{"cached_at":"2026-11-15T11:44:48.214744+00:00","cl_docket_id":"70173082","docket":{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","id":70173082,"court":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/courts/ca10/","court_id":"ca10","original_court_info":{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/originating-court-information/41798/","id":41798,"date_created":"2025-05-06T17:55:11.533053-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-11T18:35:23.828627-07:00","docket_number":"1:22-CV-02384","docket_number_raw":"1:22-CV-02384","assigned_to_str":"Gordon P. Gallagher","ordering_judge_str":"","court_reporter":"Erin Valenti","date_disposed":null,"date_filed":"2022-09-15","date_judgment":null,"date_judgment_eod":null,"date_filed_noa":null,"date_received_coa":null,"date_rehearing_denied":null,"assigned_to":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/people/9117/","ordering_judge":null},"idb_data":null,"clusters":[],"audio_files":["https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/audio/103122/"],"assigned_to":null,"referred_to":null,"bankruptcy_information":null,"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2025-05-06T17:55:11.543112-07:00","date_modified":"2026-11-10T15:54:09.578403-08:00","source":3,"appeal_from_str":"United States District Court for the District of Colorado - Denver","assigned_to_str":"","referred_to_str":"","panel_str":"","date_last_index":null,"date_cert_granted":null,"date_cert_denied":null,"date_argued":"2026-03-16","date_reargued":null,"date_reargument_denied":null,"date_filed":"2025-05-06","date_terminated":null,"date_last_filing":"2026-03-16","case_name_short":"","case_name":"California Public Employees v. Palantir Technologies Inc.","case_name_full":"","slug":"california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc","docket_number":"25-1178","docket_number_core":"25001178","docket_number_raw":"25-1178","docket_number_source":0,"federal_dn_office_code":"","federal_dn_case_type":"","federal_dn_judge_initials_assigned":"","federal_dn_judge_initials_referred":"","federal_defendant_number":null,"pacer_case_id":"90104","cause":"","nature_of_suit":"3850 Securities, Commodities, Exch.","jury_demand":"","jurisdiction_type":"","appellate_fee_status":"Fee Paid","appellate_case_type_information":"civil, private","mdl_status":"","filepath_ia":"","filepath_ia_json":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"ia_needs_upload":true,"ia_date_first_change":"2025-05-06T17:55:11.520436-07:00","date_blocked":null,"blocked":false,"appeal_from":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/courts/cod/","parent_docket":null,"tags":[],"panel":[]},"parties":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/17333724/","id":17333724,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284224/","attorney_id":11284224,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284225/","attorney_id":11284225,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284226/","attorney_id":11284226,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:26.724584-08:00","date_modified":"2026-02-17T09:47:26.724596-08:00","name":"WILLIAM HO","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/17333723/","id":17333723,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284224/","attorney_id":11284224,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284225/","attorney_id":11284225,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284226/","attorney_id":11284226,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"name":"Defendant\u00a0-\u00a0Appellee","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:26.669238-08:00","date_modified":"2026-02-17T09:47:26.669250-08:00","name":"ALEXANDRA SCHIFF","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/17333722/","id":17333722,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284224/","attorney_id":11284224,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284225/","attorney_id":11284225,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284226/","attorney_id":11284226,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"name":"Defendant\u00a0-\u00a0Appellee","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:26.541079-08:00","date_modified":"2026-02-17T09:47:26.541094-08:00","name":"SPENCER RASCOFF","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/17333721/","id":17333721,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284224/","attorney_id":11284224,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284225/","attorney_id":11284225,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284226/","attorney_id":11284226,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"name":"Defendant\u00a0-\u00a0Appellee","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:26.409144-08:00","date_modified":"2026-02-17T09:47:26.409154-08:00","name":"ALEXANDER MOORE","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/17333720/","id":17333720,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284224/","attorney_id":11284224,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284225/","attorney_id":11284225,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284226/","attorney_id":11284226,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"name":"Defendant\u00a0-\u00a0Appellee","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:26.331018-08:00","date_modified":"2026-02-17T09:47:26.331029-08:00","name":"SHYAM SANKAR","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/17333719/","id":17333719,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284224/","attorney_id":11284224,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284225/","attorney_id":11284225,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284226/","attorney_id":11284226,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"name":"Defendant\u00a0-\u00a0Appellee","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:26.271474-08:00","date_modified":"2026-02-17T09:47:26.271489-08:00","name":"DAVID GLAZER","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/17333718/","id":17333718,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284224/","attorney_id":11284224,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284225/","attorney_id":11284225,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284226/","attorney_id":11284226,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"name":"Defendant\u00a0-\u00a0Appellee","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:26.204300-08:00","date_modified":"2026-02-17T09:47:26.204315-08:00","name":"KEVIN KAWASAKI","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/17333717/","id":17333717,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284224/","attorney_id":11284224,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284225/","attorney_id":11284225,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284226/","attorney_id":11284226,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"name":"Defendant\u00a0-\u00a0Appellee","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:26.144069-08:00","date_modified":"2026-02-17T09:47:26.144079-08:00","name":"PETER THIEL","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/17333716/","id":17333716,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284224/","attorney_id":11284224,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284225/","attorney_id":11284225,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284226/","attorney_id":11284226,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"name":"Defendant\u00a0-\u00a0Appellee","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:26.083202-08:00","date_modified":"2026-02-17T09:47:26.083212-08:00","name":"STEPHEN COHEN","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/17333715/","id":17333715,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284224/","attorney_id":11284224,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284225/","attorney_id":11284225,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284226/","attorney_id":11284226,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"name":"Defendant\u00a0-\u00a0Appellee","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:25.984699-08:00","date_modified":"2026-02-17T09:47:25.984709-08:00","name":"ALEXANDER C. KARP","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/17333714/","id":17333714,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284224/","attorney_id":11284224,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284225/","attorney_id":11284225,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284226/","attorney_id":11284226,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"name":"Defendant\u00a0-\u00a0Appellee","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:25.708019-08:00","date_modified":"2026-02-17T09:47:25.708034-08:00","name":"PALANTIR TECHNOLOGIES INC.","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/17333713/","id":17333713,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284217/","attorney_id":11284217,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284218/","attorney_id":11284218,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284219/","attorney_id":11284219,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284220/","attorney_id":11284220,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284221/","attorney_id":11284221,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284222/","attorney_id":11284222,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284223/","attorney_id":11284223,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"name":"Plaintiff\u00a0-\u00a0Appellant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:25.518536-08:00","date_modified":"2026-02-17T09:47:25.518559-08:00","name":"SHIJUN LIU, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated trustee Liu Family Trust 2019","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/17333712/","id":17333712,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284217/","attorney_id":11284217,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284218/","attorney_id":11284218,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284219/","attorney_id":11284219,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284220/","attorney_id":11284220,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284221/","attorney_id":11284221,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284222/","attorney_id":11284222,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11284223/","attorney_id":11284223,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"role":null}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","docket_id":70173082,"name":"Plaintiff\u00a0-\u00a0Appellant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:25.059153-08:00","date_modified":"2026-02-17T09:47:25.059167-08:00","name":"CALIFORNIA PUBLIC EMPLOYEES' RETIREMENT SYSTEM","extra_info":""}],"entries":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/468484764/","id":468484764,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/483781564/","id":483781564,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/39/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2026-06-23T14:54:58.996931-07:00","date_modified":"2026-06-23T14:54:59.045709-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"39","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-06-23T14:54:58.957664-07:00","date_modified":"2026-06-23T14:54:58.966320-07:00","date_filed":"2026-03-16","time_filed":null,"entry_number":39,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-03-16.001","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"[11264167] Case argued and submitted to Judges Eid, Ebel and Federico. Arguing attorneys: Luke Orion Brooks for Appellants and Boris Feldman for Appellees. The oral argument recording may be found on the Tenth Circuit's website within 48 hours by clicking here. [25-1178] [Entered: 03/16/2026 01:08 PM]","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/457221279/","id":457221279,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/472200870/","id":472200870,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/38/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2026-03-15T18:19:05.461107-07:00","date_modified":"2026-06-23T14:54:58.929334-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"38","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"010011398248","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-03-15T18:19:05.398493-07:00","date_modified":"2026-06-23T14:54:58.900419-07:00","date_filed":"2026-03-10","time_filed":null,"entry_number":38,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-03-10.001","pacer_sequence_number":11262250,"description":"[11262250] Supplemental authority filed by Stephen Cohen, David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Palantir Technologies Inc., Spencer Rascoff, Shyam Sankar, Alexandra Schiff and Peter Thiel. Served on 03/10/2026. Manner of Service: email. [25-1178] BF [Entered: 03/10/2026 07:57 AM]","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/454066437/","id":454066437,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/468973737/","id":468973737,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/2/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:26.934061-08:00","date_modified":"2026-03-15T18:19:15.928075-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"2","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:26.909868-08:00","date_modified":"2026-03-15T18:19:15.896023-07:00","date_filed":"2025-05-12","time_filed":null,"entry_number":2,"recap_sequence_number":"2025-05-12.001","pacer_sequence_number":11181068,"description":"[11181068] Entry of appearance submitted by David Y. Livshiz, Boris Feldman, Nicholas A. Caselli for Appellees Palantir Technologies Inc., Stephen Cohen, David Glazer, William Ho, Alexander C. Karp, Kevin Kawakaki, Alexander Moore, Spencer Rascoff, Shyam Sankar, Alexandra Schiff and Peter Thiel for court review. Certificate of Interested Parties: No. Served on 05/12/2025. Manner of Service: email. [25-1178]--[Edited 05/12/2025 by LG to remove PDF from entry, as pleading was filed on 5/12/2025] DL [Entered: 05/12/2025 03:35 PM]","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/452001349/","id":452001349,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/466859366/","id":466859366,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/37/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2026-01-29T08:39:16.059736-08:00","date_modified":"2026-06-23T14:54:58.874729-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"37","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"010011374965","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-01-29T08:39:16.033473-08:00","date_modified":"2026-06-23T14:54:58.851004-07:00","date_filed":"2026-01-23","time_filed":null,"entry_number":37,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-01-23.002","pacer_sequence_number":11250333,"description":"[11250333] Calendar Acknowledgment Form filed by Stephen Cohen, David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Palantir Technologies Inc., Spencer Rascoff, Shyam Sankar, Alexandra Schiff and Peter Thiel. Served on 01/23/2026. Manner of Service: email. [25-1178] BF [Entered: 01/23/2026 02:56 PM]","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/452001348/","id":452001348,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/466859365/","id":466859365,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/36/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2026-01-29T08:39:16.004686-08:00","date_modified":"2026-06-23T14:54:58.826257-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"36","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"010011374534","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-01-29T08:39:15.977075-08:00","date_modified":"2026-06-23T14:54:58.803638-07:00","date_filed":"2026-01-23","time_filed":null,"entry_number":36,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-01-23.001","pacer_sequence_number":11250116,"description":"[11250116] Calendar Acknowledgment Form filed by California Public Employees' Retirement System and Shijun Liu. Served on 01/23/2026. Manner of Service: email. [25-1178] LOB [Entered: 01/23/2026 10:17 AM]","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/452001347/","id":452001347,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/466859364/","id":466859364,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/35/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2026-01-29T08:39:15.906664-08:00","date_modified":"2026-06-23T14:54:58.774801-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"35","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"010011368843","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-01-29T08:39:15.868407-08:00","date_modified":"2026-06-23T14:54:58.749318-07:00","date_filed":"2026-01-14","time_filed":null,"entry_number":35,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-01-14.001","pacer_sequence_number":11247552,"description":"[11247552] Oral argument notice filed. This matter is set for IN-PERSON oral argument on 3/16/2026 at 9:00 A.M. Mountain Time in Courtroom II of the Byron White United States Courthouse, Denver, CO. Arguing counsel must carefully review the attached notice. Within 10 days of today's date, arguing counsel must review the argument calendar available on the court's website, and download, complete, and e-file the required calendar form(s). Counsel for amici parties may not participate in argument without written permission from the court. Arguing counsel must check-in at the Clerk's Office 45 minutes prior to the start of arguments. [25-1178] [Entered: 01/14/2026 03:59 PM]","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/443262098/","id":443262098,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/457894347/","id":457894347,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/34/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2025-11-05T15:58:52.021673-08:00","date_modified":"2026-06-23T14:54:58.725327-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"34","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2025-11-05T15:58:51.979178-08:00","date_modified":"2026-06-23T14:54:58.701782-07:00","date_filed":"2025-10-23","time_filed":null,"entry_number":34,"recap_sequence_number":"2025-10-23.001","pacer_sequence_number":11225377,"description":"[11225377] Paper copies of appellants' reply brief received from California Public Employees' Retirement System and Shijun Liu. [25-1178] [Entered: 10/23/2025 12:27 PM]","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/443262097/","id":443262097,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/457894346/","id":457894346,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/33/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2025-11-05T15:58:51.848972-08:00","date_modified":"2026-06-23T14:54:58.678113-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"33","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2025-11-05T15:58:51.815947-08:00","date_modified":"2026-06-23T14:54:58.653575-07:00","date_filed":"2025-10-21","time_filed":null,"entry_number":33,"recap_sequence_number":"2025-10-21.002","pacer_sequence_number":11224762,"description":"[11224762] Minute order filed - the reply brief submitted by appellants is accepted for filing. Paper copies of appellants' reply brief due 10/27/2025 by California Public Employees' Retirement System and Shijun Liu. (Text Only - No Attachment) [25-1178] [Entered: 10/21/2025 04:07 PM]","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/443262096/","id":443262096,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/457894345/","id":457894345,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/32/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2025-11-05T15:58:51.780123-08:00","date_modified":"2026-11-13T16:52:23.964393-08:00","sha1":"47d494d2a2d291a76a71e6ad2c0b6c88baa53db4","page_count":40,"file_size":367421,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.ca10.90104/gov.uscourts.ca10.90104.32.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.ca10.90104/gov.uscourts.ca10.90104.32.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"      Appellate Case: 25-1178     Document: 32    Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 1\n\n\n\n                                      No. 25-1178\n                    IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS\n                            FOR THE TENTH CIRCUIT\n\n      CALIFORNIA PUBLIC EMPLOYEES\u2019 RETIREMENT SYSTEM, et al.,\n\n                                  Plaintiffs/Appellants,\n\n                                           vs.\n\n                       PALANTIR TECHNOLOGIES INC., et al.,\n\n                                 Defendants/Appellees.\n\n\n                 Appeal from a Decision of the United States District Court\n              for the District of Colorado, Case No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP\n                    Honorable Gordon P. Gallagher, U.S. District Judge\n\n                     PLAINTIFFS-APPELLANTS\u2019 REPLY BRIEF\n\n                            ROBBINS GELLER RUDMAN\n                                     & DOWD LLP\n                                DARREN J. ROBBINS\n                                  JOSEPH D. DALEY\n                                  LUKE O. BROOKS\n                             J. MARCO JANOSKI GRAY\n                                  ERIKA L. OLIVER\n                            655 West Broadway, Suite 1900\n                                 San Diego, CA 92101\n                               Telephone: 619/231-1058\n                                   619/231-7423 (fax)\n\n                            Counsel for Plaintiffs/Appellants\n\n\n\n\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f      Appellate Case: 25-1178                  Document: 32            Date Filed: 10/21/2025               Page: 2\n\n\n                                           TABLE OF CONTENTS\n\n                                                                                                                      Page\nI.       ARGUMENT ...................................................................................................1\n\n         A.         Plaintiffs\u2019 allegations confirm that Defendants acted with\n                    scienter in connection with their scheme to defraud, false-and-\n                    misleading statements, and insider selling. ........................................... 1\n\n                    1.       Defendants\u2019 arguments revolve around a specious theme\n                             and several false premises. .......................................................... 1\n\n                    2.       Pluralsight confirms Defendants\u2019 billions of dollars in\n                             insider sales at inflated prices bolster a strong inference\n                             of scienter. ...................................................................................4\n\n                    3.       Defendants\u2019 construction and utilization of the SPAC\n                             scheme was deliberate misconduct. ..........................................11\n\n                    4.       Defendants\u2019 conceded access to truthful information\n                             bolsters a strong inference of scienter.......................................18\n\n                    5.       Defendants\u2019 trumpeted \u201cstrong visibility\u201d into Palantir\u2019s\n                             revenue growth further establishes their scienter. ....................23\n\n                    6.       Defendants\u2019 deliberate manipulation of key reporting\n                             metrics cannot be explained away. ...........................................25\n\n         B.         Defendants haven\u2019t satisfactorily defended the district court\u2019s\n                    failure to address the deliberate actions comprising their\n                    scheme. ................................................................................................29\n\nII.      CONCLUSION..............................................................................................32\n\nCERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE WITH TYPE-VOLUME LIMIT.................. 33\n\nDECLARATION OF SERVICE .............................................................................34\n\n\n\n                                                            -i-\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f      Appellate Case: 25-1178              Document: 32           Date Filed: 10/21/2025            Page: 3\n\n\n                                    TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\n\n                                                                                                             Page\n\nCASES\nAdams v. Kinder-Morgan, Inc.,\n  340 F.3d 1083 (10th Cir. 2003) ......................................................................4, 21\n\nAldridge v. A.T. Cross Corp.,\n   284 F.3d 72 (1st Cir. 2002) ...........................................................................15, 16\nAshcroft v. Iqbal,\n   556 U.S. 662 (2009) ....................................................................................1, 2, 13\nBell Atl. Corp. v. Twombly,\n   550 U.S. 544 (2007) ....................................................................................1, 2, 31\n\nCent. Laborers\u2019 Pension Fund v. Karp,\n  2025 WL 1213104 (Del. Ch. Apr. 25, 2025) ........................................................ 3\nCity of Warren Police & Fire Ret. Sys. v. Prudential Fin., Inc.,\n   70 F.4th 668 (3d Cir. 2023) ................................................................................20\nClem v. Lomeli,\n   566 F.3d 1177 (9th Cir. 2009) .............................................................................. 4\nClinton v. Sec. Benefit Life Ins. Co.,\n   63 F.4th 1264 (10th Cir. 2023) .................................................................2, 13, 30\nDirks v. SEC,\n   463 U.S. 646 (1983) ............................................................................................12\nEmployees\u2019 Ret. Sys. of Gov\u2019t of the Virgin Is. v. Blanford,\n  794 F.3d 297 (2d Cir. 2015) ...............................................................................21\nFrank v. Dana Corp.,\n   547 F.3d 564 (6th Cir. 2008) ..............................................................................31\nGoldman v. Belden,\n  754 F.2d 1059 (2d Cir. 1985) ...............................................................................7\n\n                                                       - ii -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f      Appellate Case: 25-1178             Document: 32           Date Filed: 10/21/2025            Page: 4\n\n\n\n\n                                                                                                            Page\n\n\nHarris v. Union Elec. Co.,\n  787 F.2d 355 (8th Cir. 1986) ................................................................................ 3\n\nHelwig v. Vencor, Inc.,\n  251 F.3d 540 (6th Cir. 2001) (en banc) ................................................7, 8, 16, 17\n\nHerman & MacLean v. Huddleston,\n  459 U.S. 375 (1983) ............................................................................................16\n\nIn re Alphabet, Inc. Sec. Litig.,\n    1 F.4th 687 (9th Cir. 2021) .................................................................................26\n\nIn re Daou Sys.,\n    411 F.3d 1006 (9th Cir. 2005) ............................................................................21\nIn re Genius Brands Int\u2019l, Inc. Sec. Litig.,\n    97 F.4th 1171 (9th Cir. 2024) .............................................................................29\nIn re Grand Casinos Sec. Litig. Inc.,\n    988 F. Supp. 1273 (D. Minn. 1997)....................................................................17\nInd. Pub. Ret. Sys. v. Pluralsight, Inc.,\n   45 F.4th 1236 (10th Cir. 2022) ............................ 2, 4-9, 11, 15, 20, 23-25, 29, 31\nJohnson v. Reyna,\n   57 F.4th 769 (10th Cir. 2023) .............................................................................30\n\nKramer v. Time Warner, Inc.,\n  937 F.2d 767 (2d Cir. 1991) ................................................................................. 6\n\nLormand v. US Unwired, Inc.,\n   565 F.3d 228 (5th Cir. 2009) ..............................................................................21\n\nLovelace v. Software Spectrum,\n   78 F.3d 1015 (5th Cir. 1996) ................................................................................6\n\n\n                                                      - iii -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f      Appellate Case: 25-1178             Document: 32           Date Filed: 10/21/2025            Page: 5\n\n\n\n\n                                                                                                            Page\n\n\nMeitav Dash Provident Funds & Pension Ltd. v. Spirit AeroSystems\n  Holdings, Inc.,\n  79 F.4th 1209 (10th Cir. 2023) .....................................................................18, 22\n\nOmnicare, Inc. v. Laborers Dist. Council Constr. Indus. Pension Fund,\n  575 U.S. 175 (2015) ............................................................................................20\n\nPirraglia v. Novell, Inc.,\n   339 F.3d 1182 (10th Cir. 2003) ..............................................................16, 26, 28\nPlotkin v. IP Axess Inc.,\n   407 F.3d 690 (5th Cir. 2005) ..............................................................................25\n\nReese v. Malone,\n   747 F.3d 557 (9th Cir. 2014), overruled in part on other grounds\n   by City of Dearborn Heights Act 345 Police & Fire Ret. Sys. v. Align Tech.,\n   Inc., 856 F.3d 605 (9th Cir. 2017) ......................................................................17\nRonconi v. Larkin,\n  253 F.3d 423 (9th Cir. 2001), abrogation recognized by Cai v. Eargo,\n  Inc., 2025 WL 66041 (9th Cir. Jan. 10, 2025) ................................................9, 10\nSchleicher v. Wendt,\n   618 F.3d 679 (7th Cir. 2010) ................................................................................ 3\nSmallen v. W. Union Co.,\n  950 F.3d 1297 (10th Cir. 2020) ................................................................9, 10, 11\n\nTellabs, Inc. v. Makor Issues & Rts., Ltd.,\n   551 U.S. 308 (2007) ................................................. 1-2, 13, 17, 20, 23-24, 29-31\n\nVa. Bankshares, Inc. v. Sandberg,\n   501 U.S. 1083 (1991) ..........................................................................................26\n\n\n\n\n                                                      - iv -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f      Appellate Case: 25-1178                 Document: 32             Date Filed: 10/21/2025               Page: 6\n\n\n\n\n                                                                                                                      Page\n\n\nSTATUTES, RULES, AND REGULATIONS\n15 U.S.C.\n   \u00a777k.....................................................................................................................20\nDelaware Chancery Court\n  Rule 23.1 ...............................................................................................................3\n17 C.F.R.\n   \u00a7240.10b-5 ..........................................................................................................20\n   \u00a7240.10b5-1 ......................................................................................................5, 6\n\n\n\n\n                                                           -v-\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f      Appellate Case: 25-1178         Document: 32   Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 7\n\n\n\nI.       ARGUMENT\n         Plaintiffs-Appellants\u2019 Opening Brief (\u201cOB.__\u201d) explained how Defendants\n\nacted with scienter in undertaking their scheme to defraud, detailing deliberate\n\nmisconduct that included false-and-misleading statements as well as manipulation of\n\nkey metrics to facilitate $2.2 billion of insider selling.\n\n         In         response,   Defendants-Appellees\u2019    Answering    Brief    (\u201cAB.__\u201d)\n\nmischaracterizes Plaintiffs\u2019 allegations, relies upon inapposite case law, and lauds the\n\ndistrict court\u2019s erroneous pleading demands.\n\n         As explained below, none of their gambits prevail.\n\n         A.          Plaintiffs\u2019 allegations confirm that Defendants acted with\n                     scienter in connection with their scheme to defraud, false-\n                     and-misleading statements, and insider selling.\n                     1.    Defendants\u2019 arguments revolve around a specious\n                           theme and several false premises.\n\n         Before addressing Defendants\u2019 arguments, it\u2019s helpful to note their underlying\n\ntheme, to wit: that Plaintiffs argue that scienter inferences need only be \u201cplausible,\u201d\n\nversus the cogent-and-compelling \u201cstrong-inference\u201d standard required by Tellabs,\n\nInc. v. Makor Issues & Rts., Ltd., 551 U.S. 308 (2007). See AB.53-54 (\u201c[Plaintiffs]\n\nincorrectly cite Bell Atl. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544 (2007) and Ashcroft v. Iqbal,\n\n556 U.S. 662 (2009) several times for the proposition that all Plaintiffs must do is\n\n\u2018plausibly\u2019 allege scienter.\u201d); accord AB.18; AB.23.\n\n                                              -1-\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f      Appellate Case: 25-1178   Document: 32     Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 8\n\n\n\n         Defendants\u2019 theme is specious. The Supreme Court and this Court recognize\n\nthat allegations\u2019 \u201cplausibility\u201d co-exists with the PSLRA\u2019s higher scienter-pleading\n\nstandard. See, e.g., Tellabs, 551 U.S. at 323 (\u201cin determining whether the pleaded\n\nfacts give rise to a \u2018strong\u2019 inference of scienter, the court must take into account\n\nplausible opposing inferences\u201d);1 Clinton v. Sec. Benefit Life Ins. Co., 63 F.4th 1264,\n\n1281 (10th Cir. 2023) (\u201cparticularized allegations plausibly allege [defendant]\n\nengaged in a fraudulent scheme\u201d); accord Ind. Pub. Ret. Sys. v. Pluralsight, Inc., 45\n\nF.4th 1236, 1268 (10th Cir. 2022).2\n\n         Defendants build upon their specious theme utilizing three false premises:\n\n(i) Palantir\u2019s present condition and stock price somehow insulate Defendants\u2019 Class\n\nPeriod misconduct years ago; (ii) an unpublished decision in unrelated state-court\n\nlitigation means the district court here correctly dismissed the Complaint; and\n\n(iii) because this appeal centers on scienter, Defendants\u2019 alleged falsehoods don\u2019t\n\nfigure into the Court\u2019s analysis.\n\n         None of the three premises should sway this Court.\n\n\n1\n   Throughout this brief internal citations and footnotes are omitted and emphasis\nadded, unless noted otherwise.\n2\n    Plaintiffs also cited Iqbal and Twombly for a second axiom: judicial disbelief of\nfactual allegations is reversible error. OB.40; OB.58; OB.64. Defendants offer no\nreal defense of that district-court error\u2014nor could they. Twombly, 550 U.S. at 555-\n56.\n\n                                         -2-\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f      Appellate Case: 25-1178     Document: 32     Date Filed: 10/21/2025    Page: 9\n\n\n\n         As to the first, it\u2019s not only common sense but black-letter law that \u201c[f]raud\n\ndepends on the state of events when a statement is made, not on what happens later.\u201d\n\nSchleicher v. Wendt, 618 F.3d 679, 684 (7th Cir. 2010). Relatedly, that Palantir stock\n\nnow trades higher than at the Class Period\u2019s end isn\u2019t relevant; whatever Palantir\n\ninvestors did (or didn\u2019t do) with their stock following the fraud\u2019s exposure doesn\u2019t\n\nundercut the fraud\u2019s existence. See, e.g., Harris v. Union Elec. Co., 787 F.2d 355, 372\n\n(8th Cir. 1986) (by holding onto defendant\u2019s securities after fraud\u2019s discovery,\n\ninvestors made \u201csecond investment decision\u201d).\n\n         As to the second premise, the state-court decision doesn\u2019t control here. It was\n\nissued in a different venue, in a separate lawsuit brought by different plaintiffs\n\nasserting state-law claims. Cent. Laborers\u2019 Pension Fund v. Karp, 2025 WL 1213104\n\n(Del. Ch. Apr. 25, 2025). Defendants also entirely ignore that the dismissal was on\n\n\u201cdemand futility\u201d grounds under Delaware Chancery Court Rule 23.1, and not for\n\nfailure to state a claim. Id. at *22. There\u2019s no legal effect upon this litigation.\n\n         As to the third, Defendants suggest that because the parties\u2019 briefing focuses on\n\nscienter, Defendants\u2019 alleged misstatements regarding Palantir\u2019s \u201cgrowth, unit\n\neconomics and margins, bespoke versus SaaS-like offerings, and efficiencies\u201d are \u201cnot\n\nat issue.\u201d AB.55 n.41.\n\n\n\n\n                                           -3-\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178       Document: 32    Date Filed: 10/21/2025    Page: 10\n\n\n\n         Wishful thinking, for a trio of reasons: (i) Plaintiffs fully briefed Defendants\u2019\n\nmisstatements in the Opening Brief and explained why they were false-and-\n\nmisleading; (ii) the misstatements provide this Court valuable context for ruling upon\n\nthe scienter issues (see, e.g., Adams v. Kinder-Morgan, Inc., 340 F.3d 1083, 1106\n\n(10th Cir. 2003)); and (iii) Defendants\u2019 failure to address Plaintiffs\u2019 scienter\n\nallegations in connection with those misstatements constitutes waiver. Clem v.\n\nLomeli, 566 F.3d 1177, 1182 (9th Cir. 2009) (appellee waives issue by not addressing\n\nit in answering brief).\n\n         With Defendants\u2019 specious theme and false premises dispatched, we now turn\n\nto their remaining scienter arguments.\n\n                    2.   Pluralsight confirms Defendants\u2019 billions of dollars in\n                         insider sales at inflated prices bolster a strong\n                         inference of scienter.\n\n         Plaintiffs explained how Defendants\u2019 more-than-$2-billion in insider selling\n\nsatisfied this Court\u2019s Pluralsight decision, where far-less-dramatic selling\u2014$22\n\nmillion for one defendant, and just $519,000 for another\u2014helped raise a strong\n\ninference of scienter. See OB.42-44; see also Pluralsight, 45 F.4th at 1264-67\n\n(considering \u201c\u2018amount of profit from the sales, the portion of stockholdings sold, the\n\nchange in volume of insider sales, and the number of insiders selling,\u2019\u201d along with\n\ngreater volume of sales inside class period \u201cthan outside\u201d). Plaintiffs also explained\n\n\n                                            -4-\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178      Document: 32     Date Filed: 10/21/2025    Page: 11\n\n\n\nthe district court\u2019s myriad errors while considering Defendants\u2019 sales (OB.52-56),\n\nalong with its failure to \u201caddress, let alone analyze, Pluralsight\u2019s scienter holdings.\u201d\n\nOB.47.3\n\n         Defendants respond with a blunderbuss attack wrapped in arguments parroting\n\nthe district court\u2019s erroneous analyses. Each scattershot volley misses its mark.\n\n         One missed shot concerns ostensibly pre-placed stock-trading plans.\n\nDefendants contend that most of their insider selling was conducted via Rule 10b5-1\n\n\u201ctrading plans,\u201d and therefore is immunized. AB.27-29. That untested contention has\n\nmultiple flaws.\n\n         First, the district court refused to entertain that argument. Add:23 n.10 (\u201c[T]he\n\nCourt does not consider Defendants\u2019 automatic trading argument in its scienter\n\nanalysis.\u201d). That refusal was for good reason\u2014rather than submit their supposed\n\ntrading plans, Defendants proffered \u201cexhibits consisting of SEC filings and attorney-\n\ncreated documents aggregating data from those filings.\u201d Add:22 n.10. Those filings\n\nwere mostly Form 4 trading records (id.)\u2014the truth of which isn\u2019t judicially\n\n\n\n\n3\n   It\u2019s worth repeating that the district court mentioned this Court\u2019s on-point\nPluralsight opinion only twice. OB.38-39.\n\n                                           -5-\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178     Document: 32      Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 12\n\n\n\nnoticeable. Kramer v. Time Warner, Inc., 937 F.2d 767, 774 (2d Cir. 1991); accord\n\nLovelace v. Software Spectrum, 78 F.3d 1015, 1018 (5th Cir. 1996).4\n\n         In addition, this Court holds that Rule 10b5-1 trading plans aren\u2019t a per se\n\ndefense to insider-selling charges. Pluralsight, 45 F.4th at 1265-66. As this Court\n\nnoted, experience shows such plans are easily manipulated:\n\n         As Plaintiffs correctly explain, the text and history of Rule 10b5-1 shows\n         that such plans can be manipulated easily for personal financial gain\n         and thus cannot rebut the inference that personal financial gain was a\n         motive for Defendants\u2019 material misrepresentations.\nId. at 1266. Whether that occurred here is a fact-specific inquiry whose resolution is\n\nimpossible given one glaring fault: despite pushing their trading-plan theory,\n\nDefendants never produced any of the plans\u2019 details. As Plaintiffs explained below,\n\nDefendants made no showing as to the plan details, and they: (i) admitted that not all\n\nsales occurred pursuant to a 10b5-1 plan; (ii) failed to provide the district court with\n\ndate(s) on which any 10b5-1 plan was adopted or their terms; and (iii) had not\n\nestablished that they were unaware of their schedule of trades. Appdx.V9.1970.\n\nGiven that missing information, it\u2019s no wonder the district court refused to entertain\n\nDefendants\u2019 argument. Add:22 n.10.\n\n\n4\n   Defendants say Plaintiffs don\u2019t contest the filings\u2019 validity (AB.27-28), but\nPlaintiffs surely did. See ECF113:15 (\u201cDefendants only offer the Forms 3 and 4 for\nthe improper inferences and arguments that they derive from them\u2014which are not\nproper subjects of judicial notice.\u201d).\n\n                                           -6-\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178     Document: 32     Date Filed: 10/21/2025    Page: 13\n\n\n\n         One final point regarding Defendants\u2019 trading-plan argument: they\u2019ve veered\n\ndangerously close to misleading this Court by asserting that Pluralsight\u2019s trading-plan\n\n\u201cholding is inapplicable, as the District Court rightly concluded.\u201d AB.29. That\n\nassertion is unsupportable: the district court said it wasn\u2019t considering any trading-\n\nplan argument\u2014and it didn\u2019t distinguish Pluralsight\u2019s \u201cper se\u201d holding or conclude\n\nthat it didn\u2019t apply. Add:22 n.10.\n\n         Elsewhere, Defendants insist the district court never substituted its \u201c\u2018benign\n\nview\u2019\u201d of their multi-billion-dollar insider selling for Plaintiffs\u2019 contrary allegations.\n\nAB.26. Yet that\u2019s precisely what happened: the court deemed it \u201cunsurprising\u201d that\n\nPalantir insiders would cash out after taking the Company public while \u201ccandidly\u201d\n\nexplaining their actions. OB.52-53. With that reasoning the court erred twice.\n\n         First, accepting Defendants\u2019 excuse versus the Complaint\u2019s contrary\n\nallegations\u2014inflated-stock sales as part of an overall scheme\u2014is erroneous.\n\nGoldman v. Belden, 754 F.2d 1059, 1070-71 (2d Cir. 1985) (indulging defendant\u2019s\n\nexcuses for stock sales as \u201c\u2018logical\u2019\u201d and \u201c\u2018reasonable\u2019\u201d \u201cimpermissibly reached\n\nbeyond\u201d complaint\u2019s scope); see also Helwig v. Vencor, Inc., 251 F.3d 540, 558 (6th\n\nCir. 2001) (en banc) (rejecting defendant\u2019s self-serving explanation at the pleading\n\n\n\n\n                                          -7-\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178      Document: 32     Date Filed: 10/21/2025    Page: 14\n\n\n\nstage).5 Moreover, the district court\u2019s benign view sweeps too broadly. It gives\n\ncorporate insiders carte blanche to defraud when taking a company public, so long as\n\nthey announce they\u2019re tapping newfound liquidity. That has never been the law. 6\n\n         Nor do Defendants have a compelling defense to the stark contrast between\n\ntheir $2.2-billion-plus insider selling proceeds and their annual compensation.7\n\n(Recall, those proceeds represented an astronomical 13,900% to 95,200% more than\n\nthat compensation. Appdx.V1.129:\u00b6190.) Defendants simply repeat the district\n\ncourt\u2019s rationale that tech executives are often paid with equity. AB.31.\n\n         But that rationale doesn\u2019t acknowledge the reality undermining it here: if equity\n\ncompensation was Defendants\u2019 innocent motive, how to explain their actions after the\n\nClass Period, when their insider selling dried up? Appdx.V1.129-30:\u00b6192. That\n\ncessation only adds to the strong-scienter inference. Pluralsight, 45 F.4th at 1267\n\n\n\n\n5\n   Defendants\u2019 half-hearted response to Helwig and Goldman\u2019s holdings observes\nonly that neither involved public offerings. AB.27 n.9.\n6\n   The court\u2019s rationale also ignores that Defendants\u2019 inflated-stock sales weren\u2019t\nconfined to the Offering; instead, Defendants embarked upon a 13-month selling\nbinge while driving Palantir\u2019s stock price higher with continuing misconduct.\n7\n  Defendants accuse Plaintiffs of conflating \u201cproceeds\u201d with \u201cprofits.\u201d AB.25 n.7.\nThat accusation rings hollow, as the Opening Brief repeatedly speak of the proceeds\nDefendants reaped. E.g., OB.14; OB.35; OB.43.\n\n                                           -8-\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178     Document: 32     Date Filed: 10/21/2025    Page: 15\n\n\n\n(suspicious when \u201cvolume of sales within the class period was dramatically higher\n\nthan outside it\u201d).8\n\n         Defendants really miss the mark concerning the district court\u2019s retained-equity\n\nanalysis. AB.29. For example, they don\u2019t address the court\u2019s error in reasoning that\n\n\u201conly\u201d Glazer sold \u201ca majority of his holdings\u201d (Add:21)\u2014when this Court doesn\u2019t\n\nrequire insiders to have sold a \u201cmajority\u201d of their holdings to find the sales suspicious.\n\nPluralsight, 45 F.4th at 1267 (5% and 12% deemed suspicious). Defendants also\n\ndon\u2019t address Plaintiffs\u2019 argument that the district court didn\u2019t even mention\n\nPluralsight while discussing percentages\u2014error again. OB.55.\n\n         Compounding those shortcomings, Defendants claim that in calculating their\n\nretained equity, Plaintiffs disregarded \u201cunvested options and [restricted stock units]\u201d\n\nthat courts supposedly \u201croutinely consider.\u201d AB.29 (citing Ronconi v. Larkin, 253\n\nF.3d 423, 435-36 (9th Cir. 2001), abrogation recognized by Cai v. Eargo, Inc., 2025\n\nWL 66041 (9th Cir. Jan. 10, 2025), and Smallen v. W. Union Co., 950 F.3d 1297,\n\n1310-11 (10th Cir. 2020)). AB.29.\n\n\n\n\n8\n   The reduced sales also undermine Defendants\u2019 \u201ctrading plan\u201d defense. Wouldn\u2019t\nthose plans still have been in place despite Palantir\u2019s stock-price movements? Or\nwere Defendants manipulating the plans, too, while avoiding lower stock prices? The\nresulting inference cuts against Defendants.\n\n                                           -9-\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178   Document: 32      Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 16\n\n\n\n         Defendants hoist themselves on their own petard. Unvested securities like\n\ngranted options or restricted stock units cannot be exercised or sold until they vest!9\n\nDefendants\u2019 authority even highlights that key distinction. See Ronconi, 253 F.3d at\n\n435 n.25 (\u201cStock options should be considered in calculating the percentage of shares\n\nsold unless the insider could not have exercised them.\u201d).            Smallen doesn\u2019t\n\nacknowledge Ronconi\u2019s distinction, but simply repeats that options are included in\n\noverall holdings. Smallen, 950 F.3d at 1310.10\n\n         Defendants have another problem with their retained-equity argument. Even\n\ncrediting the figures they list at AB.29\u2014which Plaintiffs don\u2019t\u2014Defendants concede\n\nstill-dramatic selling percentages: 23% for Thiel, 19% for both Karp and Cohen, 24%\n\n\n\n\n9\n   Restricted stock units \u201chave no tangible value until they are vested.\u201d Jason\nFernando, Restricted Stock Unit (RSU): How It Works and Pros and Cons,\nInvestopedia (Sep. 18, 2025), https://www.investopedia.com/terms/r/restricted-stock-\nunit.asp. Similarly, employee stock options \u201cvest over a designated period of time.\nVesting means it becomes available to use.\u201d James Chen, Understanding Stock\nOptions: Trading Basics and Practical Examples, Investopedia (Aug. 17, 2025),\nhttps://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/stockoption.asp.\n10\n   Defendants inadvertently concede that unvested options shouldn\u2019t be considered\npart of their \u201cretained equity.\u201d Despite claiming that Karp \u201cretained\u201d 81% of his\nequity (AB.29), Defendants elsewhere argue that the August 2020 stock awards to him\ndon\u2019t add to the scienter inference because \u201cmore than 90% of Karp\u2019s options did not\nvest\u201d by the Class Period\u2019s end \u201cand thus could not be sold\u201d until then. AB.32.\n\n                                        - 10 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178       Document: 32     Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 17\n\n\n\nfor Sankar, and 55% for Glazer.11 Defendants\u2019 self-serving percentages still dwarf the\n\nnumbers this Court in Pluralsight found suspicious\u2014as does their overall $2.2 billion\n\nin insider selling, which is nearly 100 times the sum that helped raise suspicion in\n\nPluralsight.\n\n                    3.   Defendants\u2019 construction and utilization of the SPAC\n                         scheme was deliberate misconduct.\n\n         Defendants\u2019 primary defense to the round-trip SPAC scheme they concocted\n\n(OB.17-25) centers on disclosure\u2014that they supposedly disclosed all material\n\ninformation about the deals, and thus didn\u2019t mislead investors. AB.34-36.\n\n         That\u2019s untrue. Analysts covering Palantir certainly found the disclosures\n\nlacking. Following Palantir\u2019s May 9, 2022 announcement that the SPAC program had\n\nbeen wound down in the prior quarter, analysts carped they lacked the ability to\n\ncalculate the underlying businesses\u2019 strength. See Appdx.V1.126:\u00b6182. Indeed,\n\nWilliam Blair and RBC analysts complained they were \u201cdisappointed with fewer\n\ndisclosures in the 10-Q,\u201d and that they had been forced to guess about the state of\n\nsome of Palantir\u2019s SPAC investments, without knowing some had already been\n\nterminated. Id. It wasn\u2019t until three months later that RBC published a report that\n\n\n11\n   Plaintiffs\u2019 allegations of Defendants\u2019 insider selling (including exercisable options\nand vested RSUs) show dramatic percentages: 22.5% (Thiel); 27.8% (Cohen); 40.6%\n(Karp); 41.3% (Sankar); and 71.7% (Glazer). Appdx.V1.128-29:\u00b6189. Those\npercentages are taken as true. Pluralsight, 45 F.4th at 1250.\n\n                                           - 11 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178    Document: 32    Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 18\n\n\n\nprovided a deep dive into Palantir\u2019s SPAC-related misconduct, and revealed how\n\npoorly the SPACs had fared. Appdx.V1.127:\u00b6185. That savvy analysts found\n\nPalantir\u2019s SPAC-related disclosures deficient speaks volumes. Dirks v. SEC, 463 U.S.\n\n646, 658-59 (1983) (securities analysts \u201c\u2018ferret out and analyze [corporate]\n\ninformation\u2019\u201d that \u201cnormally may be the basis for judgments as to the market worth of\n\na corporation\u2019s securities\u201d).\n\n         Moreover, while Defendants describe some general SPAC-related information\n\nthey supposedly disclosed (AB.34), the Complaint alleges other material facts that\n\nweren\u2019t disclosed. Significantly, Defendants didn\u2019t disclose that because the SPAC\n\ndeals carried much-lower costs\u201490% lower than Palantir\u2019s traditional commercial\n\ndeals\u2014Palantir\u2019s reported margins were materially inflated. Appdx.V1.91-95:\u00b6\u00b6103-\n\n109.       Other SPAC-related non-disclosures also misled investors.       See, e.g.,\n\nAppdx.V1.73:\u00b663 (although first SPAC deal executed in March 2021, no disclosures\n\nuntil May 2021\u2014and even then, misleadingly described as a \u201clong-term strategy\u201d);\n\nAppdx.V1.77:\u00b673 (referencing just four SPAC deals while concealing the massive\n\nSPAC Scheme expansion that was underway); Appdx.V1.79:\u00b676 n.16 (Defendants\n\nkept two SPACs\u2019s identities under wraps for six months); Appdx.V1.83:\u00b684 (at least\n\nfour SPACs were teetering on insolvency, as some publicly stated soon thereafter).\n\n\n\n\n                                       - 12 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178     Document: 32      Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 19\n\n\n\n         Defendants\u2019 counter-narrative claims that the SPACs \u201cused Palantir\u2019s software\u201d\n\n(AB.35), implying the deals were specifically tailored and working well, but the\n\nComplaint alleges otherwise. Palantir gave the SPACs off-the-rack, partial versions\n\nof the complete Foundry software package, without providing the necessary support to\n\nmake Foundry work. Appdx.V1.85-86:\u00b689; Appdx.V1.91-92:\u00b6103. The Complaint\n\nalleges at least four SPACs that either couldn\u2019t, or didn\u2019t, use Foundry as Defendants\n\nrepresented.        Appdx.V1.75-76:\u00b669       (Lilium);    Appdx.V1.76:\u00b670      (Sarcos);\n\nAppdx.V1.81:\u00b680 (Celularity); Appdx.V1.81-82:\u00b681 (Wejo); see also Appdx.V1.85-\n\n86:\u00b689 (Celularity\u2019s Foundry-specific complaints). These facts must be accepted as\n\ntrue. Tellabs, 551 U.S. at 322.\n\n         Defendants also insist the quid pro quo SPAC deals were \u201c[l]egitimate,\u201d and\n\nthat it\u2019s \u201cundisputed that Palantir received equity and cash consideration from the\n\nSPACs.\u201d AB.35-36. Not so.\n\n         First, and most notably, Defendants don\u2019t defend the district court\u2019s error in\n\nrequiring that sham deals be \u201cobviously lacking in commercial justification.\u201d Add:23.\n\nThat heightened criterion ignored well-pleaded allegations that only needed to\n\n\u201cplausibly\u201d allege the SPAC deals\u2019 fraudulent nature. Iqbal, 556 U.S. at 679; see also\n\nClinton, 63 F.4th at 1281 (\u201cparticularized allegations plausibly allege[d] \u2026 a\n\nfraudulent scheme\u201d).\n\n\n                                          - 13 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178    Document: 32      Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 20\n\n\n\n         Moreover, Palantir\u2019s receipt of cash from the SPACs isn\u2019t a defense; in fact,\n\nreceiving cash back after providing the SPACs with funding was the entire point of\n\nthe quid pro quo scheme! See, e.g., Appdx.V1.78:\u00b676 (Boxed agrees to pay back $20\n\nmillion following Palantir\u2019s $20 million infusion). And the notion that Palantir\n\nreceived material \u201cequity\u201d in the SPACs is laughable: many of the 20-odd SPACs\n\nwere spiraling toward insolvency\u2014seven of them going bankrupt. Appdx.V1.71-\n\n72:\u00b660; see also Appdx.V1.127:\u00b6185 (\u201cat least 15 SPAC customers \u2026 have\n\nsubstantial doubt as going concerns\u201d).\n\n         Trying to combat the damning inference arising out of the SPACs paying\n\nmillions of dollars back to Palantir, Defendants say some paybacks were \u201csignificantly\n\ndifferent\u201d than Palantir\u2019s cash infusions. AB.36 & n.23. Some were\u2014but sauce for\n\nthe goose is sauce for the gander: several others involved dollar-for-dollar round-trips.\n\nSee, e.g., Appdx.V1.78:\u00b676 (Boxed agrees to pay back the $20 million after Palantir\u2019s\n\n$20 million infusion); Appdx.V1.87:\u00b693 (BlackSky assumes an $8 million Foundry\n\nsubscription after Palantir hands it $8 million); Appdx.V1.87:\u00b694 (Rigetti given $10\n\nmillion in exchange for what appears to be an estimated $10 million Palantir\n\nsubscription agreement).       Other deals made no financial sense.           See, e.g.,\n\nAppdx.V1.73:\u00b664 (in exchange for $41 million cash infusion, Lilium agrees to a $50\n\n\n\n\n                                         - 14 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178     Document: 32      Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 21\n\n\n\nmillion Foundry subscription\u2014a sum approximately 1,000 times Lilium\u2019s 2021\n\nrevenue). 12\n\n         Taking aim at allegations that they knew how troubled the SPACs were given\n\nin-depth due diligence and Palantir\u2019s Foundry software, Defendants parrot the district\n\ncourt\u2019s \u201c\u2018digital twin\u2019\u201d criticism\u2014i.e., that supposedly only the SPACs, and not\n\nPalantir, had access to the SPACs\u2019s data after Foundry\u2019s installation. AB.37; see\n\nAdd:19 n.8 (court rejects alleged access as \u201cpure speculation\u201d).\n\n         But Defendants (and the district court) ignore the well-pleaded allegation that,\n\ngiven Foundry\u2019s \u201cdigital twin\u201d function, shortly after each deal closed, Palantir had\n\nas much information about the SPACs as the SPACs themselves. Appdx.V1.71:\u00b659;\n\nsee also Appdx.V1.86:\u00b690 (Palantir\u2019s Form 10-Q boasts of Company\u2019s \u201cproximity to\n\nthese [SPACs]\u201d). Those well-pleaded facts are accepted as true. Pluralsight, 45 F.4th\n\nat 1250.\n\n         Concerning \u201cdue diligence\u201d allegations, Defendants say the district court simply\n\nfollowed precedent when it demanded the \u201c\u2018specific facts or data\u2019\u201d Defendants\n\ngleaned from their pre-deal examinations. AB.37. But that\u2019s untrue; the court\n\n12\n   Defendants also try to counter the \u201csham\u201d nature of their deals by noting Plaintiffs\nhaven\u2019t alleged an accounting restatement or revenue-recognition violation. AB.4;\nAB.35 n.21. The suggestion is a straw man, as accounting restatements aren\u2019t\nrequired to show scienter. See, e.g., Aldridge v. A.T. Cross Corp., 284 F.3d 72, 83 (1st\nCir. 2002).\n\n                                          - 15 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178    Document: 32      Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 22\n\n\n\ndemanded far-more-granular, internal data\u2014which isn\u2019t required to sufficiently plead\n\nfraud.       Herman & MacLean v. Huddleston, 459 U.S. 375, 390 n.30 (1983)\n\n(\u201ccircumstantial evidence\u201d of scienter \u201ccan be more than sufficient\u201d); see also\n\nPirraglia v. Novell, Inc., 339 F.3d 1182, 1193 n.14 (10th Cir. 2003) (demanding\n\nalleged internal paperwork \u201cis asking too much\u201d at the pleading stage). 13\n\n         Defendants\u2019 final attack on the SPAC scheme centers on Plaintiffs\u2019 \u201ctemporal\n\nproximity\u201d argument (AB.38), which explains that abruptly terminating the SPAC\n\nprogram shortly after extolling its contributions adds to a strong-scienter inference.\n\nOB.49-50; see, e.g., Helwig, 251 F.3d at 552 (\u201ccloseness in time\u201d one of \u201cfixed\n\nconstellations of facts \u2026 relevant to scienter\u201d). Defendants argue that the six-month\n\nspan between their SPAC-program cheerleading and its sudden wind-down is\n\ninsufficient as a matter of law (AB.38)\u2014but cite no precedent so holding.\n\n         Instead, Defendants lift a couple of time periods from Helwig and two other\n\ndecisions\u20142, 4, and 11 weeks\u2014and present them as the final word on acceptable\n\ntemporal proximity. AB.38 n.26. That arbitrary cherry-picking is twice wrong.\n\n\n\n\n13\n   Defendants\u2019 criticism that Plaintiffs haven\u2019t identified \u201ca single fact\u201d gleaned in\ndue diligence is unfounded. See, e.g., Appdx.V1.82:\u00b682 (Glazer participated in\nextensive due diligence into Fast Radius, which focused on Fast Radius\u2019s financing\nand cash positions for the coming 12 months.). Fast Radius declared bankruptcy a\nmere nine months after Palantir\u2019s funding. Id.\n\n                                         - 16 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178      Document: 32      Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 23\n\n\n\n         First, the salient point is that Defendants reassured Palantir investors that the\n\nSPAC deals were part of the Company\u2019s \u201clong-term strategy,\u201d and that \u201c[t]hese are\n\ncompanies that we think we will be working with for a very long time.\u201d\n\nAppdx.V1.82-83:\u00b683. Yet within a few months of those reassurances, Palantir shut\n\ndown the SPAC program in 1Q22 (Appdx.V1.125-26:\u00b6181)\u2014which shutdown, along\n\nwith disappointing revenue-growth figures, helped drive Palantir\u2019s stock down 21%\n\nduring a single trading day, with an additional 10% drop over the next two days.\n\nAppdx.V1.126:\u00b6183. The contrast between Defendants\u2019 reassurances and their 180-\n\ndegree turnaround is \u201crelevant to scienter.\u201d Helwig, 251 F.3d at 552.\n\n         Second, Defendants\u2019 focus on those three time periods is easily countered by\n\nother periods deemed sufficient\u2014illustrating there\u2019s no hard-and-fast temporal-\n\nproximity span as a matter of law. See, e.g., Reese v. Malone, 747 F.3d 557, 574-75\n\n(9th Cir. 2014) (\u201cthree to six months\u201d temporal proximity bolsters scienter inference),\n\noverruled in part on other grounds by City of Dearborn Heights Act 345 Police &\n\nFire Ret. Sys. v. Align Tech., Inc., 856 F.3d 605 (9th Cir. 2017); In re Grand Casinos\n\nSec. Litig. Inc., 988 F. Supp. 1273, 1283 (D. Minn. 1997) (seven months is \u201cshort time\n\nframe\u201d bolstering strong inference of defendants\u2019 knowledge).\n\n         Under Tellabs\u2019s holistic approach, temporal proximity remains relevant, and is\n\nyet one more factor bolstering Defendants\u2019 scienter.\n\n\n                                           - 17 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178       Document: 32      Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 24\n\n\n\n                    4.   Defendants\u2019 conceded access to truthful information\n                         bolsters a strong inference of scienter.\n\n         Defendants have no real answer to Plaintiffs\u2019 charge that the district court erred\n\nwhen proclaiming that \u201c\u2018access alone\u2019\u201d wasn\u2019t enough to support a strong inference\n\nof their scienter (Add:19), given that here\u2014unlike in Meitav Dash Provident Funds &\n\nPension Ltd. v. Spirit AeroSystems Holdings, Inc., 79 F.4th 1209 (10th Cir. 2023)\u2014\n\nPlaintiffs alleged more than mere access. OB.62-64. And Defendants conspicuously\n\nignore the court\u2019s error in opining that it was \u201cpretty unlikely that Defendants actually\n\nhad access\u201d to the data \u201cthat Plaintiffs allege they did.\u201d OB.64 (noting erroneous\n\n\u201cjudicial disbelief\u201d).\n\n         Instead, Defendants assert that Plaintiffs\u2019 \u201clone response\u201d to the district court\u2019s\n\naccess reasoning is that the Complaint attributed certain falsehoods to certain\n\nDefendants\u2014which attribution, they say, has nothing to do with scienter. AB.39.\n\n         Defendants\u2019 assertion is incorrect on multiple levels.\n\n         First, Defendants themselves repeatedly confirmed their access to relevant\n\ninformation. See, e.g., Appdx.V1.103:\u00b6126 (Palantir tells investors that its sales\n\nefforts have \u201chistorically depended on the significant direct involvement of [its] senior\n\nmanagement team, including Mr. Karp\u201d); see also Appdx.V1.57-58:\u00b625 (regular\n\n\u201csales ops\u201d team meetings attended by Karp, Cohen, or Sankar); Appdx.V1.71:\u00b659\n\n(after installation Foundry unlocks a \u201cdigital twin\u201d of each company\u2019s \u201centire\n\n                                            - 18 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178       Document: 32     Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 25\n\n\n\nenterprise\u201d and customer data in hours, or even \u201cminutes\u201d);14 Appdx.V1. 102-03:\u00b6125\n\n(on investor/analyst conference call, Defendants emphasized a \u201cnumber of factors that\n\nprovide strong visibility and stability for future revenue growth\u201d); Appdx.V1.103-\n\n04:\u00b6127 (Defendants confirm they\u2019re aware of negative trends in Palantir\u2019s revenues\n\nseveral periods before publicly reporting them); Appdx.V1.103:\u00b6126 (Karp insisting,\n\n\u201cI know how the business is doing.\u201d).\n\n         Second, Defendants\u2019 alleged misstatements did communicate their access to\n\ninformation contradicting those public statements. See, e.g., Appdx.V1.67:\u00b647\n\n(\u201ccustomers are increasingly adopting our software, which can be ready in days\u201d);\n\nAppdx.V1.85:\u00b688 (Kawasaki insists Palantir is delivering the \u201cfull power of Foundry\u201d\n\nto the SPACs); Appdx.V1.107:\u00b6\u00b6135-136 (Sankar boasts that government growth is\n\n\u201cjust at the tip of the iceberg,\u201d while commercial segment\u2019s pipeline is ostensibly\n\n\u201csubstantial and growing\u201d); Appdx.V1.61-62:\u00b634 (Sankar claims Palantir now\n\npossesses \u201cSAAS[-]like economics,\u201d and isn\u2019t doing \u201cbespoke applications\u201d\n\nanymore). 15        Public statements like those raise the unassailable inference that\n\nDefendants were privy to data and facts underlying the subjects about which they\n\n\n\n14\n     Plaintiffs dealt with the Defendants\u2019 incorrect \u201cdigital twin\u201d argument supra.\n15\n   At the Class Period\u2019s end, Sankar admitted that was false; Palantir had continued\nbuilding bespoke applications all along. Appdx.V1.62:\u00b635.\n\n                                           - 19 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178    Document: 32      Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 26\n\n\n\nspoke. E.g., Omnicare, Inc. v. Laborers Dist. Council Constr. Indus. Pension Fund,\n\n575 U.S. 175, 189 (2015) (investors reasonably believe issuer\u2019s statement \u201cfairly\n\naligns with the information in the issuer\u2019s possession at the time\u201d). 16\n\n         Third, while Defendants dispute or deny Plaintiffs\u2019 well-pleaded factual\n\nallegations going to their access, it\u2019s axiomatic that those allegations are accepted as\n\ntrue, with the resulting inferences taken in Plaintiffs\u2019 favor. Tellabs, 551 U.S. at 322.\n\nIn refusing to do so, the district court committed reversible error. Pluralsight, 45\n\nF.4th at 1261, 1263.\n\n         Trying to chip away at \u201c\u2018access,\u2019\u201d Defendants paint as commonplace corporate-\n\nspeak CEO Karp\u2019s insistence that \u201c\u2018I run this business, for better or worse. I know\n\nhow the business is doing.\u2019\u201d AB.41.\n\n         Karp\u2019s admission of his involvement and knowledge is accepted at face value,\n\nand goes directly to his scienter. See, e.g., Pluralsight, 45 F.4th at 1264 (defendant\n\nadmitted monitoring key metric that he \u201cregularly reported to investors and analysts\u201d);\n\n\n\n16\n    Defendants say Omnicare is \u201cno help\u201d because it was addressing non-fraud claims\nand falsity under Securities Act \u00a711. AB.40 n.27. They\u2019re mistaken; that investors\nunderstand corporate public statements to reflect \u201cthe information in the [speaker\u2019s]\npossession at the time\u201d (Omnicare, 575 U.S. at 189) is surely a universal truth across\nall types of securities lawsuits involving both fraud and non-fraud claims. See, e.g.,\nCity of Warren Police & Fire Ret. Sys. v. Prudential Fin., Inc., 70 F.4th 668, 685 (3d\nCir. 2023) (\u201cevery other Court of Appeals to encounter the issue has applied the\nOmnicare framework for opinion falsity to claims for Rule 10b-5 violations\u201d).\n\n                                         - 20 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178     Document: 32      Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 27\n\n\n\nsee also In re Daou Sys., 411 F.3d 1006, 1022 (9th Cir. 2005) (\u201cspecific admissions\n\nfrom top executives that they are involved in every detail of the company \u2026 are\n\nfactors in favor of inferring scienter\u201d); Lormand v. US Unwired, Inc., 565 F.3d 228,\n\n254 (5th Cir. 2009) (defendants\u2019 admissions \u201cdirectly and cogently tend to prove\u201d\n\ntheir state of mind).17\n\n         Defendants also try to soft pedal their admission that Palantir\u2019s sales efforts\n\ndepended upon the \u201csignificant direct involvement\u201d of the Company\u2019s \u201c\u2018senior\n\nmanagement team\u2019\u201d while singling out CEO Karp. AB.41; see Appdx.V1.103:\u00b6126.\n\nDefendants say the admission is much ado about nothing because they simultaneously\n\nnoted that the direct involvement had been done historically\u2014implying the\n\nexecutives\u2019 participation was long past. AB.41.\n\n         It takes more than a self-serving implication to undercut the Complaint\u2019s\n\nallegations. Employees\u2019 Ret. Sys. of Gov\u2019t of the Virgin Is. v. Blanford, 794 F.3d 297,\n\n307 (2d Cir. 2015) (defendants\u2019 excuses \u201c[are] entitled to little weight at this stage of\n\nlitigation, when we must \u2018accept all factual claims in the complaint as true and draw\n\nall reasonable inferences in the plaintiff\u2019s favor\u2019\u201d). Whatever was happening with\n\n\n\n17\n    Under this Court\u2019s precedents, that Karp was Palantir\u2019s CEO also adds to the\nstrong-scienter inference. Adams, 340 F.3d at 1106 (\u201cthat [defendant] was the most\nsenior executive of the Company is a fact relevant in our weighing of the totality of\nthe [scienter] allegations\u201d).\n\n                                          - 21 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178     Document: 32       Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 28\n\n\n\nPalantir\u2019s sales-force ranks during the Class Period, 18 the logical inference arising out\n\nof Defendants\u2019 assurances about senior management\u2019s involvement was that top\n\nexecutives had been, and were continuing to be, \u201csignificant[ly]\u201d and \u201cdirect[ly]\u201d\n\ninvolved in Palantir\u2019s sales efforts. Appdx.V1.103:\u00b6126. The opposing inference\u2014\n\nthat their \u201csignificant direct involvement\u201d suddenly halted the day Palantir went\n\npublic\u2014lacks any record support and is nonsensical. In fact, Palantir repeated this\n\nrepresentation in every 10-Q and 10-K filed during the Class Period.19\n\n         Finally, Defendants spend several pages dissecting the Meitav decision (AB.42-\n\n44), but scrupulously avoid specific language that the district court deemed so\n\nimportant that it block-quoted the text:\n\n         [I]t would make little sense to draw a strong inference of scienter from\n         access to information. If access alone were enough, a strong inference of\n         scienter would exist for high-level executives whenever they make a\n         public statement contradicting something in the company\u2019s files.\nAdd:19 (quoting Meitav, 79 F.4th at 1217).\n\n\n18\n   Plaintiffs do not \u201cconcede\u201d that Palantir was successfully doubling its sales force\nduring the Class Period. AB.41. The Complaint only notes Karp\u2019s claim in February\n2021 that Palantir \u201cwas in the midst of an effort\u201d to do so. Appdx.V1.65:\u00b640 n.10.\n19\n    A quick search reveals that Palantir continued to make this representation in its 10-\nKs and 10-Qs long after the Class Period ended, including in its most-recent 10-Q,\nfiled with the SEC on August 5, 2025. See Palantir Technologies Inc., Quarterly\nReport           (Form             10-Q)            (Aug.            5,           2025)\nhttps://www.sec.gov/ix?doc=/Archives/edgar/data/0001321655/000132165525000106\n/pltr-20250630.htm, at 47.\n\n                                           - 22 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178       Document: 32     Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 29\n\n\n\n         Defendants\u2019 avoidance is understandable, perhaps, because Plaintiffs have\n\nalleged much more than access-alone facts: e.g., Defendants\u2019 self-proclaimed \u201cstrong\n\nvisibility\u201d and \u201csignificant direct involvement\u201d of senior executives, Karp\u2019s own\n\nwords, Palantir\u2019s admitted proximity to the SPACs, etc. Plaintiffs then complemented\n\nthose facts with additional allegations of Defendants\u2019 deliberate actions: e.g.,\n\nbreathtaking insider selling of $2.2 billion-plus, scheming conduct vis-\u00e0-vis the round-\n\ntrip SPAC transactions, manipulation of reported metrics, etc.\u2014all of which are\n\n(i) taken as true, and (ii) considered collectively. Tellabs, 551 U.S. at 322-23;\n\nPluralsight, 45 F.4th at 1259, 1261.\n\n         When they are, Meitav\u2019s fact-specific \u201caccess alone\u201d criticism has no\n\napplication here.\n\n                    5.   Defendants\u2019 trumpeted \u201cstrong visibility\u201d into\n                         Palantir\u2019s revenue growth further establishes their\n                         scienter.\n\n         Defendants claim Plaintiffs \u201cdo not dispute\u201d the district court\u2019s holding that\n\n\u201c\u2018strong visibility\u2019\u201d isn\u2019t enough to find that they misled Palantir investors (AB.45),\n\nbut nothing is further from the truth.         Time and again Plaintiffs argued that\n\nDefendants\u2019 constant claims of \u201cstrong visibility\u201d into growth and revenue provided\n\ndirect on-ramps to their knowledge that the two areas were not progressing as\n\nrepresented. See, e.g., OB.26 (the opposite of Defendants\u2019 representations was true,\n\n\n                                           - 23 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178      Document: 32      Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 30\n\n\n\nand Defendants were aware of this at the time they spoke, given their \u201cstrong\n\nvisibility\u201d into Palantir\u2019s future revenue); accord OB.40; OB.41; OB.46; OB.50;\n\nOB.61.\n\n         Indeed, Plaintiffs reject the district court\u2019s reasoning that Defendants\u2019 admitted\n\n\u201cstrong visibility\u201d cannot satisfy the \u201ctotal visibility\u201d it demanded. OB.60 (original\n\nemphasis). The court\u2019s demand is doubly wrong: (i) it undermines the \u201cstrongly\n\nsupport[ed]\u201d scienter inferences arising from Defendants\u2019 admissions (Pluralsight, 45\n\nF.4th at 1259-60); and (ii) improperly elevates the requisite inference to an\n\n\u201cirrefutable\u201d level. Tellabs, 551 U.S. at 324. 20\n\n         Defendants say Plaintiffs are asking this Court to infer that they had an\n\n\u201comniscient view\u201d of Palantir\u2019s financial results in advance (AB.46), but that\u2019s untrue.\n\nPlaintiffs aren\u2019t urging omniscience, but advance the commonsense argument that\n\nDefendants\u2019 self-professed \u201cstrong visibility\u201d\u2014specifically based on the nature of\n\ntheir business and contracts\u2014meant they saw Palantir\u2019s existing revenue, growth, and\n\nSPAC-related problems. See, e.g., Appdx.V1.103-04:\u00b6127 (Defendants explain that\n\n\n\n\n20\n   Defendants defend the district court\u2019s \u201c\u2018total visibility\u2019\u201d demand as merely\n\u201csemantic.\u201d AB.45 n.33. If Defendants mean the two levels of visibility are\nfundamentally equivalent while using different words, they\u2019re mistaken: \u201cstrong\u201d isn\u2019t\n\u201ctotal\u201d by anyone\u2019s measure.\n\n                                           - 24 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178       Document: 32     Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 31\n\n\n\nrevenue-related problems arising in the present quarter won\u2019t be \u201cfully reflected in\n\nour results of operations until future periods\u201d).\n\n         Defendants wind up their \u201c\u2018total visibility\u2019\u201d screed by charging Plaintiffs with\n\nignoring Circuit precedent involving \u201cgrowth forecasts.\u201d AB.45, 46 & n.35. But\n\nPlaintiffs\u2019 case doesn\u2019t concern Defendants\u2019 forecasts, but rather their real-time\n\nknowledge of, and misstatements concerning: (i) stagnating growth; (ii) revenue\n\nimpact; and (iii) the sham SPAC deals Defendants used to prop up (i) and (ii).\n\nDefendants would have this Court to leave common sense at the courthouse steps, yet\n\nPalantir\u2019s SPAC customers\u2019 myriad bankruptcies and insolvencies didn\u2019t happen\n\novernight. Pluralsight, 45 F.4th at 1259-60; see also Plotkin v. IP Axess Inc., 407\n\nF.3d 690, 698 (5th Cir. 2005) (\u201cnot unwarranted to infer that when a company\u2019s big\n\ndeal collapses so fast, something was amiss at the outset\u201d).21\n\n                    6.   Defendants\u2019 deliberate manipulation of key reporting\n                         metrics cannot be explained away.\n\n         Plaintiffs\u2019 Opening Brief tabulates the five key metrics whose reporting\n\nDefendants manipulated to further their scheme and conceal stagnation in Palantir\u2019s\n\n\n21\n   Defendants say Plaintiffs overlooked new contracts that Palantir \u201choped to sign\u201d or\nexisting contracts that \u201ccould be renewed or upsized.\u201d AB.47. Their charge is\ntoothless\u2014\u201chope[]\u201d and \u201ccould be\u201d may be understandable aspirations, but cannot\nexcuse Palantir\u2019s existing reality of stagnating growth, quid pro quo revenue from\nunsustainable contracts, and manipulated metrics used in Palantir\u2019s public\n(mis)statements.\n\n                                           - 25 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178     Document: 32      Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 32\n\n\n\ntwo main business segments. OB.29-33. The brief further explains the district court\u2019s\n\nerroneous reasoning that because some truthful information was available elsewhere in\n\nPalantir\u2019s filings or public statements, their manipulative conduct was excused.\n\nOB.64-66; see also Va. Bankshares, Inc. v. Sandberg, 501 U.S. 1083, 1097 (1991) (\u201cIf\n\nit would take a financial analyst to spot the tension between the one and the other,\n\nwhatever is misleading will remain materially so, and liability should follow.\u201d).\n\n         Responding, Defendants criticize Plaintiffs for not offering any \u201c[confidential\n\nwitnesses], internal document, or any facts\u2014as to why these changes were\n\nimplemented.\u201d AB.48 (original emphasis). Their criticism, untethered to precedent,\n\nis fanciful and misplaced.\n\n         Plaintiffs did explain why Defendants made the deliberate changes. See OB.29-\n\n33 (detailing manipulated performance metrics, and explaining how each concealed\n\nstagnation in Palantir\u2019s business). And neither confidential witnesses nor internal\n\ndocuments are required to plead a strong inference of scienter. See, e.g., In re\n\nAlphabet, Inc. Sec. Litig., 1 F.4th 687, 707 (9th Cir. 2021) (\u201cconfidential witnesses are\n\nnot needed where, as here, other allegations in the complaint raise a strong inference\n\nof scienter\u201d); see also Pirraglia, 339 F.3d at 1193 n.14 (internal documents not\n\nneeded at the pleading stage).\n\n\n\n\n                                          - 26 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178    Document: 32      Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 33\n\n\n\n         Undaunted, Defendants proceed to give their own narrative of why each of the\n\nreporting metrics was suddenly changed. Their excuses are not only premature, but\n\nunpersuasive.\n\n         As to Defendants\u2019 sudden concealment of the \u201cAcquire, Expand, and Scale\u201d\n\ninformation that undergirded Palantir\u2019s entire business model (Appdx.V1.118-\n\n20:\u00b6\u00b6164-168), Defendants claim that continuing to disclose those categories wouldn\u2019t\n\nhave revealed anything \u201cabout non-SPAC clients\u201d because SPACs would\u2019ve still been\n\nrepresented in the metric. AB.49. Even if true, that doesn\u2019t mean that Palantir\n\ninvestors wouldn\u2019t realize that non-SPAC customers were also languishing in the first\n\nor second phase; logically, investors would\u2019ve understood precisely what the cessation\n\nobscured: Palantir\u2019s diminishing business prospects for its organic (i.e., non-SPAC)\n\ncustomers, including the: (i) revenue and contribution margins associated with each\n\ncohort of new customers acquired in FY21; (ii) rate at which Palantir\u2019s customers\n\nsigned in 2021 had failed to advance through the cohorts to profitability; and\n\n(iii) SPAC Scheme\u2019s effect in masking this downward trend. Appdx.V1.120:\u00b6168. In\n\nother words, Palantir\u2019s declining performance would have been obvious.\n\n         As to the newly-expanded definition of \u201ccustomer,\u201d Defendants say they\n\nprovided \u201cmore[-]meaningful\u201d period-over-period comparisons, and that Plaintiffs\n\ndon\u2019t challenge that explanation. AB.49. But Plaintiffs certainly do\u2014alleging that\n\n\n                                         - 27 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178    Document: 32       Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 34\n\n\n\nthe change was deliberately done to: (i) artificially inflate Palantir\u2019s existing customer\n\ncount; and (ii) rope in revenues from the temporarily boosted financial performance in\n\n2Q20, 3Q20, and 4Q20 that reflected short-term COVID-19-related contracts.\n\nAppdx.V1.117:\u00b6162.\n\n         As to obscuring the Total Remaining Deal Value breakdown between\n\ngovernment and commercial sectors (OB.32), Defendants say TRDV was disclosed on\n\nnearly all earnings calls during the Class Period, and again at year-end. AB.50. But\n\nthat doesn\u2019t address, let alone excuse, the fact that Defendants deliberately hid the\n\nimportant metric for three straight quarters. Appdx.V1.120-21:\u00b6170. Whether the\n\nlengthy concealment mattered to investors, or was cured by year-end reports, cannot\n\nbe decided now. Pirraglia, 339 F.3d at 1192 n.13.22\n\n         As to changing \u201caverage revenue per customer\u201d from all customers to just\n\nPalantir\u2019s top 20 clients after the former figure dwindled (OB.32-33), Defendants say\n\nthey disclosed the change\u2019s true impetus: acquiring more customers (especially\n\ngrowth-stage ones) supposedly meant that only the top 20 demonstrated their\n\n\n\n\n22\n    Defendants offer the same excuse for omitting average contract duration despite\nreliably citing it quarter after quarter as a revenue-visibility metric. Appdx.V1.117-\n18:\u00b6163. See AB.50 (Palantir included metric in 2021 annual report). Whether that\nsingle disclosure cured Defendants\u2019 omissions over three straight quarters is not\nproperly resolved now. Pirraglia, 339 F.3d at 1192 n.13.\n\n                                          - 28 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178        Document: 32      Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 35\n\n\n\n\u201c\u2018expanding relationship with existing customers\u2019\u201d\u2014and that Plaintiffs haven\u2019t\n\ncontested that explanation. AB.50 (citing Appdx.V1.121-22:\u00b6171).\n\n         Defendants again twist the Complaint\u2019s allegations. While Plaintiffs repeat\n\nPalantir\u2019s claim that growing customer counts meant lower average revenues,\n\nPlaintiffs further allege that when revenues dropped, Defendants deliberately shifted\n\nto just the top 20\u2014along with the manipulated Acquire-Expand-Scale reporting\u2014in\n\norder to conceal from investors that Palantir\u2019s newest customers were not scaling up\n\nin size or profitability. Appdx.V1.121-22:\u00b6171. That allegation, accepted as true, is\n\nat least as compelling as Defendants\u2019 self-serving excuse. Tellabs, 551 U.S. at 324;\n\nPluralsight, 45 F.4th at 1268.23\n\n         B.         Defendants haven\u2019t satisfactorily defended the district\n                    court\u2019s failure to address the deliberate actions comprising\n                    their scheme.\n         While Plaintiffs explained the district court\u2019s erroneous scienter analyses\n\n(OB.52-68), they also described what the court didn\u2019t do\u2014namely, that it failed to\n\n23\n    Defendants suggest that investors could have made \u201cstraightforward calculation[s]\u201d\nto discover what the actual average-revenue-per-customer was (AB.51), but cite no\nauthority requiring investors to dig through complex data to double-check corporate\nrepresentations. Cf. In re Genius Brands Int\u2019l, Inc. Sec. Litig., 97 F.4th 1171, 1186\n(9th Cir. 2024) (\u201csecurities issuers should not escape liability for misrepresentations\nmerely because they can show that corrective information was publicly available on\nsome webpage tucked in a deep corner of the internet or buried in some unwieldy\nspreadsheet\u201d). Moreover, even if Palantir investors had attempted that excavation, the\ntruth would have been thwarted by the Company\u2019s ever-changing definition of\n\u201ccustomer.\u201d\n\n                                             - 29 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178     Document: 32     Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 36\n\n\n\naddress how the deliberate actions comprising Defendants\u2019 scheme and wrongful\n\ncourse of conduct couldn\u2019t be excused as mere negligence, and thus were intertwined\n\nwith their overall scienter. OB.48-52. Under this Court\u2019s precedents, that failure was\n\nerror. See Clinton, 63 F.4th at 1288-89 (reversing district court that \u201cignored other\n\nallegations\u201d relevant to scienter associated with fraudulent scheme and\n\nmisstatements); Johnson v. Reyna, 57 F.4th 769, 776 (10th Cir. 2023) (court\n\n\u201cimproperly construed Johnson\u2019s complaint by overlooking his plain-language\n\nallegations\u201d).\n\n         Defendants grudgingly admit that the district court \u201cdid not reach Plaintiffs\u2019\n\nfalsity or scheme allegations.\u201d AB.55. Their follow-on insistence that the court\n\nwasn\u2019t \u201crequired to reach\u201d the alleged \u201cmisstatements or conduct\u201d to analyze their\n\nscienter (id.) is dead wrong. See, e.g., Tellabs, 551 U.S. 326 (court considering\n\nscienter allegations must \u201cassess all [of] the allegations\u201d).\n\n         Defendants also assert that even \u201c\u2018deliberate\u2019\u201d conduct isn\u2019t necessarily\n\nfraudulent. AB.54. That may be so in a different context, but their actions here are\n\nalleged to be fraudulent\u2014and, when considered together \u201ccollectively\u201d and\n\n\u201cholistically\u201d (Tellabs, 551 U.S. at 326), combine to form a strong inference of\n\nDefendants\u2019 scienter. Plotting for massive financial gain via quid pro quo SPAC deals\n\nwhile concealing stagnated growth using manipulated metric-reporting levers doesn\u2019t\n\n\n                                         - 30 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178      Document: 32       Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 37\n\n\n\nhappen innocently, or even recklessly. Defendants\u2019 deliberate misconduct was\n\nparadigmatic securities fraud.\n\n         Defendants also insist that the district court did do the comparative analysis that\n\nTellabs mandates (AB.54), but that\u2019s overt question-begging. In truth, the court\u2019s\n\nabbreviated analysis was infected by (i) improperly-heightened pleading burdens, and\n\n(ii) its disbelief of allegations that it should have accepted as true. Each error warrants\n\nreversal. Tellabs, 551 U.S. at 324 (scienter inferences \u201cneed not be irrefutable\u201d);\n\nTwombly, 550 U.S. at 555-56 (judicial disbelief).\n\n         Relating to Defendants\u2019 comparative-analysis argument, they assert that the\n\nscienter-ties-go-to-plaintiffs truism is Plaintiffs\u2019 \u201clast-resort position\u201d with no support.\n\nAB.53 n.39. Defendants\u2019 assertion is baffling, as both the truism\u2019s existence\u2014and\n\nthis Court\u2019s embrace of it\u2014are undeniable. Pluralsight, 45 F.4th at 1268 (plaintiffs\u2019\n\nscienter inference need only be \u201c\u2018at least as compelling as any opposing inference one\n\ncould draw from the facts alleged\u2019\u201d) (quoting Tellabs, 551 U.S. at 324); see also\n\nFrank v. Dana Corp., 547 F.3d 564, 571 (6th Cir. 2008) (\u201c\u2018Tellabs now awards the\n\ndraw to the plaintiff.\u2019\u201d).\n\n\n\n\n                                            - 31 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f      Appellate Case: 25-1178     Document: 32     Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 38\n\n\n\nII.      CONCLUSION\n         For the reasons given supra and in the Opening Brief, this Court should reverse\n\nthe district court\u2019s dismissal.\n\nDATED: October 21, 2025                    Respectfully submitted,\n\n                                           ROBBINS GELLER RUDMAN\n                                             & DOWD LLP\n                                           DARREN J. ROBBINS\n                                           JOSEPH D. DALEY\n                                           LUKE O. BROOKS\n                                           J. MARCO JANOSKI GRAY\n                                           ERIKA L. OLIVER\n\n\n                                                        s/Joseph D. Daley\n                                                       JOSEPH D. DALEY\n\n                                           655 West Broadway, Suite 1900\n                                           San Diego, CA 92101\n                                           Telephone: 619/231-1058\n                                           619/231-7423 (fax)\n                                           darrenr@rgrdlaw.com\n                                           joed@rgrdlaw.com\n                                           lukeb@rgrdlaw.com\n                                           mjanoski@rgrdlaw.com\n                                           eoliver@rgrdlaw.com\n\n                                           Counsel for Plaintiffs/Appellants\n\n\n\n\n                                          - 32 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178      Document: 32     Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 39\n\n\n\n      CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE WITH TYPE-VOLUME LIMIT\n\n\n                     Certificate of Compliance With Type-Volume Limit,\n                    Typeface Requirements, and Type Style Requirements\n\n1.    This document complies with the type-volume limitation of Fed. R. App. P.\n32(a)(7)(B)(i) because, excluding the parts of the document exempted by Fed. R.\nApp. P. 32(f) and 10th Cir. R. 32(B):\n\n         [X] this document contains 6,482 words, or\n         []     this brief uses a monospaced typeface and contains <state the number\n         of> lines of text.\n\n2.    This document complies with the typeface requirements of Fed. R. App. P.\n32(a)(5) and the type style requirements of Fed. R. App. P. 32(a)(6) because:\n\n         [X] this document has been prepared in a proportionally spaced typeface\n         using Microsoft Word 2016 in 14 point and Times New Roman typeface, or\n         []     this document has been prepared in a monospaced typeface using\n         <state name and version of word processing program> with <state number\n         of characters per inch and name of type style>.\n\nDate: October 21, 2025\n                                                        s/Joseph D. Daley\n                                                       JOSEPH D. DALEY\n\n\n\n\n                                          - 33 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f     Appellate Case: 25-1178          Document: 32      Date Filed: 10/21/2025   Page: 40\n\n\n\n                                DECLARATION OF SERVICE\n\n         I, the undersigned, declare:\n\n         1.         That declarant is and was, at all times herein mentioned, a citizen of the\n\nUnited States and employed in the City and County of San Diego, over the age of\n\n18 years, and not a party to or interested party in the within action; that declarant\u2019s\n\nbusiness address is 655 West Broadway, Suite 1900, San Diego, California 92101.\n\n         2.         I hereby certify that on October 21, 2025, I electronically filed the\n\nforegoing document: PLAINTIFFS-APPELLANTS\u2019 REPLY BRIEF with the Clerk of\n\nthe Court for the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit by using the\n\nappellate CM/ECF system.\n\n         3.         I certify that all participants in the case are registered CM/ECF users and\n\nthat service will be accomplished by the appellate CM/ECF system.\n\n         I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.\n\nExecuted on October 21, 2025, at San Diego, California.\n\n\n                                                             s/Joseph D. Daley\n                                                            JOSEPH D. DALEY\n\n\n\n\n                                               - 34 -\n4896-9760-9332.v1\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2026-11-10T15:54:09.168543-08:00","document_number":"32","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"010011322092","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2025-11-05T15:58:51.745913-08:00","date_modified":"2026-06-23T14:54:58.597779-07:00","date_filed":"2025-10-21","time_filed":null,"entry_number":32,"recap_sequence_number":"2025-10-21.001","pacer_sequence_number":11224750,"description":"[11224750] Appellant/Petitioner's reply brief filed by California Public Employees' Retirement System and Shijun Liu. Served on 10/21/2025. Manner of Service: email. Word/page count: 6482. This pleading complies with all required privacy and virus certifications: Yes. [25-1178] JDD [Entered: 10/21/2025 03:55 PM]","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/443262095/","id":443262095,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/457894344/","id":457894344,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/31/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2025-11-05T15:58:51.708186-08:00","date_modified":"2026-06-23T14:54:58.573488-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"31","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2025-11-05T15:58:51.673353-08:00","date_modified":"2026-06-23T14:54:58.550763-07:00","date_filed":"2025-10-20","time_filed":null,"entry_number":31,"recap_sequence_number":"2025-10-20.001","pacer_sequence_number":11224087,"description":"[11224087] Paper copies of appellees' response brief received from Stephen Cohen, David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Palantir Technologies Inc., Spencer Rascoff, Shyam Sankar, Alexandra Schiff and Peter Thiel. [25-1178] [Entered: 10/20/2025 12:24 PM]","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/443262094/","id":443262094,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/457894343/","id":457894343,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/30/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2025-11-05T15:58:51.638768-08:00","date_modified":"2026-06-23T14:54:58.519856-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"30","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2025-11-05T15:58:51.605605-08:00","date_modified":"2026-06-23T14:54:58.492013-07:00","date_filed":"2025-10-17","time_filed":null,"entry_number":30,"recap_sequence_number":"2025-10-17.001","pacer_sequence_number":11223742,"description":"[11223742] Paper copies of appellants' opening brief received from California Public Employees' Retirement System and Shijun Liu. [25-1178] [Entered: 10/17/2025 12:01 PM]","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/443262093/","id":443262093,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/457894342/","id":457894342,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/29/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2025-11-05T15:58:51.572791-08:00","date_modified":"2026-03-15T18:19:18.259345-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"29","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2025-11-05T15:58:51.540928-08:00","date_modified":"2026-03-15T18:19:18.234387-07:00","date_filed":"2025-10-15","time_filed":null,"entry_number":29,"recap_sequence_number":"2025-10-15.001","pacer_sequence_number":11222949,"description":"[11222949] Minute order filed - Pursuant to 10th Cir. R. 31.5, paper copies of all merits briefs that have not already been submitted are now due. This directive extends to briefs not yet filed but does not extend to any appendix volumes filed. Paper copies of briefs not yet filed will be due 5 days after filing of the electronic versions. All copies must be exact replicas of the electronic filing(s), including all attachments. Number of copies due: 7. Paper copies of appellant and appellee brief due 10/20/2025 by California Public Employees' Retirement System, Stephen Cohen, David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Kevin Kawasaki, Shijun Liu, Alexander Moore, Palantir Technologies Inc., Spencer Rascoff, Shyam Sankar, Alexandra Schiff and Peter Thiel [25-1178] [Entered: 10/15/2025 12:22 PM]","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/443262092/","id":443262092,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/457894341/","id":457894341,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/28/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2025-11-05T15:58:51.509125-08:00","date_modified":"2026-03-15T18:19:18.205186-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"28","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2025-11-05T15:58:51.474336-08:00","date_modified":"2026-03-15T18:19:18.175801-07:00","date_filed":"2025-10-01","time_filed":null,"entry_number":28,"recap_sequence_number":"2025-10-01.001","pacer_sequence_number":11218975,"description":"[11218975] Minute order filed - Appellees' brief is accepted for filing. The parties will be notified via separate docket entry if paper copies are required. Appellants' optional reply brief due 10/21/2025 for Shijun Liu and California Public Employees' Retirement System. (Text Only - No Attachment) [25-1178] [Entered: 10/01/2025 08:16 AM]","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/443262091/","id":443262091,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/457894340/","id":457894340,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/27/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2025-11-05T15:58:51.417843-08:00","date_modified":"2026-03-15T18:19:18.147344-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"27","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"010011310153","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2025-11-05T15:58:51.378498-08:00","date_modified":"2026-03-15T18:19:18.118990-07:00","date_filed":"2025-09-30","time_filed":null,"entry_number":27,"recap_sequence_number":"2025-09-30.001","pacer_sequence_number":11218918,"description":"[11218918] Appellee/Respondent's brief filed by Palantir Technologies Inc., Alexander C. Karp, Stephen Cohen, Peter Thiel, Kevin Kawasaki, David Glazer, Shyam Sankar, Alexander Moore, Spencer Rascoff and Alexandra Schiff. Served on: 09/30/2025. Manner of service: email. Oral argument requested? No. Word/page count: 12984. This pleading complies with all required privacy and virus certifications: Yes. [25-1178] DL [Entered: 09/30/2025 05:10 PM]","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/439330144/","id":439330144,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/453855391/","id":453855391,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/26/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2025-09-29T15:51:18.105792-07:00","date_modified":"2026-03-15T18:19:18.083382-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"26","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2025-09-29T15:51:18.064131-07:00","date_modified":"2026-03-15T18:19:18.056820-07:00","date_filed":"2025-08-18","time_filed":null,"entry_number":26,"recap_sequence_number":"2025-08-18.001","pacer_sequence_number":11206075,"description":"[11206075] Order filed by Clerk of the Court granting Appellees' unopposed motion to extend time to file brief (28-days). Appellees' brief now due 09/30/2025 for Stephen Cohen, David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Palantir Technologies Inc., Spencer Rascoff, Shyam Sankar, Alexandra Schiff and Peter Thiel. Served on 08/18/2025. Text only entry - no attachment. [25-1178] [Entered: 08/18/2025 07:25 AM]","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/439330143/","id":439330143,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/453855390/","id":453855390,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/25/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2025-09-29T15:51:17.999688-07:00","date_modified":"2026-03-15T18:19:18.019438-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"25","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"010011283320","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2025-09-29T15:51:17.839464-07:00","date_modified":"2026-03-15T18:19:17.985766-07:00","date_filed":"2025-08-15","time_filed":null,"entry_number":25,"recap_sequence_number":"2025-08-15.001","pacer_sequence_number":11205981,"description":"[11205981] Motion filed by Appellees Palantir Technologies Inc., Stephen Cohen, David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Kevin Kawasaki, Peter Thiel and Shyam Sankar to extend time to file appellee/respondent's brief until 09/30/2025. Served on: 08/15/2025. Manner of service: email. This pleading complies with all required privacy and virus certifications: Yes. [25-1178] DL [Entered: 08/15/2025 03:10 PM]","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/433926242/","id":433926242,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/448295200/","id":448295200,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/24/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2025-08-06T14:38:14.307510-07:00","date_modified":"2026-03-15T18:19:17.956576-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"24","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2025-08-06T14:38:14.284682-07:00","date_modified":"2026-03-15T18:19:17.870033-07:00","date_filed":"2025-07-31","time_filed":null,"entry_number":24,"recap_sequence_number":"2025-07-31.003","pacer_sequence_number":11201956,"description":"[11201956] Minute order filed - the brief and appendix submitted by appellant is accepted for filing. The parties will be notified via separate docket entry if paper copies are required. Appellees brief now due 09/02/2025 for Stephen Cohen, David Glazer, William Ho, Alexander C. Karp, Kevin Kawakaki, Alexander Moore, Palantir Technologies Inc., Spencer Rascoff, Shyam Sankar, Alexandra Schiff and Peter Thiel. (Text Only - No Attachment) [25-1178] [Entered: 07/31/2025 02:51 PM]","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/433926241/","id":433926241,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/448295199/","id":448295199,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/23/1/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2025-08-06T14:38:14.265754-07:00","date_modified":"2026-03-15T18:19:17.762824-07:00","sha1":"c322baf4c6f4d73148fdc14895801a1c3009d44b","page_count":233,"file_size":3702146,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.ca10.90104/gov.uscourts.ca10.90104.23.1.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.ca10.90104/gov.uscourts.ca10.90104.23.1.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"                           No. 25-1178\n        IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS\n                FOR THE TENTH CIRCUIT\n\nCALIFORNIA PUBLIC EMPLOYEES\u2019 RETIREMENT SYSTEM, et al.,\n\n                       Plaintiffs/Appellants,\n\n                                vs.\n\n            PALANTIR TECHNOLOGIES INC., et al.,\n\n                      Defendants/Appellees.\n\n\n      Appeal from a Decision of the United States District Court\n   for the District of Colorado, Case No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP\n         Honorable Gordon P. Gallagher, U.S. District Judge\n\n                 APPELLANTS\u2019 APPENDIX\n              VOLUME 1 OF 10 \u2013 PAGES 1 TO 233\n\n                 ROBBINS GELLER RUDMAN\n                          & DOWD LLP\n                     DARREN J. ROBBINS\n                       JOSEPH D. DALEY\n                       LUKE O. BROOKS\n                  J. MARCO JANOSKI GRAY\n                       ERIKA L. OLIVER\n                 655 West Broadway, Suite 1900\n                      San Diego, CA 92101\n                    Telephone: 619/231-1058\n                        619/231-7423 (fax)\n\n                 Counsel for Plaintiffs/Appellants\n\n\n\n\n                                 1\n\f                                     INDEX\n\nDocket                     Document \u2013 Date                           Page\nNumber\n\n                     VOLUME 1 OF 10 \u2013 Pages 1-233\n  --     Civil Docket, Cupat v. Palantir Technologies Inc. et al,     5\n         No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP (D. Colo.)\n\n  91     Transcript of April 24, 2024 Status Conference               32\n\n  92     Second Amended Consolidated Class Action Complaint           47\n         for Violations of the Federal Securities Laws\n\n 92-1    Appendix 1 to the Second Amended Consolidated Class         155\n         Action Complaint for Violations of the Federal Securities\n         Laws\n\n 92-2    Appendix 2 to the Second Amended Consolidated Class         167\n         Action Complaint for Violations of the Federal Securities\n         Laws\n\n 102     Defendants\u2019 Combined Motion and Brief to Dismiss            172\n         Plaintiffs\u2019 Second Amended Complaint\n\n                   VOLUME 2 OF 10 \u2013 Pages 234-459\n 102-1   Defendants\u2019 Appendix \u2013 Volume I of III (D.A. 1 to D.A.      238\n         635) to Defendants\u2019 Combined Motion and Brief to\n         Dismiss Plaintiffs\u2019 Second Amended Complaint [partial]\n\n                   VOLUME 3 OF 10 \u2013 Pages 460-689\n 102-1   Defendants\u2019 Appendix \u2013 Volume I of III (D.A. 1 to D.A.      464\n         635) to Defendants\u2019 Combined Motion and Brief to\n         Dismiss Plaintiffs\u2019 Second Amended Complaint [partial]\n\n                    VOLUME 4 OF 3 \u2013 Pages 690-912\n 102-1   Defendants\u2019 Appendix \u2013 Volume I of III (D.A. 1 to D.A.      694\n         635) to Defendants\u2019 Combined Motion and Brief to\n         Dismiss Plaintiffs\u2019 Second Amended Complaint [partial]\n\n\n\n\n                                         2\n\f                 VOLUME 5 OF 10 \u2013 Pages 913-1186\n102-2   Defendants\u2019 Appendix \u2013 Volume II of III (D.A. 636 to      917\n        D.A. 887) to Defendants\u2019 Combined Motion and Brief to\n        Dismiss Plaintiffs\u2019 Second Amended Complaint\n\n                VOLUME 6 OF 10 \u2013 Pages 1187-1436\n102-3   Defendants\u2019 Appendix \u2013 Volume III of III (D.A. 888 to     1191\n        D.A. 1529) to Defendants\u2019 Combined Motion and Brief to\n        Dismiss Plaintiffs\u2019 Second Amended Complaint [partial]\n\n                VOLUME 7 OF 10 \u2013 Pages 1437-1650\n102-3   Defendants\u2019 Appendix \u2013 Volume III of III (D.A. 888 to     1441\n        D.A. 1529) to Defendants\u2019 Combined Motion and Brief to\n        Dismiss Plaintiffs\u2019 Second Amended Complaint [partial]\n\n                VOLUME 8 OF 10 \u2013 Pages 1651-1872\n102-3   Defendants\u2019 Appendix \u2013 Volume III of III (D.A. 888 to     1655\n        D.A. 1529) to Defendants\u2019 Combined Motion and Brief to\n        Dismiss Plaintiffs\u2019 Second Amended Complaint [partial]\n\n                VOLUME 9 OF 10 \u2013 Pages 1873-2085\n103     Defendants\u2019 Request for Judicial Notice and Notice of     1877\n        Documents Incorporated by Reference in Support of\n        Defendants\u2019 Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs\u2019 Second\n        Amended Complaint\n\n107-1   Appendix in Support of Defendants\u2019 Opposition to          1893\n        Plaintiffs\u2019 Motion for a Partial Lift of the PSLRA\n        Discovery Stay\n\n112     Plaintiffs\u2019 Opposition to Defendants\u2019 Motion to Dismiss   1921\n        Plaintiffs\u2019 Second Amended Complaint\n\n115     Defendants\u2019 Reply in Support of Their Motion to Dismiss   1981\n        Plaintiffs\u2019 Second Amended Complaint Together with\n        Request for Oral Argument\n\n115-1   Defendants\u2019 Reply Appendix (R.A. 1 to R.A. 59) in         2013\n        Support of Defendants\u2019 Reply in Support of Their Motion\n\n\n\n\n                                       3\n\f        to Dismiss Plaintiffs\u2019 Second Amended Complaint\n        Together with Request for Oral Argument\n\n118     Defendants\u2019 Response to Plaintiffs\u2019 Objection to           2080\n        Materials Submitted with Defendants\u2019 Reply in Support of\n        Their Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs\u2019 Second Amended\n        Complaint\n\n                VOLUME 10 OF 10 \u2013 Pages 2086-2186\n119     Defendants\u2019 Notice of Supplemental Authority               2090\n\n120     Exhibit A to Defendants\u2019 Notice of Supplemental            2094\n        Authority\n\n122     Defendants\u2019 Notice of Lead Plaintiffs\u2019 Attempt to          2113\n        Circumvent the PSLRA\u2019s Mandatory Discovery Stay\n\n122-1   Exhibit A to Defendants\u2019 Notice of Lead Plaintiffs\u2019        2117\n        Attempt to Circumvent the PSLRA\u2019s Mandatory\n        Discovery Stay\n\n122-2   Exhibit B to Defendants\u2019 Notice of Lead Plaintiffs\u2019        2121\n        Attempt to Circumvent the PSLRA\u2019s Mandatory\n        Discovery Stay\n\n122-3   Exhibit C to Defendants\u2019 Notice of Lead Plaintiffs\u2019        2126\n        Attempt to Circumvent the PSLRA\u2019s Mandatory\n        Discovery Stay\n\n123     Order                                                      2143\n\n\n124     Final Judgment                                             2181\n\n125     Notice of Appeal                                           2183\n\n\n\n\n                                       4\n\f                                                                     APPEAL,JD1,LEAD,NDISPO,TERMED\n\n                           U.S. District Court - District of Colorado\n                                 District of Colorado (Denver)\n                    CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE #: 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP\n\n\nCupat v. Palantir Technologies Inc. et al                         Date Filed: 09/15/2022\nAssigned to: District Judge Gordon P Gallagher                    Date Terminated: 04/04/2025\nReferred to: Magistrate Judge Susan Prose                         Jury Demand: Plaintiff\nCase in other court: U.S. Court of Appeals, 10th Cir., 25-01178   Nature of Suit: 850 Securities, Commodities,\nCause: 15:78 Securities Exchange Act                              Exchange\n                                                                  Jurisdiction: Federal Question\nPlaintiff\nMinchie Galot Cupat                                 represented by Joseph Alexander Hood , II\nIndividually and on Behalf of All Others                           Pomerantz LLP\nSimilarly Situated                                                 600 Third Avenue\n                                                                   20th Floor\n                                                                   New York, NY 10016\n                                                                   212-661-1100\n                                                                   Email: ahood@pomlaw.com\n                                                                   ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                                                                  Jeremy Alan Lieberman\n                                                                  Pomerantz LLP\n                                                                  600 Third Avenue\n                                                                  20th Floor\n                                                                  New York, NY 10016\n                                                                  212-661-1100\n                                                                  Fax: 212-661-8665\n                                                                  Email: jalieberman@pomlaw.com\n                                                                  ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\nPlaintiff\nWenHong Hu                                          represented by Kathryn A. Reilly\n                                                                   Wheeler Trigg O'Donnell LLP\n                                                                   370 17th Street\n                                                                   Suite 4500\n                                                                   Denver, CO 80202-5647\n                                                                   303-244-1800\n                                                                   Fax: 303-244-1879\n                                                                   Email: reilly@wtotrial.com\n                                                                   ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\nPlaintiff\nShijun Liu, Individually and as Trustee of          represented by Erika L. Oliver\nthe Liu Family Trust 2019                                          Robbins Geller Rudman & Dowd LLP\n                                                                   655 West Broadway\n                                                                   Suite 1900\n                                                                   San Diego, CA 92101\n                                                                   619-744-2617\n                                                       5\n\f                                                         Email: eoliver@rgrdlaw.com\n                                                         ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                                                         J. Marco Janoski Gray\n                                                         Robbins Geller Rudman & Dowd LLP\n                                                         655 West Broadway\n                                                         Suite 1900\n                                                         San Diego, CA 92101\n                                                         619-231-1058\n                                                         Fax: 619-231-7423\n                                                         Email: mjanoski@rgrdlaw.com\n                                                         ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                                                         Luke Orion Brooks\n                                                         Robbins Geller Rudman & Dowd LLP\n                                                         655 West Broadway\n                                                         Suite 1900\n                                                         San Diego, CA 92101\n                                                         619-231-1058\n                                                         Fax: 619-231-7423\n                                                         Email: lukeb@rgrdlaw.com\n                                                         ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n\nV.\nConsol Plaintiff\nShujun Liu                                 represented by Jeffrey Allen Berens\nIndividually and on Behalf of All Others                  Johnson Fistel LLP\nSimilarly Situated                                        2373 Central Park Boulevard\ntrustee                                                   Suite 100\nLiu Family Trust 2019                                     Denver, CO 80238\n                                                          303-861-1764\n                                                          Email: jeffb@johnsonfistel.com\n                                                          LEAD ATTORNEY\n                                                          ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n\nV.\nDefendant\nPalantir Technologies Inc.                 represented by Anna C. Van de Stouwe\n                                                          Holland & Hart LLP\n                                                          Commercial Litigation/Appellate\n                                                          555 17th Street\n                                                          Suite 3200\n                                                          Denver, CO 80202\n                                                          303-295-8017\n                                                          Email: avandestouwe@ftc.gov\n                                                          TERMINATED: 08/03/2023\n                                                          ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                                                         Boris Feldman\n                                                         Freshfields US LLP\n                                                         855 Main Street\n                                             6\n\f    Redwood City, CA 94063\n    650-461-8200\n    Email: boris.feldman@freshfields.com\n    ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n    David Y. Livshiz\n    Freshfields US LLP\n    3 World Trade Center\n    175 Greenwich Street\n    51st Floor\n    New York, NY 10007\n    212-284-4979\n    Email: david.livshiz@freshfields.com\n    ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n    Holly Stein Sollod\n    Holland & Hart LLP\n    P. O. Box 8749\n    555 17th Street\n    Suite 3200\n    Denver, CO 80201-8749\n    303-295-8085\n    Fax: 303-295-8261\n    Email: hsteinsollod@hollandhart.com\n    TERMINATED: 04/08/2024\n    ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n    Kimberly J. Willis\n    Holland & Hart LLP\n    P. O. Box 8749\n    555 17th Street\n    Suite 3200\n    Denver, CO 80201-8749\n    303-295-8528\n    Fax: 303-975-5426\n    Email: kjwillis@hollandhart.com\n    TERMINATED: 04/08/2024\n    ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n    Matthew S. Kahn\n    Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP\n    One Embarcadero Center\n    Suite 2600\n    San Francisco, CA 94111-3715\n    415-393-8212\n    Email: MKahn@gibsondunn.com\n    ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n    Michael David Celio\n    Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP\n    310 University Avenue\n    Palo Alto, CA 94301\n    650-849-5326\n    Email: MCelio@gibsondunn.com\n7\n\f                                ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                                Nathan A. Keever\n                                Dufford Waldeck Milburn & Krohn, LLP\n                                744 Horizon Court\n                                Suite 300\n                                Grand Junction, CO 81504\n                                970-241-5500\n                                Fax: 970-243-7738\n                                Email: keever@dwmk.com\n                                TERMINATED: 07/30/2024\n\n                                Nicholas Angelo Caselli\n                                Freshfields US LLP\n                                3 World Trade Center\n                                175 Greenwich Street\n                                51st Floor\n                                New York, NY 10007\n                                212-277-4000\n                                Email: nicholas.caselli@freshfields.com\n                                ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                                Sam D. Starritt\n                                Starritt Legal LLC\n                                222 North 7th Street\n                                Suite A\n                                Grand Junction, CO 81501\n                                970-335-8831\n                                Email: sam@starrittlegal.com\n                                ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                                Wesley Sze\n                                Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP\n                                310 University Avenue\n                                Palo Alto, CA 94301\n                                650-849-5347\n                                Email: wsze@gibsondunn.com\n                                ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\nDefendant\nAlexander C. Karp   represented by Anna C. Van de Stouwe\n                                   (See above for address)\n                                   TERMINATED: 08/03/2023\n                                   ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                                Boris Feldman\n                                (See above for address)\n                                ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                                David Y. Livshiz\n                                (See above for address)\n                                ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                                Holly Stein Sollod\n                      8\n\f                           (See above for address)\n                           TERMINATED: 04/08/2024\n                           ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                           Kimberly J. Willis\n                           (See above for address)\n                           TERMINATED: 04/08/2024\n                           ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                           Matthew S. Kahn\n                           (See above for address)\n                           ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                           Michael David Celio\n                           (See above for address)\n                           ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                           Nathan A. Keever\n                           (See above for address)\n                           TERMINATED: 07/30/2024\n\n                           Nicholas Angelo Caselli\n                           (See above for address)\n                           ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                           Sam D. Starritt\n                           (See above for address)\n                           ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                           Wesley Sze\n                           (See above for address)\n                           ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\nDefendant\nDavid Glazer   represented by Anna C. Van de Stouwe\n                              (See above for address)\n                              TERMINATED: 08/03/2023\n                              ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                           Boris Feldman\n                           (See above for address)\n                           ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                           David Y. Livshiz\n                           (See above for address)\n                           ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                           Holly Stein Sollod\n                           (See above for address)\n                           TERMINATED: 04/08/2024\n                           ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                           Kimberly J. Willis\n                           (See above for address)\n                 9\n\f                           TERMINATED: 04/08/2024\n                           ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                           Matthew S. Kahn\n                           (See above for address)\n                           ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                           Michael David Celio\n                           (See above for address)\n                           ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                           Nathan A. Keever\n                           (See above for address)\n                           TERMINATED: 07/30/2024\n\n                           Nicholas Angelo Caselli\n                           (See above for address)\n                           ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                           Sam D. Starritt\n                           (See above for address)\n                           ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                           Wesley Sze\n                           (See above for address)\n                           ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\nDefendant\nShyam Sankar   represented by Anna C. Van de Stouwe\n                              (See above for address)\n                              TERMINATED: 08/03/2023\n                              ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                           Boris Feldman\n                           (See above for address)\n                           ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                           David Y. Livshiz\n                           (See above for address)\n                           ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                           Holly Stein Sollod\n                           (See above for address)\n                           TERMINATED: 04/08/2024\n                           ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                           Kimberly J. Willis\n                           (See above for address)\n                           TERMINATED: 04/08/2024\n                           ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                           Matthew S. Kahn\n                           (See above for address)\n                           ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n                10\n\f                               Michael David Celio\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Nathan A. Keever\n                               (See above for address)\n                               TERMINATED: 07/30/2024\n\n                               Nicholas Angelo Caselli\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Sam D. Starritt\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Wesley Sze\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n\nV.\nConsol Defendant\nStephen Cohen      represented by Boris Feldman\n                                  (See above for address)\n                                  ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               David Y. Livshiz\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Matthew S. Kahn\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Michael David Celio\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Nicholas Angelo Caselli\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Sam D. Starritt\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Wesley Sze\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\nConsol Defendant\n                    11\n\fPeter Thiel        represented by Boris Feldman\n                                  (See above for address)\n                                  ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               David Y. Livshiz\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Matthew S. Kahn\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Michael David Celio\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Nicholas Angelo Caselli\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Sam D. Starritt\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Wesley Sze\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\nConsol Defendant\nWilliam Ho         represented by Boris Feldman\n                                  (See above for address)\n                                  ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               David Y. Livshiz\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Nicholas Angelo Caselli\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Sam D. Starritt\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\nConsol Defendant\nKevin Kawasaki     represented by Boris Feldman\n                                  (See above for address)\n                                  ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               David Y. Livshiz\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n                    12\n\f                               Matthew S. Kahn\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Michael David Celio\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Nicholas Angelo Caselli\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Sam D. Starritt\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Wesley Sze\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\nConsol Defendant\nAlexander Moore    represented by Boris Feldman\n                                  (See above for address)\n                                  ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               David Y. Livshiz\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Matthew S. Kahn\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Michael David Celio\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Nicholas Angelo Caselli\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Sam D. Starritt\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Wesley Sze\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\nConsol Defendant\nSpencer Rascoff    represented by Boris Feldman\n                                  (See above for address)\n                                  ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n                    13\n\f                               David Y. Livshiz\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Matthew S. Kahn\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Michael David Celio\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Nicholas Angelo Caselli\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Sam D. Starritt\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Wesley Sze\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\nConsol Defendant\nAlexandra Schiff   represented by Boris Feldman\n                                  (See above for address)\n                                  ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               David Y. Livshiz\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Matthew S. Kahn\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Michael David Celio\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Nicholas Angelo Caselli\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Sam D. Starritt\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                               Wesley Sze\n                               (See above for address)\n                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\nMovant\n                    14\n\fAfa Sjuk tjanstepensionsaktiebolag        represented by Naumon Amjed\n                                                         Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check LLP\n                                                         280 King of Prussia Road\n                                                         Radnor, PA 19087\n                                                         (610) 667-7706\n                                                         Fax: (610) 667-7056\n                                                         Email: namjed@ktmc.com\n                                                         ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\nMovant\nAfa Liv tjanstepensionsaktiebolag         represented by Naumon Amjed\n                                                         (See above for address)\n                                                         ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\nMovant\nAfa Trygg tjanstepensionsaktiebolag       represented by Naumon Amjed\n                                                         (See above for address)\n                                                         ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\nMovant\nMichael Nagar                             represented by Adam Marc Apton\n                                                         Levi & Korsinsky LLP\n                                                         33 Whitehall Street\n                                                         27th Floor\n                                                         New York, NY 10004\n                                                         212-363-7500\n                                                         Email: aapton@zlk.com\n                                                         ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\nMovant\nMohammad Aboobakar                        represented by Adam Marc Apton\n                                                         (See above for address)\n                                                         ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\nMovant\nNew Mexico State Investment Council       represented by Rusty Evan Glenn\n                                                         Shuman Glenn & Stecker\n                                                         600 17th Street\n                                                         Suite 2800 South\n                                                         Denver, CO 80202\n                                                         303-861-3003\n                                                         Fax: 303-536-7849\n                                                         Email: rusty@shumanlawfirm.com\n                                                         ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\nMovant\nPublic Employees Retirement Association   represented by Rusty Evan Glenn\nof New Mexico                                            (See above for address)\n                                                         ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\nMovant\nPublic Employees' Retirement System of    represented by Rusty Evan Glenn\nMississippi                                              (See above for address)\n                                            15\n\f                                                        ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\nMovant\nVitoldas Ciparis                          represented by Robert Vincent Prongay\n                                                         Glancy Prongay & Murray LLP\n                                                         1925 Century Park East\n                                                         Suite 2100\n                                                         Los Angeles, CA 90067\n                                                         310-201-9150\n                                                         Fax: 310-201-9160\n                                                         Email: rprongay@glancylaw.com\n                                                         ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\nMovant\nGagik Yepremyan                           represented by Robert Vincent Prongay\n                                                         (See above for address)\n                                                         ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\nMovant\nLilit Yepremyan                           represented by Robert Vincent Prongay\n                                                         (See above for address)\n                                                         ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\nMovant\nCalifornia Public Employees' Retirement   represented by Christopher Ryan Kinnon\nSystem                                                   Robbins Geller Rudman & Dowd LLP\n                                                         655 West Broadway\n                                                         Suite 1900\n                                                         San Diego, CA 92101\n                                                         619-408-7787\n                                                         Email: ckinnon@rgrdlaw.com\n                                                         ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                                                        Danielle S. Myers\n                                                        Robbins Geller Rudman & Dowd LLP\n                                                        655 West Broadway\n                                                        Suite 1900\n                                                        San Diego, CA 92101\n                                                        619-231-1058\n                                                        Fax: 619-231-7423\n                                                        Email: dmyers@rgrdlaw.com\n                                                        ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                                                        Darren Jay Robbins\n                                                        Robbins Geller Rudman & Dowd LLP\n                                                        655 West Broadway\n                                                        Suite 1900\n                                                        San Diego, CA 92101\n                                                        619-231-1058\n                                                        Email: darrenr@rgrdlaw.com\n                                                        ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                                                        Erika L. Oliver\n                                           16\n\f                                                               (See above for address)\n                                                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                                                               J. Marco Janoski Gray\n                                                               (See above for address)\n                                                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                                                               Jeffrey Allen Berens\n                                                               (See above for address)\n                                                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                                                               Luke Orion Brooks\n                                                               (See above for address)\n                                                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n                                                               Sarah A. Fallon\n                                                               Robbins Geller Rudman & Dowd LLP\n                                                               655 West Broadway\n                                                               Suite 1900\n                                                               San Diego, CA 92101\n                                                               619-231-1058\n                                                               Email: sfallon@rgrdlaw.com\n                                                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\nMovant\nAtef Zakhary                                    represented by Jeremy Alan Lieberman\n                                                               (See above for address)\n                                                               ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED\n\n\nDate Filed     #   Docket Text\n09/15/2022     1 COMPLAINT against David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Palantir Technologies Inc.,\n                 Shyam Sankar (Filing fee $ 402,Receipt Number ACODC-8659939)Attorney Jeremy\n                 Alan Lieberman added to party Minchie Galot Cupat(pty:pla), filed by Minchie Galot\n                 Cupat. (Attachments: # 1 Civil Cover Sheet, # 2 Proposed Summons - Palantir\n                 Technologies Inc., # 3 Proposed Summons - Alexander C. Karp, # 4 Proposed Summons -\n                 David Glazer, # 5 Proposed Summons - Shyam Sankar)(Lieberman, Jeremy) (Entered:\n                 09/15/2022)\n09/15/2022     2 Case assigned to Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney and drawn to Magistrate Judge S. Kato\n                 Crews. Text Only Entry. (jcharl, ) (Entered: 09/15/2022)\n09/15/2022     3 SUMMONS issued by Clerk. (Attachments: # 1 Summons, # 2 Summons, # 3 Summons,\n                 # 4 Magistrate Judge Consent Form) (jcharl, ) (Entered: 09/15/2022)\n09/16/2022     4 ORDER REFERRING CASE to Magistrate Judge S. Kato Crews non-dispositive\n                 matters. Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. \u00a7 636(b)(1)(A) and (B) and Fed. R. Civ. P. 72(a) and (b),\n                 this case is referred to the assigned United States Magistrate Judge to (1) convene a\n                 scheduling conference under Fed. R. Civ. P. 16(b) and enter a scheduling order meeting\n                 the requirements of Local Civ. R. 16.2, (2) conduct such status conferences and issue such\n                 orders necessary for compliance with the scheduling order, including amendments or\n                 modifications of the scheduling order upon a showing of good cause, (3) hear and\n                 determine pretrial matters, including discovery and other non-dispositive motions, (4)\n                 pursuant to Local Civ. R. 16.6 and at the discretion of the Magistrate Judge, convene such\n                                                    17\n\f                 early neutral evaluation and/or settlement conferences and direct related procedures as\n                 may facilitate resolution of this case without the necessity of a motion or prior\n                 authorization of the undersigned. By Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney on 9/16/2022. Text\n                 Only Entry (cnssec.) (Entered: 09/16/2022)\n09/22/2022    5 NOTICE of Entry of Appearance by Joseph Alexander Hood, II on behalf of Minchie\n                Galot CupatAttorney Joseph Alexander Hood, II added to party Minchie Galot\n                Cupat(pty:pla) (Hood, Joseph) (Entered: 09/22/2022)\n11/14/2022    6 WITHDRAWN MOTION to Consolidate Cases , MOTION for Appointment as Lead\n                Plaintiff, MOTION to Appoint Counsel by Movants Afa Sjuk tjanstepensionsaktiebolag,\n                Afa Liv tjanstepensionsaktiebolag, Afa Trygg tjanstepensionsaktiebolag. (Attachments: #\n                1 Proposed Order (PDF Only), # 2 Declaration of Naumon A. Amjed, # 3 Exhibit A -\n                Certification, # 4 Exhibit B - Loss Chart, # 5 Exhibit C - Notice of Pendency, # 6 Exhibit\n                D - Firm Resume)(Amjed, Naumon) Modified on 11/30/2022 motion withdrawn per\n                [#21] Order. (sphil, ). (Entered: 11/14/2022)\n11/14/2022    7 WITHDRAWN MOTION to Consolidate Cases , MOTION to Appoint Lead Plaintiff,\n                MOTION to Appoint Counsel by Movants Michael Nagar, Mohammad Aboobakar.\n                (Attachments: # 1 Declaration of Adam M. Apton, # 2 Exhibit A- PSLRA Certification, #\n                3 Exhibit B- Loss Chart, # 4 Exhibit C- PSLRA Notice, # 5 Exhibit D- Joint Declaration,\n                # 6 Exhibit E- LK Resume, # 7 Proposed Order (PDF Only))(Apton, Adam) Modified on\n                11/30/2022 to withdraw motion per [#23] Order. (sphil, ). (Entered: 11/14/2022)\n11/14/2022    8 WITHDRAWN MOTION to Consolidate Cases , MOTION for Appointment as Lead\n                Plaintiff, MOTION to Appoint Counsel by Movants New Mexico State Investment\n                Council, Public Employees Retirement Association of New Mexico, Public Employees'\n                Retirement System of Mississippi. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, NM SIC Certification, #\n                2 Exhibit B, NM SIC Loss Chart, # 3 Exhibit C, NM PERA Certification, # 4 Exhibit D,\n                NM PERA Loss Chart, # 5 Exhibit E, MS PERS Certification, # 6 Exhibit F, MS PERS\n                Loss Chart, # 7 Exhibit G, Cupat PSLRA Notice, # 8 Exhibit H, Allegheny PSLRA\n                Notice, # 9 Exhibit I, Liu PSLRA Notice, # 10 Exhibit J, Joint Declaration, # 11 Exhibit\n                K, G&E Firm Resume, # 12 Proposed Order (PDF Only))(Glenn, Rusty) Modified on\n                12/5/2022 to withdraw motion per [#25] Order. (sphil, ). (Entered: 11/14/2022)\n11/14/2022    9 WITHDRAWN MOTION to Consolidate Cases , MOTION for Appointment as Lead\n                Plaintiff, MOTION to Appoint Counsel by Movants Vitoldas Ciparis, Gagik Yepremyan,\n                Lilit Yepremyan. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A - PSLRA Notice, # 2 Exhibit B -\n                Certifications of Movants, # 3 Exhibit C - Financial Interest Analysis, # 4 Exhibit D -\n                Movants' Joint Declaration, # 5 Exhibit E - GPM Firm Resume, # 6 Proposed Order (PDF\n                Only))(Prongay, Robert) Modified on 12/6/2022 to withdraw motion per [#32] Order.\n                (sphil, ). (Entered: 11/14/2022)\n11/14/2022   10 MOTION to Consolidate Cases , for Appointment as Lead Plaintiff, MOTION to Appoint\n                Counsel by Movant California Public Employees' Retirement System. (Attachments: # 1\n                Proposed Order (PDF Only))(Myers, Danielle) (Entered: 11/14/2022)\n11/14/2022   11 WITHDRAWN MOTION to Consolidate Cases Motion Of WenHong Hu For\n                Consolidation Of Related Actions, Appointment As Lead Plaintiff, And Approval Of\n                Selection Of Counsel by Plaintiff WenHong Hu. (Attachments: # 1 Proposed Order (PDF\n                Only), # 2 Declaration of Kathryn A. Reilly, # 3 Exhibit A to Declaration of Kathryn A.\n                Reilly, # 4 Exhibit B to Declaration of Kathryn A. Reilly, # 5 Exhibit C to Declaration of\n                Kathryn A. Reilly, # 6 Exhibit D to Declaration of Kathryn A. Reilly, # 7 Exhibit E to\n                Declaration of Kathryn A. Reilly)(Reilly, Kathryn) Modified on 12/6/2022 to withdraw\n                motion per [#31] Order. (sphil, ). (Entered: 11/14/2022)\n\n                                                 18\n\f11/14/2022   12 DECLARATION of Danielle S. Myers regarding MOTION to Consolidate Cases , for\n                Appointment as Lead Plaintiff MOTION to Appoint Counsel 10 by Movant California\n                Public Employees' Retirement System. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1 - PSLRA Notice, # 2\n                Exhibit 2 - Allegheny Notice, # 3 Exhibit 3 - Liu Notice, # 4 Exhibit 4 - Certification, # 5\n                Exhibit 5 - Estimate of losses, # 6 Exhibit 6 - Declaration of Matthew Jacobs)(Myers,\n                Danielle) (Entered: 11/14/2022)\n11/14/2022   13 WITHDRAWN MOTION to Consolidate Cases , MOTION for Appointment as Lead\n                Plaintiff and Lead Counsel by Movant Atef Zakhary. (Lieberman, Jeremy) Modified on\n                12/6/2022 to withdraw motion per [#28] Order. (sphil, ). (Entered: 11/14/2022)\n11/14/2022   14 DECLARATION of Jeremy A. Lieberman regarding MOTION to Consolidate Cases\n                MOTION for Appointment as Lead Plaintiff and Lead Counsel 13 by Movant Atef\n                Zakhary. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A - Damages Analysis, # 2 Exhibit B - Press Release,\n                # 3 Exhibit C - Certification, # 4 Exhibit D - Movant Declaration, # 5 Exhibit E - Firm\n                Resume, # 6 Proposed Order (PDF Only))(Lieberman, Jeremy) (Entered: 11/15/2022)\n11/14/2022   15 ADVISORY NOTICE OF NONCOMPLIANCE WITH COURT\n                RULES/PROCEDURES: re: 7 MOTION to Consolidate Cases , MOTION to Appoint\n                Lead Plaintiff MOTION to Appoint Counsel filed by attorneyAdam M. Apton. DO NOT\n                REFILE THE DOCUMENT. Action to take - counsel must submit a change of contact\n                request through the Manage my Account tab at the PACER website at\n                https://www.pacer.gov/, pursuant to D.C.COLO.LAttyR 5(c) and 3.5 of the Electronic\n                Case Filing Procedures (Civil cases).(Text Only Entry) (sphil, ) (Entered: 11/15/2022)\n11/17/2022   16 NOTICE of Entry of Appearance by Boris Feldman on behalf of All Defendants Attorney\n                Boris Feldman added to party David Glazer(pty:dft), Attorney Boris Feldman added to\n                party Alexander C. Karp(pty:dft), Attorney Boris Feldman added to party Palantir\n                Technologies Inc.(pty:dft), Attorney Boris Feldman added to party Shyam Sankar(pty:dft)\n                (Feldman, Boris) (Entered: 11/17/2022)\n11/17/2022   17 CORPORATE DISCLOSURE STATEMENT. (Feldman, Boris) (Entered: 11/17/2022)\n11/17/2022   18 NOTICE of Entry of Appearance by David Y. Livshiz on behalf of All Defendants\n                Attorney David Y. Livshiz added to party David Glazer(pty:dft), Attorney David Y.\n                Livshiz added to party Alexander C. Karp(pty:dft), Attorney David Y. Livshiz added to\n                party Palantir Technologies Inc.(pty:dft), Attorney David Y. Livshiz added to party Shyam\n                Sankar(pty:dft) (Livshiz, David) (Entered: 11/17/2022)\n11/21/2022   19 NOTICE of Entry of Appearance by Nicholas Angelo Caselli on behalf of All Defendants\n                Attorney Nicholas Angelo Caselli added to party David Glazer(pty:dft), Attorney\n                Nicholas Angelo Caselli added to party Alexander C. Karp(pty:dft), Attorney Nicholas\n                Angelo Caselli added to party Palantir Technologies Inc.(pty:dft), Attorney Nicholas\n                Angelo Caselli added to party Shyam Sankar(pty:dft) (Caselli, Nicholas) (Entered:\n                11/21/2022)\n11/28/2022   20 NOTICE re 6 MOTION to Consolidate Cases MOTION for Appointment as Lead\n                Plaintiff MOTION to Appoint Counsel Notice of Withdrawal of Motion by Movants Afa\n                Liv tjanstepensionsaktiebolag, Afa Sjuk tjanstepensionsaktiebolag, Afa Trygg\n                tjanstepensionsaktiebolag (Amjed, Naumon) (Entered: 11/28/2022)\n11/29/2022   21 ORDER withdrawing 6 MOTION to Consolidate Cases, MOTION for Appointment as\n                Lead Plaintiff, MOTION to Appoint Counsel by Movants Afa Sjuk\n                tjanstepensionsaktiebolag, Afa Liv tjanstepensionsaktiebolag, Afa Trygg\n                tjanstepensionsaktiebolag. The Motion at ECF No. 6 is withdrawn pursuant to the Notice\n                at ECF No. 20 . By Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney on 11/29/2022. Text Only Entry(cnssec.)\n                (Entered: 11/29/2022)\n                                                  19\n\f11/29/2022   22 NOTICE re 7 MOTION to Consolidate Cases , MOTION to Appoint Lead Plaintiff\n                MOTION to Appoint Counsel - Notice of Withdrawal of Motion by Movants Mohammad\n                Aboobakar, Michael Nagar (Apton, Adam) (Entered: 11/29/2022)\n11/29/2022   23 ORDER withdrawing 7 MOTION to Consolidate Cases, MOTION to Appoint Lead\n                Plaintiff, MOTION to Appoint Counsel by Movants Michael Nagar, Mohammad\n                Aboobakar. The Motion at ECF No. 7 is withdrawn pursuant to the Notice filed at ECF\n                No. 22 . By Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney on 11/29/2022. Text Only Entry(cnssec. )\n                (Entered: 11/29/2022)\n12/02/2022   24 NOTICE re 8 MOTION to Consolidate Cases MOTION for Appointment as Lead\n                Plaintiff MOTION to Appoint Counsel Notice of Non-Opposition to Competing Motions\n                for Appointment as Lead Plaintiff and Approval of Lead Counsel by Movants New\n                Mexico State Investment Council, Public Employees Retirement Association of New\n                Mexico, Public Employees' Retirement System of Mississippi (Glenn, Rusty) (Entered:\n                12/02/2022)\n12/02/2022   25 ORDER withdrawing 8 MOTION to Consolidate Cases, MOTION for Appointment as\n                Lead Plaintiff, MOTION to Appoint Counsel by Movants New Mexico State Investment\n                Council, Public Employees Retirement Association of New Mexico, Public Employees'\n                Retirement System of Mississippi. The Motion at ECF No. 8 is withdrawn pursuant to the\n                Notice filed at ECF No. 24 . By Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney on 12/2/2022. Text Only\n                Entry(cnssec. ) (Entered: 12/02/2022)\n12/02/2022   26 Joint MOTION for Order to grant Unopposed Motion Regarding Scheduling by\n                Defendants David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Palantir Technologies Inc., Shyam Sankar.\n                (Attachments: # 1 Proposed Order (PDF Only))(Feldman, Boris) (Entered: 12/02/2022)\n12/05/2022   27 NOTICE re 13 MOTION to Consolidate Cases MOTION for Appointment as Lead\n                Plaintiff and Lead Counsel Notice of Non-Opposition to Competing Motions for\n                Consolidation, Appointment as Lead Plaintiff, and Approval of Counsel by Movant Atef\n                Zakhary (Lieberman, Jeremy) (Entered: 12/05/2022)\n12/05/2022   28 ORDER withdrawing 13 MOTION to Consolidate Cases, MOTION for Appointment as\n                Lead Plaintiff and Lead Counsel. The Motion at ECF No. 13 is withdrawn pursuant to the\n                Notice filed at ECF No. 27 . By Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney on 12/5/2022. Text Only\n                Entry(cnssec.) (Entered: 12/05/2022)\n12/05/2022   29 NOTICE re 11 MOTION to Consolidate Cases Motion Of WenHong Hu For\n                Consolidation Of Related Actions, Appointment As Lead Plaintiff, And Approval Of\n                Selection Of Counsel (Notice of Non-Opposition of WenHong Hu to Competing Lead\n                Plaintiff Motions) by Plaintiff WenHong Hu (Reilly, Kathryn) (Entered: 12/05/2022)\n12/05/2022   30 NOTICE re 9 MOTION to Consolidate Cases MOTION for Appointment as Lead\n                Plaintiff MOTION to Appoint Counsel [Notice of Withdrawal of Motion] by Movants\n                Vitoldas Ciparis, Gagik Yepremyan, Lilit Yepremyan (Prongay, Robert) (Entered:\n                12/05/2022)\n12/05/2022   31 ORDER withdrawing 11 MOTION to Consolidate Cases Motion Of WenHong Hu For\n                Consolidation Of Related Actions, Appointment As Lead Plaintiff, And Approval Of\n                Selection Of Counsel. The Motion at ECF No. 11 is withdrawn pursuant to the Notice\n                filed at ECF No. 29 . By Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney on 12/5/2022. Text Only\n                Entry(cnssec.) (Entered: 12/05/2022)\n12/05/2022   32 ORDER withdrawing 9 MOTION to Consolidate Cases, MOTION for Appointment as\n                Lead Plaintiff, MOTION to Appoint Counsel. The Motion at ECF No. 9 is withdrawn\n\n                                                20\n\f                 pursuant to the Notice filed at ECF No. 30 . By Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney on\n                 12/5/2022. Text Only Entry(cnssec.) (Entered: 12/05/2022)\n12/05/2022   33 NOTICE re 10 MOTION to Consolidate Cases , for Appointment as Lead Plaintiff\n                MOTION to Appoint Counsel Notice of Unopposed Motion by Movant California Public\n                Employees' Retirement System (Myers, Danielle) (Entered: 12/05/2022)\n12/06/2022   34 ORDER Granting 10 California Public Employees' Retirement System's (\"CalPERS\")\n                Motion for Consolidation of Related Actions, Appointment as Lead Plaintiff, and\n                Approval of Lead Plaintiffs Selection of Lead Counsel. ORDERED that the Clerk of\n                Court will reassign Civil Actions 1:22-cv-02805-SKC and 1:22-cv-02893-PAB-KLM to\n                the undersigned as the Presiding District Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney, and to U.S.\n                Magistrate Judge S. Kato Crews in the referral role. All future filings in these\n                consolidated actions shall be made exclusively in the lead case number 22-cv-02384-\n                CNS-SKC. by Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney on 12/6/2022.(sphil, ) (Entered: 12/06/2022)\n12/06/2022   35 ORDER granting 26 Joint Unopposed Motion Regarding Scheduling. By Judge Charlotte\n                N. Sweeney on 12/6/2022.(cnssec. ) (Entered: 12/06/2022)\n12/08/2022   36 NOTICE of Entry of Appearance by Luke Orion Brooks on behalf of California Public\n                Employees' Retirement SystemAttorney Luke Orion Brooks added to party California\n                Public Employees' Retirement System(pty:mov) (Brooks, Luke) (Entered: 12/08/2022)\n12/09/2022   37 NOTICE of Entry of Appearance by Jeffrey Allen Berens on behalf of California Public\n                Employees' Retirement SystemAttorney Jeffrey Allen Berens added to party California\n                Public Employees' Retirement System(pty:mov) (Berens, Jeffrey) (Entered: 12/09/2022)\n12/09/2022   38 NOTICE of Entry of Appearance by J. Marco Janoski Gray on behalf of California Public\n                Employees' Retirement SystemAttorney J. Marco Janoski Gray added to party California\n                Public Employees' Retirement System(pty:mov) (Janoski Gray, J.) (Entered: 12/09/2022)\n12/09/2022   39 NOTICE of Entry of Appearance by Christopher Ryan Kinnon on behalf of California\n                Public Employees' Retirement SystemAttorney Christopher Ryan Kinnon added to party\n                California Public Employees' Retirement System(pty:mov) (Kinnon, Christopher)\n                (Entered: 12/09/2022)\n12/09/2022   40 NOTICE of Entry of Appearance by Sarah A. Fallon on behalf of California Public\n                Employees' Retirement SystemAttorney Sarah A. Fallon added to party California Public\n                Employees' Retirement System(pty:mov) (Fallon, Sarah) (Entered: 12/09/2022)\n12/09/2022   41 Joint MOTION for Order to Set Schedule for Consolidated Complaint and Response by\n                Movant California Public Employees' Retirement System. (Attachments: # 1 Proposed\n                Order (PDF Only))(Berens, Jeffrey) (Entered: 12/09/2022)\n12/12/2022   42 ORDER granting 41 Joint Motion for Order to Set Schedule for Consolidated Complaint\n                and Response. 1. Lead Plaintiff shall serve and file a consolidated complaint on or before\n                2/10/2023. 2. Defendants shall serve and file their response to the consolidated complaint\n                on or before 4/7/2023. 3. If Defendants move to dismiss the consolidated complaint, Lead\n                Plaintiff shall serve and file its brief in opposition to Defendants' motion to dismiss on or\n                before 6/19/2023, and Defendants shall serve and file their reply brief in support of their\n                motion to dismiss on or before 7/19/2023. By Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney on\n                12/12/2022. Text Only Entry(cnssec.) (Entered: 12/12/2022)\n12/13/2022   43 NOTICE of Entry of Appearance by Holly Stein Sollod on behalf of David Glazer,\n                Alexander C. Karp, Palantir Technologies Inc., Shyam SankarAttorney Holly Stein Sollod\n                added to party David Glazer(pty:dft), Attorney Holly Stein Sollod added to party\n                Alexander C. Karp(pty:dft), Attorney Holly Stein Sollod added to party Palantir\n\n                                                  21\n\f                 Technologies Inc.(pty:dft), Attorney Holly Stein Sollod added to party Shyam\n                 Sankar(pty:dft) (Sollod, Holly) (Entered: 12/13/2022)\n12/13/2022   44 NOTICE of Entry of Appearance by Darren Jay Robbins on behalf of California Public\n                Employees' Retirement SystemAttorney Darren Jay Robbins added to party California\n                Public Employees' Retirement System(pty:mov) (Robbins, Darren) (Entered: 12/13/2022)\n12/19/2022   45 NOTICE of Entry of Appearance by Kimberly J. Willis on behalf of All Defendants\n                Attorney Kimberly J. Willis added to party David Glazer(pty:dft), Attorney Kimberly J.\n                Willis added to party Alexander C. Karp(pty:dft), Attorney Kimberly J. Willis added to\n                party Palantir Technologies Inc.(pty:dft), Attorney Kimberly J. Willis added to party\n                Shyam Sankar(pty:dft) (Willis, Kimberly) (Entered: 12/19/2022)\n01/06/2023   46 NOTICE of Entry of Appearance by Erika L. Oliver on behalf of California Public\n                Employees' Retirement SystemAttorney Erika L. Oliver added to party California Public\n                Employees' Retirement System(pty:mov) (Oliver, Erika) (Entered: 01/06/2023)\n02/10/2023   47 AMENDED COMPLAINT Consolidated Class Action Complaint for Violations of the\n                Federal Securities Laws against Stephen Cohen, David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Kevin\n                Kawasaki, Palantir Technologies Inc., Shyam Sankar, Peter Thiel Attorney Luke Orion\n                Brooks added to party Shijun Liu, Individually and as Trustee of the Liu Family Trust\n                2019(pty:pla), filed by California Public Employees' Retirement System, Shijun Liu,\n                Individually and as Trustee of the Liu Family Trust 2019. (Attachments: # 1 Appendix 1)\n                (Brooks, Luke) (Entered: 02/10/2023)\n02/27/2023   48 MOTION for Order to Defer Briefing on Defendants' Motion to Dismiss by Consol\n                Defendants Stephen Cohen, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Spencer Rascoff,\n                Alexandra Schiff, Peter Thiel, Defendants David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Palantir\n                Technologies Inc., Shyam Sankar. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B)(Livshiz,\n                David) (Entered: 02/27/2023)\n02/27/2023   49 Unopposed MOTION for Order to Set Briefing Schedule on Defendants' Motion to Defer\n                Briefing by Consol Defendants Stephen Cohen, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore,\n                Spencer Rascoff, Alexandra Schiff, Peter Thiel, Defendants David Glazer, Alexander C.\n                Karp, Palantir Technologies Inc., Shyam Sankar. (Attachments: # 1 Proposed Order (PDF\n                Only))(Livshiz, David) (Entered: 02/27/2023)\n03/01/2023   50 ORDER granting 49 Unopposed Motion for Order to Set Briefing Schedule on\n                Defendants' Motion to Defer Briefing. The Plaintiff's Response to the Defendants' Motion\n                to Defer Briefing (ECF No. 48 ) is due by 3/15/2023. By Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney on\n                3/1/2023. Text Only Entry(cnssec. ) (Entered: 03/01/2023)\n03/08/2023   51 NOTICE of Entry of Appearance by Anna C. Van de Stouwe on behalf of All Defendants\n                Attorney Anna C. Van de Stouwe added to party David Glazer(pty:dft), Attorney Anna C.\n                Van de Stouwe added to party Alexander C. Karp(pty:dft), Attorney Anna C. Van de\n                Stouwe added to party Palantir Technologies Inc.(pty:dft), Attorney Anna C. Van de\n                Stouwe added to party Shyam Sankar(pty:dft) (Van de Stouwe, Anna) (Entered:\n                03/08/2023)\n03/15/2023   52 BRIEF in Opposition to 48 MOTION for Order to Defer Briefing on Defendants' Motion\n                to Dismiss filed by Movant California Public Employees' Retirement System, Plaintiff\n                Shijun Liu, Individually and as Trustee of the Liu Family Trust 2019. (Attachments: # 1\n                Declaration of Erika L. Oliver in Support of Plaintiffs' Opposition, # 2 Exhibit 1)(Oliver,\n                Erika) (Entered: 03/15/2023)\n03/16/2023   53 REPLY to Response to 48 MOTION for Order to Defer Briefing on Defendants' Motion\n                to Dismiss filed by Consol Defendants Stephen Cohen, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander\n                Moore, Spencer Rascoff, Alexandra Schiff, Peter Thiel, Defendants David Glazer,\n                                               22\n\f                 Alexander C. Karp, Palantir Technologies Inc., Shyam Sankar. (Feldman, Boris) (Entered:\n                 03/16/2023)\n03/21/2023   54 ORDER granting 48 MOTION for Order to Defer Briefing on Defendants' Motion to\n                Dismiss. Defendants' Opposed Motion to Defer Briefing on Defendants' Motion to\n                Dismiss Pending United States Supreme Court's Decision in Slack Technologies v. Pirani\n                (ECF No. 48 ) is GRANTED. The parties shall file a joint motion regarding a proposed\n                briefing schedule within seven days of the United States Supreme Court's issuance of its\n                decision in Slack Technologies v. Pirani. By Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney on 3/21/2023.\n                (cnssec.) (Entered: 03/21/2023)\n04/05/2023   55 REASSIGNMENT OF JUDGE. This action is reassigned to Judge Gordon P. Gallagher\n                upon his appointment as United States District Judge. Unless otherwise ordered, the dates\n                and times for all previously scheduled matters will be maintained. Judge Gallagher is\n                located in Courtroom 323 in the Wayne Aspinall Courthouse. His telephone number is\n                (970) 241-8932. All future pleadings should be designated as 22-cv-02384-GPG. (Text\n                only entry) (cmadr, ) (Entered: 04/05/2023)\n05/02/2023   56 REASSIGNING MAGISTRATE JUDGE. This action is reassigned to Magistrate Judge\n                Susan Prose upon her appointment. All future pleadings should reference Magistrate\n                Judge Prose at the end of the civil action number (such as 22-cv-02384-GPG-SP). Unless\n                otherwise ordered, the dates and times for all previously scheduled matters will be\n                maintained and will now be handled by Magistrate Judge Prose in Courtroom C-205. Her\n                chambers are located in Room C-254 of the Byron G. Rogers Courthouse. Her telephone\n                number is 303-335-2722. (Text only entry) (rvill, ) (Entered: 05/02/2023)\n06/08/2023   57 Joint MOTION for Leave to File Excess Pages Joint Motion for Page Enlargement and\n                Briefing Schedule for Complaint and Motion to Dismiss by Movant California Public\n                Employees' Retirement System, Plaintiff Shijun Liu, Individually and as Trustee of the\n                Liu Family Trust 2019. (Attachments: # 1 Proposed Order (PDF Only))(Oliver, Erika)\n                (Entered: 06/08/2023)\n06/09/2023   58 ORDER granting 57 Motion for Leave to File Excess Pages: The Plaintiffs' Consolidated\n                Amended Complaint, if any, shall be filed by June 29, 2023. That filing shall not exceed\n                the length of the current Amended Complaint (D. 47). Any motion to dismiss shall be\n                filed by August 18, 2023 and shall not exceed 55 pages. Any response to such motion\n                shall be filed by October 13, 2023 and shall not exceed 55 pages. Any reply shall be filed\n                by November 17, 2023 and shall not exceed 25 pages. By District Judge Gordon P\n                Gallagher on 6/9/23. Text Only Entry(msklc2, ) (Entered: 06/09/2023)\n06/29/2023   59 AMENDED COMPLAINT Amended Consolidated Class Action Complaint for\n                Violations of the Federal Securities Laws against Stephen Cohen, David Glazer,\n                Alexander C. Karp, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Palantir Technologies Inc.,\n                Spencer Rascoff, Shyam Sankar, Alexandra Schiff, Peter Thiel, filed by Shijun Liu,\n                Individually and as Trustee of the Liu Family Trust 2019, California Public Employees'\n                Retirement System. (Attachments: # 1 Appendix 1)(Brooks, Luke) (Entered: 06/29/2023)\n06/29/2023   60 NOTICE of Filing Amended Pleading re 59 Amended Complaint, by Movant California\n                Public Employees' Retirement System, Plaintiff Shijun Liu, Individually and as Trustee of\n                the Liu Family Trust 2019 (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A)(Brooks, Luke) (Entered:\n                06/29/2023)\n08/02/2023   61 MOTION to Withdraw as Attorney by Defendants David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp,\n                Palantir Technologies Inc., Shyam Sankar. (Attachments: # 1 Proposed Order (PDF\n                Only))(Sollod, Holly) (Entered: 08/02/2023)\n08/02/2023   62 MEMORANDUM regarding 61 MOTION to Withdraw as Attorney filed by Palantir\n                Technologies Inc., Shyam Sankar, Alexander C. Karp, David Glazer. Motion referred to\n                                              23\n\f                 Magistrate Judge Susan B. Prose, by District Judge Gordon P Gallagher on 8/2/2023. Text\n                 Only Entry (schap, ) (Entered: 08/02/2023)\n08/03/2023   63 MINUTE ORDER by Magistrate Judge Susan Prose on 8/3/2023, GRANTING 61\n                Motion to Withdraw as Attorney. Attorney Anna C. Van de Stouwe terminated. Text Only\n                Entry (splc3) (Entered: 08/03/2023)\n08/18/2023   64 NOTICE of Entry of Appearance by Sam D. Starritt on behalf of David Glazer, Alexander\n                C. Karp, Palantir Technologies Inc., Shyam SankarAttorney Sam D. Starritt added to\n                party David Glazer(pty:dft), Attorney Sam D. Starritt added to party Alexander C.\n                Karp(pty:dft), Attorney Sam D. Starritt added to party Palantir Technologies Inc.(pty:dft),\n                Attorney Sam D. Starritt added to party Shyam Sankar(pty:dft) (Starritt, Sam) (Entered:\n                08/18/2023)\n08/18/2023   65 NOTICE of Entry of Appearance by Nathan A. Keever on behalf of All Defendants\n                Attorney Nathan A. Keever added to party David Glazer(pty:dft), Attorney Nathan A.\n                Keever added to party Alexander C. Karp(pty:dft), Attorney Nathan A. Keever added to\n                party Palantir Technologies Inc.(pty:dft), Attorney Nathan A. Keever added to party\n                Shyam Sankar(pty:dft) (Keever, Nathan) (Entered: 08/18/2023)\n08/18/2023   66 NOTICE (DEFENDANTS REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE IN SUPPORT OF\n                DEFENDANTS MOTION TO DISMISS) by Consol Defendants Stephen Cohen, Kevin\n                Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Spencer Rascoff, Alexandra Schiff, Peter Thiel, Defendants\n                David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Palantir Technologies Inc., Shyam Sankar (Livshiz,\n                David) (Entered: 08/19/2023)\n08/19/2023   67 MOTION to Dismiss Plaintiffs' Amended Complaint by Consol Defendants Stephen\n                Cohen, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Spencer Rascoff, Alexandra Schiff, Peter\n                Thiel, Defendants David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Palantir Technologies Inc., Shyam\n                Sankar. (Livshiz, David) (Entered: 08/19/2023)\n08/19/2023   68 DECLARATION of Nicholas A. Caselli regarding MOTION to Dismiss Plaintiffs'\n                Amended Complaint 67 , Notice (Other), 66 by Consol Defendants Stephen Cohen, Kevin\n                Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Spencer Rascoff, Alexandra Schiff, Peter Thiel, Defendants\n                David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Palantir Technologies Inc., Shyam Sankar.\n                (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5, # 6\n                Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit 7, # 8 Exhibit 8, # 9 Exhibit 9, # 10 Exhibit 10, # 11 Exhibit 11, #\n                12 Exhibit 12, # 13 Exhibit 13, # 14 Exhibit 14, # 15 Exhibit 15, # 16 Exhibit 16, # 17\n                Exhibit 17, # 18 Exhibit 18, # 19 Exhibit 19, # 20 Exhibit 20, # 21 Exhibit 21, # 22\n                Exhibit 22, # 23 Exhibit 23, # 24 Exhibit 24, # 25 Exhibit 25, # 26 Exhibit 26, # 27\n                Exhibit 27, # 28 Exhibit 28, # 29 Exhibit 29, # 30 Exhibit 30, # 31 Exhibit 31, # 32\n                Exhibit 32, # 33 Exhibit 33, # 34 Exhibit 34, # 35 Exhibit 35, # 36 Exhibit 36, # 37\n                Exhibit 37, # 38 Exhibit 38, # 39 Exhibit 39, # 40 Exhibit 40, # 41 Exhibit 41, # 42\n                Exhibit 42, # 43 Exhibit 43, # 44 Exhibit 44, # 45 Exhibit 45, # 46 Exhibit 46, # 47\n                Exhibit 47, # 48 Exhibit 48, # 49 Exhibit 49, # 50 Exhibit 50)(Caselli, Nicholas) (Entered:\n                08/19/2023)\n08/22/2023   69 CONSENT to Jurisdiction of Magistrate Judge by Consol Defendants Stephen Cohen,\n                Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Spencer Rascoff, Alexandra Schiff, Peter Thiel,\n                Defendants David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Palantir Technologies Inc., Shyam Sankar\n                All parties do not consent.. (Livshiz, David) (Entered: 08/22/2023)\n10/13/2023   70 BRIEF in Opposition to 67 MOTION to Dismiss Plaintiffs' Amended Complaint filed by\n                Movant California Public Employees' Retirement System, Plaintiff Shijun Liu,\n                Individually and as Trustee of the Liu Family Trust 2019. (Attachments: # 1 Appendix 1 -\n                Comparison of Alleged Misstatements)(Brooks, Luke) (Entered: 10/13/2023)\n\n                                                  24\n\f10/13/2023   71 MOTION to Strike 68 Declaration,,,,, 67 MOTION to Dismiss Plaintiffs' Amended\n                Complaint, 66 Notice (Other), by Movant California Public Employees' Retirement\n                System, Plaintiff Shijun Liu, Individually and as Trustee of the Liu Family Trust 2019.\n                (Attachments: # 1 Proposed Order (PDF Only))(Janoski Gray, J.) (Entered: 10/13/2023)\n10/13/2023   72 RESPONSE to 66 Notice (Other), Plaintiffs' Response to Defendants' Request for\n                Judicial Notice by Movant California Public Employees' Retirement System, Plaintiff\n                Shijun Liu, Individually and as Trustee of the Liu Family Trust 2019. (Janoski Gray, J.)\n                (Entered: 10/13/2023)\n11/03/2023   73 BRIEF in Opposition to 71 MOTION to Strike 68 Declaration,,,,, 67 MOTION to\n                Dismiss Plaintiffs' Amended Complaint, 66 Notice (Other), filed by Consol Defendants\n                Stephen Cohen, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Spencer Rascoff, Alexandra Schiff,\n                Peter Thiel, Defendants David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Palantir Technologies Inc.,\n                Shyam Sankar. (Livshiz, David) (Entered: 11/03/2023)\n11/17/2023   74 REPLY to Response to 67 MOTION to Dismiss Plaintiffs' Amended Complaint filed by\n                Consol Defendants Stephen Cohen, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Spencer Rascoff,\n                Alexandra Schiff, Peter Thiel, Defendants David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Palantir\n                Technologies Inc., Shyam Sankar. (Attachments: # 1 Reply Annex A, # 2 Amended\n                Annex E)(Livshiz, David) (Entered: 11/17/2023)\n11/17/2023   75 DECLARATION of Nicholas A. Caselli regarding Reply to Response to Motion, 74 by\n                Consol Defendants Stephen Cohen, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Spencer Rascoff,\n                Alexandra Schiff, Peter Thiel, Defendants David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Palantir\n                Technologies Inc., Shyam Sankar. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 51, # 2 Exhibit 52, # 3\n                Exhibit 53, # 4 Exhibit 54, # 5 Exhibit 55)(Caselli, Nicholas) (Entered: 11/17/2023)\n11/17/2023   76 RESPONSE to 72 Response, in Further Support of Defendants' Request for Judicial\n                Notice by Consol Defendants Stephen Cohen, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore,\n                Spencer Rascoff, Alexandra Schiff, Peter Thiel, Defendants David Glazer, Alexander C.\n                Karp, Palantir Technologies Inc., Shyam Sankar. (Livshiz, David) (Entered: 11/17/2023)\n11/17/2023   77 REPLY to Response to 71 MOTION to Strike 68 Declaration,,,,, 67 MOTION to Dismiss\n                Plaintiffs' Amended Complaint, 66 Notice (Other), filed by Movant California Public\n                Employees' Retirement System, Plaintiff Shijun Liu, Individually and as Trustee of the\n                Liu Family Trust 2019. (Janoski Gray, J.) (Entered: 11/17/2023)\n11/28/2023   78 NOTICE re 71 MOTION to Strike 68 Declaration,,,,, 67 MOTION to Dismiss Plaintiffs'\n                Amended Complaint, 66 Notice (Other), , 75 Declaration, 77 Reply to Response to\n                Motion, 74 Reply to Response to Motion, Plaintiffs' Notice of Additional Materials\n                Subject to Plaintiffs' Motion to Strike by Movant California Public Employees'\n                Retirement System, Plaintiff Shijun Liu, Individually and as Trustee of the Liu Family\n                Trust 2019 (Janoski Gray, J.) (Entered: 11/28/2023)\n12/01/2023   79 RESPONSE to 78 Notice (Other),, Defendants' Response to Plaintiffs' Objection Seeking\n                to Strike Additional Documents by Consol Defendants Stephen Cohen, Kevin Kawasaki,\n                Alexander Moore, Spencer Rascoff, Alexandra Schiff, Peter Thiel, Defendants David\n                Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Palantir Technologies Inc., Shyam Sankar. (Livshiz, David)\n                (Entered: 12/01/2023)\n02/22/2024   80 NOTICE of Change of Address/Contact Information by David Y. Livshiz (Livshiz,\n                David) (Entered: 02/22/2024)\n02/22/2024   81 NOTICE of Change of Address/Contact Information by Nicholas Angelo Caselli (Caselli,\n                Nicholas) (Entered: 02/22/2024)\n\n                                                 25\n\f03/31/2024   82 ORDER granting 67 Motion to Dismiss. The matter is dismissed without prejudice. No\n                later than April 5, 2024, the parties SHALL jointly contact Chambers to set a status\n                conference as set forth in the Order. by District Judge Gordon P Gallagher on 3/31/24.\n                Text Only Entry(Gallagher, Gordon) (Entered: 03/31/2024)\n03/31/2024   83 ORDER finding as moot 71 Motion to Strike 71 MOTION to Strike 68 Declaration,,,,, 67\n                MOTION to Dismiss Plaintiffs' Amended Complaint, 66 Notice (Other), . Due to the\n                Order dismissing the Complaint without prejudice, both this pleading and the Request for\n                Judicial Notice (D. 66) are moot. by District Judge Gordon P Gallagher on 3/31/24. Text\n                Only Entry(Gallagher, Gordon) (Entered: 03/31/2024)\n04/04/2024   84 ORDER: VTC Status Conference set for 4/24/2024 from 2:00 - 3:00 PM in Room 323\n                (Grand Junction) before District Judge Gordon P Gallagher. For further assistance with\n                the VTC link or instructions, parties may contact Donald_Clement@cod.uscourts.gov. By\n                District Judge Gordon P Gallagher on April 4, 2024. Text Only Entry (gpglc3, ) (Entered:\n                04/04/2024)\n04/08/2024   85 MOTION to Withdraw as Attorney by Defendants David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp,\n                Palantir Technologies Inc., Shyam Sankar. (Attachments: # 1 Proposed Order (PDF\n                Only))(Sollod, Holly) (Entered: 04/08/2024)\n04/08/2024   86 MEMORANDUM regarding 85 MOTION to Withdraw as Attorney filed by Palantir\n                Technologies Inc., Shyam Sankar, Alexander C. Karp, David Glazer. Motion referred to\n                Magistrate Judge Susan Prose, by District Judge Gordon P Gallagher on 4/8/2024. Text\n                Only Entry (schap, ) (Entered: 04/08/2024)\n04/08/2024   87 MOTION to Withdraw as Attorney by Defendants David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp,\n                Palantir Technologies Inc., Shyam Sankar. (Attachments: # 1 Proposed Order (PDF\n                Only))(Willis, Kimberly) (Entered: 04/08/2024)\n04/08/2024   88 ORDER by Magistrate Judge Susan Prose on 4/8/2024, granting 85 Motion to Withdraw\n                as Attorney. Attorney Holly Stein Sollod terminated as counsel of record for Defendants,\n                who continue to be represented by Messers. Sterritt and Kever and who shall send a copy\n                of this order to the Defendants. The Clerk's office is requested to remove Ms. Stein Sollod\n                from the notice list. Text Only Entry (sbplc1) (Entered: 04/08/2024)\n04/08/2024   89 ORDER by Magistrate Judge Susan Prose on 4/8/2024, granting 87 Motion to Withdraw\n                as Attorney. Attorney Kimberly J. Willis terminated as counsel of record for Defendants,\n                who continue to be represented by Messers. Sterritt and Kever as local counsel (and by\n                several others as lead counsel; the same is true for ECF No. 88, though not noted therein).\n                Continuing counsel for Defendants shall send a copy of this order to the Defendants. The\n                Clerk's office is requested to remove Ms. Willis from the notice list. Text Only Entry\n                (sbplc1) (Entered: 04/08/2024)\n04/24/2024   90 MINUTE ENTRY for Status Conference proceeding held before District Judge Gordon P\n                Gallagher on 4/24/2024. That on or before May 24, 2024, the Plaintiffs shall file an\n                amended complaint that is no more than 100 pages and associated briefing. Court\n                Reporter: Erin Valenti. (dclem) (Entered: 04/24/2024)\n04/29/2024   91 TRANSCRIPT of status conference held on 4/24/24 before Judge Gallagher. Pages: 1-14.\n                NOTICE - REDACTION OF TRANSCRIPTS: Within seven calendar days of this\n                filing, each party shall inform the Court, by filing a Notice of Intent to Redact, of the\n                party's intent to redact personal identifiers from the electronic transcript of the\n                court proceeding. If a Notice of Intent to Redact is not filed within the allotted time,\n                this transcript will be made electronically available after 90 days. Please see the\n                Notice of Electronic Availability of Transcripts document at www.cod.uscourts.gov.\n                Transcript may only be viewed at the court's public terminal or purchased through the\n                                                26\n\f                  Court Reporter/Transcriber prior to the 90 day deadline for electronic posting on PACER.\n                  (evale, ) (Entered: 04/29/2024)\n05/24/2024    92 AMENDED COMPLAINT Second Amended Consolidated Class Action Complaint for\n                 Violations of the Federal Securities Laws against Stephen Cohen, David Glazer,\n                 Alexander C. Karp, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Palantir Technologies Inc.,\n                 Spencer Rascoff, Shyam Sankar, Alexandra Schiff, Peter Thiel, filed by Shijun Liu,\n                 Individually and as Trustee of the Liu Family Trust 2019, California Public Employees'\n                 Retirement System. (Attachments: # 1 Appendix 1, # 2 Appendix 2)(Brooks, Luke)\n                 (Entered: 05/24/2024)\n05/24/2024    93 NOTICE of Filing Amended Pleading re 92 Amended Complaint, by Movant California\n                 Public Employees' Retirement System, Plaintiff Shijun Liu, Individually and as Trustee of\n                 the Liu Family Trust 2019 (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A)(Brooks, Luke) (Entered:\n                 05/24/2024)\n05/24/2024    94 MOTION to Lift Stay Plaintiffs' Motion for a Partial Lift of the PSLRA Discovery Stay\n                 by Movant California Public Employees' Retirement System, Plaintiff Shijun Liu,\n                 Individually and as Trustee of the Liu Family Trust 2019. (Attachments: # 1 Appendix in\n                 Support of Plaintiff's Motion for a Partial Lift of the PSLRA Discovery Stay, # 2\n                 Proposed Order (PDF Only))(Brooks, Luke) (Entered: 05/24/2024)\n05/24/2024    95 RESTRICTED DOCUMENT - Level 1: Plaintiffs' Unopposed Motion to Restrict Public\n                 Access by Movant California Public Employees' Retirement System, Plaintiff Shijun Liu,\n                 Individually and as Trustee of the Liu Family Trust 2019.. (Attachments: # 1 Appendix in\n                 Support of Plaintiffs' Motion for a Partial Lift of the PSLRA Discovery Stay, # 2\n                 Proposed Order (PDF Only))(Oliver, Erika) (Entered: 05/24/2024)\n05/24/2024    96 Plaintiffs' Unopposed Motion to Restrict Public Access by Movant California Public\n                 Employees' Retirement System, Plaintiff Shijun Liu, Individually and as Trustee of the\n                 Liu Family Trust 2019. [Public Entry to the 95 Restricted Document] Text Only Entry.\n                 (schap, ) (Entered: 05/28/2024)\n05/28/2024    97 MEMORANDUM regarding 96 Plaintiffs' Unopposed Motion to Restrict Public Access\n                 filed by California Public Employees' Retirement System, Shujun Liu. Motion referred to\n                 Magistrate Judge Susan Prose by District Judge Gordon P Gallagher on 5/28/2024. Text\n                 Only Entry (schap, ) (Entered: 05/28/2024)\n05/28/2024    98 ORDER by Magistrate Judge Susan Prose on 05/28/2024, granting 96 Unopposed Motion\n                 for Leave to Restrict 96 . For the reasons stated in the motions, the court is satisfied that\n                 the requirements of Local Rule 7.2 are met. The Restricted Information in the Declaration\n                 of Professor Joshua Mitts, Ph.D. shall be and remain restricted at Level One. This ruling,\n                 however, does not apply to how such information will be handled in hearings, orders, or\n                 trial. Text Only Entry (sbplct2) (Entered: 05/28/2024)\n06/05/2024    99 NOTICE of Change of Address/Contact Information by Sam D. Starritt (Starritt, Sam)\n                 (Entered: 06/05/2024)\n06/07/2024   100 Joint MOTION for Leave to File Excess Pages Joint Motion for Page Enlargement and\n                 Briefing Schedule for Defendants Motion to Dismiss the Second Amended Complaint and\n                 Plaintiffs Motion for a Partial Lift of the PSLRA Discovery Stay by Consol Defendants\n                 Stephen Cohen, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Spencer Rascoff, Alexandra Schiff,\n                 Peter Thiel, Defendants David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Palantir Technologies Inc.,\n                 Shyam Sankar. (Attachments: # 1 Proposed Order (PDF Only))(Livshiz, David) (Entered:\n                 06/07/2024)\n06/11/2024   101 ORDER granting 100 Joint Motion for Page Enlargement and Briefing Schedule for\n                 Defendants' Motion to Dismiss the Second Amended Complaint and Plaintiffs' Motion for\n                                                27\n\f                  a Partial Lift of the PSLRA Discovery Stay. By District Judge Gordon P Gallagher on\n                  6/11/2024. (schap, ) (Entered: 06/11/2024)\n07/25/2024   102 MOTION to Dismiss Plaintiffs' Second Amended Complaint by Consol Defendants\n                 Stephen Cohen, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Spencer Rascoff, Alexandra Schiff,\n                 Peter Thiel, Defendants David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Palantir Technologies Inc.,\n                 Shyam Sankar. (Attachments: # 1 Appendix Volume I of III, # 2 Appendix Volume II of\n                 III, # 3 Appendix Volume III of III)(Livshiz, David) (Entered: 07/25/2024)\n07/25/2024   103 NOTICE of Request for Judicial Notice and Notice of Documents Incorporated by\n                 Reference in Support of Defendants' Motion to Dismiss by Consol Defendants Stephen\n                 Cohen, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Spencer Rascoff, Alexandra Schiff, Peter\n                 Thiel, Defendants David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Palantir Technologies Inc., Shyam\n                 Sankar (Livshiz, David) (Entered: 07/25/2024)\n07/25/2024   104 NOTICE of Entry of Appearance by Michael David Celio on behalf of Stephen Cohen,\n                 David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Palantir\n                 Technologies Inc., Spencer Rascoff, Shyam Sankar, Alexandra Schiff, Peter\n                 ThielAttorney Michael David Celio added to party Stephen Cohen(pty:condft), Attorney\n                 Michael David Celio added to party David Glazer(pty:dft), Attorney Michael David Celio\n                 added to party Alexander C. Karp(pty:dft), Attorney Michael David Celio added to party\n                 Kevin Kawasaki(pty:condft), Attorney Michael David Celio added to party Alexander\n                 Moore(pty:condft), Attorney Michael David Celio added to party Palantir Technologies\n                 Inc.(pty:dft), Attorney Michael David Celio added to party Spencer Rascoff(pty:condft),\n                 Attorney Michael David Celio added to party Shyam Sankar(pty:dft), Attorney Michael\n                 David Celio added to party Alexandra Schiff(pty:condft), Attorney Michael David Celio\n                 added to party Peter Thiel(pty:condft) (Celio, Michael) (Entered: 07/25/2024)\n07/25/2024   105 NOTICE of Entry of Appearance by Matthew S. Kahn on behalf of Stephen Cohen,\n                 David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Palantir\n                 Technologies Inc., Spencer Rascoff, Shyam Sankar, Alexandra Schiff, Peter\n                 ThielAttorney Matthew S. Kahn added to party Stephen Cohen(pty:condft), Attorney\n                 Matthew S. Kahn added to party David Glazer(pty:dft), Attorney Matthew S. Kahn added\n                 to party Alexander C. Karp(pty:dft), Attorney Matthew S. Kahn added to party Kevin\n                 Kawasaki(pty:condft), Attorney Matthew S. Kahn added to party Alexander\n                 Moore(pty:condft), Attorney Matthew S. Kahn added to party Palantir Technologies Inc.\n                 (pty:dft), Attorney Matthew S. Kahn added to party Spencer Rascoff(pty:condft),\n                 Attorney Matthew S. Kahn added to party Shyam Sankar(pty:dft), Attorney Matthew S.\n                 Kahn added to party Alexandra Schiff(pty:condft), Attorney Matthew S. Kahn added to\n                 party Peter Thiel(pty:condft) (Kahn, Matthew) (Entered: 07/25/2024)\n07/25/2024   106 NOTICE of Entry of Appearance by Wesley Sze on behalf of Stephen Cohen, David\n                 Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Palantir Technologies\n                 Inc., Spencer Rascoff, Shyam Sankar, Alexandra Schiff, Peter ThielAttorney Wesley Sze\n                 added to party Stephen Cohen(pty:condft), Attorney Wesley Sze added to party David\n                 Glazer(pty:dft), Attorney Wesley Sze added to party Alexander C. Karp(pty:dft), Attorney\n                 Wesley Sze added to party Kevin Kawasaki(pty:condft), Attorney Wesley Sze added to\n                 party Alexander Moore(pty:condft), Attorney Wesley Sze added to party Palantir\n                 Technologies Inc.(pty:dft), Attorney Wesley Sze added to party Spencer\n                 Rascoff(pty:condft), Attorney Wesley Sze added to party Shyam Sankar(pty:dft), Attorney\n                 Wesley Sze added to party Alexandra Schiff(pty:condft), Attorney Wesley Sze added to\n                 party Peter Thiel(pty:condft) (Sze, Wesley) (Entered: 07/25/2024)\n07/25/2024   107 BRIEF in Opposition to 94 MOTION to Lift Stay Plaintiffs' Motion for a Partial Lift of\n                 the PSLRA Discovery Stay filed by Consol Defendants Stephen Cohen, Kevin Kawasaki,\n                 Alexander Moore, Spencer Rascoff, Alexandra Schiff, Peter Thiel, Defendants David\n                                                28\n\f                  Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Palantir Technologies Inc., Shyam Sankar. (Attachments: # 1\n                  Appendix in Support of Opposition)(Celio, Michael) (Entered: 07/25/2024)\n07/30/2024   108 MOTION to Withdraw as Attorney by Defendants David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp,\n                 Palantir Technologies Inc., Shyam Sankar. (Keever, Nathan) (Entered: 07/30/2024)\n07/30/2024   109 MEMORANDUM regarding 108 MOTION to Withdraw as Attorney filed by Palantir\n                 Technologies Inc., Shyam Sankar, Alexander C. Karp, David Glazer. Motion referred to\n                 Magistrate Judge Susan Prose by District Judge Gordon P Gallagher on 7/30/2024. Text\n                 Only Entry (schap, ) (Entered: 07/30/2024)\n07/30/2024   110 ORDER by Magistrate Judge Susan Prose on 07/30/2024, granting 108 Motion to\n                 Withdraw as Attorney. Attorney Nathan A. Keever terminated as counsel of record in this\n                 case. Remaining counsel of record must provide the client(s) of withdrawing attorney a\n                 copy of the motion to withdraw pursuant to D.C.COLO.LAttyR 5. Text Only Entry\n                 (sbplct2) (Entered: 07/30/2024)\n09/16/2024   111 REPLY to Response to 94 MOTION to Lift Stay Plaintiffs' Motion for a Partial Lift of\n                 the PSLRA Discovery Stay filed by Movant California Public Employees' Retirement\n                 System, Plaintiff Shijun Liu, Individually and as Trustee of the Liu Family Trust 2019.\n                 (Attachments: # 1 Appendix in Support of Plaintiffs' Motion for a Partial Lift of the\n                 PSLRA Discovery Stay - Volume II)(Brooks, Luke) (Entered: 09/16/2024)\n09/16/2024   112 RESPONSE to 102 MOTION to Dismiss Plaintiffs' Second Amended Complaint filed by\n                 Movant California Public Employees' Retirement System, Plaintiff Shijun Liu,\n                 Individually and as Trustee of the Liu Family Trust 2019. (Brooks, Luke) (Entered:\n                 09/16/2024)\n09/16/2024   113 RESPONSE to 103 Notice (Other), Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendants' Request for\n                 Judicial Notice by Movant California Public Employees' Retirement System, Plaintiff\n                 Shijun Liu, Individually and as Trustee of the Liu Family Trust 2019. (Brooks, Luke)\n                 (Entered: 09/16/2024)\n10/16/2024   114 NOTICE of Change of Firm Name by Consol Defendants Stephen Cohen, Kevin\n                 Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Spencer Rascoff, Alexandra Schiff, Peter Thiel, Defendants\n                 David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp, Palantir Technologies Inc., Shyam Sankar (Livshiz,\n                 David) (Entered: 10/16/2024)\n10/16/2024   115 REPLY to Response to 102 MOTION to Dismiss Plaintiffs' Second Amended Complaint\n                 filed by Consol Defendants Stephen Cohen, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Spencer\n                 Rascoff, Alexandra Schiff, Peter Thiel, Defendants David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp,\n                 Palantir Technologies Inc., Shyam Sankar. (Attachments: # 1 Reply Appendix)(Livshiz,\n                 David) (Entered: 10/16/2024)\n10/16/2024   116 REPLY to 113 Response, in Further Support of Defendants' Request for Judicial Notice\n                 by Consol Defendants Stephen Cohen, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Spencer\n                 Rascoff, Alexandra Schiff, Peter Thiel, Defendants David Glazer, Alexander C. Karp,\n                 Palantir Technologies Inc., Shyam Sankar. (Livshiz, David) (Entered: 10/16/2024)\n10/24/2024   117 OBJECTIONS to 115 Reply to Response to Motion, Plaintiffs' Objection to Additional\n                 Materials Improperly Submitted With Defendants' Reply in Support of Their Motion to\n                 Dismiss Plaintiffs' Second Amended Complaint by Movant California Public Employees'\n                 Retirement System, Plaintiff Shijun Liu, Individually and as Trustee of the Liu Family\n                 Trust 2019. (Brooks, Luke) (Entered: 10/24/2024)\n11/01/2024   118 RESPONSE to 117 Objections, RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS OBJECTION TO\n                 MATERIALS SUBMITTED WITH DEFENDANTS REPLY IN SUPPORT OF THEIR\n                 MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFFS SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT by Consol\n                                             29\n\f                  Defendants Stephen Cohen, Peter Thiel, William Ho, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore,\n                  Spencer Rascoff, Alexandra Schiff, Defendants Palantir Technologies Inc., Alexander C.\n                  Karp, David Glazer, Shyam SankarAttorney Sam D. Starritt added to party, Attorney Sam\n                  D. Starritt added to party, Attorney Sam D. Starritt added to party, Attorney Sam D.\n                  Starritt added to party, Attorney Sam D. Starritt added to party, Attorney Sam D. Starritt\n                  added to party, Attorney Sam D. Starritt added to party. (Starritt, Sam) (Entered:\n                  11/01/2024)\n02/10/2025   119 NOTICE of Supplemental Authorities by Consol Defendants Stephen Cohen, Peter Thiel,\n                 William Ho, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Spencer Rascoff, Alexandra Schiff,\n                 Defendants Palantir Technologies Inc., Alexander C. Karp, David Glazer (Starritt, Sam)\n                 (Entered: 02/10/2025)\n02/10/2025   120 NOTICE of Supplemental Authorities Exhibit A - Supplemental Authority re: 119 Notice\n                 of Supplemental Authorities, by Consol Defendants Stephen Cohen, Peter Thiel, William\n                 Ho, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander Moore, Spencer Rascoff, Alexandra Schiff, Consol\n                 Plaintiff Shujun Liu, Defendants Palantir Technologies Inc., Alexander C. Karp, David\n                 Glazer (Starritt, Sam) (Entered: 02/10/2025)\n02/13/2025   121 RESPONSE to 119 Notice of Supplemental Authorities, by Plaintiff Shijun Liu,\n                 Individually and as Trustee of the Liu Family Trust 2019, Movant California Public\n                 Employees' Retirement System. (Brooks, Luke) (Entered: 02/13/2025)\n04/03/2025   122 NOTICE of Lead Plaintiffs' Attempt to Circumvent the PSLRA's Mandatory Discovery\n                 Stay by Consol Defendants Stephen Cohen, Peter Thiel, Kevin Kawasaki, Alexander\n                 Moore, Spencer Rascoff, Alexandra Schiff, Defendants Palantir Technologies Inc.,\n                 Alexander C. Karp, David Glazer, Shyam Sankar (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A - Notice of\n                 Appearance, # 2 Exhibit B - Notice of Challenge to Confidential Treatment, # 3 Exhibit C\n                 - Motion for Continued Confidential Treatment)(Livshiz, David) (Entered: 04/03/2025)\n04/04/2025   123 ORDER denying 94 Motion to Lift Stay and granting 102 Motion to Dismiss by District\n                 Judge Gordon P Gallagher on 04/04/2025.(dclem) (Entered: 04/04/2025)\n04/04/2025   124 FINAL JUDGMENT in favor of Palantir Technologies Inc., Alexander C. Karp, David\n                 Glazer, Shyam Sankar against Minchie Galot Cupat, Shijun Liu, Individually and as\n                 Trustee of the Liu Family Trust 2019, WenHong Hu. Entered by the Clerk on 04/04/2025.\n                 (dclem) (Entered: 04/04/2025)\n05/02/2025   125 NOTICE OF APPEAL as to 124 Judgment, by Plaintiff Shijun Liu, Individually and as\n                 Trustee of the Liu Family Trust 2019, Movant California Public Employees' Retirement\n                 System (Filing fee $ 605, Receipt Number ACODC-10316011) (Brooks, Luke) (Entered:\n                 05/02/2025)\n05/05/2025   126 LETTER Transmitting Notice of Appeal to all counsel advising of the transmittal of the\n                 125 Notice of Appeal, filed by California Public Employees' Retirement System, Shijun\n                 Liu, Individually and as Trustee of the Liu Family Trust 2019 to the U.S. Court of\n                 Appeals. ( Retained Counsel, Fee paid,) (Attachments: # 1 Preliminary Record)(sphil, )\n                 (Entered: 05/05/2025)\n05/06/2025   127 USCA Case Number 25-1178 for 125 Notice of Appeal, filed by California Public\n                 Employees' Retirement System, Shijun Liu, Individually and as Trustee of the Liu Family\n                 Trust 2019. (sphil, ) (Entered: 05/06/2025)\n05/20/2025   128 TRANSCRIPT ORDER FORM re 125 Notice of Appeal, by Plaintiff Shijun Liu,\n                 Individually and as Trustee of the Liu Family Trust 2019, Movant California Public\n                 Employees' Retirement System (Brooks, Luke) (Entered: 05/20/2025)\n\n\n                                                  30\n\f05/28/2025   129 LETTER TO USCA and all counsel certifying the record is complete as to 125 Notice of\n                 Appeal, filed by California Public Employees' Retirement System, Shijun Liu,\n                 Individually and as Trustee of the Liu Family Trust 2019. A transcript order form was\n                 filed stating that a transcript is not necessary. ( Appeal No. 25-1178) Text Only Entry\n                 (sphil, ) (Entered: 05/28/2025)\n\n\n\n                                           PACER Service Center\n                                              Transaction Receipt\n                                               07/24/2025 11:48:29\n                      PACER\n                                     Lobrooks9456 Client Code:\n                      Login:\n                                     Docket         Search           1:22-cv-02384-GPG-\n                      Description:\n                                     Report         Criteria:        SBP\n                      Billable Pages: 29            Cost:            2.90\n\n\n\n\n                                                      31\n\f     Case No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP              Document 91            filed 04/29/24         USDC Colorado\n                                                 pg 1 of 15\n                                                                                                               1\n\n\n\n 1                              IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n\n 2                                    FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO\n\n 3        Civil Action No. 22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP\n\n 4        MINCHIE GALOT CUPAT, Individually and on Behalf of All Others\n          Similarly Situated,\n 5\n                 Plaintiff,\n 6\n                 vs.\n 7\n          PALANTIR TECHNOLOGIES, INC.; ALEXANDER C. KARP; DAVID GLAZER;\n 8        and SHYAM SANKAR,\n\n 9               Defendants.\n\n10        ---------------------------------------------------------------\n\n11                                           REPORTER'S TRANSCRIPT\n                                               Status Conference\n12\n          ---------------------------------------------------------------\n13\n          Proceedings before the HONORABLE GORDON P. GALLAGHER, Judge,\n14        United States District Court for the District of Colorado,\n          commencing at 2:03 p.m. on the 24th day of April, 2024, United\n15        States Courthouse, Grand Junction, Colorado.\n\n16                                                    APPEARANCES\n\n17        For the Plaintiff CalPERS:\n          LUKE O. BROOKS, ESQ. and DARREN J. ROBBINS, ESQ.,\n18        Robbins Geller Rudman & Dowd LLP, 655 West Broadway,\n          Suite 1900, San Diego, CA 91201\n19\n          For the Plaintiff Shujun Liu:\n20        JEFFREY A. BERENS, ESQ., Berens Law LLC,\n          2373 Central Park Boulevard, Suite 100, Denver, CO 80238\n21\n          For the Defendant Palantir Technologies, Inc.:\n22        BORIS FELDMAN, ESQ., DAVID Y. LIVSHIZ, ESQ., and\n          NICHOLAS A. CASELI, ESQ.,\n23        Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer US LLP, 175 Greenwich Street,\n          51st Floor, New York, NY 10007\n24\n          NATHAN A. KEEVER, ESQ., Dufford Waldeck Milburn & Krohn, LLP\n25        744 Horizon Court, Suite 300, Grand Junction, CO 81504\n\n                                                 Erin E. Valenti, RMR, CRR\n                                        901 19th Street, Room A256, Denver, CO 80294\n                       Proceedings reported by mechanical stenography; transcription produced via computer.\n                                                       32\n\f     Case No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP     Document 91       filed 04/29/24   USDC Colorado\n                                        pg 2 of 15\n                                                                                             2\n\n\n\n 1                                    P R O C E E D I N G S\n\n2                     (Counsel were present, and the following proceedings\n\n3         were had:)\n\n4                     DEPUTY CLERK:     Court is now in session.\n\n5                     THE COURT:    All right.        Good afternoon, everybody.\n\n6         We're here in 22-cv-2384.          This is Cupat et al. versus\n\n7         Defendant Palantir Technologies, Inc.                The matter comes on for\n\n8         essentially a status conference today.\n\n9                     Let me go ahead and take entries of appearance,\n\n10        starting with the plaintiffs.\n\n11                    MR. BROOKS:     Good afternoon, Your Honor.             Luke -- Luke\n\n12        Brooks --\n\n13                    (Multiple speakers.)\n\n14                    THE COURT:    All right.        Let's start with Mr. Books,\n\n15        and I'll have everybody who's not talking mute themselves.                       And\n\n16        I think that might get rid of our feedback.\n\n17                    MR. BROOKS:     Your Honor, it's Luke Brooks and Darren\n\n18        Robbins from Robbins Geller Rudman & Dowd for the Plaintiff\n\n19        CalPERS.\n\n20                    THE COURT:    All right.        And, Mr. Brooks, my\n\n21        understanding is that your intent is to be in the primary\n\n22        speaking role today?\n\n23                    MR. BROOKS:     That's correct, Your Honor.\n\n24                    THE COURT:    All right.        Then I'll just note that\n\n25        Mr. Hood, Mr. Lieberman, Ms. Reilly, Ms. Oliver, and Mr. Gray\n\n\n\n\n                                        Erin E. Valenti, RMR, CRR\n                                            33\n\f     Case No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP    Document 91       filed 04/29/24     USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 3 of 15\n                                                                                            3\n\n\n\n 1        are also either on the phone or checked in in some fashion, and\n\n 2        as is Mr. Berens.\n\n 3                   Then let's turn to defense, please.\n\n 4                   MR. KEEVER:      Your Honor, Nathan Keever with the\n\n 5        defendant as local counsel.          And with me today is David\n\n 6        Livshiz, Nicholas Caseli, and Boris Feldman.                    And Mr. Feldman\n\n 7        will be handling the bulk of the discussion today.\n\n 8                   THE COURT:    All right.        Mr. Feldman, good afternoon.\n\n 9        Let me make sure that you can hear me.\n\n10                   MR. FELDMAN:      Perfectly, Your Honor.              Thank you.    Good\n\n11        afternoon.\n\n12                   THE COURT:    Okay.     All right.        Great.\n\n13                   I think the first question -- I suspect I know the\n\n14        answer, but it probably overrides everything else -- is do the\n\n15        plaintiffs intend to try and submit an amended complaint?\n\n16                   MR. BROOKS:      We do, Your Honor.\n\n17                   THE COURT:    All right.        With that in mind, then, I\n\n18        want to look at a couple of different areas.                    One of those\n\n19        being the length of the complaint, which we obviously struck as\n\n20        being significantly excessive; the other being how the\n\n21        plaintiffs propose addressing the other issue that needs to be\n\n22        brought up in terms of the registration.\n\n23                   And I think I have to have everybody go back and mute\n\n24        themselves.    Somebody's not muted.           Can you tell who, Don?\n\n25                   DEPUTY CLERK:      I believe it's Mr. Brooks that doesn't\n\n\n\n\n                                       Erin E. Valenti, RMR, CRR\n                                            34\n\f     Case No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP   Document 91       filed 04/29/24    USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 4 of 15\n                                                                                          4\n\n\n\n 1        show muted, but we'll -- looks like he just muted, maybe.\n\n 2                   THE COURT:   Okay.     So those are the two main areas.\n\n 3        With regard to the Rule 11 defect and the length, we -- or I'm\n\n 4        willing to accept a complaint, at this juncture, of no more\n\n 5        than 75 pages.     This last iteration was 212 pages long.\n\n 6                   A couple of comments with regard to that.                First, in\n\n 7        terms of the false and misleading statements and omissions\n\n 8        section, that section was some 70 pages long.                  In that, the\n\n 9        plaintiffs went document by document and extensively quoted\n\n10        from each document, selectively bolding and italicizing certain\n\n11        text and then repeating the same general reasons and statements\n\n12        in each document that were fraudulent.\n\n13                   One thing that wasn't clear to me is if the challenged\n\n14        statement was only the bolded and italicized statement and the\n\n15        remaining text was simply for context or if the bolding and\n\n16        italicizing was just intended to highlight the statement that\n\n17        tied it to plaintiffs' general themes.              And I'll note that in a\n\n18        prior case, Judge Krieger made the same observation and had the\n\n19        same concern.\n\n20                   What I need to know is exactly what statement\n\n21        plaintiff believes to be fraudulent and what part of that\n\n22        statement.    And I think it's probably going to be most\n\n23        effective if that is then integrated in some reasonable and\n\n24        logical fashion into the narrative, consolidated therein.\n\n25                   In any event, I think the plaintiffs only need to\n\n\n\n\n                                      Erin E. Valenti, RMR, CRR\n                                           35\n\f     Case No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP   Document 91       filed 04/29/24   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 5 of 15\n                                                                                         5\n\n\n\n 1        focus on the statements they really think are fraudulent or\n\n 2        that give important context to their scheme liability theory\n\n 3        and integrate those into the factual chronology.                 That's\n\n 4        already done to some extent, but that's one of the reasons that\n\n 5        Section 7 is so repetitive and unnecessary, and a lot of extra\n\n 6        heft could be eliminated by doing that.\n\n 7                   The additional scienter allegations in Section 9 in\n\n 8        the last complaint were largely duplicative of the scienter\n\n 9        allegations elsewhere.      This seems to me to have been easily\n\n10        integrated into plaintiffs' allegations concerning the\n\n11        pertinent factual events.        Perhaps plaintiffs also don't need\n\n12        or can drastically shorten their introduction and their summary\n\n13        of the factual chronology.        And then the factual chronology,\n\n14        that is largely repetitive of each other.\n\n15                   I will note I think that the Section 11 standing\n\n16        allegations and the length of that are somewhat understandable,\n\n17        because plaintiff needs to plead traceability in the wake of\n\n18        the Slack decision.     But as there's little post-Slack authority\n\n19        with regard to traceability, perhaps these are issues that can\n\n20        be cleaned up after we discuss our second issue, which is with\n\n21        regard to how the plaintiffs think they want to propose to\n\n22        address traceability.\n\n23                   I understand one theory that you're going to go on is\n\n24        essentially probability, but, put simply, that theory may not\n\n25        fly.   So we need to talk about whether you have an alternate\n\n\n\n\n                                      Erin E. Valenti, RMR, CRR\n                                           36\n\f     Case No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP    Document 91       filed 04/29/24     USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 6 of 15\n                                                                                            6\n\n\n\n 1        theory that you may want to address in terms of traceability,\n\n 2        whether the plaintiff is proposing in some fashion to address\n\n 3        discovery on that, how the plaintiff wants to address the\n\n 4        mandatory stay that's going to be juxtaposed against that if\n\n 5        another motion to dismiss is filed.\n\n 6                    So let me turn, Mr. Brooks, to you for thoughts on\n\n 7        both of those topics, the length of the complaint and then how\n\n 8        you want to address traceability.\n\n 9                    MR. BROOKS:     Thank you, Your Honor.              In terms of\n\n10        length of complaint, we -- we have read and understand the\n\n11        Court's order.     We understand that there's a lot of repetition\n\n12        in the complaint, and that arises out of several different\n\n13        things, including one issue, which is that there's a scheme\n\n14        liability claim here.       And we wanted to be very clear that\n\n15        that's a separate -- those claims are separate from the\n\n16        10b-5(b) claims under false and misleading statements.\n\n17                    We have had the Court's order.               We're working on\n\n18        reformulating the complaint.          I will say that it -- it --\n\n19        having begun to undertake that work, it will be very difficult\n\n20        to get it down to 75 pages.          The rework has included and will\n\n21        include cutting substantial portions of the context around the\n\n22        statements so that it's just the false statements that are\n\n23        apparent.\n\n24                    And, you know, as the Court probably realizes, in\n\n25        these cases, there's a little bit of -- of a damned if you do,\n\n\n\n\n                                       Erin E. Valenti, RMR, CRR\n                                            37\n\f     Case No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP    Document 91       filed 04/29/24   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 7 of 15\n                                                                                           7\n\n\n\n 1        damned if you don't scenario whereby if you just include a bald\n\n 2        statement, the defendants often will complain that it's taken\n\n 3        out of context and you'll be dealing with arguments on that\n\n 4        score; and if you include too much, it's frustrating for -- for\n\n 5        the Court.\n\n 6                   So we did try to -- given this long class period,\n\n 7        complicated fraud, we did try to balance it, Your Honor.                  I\n\n 8        understand we did not get the balance correct, and so we're\n\n 9        seeking to rebalance that.         You know, our target had been to\n\n10        get it down to around 125 pages, which is about 25 pages fewer\n\n11        than the Pluralsight complaint, which was approved by the Tenth\n\n12        Circuit.\n\n13                   As I said, 75 will be difficult.                We are cognizant of\n\n14        the Court's need and desire to have something as short as\n\n15        possible, and I would ask leave of the Court to make it 100.\n\n16        And if we can do it in under 100, we will -- we will do that.\n\n17                   THE COURT:    I can live with 100.              That's -- that will\n\n18        be the order of the Court.\n\n19                   MR. BROOKS:      Thank you, Your Honor.\n\n20                   In terms of the -- in terms of the tracing, what we've\n\n21        done is, as the Court knows, described that it's a virtual\n\n22        certainty, based on the facts of this case, that CalPERS\n\n23        purchased at least one traceable share.                  And in reality, it's\n\n24        going to be many, many traceable shares.                 Our intent -- we\n\n25        believe that that is sufficient, under the law at the pleading\n\n\n\n\n                                       Erin E. Valenti, RMR, CRR\n                                            38\n\f     Case No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP    Document 91       filed 04/29/24   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 8 of 15\n                                                                                          8\n\n\n\n 1        stage, in order to -- in order to get past the pleading stage\n\n 2        and then get into discovery.          And we've described, briefly, a\n\n 3        plan in discovery to -- to prove it.\n\n 4                   I think that the Court is likely correct, although we\n\n 5        are in unchartered territory, that for proof, it may not be\n\n 6        sufficient to have --\n\n 7                   THE COURT:    Give me just a moment.            Did we -- did we\n\n 8        lose somebody, Don, or did they just turn the screen off, which\n\n 9        is fine.    I just want to make sure we didn't lose anybody\n\n10        critical to the --\n\n11                   DEPUTY CLERK:     I believe --\n\n12                   THE COURT:    One picture --\n\n13                   DEPUTY CLERK:     -- somebody turned his camera off.\n\n14                   THE COURT:    All right.        Fantastic.\n\n15                   Go ahead, sir.\n\n16                   MR. BROOKS:      I -- so in terms of proof, although I\n\n17        don't think there's a case that says it directly, and part of\n\n18        our proof probably would be a statistics expert which -- you\n\n19        know, who had been qualified in a variety of different types of\n\n20        cases to provide opinions relating to statistical probability\n\n21        and analyzing evidence, our plan would be to also seek\n\n22        discovery and prove it based on the records that are -- we\n\n23        believe are available as described in the complaint.\n\n24                   If the Court is of the opinion that -- that\n\n25        probability is insufficient to -- to get past the pleadings --\n\n\n\n\n                                       Erin E. Valenti, RMR, CRR\n                                           39\n\f     Case No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP    Document 91       filed 04/29/24   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 9 of 15\n                                                                                          9\n\n\n\n 1        the pleadings stage and the pleading bar, then I do think that\n\n 2        the Court's suggestion of a -- of a partial lift of the PSLRA\n\n 3        discovery stay makes sense.          It can't be the law that -- that\n\n 4        we are both held to a standard of proof that's beyond any --\n\n 5        any other standard, really, in the law in terms of -- of\n\n 6        pleading tracing and then at the same time not allowed to have\n\n 7        discovery on that question.\n\n 8                   THE COURT:    Have you given some thought to very\n\n 9        limited discovery to prove traceability in that posture if\n\n10        there was a brief and extremely limited lifting of the stay?\n\n11                   MR. BROOKS:      Your Honor, we've given some thought as\n\n12        to how we would do it in the course of discovery, and what we\n\n13        would do is -- is try to, as the -- as the complaint describes,\n\n14        bore in on the records that establish that at least some of the\n\n15        shares that CalPERS purchased were registered.                  I'm not sure --\n\n16        and beyond that, Your Honor, I think we would be relying on\n\n17        sort of experts and consultants to guide us in that area beyond\n\n18        what we've described in the complaint.\n\n19                   And I -- not having gone through this process before,\n\n20        I -- I don't -- I'm not sure precisely how limited the\n\n21        discovery would be, just to be open and honest.                  I don't want\n\n22        to talk myself out of it, Your Honor.\n\n23                   THE COURT:    Sure.\n\n24                   MR. BROOKS:      But I just don't have a sense that it --\n\n25        as to whether it would be something that is -- that's short and\n\n\n\n\n                                       Erin E. Valenti, RMR, CRR\n                                            40\n\f     Case No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP    Document 91       filed 04/29/24   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 10 of 15\n                                                                                          10\n\n\n\n 1        fast or -- or longer.\n\n 2                   THE COURT:    All right.        And I think the answer is you\n\n 3        might not know, but at this point do you have any reasonable\n\n 4        idea, with regard to the consolidated audit trail, whether that\n\n 5        requires a subpoena to access, whether that's public records\n\n 6        that you can access without it?            Any looking into that issue at\n\n 7        this juncture?\n\n 8                   MR. BROOKS:      Yeah.     And it's my understanding that it\n\n 9        would require formal discovery to -- to access that, so\n\n10        subpoenas, et cetera.\n\n11                   THE COURT:    All right.        Well, it appears to me -- and\n\n12        I'm certainly going to turn to the defense at this point.                  But\n\n13        it appears to me at this juncture that what probably would be\n\n14        most fruitful would be at the same time that you file your\n\n15        amended complaint to also file a discovery motion, by then\n\n16        having outlined or perhaps even discussed -- even though it\n\n17        might be opposed -- with opposing counsel a plan for limited\n\n18        discovery to see what you can do to prove traceability prior to\n\n19        proceeding on the -- on the complaint, or at least on that\n\n20        portion of it.\n\n21                   I think as we all know, we're a bit in unchartered\n\n22        territory here.     There's a couple of circuits that have\n\n23        addressed this issue, a number of district courts.                  The Tenth\n\n24        Circuit has not yet, and I don't think a district court in the\n\n25        Tenth Circuit has yet directly squarely addressed this issue\n\n\n\n\n                                       Erin E. Valenti, RMR, CRR\n                                           41\n\f     Case No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP    Document 91       filed 04/29/24    USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 11 of 15\n                                                                                           11\n\n\n\n 1        either.    So I'd like to see what the different options are\n\n 2        before we move forward.\n\n 3                   It seems like simultaneously addressing an amended\n\n 4        complaint along with a limited discovery plan that would have\n\n 5        to occur, if it did occur -- and I'm certainly not saying it's\n\n 6        going to, but if it did, it would have to -- or would require\n\n 7        limited lifting of the stay to get to that juncture.                   But it\n\n 8        seems like addressing those in tandem is reasonable.                   What type\n\n 9        of time frame do you think you're looking at for addressing\n\n10        those things?\n\n11                   MR. BROOKS:      Your Honor, we had 30 days for the\n\n12        amended complaint, and I think we can do the discovery plan\n\n13        concurrently by May 24th.\n\n14                   THE COURT:    Okay.     Mr. Feldman, let me turn to you,\n\n15        sir.   What are your thoughts on all this?\n\n16                   MR. FELDMAN:      Thank you, Your Honor.             It's obvious\n\n17        that you've dug into the issues.            I think both sides are\n\n18        appreciative of that.       I don't know if you've ever read to your\n\n19        kids or your grandkids the book If You Give a Mouse a Cookie.\n\n20        Is that familiar to you, Your Honor?\n\n21                   THE COURT:    Various versions of it, although I think I\n\n22        like the moose and the muffin better.\n\n23                   MR. FELDMAN:      Exactly.      Well, what I worry about is I\n\n24        just heard them ask for a glass of milk and to offer expert\n\n25        declarations with the complaint.            I think there's a legal\n\n\n\n\n                                       Erin E. Valenti, RMR, CRR\n                                            42\n\f     Case No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP   Document 91       filed 04/29/24   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 12 of 15\n                                                                                         12\n\n\n\n 1        issue.   Obviously, that's for you to decide in ruling on the\n\n 2        motion to dismiss.      But I think the probability rationale is\n\n 3        not one -- you're absolutely right about the law in the Tenth\n\n 4        Circuit, but I think the law generally in other courts is\n\n 5        pretty clear that probability doesn't suffice.\n\n 6                   And on the --\n\n 7                   THE COURT:    That has certainly been the answer out of\n\n 8        the First and the Ninth, so it seems like at least a couple of\n\n 9        circuits are going that way.\n\n10                   MR. FELDMAN:     And on the issue of the limited\n\n11        discovery stay, I don't know if you ever had interaction with\n\n12        Judge Jeremy Fogel.     He was a judge in the Northern District of\n\n13        California; then he was head of the Federal Judicial Center for\n\n14        several years.     And in his first securities case as a district\n\n15        judge, he granted -- he did a limited stay -- a limited lifting\n\n16        of the stay under the Reform Act in the Ninth Circuit.                 So I've\n\n17        always followed the law on that very closely.\n\n18                   And what my friend, plaintiffs' counsel, indicated\n\n19        about how unfair it would be if there are very tough pleading\n\n20        standards and you can't even get discovery to help you on them,\n\n21        that's the whole legislative scheme.             So I will spare you and\n\n22        everyone on the call the argument about why lifting the stay\n\n23        would be inappropriate.\n\n24                   In the prototypical case, Your Honor, if you buy\n\n25        shares in an IPO, you show that you bought them that day from\n\n\n\n\n                                      Erin E. Valenti, RMR, CRR\n                                           43\n\f     Case No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP    Document 91       filed 04/29/24   USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 13 of 15\n                                                                                          13\n\n\n\n 1        one of the investment bankers at the IPO price, and then you\n\n 2        don't need to trace, because you bought in the IPO.                  As soon as\n\n 3        you start to deviate away from that, the law is quite strict.\n\n 4        One might say harsh.        But because a Section 11 claim is\n\n 5        essentially no fault against the issuer, Congress really wanted\n\n 6        to limit who could bring it.\n\n 7                   So I think that your proposed solution is Solomonic.\n\n 8        They file their complaint, and if they want to try to get\n\n 9        discovery at the same time, they move to lift the stay.                  And\n\n10        then I'll save all my blather for our opposition to that.\n\n11                   THE COURT:   All right.         Well, I appreciate that.        I\n\n12        think that everybody knows that is where we're going in terms\n\n13        of essentially, putting it in lay terms for the record, a\n\n14        policy argument over if Congress provided this statute, who do\n\n15        they really think gets a remedy and how is it tailored to\n\n16        figure that out.\n\n17                   I think that's where we are is determining beyond an\n\n18        IPO, where traceability is certain, who else gets to dive into\n\n19        that pool.    And, you know, different courts are struggling with\n\n20        that, but that will be addressed I think extensively in the\n\n21        briefing I suspect will be where we're heading.\n\n22                   So any problem, Mr. Feldman, with the 30-day\n\n23        suggestion from counsel for the plaintiff?\n\n24                   MR. FELDMAN:      No.    It's -- it's good for us,\n\n25        Your Honor.    Thank you.\n\n\n\n\n                                       Erin E. Valenti, RMR, CRR\n                                             44\n\f     Case No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP    Document 91       filed 04/29/24     USDC Colorado\n                                       pg 14 of 15\n                                                                                            14\n\n\n\n 1                   THE COURT:    Okay.     Given -- given all of that, I'm not\n\n 2        sure that there's anything else that needs to be done today,\n\n 3        but let me turn back to you, Mr. Brooks.                 Anything else that\n\n 4        you think I need to address?\n\n 5                   MR. BROOKS:      Not today, Your Honor.              Thank you.\n\n 6                   THE COURT:    Absolutely.\n\n 7                   Mr. Feldman, how about from your perspective?\n\n 8                   MR. FELDMAN:      Nothing else, Your Honor.              Thank you\n\n 9        very much.\n\n10                   THE COURT:    All right.        Well, I look forward to seeing\n\n11        the renewed briefing and talking with you all as the case goes\n\n12        on.\n\n13                   Have a great day, everybody.             We'll be in recess.\n\n14                   (The hearing was concluded at 2:22 p.m. on Wednesday,\n\n15        April 24, 2024.)\n\n16\n\n17\n\n18\n\n19\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\n\n\n\n                                       Erin E. Valenti, RMR, CRR\n                                           45\n\f     Case No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP   Document 91       filed 04/29/24   USDC Colorado\n                                      pg 15 of 15\n\n\n\n\n1                                 REPORTER'S CERTIFICATE\n\n2                I, ERIN E. VALENTI, Official Court Reporter for the\n\n3         United States District Court for the District of Colorado, a\n\n4         Registered Merit Reporter and Certified Realtime Reporter, do\n\n5         hereby certify that I reported by machine shorthand the\n\n6         proceedings contained herein at the time and place\n\n7         aforementioned and that the foregoing pages constitute a full,\n\n8         true, and correct transcript.\n\n9                Dated this 29th day of April, 2024.\n\n10\n\n11\n\n12\n\n13\n\n14                                                         /s/ Erin E. Valenti\n\n15                                                     ERIN E. VALENTI, RMR, CRR\n                                                        Official Court Reporter\n16\n\n17\n\n18\n\n19\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\n\n\n\n                                      Erin E. Valenti, RMR, CRR\n                                          46\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 1 of\n                                    108\n\n\n\n\n                       IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                           FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO\n                               Judge Gordon P. Gallagher\n\n  Lead Civil Action No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP\n  Consolidated with Civil Actions 1:22-cv-02805-GPG-SBP and 1:22-cv-02893-GPG-SBP\n\n  MINCHIE GALOT CUPAT, Individually and on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated,\n\n          Plaintiff,\n\n  v.\n\n  PALANTIR TECHNOLOGIES INC.,\n  ALEXANDER C. KARP,\n  DAVID GLAZER, and\n  SHYAM SANKAR,\n       Defendants.                                   DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL\n\n        SECOND AMENDED CONSOLIDATED CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT FOR\n               VIOLATIONS OF THE FEDERAL SECURITIES LAWS\n\n\n\n\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                          47\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 2 of\n                                    108\n\n\n\n                                               TABLE OF CONTENTS\n\n                                                                                                                         Page\n\n  I.      INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................. 1\n\n  II.     JURISDICTION AND VENUE............................................................................... 4\n\n  III.    PARTIES .............................................................................................................. 4\n\n  IV.     DEFENDANTS\u2019 FRAUDULENT SCHEME AND DISSEMINATION OF\n          FALSE AND MISLEADING STATEMENTS ......................................................... 7\n\n          A.          Defendants Misrepresent the Efficiencies of Palantir Software................ 10\n\n                      1.     Defendants Misleadingly Portray Palantir as a \u201cSaaS-like\u201d\n                             Company in Connection with the Offering ..................................... 10\n\n                      2.     Defendants Continued to Misrepresent Palantir\u2019s Operational\n                             Efficiencies After the Offering ........................................................ 16\n\n          B.          Defendants Implement the SPAC Scheme to Mask Stagnation in\n                      Palantir\u2019s Business by Purchasing High-Margin Revenue ....................... 19\n\n                      1.     Defendants Mischaracterize Palantir\u2019s Business Strategy ............ 21\n\n                      2.     Defendants Mislead About the Legitimacy and Sustainability\n                             of the SPAC Deals ........................................................................ 22\n\n                             a.        First Stage SPACs: Defendants Mischaracterize the\n                                       SPACs\u2019 Use of Foundry...................................................... 22\n\n                             b.        Second Stage SPACs: Defendants Misrepresent the\n                                       Sustainability of the SPAC Scheme ................................... 27\n\n                             c.        Third Stage SPACs: Defendants\u2019 Last-Gasp\n                                       Expansion of the SPAC Scheme ........................................ 36\n\n                      3.     Defendants\u2019 SPAC Scheme Was Designed to and Did Inflate\n                             Palantir\u2019s Key Performance Metrics .............................................. 39\n\n                             a.        Profit Margins ..................................................................... 40\n\n                             b.        Reported Revenue, Revenue Growth, and TRDV .............. 44\n\n                             c.        Customer Count ................................................................. 47\n\n                             d.        Defendants Cite Palantir\u2019s Misleading Metrics as\n                                       Evidence of Continued Sustainable Growth ....................... 48\n\n                                                              -i-\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                               48\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 3 of\n                                    108\n\n\n\n\n                                                                                                                 Page\n\n\n          C.          Defendants Misrepresent the Momentum in Palantir\u2019s Business to\n                      Obscure Palantir\u2019s Declining Growth Trends ........................................... 50\n\n                      1.      The Offering: Defendants Misleadingly Depict an\n                              Accelerating Trend of Immense Revenue Growth......................... 53\n\n                      2.      3Q20 Earnings: Defendants Misleadingly Claim \u201cSignificant\n                              Momentum\u201d Across the Business.................................................. 55\n\n                      3.      FY20 Earnings: Defendants Misleadingly State Commercial\n                              Pipeline Is \u201cSubstantial and Growing\u201d and Government\n                              Growth Is Just at the \u201cTip of the Iceberg\u201d ...................................... 56\n\n                      4.      1Q21 Earnings: Defendants Misleadingly Point to SPAC\n                              Customers as Proof of Commercial Momentum and Claim\n                              Government Momentum \u201cContinues Unabated\u201d ........................... 57\n\n                      5.      2Q21 Earnings: Defendants Misleadingly Portray a Strong\n                              Pipeline for Growth Across the Business ...................................... 60\n\n                      6.      3Q21 Earnings: Defendants Misleadingly Claim Commercial\n                              Segment Is \u201cConsistently Accelerating\u201d and Government\n                              Segment Is \u201cBig and Building\u201d ....................................................... 61\n\n                      7.      FY21 Earnings: Defendants Misleadingly Claim U.S.\n                              Commercial Growth Will Double While Denying the\n                              Sequential Deceleration of Government Growth ........................... 62\n\n                      8.      1Q22 Earnings: Defendants Misleadingly Claim Palantir\u2019s\n                              Business Segments Are Seeing a \u201cReacceleration\u201d...................... 63\n\n          D.          Defendants Falsely Assure Investors that Palantir Was Positioned\n                      to Achieve 30% Long-Term Revenue Growth.......................................... 64\n\n          E.          Defendants Manipulated the Reporting of Key Reported Metrics in\n                      Order to Mislead the Market .................................................................... 65\n\n                      1.      Definition of \u201cCustomer\u201d: Defendants Start Including\n                              Customers from the Entire Prior Year in 1Q21 .............................. 66\n\n                      2.      Average Contract Duration: Defendants Stop Regular\n                              Quarterly Disclosures in 3Q21 ...................................................... 66\n\n\n                                                           - ii -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                            49\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 4 of\n                                    108\n\n\n\n\n                                                                                                                        Page\n\n\n                      3.       Palantir\u2019s Acquire, Expand, Scale Business Model:\n                               Defendants Stop Reporting All Related Metrics in 1Q22............... 67\n\n                      4.       Total Remaining Deal Value (\u201cTRDV\u201d): Defendants Conceal\n                               Segment-Level Breakdown in 1Q22.............................................. 69\n\n                      5.       Average Revenue Per Customer: Defendants Switch to Only\n                               Reporting Palantir\u2019s Top 20 Customers in 1Q22 in Order to\n                               Hide that Customers Were Not Scaling Up ................................... 70\n\n  V.      LOSS CAUSATION ............................................................................................ 71\n\n          A.          November 2021 Loss Event..................................................................... 71\n\n          B.          February 2022 Loss Event ....................................................................... 73\n\n          C.          May 2022 Loss Event .............................................................................. 74\n\n          D.          August 2022 Loss Event .......................................................................... 75\n\n  VI.     THE INDIVIDUAL DEFENDANTS\u2019 $2.2 BILLION OF INSIDER TRADING\n          FURTHER SUPPORTS A STRONG INFERENCE OF SCIENTER ................... 76\n\n  VII.    APPLICABILITY OF THE PRESUMPTION OF RELIANCE ............................... 80\n\n  VIII.   CLASS ACTION ALLEGATIONS ....................................................................... 81\n\n  IX.     EXCHANGE ACT CLAIMS ................................................................................. 81\n\n  X.      SECURITIES ACT ALLEGATIONS .................................................................... 85\n\n          A.          Securities Act Parties ............................................................................... 85\n\n          B.          The Registration Statement Contained Untrue Statements of\n                      Material Fact and Material Omissions ...................................................... 86\n\n                      1.       Untrue Statements About Palantir\u2019s Operational Efficiencies\n                               and Margins .................................................................................. 86\n\n                      2.       Untrue Statements About Strategic Partnerships .......................... 88\n\n                      3.       Untrue Statements About Growth Rates, Sustainability of\n                               Growth, and Total Addressable Market (\u201cTAM\u201d)............................ 88\n\n\n                                                             - iii -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                               50\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 5 of\n                                    108\n\n\n\n\n                                                                                                         Page\n\n\n          C.          The Direct Listing Was an Integrated Offering ......................................... 91\n\n          D.          Even if Not Part of an Integrated Offering, Plaintiffs Purchased\n                      Shares Traceable to the Registration Statement ..................................... 94\n\n  XI.     THE SECURITIES ACT CLAIMS ....................................................................... 96\n\n\n\n\n                                                        - iv -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                         51\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 6 of\n                                    108\n\n\n\n\n          Lead Plaintiff California Public Employees\u2019 Retirement System (\u201cCalPERS\u201d) and\n\n  additional named plaintiff Shijun Liu, Individually and as Trustee of The Liu Family Trust\n\n  2019 (\u201cLiu,\u201d and together with CalPERS, \u201cPlaintiffs\u201d), by and through their counsel Robbins\n\n  Geller Rudman & Dowd LLP, allege the following upon personal knowledge as to\n\n  themselves and their own acts, and upon information and belief as to all other matters.1\n\n  I.      INTRODUCTION\n\n          1.          This action asserts violations of the federal securities laws against software\n\n  and data analytics company Palantir Technologies Inc. (\u201cPalantir\u201d or the \u201cCompany\u201d) and\n\n  certain of its officers and directors on behalf of Plaintiffs and all other persons that\n\n  purchased Palantir Class A common stock between September 30, 2020 and August 5,\n\n  2022, inclusive (the \u201cClass Period\u201d), and were damaged thereby.2\n\n          2.          Defendants (defined infra, \u00b624) violated the Securities Exchange Act of 1934\n\n  (\u201cExchange Act\u201d) and SEC Rules 10b-5(a) and (c) by engaging in a scheme to create a\n\n  public market for Palantir stock and thereafter artificially inflate the trading price of Palantir\n\n\n  1\n     Plaintiffs\u2019 information and belief is based on, among other things, the independent\n  investigation of counsel, which includes, but is not limited to, a review and analysis of: (i)\n  public filings with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (\u201cSEC\u201d); (ii) transcripts of\n  Palantir senior management\u2019s conferences with investors and analysts; (iii) interviews of\n  former Palantir employees; (iv) interviews of former employees of companies in which\n  Palantir invested; (v) releases and media reports issued about and disseminated by the\n  Company; (vi) analyst reports issued about Palantir; (vii) other public information and data\n  regarding the Company; and (viii) documents cited herein. Plaintiffs believe that substantial\n  additional evidentiary support will exist for the allegations set forth herein after a reasonable\n  opportunity for discovery.\n  2\n     Unless otherwise stated, Palantir \u201cshares\u201d or \u201cstock\u201d refer to Palantir Class A common\n  stock.\n\n\n                                                   -1-\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    52\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 7 of\n                                    108\n\n\n\n\n  shares in order to sell more than $2.2 billion of their own Palantir stock.\n\n          3.          In July 2020, Palantir announced it would go public via a direct listing. The\n\n  timing of the announcement followed Palantir\u2019s stellar but \u2013 unknown to investors \u2013\n\n  unsustainable 1H20 results.3 Defendants misleadingly claimed Palantir\u2019s 1H20 results\n\n  were indicative of its prospects as a public company and that Palantir had successfully\n\n  transitioned from selling expensive bespoke solutions to providing highly-efficient plug-and-\n\n  play software. When Palantir\u2019s actual performance as a public company threatened to\n\n  undermine this narrative, Defendants implemented other facets of their scheme, which\n\n  included the outright purchase of revenue in 20+ sham SPAC deals and altering Palantir\u2019s\n\n  reporting of key metrics to obfuscate decelerating growth in its business segments.4\n\n          4.          In furtherance of their scheme, Defendants also violated \u00a710(b) of the\n\n  Exchange Act and Rule 10b-5(b) by issuing a series of false and misleading statements\n\n  and omissions concerning Palantir\u2019s: (1) operational efficiencies and product capabilities;\n\n  (2) SPAC transactions; (3) decelerating growth trends; and (4) long-term revenue guidance.\n\n          5.          Finally, the Securities Act Defendants (defined infra, \u00b6218) violated \u00a711 of the\n\n  Securities Act of 1933 (\u201cSecurities Act\u201d) by causing Palantir to issue a Registration\n\n  3\n     Palantir\u2019s fiscal year (\u201cFY\u201d) runs concurrent with the calendar year. Thus, the first half of\n  2020 (\u201c1H20\u201d) comprised the first and second quarters of 2020 (\u201c1Q20\u201d and \u201c2Q20\u201d).\n  4\n      Special purpose acquisition companies (\u201cSPACs\u201d) are \u201cblank check\u201d companies that\n  raise cash in an initial public offering (\u201cIPO\u201d) to acquire a private company and bring that\n  company public. SPACs typically raise money through the private placement of additional\n  equity securities in order to complete the acquisition, fund operations post-closing, and/or\n  serve as a backstop to shareholder redemptions. These private investments in public\n  equity are known as \u201cPIPE\u201d financings. The SPACs\u2019 need for PIPE funds created an\n  opportunity for Palantir to effectively buy the growth and revenue it promised the market.\n\n\n                                                    -2-\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                     53\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 8 of\n                                    108\n\n\n\n\n  Statement (defined infra, \u00b629 n.7), which contained untrue statements and omitted material\n\n  facts about the Company\u2019s operations, product capabilities, and growth prospects. The\n\n  Registration Statement also asserted Palantir\u2019s growth strategy focused on deploying its\n\n  software among a potential customer base of large companies with more than $500 million\n\n  in annual revenue. In truth, Palantir\u2019s commercial business strategy was predicated on\n\n  buying illusory revenue and growth from nonviable SPACs with little or no revenue.\n\n          6.          As Defendants\u2019 fraud unraveled, Palantir\u2019s stock price plummeted via a series\n\n  of disclosures. By the end of the Class Period, Palantir\u2019s stock price had declined by 80%\n\n  from its $45 Class Period high \u2013 right back to where it was at the start of the Class Period.\n\n\n\n\n                                                   -3-\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    54\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 9 of\n                                    108\n\n\n\n\n          7.          Plaintiffs and other members of the Class (defined infra, \u00b6198 & n.42)\n\n  suffered significant damages as a result of Defendants\u2019 misconduct as the relevant truth\n\n  about Palantir reached the market.\n\n  II.     JURISDICTION AND VENUE\n\n          8.          The claims alleged herein arise under \u00a7\u00a711 and 15 of the Securities Act (15\n\n  U.S.C. \u00a7\u00a777k and 77o), \u00a7\u00a710(b), 20(a), and 20A of the Exchange Act (15 U.S.C. \u00a7\u00a778j(b),\n\n  78t(a), and 78t-1), and SEC Rule 10b-5 promulgated thereunder (17 C.F.R. \u00a7240.10b-5).\n\n          9.          This Court has subject-matter jurisdiction pursuant to 28 U.S.C. \u00a71331, \u00a722 of\n\n  the Securities Act (15 U.S.C. \u00a777v), and \u00a727 of the Exchange Act (15 U.S.C. \u00a778aa).\n\n          10.         Venue is proper in this District pursuant to \u00a722 of the Securities Act, \u00a727 of\n\n  the Exchange Act, and 28 U.S.C. \u00a71391(b) as Palantir is headquartered in this District, and\n\n  substantial acts in furtherance of the alleged misconduct occurred in this District.\n\n          11.         In connection with the acts alleged herein, Defendants, directly or indirectly,\n\n  used the means and instrumentalities of interstate commerce, including, but not limited to,\n\n  the mails, interstate telephone communications, and the national securities markets.\n\n  III.    PARTIES\n\n          12.         Lead Plaintiff CalPERS is the largest state public pension fund in the United\n\n  States, with more than 2 million members and more than $400 billion in assets under\n\n  management. CalPERS purchased Palantir stock during the Class Period, as set forth in\n\n  its Certification (ECF 12-4) and incorporated herein, including shares traceable to the\n\n  Registration Statement, and was damaged thereby.\n\n          13.         Plaintiff Liu purchased Palantir stock during the Class Period as set forth in\n\n                                                    -4-\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    55\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 10 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  the Certification previously filed with the Court and incorporated herein, including shares\n\n  traceable to the Registration Statement, and was damaged thereby.5\n\n          14.         Defendant Palantir is incorporated in Delaware and headquartered in Denver,\n\n  Colorado. In September 2020, the Company went public via a direct listing (the \u201cOffering\u201d),\n\n  utilizing the Registration Statement through which Palantir shares became publicly listed on\n\n  the New York Stock Exchange (\u201cNYSE\u201d) under the ticker symbol \u201cPLTR.\u201d\n\n          15.         Defendant Alexander C. Karp (\u201cKarp\u201d) was, at all relevant times, Palantir\u2019s\n\n  Chief Executive Officer (\u201cCEO\u201d) and a member of its Board of Directors (the \u201cBoard\u201d).\n\n          16.         Defendant Peter Thiel (\u201cThiel\u201d) was, at all relevant times, Palantir\u2019s Chairman\n\n  of the Board.\n\n          17.         Defendant Stephen Cohen (\u201cCohen\u201d) was, at all relevant times, Palantir\u2019s\n\n  President and Secretary and a member of its Board.\n\n          18.         Defendant David Glazer (\u201cGlazer\u201d) was, at all relevant times, Palantir\u2019s Chief\n\n  Financial Officer (\u201cCFO\u201d) and Treasurer.\n\n          19.         Defendant Shyam Sankar (\u201cSankar\u201d) was, at all relevant times, Palantir\u2019s\n\n  Chief Operating Officer (\u201cCOO\u201d) and Executive Vice President.\n\n          20.         Defendant Kevin Kawasaki (\u201cKawasaki\u201d) was, at all relevant times, Palantir\u2019s\n\n  Global Head of Business Development.\n\n          21.         Defendant Alexander Moore (\u201cMoore\u201d) was a member of Palantir\u2019s Board\n\n  when the Registration Statement was issued and signed the Registration Statement.\n\n  5\n      Shijun Liu, Individually and as Trustee of The Liu Family Trust 2019 v. Palantir Techs.\n  Inc., No. 1:22-cv-02893-PAB-KLM (D. Colo. Nov. 2, 2022) (ECF 1-1).\n\n\n                                                    -5-\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    56\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 11 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          22.         Defendant Spencer Rascoff (\u201cRascoff\u201d) was a member of Palantir\u2019s Board\n\n  when the Registration Statement was issued and signed the Registration Statement.\n\n          23.         Defendant Alexandra Schiff (\u201cSchiff\u201d) was a member of Palantir\u2019s Board when\n\n  the Registration Statement was issued and signed the Registration Statement.\n\n          24.         Karp, Cohen, Thiel, Glazer, Sankar, and Kawasaki are collectively referred to\n\n  herein as the \u201cIndividual Defendants.\u201d            Palantir and the Individual Defendants are\n\n  collectively referred to herein as the \u201cDefendants.\u201d\n\n          25.         As a result of their positions with the Company, the Individual Defendants\n\n  possessed the power and authority to control the contents of Palantir\u2019s quarterly reports,\n\n  press releases, and presentations to investors and market participants.              They were\n\n  provided with copies of the Company\u2019s reports and press releases alleged herein to be\n\n  misleading prior to or shortly after their issuance and had the ability and opportunity to\n\n  prevent their issuance or cause them to be corrected. Karp and Sankar participated in\n\n  Company-wide town hall meetings that generally took place every other month, wherein\n\n  updates were provided on Palantir\u2019s new contract wins. The Individual Defendants sent\n\n  and received widely disseminated monthly email updates that included metrics on the state\n\n  of the Company\u2019s business, including the number of pilots started, converted, and\n\n  cancelled, and the number of contracts cancelled. They also had access to daily-updated\n\n  dashboards with information on the start dates, expected completion dates, and\n\n  expenditures on each of Palantir\u2019s contracts. Regular \u201csales ops\u201d team meetings were\n\n  attended by Karp, Cohen, or Sankar. The Individual Defendants participated in the\n\n  fraudulent scheme alleged herein, and because of their positions with the Company and\n\n                                                   -6-\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    57\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 12 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  their access to material nonpublic information, the Individual Defendants were aware of\n\n  and/or recklessly disregarded the adverse facts specified herein.\n\n  IV.     DEFENDANTS\u2019 FRAUDULENT SCHEME AND DISSEMINATION OF\n          FALSE AND MISLEADING STATEMENTS\n\n          26.         Karp, Cohen, and Thiel cofounded Palantir in 2003. Palantir offers bespoke\n\n  software products built on its two customer-facing platforms, Gotham and Foundry, and\n\n  reports in two business segments: commercial and government. Its initial platform,\n\n  Gotham, organizes and evaluates large, complex, and disparate datasets, and is used to\n\n  design software for Palantir\u2019s government clients. Historically, the vast majority of Palantir\u2019s\n\n  customers were government clients.            In 2016, Palantir launched Foundry to attract\n\n  commercial clients. According to Palantir, Foundry is designed to link disparate and largely\n\n  incompatible data sources into a central operating system. Following Foundry\u2019s launch,\n\n  Palantir grew its commercial client base such that, by 2020, the Company reported that\n\n  53% of its revenue was derived from commercial clients.\n\n          27.         For many years Defendants resisted taking Palantir public, as Karp told The\n\n  New York Times in May 2014 that doing so would be \u201c\u2018corrosive to our culture, corrosive to\n\n  our outcomes.\u2019\u201d At that time, Karp had long held options to purchase 68.9 million shares of\n\n  Palantir Class B common stock, which options were set to expire on December 3, 2021. If\n\n  Karp did not exercise the options before their expiration date he would lose all the shares.\n\n          28.         Karp\u2019s opinion on going public changed as the December 2021 expiration\n\n  date on his options drew close. As a private company, Palantir shares were illiquid and\n\n  subject to an \u201cilliquidity\u201d discount, trading between $4.50 and $6.50 per share in the private\n\n  markets in 2019 and 2020. In order to exercise their options and dispose of their Palantir\n                                           -7-\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   58\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 13 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  shares at lucrative prices, Karp and the other Individual Defendants needed access to a\n\n  public market. In July 2020, Palantir announced a proposed public offering of its shares.6\n\n  This required the consent of Karp, Thiel, and Cohen \u2013 as they occupied three of the\n\n  Company\u2019s four Board seats when the decision was made to go public.\n\n          29.         On September 30, 2020, Palantir went public via a direct listing.7 In a direct\n\n  listing, the Company does not raise any capital. Instead, existing shares are sold by\n\n  Company insiders at whatever price the market will bear without underwriting. Utilizing a\n\n  direct listing allowed Defendants to avoid the scrutiny and due diligence review that occurs\n\n  in connection with a traditional IPO.\n\n          30.         As a private company, Palantir consistently reported net losses each year\n\n  since inception, culminating with a 2019 net loss of $580 million. Accordingly, to attain a\n\n  high valuation, Defendants knew they had to demonstrate that Palantir was poised to post\n\n  a profit, which meant sustaining its recent revenue growth and reporting improving\n\n  6\n      Following Palantir\u2019s July 2020 announcement that it would go public, the Company saw\n  its share prices increase to $11.50 per share during 3Q20 (through September 1, 2020).\n  This is consistent with the fact that an illiquidity discount is generally reduced when there is\n  a probability of the company going public in the future.\n  7\n      On August 25, 2020, Palantir filed with the SEC a registration statement on Form S-1,\n  which was followed by several amendments, the last of which was filed with the SEC on\n  September 21, 2020 (the \u201cFinal Registration Statement\u201d). The Final Registration Statement\n  became effective on September 22, 2020. That same day, Palantir also filed with the SEC\n  a registration statement on Form S-8 (the \u201cForm S-8\u201d). On September 30, 2020, the first\n  day of the Class Period, the Company filed with the SEC a final prospectus on Form 424B4\n  (the \u201cProspectus\u201d), which was updated via a prospectus supplement filed with the SEC on\n  November 13, 2020 (the \u201cProspectus Supplement\u201d). The Form S-8, Prospectus, and\n  Prospectus Supplement were each incorporated into and formed part of the Final\n  Registration Statement. The Final Registration Statement, Form S-8, Prospectus, and\n  Prospectus Supplement are collectively referred to herein as the \u201cRegistration Statement.\u201d\n\n\n                                                   -8-\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    59\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 14 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  operating efficiencies. Capitalizing on the fact that Palantir had just posted 49% 1H20\n\n  revenue growth and significant margin expansion over the same period the prior year\n\n  (\u201cyear-over-year\u201d or \u201cYoY\u201d), Defendants misleadingly underscored these results as\n\n  indicative of the growth investors could expect from Palantir as a public company.\n\n          31.         But Palantir\u2019s growth story was a fiction. As Defendants were aware it would,\n\n  Palantir\u2019s revenue growth rate decelerated beginning in 2021 as the Company\u2019s short-term\n\n  COVID-19 contracts rolled off. Palantir\u2019s government revenue growth rate peaked in 4Q20\n\n  (which began the day after Palantir went public) and sequentially declined in every\n\n  subsequent quarter, while Palantir\u2019s organic commercial revenue growth rate (i.e., ex-\n\n  SPAC growth) significantly dropped in 4Q20 and failed to meaningfully recover.\n\n          32.         Defendants used a two-pronged approach to conceal Palantir\u2019s declining\n\n  growth rates. First, in violation of Rule 10b-5(a) and (c), Defendants devised and executed\n\n  a scheme to create the appearance of continued robust high-margin growth. In furtherance\n\n  of the scheme, Defendants caused Palantir to invest in early-stage companies in quid pro\n\n  quo exchanges for these companies signing contracts for Palantir\u2019s products and services\n\n  that the companies neither needed nor could afford (the \u201cSPAC Scheme\u201d), a move Citibank\n\n  would later describe as \u201cnefarious.\u201d          Defendants further masked Palantir\u2019s declining\n\n  performance by continually manipulating how they reported Palantir\u2019s key metrics. Second,\n\n  in violation of Rule 10b-5(b), Defendants issued a series of materially false and misleading\n\n  statements and omitted material facts concerning Palantir\u2019s performance and operations.\n\n  The purpose of Defendants\u2019 fraudulent conduct was to take Palantir public through a direct\n\n  listing and artificially pump up the price of Palantir stock, so that the Individual Defendants\n\n                                                   -9-\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    60\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 15 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  could cash out billions of dollars by selling their own Palantir shares.\n\n          A.          Defendants Misrepresent the Efficiencies of Palantir Software\n\n          33.         Software companies whose products require significant amounts of high-cost\n\n  customization and professional services typically have low margins and correspondingly\n\n  command low valuation multiples. In contrast, software companies with high margins that\n\n  provide software as a service (or \u201cSaaS\u201d) with little additional marginal cost \u2013 i.e., plug-and-\n\n  play systems \u2013 command far higher valuation multiples. To command a higher valuation\n\n  multiple, Defendants had to misleadingly portray Palantir as having left behind the days of\n\n  creating custom software products. Thus, when taking Palantir public, Defendants claimed\n\n  that Palantir had \u201cSAAS like economics regardless of [its] deployment target\u201d and as a\n\n  result was enjoying significantly improved efficiencies and margins.\n\n                      1.    Defendants Misleadingly Portray Palantir as a \u201cSaaS-\n                            like\u201d Company in Connection with the Offering\n\n          34.         Starting at the September 9, 2020 Investor Day presentation, Defendants\n\n  strained mightily to portray Palantir as a highly-efficient, high margin SaaS-like company,\n\n  rather than a low margin service or consulting company:\n\n          [Sankar:] Apollo is really important because it enables us to have SAAS\n          like economics regardless of our deployment target.8\n\n\n  8\n      Plaintiffs allege both \u201cscheme liability\u201d under Rules 10b-5(a) and (c) and \u201cmisstatement\n  liability\u201d under Rule 10b-5(b). The statements in bold italics, the statements and figures\n  referenced in nn.12-14, 20, 23, 25-26, 29, and 35-36, and the figures presented in charts in\n  \u00b6\u00b6104, 107, 110, 112, 114, 116, and 128 are alleged to be materially false and misleading\n  as bases for the Rule 10b-5(b) misstatement claim. The scheme allegations under Rule\n  10b-5(a) and (c) are based both on these statements and the additional deceptive acts\n  alleged herein.\n\n\n                                                 - 10 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   61\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 16 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n                                             *      *      *\n\n          [Glazer:] So while it\u2019s true in the past that we did custom development\n          work, and built bespoke applications, we aren\u2019t doing that today.\n\n          35.         The statements detailed in \u00b634 were false and misleading when made as\n\n  Palantir was, in fact, still building \u201cbespoke applications,\u201d engaged in \u201ccustom development\n\n  work,\u201d and did not \u201chave SAAS like economics regardless of [its] deployment target.\u201d\n\n  Palantir\u2019s Gotham and Foundry products rarely fit into a customer\u2019s workplace straight \u201cout\n\n  of the box.\u201d Instead, Palantir was undertaking a lengthy, expensive, and highly-customized\n\n  process to secure client contracts and build out software solutions. This entailed creating a\n\n  need for the product, convincing a client they needed Palantir\u2019s expensive software,\n\n  building it to the identified use, and closing a deal \u2013 all at low or no-cost to the prospective\n\n  client (a \u201cpilot\u201d). Pilot deployments typically lasted months, during which time Palantir\n\n  engineers had to rework or adapt a preexisting product, or build something new altogether.\n\n  Foundry is not a SaaS-like software product with a predefined function, but rather a set of\n\n  digital infrastructure tools which engineers use to build a bespoke product or \u201cuse case\u201d\n\n  themselves. Indeed, five days after the Class Period ended (and after Defendants\n\n  unloaded billions of dollars\u2019 worth of their own Palantir shares), Sankar admitted that\n\n  Palantir had been building bespoke applications all along. Distinguishing Palantir from\n\n  \u201c\u2018most software companies [that] just want to sell software, generic software that they sell\n\n  broadly to large swaths of the market\u2019\u201d (i.e., SaaS-like companies), Sankar described\n\n  Palantir\u2019s products as \u201c\u2018more like a grab bag from a leg[o] box that we can use to assemble\n\n  the right product for the customer \u2013 to custom build their product today and in the future.\u2019\u201d\n\n          36.         To support their portrayal of Palantir as a SaaS-like Company with improved\n                                                    - 11 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   62\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 17 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  efficiencies, Defendants highlighted recent improvements in the Company\u2019s contribution\n\n  margin at the September 9, 2020 Investor Day presentation, stating:\n\n          [Kawasaki:] And as you can see, here, we\u2019re getting much more efficient,\n          our contribution margins have increased nearly four times since the\n          first quarter of 2019.\n\n                                             *      *      *\n\n          [Glazer:] Our contracts are generally fixed fee our customers pay us for the\n          all in cost to deliver, maintain and service these platforms. And we continue\n          to do this more and more efficiently as our products have matured, and\n          adoption across our customer base has increased. To measure this\n          efficiency, we look to our margins. . . . As gross margin has increased,\n          contribution margin is also improving, due to the improvements in our\n          platform, and the fact that we still have a relatively small salesforce.\n\n          37.         With respect to the Company\u2019s \u201cAcquire, Expand, Scale\u201d business model (see\n\n  infra, \u00b6\u00b6164-168), Kawasaki stressed that the Company had the capability to get all its\n\n  customers to the high-revenue, high-margin \u201cScale\u201d phase over time: \u201cWhen we look at\n\n  this as a whole, all customers should be scale phase over time.\u201d\n\n          38.         The Registration Statement (signed by Karp, Cohen, Thiel, and Glazer and\n\n  declared effective on September 22, 2020) similarly sought to portray Palantir as a highly-\n\n  efficient company with increasing margins and lower deployment times:\n\n          The improvements in our operating results have principally been driven\n          by increasing revenue and a significant decrease in the time and number\n          of software engineers required to install and deploy our software\n          platforms.\n\n          In particular, the time required to install our software and begin working\n          with a customer has decreased more than five-fold since Q2 2019 to an\n          average of 14 days in Q2 2020. In some cases, our customers can now\n          be up and running in six hours.\n\n          39.         The Registration Statement also stated that all customers will Scale:\n\n\n                                                  - 12 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   63\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 18 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          We believe that all of our customers will move into the Scale phase over\n          the long term. We also believe that contribution margin for Scale phase\n          accounts will increase further as we become more efficient at deploying\n          our software platforms across the entirety of our customers\u2019 operations\n          and at managing and operating our software.\n\n          40.         Defendants\u2019 statements in \u00b6\u00b636-39 emphasizing Palantir\u2019s margin growth and\n\n  attributing it to product improvements and increased operational efficiencies were materially\n\n  misleading. Defendants were aware that Palantir\u2019s historical margin improvement could not\n\n  continue, because in order to post the growth rate that Defendants led the market to\n\n  expect, Palantir had to quickly pivot to industries in which it had never operated. As\n\n  Defendants acknowledged in the Registration Statement, \u201c[c]ontinue[d] expansion into the\n\n  commercial sector\u201d was critical to Palantir\u2019s growth. Yet, Palantir\u2019s software was not easily\n\n  adaptable outside of its established \u201cuse cases.\u201d9 Rather, its software was expensive and\n\n  required substantial customization for each client. To land customers in new industries,\n\n  Palantir had to provide prospective clients with a pilot test run at low or no cost, during\n\n  which Palantir was compelled to invest substantial time, money, and manpower finding a\n\n  use for its software and then building a bespoke product to suit that use. Coupled with the\n\n  highly-customized nature and high cost of Palantir\u2019s software, this meant signing new\n\n  commercial customers was much more difficult, and closing deals was far more costly to\n\n  Palantir than its existing commercial customers. Moreover, Palantir\u2019s expansion to new\n\n\n\n\n  9\n      Palantir\u2019s established \u201cuse cases\u201d involved government entities and a limited number of\n  large commercial applications, like the Skywise program used by the airline industry.\n\n\n                                                 - 13 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   64\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 19 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  industries and customers required a costly buildout of the Company\u2019s sales force.10 And\n\n  the substantial decreases in travel and office costs that Palantir experienced in FY20 due to\n\n  COVID-19 were not indicative of normal operating costs.11 Thus, all the foreseeable costs\n\n  associated with Palantir\u2019s commercial expansion efforts would (and did) result in much\n\n  lower margins than those the Company experienced prior to the Offering.\n\n          41.         A typical pilot began with initial conversations between leadership at the\n\n  potential client and a Palantir \u201cLeverage\u201d staff member. Leverage staff were responsible\n\n  for bringing in potential clients, convincing them to do a pilot, and closing the deal. A c-\n\n  suite Palantir executive would also speak with a member of the potential client\u2019s leadership,\n\n  to discuss software needs. These initial conversations could last months and involve\n\n  dozens of meetings, during which the Palantir employees had to find a reason why a\n\n  potential client needed Palantir\u2019s software. Moreover, to even begin conducting a pilot and\n\n  building out \u201cuse cases,\u201d Palantir would need access to a potential client\u2019s data. This would\n\n  often require the negotiation of non-disclosure agreements, and often companies would\n\n  decline to proceed with a pilot simply because they did not wish to share their data.\n\n          42.         When a provisional contract was signed, however, Palantir went to work on a\n\n  pilot. Pilots generally lasted three months but could last much longer for large clients. A\n\n  10\n      Karp acknowledged in February 2021 that Palantir was in the midst of an effort to more\n  than double its direct sales force. Palantir reported over $114 million of incremental costs\n  attributable to increased sales and marketing headcount in FY21 and FY22.\n  11\n      Palantir\u2019s FY20 results reported $189.9 million of adjusted operating profit \u2013 over $132\n  million (70%) of which was the result of temporary travel and office cost reductions due to\n  COVID-19. In contrast, Palantir\u2019s FY22 results called out approximately $94 million of\n  increased travel and office expenses as these temporary reductions were reversed.\n\n\n                                                  - 14 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   65\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 20 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  Palantir pilot team typically comprised seven or eight employees, but could be as large as\n\n  50. This team included two leads, one from business development and one from product\n\n  development. Once a contract was signed, the team would expend substantial time on the\n\n  product the prospective client had agreed to try. At minimum, this consisted of reworking or\n\n  adapting a preexisting product for the client. Other times, the engineering team had to\n\n  design and build completely new features. The product, built on Foundry\u2019s foundation, was\n\n  essentially a number of bricks. Each brick was a different Palantir product. It was the\n\n  engineering team\u2019s job to try to rearrange the bricks into the shape the customer wanted.\n\n          43.         Closing a deal at Palantir was challenging because the products Palantir sold\n\n  were expensive and difficult to implement. Contrary to Defendants\u2019 public representations,\n\n  it was not possible to simply throw someone the keys to a Palantir product and say \u201cdrive.\u201d\n\n  Also, the pilot deployment process itself was time-consuming and expensive. Even after\n\n  the pilot process, Palantir regularly failed to convert customers to longer-term contracts.\n\n          44.         Because of all this, Palantir\u2019s operations were far less efficient than\n\n  represented and its recent margin growth was unsustainable. Furthermore, Defendants\n\n  also had no good faith basis to believe, and did not actually believe, their statements in\n\n  \u00b6\u00b637 and 39 that \u201call of [Palantir\u2019s] customers will move into the Scale phase over the long\n\n  term,\u201d as that was not the case historically and had become even more difficult as the\n\n  Company expanded into new markets and industries.\n\n          45.         Yet investors were swayed by Defendants\u2019 assurances. A September 22,\n\n  2020 Seeking Alpha article titled \u201cBullish On Palantir As It Is Just Beginning To Monetize Its\n\n  Platforms\u201d parroted Defendants\u2019 claims and highlighted that \u201cthe numbers tell a positive\n\n                                                  - 15 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    66\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 21 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  story, with contribution margins rising sharply and consistently every quarter.\u201d\n\n          46.         The statements at Investor Day and in the Registration Statement described\n\n  in \u00b6\u00b634, 36-39 above were all made in connection with (and to solicit interest in) the\n\n  Offering, and remained live in the market throughout the Class Period.\n\n                      2.    Defendants Continued to Misrepresent Palantir\u2019s\n                            Operational Efficiencies After the Offering\n\n          47.         Beginning with Palantir\u2019s November 13, 2020 3Q20 Form 10-Q (signed by\n\n  Karp and Glazer), Defendants repeatedly claimed that: \u201c[C]ustomers are increasingly\n\n  adopting our software, which can be ready in days, over internal software development\n\n  efforts, which may take months or years.\u201d12\n\n          48.         These statements were false and misleading when made. Most Palantir\n\n  software could not be \u201cready in days,\u201d but rather took months to develop and install for new\n\n  customers. Supra, \u00b6\u00b635, 40-43. Further, from 1Q21 onward, many of the Company\u2019s new\n\n  commercial customers adopted Palantir solely due to SPAC swap deals, not because\n\n  Palantir reduced timelines for developing internal software solutions. Infra, \u00a7IV.B.\n\n          49.         During Palantir\u2019s February 16, 2021 FY20 earnings call, Defendants\n\n  emphasized Palantir\u2019s increasing margins and efficiency in obtaining new customers:\n\n          [Glazer:] This rapid scaling and expanding contribution margin\n          demonstrates the increasing efficiency of our customer acquisition and\n\n  12\n      This statement was repeated in Palantir\u2019s: (i) February 26, 2021 FY20 Form 10-K\n  (signed by Karp, Glazer, Cohen, and Thiel); (ii) May 12, 2021 1Q21 Form 10-Q (signed by\n  Karp and Glazer); (iii) August 12, 2021 2Q21 Form 10-Q (signed by Karp and Glazer); (iv)\n  November 9, 2021 3Q21 Form 10-Q (signed by Karp and Glazer); (v) February 24, 2022\n  FY21 Form 10-K (signed by Karp, Glazer, Cohen, and Thiel); and (vi) May 9, 2022 1Q22\n  Form 10-Q (signed by Karp and Glazer).\n\n\n                                                 - 16 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   67\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 22 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          onboarding process, which we believe will help fuel an expanding\n          pipeline into 2021 and beyond.\n\n          50.         During the Q&A portion of the call, Sankar highlighted both the purported\n\n  deployment speeds and \u201cmodularity\u201d of Palantir\u2019s software:\n\n          [Sankar:] [W]ith a few clicks you can deploy end-to-end powerful use\n          cases. Use cases that would have cost millions of dollars and taken\n          many months can now be deployed in minutes.\n\n          It\u2019s about software-defined data integration and modularity. That\n          means that you get 100% of the power of Palantir, but with the ease of\n          self-managing software. And these are examples of why we\u2019re confident in\n          our long-term growth of being greater than $4 billion in 2025.\n\n          51.         In response to a separate question on the call, Kawasaki similarly touted the\n\n  \u201cautomat[ed] . . . delivery of Foundry\u201d with \u201cdrag and drop\u201d use cases:\n\n          [Kawasaki:] Shyam just talked about how our TAM is expanding. But we\u2019re\n          automating the delivery of Foundry. This means you can have full end-\n          to-end use cases with no code, just drag and drop. And the result of this\n          is that we can deliver the full power of our products, the small, medium\n          and, of course, large institutions.\n\n          52.         Beginning with Palantir\u2019s August 12, 2021 2Q21 Form 10-Q (signed by Karp\n\n  and Glazer), Defendants also repeatedly claimed that faster deployment times had\n\n  expanded the realm of potential customers, stating:\n\n          Our software platforms can now be installed and ready for use within\n          hours. The speed with which our platforms can be deployed has\n          significantly expanded the range of potential customers with which we\n          plan on partnering over the long term. We anticipate that our reach\n          among an increasingly broad set of customers, in both the commercial\n          and government sectors, will accelerate moving forward.13\n\n\n\n  13\n     This statement was repeated in Palantir\u2019s November 9, 2021 3Q21 Form 10-Q (signed\n  by Karp and Glazer). It was also repeated without the first sentence in Palantir\u2019s\n\n                                                  - 17 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    68\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 23 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          53.         Contrary to Defendants\u2019 statements in \u00b6\u00b649-52 exalting Palantir\u2019s operational\n\n  efficiencies, acquiring and onboarding new customers was not a process that took only\n\n  \u201chours,\u201d \u201cdays,\u201d or \u201ca few clicks\u201d \u2013 but instead was a lengthy, time-consuming, and costly\n\n  process, and Palantir had to incur far greater costs to close new deals than it spent on\n\n  existing commercial customers. Supra, \u00b6\u00b635, 40-43.\n\n          54.         Glazer\u2019s statements in \u00b649 attributing Palantir\u2019s recent margin growth to\n\n  increased efficiencies were materially misleading. Glazer knew Palantir\u2019s success with its\n\n  established clients could not translate into the same efficiencies with its \u201ccommercial\n\n  expansion\u201d to new customers, as its software customization efforts increased and pilot\n\n  deployments failed more frequently when the deployments were in new industries, causing\n\n  deterioration in Palantir\u2019s margins. Supra, \u00b6\u00b635, 40-43; infra, \u00b6102.\n\n          55.         The statements in \u00b6\u00b650-52 that Palantir had automated the delivery of \u201cdrag\n\n  and drop\u201d Foundry use cases to a \u201cfew clicks\u201d leading to an expansion of \u201cthe range of\n\n  potential customers\u201d were materially misleading, as the \u201cdrag and drop\u201d use of Foundry was\n\n  primarily limited to SPAC customers (see infra, \u00b6\u00b678,103) and was not broadly applicable\n\n  to Palantir\u2019s traditional commercial customer base. To the contrary, as explained infra, the\n\n  SPAC transactions were sham deals obtained outside of Palantir\u2019s normal customer\n\n  acquisition process; and because the SPACs badly needed Palantir\u2019s cash but not its\n\n  product, they did not receive a standard (highly customized) Foundry product.\n\n\n\n  February 24, 2022 FY21 Form 10-K (signed by Karp, Glazer, Cohen, and Thiel) and May 9,\n  2022 1Q22 Form 10-Q (signed by Karp and Glazer).\n\n\n                                                  - 18 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    69\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 24 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          B.          Defendants Implement the SPAC Scheme to Mask Stagnation\n                      in Palantir\u2019s Business by Purchasing High-Margin Revenue\n\n          56.         At the time of the Offering, Defendants defined Palantir\u2019s \u201cpotential\n\n  customers\u201d in the commercial sector as companies with more than $500 million in recurring\n\n  annual revenue. They did so because most early-stage companies did not need and could\n\n  not afford Palantir, as its products are expensive to purchase and difficult to implement.\n\n          57.         By early 2021, market participants expressed concern about Palantir\u2019s\n\n  slowing growth from commercial customers after the Company reported 4Q20 YoY\n\n  commercial revenue growth of just 4%. Defendants were well aware of this deceleration at\n\n  the time of the Offering and frequently confirmed their \u201cstrong visibility into future revenues\n\n  across [Palantir\u2019s] customer base.\u201d Infra, \u00b6125. The decelerating commercial revenue\n\n  growth was particularly significant because Palantir\u2019s continued expansion into the\n\n  commercial sector was a key growth driver. Supra, \u00b640. As Morningstar summarized in\n\n  August 2021: \u201c[M]omentum in commercial is key to the long-term opportunity for Palantir.\u201d\n\n          58.         Because Palantir\u2019s actual growth and margin trends were inconsistent with\n\n  Defendants\u2019 public representations, the Individual Defendants abruptly pivoted away from\n\n  Palantir\u2019s publicly-stated \u201cpotential customers\u201d and implemented the SPAC Scheme to\n\n  foster an illusion of improved revenue and margin growth \u2013 further inflating Palantir\u2019s stock\n\n  price while they were selling their shares. In executing the SPAC Scheme, Defendants\n\n  resorted to the outright purchase of revenue via 20+ sham transactions with early-stage,\n\n  low- to no-revenue and/or barely solvent companies looking to be acquired by SPACs.\n\n  Palantir invested or committed to invest approximately $400 million in these deals. And in\n\n  exchange, each SPAC signed multiyear, multimillion-dollar contracts for Palantir software\n                                        - 19 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                  70\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 25 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  which they were too nascent to need or afford. The value of these deals often dwarfed the\n\n  potential SPAC\u2019s annual revenue, with some agreements obligating the SPACs to\n\n  immediately return up to 75% of Palantir\u2019s \u201cinvestment\u201d back to Palantir.\n\n          59.         Defendants knew that Palantir was unlikely to receive a substantial portion of\n\n  the revenue contracted for under this scheme because the SPACs Palantir targeted were\n\n  early-stage businesses that could not afford Palantir software. In fact, the total amount due\n\n  to Palantir under each contract exceeded the target SPAC\u2019s annual revenue, and most\n\n  contracts cost the SPAC between $7 million and $10 million a year for five or six years. In\n\n  addition, Palantir completed due diligence of each SPAC before closing each transaction,\n\n  and the Individual Defendants were personally involved in negotiating the SPAC deals.\n\n  Shortly after each deal closed, Palantir had as much information about the SPACs as the\n\n  SPACs themselves, as Foundry was, in Defendants\u2019 own words, the \u201csingle source of truth\u201d\n\n  for its customers. In fact, according to Defendants, Foundry would \u201cunlock\u201d a \u201cdigital twin\u201d\n\n  of each company\u2019s \u201centire enterprise\u201d and customer data in \u201chours,\u201d even \u201cminutes,\u201d after\n\n  installation and in \u201creal time.\u201d Sankar boasted: \u201c[A]s a consequence of simply integrating\n\n  your data into foundry, you now have a digital twin of your entire enterprise.\u201d\n\n          60.         Wejo, Boxed, Pear Therapeutics, Fast Radius, Starry Group, Babylon, and\n\n  Bird Global are all bankrupt; Tritium is insolvent; Faraday Future trades at $1.19, Sarcos at\n\n  $1.93, Rubicon at $0.22, Celularity at $3.47, Rigetti at $1.06, AdTheorent at $3.18, Lilium at\n\n  $1.06, Blacksky at $1.13, Allego at $0.95, and Energy Vault at $1.17; and Embark Trucks,\n\n  now privately owned after being taken private at $2.88 per share. That almost all of the\n\n  SPACs Palantir \u201cpartnered\u201d with have declined to worthless or near-worthless status further\n\n                                                   - 20 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    71\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 26 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  confirms what Defendants were aware of at the time Palantir entered the SPAC deals and\n\n  when they spoke \u2013 that the SPACs were not legitimate, long-term customers.\n\n                      1.    Defendants Mischaracterize Palantir\u2019s Business\n                            Strategy\n\n          61.         The Individual Defendants conceived the SPAC Scheme prior to the Offering\n\n  and described in the Registration Statement (signed by Karp, Cohen, Thiel, and Glazer and\n\n  effective September 22, 2020) Palantir\u2019s intent to enter into \u201cstrategic transactions\u201d and\n\n  \u201cinvestments,\u201d while failing to disclose their true nature:\n\n          As part of our business strategy, we have engaged in strategic transactions\n          in the past and expect to evaluate and consider potential strategic\n          transactions, including acquisitions of, or investments in, businesses,\n          technologies, services, products and other assets in the future. We\n          also may enter into relationships with other businesses to expand our\n          products or our ability to provide services.14\n\n          62.         Defendants knew the statements in \u00b661 were materially misleading, as\n\n  Defendants\u2019 true business strategy was not predicated on \u201cstrategic transactions,\u201d\n\n  \u201cacquisitions,\u201d or \u201cinvestments\u201d but instead on the undisclosed SPAC Scheme. While the\n\n  first SPAC deal was finalized in March 2021, these deals were high-dollar transactions (with\n\n  both sides typically assisted by bankers and/or lawyers) whose negotiations were typically\n\n  conducted over a three to four month period. Thus, Defendants began to execute the\n\n  SPAC Scheme in 4Q20 and had planned it at the time of the Offering, as demonstrated by\n\n  the Registration Statement\u2019s use of the very same language \u2013 i.e., the \u201cstrategic investment\n\n  14\n      Defendants repeated this statement in Palantir\u2019s November 13, 2020 3Q20 Form 10-Q\n  (signed by Karp and Glazer), and continued to do so after they began executing the SPAC\n  Scheme in Palantir\u2019s February 26, 2021 FY20 Form 10-K (signed by Karp, Glazer, Cohen,\n  and Thiel) and May 12, 2021 1Q21 Form 10-Q (signed by Karp and Glazer).\n\n\n                                                 - 21 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                  72\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 27 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  program\u201d (see infra, \u00b6\u00b683, 88) \u2013 Defendants used for the SPACs.15\n\n                      2.    Defendants Mislead About the Legitimacy and\n                            Sustainability of the SPAC Deals\n\n          63.         Palantir executed its first SPAC deal in March 2021, but did not disclose\n\n  anything about the deals until May 2021. When Defendants did begin to disclose certain\n\n  aspects of Palantir\u2019s SPAC transactions, they misleadingly portrayed the SPAC Scheme as\n\n  a sustainable \u201clong-term strategy\u201d involving \u201clong-term\u201d contracts with \u201ccompelling\n\n  businesses.\u201d\n\n                            a.     First Stage SPACs: Defendants Mischaracterize\n                                   the SPACs\u2019 Use of Foundry\n\n          64.         Prior to May 11, 2021, Palantir entered into at least four roundtrip SPAC\n\n  deals, buying approximately $171 million in future revenue in exchange for $112 million in\n\n  PIPE funding (collectively, the \u201cFirst Stage SPACs\u201d):\n\n  \uf0b7       Lilium: $41 million on or around March 28, 2021, in exchange for a 5-year, $50\n          million Foundry subscription (approximately 1,000 times Lilium\u2019s 2021 revenue);\n\n  \uf0b7       Sarcos: $21 million on or around April 4, 2021 in exchange for a 6-year, $42 million\n          Foundry subscription (over 8 times Sarcos\u2019s 2021 revenue);\n\n  \uf0b7       Roivant Sciences: $30 million on or around May 1, 2021 in exchange for a 5-year,\n          $39 million Foundry subscription (nearly double Roivant\u2019s 2021 revenue); and\n\n  \uf0b7       Celularity: $20 million on or around May 5, 2021, in exchange for a 5-year, $40\n          million Foundry subscription (nearly double Celularity\u2019s 2021 revenue).\n\n\n  15\n      Throughout the Class Period, Defendants\u2019 use of the phrase \u201cstrategic transactions\u201d or\n  \u201cstrategic investments\u201d referred solely to the SPAC deals. Indeed, the very same statement\n  in \u00b661 describing \u201cstrategic transactions\u201d was amended to include a reference to \u201cspecial\n  purpose acquisition companies\u201d when Defendants began to disclose certain limited aspects\n  of the SPAC investments in Palantir\u2019s May 12, 2021 1Q21 Form 10-Q.\n\n\n                                                 - 22 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                  73\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 28 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          65.         During the May 11, 2021 1Q21 earnings call, Sankar repeatedly sought to\n\n  portray Palantir\u2019s SPAC customers as companies that had a legitimate use for Foundry:\n\n          [Sankar:] And it\u2019s not just established industry players where we are\n          winning, we are seeing opportunities for companies to build their digital\n          infrastructure around Foundry from day 0 where they can shave years\n          off their ramps and mountains of risk off their road maps by cost\n          efficiently standing on the shoulders of 15 years and more than $2\n          billion of R&D. And we see this as the first salvo in expanding\n          distribution of Foundry to broader markets and a broader set of\n          customers.\n\n          In Q1, we entered into a partnership with Lilium, a revolutionary eVTOL\n          transportation company that will use Foundry to build an integrated\n          business from the ground up, incorporating design and engineering,\n          procurement, testing, production, quality, logistics and in-service\n          operations. We have also partnered with Sarcos.\n\n          We have always talked about Gotham as the digital Iron Man suit. Well,\n          these guys, they\u2019re building the physical Iron Man suit. Sarcos will leverage\n          Foundry for all of Palantir\u2019s well-understood industrials and\n          manufacturing use cases . . . . These customers and even more\n          prospects in our pipeline are at the forefront of the next major sea change\n          software . . . .\n\n          We are investing in innovation in the west, backing companies with\n          ambitious goals and executing on our ability to move down market.\n          And the fit is natural, our software can radically accelerate production\n          ramps and time to market and help these companies get to scale on\n          dramatically shorter time horizons.\n\n          66.         Sankar reiterated that these companies would build their manufacturing\n\n  operations around Foundry from \u201cday 0\u201d:\n\n          [Sankar:] And here, we see a unique opportunity with ambitious\n          companies to invest in both compelling management teams and\n          compelling businesses and to partner with them on using our software\n          from day 0. These are folks that are focused on winning. . . .\n\n          They viscerally understand the value of buying the best operating\n          system for their enterprise, shaving years and mountains of risk off\n          their road map. . . . Overall, we think this is a really compelling opportunity\n                                                - 23 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                 74\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 29 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          to accelerate our business, to accelerate our distribution and to bet on our\n          customers.\n\n                                             *      *      *\n\n          And I call out companies like Lilium and Sarcos again that are going to\n          build their operations around Foundry from day 0, using Foundry for\n          ERP, CRM, manufacturing execution, for quality and much more.\n\n          67.         Analysts noted Palantir\u2019s SPAC statements, with Morgan Stanley reporting in\n\n  its May 12, 2021 analyst report that Palantir added \u201c11 new commercial customers,\u201d was\n\n  positioned for \u201cdurable 30% growth ahead,\u201d and had a \u201c[m]ore [d]urable [g]rowth [p]rofile.\u201d\n\n          68.         In reality, Defendants knew the SPACs detailed in \u00b664 above were too\n\n  nascent to need Palantir\u2019s software for operations and/or lacked the revenue or commercial\n\n  prospects to legitimately afford the longer duration Palantir subscription contracts. These\n\n  SPACs were not positioned to meaningfully utilize Foundry as they were all suffering huge\n\n  operating losses in 2021 at the time the PIPE deals were signed and were on track for\n\n  2021 losses of $1 billion (Roivant), over \u20ac400 million (Lilium), over $109 million (Celularity),\n\n  and approximately $81 million (Sarcos). These losses were not one-offs. Rather, Palantir\n\n  was ultimately forced to sell approximately 90% of its $40 million Lilium investment at a\n\n  50%-80% loss, and Lilium, Celularity, and Sarcos received notices warning they would be\n\n  delisted from Nasdaq, with Sarcos issuing a 1-for-6 reverse stock split to avoid that fate.\n\n  Thus, contrary to Defendants\u2019 statements in \u00b6\u00b665-66, the SPACs Palantir contracted with\n\n  were not \u201ccompelling businesses\u201d ready to \u201cbuild their operations around Foundry from day\n\n  0\u201d and to use Foundry for legitimate manufacturing or commercialization purposes.\n\n          69.         For example, Lilium was not positioned to use Foundry for \u201cmanufacturing\n\n  execution.\u201d Lilium had asserted it could make a battery-powered aircraft fly longer and with\n                                                  - 24 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   75\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 30 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  heavier payloads than its competitors. In truth, it was impossible for Lilium to accomplish\n\n  its stated manufacturing goals absent a major breakthrough in battery technology and until\n\n  it achieved numerous difficult aviation certifications from regulators, and the SPAC did not\n\n  generate enough cash to commercially launch the jet.\n\n          70.         And Sarcos could not \u201cleverage Foundry for all of Palantir\u2019s well-understood\n\n  industrials and manufacturing use cases\u201d because its \u201cphysical Iron Man suit\u201d was (as\n\n  Sarcos later stated in its 3Q21 Form 10-Q) still a \u201cprototype\u201d and \u201cnot yet commercially\n\n  available.\u201d Later, in its 3Q22 Form 10-Q, Sarcos acknowledged: \u201cWe have no experience\n\n  to date in high volume manufacture of our products, nor do we have the facility, employees\n\n  or equipment needed to manufacture our products in high volumes.\u201d And ultimately, in\n\n  November 2023, Sarcos shut down all robotics hardware commercialization efforts.\n\n          71.         Further, the costs for Roivant, Celularity, Sarcos, and Lilium under their\n\n  Palantir contracts far exceeded each SPAC\u2019s annual revenue. Thus, the substantial\n\n  Palantir subscriptions further undermined the SPACs\u2019 commercial development by requiring\n\n  each to spend its modest resources on unnecessary and expensive software.\n\n          72.         The Individual Defendants knew their SPAC strategy was a key area of\n\n  interest for investors because they had to repeatedly field questions from analysts on the\n\n  1Q21 earnings call. Analysts asked Defendants to address \u201cthe motivation behind these\n\n  decisions\u201d to invest in the SPACs and how they \u201cview risk, investment size and potential\n\n  return.\u201d As explained in supra, \u00b659, Defendants knew from Palantir\u2019s SPAC due diligence\n\n  and installation data that the First Stage SPACs were largely nonviable and, therefore,\n\n  offered minimal potential revenue value. Nonetheless, Sankar, Glazer, and Kawasaki\n\n                                                  - 25 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   76\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 31 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  repeatedly provided misleading assurances in response, concealing that their motivation\n\n  was, in fact, to buy revenue for Palantir in order to conceal Palantir\u2019s declining metrics.\n\n          73.         Moreover, Defendants knew their statements in \u00b6\u00b665-66 concealed that\n\n  Defendants had already expanded the SPAC Scheme by arranging to manufacture more\n\n  high-margin revenue and illusory growth shortly after Palantir\u2019s May 11, 2021 earnings call\n\n  (infra, \u00b676). Because SPAC transactions typically were negotiated over multiple months\n\n  and involved bankers and/or lawyers on both sides, Defendants were negotiating most, if\n\n  not all, of the Second Stage SPAC deals (defined infra, \u00b676) when they convened the May\n\n  11, 2021 earnings call. Indeed, some of the deals were just days or weeks from closing.\n\n  Yet, during the May 11, 2021 call, Sankar obliquely referred only to \u201cprospects in our\n\n  pipeline,\u201d and in its 1Q21 Form 10-Q filed the next day, Palantir referenced only the four\n\n  First Stage SPAC deals while again concealing the massive SPAC Scheme expansion that\n\n  was underway. By concealing the full scope of the SPAC Scheme on the May 11, 2021\n\n  call, Defendants were able to extend it into subsequent quarters as they continued to cash\n\n  out via their insider trading.\n\n          74.         At the June 8, 2021 Annual Shareholders Meeting, Sankar cited the SPAC\n\n  deals as evidence of Palantir\u2019s product advancements and commercial market approach:\n\n          [Sankar:] [O]ne of the most humbling and exciting things we are seeing right\n          now is that a bunch of day zero, hyper growth start-ups, free of legacy\n          are choosing to build their offerings on top of our software. . . .\n\n          . . . To me, that\u2019s literally what an operating system is, it is very validating\n          of our end-to-end approach. It\u2019s allowed us to add extreme value over the\n          do-it-yourself custom build approaches. Or really, should I say, customers\n          are realizing that they can build on top of what they are buying with\n          foundry, and we expect to continue to make product investments here.\n\n                                                - 26 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                 77\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 32 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          75.         However, contrary to the statements in \u00b674 characterizing the SPAC sales as\n\n  a validation of Palantir\u2019s business model, Defendants knew Palantir\u2019s SPAC partners did\n\n  not have a legitimate need for Foundry and were not \u201cchoosing\u201d Palantir\u2019s software in order\n\n  to \u201cbuild their offerings\u201d \u2013 but were instead being paid to buy it. Rather than \u201cvalidating\u201d\n\n  Palantir\u2019s \u201cend-to-end approach,\u201d the SPAC deals were unsustainable one-off quid pro quo\n\n  transactions designed to enable Palantir to show high-margin revenue growth and only\n\n  occurred because of the SPACs\u2019 need for PIPE funding. See supra, \u00b6\u00b658, 64, 68-71; infra,\n\n  \u00b6\u00b678, 103.\n\n                             b.     Second Stage SPACs: Defendants Misrepresent\n                                    the Sustainability of the SPAC Scheme\n\n          76.         Following the May 11, 2021 call, Palantir bought approximately $212 million in\n\n  future revenue from at least nine different commercial clients in exchange for approximately\n\n  $200 million in PIPE funding (collectively the \u201cSecond Stage SPACs\u201d):\n\n  \uf0b7       Wejo: $35 million on or around May 28, 2021 in exchange for a 6-year, $50 million\n          Foundry subscription;\n\n  \uf0b7       Babylon Health: $35 million on or around June 3, 2021 (Foundry subscription\n          commitment undisclosed);\n\n  \uf0b7       Boxed: $20 million on or around June 13, 2021 in exchange for a $20 million, 5-year\n          Foundry subscription with $15 million payable within 30 days of closing;\n\n  \uf0b7       Pear Therapeutics: $10 million on or around June 21, 2021 in exchange for a 3-\n          year, $9.3 million Foundry subscription;\n\n  \uf0b7       Embark Trucks: $18 million on or around June 22, 2021 (Foundry subscription\n          commitment undisclosed);\n\n  \uf0b7       Fast Radius: $20 million on or around July 18, 2021 in exchange for a 6-year, $45\n          million Foundry subscription signed in May 2021 with nearly $10 million paid at\n          SPAC close in February 2022;\n\n                                                   - 27 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    78\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 33 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  \uf0b7       Tritium: $15 million on or around July 27, 2021 in exchange for a 5-year, $21 million\n          Foundry subscription;\n\n  \uf0b7       AdTheorent: $15 million on or around July 27, 2021 in exchange for a 5-year, $20\n          million Foundry subscription;\n\n  \uf0b7       Faraday Future: $25 million in or around July 2021 in exchange for a 6-year, $47\n          million Foundry subscription; and\n\n  \uf0b7       FinAccel: $10 million on or around August 2, 2021 (SPAC cancelled).16\n\n          77.         During Palantir\u2019s August 12, 2021 2Q21 earnings call, Sankar again asserted\n\n  that the SPACs\u2019 widespread use of Foundry was proof that the product was \u201cfor everyone\u201d:\n\n          [Sankar:] [W]hat we\u2019ve really proven over the last few quarters, and\n          that\u2019s really reflected in the tremendous growth of the commercial\n          customer count, 32% growth in Q2, is that Foundry is for everyone.\n\n                                             *      *      *\n\n          And these young guns, they see Foundry as an alternative to building\n          bespoke solutions in AWS or Azure or any other cloud. They need\n          software today that is ready for any tomorrow. Our software is that\n          enabling platform, and a growing number of companies from early stage to\n          newly public companies, they\u2019re pursuing that vision on Foundry. We refer to\n          these organizations as day 0 companies.\n\n          The innovation in our distribution is enabling us to partner with these\n          organizations across many industries as they build their offerings on\n          Foundry. For example, in biotech, Cellularity [sic] is leveraging our\n          experience in both pharma R&D and manufacturing to accelerate drug\n          development and set a new standard for cell-based therapies. Roivant\n          is drawing on the work that we\u2019ve done, spanning pharma companies like\n          Sanofi and Merck Group and public health platforms like N3C UNITE to pool\n\n  16\n      Defendants mentioned Wejo and Boxed by name on the August 12, 2021 2Q21\n  earnings call. Palantir\u2019s 2Q21 Form 10-Q, released the same day, disclosed Babylon\n  Health, Boxed, Pear Therapeutics, AdTheorent, FinAccel, Tritium, and Fast Radius by\n  name, but it described Embark Trucks as an \u201c[a]utonomous vehicle company\u201d and Faraday\n  Future as an \u201c[e]lectric vehicle company.\u201d Defendants did not disclose the names of these\n  latter two companies until six months later \u2013 in the February 24, 2022 FY21 Form 10-K.\n\n\n                                                  - 28 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   79\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 34 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          and share trial data with development partners and build out real-world\n          evidence capabilities to support key disease areas.\n\n          In automotive, Wejo is building a SaaS ecosystem [of] connected vehicle\n          data spanning use cases across OEMs, suppliers, insurers and\n          government authorities on top of foundry. In logistics, Box is building a\n          digital twin, incorporating both shipment and sales operations, spanning raw\n          materials all the way through to end customers, and just so much more.\n\n          We are making Foundry accessible to even more day 0 companies with\n          Foundry for Builders, a program which supports early-stage companies with\n          access to Foundry, allowing these companies to build their operations on\n          Foundry from the outset, enabling them not just to efficiently manage, but\n          actually to wield the increasing complexity of their growing businesses\n          to disrupt incumbents and to win in the marketplace.\n\n          [T]hese companies . . . are just founders, entrepreneurs and engineers\n          focused on winning, and they see Foundry as the best way to do that.\n\n          78.         Sankar\u2019s statements in \u00b677 above were materially false and misleading.\n\n  Defendants knew Foundry was not an \u201calternative to building bespoke solutions,\u201d but\n\n  instead required substantial costly customization for each client. Supra, \u00b6\u00b635, 40-43. The\n\n  partial, \u201cout of the box\u201d versions of Foundry that Palantir provided the SPACs were only a\n\n  pretext for quid pro quo arrangements, and were not broadly applicable to Palantir\u2019s normal\n\n  commercial customers. Nor was it \u201cinnovation in [Palantir\u2019s] distribution\u201d that enabled these\n\n  \u201cpartnerships,\u201d but instead Palantir\u2019s willingness to contemporaneously provide multimillion-\n\n  dollar PIPE funding that secured the deals.\n\n          79.         Defendants highlighted the SPACs as proof that \u201cFoundry is for everyone,\u201d\n\n  but far from establishing the viability and sustainability of commercial expansion, these\n\n  \u201ccustomers\u201d comprised a limited universe of financially-desperate companies willing to sign\n\n  Foundry subscriptions in exchange for a quick cash infusion. Indeed, these SPACs lacked\n\n  the revenue or commercial ability to even continue as \u201cgoing concerns\u201d \u2013 let alone afford\n                                                 - 29 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                  80\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 35 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  the longer duration Palantir subscription contracts.17              Five (Wejo, Boxed, Pear\n\n  Therapeutics, Fast Radius, and Babylon Health) are now bankrupt. A sixth, Tritium, is\n\n  insolvent.\n\n          80.         For example, Celularity was not leveraging Foundry or Palantir \u201cto accelerate\n\n  drug development.\u201d As Celularity founder Bob Hariri acknowledged \u2013 less than two weeks\n\n  after the deal \u2013 Celularity and its medicine were still \u201c\u2018in its infancy.\u2019\u201d In fact, Celularity\n\n  ultimately ceased using Palantir software because the software had never performed as\n\n  promised and Palantir failed to properly support the Foundry platform.\n\n          81.         Nor was Wejo building a SaaS ecosystem \u201con top of [F]oundry\u201d with \u201cuse\n\n  cases across OEMs, suppliers, insurers and government authorities.\u201d In reality, Palantir\u2019s\n\n  Foundry software was fundamentally incompatible with Wejo\u2019s technology and products.\n\n  Wejo was a company established to analyze and sell automotive data. And while Foundry\n\n  is an organizational tool for structuring data across varying data sets, the majority of Wejo\u2019s\n\n  operational data is of a single type \u2013 i.e., that from automakers (OEMs) like GM, Ford, and\n\n  Volkswagen. Moreover, due to legal restrictions, Wejo could not even put its data on\n\n  Palantir\u2019s platform without approval from the automakers, which they refused to give. Of\n\n  course Palantir, having a \u201cdigital twin\u201d of the platform (supra, \u00b659), knew that Wejo was\n\n  unable to upload the automaker data or meaningfully use the Foundry platform. For these\n\n  17\n      \u201cGoing concern\u201d is an accounting term used to indicate the belief that a company has\n  the resources needed to continue operating. Auditors of public companies are responsible\n  for evaluating whether there is substantial doubt as to the entity\u2019s ability to continue as a\n  going concern for a reasonable period of time, not to exceed one year beyond the date of\n  the financial statements being audited. Going concern doubts have been raised by\n  management and/or auditors of approximately 16 of the 20 SPACs Palantir partnered with.\n\n\n                                                  - 30 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    81\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 36 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  reasons, Wejo never developed any marketable products with Foundry, let alone an\n\n  \u201cecosystem [of] connected vehicle data.\u201d Ultimately, Wejo went bankrupt in summer 2023 \u2013\n\n  due in part to the outsized Foundry subscription that Wejo could not afford, but was\n\n  obligated to pay in exchange for Palantir\u2019s PIPE funding.\n\n          82.         And for Fast Radius, Foundry was not an \u201cenabling platform\u201d allowing it to be\n\n  \u201cready for any tomorrow,\u201d as Palantir insisted on an immediate $9.4 million upfront payment\n\n  from Fast Radius. Indeed, its extensive due diligence into Fast Radius, which Glazer\n\n  participated in, focused on Fast Radius\u2019s financing and cash positions for the coming 12\n\n  months. Tellingly, Fast Radius declared bankruptcy approximately nine months after\n\n  Palantir funded its investment.\n\n          83.         On the August 12, 2021 call, Glazer and Kawasaki sought to deflect investor\n\n  concerns about Palantir potentially \u201cbuying revenue,\u201d stressing that the SPACs only\n\n  contributed 1% of Palantir\u2019s 2Q21 revenue and were part of a \u201clong-term strategy\u201d:\n\n          [Glazer:] In the first half of the year, we committed to invest $250 million, and\n          we funded approximately $20 million of those commitments to date. We\n          have and expect to continue to make additional strategic investments in the\n          future. In the second quarter, $3 million or less than 1% of our quarterly\n          revenue was from companies we invested in as part of the strategic\n          investment program we launched earlier this year.\n\n                                              *      *      *\n\n          [Head of Palantir Investor Relations:] (inaudible) asks, can you guys describe\n          your long-term vision with your pipe investments into pre-revenue\n          companies? The talk is Palantir\u2019s buying revenue, but I believe it is a clever,\n          high-risk, high-reward strategy, enhancing network effects.\n\n          [Kawasaki:] Thank you. This is a huge opportunity for us to invest in our\n          customers. And that\u2019s something we feel we\u2019ve always done. Now we can\n          do it with our balance sheet. These are companies that we think we will\n          be working with for a very long time.\n                                                  - 31 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    82\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 37 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n                                               *      *       *\n\n          So I\u2019ll also break down the numbers a little bit here. Dave already mentioned\n          that less than 1% of our revenue came from this program in Q2.\n          Additionally, of the $925 million of total TCV in Q2, $543 million from\n          this program. This is a long-term strategy, and the deal is a long term\n          as well. So we expect longer duration and time to revenue recognition.\n\n          84.         Defendants knew that Palantir was, in fact, artificially inflating its commercial\n\n  performance by \u201cbuying revenue.\u201d Supra, \u00b659. They also knew from SPAC due diligence\n\n  and installation data that, contrary to Glazer\u2019s and Kawasaki\u2019s statements in \u00b683, the First\n\n  and Second Stage SPACs were overwhelmingly nonviable businesses, not companies that\n\n  Palantir expected to be \u201cworking with for a very long time,\u201d or part of a \u201clong-term strategy\u201d\n\n  that could provide $543 million (or even a substantial portion of that) in total contract value\n\n  (\u201cTCV\u201d). Indeed, Palantir\u2019s Second Stage SPACs included $88 million of investments in no-\n\n  or-nearly-no-revenue companies in exchange for at least $107 million in software\n\n  subscriptions: Embark Trucks (no revenue in 2021), Faraday Future (no revenue in 2021\n\n  but $47 million Foundry subscription), Wejo ($2.57 million in 2021 revenue but $50 million\n\n  Foundry subscription), and Pear Therapeutics ($4.2 million in 2021 revenue but $9.3 million\n\n  Foundry subscription). These SPACs were teetering on insolvency, as some publicly\n\n  stated soon thereafter.18 Nonetheless, Defendants\u2019 misleading assurances to analysts\u2019\n\n  inquiries worked, as an August 12, 2021 Jefferies analyst report reiterated that Palantir\u2019s\n\n\n  18\n      Unsurprisingly, the Second Stage SPACs suffered dramatic declines in stock price\n  during the Class Period, falling on average approximately 80% from their IPO prices. Five\n  are bankrupt; Tritium is insolvent; Nasdaq has issued Faraday Future a delisting notice;\n  AdTheorent \u2013 the only other Second Stage SPAC still publicly-traded \u2013 is being taken\n  private; and Embark\u2019s stock price declined approximately 99% before being taken private.\n\n\n                                                    - 32 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                     83\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 38 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  \u201cpartnership investments are paying off as net new logo growth accelerates.\u201d\n\n          85.         Only three months after Palantir\u2019s investment, Faraday Future was revealed\n\n  to be an \u201cEV scam\u201d that had never been in a position to sell a car; that of the 14,000\n\n  reservations for the FF91 vehicle Faraday reported, only several hundred were paid and\n\n  the others simply unpaid indications of interest; and that China\u2019s infamous securities\n\n  fraudster Jia Yueting was involved in managing the Company post-SPAC.\n\n          86.         Similarly, a January 6, 2022 short-seller report and subsequent securities\n\n  fraud lawsuit revealed that Embark Trucks had far more limited operational and\n\n  technological capabilities than publicly disclosed, held \u201cno patents, [and] has only a dozen\n\n  or so test trucks.\u201d Defendants\u2019 effort to conceal the actual identity of Embark Trucks \u2013\n\n  describing it only as an \u201c[a]utonomous vehicle company\u201d in Palantir\u2019s 2Q21 Form 10-Q \u2013\n\n  further confirms their efforts to conceal the SPAC Scheme. Embark laid off 70% of its\n\n  workforce in March 2023 and was then taken private.\n\n          87.         Defendants\u2019 knowledge of the Second Stage SPACs\u2019 precarious financial\n\n  state is further confirmed by Palantir\u2019s insistence that Boxed and Fast Radius make front-\n\n  loaded payments immediately following Palantir\u2019s PIPE investments. For example, in\n\n  exchange for $20 million from Palantir \u2013 the precise amount Fast Radius needed to\n\n  complete its PIPE funding \u2013 Fast Radius signed a $45 million, 6-year Foundry subscription\n\n  in May 2021. Consistent with its extensive due diligence into Fast Radius before the\n\n  closing, which Glazer participated in, and which focused on Fast Radius\u2019s financial position,\n\n  Palantir insisted on an immediate $9.4 million upfront payment from Fast Radius due at\n\n  close and another provision allowing Fast Radius out of the deal if it paid $19.5 million\n\n                                                 - 33 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   84\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 39 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  within a certain time frame.19 Fast Radius declared bankruptcy approximately nine months\n\n  after Palantir funded its investment. Similarly, Palantir demanded $15 million of the now-\n\n  bankrupt Boxed\u2019s $20 million Foundry subscription (75%) 30 days after close. These\n\n  upfront payments are further evidence that Defendants did not believe, as they represented\n\n  to investors, that Fast Radius or Boxed were part of \u201ca long-term strategy,\u201d or \u201clong term\n\n  deal[s]\u201d with \u201clonger duration and time to revenue recognition.\u201d\n\n          88.         Kawasaki also claimed on the August 12, 2021 call that the SPACs were\n\n  \u201cchoosing Foundry\u201d and that Palantir delivered the \u201cfull power\u201d of Foundry to them:\n\n          [Kawasaki:] We are now delivering the full power of Foundry to small\n          companies through a subscription model, and we\u2019re doing this across many\n          sectors, ranging from health care to robotics to software companies, SaaS\n          businesses using Foundry to build their offerings.\n\n                                             *     *      *\n\n          Now these are companies that have cutting-edge technology of their own,\n          and they\u2019re choosing Foundry to help drive their vision forward. And we\n          think many will follow and our strategic investment program accelerates this.\n\n          89.         Contrary to the statements in \u00b688, Palantir\u2019s SPAC partners did not have a\n\n  legitimate need for Foundry and were not \u201cchoosing\u201d the software to \u201cbuild their offerings.\u201d\n\n  Rather, these SPAC \u201cpartners\u201d merely signed up for expensive multi-year Foundry\n\n  subscriptions as quid pro quo exchanges for desperately needed PIPE funding. Nor were\n\n  Defendants providing the SPACs the \u201cfull power\u201d of Foundry. Palantir supported the SPAC\n\n  customers with a fraction of the engineers required for typical commercial contracts and no\n\n\n  19\n     The terms of Fast Radius\u2019 (i) Foundry subscription cost and (ii) immediate upfront\n  payment were not made public until November 26, 2021, and March 30, 2022, respectively.\n\n\n                                                 - 34 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   85\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 40 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  salespeople, and unlike Palantir\u2019s typical commercial accounts, provided the SPACs only\n\n  parts of Foundry, delivering the product all at once without the bespoke setup its non-SPAC\n\n  commercial customers received. As Celularity explained in its 1Q23 Form 10-Q, it ceased\n\n  using Palantir software in January 2023 because \u201cthe software has not performed as\n\n  promised and . . . Palantir has failed to provide the Company with the professional services\n\n  necessary to successfully implement, integrate and enable the Foundry platform.\u201d\n\n          90.         Beginning with Palantir\u2019s August 12, 2021 2Q21 Form 10-Q (signed by Karp\n\n  and Glazer), Palantir misleadingly portrayed its SPAC \u201cinvestments\u201d as legitimate growth-\n\n  enhancing partnerships that would expand Palantir\u2019s customer base:\n\n          Our proximity to these businesses and the industries in which they are\n          operating has enhanced . . . our own product and business\n          development efforts, as we continue expanding access to our platforms\n          to the broadest possible set of customers.20\n\n          91.         Contrary to the statements in \u00b690, rather than \u201cenhanc[ing]\u201d Palantir\u2019s\n\n  \u201cbusiness development efforts\u201d and \u201cexpanding access\u201d to its products, Defendants knew\n\n  the SPAC Scheme was undertaken to conceal Palantir\u2019s stagnating growth by generating\n\n  artificial short-term \u201cdemand\u201d that was illusory and unsustainable.\n\n          92.         Defendants\u2019 statements (\u00b6\u00b683, 88, 90) also omitted that Defendants had\n\n  already expanded the SPAC Scheme by arranging to manufacture additional margin and\n\n  revenue growth through at least seven more SPAC transactions shortly after Palantir\u2019s\n\n\n  20\n      This statement was repeated in Palantir\u2019s: (i) November 9, 2021 3Q21 Form 10-Q\n  (signed by Karp and Glazer); (ii) February 24, 2022 FY21 Form 10-K (signed by Karp,\n  Glazer, Cohen, and Thiel); and (iii) May 9, 2022 1Q22 Form 10-Q (signed by Karp and\n  Glazer).\n\n\n                                                - 35 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                  86\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 41 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  August 12, 2021 earnings call (infra, \u00b693).\n\n                             c.     Third Stage SPACs: Defendants\u2019 Last-Gasp\n                                    Expansion of the SPAC Scheme\n\n          93.         Within months of its August 12, 2021 call, Palantir purchased $91.5 million in\n\n  future revenue from approximately seven more commercial clients in exchange for\n\n  approximately $117.5 million in PIPE funding (the \u201cThird Stage SPACs\u201d). Three of the\n\n  deals totaled $65.2 million in purchased revenue, $17 million of which was front-loaded:\n\n  \uf0b7       BlackSky: $8 million on or around September 1, 2021 in exchange for $8 million\n          Foundry subscription payable \u201cover multiple years\u201d;\n\n  \uf0b7       Energy Vault: $8.5 million on or around September 8, 2021 in exchange for $7.5\n          million Foundry subscription payable at $3 million a year over two and a half years;\n          and\n\n  \uf0b7       Rubicon Technologies: $35 million on or around December 15, 2021 (negotiated\n          in September 2021 but amended in December 2021) in exchange for at least $17\n          million in Palantir services payable within 12 months and $30 million thereafter\n          through October 2024 (a total commitment of $49.7 million).\n\n          94.         The four remaining deals had unknown subscription terms (estimated to be at\n\n  least $26 million), in exchange for approximately $66 million in PIPE funding:\n\n  \uf0b7       Allego: $20 million on or around September 9, 2021 for unknown exchange (\u201cAllego\n          is a customer of Palantir\u201d);\n\n  \uf0b7       Starry Group: $16 million on or around October 6, 2021 in exchange for what\n          appears to be an estimated $16 million Palantir subscription agreement over 3 or 4\n          years;\n\n  \uf0b7       Rigetti: $10 million on or around October 6, 2021 in exchange for what appears to\n          be an estimated $10 million Palantir subscription agreement over 3 or 4 years; and\n\n  \uf0b7       Bird Global: $20 million on or around November 29, 2021 for unknown exchange\n          (\u201c[w]e are a customer of Palantir\u201d).\n\n          95.         During Palantir\u2019s November 9, 2021 3Q21 earnings call, Sankar again\n\n\n                                                   - 36 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    87\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 42 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  stressed that the SPAC customers were using Foundry to manage their operations:\n\n          [Sankar:] These companies have enormous ambition and deeply value\n          the step change in speed and the reduction of expenses Foundry\n          delivers when consumed as Infrastructure as a Service. Wejo is able to\n          develop market-ready applications in as little as 6 weeks on Foundry.\n          Sarcos is integrating 0.5 trillion data points per month to accelerate\n          design, maintenance and commercialization of their Iron Man suits.\n          Lilium is flying through ground and flight testing [wielding] the vast\n          data generated by every sensor streaming from the aircraft.\n\n                                              *      *      *\n\n          We started this program to supercharge earlier-stage companies,\n          enabling them to create a central operating system for their data and to\n          scale rapidly from Day 0. These companies, they\u2019re not just managing\n          their data and their operations, they are wielding them to blitz, scale\n          and win.\n\n          96.         On the same call, Glazer highlighted the $640 million \u201clong term\u201d revenue the\n\n  Company would generate from these \u201cinvestments\u201d:\n\n          [Glazer:] Just to repeat some numbers and get some context with our Q4\n          guide, we\u2019re expecting 40% revenue growth for the year in 2021. . . .\n          We\u2019ve invested about \u2013 invested about $150 million through Q3.\n\n          Total revenue from the program is about 2% of revenue for the year through\n          Q3, and there\u2019s about $640 million of total revenue long term from this\n          program at the end of the quarter.\n\n          97.         Contrary to Sankar\u2019s statements in \u00b695, Wejo, Sarcos, and Lilium were not\n\n  using Foundry to manage, commercialize, and scale their operations. Supra, \u00b6\u00b669-70, 81.\n\n  Nor was Foundry delivering a \u201creduction [in] expenses\u201d to these companies or any of\n\n  Palantir\u2019s other SPAC customers. To the contrary, most of the Foundry subscriptions cost\n\n  the SPACs between $7 million and $10 million a year \u2013 a burdensome cost these nascent\n\n  companies could not afford. Supra, \u00b6\u00b659-60, 68-71, 79-82; infra, \u00b698. Moreover, as with\n\n  the prior SPAC deals, the Third Stage SPAC investments were quid pro quo transactions\n                                                  - 37 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    88\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 43 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  undertaken to conceal Palantir\u2019s stagnating growth. Palantir therefore did not \u201cstart[]\u201d\n\n  making SPAC investments to \u201csupercharge earlier-stage companies,\u201d as claimed in \u00b695\n\n  above, but instead implemented the SPAC Scheme to buy artificially inflated high-margin\n\n  revenue so that Palantir could post the growth Defendants promised investors.\n\n          98.         Glazer\u2019s statements in \u00b696 were also materially misleading for highlighting the\n\n  expected revenue from the SPAC program and the anticipated revenue growth for 2021\n\n  inflated by the SPACs \u2013 as Defendants knew Palantir was unlikely to ever receive a\n\n  substantial portion of the contracted-for SPAC-related revenue. Indeed, Defendants knew\n\n  from Palantir\u2019s due diligence and the complete customer data it \u201cunlocked\u201d minutes after\n\n  installing Foundry that most of these Third Stage SPACs could not afford Foundry and\n\n  were either insolvent or nearly so.21 For example, as reported by WasteDive on November\n\n  21, 2022, Rubicon attributed its subsequent layoffs and restructuring to \u201c\u2018higher software\n\n  subscription costs\u2019\u201d from its Palantir agreement. Moreover, it was known to or recklessly\n\n  disregarded by Defendants at the time of each deal that these SPACs were operating at\n\n  substantial losses in 2021: Rubicon ($915,000 net loss); Bird Global ($279 million net\n\n  operating loss); Starry Group ($166.5 million net loss); BlackSky ($120 million operating\n\n  loss); Allego (\u20ac126 million net loss); Rigetti ($23.2 million net loss); and Energy Vault ($3.3\n\n\n  21\n     Defendants also knew from their close relationships with some of Palantir\u2019s Third Stage\n  SPACs that these companies could not afford Foundry. For example, Rigetti executive\n  Spencer Rascoff is on Palantir\u2019s Board, and Rigetti is connected to the Thiel-founded Y\n  Combinator. Likewise, Thiel\u2019s friend and fellow PayPal alumnus Roelof Botha is on the Bird\n  Global Board. And Thiel Capital Managing Director and former PayPal executive Jack\n  Selby, who facilitated several investments in Palantir, was on the Board of Founder SPAC,\n  which merged with Rubicon in Rubicon\u2019s SPAC, and subsequently joined Rubicon\u2019s Board.\n\n\n                                                   - 38 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    89\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 44 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  million net loss). And subsequent to these deals (or immediately before them, as with Bird\n\n  Global), the auditors or management of almost all of the Third Stage SPACs expressed\n\n  going concern doubts. All lost over 50% of their listing stock price by the end of the Class\n\n  Period. Rubicon, Rigetti, and Allego have been issued notices warning of delisting from\n\n  Nasdaq and NYSE, respectively. Starry Group and Bird Global are now bankrupt.\n\n          99.         That Defendants went to great lengths to conceal the details (going so far as\n\n  to hide even the names of some) of the Third Stage SPACs from investors further confirms\n\n  their desire to conceal their true state as well as the scope and purpose of the SPAC\n\n  Scheme. In its SEC filings, Palantir concealed Starry Group as a \u201c[t]elecommunications\n\n  company,\u201d Allego as an \u201c[e]lectric vehicle charging company,\u201d and Bird Global as a\n\n  \u201c[m]obility company.\u201d Moreover, Palantir concealed details concerning the Allego, Starry\n\n  Group, Rigetti, and Bird Global deals, including the deal value of the contracts. Palantir\n\n  also concealed from the market the names of approximately $70 million worth of deals\n\n  reached in September 2021 (Rubicon, Allego) and October 2021 (Starry Group) \u2013 until later\n\n  in February 2022 (Rubicon) and May 2022 (Allego, Starry Group).\n\n          100.        Glazer\u2019s statement on the November 9, 2021 earnings call (\u00b696) also omitted\n\n  that Defendants had already expanded the SPAC Scheme by entering into quid pro quo\n\n  agreements with Bird Global on or around November 29, 2021 and with Rubicon on or\n\n  around December 15, 2021 (which had been negotiated in September 2021).\n\n                      3.    Defendants\u2019 SPAC Scheme Was Designed to and Did\n                            Inflate Palantir\u2019s Key Performance Metrics\n\n          101.        Defendants\u2019 implementation of the SPAC Scheme was designed to and did\n\n  manipulate Palantir\u2019s reported profit margins, revenue growth, total remaining deal value\n                                            - 39 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    90\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 45 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  (\u201cTRDV\u201d), and customer count \u2013 the key metrics that Defendants pointed to as evidence of\n\n  acceleration in the commercial sector in order to prop up the trading price of Palantir stock.\n\n                            a.     Profit Margins\n\n          102.        As explained above, Palantir\u2019s attempt to expand its commercial business to\n\n  new customers and industries was an expensive and time-consuming endeavor \u2013 and\n\n  resulted in declining profit margins throughout the Class Period (see supra, \u00b6\u00b635, 40-43):\n\n\n\n\n          103.        The SPAC transactions were designed to and did mask the full extent of\n\n  Palantir\u2019s deteriorating margins. Palantir\u2019s SPAC deals had a much lower cost to obtain\n\n  and implement than its typical commercial contracts, inflating Palantir\u2019s margins\n\n  significantly. Contrary to typical commercial deals, there were no salespeople involved in\n\n  the SPAC deals. Furthermore, whereas a single non-SPAC commercial client typically\n\n  required about eight Palantir employees\u2019 support to create a bespoke Foundry platform,\n\n  eight Palantir employees could support ten SPACs. And because the SPACs were locked\n\n  into Foundry subscriptions as a prerequisite to receiving PIPE funding, Palantir did not\n\n  need to create bespoke products for its SPAC clients or give them the full Foundry\n\n                                                  - 40 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    91\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 46 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  treatment afforded non-SPAC clients. Instead, the SPAC customers were provided off-\n\n  the-rack and partial Foundry applications. Because the costs associated with SPAC deals\n\n  were approximately 10% as much as its traditional commercial contracts, these deals\n\n  materially inflated Palantir\u2019s reported margins \u2013 masking the true extent of the decline in\n\n  margins as the Company struggled to efficiently expand to non-SPAC commercial clients.\n\n          104.        From the time Palantir began recognizing revenue from the SPAC Scheme in\n\n  2Q21 until the scheme unraveled in 2Q22, Defendants repeatedly reported misleadingly\n\n  inflated contribution margins22:\n\n                                                             Contribution       Commercial\n                Source23                          Quarter      Margin        Contribution Margin\n  August 12, 2021 Form 10-Q                        2Q21         58%                 52.3%\n  (signed by Karp and Glazer)\n  November 9, 2021 Form 10-Q                        3Q21          57%                56.3%\n  (signed by Karp and Glazer)\n  February 24, 2022 Form 10-K                       4Q21          58%                57.6%\n  (signed by Karp, Glazer, Cohen, Thiel)\n  May 9, 2022 Form 10-Q                             1Q22          57%                55.0%\n  (signed by Karp and Glazer)\n\n          105.        The table below illustrates how the SPAC deals inflated Palantir\u2019s commercial\n\n\n  22\n      Contribution margin is Palantir\u2019s \u201crevenue less [the] cost of revenue and sales and\n  marketing expenses, excluding stock-based compensation, divided by revenue.\u201d As\n  Defendants emphasized in their SEC filings, contribution margin is \u201can important measure\n  of the efficiency of [the] business,\u201d and was the sole \u201ckey non-GAAP business measure to\n  help [Defendants] evaluate [their] business, identify trends affecting [their] business,\n  formulate business plans and financial projections, and make strategic decisions.\u201d\n  23\n      Each of these SEC filings reported enterprise-wide contribution margins and segment-\n  level contribution. The commercial contribution margin percentages have been calculated\n  using those reported segment-level contribution numbers and the calculation indicated in\n  each SEC filing. Glazer also provided these contribution margin figures during the earnings\n  calls for 2Q21 (Glazer: \u201c58%\u201d), 3Q21 (Glazer: \u201c57%\u201d), and 1Q22 (Glazer: \u201c57%\u201d).\n\n\n                                                  - 41 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    92\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 47 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  contribution margins, estimating conservatively that a 90% contribution margin from the\n\n  SPACs inflated commercial contribution margins in 2021-2022 by as much as 17.7%24:\n\n                                          2Q21         3Q21                       4Q21                   1Q22\n  Commercial revenue                   $143,523,000 $174,310,000               $193,886,000           $204,567,000\n  Contribution margin\n                                            52.3%               56.3%                57.6%                 55.0%\n  (as reported)\n\n  SPAC Revenue                          $3,000,000          $19,000,000         $26,300,000           $39,200,000\n\n  Contribution margin ex-\n                                            51.5%               52.2%                52.5%                 46.8%\n  SPAC (at 90% CM)\n  Reported contribution\n                                            1.6%                 7.9%                9.7%                  17.7%\n  margin inflated by:\n\n           106.       Indeed, excluding the SPAC customers that Palantir bought in 2021 reveals\n\n  that it was, in fact, operating at a significant loss on new organic commercial customers:\n\n                                               1Q21             2Q21          3Q21          4Q21           FY21\n\n   Avg revenue per commercial customer $ 2,213,567          $ 1,816,747   $ 1,515,739   $ 1,318,952    $ 4,384,578\n       Avg contribution profit (loss) per\n                                             $ 1,209,050    $   950,899   $   853,713   $   759,898    $ 2,432,286\n            commercial customer\n\n   Avg revenue per new YTD commercial\n                                          $   39,455 $ 272,323 $              433,522   $   455,228    $   830,693\n                 customer\n   Avg contribution profit (loss) per new\n                                          $ (570,455) $ (183,677) $            28,269   $   269,088    $   169,336\n         YTD commercial customer\n\n   Avg revenue per new YTD commercial\n                                      $          39,455     $   224,769   $   196,173   $   226,078    $   413,932\n           customer (Ex-SPAC)\n\n   Avg contribution profit (loss) per new\n                                             $ (570,455) $ (356,971) $ (310,903) $           33,342    $ (333,567)\n   YTD commercial customer (Ex-SPAC)\n\n\n           107.       SPAC revenue also misleadingly inflated adjusted operating margins:\n\n\n\n\n  24\n     The true costs of the SPAC Scheme \u2013 the PIPE investments that enabled the sales \u2013\n  were not reflected as an expense to Palantir under Palantir\u2019s contribution margin formula.\n\n\n                                                      - 42 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                           93\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 48 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n                Source25                           Quarter          Adjusted Operating Margin\n  August 12, 2021 Release                           2Q21                      31.1%\n  (signed by Karp)\n  November 9, 2021 Release                          3Q21                      29.6%\n  (signed by Karp)\n  February 24, 2022 Release                         4Q21                      28.7%\n  (signed by Karp)\n  May 9, 2022 Release                               1Q22                      26.3%\n  (signed by Karp)\n\n          108.        The following table illustrates how the SPAC deals inflated Palantir\u2019s adjusted\n\n  operating margin, estimating conservatively that a 90% profit margin from the SPACs\n\n  inflated Palantir\u2019s adjusted operating margin during 2021-2022 by as much as 30.4%:\n\n                                      2Q21              3Q21              4Q21             1Q22\n  Revenue                          $375,642,000      $392,146,000      $432,867,000     $446,357,000\n  Adjusted operating\n                                       31.1%                29.6%         28.7%             26.3%\n  margin (as reported)\n\n  SPAC Revenue                       $3,000,000       $19,000,000      $26,300,000       $39,200,000\n  Adjusted operating\n  margin ex-SPAC (at 90%               30.6%                26.5%         24.7%             20.2%\n  profit margin)\n  Reported adjusted\n  operating margin                      1.6%                11.6%         16.1%             30.4%\n  inflated by:\n\n          109.        Thus, the SPAC Scheme masked the timing and extent of the stagnation and\n\n  declines in Palantir\u2019s commercial contribution margin and adjusted operating margin,\n\n  thereby inflating its reported margins. As a result, the SPAC Scheme misled investors as to\n\n\n  25\n      Each Palantir earnings release (\u201cRelease\u201d) issued during the Class Period was\n  incorporated into a Form 8-K signed by Karp and filed with the SEC on the date of\n  issuance. Glazer and Sankar also provided these misleading adjusted operating margin\n  figures during the earnings calls for 2Q21 (Glazer: \u201c31%\u201d), 3Q21 (Glazer: \u201c30%\u201d), and 1Q22\n  (Glazer/Sankar: \u201c26%\u201d) as evidence of the Company\u2019s purported path to profitability.\n\n\n                                                   - 43 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    94\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 49 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  the true profitability (or lack thereof) of the Company\u2019s commercial expansion efforts.\n\n                            b.     Reported Revenue, Revenue Growth, and TRDV\n\n          110.        Palantir had no reasonable expectation of long-term revenue from the SPACs\n\n  over the length of their contracts \u2013 as most lacked the revenue and cash flow to afford the\n\n  Palantir contracts and did not have a clear path to commercial production or operations on\n\n  the scale Defendants represented. Nevertheless, from the time Palantir began recognizing\n\n  revenue from the SPAC Scheme in 2Q21 until the scheme unraveled in 2Q22, Defendants\n\n  continuously reported misleadingly inflated revenue growth, as shown in the table below:\n\n                                                                                           U.S.\n                                                              Commercial       Growth     Growth\n                Source26                         Quarter       Revenue          YoY        YoY\n  August 12, 2021 Form 10-Q                       2Q21       $ 143,523,000      28%        90%\n  (signed by Karp and Glazer) and\n  Release (signed by Karp)\n  November 9, 2021 Form 10-Q                       3Q21      $ 174,310,000       37%       103%\n  (signed by Karp and Glazer) and\n  Release (signed by Karp)\n  February 24, 2022 Form 10-K                      4Q21      $ 193,886,000       47%       132%\n  (signed by Karp, Glazer, Cohen, Thiel)\n  and Release (signed by Karp)\n  May 9, 2022 Form 10-Q                            1Q22      $ 204,567,000       54%       136%\n  (signed by Karp and Glazer) and\n  Release (signed by Karp)\n\n\n  26\n     For 4Q21, commercial revenue is derived from the prior quarterly revenue and annual\n  revenue disclosed in the FY21 Form 10-K. Sankar, Glazer, and Kawasaki also cited these\n  misleading figures on the earnings calls for 2Q21 (Glazer: \u201c$144 million\u201d commercial\n  revenue, \u201c28%\u201d commercial revenue growth; Glazer/Sankar: \u201c90%\u201d U.S. commercial\n  revenue    growth),    3Q21    (Glazer:    \u201c$174   million\u201d    commercial     revenue;\n  Glazer/Sankar/Kawasaki: \u201c37%\u201d commercial revenue growth, \u201c103%\u201d U.S. commercial\n  revenue growth), and 1Q22 (Glazer: \u201c$205 million\u201d commercial revenue;\n  Glazer/Sankar/Kawasaki: \u201c54%\u201d commercial revenue growth; Glazer/Sankar: \u201c136%\u201d U.S.\n  commercial revenue growth) as evidence of the \u201caccelerating\u201d commercial business.\n\n\n                                                 - 44 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   95\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 50 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          111.        The SPAC Scheme enabled Palantir to report this revenue growth by\n\n  purchasing high-margin revenue to misleadingly prop up its reported commercial results \u2013\n\n  as the SPAC deals accounted for revenues of $3 million in 2Q21, $19 million in $3Q21,\n\n  $26.3 million in 4Q21, and $39.2 million in 1Q22. In fact, absent the SPAC revenue,\n\n  Palantir\u2019s commercial growth had stagnated (see infra, \u00b6123), and Company-wide revenue\n\n  growth would have fallen below Palantir\u2019s 30% long-term annual growth target in 3Q21 \u2013\n\n  three full quarters before 2Q22 when Palantir admitted to falling below the target:\n\n\n\n\n          112.        Palantir further touted, as part of \u201cInvestment Agreements,\u201d the \u201cmaximum\n\n  potential revenue\u201d of its SPAC arrangements reported, as shown in the table below:\n\n                Source27                         Quarter       Maximum Potential Revenue\n  August 12, 2021 Form 10-Q                       2Q21               $ 428 million\n  (signed by Karp and Glazer)\n  November 9, 2021 Form 10-Q                      3Q21                $ 640.2 million\n  (signed by Karp and Glazer)\n  February 24, 2022 Form 10-K                     4Q21                $ 767.9 million\n  (signed by Karp, Glazer, Cohen, Thiel)\n  May 9, 2022 Form 10-Q                           1Q22                $ 754.9 million\n  (signed by Karp and Glazer)\n\n\n  27\n     The FY21 Form 10-K and 1Q21 Form 10-Q disclosed a \u201ctotal value\u201d rather than a\n  \u201cmaximum potential revenue\u201d figure. The 4Q21 potential revenue was calculated based on\n  the to-date total in the 3Q21 Form 10-Q and the annual total in the FY21 Form 10-K.\n\n\n                                                 - 45 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                  96\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 51 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          113.        Thus, in addition to reporting misleading short-term revenue, the SPAC deals\n\n  also allowed Palantir to eventually report $767.9 million of additional TRDV, creating the\n\n  illusion of sustainable growth in the Company\u2019s commercial segment. In fact, SPACs\n\n  represented over 20% of the $3.8 billion in TRDV by December 31, 2021 (and more than\n\n  76% of the YoY increase), at least a quarter of the $925 million in contracts Palantir signed\n\n  in 2Q21, and roughly one-third of Palantir\u2019s Class Period revenue growth by early 2022.\n\n          114.        Thus, from the time Palantir began entering into contracts with the SPACs in\n\n  1Q21 until the scheme unraveled in 2Q22, Defendants continuously reported misleadingly\n\n  inflated TRDV figures, as shown in the table below:\n\n                 Source                           Quarter       TRDV         Commercial TRDV\n  May 11, 2021 Earnings Call                       1Q21      $ 2.8 billion     not disclosed\n  (Glazer)\n  August 12, 2021 Earnings Call                    2Q21      $ 3.4 billion       $ 2.1 billion\n  (Glazer)\n  November 9, 2021 Earnings Call                   3Q21      $ 3.6 billion       $ 2.2 billion\n  (Glazer, Sankar, and Kawasaki)\n  February 24, 2022 Form 10-K                      4Q21      $ 3.8 billion       $ 2.6 billion\n  (signed by Karp, Glazer, Cohen, Thiel)\n  May 9, 2022 1Q22 Earnings Call                   1Q22      $ 3.5 billion       not disclosed\n  (Glazer)\n\n          115.        These \u201cmaximum potential revenue\u201d and TRDV figures were materially\n\n  misleading \u2013 as Defendants were aware that Palantir was unlikely to receive a substantial\n\n  portion of the revenue contracted for under Defendants\u2019 scheme. Supra, \u00b6\u00b659-60. The\n\n  SPACs Palantir partnered with had little to no revenue, no commercial prospects, and could\n\n  not afford Palantir\u2019s software \u2013 and almost all of them have either gone bankrupt or\n\n  declined in value to worthless or near-worthless status. Supra, \u00b6\u00b660, 68-71, 79-82, 84 &\n\n  n.18, 85-87, 98. Defendants had no reasonable expectation of \u201clong-term\u201d revenue,\n                                                  - 46 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   97\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 52 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  growth, or equity from the SPAC deals.\n\n                              c.   Customer Count\n\n          116.        The SPAC Scheme also allowed Palantir to report misleadingly high customer\n\n  count and growth starting in 2Q21.28 Even though many of Palantir\u2019s SPACs lacked the\n\n  revenue or commercial ability to continue as \u201cgoing concerns,\u201d let alone afford the longer\n\n  duration Palantir subscription contracts (even in the short term), Palantir nonetheless\n\n  included its SPAC \u201cpartners\u201d in its customer count:\n\n                                                           Customer Count       Commercial\n                         29\n           Source                       Quarter               (net new)      Customer Growth\n  August 12, 2021 Release                2Q21                    20           32% (sequential)\n  (signed by Karp)\n  November 9, 2021 Release                3Q21                   34          46% (sequential)\n  (signed by Karp)\n  February 17, 2022 Release               4Q21                   34                  -\n  (signed by Karp)\n  May 9, 2022 Release                     1Q22                40;            25% (sequential);\n  (signed by Karp) and                                  86% growth (YoY)       207% (YoY);\n  Earnings Call (Kawasaki)                                                   368% (U.S. YoY)\n\n          117.        These customer count figures were materially misleading, as the SPACs were\n\n  not organic commercial customers that chose Foundry to meet legitimate business needs,\n\n  but rather were businesses too nascent to afford or need Palantir\u2019s software that had\n\n  28\n       Palantir changed its definition of \u201ccustomer\u201d in 1Q21. Infra, \u00b6162.\n  29\n     Glazer, Sankar, and Kawasaki also provided these misleading customer figures during\n  the earnings calls for 2Q21 (Glazer/Sankar: \u201c20 net new customers\u201d; Glazer/\n  Sankar/Kawasaki: \u201c32%\u201d sequential commercial customer growth), 3Q21 (Glazer/Sankar:\n  \u201c34 net new customers,\u201d \u201c46%\u201d sequential commercial customer growth), and 1Q22\n  (Glazer/Sankar: \u201c40\u201d net new customers\u201d; Sankar: \u201c86% year-over-year\u201d customer\n  growth; Glazer/Kawasaki: \u201c25%\u201d sequential commercial customer growth, \u201c207%\u201d YoY\n  commercial customer growth; Kawasaki: \u201c368%\u201d YoY U.S. commercial customers growth)\n  as evidence of the Company\u2019s purported commercial expansion.\n\n\n                                                  - 47 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   98\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 53 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  agreed to unnecessary software contracts in exchange for much needed PIPE funding.\n\n  Supra, \u00b6\u00b658, 68-71.\n\n                            d.     Defendants Cite Palantir\u2019s Misleading Metrics as\n                                   Evidence of Continued Sustainable Growth\n\n          118.        Starting when Palantir began recognizing SPAC revenue in 2Q21,\n\n  Defendants repeatedly pointed to misleadingly-inflated commercial metrics (supra,\n\n  \u00a7\u00a7IV.B.2.a-IV.B.2.c) as evidence of the commercial segment\u2019s successful expansion.\n\n          119.        For instance, on the August 12, 2021 earnings call, Sankar and Glazer cited\n\n  inflated commercial revenue growth and customer count metrics as proof of \u201cproduct\n\n  innovation\u201d and \u201ccontinued efficiencies\u201d driving growth:\n\n          [Sankar:] Cutting-edge product and continued efficiencies in distribution\n          drove exceptionally strong year-over-year Q2 results.\n\n          Total revenue grew 49% in Q2. U.S. commercial revenue accelerated to\n          90%. . . . . We added 20 net new customers in Q2 alone, while generating\n          $7.9 million of average revenue per customer. . . . The number of\n          commercial customers grew 32% over last quarter.\n\n                                             *      *      *\n\n          Product innovation is at the core of these results and the momentum\n          that's driving our business forward.\n\n                                             *      *      *\n\n          [Glazer:] Second quarter commercial revenue growth accelerated to $144\n          million, up 28% year-over-year compared with 19% growth in the first\n          quarter. Speed and innovation are driving strong results in our\n          commercial business, particularly in the U.S., where commercial revenue\n          growth accelerated to 90% year-over-year in Q2 . . . .\n\n          120.        On the November 9, 2021 earnings call, Sankar and Glazer again pointed to\n\n  revenue, customer count, and TRDV metrics as proof of \u201caccelerating\u201d commercial growth:\n\n\n                                                  - 48 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   99\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 54 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          [Sankar:] Commercial revenue growth has accelerated in every quarter\n          over the last year from 4% in Q4 2020 to 19% in Q1 to 28% in Q2 now 37%\n          in Q3. At this scale, acceleration like this is gravity defined. U.S. commercial\n          revenue growth accelerated once again to 103% year-over-year. We added\n          34 net new customers in Q3. To put this in perspective, our commercial\n          customer count grew by 46% sequentially. We have more than doubled\n          our commercial customer count at the beginning of the year.\n\n                                             *      *      *\n\n          [Glazer:] Looking at our Q3 revenue year-over-year by segment, we\n          continue to see broad-based momentum in our commercial business.\n          Total commercial revenue was $174 million, up 37% and representing our\n          third straight quarter of accelerating commercial revenue growth.\n\n          Our investments in product and distribution continue to drive growth,\n          particularly in the U.S., where commercial revenue increased 103% in Q3.\n\n                                             *      *      *\n\n          Our forward indicators also really strong. Total deal value up 50% to\n          $3.6 billion. Total deal value in commercial doubled to $2.2 billion.\n\n          121.        And on the May 9, 2022 earnings call, Glazer and Kawasaki again highlighted\n\n  accelerating (and inflated) commercial revenue and customer counts:\n\n          [Glazer:] Commercial revenue growth accelerated for the fifth\n          consecutive quarter. First quarter commercial revenue increased 54%\n          year-over-year to $205 million, up from a 47% increase in the fourth\n          quarter. . . . U.S. commercial revenue growth accelerated to 136% in the\n          first quarter, up from 132% in Q4.\n\n                                             *      *      *\n\n          [Kawasaki:] We had our strongest quarter for winning new commercial\n          customers overall. Commercial customer count up 25% sequentially and\n          up 207% from a year ago. And in the United States, commercial\n          customer count grew 368%. We expect continued growth in\n          commercial customer acquisition.\n\n          122.        The statements detailed in \u00b6\u00b6119-121 were materially misleading when\n\n  made. Palantir\u2019s reported commercial growth was not driven by \u201cinvestments in product\n\n                                                  - 49 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                  100\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 55 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  and distribution,\u201d but rather was the result of the unsustainable SPAC Scheme, which\n\n  materially and artificially inflated the commercial metrics that Defendants reported (i.e.,\n\n  profit margins, revenue, revenue growth, TRDV, and customer count). These inflated\n\n  metrics concealed that, rather than \u201caccelerating,\u201d Palantir\u2019s organic commercial revenue\n\n  growth rate had stagnated. See supra, \u00b6\u00b631, 57; infra, \u00a7IV.B.3.\n\n          C.          Defendants Misrepresent the Momentum in Palantir\u2019s\n                      Business to Obscure Palantir\u2019s Declining Growth Trends\n\n          123.        Throughout the Class Period, Defendants claimed that Palantir\u2019s government\n\n  and commercial segments were continuing to accelerate the tremendous growth it posted in\n\n  early 2020 and at the time of the Offering. This growth story was necessary to prop up\n\n  Palantir\u2019s stock price, enabling the Individual Defendants to sell their Palantir shares at\n\n  artificially inflated prices. However, unbeknownst to investors, at the time of the Offering\n\n  the Company\u2019s commercial revenue growth rate was set to decline significantly in 4Q20\n\n  (the quarter that began the day after the Offering). Without the inclusion of revenue that\n\n  Palantir bought and paid for via quid pro quo SPAC deals, Palantir\u2019s Class Period\n\n  commercial growth rate never recovered to pre-Offering levels:\n\n\n\n\n                                                 - 50 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                  101\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 56 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          124.        In addition to this commercial growth stagnation, Palantir\u2019s government\n\n  growth rate peaked in 4Q20 before suffering six sequential quarters of declining revenue\n\n  growth rates \u2013 falling from 85% YoY in 4Q20 to 13% YoY in 2Q22:\n\n\n\n\n          125.        Defendants were aware throughout the Class Period that Palantir\u2019s growth\n\n  had decelerated and had direct insight into the negative trends then impacting Palantir.\n\n  Indeed, at Investor Day, Defendants emphasized that there were a \u201cnumber of factors that\n\n  provide strong visibility and stability for future revenue growth\u201d \u2013 highlighting Palantir\u2019s\n\n  TRDV, customer base, average length of contract, and ratable revenue recognition as key\n\n  factors in the \u201cstability and predictability of our revenues.\u201d Throughout the Class Period,\n\n  Defendants reiterated that they maintained \u201cstrong visibility into future revenues across\n\n  [Palantir\u2019s] customer base\u201d (3Q20 call) and claimed that \u201cvisibility into future growth is\n\n  strong\u201d (2Q21 call) \u2013 highlighting the aforementioned metrics as evidence of \u201cincreased\n\n  visibility for durable long-term growth\u201d (2Q21 call). The \u201cstrong visibility\u201d provided by the\n\n  average length of Palantir\u2019s contracts increased from 3.5 years at the time of the Offering to\n\n  3.9 years by the end of 2Q21. Palantir\u2019s customer base was also very narrow, with 125\n                                                - 51 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                 102\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 57 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  customers at the start of the Class Period and approximately 300 by the end. Palantir also\n\n  had additional lead time with regard to notice of government revenue dropping off the\n\n  books due to the lengthy nature of the government contracting and procurement process.\n\n          126.        Given the importance of each customer and the size of each contract, and as\n\n  Defendants expressly acknowledged in Palantir\u2019s SEC filings, the Company\u2019s \u201csales efforts\n\n  ha[d] historically depended on the significant direct involvement of [its] senior management\n\n  team, including Mr. Karp.\u201d Palantir\u2019s senior management team also included Cohen,\n\n  Glazer, Sankar, and Kawasaki. As Karp admitted on January 17, 2023: \u201cI run this\n\n  business, for better or worse. I know how the business is doing.\u201d Thiel also had heavy\n\n  involvement in securing deals, from facilitating Palantir\u2019s government business to\n\n  negotiating for commercial sector projects. The involvement of Palantir\u2019s c-suite executives\n\n  and Thiel in the customer acquisition process was necessary given the Company\u2019s\n\n  acknowledged \u201climited direct sales force.\u201d Moreover, Karp, Glazer, and the other \u201cc-suite\u201d\n\n  executives had access to dashboards that were updated daily and provided them additional\n\n  granular information on the Company\u2019s contracts \u2013 including a contract\u2019s signature date,\n\n  expected \u201ccompletion date,\u201d and Palantir\u2019s expenditures on the contract.\n\n          127.        Although Defendants were aware Palantir had hit a growth wall, Palantir\u2019s\n\n  method of recognizing revenue obscured the financial impact of the slowdown from\n\n  investors. As explained in the Registration Statement and Palantir\u2019s quarterly SEC filings:\n\n          We generally recognize revenue from our platforms and O&M services over\n          the contractual term. As a result, a portion of the revenue we recognize in\n          each quarter is derived from customer contracts generally entered into during\n          previous periods. Consequently, a decline in new or renewed contracts in\n          any single quarter may have an immaterial impact on the revenue that we\n\n                                                  - 52 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                  103\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 58 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          recognize for that quarter. However, such a decline would negatively affect\n          our revenue in future quarters. Accordingly, the effect of significant\n          downturns in sales or renewals, significant customer terminations, and\n          potential changes in our contracting terms and pricing policies would not be\n          fully reflected in our results of operations until future periods.\n\n  Defendants were thus aware of the negative trends in Palantir\u2019s expected revenue at least\n\n  two quarters (i.e., six months) before Palantir reported the effects of those trends fully as\n\n  reflected in the Company\u2019s publicly reported financials. Despite this advanced knowledge,\n\n  Defendants continued to falsely tout Palantir\u2019s positive growth story quarter after quarter.\n\n                      1.    The Offering: Defendants Misleadingly Depict an\n                            Accelerating Trend of Immense Revenue Growth\n\n          128.        The Registration Statement, which became effective on September 22, 2020,\n\n  emphasized that Palantir was experiencing accelerating growth at the time of the Offering,\n\n  stating \u201c[o]ur growth this year has accelerated\u201d and including the following graph:\n\n\n\n\n          129.        The statement and graph in \u00b6128 misled investors. In truth, the temporary\n\n  boost that Palantir received in 1H20 from short-term contracts related to clients\u2019 responses\n\n  to the COVID-19 pandemic was neither sustainable nor representative of Palantir\u2019s growth\n\n\n\n                                                 - 53 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                  104\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 59 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  potential.30 As one former Palantir employee later admitted, \u201cCOVID really accelerated the\n\n  growth of the company\u201d so the direct listing \u201cgot brought forward.\u201d The Company\u2019s COVID-\n\n  19 contracts, however, were much shorter in duration than Palantir\u2019s typical contracts, and\n\n  Palantir had failed to secure additional contracts sufficient to offset the expected loss of the\n\n  temporary surge in revenue from these contracts. As a result, Defendants were aware from\n\n  their \u201cstrong visibility\u201d into future revenues that: (i) the government segment\u2019s growth\n\n  performance was set to peak in 4Q20 and decelerate sequentially in 1Q21; and (ii) organic\n\n  growth rates in the commercial segment (i.e., growth achieved outside of the SPAC\n\n  Scheme) were set to decline in 4Q20. \u00b6\u00b6123-127. In order to grow on the commercial side\n\n  at the pace claimed by Palantir, the Company was entirely dependent on the SPAC\n\n  Scheme. See supra, \u00a7 IV.B. Defendants were thus aware that, contrary to the misleading\n\n  impression of accelerating revenue growth, Palantir\u2019s revenue growth was set to\n\n  decelerate.\n\n          130.        Based on the growth story Defendants pitched in connection with the Offering,\n\n  Palantir shares traded between $9 and $10 per share on the first day of trading. The\n\n  Individual Defendants immediately took advantage of the inflation in the price of Palantir\n\n  shares by collectively dumping nearly 48.7 million shares during the first three days of the\n\n\n\n\n  30\n     Defendants acknowledged with their FY20 earnings that \u201ca lot of new 2020 U.S.\n  defense opportunities started as [a] crisis response to COVID,\u201d and that the Company\n  purportedly \u201chelped 100 commercial organizations\u201d on COVID-19-related issues in 2020.\n\n\n                                                  - 54 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   105\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 60 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  Offering, pocketing more than $483 million.31\n\n                      2.    3Q20 Earnings: Defendants Misleadingly Claim\n                            \u201cSignificant Momentum\u201d Across the Business\n\n          131.        Following the Offering, Palantir\u2019s November 12, 2020 3Q20 Release (signed\n\n  by Karp) repeated the mantra of continued growth, stating:\n\n          Our growth and momentum across the business have continued.\n\n                                            *      *      *\n\n          The demand for our software has increased steadily over the past year.\n\n                                            *      *      *\n\n          We are continuing to see significant momentum in our business across\n          the commercial sector this year, both in the United States and abroad.\n\n          132.        Also on November 12, 2020, Palantir convened a conference call with\n\n  analysts and investors to discuss Palantir\u2019s 3Q20 results. During his prepared remarks,\n\n  Glazer asserted that the tremendous growth would continue on the commercial side:\n\n          [Glazer:] Taken together with continued revenue growth from our\n          acquire phase customers, we believe the rapid growth in revenue from\n          new customers creates a strong basis for future growth to augment the\n          consistent expansion we are generating from our install base of customers in\n          the expand and scale basis.\n\n          133.        Contrary to the statements in \u00b6\u00b6131-132, \u201cgrowth and momentum across the\n\n  business\u201d had not continued, and Defendants were not \u201ccontinuing to see significant\n\n  momentum\u201d in the commercial sector. Rather, at the time the statements in \u00b6\u00b6131-132\n\n  were made \u2013 in the midst of 4Q20 \u2013 Defendants knew that the commercial revenue growth\n\n  31\n     To ameliorate potential investor concerns, Defendants incorporated a 180-day lockup\n  period into Palantir\u2019s direct listing, limiting the supply of stock by assuring the market that\n  company insiders could only sell 20% of their shares prior to February 18, 2021.\n\n\n                                                 - 55 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                  106\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 61 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  rate had already dropped significantly to a modest single-digit YoY growth, and that the\n\n  government segment\u2019s revenue growth rate was set to begin a sequential decline in 1Q21.\n\n          134.        Defendants\u2019 scheme and misrepresentations caused Palantir\u2019s stock price to\n\n  soar to $45 per share by late January 2021. But as Karp later acknowledged to CNBC in\n\n  January 2023, \u201cI never thought we were that good when the share price was $40.\u201d\n\n                      3.    FY20 Earnings: Defendants Misleadingly State\n                            Commercial Pipeline Is \u201cSubstantial and Growing\u201d and\n                            Government Growth Is Just at the \u201cTip of the Iceberg\u201d\n\n          135.        During Palantir\u2019s February 16, 2021 FY20 earnings call, Sankar stressed that\n\n  Palantir\u2019s new account pipeline for commercial customers was thriving and growing:\n\n          [Sankar:] Our pipeline is substantial and growing. These deals, they start\n          in the Acquire phase of our 3-phase model and with new customers who\n          were acquired in the year that had yet to even join a phase. Both of these\n          groups performed exceptionally, a very positive forward-looking\n          indicator.\n\n                                             *      *      *\n\n          And it\u2019s still very clear that we\u2019re just at the beginning. Our customers\n          include only 8 of the Fortune 100, 12 of the Global 100 and only 24 of\n          the Global 300. The opportunity in front of us is immense and growing.\n\n          136.        Sankar also claimed government growth was \u201cjust at the tip of the iceberg\u201d:\n\n          [Sankar:] The full year government revenue rose 77%, led by ongoing\n          momentum in the U.S., which grew 91%. As tremendous of a year as 2020\n          was for the government segment, we believe we are just at the tip of the\n          iceberg, and we are well positioned to capture significant new\n          opportunities in 2021 and beyond.\n\n          137.        Sankar and Glazer also claimed that the Company\u2019s COVID-19 contracts\n\n  would continue to provide a government segment tailwind:\n\n          [Sankar:] And while a lot of new 2020 U.S. defense opportunities started\n          as crisis response to COVID, almost all of it is relevant to enduring\n                                                  - 56 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   107\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 62 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          problems and needs.\n\n                                             *      *      *\n\n          [Glazer:] We expect a tailwind for government as these customers renew\n          and expand.\n\n          138.        The statements in \u00b6\u00b6135-137 above were false and misleading when made.\n\n  Contrary to being \u201cjust at the tip of the iceberg\u201d and \u201cexpect[ing] a tailwind\u201d for government\n\n  revenue growth, Sankar and Glazer knew at the time these statements were made (in the\n\n  middle of 1Q21) that the government segment\u2019s revenue growth rate had already peaked in\n\n  4Q20 and had begun a sequential decline in 1Q21. Supra, \u00b6\u00b6124-127. Moreover,\n\n  Defendants admitted that Palantir\u2019s COVID-19 contracts were much \u201cshorter-than-usual\u201d\n\n  contracts, and Palantir had failed to secure additional contracts sufficient to offset the\n\n  expected loss of these temporary contracts. Further, the cost savings and efficiencies\n\n  Palantir gained from COVID-19 were not scalable.              Contrary to the claim that the\n\n  commercial \u201cpipeline [wa]s substantial and growing,\u201d Sankar and Glazer also knew\n\n  Palantir\u2019s organic (non-SPAC) commercial segment growth rates were not set to\n\n  meaningfully recover from their 4Q20 decline.\n\n          139.        The lockup period expired two days later on February 18, 2021. When it did,\n\n  the Individual Defendants quickly pocketed more than $594 million in insider sales.\n\n                      4.    1Q21 Earnings: Defendants Misleadingly Point to SPAC\n                            Customers as Proof of Commercial Momentum and\n                            Claim Government Momentum \u201cContinues Unabated\u201d\n\n          140.        On Palantir\u2019s May 11, 2021 1Q21 earnings calls, Sankar highlighted the\n\n  Company\u2019s purported ongoing \u201ccommercial tailwind\u201d: \u201cWhere the government response to\n\n  the pandemic has been efficacious, we are seeing a commercial tailwind.\u201d\n                                                  - 57 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                  108\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 63 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          141.        In response to a question regarding the \u201cconfidence in the commercial\n\n  revenue growth,\u201d Kawasaki confirmed that Palantir was building a \u201cbigger and bigger\n\n  pipeline\u201d and was \u201cgoing to continue to see acceleration\u201d across the commercial business:\n\n          [Kawasaki:] [S]o as we build bigger and bigger pipeline here, we\u2019re feeling\n          good about how that funnel is flowing through. And if you combine that with\n          the additional product investments, the road map that we\u2019re executing on, we\n          have every reason to believe that we\u2019re going to continue to see\n          acceleration across all these dimensions.\n\n          142.        Kawasaki similarly claimed that Palantir\u2019s commercial sales cycle was\n\n  \u201c[h]eating up\u201d and gaining \u201cmomentum\u201d with new small and medium-sized business clients:\n\n          [Kawasaki:] [W]e signed up a number of great small and medium-sized\n          businesses recently. . . . Our sales cycle is [h]eating up.\n\n                                           *     *      *\n\n          Yes, the commercial business is gaining more and more momentum.\n          As we mentioned, it grew 72% in the U.S. So what we\u2019re seeing is where\n          economies are opening, there\u2019s just incredible traction there. We\u2019ve hired\n          50 sales folks in the last quarter. You\u2019re starting to see that translate\n          through in terms of activity, 2.5x the number of qualified opportunities in\n          the U.S. and the U.K., double the number of commercial pilots, the product\n          investments that we\u2019ve made around modularization and archetypes, those\n          are what are translating also into increased activity. It\u2019s what\u2019s fueling our\n          ability to do substantially more pilots here.\n\n          . . . We continue to win deals in Europe. [Faurecia], Lilium in Europe,\n          Fuzhou, Engie. So a bunch of momentum there. And as Europe starts to\n          open and manage through the pandemic, we\u2019re also expecting the same\n          sort of tailwind that we\u2019ve seen in the U.S. in Europe.\n\n          143.        With respect to the government segment, Sankar claimed that \u201cthe\n\n  momentum in our government business continues unabated,\u201d and both Sankar and\n\n  Glazer repeatedly claimed that the Company was experiencing government tailwinds:\n\n          [Sankar:] As we look forward, over the balance of the year, we continue to\n          have tailwinds as we pursue opportunities across both defense and civilian\n                                               - 58 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                109\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 64 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          agencies in our government business.\n\n          . . . This work dovetails with the strong pipeline we see in our\n          government business across a variety of defense initiatives, and we\n          expect deal activity to increase over the course of the year.\n\n                                             *     *      *\n\n          [Glazer:] We expect this momentum to continue as we have a significant\n          pipeline of government deals building in Q2 and beyond that we believe\n          will fuel durable, elevated growth in our government segment.\n\n          144.        On the call, an analyst specifically queried: \u201cOn the government business,\n\n  there\u2019s a lot of questions about the sustainable strength post-COVID.\u201d In response, Sankar\n\n  claimed the government business was \u201ccontinuing to build,\u201d \u201caccelerat[ing]\u201d and would\n\n  remain robust after the pandemic:\n\n          [Sankar:] We\u2019ve seen work across health care, DoD, civilian agencies,\n          accelerate inside the U.S. and outside of the U.S. We\u2019ve also seen that\n          the pipeline is continuing to build there. We\u2019re expecting a lot of\n          defense-related activity to build over the back half of the year and into\n          next year.\n\n          145.        The statements listed in \u00b6\u00b6140-144 above were false and misleading.\n\n  Contrary to the claim of \u201cmomentum in [the] government business continu[ing] unabated\u201d\n\n  with \u201ctailwinds\u201d and a \u201cstrong pipeline,\u201d Sankar, Kawasaki, and Glazer knew at the time\n\n  these statements were made (i.e., in the middle of 2Q21) that Palantir\u2019s government\n\n  segment\u2019s revenue growth rate was already in the midst of a sequential decline that had\n\n  started the prior quarter. Supra, \u00b6\u00b6124-127. Indeed, just the month before, Palantir had\n\n  been notified the Navy decided to end an $84 million contract in February 2022 \u2013 a year\n\n  earlier than the potential end date of February 2023 \u2013 and pay Palantir only $36 million, or\n\n  less than half the potential award amount. And, contrary to Sankar\u2019s and Kawasaki\u2019s claim\n\n\n                                                 - 59 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                  110\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 65 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  that the commercial segment was gaining \u201cmore and more momentum\u201d with a \u201cbigger and\n\n  bigger pipeline,\u201d in reality the expansion in Palantir\u2019s commercial sector was driven by the\n\n  unsustainable SPAC Scheme.\n\n                      5.    2Q21 Earnings: Defendants Misleadingly Portray a\n                            Strong Pipeline for Growth Across the Business\n\n          146.        On Palantir\u2019s August 12, 2021 2Q21 earnings call, Glazer reported that the\n\n  Company expected elevated growth in both its government and commercial segments:\n\n          [Glazer:] We continue to build a strong pipeline of opportunities within\n          our government segment, and we expect these deals to drive sustained,\n          elevated growth in our government business moving forward.\n\n          Second quarter commercial revenue growth accelerated to $144 million,\n          up 28% year-over-year compared with 19% growth in the first quarter.\n          Speed and innovation are driving strong results in our commercial\n          business, particularly in the U.S., where commercial revenue growth\n          accelerated to 90% year-over-year in Q2, up from 72% in Q1.32\n\n          147.        The statements in \u00b6146 were false and misleading. In reality, Glazer knew at\n\n  the time these statements were made (i.e., the middle of 3Q21) that the government\n\n  segment\u2019s revenue growth rate was in the midst of a third consecutive quarter of sequential\n\n  decline.     Supra, \u00b6\u00b6124-127.        Further, it was the SPAC Scheme \u2013 not \u201cspeed and\n\n  innovation\u201d \u2013 that was driving the stronger results Palantir reported in the commercial\n\n  segment.\n\n\n\n\n  32\n      These statements went hand-in-hand with Sankar\u2019s and Glazer\u2019s misleading 2Q21\n  statements citing SPAC-inflated commercial metrics as evidence of \u201cproduct innovation\u201d\n  and \u201ccontinued efficiencies\u201d driving growth. Supra, \u00b6119.\n\n\n                                                  - 60 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   111\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 66 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n                      6.    3Q21 Earnings: Defendants Misleadingly Claim\n                            Commercial Segment Is \u201cConsistently Accelerating\u201d and\n                            Government Segment Is \u201cBig and Building\u201d\n\n          148.        Palantir reported disappointing 3Q21 earnings results on November 9, 2021.\n\n  See infra, \u00b6175. Karp, Cohen, and Glazer, however, took advantage of the time lag\n\n  between the end of 3Q21 (September 30, 2021) and the public announcement of the 3Q21\n\n  results (November 9, 2021) to sell an additional $150 million in stock.\n\n          149.        On the November 9, 2021 3Q21 earnings call, Sankar repeatedly emphasized\n\n  Palantir\u2019s \u201caccelerating commercial business,\u201d claiming \u201c[c]utting-edge product and\n\n  continued innovation and distribution drove these exceptional results in Q3. And\n\n  you can really see that in the consistently accelerating commercial business.\u201d33\n\n          150.        With respect to the government segment, Sankar claimed that the\n\n  government \u201cpipeline in aggregate is big and building,\u201d and was \u201cjust at the beginning\n\n  of big secular trends here, trends that we anticipated and have invested in for years.\u201d\n\n          151.        The statements in \u00b6\u00b6149-150 were false and misleading. Sankar knew at the\n\n  time these statements were made (i.e., the middle of 4Q21) that the government segment\u2019s\n\n  revenue growth rate was in the midst of a fourth consecutive quarter of sequential decline.\n\n  Supra, \u00b6\u00b6124-127. And the \u201cconsistently accelerating\u201d commercial segment was only\n\n  accelerating because of the revenue Palantir recognized from SPACs \u2013 not \u201c[c]utting-edge\n\n  product and continued innovation\u201d as Defendants claimed.\n\n\n  33\n      These statements went hand-in-hand with Sankar\u2019s and Glazer\u2019s misleading 3Q21\n  statements citing SPAC-inflated commercial metrics as evidence of \u201caccelerating\u201d\n  commercial growth. Supra, \u00b6120.\n\n\n                                                 - 61 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                  112\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 67 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n                      7.    FY21 Earnings: Defendants Misleadingly Claim U.S.\n                            Commercial Growth Will Double While Denying the\n                            Sequential Deceleration of Government Growth\n\n          152.        On Palantir\u2019s February 17, 2022 FY21 earnings call, Karp claimed that\n\n  Palantir was on track to \u201cdouble\u201d its U.S. commercial growth in 2022:\n\n          [Karp:] Obviously, to the extent we get this to work, you could expect even\n          higher growth than what we have, although I\u2019m very happy with. It was like\n          we\u2019ve doubled USG U.S. commercial now from 50 to 100, 100 to 200. I\n          believe we will double it again this year.\n\n          153.        And even though the Company had already seen four sequential quarters of\n\n  deceleration in government revenue growth, Karp flat out denied the true state of affairs\n\n  when an analyst asked: \u201cIt did decelerate pretty materially in Q1 in terms of the growth.\n\n  Can you give us your perspective on what\u2019s happening on the government side?\u201d:\n\n          [Karp:] . . . Are there \u2013 is a deceleration in actual one over a long time\n          series? The answer is clearly no. . . .\n\n          154.        The statements listed in \u00b6\u00b6152-153 above were false and misleading.\n\n  Directly contrary to Karp\u2019s denial of a deceleration in the government business, at the time\n\n  these statements were made (i.e., in the middle of 1Q22) the government segment\u2019s\n\n  revenue growth rate was actually in the midst of the fifth consecutive quarter of sequential\n\n  decline. Nor was the Company positioned to double its U.S. commercial growth again in\n\n  2022, as the commercial expansion Palantir had experienced in 2021 was a product of the\n\n  SPAC Scheme, which represented a finite universe of revenue that Palantir had almost\n\n  completely tapped. Indeed, Defendants would announce that Palantir was winding down\n\n  its SPAC \u201cinvestments\u201d less than three months later.\n\n\n\n\n                                                - 62 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                 113\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 68 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n                      8.    1Q22 Earnings: Defendants Misleadingly Claim\n                            Palantir\u2019s Business Segments Are Seeing a\n                            \u201cReacceleration\u201d\n\n          155.        On the May 9, 2022 1Q22 earnings call, Defendants claimed there was a\n\n  \u201creacceleration\u201d of revenue growth in both business segments:\n\n          [Glazer:] In Q2 to date, we\u2019ve already seen the reacceleration of U.S.\n          government revenue and expect acceleration of the overall government\n          segment to follow in the next quarter or shortly thereafter.\n\n                                            *      *      *\n\n          [Kawasaki:] So in this macro environment, we feel very well positioned for\n          the full year and beyond. Our U.S. government revenue represented 42%\n          of our Q1 revenue, and a significant amount of this is in the defense space.\n          Our commercial business has been outpacing the government\n          business, accelerating in each of the last 5 quarters to a 54% growth\n          rate in Q1. And as Shyam just mentioned, in Q2, we\u2019ve already seen some\n          reacceleration in the U.S. government business, which we think is a long-\n          term trend and expect acceleration of the overall government segment\n          this quarter or shortly after.34\n\n          156.        The statements listed in \u00b6155 above were false and misleading. Defendants\n\n  misleadingly assured the market that government revenue growth was \u201creaccelerating,\u201d\n\n  when in reality at the time of these statements (i.e., the middle of 2Q22) the government\n\n  segment\u2019s revenue growth rate was actually in the midst of a sixth consecutive quarter of\n\n  sequential decline. Supra, \u00b6\u00b6124-127. And the commercial segment\u2019s sequential growth in\n\n  revenue was only made possible by the inclusion of the roundtrip SPAC deal revenue.\n\n  Supra, \u00a7IV.B.\n\n\n  34\n      These statements went hand-in-hand with Glazer\u2019s and Kawasaki\u2019s misleading 1Q22\n  statements citing SPAC-inflated commercial metrics as evidence of \u201cwinning\u201d new\n  commercial customers. Supra, \u00b6121.\n\n\n                                                 - 63 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                  114\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 69 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          D.          Defendants Falsely Assure Investors that Palantir Was\n                      Positioned to Achieve 30% Long-Term Revenue Growth\n\n          157.        Beginning in February 2021, Defendants repeatedly (mis)represented that\n\n  Palantir was poised to generate annual revenue growth of more than 30% in each of the\n\n  next five years such that Palantir would break $4 billion in annual revenue by 2025 \u2013\n\n  guidance that Defendants would abandon just 18 months later in August 2022. Starting on\n\n  the February 16, 2021 FY20 earnings call, Defendants committed Palantir to this guidance:\n\n          [Karp:] [W]e are providing long-term guidance, pretty radical in the\n          sense that we are committing to keeping a growth threshold of above\n          30% for the next 5 years . . . .\n\n                                            *      *     *\n\n          [Glazer:] Starting in 2021, we expect greater than 30% annual revenue\n          growth each year for the next 5 years.\n\n          158.        Defendants reiterated this misleading revenue guidance in its subsequent\n\n  earnings releases through 1Q22, beginning with Palantir\u2019s May 11, 2021 1Q21 Release:\n\n          Per long-term guidance policy, as provided by our Chief Executive\n          Officer, Alex Karp, we continue to expect: Annual revenue growth of\n          30% or greater for 2021 through 2025.35\n\n          159.        Glazer also repeated this misleading revenue guidance on subsequent\n\n  earnings calls through 1Q22, beginning with the May 11, 2021 1Q21 earnings call:\n\n          [Glazer:] Continuing to execute the guidance strategy set forth by our\n          CEO, Alex Karp, in our year-end 2020 earnings call with regard to long-\n          term revenue guidance, we are providing and will continue to provide\n\n  35\n      This statement (\u00b6158) was repeated in Palantir\u2019s: (i) August 12, 2021 2Q21 Release\n  (signed by Karp); (ii) November 9, 2021 3Q21 Release (signed by Karp); (iii) February 17,\n  2022 FY21 Release (signed by Karp); and (iv) May 9, 2022 1Q22 Release (signed by\n  Karp).\n\n\n                                                - 64 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                 115\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 70 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          [revenue] guidance of [greater than] 30% . . . for this year and the next\n          [4] years at each earnings call.36\n\n          160.        The representations in \u00b6\u00b6157-159 above were false and misleading. As\n\n  discussed in supra, \u00a7IV.C, at the time of each statement, Karp and Glazer knew that\n\n  Palantir had already hit a wall in its growth rate in both business segments. This sequential\n\n  decline in growth rates had commenced in 1Q21 and worsened each quarter in which this\n\n  guidance was reiterated. To mask this decline, Defendants implemented the SPAC\n\n  Scheme, which materially distorted Palantir\u2019s reported financial metrics, as discussed in\n\n  supra, \u00b6\u00b6101-122. Further, Defendants knew that Palantir would not realize a substantial\n\n  portion of the SPAC deals. See supra, \u00b6\u00b659-60. Nor was the SPAC Scheme sustainable,\n\n  as Defendants had tapped the universe of SPACs from whom Palantir could purchase\n\n  revenue within nine months of the first deal. As a result, Defendants had no reasonable\n\n  basis to believe, and did not believe, Palantir could achieve the long-term guidance that\n\n  Karp and Glazer touted in \u00b6\u00b6157-159. Indeed, if not for the SPAC Scheme artificially (and\n\n  temporarily) propping up Palantir\u2019s declining revenue growth rate, Palantir\u2019s growth rate\n\n  would have fallen below the 30% long-term annual growth number in 3Q21 \u2013 three full\n\n  quarters before 2Q22 when Palantir so acknowledged. Supra, \u00b6111.\n\n          E.          Defendants Manipulated the Reporting of Key Reported\n                      Metrics in Order to Mislead the Market\n\n          161.        As the Company experienced declining growth rates and profitability in 2021,\n\n\n  36\n       Glazer repeated this statement (\u00b6159) in substantially the same format during Palantir\u2019s:\n  (i) August 12, 2021 2Q21 earnings call; (ii) November 9, 2021 3Q21 earnings call; and (iii)\n  May 9, 2022 1Q22 earnings call.\n\n\n                                                  - 65 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   116\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 71 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  Defendants began manipulating key metrics critical to evaluating the state of Palantir\u2019s\n\n  business in furtherance of their scheme in violation of Rule 10b-5(a) and (c).\n\n                      1.     Definition of \u201cCustomer\u201d: Defendants Start Including\n                             Customers from the Entire Prior Year in 1Q21\n\n          162.        For its quarterly earnings reports, Palantir originally defined a \u201ccustomer\u201d as\n\n  one might expect, i.e., \u201can organization from which we have recognized revenue in a\n\n  reporting period.\u201d But starting with its 1Q21 earnings, Defendants altered the definition of\n\n  \u201ccustomer\u201d to include \u201can[y] organization from which we have recognized revenue during\n\n  the trailing twelve month period.\u201d That is, instead of reporting the number of customers\n\n  from whom Palantir received revenue during the current quarter, Palantir manipulated its\n\n  \u201ccustomer\u201d reporting beginning in 1Q21 to report the total number of customers from whom\n\n  it received revenue during any of the four prior quarters. By doing so, Defendants\n\n  artificially inflated Palantir\u2019s customer count and the revenue recognized from each\n\n  customer starting in 1Q21 by including the temporarily boosted financial performance in\n\n  2Q20, 3Q20, and 4Q20, which was driven by the COVID-19-related contracts Palantir\n\n  entered into during 2020.\n\n                      2.     Average Contract Duration: Defendants Stop Regular\n                             Quarterly Disclosures in 3Q21\n\n          163.        Defendants repeatedly cited average contract duration as a metric providing\n\n  strong visibility into future revenue \u2013 as it measured the additional number of years\n\n  Defendants expected to generate revenue under existing customer contracts. As it was\n\n  increasing, Defendants regularly reported this metric every quarter, touting an average\n\n  contract length of 3.6 years in 3Q20 and FY20, up to 3.7 years in 1Q21, and then 3.9 years\n\n                                                   - 66 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    117\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 72 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  in 2Q21. Defendants acknowledged with their 3Q20 earnings that such increases provided\n\n  them with \u201cadditional visibility on the revenue.\u201d Defendants, however, failed to disclose\n\n  average contract duration with 3Q21, 1Q22, or 2Q22 earnings \u2013 only revealing with FY21\n\n  earnings that it had fallen to an average of 3.5 years. This change was designed to and did\n\n  further obscure the deterioration in Palantir\u2019s prospects, and prevented investors from\n\n  assessing the stability and sustainability of future revenue growth.\n\n                      3.    Palantir\u2019s Acquire, Expand, Scale Business Model:\n                            Defendants Stop Reporting All Related Metrics in 1Q22\n\n          164.        Defendants claimed in the Registration Statement and subsequent quarterly\n\n  SEC filings that Palantir\u2019s entire business model, with respect to acquiring and growing its\n\n  customer accounts, had three phases: (1) Acquire; (2) Expand; and (3) Scale. Each\n\n  customer was categorized into one of these \u201ccohorts\u201d on December 31st each year:\n\n  \uf0b7       Acquire (or customer acquisition) is the first phase. During this phase, Palantir\n          acquires new customers through pilot deployments of Palantir software. See supra,\n          \u00b6\u00b635, 40-43. Customer accounts are operated at a loss during the Acquire phase.\n          Customers are cohorted into this phase if, as of the end of a calendar year, Palantir\n          has recognized less than $100,000 in revenue from the customer that year.\n\n  \uf0b7       Expand (or account growth) is the second phase during which Palantir invests\n          significant resources and accounts are operated at a loss to drive future revenue\n          growth. Customers are cohorted into the Expand phase when: (i) Palantir has\n          recognized more than $100,000 in revenue in a calendar year; and (ii) the account\n          has a negative contribution margin during the year at issue, as determined as of the\n          end of the year.\n\n  \uf0b7       Scale (or account profitability) is the final phase. During this phase, Palantir\u2019s\n          investment costs relative to revenue generally decrease, while usage of the platform\n          increases across the customer\u2019s operations. Palantir stated that after having\n          installed and configured the software across an entire enterprise, customers\n          become more self-sufficient in their use of its platforms, including developing\n          software and applications that run on top of the platforms, while still continuing to\n          benefit from the support of Palantir\u2019s operations and maintenance services.\n          Customers are cohorted into the Scale phase when: (i) Palantir has recognized\n                                              - 67 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                  118\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 73 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          more than $100,000 in revenue in a calendar year; and (ii) the account has a\n          positive contribution margin during the year at issue, as determined at year-end.\n\n          165.        Palantir\u2019s Business Model. According to Defendants, Palantir\u2019s entire\n\n  approach to sales and marketing was built around the first two phases of its business\n\n  model, and its ability to turn a profit hinged on the third phase. As customers move from\n\n  Acquire to Expand to Scale, Palantir\u2019s costs decrease and its revenue and contribution\n\n  margin increase. Thus, Defendants\u2019 \u201cobjective is to make the Acquire and Expand phases\n\n  as short as possible\u201d to quickly get to Scale. Defendants repeatedly told investors that\n\n  \u201c[w]e believe that all of our customers will move into the Scale phase over the long term.\u201d\n\n          166.        To this end, Palantir presented investors with detailed quantitative information\n\n  regarding the Acquire, Expand, Scale phases in all of its quarterly SEC filings under the\n\n  heading \u201cOur Business Model\u201d from the start of the Class Period up until the filing of the\n\n  FY21 Form 10-K.            Each filing provided investors with updates on the revenue and\n\n  contribution margins derived from each cohort for the prior year. These Acquire, Expand,\n\n  and Scale disclosures were critical as they were the way investors could gauge the\n\n  Company\u2019s commercial segment growth prospects.\n\n          167.        But throughout the Class Period, Palantir\u2019s new customers were failing to\n\n  advance through the cohorts to the Scale phase.                 As these deteriorating business\n\n  prospects threatened to emerge, Defendants began to actively conceal this information\n\n  from the market, eliminating all disclosures related to the Acquire, Expand, and Scale\n\n  phases \u2013 beginning with Palantir\u2019s 1Q22 Form 10-Q.                  That is, Defendants stopped\n\n  reporting data and metrics for the three customer phases on which it had built its entire\n\n  business model to go public.\n                                                   - 68 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    119\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 74 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          168.        Concealing the detailed cohort information tracking the performance of the\n\n  Company\u2019s new FY21 customers was designed to and did obscure Palantir\u2019s diminishing\n\n  business prospects for its organic (i.e., non-SPAC) customers, including the: (i) revenue\n\n  and contribution margins associated with each cohort of new customers acquired in FY21;\n\n  (ii) rate at which Palantir\u2019s customers signed in 2021 had failed to advance through the\n\n  cohorts to profitability; and (iii) SPAC Scheme\u2019s effect in masking this downward trend.\n\n                      4.    Total Remaining Deal Value (\u201cTRDV\u201d): Defendants\n                            Conceal Segment-Level Breakdown in 1Q22\n\n          169.        Palantir\u2019s customer contracts are typically multiyear agreements, and the\n\n  Company recognized revenue over the contract\u2019s life. TRDV represents the total value of\n\n  the contracts that Palantir had been awarded but not yet recognized as revenue. Thus,\n\n  TRDV purportedly provided management significant visibility into Palantir\u2019s future expected\n\n  revenue and was cited by Defendants as a \u201ckey\u201d measure of future revenue visibility.\n\n          170.        Palantir disclosed TRDV in the government and commercial sectors\n\n  separately, although it reported these figures inconsistently. The Registration Statement,\n\n                                                 - 69 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                  120\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 75 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  3Q20 Form 10-Q, and FY20 Form 10-K provided updates on government segment TRDV\n\n  for 2Q20, 3Q20, and FY20, respectively, yet the 1Q21, 2Q21, and 3Q21 Forms 10-Q each\n\n  concealed current quarterly TRDV information and instead misleadingly referred back to\n\n  TRDV as of the end of FY20. While Defendants provided quarterly updates on enterprise-\n\n  wide TRDV on earnings presentations, they concealed the split between government and\n\n  commercial in both 1Q21 and 1Q22. See supra, \u00b6115. This change was designed to and\n\n  did further obscure the distinction in growth trends between the two sectors, preventing\n\n  investors from gleaning the truth about the adverse trends affecting both business\n\n  segments, as they were masked by the commercial segment\u2019s SPAC-inflated TRDV.\n\n                      5.    Average Revenue Per Customer: Defendants Switch to\n                            Only Reporting Palantir\u2019s Top 20 Customers in 1Q22 in\n                            Order to Hide that Customers Were Not Scaling Up\n\n          171.        Average revenue per customer represented the average amount of revenue\n\n  Palantir recognized from all its customers during a specified period. In 1Q21 and 2Q21,\n\n  Palantir emphasized this increasing metric as proof that the Company was continuing to\n\n  demonstrate its \u201cability to grow customer relationships at scale.\u201d As the metric decreased\n\n  in 3Q21 and 4Q21, Palantir shifted, claiming that the lower average revenue per customer\n\n  was just the \u201cresult of [their] growing customer count.\u201d Then in 1Q22, Defendants further\n\n  attempted to conceal declines in the metric by omitting the figure from the market altogether\n\n  and switching to only reporting \u201caverage revenue for the top twenty customers.\u201d By\n\n  manipulating Palantir\u2019s reporting of this metric at the same time as the Acquire, Expand,\n\n  Scale information \u2013 and disclosing information for only the largest customers that already\n\n  provided significant revenue \u2013 Defendants were able to conceal from investors that\n\n                                                - 70 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                121\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 76 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  Palantir\u2019s newest customers were not scaling up in size or profitability.\n\n  V.      LOSS CAUSATION\n\n          172.        The market for Palantir stock was open, well-developed, and efficient during\n\n  the Class Period \u2013 throughout which Palantir stock traded at artificially inflated prices due to\n\n  Defendants\u2019 misconduct. As the relevant truth about Palantir\u2019s business and prospects\n\n  entered the market through a series of partial disclosures, the artificial inflation came out of\n\n  Palantir\u2019s stock price over time. As a result of their purchases of Palantir stock during the\n\n  Class Period, which relied upon the integrity of the market price, Plaintiffs and other Class\n\n  members suffered economic loss, i.e., damages, under the federal securities laws.\n\n          173.        The corrective impact of the partial disclosures during the Class Period,\n\n  however, was tempered by Defendants\u2019 continuing scheme and misleading statements and\n\n  omissions. Each partial disclosure did not on its own fully remove the inflation from\n\n  Palantir\u2019s stock price. Defendants\u2019 ongoing scheme, misrepresentations, and omissions\n\n  maintained the price of Palantir stock at artificially inflated levels.\n\n          174.        The disclosures that corrected the market price of Palantir shares are detailed\n\n  below. All or a substantial portion of each of these stock price declines were due to firm-\n\n  specific, fraud-related disclosures and not market, industry, or firm-specific, non-fraud\n\n  factors.\n\n          A.          November 2021 Loss Event\n\n          175.        On November 9, 2021, before the market opened, Palantir issued its 3Q21\n\n  Release \u2013 which revealed a significant deceleration in Palantir\u2019s revenue growth, including\n\n  quarterly revenue of $392 million (36% YoY revenue growth), and projected 4Q21 revenue\n\n                                                   - 71 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    122\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 77 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  of $418 million (which would represent 30% YoY revenue growth, compared to 49% YoY\n\n  revenue growth in the prior quarter). That same day, Palantir also filed its 3Q21 Form 10-\n\n  Q, which revealed that Palantir\u2019s government revenue had actually declined on a sequential\n\n  basis from $232 million to $218 million for 3Q21 and that its contribution margins had also\n\n  declined. The price of Palantir shares declined on this news, falling 9.3% to $24.25 per\n\n  share on November 9, 2021, on abnormally high volume, as compared to a 0.4% decline in\n\n  the S&P 500 Index and a 0.4% decline in the S&P Information Technology Index.37\n\n          176.        Following the close of the market on November 9, 2021, numerous analyst\n\n  firms published reports reacting negatively to this news. For instance:\n\n  \uf0b7       RBC Capital Markets (\u201cRBC\u201d) published a report downgrading Palantir stock from\n          \u201c[s]ector [p]erform\u201d to \u201c[u]nderperform,\u201d citing \u201cgovernment deceleration\u201d as one\n          reason for the downgrade and noting \u201c[w]e believe Palantir got direct benefits from\n          COVID-related spending and those benefits have already faded.\u201d The report also\n          cited \u201ccommercial deceleration\u201d and commented on \u201c[c]racks [e]merging in the\n          [SPAC] [s]tory,\u201d stating: \u201cWe do not believe revenue from SPAC investments is\n          sustainable . . . .\u201d The report also expressed \u201clowered confidence in 30%+ growth\u201d\n          in light of the deceleration in both the commercial and government businesses.\n\n  \uf0b7       Deutsche Bank called the quarter \u201c[t]hesis [c]hallenging\u201d and citing \u201c[s]urprising\n          [g]ovt [d]ecel, SPAC [i]nvestments and [m]argins.\u201d In particular, Deutsche Bank\n          noted Palantir\u2019s \u201c[g]overnment business decelerating significantly\u201d and that,\n          \u201cexcluding related party revenue, [commercial] actually decelerated.\u201d It also stated:\n          \u201cGross margins continue to compress and contribution margins declined, all raising\n          questions around the mix and [long-term] profitability of the business.\u201d\n\n  \uf0b7       William Blair published an analyst report, \u201cestimat[ing]\u201d that without the SPACs\n          Palantir\u2019s commercial revenue \u201clikely\u201d had decelerated; that revenue from the\n          SPACs was, in their view, unsustainable; and that overall total deal value was down\n          sequentially excluding SPACs.\n\n\n  37\n      Palantir\u2019s annual reports on Form 10-K compared the performance of its returns to the\n  returns of the S&P 500 Index and the S&P Information Technology Index.\n\n\n                                                - 72 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                 123\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 78 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          177.        In response, Palantir\u2019s stock price declined another 7.1%, on unusually high\n\n  volume, to close at $22.52 per share on November 10, 2021, while the S&P 500 and S&P\n\n  Information Technology Indices declined only 0.8% and 1.7%, respectively. All told,\n\n  Palantir\u2019s two-day stock price decline totaled nearly 16%, compared to respective two-day\n\n  declines of just 1.2% and 2.1% in the S&P 500 and S&P Information Technology Indices.\n\n          B.          February 2022 Loss Event\n\n          178.        On February 17, 2022, Palantir issued its FY21 Release \u2013 which revealed that\n\n  Palantir\u2019s government business continued to decelerate to just 26% YoY growth in 4Q21\n\n  (compared to a 76% YoY growth rate earlier in the year). The same day, Palantir issued: (i)\n\n  its FY 2021 Business Update presentation, which revealed declining YoY contribution\n\n  margins, falling from 62% in 4Q20 to 58% in 4Q21; and (ii) accompanying remarks that\n\n  further revealed Palantir\u2019s TRDV at quarter\u2019s end was $3.8 billion \u2013 indicating significant\n\n  business deceleration. Factoring out Palantir\u2019s SPAC Scheme, Palantir\u2019s total deal value\n\n  was essentially flat year-over-year. Further, as was later revealed, Palantir\u2019s government\n\n  TRDV had actually declined by $100 million from the prior year and $200 million from the\n\n  prior quarter. Additionally, although Defendants provided 2022 revenue guidance, 1Q22\n\n  operating margin guidance of 23% was below analysts\u2019 consensus of 28%.\n\n          179.        Analysts reacted negatively to this news. RBC published a report on the\n\n  same day reiterating an underperform rating while reducing its price target by 40% to $9\n\n  from $15. William Blair issued a report highlighting Palantir\u2019s decelerating growth and\n\n  calling SPACs a \u201c[k]ey [t]ailwind,\u201d and after the market closed, Deutsche Bank published a\n\n  report reducing its price target because contribution margins declined and total deal value\n\n                                                  - 73 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   124\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 79 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  \u201cexcluding related party contributions [i.e., SPACs] decelerated to 1% y/y growth.\u201d\n\n          180.        The price of Palantir shares declined on this news, falling nearly 16% to close\n\n  at $11.77 per share on February 17, 2022 on abnormally high trading volume, while the\n\n  S&P 500 Index only declined 2.1% and the S&P Information Technology Index declined\n\n  only 3.1%. Palantir\u2019s stock price continued to decline on February 18, 2022 as the market\n\n  digested and reacted to the adverse information, dropping another 6.4% while the S&P 500\n\n  and S&P Information Technology Indices declined just 0.7% and 1.1%, respectively.\n\n          C.          May 2022 Loss Event\n\n          181.        On May 9, 2022, before the market opened, Palantir issued its 1Q22 Release\n\n  \u2013 which revealed that Palantir expected 2Q22 revenue of $470 million, which would\n\n  represent only 25% YoY growth \u2013 substantially below the Company\u2019s 30% long-term\n\n  revenue guidance. Further, Palantir\u2019s 2Q22 guidance of 25.1% YoY revenue growth and\n\n  20% operating margin was approximately one-third below consensus estimates of 28.8%\n\n  and 26.5%, respectively. Also on May 9, 2022, after the market closed, Palantir filed its\n\n  1Q22 Form 10-Q, which disclosed Palantir\u2019s Starry Group and Allego SPAC investments.\n\n  The 1Q22 Form 10-Q also revealed that Palantir had received over $39 million in revenue\n\n  from its SPAC Scheme during the quarter, meaning that without this program standalone\n\n  1Q22 revenue growth would have been only 19%. That same day, Defendants convened a\n\n  conference call, on which they disclosed that the Company\u2019s total deal value had actually\n\n  declined by $300 million during the quarter, that Palantir had \u201cwound the [SPAC] program\n\n  down,\u201d and the Company was reporting \u201cnegative $0.02 impact on earnings per share from\n\n  the marketable securities.\u201d Defendants also disclosed that SPACs\u2019 contribution to total\n\n                                                   - 74 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    125\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 80 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  deal value was $755 million in the quarter, down from $965 million in 4Q21.\n\n          182.        Analyst firms reacted negatively to this news on May 9, 2022:\n\n  \uf0b7       RBC published a report downgrading Palantir, citing as \u201cdisappointing\u201d that \u201c1Q\n          topline lacked upside to consensus,\u201d that \u201c2Q guide missed consensus on both\n          revenue growth & profitability,\u201d and that \u201cTotal Deal Value growth ex \u2018investment\n          agreements\u2019 declined both Y/Y and Q/Q.\u201d\n\n  \uf0b7       Credit Suisse decreased its target price citing as \u201c[n]egatives\u201d the news that\n          \u201cexcluding ~$39M of SPAC investments, standalone growth was 19.4% y/y in Q1 vs.\n          26.3% y/y in Q4\u201d and that \u201c[r]eported total remaining deal value of $3.5 billion (26%\n          y/y) compared to $3.8 billion (35% y/y) in Q4, declining $300 million sequentially.\u201d\n\n  \uf0b7       Despite the partial disclosures of SPAC-related problems, analysts saw the\n          program\u2019s winding down as the right move, while noting they lacked the ability to\n          calculate the underlying businesses\u2019 strength. Analysts such as William Blair and\n          RBC noted they were \u201cdisappointed with fewer disclosures in the 10-Q\u201d and forced\n          to guess about the state of some of Palantir\u2019s SPAC investments, without knowing\n          some had already been terminated.\n\n          183.        The price of Palantir shares declined on this news, falling 21% over a single\n\n  trading day to $7.46 per share by market close on May 9, 2022, on abnormally high trading\n\n  volume, while the S&P 500 and S&P Information Technology Indices fell just 3.2% and\n\n  3.9%, respectively. Palantir\u2019s stock price fell another 10% over the next two days, again on\n\n  high trading volume, as the 1Q22 Form 10-Q was released and analysts further\n\n  downgraded Palantir stock, to close at $6.71 per share on May 11, 2022. By contrast, the\n\n  S&P 500 Index declined only 1.4% and the S&P Information Technology Index declined\n\n  only 1.8% over May 10-11, 2022.\n\n          D.          August 2022 Loss Event\n\n          184.        On August 8, 2022, Palantir issued its 2Q22 Release \u2013 which stated that\n\n  Palantir expected 2022 revenue to be in a range of $1.9 billion to $1.902 billion, which\n\n  would represent an annual YoY revenue growth rate of only 23%. This was well below the\n                                                  - 75 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   126\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 81 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  Company\u2019s 30% long-term guidance, despite Defendants reaffirming this figure nearly\n\n  halfway through the quarter. The release further stated that the \u201crevised guidance excludes\n\n  any new major U.S. government awards.\u201d The release also disclosed that Palantir had\n\n  terminated several SPAC contracts, further reducing TCV, and that its growth had further\n\n  decelerated without SPACs. The same day, Palantir released its 2Q22 Form 10-Q, which\n\n  disclosed additional SPAC-related information. In a related earnings call, Glazer admitted\n\n  that the Company\u2019s deal value remained \u201croughly flat quarter-over-quarter\u201d at $3.5 billion.\n\n          185.        Analyst and market commentators reacted negatively to this news. For\n\n  instance, on August 9, 2022, RBC published a report that provided a deep dive into\n\n  Palantir\u2019s SPAC-related misconduct. The report stated: \u201cMost importantly, we estimate the\n\n  SPAC-related [total contract value] potentially at-risk of not fully converting into revenue is\n\n  $406M (note some of this may have already been recognized) and count at least 15 SPAC\n\n  customers that have substantial doubt as going concerns (based on their respective\n\n  filings).\u201d The report continued: \u201c21 of these companies are now publicly listed; none of the\n\n  20 listed SPACs are trading above their $10 reference price (the vast majority are now\n\n  trading in the <$5 penny stock range).\u201d\n\n          186.        The price of Palantir stock declined again on this news, falling 19% over two\n\n  trading days (-14.2% on August 8 and -5.8% on August 9) to $9.25 per share by market\n\n  close on August 9, 2022, on abnormally high trading volume, while the S&P 500 and S&P\n\n  Information Technology Indices only fell 0.5% and 1.9%, respectively.\n\n  VI.     THE INDIVIDUAL DEFENDANTS\u2019 $2.2 BILLION OF INSIDER TRADING\n          FURTHER SUPPORTS A STRONG INFERENCE OF SCIENTER\n\n          187.        The Individual Defendants had substantial incentive to commit the fraud\n                                                - 76 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   127\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 82 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  alleged herein. In August 2020, in furtherance of the scheme, Palantir\u2019s Board established\n\n  a Special Compensation Committee to assess the propriety of Karp\u2019s, Cohen\u2019s, and\n\n  Sankar\u2019s compensation, which granted to the executives the following awards:\n\n\n\n\n          188.        These awards were substantial, with Karp\u2019s alone valued at the time at $1.1\n\n  billion. The Wall Street Journal described the award as one of \u201cthe biggest compensation\n\n  packages ever awarded.\u201d Glazer also received an award of restricted stock units covering\n\n  more than 4 million shares. To unlock these awards, all the Individual Defendants were\n\n  required to do was take Palantir public, which they did in September 2020.\n\n          189.        In connection with and immediately following Palantir\u2019s direct listing, the\n\n  Individual Defendants commenced a massive insider selling spree. Their Class Period\n\n  insider sales of 122,038,868 Palantir shares for over $2.2 billion in proceeds supports a\n\n  strong inference that the Individual Defendants timed their respective trading with\n\n  knowledge of the alleged fraud and sought to capture the stock\u2019s artificially inflated trading\n\n  price before the market could absorb the truth regarding Palantir\u2019s actual growth and\n\n  margin trends. As demonstrated below and in Appendix 1, the magnitude of the Individual\n\n  Defendants\u2019 sales is extraordinary \u2013 if not unprecedented \u2013 and represented significant\n\n  proportions of each of their total shares38:\n\n\n  38\n       The percentage sold calculation equals the number of shares sold divided by total\n\n                                                  - 77 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                  128\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 83 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n                                                                                     % Sold\n         Defendant                    Shares                Proceeds   % Sold          incl.\n                                        Sold                                         vested\n         Alexander Karp           52,976,553       $1,050,011,752         89%         40.6%\n         Peter Thiel              47,391,859         $783,336,392         27%         22.5%\n         Stephen Cohen            11,036,391        $188,188,139       99.99%         27.8%\n         Shyam Sankar              6,444,950         $117,701,892         77%         41.3%\n         David Glazer              4,189,115          $63,134,903         72%         71.7%\n\n          190.        The total proceeds and percentage of holdings sold are astronomical \u2013 Karp\u2019s\n\n  stock sales yielded him 95,200% more than his 2021 compensation, Cohen 15,200% more\n\n  than his 2021 compensation, Sankar 23,000% more than his 2021 compensation, and\n\n  Glazer 13,900% more than his 2021 compensation.\n\n          191.        Defendants timed their sales suspiciously to coincide with peak Palantir stock\n\n  prices, offloading more than 116 million shares in the 13 months before the first corrective\n\n  disclosure on November 9, 2021, or 95% of the shares they sold during the Class Period.\n\n  Defendants dramatically tempered their sales as the relevant truth was revealed to the\n\n  market through a series of disclosures and Palantir\u2019s stock price declined.39\n\n          192.        The rates at which each Individual Defendant sold his stock after the Class\n\n\n  shares. Total shares, used to calculate \u201c% Sold,\u201d represent the sum of Class A shares sold\n  during and held on the last day of the Class Period. Total shares, used to calculate \u201c%\n  Sold incl. vested,\u201d include Class A and Class B shares held as of November 2, 2022, Class\n  B common stock subject to options exercisable within 60 days of November 2, 2022, and\n  Class B common stock subject to RSUs for which the applicable vesting and settlement\n  conditions will be satisfied within 60 days of November 2, 2022. This total thus includes an\n  additional five months of vesting, and, therefore, presents an overly conservative estimate\n  of Defendants\u2019 percentage of shares sold.\n  39\n     In addition, Karp, Cohen, and Glazer took advantage of the time lag between the end of\n  3Q21 (September 30, 2021) and the public announcement of Palantir\u2019s disappointing 3Q21\n  results (November 9, 2021) to sell over $150 million in stock, collectively.\n\n\n                                                   - 78 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   129\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 84 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  Period are also dramatically out of line with their Class Period insider sales.40 The table\n\n  below depicts the Individual Defendants\u2019 sales on an average monthly basis.\n\n                          Number of Shares Sold                    Rate (shares/month)\n                           Class                             Class                CP vs. Post-\n       Defendant           Period     Post-CP               Period     Post-CP         CP\n       Karp              52,976,553    7,026,434            2,358,006 320,354 636.1% greater\n       Thiel             47,391,859   20,000,000            2,109,429 911,854 131.3% greater\n       Cohen             11,036,391    3,817,785              491,234 174,063 182.2% greater\n       Sankar             6,444,950    6,413,542              286,867 292,411          1.9% less\n       Glazer             4,189,115    2,344,705              186,459 106,901     74.4% greater\n\n          193.        For Palantir\u2019s founders, selling in such volumes would normally dilute their\n\n  ownership and control of the Company, as Class A shares entitle the holder to one vote per\n\n  share and Class B shares (convertible into Class A shares) entitle the holder to ten votes\n\n  per share. Karp, Thiel, and Cohen, however, had formulated a plan that would allow them\n\n  to balance these competing concerns.\n\n          194.        To ensure their control of Palantir regardless of the number of Class B shares\n\n  they converted or Class A shares they sold, Karp, Thiel, and Cohen implemented one of\n\n  the most aggressive governance structures ever devised. In particular, in August 2020, the\n\n  Company created a special class of stock \u2013 Class F for \u201cfounders.\u201d The Class F shares,\n\n  owned by Thiel, Karp, and Cohen through a trust, guarantee the founders at least\n\n  49.99999% of the total votes, \u201cnotwithstanding the number of outstanding shares of Class\n\n  A common stock and Class B common stock or the Founders\u2019 relative ownership of shares\n\n  of Class A common stock and Class B common stock,\u201d so long as they retained a collective\n\n  40\n     The Individual Defendants\u2019 stock sales before the Class Period (if any) are not publicly\n  reported, as Palantir was not publicly listed until September 30, 2020.\n\n\n                                                   - 79 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   130\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 85 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  \u201cOwnership Threshold\u201d equal to approximately 6%.\n\n          195.        This structure allowed the founders to \u201ceffectively [retain] control [of] all\n\n  matters submitted to a vote of the stockholders for the foreseeable future.\u201d As the\n\n  cofounders die, control of the Class F shares is consolidated with the remaining founders.\n\n  The provision terminates only when the last of Palantir\u2019s founders dies.41\n\n  VII.    APPLICABILITY OF THE PRESUMPTION OF RELIANCE\n\n          196.        Plaintiffs will rely, in part, upon the presumption of reliance established by the\n\n  fraud-on-the-market doctrine in that: (i) Defendants made public misrepresentations or\n\n  failed to disclose material facts during the Class Period; (ii) the omissions and\n\n  misrepresentations were material; (iii) Palantir stock traded in an efficient market; and (iv)\n\n  Plaintiffs and Class members purchased, acquired, and/or sold Palantir stock between the\n\n  time Defendants failed to disclose or misrepresented material facts and the time the true\n\n  facts were disclosed. Based upon the foregoing, Plaintiffs and Class members are entitled\n\n  to a presumption of reliance upon the integrity of the market.\n\n          197.        Plaintiffs and Class members are also entitled to the presumption of reliance\n\n  established by the Supreme Court in Affiliated Ute Citizens v. United States, 406 U.S. 128\n\n  (1972), as Defendants omitted material information in their Class Period statements in\n\n  violation of a duty to disclose such information, as detailed above.\n\n\n\n  41\n      Moreover, pursuant to the Founder Voting Trust Agreement, the Class F shares cannot\n  be sold. The trust through which Karp, Cohen, and Thiel hold the Class F shares is\n  prohibited from transferring or converting the shares, and the founders are prohibited from\n  transferring their interest in the trust.\n\n\n                                                    - 80 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                     131\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 86 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  VIII.   CLASS ACTION ALLEGATIONS\n\n          198.        Plaintiffs bring this class action pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(a) and (b)(3) on\n\n  behalf of a class, consisting of all those who purchased Palantir Class A common stock\n\n  during the Class Period (the \u201cClass\u201d) and were damaged thereby,42 as:\n\n  \uf0b7       The members of the Class are so numerous that joinder is impracticable;\n\n  \uf0b7       Plaintiffs\u2019 claims are typical of the claims of the members of the Class as all\n          members of the Class are similarly affected by Defendants\u2019 wrongful conduct;\n\n  \uf0b7       Plaintiffs will fairly and adequately protect the interests of the members of the Class\n          and have retained competent and experienced counsel. Plaintiffs have no interests\n          antagonistic to or in conflict with those of the Class;\n\n  \uf0b7       Common questions of law and fact exist as to all of the Class and predominate over\n          any questions solely affecting individual members of the Class, including: (i) whether\n          the federal securities laws were violated by Defendants\u2019 acts as alleged herein; (ii)\n          whether the members of the Class have sustained damages and, if so, what is the\n          proper measure of damages; and\n\n  \uf0b7       A class action is superior to all other available methods for the fair and efficient\n          adjudication of this controversy.\n\n  IX.     EXCHANGE ACT CLAIMS\n\n                                               COUNT I\n                           For Violation of \u00a710(b) of the Exchange Act and\n                                Rule 10b-5 Promulgated Thereunder\n\n          199.        Plaintiffs repeat and reallege each and every allegation set forth above.\n\n          200.        This Count is brought against each of the Defendants based upon \u00a710(b) of\n\n  the Exchange Act, 15 U.S.C. \u00a778j(b), and SEC Rule 10b-5 promulgated thereunder.\n\n\n\n  42\n     Excluded from the Class are Defendants, Palantir\u2019s officers and directors, at all relevant\n  times, members of their immediate families and their legal representatives, heirs,\n  successors or assigns, and any entity in which Defendants have had a controlling interest.\n\n\n                                                    - 81 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                     132\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 87 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          201.        Defendants engaged in a course of conduct pursuant to which they knowingly\n\n  and/or recklessly engaged in acts, transactions, and practices which operated as a fraud\n\n  and deceit upon Plaintiffs and the other Class members in connection with the purchase\n\n  and sale of securities. Defendants knowingly and/or recklessly made various untrue\n\n  statements of material fact and omitted to state material facts necessary in order to make\n\n  the statements made, in light of the circumstances under which they were made, not\n\n  misleading; and employed a course of business, which conduct was intended to, and,\n\n  throughout the Class Period, did: (i) deceive the investing public, including Plaintiffs and\n\n  other Class members; (ii) artificially inflate and maintain the market price of Palantir stock;\n\n  and (iii) cause Plaintiffs and other Class members to purchase or otherwise acquire Palantir\n\n  stock at artificially inflated prices. In furtherance of this unlawful scheme and course of\n\n  conduct, Defendants, and each of them, took the actions set forth herein.\n\n          202.        During the Class Period, Palantir stock was traded on an active and efficient\n\n  market. As a result of Defendants\u2019 misconduct, the market price of Palantir stock was\n\n  artificially inflated throughout the Class Period.         In ignorance of the adverse facts\n\n  concerning Palantir\u2019s business and financial condition which were concealed by the\n\n  Individual Defendants, Plaintiffs and the other members of the Class purchased or\n\n  otherwise acquired Palantir stock at prices artificially inflated by Defendants\u2019 wrongful\n\n  conduct and in doing so relied upon the price of the securities, the integrity of the market for\n\n  the securities, and/or the Defendants\u2019 statements, and were damaged thereby.\n\n          203.        Palantir\u2019s stock price declined as Defendants\u2019 scheme unraveled and the\n\n  relevant truth and its impact on Palantir\u2019s financial results and prospects entered the market\n\n                                                  - 82 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   133\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 88 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  through a series of partial disclosures, causing injury to Plaintiffs and Class members. Had\n\n  Plaintiffs and the other members of the Class known the truth, they would not have\n\n  purchased or otherwise acquired said stock, or would not have purchased or otherwise\n\n  acquired them at the inflated prices paid. At the time of the purchases and/or acquisitions\n\n  by Plaintiffs and the Class, the true value of Palantir stock was substantially lower than the\n\n  prices paid by members of the Class. The market price of Palantir stock declined upon\n\n  public disclosure of the facts alleged herein to the injury of Plaintiffs and Class members.\n\n          204.        By reason of the conduct alleged herein, Defendants knowingly or recklessly\n\n  violated \u00a710(b) of the Exchange Act and Rule 10b-5 promulgated thereunder.\n\n          205.        As a direct and proximate result of Defendants\u2019 wrongful conduct, Plaintiffs\n\n  and the other members of the Class suffered damages in connection with their respective\n\n  purchases of Palantir\u2019s stock during the Class Period.\n\n                                               COUNT II\n                             For Violation of \u00a720(a) of the Exchange Act\n\n          206.        Plaintiffs repeat and reallege each and every allegation set forth above.\n\n          207.        This Count is brought against each of the Defendants pursuant to \u00a720(a) of\n\n  the Exchange Act, 15 U.S.C. \u00a778t(a).\n\n          208.        During the Class Period, the Individual Defendants participated in and\n\n  oversaw the operation and management of Palantir, and conducted and participated,\n\n  directly and indirectly, in the conduct of Palantir\u2019s business affairs. By reason of their senior\n\n  management positions and/or being directors of Palantir, each Individual Defendant had\n\n  the power to direct the actions of, and exercised the same to cause, Palantir to engage in\n\n  the unlawful acts and conduct complained of herein. Karp, Thiel, and Cohen also owned all\n                                           - 83 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   134\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 89 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  of Palantir\u2019s Class F shares through a trust, which shares guarantee Karp, Thiel, and\n\n  Cohen at least 49.99999% of the total votes, effectively giving them full control over\n\n  Palantir, even if their collective ownership of Palantir fell to just 6%. The Individual\n\n  Defendants, therefore, were \u201ccontrolling persons\u201d of Palantir within the meaning of \u00a720(a)\n\n  of the Exchange Act. By reason of the above conduct, the Individual Defendants are liable\n\n  pursuant to \u00a720(a) of the Exchange Act for the violations committed by Palantir.\n\n          209.        Palantir had the power to control and influence the Individual Defendants\n\n  through its power to hire, fire, supervise, and otherwise control the actions of its employees\n\n  and their salaries, bonuses, incentive compensation, and other employment considerations.\n\n  Thus, Palantir had the power to influence and control, and did influence and control, directly\n\n  or indirectly, the decision-making of the Individual Defendants. By reason of the above\n\n  conduct, Palantir is liable pursuant to \u00a720(a) of the Exchange Act for the violations\n\n  committed by the Individual Defendants.\n\n                                               COUNT III\n                              For Violation of \u00a720A of the Exchange Act\n\n          210.        Plaintiffs repeat and reallege each and every allegation set forth above as if\n\n  fully set forth herein.\n\n          211.        This Count is brought against Karp, Cohen, Thiel, Sankar, and Glazer\n\n  pursuant to \u00a720A of the Exchange Act, on behalf of Plaintiffs and members of the Class\n\n  who were damaged by these defendants\u2019 insider trading.\n\n          212.        As detailed herein, Karp, Cohen, Thiel, Sankar, and Glazer were in\n\n  possession of material nonpublic information concerning Palantir. They took advantage of\n\n  their possession of material nonpublic information regarding Palantir to obtain billions of\n                                            - 84 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   135\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 90 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  dollars in insider trading profits during the Class Period.\n\n          213.        As set forth in Appendix 2, these defendants\u2019 sales of Palantir shares were\n\n  made contemporaneously with Plaintiffs\u2019 purchases of Palantir shares during the Class\n\n  Period.\n\n          214.        Plaintiffs and Class members who purchased shares of Palantir shares\n\n  contemporaneously with sales by these defendants suffered damages because: (i) in\n\n  reliance on the integrity of the market, they paid artificially inflated prices as a result of the\n\n  violations of \u00a7\u00a710(b) and 20(a) of the Exchange Act as alleged herein; and (ii) they would\n\n  not have purchased Palantir common stock at the prices they paid, or at all, if they had\n\n  been aware that the market prices had been artificially inflated by the misconduct alleged\n\n  herein.\n\n  X.      SECURITIES ACT ALLEGATIONS\n\n          A.          Securities Act Parties\n\n          215.        Plaintiffs purchased Palantir shares traceable to the Registration Statement\n\n  and were damaged thereby.\n\n          216.        Defendants Karp, Cohen, Thiel, Glazer, Rascoff, Schiff, and Moore are\n\n  collectively referred to herein as the \u201cSecurities Act Individual Defendants.\u201d Each of the\n\n  Securities Act Individual Defendants had the opportunity to review and did approve, sign,\n\n  and cause the Registration Statement to be filed with, and declared effective by, the SEC.\n\n          217.        Palantir is subject to liability for violations of the Securities Act as an issuer\n\n  and control person. Each of the Securities Act Individual Defendants is subject to liability\n\n  for violations of the Securities Act as each was a director of Palantir and/or signed the\n\n                                                    - 85 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                     136\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 91 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  Registration Statement.\n\n          218.        Palantir and the Securities Act Individual Defendants are collectively referred\n\n  to herein as the \u201cSecurities Act Defendants.\u201d\n\n          B.          The Registration Statement Contained Untrue Statements of\n                      Material Fact and Material Omissions\n\n                      1.     Untrue Statements About Palantir\u2019s Operational\n                             Efficiencies and Margins\n\n          219.        The Registration Statement represented that Palantir\u2019s operating results were\n\n  improving and that the Company was getting much more efficient at installing and\n\n  deploying its complex software products:\n\n          The improvements in our operating results have principally been driven\n          by increasing revenue and a significant decrease in the time and number\n          of software engineers required to install and deploy our software\n          platforms.\n\n          In particular, the time required to install our software and begin working\n          with a customer has decreased more than five-fold since Q2 2019 to an\n          average of 14 days in Q2 2020. In some cases, our customers can now\n          be up and running in six hours.\n\n          220.        The Registration Statement also cited the ease with which Palantir\u2019s software\n\n  platforms could \u201caccommodate new users, workflows, and use cases\u201d:\n\n          Increase our reach within existing customers. The value that our\n          software creates is what drives our expansion within individual organizations.\n          Our platforms are designed to easily accommodate new users, workflows,\n          and use cases. This allows us to rapidly scale within an institution.\n\n          221.        The Registration Statement further represented that all customers were\n\n  expected to enter the \u201cScale phase,\u201d which indicated improved margins:\n\n          We believe that all of our customers will move into the Scale phase over\n          the long term. We also believe that contribution margin for Scale phase\n          accounts will increase further as we become more efficient at deploying\n                                                   - 86 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    137\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 92 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          our software platforms across the entirety of our customers\u2019 operations\n          and at managing and operating our software.\n\n          222.        The statements in \u00b6\u00b6219-221 emphasizing Palantir\u2019s margin growth and\n\n  attributing it to product improvements and increased operational efficiencies were materially\n\n  misleading. In reality, Defendants were aware that Palantir\u2019s historical margin improvement\n\n  could not continue, because in order to post the growth rate that Defendants led the market\n\n  to expect, Palantir had to quickly pivot to industries in which it had never operated. Yet,\n\n  Palantir\u2019s software was not easily adaptable outside of its established \u201cuse cases,\u201d was\n\n  expensive, and required substantial customization for each new client. To land customers\n\n  in new industries, Palantir had to provide prospective clients with a pilot test run at low or\n\n  no cost, during which Palantir was compelled to invest substantial time, money, and\n\n  manpower finding a use for its software and then building a bespoke product to suit that\n\n  use. Coupled with the highly-customized nature and high cost of Palantir\u2019s software, this\n\n  meant signing new commercial customers was much more difficult, and closing deals was\n\n  far more costly to Palantir than its existing commercial customers. In addition, as Palantir\n\n  had moved into industries in which it had not previously operated, its pilot deployments\n\n  failed more frequently, and the expenses associated therewith further deteriorated\n\n  Palantir\u2019s margins. This expansion to new industries and customers also required a costly\n\n  buildout of the Company\u2019s sales force, and the substantial cost savings that Palantir\n\n  experienced in FY20 due to COVID-19 were not indicative of normal operating costs.\n\n  Thus, all the foreseeable costs associated with Palantir\u2019s commercial expansion efforts\n\n  would and did result in much lower margins than those Palantir experienced at the time of\n\n  the Offering, and the Securities Act Defendants had no reasonable basis to believe and did\n                                             - 87 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                138\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 93 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  not, in fact, believe, that \u201call of [their] customers will move into the Scale phase over the\n\n  long term,\u201d as that was historically not the case and was more difficult as Palantir expanded\n\n  into new markets.\n\n                      2.     Untrue Statements About Strategic Partnerships\n\n          223.        The Registration Statement identified a strategy to engage in \u201cstrategic\n\n  transactions\u201d to continue to grow the Company:\n\n          As part of our business strategy, we have engaged in strategic transactions\n          in the past and expect to evaluate and consider potential strategic\n          transactions, including acquisitions of, or investments in, businesses,\n          technologies, services, products and other assets in the future. We\n          also may enter into relationships with other businesses to expand our\n          products or our ability to provide services.\n\n          224.        The statements in \u00b6223 were materially false or misleading, in that Palantir\u2019s\n\n  growth plan was not centered on \u201cpursuing specific channel-selling opportunities with\n\n  leading cloud hosting providers\u201d or other \u201cstrategic transactions,\u201d but instead was\n\n  dependent on an undisclosed plan to offset expected declines in Palantir\u2019s business by\n\n  artificially inflating its total deal value, commercial client base, short-term commercial client\n\n  revenue, and profit margins by \u201cinvesting\u201d in early-stage businesses consisting primarily of\n\n  SPAC target companies (that had little or no revenue, and far less than $500 million in\n\n  recurring annual revenue), on the condition of, and in exchange for, these businesses\n\n  entering into multiyear, multimillion dollar contracts for Palantir\u2019s products and services that\n\n  the companies were too nascent to need or afford.\n\n                      3.     Untrue Statements About Growth Rates, Sustainability\n                             of Growth, and Total Addressable Market (\u201cTAM\u201d)\n\n          225.        The Registration Statement emphasized that Palantir was experiencing\n\n                                                   - 88 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   139\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 94 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  accelerating growth at the time of the Offering, stating \u201c[o]ur growth this year has\n\n  accelerated.\u201d The Registration Statement also included the following graph:\n\n\n\n\n          226.        The Registration Statement emphasized Palantir\u2019s growth opportunity,\n\n  estimating Palantir\u2019s TAM \u201cto be approximately $119 billion across the commercial and\n\n  government sectors.\u201d Specifically, Palantir\u2019s \u201cestimate of the TAM in the commercial\n\n  sector is $56 billion,\u201d comprised of \u201capproximately 6,000 companies with more than\n\n  $500 million in annual revenue,\u201d and \u201c$63 billion\u201d for \u201cthe government sector.\u201d\n\n          227.        The Registration Statement also stated that Palantir\u2019s recent win in federal\n\n  court in a case had fostered a \u201cshift in government acquisition\u201d that would allow Palantir\n\n  to become \u201cthe central operating system for all U.S. defense programs,\u201d and\n\n  \u201crepresents a significant expansion of our TAM with the U.S. federal government.\u201d\n\n          228.        The Registration Statement further identified a \u201cnumber of strategies to\n\n  continue to grow the company,\u201d including:\n\n          Become the default operating system for data across the U.S.\n          government. Our successful lawsuit against the U.S. Army, brought in\n          2016, is transforming the way the entire U.S. government buys software, not\n          just the military. We are working towards becoming the default operating\n          system across the U.S. government. Our victory in federal court now\n                                                  - 89 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   140\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 95 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          makes that possible.\n\n          229.        On November 13, 2020, Palantir supplemented the Registration Statement\n\n  via the filing of the Prospectus Supplement, which was incorporated by reference into and\n\n  formed part of the Registration Statement. This November Prospectus Supplement\n\n  bolstered Palantir\u2019s growth story, reporting:\n\n          For the three months ended September 30, 2020, we generated $289.4\n          million in revenue, reflecting a 52% growth rate from the three months\n          ended September 30, 2019, when we generated $190.5 million in revenue.\n          In the nine months ended September 30, 2020, we generated $770.6 million\n          in revenue, reflecting a 50% growth rate from the nine months ended\n          September 30, 2019, when we generated $513.2 million in revenue.\n\n          230.        The statements detailed in \u00b6\u00b6225-229 were materially false or misleading.\n\n  Palantir\u2019s reported revenue and deal value growth rates were not sustainable and were set\n\n  to decelerate beginning in 4Q20. In particular: (i) organic commercial growth was set to\n\n  sharply decelerate in 4Q20; and (ii) the government segment\u2019s growth performance was set\n\n  to peak in 4Q20 and decelerate thereafter in 1Q21. Defendants were aware of this at the\n\n  time, as they had \u201cstrong visibility into future revenues across [its] customer base\u201d due to\n\n  the multiyear, multimillion-dollar nature of their contracts, the fact that Palantir recognized\n\n  revenue ratably, and the narrow nature of Palantir\u2019s customer base of just 125 customers at\n\n  the time. Palantir also had additional lead time with regard to notice of government\n\n  revenue dropping off the books due to the lengthy nature of the government contracting\n\n  and procurement process. Via their \u201cstrong visibility,\u201d Defendants were aware that: (iii)\n\n  Palantir\u2019s commercial segment growth plan was dependent on investing in early-stage\n\n  SPACs with far less than $500 million in recurring annual revenue; (iv) the Company\u2019s\n\n  government segment\u2019s revenue and deal value had been temporarily inflated by short-term\n                                         - 90 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                  141\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 96 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  contracts which government agencies had entered into with Palantir in connection with their\n\n  responses to the COVID-19 pandemic; and (v) as a result of (i)-(iv), the statements in the\n\n  Registration Statement about government and commercial businesses\u2019 growth trends and\n\n  addressable markets were overstated and misleading.\n\n          C.          The Direct Listing Was an Integrated Offering\n\n          231.        Defendants caused Palantir to execute a Company-sponsored direct listing\n\n  whereby Company insiders and early shareholders sold Palantir shares in a single liquidity\n\n  event, distributing Palantir\u2019s shares to the public while concurrently making a market for\n\n  those securities on the NYSE. The direct listing and distribution of Palantir\u2019s shares to the\n\n  public thereby constituted an integrated public offering without regard to whether the shares\n\n  purchased were designated as registered or unregistered.\n\n          232.        The Registration Statement represented the first information about Palantir\n\n  filed with the SEC designed to support public trading in its stock. Prior to the direct listing,\n\n  Palantir\u2019s existing shares were \u201crestricted securities\u201d and not freely tradeable. Restricted\n\n  securities typically include a restrictive legend or other notice electronically appended to the\n\n  securities to notify the transfer agent and other securities professionals that such securities\n\n  cannot be freely traded until the restrictive legends are removed. To facilitate selling in the\n\n  direct listing, Palantir coordinated with its transfer agent to have such restrictive legends\n\n  removed in order to allow Palantir stock to be sold in the direct listing and traded thereafter.\n\n          233.        Publicly distributing securities through the direct listing was designed to and\n\n  did benefit Palantir by improving the attractiveness of its executive compensation packages\n\n  \u2013 which frequently involved stock options \u2013 because once a public market for such\n\n                                                   - 91 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    142\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 97 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  securities existed, executives could easily sell them upon vesting of their stock options. In\n\n  addition, the direct listing transaction was designed to and did benefit Palantir\u2019s controlling\n\n  persons and other shareholders by immediately providing a source of liquidity for these\n\n  shareholders who previously held restricted securities with no established public market in\n\n  which to sell them. Indeed, from the outset Karp made clear that the Offering was made as\n\n  part of a single plan of financing and for the same general purpose: to provide \u201cthe people\n\n  at Palantir who built this company over 17 years [with] access to liquidity.\u201d\n\n          234.        This \u201caccess to liquidity\u201d was not limited to stockholders whose shares were\n\n  registered via the Registration Statement, but rather was designed to and did allow access\n\n  to liquidity for existing Palantir shareholders who held unregistered shares as well.\n\n  However, the Offering was limited to only one class of Palantir securities, the Class A\n\n  common stock.            Indeed, the Registration Statement discussed all Palantir shares,\n\n  regardless of registration status:\n\n          [A]s of June 30, 2020, we had a total of 496,530,269 shares of our Class A\n          common stock outstanding, assuming the settlement of 55,521,520 RSUs for\n          which the service-based vesting condition was satisfied as of June 30, 2020\n          into the same number of shares of Class A common stock, 1,089,984,003\n          shares of our Class B common stock outstanding, assuming the Capital\n          Stock Conversion, and 1,005,000 shares of our Class F common stock\n          outstanding.43\n\n  Pursuant to the Registration Statement, a total of 489,128,232 shares would be available\n\n  for trading on the first day. Of that amount, 257,135,415 shares of Class A common stock\n\n  were to be registered in connection with Palantir\u2019s Offering with up to 231,992,817\n\n  43\n     To trade Palantir\u2019s Class B common stock, they first had to be converted into Class A\n  common stock. Class F shares were excluded from the Offering.\n\n\n                                                  - 92 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   143\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 98 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n  unregistered shares also available for immediate sale in the Offering. According to the\n\n  Registration Statement, \u201csubstantially all of these shares may be immediately sold either by\n\n  the Registered Stockholders pursuant to this prospectus or by our other existing\n\n  stockholders under Rule 144 since such shares held by such other stockholders will have\n\n  been beneficially owned by non-affiliates for at least one year,\u201d subject to the lock-up\n\n  agreements. In other words, the Registration Statement unlocked \u201csubstantially all\u201d of\n\n  Palantir\u2019s shares, including both registered and unregistered shares, and was utilized to\n\n  make available, offer, and sell all of the shares sold in the direct listing.\n\n          235.        The Registration Statement remained effective for 90 days, or until December\n\n  28, 2020. Throughout this period, registered and unregistered shares were sold into the\n\n  public market created via the direct listing. All of the Company\u2019s shares, whether they were\n\n  registered or unregistered, traded at the same prevailing trading prices at any given time.\n\n  Each shareholder received the same consideration for Palantir shares in the public market.\n\n          236.        In sum, the Offering was a single, unified liquidity event wherein all sales\n\n  between September 30, 2020 and December 28, 2020: (i) were part of a single plan of\n\n  financing; (ii) involved the same class of securities; (iii) were made at or about the same\n\n  time; (iv) received the same type of consideration; and (v) were made for the same general\n\n  purpose. Thus, the Offering was a single integrated offering such that all shares sold\n\n  between September 30, 2020 and December 28, 2020 are deemed registered and are\n\n  traceable to the Registration Statement. And because CalPERS purchased 1,280,700\n\n  shares during this period, it has statutory standing under \u00a711.\n\n\n\n                                                  - 93 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   144\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 99 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n          D.          Even if Not Part of an Integrated Offering, Plaintiffs Purchased\n                      Shares Traceable to the Registration Statement\n\n          237.        Plaintiffs purchased shares directly traceable to the Registration Statement.\n\n  The probability that CalPERS purchased at least one registered share is so high as to\n\n  constitute a legal certainty. With discovery, a reliable chain of title can be constructed that\n\n  will allow Plaintiffs to prove they purchased shares traceable to the Registration Statement\n\n  using account-level data and well-accepted accounting methods.\n\n          238.        As set forth in the Registration Statement, on the first day of trading, a\n\n  maximum total of 489,128,232 shares of Palantir Class A common stock were available to\n\n  trade. This amount included 257,135,415 registered shares (52.6%), leaving 231,992,817\n\n  unregistered shares available to trade.\n\n          239.        Between October 16, 2020 and December 18, 2020, CalPERS purchased\n\n  1,280,700 shares of Palantir common stock. A simple application of the 52.6% probability\n\n  that any single share purchased was a registered share establishes that the probability that\n\n  CalPERS did not purchase a single registered share is infinitesimally small. In particular,\n\n  the likelihood is equal to (1 \u2013 52.6%)1,280,700, which is approximately 4 x 10-414,881. The\n\n  resulting probability would be expressed by a zero, followed by a decimal point, followed by\n\n  more than 400,000 additional zeros, then a 4.44\n\n\n  44\n      Standard business software applications report this probability as zero. The\n  probabilities in this section were computed using the mpmath and gmpy2 Python libraries.\n  Even assuming that CalPERS\u2019 purchases were filled in round lots of 100 shares (the\n  number of shares in a NYSE round lot) and that registered shares were only sold in round\n  lots, the corresponding probability of CalPERS purchasing zero registered shares would be\n  (1 \u2013 52.6%)12,807.\n\n\n                                                  - 94 -\n  4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   145\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 100 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n           240.        In practice, the ratio of registered shares to unregistered shares would have\n\n   varied each day depending on how many of each type of share had been sold into the\n\n   market. By the time of CalPERS\u2019 purchases between October 16 and December 18, 2020:\n\n                       (a)    Insiders sold at least 50,449,187 registered shares into the open\n\n   market by October 2, 2020; this figure had increased to 59,200,084 by December 14,\n\n   2020.45 Thus, at least 50,449,187 registered shares would have been available to trade on\n\n   all days on which CalPERS purchased shares in the 90 days following the Offering.\n\n                       (b)    The maximum number of unregistered shares available to trade was\n\n   231,992,817 shares. Therefore, no more than 231,992,817 unregistered shares would\n\n   have been available to trade on any day when CalPERS purchased shares.\n\n                       (c)    Ignoring the additional shares sold by insiders after October 2, 2020,\n\n   registered shares constituted at least 17.9% (50,449,187 / (231,992,817 + 50,449,187)) of\n\n   shares available to trade on any day that CalPERS purchased shares.\n\n           241.        Applying this conservative assumption, the probability of CalPERS purchasing\n\n   no registered shares is (1 \u2013 17.9%)1,280,700, which is approximately 1 x 10-109,442, or zero\n\n   followed by a decimal point, followed by more than 100,000 additional zeros after the\n\n   decimal, then a 1.46\n\n\n   45\n     These figures represent open market sales of the following individuals as reported in\n   SEC Form 4s: Jeffrey Johansing Buckley, Cohen, Glazer, Karp, Matthew A. Long, Moore,\n   Rascoff, Sankar, Ryan D. Taylor, and Thiel.\n   46\n      Assuming CalPERS\u2019 purchases were filled in round lots of 100 shares and that\n   registered shares were only sold in round lots, the probability of CalPERS purchasing no\n   registered share lots is (1 \u2013 17.9%)12,807.\n\n\n                                                   - 95 -\n   4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    146\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 101 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n           242.        Subtracting any of these probabilities from 1 (or 100%) indicates that it is a\n\n   virtual certainty that CalPERS purchased at least one registered share. The corresponding\n\n   likelihood based on the extremely conservative set of assumptions above would be no less\n\n   than 99.99 (followed by 1,000+ to 400,000+ nines) percent.\n\n           243.        With appropriate discovery, Plaintiffs will be able to prove that they acquired\n\n   shares directly traceable to the Registration Statement. Broker-dealers, exchanges, and\n\n   FINRA are required by law to maintain detailed, time-stamped transactional records which\n\n   can be obtained through discovery. These records show when securities in one account\n\n   are transferred to another account, whether within the same broker-dealer or between\n\n   different broker dealers. Using these records along with transfer journals from Palantir\u2019s\n\n   transfer agent Computershare Trust Company, N.A. (\u201cComputershare\u201d) and underlying\n\n   records regarding share registration from Computershare and/or Palantir, and applying\n\n   well-accepted accounting methodologies such as first-in first-out and last-in first-out,\n\n   Plaintiffs can reliably trace shares they purchased to the Registration Statement.\n\n   XI.     THE SECURITIES ACT CLAIMS\n\n                                                COUNT IV\n                                For Violation of \u00a711 of the Securities Act\n\n           244.        Plaintiffs repeat and reallege each and every allegation contained in \u00b6\u00b68-24\n\n   and \u00b6\u00b6215-243 as if fully set forth herein.\n\n           245.        This Count is brought against each of the Securities Act Defendants pursuant\n\n   to \u00a711 of the Securities Act, 15 U.S.C. \u00a777k, on behalf of members of the Class who\n\n   purchased Palantir stock traceable to the Registration Statement.\n\n           246.        This claim is based on strict liability and does not sound in fraud. Plaintiffs do\n                                                      - 96 -\n   4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                      147\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 102 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n   not assert in this Count that any Securities Act Defendant committed intentional or reckless\n\n   misconduct or that any Securities Act Defendant acted with scienter or fraudulent intent.\n\n   While Plaintiffs disclaim any allegations of scienter or fraudulent intent with respect to these\n\n   non-fraud claims, challenged statements of opinion or belief in the Registration Statement\n\n   are alleged to have been materially misstated statements of opinion or belief when made.\n\n           247.        The Registration Statement contained untrue statements of material fact and\n\n   omitted material facts otherwise required to be stated therein necessary to make the\n\n   statements made therein not misleading.\n\n           248.        Palantir is the issuer of the securities purchased by Plaintiffs and Class\n\n   members who purchased Palantir stock traceable to the Registration Statement. As such,\n\n   Palantir is strictly liable for the untrue statements of material fact and/or omissions of\n\n   material fact necessary to make the statements made in the Registration Statement not\n\n   false or misleading.\n\n           249.        The Securities Act Defendants each signed the Registration Statement and\n\n   are each strictly liable for untrue statements of material fact therein and the omission of\n\n   facts necessary to make the statements made therein not misleading, unless able to carry\n\n   their burden of establishing an affirmative \u201cdue diligence\u201d defense. The Securities Act\n\n   Defendants each had a duty to make a reasonable and diligent investigation of the\n\n   statements contained in the Registration Statement and ensure that they were true and that\n\n   there were no omissions of material fact that were required to be stated therein or\n\n   otherwise rendered the statements made in the Registration Statement misleading. None\n\n   of the Securities Act Defendants made a reasonable investigation or possessed reasonable\n\n                                                   - 97 -\n   4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                   148\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 103 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n   grounds for the belief that the Registration Statement was accurate and without omissions\n\n   of any material facts. Had they done so, the Securities Act Defendants would have known\n\n   of the material misstatements and omissions alleged herein.\n\n           250.        Plaintiffs acquired shares of the Company\u2019s stock traceable to the\n\n   Registration Statement without knowledge of the untruths and/or omissions alleged herein.\n\n           251.        By virtue of the foregoing, each Securities Act Defendant violated \u00a711 of the\n\n   Securities Act. Plaintiffs and the other members of the Class who purchased Palantir stock\n\n   traceable to the Registration Statement are entitled to relief under \u00a711.\n\n           252.        This claim is brought within one year of discovery of the untrue statements in\n\n   and omissions from the Registration Statement and within three years after the Company\u2019s\n\n   shares were sold in connection with the Offering.\n\n           253.        By reason of such conduct, the Securities Act Defendants are liable pursuant\n\n   to \u00a711 of the Securities Act. As a direct and proximate result of the wrongful conduct, Class\n\n   members suffered damages in connection with their purchases of the Company\u2019s shares.\n\n                                                COUNT V\n                                For Violation of \u00a715 of the Securities Act\n\n           254.        Plaintiffs repeat and reallege each and every allegation contained in \u00b6\u00b68-24\n\n   and \u00b6\u00b6215-253 above as if fully set forth herein.\n\n           255.        This Count is brought against each of the Securities Act Defendants pursuant\n\n   to \u00a715 of the Securities Act, 15 U.S.C. \u00a777o, on behalf of members of the Class who\n\n   purchased Palantir stock traceable to the Registration Statement.\n\n           256.        This claim does not sound in fraud. Plaintiffs do not assert in this Count that\n\n   any of the Securities Act Defendants committed intentional or reckless misconduct or that\n                                           - 98 -\n   4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                     149\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 104 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n   any of the Securities Act Defendants acted with scienter or fraudulent intent.\n\n           257.        The Securities Act Defendants were each control persons of Palantir by virtue\n\n   of their positions at Palantir as directors and/or senior officers.          The Securities Act\n\n   Defendants each had relationships with other directors and/or officers and/or major\n\n   shareholders of Palantir. In addition, Karp, Thiel, and Cohen owned all of Palantir\u2019s Class\n\n   F shares through a trust, which shares guarantee Karp, Thiel, and Cohen at least\n\n   49.99999% of the total votes, effectively giving them full control over Palantir, including\n\n   whether, when, and how to execute the Offering and the contents of the Registration\n\n   Statement, even if their collective ownership of Palantir fell to just 6%.\n\n           258.        The Securities Act Defendants were each critical to effectuating the Offering,\n\n   based on their signing or authorization of the signing of the Registration Statement, by\n\n   voting (including voting their shares) to execute the Offering, and by having otherwise\n\n   directed through their authority the processes leading to execution of the Offering, including\n\n   registration and sale of the shares in the public listing.\n\n           259.        Palantir had the power to control and influence the Individual Defendants, and\n\n   other Company executives through its power to hire, fire, supervise, and otherwise control\n\n   the actions of its employees and their salaries, bonuses, incentive compensation, and other\n\n   employment considerations. By virtue of the foregoing, Palantir had the power to influence\n\n   and control, and did influence and control, directly or indirectly, the decision-making of the\n\n   Individual Defendants, including the content of the Registration Statement.\n\n           260.        By reason of such conduct, the Securities Act Defendants are liable pursuant\n\n   to \u00a715 of the Securities Act. As a direct and proximate result of the wrongful conduct, Class\n\n                                                    - 99 -\n   4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                    150\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 105 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n   members suffered damages in connection with their purchases of the Company\u2019s shares.\n\n                                          PRAYER FOR RELIEF\n\n           WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs demand judgment against Defendants as follows:\n\n           A.          Declaring this action to be a class action properly maintained pursuant to Rule\n\n   23(a) and (b)(3) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and certifying Plaintiffs as Class\n\n   Representatives and Robbins Geller Rudman & Dowd LLP as Class Counsel;\n\n           B.          Awarding compensatory damages in favor of Plaintiffs and other Class\n\n   members against all Defendants, jointly and severally, for all damages sustained as a result\n\n   of Defendants\u2019 wrongdoing, in an amount to be proven at trial, including interest thereon;\n\n           C.          Awarding Plaintiffs rescission or a rescissory measure of damages;\n\n           D.          Awarding Plaintiffs and the Class their reasonable costs and expenses\n\n   incurred in this action, including reasonable attorneys\u2019 fees, accountants\u2019 fees, and experts\u2019\n\n   fees, and other costs and disbursements; and\n\n           E.          Awarding Plaintiffs and other members of the Class such other injunctive or\n\n   equitable relief, including disgorgement and/or the imposition of a constructive trust, that\n\n   may be deemed just and proper by the Court.\n\n                                     DEMAND FOR TRIAL BY JURY\n\n           Plaintiffs hereby demand a trial by jury.\n\n\n\n\n                                                   - 100 -\n   4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                                     151\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 106 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n   DATED: May 24, 2024                 ROBBINS GELLER RUDMAN\n                                         & DOWD LLP\n                                       DARREN J. ROBBINS\n                                       LUKE O. BROOKS\n                                       J. MARCO JANOSKI GRAY\n                                       ERIKA L. OLIVER\n                                       CHRISTOPHER R. KINNON\n                                       SARAH A. FALLON\n\n\n                                                     s/ Luke O. Brooks\n                                                    LUKE O. BROOKS\n\n                                       655 West Broadway, Suite 1900\n                                       San Diego, CA 92101\n                                       Telephone: 619/231-1058\n                                       619/231-7423 (fax)\n                                       darrenr@rgrdlaw.com\n                                       lukeb@rgrdlaw.com\n                                       mjanoski@rgrdlaw.com\n                                       eoliver@rgrdlaw.com\n                                       ckinnon@rgrdlaw.com\n                                       sfallon@rgrdlaw.com\n\n                                       Lead Counsel for Plaintiffs\n\n                                       JOHNSON FISTEL, LLP\n                                       JEFFREY A. BERENS\n                                       2373 Central Park Boulevard, Suite 100\n                                       Denver, CO 80238-2300\n                                       Telephone: 303/861-1764\n                                       303/861-1764 (fax)\n                                       jeffb@johnsonfistel.com\n\n                                       Local Counsel\n\n\n\n\n                                     - 101 -\n   4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                      152\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 107 of\n                                     108\n\n\n\n\n                                 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\n\n           I hereby certify under penalty of perjury that on May 24, 2024, I authorized the\n\n   electronic filing of the foregoing with the Clerk of the Court using the CM/ECF system which\n\n   will send notification of such filing to the email addresses on the attached Electronic Mail\n\n   Notice List, and I hereby certify that I caused the mailing of the foregoing via the United\n\n   States Postal Service to the non-CM/ECF participants indicated on the attached Manual\n\n   Notice List.\n\n                                                  s/ Luke O. Brooks\n                                                  LUKE O. BROOKS\n\n                                                  ROBBINS GELLER RUDMAN\n                                                        & DOWD LLP\n                                                  655 West Broadway, Suite 1900\n                                                  San Diego, CA 92101-8498\n                                                  Telephone: 619/231-1058\n                                                  619/231-7423 (fax)\n\n                                                  Email: lukeb@rgrdlaw.com\n\n\n\n\n   4879-7335-0845.v1\n\n\n                                               153\n\f       Case No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 108 of\n       \u00ff \u00ff                                  \u0084\u0083z\n                                            108\u0084\u0086\u00ff\u0087\u00ff\u0088\u0089\u008a\u0089\u00ff\u008b\u008c\n                                                          \u008d\u008e\u008f\u008c\u0090\u008e\u00ff\u0084\u0091\u0092\u008f\u008e\u0081\u0090\u0091\u0093\n0123245\u00ff7489 1294\u00ff89\u00ff1\u00ff1\u000e\u000f\u00ff\u0010\u0011\u0012\u0012\u0013\u0014\u0015\u0013\u0016\u0012\u0017\u0018\u0019\u0013\u001a\u001b\u001a\u0013\u001c\u001d\u001b\u00ff\u001e\u001f1\u00ff\u0015\u00ff\u001b13142\u00ff!\u000f\u0014\"493952\u000f\u000e\u00ff74\u0014\u00ff\u000f\u00ff13\n#3\u000f\u0014 942\u0014\u00ff0123\u00ff$92\u0014\u000f\u00ff%2\u000e\n&'(\u00ff*+,,+-./0\u00ff12(\u00ff3'+4(\u00ff-'+\u00ff12(\u00ff5622(/3,7\u00ff+/\u00ff3'(\u00ff,.43\u00ff3+\u00ff2(5(.8(\u00ff(9:1.,\u00ff/+3.5(4\u00ff*+2\u00ff3'.4\u00ff514(;\n      $1\u001e 94\u00ff< =\u000f>\n      /1:?(@AB3:5;5+:C2@(0/1/AB3:5;5+:C'D1**14AB3:5;5+:C.7(13(4AB3:5;5+:CE45'-123FAB3:5;5+:\n      <>1 \u00ff01\u0014\u00ff<\u001f94\n      11D3+/AF,B;5+:C(5*AF,B;5+:\n      G\u000f88\u000fH\u00ff<33\u000f4\u00ff\u001d\u000f\u000f4\u000e\n      ?(**A?E(2(/4,1-;5+:C:.5'1(,*A?+'/4+/*.43(,;5+:C?(**EA?+'/4+/*.43(,;5+:CD121,(01,A?+'/4+/*.43(,;5+:\n      %\u001eI\u000f\u00ffJ 294\u00ff\u001d 99I\u000e\n      ,6B(EA202@,1-;5+:C(K*.,(K4@A202@,1-;5+:CB-++@4A202@,1-;5+:\n      $2\u0014\"931\u000e\u00ff<45\u000f39\u00ff1\u000e\u000f332\n      /.5'+,14;514(,,.A*2(4'*.(,@4;5+:C*.,./0K/+3.5(A*2(4'*.(,@4;5+:CLMNNOMPPQRA*.,./04;@+5B(3E.2@;5+:\n      \u001c11\"\u00ff<\u00ffS13394\n      4*1,,+/A202@,1-;5+:C(K*.,(K4@A202@,1-;5+:\n      \u001d92\u000e\u00ffS\u000f3> 14\n      E+2.4;*(,@:1/A*2(4'*.(,@4;5+:C*.,./0K/+3.5(A*2(4'*.(,@4;5+:C?+/13'1/;41:D4+/A*2(4'*.(,@4;5+:CT(1//(33(;U:.3'A*2(4'*.(,@4;5+:CLMNNOMPPQRA*.,./04;@+5B(3E.2@;5\n      V\u001e\u000eH\u00ff#\u001514\u00ff\u001a3\u000f44\n      26437A4'6:1/,1-*.2:;5+:CB.DA4'6:1/,1-*.2:;5+:\n      G9\u000e\u000f\u001f\"\u00ff<3\u000fW14>\u000f\u00ffX99>\u00ffY\u00ff77\n      1'++@AD+:,1-;5+:C:3?+'/43+/AD+:,1-;5+:C34172(AD+:,1-;5+:C@.41154+/AD+:,1-;5+:C14':13B+81AD+:,1-;5+:C1E12E+41AD+:,1-;5+:\n      G\u00ff01\u00149\u00ffG149\u000eI2\u00ff\u001a 1H\n      :?1/+4B.A202@,1-;5+:C(K*.,(K4@A202@,1-;5+:C&(22((ZA202@,1-;5+:\n      $1\"14\u00ff<\u00ff[\u000f\u000f\u0015\u000f\n      B((8(2A@-:B;5+:C-./(012@A@-:B;5+:C@-:BA@-:B;5+:C432133+/A@-:B;5+:\n        \"2\u000e9\u001f\"\u000f\u00ffVH14\u00ff[24494\n      5B.//+/A202@,1-;5+:C(K*.,(K4@A202@,1-;5+:\n      G\u000f\u000f H\u00ff<314\u00ff%2\u000f\\\u000f 14\n      ?1,.(E(2:1/AD+:,1-;5+:C@.41154+/AD+:,1-;5+:C14':13B+81AD+:,1-;5+:C1E12E+41AD+:,1-;5+:\n      ]1\u00152>\u00ff^\u00ff%2\u0015\u000e\"2_\n      @18.@;,.84'.FA*2(4'*.(,@4;5+:C*.,./0K/+3.5(A*2(4'*.(,@4;5+:CLMNNOMPPQRA*.,./04;@+5B(3E.2@;5+:\n      ]142\u000f33\u000f\u00ff\u001c\u00ff0H\u000f\u000e\n      @:7(24A202@,1-;5+:C@:7(24A(5*;5+623@2.8(;5+:C(K*.,(K4@A202@,1-;5+:\n      # 2I1\u00ff%\u00ffJ32\u0015\u000f\n      (+,.8(2A202@,1-;5+:C(K*.,(K4@A202@,1-;5+:\n      V9\\\u000f \u00ff\u030024\u0014\u000f4\u00ff\u001b9451H\n      2D2+/017A0,1/57,1-;5+:C./*+A0,1/57,1-;5+:C2+E(239D2+/0179RQaQA(5*;D15(2D2+;5+:\n      [1\"H4\u00ff<\u00ffV\u000f233H\n      2(.,,7A-3+32.1,;5+:C41/5'(FA-3+32.1,;5+:CbcT+/(4A-3+32.1,;5+:\n      ]1 \u000f4\u00ffG1H\u00ffV9\\\\24\u000e\n      @122(/2A202@,1-;5+:C(K*.,(K4@A202@,1-;5+:\n      \u001c1 \u00ff]\u00ff\u001c1 2\n      43122.33A@-:B;5+:C-./(012@A@-:B;5+:C@-:BA@-:B;5+:\n014\u001e13\u00ff$92\u0014\u000f\u00ff%2\u000e\n&'(\u00ff*+,,+-./0\u00ff.4\u00ff3'(\u00ff,.43\u00ff+*\u00ff133+2/(74\u00ff-'+\u00ff12(\u00ff49\u00ff+/\u00ff3'(\u00ff,.43\u00ff3+\u00ff2(5(.8(\u00ff(9:1.,\u00ff/+3.5(4\u00ff*+2\u00ff3'.4\u00ff514(\u00ffd-'+\u00ff3'(2(*+2(\u00ff2(e6.2(\u00ff:1/61,\u00ff/+3.5./0f;\u00ffg+6\u00ff:17\u00ff-.4'\u00ff3+\u00ff64(\u00ff7+62\u00ff:+64(\n3+\u00ff4(,(53\u00ff1/@\u00ff5+D7\u00ff3'.4\u00ff,.43\u00ff./3+\u00ff7+62\u00ff-+2@\u00ffD2+5(44./0\u00ffD2+021:\u00ff./\u00ff+2@(2\u00ff3+\u00ff52(13(\u00ff/+3.5(4\u00ff+2\u00ff,1E(,4\u00ff*+2\u00ff3'(4(\u00ff2(5.D.(/34;\n   hij\u00fflmnomp\u00ffqrstutrnvwx\n\n\n\n\n                                                                                   154\n\u0094\u008e\u008e\u0095\u008d\u0081zz\u0096\u0090\u0097\u0089\u0090\u0091\u0093\u0089\u0092\u008d\u0090\u0091\u0092\u008f\u008e\u008d\u0089\u0098\u0091\u0099z\u0090\u0098\u008c\u0087\u009a\u008c\u009bz\u0083\u009c\u008c\u009d\u009e\u008c\u008d\u008e\u0089\u0095\u009d\u009f \u0080\u0080\u0080|}}\u00a1\u0080|\u00a1\u00a2\u0080\u0087\u009e\u00a3\u0080\u00a3\u00a2\u0087\u0080                                                                                                    \u0080z\u0080\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92-1 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 1 of\n                                     12\n\n\n\n\n                        APPENDIX 1\n\n\n\n\n                                      155\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92-1 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 2 of\n                                     12\n\n\n\n\n                               PLAINTIFFS\u2019 APPENDIX 1\n\n             KARP\u2019S SALE OF PALANTIR STOCK DURING THE CLASS PERIOD\n\n                Transaction\n                              Price      Shares Sold    Proceeds\n                   Date\n                  9/30/2020     $10.77     2,000,000     $21,540,000.00\n                  9/30/2020      $9.72     1,600,000     $15,552,000.00\n                  10/1/2020      $9.43     7,900,000     $74,497,000.00\n                  10/2/2020      $9.10     2,600,000     $23,660,000.00\n                 11/16/2020     $16.06        15,911        $255,530.66\n                 11/16/2020     $15.79     1,269,212     $20,040,857.48\n                  12/2/2020     $23.32         3,255         $75,906.60\n                  12/2/2020     $22.55       909,191     $20,502,257.05\n                  12/2/2020     $21.95       372,677      $8,180,260.15\n                   1/4/2021     $23.78       697,499     $16,586,526.22\n                   1/4/2021     $23.30       587,624     $13,691,639.20\n                   2/2/2021     $33.89        17,919        $607,274.91\n                   2/2/2021     $33.05        46,765      $1,545,583.25\n                   2/2/2021     $31.77       661,897     $21,028,467.69\n                   2/2/2021     $31.18       558,542     $17,415,339.56\n                  3/30/2021     $21.96        76,180      $1,672,912.80\n                  3/30/2021     $21.55       161,599      $3,482,458.45\n                  3/31/2021     $23.54       101,821      $2,396,866.34\n                  3/31/2021     $23.12       121,934      $2,819,114.08\n                   4/6/2021     $23.15     1,308,465     $30,290,964.75\n                   4/7/2021     $23.08       638,629     $14,739,557.32\n                   4/8/2021     $23.19       638,629     $14,809,806.51\n                  4/19/2021     $21.86       638,629     $13,960,429.94\n                  4/20/2021     $22.36        65,436      $1,463,148.96\n                  4/20/2021     $21.68       573,193     $12,426,824.24\n                  4/21/2021     $22.54       244,636      $5,514,095.44\n                  4/21/2021     $22.26       393,993      $8,770,284.18\n                   5/4/2021     $21.99        19,108        $420,184.92\n                   5/4/2021     $21.31       619,521     $13,201,992.51\n                   5/5/2021     $21.50       638,629     $13,730,523.50\n                   5/6/2021     $20.73       126,190      $2,615,918.70\n                   5/6/2021     $19.99       512,439     $10,243,655.61\n                                          -1-\n  4887-2916-4481.v1\n\n\n                                          156\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92-1 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 3 of\n                                     12\n\n\n\n\n                Transaction\n                              Price      Shares Sold    Proceeds\n                   Date\n                  5/13/2021     $19.09           144          $2,748.96\n                  5/13/2021     $18.41           355          $6,535.55\n                  5/19/2021     $21.00         1,500         $31,500.00\n                  5/19/2021     $20.66       637,129     $13,163,085.14\n                  5/20/2021     $20.52       638,629     $13,104,667.08\n                  5/21/2021     $20.85       638,629     $13,315,414.65\n                   6/7/2021     $24.42       638,629     $15,595,320.18\n                   6/8/2021     $25.05        26,483        $663,399.15\n                   6/8/2021     $24.45       612,146     $14,966,969.70\n                   6/9/2021     $24.49       638,629     $15,640,024.21\n                  6/21/2021     $25.52         9,917        $253,081.84\n                  6/21/2021     $25.15       628,712     $15,812,106.80\n                  6/22/2021     $25.21       638,629     $16,099,837.09\n                  6/23/2021     $26.34           200          $5,268.00\n                  6/23/2021     $26.00       638,429     $16,599,154.00\n                   7/6/2021     $24.76       638,629     $15,812,454.04\n                   7/7/2021     $23.91        31,961        $764,187.51\n                   7/7/2021     $23.04       606,668     $13,977,630.72\n                   7/8/2021     $22.96       638,629     $14,662,921.84\n                  7/21/2021     $22.48       638,629     $14,356,379.92\n                  7/22/2021     $22.08       638,629     $14,100,928.32\n                  7/23/2021     $21.82       638,629     $13,934,884.78\n                   8/2/2021     $22.05       638,629     $14,081,769.45\n                   8/3/2021     $21.96       638,629     $14,024,292.84\n                   8/4/2021     $22.27       638,629     $14,222,267.83\n                  8/20/2021     $23.94       398,655      $9,543,800.70\n                  8/20/2021     $23.93       638,629     $15,282,391.97\n                  8/23/2021     $24.63       638,629     $15,729,432.27\n                  8/24/2021     $25.14     1,214,974     $30,544,446.36\n                   9/7/2021     $26.56       638,629     $16,961,986.24\n                   9/8/2021     $26.15        29,388        $768,496.20\n                   9/8/2021     $25.51       609,241     $15,541,737.91\n                   9/9/2021     $26.01       638,629     $16,610,740.29\n                  9/28/2021     $26.53        62,443      $1,656,612.79\n                  9/28/2021     $25.70       576,186     $14,807,980.20\n                                          -2-\n  4887-2916-4481.v1\n\n\n                                          157\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92-1 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 4 of\n                                     12\n\n\n\n\n                Transaction\n                              Price      Shares Sold    Proceeds\n                   Date\n                  9/29/2021     $25.54        56,677       $1,447,530.58\n                  9/29/2021     $24.92       581,952      $14,502,243.84\n                  9/30/2021     $24.95         5,700         $142,215.00\n                  9/30/2021     $24.28       632,929      $15,367,516.12\n                 10/12/2021     $23.56       638,629      $15,046,099.24\n                 10/13/2021     $24.06       638,629      $15,365,413.74\n                 10/14/2021     $24.46       638,629      $15,620,865.34\n                 10/26/2021     $26.38        43,104       $1,137,083.52\n                 10/26/2021     $25.72       595,525      $15,316,903.00\n                 10/27/2021     $25.35       638,629      $16,189,245.15\n                 10/28/2021     $25.51       638,629      $16,291,425.79\n                  11/3/2021     $26.20         4,789         $125,471.80\n                  11/3/2021     $25.88       633,840      $16,403,779.20\n                  11/4/2021     $26.39       638,629      $16,853,419.31\n                  11/5/2021     $26.06       638,629      $16,642,671.74\n                 11/16/2021     $22.91       638,629      $14,630,990.39\n                 11/17/2021     $22.66       638,629      $14,471,333.14\n                 11/18/2021     $22.46         6,839         $153,603.94\n                 11/18/2021     $21.66       631,790      $13,684,571.40\n                 11/22/2021     $21.45         5,712         $122,522.40\n                 11/22/2021     $20.75       289,971       $6,016,898.25\n                 11/23/2021     $20.36       104,483       $2,127,273.88\n                 11/26/2021     $20.89       195,443       $4,082,804.27\n                 11/29/2021     $20.96       189,695       $3,976,007.20\n                 11/30/2021     $21.17        10,669        $225,862.73\n                 11/30/2021     $20.59       179,027       $3,686,165.93\n                Total                     52,976,553   $1,050,011,752.45\n\n\n\n\n                                          -3-\n  4887-2916-4481.v1\n\n\n                                          158\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92-1 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 5 of\n                                     12\n\n\n\n\n            THIEL\u2019S SALES OF PALANTIR STOCK DURING THE CLASS PERIOD\n\n                Transaction\n                              Price      Shares Sold    Proceeds\n                   Date\n                  9/30/2020     $11.19             5              $55.95\n                  9/30/2020     $11.19           794           $8,884.86\n                  9/30/2020     $11.19         1,609          $18,004.71\n                  9/30/2020     $11.19         2,633          $29,463.27\n                  9/30/2020     $11.19         5,699          $63,771.81\n                  9/30/2020     $11.19         9,369         $104,839.11\n                  9/30/2020     $11.19        15,436         $172,728.84\n                  9/30/2020     $11.19        17,756         $198,689.64\n                  9/30/2020     $11.19        43,460         $486,317.40\n                  9/30/2020     $11.19        53,239         $595,744.41\n                  9/30/2020     $11.16        62,209         $694,252.44\n                  9/30/2020     $11.16     2,018,004      $22,520,924.64\n                  9/30/2020     $10.34            65             $672.10\n                  9/30/2020     $10.34         9,790         $101,228.60\n                  9/30/2020     $10.34        19,851         $205,259.34\n                  9/30/2020     $10.34        32,469         $335,729.46\n                  9/30/2020     $10.34        70,297         $726,870.98\n                  9/30/2020     $10.34       115,553       $1,194,818.02\n                  9/30/2020     $10.34       190,372       $1,968,446.48\n                  9/30/2020     $10.34       218,992       $2,264,377.28\n                  9/30/2020     $10.34       536,002       $5,542,260.68\n                  9/30/2020     $10.34       656,609       $6,789,337.06\n                  9/30/2020     $10.13       566,208       $5,735,687.04\n                  9/30/2020     $10.13    18,367,343     $186,061,184.59\n                  10/1/2020      $9.75        58,836         $573,651.00\n                  10/1/2020      $9.75       418,672       $4,082,052.00\n                  10/1/2020      $9.75     1,908,596      $18,608,811.00\n                  10/1/2020      $9.75     1,983,906      $19,343,083.50\n                  10/2/2020      $9.14           908           $8,299.12\n                  2/18/2021     $25.93           600          $15,558.00\n                  2/18/2021     $25.87     4,346,459     $112,442,894.33\n                  2/18/2021     $25.10         3,315          $83,206.50\n                  2/18/2021     $25.06    15,653,541     $392,277,737.46\n\n                                          -4-\n  4887-2916-4481.v1\n\n\n                                          159\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92-1 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 6 of\n                                     12\n\n\n\n\n                Transaction\n                              Price      Shares Sold    Proceeds\n                   Date\n                  8/13/2021     $25.00         3,262          $81,550.00\n                Total                     47,391,859     $783,336,391.62\n\n\n\n\n                                          -5-\n  4887-2916-4481.v1\n\n\n                                          160\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92-1 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 7 of\n                                     12\n\n\n\n\n           COHEN\u2019S SALES OF PALANTIR STOCK DURING THE CLASS PERIOD\n\n                 Transaction\n                                Price     Shares Sold   Proceeds\n                     Date\n                    9/30/2020    $10.00     1,000,000    $10,000,000.00\n                    10/1/2020     $9.42     1,000,000     $9,420,000.00\n                    10/2/2020     $9.09     2,000,000    $18,180,000.00\n                  11/16/2020     $16.07         3,379        $54,300.53\n                  11/16/2020     $15.58       596,621     $9,295,355.18\n                  11/17/2020     $18.38       107,090     $1,968,314.20\n                  11/17/2020     $17.80       343,785     $6,119,373.00\n                  11/17/2020     $16.82        82,125     $1,381,342.50\n                  11/18/2020     $18.86       166,756     $3,145,018.16\n                  11/18/2020     $18.10       366,244     $6,629,016.40\n                  11/19/2020     $18.55       533,000     $9,887,150.00\n                    2/18/2021    $25.93       225,622     $5,850,378.46\n                    2/18/2021    $25.07       924,378    $23,174,156.46\n                    2/19/2021    $29.04       250,000     $7,260,000.00\n                    2/19/2021    $27.71       300,000     $8,313,000.00\n                    2/22/2021    $30.03       300,000     $9,009,000.00\n                    3/16/2021    $26.40        39,341     $1,038,602.40\n                    3/16/2021    $25.94       101,114     $2,622,897.16\n                    3/30/2021    $21.96        28,611       $628,297.56\n                    3/30/2021    $21.55        60,800     $1,310,240.00\n                    3/31/2021    $23.54        38,309       $901,793.86\n                    3/31/2021    $23.12        45,875     $1,060,630.00\n                     4/6/2021    $23.16        60,000     $1,389,600.00\n                     5/4/2021    $22.03         1,000        $22,030.00\n                     5/4/2021    $21.33        29,400       $627,102.00\n                    5/13/2021    $19.09           179         $3,417.11\n                    5/13/2021    $18.41           442         $8,137.22\n                     6/1/2021    $23.04        89,600     $2,064,384.00\n                     6/2/2021    $24.39        30,000       $731,700.00\n                    6/15/2021    $25.21         3,900        $98,319.00\n                    6/17/2021    $25.21        26,100       $657,981.00\n                     7/6/2021    $24.79        97,100     $2,407,109.00\n                     8/3/2021    $22.04        45,000       $991,800.00\n\n                                            -6-\n  4887-2916-4481.v1\n\n\n                                            161\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92-1 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 8 of\n                                     12\n\n\n\n\n                Transaction\n                               Price     Shares Sold    Proceeds\n                    Date\n                   8/17/2021    $24.07        15,000        $361,050.00\n                   8/18/2021    $25.45        22,900        $582,805.00\n                   8/20/2021    $23.94       345,018      $8,259,730.92\n                    9/7/2021    $26.55       200,000      $5,310,000.00\n                    9/8/2021    $26.18           900         $23,562.00\n                    9/9/2021    $26.09        18,645        $486,448.05\n                   9/21/2021    $27.02         6,000        $162,120.00\n                   9/22/2021    $27.43       114,000      $3,127,020.00\n                   9/23/2021    $29.08        32,621        $948,618.68\n                   9/23/2021    $28.54       129,199      $3,687,339.46\n                   10/5/2021    $23.32        60,000      $1,399,200.00\n                   11/2/2021    $26.63         1,500         $39,945.00\n                   11/2/2021    $26.01       130,945      $3,405,879.45\n                   11/3/2021    $26.09        17,555        $458,009.95\n                 11/22/2021     $21.45         4,951        $106,198.95\n                 11/22/2021     $20.75       251,319      $5,214,869.25\n                 11/23/2021     $20.36        90,556      $1,843,720.16\n                   2/22/2022    $10.62       251,863      $2,674,785.06\n                   2/23/2022    $10.90        93,155      $1,015,389.50\n                   5/20/2022     $8.09       203,178      $1,643,710.02\n                   5/23/2022     $8.03        94,647        $760,015.41\n                   5/24/2022     $7.54        56,668        $427,276.72\n                Total                     11,036,391    $188,188,138.78\n\n\n\n\n                                           -7-\n  4887-2916-4481.v1\n\n\n                                           162\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92-1 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 9 of\n                                     12\n\n\n\n\n          SANKAR\u2019S SALES OF PALANTIR STOCK DURING THE CLASS PERIOD\n\n                 Transaction\n                                Price     Shares Sold   Proceeds\n                     Date\n                    9/30/2020    $11.22        77,933       $874,408.26\n                    9/30/2020    $10.65       435,242     $4,635,327.30\n                    9/30/2020     $9.76       892,540     $8,711,190.40\n                  11/16/2020     $16.02         4,732        $75,806.64\n                  11/16/2020     $15.53       695,268    $10,797,512.04\n                  11/17/2020     $17.03       300,000     $5,109,000.00\n                  11/20/2020     $19.21        23,900       $459,119.00\n                  11/20/2020     $18.43       119,444     $2,201,352.92\n                  11/23/2020     $20.00       500,000    $10,000,000.00\n                  11/24/2020     $22.50       100,000     $2,250,000.00\n                  11/27/2020     $31.39        80,305     $2,520,773.95\n                    2/19/2021    $29.00       300,000     $8,700,000.00\n                    2/19/2021    $28.00       300,000     $8,400,000.00\n                    2/22/2021    $30.00       300,000     $9,000,000.00\n                    2/22/2021    $29.85         4,092       $122,146.20\n                    2/22/2021    $28.94        29,505       $853,874.70\n                    2/22/2021    $28.17        73,913     $2,082,129.21\n                    2/23/2021    $26.79         9,855       $264,015.45\n                    2/23/2021    $26.18        37,737       $987,954.66\n                    2/23/2021    $24.59         2,408        $59,212.72\n                    5/13/2021    $19.09           162         $3,092.58\n                    5/13/2021    $18.41           399         $7,345.59\n                    5/20/2021    $20.51        98,053     $2,011,067.03\n                    5/24/2021    $21.00        50,000     $1,050,000.00\n                    7/19/2021    $21.61         8,481       $183,274.41\n                    7/19/2021    $21.29       164,059     $3,492,816.11\n                    8/20/2021    $23.94       266,865     $6,388,748.10\n                    8/23/2021    $24.65       114,435     $2,820,822.75\n                    8/24/2021    $25.20       204,030     $5,141,556.00\n                  11/22/2021     $21.45         3,822        $81,981.90\n                  11/22/2021     $20.75       194,003     $4,025,562.25\n                  11/23/2021     $20.36        69,894     $1,423,041.84\n                  11/24/2021     $21.03       317,611     $6,679,359.33\n\n                                            -8-\n  4887-2916-4481.v1\n\n\n                                            163\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92-1 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 10\n                                    of 12\n\n\n\n\n                Transaction\n                               Price     Shares Sold   Proceeds\n                    Date\n                   2/22/2022    $10.62       194,817     $2,068,956.54\n                   2/23/2022    $10.90        72,055       $785,399.50\n                   5/20/2022     $8.09       157,267     $1,272,290.03\n                   5/23/2022     $8.03        73,260       $588,277.80\n                   5/24/2022     $7.54        43,863       $330,727.02\n                   7/22/2022     $9.95       125,000     $1,243,750.00\n                Total                      6,444,950   $117,701,892.23\n\n\n\n\n                                           -9-\n  4887-2916-4481.v1\n\n\n                                           164\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92-1 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 11\n                                    of 12\n\n\n\n\n          GLAZER\u2019S SALES OF PALANTIR STOCK DURING THE CLASS PERIOD\n\n                 Transaction\n                                Price     Shares Sold    Proceeds\n                     Date\n                    9/30/2020    $11.22         75,505       $847,166.10\n                    9/30/2020    $10.65        421,683     $4,490,923.95\n                    9/30/2020     $9.76        864,733     $8,439,794.08\n                    10/1/2020     $9.58        253,700     $2,430,446.00\n                    10/2/2020     $9.16        186,000     $1,703,760.00\n                  11/16/2020     $16.06          4,412        $70,856.72\n                  11/16/2020     $15.69        451,373     $7,082,042.37\n                  11/17/2020     $18.01        180,000     $3,241,800.00\n                  11/20/2020     $19.21         15,689       $301,385.69\n                  11/20/2020     $18.43         78,405     $1,445,004.15\n                  11/23/2020     $20.94         39,283       $822,586.02\n                  11/23/2020     $20.14        230,710     $4,646,499.40\n                    2/22/2021    $29.85          3,617       $107,967.45\n                    2/22/2021    $28.94         26,080       $754,755.20\n                    2/22/2021    $28.17         65,333     $1,840,430.61\n                    2/23/2021    $27.18          4,819       $130,980.42\n                    2/23/2021    $26.46         84,373     $2,232,509.58\n                    2/23/2021    $25.66         13,068       $335,324.88\n                    2/23/2021    $24.58          3,900        $95,862.00\n                    5/13/2021    $19.09            139         $2,653.51\n                    5/13/2021    $18.41            343         $6,314.63\n                    5/20/2021    $20.51         94,508     $1,938,359.08\n                    5/21/2021    $20.85        106,682     $2,224,319.70\n                    6/28/2021    $27.00          9,000       $243,000.00\n                    8/12/2021    $24.72         54,000     $1,334,880.00\n                    8/18/2021    $25.90          9,000       $233,100.00\n                    8/20/2021    $23.94         93,961     $2,249,426.34\n                    8/23/2021    $24.65        107,229     $2,643,194.85\n                    9/16/2021    $27.90          9,000       $251,100.00\n                    9/20/2021    $27.53         10,539       $290,138.67\n                    9/20/2021    $26.25          7,461       $195,851.25\n                    9/21/2021    $27.11            314         $8,512.54\n                    9/21/2021    $26.62         71,686     $1,908,281.32\n\n                                           - 10 -\n  4887-2916-4481.v1\n\n\n                                            165\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92-1 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 12\n                                    of 12\n\n\n\n\n                Transaction\n                               Price     Shares Sold   Proceeds\n                    Date\n                 10/29/2021     $25.91         9,000       $233,190.00\n                 11/22/2021     $21.45         1,339        $28,721.55\n                 11/22/2021     $20.75        67,954     $1,410,045.50\n                 11/23/2021     $20.36        24,485       $498,514.60\n                 11/24/2021     $21.04       107,412     $2,259,948.48\n                   2/22/2022    $10.62        68,070       $722,903.40\n                   2/23/2022    $10.90         1,300        $14,170.00\n                   2/23/2022    $10.90        25,177       $274,429.30\n                   2/24/2022    $11.41       106,643     $1,216,796.63\n                   5/20/2022     $8.09        54,814       $443,445.26\n                   5/23/2022     $8.03        25,535       $205,046.05\n                   5/24/2022     $7.54        15,288       $115,271.52\n                    8/2/2022    $11.02       105,553     $1,163,194.06\n                Total                      4,189,115    $63,134,902.86\n\n\n\n\n                                          - 11 -\n  4887-2916-4481.v1\n\n\n                                           166\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92-2 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 1 of\n                                      5\n\n\n\n\n                        APPENDIX 2\n\n\n\n\n                                      167\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92-2 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 2 of\n                                      5\n\n\n\n\n                                PLAINTIFFS\u2019 APPENDIX 2\n\n                      DEFENDANTS\u2019 SALES MADE CONTEMPORANEOUSLY\n                              WITH PLAINTIFFS\u2019 PURCHASES\n\n                                  Date of\n                        Name                        Amount      Price\n                                Transaction\n                                                    225,622     $25.93\n                       Cohen     2/18/2021\n                                                    924,378     $25.07\n                                                       600      $25.93\n                                                   4,346,459    $25.87\n                        Thiel    2/18/2021\n                                                      3,315     $25.10\n                                                   15,653,541   $25.06\n                                                    250,000     $29.04\n                       Cohen     2/19/2021\n                                                    300,000     $27.71\n                                                    300,000     $29.00\n                       Sankar    2/19/2021\n                                                    300,000     $28.00\n                       Cohen     2/22/2021          300,000     $30.03\n                                                      3,617     $29.85\n                       Glazer    2/22/2021           26,080     $28.94\n                                                     65,333     $28.17\n                                                    300,000     $30.00\n                                                      4,092     $29.85\n                       Sankar    2/22/2021\n                                                     29,505     $28.94\n                                                     73,913     $28.17\n                                                      1,000     $28.00\n                                                       351      $28.05\n                                                        21      $28.00\n                                                       120      $27.63\n                                                       158      $27.83\n                         Liu     2/22/2021             621      $28.05\n                                                       568      $28.05\n                                                       568      $28.05\n                                                       134      $28.05\n                                                       208      $28.05\n                                                       100      $28.00\n\n\n\n\n  4860-3470-9441.v1\n                                             168\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92-2 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 3 of\n                                      5\n\n\n\n\n                                 Date of\n                      Name                        Amount      Price\n                               Transaction\n                                                    4,819     $27.18\n                                                   84,373     $26.46\n                      Glazer    2/23/2021\n                                                   13,068     $25.66\n                                                    3,900     $24.58\n                                                    9,855     $26.79\n                      Sankar    2/23/2021          37,737     $26.18\n                                                    2,408     $24.59\n                                                      28      $26.47\n                                                     680      $25.57\n                                                      40      $25.73\n                       Liu      2/23/2021\n                                                      97      $25.75\n                                                       3      $25.74\n                                                       5      $25.40\n                                                   38,309     $23.54\n                      Cohen     3/31/2021\n                                                   45,875     $23.12\n                                                   101,821    $23.54\n                       Karp     3/31/2021\n                                                   121,934    $23.12\n                      Cohen      4/6/2021          60,000     $23.16\n                                 4/6/2021         1,308,465   $23.15\n                       Karp      4/7/2021          638,629    $23.08\n                                 4/8/2021          638,629    $23.19\n                                 4/9/2021             29      $24.00\n                       Liu\n                                4/13/2021            400      $24.88\n                                                   65,436     $22.36\n                                4/20/2021\n                                                   573,193    $21.68\n                       Karp\n                                                   244,636    $22.54\n                                4/21/2021\n                                                   393,993    $22.26\n                       Liu      4/26/2021             10      $24.14\n                      Cohen      6/2/2021          30,000     $24.39\n                                 6/7/2021          638,629    $24.42\n                       Karp                        26,483     $25.05\n                                6/8/2021\n                                                   612,146    $24.45\n                        Liu     6/8/2021              30      $24.34\n                       Karp     6/9/2021           638,629    $24.49\n                                6/9/2021              18      $24.66\n                       Liu                            40      $24.00\n                                6/10/2021\n                                                       2      $24.24\n\n                                            -2-\n  4860-3470-9441.v1\n                                            169\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92-2 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 4 of\n                                      5\n\n\n\n\n                                  Date of\n                       Name                        Amount      Price\n                                Transaction\n                       Glazer    6/28/2021           9,000     $27.00\n                         Liu      7/2/2021            400      $24.45\n                        Karp      8/2/2021          638,629    $22.05\n                       Cohen      8/3/2021          45,000     $22.04\n                                  8/3/2021          638,629    $21.96\n                       Karp\n                                  8/4/2021          638,629    $22.27\n                         Liu      8/6/2021            306      $21.95\n                       Glazer    8/12/2021          54,000     $24.72\n                        Thiel    8/13/2021           3,262     $25.00\n                                                       2       $24.89\n                                                       2       $24.98\n                        Liu      8/13/2021\n                                                       1       $25.18\n                                                       1       $25.18\n                       Glazer    9/16/2021           9,000     $27.90\n                                                    13,738     $28.71\n                      CalPERS    9/17/2021          324,885    $28.71\n                                                   3,246,621   $28.71\n                                                    10,539     $27.53\n                       Glazer    9/20/2021\n                                                     7,461     $26.25\n                                                     3,088     $26.52\n                        Liu      9/20/2021           3,087     $26.56\n                                                       1       $26.56\n                       Cohen     9/21/2021           6,000     $27.02\n                                                      314      $27.11\n                       Glazer    9/21/2021\n                                                    71,686     $26.62\n                                                     1,200     $26.58\n                        Liu      9/21/2021            320      $26.54\n                                                      240      $26.58\n                                 11/4/2021          638,629    $26.39\n                       Karp\n                                 11/5/2021          638,629    $26.06\n\n\n\n\n                                             -3-\n  4860-3470-9441.v1\n                                             170\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 92-2 filed 05/24/24 USDC Colorado pg 5 of\n                                      5\n\n\n\n\n                                  Date of\n                       Name                        Amount    Price\n                                Transaction\n                                 11/10/2021         2,400    $22.58\n                                                    3,200    $22.83\n                                                    3,000    $22.88\n                                                    1,250    $22.87\n                        Liu\n                                11/11/2021          1,330    $22.85\n                                                      2      $22.86\n                                                    1,330    $22.84\n                                                    1,335    $22.81\n                      Sankar     7/22/2022         125,000   $9.95\n                                 7/22/2022          1,800    $10.35\n                        Liu                         5,720     $9.85\n                                 7/25/2022\n                                                    4,442     $9.85\n                      CalPERS    7/28/2022         94,569    $10.13\n                         Liu     7/28/2022           200     $10.06\n                       Glazer     8/2/2022         105,553   $11.02\n                      CalPERS     8/4/2022         54,074    $11.30\n\n\n\n\n                                             -4-\n  4860-3470-9441.v1\n                                             171\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 1 of\n                                     63\n\n\n\n\n                       IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                           FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO\n\n\n  Lead Civil Action No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP\n  Consolidated with Civil Actions 1:22-cv-02805-GPG-SBP\n  and 1:22-cv-02893-GPG-SBP\n\n  MINCHIE GALOT CUPAT, Individually                 IN-PERSON ORAL ARGUMENT\n  and on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated,   REQUESTED\n\n        Plaintiff,\n\n  v.\n\n  PALANTIR TECHNOLOGIES INC.,\n  ALEXANDER C. KARP,\n  DAVID GLAZER, and\n  SHYAM SANKAR,\n\n        Defendants.\n\n\n                   DEFENDANTS\u2019 COMBINED MOTION AND BRIEF\n              TO DISMISS PLAINTIFFS\u2019 SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT\n\n\n\n\n                                             172\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 2 of\n                                     63\n\n\n\n\n                                                TABLE OF CONTENTS\n\n                                                                                                                           Page\n  TABLE OF AUTHORITIES .............................................................................................. iii\n\n  TABLE OF DEFINITIONS ............................................................................................... x\n\n  PRELIMINARY STATEMENT .......................................................................................... 1\n\n  BACKGROUND .............................................................................................................. 4\n\n           A.        Palantir\u2019s Origins and Products.................................................................. 4\n\n           B.        Palantir Goes Public After 17 Promising Years as a Private Company. ..... 4\n\n           C.        The Registration Statement ....................................................................... 5\n\n           D.        Palantir Warns of the Risks About Which Plaintiffs Complain. ................... 5\n\n           E.        Palantir\u2019s Strategic Investment Program.................................................... 7\n\n           F.        The SPAC Market Declines. ...................................................................... 8\n\n           G.        This Litigation............................................................................................. 9\n\n  ARGUMENT .................................................................................................................... 9\n\n  I.       THE SECTION 11 CLAIM FAILS BECAUSE PLAINTIFFS CANNOT\n           \u201cTRACE\u201d THEIR SHARES.................................................................................. 10\n\n           A.        Plaintiffs Cannot Substitute Mere Possibility for Traceability. ....................11\n\n           B.        The Integrated Offering Doctrine Is Inapplicable. ..................................... 12\n\n  II.      LACK OF SCIENTER COMPELS DISMISSAL OF SECTION 10(b)\n           CLAIMS. ............................................................................................................. 13\n\n           A.        The Complaint Fails Adequately to Allege Intent to Defraud. ................... 14\n\n           B.        The Complaint Fails Adequately to Allege Deliberate Recklessness. ...... 17\n\n  III.     PLAINTIFFS\u2019 CLAIMS SHOULD BE DISMISSED FOR FAILURE TO\n           PLEAD AN ACTIONABLE MISSTATEMENT OR OMISSION. ............................ 21\n\n           A.        Plaintiffs Fail to Plead Falsity as to the SPAC-Related Statements. ........ 22\n\n\n\n\n                                                               173\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 3 of\n                                     63\n\n\n\n\n                                                                                                                      Page\n                     1.       Section 11 Claims Not Adequately Pleaded .................................. 22\n\n                     2.       Section 10(b) Claims Not Adequately Pleaded ............................. 22\n\n           B.        Plaintiffs Fail to Plead Falsity as to Non-SPAC Statements. .................... 28\n\n                     1.       Plaintiffs Plead No False Statement as to Financial\n                              Performance.................................................................................. 28\n\n                     2.       Plaintiffs Plead No False Statement Concerning Efficiencies........ 31\n\n           C.        The Complaint Fails to Plead Falsity as to Any Remaining\n                     Statement in the FRS............................................................................... 33\n\n  IV.      FORWARD-LOOKING STATEMENTS ARE INACTIONABLE. ........................... 35\n\n  V.       MANY CHALLENGED STATEMENTS ARE INACTIONABLE OPINIONS OR\n           CORPORATE OPTIMISM. ................................................................................. 37\n\n  VI.      PLAINTIFFS FAIL ADEQUATELY TO PLEAD SCHEME LIABILITY. .................. 39\n\n  VII.     PLAINTIFFS FAIL ADEQUATELY TO PLEAD LOSS CAUSATION. ................... 44\n\n  VIII.    PLAINTIFFS FAIL TO STATE A CLAIM UNDER SECTION 20A. ....................... 45\n\n  CONCLUSION .............................................................................................................. 45\n\n\n\n\n                                                             - ii -\n                                                             174\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 4 of\n                                     63\n\n\n\n\n                                            TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\n\n  Cases                                                                                                          Page(s)\n\n  Abbey v. Comput. Memories, Inc.,\n    634 F.Supp. 870 (N.D. Cal. 1986)....................................................................... 11,12\n\n  Acme Propane, Inc. v. Tenexco, Inc.,\n    844 F.2d 1317 (7th Cir. 1988) .................................................................................. 43\n\n  In re Advanta Corp. Sec. Litig.,\n      180 F.3d 525 (3d Cir. 1999) ..................................................................................... 39\n\n  In re Airgate PCS, Inc. Sec. Litig.,\n      389 F.Supp.2d 1360 (N.D. Ga. 2005) ...................................................................... 39\n\n  Amr v. Sollitto,\n    08-cv-1686, 2009 WL 10673610 (D. Ariz. Sept. 30, 2009) ...................................... 28\n\n  Anderson v. Spirit Aerosystems Holdings, Inc.,\n    827 F.3d 1229 (10th Cir. 2016) ......................................................................... passim\n\n  In re Ariad Pharm., Inc. Sec. Litig.,\n      842 F.3d 744 (1st Cir. 2016) .................................................................................... 11\n\n  Ark. Pub. Emps. Ret. Sys. v. Bristol-Myers Squibb Co.,\n     28 F.4th 343 (2d Cir. 2022) ...................................................................................... 16\n\n  Ashland Inc. v. Morgan Stanley & Co.,\n     652 F.3d 333 (2d Cir. 2011) ..................................................................................... 31\n\n  In re AST Rsch. Sec. Litig.,\n      887 F.Supp. 231 (C.D. Cal. 1995)............................................................................ 45\n\n  Bell Atl. Corp. v. Twombly,\n     550 U.S. 544 (2007)................................................................................................... 9\n\n  In re Centerline Holding Co. Sec. Litig.,\n      678 F.Supp.2d 150 (S.D.N.Y. 2009) ........................................................................ 22\n\n  Cent. Laborers\u2019 Pension Fund v. Karp,\n    2023-0864 (D. Ch. Aug. 22, 2023) ........................................................................... 23\n\n  Century Aluminum Co. Sec. Litig.,\n    729 F.3d 1104 (9th Cir. 2013) .................................................................................. 11\n\n\n\n                                                            - iii -\n                                                            175\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 5 of\n                                     63\n\n\n\n\n  Cases                                                                                                         Page(s)\n\n  In re Citigroup Sec. Litig.,\n      20-cv-9132, 2023 WL 2632258 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 24, 2023) ....................................... 38\n\n  Copland v. Grumet,\n    88 F.Supp.2d 326 (D.N.J. 1999) .............................................................................. 45\n\n  In re Crocs, Inc. Sec. Litig.,\n      774 F.Supp.2d 1122 (D. Colo. Feb. 28, 2011) ......................................................... 30\n\n  Croker v. Carrier Access Corp.,\n     05-cv-01011, 2006 WL 2035366 (D. Colo. July 18, 2006) ....................................... 45\n\n  Curry v. Yelp Inc.,\n     875 F.3d 1219 (9th Cir. 2017) .................................................................................. 45\n\n  In re Daou Sys., Inc.,\n      411 F.3d 1006 (9th Cir. 2005) .................................................................................. 26\n\n  Doherty v. Pivotal Software, Inc.,\n    19-cv-3589, 2019 WL 5864581 (N.D. Cal. Nov. 8, 2019)......................................... 11\n\n  Dura Pharm., Inc. v. Broudo,\n     544 U.S. 336 (2005)................................................................................................. 44\n\n  Ellis v. Spectranetics,\n      15-cv-01857, 2018 WL 1583837 (D. Colo. Apr. 2, 2018) ......................................... 15\n\n  Emps.\u2019 Ret. Sys. of R.I. v. Williams Cos.,\n    889 F.3d 1153 (10th Cir. 2018) ................................................................................ 17\n\n  In re FoxHollow Techs., Inc., Sec. Litig.,\n      06-cv-04595, 2008 WL 2220600 (N.D. Cal. May 27, 2008) ..................................... 24\n\n  In re Gold Res. Corp. Sec. Litig.,\n      776 F.3d 1103 (10th Cir. 2015) ................................................................................ 20\n\n  In re Gold Res. Corp. Sec. Litig.,\n      957 F.Supp.2d 1284 (D. Colo. 2013) ................................................................. 36, 37\n\n  Grossman v. Novell, Inc.,\n     120 F.3d 1112 (10th Cir. 1997) ......................................................................... passim\n\n  Guangyi Xu v. ChinaCache Int\u2019l Holdings Ltd.,\n    15-cv-07952, 2017 WL 114401 (C.D. Cal. Jan. 9, 2017) ......................................... 39\n\n\n                                                            - iv -\n                                                            176\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 6 of\n                                     63\n\n\n\n\n  Cases                                                                                                          Page(s)\n\n  Halperin v. eBanker USA.com, Inc.,\n     295 F.3d 352 (2d. Cir. 2002) .................................................................................... 23\n\n  Hampton v. Root9B Techs., Inc.,\n    15-cv-02152, 2016 WL 9735744 (D. Colo. Sept. 21, 2016) ..................................... 33\n\n  Hampton v. root9B Techs., Inc.,\n    897 F.3d 1291 (10th Cir. 2018) ............................................................................ 9, 38\n\n  In re Hennessy Cap. Acquisition Corp. IV S\u2019holder Litig.,\n      \u2014 A.3d \u2014, 2024 WL 2799044 (Del. Ch. May 31, 2024) ...................................... 7, 21\n\n  Ind. Elec. Workers\u2019 Pension Tr. Fund IBEW v. Shaw Grp.,\n     537 F.3d 527 (5th Cir. 2008) .................................................................................... 15\n\n  Ind. Pub. Ret. Sys. v. Pluralsight, Inc.,\n     45 F.4th 1236 (10th Cir. 2022) ................................................................................. 16\n\n  In re Intrexon Corp. Sec. Litig.,\n      16-cv-02398, 2017 WL 732952 (N.D. Cal. Feb. 24, 2017) ....................................... 27\n\n  Ironworkers Local 580\u2013Joint Funds v. Linn Energy, LLC,\n      29 F.Supp.3d 400 (S.D.N.Y. 2014) .......................................................................... 42\n\n  Joseph v. Wiles,\n     223 F.3d 1155 (10th Cir. 2000) ................................................................................ 10\n\n  Krim v. pcOrder.com, Inc.,\n     402 F.3d 489 (5th Cir. 2005) .................................................................................... 11\n\n  Lanigan Grp., Inc. v. Li-Cycle Holdings. Corp.,\n     22-cv-0222, 2023 WL 6541884 (E.D.N.Y. Oct. 6, 2023) .......................................... 45\n\n  In re Level 3 Commc\u2019ns, Inc. Sec. Litig.,\n       667 F.3d 1331 (10th Cir. 2012) ............................................................ 16, 17, 19, 30\n\n  Loos v. Immersion Corp.,\n     762 F.3d 880 (9th Cir. 2014) .................................................................................... 44\n\n  Lorenzo v. SEC,\n     587 U.S. 71 (2019)................................................................................................... 40\n\n  Lorusso v. Boulder Brands,\n     15-cv-00679, 2017 WL 4365180 (D. Colo. Mar. 1, 2017) ....................................... 37\n\n\n                                                            -v-\n                                                            177\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 7 of\n                                     63\n\n\n\n\n  Cases                                                                                                        Page(s)\n\n  In re Lottery.com, Inc. Sec. Litig.,\n      22-cv-07111, 2024 WL 454298 (S.D.N.Y. Feb. 6, 2024) ......................................... 15\n\n  McDonald v. Kinder-Morgan, Inc.,\n    287 F.3d 992 (10th Cir. 2002) ...................................................................... 29, 30, 34\n\n  Meitav Dash Provident Funds & Pension Ltd. v. Spirit AeroSystems\n     Holdings, Inc.,\n     79 F.4th 1209 (10th Cir. 2023) ....................................................................... 2, 18, 37\n\n  Metzler Inv. GMBH v. Corinthian Colls., Inc.,\n    540 F.3d 1049 (9th Cir. 2008) .................................................................................. 16\n\n  MHC Mut. Conversion Fund, L.P. v. Sandler O\u2019Neill & Partners, L.P.,\n    761 F.3d 1109 (10th Cir. 2014) .............................................................. 18, 19, 34, 38\n\n  In re Molycorp, Inc. Sec. Litig.,\n      12-cv-00292, 2015 WL 1540523 (D. Colo. Mar. 31, 2015) ................................ 35, 45\n\n  Noble Asset Mgmt. v. Allos Therapeutics, Inc.,\n    04-cv-1030, 2005 WL 4161977 (D. Colo. Oct. 20, 2005) ......................................... 31\n\n  In re Nokia Oyj (Nokia Corp.) Sec. Litig.,\n      423 F.Supp.2d 364 (S.D.N.Y. 2006) ........................................................................ 20\n\n  Okla. Firefighters Pension & Ret. Sys. v. Xerox Corp.,\n     300 F.Supp.3d 551 (S.D.N.Y. 2018) ........................................................................ 37\n\n  Okla. Police Pension & Ret. Sys. v. Boulder Brands, Inc.,\n     15-cv-00679, 2017 WL 1148689 (D. Colo. Mar. 28, 2017) .......................... 29, 30, 37\n\n  Omnicare, Inc. v. Laborers Dist. Council Const. Indus. Pension Fund,\n    575 U.S. 175 (2015)................................................................................................. 38\n\n  In re Overstock Sec. Litig.,\n      19-cv-0709, 2021 WL 4267920 (D. Utah Sept. 20, 2021) ........................................ 21\n\n  Pirani v. Slack Techs., Inc.,\n      445 F.Supp.3d 367 (N.D. Cal. 2020)........................................................................ 10\n\n  In re Pivotal Sec. Litig.,\n      19-cv-03589, 2020 WL 4193384 (N.D. Cal. July 21, 2020)...................................... 20\n\n\n\n\n                                                           - vi -\n                                                           178\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 8 of\n                                     63\n\n\n\n\n  Cases                                                                                                      Page(s)\n\n  Prissert v. EMCORE Corp.,\n      894 F.Supp.2d 1361 (D.N.M. 2012) ......................................................................... 45\n\n  Prodanova v. H.C. Wainwright & Co.,\n     993 F.3d 1097 (9th Cir. 2021) .................................................................................. 17\n\n  In re Quarterdeck Off. Sys., Inc. Sec. Litig.,\n      92-cv-0397, 1993 WL 623310 (C.D. Cal. Sept. 30, 1993)........................................ 11\n\n  In re Qwest Commc\u2019n Int\u2019l, Inc.,\n      396 F.Supp.2d 1178 (D. Colo. 2004) ....................................................................... 26\n\n  In re Refco, Inc. Sec. Litig.,\n      503 F.Supp.2d 611 (S.D.N.Y. 2007) ........................................................................ 12\n\n  Retail Wholesale Dep\u2019t Store Union Loc. 338 Ret. Fund v. Stitch Fix, Inc.,\n     22-cv-04893, 2024 WL 3447524 (N.D. Cal. July 16, 2024)...................................... 19\n\n  In re Rigel Pharm., Inc. Sec. Litig.,\n      697 F.3d 869 (9th Cir. 2012) ............................................................................. 24, 34\n\n  Rombach v. Chang,\n    355 F.3d 164 (2d Cir. 2004) ............................................................................... 10, 39\n\n  Ronconi v. Larkin,\n    253 F.3d 423 (9th Cir. 2001) .................................................................................... 17\n\n  Rubke v. Capitol Bancorp Ltd.,\n    551 F.3d 1156 (9th Cir. 2009) ............................................................................ 10, 34\n\n  In re Sanofi Sec. Litig.,\n      87 F.Supp.3d 510 (S.D.N.Y. 2015) .......................................................................... 38\n\n  Schaffer v. Evolving Sys., Inc.,\n     29 F.Supp.2d 1213 (D. Colo. 1998) ......................................................................... 35\n\n  SEC v. GPL Ventures LLC,\n    2022 WL 158885 (S.D.N.Y. 2022) ........................................................................... 41\n\n  SEC v. Kelly,\n    817 F.Supp.2d 340 (S.D.N.Y. 2011) ........................................................................ 41\n\n  SEC v. Murphy,\n    626 F.2d 633 (9th Cir. 1980) .................................................................................... 12\n\n\n                                                         - vii -\n                                                          179\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 9 of\n                                     63\n\n\n\n\n  Cases                                                                                                        Page(s)\n\n  SEC v. Simpson Capital Mgmt., Inc.,\n    586 F.Supp.2d 196 (S.D.N.Y. 2008) ........................................................................ 41\n\n  SEC v. St. Anselm Expl. Co.,\n    936 F.Supp.2d 1281 (D. Colo. 2013) ........................................................... 39, 40, 41\n\n  Shafer v. Lightning eMotors, Inc.,\n    21-cv-02774, 2024 WL 691458 (D. Colo. Feb. 20, 2024) .................................. 37, 40\n\n  In re Silicon Graphics Inc. Sec. Litig.,\n      183 F.3d 970 (9th Cir. 1999) .................................................................................... 17\n\n  Slack Techs., LLC v. Pirani,\n     598 U.S. 759 (2023).......................................................................................... passim\n\n  Slater v. A.G. Edwards & Sons, Inc.,\n     719 F.3d 1190 (10th Cir. 2013) .................................................................................. 4\n\n  Smallen v. W. Union Co.,\n    17-cv-00474, 2019 WL 1382823 (D. Colo. Mar. 27, 2019) ................................ 13, 18\n\n  Smallen v. W. Union Co.,\n    950 F.3d 1297 (10th Cir. 2020) .............................................................. 13, 14, 15, 17\n\n  In re SolarCity Corp. Sec. Litig.,\n      274 F.Supp.3d 972 (N.D. Cal. 2017)........................................................................ 42\n\n  Sorkin, LLC v. Fischer Imaging Corp.,\n     03-cv-00631, 2005 WL 1459735 (D. Colo. June 21, 2005) ...................................... 19\n\n  Steamfitters Loc. 449 Pension Plan v. Molina Healthcare, Inc.,\n     18-cv-3579,2018 WL 6787349 (C.D. Cal. Dec. 13, 2018)........................................ 37\n\n  TDC Lending LLC v. Priv. Cap. Grp., Inc.,\n    340 F.Supp.3d 1218 (D. Utah 2018) ........................................................................ 18\n\n  Teachers\u2019 Ret. Sys. of La. v. Hunter,\n     477 F.3d 162 (4th Cir. 2007) .............................................................................. 17, 28\n\n  Tellabs, Inc. v. Makor Issues & Rights, Ltd.,\n      551 U.S. 308 (2007)..................................................................................... 13, 14, 21\n\n  Werner v. Werner,\n    267 F.3d 288 (3d Cir. 2001) ......................................................................... 26, 27, 43\n\n\n                                                          - viii -\n                                                           180\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 10 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   Cases                                                                                                                    Page(s)\n\n   In re Williams Sec. Litig.,\n       339 F.Supp.2d 1206 (N.D. Okla. 2003).................................................................... 35\n\n   In re Williams Sec. Litig.,\n       558 F.3d 1130 (10th Cir. 2009) ................................................................................ 44\n\n   Wolfe v. Aspenbio Pharma, Inc.,\n     587 F. App\u2019x 493 (10th Cir. 2014) ............................................................................ 20\n\n   In re Zagg, Inc. Sec. Litig.,\n       797 F.3d 1194 (10th Cir. 2015) ................................................................................ 14\n\n   Statutes ............................................................................................................................\n\n   Private Securities Litigation Reform Act, 15 U.S.C. \u00a7 78u-4................................... passim\n\n   15 U.S.C. \u00a7 78u-5 ......................................................................................................... 35\n\n   Other Authorities .............................................................................................................\n\n   Civ. Practice Standard 7.1B(c) ........................................................................................ 1\n\n   Initial Public Offerings: Lockup Agreements, SEC Answers (Sept. 6,\n        2011), available at https://www.sec.gov/answers/lockup.htm .................................. 15\n\n   Fed. R. Civ. P. 8(a).................................................................................................... 1, 34\n\n   Fed. R. Civ. P. 9(b)................................................................................................. passim\n\n   Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(6) ................................................................................................... 1\n\n   SEC Release, 86 Fed. Reg. 3496, 3499 (Jan. 14, 2021) .............................................. 12\n\n\n\n\n                                                                  - ix -\n                                                                  181\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 11 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n                                  TABLE OF DEFINITIONS\n\n               Term                                        Definition\n    \u00b6                              Paragraph of the Complaint (unless otherwise noted)\n    1Q                             The first quarter of a fiscal year (e.g., 1Q22 is the first\n                                   quarter of the 2022 fiscal year)\n    2Q                             The second quarter of a fiscal year (e.g., 2Q22 is the\n                                   second quarter of the 2022 fiscal year)\n    3Q                             The third quarter of a fiscal year (e.g., 3Q22 is the third\n                                   quarter of the 2022 fiscal year)\n    4Q                             The fourth quarter of a fiscal year (e.g., 4Q22 is the\n                                   fourth quarter of the 2022 fiscal year)\n    10b5-1 Plans                   Pre-determined trading plans entered into by insiders\n                                   of a company that specify in advance the share price,\n                                   amount and transaction date, pursuant to 17 C.F.R. \u00a7\n                                   240.10b5-1 et seq.\n    ACD                            Average Contract Duration\n    Annex                          Annex to Motion submitted at D.A.1432\u20131529\n    Annual Shareholders            The transcript of Palantir\u2019s June 8, 2021 Annual\n    Meeting                        Shareholders Meeting and Analyst Call, submitted as\n                                   Ex.92 at D.A.1147\u201354\n    April 26, 2023 Schedule 14A    Palantir\u2019s Schedule 14A Proxy Statement, filed with the\n                                   SEC on April 26, 2023, submitted as Ex.96 at\n                                   D.A.1186\u201399\n    ARPC                           Average Revenue per Customer\n    ASC 606                        Accounting Standards Codification 606, promulgated\n                                   by the Financial Accounting Standards Board\n    Aug. 12, 2021 10-Q or 2Q21     Palantir\u2019s Form 10-Q for the quarter ended June 30,\n    Form 10-Q                      2021, filed with the SEC on August 12, 2021, submitted\n                                   as Ex.62 at D.A.263\u2013335\n    Aug. 12, 2021 PR or 2Q21       Palantir\u2019s press release concerning its earnings for the\n    Press Release                  quarter ended June 30, 2021, attached as Exhibit 99.1\n                                   to Palantir\u2019s Form 8-K, filed with the SEC on August 12,\n                                   2021, submitted as Ex.80 at D.A.720\u201328\n    Aug. 12, 2021 Tr. or 2Q21      Palantir\u2019s August 12, 2021 earnings call transcript,\n    Earnings Call                  submitted as Ex.63 at D.A.336\u2013353\n    Aug. 8, 2022 10-Q or 2Q22      Palantir\u2019s Form 10-Q for the quarter ended June 30,\n    Form 10-Q                      2022, filed with the SEC on August 8, 2022, submitted\n                                   as Ex.87 at D.A.980\u20131037\n\n\n\n\n                                             -x-\n                                             182\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 12 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n               Term                                Definition\n    Aug. 8, 2022 Tr. or 2Q22 Palantir\u2019s August 8, 2022 earnings call transcript,\n    Earnings Call            submitted as Ex.68 at D.A.550\u201364\n\n\n\n\n    BP                             BP p.l.c.\n    CalPERS                        Lead Plaintiff California Public Employees\u2019 Retirement\n                                   System\n    CDC                            The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention\n    CELU 10-Q                      Celularity\u2019s Form 10-Q for the quarter ended March 31,\n                                   2023, filed with the SEC on May 22, 2023, submitted as\n                                   Ex. 77 at D.A.688\u201393\n    CELU S-1                       Celularity\u2019s Form S-1 Registration Statement, filed with\n                                   the SEC on August 6, 2021, submitted as Ex.65 at\n                                   D.A.452\u201360\n    Celularity or CELU             Celularity Inc.\n    Celularity Investor Deck or ID Celularity\u2019s Investor Presentation, attached as Ex. 99.3\n                                   to GX Acquisition Corp.\u2019s Form 8-K, filed with the SEC\n                                   on January 8, 2021, submitted as Ex.75 at D.A.669-75\n    Challenged Statements          The allegedly false and/or misleading statements\n                                   challenged in the Complaint\n    Class Period                   Putative Class Period, September 30, 2020 through\n                                   August 5, 2022, as defined at \u00b6 1\n    Complaint       or    Second Second Amended Consolidated Class Action\n    Amended Complaint              Complaint dated May 24, 2024 (ECF 92)\n    Defendants                     Exchange Act Defendants or Securities Act\n                                   Defendants, as applicable\n    Defendants\u2019 Appendix or        The Appendix submitted with Defs\u2019 Mot. Dismiss,\n    D.A.                           containing Annexes and Exhibits supporting this motion\n    Defs\u2019 Mot. Dismiss or Motion Defendants\u2019 Combined Motion and Brief\n                                   to Dismiss Plaintiffs\u2019 Second Amended Complaint\n    ECF                            Electronic Case Filing number on the docket for Lead\n                                   Civil Action No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP\n    Ex.                            Exhibit submitted in the D.A. and defined in the Livshiz\n                                   Declaration\n    Exchange Act                   The Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended, 15\n                                   U.S.C. \u00a7 78a et seq.\n    Exchange Act Defendants        Together, Palantir, Alexander C. Karp (\u201cKarp\u201d),\n                                   Stephen Cohen (\u201cCohen\u201d), Peter Thiel (\u201cThiel\u201d), David\n                                   Glazer (\u201cGlazer\u201d), Shyam Sankar (\u201cSankar\u201d), and Kevin\n                                   Kawasaki (\u201cKawasaki\u201d)\n\n\n                                             - xi -\n                                             183\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 13 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n               Term                                         Definition\n    FDA                             U.S. Food and Drug Administration\n    Feb. 16, 2021 PR or FY20        Palantir\u2019s press release concerning its earnings for the\n    Press Release                   fiscal year and quarter ended December 31, 2020,\n                                    attached as Exhibit 99.1 to Palantir\u2019s Form 8-K, filed\n                                    with the SEC on February 16, 2021, submitted as Ex.78\n                                    at D.A.694\u2013702\n    Feb. 16, 2021 Tr. or FY20       Palantir\u2019s February 16, 2021 earnings call transcript,\n    Earnings Call                   submitted as Ex.90 at D.A.1122\u20131138\n    Feb. 26, 2021 10-K or FY20      Palantir\u2019s Form 10-K for the year ended December 31,\n    Form 10-K                       2020, filed with the SEC on February 26, 2021,\n                                    submitted as Ex.83 at D.A.813\u201387\n    Feb. 17, 2022 PR or FY21        Palantir\u2019s press release concerning its earnings for the\n    Press Release                   fiscal year and quarter ended December 31, 2021,\n                                    attached as Exhibit 99.1 to Palantir\u2019s Form 8-K, filed\n                                    with the SEC on February 17, 2022, submitted as Ex.93\n                                    at D.A.1155-63\n    Feb. 17, 2022 Tr. or FY21       Palantir\u2019s February 17, 2022 earnings call transcript,\n    Earnings Call                   submitted as Ex.94 at D.A.1164\u201378\n    Feb. 24, 2022 10-K or FY21      Palantir\u2019s Form 10-K for the year ended December 31,\n    Form 10-K                       2021, filed with the SEC on February 24, 2022,\n                                    submitted as Ex.64 at D.A.354\u2013451\n    Feb. 13, 2023 Tr. or FY22       Palantir\u2019s February 13, 2023 earnings call transcript,\n    Earnings Call                   submitted as Ex.59 at D.A.164\u201378\n    FedScoop Article                John Hewitt Jones, Palantir COO Says Partnerships\n                                    with Hardware Manufacturers Key to Growth of US\n                                    Gov Business (August 10, 2022), submitted as Ex.85\n                                    at D.A.960\u2013969, https://tinyurl.com/3yc4cnah\n    Final Registration Statement,   Palantir\u2019s Form S-1 Registration Statement, filed with\n    FRS,      or     Form    S-1    the SEC on September 21, 2020, submitted as Ex.56\n    Registration Statement          at D.A.1\u2013132\n    Form 3                          Form filed with the SEC disclosing ownership of\n                                    company securities. Compilations of Forms 3 and 4\n                                    have been submitted for each Defendant as Exs.97\u2013\n                                    101 at D.A.1200\u20131431\n    Form 4                          Form filed with the SEC disclosing transactions in\n                                    company securities. Compilations of Forms 3 and 4\n                                    have been submitted for each Defendant as Exs.97\u2013\n                                    101 at D.A.1200\u20131431\n    FY                              Fiscal Year (e.g., FY22 is the 2022 fiscal year)\n    GAAP                            Generally Accepted Accounting Principles\n    H1                              First half of the year (e.g., H122 is the first half of the\n                                    2022 fiscal year)\n\n\n                                              - xii -\n                                               184\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 14 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n                 Term                                      Definition\n    H2                             Second half of the year (e.g., H222 is the second half\n                                   of the 2022 fiscal year)\n    IPO                            Initial Public Offering\n    Initial Public Offerings:      SEC description of lock up agreements in connection\n    Lockup Agreements, SEC         with initial public offerings, published September 6,\n    Answers                        2011, available here: https://www.sec.gov/answers/\n                                   lockup.htm\n    Investor Day Tr. or Investor   Palantir\u2019s September 9, 2020 Investor Day Webcast,\n    Day Webcast                    transcript submitted as Ex.86 at D.A.970\u2013979 and\n                                   webcast available here:\n                                    https://investors.palantir.com/news-\n                                   details/2020/Palantir-Posts-Investor-Day-Webcast-\n                                   and-Live-QA-Recordings-Including-Management-\n                                   Presentation/\n    Lilium                         Lilium GmbH\n    Lilium Investor Deck or ID     Lilium\u2019s Analyst Presentation, filed with the SEC on Qell\n                                   Acquisition Corp.\u2019s Form 425 on June 15, 2021,\n                                   submitted as Ex.72 at D.A.636\u201343\n    Lilium 6-K                     Lilium\u2019s Form 6-K Report of Foreign Private Issuer, filed\n                                   with the SEC on November 15, 2021, submitted as\n                                   Ex.70 at D.A.619\u201329\n    Liu or Shijun Liu              Additional Plaintiff Shijun Liu, Individually and as\n                                   Trustee of The Liu Family Trust 2019\n    Livshiz Declaration            Declaration of David Y. Livshiz dated July 25, 2024,\n                                   submitted with Defendants\u2019 Appendix\n    May 11, 2021 PR or 1Q21        Palantir\u2019s press release concerning its earnings for the\n    Press Release                  fiscal year and quarter ended March 31, 2021, attached\n                                   as Exhibit 99.1 to Palantir\u2019s Form 8-K, filed with the\n                                   SEC on May 11, 2021, submitted as Ex.91 at\n                                   D.A.1139\u201346\n    May 11, 2021 Tr. or 1Q21       Palantir\u2019s May 11, 2021 earnings call transcript,\n    Earnings Call                  submitted as Ex.60 at D.A.179\u201395\n    May 12, 2021 10-Q or 1Q21      Palantir\u2019s Form 10-Q for the quarter ended March 31,\n    Form 10-Q                      2021, filed with the SEC on May 12, 2021, submitted as\n                                   Ex.61 at D.A.196\u2013262\n    May 9, 2022 10-Q or 1Q22       Palantir\u2019s Form 10-Q for the quarter ended March 31,\n    Form 10-Q                      2022, filed with the SEC on May 9, 2022, submitted as\n                                   Ex.67 at D.A.476\u2013549\n\n\n\n\n                                            - xiii -\n                                             185\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 15 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n                 Term                                 Definition\n    May 9, 2022 PR or 1Q22 Palantir\u2019s press release concerning its earnings for the\n    Press Release              fiscal year and quarter ended March 31, 2022, attached\n                               as Exhibit 99.1 to Palantir\u2019s Form 8-K, filed with the\n                               SEC on May 9, 2022, submitted as Ex.95 at D.A.1179\u2013\n                               85\n    May 9, 2022 Tr. or 1Q22 Palantir\u2019s May 9, 2022 earnings call transcript,\n    Earnings Call              submitted as Ex.58 at D.A.149\u201363\n    MNPI                       Material Non-Public Information\n    NNSA                       U.S. National Nuclear Security Administration\n    Nov. 12, 2020 PR or 3Q20 Palantir\u2019s press release concerning its earnings for the\n    Press Release              quarter ended September 30, 2020, attached as Exhibit\n                               99.1 to Palantir\u2019s Form 8-K, filed with the SEC on\n                               November 12, 2020, submitted as Ex.88 at D.A.1038\u2013\n                               47\n    Nov. 12, 2020 Tr. or 3Q20 Palantir\u2019s November 12, 2020 earnings call transcript,\n    Earnings Call              submitted as Ex.57 at D.A.133\u201348\n    Nov. 13, 2020 10-Q or 3Q20 Palantir\u2019s Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September\n    Form 10-Q                  30, 2020, filed with the SEC on November 13, 2020,\n                               submitted as Ex.82 at D.A.738\u2013812\n    Nov. 9, 2021 10-Q or 3Q21 Palantir\u2019s Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September\n    Form 10-Q                  30, 2021, filed with the SEC on November 9, 2021,\n                               submitted as Ex.84 at D.A.888\u2013959\n    Nov. 9, 2021 PR or 3Q21 Palantir\u2019s press release concerning its earnings for the\n    Press Release              quarter ended September 30, 2021, attached as Exhibit\n                               99.1 to Palantir\u2019s Form 8-K, filed with the SEC on\n                               November 9, 2021, submitted as Ex.81 at D.A.729\u201337\n    Nov. 9, 2021 Tr. or 3Q21 Palantir\u2019s November 9, 2021 earnings call transcript,\n    Earnings Call              submitted as Ex. 79 at D.A.703\u201319\n    Nov. 7, 2022 10-Q or 3Q22 Palantir\u2019s Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September\n    Form 10-Q                  30, 2022, filed with the SEC on November 7, 2022,\n                               submitted as Ex.69 at D.A.565\u2013618\n    Opp\u2019n to Mot. to Lift      Defendants\u2019 Opposition to Plaintiffs\u2019 Motion for a Partial\n                               Lift of the PSLRA Discovery Stay (ECF 94), dated July\n                               25, 2024\n    Palantir or the Company    Palantir Technologies Inc.\n    Plaintiffs                 Collectively, CalPERS and Shijun Liu, Individually and\n                               as Trustee of The Liu Family Trust 2019\n    Prospectus Supplement      Palantir\u2019s Form 424B3 Supplement to the Prospectus,\n                               filed with the SEC on November 13, 2020, submitted as\n                               Ex.89 at D.A.1048\u20131121\n    PSLRA                      Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995, 15\n                               U.S.C. \u00a7 77z-1 and 78u-4 et seq.\n\n\n                                           - xiv -\n                                            186\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 16 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n             Term                                        Definition\n    RBC Report                    November 9, 2021 report by RBC Capital Markets\n                                  analysts, titled \u201cPalantir Technologies Inc.: Cracks\n                                  Emerging in the Story; Downgrading to Underperform,\u201d\n                                  submitted as Ex.66 at D.A.461\u201375\n    RJN                           Request for Judicial Notice, submitted concurrently\n                                  herewith\n    Roivant                       Roivant Sciences Ltd.\n    Roivant Investor Deck or ID   Roivant\u2019s Investor Presentation, attached as Exhibit\n                                  99.1 to Montes Archimedes Acquisition Corp.\u2019s Form 8-\n                                  K, filed with the SEC on June 26, 2021, submitted as\n                                  Ex.74 at D.A.657\u201368\n    Rule 8(a)                     Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 8(a)\n    Rule 9(b)                     Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 9(b)\n    Rule 10b-5                    SEC Rule 10b-5 promulgated under Section 10 of the\n                                  Exchange Act, 17 C.F.R. \u00a7 240.10b\u20135\n    SaaS                          Software as a Service\n    Sarcos                        Sarcos Technology and Robotics Corporation\n    Sarcos 14A                    Sarcos\u2019s Schedule 14A Proxy Statement, filed with the\n                                  SEC on August 6, 2021 as Ex.76 at D.A.676-87\n    Sarcos Investor Deck or ID    Sarcos\u2019s Investor Presentation, attached as Exhibit\n                                  99.2 to Rotor Acquisition Corp.\u2019s Form 8-K, filed with\n                                  the SEC on April 6, 2021, submitted as Ex.73 at\n                                  D.A.644\u201356\n    Sarcos PR                     Sarcos\u2019s press release, attached as Exhibit 99.1 to\n                                  Rotor Acquisition Corp.\u2019s Form 8-K, filed with the SEC\n                                  on April 6, 2021, submitted as Ex.71 at D.A.630\u201335\n    SEC                           U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission\n    Section 10                    Section 10 of the Exchange Act, 15 U.S.C. \u00a7 78j\n    Section 11                    Section 11 of the Securities Act, 15 U.S.C. \u00a7 77k\n    Section 15                    Section 15 of the Securities Act, 15 U.S.C. \u00a7 77o\n    Section 20(a)                 Section 20(a) of the Exchange Act, 15 U.S.C. \u00a7 78t(a)\n    Section 20A                   Section 20A of the Exchange Act, 15 U.S.C. \u00a7 78t\u20131\n    Securities Act                Securities Act of 1933, as amended, 15 U.S.C. \u00a7 77a et\n                                  seq.\n    Securities Act Defendants     Together, Palantir, Karp, Cohen, Thiel, Glazer,\n                                  Alexandra Schiff (\u201cSchiff\u201d), Alexander Moore (\u201cMoore\u201d),\n                                  and Spencer Rascoff (\u201cRascoff\u201d)\n    SPAC                          Special Purpose Acquisition Company\n    TAM                           Total Addressable Market\n    TRDV                          Total Remaining Deal Value\n    Tyson Foods                   Tyson Foods, Inc.\n\n\n\n                                           - xv -\n                                            187\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 17 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n          Defendants, by and through undersigned counsel, move to dismiss the Complaint\n\n   pursuant to the PSLRA and Fed. R. Civ. P. 8(a), 9(b) and 12(b)(6). 1\n\n                                 PRELIMINARY STATEMENT\n\n          For two decades, Palantir has pioneered software vital to our safety and prosperity.\n\n   Palantir\u2019s software supports counterterrorism missions, powers leading businesses, and\n\n   enabled COVID-19 vaccine rollouts. As Plaintiffs would have it, however, Palantir lied to\n\n   the market about its well-documented successes and future prospects in its Final\n\n   Registration Statement and in every SEC filing and earnings call since going public.\n\n          Fraud is a serious allegation. Particularly when it is unsupported. Despite having\n\n   nearly two years and three attempts to do so, Plaintiffs\u2019 newest Complaint fails to muster\n\n   a single hallmark of fraud\u2014no SEC investigation, restated earnings, or documentary\n\n   evidence of \u201cundisclosed truth,\u201d and not one confidential witness. Plaintiffs instead resort\n\n   to fraud by hindsight innuendo: because some of Palantir\u2019s SPAC investments lost money,\n\n   there must have been fraud. That does not satisfy the PSLRA and Rule 9(b)\u2019s heightened\n\n   pleading standards, as courts in this Circuit have repeatedly held.\n\n          Plaintiffs\u2019 case fails as a matter of law for these and several other reasons. First,\n\n   Plaintiffs do not, and cannot, connect their shares to those registered for resale pursuant\n\n   to the FRS. As the Supreme Court recently held, to pursue a Section 11 claim, a plaintiff\n\n   must \u201cplead and prove\u201d that it can \u201ctrace\u201d its specific shares to those registered by the\n\n   challenged registration statement. Slack Techs., LLC v. Pirani, 598 U.S. 759 (2023). This\n\n\n\n   1   On July 22, 2024, counsel for all parties conferred regarding the requested relief\n       pursuant to Civ. Practice Standard 7.1B(b). Plaintiffs do not consent to the Motion.\n\n\n\n                                               188\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 18 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   Court already told Plaintiffs that probabilistic allegations were unlikely to satisfy that\n\n   burden. ECF 91. Ignoring that guidance, Plaintiffs rest on the same defective theories\n\n   as before: arguing that it is \u201cprobable\u201d that their shares were among those tied to the FRS\n\n   and that, alternatively, all shares issued by Palantir are traceable to the FRS under an\n\n   \u201cintegrated offering\u201d theory. These theories are as defective now as they were last time.\n\n          Second, the PSLRA requires Section 10 claims be pleaded with facts showing not\n\n   simply that it is plausible that each defendant acted with fraudulent intent, but rather that\n\n   such inference is so strong that it is at least as compelling as any other. Despite years of\n\n   investigating and multiple chances to amend, Plaintiffs\u2019 allegations still do not clear this\n\n   hurdle. Plaintiffs allege no facts\u2014no specific document, whistleblower testimony, or\n\n   government finding\u2014that demonstrate intent to defraud by any Defendant or contradict\n\n   any Challenged Statement. Plaintiffs fall back on the refrain that Defendants had \u201cstrong\n\n   visibility\u201d into future performance through \u201caccess\u201d to unspecified reports and \u201cregular\u201d\n\n   meetings, which somehow made their statements fraudulent. But court after court has\n\n   rejected such theories. As the Tenth Circuit recently confirmed: visibility allegations fail\n\n   to plead scienter absent particularized facts showing what each report or meeting\n\n   revealed and how that information rendered any statement contemporaneously false.\n\n   Meitav Dash Provident Funds & Pension Ltd. v. Spirit AeroSystems Holdings, Inc., 79\n\n   F.4th 1209, 1217 (10th Cir. 2023). The Complaint is devoid of any such allegations.\n\n          Third, Plaintiffs\u2019 claims fail because the Challenged Statements are accurate\n\n   statements of historical fact, inactionable opinions, corporate optimism, or immunized\n\n   forward-looking projections.     Moreover, Palantir warned investors repeatedly and\n\n\n\n                                               -2-\n                                               189\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 19 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   extensively of the very risks about which Plaintiffs now complain. The FRS overflowed\n\n   with specific and detailed disclosures, warning that there were \u201cno assurances\u201d that\n\n   Palantir\u2019s revenue \u201cwill continue to grow\u201d \u201cat current rates.\u201d Palantir also warned investors\n\n   that it invested in businesses with \u201cunproven technologies\u201d that may be \u201cunable to\n\n   generate . . . sufficient revenues\u201d to pay Palantir, thus \u201cnegatively impact[ing]\u201d Palantir\u2019s\n\n   results. It is blackletter law that disclosed risks cannot form the basis of a securities claim.\n\n          Fourth, Plaintiffs fail to plead loss causation. To pursue a \u201ccorrective\u201d disclosure\n\n   theory, Plaintiffs must identify a disclosure that reveals and corrects prior falsehoods. The\n\n   only \u201creve[lations]\u201d to which Plaintiffs point, however, are regularly scheduled earnings\n\n   releases. None of these corrected any earlier statement or revealed any prior fraud.\n\n          Unable to identify any misconduct, Plaintiffs invent several \u201cscheme[s].\u201d            For\n\n   instance, they allege that Defendants schemed to take Palantir public solely to profit from\n\n   a \u201cmassive insider selling spree.\u201d The truth is: as is typical after a company goes public,\n\n   and after being compensated in stock for nearly two decades, Palantir\u2019s insiders\n\n   (including rank and file employees) elected to sell a portion of their stock. Yet most\n\n   Defendants retained over 75% of their Palantir holdings. Equally deficient is Plaintiffs\u2019\n\n   fantasy \u201cSPAC scheme,\u201d pursuant to which Palantir allegedly invested in SPACs to inflate\n\n   financial metrics. Plaintiffs cannot show that any revenue recognized from Palantir\u2019s\n\n   SPAC transactions was fabricated, or that the SPAC investments were inherently\n\n   deceptive. Plaintiffs thus cannot satisfy the PSLRA and Rule 9(b)\u2019s demanding standards.\n\n          The Complaint should be dismissed, this time with prejudice.\n\n\n\n\n                                                -3-\n                                                190\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 20 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n                                        BACKGROUND2\n\n          A.     Palantir\u2019s Origins and Products\n\n          Founded in 2003, Palantir\u2019s products include Gotham and Foundry. \u00b6 26. Gotham\n\n   organizes and evaluates complex datasets and is used to design software. Id.; D.A.9, 14\n\n   (FRS). Foundry creates an operating system that permits organizations to better utilize\n\n   data. \u00b6 26; D.A.9, 14 (FRS). Palantir\u2019s products assist U.S. Special Forces, aid in\n\n   distributing the COVID vaccine, and help Ukraine resist the Russian invasion.            See\n\n   D.A.138 (Nov. 12, 2020 Tr.); D.A.152, 154 (May 9, 2022 Tr.). Its government customers\n\n   include the U.S. Army, the FDA, and the CDC. D.A.112 (FRS). Its commercial clients\n\n   include BP, Tyson Foods, and the Cleveland Clinic. D.A.121\u201322 (FRS); D.A.168\u201369 (Feb.\n\n   13, 2023 Tr.).\n\n          B.     Palantir Goes Public After 17 Promising Years as a Private Company.\n\n          After 17 years operating privately, developing marquee products, and building\n\n   relationships with over 125 customers but having limited liquidity for its shareholders,\n\n   Palantir decided to go public. Rather than use an IPO structure, where a company issues\n\n   new shares which are sold via financial institutions who act as underwriters, Palantir used\n\n   a direct listing in which it issued no new shares but registered certain shares of preexisting\n\n   shareholders so that they could (and did) sell directly to the public together with\n\n\n   2   Defendants accept the Complaint\u2019s well-pleaded facts only for this Motion. The Court\n       may consider publicly available documents, annexes, and exhibits in Defendants\u2019\n       Appendix filed herewith, see Civ. Practice Standard 7.1B(c), without converting this\n       Motion into one for summary judgment, because they are incorporated into or integral\n       to the Complaint and/or are subject to judicial notice. See RJN; see also Slater v. A.G.\n       Edwards & Sons, Inc., 719 F.3d 1190, 1196 (10th Cir. 2013). Unless otherwise noted,\n       all emphasis is added, and all internal quotations and citations are omitted.\n\n\n                                               -4-\n                                               191\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 21 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   unregistered shares. See \u00b6 29. As a result, both registered and unregistered Palantir\n\n   shares were available for purchase simultaneously, without brokers tracking which\n\n   transacted shares were registered and which were not. See Opp\u2019n to Mot. to Lift.\n\n          C.     The Registration Statement\n\n          To facilitate the Offering, Palantir filed the FRS on September 21. \u00b6 29 n.7. 3\n\n   Taking as true the Complaint\u2019s allegations, 489 million shares of Class A common stock\n\n   were available for resale upon Palantir\u2019s direct listing, of which 257 million were registered\n\n   under the FRS, leaving 232 million shares unregistered. \u00b6 234. This immediately created\n\n   a public market for registered and unregistered shares.\n\n          The FRS also described Palantir\u2019s capital structure, which has three share classes:\n\n   Class A common stock, which was entitled to one vote per share; Class B common stock,\n\n   with ten votes per share and that can be converted to Class A; and Class F common\n\n   stock, which is held in a voting trust established by Palantir\u2019s founders. D.A.16 (FRS).\n\n          D.     Palantir Warns of the Risks About Which Plaintiffs Complain.\n\n          The FRS referenced Palantir\u2019s recent historical financial success, including\n\n   Palantir\u2019s \u201caccelerat[ing]\u201d growth: generating a 25% increase in revenue in 2019\n\n   compared to 2018; and a 49% increase in H1 2020 revenue, compared to H1 2019.\n\n   D.A.108 (FRS). At the same time, Palantir cautioned that, while \u201crevenue ha[d] increased,\u201d\n\n   there could be \u201cno assurances that revenue will continue to grow or do so at current rates.\u201d\n\n   Id. at D.A.26.   Palantir specifically warned investors that \u201cthe revenue of any prior\n\n\n\n   3   On September 30, the first day of the Class Period, Palantir filed a final prospectus\n       with the SEC. \u00b6 29 n.7. A supplement was filed on November 13. Id.\n\n\n                                               -5-\n                                               192\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 22 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   quarterly or annual period\u201d is not a reliable indicator of future performance. Id. It further\n\n   disclosed:\n\n      \uf0b7   \u201c[Y]ou should not rely on the revenue of any prior [year] or quarter[] as an indication\n          of\u201d future performance. \u201cOur revenue growth rate may decline.\u201d Id.\n      \uf0b7   \u201cWe have incurred losses each year since our inception\u201d and \u201cmay never achieve\n          or maintain profitability.\u201d Id.\n      \uf0b7   \u201c[D]ownturns in new sales may not be immediately reflected in our revenue\n          because we generally recognize revenue over the term of our contracts.\u201d Id. at\n          D.A.28.\n          The FRS also noted recent government growth: as of June 30, 2020, government\n\n   TRDV \u201cwas $1.2 billion, up 74% from December 31, 2018.\u201d Id. at D.A.102. It warned that\n\n   these growth rates may not be sustained as \u201cchanges in the contracting or fiscal policies\n\n   of the public sector could have a material adverse effect on our business.\u201d Id. at D.A.42.\n\n          Palantir \u201cbelieve[d]\u201d that, over time, its \u201ccontribution margin\u201d \u201c[would] increase\u201d as\n\n   software efficiency improved. Id. at D.A.100. Palantir acknowledged, however, that its\n\n   sales efforts \u201cinvolve considerable time and expense\u201d and the \u201csales cycle is often long\n\n   and unpredictable,\u201d adding \u201cthere is no guarantee\u201d that its customers would scale or that\n\n   its contribution margin would increase. Id. at D.A.26\u201329. As for its products, Palantir\n\n   stated that they have a \u201ccomplex,\u201d \u201clengthy implementation process, and any failure of\n\n   our platforms to satisfy\u201d customers \u201ccould harm our business[.]\u201d Id. at D.A.30\u201331.\n\n          Further, while Palantir was optimistic about a $119 billion TAM, it warned that \u201c[t]he\n\n   estimates and assumptions that are used to calculate our market opportunity are subject\n\n   to change,\u201d may prove \u201cinaccurate,\u201d and \u201cthere is no guarantee\u201d of \u201cany particular level of\n\n   revenue.\u201d \u00b6 226, D.A.57, 73 (FRS); see also D.A.46\u201347 (FRS) (warning that if Palantir is\n\n   \u201cnot successful in executing our strategy,\u201d \u201cour results of operations may suffer\u201d).\n\n\n                                               -6-\n                                               193\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 23 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n          Palantir reiterated and updated these risk disclosures throughout the Class Period.\n\n          E.     Palantir\u2019s Strategic Investment Program\n\n          Six months after going public, in March 2021, Palantir began a strategic investment\n\n   program in which it invested in early- and growth-stage companies, including SPACs, and\n\n   entered into multi-year commercial agreements with these same companies. \u00b6\u00b6 63\u201364.\n\n          Palantir aimed to expand its commercial customer base from \u201cestablished industry\n\n   players\u201d to \u201cday 0\u201d companies with \u201cambitious goals.\u201d D.A.183 (May 11, 2021 Tr.).\n\n   Palantir viewed these partnerships as a natural fit: its software would allow these clients\n\n   to \u201caccelerate production ramps and time to market.\u201d Id. Palantir would benefit from the\n\n   opportunity to be at the forefront of innovation and growth in new markets. See id.\n\n          Palantir\u2019s investment strategy was not unique. SPACs were among the most\n\n   popular transactions in 2021, the year Palantir began investing. See In re Hennessy Cap.\n\n   Acquisition Corp. IV S\u2019holder Litig., \u2014 A.3d \u2014, 2024 WL 2799044, at *1 (Del. Ch. May\n\n   31, 2024) (describing 2020 and 2021 as a SPAC transaction \u201cfrenzy\u201d). Nor was it a secret.\n\n   Palantir disclosed the details of its SPAC investments, including investment dates and\n\n   amounts; names or descriptions of the investee; number and type of shares acquired;\n\n   maximum potential revenue; and recognized revenue. \u00b6 3; see, e.g., D.A.202 (May 12,\n\n   2021 10-Q); D.A.266 (Aug. 12, 2021 10-Q). It also disclosed the \u201chigh-risk, high-reward\n\n   strategy\u201d of investing in, and working with, Day 0 companies. D.A.347 (Aug 12, 2021 Tr.).\n\n   Palantir told the market that SPAC investments \u201cmay decline in value or be entirely lost,\u201d\n\n   and SPACs \u201cmay be unable to perform their obligations\u201d so Palantir \u201cmay not realize a\n\n   return.\u201d See, e.g., D.A.232 (May 12, 2021 10-Q); D.A.288, 305\u201306 (Aug. 12, 2021 10-Q).\n\n\n\n                                              -7-\n                                              194\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 24 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n          Palantir also disclosed that it recognized its revenue from SPAC contracts in\n\n   compliance with ASC 606. See, e.g., D.A.438 (Feb. 24, 2022 10-K). Moreover, because\n\n   Palantir recognized SPAC revenue ratably, its commercial agreements with SPACs had\n\n   a limited impact on its revenue. See, e.g., D.A.344, 347 (Aug 12, 2021 Tr.) (SPAC\n\n   revenue made up less than 1% of Palantir\u2019s 2Q21 revenue).\n\n          Beyond Palantir\u2019s extensive disclosures, there was ample SPAC investment\n\n   information available to the market. The companies in which Palantir invested (including\n\n   those the Complaint names) issued their own disclosures, detailing Palantir\u2019s investments\n\n   and the risks associated with that company\u2019s business. For example, Celularity warned\n\n   that it already \u201cincurred net losses,\u201d had \u201cno cellular therapeutics approved for commercial\n\n   sale,\u201d and \u201canticipate[d] that it will incur substantial net losses in the future.\u201d \u00b6 64; D.A.456\n\n   (CELU S-1).       Celularity disclosed that its \u201chistorical operating results indicate[d]\n\n   substantial doubt\u201d as to its ability to continue as a going concern. D.A.457 (CELU S-1).\n\n   Additionally, the SPACs in which Palantir invested were required to make regular public\n\n   filings, providing yet more information to investors. Analysts also monitored the public\n\n   information regarding Palantir\u2019s SPAC investments. RBC, for example, published a\n\n   strategic investment tracker. \u00b6 182; see also D.A.463 (Nov. 9, 2021 RBC Report).\n\n          F.     The SPAC Market Declines.\n\n          In 2022, the popularity of SPAC investments began to wane. Many SPACs,\n\n   including those in which Palantir had invested, underperformed expectations. During its\n\n   earnings call on May 9, 2022, Palantir explained that revenue from its strategic investment\n\n   program had \u201cpeaked\u201d at about $39 million in 1Q22 and that it would no longer make\n\n\n\n                                                 -8-\n                                                 195\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 25 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   additional such investments. D.A.160 (May 9, 2022 Tr.).\n\n          Despite the downturn in SPACs, Palantir\u2019s performance remained strong, with total\n\n   revenue exceeding $446 million. D.A.479 (May 9, 2022 10-Q). At that time, Palantir\n\n   announced that it had experienced \u201ccontinued strength and growth in the U.S. business,\n\n   ex SPACs,\u201d growing 65% year-over-year and 9% quarter-over-quarter. D.A.160 (May 9,\n\n   2022 Tr.); D.A.558 (Aug 8, 2022 Tr.) (80% ex SPAC growth for year). Ultimately, Palantir\n\n   achieved its disclosed goal of long-term growth and profitability in 4Q22, two years earlier\n\n   than expected. Compare D.A.157\u201359 (May 9, 2022 Tr.), with D.A.167 (Feb. 13, 2023 Tr.).\n\n          G.     This Litigation\n\n          Plaintiffs filed their original complaint in September 2022, which they amended in\n\n   February 2023. ECF 1, 47. Over Plaintiffs\u2019 objections, Judge Sweeney stayed this action\n\n   pending the decision in Slack. ECF 54. Plaintiffs amended again on June 29, 2023. ECF\n\n   59. Defendants moved to dismiss. ECF 67. On March 31, 2024, the Court dismissed\n\n   that complaint without prejudice. ECF 82. This Complaint followed. ECF 92.\n\n                                          ARGUMENT\n\n          To survive dismissal, a complaint must contain sufficient facts which, if true, show\n\n   that a claim \u201cis plausible.\u201d Bell Atl. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544, 570 (2007). A Section\n\n   10(b) claim must also satisfy the heightened pleading standards of the PSLRA and Rule\n\n   9(b). These require Plaintiffs to plead particularized facts showing why a statement was\n\n   false when made and why each defendant acted with the requisite scienter. See Hampton\n\n   v. root9B Techs., Inc., 897 F.3d 1291, 1298 (10th Cir. 2018); see also 15 U.S.C. \u00a7 78u-\n\n   4(b)(1)(B) (Plaintiffs must \u201cspecify each statement alleged to have been misleading\u201d and\n\n\n\n                                              -9-\n                                              196\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 26 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   plead with particularized facts \u201cthe reasons why.\u201d). Where, as here, Plaintiffs\u2019 Section 11\n\n   claim is based on the same allegations as their Section 10(b) claims, it must also satisfy\n\n   Rule 9(b), even if fraud is summarily disclaimed. See, e.g., Rubke v. Capitol Bancorp\n\n   Ltd., 551 F.3d 1156, 1161 (9th Cir. 2009) (Rule 9(b) applies to Section 11 claim \u201csound[ing]\n\n   in fraud\u201d); Rombach v. Chang, 355 F.3d 164, 170\u201371 (2d Cir. 2004) (same).\n\n   I.      THE SECTION 11 CLAIM FAILS BECAUSE PLAINTIFFS CANNOT \u201cTRACE\u201d\n           THEIR SHARES.\n\n           The Section 11 claim should be dismissed because Plaintiffs fail to plead, as\n\n   required, that they purchased shares registered by (i.e., \u201ctraceable\u201d to) the \u201callegedly\n\n   defective registration statement\u201d as opposed to \u201cunregistered shares unconnected to the\n\n   registration statement.\u201d Slack, 598 U.S. at 765, 768\u201370 & n.2 (citing Joseph v. Wiles,\n\n   223 F.3d 1155, 1159 (10th Cir. 2000)).\n\n           Slack directly parallels this case. Like Palantir, Slack went public via a direct listing\n\n   in which registered and unregistered shares simultaneously entered the market. Id. This\n\n   commingling of registered and unregistered shares renders tracing impossible, as the\n\n   district court in Slack acknowledged. Pirani v. Slack Techs., Inc., 445 F. Supp. 3d 367,\n\n   379 (N.D. Cal. 2020) (\u201cIn a direct listing, the impossibility of tracing begins on the very\n\n   first day of listing due to the simultaneous offering of unregistered and registered shares\u201d).\n\n           Slack compels dismissal of Plaintiffs\u2019 Section 11 claim. Plaintiffs\u2019 attempts to\n\n   circumvent Slack\u2019s clear mandate through (1) probabilistic reasoning, \u00b6\u00b6 237\u201342, and\n\n   (2) the \u201cintegrated offering\u201d doctrine, \u00b6\u00b6 231\u201336, should be rejected. 4\n\n\n\n   4    These allegations about CalPERS cannot show tracing as to Plaintiff Liu.\n\n\n                                                - 10 -\n                                                 197\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 27 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n          A.      Plaintiffs Cannot Substitute Mere Possibility for Traceability.\n\n          Plaintiffs argue they satisfy the tracing requirement because \u201cthe probability that\n\n   CalPERS purchased at least one registered share is so high as to constitute a legal\n\n   certainty.\u201d   \u00b6 237.    The leading circuit decision rejected this argument.             Krim v.\n\n   pcOrder.com, Inc., 402 F.3d 489, 492 (5th Cir. 2005). In Krim, plaintiffs purchased stock\n\n   when registered shares comprised 99.85% of the market\u2014far more than the 52.6%\n\n   assumed here. Id., \u00b6 238. The Krim plaintiffs argued that tracing can be established \u201cby\n\n   proffering nothing more than statistics indicating a high mathematical probability\u201d that they\n\n   purchased traceable shares. 402 F.3d at 494 & n.6. The Fifth Circuit rejected this\n\n   assertion because \u201cthese general statistics say nothing about the shares that a specific\n\n   person actually owns and have no ability to separate those shares upon which [statutory]\n\n   standing can be based from those for which [statutory] standing is improper.\u201d Id. at 501.5\n\n          Numerous lower courts have reached the same conclusion because \u201cprobabilistic\u201d\n\n   tracing is speculative. See, e.g., Doherty v. Pivotal Software, Inc., 19-cv-3589, 2019 WL\n\n   5864581, at *10 (N.D. Cal. Nov. 8, 2019) (\u201ca favorable percentage\u201d insufficient to plead\n\n   tracing); In re Quarterdeck Off. Sys., Inc. Sec. Litig., 92-cv-0397, 1993 WL 623310, at *2\u2013\n\n   3 (C.D. Cal. Sept. 30, 1993) (tracing not pleaded even though 97% of the shares were\n\n   traceable); Abbey v. Comput. Memories, Inc., 634 F. Supp. 870, 875 (N.D. Cal. 1986)\n\n   (\u201chigh probability\u201d of tracing is not enough). Despite amici urging the Supreme Court to\n\n\n\n   5   See also Century Aluminum Co. Sec. Litig., 729 F.3d 1104, 1108 (9th Cir. 2013)\n       (allegation that plaintiffs\u2019 shares \u201ccould have\u201d come from challenged offering\n       insufficient); In re Ariad Pharm., Inc. Sec. Litig., 842 F.3d 744, 755 (1st Cir. 2016)\n       (allegation that plaintiff\u2019s shares \u201care traceable to the offering in question\u201d insufficient).\n\n\n                                                 - 11 -\n                                                  198\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 28 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   adopt this probability-based methodology in Slack, the Court declined to do so. See Br.\n\n   for Evid. and Civ. Proc. Scholars, Slack, 22-200, 2023 WL 2439653 (U.S. Mar. 6, 2023).\n\n          B.      The Integrated Offering Doctrine Is Inapplicable.\n\n          Alternatively, Plaintiffs argue that\u2014notwithstanding Slack\u2014they need not trace at\n\n   all, because Palantir\u2019s direct listing was a \u201csingle integrated offering such that all shares\n\n   sold . . . are deemed registered and are traceable to the Registration Statement.\u201d \u00b6 236.\n\n   This argument fails for two independent reasons.\n\n          First, the integration doctrine has nothing to do with Section 11\u2019s tracing\n\n   requirement.     Rather, it \u201cdetermine[s] whether exemptions from the registration\n\n   requirements [of the Securities Act] apply.\u201d In re Refco, Inc. Sec. Litig., 503 F. Supp. 2d\n\n   611, 627 (S.D.N.Y. 2007). Its purpose is to prevent issuers from avoiding registration by\n\n   artificially dividing a single offering that should be registered into multiple exempt offerings.\n\n   See SEC Release, 86 Fed. Reg. 3496, 3499 (Jan. 14, 2021). Plaintiffs do not claim that\n\n   Palantir violated the Securities Act\u2019s registration provisions. Nor is there any support,\n\n   including from Slack, for using the integration doctrine as Plaintiffs seek to do here.\n\n          Second, even if the integration doctrine were applicable, Plaintiffs fail to satisfy its\n\n   requirements. Courts consider five factors when determining whether securities offerings\n\n   should be integrated, the most important of which are \u201c(a) whether the offerings are part\n\n   of a single plan of financing . . . and (e) whether the offerings are made for the same\n\n   general purposes.\u201d SEC v. Murphy, 626 F.2d 633, 645 (9th Cir. 1980). These factors\n\n   typically apply when a company is raising money for a single purpose.\n\n          That is not the case here. There was no \u201csingle plan of financing\u201d in Palantir\u2019s\n\n\n\n                                                - 12 -\n                                                 199\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 29 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   direct listing; hundreds of stockholders independently decided whether and when they\n\n   wanted to sell their shares. See D.A.130 (FRS) (\u201c[W]e will have no input if and when any\n\n   Registered Stockholder may, or may not, elect to sell their shares\u201d). The proceeds from\n\n   those sales went to the stockholders, not Palantir. Id. (\u201cWe will not receive any proceeds\n\n   from the sale of shares of Class A common stock by the Registered Stockholders.\u201d). Nor\n\n   were these sales \u201cmade for the same general purpose.\u201d Plaintiffs attempt to circumvent\n\n   this distinction by alleging all Palantir stockholders had the \u201csame general purpose\u201d of\n\n   gaining \u201caccess to liquidity\u201d (i.e., raising money). \u00b6 233. But that argument would render\n\n   this factor superfluous because raising money is the purpose of all offerings.\n\n          Plaintiffs fail to allege facts establishing tracing, and they cannot skirt their pleading\n\n   burden based on probabilities and an inapplicable doctrine.\n\n   II.    LACK OF SCIENTER COMPELS DISMISSAL OF SECTION 10(b) CLAIMS.\n\n          Plaintiffs\u2019 Section 10(b) claims fail because the Complaint does not plead with\n\n   particularity a \u201cstrong inference\u201d of scienter\u2014a mental state evidencing an \u201cintent to\n\n   deceive, manipulate, or defraud,\u201d or \u201crecklessness\u201d for the truth\u2014for any Defendant. See\n\n   Smallen v. W. Union Co., 950 F.3d 1297, 1304\u201305 (10th Cir. 2020); Anderson v. Spirit\n\n   Aerosystems Holdings, Inc., 827 F.3d 1229, 1236\u201337 (10th Cir. 2016); Smallen v. W.\n\n   Union Co., 17-cv-00474, 2019 WL 1382823, at *40 (D. Colo. Mar. 27, 2019) (scienter\n\n   cannot be group-pled), aff\u2019d, 950 F.3d 1297. To survive dismissal, a complaint must\n\n   contain enough well-pleaded facts to establish that the inference of scienter is not only\n\n   \u201cplausible\u201d but that it is \u201cat least as compelling as any opposing inference.\u201d Tellabs, Inc.\n\n   v. Makor Issues & Rights, Ltd., 551 U.S. 308, 314 (2007). Allegations of fraudulent intent\n\n\n\n                                                - 13 -\n                                                 200\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 30 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   through motive (i.e., personal financial gain) and opportunity must be supported by\n\n   particularized facts but even then \u201care typically not sufficient\u201d \u201cto establish a strong\n\n   inference of scienter.\u201d In re Zagg, Inc. Sec. Litig., 797 F.3d 1194, 1206 (10th Cir. 2015).\n\n   \u201c[R]ecklessness\u201d requires conduct that is both \u201can extreme departure from the standards\n\n   of ordinary care\u201d and \u201cpresents a danger of misleading [investors] that is either known to\n\n   the defendant or is so obvious that the actor must have been aware of it.\u201d Id. at 1201.\n\n          Unable to point to an SEC investigation, financial restatement, confidential witness,\n\n   or internal report demonstrating fraud, Plaintiffs speculate about Defendants\u2019 motives.\n\n   Alternatively, they hypothesize about Defendants\u2019 collective and generalized access to\n\n   information about Palantir\u2019s business. Neither meets the PSLRA\u2019s high bar. What\n\n   remains is the claim that because the SPAC investments were not as successful as hoped,\n\n   Defendants must have known they would fail when Palantir entered them. It is black letter\n\n   law that \u201cPlaintiff[s] may not rely on a subsequent event triggering a decrease in stock\n\n   price \u2018to say that the later, sobering revelations make the earlier, cheerier statement a\n\n   falsehood.\u2019\u201d Smallen, 950 F.3d at 1309 (quoting Grossman v. Novell, Inc., 120 F.3d 1112,\n\n   1124 (10th Cir. 1997)). Rather, Plaintiffs \u201cmust provide particularized allegations showing\n\n   the Individual Defendants\u201d \u201cknew of or recklessly disregarded the falsity of the challenged\n\n   statements at the time they made the statements.\u201d Id. Plaintiffs fail to do so.\n\n          A.     The Complaint Fails Adequately to Allege Intent to Defraud.\n\n          Plaintiffs allege that Defendants acted with scienter because they took Palantir\n\n   public solely to engage in a \u201cmassive . . . selling spree\u201d and \u201ccash out\u201d over $ 2.2 billion.\n\n   \u00b6\u00b6 32, 187\u201392. This argument fails.\n\n\n\n                                              - 14 -\n                                               201\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 31 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n          Liquidity & Profit. Plaintiffs ground their scienter claim in Defendants\u2019 desire for\n\n   liquidity, but \u201c[g]eneralized motives shared by all companies\u201d do not suffice to plead\n\n   scienter. Anderson, 827 F.3d at 1239. Companies routinely go public \u201cto afford their\n\n   shareholders\u201d liquidity. Slack, 598 U.S. at 764; Ellis v. Spectranetics Corp., 15-cv-01857,\n\n   2018 WL 1583837, at *12 (D. Colo. Apr. 2, 2018) (motive to complete offering insufficient).\n\n   Thus, allegations of stock sales, even at substantial profit, are insufficient \u201cto give rise to\n\n   a strong inference of scienter.\u201d Smallen, 950 F.3d at 1310. That is especially true here\n\n   where Defendants were, for years, primarily compensated with equity grants, such that\n\n   their sales represent 17 years of deferred compensation. 6 See Ind. Elec. Workers\u2019\n\n   Pension Tr. Fund IBEW v. Shaw Grp., Inc., 537 F.3d 527, 543 (5th Cir. 2008) (post-public\n\n   offering sales \u201coverstated and innocuous\u201d).\n\n          Moreover, a supposed motive to take Palantir public fails to show scienter for any\n\n   post-offering Challenged Statements in 2020 or in 2021 and 2022, when the \u201cSPAC\n\n   Scheme\u201d allegedly occurred and most of those statements were made.                  See In re\n\n   Lottery.com, Inc. Sec. Litig., 22-cv-07111, 2024 WL 454298, at *32 (S.D.N.Y. Feb. 6,\n\n   2024) (motive to take public \u201cdissipate[s] once the [] transaction [is] complete\u201d).\n\n          10b5-1 Plans & Tax Withholding Sales. Scienter is further lacking because a\n\n   majority of the challenged trades were made automatically pursuant to 10b5-1 plans or\n\n   6   Plaintiffs allege that Defendants\u2019 stock sales during the Class Period were \u201cout of line\u201d\n       with post-Class Period sales. \u00b6 192. It makes sense for insiders to sell stock at a\n       higher rate in the first few months (and even years) of the public listing due to\n       newfound liquidity. See Initial Public Offerings: Lockup Agreements, SEC Answers\n       (Sept. 6, 2011) (extensive post-listing sales so typical \u201cstock price may drop in\n       anticipation\u201d). The notion that Defendants \u201ctempered their sales\u201d later in the Class\n       Period, \u00b6 191, merely reflects high sales post-listing, and is not indicative of scienter.\n\n\n                                               - 15 -\n                                                202\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 32 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   to cover tax withholdings.7 Such automatic sales are routinely held to \u201crebut any inference\n\n   of scienter.\u201d In re Level 3 Commc\u2019ns, Inc. Sec. Litig., 667 F.3d 1331, 1346\u201347 (10th Cir.\n\n   2012) (no scienter for automatic sales to cover tax withholding); Metzler Inv. GMBH v.\n\n   Corinthian Colls., Inc., 540 F.3d 1049, 1067 n.11 (9th Cir. 2008) (same, for automatic\n\n   sales pursuant to 10b5-1 plans); Ark. Pub. Emps. Ret. Sys. v. Bristol-Myers Squibb Co.,\n\n   28 F.4th 343, 355\u201356 (2d Cir. 2022) (10b5-1 sales \u201ccould not be timed suspiciously\u201d). In\n\n   the Tenth Circuit, pleading scienter based on 10b5-1 sales requires particularized facts\n\n   that defendants knew when their trades were scheduled and made false and misleading\n\n   statements to take advantage of that schedule. Ind. Pub. Ret. Sys. v. Pluralsight, Inc., 45\n\n   F.4th 1236, 1266 (10th Cir. 2022). The Complaint alleges nothing of the sort.\n\n           2020 Awards. Plaintiffs allege the August 2020 stock awards made to Karp,\n\n   Cohen, and Sankar influenced these Defendants to take Palantir public in September\n\n   2020. \u00b6\u00b6 187\u201388. But this does not plead scienter for several reasons:\n\n       \uf0b7   Palantir had already decided to go public before the awards. See \u00b6\u00b6 28, 187\n           (proposing a public offering in July 2020 but granting awards in August 2020).\n       \uf0b7   Defendants could have exercised their options prior to expiration and sold the\n           stock later, thus undermining any supposed urgency to take Palantir public.\n       \uf0b7   Defendants kept most of their equity, including from these awards. See D.A.1517\u2013\n           25 (Annex F).\n       \uf0b7   Over 90% of Karp\u2019s options did not vest by the end of the Class Period and thus\n           could not have been sold until after the \u201cfraud\u201d had been revealed. See D.A.1201.\n           Retained Holdings. Finally, Defendants retained substantial portions of their\n\n\n\n   7   All other sales occurred shortly after the direct listing when any MNPI had just been\n       disclosed and SPAC investments were not yet under consideration. Plaintiffs fail to\n       allege which trades were not automatic and the statements these sales coincide with.\n\n\n                                             - 16 -\n                                              203\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 33 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   holdings, further undermining scienter. The allegation that Thiel retained 73% of his\n\n   shares, \u00b6 189, rebuts scienter. Smallen, 950 F.3d at 1310\u201311 (no scienter where sales\n\n   are \u201conly a fraction\u201d of holdings). Similarly, the proportion of holdings retained by Karp,\n\n   Cohen, Sankar, and Glazer (81%, 81%, 76%, and 45%, respectively) is contrary to an\n\n   inference of scienter. See D.A.1517\u201325 (Annex F); In re Silicon Graphics Inc. Sec. Litig.,\n\n   183 F.3d 970, 987 (9th Cir. 1999) (no scienter where 24.7% of holdings retained); Ronconi\n\n   v. Larkin, 253 F.3d 423, 435\u201337 (9th Cir. 2001) (same, for 31% and 2% retained holdings);\n\n   Teachers\u2019 Ret. Sys. of La. v. Hunter, 477 F.3d 162, 185 (4th Cir. 2007) (18%, 8%, and 0%\n\n   retained holdings not suspicious in light of vested stock options). 8\n\n          B.     The Complaint Fails Adequately to Allege Deliberate Recklessness.\n\n          Absent motive to defraud, Plaintiffs\u2019 burden to plead scienter grows\n\n   \u201ccorrespondingly greater\u201d and is \u201cmore difficult to sustain.\u201d Level 3, 667 F.3d at 1347;\n\n   Emps.\u2019 Ret. Sys. of R.I. v. Williams Cos., 889 F.3d 1153, 1173 (10th Cir. 2018). Plaintiffs\n\n   thus face the \u201csubstantial hurdle\u201d of pleading \u201ccompelling and particularized facts showing\u201d\n\n   deliberate recklessness. Prodanova v. H.C. Wainwright & Co., 993 F.3d 1097, 1103,\n\n   1108 (9th Cir. 2021). Plaintiffs fail to meet this heavy burden.\n\n          Plaintiffs argue that \u201cDefendants\u201d collectively and generally had \u201cstrong visibility\u201d\n\n   and \u201caccess to [MNPI],\u201d and thus must have had contemporaneous knowledge that their\n\n\n\n   8   The Complaint emphasizes the purported value of Class F shares to insiders, \u00b6 194,\n       but Plaintiffs omit Class F shares (and other equity) from their \u201c% Sold\u201d calculation, \u00b6\n       189. Ronconi, 253 F.3d at 435\u201336 (considering stock options in calculations).\n       Moreover, the claim that Class F allowed Karp, Thiel, and Cohen to sell stock but\n       retain control, \u00b6\u00b6 193\u201395, fails, because if they were so motivated, they would not\n       have retained multiple times the holdings required to retain control, foregoing billions.\n\n\n                                              - 17 -\n                                               204\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 34 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   statements were false. See, e.g., \u00b6\u00b6 25 (\u201cIndividual Defendants\u201d sent and received\n\n   \u201cmonthly email updates,\u201d \u201cKarp, Cohen, or Sankar\u201d attended \u201csales ops\u201d meetings); 125\u2013\n\n   27 (\u201cKarp, Glazer, and the other[s]\u201d had \u201caccess to dashboards,\u201d \u201cDefendants\u201d had \u201cstrong\n\n   visibility\u201d into the business), 129 (\u201cstrong visibility into future revenue\u201d), 230 (same).\n\n          First, such group-pled allegations are impermissible. Smallen, 2019 WL 1382823,\n\n   at *40 (plaintiff \u201crequired to adequately allege scienter on the part of each Defendant\u201d);\n\n   TDC Lending LLC v. Priv. Cap. Grp., Inc., 340 F.Supp.3d 1218, 1227 (D. Utah 2018) (By\n\n   group pleading, a plaintiff attempts \u201cto group defendants together without distinguishing\n\n   the bases for each defendant\u2019s culpability. This is incompatible with the [PSLRA\u2019s]\n\n   purpose\u201d of \u201celiminat[ing] complaints that do not clearly show scienter.\u201d); see \u00a7 78u-4(b)(2)\n\n   & (d) (ultimate question is \u201ceach such defendant\u2019s state of mind\u201d).\n\n          Second, in Spirit, the Tenth Circuit recently considered and squarely rejected this\n\n   very theory. Spirit, 79 F.4th at 1217. The court held that while \u201ctop executives presumably\n\n   had access to\u201d information, mere access \u201cd[id] [not] show knowledge of specific facts\u201d\n\n   required to plead scienter. Id. The court explained that \u201cit\u2019s not enough\u201d to allege\n\n   knowledge of \u201cunderlying data,\u201d \u201caccess to internal reports,\u201d or \u201cclose involvement\u201d in the\n\n   business. Id. at 1216, 1222. Rather, plaintiffs must point to \u201cparticularized allegations\n\n   about the contents\u201d of those meetings or reports, like that the defendant \u201csaw data that\n\n   would have alerted him\u201d that his statements were false. Id. at 1220, 1222 n.4. Spirit is\n\n   consistent with other Tenth Circuit authority, as well as authority in this District. See MHC\n\n   Mut. Conversion Fund, L.P. v. Sandler O\u2019Neill & Partners, L.P., 761 F.3d 1109, 1122 (10th\n\n   Cir. 2014) (\u201c[N]othing in the defendants\u2019 routine [meeting] attendance\u201d \u201csuggest[s] a\n\n\n\n                                               - 18 -\n                                                205\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 35 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   cogent and \u2018compelling\u2019 inference of scienter.\u201d); Anderson, 827 F.3d at 1245\u201346 (alleging\n\n   defendants were \u201cintimately involved\u201d in or \u201cpersonally monitored\u201d the business\n\n   insufficient to plead scienter); Level 3, 667 F.3d at 1344 (same, for \u201cmonitor[ing]\u201d \u201cthrough\n\n   regular meetings and reports\u201d); Sorkin, LLC v. Fischer Imaging Corp., 03-cv-00631, 2005\n\n   WL 1459735, at *10 (D. Colo. June 21, 2005) (same, for \u201cmere access to\u201d information). 9\n\n           The Complaint is devoid of the particularized showing the Tenth Circuit requires.\n\n   It pleads no \u201cspecific\u201d facts about what each Defendant knew and how that information\n\n   rendered any statement contemporaneously false. There are no allegations about what\n\n   the email updates discussed, what specific information the meetings covered, nor what\n\n   the dashboards revealed. Level 3, 667 F.3d at 1344\u201345 (noting \u201cfundamental weakness\u201d\n\n   in plaintiffs\u2019 scienter allegations, \u201c[g]iven the difficulty\u201d \u201cin determining whether a conflict\n\n   actually existed between the reports and defendants\u2019 statements\u201d); Sorkin, 2005 WL\n\n   1459735, at *8 (\u201cWithout specific facts about . . . what information was presented\u201d at\n\n   meetings, \u201cthere is no way to determine whether the matters discussed\u201d support a strong\n\n   inference of scienter). Plaintiffs\u2019 allegations are thus insufficient to plead scienter.\n\n           Unable to point to specific facts that would support their theory, Plaintiffs default to\n\n   group-pled speculation. This is of no help. For example, speculation that a \u201ctypical\n\n   contract[\u2019s]\u201d length permitted \u201cDefendants\u201d to predict quarterly revenue fails to account\n\n   for new contracts Palantir hoped to sign or existing contracts that could be renewed or\n\n   upsized during a particular period. See, e.g., \u00b6 129 (\u201caware from their \u2018strong visibility\u2019\n\n\n\n   9   Retail Wholesale Dep\u2019t Store Union Loc. 338 Ret. Fund v. Stitch Fix, Inc., 22-cv-04893,\n       2024 WL 3447524, at *7 (N.D. Cal. July 16, 2024) (\u201caccess to such data\u201d insufficient).\n\n\n                                                - 19 -\n                                                 206\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 36 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   [that] performance was set to peak\u201d and \u201cgrowth rates\u201d \u201cdecline\u201d). These allegations also\n\n   rest entirely on Defendants\u2019 clairvoyance, which courts repeatedly reject. 10 Wolfe v.\n\n   Aspenbio Pharma, Inc., 587 F. App\u2019x 493, 497\u201398 (10th Cir. 2014) (rejecting \u201cnotion that\n\n   knowledge may be imputed solely from an individual\u2019s position within a company\u201d); In re\n\n   Pivotal Sec. Litig., 19-cv-03589, 2020 WL 4193384, at *16\u201317 (N.D. Cal. July 21, 2020)\n\n   (\u201cquite a bit of revenue visibility\u201d insufficient); In re Nokia Oyj (Nokia Corp.) Sec. Litig.,\n\n   423 F.Supp.2d 364, 406\u201307 (S.D.N.Y. 2006) (\u201cexceptionally good visibility\u201d insufficient).\n\n           Similarly, Plaintiffs suggest, without any supporting facts, that \u201cDefendants\u201d \u201cknew\u201d\n\n   that Palantir would not receive a \u201csubstantial portion\u201d of SPAC-related revenue because\n\n   Palantir \u201chad as much information about the SPAC as the SPAC themselves\u201d and so\n\n   knew the SPACs would fail.11 \u00b6 59 (pointing to unspecified \u201cdue diligence\u201d and alleging\n\n   Foundry would \u201cunlock\u201d a \u201cdigital twin\u201d of the SPAC\u2019s \u201centire enterprise\u201d for the customer\u2019s\n\n   use).    Plaintiffs\u2019 assertion that \u201cDefendants\u201d entered SPAC customers\u2019 digital twin\n\n   environments, accessed customers\u2019 internal data and became aware of information that\n\n   contradicted Palantir\u2019s disclosures is baseless. See \u00b6 81. Indeed, Plaintiffs fail to allege\n\n\n\n   10   To the extent Plaintiffs seek to plead scienter through a core operations theory\u2014that\n        SPACs were so key to Palantir that Defendants must have knowledge of the alleged\n        \u201cScheme\u201d\u2014this theory has repeatedly been rejected. Anderson, 827 F.3d at 1246; In\n        re Gold Res. Corp. Sec. Litig., 776 F.3d 1103, 1116 (10th Cir. 2015) (rejecting\n        allegations that defendants working at a small, single-product company \u201cmust have\n        known\u201d the misleading nature of their statements, as \u201cinsufficient under the heightened\n        pleading requirements to establish\u201d scienter).\n   11   The conclusory argument that scienter may be inferred from \u201cfront-loaded\u201d or \u201cupfront\u201d\n        payment, \u00b6\u00b6 82, 87, 93, also fails because \u201c[g]eneralized motives shared by all\n        companies\u201d do not suffice to plead scienter. Anderson, 827 F.3d at 1239. Negotiating\n        favorable contract terms and insulating against risk is not indicative of fraud.\n\n\n                                               - 20 -\n                                                207\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 37 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   any facts\u2014well pleaded or otherwise\u2014to show that \u201cDefendants\u201d had access to or\n\n   entered any SPAC customer\u2019s digital twin environment. Plaintiffs fail to allege what\n\n   information \u201cDefendants\u201d allegedly obtained that informed their individual knowledge of\n\n   SPAC customers\u2019 operations. This outlandish and unsupported speculation does not\n\n   suffice to plead scienter. In re Overstock Sec. Litig., 19-cv-0709, 2021 WL 4267920, at\n\n   *13 (D. Utah Sept. 20, 2021) (\u201c[S]peculation does not support an allegation of scienter.\u201d).\n\n          Plaintiffs have not alleged a cogent inference of fraud at least as compelling as all\n\n   opposing inferences. Tellabs, 551 U.S. at 324. The alternative non-fraudulent inference\n\n   is that Palantir experienced, as every company does, routine business setbacks. Palantir\n\n   went public after years of operating privately, which is not motive to defraud. Nor is the\n\n   fact that Palantir invested in SPACs, like many other sophisticated investors at the time,\n\n   evidence of fraud. See Hennessy, 2024 WL 2799044, at *1 (\u201cExperienced investors . . .\n\n   sponsored SPACs with the promise of huge returns.\u201d). Defendants saw SPACs as\n\n   strategic investments, symbiotic with Palantir\u2019s business model and disclosed the\n\n   Company\u2019s SPAC-related strategy and risks. As the market discovered in 2022, SPACs\n\n   were not the investment opportunities that they appeared to be. Investors, including\n\n   Palantir, were affected. That suggests, at most, a business decision that did not pan out.\n\n   III.   PLAINTIFFS\u2019 CLAIMS SHOULD BE DISMISSED FOR FAILURE TO PLEAD\n          AN ACTIONABLE MISSTATEMENT OR OMISSION.\n\n          The Challenged Statements comprise three categories: (i) Palantir\u2019s SPAC\n\n   investments; (ii) Palantir\u2019s financial performance, and (iii) Palantir\u2019s efficiencies. Plaintiffs\n\n   fail to plead with particularity the reasons \u201cwhy [each] statement was misleading,\u201d and \u201call\n\n   facts\u201d that contradict them.\n\n\n                                                - 21 -\n                                                 208\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 38 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n          A.     Plaintiffs Fail to Plead Falsity as to the SPAC-Related Statements.\n\n                 1.     Section 11 Claims Not Adequately Pleaded\n\n          There can be no SPAC-related Section 11 claim because no SPAC investments\n\n   had yet been made at the time of the direct listing. Plaintiffs\u2019 sole attempt to link SPACs\n\n   to the FRS is to point to a generic reference to \u201cstrategic transactions.\u201d \u00b6\u00b6 62, 223-24.\n\n   This fails. \u201c[S]trategic transactions\u201d is a generic term that did not refer exclusively to\n\n   SPACs. In fact, Palantir continued to use that term even after it stopped making SPAC\n\n   investments. Compare D.A.305 (Aug. 12, 2021 10-Q) (Palantir \u201cexpects\u201d to \u201cengage[] in\n\n   strategic transactions\u201d \u201cin the future.\u201d), with D.A.585 (Nov. 7, 2022 10-Q) (same). When\n\n   Palantir discussed SPACs, it did so explicitly. See, e.g., D.A.306 (Aug. 12, 2021 10-Q)\n\n   (Palantir entered into agreements with \u201cspecial purpose acquisition companies.\u201d).\n\n          Plaintiffs\u2019 challenge in \u00b6 224 also fails because Palantir had no duty to disclose\n\n   future business strategies not yet \u201cconsummated.\u201d See In re Centerline Holding Co. Sec.\n\n   Litig., 678 F.Supp.2d 150, 161 n.74 (S.D.N.Y. 2009), aff\u2019d, 380 F.App\u2019x 91, 94 (2d Cir.\n\n   2010). Moreover, Plaintiffs\u2019 attempt to create Section 11 liability runs into their own\n\n   allegation that it took 3 or 4 months to negotiate SPAC investments. \u00b6 62. Taking that\n\n   allegation as true means that Palantir was not working on SPAC transactions until\n\n   December 2020, months after the Final Registration Statement was filed. Plaintiffs\u2019\n\n   attempt to conjure Section 11 liability for SPAC-related statements fails.\n\n                 2.     Section 10(b) Claims Not Adequately Pleaded\n\n          Plaintiffs\u2019 critiques of Palantir\u2019s SPAC investment strategy do not come within the\n\n   ambit of Section 10(b). Plaintiffs allege fraud existed because the investments were not\n\n\n\n                                             - 22 -\n                                              209\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 39 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   as successful as expected. But a business strategy that does not pan out is not actionable\n\n   under federal securities laws. See Halperin v. eBanker USA.com, Inc., 295 F.3d 352,\n\n   361 (2d. Cir. 2002) (no redress through fraud claim where \u201cinvestment did not turn out\u201d\n\n   as hoped). Plaintiffs\u2019 actual complaint concerning SPACs concerns an alleged breach of\n\n   fiduciary duties; that claim will be decided by the Delaware Chancery Court. See Cent.\n\n   Laborers\u2019 Pension Fund v. Karp, 2023-0864 (D. Ch. Aug. 22, 2023).\n\n            Plaintiffs allege SPAC-related disclosure and accounting claims. Both fail.\n\n            Disclosure. Plaintiffs allege that the SPAC investments were not adequately\n\n   disclosed. \u00b6 61. Yet, the very documents on which Plaintiffs rely rebut that theory. In\n\n   fact, Palantir disclosed the material details of each of its SPAC investments. See supra\n\n   pp. 7\u20138; D.A.266 (Aug. 12, 2021 10-Q). Moreover, Palantir warned investors about the\n\n   riskiness of these investments, which Plaintiffs themselves concede. See, e.g., \u00b6\u00b6 61,\n\n   63.12 These disclosures were specific and cautioned, for example, that:\n\n        \uf0b7   \u201cIf [SPACs are] unable to generate sufficient revenues or profitability or to\n            access financing or funding . . . [our results] would also be negatively\n            impacted.\u201d D.A.232 (May 12, 2021 10-Q).\n        \uf0b7   \u201c[W]e make strategic investments. . . including, [in SPACs] in connection with . . .\n            transactions with growth-stage companies. . . our investments may decline in\n            value or be entirely lost.\u201d Id.\n        \uf0b7   The SPAC companies with which we contract \u201cmay be engaged in businesses that\n            involve novel and unproven technologies, products, and services and such\n            companies may be unable to perform their obligations under any commercial\n            agreements . . ., in a timely manner or at all.\u201d Id.\n   It is black letter law that no securities fraud claim can lie where the very risks about which\n\n\n\n   12   These risks were also noted early in the Class Period in analyst reports that suggested\n        SPAC revenue was \u201cunsustainable\u201d and that the \u201cSPAC story\u201d had \u201ccracks.\u201d \u00b6 176.\n\n\n                                               - 23 -\n                                                210\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 40 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   plaintiffs complain were disclosed. See Novell, 120 F.3d at 1119.\n\n           Plaintiffs also claim Palantir did not disclose the rationale for its SPAC investment\n\n   strategy. See \u00b6\u00b6 61\u201362. That is incorrect. Though Palantir had no duty to disclose such\n\n   information, it, in fact, did so. See, e.g., D.A.183 (May 11, 2021 Tr.) (\u201cwe are investing in\n\n   innovation. . .companies with ambitious goals\u201d); In re FoxHollow Techs., Inc., Sec. Litig.,\n\n   06-cv-04595, 2008 WL 2220600, at *23 (N.D. Cal. May 27, 2008) (no duty to disclose\n\n   every detail of business strategy), aff\u2019d, 359 F. App\u2019x 802 (9th Cir. 2009).13\n\n           Plaintiffs also allege that SPACs were not \u201clegitimate\u201d investments, not \u201clong-term\n\n   customers,\u201d and could not \u201cafford\u201d Palantir\u2019s software, thereby rendering Palantir\u2019s\n\n   statements that SPACs would be \u201clong term\u201d \u201cgrowth\u201d partners false. \u00b6\u00b6 60, 79, 83, 90,\n\n   97, 115, 117, 224. The sole basis for Plaintiffs\u2019 conclusion is that SPACs eventually\n\n   became \u201c[nearly] insolvent,\u201d \u201cbankrupt,\u201d or did not achieve commercialization. 14 \u00b6\u00b6 60,\n\n   69, 70, 79, 82, 86, 98, 115. This, however, is the very essence of impermissible fraud by\n\n   hindsight. Novell, 120 F.3d at 1124. Tellingly, Plaintiffs fail to identify a single fact,\n\n   statement or document to support their conclusion that \u201cDefendants\u201d did not believe that\n\n   SPACs would become \u201clegitimate,\u201d long-term customers when they made those\n\n\n   13   The claim that Palantir delayed disclosing its SPAC investments from March to May\n        2021 is unavailing. \u00b6 63. Palantir was not required to disclose the investments before\n        it reported quarterly results, which it did in May. The notion that Palantir did not timely\n        disclose the names of two SPACs (although it described them) also falls flat, \u00b6 76 n.16.\n        See In re Rigel Pharm., Inc. Sec. Litig., 697 F.3d 869, 880 n.8 (9th Cir. 2012) (no duty\n        to disclose every fact \u201ceven if investors\u201d \u201cconsider the omitted information significant\u201d).\n        Plaintiffs\u2019 omission allegations relating to the 1Q21 and 3Q21 earnings calls fail for the\n        same reason. \u00b6\u00b6 73, 92, 100; see id.\n   14   Investors like Blackrock and Honeywell believed SPACs were legitimate and invested\n        in the same SPACs as Palantir. See D.A.628 (Lilium 6-K); D.A.632 (Sarcos PR).\n\n\n                                                - 24 -\n                                                 211\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 41 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   statements. Their contrary speculation does not suffice to carry their burden. 15 Plaintiffs\u2019\n\n   contention that the SPACs could not \u201cafford\u201d Palantir services is belied by the fact that\n\n   each of the SPACs received cash infusions of hundreds of millions of dollars. 16 \u00b6 68.\n\n           Plaintiffs also take aim at statements concerning the SPACs\u2019 use of Palantir\u2019s\n\n   software. \u00b6\u00b6 65\u201366, 74, 88, 95, 96. They argue the SPACs were too \u201cnascent\u201d to need\n\n   Palantir\u2019s software and received an \u201cout of the box\u201d version of Foundry as a \u201cpretext.\u201d\n\n   See, e.g., \u00b6\u00b6 58, 68, 78, 97. Not only do Plaintiffs fail to allege contemporaneous falsity,\n\n   but the SPACs\u2019 public disclosures themselves refute this. For example, Lilium disclosed\n\n   that: \u201cby leveraging Palantir\u2019s . . . Foundry\u201d it could \u201cdevelop powerful . . . data analytics\n\n   to gain insights and optimize processes.\u201d D.A.625 (Lilium 6-K); D.A.686 (Sarcos 14A).\n\n   Plaintiffs make much of Celularity\u2019s disclosure that it \u201cceased using Palantir software.\u201d \u00b6\u00b6\n\n   80, 89. But, the fact that Celularity \u201cceased\u201d using the software, implies that until then,\n\n   Celularity was using it. Further, a single customer complaint\u2014made almost two years\n\n   after the contract was signed and after the Class Period\u2014does not suggest fraud. See\n\n   D.A.691 (CELU 10-Q). It also undermines Plaintiffs\u2019 argument that Palantir was engaged\n\n   in sham transactions. Were that the case, Celularity would not care about the efficacy of\n\n\n   15   The unsubstantiated contention \u201cDefendants\u201d had \u201cclose relationships\u201d with SPAC\n        directors meant that they had information about the SPACs\u2019 future lack of success is\n        baseless. \u00b6 98 n.21.\n   16   Lilium, Sarcos, Roivant, and Celularity were expected to raise $830 million, $496\n        million, $631 million, and $375 million, respectively. See D.A.641 (Lilium ID); D.A.649\n        (Sarcos ID); D.A.662, 666 (Roivant ID); D.A.672 (Celularity ID). Further, five-year\n        projections for Lilium and Sarcos predicted $3.3 billion and $2.7 billion in annual\n        revenue, well in excess of the fees owed Palantir. See D.A.640 (Lilium ID); D.A.652\n        (Sarcos ID). The same was true for Roivant\u2019s ($7.3 billion) and Celularity\u2019s ($1.3 billion)\n        post-transaction valuations. See D.A.666 (Roivant ID); D.A.673 (Celularity ID).\n\n\n                                                - 25 -\n                                                 212\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 42 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   Palantir\u2019s software once it received Palantir\u2019s cash. Regardless of Plaintiffs\u2019 view on\n\n   whether the software was needed, the SPACs\u2019 intent to use the software and actual use\n\n   of the software are the critical inquiry. And there is no doubt that the SPACs so intended\n\n   and did use Palantir\u2019s products. See D.A.625 (Lilium 6-K); D.A.686 (Sarcos 14A).\n\n           Accounting. Unable to plead a traditional disclosure claim, Plaintiffs imply that\n\n   Palantir improperly accounted for the SPAC transactions. To establish an accounting-\n\n   based securities fraud claim, Plaintiffs must plead \u201cwidespread and significant inflation of\n\n   revenue\u201d and particularized facts, including the amount overstated, products involved,\n\n   dates of such transactions, and customers or employees involved. In re Daou Sys., Inc.,\n\n   411 F.3d 1006, 1017 (9th Cir. 2005), abrogated on other grounds by Tellabs, 551 U.S.\n\n   308. Plaintiffs fail to do so, thereby dooming this theory. See In re Qwest Commc\u2019n Int\u2019l,\n\n   Inc., 396 F.Supp.2d 1178, 1191 (D. Colo. 2004) (generalized allegations critiquing\n\n   revenue recognition and sources of revenue do not suffice).\n\n           Plaintiffs allege that many statements regarding financial metrics were false or\n\n   misleading because they included SPAC revenue, which purportedly was not sustainable\n\n   in the long term. None is alleged to be false with the requisite degree of particularity.\n\n           Plaintiffs contend that SPAC revenue artificially \u201cinflated\u201d adjusted operating\n\n   margins, contribution margins, revenue and revenue growth, number of customers, and\n\n   TRDV.     \u00b6\u00b6 104, 106-07, 110, 112, 114, 120, 121, 146.          But Palantir disclosed all\n\n   information (SPAC revenue and TRDV, number of SPAC customers, etc.) necessary to\n\n   calculate these metrics ex SPAC. Werner v. Werner, 267 F.3d 288, 299 (3d Cir. 2001)\n\n   (affirming dismissal where shareholders could calculate allegedly omitted information).\n\n\n\n                                              - 26 -\n                                               213\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 43 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n           Furthermore, missing from the Complaint are any particularized facts that the\n\n   SPAC related revenue was overstated, inaccurate, or nonexistent. See, e.g., \u00b6\u00b6 147, 122.\n\n   Plaintiffs cannot escape the facts: the agreements existed, the customers paid, and the\n\n   revenue recognized met the appropriate revenue recognition criteria. Indeed, Palantir\n\n   disclosed that it recognized revenue consistent with ASC 606, and Plaintiffs do not argue\n\n   that this accounting treatment was improper. D.A.266 (Aug. 12, 2021 10-Q); In re Intrexon\n\n   Corp. Sec. Litig., 16-cv-02398, 2017 WL 732952, at *5 (N.D. Cal. Feb. 24, 2017)\n\n   (financials not misleading where revenue recognition policy disclosed).\n\n           The assertion that Palantir\u2019s commercial contribution margin was \u201cinflated\u201d is\n\n   baseless.    It is premised on Plaintiffs\u2019 assumption\u2014drawn from thin air\u2014of SPAC\n\n   contracts having a 90% contribution margin. \u00b6 105. Having invented a 90% contribution\n\n   margin for SPACs, Plaintiffs claim that Palantir overstated its commercial contribution\n\n   margin by as much as 17.7% in 2021 and 2022. Id. But Plaintiffs cannot invent alternative\n\n   metrics from whole cloth to argue that the properly reported metrics are false.17\n\n           Finally, Plaintiffs allege that Palantir\u2019s agreements with SPACs were \u201croundtrip\u201d or\n\n   \u201cquid pro quo\u201d exchanges made to \u201cmask[] the timing and extent of the stagnation\u201d of its\n\n   business. See, e.g., \u00b6\u00b6 3, 32, 64, 84, 100, 103, 104. This too is wrong. A \u201cround tripping\u201d\n\n   scheme involves parties entering into off-setting contracts exchanging similar amounts of\n\n   money. Such transactions are improper because parties book revenues even though the\n\n   transactions \u201cwash out\u201d without any economic substance. That did not happen here.\n\n\n\n   17   Plaintiffs similarly estimate\u2014without any basis\u2014a 90% profit margin from the SPAC\n        contracts, \u00b6 108, which the Court should reject for the same reasons.\n\n\n                                              - 27 -\n                                               214\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 44 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   Palantir\u2019s SPAC investments did not \u201cwash out\u201d the value of each subscription agreement.\n\n   See, e.g., \u00b6\u00b6 64 (Lilium: $41M investment and 5-year $50M contract); 76 (AdTheorent:\n\n   $15M investment and 5-year $20M contract); Amr v. Sollitto, 08-cv-1686, 2009 WL\n\n   10673610, at *4 (D. Ariz. Sept. 30, 2009) (dismissing complaint; \u201c[i]f Plaintiffs wish to\n\n   pursue their round-tripping theory, they must plead more specific facts establishing that\n\n   these transactions lacked economic substance\u201d because transactions that do not \u201cmatch\n\n   up\u201d cannot conceivably be construed as \u201cwashing each other out\u201d as required to show\n\n   round tripping); Hunter, 477 F.3d at 178 (affirming dismissal because \u201c[t]he mere\n\n   existence of reciprocal dealing does not suggest \u2018round-tripping\u2019\u201d).          Moreover, in\n\n   exchange for its investment, Palantir received shares at market value in the SPAC. See,\n\n   e.g., D.A.202 (May 12, 2021 10-Q) (\u201c3.0 million shares\u201d in Roivant). Plaintiffs therefore\n\n   fail to adequately establish falsity as to the SPAC-related statements.\n\n          B.     Plaintiffs Fail to Plead Falsity as to Non-SPAC Statements.\n\n                 1.     Plaintiffs Plead No False Statement as to Financial Performance.\n\n          Plaintiffs challenge statements about Palantir\u2019s financial performance metrics,\n\n   including statements about (i) reported revenue, TRDV and customer count, (ii) revenue\n\n   growth, and (iii) projected long-term revenue growth. None of Plaintiffs\u2019 allegations suffice\n\n   to make out a securities fraud claim.\n\n          Reported Revenue, TRDV, and Customers.              Plaintiffs challenge statements\n\n   concerning Palantir\u2019s reported revenue, TRDV, and customer count. \u00b6\u00b6 112, 113\u201316.\n\n   They argue, inter alia, that because the SPAC customers did not have a \u201clegitimate\u201d need\n\n   for Foundry, the revenue recognized, TRDV, and customer counts relating to these\n\n\n\n                                              - 28 -\n                                               215\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 45 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   customers were false. See id. However, Plaintiffs do not allege\u2014because they cannot\u2014\n\n   that the revenue recognized was incorrect or that the SPAC customers and related\n\n   agreements did not exist. As such, these are \u201caccurate recitations of historical successes\u201d\n\n   and \u201cnot actionable.\u201d McDonald v. Kinder-Morgan, Inc., 287 F.3d 992, 998 (10th Cir.\n\n   2002); see also Okla. Police Pension & Ret. Sys. v. Boulder Brands, Inc., 15-cv-00679,\n\n   2017 WL 1148689, at *7 (D. Colo. Mar. 28, 2017) (\u201caccurate reporting of historical\n\n   successes\u201d are \u201cnon-actionable\u201d).\n\n         Revenue Growth. Plaintiffs also contend that Palantir \u201cinflated\u201d revenue, TRDV\n\n   and customer growth. See \u00b6\u00b6 110-17. This is untrue. Plaintiffs acknowledge that\n\n   revenue growth occurred and instead take issue with the source of revenue (i.e., derived\n\n   from SPAC contracts). See \u00b6\u00b6 129, 133 (\u201cmodest single-digit YoY\u201d ex-SPAC growth).\n\n   The fact is, however, Palantir\u2019s revenue, deal value, and customer count increased to the\n\n   extent disclosed, both prior to and during the Class Period. See, e.g., D.A.96 (FRS) (15.5%\n\n   growth from 2017 to 2018; 24.9% growth from 2018 to 2019; 49% growth from H1 2019\n\n   to H1 2020); D.A.694 (Feb. 16, 2021 PR) (47% Y/Y revenue growth for FY20; 40% Y/Y\n\n   revenue growth for 4Q20); compare D.A.206 (May 12, 2021 10-Q) (149 customers) with\n\n   D.A.275 (Aug. 12, 2021 10-Q) (169 customers); D.A.1526 (Annex G). Plaintiffs do not\n\n   show that any of these figures were false.\n\n         Plaintiffs argue that statements about the performance of the government sector\n\n   were false. See, e.g., \u00b6\u00b6 136\u201337 (\u201cenduring problems;\u201d \u201ctip of the iceberg\u201d), 143\u201344, 146\u2013\n\n   47, 150 (\u201cpipeline . . . is big and building\u201d), 152\u201353, 155. But Palantir\u2019s US government\n\n   revenue and pipeline grew at all times that Plaintiffs contest. See, e.g., D.A.1527\u201329\n\n\n\n                                             - 29 -\n                                              216\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 46 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   (Annex H); D.A.342 (Aug. 12, 2021 Tr.) (new deals with U.S. Army, Air Force); D.A.715\u2013\n\n   16 (Nov. 9, 2021 Tr.) (reporting deals with U.S., U.K., and Australian Navies, and more);\n\n   D.A.183 (May 11, 2021 Tr.) (new contract with NNSA); D.A.156 (May 9, 2022 Tr.) (new\n\n   order with Bavarian police; CDC expansion).        Plaintiffs offer no particularized facts\n\n   demonstrating contemporaneous falsity of these historical facts, so their claim fails.\n\n   McDonald, 287 F.3d at 998; In re Crocs, Inc. Sec. Litig., 774 F.Supp.2d 1122, 1151 (D.\n\n   Colo. 2011), aff\u2019d sub nom. Sanchez v. Crocs, Inc, 667 F. App\u2019x 710 (10th Cir. 2016);\n\n   Boulder Brands, 2017 WL 1148689, at *7.\n\n         Plaintiffs also allege that statements about commercial sector performance were\n\n   false. E.g., \u00b6\u00b6 131 (\u201csignificant momentum\u201d), 135 (\u201cpipeline is substantial and growing\u201d),\n\n   140-41 (\u201ccommercial tailwind\u201d), 142 (\u201csales cycle is [h]eating up\u201d), 146 (\u201crevenue growth\n\n   accelerated\u201d), 149 (\u201caccelerating commercial business\u201d). Again, there is no dispute that\n\n   Palantir saw its commercial pipeline grow and its commercial revenue and customers\n\n   increase during the relevant period. See D.A.720 (Aug. 12, 2021 PR) (commercial\n\n   revenue up 90% Y/Y in 2Q21; commercial customer count up 32%); D.A.729 (Nov. 9,\n\n   2021 PR) (commercial revenue up 103% Y/Y in 3Q21); D.A.154, 160 (May 9, 2022 Tr.)\n\n   (commercial revenue accelerated in the previous five quarters, reaching 54% growth rate\n\n   in 1Q22; US commercial revenue ex SPACs up 65% Y/Y and 9% sequentially Q/Q);\n\n   D.A.1527\u201329 (Annex H). These \u201caccurate recitations of historical successes\u201d are \u201cnot\n\n   actionable.\u201d McDonald, 287 F.3d at 998; see also In re Crocs, 774 F.Supp.2d at 1151\n\n   (that company had \u201cachieved significant growth\u201d was inactionable historical fact).\n\n         Projected Long-term Revenue Growth.              Meanwhile, Plaintiffs\u2019 allegations\n\n\n\n                                             - 30 -\n                                              217\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 47 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   concerning the rate of Palantir\u2019s growth fail because the risks associated with Palantir\u2019s\n\n   projected long-term revenue guidance was repeatedly and emphatically disclosed. See,\n\n   e.g., D.A.752 (Nov. 13, 2020 10-Q) (\u201cthere can be no assurances that revenue will\n\n   continue to grow or do so at current rates, and you should not rely on the revenue of\n\n   any prior quarterly or annual period as an indication of our future performance\u201d; \u201crevenue\n\n   growth rate may decline in future periods\u201d); D.A.821 (Feb. 26, 2021 10-K) (same);\n\n   D.A.366 (Feb. 24, 2022 10-K) (same); D.A.214 (May 12, 2021 Form 10-Q) (\u201cif our\n\n   relationships with our largest customers are impaired or terminated, our revenue could\n\n   decline\u201d); D.A.289 (Aug. 12, 2021 Form 10-Q) (same); D.A.914 (Nov. 9, 2021 Form 10-\n\n   Q); see also D.A.1527\u201329 (Annex H). Disclosed risks cannot ground a securities fraud\n\n   claim. See Noble Asset Mgmt. v. Allos Therapeutics, Inc., 04-cv-1030, 2005 WL 4161977,\n\n   at *12 (D. Colo. Oct. 20, 2005) (positive statements not misleading because company\n\n   disclosed relevant risks and uncertainties).18 As such, Plaintiffs\u2019 allegations fail.\n\n                 2.     Plaintiffs Plead No False Statement Concerning Efficiencies.\n\n           The Complaint next takes aim at several statements about Palantir\u2019s efficiencies.\n\n   \u00b6\u00b6 34, 36, 37, 38-39, 47, 49, 50-52. None is adequately pleaded to be false.\n\n           Plaintiffs challenge accurate statements about the rise in Palantir\u2019s operating\n\n   results, including contribution margins. \u00b6\u00b6 36\u201339. Plaintiffs claim these statements were\n\n   false or misleading because they do not reflect the time and resources required to\n\n\n\n   18   Accord Ashland Inc. v. Morgan Stanley & Co., 652 F.3d 333, 336\u201338 (2d Cir. 2011)\n        (rejecting misrepresentation claim concerning liquidity risks when defendants\n        \u201cexplicitly disclosed\u201d that a successful auction \u201cdoes not mean that an investment\u201d\n        \u201cinvolves no significant liquidity or credit risk\u201d).\n\n\n                                               - 31 -\n                                                218\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 48 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   onboard new clients, including the use of pilots. \u00b6\u00b6 35, 40\u201344. As a threshold matter,\n\n   Plaintiffs do not dispute that Palantir\u2019s contribution margin, a measure of efficiency in\n\n   selling and delivering software, improved from 15% to 55% over the four quarters\n\n   preceding these statements. D.A.97\u201398 (FRS). Unable to challenge the truth of these\n\n   metrics, Plaintiffs claim they were misleading because Defendants knew that they were\n\n   unsustainable. See, e.g., \u00b6\u00b6 40, 44. Yet, Plaintiffs identify no contemporaneous facts to\n\n   support their view that Palantir did not believe that it could sustain improved contribution\n\n   margins. Rather, their argument is based on alleged lower margins after the direct listing.\n\n   \u00b6\u00b6 40, 44. That is impermissible fraud by hindsight. \u00b6 58; Novell, 120 F.3d at 1124.\n\n          Plaintiffs next challenge Palantir\u2019s statements that its platform Apollo gave it \u201cSaaS\n\n   like economics.\u201d \u00b6 34. Plaintiffs point to \u201ca lengthy, expensive, and highly-customized\n\n   process to secure client contracts and build out software solutions\u201d for Gotham and\n\n   Foundry. \u00b6 35. Plaintiffs conflate two separate things. Palantir\u2019s SaaS-related statement\n\n   described its Apollo platform, which permitted Palantir to deploy its other products in\n\n   various environments\u2014a Humvee, a submarine, or a drone\u2014and which had SaaS like\n\n   economics. See D.A.970\u2013979 (Investor Day Tr.). The statement did not purport to\n\n   address Gotham and Foundry, which Palantir did customize for customers, as Palantir\n\n   disclosed.   D.A.111 (FRS) (\u201c[Gotham and Foundry are] comprised of user-facing\n\n   applications that are targeted to the specific industries and sectors in which they are\n\n   used.\u201d); see also \u00b6 35 (citing D.A.960\u2013969 (FedScoop Article)).\n\n          Plaintiffs also challenge the statements that Palantir did not do \u201ccustom\n\n   development work\u201d or \u201cbuil[d] bespoke applications,\u201d because Foundry was \u201ca set of\n\n\n\n                                              - 32 -\n                                               219\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 49 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   digital infrastructure tools which engineers use to build a bespoke product.\u201d \u00b6 34. Again,\n\n   Palantir disclosed all of this.   D.A.38\u201339, 111 (FRS).     It thus could not have been\n\n   surprising to a reasonable investor that business-to-business sales involved some user-\n\n   facing modulation of Palantir\u2019s applications.\n\n          Finally, Plaintiffs challenge Palantir\u2019s statement that its software can be \u201cready in\n\n   days\u201d or \u201cwithin hours,\u201d or can be deployed with a \u201cfew clicks.\u201d See \u00b6\u00b6 47, 49, 50-52.\n\n   Plaintiffs claim these statements were false because Palantir\u2019s process was \u201clengthy,\n\n   time-consuming, and costly.\u201d \u00b6 47. But Plaintiffs advance no well pleaded facts to support\n\n   these ipse dixit assertions, which cannot support a securities fraud claim. Hampton v.\n\n   Root9B Techs., Inc., 15-cv-02152, 2016 WL 9735744, at *3 (D. Colo. Sept. 21, 2016)\n\n   (falsity must be pleaded with particularity), aff\u2019d, 897 F.3d 1291 (10th Cir. 2018).\n\n   Moreover, that Palantir\u2019s products could be \u201cready in days\u201d did not mean that some clients\n\n   would not demand substantial customization. This was precisely why Palantir disclosed\n\n   both its intensive sales and deployment process to investors. Supra p. 6.\n\n          C.     The Complaint Fails to Plead Falsity as to Any Remaining Statement\n                 in the FRS.\n          Plaintiffs\u2019 remaining challenges under Section 11 are equally meritless. To start,\n\n   Plaintiffs predicate their Securities Act claims on the same \u201cscheme\u201d as their Exchange\n\n   Act claims. Specifically, Plaintiffs allege: (i) Defendants \u201cplanned\u201d the \u201cSPAC Scheme\u201d\n\n   \u201cat the time of the Offering, as demonstrated by the Registration Statement,\u201d and \u201cfail[ed]\n\n   to disclose\u201d the investments\u2019 \u201ctrue nature\u201d; (ii) the FRS \u201csought to portray Palantir as a\n\n   highly-efficient company even though Defendants \u201chad no good faith basis to believe, and\n\n   did not actually believe\u201d the statements in the FRS; and (iii) the statements in the FRS\n\n\n                                              - 33 -\n                                               220\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 50 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   \u201cwere all made in connection with (and to solicit interest in) the Offering,\u201d so Defendants\n\n   could \u201cunlock [their] awards.\u201d \u00b6\u00b6 38, 44, 46, 61-62, 188. None suffices.\n\n          The Securities Act section challenges four of the same statements as the\n\n   Exchange Act section, and even expressly alleges fraud. \u00b6\u00b6 219, 221, 223, 225; see \u00b6\u00b6\n\n   222 (\u201cDefendants were aware\u201d of falsity and \u201cdid not believe\u201d their statements); 224\n\n   (\u201cartificially inflating\u201d metrics); 230 (Defendants \u201caware of\u201d contradictory facts). Because\n\n   Plaintiffs\u2019 theory of falsity is the same under both statutes, they must satisfy Rule 9(b)\u2019s\n\n   heightened pleading requirement. Rubke, 551 F.3d at 1161. Plaintiffs cannot avoid doing\n\n   so by disclaiming fraud. \u00b6\u00b6 246, 256; Rigel, 697 F.3d at 885.\n\n          Plaintiffs cannot satisfy the exacting requirements of Rule 9(b) (or even Rule 8(a))\n\n   and thus fail to plead falsity of any statement in the FRS. The Challenged Statements in\n\n   \u00b6\u00b6 219, 221, 223, and 225 fail for the same reasons as their counterparts in \u00b6\u00b6 38, 39,\n\n   61, and 128. Supra III.A, B. As to the rest, Plaintiffs fail to show that they are actionable:\n\n      \uf0b7   The \u201cestimate\u201d of then-current TAM in \u00b6 226 is a statement of opinion and\n          corporate optimism, and thus cannot be rendered false by future deceleration, as\n          alleged, \u00b6 230. See MHC Mut. Conversion Fund, 761 F.3d at 1119\u201321\n          (statements about prospects are inactionable opinions); Novell, 120 F.3d at 1121\n          (\u201ccompelling set of opportunities\u201d is inactionable corporate optimism). Palantir also\n          warned TAM was not a guarantee and may change. Supra p.6.\n      \uf0b7   The statements in \u00b6\u00b6 220, 227\u201328 are forward-looking, and cannot be rendered\n          false by future events. See \u00b6 230 (alleging statements false because revenue\n          growth rates \u201cset to decelerate\u201d in next quarter). Plaintiffs omit from \u00b6 227 the\n          words \u201cWe are working towards becoming,\u201d which also appear in \u00b6 228 and which\n          confirm that they are forward-looking. They also omit from \u00b6\u00b6 220 and 228 the\n          lead-in: \u201cWe are pursuing a number of strategies . . .,\u201d which confirms the same.\n      \uf0b7   The statement in \u00b6 229 about Palantir\u2019s 3Q20 revenue growth is an inactionable\n          recitation of historical success. See McDonald, 287 F.3d at 998.\n          Finally, the Complaint\u2019s challenge to Palantir\u2019s plan to increase its reach with\n\n\n\n                                               - 34 -\n                                                221\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 51 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   existing customers and \u201cdesign[ing]\u201d its platform to easily accommodate new users,\n\n   workflows, and use cases, fails. \u00b6 220. Plaintiffs proffer nothing that shows Palantir was\n\n   not planning to increase its reach or that its platforms were not \u201cdesigned\u201d as stated. \u00b6122.\n\n   Thus, Plaintiffs\u2019 allegations should be dismissed.\n\n   IV.       FORWARD-LOOKING STATEMENTS ARE INACTIONABLE.\n\n             Forward-looking statements, such as \u201cprojections of revenues, expenditures, and\n\n   income; statements of management\u2019s plans and objectives for future operations;\n\n   statements of future economic performance,\u201d are insulated from liability under the\n\n   PSLRA\u2019s safe harbor (15 U.S.C. \u00a7 78u-5). In re Molycorp, Inc. Sec. Litig., 12-cv-00292,\n\n   2015 WL 1540523, at *25 (D. Colo. Mar. 31, 2015). They are separately protected by the\n\n   judicially created \u201cbespeaks caution doctrine.\u201d Novell, 120 F.3d at 1120; Schaffer v.\n\n   Evolving Sys., Inc., 29 F.Supp.2d 1213, 1221 (D. Colo. 1998). Such statements are\n\n   inactionable if they are \u201caccompanied by meaningful cautionary statements\u201d or the plaintiff\n\n   fails to prove that the statement was made with \u201cactual knowledge\u201d that it was false and\n\n   misleading. \u00a7 78u-5I(1)(A)(i); In re Williams Sec. Litig., 339 F.Supp.2d 1206, 1220 (N.D.\n\n   Okla. 2003). Many Challenged Statements, including those about Palantir\u2019s long-term\n\n   revenue guidance, are textbook inactionable forward-looking statements. 19 For example:\n\n         \uf0b7   Revenue Projections and Long-Term Guidance: \u00b6\u00b6 157\u201359 (expecting \u201c30%\u201d\n             \u201crevenue growth\u201d); 96 (expecting \u201c40% revenue growth\u201d for 2021).\n         \uf0b7   Customer Pipeline: \u00b6\u00b6 37, 39, 221 (predicting customers will move into Scale\n             phase and increased margins); 120, 141, 150, 152 (predicting revenue growth).\n         \uf0b7   Strategy: \u00b6\u00b6 65 (Sarcos \u201cwill leverage Foundry\u201d); 66 (Lilium and Sarcos are \u201cgoing\u201d\n\n   19    A list of inactionable forward-looking Challenged Statements is at D.A.1432\u201343\n         (Annex A).\n\n\n                                                - 35 -\n                                                 222\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 52 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n            to build around Foundry from \u201cday 0\u201d).\n        \uf0b7   Operational Efficiencies: \u00b6\u00b6 36 (contribution margin increase due to \u201cgetting\n            much more efficient\u201d); 52 (predicting Palantir will reach a \u201cbroad set of customers\u201d).\n            Here, the forward-looking statements are inactionable for both reasons. First, they\n\n   were accompanied by meaningful cautionary language warning of the precise risks that\n\n   Plaintiffs claim occurred. Palantir\u2019s warnings were \u201chighly specific, very factual, and\n\n   directly address[ed] the predictive statements [at issue],\u201d so as to \u201cnullify any potentially\n\n   misleading effect.\u201d20 Novell, 120 F.3d at 1120\u201321; In re Gold Res. Corp. Sec. Litig., 957\n\n   F.Supp.2d 1284, 1297 (D. Colo. 2013) (\u201c[W]hen an investor has been warned of risks of\n\n   a significance similar to that actually realized, she is sufficiently on notice of the danger\n\n   of the investment\u201d), aff\u2019d, 776 F.3d 1103 (10th Cir. 2015).\n\n            Indeed, Palantir\u2019s disclosures cautioned about the uncertainty of its revenue\n\n   growth and earnings guidance. See, e.g., D.A.1476\u20131516 (Annex E) (\u201cno assurances\n\n   that revenue will continue to grow\u201d; \u201cdownturns in sales . . . may not be immediately\n\n   reflected\u201d; results \u201cmay fluctuate\u201d due to \u201cintensive nature of our sales efforts\u201d). Similarly,\n\n   Palantir disclosed the nature of its strategic investment program and its attendant risks.\n\n   See, e.g., D.A.305 (Aug. 12, 2021 10-Q) (investments could lead to \u201ca partial or complete\n\n   loss of invested capital\u201d); D.A.388 (Feb. 24, 2022 10-K) (\u201ccompanies may be engaged in\n\n   businesses that involve novel and unproven technologies, products, and services\u201d and\n\n   \u201cmay be unable to perform their obligations under any commercial contracts\u201d). Palantir\n\n   further disclosed the complexities associated with its software sales, customer base, and\n\n\n   20   A non-exhaustive list of Palantir\u2019s cautionary statements, which accompanied the\n        Challenged Statements, is at D.A.1476\u20131516 (Annex E).\n\n\n                                                - 36 -\n                                                 223\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 53 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   operational efficiencies. See supra pp.31\u201333; see also, e.g., D.A.819 (Feb. 26, 2021 10-\n\n   K) (\u201csales cycle is often long and unpredictable\u201d); Lorusso v. Boulder Brands, 15-cv-\n\n   00679, 2017 WL 4365180, at *11 (D. Colo. Mar. 1, 2017) (defendants sufficiently\n\n   disclosed risks related to company\u2019s ability to implement growth strategy and adverse\n\n   developments with respect to sale of product), R&R adopted, 2017 WL 1148689, at *3.21\n\n           Second, Plaintiffs rely on conclusory allegations that Defendants knew, when the\n\n   SPAC transactions were entered, that SPACs would fail and Palantir would not receive a\n\n   \u201csubstantial\u201d portion of SPAC-related revenue. \u00b6\u00b6 84, 98, 115. But Plaintiffs fail to plead\n\n   any facts showing that any Defendants actually had this \u201cknowledge;\u201d and their\n\n   speculation to the contrary does not suffice. \u00b6\u00b6 59, 68, \u00a7 78u-5I(1)(B); Spirit, 79 F.4th at\n\n   1217; Shafer v. Lightning eMotors, Inc., 21-cv-02774, 2024 WL 691458, at *1, (D. Colo.\n\n   Feb. 20, 2024), R&R adopted, 2024 WL 1509166 (D. Colo. Mar. 26, 2024); Gold Res.,\n\n   957 F.Supp.2d at 1298 (\u201cconclusory allegations\u201d insufficient to plead \u201cactual knowledge\u201d).\n\n   Accordingly, these allegations fail.\n\n   V.      MANY CHALLENGED STATEMENTS ARE INACTIONABLE OPINIONS OR\n           CORPORATE OPTIMISM.\n\n           Several Challenged Statements are inactionable opinion. See, e.g., \u00b6\u00b6 39 (\u201cWe\n\n\n   21   See Okla. Firefighters Pension & Ret. Sys. v. Xerox Corp., 300 F.Supp.3d 551, 574\n        (S.D.N.Y. 2018) (statements concerning a new venture and how it \u201cwould benefit the\n        company in the future\u201d shielded by safe harbor because disclosures warned of\n        potential \u201ccost challenges\u201d and difficulties in implementing new systems), aff\u2019d sub\n        nom. Ark. Pub. Emps. Ret. Sys. v. Xerox Corp., 771 F. App\u2019x 51 (2d Cir. 2019);\n        Steamfitters Loc. 449 Pension Plan v. Molina Healthcare, Inc., 18-cv-3579, 2018 WL\n        6787349, at *2 (C.D. Cal. Dec. 13, 2018) (statements concerning \u201cscalability\u201d of\n        company\u2019s infrastructure, expected \u201cadministrative cost leverage\u201d from new\n        acquisitions, and associated investments shielded by safe harbor because\n        disclosures warned of risks that company faced \u201cas it moved into\u201d a new market).\n\n\n                                              - 37 -\n                                               224\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 54 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   believe that all of our customers will move into the Scale phase over the long term\u201d), 83\n\n   (\u201cThese are companies that we think we will be working with for a very long time.\u201d); 152\n\n   (\u201cI believe we will double it again this year.\u201d).22 Courts routinely hold such statements to\n\n   be non-actionable. See MHC Mut. Conversion Fund, 761 F.3d at 1119\u201321 (statements\n\n   about prospects of company\u2019s investments were inactionable opinions) (Gorsuch, J.).\n\n           To plead falsity based on opinion statements, it is insufficient to show that\n\n   defendants\u2019 \u201cbelief turned out to be wrong.\u201d Omnicare, Inc. v. Laborers Dist. Council\n\n   Const. Indus. Pension Fund, 575 U.S. 175, 186 (2015). Rather, a plaintiff must plead\n\n   particularized facts establishing that defendants \u201cinaccurately represent[ed]\u201d their\n\n   subjective \u201cbeliefs concerning then-present factual conditions.\u201d Hampton, 897 F.3d at\n\n   1299; In re Sanofi Sec. Litig., 87 F.Supp.3d 510, 534 (S.D.N.Y. 2015) (for opinion\n\n   statements, \u201cthe falsity and scienter requirements are essentially identical\u201d). Plaintiffs\n\n   make no such showing. Indeed, Plaintiffs fail to plausibly allege that \u201c(i) the speaker did\n\n   not hold the belief []he professed, (ii) any supporting fact[s] []he supplied with h[is] opinion\n\n   were untrue, or (iii) the speaker omitted facts whose omission makes the statement\n\n   misleading to a reasonable investor.\u201d In re Citigroup Sec. Litig., 20-cv-9132, 2023 WL\n\n   2632258, at *12 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 24, 2023) (citing Omnicare, 575 U.S. at 186).\n\n           Moreover, many of the Challenged Statements are inactionable statements of\n\n   corporate optimism.       See, e.g., \u00b6\u00b6 36 (\u201cmuch more efficient\u201d); 131 (continuing\n\n   \u201cmomentum\u201d); 132 (\u201crapid growth\u201d); 140 (\u201ctailwind\u201d); 141 (\u201cbigger and bigger\u201d); 149\n\n\n\n   22   A list of Challenged Statements that are inactionable opinion is at D.A.1444\u201359\n        (Annex B).\n\n\n                                                - 38 -\n                                                 225\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 55 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   (\u201ccutting-edge\u201d product \u201cinnovation\u201d driving \u201cexceptional results\u201d). 23 As the Tenth Circuit\n\n   explained: \u201c[v]ague, optimistic statements\u201d are \u201cnot actionable because reasonable\n\n   investors do not rely on them in making investment decisions.\u201d 24 Novell, 120 F.3d at 1119.\n\n   Defendants are \u201cnot required to take a gloomy, fearful, or defeatist view\u201d of their business\n\n   model. Rombach, 355 F.3d at 174. Therefore, Plaintiffs\u2019 allegations fall flat.\n\n   VI.      PLAINTIFFS FAIL ADEQUATELY TO PLEAD SCHEME LIABILITY.\n\n            Unable to make a disclosure claim, Plaintiffs try for \u201cscheme\u201d liability. To do so,\n\n   Plaintiffs must plead that Defendants participated \u201cin an illegitimate, sham or inherently\n\n   deceptive transaction\u201d with \u201cthe purpose and effect of creating a false appearance.\u201d SEC\n\n   v. St. Anselm Expl. Co., 936 F.Supp.2d 1281, 1299 (D. Colo. 2013). The conduct \u201cmust\n\n   be inherently deceptive\u201d and undertaken with scienter. Id. at 1298\u201399. Thus, to the extent\n\n   that Plaintiffs fail to plead scienter, supra pp. 13\u201321, their scheme claim also fails.\n\n            Plaintiffs suggest that Defendants engaged in a scheme by making the SPAC\n\n   investments and/or changing the way Palantir disclosed certain non-GAAP metrics. They\n\n   fail, however, to allege that either was an \u201cillegitimate\u201d or an \u201cinherently deceptive\u201d act\n\n\n\n\n   23    A list of Challenged Statements with inactionable corporate optimism is at D.A.1460\u2013\n         70 (Annex C).\n   24    Examples of inactionable statements of corporate optimism include: Guangyi Xu v.\n         ChinaCache Int\u2019l Holdings Ltd., 15-cv-07952, 2017 WL 114401, at *9 (C.D. Cal. Jan.\n         9, 2017) (\u201cmore efficient\u201d); Anderson, 105 F.Supp.3d at 1256\u201357 (\u201cgrowing tailwinds\u201d),\n         aff\u2019d, 827 F.3d 1229 (10th Cir. 2016); In re Airgate PCS, Inc. Sec. Litig., 389 F.Supp.2d\n         1360, 1378\u201379 (N.D. Ga. 2005) (\u201cadditional operating efficiencies\u201d; \u201cgrowth potential\u201d);\n         In re Advanta Corp. Sec. Litig., 180 F.3d 525, 529 (3d Cir. 1999) (\u201cmaintain[ing]\u201d\n         growth and \u201caccelerat[ing]\u201d expansion); Novell, 120 F.3d at 1121 (\u201ccompelling set of\n         opportunities\u201d; \u201cmoving rapidly\u201d).\n\n\n                                                - 39 -\n                                                 226\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 56 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   undertaken with the \u201cpurpose and effect\u201d of defrauding investors.25\n\n           First, Plaintiffs suggest that Defendants initiated \u201csham transactions\u201d and signed\n\n   \u201cmultiyear, multimillion-dollar contracts\u201d with SPACs to \u201cfoster an illusion of improved\n\n   revenue and margin growth.\u201d \u00b6 58. This claim fails because it is based on the Challenged\n\n   Statements. \u00b6\u00b6 34 n.8; 56\u2013122. As the Supreme Court made clear, claims of scheme\n\n   liability cannot be premised on misstatements alone. Lorenzo v. SEC, 587 U.S. 71, 78\n\n   (2019). Otherwise, there would be no difference between Rule 10b-5(b) misstatement\n\n   liability and Rule 10b-5(a) and (c) scheme liability. Id. at 82\u201384; accord Shafer, 2024 WL\n\n   1509166, *1.       Moreover, \u201cbolster[ing] the allegedly false impression created by\n\n   defendants\u2019 misrepresentations . . . that form the basis of the 10b-5(b)\u201d claim is\n\n   impermissible \u201clegal double dipping.\u201d St. Anselm, 936 F.Supp.2d at 1298\u201399 (\u201cliability\n\n   does not arise\u201d by \u201crepackaging a fraudulent misrepresentation a \u2018scheme to defraud\u2019\u201d).\n\n           Plaintiffs suggest that SPAC investments were inherently deceptive because they\n\n   \u201ccreate[d] the appearance of continued robust high-margin growth.\u201d \u00b6 32. That allegation\n\n   fails for several reasons. Labeling an investment that does not pan out as deceptive is\n\n   merely fraud by hindsight. Novell, 120 F.3d at 1124. That these investments were not\n\n   as successful as expected does not mean that the transactions were entered into for an\n\n   inherently deceptive purpose.       Compare St. Anselm, 936 F. Supp. 2d at 1298\u201399\n\n   25   Plaintiffs challenge the direct listing under scheme liability but going public via this\n        SEC-approved method is hardly \u201cinherently deceptive.\u201d \u00b6\u00b6 29, 32. Plaintiffs also do\n        not allege how taking Palantir public in 2020 motivated Defendants to mislead\n        investors in 2021 and 2022, which is when the SPAC investments and metric changes\n        occurred. Plaintiffs need to allege\u2014with particularity\u2014facts that show Palantir\n        planned the \u201cscheme\u201d prior to going public. The Complaint is devoid of any such\n        allegations.\n\n\n                                               - 40 -\n                                                227\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 57 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   (\u201cnothing inherently deceptive\u201d about investing in \u201cpromising opportunities that seemed\n\n   likely to yield enormous returns\u201d that failed to do so); with SEC v. GPL Ventures LLC, 21-\n\n   cv-6814, 2022 WL 158885, *10 (S.D.N.Y. 2022) (scheme liability adequately pleaded\n\n   where defendants \u201cwere the puppet masters of a scheme to launder their investments for\n\n   profit\u201d); and SEC v. Simpson Capital Mgmt., Inc., 586 F. Supp. 2d 196, 205 (S.D.N.Y.\n\n   2008) (allowing scheme claim where the alleged scheme was to \u201clate trade\u201d mutual funds,\n\n   which is \u201citself illegal\u201d).   Plaintiffs\u2019 allegations that Palantir engaged in roundtrip\n\n   transactions, likewise, do not satisfy the requisite pleading standard. See SEC v. Kelly,\n\n   817 F.Supp.2d 340, 344 (S.D.N.Y. 2011) (\u201cnothing inherently deceptive\u201d with defendant\n\n   paying money to a counterparty and structuring the transaction so that the \u201ccounterparty\n\n   purchases advertising\u201d).      Plaintiffs must plead facts showing that Palantir\u2019s SPAC\n\n   investments were inherently deceptive when made. They have not.\n\n          Second, Plaintiffs allege that Defendants failed to report negative trends by\n\n   \u201caltering Palantir\u2019s reporting of key metrics\u201d and that this practice demonstrates efforts \u201cin\n\n   furtherance of their scheme.\u201d \u00b6\u00b6 3, 161. However, to survive dismissal, plaintiffs must\n\n   allege \u201cconduct beyond\u201d misstatements. The full extent of Plaintiffs\u2019 argument is that\n\n   these \u201cdisclosures were critical\u201d for \u201cinvestors [to] gauge\u201d the Company\u2019s performance\n\n   and Defendants misrepresented performance by \u201cconceal[ing] this information from the\n\n   market.\u201d \u00b6\u00b6 166\u201367. As such, Plaintiffs do not allege fraudulent conduct beyond the\n\n   statements themselves and so this claim also fails. See supra pp. 23\u201333, 35\u201339.\n\n          Moreover, Plaintiffs plead no facts that plausibly allege changes to these non-\n\n   GAAP metrics were motivated by fraud. Nor can they\u2014the changes at issue are a result\n\n\n\n                                               - 41 -\n                                                228\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 58 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   of Palantir\u2019s evolving business needs, and so, entirely appropriate. 26 See In re SolarCity\n\n   Corp. Sec. Litig., 274 F.Supp.3d 972, 1002 (N.D. Cal. 2017) (\u201c[t]here are many potential\n\n   reasons\u201d to \u201ccease to report a metric\u201d that may \u201chave no relation to the prior falsity of that\n\n   metric\u201d); Ironworkers Local 580\u2013Joint Funds v. Linn Energy, LLC, 29 F.Supp.3d 400, 426\n\n   (S.D.N.Y. 2014) (\u201cPlaintiff\u2019s effort to transform [a] business decision [to change the way\n\n   defendant calculated certain metrics] into some sort of admission that statements made\n\n   in prior reporting periods were false and materially misleading is entirely misguided.\u201d).\n\n            Finally, Plaintiffs\u2019 metrics allegations mischaracterize Palantir\u2019s disclosures:\n\n        \uf0b7   Customers. Plaintiffs allege that Palantir changed their definition of customer to\n            \u201cartificially inflate[]\u201d the customer count. \u00b6 162. But the Company explained this\n            change to the market when it was made, shortly after they went public\u2014\u201c[w]e have\n            updated our definition of a customer to be an organization from which we have\n            recognized revenue during the trailing twelve month period to provide more\n            meaningful period over period comparisons\u201d\u2014and maintained this definition of\n            \u201ccustomer\u201d ever since. D.A.206 (May 12, 2021 10-Q); Compare D.A.745 (Nov. 13,\n            2020 10-Q) (\u201cWe define a customer as an organization from which we have\n            recognized revenue in a reporting period.\u201d) with D.A.275 (Aug. 12, 2021 10-Q);\n            D.A.897 (Nov. 9, 2021 10-Q); D.A.425 (Feb. 24, 2022 10-K); D.A.493 (May 9, 2022\n            10-Q); D.A.983 (Aug. 8, 2022 10-Q).\n        \uf0b7   ACD. Plaintiffs allege that Defendants \u201cfailed to disclose [ACD] with 3Q21, 1Q22,\n            or 2Q22 earnings\u201d to \u201cobscure the deterioration in Palantir\u2019s prospects.\u201d \u00b6 163.\n            But Plaintiffs overlook that Palantir regularly disclosed ACD in its annual reports.\n            Compare D.A.881 (Feb. 26, 2021 10-K), and D.A.426 (Feb. 24, 2022 10-K), with\n            D.A.206 (May 2021 10-Q). Thus, the FY21 10-K provided ACD directly between\n            the only two challenged announcements in the Class Period, and in so doing\n            disclosed the 0.1-year drop that Plaintiffs allege was \u201cobscure[d].\u201d \u00b6 163. The\n\n   26   Palantir included certain metrics in the FRS because it was an emerging-growth\n        company, but figures that had initially been meaningful were no longer relevant in later\n        quarters as the Company grew. For example, once Palantir was growing by 10+ new\n        customers in a quarter, ARPC was less meaningful. Compare D.A.745 (Nov. 13, 2020\n        10-Q) (132 customers), and D.A.880 (Feb. 26, 2021 10-K) (139), with D.A.493 (May\n        9, 2022 10-Q) (277); D.A.983 (Aug. 8, 2022 10-Q) (304). Regardless, Palantir\n        continued to report Top 20 revenue. E.g., D.A.745 (Nov. 13, 2020 10-Q); D.A.359,\n        425 (Feb. 24, 2022 10-K); D.A.493 (May 9, 2022 10-Q); D.A.983 (Aug. 8, 2022 10-Q).\n\n\n                                                - 42 -\n                                                 229\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 59 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n            2Q22 earnings occurred after the Class Period concluded.\n        \uf0b7   Acquire, Scale, and Expand. Palantir reported these metrics until 1Q22.\n            Plaintiffs allege that by not providing the FY22 metric, Palantir \u201cobscure[d]\u201d its\n            prospects with non-SPAC customers. \u00b6\u00b6 167\u201368. That change cannot be part of\n            any supposed \u201cscheme,\u201d because Palantir implemented it in the same quarter that\n            the supposed \u201cSPAC scheme\u201d ended. \u00b6 167. As such, the lack of these metrics\n            could not obscure the performance of either SPAC or non-SPAC customers. Nor\n            do Plaintiffs explain how \u201crevenue or contribution margins associated with [the\n            Acquire, Expand, or Scale] cohort[s] of new customers acquired in 2021\u201d showed\n            \u201cdiminishing business prospects\u201d for non-SPAC customers.\u201d \u00b6 168. In fact,\n            Plaintiffs are wrong that the metric would not include SPAC customers. This metric\n            defines cohorts of specific customers and then tracks each cohort\u2019s progress for\n            two years. See, e.g., D.A.427 (Feb. 24, 2022 10-K) (comparing metrics for a set\n            of contracts defined in 2020 to the same set in 2021).\n        \uf0b7   TRDV. Plaintiffs allege that \u201cthe 1Q21, 2Q21, and 3Q21 Forms 10-Q each\n            concealed current quarterly TRDV information\u201d and Defendants \u201cconcealed the\n            split between government and commercial [TRDV] in both 1Q21 and 1Q22.\u201d \u00b6\u00b6\n            115, 170. This misconstrues Palantir\u2019s reporting. Palantir disclosed the TRDV\n            reported in the previous 10-K in its Form 10-Qs, beginning with its first 10-K in\n            2021. 27 Palantir additionally disclosed quarterly TRDV in all 1Q, 2Q, and 3Q\n            earnings calls.28 That Palantir did not disclose the TRDV split the way Plaintiffs\n            would have preferred is not actionable.\n        \uf0b7   ARPC. Plaintiffs allege that Defendants moved from reporting ARPC to average\n            revenue of Palantir\u2019s top twenty customers in 1Q22 to \u201cconceal\u201d that \u201cPalantir\u2019s\n            newest customers were not scaling up in size or profitability.\u201d \u00b6 171. But Plaintiffs\n            admit that Palantir acknowledged and disclosed the reasons for changes in the\n            reported ARPC metric. Id. Palantir also continued to report both revenue and their\n            total numbers of customers\u2014making ARPC a straightforward equation. See,\n            D.A.488\u201389, 493 (May 9, 2022 10-Q); D.A.983, 986 (Aug. 8, 2022 10-Q). 29\n            Thus, Plaintiffs fail to allege particularized facts to ground a scheme liability claim.\n\n\n\n\n   27   See, e.g., D.A.823, 883 (Feb. 26, 2021 10-K); D.A.215 (May 12, 2021 10-Q); D.A.207\n        (Aug. 12, 2021 10-Q); D.A.913 (Nov. 9, 2021 10-Q).\n   28   D.A.185 (May 11, 2021 Tr.); D.A.344 (Aug. 12, 2021 Tr.); D.A.711 (Nov. 9, 2021 Tr.).\n   29   See also Werner, 267 F.3d at 299; Acme Propane, Inc. v. Tenexco, Inc., 844 F.2d\n        1317, 1323 (7th Cir. 1988) (no fraud where defendant disclosed the relevant numbers\n        and the necessary calculation for the ratio at issue).\n\n\n                                                 - 43 -\n                                                  230\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 60 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n   VII.   PLAINTIFFS FAIL ADEQUATELY TO PLEAD LOSS CAUSATION.\n\n          Because Plaintiffs attempt to plead loss causation through a \u201ccorrective\u201d disclosure\n\n   theory, they must show that \u201cthe truth\u201d about the allegedly false statements \u201cbecame\n\n   known\u201d upon issuance of those disclosures. \u00b6\u00b6 173\u201374; Dura Pharm., Inc. v. Broudo,\n\n   544 U.S. 336, 347 (2005). That Palantir\u2019s earnings disappointed is not sufficient. Loos\n\n   v. Immersion Corp., 762 F.3d 880, 887\u201388 (9th Cir. 2014). Rather, Plaintiffs must show\n\n   that the \u201ccorrective\u201d disclosures revealed \u201cthe wrongfully concealed information.\u201d In re\n\n   Williams Sec. Litig., 558 F.3d 1130, 1138 (10th Cir. 2009). Plaintiffs fail to do so.\n\n          The Complaint alleges four \u201closs events\u201d\u2014each a regularly scheduled earnings\n\n   release through which Palantir reported quarterly or annual results. Plaintiffs do not and\n\n   cannot show that any Challenged Statement was revealed to be false in these releases:\n\n      \uf0b7   On November 9, 2021, Palantir\u2019s 3Q21 earnings allegedly \u201crevealed a significant\n          deceleration\u201d in revenue growth and declining government metrics. \u00b6 175.\n      \uf0b7   On February 17, 2022, Palantir\u2019s FY21 release allegedly \u201crevealed\u201d that the\n          government sector continued to decelerate along with declining contribution\n          margins, flat TRDV, and certain guidance below consensus. \u00b6 178.\n      \uf0b7   On May 9, 2022, Palantir\u2019s 1Q22 earnings allegedly \u201crevealed\u201d that Palantir\n          achieved \u201conly\u201d 25% growth, \u201csubstantially below\u201d the 30% long-term revenue\n          target, certain guidance below expectations, a decline in $300 million in total deal\n          value, and that it had \u201cwound\u201d the SPAC investment program down. \u00b6 181.\n      \uf0b7   On August 8, 2022, Palantir\u2019s 2Q22 earnings allegedly revealed that it had\n          terminated several SPAC contracts, that its deal value remained \u201cflat,\u201d and that it\n          anticipated \u201conly\u201d 23% annual revenue growth, \u201cwell below\u201d the 30% target. \u00b6 184.\n          Each fails to plead loss causation for several reasons. First, the releases did not\n\n   correct any prior untruth or reveal any fraud. They did not reveal, for example, that\n\n   reported revenue was inaccurate, that Palantir no longer aimed for 30% growth, or that it\n\n   did not believe that SPAC investments represented opportunities when they were made.\n\n\n\n                                              - 44 -\n                                               231\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 61 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n           Second, \u201closs causation is not pled upon allegations of drops in stock price\n\n   following an announcement of bad news that does not disclose the fraud.\u201d Prissert v.\n\n   EMCORE Corp., 894 F.Supp.2d 1361, 1376 (D.N.M. 2012).                    Therefore, Plaintiffs\u2019\n\n   allegations do not suffice. See Lanigan Grp., Inc. v. Li-Cycle Holdings Corp., 22-cv-0222,\n\n   2023 WL 6541884, at *9 (E.D.N.Y. Oct. 6, 2023).\n\n           Finally, Plaintiffs point to analyst reports issued after these earnings releases, as\n\n   is typical for public companies, but they do not show how anything in the reports rendered\n\n   any prior statement false. \u00b6\u00b6 176, 179, 182, 185; see Curry v. Yelp Inc., 875 F.3d 1219,\n\n   1228 (9th Cir. 2017) (affirming dismissal of claim that pointed to \u201canalyst reports\u201d as basis\n\n   for loss causation \u201cwithout providing additional facts that demonstrate fraud\u201d).\n\n           Accordingly, Plaintiffs fail to plead facts sufficient to show loss causation.\n\n   VIII.   PLAINTIFFS FAIL TO STATE A CLAIM UNDER SECTION 20A.\n\n           Because no separate violation of the securities laws was adequately pleaded, the\n\n   Section 20A insider trading claim (like the Section 20(a) and 15 control person claims)\n\n   fails. Molycorp, 2015 WL 1540523, at *30 (requiring \u201cseparate violation\u201d). 30\n\n                                          CONCLUSION\n\n           For the foregoing reasons, the Complaint should be dismissed with prejudice.\n\n                                            Respectfully submitted,\n\n                                            Sam D. Starritt\n\n   30   The 20A claim also fails as Plaintiffs do not allege what MNPI Defendants possessed\n        and when, and for lack of contemporaneity. See Croker v. Carrier Access Corp., 05-\n        cv-01011, 2006 WL 2035366, at *13 (D. Colo. July 18, 2006); In re AST Rsch. Sec.\n        Litig., 887 F.Supp.231, 234 (C.D. Cal. 1995) (same-day trades required); Copland v.\n        Grumet, 88 F.Supp.2d 326, 338 (D.N.J. 1999) (two days insufficient); D.A.1471\u201375\n        (Annex D).\n\n\n                                                - 45 -\n                                                 232\n\fCase No. 1:22-cv-02384-GPG-SBP Document 102 filed 07/25/24 USDC Colorado pg 62 of\n                                      63\n\n\n\n\n                                   Starritt Legal, LLC\n                                   222 North 7th Street, Suite A-1\n                                   Grand Junction, Colorado 81501\n                                   Telephone: (970) 335-8831\n                                   email: sam@starrittlegal.com\n\n                                   /s/ David Y. Livshiz\n                                   David Y. Livshiz\n                                   Nicholas A. Caselli\n                                   FRESHFIELDS BRUCKHAUS DERINGER\n                                   US LLP\n                                   3 World Trade Center\n                                   175 Greenwich Street\n                                   New York, NY 10007\n                                   (212) 277-4000\n                                   david.livshiz@freshfields.com\n                                   nicholas.caselli@freshfields.com\n\n                                   Boris Feldman\n                                   FRESHFIELDS BRUCKHAUS DERINGER\n                                   US LLP\n                                   855 Main Street\n                                   Redwood City, CA 94063\n                                   (650) 618-9250\n                                   boris.feldman@freshfields.com\n\n                                   Attorneys for Defendants Palantir Technologies\n                                   Inc., Alexander C. Karp, David Glazer, Shyam\n                                   Sankar, Kevin Kawasaki, Peter Thiel, Stephen\n                                   Cohen, Alexandra Schiff, Alexander Moore, and\n                                   Spencer Rascoff\n\n\n\n\n                                      - 46 -\n                                       233\n\f","ocr_status":1,"date_upload":"2026-02-17T09:48:29.099355-08:00","document_number":"23","attachment_number":1,"pacer_doc_id":"010011275481","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Appellants' Appendix Vol. 1","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/468973741/","id":468973741,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/23/2/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:56.502685-08:00","date_modified":"2026-02-17T09:47:56.502702-08:00","sha1":"","page_count":226,"file_size":5337619,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"23","attachment_number":2,"pacer_doc_id":"010011275482","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Appellants' Appendix Vol. 2","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/468973742/","id":468973742,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/23/3/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:56.519296-08:00","date_modified":"2026-02-17T09:47:56.519307-08:00","sha1":"","page_count":230,"file_size":8329025,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"23","attachment_number":3,"pacer_doc_id":"010011275483","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Appellants' Appendix Vol. 3","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/468973743/","id":468973743,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/23/4/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:56.534825-08:00","date_modified":"2026-02-17T09:47:56.534837-08:00","sha1":"","page_count":223,"file_size":6842272,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"23","attachment_number":4,"pacer_doc_id":"010011275484","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Appellants' Appendix Vol. 4","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/468973744/","id":468973744,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/23/5/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:56.552384-08:00","date_modified":"2026-02-17T09:47:56.552396-08:00","sha1":"","page_count":274,"file_size":21483367,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"23","attachment_number":5,"pacer_doc_id":"010011275485","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Appellants' Appendix Vol. 5","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/468973745/","id":468973745,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/23/6/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:56.574113-08:00","date_modified":"2026-02-17T09:47:56.574126-08:00","sha1":"","page_count":250,"file_size":9135249,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"23","attachment_number":6,"pacer_doc_id":"010011275486","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Appellants' Appendix Vol. 6","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/468973746/","id":468973746,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/23/7/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:56.590494-08:00","date_modified":"2026-02-17T09:47:56.590512-08:00","sha1":"","page_count":214,"file_size":5260796,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"23","attachment_number":7,"pacer_doc_id":"010011275487","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Appellants' Appendix Vol. 7","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/468973747/","id":468973747,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/23/8/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:56.608251-08:00","date_modified":"2026-02-17T09:47:56.608267-08:00","sha1":"","page_count":222,"file_size":4335494,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"23","attachment_number":8,"pacer_doc_id":"010011275488","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Appellants' Appendix Vol. 8","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/468973748/","id":468973748,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/23/9/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:56.625969-08:00","date_modified":"2026-02-17T09:47:56.625986-08:00","sha1":"","page_count":213,"file_size":5029049,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"23","attachment_number":9,"pacer_doc_id":"010011275489","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Appellants' Appendix Vol. 9","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/468973749/","id":468973749,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/23/10/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2026-02-17T09:47:56.642503-08:00","date_modified":"2026-02-17T09:47:56.642515-08:00","sha1":"","page_count":101,"file_size":7554653,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"23","attachment_number":10,"pacer_doc_id":"010011275490","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Appellants' Appendix Vol. 10","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2025-08-06T14:38:14.245305-07:00","date_modified":"2026-03-15T18:19:17.716247-07:00","date_filed":"2025-07-31","time_filed":null,"entry_number":23,"recap_sequence_number":"2025-07-31.002","pacer_sequence_number":11201946,"description":"[11201946] Appellant's appendix filed by California Public Employees' Retirement System and Shijun Liu. Total number of volumes filed: 10. Served on 07/31/2025. Manner of Service: email. This pleading complies with all required privacy and virus certifications: Yes. [25-1178] JDD [Entered: 07/31/2025 02:38 PM]","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/433926239/","id":433926239,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/448295196/","id":448295196,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/22/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2025-08-06T14:38:14.222398-07:00","date_modified":"2026-03-15T18:19:17.688638-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"22","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"010011275040","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2025-08-06T14:38:14.204284-07:00","date_modified":"2026-03-15T18:19:17.652288-07:00","date_filed":"2025-07-31","time_filed":null,"entry_number":22,"recap_sequence_number":"2025-07-31.001","pacer_sequence_number":11201682,"description":"[11201682] Notice of deficient appendix received from California Public Employees' Retirement System and Shijun Liu. Type of deficiency: Volumes 2-10 contain insufficient bookmarks. See attached letter for specifics. Appendix due on 08/04/2025 for California Public Employees' Retirement System and Shijun Liu [25-1178] [Entered: 07/31/2025 08:11 AM]","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/433926238/","id":433926238,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70173082/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/448295195/","id":448295195,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70173082/21/california-public-employees-v-palantir-technologies-inc/","date_created":"2025-08-06T14:38:14.176207-07:00","date_modified":"2026-03-15T18:19:17.624480-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"21","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2025-08-06T14:38:14.157133-07:00","date_modified":"2026-03-15T18:19:17.588151-07:00","date_filed":"2025-07-30","time_filed":null,"entry_number":21,"recap_sequence_number":"2025-07-30.002","pacer_sequence_number":11201642,"description":"This entry has been removed from the docket. [lg] Cited as deficient. A corrected appendix has been filed. [11201642] Appellant's appendix filed by California Public Employees' Retirement System and Shijun Liu. Total number of volumes filed: 10. Served on 07/30/2025. Manner of Service: email. This pleading complies with all required privacy and virus certifications: Yes. [25-1178] JDD [Entered: 07/30/2025 06:24 PM]","tags":[]}],"entries_total":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/?count=on&docket=70173082&page_size=40"}