirectly relied upon the misrepresentations and omissions for which\n   Defendants are responsible.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 397 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 397.\n\n398. Plaintiff and other Class members justifiably relied on the integrity of the market\n   price for the Company\u2019s securities and were substantially damaged as a direct and\n   proximate result of their purchases of ModivCare securities at artificially inflated prices\n   and the subsequent decline in the price of that stock when the truth was disclosed.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 398 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 398.\n\n399. Plaintiff and the other Class members are also entitled to a presumption of reliance\n   under Affiliated Ute Citizens v. United States, 406 U.S. 128 (1972), because claims\n   asserted in this Complaint against Defendants are predicated upon omissions of\n   material fact for which there was a duty to disclose.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 399 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 399.\n\n\n\n                                            251\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 252 of 269\n\n\n\n\n400. Had Plaintiff and other members of the Class known of the material adverse\n   information not disclosed by Defendants or otherwise been aware of the truth behind\n   Defendants\u2019 material misstatements, they would not have purchased ModivCare\n   securities at artificially inflated prices.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 400 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the allegations concerning\n\nPlaintiff\u2019s and unknown alleged class members\u2019 states of mind, and on that basis deny\n\nthem. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 400.\n\nXI.    NO STATUTORY SAFE HARBOR\n\n401. The statutory safe harbor provided for forward-looking statements under certain\n   circumstances does not apply to any of the allegedly false statements plead in this\n   Complaint. The statements alleged to be false and misleading herein all relate to then-\n   existing facts and conditions.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 401 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 401.\n\n402. In addition, to the extent certain of the statements alleged to be false may be\n   characterized as forward looking, they were not identified as \u201cforward-looking\n   statements\u201d when made and there were no meaningful cautionary statements\n   identifying important factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from\n   those in the purportedly forward-looking statements.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 402 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 402.\n\n403. In the alternative, to the extent that the statutory safe harbor is determined to apply\n   to any forward-looking statements pleaded herein, Defendants are liable for those\n   false forward-looking statements because at the time each of those forward-looking\n\n\n                                            252\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS              Document 79        filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                           pg 253 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       statements was made, the speaker had actual knowledge that the forward-looking\n       statement was materially false or misleading, and/or the forward-looking statement\n       was authorized or approved by an executive officer of ModivCare who knew that the\n       statement was false when made.\n          ANSWER: Paragraph 403 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 403.\n\nXII.      CLAIMS FOR RELIEF\n\nCOUNT I\n\nFOR VIOLATION OF SECTION 10(B) OF THE EXCHANGE ACT AND SEC RULE\n10B-5 PROMULGATED THEREUNDER AGAINST ALL DEFENDANTS\n\n404.      Plaintiff realleges each allegation as if fully set forth herein.\n          ANSWER: Defendants repeat and reallege each and every response set forth\n\nabove as if fully set forth herein.\n\n405. This claim is brought under Section 10(b) of the Exchange Act, 15 U.S.C. \u00a7 78j(b)\n   and Rule 10b-5 promulgated thereunder by the SEC, 17 C.F.R. \u00a7 240.10b-5, against\n   all Defendants named herein.\n          ANSWER: Paragraph 405 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 405.\n\n406. During the Class Period, Defendants carried out a plan, scheme, and course of\n   conduct that was intended to and, throughout the Class Period, did: (i) deceive the\n   investing public, including Plaintiff and other Class members, as alleged herein; (ii)\n   artificially inflate and maintain the market price of ModivCare securities; and (iii) cause\n   Plaintiff and other members of the Class to purchase or otherwise acquire ModivCare\n   securities at artificially inflated prices. In furtherance of this unlawful scheme, plan,\n   and course of conduct, the Defendants, and each of them, took the actions set forth\n   herein.\n\n\n\n                                                 253\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 254 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 406 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 406.\n\n407. During the Class Period, Defendants, by the use of means and instrumentalities of\n   interstate commerce: (a) employed devices, schemes and artifices to defraud; (b)\n   made untrue statements of material fact and/or omitted material facts necessary to\n   make the statements made not misleading; and (c) engaged in acts, practices and a\n   course of business which operated as a fraud and deceit upon Plaintiff and the Class,\n   all in an effort to maintain artificially high market prices for ModivCare securities in\n   violation of Section 10(b) of the Exchange Act and Rule 10b-5 promulgated thereunder.\n   Defendants acted individually and in concert in a continuous course of conduct to\n   conceal non-public, adverse material information about the Company\u2019s outlook and\n   condition, as reflected in the misrepresentations and omissions set forth above.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 407 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 407.\n\n408. During the Class Period, Defendants acted with scienter in that they knew that the\n   public documents and statements issued or disseminated in the name of the Company\n   were materially false and misleading; knew that such statements or documents would\n   be issued or disseminated to the investing public; and knowingly and substantially\n   participated or acquiesced in the issuance or dissemination of such statements or\n   documents as primary violations of the securities laws. By virtue of their receipt of\n   information reflecting the true facts of the Company, their control over, and/or receipt\n   and/or modification of ModivCare\u2019s allegedly materially misleading statements, and/or\n   their associations with ModivCare which made them privy to confidential proprietary\n   information concerning the Company, Defendants participated in the fraudulent\n   scheme alleged herein.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 408 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 408.\n\n\n\n\n                                           254\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 255 of 269\n\n\n\n\n409. Defendants, who are senior officers and/or directors of the Company, had actual\n   knowledge of the material omissions and/or the falsity of the material statements set\n   forth above, and intended to deceive Plaintiff and the other members of the Class, or,\n   in the alternative, acted with reckless disregard for the truth when they failed to\n   ascertain and disclose the true facts in the statements made by them, or other\n   personnel of ModivCare to members of the investing public, including Plaintiff and the\n   Class.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 409 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 409.\n\n410. As a result of the foregoing, the market price of ModivCare securities was artificially\n   inflated during the Class Period. In ignorance of the falsity of Defendants\u2019 statements\n   and knowing and/or reckless inability to effectuate their purported business plans,\n   Plaintiff and the other members of the Class relied on the statements and business\n   plans described above and/or the integrity of the market price of ModivCare securities\n   during the Class Period in purchasing ModivCare securities at prices that were\n   artificially inflated as a result of Defendants\u2019 false and misleading statements.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 410 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 410.\n\n411. Had Plaintiff and the other Class members of the Class been aware that the market\n   price of ModivCare securities had been artificially and falsely inflated by Defendants\u2019\n   misleading statements and by the material adverse information which Defendants did\n   not disclose, they would not have purchased ModivCare securities at the artificially\n   inflated prices that they did, or at all.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 411 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 411.\n\n412. As a result of the wrongful conduct alleged herein, Plaintiff and the other members\n   of the Class have suffered damages in an amount to be established at trial. Plaintiff\u2019s\n\n\n                                            255\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS           Document 79        filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 256 of 269\n\n\n\n\n   and the Class\u2019s losses were proximately caused by Defendants\u2019 scheme to defraud\n   the investing public by, among other things, failing to fully and accurately disclose to\n   investors adverse material information regarding the Company. Plaintiff and other\n   members of the Class purchased ModivCare securities in reliance on the integrity of\n   the market price of the securities, and Defendants manipulated the price of ModivCare\n   securities through their misconduct as described herein. Plaintiff\u2019s and the Class\u2019s\n   losses were a direct and foreseeable consequence of Defendants\u2019 concealment of,\n   among other things, Defendants\u2019 concealment of material facts related to ModivCare\u2019s\n   business and operations, in violation of federal and state laws.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 412 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants lack knowledge\n\nor information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the allegations concerning\n\nPlaintiff\u2019s and unknown alleged class members\u2019 purported damages, and on that basis\n\ndeny them. Defendants otherwise deny the allegations in Paragraph 412.\n\n413. By reason of the foregoing, Defendants violated Section 10(b) of the Exchange Act\n   and Rule 10b-5 promulgated thereunder and are liable to the Plaintiff and the other\n   members of the Class for substantial damages which they suffered in connection with\n   their purchases of ModivCare securities during the Class Period.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 413 states legal conclusions to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 413.\n\nCOUNT II\n\nFOR VIOLATION OF SECTION 20(A) OF THE EXCHANGE ACT AGAINST ALL\nDEFENDANTS\n\n414.   Plaintiff realleges each allegation as if fully set forth herein.\n       ANSWER: Defendants incorporate by reference their responses to Paragraphs 1\n\nthrough 413 as if fully set forth herein.\n\n\n\n\n                                              256\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS       Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                    pg 257 of 269\n\n\n\n\n415. This claim is brought under Section 20(a) of the Exchange Act, 15 U.S.C. \u00a7 78t,\n   against Defendants.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 415 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 415.\n\n416. Defendants are liable as primary violators of Section 10(b) of the Exchange Act\n   and Rule 10b-5 as set forth herein.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 416 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 416.\n\n417. Defendants acted as controlling persons of ModivCare within the meaning of\n   Section 20(a) of the Exchange Act. Because of their positions, Defendants had the\n   power and authority to cause ModivCare to engage in the wrongful conduct\n   complained of herein. By reason of such conduct, Defendants are liable pursuant to\n   Section 20(a) of the Exchange Act.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 417 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 417.\n\n418. Specifically, Defendants, by reason of their status as senior executive officers\n   and/or directors of ModivCare, directly or indirectly, controlled the conduct of the\n   Company\u2019s business and its representations to Plaintiff and the Class, within the\n   meaning of Section 20(a) of the Exchange Act. Defendants directly or indirectly\n   controlled the content of the Company\u2019s SEC filings, press releases and interviews\n   with various news sources cited herein related to Plaintiff\u2019s and the Class\u2019s\n   investments in ModivCare securities within the meaning of Section 20(a) of the\n   Exchange Act. Therefore, Defendants are jointly and severally liable for the\n   Company\u2019s fraud, as alleged herein.\n\n\n\n\n                                         257\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 258 of 269\n\n\n\n\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 418 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 418.\n\n419. Defendants controlled and had the authority to control the content of the\n   Company\u2019s SEC statements, press releases and other public statements. Because of\n   their close involvement in the everyday activities of the Company, and because of\n   their wide-ranging supervisory authority, Defendants reviewed or had the opportunity\n   to review these documents prior to their issuance or could have prevented their\n   issuance or caused them to be corrected.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 419 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 419.\n\n420. Defendants knew or recklessly disregarded the fact that ModivCare\u2019s\n   representations were materially false and misleading and/or omitted material facts\n   when made. In so doing, Defendants did not act in good faith.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 420 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 420.\n\n421. By virtue of their high-level positions and their participation in and awareness of\n   ModivCare\u2019s operations and public statements, Defendants were able to and did\n   influence and control the Company\u2019s decision-making, including controlling the\n   content and dissemination of the documents that Plaintiff and the Class contend\n   contained materially false and misleading information and on which Plaintiff and the\n   Class relied.\n      ANSWER: Paragraph 421 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 421.\n\n\n\n\n                                          258\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 259 of 269\n\n\n\n\n422. As set forth herein, Defendants each violated Section 10(b) of the Exchange Act\n   and Rule 10b-5, thereunder, by their acts and omissions as alleged herein. By virtue\n   of their positions as controlling persons, Defendants are further liable pursuant to\n   Section 20(a) of the Exchange Act.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 422 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 422.\n\n423. As a direct and proximate result of Defendants\u2019 wrongful conduct, Plaintiff and the\n   Class suffered damages in connection with their purchase or acquisition of ModivCare\n   securities.\n       ANSWER: Paragraph 423 states a legal conclusion to which no response from\n\nDefendants is required. To the extent a response is required, Defendants deny the\n\nallegations in Paragraph 423.\n\nPRAYER FOR RELIEF\n\nWHEREFORE, Plaintiff prays for relief and judgment, as follows:\n\n       A. Determining that the instant action may be maintained as a class action under\n\nRule 23 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, and certifying the Plaintiff as Class\n\nrepresentative;\n\n       B. Requiring Defendants to pay damages sustained by Plaintiff and the Class by\n\nreason of the acts and transactions alleged herein;\n\n       C. Awarding Plaintiff and the other members of the Class prejudgment and post-\n\njudgment interest, as well as their reasonable attorneys\u2019 fees, expert fees and other costs;\n\n       D. Granting Plaintiff leave to amend this complaint to conform to the evidence; and\n\n       E. Awarding such equitable/injunctive or other relief in Plaintiff\u2019s favor as the Court\n\nmay deem just and proper.\n\n\n                                            259\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS           Document 79        filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 260 of 269\n\n\n\n\n       ANSWER: Plaintiff\u2019s Prayer for Relief, including subparts (a) to (e) thereto, does\n\nnot allege factual allegations to which a response is required. To the extent a response\n\nis required, Defendants deny the allegations in Plaintiff\u2019s Prayer for Relief.\n\nDEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL\n\n       In accordance with Fed. R. Civ. P. 38(b), Plaintiff demands a jury trial of all issues\n\ninvolved, now, or in the future, in this action.\n\n       ANSWER: Plaintiff\u2019s Demand for Jury Trial states a legal conclusion to which no\n\nresponse from Defendants is required. Defendants reserve the right to move to strike\n\nPlaintiff\u2019s demand for jury trial on any single or all counts.\n\n\n\n\n                                              260\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS            Document 79        filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                         pg 261 of 269\n\n\n\n\nDEFENDANTS\u2019 DEFENSES\n\n       Defendants assert the following separate and additional defenses without\n\nassuming the burden of proof as to any issue or element that otherwise rests with Plaintiff.\n\nThis statement of defenses is based on Defendants\u2019 investigation to date, and Defendants\n\nreserve the right to supplement and amend these defenses during the course of litigation.\n\nAll of Defendants\u2019 defenses are stated in the alternative and do not constitute an\n\nadmission that any Defendant is liable to Plaintiff, or that Plaintiff is entitled to any relief.\n\nFIRST DEFENSE\n\n       Plaintiff has not stated a claim under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act\n\nfor each and every alleged misrepresentation or omission.\n\nSECOND DEFENSE\n\n       Plaintiff\u2019s claims, and the claims of the putative class that Plaintiff purports to\n\nrepresent, are barred, in whole or in part, because Plaintiff, and the putative class that\n\nPlaintiff purports to represent, would have purchased ModivCare\u2019s shares as they did,\n\neven with full knowledge of the facts that Plaintiff, and the putative class that Plaintiff\n\npurports to represent, have now alleged were misrepresented or omitted by Defendants.\n\nTHIRD DEFENSE\n\n       Plaintiff\u2019s claims, and the claims of the putative class that Plaintiff purports to\n\nrepresent, are barred, in whole or in part, because any increase or decrease in the market\n\nvalue of ModivCare\u2019s stock held by Plaintiff and/or any putative class members was the\n\nresult of market or other economic factors separate from the alleged wrongful conduct by\n\nDefendants.\n\n\n\n\n                                              261\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 262 of 269\n\n\n\n\nFOURTH DEFENSE\n\n       Plaintiff\u2019s claims, and the claims of the putative class that Plaintiff purports to\n\nrepresent, are barred in whole or in part because any alleged damages that Plaintiff, or\n\nthe putative class that Plaintiff purports to represent, suffered, were caused by\n\nindependent, intervening, and/or superseding events beyond Defendants\u2019 conduct,\n\ncontrol, policies, acts, or alleged material misrepresentations or omissions.\n\nFIFTH DEFENSE\n\n       Plaintiff\u2019s claims, and the claims of the putative class that Plaintiff purports to\n\nrepresent, are barred in whole or in part because Plaintiff, and the putative class that\n\nPlaintiff purports to represent, have failed to take reasonable actions to mitigate damages,\n\nif any, allegedly suffered as a result of Defendants\u2019 alleged material misstatements and\n\nomissions.\n\nSIXTH DEFENSE\n\n       Plaintiff\u2019s claims, and the claims of the putative class that Plaintiff purports to\n\nrepresent, are barred in whole or in part inasmuch as Plaintiff, or the putative class that\n\nPlaintiff purports to represent, sold their ModivCare shares for a greater price than the\n\nprice at which they purchased them, and therefore suffered no losses from their purchase\n\nof ModivCare shares.\n\nSEVENTH DEFENSE\n\n       Defendants are not liable because they acted in good faith and exercised\n\nreasonable care at all times, and any alleged misrepresentations or omissions by\n\nDefendants were based on good faith and in reasonable reliance upon information\n\n\n\n\n                                            262\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS         Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 263 of 269\n\n\n\n\nprovided by others upon whom Defendants were entitled to rely.\n\nEIGHTH DEFENSE\n\n      Plaintiff\u2019s claims, and the claims of the putative class that Plaintiff purports to\n\nrepresent, are barred in whole or in part because Plaintiff, and the putative class that\n\nPlaintiff purports to represent, are sophisticated and knowledgeable investors, knew or\n\nshould have known of the speculative nature and risks associated with an investment in\n\nModivCare, and therefore Plaintiff, and the putative class that Plaintiff purports to\n\nrepresent, assumed the risk of any alleged damages proximately caused thereby.\n\nNINTH DEFENSE\n\n      Plaintiff\u2019s claims, and the claims of the putative class that Plaintiff purports to\n\nrepresent, are barred in whole or in part because Plaintiff and/or other members of the\n\nclass had actual or constructive knowledge of the risks involved and thus assumed the\n\nrisk that the value of ModivCare stock would decline if such risks materialized.\n\nTENTH DEFENSE\n\n      Plaintiff\u2019s claims, and the claims of the putative class that Plaintiff purports to\n\nrepresent, are barred in whole or in part because any allegedly misstated facts or\n\nomissions were known to Plaintiff and other members of the putative class.\n\nELEVENTH DEFENSE\n\n      Plaintiff\u2019s claims, and the claims of the putative class that Plaintiff purports to\n\nrepresent, are barred in whole or in part to the extent that the alleged material\n\nmisrepresentations or omissions would not have been material to a reasonable investor.\n\nTWELFTH DEFENSE\n\n      Plaintiff\u2019s claims, and the claims of the putative class that Plaintiff purports to\n\n\n                                           263\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS             Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                          pg 264 of 269\n\n\n\n\nrepresent, are barred in whole or in part because of the actions, omissions, and/or\n\ncomparative fault and contributory negligence of Plaintiff, other members of the class, or\n\nother third parties, including the failure to undertake their own due diligence.\n\nTHIRTEENTH DEFENSE\n\n          Plaintiff\u2019s claims, and the claims of the putative class that Plaintiff purports to\n\nrepresent, are barred in whole or in part because the damages alleged by Plaintiff, and\n\nthe class that Plaintiff purports to represent, if any, are speculative, uncertain, and/or\n\ncontingent.\n\nFOURTEENTH DEFENSE\n\n          In the event one or more Defendants enter into a settlement with Plaintiff, any\n\nsubsequent judgment against the remaining Defendants must be reduced by the greater\n\nof the dollar value of the settlement or the amount of the settling Defendants\u2019\n\nproportionate liability.\n\nFIFTEENTH DEFENSE\n\n          Plaintiff\u2019s claims, and the claims of the putative class that Plaintiff purports to\n\nrepresent, are barred in whole or in part because this action may not be maintained as a\n\nclass action under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.\n\nSIXTEENTH DEFENSE\n\n          Plaintiff\u2019s claims fail because Defendants are not responsible (in law or in fact) for\n\nthe alleged misleading statements or omissions by others on which Plaintiff allegedly\n\nrelied.\n\n\n\n\n                                               264\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS           Document 79        filed 10/05/26     USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 265 of 269\n\n\n\n\nSEVENTEENTH DEFENSE\n\n       Class certification fails to provide adequate due process protections and would\n\nviolate the Rules Enabling Act, 28 U.S.C. \u00a7 2072, and the United States Constitution\n\ninasmuch as it constitutes trial by formula and would unfairly restrict Defendants\u2019 right to\n\nlitigate affirmative defenses to the individual claims of Plaintiff, and the class that Plaintiff\n\npurports to represent.\n\nEIGHTEENTH DEFENSE\n\n       Plaintiff\u2019s claims against any Defendant are barred to the extent that Plaintiff seeks\n\nany portion of a judgment beyond the percentage of that Defendant\u2019s responsibility, if any,\n\nas determined under paragraph (3) of 15 U.S.C. \u00a7 78u-4(f).\n\nNINETEENTH DEFENSE\n\n       Plaintiff\u2019s claims, and the claims of the putative class that Plaintiff purports to\n\nrepresent, are barred in whole or in part because, to the extent their allegations sound in\n\nfraud, they are not pleaded with particularity, as required by statute, including but not\n\nlimited to the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995, and the Federal Rules of\n\nCivil Procedure.\n\nTWENTIETH DEFENSE\n\n       Plaintiff\u2019s claims, and the claims of the putative class that Plaintiff purports to\n\nrepresent, are barred in whole or in part by the \u201cbespeaks caution\u201d doctrine to the extent\n\nthey are based on predictions, expressions of opinion, or forward-looking statements.\n\nTWENTY-FIRST DEFENSE\n\n       Plaintiff\u2019s claims, and the claims of the putative class that Plaintiff purports to\n\nrepresent, are barred in whole or in part by the equitable doctrines of laches, estoppel,\n\n\n                                              265\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS          Document 79       filed 10/05/26    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 266 of 269\n\n\n\n\nunclean hands, and/or waiver.\n\nTWENTY-SECOND DEFENSE\n\n       Plaintiff\u2019s claims, and the claims of the putative class that Plaintiff purports to\n\nrepresent, are barred in whole or in part because Defendants acted in good faith, including\n\nby acting in conformity with the law and rules and regulations of the U.S. Securities and\n\nExchange Commission, and did not directly or indirectly induce the act or acts constituting\n\nthe alleged violations and/or because Defendants had no knowledge of or reasonable\n\ngrounds to believe in the existence of facts by reason of which liability is alleged to exist.\n\nTWENTY-THIRD DEFENSE\n\n       Defendants are not subject to control person liability under Section 20(a) of the\n\nExchange Act because they acted in good faith and they did not directly, or indirectly,\n\ninduce any of the alleged acts that would constitute a violation of the Exchange Act.\n\nTWENTY-FOURTH DEFENSE\n\n       Defendants are not subject to control person liability under Section 20(a) of the\n\nExchange Act because they did not exercise general or specific control over the alleged\n\nprimary violations of Section 10(b) of the Exchange Act.\n\nRESERVATION OF RIGHTS\n\n       Defendants reserve the right to amend these affirmative defenses and to assert\n\nadditional affirmative or other defenses as the facts of this matter become known through\n\nlitigation and discovery. Defendants further reserve the right to amend this Answer to\n\nraise cross-claims or third-party claims not asserted herein as may be warranted by the\n\nrevelation of information during discovery and investigation.\n\n\n\n\n                                            266\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79       filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 267 of 269\n\n\n\n\nPRAYER FOR RELIEF\n\n      Wherefore, having fully answered the Amended Complaint and having asserted\n\naffirmative and additional defenses, Defendants pray for judgment as follows:\n\n      1. That all claims against Defendants be dismissed in their entirety and with\n\nprejudice;\n\n      2. That Plaintiff take nothing from Defendants;\n\n      3. That judgment be entered in favor of Defendants and against Plaintiff with\n\nrespect to all causes of action in the Amended Complaint;\n\n      4. That Defendants be awarded their reasonable attorneys\u2019 fees, costs, and\n\ndisbursements to the fullest extent permitted by law; and\n\n      5. For such other and further relief as the Court may deem just and proper.\n\n\n\n\n                                          267\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS    Document 79    filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                 pg 268 of 269\n\n\n\n\nDated: October 5, 2026                 Respectfully Submitted,\n\n                                       GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP\n\n\n\n                                       By: /s/ Monica K. Loseman\n                                           Monica K. Loseman\n                                           mloseman@gibsondunn.com\n                                           Allison Kostecka\n                                           akostecka@gibsondunn.com\n                                           Lydia Lulkin\n                                           llulkin@gibsondunn.com\n                                           GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP\n                                           1900 Lawrence St, Suite 3000,\n                                           Denver, CO 80202\n                                           Telephone: 303.298.5700\n                                           Facsimile: 303.298.2829\n\n                                           Brian M. Lutz\n                                           blutz@gibsondunn.com\n                                           GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP\n                                           One Embarcadero Center # 2600,\n                                           San Francisco, CA 94111\n                                           Telephone: 415.393.8200\n\n\n                                       Counsel for L. Heath Sampson, Kenneth\n                                       Shepard, and Barbara K. Gutierrez\n\n\n\n\n                                     268\n\fCase No. 1:25-cv-00306-GPG-KAS        Document 79      filed 10/05/26   USDC Colorado\n                                     pg 269 of 269\n\n\n\n\n                              CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\n      I hereby certify that on October 5, 2026, a true and correct copy of the foregoing\nwas served via the CM/ECF to counsel of record.\n                                        s/ Lynette Apodaca\n                                        Lynette Apodaca\n\n\n\n\n                                          269\n\f","ocr_status":1,"date_upload":"2026-11-11T01:53:49.433237-08:00","document_number":"79","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"039013005726","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-19T09:50:46.039662-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-19T09:50:46.044314-07:00","date_filed":"2026-10-05","time_filed":null,"entry_number":79,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-10-05.001","pacer_sequence_number":251,"description":"Defendants ANSWER to 54 Amended Complaint by Barbara K. Gutierrez, L. Heath Sampson, Kenneth Shepard.(Loseman, Monica) (Entered: 10/05/2026)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/481958315/","id":481958315,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497722998/","id":497722998,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69604143/78/skrypski-v-sampson/","date_created":"2026-10-19T09:50:46.013411-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-19T09:50:46.013427-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"78","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"039012978981","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-19T09:50:45.993769-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-19T09:50:45.999194-07:00","date_filed":"2026-09-23","time_filed":null,"entry_number":78,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-09-23.002","pacer_sequence_number":248,"description":"REPLY to Response to 74 MOTION to Clarify re 67 Order on Motion to Dismiss,,, Order on Motion for Order,, [DEFENDANTS REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO CLARIFY ORDER (DKT. 67)] filed by Defendants Barbara K. Gutierrez, L. Heath Sampson, Kenneth Shepard. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B)(Loseman, Monica) (Entered: 09/23/2026)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/481958314/","id":481958314,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497722997/","id":497722997,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69604143/76/skrypski-v-sampson/","date_created":"2026-10-19T09:50:45.960492-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-19T09:50:45.960508-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"76","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"039012941017","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-19T09:50:45.939952-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-19T09:50:45.945996-07:00","date_filed":"2026-09-09","time_filed":null,"entry_number":76,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-09-09.001","pacer_sequence_number":243,"description":"BRIEF in Opposition to 74 MOTION to Clarify re 67 Order on Motion to Dismiss,,, Order on Motion for Order,, filed by Plaintiff Christopher Skrypski. (Attachments: # 1 Declaration of Gregory M. Potrepka, # 2 Exhibit A - Email from Gregory M. Potrepka to Lydia Lulkin)(Potrepka, Gregory) (Entered: 09/09/2026)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/481958313/","id":481958313,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497722996/","id":497722996,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69604143/75/skrypski-v-sampson/","date_created":"2026-10-19T09:50:45.911889-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-19T09:50:45.911906-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"75","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"039012928962","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-19T09:50:45.891909-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-19T09:50:45.897625-07:00","date_filed":"2026-09-03","time_filed":null,"entry_number":75,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-09-03.001","pacer_sequence_number":240,"description":"NOTICE of Entry of Appearance by Joshua Evan Kluger on behalf of Christopher SkrypskiAttorney Joshua Evan Kluger added to party Christopher Skrypski(pty:pla) (Kluger, Joshua) (Entered: 09/03/2026)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/479145069/","id":479145069,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/494788035/","id":494788035,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69604143/77/skrypski-v-sampson/","date_created":"2026-09-23T14:01:59.426301-07:00","date_modified":"2026-09-23T14:01:59.436866-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"77","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"039012977745","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Order on Motion for Leave to Restrict","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-09-23T14:01:59.394947-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-19T09:50:45.968634-07:00","date_filed":"2026-09-23","time_filed":"14:38:45","entry_number":77,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-09-23.001","pacer_sequence_number":246,"description":"MINUTE ORDER. IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the Motion [# 55 ] is DENIED without prejudice. Entered by Magistrate Judge Kathryn A. Starnella on 9/23/2026. For all non-e-filer pro se parties, a copy of this document has been sent via U.S. Mail to the mailing address of record.(echa, ) (Entered: 09/23/2026)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/475795602/","id":475795602,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/491339698/","id":491339698,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69604143/74/skrypski-v-sampson/","date_created":"2026-08-25T18:04:04.740702-07:00","date_modified":"2026-08-25T18:04:04.812087-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"74","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"039012907931","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Clarify","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-08-25T18:04:04.628718-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-19T09:50:45.862451-07:00","date_filed":"2026-08-25","time_filed":"18:42:51","entry_number":74,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-08-25.001","pacer_sequence_number":236,"description":"MOTION to Clarify re 67 Order on Motion to Dismiss,,, Order on Motion for Order,, by Defendants Barbara K. Gutierrez, L. Heath Sampson, Kenneth Shepard. (Loseman, Monica) (Entered: 08/25/2026)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/475567558/","id":475567558,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/491104116/","id":491104116,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69604143/73/skrypski-v-sampson/","date_created":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.722142-07:00","date_modified":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.722164-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"73","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.695601-07:00","date_modified":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.702721-07:00","date_filed":"2026-08-14","time_filed":null,"entry_number":73,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-08-14.003","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"MINUTE ORDER. For good cause shown, Defendants' Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to Respond to Plaintiff's Amended Class Action Complaint [# 71 ] is GRANTED. Defendants' answer or other response to the Amended Complaint [# 54 ] is now due October 5, 2026. Entered by Magistrate Judge Kathryn A. Starnella on 8/14/2026. For all non-e-filer pro se parties, a copy of this document has been sent via U.S. Mail to the mailing address of record. Text Only Entry. (echa, ) (Entered: 08/17/2026)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/475567556/","id":475567556,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/491104114/","id":491104114,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69604143/72/skrypski-v-sampson/","date_created":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.646821-07:00","date_modified":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.646837-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"72","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.547554-07:00","date_modified":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.565535-07:00","date_filed":"2026-08-14","time_filed":null,"entry_number":72,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-08-14.002","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"MEMORANDUM regarding 71 Unopposed MOTION for Extension of Time to File Answer or Otherwise Respond re 54 Amended Complaint filed by L. Heath Sampson, Barbara K. Gutierrez, Kenneth Shepard. Motion referred to Magistrate Judge Kathryn A. Starnella by District Judge Gordon P Gallagher on 08/14/2026. For all non-e-filer pro se parties, a copy of this document has been sent via U.S. Mail to the mailing address of record. Text Only Entry (dclem) (Entered: 08/14/2026)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/475567552/","id":475567552,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/491104110/","id":491104110,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69604143/68/skrypski-v-sampson/","date_created":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.372037-07:00","date_modified":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.372058-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"68","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.340667-07:00","date_modified":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.347477-07:00","date_filed":"2026-08-10","time_filed":null,"entry_number":68,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-08-10.001","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"ORDER: In light of the Courtss Order (D. 67) addressing the motion to dismiss, the Parties SHALL jointly contact the Chambers of United States Magistrate Judge Kathryn A. Starnella within thirty (30) days to begin crafting a litigation plan moving forward. So Ordered. By District Judge Gordon P. Gallagher on August 10, 2026. For all non-e-filer pro se parties, a copy of this document has been sent via U.S. Mail to the mailing address of record. Text Only Entry. (gpglc3) (Entered: 08/10/2026)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/475567550/","id":475567550,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/491104108/","id":491104108,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69604143/66/skrypski-v-sampson/","date_created":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.250964-07:00","date_modified":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.250986-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"66","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"039012744343","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.171614-07:00","date_modified":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.196146-07:00","date_filed":"2026-06-11","time_filed":null,"entry_number":66,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-06-11.002","pacer_sequence_number":216,"description":"REPLY to Response to 62 MOTION for Order to REQUEST JUDICIAL NOTICE IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS MOTION TO DISMISS AMENDED COMPLAINT (DKT. 54) filed by Defendants Barbara K. Gutierrez, L. Heath Sampson, Kenneth Shepard. (Loseman, Monica) (Entered: 06/11/2026)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/475567548/","id":475567548,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/491104106/","id":491104106,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69604143/65/skrypski-v-sampson/","date_created":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.127380-07:00","date_modified":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.127402-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"65","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"039012744332","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.080922-07:00","date_modified":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.095663-07:00","date_filed":"2026-06-11","time_filed":null,"entry_number":65,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-06-11.001","pacer_sequence_number":213,"description":"REPLY to Response to 61 MOTION to Dismiss THE AMENDED CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT FOR VIOLATIONS OF THE FEDERAL SECURITIES LAWS (DKT. 54) filed by Defendants Barbara K. Gutierrez, L. Heath Sampson, Kenneth Shepard. (Loseman, Monica) (Entered: 06/11/2026)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/475567546/","id":475567546,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/491104105/","id":491104105,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69604143/64/skrypski-v-sampson/","date_created":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.050145-07:00","date_modified":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.050166-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"64","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"039012676569","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-08-24T11:27:33.933105-07:00","date_modified":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.021444-07:00","date_filed":"2026-05-12","time_filed":null,"entry_number":64,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-05-12.002","pacer_sequence_number":210,"description":"RESPONSE to 62 MOTION for Order to REQUEST JUDICIAL NOTICE IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS MOTION TO DISMISS AMENDED COMPLAINT (DKT. 54) filed by Plaintiff Christopher Skrypski. (Potrepka, Gregory) (Entered: 05/12/2026)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/475567541/","id":475567541,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/491104100/","id":491104100,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69604143/63/skrypski-v-sampson/","date_created":"2026-08-24T11:27:33.790820-07:00","date_modified":"2026-08-24T11:27:33.790841-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"63","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"039012676558","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-08-24T11:27:33.641882-07:00","date_modified":"2026-08-24T11:27:33.696038-07:00","date_filed":"2026-05-12","time_filed":null,"entry_number":63,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-05-12.001","pacer_sequence_number":207,"description":"BRIEF in Opposition to 61 MOTION to Dismiss THE AMENDED CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT FOR VIOLATIONS OF THE FEDERAL SECURITIES LAWS (DKT. 54) filed by Plaintiff Christopher Skrypski. (Attachments: # 1 Appendix Chart of Alleged Misstatements)(Potrepka, Gregory) (Entered: 05/12/2026)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/474699446/","id":474699446,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/490208946/","id":490208946,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"","date_created":"2026-08-17T07:37:08.360590-07:00","date_modified":"2026-08-17T07:37:08.360597-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Order on Motion for Extension of Time to Answer or Otherwise Respond","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-08-17T07:37:08.351481-07:00","date_modified":"2026-08-17T07:37:08.351493-07:00","date_filed":"2026-08-17","time_filed":"08:11:28","entry_number":null,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-08-17.001","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/474555069/","id":474555069,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69604143/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/490059511/","id":490059511,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69604143/71/skrypski-v-sampson/","date_created":"2026-08-14T15:33:23.197538-07:00","date_modified":"2026-08-14T15:33:23.206914-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"71","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"039012884803","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Extension of Time to File Answer or Otherwise Respond","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-08-14T15:33:23.138089-07:00","date_modified":"2026-08-24T11:27:34.496335-07:00","date_filed":"2026-08-14","time_filed":"16:00:01","entry_number":71,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-08-14.001","pacer_sequence_number":228,"description":"Unopposed MOTION for Extension of Time to File Answer or Otherwise Respond re 54 Amended Complaint by Defendants Barbara K. Gutierrez, L. Heath Sampson, Kenneth Shepard. (Attachments: # 1 Proposed Order (PDF Only) Proposed Order re Unopposed Motion to Extend Time to Respond to Complaint)(Loseman, Monica) (Entered: 08/14/2026)","tags":[]}],"entries_total":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/?count=on&docket=69604143&page_size=40"}