Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 1 of 12 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SO U TH ER N D ISTR ICT O F FLO R IDA CASE NO.:15-22134-ClV-UNGARO/OTAZO-% YES H YDEN TM H LP IN T.LIM ITED , a foreign colw ration d/b/a M ETA R T, Plaintiff, CON STA N TIN LU CH IA N ,an individual, KON STANTW BOLOTIN,an individual, SUN SOC IA L M ED IA ,IN C .,a corporation, individually and d/b/aPLAYVID.COM , FEEDV ID .CO M ,PLAY V ID S.COM ,and PEEKV ID S.CO M ;PLA YV ID .CO M ; FEED V ID .CO M ;PLA YV ID S.CO M ; PEEK V ID S.CO M ;and Jolm Does 1-20, Defendants. / REPORT AND RECOM M ENDATION THIS CAUSE cnmebeforethe Courtupon DefendantsConstantin Luchian (1$Luchian''), Konstantin Bolotin (d1Bolotin''), and Sun Social M edia, lnc.'s (û$SSM '') (collectively, ir efendants'')M otion forAttorney's Fees (hereafter,çfM otion for Fees'') (D.E.1481. This matterwasreferred to the undersigned pursuantto 28 U.S.C.j 636 by the HonorableUrsula Ungaro,United States District Judge (D.E. 1511. For the reasons discussed below,the undersigned respectfully recomm endsthatDefendants'M otion forFeesbeDENIED. Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 2 of 12 FA CT UA L A N D PR O C EDU R AL BA C K G R O U N D Plaintiff Hydentra HLP lnt. Limited (sll-lydentra'' or içplaintiff') produced or held licensing rights to adult-content videos,which were displayed on Hydentra's websites. See OmnibusOrder(D.E.138at1-21.1 Defendant SSM developed the following video-sharing websites through which users could upload adult-contentvideos:Playvid.com ,Playvids.com ,Peekvids.com ,and Feedvid.com (collectively,çiW ebsites''). ld.at3-4.Videosavailable on SSM 'SW ebsiteswereuploaded by SSM 'Susers,notby SSM oritsagentsorcontractors.Id.at3. DefendantBolotin wasthedirectorofoperationsatSSM .Ld.aat4. SSM designated Defendant Luchian as its agent to receive notitications of claim ed infringement(hereafter,içtakedown notices''),pursuanttotheDigitalM illennium CopyrightAct (ç$DM cA''). Id.at5.2 On its W ebsites,SSM provided a number of methods for sending takedow n notices to Luchian,including via em ail or physicaldelivery. Id.at 5-6. G enerally, within 48 hours of receiving a takedown notice via physicaldelivery,Luchian scanned itand emailed itto SSM . 1d.at7. Under SSM 'S procedures,upon receiving a takedown notice,it acted to removetheinfringing videos. Id.at6. HydentrahiredJasonTucker($1Tucker'')toinvestigateinfringementofitscopyrightsand to sendtakedownnoticesfordetected infringements.J#-,at9.Tuckerdiscovered thatanumber ofHydentra'scopyrighted videoswere displayed on Playvid.com. Ld.a On January 15,2015, Tucker senta package containing takedown noticesto Luchian via U .S.m ail,using a tracking 1The Om nibusOrderhas been published atHydentra HLP lnt. Ltd.v.Luchian,No.1:15-cv-22134-UU, 2016W L 5951808(S.D.Fla.June2,2016). 2The DM CA shieldsservice providersfrom liability forthe actsofthird-party users, where theproviders meetcertain criteriasuchasdesignatinganagentto receivetakedown notices. See l7U.S.C.j 512(c)(2). Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 3 of 12 numberto confinn thatthe package wasreceived. J i.at9-10.3 On January 20,2015,Carmen . Jusino (s1Jusino'')signed forthepackage on Luchian'sbehalf. Id.at10. However,liLuchian neverpersonally received thepackage ...and claimged)thatitwaslostaherJusino signed for gitq.'' 1d.'CSSM claimledjthatitneverreceivedthesetakedownnoticesand wasunawareofthe allegedly infringing filesuntilthis lawsuit.'' 1d. Priorto the filing ofthislawsuit,SSM did not removeHydentra'scopyrightedvideosfrom Playvid.com (D.E.155at2). On June 4, 2015, Hydentra filed this action asserting the following claim s against Defendants: Count1: DirectCopyrightInfringementUndertheCopyrightAct,17U.S.C.jj101 etseg.(hereaher,çicopyrightAct''); CountlI: Contributory CopyrightInfringem ent; Count111: VicariousCopyrightInfringement; Count1V: Inducement of Copyright Infringement (Counts I-IV collectively, iscopyrightActCounts''); CountV: Unauthorized Publication ofN ame and Likeness in Violation of Florida Statutej540.08; CountVI: TrademarklnfringementUndertheLanham Act,15U.S.C.j1114; CountVlI: Contributory Trademark lnfringement; CountV1l1: FalseDesignationofOriginUndertheLanhnm Act,15U.S.C.j 1125. SeeCompl.(D.E.1at14-381.Hydentrasought,interalia,damagesSsfora11infringingactivities'' from the date on which its copyrights were first infringed;and to enjoin Defendants from engaging in further infringing activities. ld.at 17-18,20-21,23-24,26-27. Hydentra attached to the Com plainta listidentifying its copyrighted videos thatw ere displayed on the W ebsites. Id. 3 Later, Tucker discovered more of Hydentra's copyrighted videos displayed on Playvids.com , Peekvids.com,and Feedvid.com ;buthedid notsend takedown noticesasto these videos. Id.at 2,9. Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 4 of 12 at41-46. Upon receiving the Com plaint,'tSSM disabled access to and/orrem oved''the listed videos.SeeOmnibusOrder(D.E.138at10j. On February 12, 2016, Hydentra and Defendants filed Cross M otions for Summary Judgment(D.E.72,73 & 861.4 On June2,2016,theCourtissuedan OmnibusOrderruling on thesummaryjudgmentmotions.SeeOmnibusOrder(D.E.1381. Regarding Count 1,Hydentra needed to establish thatit owned valid copyrights to the videosatissueand thatDefendantscopiedthevideos. J/..Sat14-15. Defendantsconceded that H ydentra owned valid copyrights to the videos at issue. 1d. at 15. Thus,the Court had to determine SçwhetherDefendantsmay beheld liable fordirectinfringem entbased upon third-party users'uploading of gldydentra's)copyrighted videos onto Defendants'W ebsites-'' Id. ln its analysis,the Courtnoted that,to establish such liability,Hydentra had to provefçthatDefendants engaged in a volitionalactto cause the illegalcopying'';butacknowledged thatthe Eleventh Circuithad k%notconsidered whether volitional conductis a necessary elem entfor inding an internetcompany liable fordirectcopyrightinfringement,'' Id.at 15,17. Hydentra argued that Dtfendants engaged in volitionalacts by em ploying a m oderator to screen videos thatwere uploaded to,but not yet displayed on, their W ebsites showing Sçchild pornography,animal pornography,spam,and to ensure thatthevideo constitutegd)adultentertainment.'' 1d.at18. However, the Court disagreed that such m onitoring constituted volitional acts. 1d. at 20. Accordingly,the Courtgranted SSM and Bolotin'sM otion forSum mary Judgm entand denied Hydentra'sM otion forSummaryJudgmentastoCount1.J#a. Regarding Count11,Hydentra needed to establish:thatD efendants knew orhad reason to know aboutthe infringing activity;thatDefendants induced,caused,orm aterially contributed to 4 SSM and Bolotin filed ajointM otion forSummary Judgment,while Luchian moved for summary judgmentindependently. 4 Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 5 of 12 the infringing conductof another; and that ilthe product in question (was not) capable of Ssubstantialnoninfringing uses.''' Id.at24,26. Afterdetennining thata question offactexisted as to whether Defendants had constructive knowledge of the infringing activities,the Court proceeded to discuss the noninfringing-use requirem ent. 1d. at 26. W ith respect to the noninfringing-use requirement,Hydentra argued thattherequirementapplied only to the sale of products,notto casesinvolving the use ofa website;and thatçithere(was)nothing aboutthe infringing videosthathaldqanon-infringingpurpose.'' Id.at27. TheCourtrecognized thatthe noninfringing-use requirementoriginally addressed only the sale ofproducts;butexplained that the requirement predated the Internet and found that it applied in this case. 1d. Further, Deftndants dem onstrated thattheW ebsiteswere capable ofsubstantialnoninfringing usessince SSM started as an online dating website;and the W ebsites hosted videos and allow ed usersto upload,playback,and organize videos. Ld.. a at 27-28. Hence,the Courtgranted SSM and Bolotin'sM otionforSummaryJudgmentastoCountl1.J.Z at28. Regarding Count111,Hydentra needed to establish thatDefendantsprofited directly from theinfringementandthatthey declined to exercisearightto stop orlimittheinfringement Ld-a at28-29. Hydentra argued thatSSM was compensated by advertisersbased on the am ountof lnternettraffic thatwasdirected to the advertisers'websitesfrom SSM 'SW ebsites. Ld.aat29. Therefore, Hydentra argued thatthe existence of its copyrighted videos on SSM 'S W ebsites dlfinancially benefitgedj Defendants''because çithe attractiveness of the content''on SSM 'S W ebsiteswould increasetrafscto theadvertisers'websites. J#a However,theCourtfoundthat there was iino evidence that (Hydentra'sl copyrighted videos drew additional traffic to Defendants' W ebsitess''so Hydentra could not establish that Defendants ûtreceived a direct 5 Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 6 of 12 snancialbenefitfrom theuploading of(Hydentra'sjvideos.'' Ld-us Thus,theCourtgrantedSSM andBolotin'sM otion forSummaryJudgmentastoCount111.J#.,at30. Regarding Count 1V,the Courtnoted that Hydentra neither responded to Defendants' arguments,normoved forsummaryjudgmentastothisCount. Ld= The Courtfoundthatthere wasno evidence thatDefendantsinduced users to upload copyrighted videos because they acted as ilpassive intenwt service providers.'' ld. Therefore,the Courtgranted SSM and Bolotin's M otionforSummaryJudgmentastoCountIV.l/s A dditionally,the Courtgranted SSM and Bolotin's M otion for Sum m ary Judgm entasto CountV;denied itasto CountsVI-VII1;and denied Hydentra'sM otion forSumm ary Judgment. ld. at37.5 On June7,2016,Hydentrafiled aM otion to DismisswithoutprejudiceCountsVI-Vll1 which the Courtgranted,thereby dismissing the remaining Countsand closing the case (D.E. 140& 141). On August2,2016,Defendantsfiled the instantM otion forFees seeking $162,165.00 in attomey'sfeespursuanttotheCopyrightAct. See Motion forFees(D.E.148j. OnAugust19, 2016,Hydentra tsled itsOpposition to Defendants'M otion for Fees (hereafter,diplaintiff's Response'')(D.E.154j. On August26,2016,Defendantsfiled theirReply in Supportoftheir M otion for Fees (hereafter,SsDefendants'Reply'') ED.E.155) in which Defendants corrected errors in theirinitialfee calculation and soughtan amended totalof$151,902.50 in attorney's fees.1d.at5. APPLICA BLE LA W In copyright infringem entactions,Section 505 of the Copyright A ctauthorizes courts to dlaward areasonableattorney'sfeetotheprevailingpartyaspartofthecosts.'' 17 U.S.C.j505, 5The Courtalso granted Luchian'sM otion forSum mary Judgment. J-1J.Sat36. 6 Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 7 of 12 Generally,the prevailing party is Sçthe party succeeding on a signifkant litigated issue that achievessom eofthe benefitssoughtby thatparty in initiating the suit.'' Cable/Home Comm c'n Corp.v.Network Prods..lnc.,902 F.2d 829,853 (11th Cir.1990). Here,Defendantsprevailed at summary judgment on Plaintiffs Copyright Act Counts, and Plaintiff concedes that Defendantsaretheprevailing partiesastothose Counts. SeePlaintiffsResponse ED.E.154 at 10). Asprevailingparties,Defendantsbeartheburden ofestablishing entitlementto attom ey's fees. Katzv.Chevaldina,127 F.Supp.3d 1285,1296(S.D.Fla.2015). Thedecision to award attom ey'sfeesfallswithin thecourt'ssound discretion. Klein & Heuchan.Inc.v.CostarRealtv lnfo..lnc.,No.8:08-cv-l227-T-30EAJ,2011W L 6097980,at*2 (M .D.Fla.Dec.7,2011). In exercisingtheirdiscretion,courtsconsiderthefollowingnon-exclusivefactors:(1)frivolousness; (2)motivation;(3)objective urtreasonablenessofthe non-prevailing party'spositions;and (4) the need to advance considerations ofcompensation and deterrence. Foaerty v.Fantasy.lnc., 510 U .S.517,534n.19(1994).6 DISCU SSIO N (1)Frivolousness ikFrivolousness,incopyrightcases,isusually foundin casesinwhichthe(plaintiffjdoes noteven own the copyrightin question orhasgranted a licenseto the alleged infringerbutsues forinfringem entnonetheless.'' M edallion HomesGulfCoast.lnc.v.TivoliHom esofSarasota. Inc.,No.8:14-cv-3117-T-33JSS,2016 W L 5870215,at*2 (M .D.Fla.Oct.7,2016)(citations omitted);ProflLED Lichtinc.Ltd.v.AAdvn Tech..LLC,88 F.Supp.3d 1356,1375 (S.D.Fla. 2015)(same). Defendantsarguethatt'the claimsbroughtagainst(Bolotin and Luchian)could 6Thesearegenerally called the ddFogertv''factors. M alibu M edia.LLC v.Pelizzos604 F.App'x 879 881 (11thCir.2015). ' l . Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 8 of 12 è notbe eonsidered anything other than frivolous.'' See Motion for Fees CD.E. 148 at 9). However,Defendantsconceded thatPlaintiffowned valid copyrightsto thevideosatissue in this case.Thus,the undersigned concludesthatPlaintiffscase wasnotfrivolous. M edallion Homes GulfCoast,2016 W L 5870215,at*2;Pm flLED Lighting,88 F.Supp.3d at 1375. Therefore, thisfactormilitatesagainstawarding attorney'sfeestoDefendants. (2)M otivation In evaluating this factor,courts considerwhether the non-prevailing ésparty litigated in good orbad faith.'' Klein & Heuchan,2011 W L 6097980,at#5. Thisdetennination may turn on a num berofconsiderations,including whetherthe non-prevailing party initiated the lawsuit foran impropermotive. ld.;see Luken v.lnt'lYachtCouncil.Ltd.,581 F.Supp.2d 1226,1245 (S.D.Fla.2008)(consideringthenon-prevailingparty'smotivationforbringingthelawsuit). Defendants argue that Plaintiff brought this action in bad faith for the pumose of achieving awindfallby forcingasettlement.SeeMotionforFees(D.E.148 at11). Tosupport thisposition,Defendantsarguethat:(1)Plaintiff'slawsuitshould neverhavebeen initiated;(2) Plaintiffsentthe takedown noticesvia U.S.mail,ratherthan em ail,to m anufacture Defendants' error;and (3)Plaintiff did notdismissthislawsuitafter Defendantsremoved its copyrighted videos from the W ebsites. Id.at2,11 n.7,13;Defendants'Reply (D.E.155 at2-31. The undersigned findsno meritin theseargum ents. First,Plaintiffonly fled this lawsuitafter:Plaintiffdiscovered its copyrighted videoson Playvid.com ;PlaintiffsentLuchian takedown notices via U.S.m ail;the takedown noticeswere delivered to,and accepted by,Jusino on Luchian's behalf;and Plaintiff's copyrighted videos werenotrem oved from Playvid.vom .Given thispre-suithistory,theundersigned concludesthat Plaintifffiledthisaction in good faith to protectitscopyrighted videos. S4ç Luken,581F.Supp. 8 Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 9 of 12 2d at1245 (ltltgoeswithoutsaying thatprotection ofone'scopyrightconstitutesapermissible m otivation in sling a copyright infringement case against one whom the copyright holder believesingoodfaithtohaveinfringedthecopyright.''). Second,pursuantto inform ation on SSM 'S W ebsites,takedown notices could be sentto Luchian viaem ailorphysicaldelivery,so Plaintiffsentthetakedown noticesin accordance with SSM 'Sinstructions.Therefore,the method ofdelivery isnotevidenceofimproperm otivation. Third,although Defendants removed Plaintiffs copyrighted videos from the W ebsites afterbeing served with theComplaint,such removaldid notobligePlaintiffto dismissthisaction given thatPlaintiffsoughtto recoverdamagesfrom the date on which its copyrightswere frst infringed. Therefore,the undersigned concludesthatPlaintiffbroughtthisaction in good faith,and notforan impropermotive. Klein & Heuchan,2011W L 6097980,at*5;Luken,581 F.Supp. 2d at1245. Thus,thisfactormilitatesagainstawarding attorney'sfeesto Defendants. (3)ObjectiveUnreasonableness To detenninewhetherthe non-prevailing party'sposition wasobjectively unreasonable, courts considerûithe clarity ofthe law w ith respectto the losing party's position atthe tim e that the losing party pressed itsargum ent.'' Luken,581 F.Supp.2d at 1240. To thatend,courts consider whether the unsuccessful lfposition was patently without m erit or otherw ise clearly lacking alegalorfactualbasis.''Klein & Heuchan,2011W L 6097980,at*2 (citation omitted). The Supreme Courthas recently cautioned that çlobjective reasonableness can be only an im portant factor in assessing fee applications not the controlling one.'' K irtsaeng v. John W iley& Sons.Inc.,136S.Ct.1979,1988(2016). 9 Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 10 of 12 Defendants argue that Plaintiffs positions were objectively unreasonable because the iécourtfully examined - and rejected - each ofPlaintiff'stheoriesofliability against(SSM I.'' SeeM otionforFees(D.E.148at9).However,thefactthatPlaintifflostatsummaryjudgement isinsuffcienttoestablishthatPlaintiffspositionswereobjedivelyunreasonable.SeeCorwinv. W altDisnevW orldCo.,No.6:02-cv-1377-Orl-19KRS,2008 W L 754697,at*7(M .D.Fla.Mar. 18,2008)(li- f'hemerefactthatsummaryjudgmentwasgranted to W orldco,inand ofitself,also doesnotspeak to whetherPlaintifpsclaimswere lobjectively unreasonable.'''). M oreover,in sum marizing the Court's fndings in its Omnibus Order,Defendants simply m ade conclusory statementsthatPlaintiffsclaimswereobjectively unreasonable.SeeMotion forFees(D.E.148 at8-10J. However,a review oftheCourt'sOmnibusOrderon the CopyrightActCountsdoes notsupportDefendants'conclusion thatPlaintiffspositionswereobjectively unreasonable. As to Counts 1-111,the Court's determ inations turned on close questions of factand law. As to Count1V,PlaintiffdidnotrespondtoDefendants'argumentsormoveforsummaryjudgment. Therefore,the undersigned finds no supportfor Defendants'argument that Plaintiff's positionswere objectively unreasonable. Klein & Heuchan,2011W L 6097980,at#2;Luken, 581 F. Supp.2d at 1240. Hence, this factor militates against awarding attorney's fees to Defendants. (4)ConsiderationsofCompensationandDeterrence In evaluating thisfactor,courtsconsiderwhetherawarding attorney'sfeeswould further the purposesofthe CopyrightAd,Luken,581F.Supp.2d at1246,by looking to theirfindings with respect to the frivolousness, motivation, and objective unreasonableness of the non- prevailing party's positions. See K lein & H euchan,2011 W L 6097980,at*6;see also M alibu - M edias604F.App'xat881(ç$Asforconsiderationsofcompensationand deterrence,weevaluate 10 Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 11 of 12 those factors as iinextricably intertwined'with the reasonableness and frivolity of M alibu's claims.''). Here,the undersigned has already found that Plaintiffs case was not frivolous;that Plaintiffinitiated thisaction in good faith, and notforan improperm otive;and thatthere isno supportfor finding Plaintiffs positions to have been objectively unreasonable. Given these findingsand the pre-suithistory ofthiscase, Plaintiffs claim sproperly served the purposesof the CopyrightAct. See M alibu M edia, 604 F.App'x at881('t IfM alibu'sclaimswereproperly broughtand properlym aintained,thenthey properly served thepurposesofthe CopyrightAct.' '). Putanotherway,awarding attorney's feeswould frustratethepurposesofthe CopyrightActifit detersplaintiffsfrom bringing reasonable actions in good faith to protecttheircopyrights. Klein & Heuzhan,2011W L 6097980,at*6;see Luken,581 F.Supp.2d at 1246 (lsconsistentwith furthering the pum osesofthe CopyrightAct,aparty thatadvancesareasonableposition should notbedeterred from doingsoforfearthatitwillhavetopay attolmey'sfeesifitloses.''(citation omittedl).Hence,thisfactoralsomilitatesagainstawardingattomey'sfeesto Defendants. C O N CLU SIO N The undersigned hasconsidered a11ofthe Fogerty factorsand hasconcluded thateach of them militates against awarding attorney's fees to Defendants. Therefore, it is RESPECTFULLY RECOM M ENDED that Defendants' M otion for Fees (D.E. 148) be DEN IED . Pursuantto LocalM agistrate Judge Rule 4(b),the partieshavefourteen daysfrom the dateofthisReportand Recommendation to file written objections,ifany,with theHonorable UrsulaUngaro. Failureto timely file objectionsshallbarthepartiesfrom attacking on appeal the factualfindings contained herein. See Rqsolution Tr.Corp.v.Hallm ark Builders.lnc.,996 Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 12 of 12 F.2d 1144,1149 (11th Cir.1993). Further,çifailureto objectin accordancewith theprovisions of(28U.S.C.)j636(b)(1)waivestherighttochallengeon appealthedistrictcourt'sorderbased onunobjected-tofactualandlegalconclusions.''See11th Cir.R.3-1(I.O.P.-3). RESPECTFULLY SUBM ITTED in Cham bers at M iam i, Florida, this 23'd day of February,2017. < ALICIA M .O ZO YES UN ITED STATES M AGISTM TE JUDGE cc: United StatesDistrictJudgeUrsulaUngaro CounselofRecord