{"cached_at":"2026-11-15T11:48:08.621871+00:00","cl_docket_id":"69825676","docket":{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","id":69825676,"court":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/courts/njd/","court_id":"njd","original_court_info":null,"idb_data":null,"clusters":["https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/clusters/10894145/"],"audio_files":[],"assigned_to":null,"referred_to":null,"bankruptcy_information":null,"absolute_url":"/docket/69825676/tedford-v-equitable-financial-life-insurance-company/","date_created":"2025-03-31T14:38:28.058303-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-30T14:40:56.537648-07:00","source":1,"appeal_from_str":"","assigned_to_str":"Jamel K. Semper","referred_to_str":"Andre M. Espinosa","panel_str":"","date_last_index":null,"date_cert_granted":null,"date_cert_denied":null,"date_argued":null,"date_reargued":null,"date_reargument_denied":null,"date_filed":"2025-03-31","date_terminated":null,"date_last_filing":"2026-10-30","case_name_short":"TEDFORD","case_name":"TEDFORD v. EQUITABLE FINANCIAL LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY","case_name_full":"","slug":"tedford-v-equitable-financial-life-insurance-company","docket_number":"2:25-cv-02180","docket_number_core":"2502180","docket_number_raw":"2:25-cv-02180","docket_number_source":0,"federal_dn_office_code":"2","federal_dn_case_type":"cv","federal_dn_judge_initials_assigned":"JKS","federal_dn_judge_initials_referred":"AME","federal_defendant_number":null,"pacer_case_id":"564930","cause":"29:1109 Breach of Fiduciary Duties","nature_of_suit":"791 Labor: E.R.I.S.A.","jury_demand":"None","jurisdiction_type":"Federal Question","appellate_fee_status":"","appellate_case_type_information":"","mdl_status":"","filepath_ia":"","filepath_ia_json":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"ia_needs_upload":true,"ia_date_first_change":"2025-03-31T14:38:28.050789-07:00","date_blocked":null,"blocked":false,"appeal_from":null,"parent_docket":null,"tags":[],"panel":[]},"parties":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/19792799/","id":19792799,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/13597062/","attorney_id":13597062,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","docket_id":69825676,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/13597062/","attorney_id":13597062,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","docket_id":69825676,"role":2}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","docket_id":69825676,"name":"Amicus","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2026-05-20T07:36:16.391320-07:00","date_modified":"2026-05-20T07:36:16.391339-07:00","name":"Stable Value Investment Association","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/19792798/","id":19792798,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/13597061/","attorney_id":13597061,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","docket_id":69825676,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/13597061/","attorney_id":13597061,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","docket_id":69825676,"role":2}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","docket_id":69825676,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2026-05-20T07:36:16.334232-07:00","date_modified":"2026-05-20T07:36:16.334253-07:00","name":"THE INVESTMENT COMMITTEE FOR THE EQUITABLE 401(K) PLAN","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/19792797/","id":19792797,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/13597061/","attorney_id":13597061,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","docket_id":69825676,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/13597061/","attorney_id":13597061,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","docket_id":69825676,"role":2}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","docket_id":69825676,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2026-05-20T07:36:16.280328-07:00","date_modified":"2026-05-20T07:36:16.280343-07:00","name":"THE BENEFITS ADMINISTRATIVE COMMITTEE FOR THE EQUITABLE 401(K) PLAN","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/19792796/","id":19792796,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/13597061/","attorney_id":13597061,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","docket_id":69825676,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/13597061/","attorney_id":13597061,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","docket_id":69825676,"role":2}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","docket_id":69825676,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2026-05-20T07:36:16.205134-07:00","date_modified":"2026-05-20T07:36:16.205154-07:00","name":"EQUITABLE FINANCIAL LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/19792795/","id":19792795,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/13597059/","attorney_id":13597059,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","docket_id":69825676,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/13597060/","attorney_id":13597060,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","docket_id":69825676,"role":1}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","docket_id":69825676,"name":"Plaintiff","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2026-05-20T07:36:15.998594-07:00","date_modified":"2026-05-20T07:36:15.998615-07:00","name":"HOLLIS TEDFORD","extra_info":""}],"entries":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/483749215/","id":483749215,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/499571489/","id":499571489,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69825676/38/tedford-v-equitable-financial-life-insurance-company/","date_created":"2026-10-30T14:40:56.619699-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-30T14:40:56.646724-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"38","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"119024612459","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Brief in Opposition to Motion","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-30T14:40:56.587456-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-30T14:40:56.598465-07:00","date_filed":"2026-10-30","time_filed":"17:23:11","entry_number":38,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-10-30.001","pacer_sequence_number":118,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/483749198/","id":483749198,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/499571472/","id":499571472,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69825676/39/tedford-v-equitable-financial-life-insurance-company/","date_created":"2026-10-30T14:40:54.671940-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-30T14:40:54.691093-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"39","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"119024612475","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Brief in Opposition to Motion","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-30T14:40:54.641754-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-30T14:40:54.651301-07:00","date_filed":"2026-10-30","time_filed":"17:24:50","entry_number":39,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-10-30.001","pacer_sequence_number":121,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/478000814/","id":478000814,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/493614969/","id":493614969,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"","date_created":"2026-09-15T06:37:07.951649-07:00","date_modified":"2026-09-15T06:37:07.951665-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Set/Reset Motion and R&R Deadlines/Hearings","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-09-15T06:37:07.940990-07:00","date_modified":"2026-09-15T06:37:07.941007-07:00","date_filed":"2026-09-15","time_filed":"09:08:27","entry_number":null,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-09-15.001","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/477739900/","id":477739900,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/493343665/","id":493343665,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69825676/36/tedford-v-equitable-financial-life-insurance-company/","date_created":"2026-09-11T15:36:58.170850-07:00","date_modified":"2026-09-11T15:36:58.176784-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"36","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"119024416293","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Dismiss","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-09-11T15:36:58.152460-07:00","date_modified":"2026-09-11T15:36:58.157882-07:00","date_filed":"2026-09-11","time_filed":"18:18:34","entry_number":36,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-09-11.001","pacer_sequence_number":110,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/477739891/","id":477739891,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/493343656/","id":493343656,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69825676/37/tedford-v-equitable-financial-life-insurance-company/","date_created":"2026-09-11T15:36:57.573536-07:00","date_modified":"2026-09-11T15:36:57.579202-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"37","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"119024416321","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Exhibit (to Document)","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-09-11T15:36:57.552022-07:00","date_modified":"2026-09-11T15:36:57.557588-07:00","date_filed":"2026-09-11","time_filed":"18:23:31","entry_number":37,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-09-11.001","pacer_sequence_number":112,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/476954567/","id":476954567,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/492532381/","id":492532381,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69825676/35/tedford-v-equitable-financial-life-insurance-company/","date_created":"2026-09-04T06:39:28.954458-07:00","date_modified":"2026-09-04T06:39:28.963716-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"35","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"119024387580","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Order on Motion to Withdraw as Attorney","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-09-04T06:39:28.932018-07:00","date_modified":"2026-09-04T06:39:28.938655-07:00","date_filed":"2026-09-04","time_filed":"09:20:48","entry_number":35,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-09-04.001","pacer_sequence_number":108,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/476948160/","id":476948160,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/492525832/","id":492525832,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"","date_created":"2026-09-04T05:37:54.857958-07:00","date_modified":"2026-09-04T05:37:54.857985-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Set/Reset Motion and R&R Deadlines/Hearings","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-09-04T05:37:54.840248-07:00","date_modified":"2026-09-04T05:37:54.840272-07:00","date_filed":"2026-09-04","time_filed":"08:34:09","entry_number":null,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-09-04.001","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/476881348/","id":476881348,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/492456630/","id":492456630,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69825676/34/tedford-v-equitable-financial-life-insurance-company/","date_created":"2026-09-03T13:41:26.710681-07:00","date_modified":"2026-09-03T13:41:26.721933-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"34","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"119024386152","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Withdraw as Attorney","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-09-03T13:41:26.676114-07:00","date_modified":"2026-09-03T13:41:26.685918-07:00","date_filed":"2026-09-03","time_filed":"16:24:57","entry_number":34,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-09-03.001","pacer_sequence_number":103,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/474157501/","id":474157501,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/489649123/","id":489649123,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69825676/33/tedford-v-equitable-financial-life-insurance-company/","date_created":"2026-08-12T09:01:30.458090-07:00","date_modified":"2026-08-12T09:01:30.474221-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"33","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"119024293309","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Substitution of Attorney","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-08-12T09:01:30.409781-07:00","date_modified":"2026-08-12T09:01:30.418776-07:00","date_filed":"2026-08-12","time_filed":"11:49:46","entry_number":33,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-08-12.001","pacer_sequence_number":100,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/472860913/","id":472860913,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/488306992/","id":488306992,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69825676/32/tedford-v-equitable-financial-life-insurance-company/","date_created":"2026-07-31T12:37:03.399879-07:00","date_modified":"2026-07-31T12:37:03.410647-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"32","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"119024247647","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Stipulation and Order","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-07-31T12:37:03.372452-07:00","date_modified":"2026-07-31T12:37:03.380034-07:00","date_filed":"2026-07-31","time_filed":"15:01:02","entry_number":32,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-07-31.001","pacer_sequence_number":98,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/472713699/","id":472713699,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/488156460/","id":488156460,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69825676/31/tedford-v-equitable-financial-life-insurance-company/","date_created":"2026-07-30T13:05:43.963037-07:00","date_modified":"2026-07-30T13:05:43.969270-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"31","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"119024242406","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Stipulation","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-07-30T13:05:43.944693-07:00","date_modified":"2026-07-30T13:05:43.949651-07:00","date_filed":"2026-07-30","time_filed":"15:43:16","entry_number":31,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-07-30.001","pacer_sequence_number":95,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/471503591/","id":471503591,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/486910174/","id":486910174,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69825676/30/tedford-v-equitable-financial-life-insurance-company/","date_created":"2026-07-20T14:06:23.571740-07:00","date_modified":"2026-07-20T14:06:23.601819-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"30","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"119024196946","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Amended Complaint","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-07-20T14:06:23.520967-07:00","date_modified":"2026-07-20T14:06:23.530833-07:00","date_filed":"2026-07-20","time_filed":"16:53:05","entry_number":30,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-07-20.001","pacer_sequence_number":93,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/464646968/","id":464646968,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/479829025/","id":479829025,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69825676/26/tedford-v-equitable-financial-life-insurance-company/","date_created":"2026-05-20T07:36:18.751543-07:00","date_modified":"2026-05-20T07:36:18.764614-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"26","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-05-20T07:36:18.721464-07:00","date_modified":"2026-05-20T07:36:18.729202-07:00","date_filed":"2026-05-15","time_filed":null,"entry_number":26,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-05-15.001","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"TEXT ORDER; granting (ECF No. 19 ) Motion for Leave to File Amicus Brief by Stable Value Investment Association. So Ordered by Judge Jamel K. Semper on 5/15/2026. (sms) (Entered: 05/15/2026)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/464646964/","id":464646964,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/479829021/","id":479829021,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"","date_created":"2026-05-20T07:36:18.546188-07:00","date_modified":"2026-05-20T07:36:18.559743-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-05-20T07:36:18.527322-07:00","date_modified":"2026-05-20T07:36:18.527336-07:00","date_filed":"2026-01-27","time_filed":null,"entry_number":null,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-01-27.001","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"19 MOTION for Leave to File Amicus Brief no longer referred to the Magistrate Judge. Motion to be decided by the District Judge. (jd, )","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/464646958/","id":464646958,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/479829014/","id":479829014,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"","date_created":"2026-05-20T07:36:18.227234-07:00","date_modified":"2026-05-20T07:36:18.240430-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-05-20T07:36:18.207240-07:00","date_modified":"2026-05-20T07:36:18.207259-07:00","date_filed":"2025-10-29","time_filed":null,"entry_number":null,"recap_sequence_number":"2025-10-29.005","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"Set Deadlines as to 17 MOTION for Leave to Appear Pro Hac Vice . Motion set for 12/1/2025 before Magistrate Judge Andre M. Espinosa. Unless otherwise directed by the Court, this motion will be decided on the papers and no appearances are required. Note that this is an automatically generated message from the Clerk`s Office and does not supersede any previous or subsequent orders from the Court. (arm)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/464646949/","id":464646949,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/479829006/","id":479829006,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"","date_created":"2026-05-20T07:36:17.834313-07:00","date_modified":"2026-05-20T07:36:17.848939-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-05-20T07:36:17.813531-07:00","date_modified":"2026-05-20T07:36:17.813547-07:00","date_filed":"2025-10-23","time_filed":null,"entry_number":null,"recap_sequence_number":"2025-10-23.001","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"Set Deadlines as to 15 MOTION to Dismiss. Motion set for 11/17/2025 before Judge Jamel K. Semper. Unless otherwise directed by the Court, this motion will be decided on the papers and no appearances are required. Note that this is an automatically generated message from the Clerk`s Office and does not supersede any previous or subsequent orders from the Court. (adc, )","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/464646942/","id":464646942,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/479828999/","id":479828999,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"","date_created":"2026-05-20T07:36:17.466655-07:00","date_modified":"2026-05-20T07:36:17.483425-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-05-20T07:36:17.447626-07:00","date_modified":"2026-05-20T07:36:17.447642-07:00","date_filed":"2025-06-12","time_filed":null,"entry_number":null,"recap_sequence_number":"2025-06-12.001","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"Pro Hac Vice counsel, SYDNEY L. JULIANO, ESQ., and RUSSELL L. HIRSCHHORN, ESQ., has been added to receive Notices of Electronic Filing. Pursuant to L.Civ.R. 101.1, only local counsel are entitled to sign and file papers, enter appearances and receive payments on judgments, decrees or orders. (ld)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/464646929/","id":464646929,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/479828986/","id":479828986,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"","date_created":"2026-05-20T07:36:16.681819-07:00","date_modified":"2026-05-20T07:36:16.699332-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-05-20T07:36:16.661552-07:00","date_modified":"2026-05-20T07:36:16.661572-07:00","date_filed":"2025-04-01","time_filed":null,"entry_number":null,"recap_sequence_number":"2025-04-01.002","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"CLERK'S QUALITY CONTROL MESSAGE - The COMPLAINT 1 filed by MARK K. GYANDOH on 03/31/2025 was uploaded prior to being flattened. Before uploading fillable forms to ECF you must flatten the file to prevent other users from manipulating or editing the information. The easiest way to flatten a PDF form is by selecting Print to PDF and saving the flattened form, other PDF software may differ. Please visit our website under Flattening PDF Forms for guidance. Your document has been corrected. This message is for informational purposes only. (pm, )","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/464646927/","id":464646927,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/479828984/","id":479828984,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"","date_created":"2026-05-20T07:36:16.630775-07:00","date_modified":"2026-05-20T07:36:16.649876-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-05-20T07:36:16.606016-07:00","date_modified":"2026-05-20T07:36:16.606040-07:00","date_filed":"2025-04-01","time_filed":null,"entry_number":null,"recap_sequence_number":"2025-04-01.001","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"Case Assigned to Judge Jamel K. Semper and Magistrate Judge Andre M. Espinosa. (mfr)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/464586960/","id":464586960,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/69825676/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/479765274/","id":479765274,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/69825676/28/tedford-v-equitable-financial-life-insurance-company/","date_created":"2026-05-19T13:41:12.635518-07:00","date_modified":"2026-07-03T16:05:12.084784-07:00","sha1":"2cabe28b169a913087e2037596c98ebf16b215bc","page_count":13,"file_size":258711,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.njd.564930/gov.uscourts.njd.564930.28.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.njd.564930/gov.uscourts.njd.564930.28.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"Case 2:25-cv-02180-JKS-AME             Document 28      Filed 05/19/26      Page 1 of 13 PageID:\n                                             1048\n\n\n\nNOT FOR PUBLICATION\n\n                             UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                                DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY\n\n\n\n\nHOLLIS TEDFORD, individually and on\nbehalf of all others similarly situated,\n\n                         Plaintiff,\n                                                              Civil Action No. 25-cv-2180\n                        v.\n                                                                       OPINION\nEQUITABLE FINANCIAL LIFE\nINSURANCE COMPANY, THE BENEFITS                                       May 19, 2026\nADMINISTRATIVE COMMITTEE FOR\nTHE EQUITABLE 401(k) PLAN, and THE\nINVESTMENT COMMITTEE FOR THE\nEQUITABLE 401(k) PLAN,\n\n                         Defendants.\n\n\n\nSEMPER, District Judge.\n\n       THIS MATTER comes before the Court upon the Motion to Dismiss filed by Equitable\n\nFinancial Life Insurance Company (\u201cEquitable\u201d), the Benefits Administrative Committee for the\n\nEquitable 401(k) Plan (\u201cAdministrative Committee\u201d), and the Investment Committee for the\n\nEquitable 401(k) Plan (\u201cInvestment Committee\u201d) (collectively, \u201cDefendants\u201d).             (ECF 15,\n\n\u201cMotion\u201d or \u201cDefs.\u2019 Mot.\u201d) Defendants seek dismissal of the First Amended Complaint (ECF 14,\n\n\u201cFirst Amended Complaint\u201d or \u201cFAC\u201d) filed by Hollis Tedford (\u201cPlaintiff\u201d) asserting three counts\n\nunder the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (\u201cERISA\u201d). Plaintiff claims\n\nDefendants are liable for (1) breaches of the fiduciary duty of prudence under 29 U.S.C. \u00a7 1104(a)\n\n(Count I); (2) failure to adequately monitor other fiduciaries under 29 U.S.C. \u00a7 1104(a) (Count II);\n\n\n                                                 1\n\fCase 2:25-cv-02180-JKS-AME            Document 28        Filed 05/19/26      Page 2 of 13 PageID:\n                                            1049\n\n\n\nand (3) prohibited transactions under 29 U.S.C. \u00a7 1106(a)(1). For the reasons stated below,\n\nDefendants\u2019 Motion to Dismiss is GRANTED and Plaintiff\u2019s First Amended Complaint is\n\nDISMISSED without prejudice in its entirety.\n\n\n      I.    FACTUAL BACKGROUND AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY 1\n\n\n        The present dispute is brought by Hollis Tedford, a resident of Falmouth, Maine, who\n\nparticipated in the Equitable 401(k) plan (the \u201cPlan\u201d) during the course of his employment. (FAC\n\n\u00b6 29.) He purports to bring this suit on behalf of a class of likely situated individuals against the\n\nPlan\u2019s fiduciaries. (Id. \u00b6 1.)\n\n        The Plan is a defined contribution retirement plan, established pursuant to 29 U.S.C. \u00a7\u00a7\n\n1002(2)(A) and 1002(34) of ERISA. (Id. \u00b6 2.) The Plan enables individuals to make tax-deferred\n\ncontributions from their salaries to the Plan. (Id.) At all times during the putative Class Period\n\nfrom approximately 2019 to 2023, the plan had over $2 billion in assets under management. (Id.\n\n\u00b6\u00b6 11, 12, 59.) The significant value of the Plan\u2019s assets makes it one of the largest plans in the\n\nUnited States. 2 (Id. \u00b6 13.) Additionally, the Plan \u201cis also large in terms of the number of\n\nparticipants\u201d because \u201c[f]rom 2019 to 2023 it had over 12,000 participants with account balances,\n\n\n\n1\n  The facts and procedural history are derived from the First Amended Complaint (ECF 14), the\nbriefs filed by the parties (ECF Nos. 15, 20, and 22), and the accompanying exhibits and\ndeclarations. The Amicus Brief filed by Stable Value Investment Association offered context\nregarding the complex facts alleged in this matter. (ECF 19-1.) When considering a motion to\ndismiss under Rule 12(b)(6), the Court is obligated to accept as true allegations in the complaint\nand all reasonable inferences that can be drawn therefrom. See Rocks v. City of Phila., 868 F.2d\n644, 645 (3d Cir. 1989). The Court also considers any \u201cdocument integral to or explicitly relied\nupon in the complaint.\u201d In re Burlington Coat Factory Sec. Litig., 114 F.3d 1410, 1426 (3d Cir.\n1997).\n2\n  Plaintiff alleges that \u201c[i]n 2021, only 0.2 percent (1,011 of 641,747) of plans in the country had\nmore than $1 billion in assets under management. In addition, this was true at the start of the\n[putative] Class Period in 2019 where only 0.1 percent (776 of 603,217) of 401(k) plans in the\ncountry were as large as the Plan.\u201d (See FAC \u00b6 13.)\n                                                 2\n\fCase 2:25-cv-02180-JKS-AME             Document 28        Filed 05/19/26     Page 3 of 13 PageID:\n                                             1050\n\n\n\nwith a high of 15,877 participants in 2020 \u2026 only 0.1 percent (844 of 641,747) of 401(k) plans in\n\nthe country were as large as the plan [in 2021.]\u201d (Id. \u00b6 15.) Plaintiff alleges that the significant\n\nsize of the Plan renders it a \u201cjumbo plan\u201d in the contributory investment plan marketplace, and\n\n\u201cthe Plan had substantial bargaining power regarding the fees and expenses that were charged\n\nagainst participant\u2019s investments.\u201d (Id. \u00b6 6.)\n\n        Plaintiff alleges that Defendants breached their fiduciary duty of prudence \u201cby selecting\n\nand/or maintaining certain guaranteed investment contracts (\u2018GICs\u2019) in the Plan with lower credit\n\nratings when compared to similar or identical investments.\u201d (Id. \u00b6 19.) Plaintiff specifically takes\n\nissue with the choice to invest in the Equitable Fixed Income Fund (\u201cEquitable Fund\u201d). (Id. \u00b6 20.)\n\nThis fund has investments in nine synthetic GICs offered by several large American banks and\n\ninsurance companies. (Id. \u00b6 57.) Plaintiff argues this fund led to \u201csignificantly lower rates of\n\nreturn\u201d and a \u201cprudent beneficiary would not have included this underperforming investment\n\noption that also carried significantly more risk than other investment options that had similar goals,\n\ni.e., the preservation of assets.\u201d (Id. \u00b6\u00b6 20, 21.)\n\n        The Equitable Fund is a stable value investment fund that has been available to Plan\n\nparticipants since 1992. (Defs.\u2019 Mot. at 3.) Stable value investments are intended to preserve\n\nprincipal and provide bond-like returns to investors. (ECF 19-1, \u201cStable Value Investment\n\nAssociation Amicus Brief\u201d or \u201cSVIA Br.\u201d at 12; Defs.\u2019 Mot. at 4 n.2.) These funds provide a rate\n\nof return known as a \u201ccrediting rate.\u201d (FAC \u00b6 76; Defs.\u2019 Mot. at 4.) Stable value investments\n\ncome in several different forms, including \u201c\u2018synthetic\u2019 stable value funds where the principal is\n\nguaranteed by multiple \u2018wrap providers\u2019 and the fund owns the assets of the underlying funds.\u201d\n\n(FAC \u00b6 77.) Synthetic funds can be further distinguished into different subdivisions including\n\nindividually managed accounts and pooled stable value investments. (SVIA Br. at 14.) In addition\n\n\n\n                                                      3\n\fCase 2:25-cv-02180-JKS-AME            Document 28         Filed 05/19/26     Page 4 of 13 PageID:\n                                            1051\n\n\n\nto synthetic funds, GICs can come in the form of \u201cgeneral account products\u201d and \u201cseparate account\n\nproducts\u201d which have different risk projections based on the extent to which the investments are\n\nsubject to collection by creditors. (Defs.\u2019 Mot. at 4.) These different categories have \u201cdistinctive\n\nstructure[s] that may cause them to be better suited for a particular plan and its participants.\u201d\n\n(SVIA Br. at 14.) Furthermore, \u201c[e]ven within each category, the options vary widely with respect\n\nto key characteristics\u201d including crediting rates and fee structures. (Id. at 14-16.) The differences\n\nbetween stable value funds allow for investors to make \u201cintentional trade-off[s] for specific\n\nstrategic reasons\u201d to benefit the specific goals and values of plan participants. (Id. at 16.) These\n\ngoals can vary, such as guaranteeing a strict rate of return or producing maximum liquidity or\n\ntransparency into assets and fee structures. (Id.)\n\n       Defendants entered into a contract with Alight Financial Solutions, LLC (\u201cAlight\u201d) to\n\nprovide recordkeeping services for the Plan.          (FAC \u00b6 18.)    The two kinds of \u201cessential\u201d\n\nrecordkeeping services required for large Plans are \u201cBundled\u201d services which provide a \u201csuite of\n\nessential recordkeeping services\u201d 3 and \u201cA La Carte\u201d services, which have \u201cadditional fees based\n\non the conduct of individual participants and the usage of the services by individual participants.\u201d 4\n\n(Id. \u00b6\u00b6 96-98.) Plaintiff alleges Alight received \u201cmillions of dollars in indirect compensation from\n\n\n\n\n3\n  \u201cBundled\u201d services include: Basic account recordkeeping (e.g., demographic, source, investment\nand vesting records); Multi-channel participant and plan sponsor access (e.g., phone, web); Daily\nparticipant transaction accounting (e.g., purchases, redemptions, exchanges; Payroll service (e.g.,\nhardships, in-service withdrawals, termination distributions); Participant tax reporting services\n(e.g., IRS Form 1099 R); Participant confirmations, statements, and standard notices; Plan-level\nreporting and annual financial package (excluding IRS Form 5500); Participant education (e.g.,\nnewsletters, web articles, standard communication materials); Plan consulting (e.g., preapproved\ndocument services, operational materials); and Plan consulting (e.g., preapproved document\nservices, operational compliance support). (FAC \u00b6 96.)\n4\n  \u201cA La Carte\u201d services include: Loan processing; Brokerage services/account maintenance (if\noffered by the plan); Distribution services; and Processing of qualified domestic relations orders.\n(Id.)\n                                                  4\n\fCase 2:25-cv-02180-JKS-AME             Document 28        Filed 05/19/26       Page 5 of 13 PageID:\n                                             1052\n\n\n\ninvestments within the Plan\u201d in addition to direct fees paid by Equitable. (Id.) Plaintiff asserts\n\nthat large plans have the leverage to take advantage of economies of scale and achieve a lower fee\n\nrate charged per-participant, rather than a fee structure based on the assets included in a fund. (Id.\n\n\u00b6 100.)\n\n          Defendants filed the present Motion to Dismiss Plaintiff\u2019s First Amended Complaint on\n\nOctober 22, 2025. (See Defs.\u2019 Mot.) Stable Value Investment Association filed its Motion for\n\nLeave to file Amicus Brief on October 29, 2025. (See SVIA Br.) Plaintiff filed his opposition\n\nbrief on November 24, 2025. (ECF 20, \u201cOpposition\u201d or \u201cOpp.\u201d) Defendants replied on December\n\n22, 2025. (ECF 22, \u201cReply.\u201d) The Court granted SVIA leave to file Amicus Brief on May 15,\n\n2026. (ECF 26.) SVIA filed an amicus brief in support of Defendant\u2019s Motion to Dismiss on May\n\n18, 2026. (ECF 27.) 5\n\n\n     II.     LEGAL STANDARD\n\n\n          Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6) permits a court to dismiss a complaint that fails\n\n\u201cto state a claim upon which relief can be granted[.]\u201d For a complaint to survive dismissal under\n\nRule 12(b)(6), it must contain sufficient factual matter to state a claim that is plausible on its face.\n\nAshcroft v. Iqbal, 556 U.S. 662, 678 (2009) (quoting Bell Atl. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544,\n\n570 (2007)). A claim is facially plausible \u201cwhen the plaintiff pleads factual content that allows\n\nthe court to draw the reasonable inference that the defendant is liable for the misconduct alleged.\u201d\n\nId. Further, a plaintiff must \u201callege sufficient facts to raise a reasonable expectation that discovery\n\nwill uncover proof of her claims.\u201d Connelly v. Lane Const. Corp., 809 F.3d 780, 789 (3d Cir.\n\n\n\n\n5\n SVIA\u2019s May 18, 2026 brief was not considered when the Court decided Defendant\u2019s Motion to\nDismiss.\n                                                   5\n\fCase 2:25-cv-02180-JKS-AME            Document 28        Filed 05/19/26      Page 6 of 13 PageID:\n                                            1053\n\n\n\n2016). In evaluating the sufficiency of a complaint, district courts must separate the factual and\n\nlegal elements. Fowler v. UPMC Shadyside, 578 F.3d 203, 210-211 (3d Cir. 2009). Restatements\n\nof the elements of a claim are legal conclusions, and therefore, are not entitled to a presumption of\n\ntruth. Burtch v. Milberg Factors, Inc., 662 F.3d 212, 224 (3d Cir. 2011). The Court, however,\n\n\u201cmust accept all of the complaint\u2019s well-pleaded facts as true.\u201d Fowler, 578 F.3d at 210.\n\n\n    III.      ANALYSIS\n\n   A. Breach of the Duty of Prudence\n\n           In Count I of his First Amended Complaint, Plaintiff argues that the Administrative\n\nCommittee and the Investment Committee breached their duties to prudently manage Plan\n\ninvestments by selecting and retaining the Equitable Fund \u201cdespite poor performance in relation\n\nto other comparable investments.\u201d (FAC \u00b6 117.) Plaintiff claims this breach directly and\n\nproximately caused \u201cmillions of dollars of losses due to excessive costs and lower net investment\n\nreturns\u201d which lowered the amount of savings Plan participants had available to them for\n\nretirement. (Id. \u00b6 118.) Plaintiff further claims that pursuant to 29 U.S.C. \u00a7\u00a7 1109(a) and\n\n1132(a)(2), the Administrative Committee and Investment Committee are obligated to restore the\n\nlosses they caused by their breach of the duty of prudence. (Id. \u00b6 119.)\n\n       Defendants argue in response that Plaintiff failed to show plausible facts giving rise to an\n\ninference of imprudent management. (Defs.\u2019 Mot. at 9.) Specifically, Defendants claim Count I\n\nis not well-plead because (1) allegations of underperformance, without more, fail to show an\n\ninference of imprudence; (2) Plaintiff fails to provide adequate benchmarks for comparison of the\n\nEquitable Fund because the Complaint does not identify or discuss the characteristics of the fifteen\n\nstable value fund comparators; and (3) Plaintiff\u2019s allegation that the Equitable Fund was riskier\n\nthan comparators is conclusory and implausible. (Id.) Additionally, Defendants argue Plaintiff\u2019s\n\n                                                 6\n\fCase 2:25-cv-02180-JKS-AME           Document 28       Filed 05/19/26     Page 7 of 13 PageID:\n                                           1054\n\n\n\nclaims are time-barred by ERISA\u2019s six-year statute of limitations and the Administrative\n\nCommittee has no fiduciary duty regarding managing Plan investments. (Id.)\n\n       When assessing the sufficiency of an ERISA complaint, courts assess the reasonableness\n\nof a fiduciary\u2019s actions. Courts \u201cbear[] in mind ERISA\u2019s twin goals of protecting participants and\n\nencouraging plan creation through a predictable set of liabilities for employers.\u201d Mator v. Wesco\n\nDistribution, Inc., 102 F.4th 172, 184 (3d Cir. 2024). Courts must also \u201cgive due regard to the\n\nrange of reasonable judgments a fiduciary may make based on her experience and expertise\u201d\n\nbecause \u201cthe circumstances facing an ERISA fiduciary will implicate difficult tradeoffs.\u201d Hughes\n\nv. Northwestern University, 595 U.S. 170, 177 (2022). Therefore, \u201c[t]o plead a breach of the duty\n\nof prudence under ERISA \u2026 a plaintiff must plausibly allege fiduciary decisions outside a range\n\nof reasonableness.\u201d Mator, 102 F. 4th at 184. An ERISA fiduciary must manage the plan \u201csolely\n\nin the interest of the participants and beneficiaries and ... with the care, skill, prudence, and\n\ndiligence under the circumstances then prevailing that a prudent [person] \u2026 would use.\u201d\n\n\u00a7 1104(a)(1).\n\n       Courts do not determine prudence based on the results of an investment choice, \u201cbut on\n\nprocess\u2014that is, whether the facts, assessed holistically, permit a reasonable inference that a\n\nfiduciary\u2019s decision-making process was deficient.\u201d Grink v. Virtua Health, Inc., 812 F. Supp. 3d\n\n434, 451 (D.N.J. 2025) (quoting In re Unisys Sav. Plan Litig., 74 F.3d 420, 434 (3d Cir. 1996)).\n\nWhen a plaintiff does not have direct evidence of a defendant\u2019s process in making investment\n\ndecisions, convincing circumstantial evidence may suffice to establish an inference of imprudent\n\nprocess. See Anderson v. Intel Corp. Inv. Pol\u2019y Comm., 137 F.4th 1015, 1022 (9th Cir. 2025) (\u201c[A]\n\nplaintiff can make circumstantial factual allegations from which the court may reasonably infer\n\nfrom what is alleged that the process was flawed.\u201d) (internal quotations omitted); Pension Ben.\n\n\n\n                                                7\n\fCase 2:25-cv-02180-JKS-AME           Document 28       Filed 05/19/26     Page 8 of 13 PageID:\n                                           1055\n\n\n\nGuar. Corp. ex rel. St. Vincent Cath. Med. Ctrs. Ret. Plan v. Morgan Stanley Inv. Mgmt. Inc., 712\n\nF.3d 705, 718 (2d Cir. 2013) (\u201c[A] claim alleging a breach of fiduciary duty may still survive a\n\nmotion to dismiss if the court, based on circumstantial factual allegations, may reasonably \u2018infer\n\nfrom what is alleged that the process was flawed.\u2019\u201d) (quoting Braden v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., 588\n\nF.3d 585, 596 (8th Cir. 2009)). The \u201ckey\u201d to establishing an inference of imprudence based on\n\ncircumstantial evidence is to present identifiable comparators\u2014that is, a \u201cmeaningful benchmark\u201d\n\nfor comparison\u2014to the Court, which requires more than simply alleging underperformance. See\n\nAlbert v. Oshkosh Corp., 47 F.4th 570, 581 (7th Cir. 2022).\n\n       Here, Plaintiff primarily relies on allegations of underperformance to establish imprudent\n\nmanagement of the Plan. Plaintiff argues \u201cthe [Equitable Fund\u2019s] rates decreased when it should\n\nhave increased and there were wide disparities\u201d between the Equitable Fund\u2019s rates and\n\n\u201ccomparable GICs, including GIC rates offered by the same carriers.\u201d (Opp. at 19.) The Court\n\nagrees with Defendants that this is simply \u201ca repackaged allegation of underperformance\u201d because\n\nPlaintiff does not elaborate on how Defendants\u2019 process lead to Defendants choosing the Equitable\n\nFund to the detriment of the Plan participants. Hindsight is an insufficient foundation to show\n\nimprudence. See Grink, 812 F. Supp. 3d at 451. For example, courts have recognized duty of\n\nprudence claims when a plaintiff presented evidence that a plan\u2019s fiduciaries did not follow the\n\nplan\u2019s Investment Policy Statement criteria. Id. at 443.\n\n       Because Plaintiff\u2019s theory of imprudence rests solely on the allegation that the Plan had\n\n\u201cconsiderable leverage to bargain for higher crediting rates\u201d yet underperformed, meaningful\n\nbenchmarks are necessary to determine whether an inference of imprudence has been stated. (FAC\n\n\u00b6 32.) However, Plaintiff did not establish that the comparator GICs presented in the First\n\nAmended Complaint are sufficiently similar to the Equitable Fund to constitute \u201cmeaningful\n\n\n\n                                                8\n\fCase 2:25-cv-02180-JKS-AME           Document 28       Filed 05/19/26      Page 9 of 13 PageID:\n                                           1056\n\n\n\nbenchmarks.\u201d Mator, 102 F.4th at 188. As previously discussed, crediting rates are not the only\n\ncharacteristics of GICs that fiduciaries consider when choosing investments. In the First Amended\n\nComplaint, Plaintiff constructed a chart of GICs with varying amounts of assets and plan\n\nparticipants. (FAC \u00b6 85.) Plaintiff only \u201csets forth the performance of just two funds over a four-\n\nyear period and for the other thirteen, just one or two years of performance, often in non-\n\nconsecutive years.\u201d (Id.) The Court agrees with Defendants that a greater analysis of the\n\ncharacteristics of the selected GICs and their specific characteristics and plan goals is necessary\n\nfor the Court to determine they are \u201csufficiently similar\u201d for the purpose of being \u201cmeaningful\n\nbenchmarks\u201d supporting an inference of imprudence.\n\n        Plaintiff argued in his opposition brief that whether benchmarks are comparable is not\n\nproperly resolved at the Motion to Dismiss stage. (Opp. at 11.) Plaintiff is right that it would be\n\npremature to conclusively hold whether the alleged comparators are sufficiently similar, or\n\nwhether the alleged 48% rate of underperformance was sufficiently calculated. (See FAC \u00b6 86.)\n\nHowever, the Court may properly rule that a plaintiff has not met their burden of presenting a\n\nplausible argument that the comparators are sufficiently similar benchmarks, and does so today.\n\nTherefore, Defendants\u2019 Motion to Dismiss Count I of Plaintiff\u2019s First Amended Complaint is\n\nGRANTED and Count I of Plaintiff\u2019s First Amended Complaint is hereby DISMISSED without\n\nprejudice. 6\n\n    B. Breach of the Duty to Monitor\n\n        Count II of the First Amended Complaint asserts that Equitable failed to adequately\n\nmonitor the Administrative Committee and Investment Committee in performing their fiduciary\n\n\n6\n Because Count I is dismissed, the Court need not decide whether Plaintiff\u2019s claim is time barred\nor whether the Administrative Committee is a fiduciary which could be liable for breach of the\nduty of prudence.\n                                                9\n\fCase 2:25-cv-02180-JKS-AME             Document 28         Filed 05/19/26      Page 10 of 13 PageID:\n                                             1057\n\n\n\n duties. (FAC \u00b6\u00b6 121-127.) This Court has held that a duty to monitor claim cannot be asserted in\n\n an ERISA action when a duty of prudence claim has not been established. In re Allergan ERISA\n\n Litigation, No. 17-1554, 2018 WL 8415676 at *7 (D.N.J. July 2, 2018) (quoting Rinehart v.\n\n Lehman Bros. Holdings Inc., 817 F.3d 56, 68 (2d Cir. 2016)). Plaintiff rests his duty to monitor\n\n claim on the plausibility of his breach of the duty of prudence claim. (Opp. at 32.) Therefore,\n\n Defendants\u2019 Motion to Dismiss Count II of Plaintiff\u2019s First Amended Complaint is GRANTED\n\n and Count II of Plaintiff\u2019s FAC is DISMISSED without prejudice.\n\n     C. Prohibited Transaction claims\n\n         Count III of the First Amended Complaint asserts two claims of prohibited transactions in\n\n violation of ERISA \u00a7\u00a7 406(a)(1)(C) and (D). (See FAC \u00b6\u00b6 128-33.) Section 406(a)(1)(C) prohibits\n\n a direct or indirect \u201cfurnishing of goods, services, or facilities between the plan and a party in\n\n interest.\u201d \u00a7 406(a)(1)(C). Section 406(a)(1)(D) prohibits the \u201ctransfer to, or use by or for the\n\n benefit of a party in interest of any assets of the plan.\u201d \u00a7 406(a)(1)(D). Plaintiff argues the contract\n\n for recordkeeping between Alight and the Plan violated \u00a7 406(a)(1)(C) because the fees were\n\n \u201cexcessive.\u201d (FAC \u00b6 132.) Plaintiff supports this claim by presenting data showing that the Plan\n\n paid higher recordkeeping fees than other plans. (Id. \u00b6 107.) Plaintiff asserts Defendants violated\n\n \u00a7 406(a)(1)(D) by making payments pursuant to the contract using income from the Plan to benefit\n\n a party in interest. (FAC \u00b6 112.) A claim under \u00a7 406(a)(1) is well-plead if the plaintiff established\n\n a fiduciary \u201c(1) caused a plan to engage in a transaction (2) that the fiduciary knows or should\n\n know ... constitutes a direct or indirect ... furnishing of goods, services, or facilities (3) between\n\n the plan and a party in interest.\u201d Cunningham v. Cornell Univ., 604 U.S. 693, 700 (2025) (cleaned\n\n up).\n\n         Defendants do not dispute that Alight received fees for recordkeeping or that the\n\n\n                                                   10\n\fCase 2:25-cv-02180-JKS-AME              Document 28         Filed 05/19/26       Page 11 of 13 PageID:\n                                              1058\n\n\n\n Investment Committee was a fiduciary under the Plan. (Defs.\u2019 Mot. at 17.) Defendants instead\n\n argue that Alight was not a party in interest at the time \u201cit was engaged to provide recordkeeping\n\n services to the Plan.\u201d (Id.) Defendants cite Danza v. Fidelity Mgmt. Tr. Co., 533 F. App\u2019x 120,\n\n 125-26 (3d Cir. 2013) for support, on the grounds this Circuit has already held that \u201ca service\n\n provider is not a party in interest at the time it first contracts with a plan.\u201d (Id. at 18.) Furthermore,\n\n Defendants argue that payments pursuant to a valid contract are not \u201ctransactions\u201d within the\n\n meaning of \u00a7 406(a)(1)(D). (Id. at 19.) Defendants also argue Plaintiff\u2019s claim is time-barred\n\n pursuant to ERISA\u2019s six-year statute of limitations because the contract was formed over a decade\n\n before Plaintiff brought the present claims.         (Id. at 19.)   Plaintiff argues in response that\n\n Defendants\u2019 reliance on Danza is misplaced because it \u201cdid not involve revenue sharing and are\n\n therefore inapplicable.\u201d Plaintiff also argues that the Supreme Court clarified in Cunningham that\n\n revenue sharing agreements can constitute a prohibited transaction and effectively overruled\n\n Danza. (Opp. at 39.)\n\n         The Court agrees with Defendants that the holding in Cunningham was limited to holding\n\n that a plaintiff need not combat potential affirmative defenses in pleading a prohibited transaction\n\n claim. (Reply at 10.) Cunningham, 604 U.S. at 702 (\u201cThe Court today holds that plaintiffs seeking\n\n to state a \u00a7 1106(a)(1)(C) claim must plausibly allege that a plan fiduciary engaged in a transaction\n\n proscribed therein, no more, no less.\u201d). The Court also holds that Danza is on point and is still\n\n good law after Cunningham. Danza clearly held that the defendant, Fidelity, a recordkeeping\n\n servicer, was not a party in interest at the time the recordkeeping contract was formed. \u201cWhile\n\n Fidelity is currently a party in interest as a service provider to the plan, it was not \u2018providing\n\n services\u2019 and was not a fiduciary when the Trust Agreement was signed, so that transaction did\n\n not fall within a prohibited category.\u201d Danza, 533 F. App\u2019x at 125. Like Fidelity in Danza, Alight\n\n\n\n                                                    11\n\fCase 2:25-cv-02180-JKS-AME             Document 28       Filed 05/19/26      Page 12 of 13 PageID:\n                                             1059\n\n\n\n did not provide services to the Plan at the time the contract was formed. Thus, Plaintiff fails to\n\n state a claim under \u00a7 406(a)(1)(C).\n\n        As for subsection (D), Defendants argue it is well-established that payments pursuant to a\n\n valid contract are not prohibited under ERISA. See D.L. Markham DDS, MSD, Inc. 401(K) Plan\n\n v. Variable Annuity Life Ins. Co. (\u201cD.L. Markham\u201d), 88 F.4th 602, 610 (5th Cir. 2023).\n\n Defendants also find support in cases from the Western District of Texas and Southern District of\n\n California. (Defs.\u2019 Mot. at 19.) In response, Plaintiff argues that the plain text of \u00a7 1106(a)(1)(C)\n\n provides no exception for transactions pursuant to a contract that \u201ccauses the service provider to\n\n be a party in interest.\u201d (Opp. at 40.) Plaintiff cites a footnote in Comerica Bank for DALRC\n\n Retiree Benefit Tr. v. Voluntary Emp. Benefits Assocs., Inc., No. 09-CV-1164, 2012 WL 12948705,\n\n at *18 n. 27 (N.D. Ga. Jan. 11, 2012). In fact, that court disagreed with an Opinion by this Court\n\n in UFCW Local 56 Health & Welfare Fund v. Brandywine Operating P\u2019ship, L.P., 2005 WL\n\n 3555390 (D.N.J. 2005). The Comerica Bank court interpreted Brandywine to stand for the\n\n proposition that \u201cto be a party in interest, the party must have a service relationship that exists\n\n independently of the transaction that is allegedly prohibited by 29 U.S.C. \u00a7 1106.\u201d Comerica Bank\n\n for DALRC Retiree Benefit Trust, 2012 WL 12948705 at *18 n. 27. Therefore, this Court\u2019s\n\n precedents align better with the cases cited by Defendants, which state a transaction pursuant to a\n\n valid contract does not give rise to ERISA liability. Accordingly, Defendants\u2019 Motion to Dismiss\n\n Count III of Plaintiff\u2019s First Amended Complaint is GRANTED and Count III of Plaintiff\u2019s First\n\n Amended Complaint is DISMISSED without prejudice. 7\n\n\n\n\n 7\n  Because Plaintiff fails to state a claim under Section 406(a), the Court need not analyze\n Defendants\u2019 statute of limitations arguments.\n\n                                                  12\n\fCase 2:25-cv-02180-JKS-AME        Document 28     Filed 05/19/26   Page 13 of 13 PageID:\n                                        1060\n\n\n\n    IV.    CONCLUSION\n\n        For the reasons stated herein, Defendants\u2019 Motion to Dismiss (ECF 15) is GRANTED.\n\n Plaintiff\u2019s First Amended Complaint is DISMISSED without prejudice in its entirety. An\n\n accompanying Order follows this Opinion.\n\n                                                       /s/ Jamel K. Semper       .\n                                                       HON. JAMEL K. SEMPER\n                                                       United States District Judge\n\n Orig: Clerk\n cc:   Andre M. Espinosa, U.S.M.J.\n       Parties\n\n\n\n\n                                            13\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2026-07-03T01:41:29.743398-07:00","document_number":"28","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"119023947213","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":true,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Opinion","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-05-19T13:41:12.607176-07:00","date_modified":"2026-07-03T01:40:32.463083-07:00","date_filed":"2026-05-19","time_filed":"16:18:03","entry_number":28,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-05-19.001","pacer_sequence_number":89,"description":"OPINION.  Signed by Judge Jamel K. Semper on 5/19/2026. (dmr3)","tags":[]}],"entries_total":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/?count=on&docket=69825676&page_size=40"}