{"cached_at":"2026-11-15T11:40:32.588970+00:00","cl_docket_id":"70904232","docket":{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","id":70904232,"court":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/courts/txwd/","court_id":"txwd","original_court_info":null,"idb_data":null,"clusters":[],"audio_files":[],"assigned_to":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/people/8533/","referred_to":null,"bankruptcy_information":null,"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2025-07-24T09:17:55.929805-07:00","date_modified":"2026-11-13T19:03:08.588246-08:00","source":1,"appeal_from_str":"","assigned_to_str":"Alan D Albright","referred_to_str":"","panel_str":"","date_last_index":null,"date_cert_granted":null,"date_cert_denied":null,"date_argued":null,"date_reargued":null,"date_reargument_denied":null,"date_filed":"2025-07-24","date_terminated":null,"date_last_filing":"2026-11-09","case_name_short":"Paxton","case_name":"Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC v. Paxton","case_name_full":"","slug":"glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton","docket_number":"1:25-cv-01153","docket_number_core":"2501153","docket_number_raw":"1:25-cv-01153","docket_number_source":0,"federal_dn_office_code":"1","federal_dn_case_type":"cv","federal_dn_judge_initials_assigned":"ADA","federal_dn_judge_initials_referred":"","federal_defendant_number":null,"pacer_case_id":"1172856380","cause":"42:1983 Civil Rights Act","nature_of_suit":"950 Constitutional - State Statute","jury_demand":"None","jurisdiction_type":"Federal Question","appellate_fee_status":"","appellate_case_type_information":"","mdl_status":"","filepath_ia":"","filepath_ia_json":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"ia_needs_upload":true,"ia_date_first_change":"2025-07-24T09:17:55.906131-07:00","date_blocked":null,"blocked":false,"appeal_from":null,"parent_docket":null,"tags":[],"panel":[]},"parties":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/17086801/","id":17086801,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11148330/","attorney_id":11148330,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11148331/","attorney_id":11148331,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11148331/","attorney_id":11148331,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":4},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11148332/","attorney_id":11148332,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11148332/","attorney_id":11148332,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":4},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11148333/","attorney_id":11148333,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11148334/","attorney_id":11148334,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11148334/","attorney_id":11148334,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":4},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11148335/","attorney_id":11148335,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11148335/","attorney_id":11148335,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":4},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11148336/","attorney_id":11148336,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11148337/","attorney_id":11148337,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11148337/","attorney_id":11148337,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":4},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11148338/","attorney_id":11148338,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11148338/","attorney_id":11148338,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":4}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"name":"Consol Plaintiff","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2026-01-05T06:54:23.604558-08:00","date_modified":"2026-01-05T06:54:23.604573-08:00","name":"Institutional Shareholder Services Inc.","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/16720043/","id":16720043,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10691620/","attorney_id":10691620,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10691620/","attorney_id":10691620,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10646453/","attorney_id":10646453,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10646453/","attorney_id":10646453,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10646454/","attorney_id":10646454,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10646454/","attorney_id":10646454,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10646455/","attorney_id":10646455,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10646455/","attorney_id":10646455,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10875992/","attorney_id":10875992,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10875992/","attorney_id":10875992,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":4}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"name":"Intervenor Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2025-11-20T12:42:55.287544-08:00","date_modified":"2025-11-20T12:42:55.287556-08:00","name":"Texas Stock Exchange LLC","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/16131567/","id":16131567,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10646456/","attorney_id":10646456,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10646456/","attorney_id":10646456,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10646457/","attorney_id":10646457,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10646458/","attorney_id":10646458,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"name":"Amicus","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2025-08-26T10:01:07.906896-07:00","date_modified":"2025-08-26T10:01:07.906914-07:00","name":"Alliance for Corporate Excellence","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/16131566/","id":16131566,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10691620/","attorney_id":10691620,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10691620/","attorney_id":10691620,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10646453/","attorney_id":10646453,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10646453/","attorney_id":10646453,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10646454/","attorney_id":10646454,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10646454/","attorney_id":10646454,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10646455/","attorney_id":10646455,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10646455/","attorney_id":10646455,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10875992/","attorney_id":10875992,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10875992/","attorney_id":10875992,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":4}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"name":"Intervenor Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2025-08-26T10:01:07.823511-07:00","date_modified":"2025-08-26T10:01:07.823533-07:00","name":"Texas Association of Business","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/15836783/","id":15836783,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10625767/","attorney_id":10625767,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10625767/","attorney_id":10625767,"date_action":"2026-08-12","docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":6},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10625767/","attorney_id":10625767,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/16191338/","attorney_id":16191338,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/16191338/","attorney_id":16191338,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/11797714/","attorney_id":11797714,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"in his official capacity as Attorney General of Texas","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2025-07-24T19:23:27.701184-07:00","date_modified":"2025-07-24T19:23:27.701211-07:00","name":"Ken Paxton","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/15834787/","id":15834787,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10522599/","attorney_id":10522599,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10522599/","attorney_id":10522599,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10524144/","attorney_id":10524144,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10524145/","attorney_id":10524145,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/10524146/","attorney_id":10524146,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"role":1}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","docket_id":70904232,"name":"Plaintiff","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2025-07-24T09:55:42.842225-07:00","date_modified":"2025-07-24T09:55:42.842238-07:00","name":"Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC","extra_info":""}],"entries":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/484965183/","id":484965183,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/500822662/","id":500822662,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/116/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-11-09T13:09:31.863943-08:00","date_modified":"2026-11-13T04:38:48.323281-08:00","sha1":"8708fb4f174ce18bd2b5319d2205c9a8700f3c2f","page_count":2,"file_size":179884,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.116.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.116.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 116       Filed 11/09/26      Page 1 of 2\n\n\n\n\n                       IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                        FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS\n                                  AUSTIN DIVISION\n\nGLASS, LEWIS & CO., LLC,         \u00a7\n     Plaintiff,                  \u00a7\n                                 \u00a7\nv.                               \u00a7\n                                 \u00a7\nKEN PAXTON, IN HIS OFFICIAL      \u00a7\nCAPACITY AS ATTORNEY GENERAL OF \u00a7                    CIVIL ACTION NO. 1:25-cv-01153-ADA\nTEXAS,                           \u00a7\n     Defendant,                  \u00a7\n                                 \u00a7\nTHE TEXAS STOCK EXCHANGE and THE \u00a7\nTEXAS ASSOCIATION OF BUSINESS,   \u00a7\n     Intervenor-Defendants.      \u00a7\n\n\n                                     VACATION NOTICE\n\n\nTo the Clerk of Court and All Parties of Record:\n\n       Please note the dates herein where the Texas Attorney General\u2019s office will be closed, and\n\nthe undersigned counsel will be out of the office on vacation. Please do not schedule any hearings\n\nor other deadlines during these time periods.\n\n           \u2022   November 11, 2026 (Attorney General closed)\n\n           \u2022   November 19-20, 2026 (Counsel out of office)\n\n           \u2022   November 23-25, 2026 (Counsel out of office)\n\n           \u2022   November 26-27, 2026 (Attorney General closed)\n\n           \u2022   December 21-23, 2026 (Counsel out of office)\n\n           \u2022   December 24-26, 2026 (Attorney General closed)\n\n           \u2022   December 28-30, 2026 (Counsel out of office)\n\n           \u2022   December 31, 2026 \u2013 January 1, 2027 (Attorney General closed)\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 116        Filed 11/09/26       Page 2 of 2\n\n\n\n\nThank you.\n\n\nDated: November 9, 2026                     Respectfully submitted,\n\n                                            KEN PAXTON\n                                            Attorney General of Texas\n\n                                            BRENT WEBSTER\n                                            First Assistant Attorney General\n\n                                            RALPH MOLINA\n                                            Deputy First Assistant Attorney General\n\n                                            WILLIAM D. WASSDORF\n                                            Deputy Attorney General for Civil Litigation\n\n                                            KIMBERLY GDULA\n                                            Chief, General Litigation Division\n\n                                            /s/ Joe Nwaokoro\n                                            JOE NWAOKORO\n                                            Attorney-in-Charge\n                                            Assistant Attorney General\n                                            Texas Bar No. 24032916\n                                            General Litigation Division\n                                            P.O. Box 12548, Capitol Station\n                                            Austin, Texas 78711-2548\n                                            (512) 979-5382 | FAX: (512) 477-2348\n                                            Joe.Nwaokoro@oag.texas.gov\n\n                                            COUNSEL FOR DEFENDANT KEN PAXTON,\n                                            IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS ATTORNEY\n                                            GENERAL OF TEXAS\n\n\n                               CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\n\n       I certify that on November 9, 2026, this document was filed electronically via the Court\u2019s\n\nCM/ECF system, causing electronic service upon all counsel of record.\n\n\n                                            /s/ Joe Nwaokoro\n                                            JOE NWAOKORO\n                                            Assistant Attorney General\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2026-11-10T06:07:50.002706-08:00","document_number":"116","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"181037779418","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Notice","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-11-09T13:09:31.842273-08:00","date_modified":"2026-11-09T13:09:31.847809-08:00","date_filed":"2026-11-09","time_filed":"14:30:33","entry_number":116,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-11-09.001","pacer_sequence_number":432,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/484822731/","id":484822731,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/500672477/","id":500672477,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/115/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-11-07T15:04:00.759586-08:00","date_modified":"2026-11-07T15:04:00.775974-08:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"115","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"181037774795","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Transcript Filed","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-11-07T15:04:00.737463-08:00","date_modified":"2026-11-07T15:04:00.746161-08:00","date_filed":"2026-11-07","time_filed":"16:54:00","entry_number":115,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-11-07.001","pacer_sequence_number":430,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/483762096/","id":483762096,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/499584569/","id":499584569,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/114/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-30T16:04:54.712861-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-30T16:04:54.726876-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"114","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"181037728978","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Reply to Response to Motion","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-30T16:04:54.660807-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-30T16:04:54.670445-07:00","date_filed":"2026-10-30","time_filed":"17:19:56","entry_number":114,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-10-30.001","pacer_sequence_number":427,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/482904707/","id":482904707,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/498700620/","id":498700620,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/113/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-26T18:18:07.776426-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-26T18:18:07.786728-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"113","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"181037687744","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Affidavit in Support","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/498772098/","id":498772098,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/113/1/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-27T08:17:11.633688-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-27T08:17:11.633708-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":19,"file_size":284848,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"113","attachment_number":1,"pacer_doc_id":"181037687745","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Rasmussen Declaration - Exhibit 1","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/498772100/","id":498772100,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/113/2/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-27T08:17:11.704868-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-27T08:17:11.704889-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":12,"file_size":236723,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"113","attachment_number":2,"pacer_doc_id":"181037687746","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Rasmussen Declaration - Exhibit 2","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/498772101/","id":498772101,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/113/3/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-27T08:17:11.726885-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-27T08:17:11.726905-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":20,"file_size":259460,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"113","attachment_number":3,"pacer_doc_id":"181037687747","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"RasmussenDeclaration - Exhibit 3","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/498772102/","id":498772102,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/113/4/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-27T08:17:11.750115-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-27T08:17:11.750135-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":12,"file_size":214316,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"113","attachment_number":4,"pacer_doc_id":"181037687748","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Rasmussen Declaration - Exhibit 4","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/498772107/","id":498772107,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/113/5/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-27T08:17:13.317479-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-27T08:17:13.317502-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":11,"file_size":238196,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"113","attachment_number":5,"pacer_doc_id":"181037687749","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Rasmussen Declaration - Exhibit 5","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/498772108/","id":498772108,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/113/6/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-27T08:17:13.713075-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-27T08:17:13.713096-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":9,"file_size":232571,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"113","attachment_number":6,"pacer_doc_id":"181037687750","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Rasmussen Declaration - Exhibit 6","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/498772109/","id":498772109,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/113/7/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-27T08:17:14.043099-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-27T08:17:14.043129-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":13,"file_size":220052,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"113","attachment_number":7,"pacer_doc_id":"181037687751","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Rasmussen Declaration - Exhibit 7","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/498772110/","id":498772110,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/113/8/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-27T08:17:14.293641-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-27T08:17:14.293663-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":9,"file_size":210233,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"113","attachment_number":8,"pacer_doc_id":"181037687752","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Rasmussen Declaration - Exhibit 8","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/498772111/","id":498772111,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/113/9/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-27T08:17:14.535170-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-27T08:17:14.535191-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":9,"file_size":316062,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"113","attachment_number":9,"pacer_doc_id":"181037687753","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Rasmussen Declaration - Exhibit 9","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/498772112/","id":498772112,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/113/10/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-27T08:17:14.740066-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-27T08:17:14.740087-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":9,"file_size":220924,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"113","attachment_number":10,"pacer_doc_id":"181037687754","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Rasmussen Declaration - Exhibit 10","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-26T18:18:07.750429-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-26T18:18:07.758704-07:00","date_filed":"2026-10-26","time_filed":"20:05:58","entry_number":113,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-10-26.001","pacer_sequence_number":424,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/482903743/","id":482903743,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/498699639/","id":498699639,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/111/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-26T18:03:50.907030-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-28T13:02:10.293752-07:00","sha1":"8a36cf65c38978f2da815483adb2aead3a4c211d","page_count":12,"file_size":309369,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.111.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.111.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA         Document 111          Filed 10/26/26     Page 1 of 12\n\n\n\n\n                     IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                      FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS\n                               AUSTIN DIVISION\nGLASS, LEWIS & CO., LLC                        \u00a7\n     Plaintiff,                                \u00a7\n                                               \u00a7\nv.                                             \u00a7\n                                               \u00a7\nKEN PAXTON, in his Official Capacity as        \u00a7\n                                                              Civil Action No.\nAttorney General of Texas                      \u00a7\n                                                            1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n       Defendant,                              \u00a7\n                                               \u00a7\nTHE TEXAS STOCK EXCHANGE LLC                   \u00a7\nand THE TEXAS ASSOCIATION OF                   \u00a7\nBUSINESS,                                      \u00a7\n      Intervenor-Defendants.                   \u00a7\n\n\nATTORNEY GENERAL\u2019S RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF GLASS LEWIS\u2019 MOTION TO\n                COMPEL DISCOVERY RESPONSES\n\n\nKEN PAXTON                                         KIMBERLY GDULA\nAttorney General of Texas                          Chief, General Litigation Division\n\nBRENT WEBSTER                                      JOE NWAOKORO\nFirst Assistant Attorney General                   Attorney-in-Charge\n                                                   Texas Bar No. 24032916\nRALPH MOLINA                                       Assistant Attorney General\nDeputy First Assistant Attorney General            P.O. Box 12548, Capitol Station\n                                                   Austin, Texas 78711-2548\nWILLIAM D. WASSDORF                                (512) 979-5382 | FAX: (512) 320-0667\nDeputy Attorney General for Civil Litigation       Joe.Nwaokoro@oag.texas.gov\n\n\nDEFENDANT KEN PAXTON, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS ATTORNEY GENERAL\n                             OF TEXAS\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 111        Filed 10/26/26      Page 2 of 12\n\n\n\n\nTO THE HONORABLE COURT:\n\n       Defendant, Ken Paxton, in his official capacity as Attorney General of Texas (\u201cDefendant\u201d\n\nor the \u201cAttorney General\u201d), files this Response to Plaintiff Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC\u2019s (\u201cGlass\n\nLewis\u201d) Motion to Compel Discovery Responses (Dkt. 109) (the \u201cMotion\u201d) and respectfully shows\n\nthe Court as follows:\n\n                                        INTRODUCTION\n\n       Glass Lewis stated that its motion for summary judgment \u201cturns on the statutory text and\n\nlegislative history of the Act,\u201d Dkt. 60 at 1, and that \u201c[f]urther discovery is not needed to resolve\n\nthis case,\u201d Dkt. 74 at 1. Yet, it moves to compel the one thing its lawsuit does not reach: the\n\nAttorney General\u2019s law-enforcement investigative and charging file from a separate Deceptive\n\nTrade Practices Act (\u201cDTPA\u201d) enforcement action against it. The as-applied First Amendment\n\nchallenge turns on how S.B. 2337 operates against Glass Lewis\u2019s speech, not the Attorney\n\nGeneral\u2019s enforcement motive or investigative methods in a separate DTPA matter. The Court\n\nshould deny the Motion because Glass Lewis (1) ignored Section IV of the Court\u2019s discovery-\n\ndispute procedure; (2) moved against responses the Attorney General has since superseded,\n\nrendering the Motion premature; and (3) seeks a file that is irrelevant, disproportionate, and\n\nprotected by multiple privileges.\n\n                                        BACKGROUND\n\n       The Attorney General incorporates the Nwaokoro Declarations filed with his Reply (Dkt.\n\n110-1) (\u201cNwaokoro Reply Decl.\u201d), his Motion for Protective Order (Dkt. 101-1) (\u201cNwaokoro\n\nDecl.\u201d), and this Response (\u201cNwaokoro Resp. Decl.\u201d), and the Declaration of Division Chief\n\nJohnathan Stone (Dkt. 101-2) (\u201cStone Decl.\u201d).\n\n\n\n\n                                                 1\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA         Document 111        Filed 10/26/26     Page 3 of 12\n\n\n\n\n       On August 22, 2025, before S.B. 2337\u2019s effective date, the Attorney General\u2019s Consumer\n\nProtection Division (\u201cDivision\u201d) issued a Civil Investigative Demand (the \u201cCID\u201d) to Glass Lewis\n\nunder Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.61, and later filed State v. Glass, Lewis & Co., No. 471-04895-\n\n2026 (471st Dist. Ct., Collin County) (the \u201cState DTPA Action\u201d). The State DTPA Action does\n\nnot assert an S.B. 2337 claim. Nwaokoro Decl. \u00b6\u00b6 2, 5. This Court held that the preliminary\n\ninjunction bars enforcement of S.B. 2337 only, not \u201cother provisions of the law against [Glass\n\nLewis] at this time.\u201d May 15, 2026 Text Order, quoted in Dkt. 107 at 2.\n\n       The Attorney General served amended responses, produced documents, and an itemized\n\nprivilege log on October 16, 2026; served his Second Amended Objections and Responses (the\n\n\u201cSecond Amended Responses\u201d), a supplemental production, and a supplemental log on October\n\n20; and a further supplement on October 23. Nwaokoro Reply Decl. (Dkt. 110-1) \u00b6 7 & Exs. B, C,\n\nE; Nwaokoro Resp. Decl. \u00b6\u00b6 5\u20137 & Exs. A\u2013B. Those responses name the Alliance for Corporate\n\nExcellence as the sole source of information about Glass Lewis\u2019s statements, state that no known\n\nTexas-based client complained, and confirm no S.B. 2337 enforcement since the injunction.\n\nSecond Am. Resp., Interrog. Nos. 14, 17, 20.\n\n       Glass Lewis moved to compel anyway, and against the wrong record. After the Attorney\n\nGeneral proposed conferring by October 19, Glass Lewis filed its Motion that day and has never\n\nconferred on the October 20 or October 23 responses, though he remained available to confer.\n\nNwaokoro Resp. Decl. Ex. C.\n\n                                         ARGUMENT\n\nI.     Glass Lewis Ignored the Discovery-Dispute Procedure and Failed to Confer in Good\n       Faith.\n\n       On August 3, 2026, the Court directed that any dispute proceed \u201cthrough the discovery\n\ndispute process outlined in Section IV\u201d of Judge Albright\u2019s Standing Order (the \u201cOGP\u201d). Dkt. 109-\n\n\n\n                                               2\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA             Document 111     Filed 10/26/26      Page 4 of 12\n\n\n\n\n2 at 3\u20134. Section IV bars a motion to compel \u201cunless\u201d lead counsel have met and conferred in good\n\nfaith and the movant has contacted the law clerk; a meet and confer requires a personal conference,\n\nas \u201c[c]orrespondence, such as e-mail, is insufficient.\u201d OGP \u00a7 IV & n.5. Glass Lewis\u2019s own counsel\n\ninvoked Section IV in August, Dkt. 109-2, yet its Certificate of Conference shows no personal\n\nconference on the written discovery, no Section IV summary, and no contact with the law clerk,\n\nonly a September 29 discussion of \u201cupcoming depositions\u201d and emails. Dkt. 109, Certificate of\n\nConference. The Federal and Local Rules impose the same requirement. Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(a)(1);\n\nW.D. Tex. Local R. CV-7(g). A letter listing deficiencies and threatening a motion \u201cdoes not meet\n\nthe conference requirement,\u201d Ramsey v. Sheet Pile, LLC, 2021 WL 9870366, at *2 (W.D. Tex. Oct.\n\n14, 2021). That alone warrants denial.\n\nII.    The Motion Attacks Superseded Responses, Is Moot in Part, and Is Premature.\n\n       A motion to compel lies only for a failure to answer or respond, Fed. R. Civ. P.\n\n37(a)(3)(B)(iii)\u2013(iv). Here, there was no such failure. The Attorney General served his original\n\nresponses on October 8 (Dkt. 107-7; Dkt. 109-3 \u00b6 6), amended them on October 16, superseded\n\nthem with his Second Amended Responses on October 20, and supplemented them again on\n\nOctober 23. Nwaokoro Reply Decl. (Dkt. 110-1) \u00b6 7 & Ex. E; Nwaokoro Resp. Decl. \u00b6\u00b6 5\u20137 &\n\nExs. A\u2013B. Glass Lewis moved on October 19 against the October 16 responses and has never\n\naddressed the responses that supplanted them. A motion filed \u201cwithout the benefit of the amended\n\nresponses \u2026 which supplant the initial responses\u201d tests the wrong record and is premature.\n\nRodriguez-Meza v. Venegas, 2020 WL 14100944, at *2 (W.D. Tex. Mar. 27, 2020).\n\n       Glass Lewis, which has the current responses, production, and October 23 log, shows no\n\nprejudice. Its October 22 log complaints, which it raised only after moving to compel, constitute\n\na new dispute that requires its own Section IV conference. Nwaokoro Resp. Decl. Ex. C. Many of\n\n\n\n\n                                                3\n\f       Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 111        Filed 10/26/26         Page 5 of 12\n\n\n\n\nGlass Lewis\u2019s requests also merely duplicate its own first-set discovery, which the Attorney\n\nGeneral answered on October 31, 2025, so the Court \u201cmust limit\u201d them as \u201cunreasonably\n\ncumulative or duplicative.\u201d Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(2)(C)(i). The enclosed chart pairs each duplicative\n\nrequest with the first-set request it restates. See Nwaokoro Resp. Decl. Ex. F.\n\nIII.    The Attorney General\u2019s Objections Are Specific, Not Waived Boilerplate.\n\n        Glass Lewis\u2019s cited authority refutes its boilerplate charge. The objections condemned in\n\nMcLeod were identical one-line recitations, \u201cOverbroad; irrelevant; privileged,\u201d that were repeated\n\nacross every request. McLeod, Alexander, Powel & Apffel, P.C. v. Quarles, 894 F.2d 1482, 1484\u2013\n\n85 (5th Cir. 1990). Not so here. Each objection by the Attorney General states why the material\n\nis outside the as-applied inquiry, identifies the privilege, and directs Glass Lewis to the October\n\n16 production at Bates AG 002090\u2013AG 003289. Dkt. 109-3 (Ex. 2); Nwaokoro Resp. Decl. Ex.\n\nG. The claim that the Attorney General \u201csubstantively answered none\u201d of the interrogatories is\n\nnegated by the Motion\u2019s own Exhibit 2, which answers Interrogatory No. 17 with thirteen quoted\n\nGlass Lewis statements and substantively answers Interrogatories 14\u201316 and 20\u201323. Dkt. 109-3 at\n\n5\u20139. In any event, Rule 33(b)(4) excuses an unstated ground \u201cfor good cause,\u201d and a defensible\n\nobjection is \u201csubstantially justified.\u201d Heller v. City of Dallas, 303 F.R.D. 466, 474, 477 (N.D. Tex.\n\n2014). The relief Glass Lewis\u2019s own authority supports, amended responses stating, \u201cwhether any\n\nresponsive materials are being withheld,\u201d Ambler v. Nissen, 2023 WL 443806, at *7 (W.D. Tex.\n\nJan. 26, 2023), is already in hand. And its lead case, LUPE, undermines its claim. There, the\n\nintervenors produced no document \u201cin response to Private Plaintiffs\u2019 twenty outstanding RFPs\u201d\n\nand answered no interrogatory, a qualifier Glass Lewis omits by ellipsis to misleadingly suggest a\n\ncategorical rule. La Union del Pueblo Entero v. Abbott, 2022 WL 17574079, at *3 (W.D. Tex. Dec.\n\n9, 2022); see Dkt. 109 at 5. The Attorney General did the opposite. Nonetheless, waiver is a\n\n\n\n\n                                                 4\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 111         Filed 10/26/26      Page 6 of 12\n\n\n\n\n\u201cserious sanction,\u201d \u201cnot automatic,\u201d reserved for \u201cbad faith[] or other flagrant violations,\u201d not the\n\nshortcomings alleged here; the remedy is an amended response, not forfeiture. Oklahoma Hosp.\n\nMed. Physicians, LLC v. Gottlieb LLC, 2025 WL 3539162, at *3 (N.D. Tex. Dec. 10, 2025); see\n\nEEOC v. BDO USA, L.L.P., 876 F.3d 690, 697 (5th Cir. 2017).\n\nIV.    The Attorney General\u2019s Investigative File Is Irrelevant and Disproportionate.\n\n       As a threshold matter, Glass Lewis must establish relevance, a burden it cannot carry.\n\nEnforcement motive is not an element of the as-applied inquiry, and Glass Lewis\u2019s pretext framing\n\ncannot convert this challenge into a motive case. Nor is S.B. 2337 enforcement investigation\n\nongoing; the preliminary injunction bars it. Glass Lewis\u2019s position is also internally inconsistent.\n\nIf S.B. 2337 is facially viewpoint-based \u201cas a matter of law,\u201d as it contends, then motive is\n\nunnecessary, and the file it seeks proves nothing. If it is not, the Court \u201cwill not strike down an\n\notherwise constitutional statute on the basis of an alleged illicit legislative motive.\u201d United States\n\nv. O\u2019Brien, 391 U.S. 367, 383 (1968); see Reed v. Town of Gilbert, 576 U.S. 155, 165\u201366 (2015).\n\nFurther, the Court\u2019s Rule 56(d) Order is the Attorney General\u2019s remedy, limited to the summary-\n\njudgment issue it identified (whether Glass Lewis\u2019s speech is deceptive) and not a license for a\n\ncounter-investigation into a separate enforcement file. Smith v. Reg\u2019l Transit Auth., 827 F.3d 412,\n\n422\u201323 (5th Cir. 2016). The deception question bears on the Attorney General\u2019s defense, not Glass\n\nLewis\u2019s affirmative claim, and the Court granted that Rule 56(d) discovery on Defendants\u2019 motion.\n\nGlass Lewis has sworn that whether its advice is \u201csolely in the financial interest\u201d of shareholders\n\n\u201cis a matter of judgment and opinion,\u201d and that its \u201creports and recommendations are viewpoints\u201d\n\nthat \u201creflect the opinions\u201d of the firm; its counsel conceded at the preliminary-injunction hearing\n\nthat Glass Lewis provides \u201copinions and advice and recommendations\u201d that are \u201cnot purely\n\nfactual,\u201d and that its viewpoint-discrimination theory rests on \u201cthe text of the statute and \u2026 the\n\n\n\n\n                                                  5\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 111       Filed 10/26/26      Page 7 of 12\n\n\n\n\nlegislative history.\u201d Decl. of John Wieck \u00b6\u00b6 12, 14, 26 (Dkt. 5); Aug. 29, 2025 Prelim. Inj. Hr\u2019g\n\nTr. 34:10\u201318, 16:4\u20137.\n\n       Glass Lewis\u2019s deception theory does not change the analysis, because the burden it invokes\n\nis the State\u2019s own. A government defending a commercial-speech restriction \u201cmust demonstrate\n\nthat the harms it recites are real,\u201d Edenfield v. Fane, 507 U.S. 761, 770\u201371 (1993), and carries that\n\nburden from its own record; whether a statement misleads turns on the statement and its audience,\n\nnot on who complained. Moreover, the State has pleaded its deception case in the State DTPA\n\nAction in detail in its verified Second Amended Petition, based on Glass Lewis\u2019s own public\n\nstatements and admissions, including its January 2023 written admission to the Attorneys General\n\nthat \u201ca significant majority of our clients have elected to simply not follow any Glass Lewis\n\npolicy,\u201d thereby confirming that Glass Lewis does not need anything from the Attorney General\u2019s\n\nprivileged file to test the deception theory. Nwaokoro Resp. Decl. Ex. H. That the Attorney General\n\ncan prove deception from Glass Lewis\u2019s own public statements is all the more reason why the\n\nprivileged file is unnecessary. He has relied on Glass Lewis\u2019s public, non-privileged admissions\n\nand has not placed the file\u2019s contents at issue.\n\n       Glass Lewis\u2019s repeated \u201ctwo-way street\u201d refrain is inapplicable. Glass Lewis uses that\n\nphrase from Wardius v. Oregon, a criminal notice-of-alibi case, while dropping the Supreme\n\nCourt\u2019s express limitation: reciprocity applies only \u201cin the absence of a strong showing of state\n\ninterests to the contrary,\u201d a qualification the Attorney General\u2019s privilege and pending-enforcement\n\ninterests satisfy. 412 U.S. 470, 475\u201376 (1973). Glass Lewis used the same \u201ctwo-way street\u201d in\n\nopposing the Defendants\u2019 motion to compel, using it to resist producing \u201cyears of sensitive\n\ncommunications.\u201d Dkt. 54 at 10. A party that invoked the two-way street to shield its own materials\n\ncannot invoke it to open the State\u2019s privileged enforcement file. That the Attorney General obtained\n\n\n\n\n                                                   6\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 111        Filed 10/26/26      Page 8 of 12\n\n\n\n\nGlass Lewis\u2019s productions to the Missouri and Florida Attorneys General is immaterial. Obtaining\n\na party\u2019s own documents from third parties is not equivalent to opening the State\u2019s privileged file.\n\nAnd in the State DTPA Action, Glass Lewis\u2019s counsel agreed that \u201cmerits discovery should not be\n\nopen and is not open.\u201d Dkt. 109-11 at 3.\n\n       Discovery into the Attorney General\u2019s motive is also barred because this is an official-\n\ncapacity suit, Kentucky v. Graham, 473 U.S. 159, 166 (1985), and the Fifth Circuit has already\n\nquashed discovery aimed at this Attorney General, holding his \u201cthoughts and statements \u2026 have\n\nno bearing on his office\u2019s legal authority to enforce\u201d the law, In re Paxton, 60 F.4th 252, 258\u201359\n\n(5th Cir. 2023); see In re FDIC, 58 F.3d 1055, 1060 (5th Cir. 1995).\n\n       Even if a thin sliver were relevant, compelling the entire investigative and charging file is\n\ndisproportionate. Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(1). A \u201cone-size-fits-all\u201d demand for an entire file \u201cis\n\ninsufficient\u201d absent \u201can individualized showing of relevancy, proportionality, and particularity.\u201d\n\nIn re Xarelto (Rivaroxaban) Prods. Liab. Litig., 313 F.R.D. 32, 36\u201337 (E.D. Tex. 2016). The one\n\nfact Glass Lewis claims it needs, whether any client was deceived or complained, has already been\n\nanswered. The rest of the DTPA file adds nothing and intrudes on a pending enforcement matter,\n\nso the burden \u201coutweighs its likely benefit.\u201d Crosby v. La. Health Serv. & Indem. Co., 647 F.3d\n\n258, 264 (5th Cir. 2011). As the movant, Glass Lewis bears the burden of showing the importance\n\nof the discovery to resolving the case, Samsung Elecs. Am. Inc. v. Yang Kun \u201cMichael\u201d Chung,\n\n325 F.R.D. 578, 591\u201392 (N.D. Tex. 2017). Glass Lewis\u2019s representations that further discovery\n\n\u201cis not needed,\u201d Dkt. 74 at 1, defeat that showing, as does its insistence, when the Defendants\n\nsought discovery, that this case \u201ccan and should be decided at summary judgment\u201d and that\n\n\u201cextensive discovery is unnecessary and disproportionate,\u201d Dkt. 54 at 2, 4. It cannot tell the Court\n\nthat no discovery is needed to win deferral and then demand sweeping discovery into the State\u2019s\n\n\n\n\n                                                 7\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 111        Filed 10/26/26      Page 9 of 12\n\n\n\n\nprivileged file. See New Hampshire v. Maine, 532 U.S. 742, 749 (2001); Occidental Petroleum\n\nCorp. v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., 117 F.4th 628, 639 (5th Cir. 2024).\n\nV.     The Attorney General\u2019s Investigative File Is Privileged, and the Logging Is Proper.\n\n       The Attorney General\u2019s privilege assertion is specific, not \u201cblanket.\u201d Based on Division\n\nChief Stone\u2019s personal review, the Stone Declaration identifies the categories withheld\u2014internal\n\ninvestigative memoranda, attorney and investigator mental impressions, predecisional charging\n\ndeliberations, and informant information\u2014and the basis for each privilege. Stone Decl. (Dkt. 101-\n\n2) \u00b6\u00b6 1\u20135. The deliberative-process privilege protects the charging deliberations, extending to\n\n\u201cpredecisional materials reflecting deliberative or policy-making processes,\u201d including their\n\nfactual analysis, Skelton v. U.S. Postal Serv., 678 F.2d 35, 38 (5th Cir. 1982). The Stone\n\nDeclaration shows that the material is inextricably intertwined with the Division\u2019s evaluation, and\n\ncannot be segregated while enforcement is pending. Stone Decl. \u00b6\u00b6 3\u20135; see De La Cruz v. Blinken,\n\n2021 WL 2709679, at *2\u20133 (W.D. Tex. Mar. 19, 2021). Section 17.61(f)\u2019s bar on disclosing CID\n\nmaterial absent \u201cgood cause,\u201d Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.61(f); see Off. of Att\u2019y Gen. v. PFLAG,\n\nInc., 731 S.W.3d 301, 318 (Tex. 2026), is persuasive authority that reinforces the Rule 26(b)(1)\n\nbalance. And Ambler is not to the contrary. It held only that Texas Local Government Code \u00a7\n\n143.089 does not provide federal privilege but confirmed that federal courts may \u201cconsider state\n\npolicies in weighing the government\u2019s interest in confidentiality.\u201d Ambler, 2023 WL 443806, at\n\n*2.\n\n       The informer\u2019s privilege protects the identity of those who provide information to law\n\nenforcement. Coughlin v. Lee, 946 F.2d 1152, 1159 (5th Cir. 1991). The Attorney General named\n\nthe Alliance for Corporate Excellence. Identifying one source did not waive protection over any\n\nother source, or over the content and evaluative analysis of those communications, which remain\n\n\n\n\n                                                8\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 111        Filed 10/26/26       Page 10 of 12\n\n\n\n\nprotected as opinion work product and under the informer\u2019s privilege. Stone Decl. (Dkt. 101-2) \u00b6\n\n4. The Attorney General\u2019s coordination with aligned defenders of S.B. 2337 is opinion work\n\nproduct that is not waived by same-side sharing. The Attorney General invoked common interest\n\nonly to show non-waiver. Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(3); Hickman v. Taylor, 329 U.S. 495, 510\u201311 (1947).\n\nNon-public communications with the bill\u2019s sponsors, if implicated, fall within the legislative\n\nprivilege. La Union del Pueblo Entero v. Abbott, 68 F.4th 228, 238\u201339 (5th Cir. 2023) (recognizing\n\nstate legislative privilege). Glass Lewis\u2019s demand for the \u201cfacts\u201d fails too. Who the investigators\n\ncontacted and how they evaluated what they learned is itself protected work-product and\n\ninformer\u2019s privilege, and the underlying facts have been answered by interrogatory. Second Am.\n\nResp., Interrog. Nos. 14, 17, 20. The work-product doctrine applies because the file is the\n\nDivision\u2019s litigation work product in the pending State DTPA Action. Compelling it here would\n\nhand Glass Lewis a roadmap to the Attorney General\u2019s evidence, strategy, and attorney mental\n\nimpressions that it cannot obtain in that forum, where merits discovery is stayed. Dkt. 109-11 at 3;\n\nStone Decl. \u00b6\u00b6 2\u20135; see Nwaokoro Resp. Decl. Ex. H (verified Second Amended Petition).\n\n       Finally, there is no logging violation. A privilege log is required only for relevant material\n\nwithheld as privileged, Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co. v. CEVA Logistics Singapore, Ltd., 348 F.R.D.\n\n54, 83 (E.D. La. 2024), and voluminous privileged material may be described by category, Fed. R.\n\nCiv. P. 26(b)(5)(A)(ii) & advisory committee\u2019s note to 1993 amendment. A document-by-\n\ndocument index of an active enforcement file would reveal its scope and sources. Nevertheless,\n\nthe Attorney General logged his S.B. 2337 withholdings and has twice supplemented them.\n\nNwaokoro Reply Decl. (Dkt. 110-1) \u00b6 7 & Ex. B; Nwaokoro Resp. Decl. Ex. B. Waiver applies\n\nonly for \u201cunjustified delay, inexcusable conduct, or bad faith,\u201d and none is present here. BDO, 876\n\nF.3d at 697. In any event, Glass Lewis is in no position to raise logging technicalities because the\n\n\n\n\n                                                 9\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 111         Filed 10/26/26       Page 11 of 12\n\n\n\n\nAttorney General has identified the deficiencies in Glass Lewis\u2019s own October 19 log and served\n\nthem on Glass Lewis on October 23, Nwaokoro Resp. Decl. Ex. E. Glass Lewis\u2019s own logging\n\ndeficiencies are even more pervasive, as the comprehensive catalogue in Exhibit D shows.\n\nVI.    Any Relief Should Be Narrow and Preserve Privilege.\n\n       The Attorney General should not be required to produce or log the investigative and\n\ncharging file, informant identities, predecisional deliberations, legislative communications, or\n\nwork product. If the Court grants any part of the Motion, any further response should be limited\n\nto non-privileged facts relating to the as-applied operation of S.B. 2337, request by request. At\n\nmost, if the Court has doubt, it should permit in camera review of a representative sample rather\n\nthan order production. Because fact discovery closed on October 20, Dkt. 99, relief should not\n\nreopen discovery or extend any deadline. And if the Motion is referred to and decided by a\n\nmagistrate judge, any portion granted over the Attorney General\u2019s objection should be stayed to\n\nallow him to seek review by the District Judge under Rule 72(a) before any production.\n\n                                         CONCLUSION\n\n       Glass Lewis ignored the Court\u2019s discovery-dispute procedure, did not confer, and moves\n\nagainst responses the Attorney General has since superseded and supplemented. On the merits,\n\nGlass Lewis seeks a privileged investigative file that is irrelevant and disproportionate, as an end-\n\nrun around merits discovery it agreed to defer. Alternatively, the Court should deny the Motion or\n\nenter the limits above and briefly stay any adverse portion under Rule 72(a).\n\n\nDated: October 26, 2026.                      Respectfully submitted,\n\n                                              KEN PAXTON\n                                              Attorney General of Texas\n\n                                              BRENT WEBSTER\n                                              First Assistant Attorney General\n\n\n\n                                                 10\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA         Document 111        Filed 10/26/26     Page 12 of 12\n\n\n\n\n                                            RALPH MOLINA\n                                            Deputy First Assistant Attorney General\n\n                                            WILLIAM D. WASSDORF\n                                            Deputy Attorney General for Civil Litigation\n\n                                            KIMBERLY GDULA\n                                            Chief, General Litigation Division\n\n                                            /s/ Joe Nwaokoro\n                                            JOE NWAOKORO\n                                            Attorney-in-Charge\n                                            Texas Bar No. 24032916\n                                            Assistant Attorney General\n                                            P.O. Box 12548, Capitol Station\n                                            Austin, Texas 78711-2548\n                                            (512) 979-5382 | FAX: (512) 320-0667\n                                            Joe.Nwaokoro@oag.texas.gov\n\n                                            Defendant Ken Paxton, in his official capacity as\n                                            Attorney General of Texas\n\n                               CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\n\n       I certify that on October 26, 2026, a true and correct copy of the foregoing was filed\n\nelectronically through the Court\u2019s CM/ECF system, which will send notice of electronic filing to\n\nall counsel of record.\n\n\n                                            /s/ Joe Nwaokoro\n                                            JOE NWAOKORO\n                                            Assistant Attorney General\n\n\n\n\n                                              11\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2026-10-27T08:14:06.664923-07:00","document_number":"111","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"181037687571","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Response to Motion","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/498771583/","id":498771583,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/111/1/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-27T08:13:40.376301-07:00","date_modified":"2026-11-03T06:22:32.903436-08:00","sha1":"fce91b245fb40347c930b49a5f3aef1b06d10994","page_count":119,"file_size":1182119,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.111.1.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.111.1.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA         Document 111-1        Filed 10/26/26      Page 1 of 119\n\n\n\n\n                       IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                        FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS\n                                  AUSTIN DIVISION\n GLASS, LEWIS & CO., LLC                         \u00a7\n      Plaintiff,                                 \u00a7\n                                                 \u00a7\n v.                                              \u00a7\n                                                 \u00a7\n KEN PAXTON, in his Official Capacity as         \u00a7\n                                                                Civil Action No.\n Attorney General of Texas                       \u00a7\n                                                              1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n        Defendant,                               \u00a7\n                                                 \u00a7\n THE TEXAS STOCK EXCHANGE LLC                    \u00a7\n and THE TEXAS ASSOCIATION OF                    \u00a7\n BUSINESS,                                       \u00a7\n       Intervenor-Defendants.                    \u00a7\n\n\n DECLARATION OF JOE NWAOKORO IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT ATTORNEY\n GENERAL\u2019S OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF\u2019S MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY\n                           RESPONSES\n\n\n        I, Joe Nwaokoro, declare under penalty of perjury pursuant to 28 U.S.C. \u00a7 1746 that the\n\nfollowing is true and correct:\n\n        1.     I am an Assistant Attorney General in the Office of the Attorney General of Texas\n\nand counsel of record for Defendant Ken Paxton, in his official capacity as Attorney General of\n\nTexas (the \u201cAttorney General\u201d), in this action. I submit this Declaration in support of the Attorney\n\nGeneral\u2019s Response to Plaintiff Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC\u2019s (\u201cGlass Lewis\u201d) Motion to Compel\n\nDiscovery Responses (the \u201cResponse\u201d). The statements below are based on my personal\n\nknowledge and my review of the files maintained by the Office of the Attorney General in the\n\nordinary course of this litigation. If called as a witness, I could and would testify competently to\n\nthese facts.\n\f    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26     Page 2 of 119\n\n\n\n\n       2.      This Declaration authenticates the exhibits cited in the Response and describes the\n\nAttorney General\u2019s written-discovery responses, privilege log, and the parties\u2019 communications\n\nafter Glass Lewis filed its Motion on October 19, 2026. I incorporate by reference my prior\n\nDeclaration filed with the Attorney General\u2019s Reply in support of his Motion for Protective Order\n\n(Dkt. 110-1) (the \u201cNwaokoro Reply Declaration\u201d) and its exhibits, my Declaration filed with the\n\nAttorney General\u2019s Motion for Protective Order (Dkt. 101-1), and the Declaration of Division\n\nChief Johnathan Stone (Dkt. 101-2).\n\n       3.      As set forth in the Nwaokoro Reply Declaration, the Attorney General served\n\namended objections and responses, a document production, and an itemized privilege log on\n\nOctober 16, 2026, and served his Second Amended Objections and Responses, a supplemental\n\nproduction, and a supplemental privilege log on October 20, 2026.\n\n       4.      On October 22, 2026, at 2:35 p.m., Jared LeBrun, counsel for Glass Lewis, sent me\n\nand co-counsel an email identifying what Glass Lewis contended were deficiencies in the Attorney\n\nGeneral\u2019s privilege log and discovery responses, including claimed internal inconsistencies\n\nregarding the Alliance for Corporate Excellence, objections to the common-interest and work-\n\nproduct designations, and a contention that the log was incomplete. The email demanded that the\n\nAttorney General confirm by the end of the following day that he would produce certain\n\ncommunications, withdraw his work-product assertions, and individually log each withheld\n\ndocument. A true and correct copy of that email, and the email thread that followed, is attached as\n\nExhibit C.\n\n       5.      On October 23, 2026, the Attorney General responded to each of Glass Lewis\u2019s\n\npoints and served supplemental discovery materials. At 3:38 p.m., I sent Mr. LeBrun a written\n\nresponse addressing his concerns item by item and stating that the Attorney General remained\n\f    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 111-1        Filed 10/26/26      Page 3 of 119\n\n\n\n\navailable to confer. At 5:56 p.m., the Attorney General served, by email, the Attorney General\u2019s\n\nSupplemental Objections and Responses to Plaintiff\u2019s Second Set of Interrogatories and Second\n\nSet of Requests for Production, the Attorney General\u2019s Second Amended Privilege Log, and a\n\nchart identifying deficiencies in Glass Lewis\u2019s own privilege log. Both emails are included in\n\nExhibit C.\n\n       6.      The Attorney General\u2019s Supplemental Objections and Responses, served October\n\n23, 2026, conformed the objections to Interrogatories 14 and 20 and supplemented the responses\n\nto Requests for Production 24 and 27. A true and correct copy is attached as Exhibit A.\n\n       7.      The Attorney General\u2019s Second Amended Privilege Log, served October 23, 2026,\n\nlists each withheld item separately, with its author, date, and recipients. In preparing it, the\n\nAttorney General located the first two drafts of the document logged as DOC000001 and logged\n\nthose drafts individually. On October 26, 2026, after Glass Lewis\u2019s counsel advised that several\n\ncells had been truncated when the log was converted to PDF for service on October 23, 2026, the\n\nAttorney General re-served the Second Amended Privilege Log in corrected form so that each\n\nentry displays in full. The corrected log is identical in substance to the version served on October\n\n23, 2026; no entry, description, or privilege assertion was changed. A true and correct copy of the\n\ncorrected Second Amended Privilege Log is attached as Exhibit B.\n\n       8.      As reflected in the Supplemental Objections and Responses and the Second\n\nAmended Privilege Log, after a diligent search, the Attorney General has no responsive, non-\n\nprivileged documents concerning the Alliance for Corporate Excellence to produce. The Attorney\n\nGeneral\u2019s communications with the United States Department of Justice, the Office of the Indiana\n\nAttorney General, and counsel for the Alliance are withheld as attorney work product, and the\n\nSecond Amended Privilege Log states that basis and the grounds for each entry. The Attorney\n\f    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26      Page 4 of 119\n\n\n\n\nGeneral does not assert common interest as an independent ground for withholding any document;\n\nthe designation is on the log to explain why sharing these materials with aligned, non-adverse\n\ncounsel did not waive the work-product protection.\n\n       9.      Attached as Exhibit D is a true and correct copy of a chart showing the\n\ncomprehensive deficiencies in Glass Lewis\u2019s October 19, 2026 privilege log.\n\n       10.     The chart the Attorney General served on October 23, 2026 identifies entries in\n\nGlass Lewis\u2019s October 19, 2026 privilege log that reflect the same categories of deficiency Glass\n\nLewis attributes to the Attorney General (automated notifications, public-statute attachments,\n\nbusiness emails with no attorney on them, communications sent to outside domains and personal\n\naccounts, work-product claims unsupported by any anticipated litigation, drafts meant for\n\npublication or clients and factual status emails, and entries too thin to evaluate under Rule\n\n26(b)(5)(A)) and states, for each, the specific deficiency and the requested cure. A true and correct\n\ncopy of the chart is attached as Exhibit E.\n\n       11.     Attached as Exhibit F is a true and correct copy of a chart that matches, request by\n\nrequest, each challenged request in Glass Lewis\u2019s second set to the request in its first set that it\n\nduplicates, drawn from the Attorney General\u2019s cumulativeness objections. The Attorney General\n\nanswered Glass Lewis\u2019s first set of discovery on October 31, 2025.\n\n       12.     Attached as Exhibit G is a true and correct copy of a chart that pairs each of the\n\nAttorney General\u2019s Second-Set Interrogatories 14-25 and Requests for Production 22-36, the\n\nrequests Glass Lewis\u2019s Motion claims were refused, with the Attorney General\u2019s actual responses,\n\nserved October 16 and superseded and supplemented on October 20 and 23, 2026, identifying for\n\neach the substantive answer, the answer by reference, or the responsive, non-privileged documents\n\nproduced at Bates range AG 002090-AG 003289.\n\f    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26     Page 5 of 119\n\n\n\n\n       13.     Attached as Exhibit H is a true and correct copy of the State\u2019s verified Second\n\nAmended Petition in the State DTPA Action, State v. Glass, Lewis & Co., No. 471-04895-2026\n\n(471st Dist. Ct., Collin County), which pleads the State\u2019s deceptive-trade-practices claim against\n\nGlass Lewis in detail, drawn from Glass Lewis\u2019s own public statements and admissions.\n\n       14.     The following exhibits are attached to this Declaration:\n\n               a.     Exhibit A: Attorney General\u2019s Supplemental Objections and Responses to\n\n                      Plaintiff\u2019s Second Set of Interrogatories and Second Set of Requests for\n\n                      Production (served October 23, 2026);\n\n               b.     Exhibit B: Attorney General\u2019s Second Amended Privilege Log (served\n\n                      October 23, 2026; re-served in corrected form October 26, 2026);\n\n               c.     Exhibit C: Email thread between Jared LeBrun and Joe Nwaokoro, dated\n\n                      October 22-23, 2026, including the Attorney General\u2019s October 23, 2026\n\n                      transmittal of the materials in Exhibits A, B, and E;\n\n               d.     Exhibit D: Comprehensive Deficiencies in Glass Lewis\u2019s October 19, 2026\n\n                      Privilege Log (chart);\n\n               e.     Exhibit E: Deficiencies in Glass Lewis\u2019s October 19, 2026 Privilege Log\n\n                      (chart) (served October 23, 2026);\n\n               f.     Exhibit F: Chart matching each challenged second-set discovery request to\n\n                      the duplicative first-set request;\n\n               g.     Exhibit G: Chart pairing Glass Lewis\u2019s challenged second-set requests\n\n                      (Interrogatories 14-25 and Requests for Production 22-36) with the\n\n                      Attorney General\u2019s actual responses and production; and\n\f    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26      Page 6 of 119\n\n\n\n\n              h.      Exhibit H: State\u2019s verified Second Amended Petition in State v. Glass,\n\n                      Lewis & Co., No. 471-04895-2026 (471st Dist. Ct., Collin County).\n\n       I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.\n\n\nExecuted on October 26, 2026, in Houston, Texas.\n\n\n                                             /s/ Joe Nwaokoro\n                                             JOE NWAOKORO\n                                             Texas Bar No. 24032916\n                                             Assistant Attorney General\n                                             General Litigation Division\n                                             Office of the Attorney General of Texas\n\fCase 1:25-cv-01153-ADA   Document 111-1   Filed 10/26/26   Page 7 of 119\n\n\n\n\n                    EXHIBIT A\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA         Document 111-1        Filed 10/26/26        Page 8 of 119\n\n\n\n\n                            UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                             WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS\n                                   AUSTIN DIVISION\n\n GLASS, LEWIS & CO., LLC                 \u00a7\n      Plaintiff,                         \u00a7\n                                         \u00a7\n v.                                      \u00a7\n                                         \u00a7\n KEN PAXTON, in his Official Capacity as \u00a7\n                                                  Civil Action No.\n Attorney General of Texas               \u00a7\n                                                1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n        Defendant,                       \u00a7\n                                         \u00a7\n THE TEXAS STOCK EXCHANGE LLC            \u00a7\n and THE TEXAS ASSOCIATION OF            \u00a7\n BUSINESS,                               \u00a7\n        Intervenor-Defendants.           \u00a7\n______________________________________________________________________________\n\n DEFENDANT THE ATTORNEY GENERAL\u2019S SUPPLEMENTAL OBJECTIONS AND\n       RESPONSES TO PLAINTIFF\u2019S SECOND SET OF INTERROGATORIES AND\n        SECOND SET OF REQUESTS FOR THE PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS\n______________________________________________________________________________\n\nTO:     Plaintiff, Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC, through its counsel of record, Bryce L. Callahan, Yetter\n        Coleman LLP, 600 Travis Street, Suite 5400, Houston, Texas 77002.\n\n        Defendant Ken Paxton, in his official capacity as Attorney General of Texas (\u201cDefendant\u201d\n\nor the \u201cOffice\u201d), submits these Supplemental Objections and Responses to Plaintiff Glass, Lewis\n\n& Co., LLC\u2019s (\u201cGlass Lewis\u201d) Second Set of Interrogatories and Second Set of Requests for\n\nProduction.\n\n\nDated: October 23, 2026.                      Respectfully submitted,\n\n                                              KEN PAXTON\n                                              Attorney General of Texas\n\n                                              BRENT WEBSTER\n                                              First Assistant Attorney General\n\n                                              RALPH MOLINA\n                                              Deputy First Assistant Attorney General\n\n\n\nDefendant AG\u2019s Supplemental Objections & Responses to Plaintiff\u2019s 2nd ROGs & RFPs                1\n\f    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 111-1       Filed 10/26/26     Page 9 of 119\n\n\n\n\n                                            WILLIAM D. WASSDORF\n                                            Deputy Attorney General for Civil Litigation\n\n                                            KIMBERLY GDULA\n                                            Chief, General Litigation Division\n                                            /s/ Joe Nwaokoro\n                                            JOE NWAOKORO\n                                            Attorney-in-Charge\n                                            Texas Bar No. 24032916\n                                            Assistant Attorney General\n                                            P.O. Box 12548, Capitol Station\n                                            Austin, Texas 78711-2548\n                                            (512) 979-5382 | FAX: (512) 477-2348\n                                            Joe.Nwaokoro@oag.texas.gov\n\n                                            Defendant Ken Paxton, in his official capacity as\n                                            Attorney General of Texas\n\n\n                                 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\n\n       I certify that on October 23, 2026, a true and correct copy of the foregoing was served on\n\nall counsel of record by electronic mail.\n\n\n                                            /s/ Joe Nwaokoro\n                                            JOE NWAOKORO\n                                            Assistant Attorney General\n\n\n\n\nDefendant AG\u2019s Supplemental Objections & Responses to Plaintiff\u2019s 2nd ROGs & RFPs              2\n\f   Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26      Page 10 of 119\n\n\n\n\n                          DEFENDANT\u2019S GENERAL OBJECTIONS\n\n    Each of these general objections is deemed incorporated into Defendant\u2019s specific objections\nto each individual request:\n        1.      Defendant objects to each request for production and interrogatory to the extent that\nit seeks materials protected from discovery by the attorney-client privilege, the work product\ndoctrine, the common-interest doctrine, the investigative privilege, the law-enforcement privilege,\nthe informer's privilege, the deliberative process privilege, or any other applicable privilege or\nprotection. To the extent that each request seeks such privileged or protected material, Defendant\nclaims such privilege and invokes such protection. Defendant does not intend to waive, and shall\nnot be construed as having waived, any such privilege or protection by failing to make a specific\nobjection.\n\n        2.     Defendant objects to each request for production and interrogatory to the extent that\nit is vague, overly broad, and fails to specify the materials sought with reasonable particularity.\nDefendant will attempt to construe the request in a reasonable manner in providing a response.\n\n       3.      Defendant objects to the definitions and instructions to Plaintiff\u2019s Second Request\nfor Production and Second Set of Interrogatories on the grounds that they are overly broad, render\nthe requests unduly burdensome, and exceed what is required by the Federal Rules of Civil\nProcedure. See Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(1), 34.\n\n        4.      Defendant objects to each request for production to the extent it seeks documents\nnot in Defendant\u2019s possession, custody, or control. Defendant can only produce those documents\nin his possession, custody, or control.\n\n       5.      Defendant objects to each request to the extent it seeks information that is irrelevant\nto any party\u2019s claim or defense or not proportional to the needs of the case. See Fed. R. Civ. P.\n26(b)(1).\n\n        6.     Defendant incorporates by reference his objections and preliminary statement in\nhis prior responses to Plaintiff\u2019s Second Request for Production and Second Set of\nInterrogatories.\n\n                                              SCOPE\n\n       These Supplemental Objections and Responses supplement and supersede only the\nresponses to Interrogatory Nos. 14 and 20 and Requests for Production Nos. 24 and 27 in\nDefendant\u2019s Second Amended Objections and Responses served October 20, 2026. Otherwise,\nthe October 20, 2026 service remains in effect and is incorporated by reference.\n\n\n\n\nDefendant AG\u2019s Supplemental Objections & Responses to Plaintiff\u2019s 2nd ROGs & RFPs                  3\n\f   Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26     Page 11 of 119\n\n\n\n\n       SUPPLEMENTAL OBJECTIONS AND RESPONSES TO SECOND SET OF\n                         INTERROGATORIES\n\n\n       INTERROGATORY NO. 14: Identify each Texas resident, consumer, customer,\ncompany, or shareholder that You contend has been deceived or misled by any statement made by\nGlass Lewis in connection with its provision of proxy advisory services, and for each, describe the\nstatement and the manner in which You contend that person was deceived or misled.\n         OBJECTIONS: Defendant objects that identification of persons deceived in the State\nDTPA Action is not relevant to whether S.B. 2337 is unconstitutional as applied to Glass Lewis\nand is not proportional to the needs of this case. Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(1). Defendant objects that\nthe identity of persons, other than the Alliance for Corporate Excellence, whose identity Defendant\nhas disclosed, who furnished information to the Consumer Protection Division (the \"Division\") is\nprotected by the informer's privilege (Decl. of Johnathan Stone, Dkt. 101-2 (\"Stone Decl.\") 4);\nDefendant's disclosure of the Alliance's identity does not waive that privilege as to any other\nsource. The content of the information furnished to the Division, and the Division's evaluation of\nit, is protected by the law-enforcement privilege, the deliberative-process privilege, and the work-\nproduct doctrine (Stone Decl. 2-3, 5). Defendant objects that the interrogatory is cumulative of\nFirst Set Interrogatory No. 11, answered October 31, 2025. Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(2)(C)(i). Subject\nto these objections, Defendant answers as follows:\n\n        ANSWER: Defendant's contentions concerning Glass Lewis's statements are pleaded in\nthe verified petition in the State DTPA Action (Dkt. 101-1) (\"Pet.\") 13-38 and the statements are\nidentified in the Answer to Interrogatory No. 17. Defendant refers Glass Lewis to its prior\nidentification of the Alliance for Corporate Excellence as a person who furnished information to\nthe Division, and to Defendant's Answer to First Set Interrogatory No. 11. As stated there, counsel\nfor the Alliance identified only, and generally, the Alliance's belief that Glass Lewis makes false\nor misleading statements to its customers. Besides the Alliance for Corporate Excellence, no other\nperson furnished information to the Division concerning Glass Lewis's statements.\n\n      INTERROGATORY NO. 20: Identify each Texas-based client of Glass Lewis that has\ncomplained to You about Glass Lewis, and for each, state the date of the complaint, the person\nwho made it, the manner in which it was communicated, and its substance.\n\n       OBJECTIONS: Defendant objects that the interrogatory seeks information that is not\nrelevant to the as-applied challenge or proportional to the needs of this case. Fed. R. Civ. P.\n26(b)(1). Defendant objects that the identity of persons, other than the Alliance for Corporate\nExcellence, whose identity Defendant has disclosed, who furnished information to the Division,\nand documents tending to reveal their identity, are protected by the informer's privilege (Stone\nDecl. 4); Defendant's disclosure of the Alliance's identity does not waive that privilege as to any\nother source. The content of the information furnished, and the Division's evaluation of it, is\n\n\nDefendant AG\u2019s Supplemental Objections & Responses to Plaintiff\u2019s 2nd ROGs & RFPs                4\n\f   Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26      Page 12 of 119\n\n\n\n\nprotected by the law-enforcement privilege, the deliberative-process privilege, and the work-\nproduct doctrine (Stone Decl. 2-3, 5). Defendant objects that the interrogatory is cumulative and\nduplicative of First Set Interrogatory No. 11 and of Interrogatory No. 14 of this Set. Fed. R. Civ.\nP. 26(b)(2)(C)(i). Subject to these objections, Defendant answers as follows:\n\n       ANSWER: Defendant has not received a complaint about Glass Lewis from any person it\nknows to be a Texas-based client of Glass Lewis. Defendant is not aware that the Alliance for\nCorporate Excellence, identified in Defendant's answer to First Set Interrogatory No. 11, is a client\nof Glass Lewis, and does not have information regarding its state of organization or principal place\nof business.\n\n\n\n\nDefendant AG\u2019s Supplemental Objections & Responses to Plaintiff\u2019s 2nd ROGs & RFPs                 5\n\f   Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26      Page 13 of 119\n\n\n\n\nSUPPLEMENTAL OBJECTIONS AND RESPONSES TO SECOND SET OF REQUESTS\n                       FOR PRODUCTION\n\n\n        REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION NO. 24: All documents concerning any complaint,\nreport, or communication received by the Office of the Attorney General from any consumer,\ncustomer, company, or shareholder asserting that Glass Lewis made a false or misleading\nstatement, and all documents sufficient to show any deception or harm You contend resulted.\n\n        OBJECTIONS: Defendant objects that the Division's complaint intake is not relevant to\nthe as-applied challenge or proportional to the needs of this case. Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(1).\nDefendant objects that the identity of any person, other than the Alliance for Corporate Excellence,\nwho furnished such information is protected by the informer's privilege, and that the content of\nany such materials and the Division's evaluation of them are protected by the law-enforcement\nprivilege, the deliberative-process privilege, and the work-product doctrine as part of the Division's\nconfidential DTPA investigative file (Stone Decl. 2-5). Defendant objects that the request is\ncumulative of First Set Request Nos. 11, 12, and 13. Defendant refers Glass Lewis to the Answers\nto Interrogatory Nos. 14 and 17. Subject to these objections, Defendant responds as follows:\n\n        RESPONSE: Defendant refers Glass Lewis to its prior identification of the Alliance for\nCorporate Excellence and to the Answer to Interrogatory No. 14. Other than the Alliance for\nCorporate Excellence, Defendant has identified no other person who furnished such information.\nAfter a diligent search, Defendant has no documents to produce.\n\n       REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION NO. 27: All communications and documents\nexchanged between You and the Alliance for Corporate Excellence, Foley & Lardner LLP, or\nPeter Loh concerning Glass Lewis, proxy advisors, or S.B. 2337.\n\n        OBJECTIONS: Defendant objects that communications between Office counsel and\ncounsel for the Alliance for Corporate Excellence, which has since appeared as amicus curiae in\nthis action, Dkt. 26, were exchanged in furtherance of a common legal interest in defending S.B.\n2337 and are protected work product. Defendant further objects that the informer's privilege\nprotects the identity of any source other than the Alliance, whose identity Defendant has disclosed,\nand that communications reflecting the motive behind S.B. 2337's enactment are not relevant to\nthe as-applied challenge. Subject to these objections, Defendant responds as follows:\n        RESPONSE: Defendant is withholding the communications with counsel for the Alliance\nidentified on its privilege log and has located no other responsive communications.\n\n\n\n\nDefendant AG\u2019s Supplemental Objections & Responses to Plaintiff\u2019s 2nd ROGs & RFPs                  6\n\f   Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26     Page 14 of 119\n\n\n\n\n                                        VERIFICATION\n\n       I, Assistant Attorney General Joe Nwaokoro, am authorized to make this verification on\n\nbehalf of Defendant. I have read the foregoing answers to Plaintiff\u2019s Second Set of Interrogatories,\n\nand the factual statements in them are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information,\n\nand belief, based on information assembled by authorized personnel of the Office of the Attorney\n\nGeneral.\n\n\nExecuted on October 23, 2026.\n                                              /s/ Joe Nwaokoro\n                                              JOE NWAOKORO\n                                              Assistant Attorney General\n\n\n\n\nDefendant AG\u2019s Supplemental Objections & Responses to Plaintiff\u2019s 2nd ROGs & RFPs                7\n\fCase 1:25-cv-01153-ADA   Document 111-1   Filed 10/26/26   Page 15 of 119\n\n\n\n\n                    EXHIBIT B\n\fDEFENDANT'S SECOND AMENDED PRIVILEGE LOG \u2014 Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC v. Paxton, No. 1:25-cv-01153-ADA (W.D. Tex.); Oct. 23, 2026\nKey: AC = attorney-client privilege; WP = work product (Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(3)); DPP = deliberative-process privilege; CI = common-interest doctrine (asserted only as the basis on which disclosure to an aligned, non-adversary third party did not waive work product; not an independent ground of withholding); * =\nattorney. This log amends and replaces the previous privilege logs dated October 16 and October 20, 2026, and is supported by the Declaration of Johnathan Stone (Dkt. 101-2).\n\n\n No.    Doc. ID / Bates            Date(s)                             Type                          Author (* = attorney)                          Recipients (To / CC)                                            Description and basis                           Protection                       Treatment\n  1 DOC000051 (version 1 of 8/11/2025                          Word memorandum                Christopher Molak*                         CPD management and executive,                   First draft of the internal memorandum from a Division attorney to       AC; WP; DPP                 Withhold\n     3)                                                                                                                                  including Johnathan Stone (Division             Division management providing legal analysis and enforcement\n                                                                                                                                         Chief) and Jerry Bergman (Deputy                recommendations concerning proxy advisors under the DTPA,\n                                                                                                                                         Division Chief); Clayton Watkins*               prepared in anticipation of enforcement litigation. Predecisional draft\n                                                                                                                                         (Assistant Attorney General); Jennifer          reflecting counsel's mental impressions; the later versions are withheld\n                                                                                                                                         Roscetti* (Deputy Chief)                        at Entries 2 and 3.\n  2    DOC000052 (version 2 of 8/14/2025                       Word memorandum                Christopher Molak*                         CPD management and executive,                   Second draft of the same internal memorandum (see Entries 1 and 3) AC; WP; DPP                       Withhold\n       3)                                                                                                                                including Johnathan Stone (Division             reflecting counsel's continued revisions, legal analysis, and mental\n                                                                                                                                         Chief) and Jerry Bergman (Deputy                impressions concerning proxy advisors under the DTPA, prepared in\n                                                                                                                                         Division Chief); Clayton Watkins*               anticipation of enforcement litigation. Predecisional draft.\n                                                                                                                                         (Assistant Attorney General); Jennifer\n                                                                                                                                         Roscetti* (Deputy Chief)\n  3    DOC000001 (version 3 of 8/14/2025                       Word memorandum                Christopher Molak*                         CPD management and executive,                   Final version of the internal memorandum concerning proxy advisors               AC; WP; DPP         Withhold\n       3)                                                                                                                                including Johnathan Stone (Division             under the DTPA (see Entries 1 and 2).\n                                                                                                                                         Chief) and Jerry Bergman (Deputy\n                                                                                                                                         Division Chief); Clayton Watkins*\n                                                                                                                                         (Assistant Attorney General); Jennifer\n                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n\n\n\n\n                                                                                                                                         Roscetti* (Deputy Chief)\n  4    AG_002098 (email 1 of 2) 9/10/2025                      Email                          Lee Winkelman*                             Christopher Molak*; Gina McDonald               Internal Division email seeking legal input on the Office's response to   AC; WP                     Produce w/ redaction\n                                                                                                                                         (Division investigator)                         Glass Lewis counsel's 9/10/2025 CID email. Glass Lewis counsel's\n                                                                                                                                                                                         own quoted text is produced; the request for legal input and the Office's\n                                                                                                                                                                                         internal analysis are redacted.\n  5    AG_002098 (email 2 of 2) 9/11/2025                      Email                          Gina McDonald (Division                    Jennifer Roscetti*; Clayton Watkins*;           Internal email within the OAG's confidential consultation on its          AC; WP                     Withhold\n                                                                                              investigator); forwarded by                Scott Froman*                                   response to the Glass Lewis CID, forwarded among Division counsel.\n                                                                                              Christopher Molak*\n  6    AG_002108                      9/10/2025                Email                          Jerry Bergman* (Deputy Chief,              Christopher Molak*; cc Jennifer Roscetti*, Internal Division email routing the CID inquiry to the assigned Division              WP; DPP             Produce w/ redaction\n                                                                                              Division)                                  Clayton Watkins*, Scott Froman*            team. Glass Lewis counsel's quoted CID text is produced; the OAG's\n                                                                                                                                                                                    internal case-handling comment is redacted.\n\n  7    AG_002110 (email 1 of 2) 9/10/2025                      Email                          Lee Winkelman*                             Jerry Bergman*                                  Forward of Glass Lewis counsel's 9/10/2025 email with the forwarding             AC; WP              Produce w/ redaction\n                                                                                                                                                                                         attorney's comments. Glass Lewis counsel's text is produced; OAG\n                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Document 111-1\n\n\n\n\n                                                                                                                                                                                         attorney's comments are redacted.\n  8    AG_002110 (email 2 of 2) 9/10/2025                      Email                          Jerry Bergman*                             Lee Winkelman*; Jennifer Roscetti*; cc          Same-day reply among OAG attorneys routing the CID inquiry to the                AC; WP              Produce w/ redaction\n                                                                                                                                         Clayton Watkins*, Scott Froman*                 assigned team; the internal comment is redacted; remaining text is\n                                                                                                                                                                                         produced.\n  9    DOC000022                      10/28/2025 (filed        Word memorandum                Jennifer Roscetti* (Deputy Chief)          Division attorneys and management               Internal memorandum reflecting OAG attorney's legal analysis and                 AC; WP; DPP         Withhold\n                                      10/29/2025)                                             (author); Clayton Watkins* (listed in      within the Office of the Attorney General       mental impressions concerning S.B. 2337 and Glass Lewis, prepared\n                                                                                              the document's metadata as                                                                 in anticipation of litigation.\n                                                                                              custodian (document owner/last-\n                                                                                              saved-by))\n 10    DOC000023                      10/28/2025 (filed        Word memorandum                Jennifer Roscetti* (Deputy Chief)          Division attorneys and management               Annotated iteration of the memorandum at Entry 9, bearing                        AC; WP; DPP         Withhold\n                                      10/30/2025)              (annotated)                    (author); Clayton Watkins* (listed in      within the Office of the Attorney General       interlineated comments and edits (in red and blue) from multiple\n                                                                                              the document's metadata as                                                                 Division attorneys reflecting their legal feedback and mental\n                                                                                              custodian (document owner/last-                                                            impressions, and incorporating supporting case-law research by Scott\n                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Filed 10/26/26\n\n\n\n\n                                                                                              saved-by))                                                                                 Froman* (Division attorney). Opinion work product.\n 11    DOC000025                      8/25/2025 (filed         Microsoft Teams                William Wassdorf* (Associate               Same participants                               Internal OAG conversation among an Associate Deputy Attorney                     DPP                 Withhold\n                                      9/22/2025)               conversation                   Deputy Attorney General); Rebecca                                                          General and Office staff deliberating how OAG would implement S.B.\n                                                                                              Cabrera (Compliance Analyst);                                                              2337's reporting mechanism. Predecisional and deliberative agency\n                                                                                              Michael O'Leary (Data Analyst)                                                             decision-making.\n\n 12    DOC000029                      9/14/2026                Email string                   Joe Nwaokoro*; H. Christopher              Each other; cc Stephanie Freudenberg*           Communications between OAG counsel and outside counsel for the          WP; CI                       Withhold\n                                                                                              Bartolomucci* (Schaerr Jaffe,              (Schaerr Jaffe)                                 Indiana Attorney General concerning the parallel litigation defending\n                                                                                              outside counsel for the Indiana                                                            similar statutes (ISS & Glass Lewis v. Rokita), exchanged in\n                                                                                              Attorney General)                                                                          furtherance of a common legal interest.\n 13    DOC000030                      9/15, 9/17, 9/24,        Email string                   Troy Sager (paralegal, Office of the       Each other                                      Cover emails between OAG counsel's staff and counsel for the Indiana WP; CI                          Withhold cover emails;\n                                      9/28/2026                                               Attorney General); John Lowrey*,                                                           Attorney General coordinating the exchange of deposition transcripts in                              attachments are public\n                                                                                              James Barta* (Indiana Attorney                                                             the parallel Indiana (Rokita) litigation defending similar statutes, in                              record\n                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Page 16 of 119\n\n\n\n\n                                                                                              General's Office)                                                                          furtherance of a common legal interest. The attached Wieck and\n                                                                                                                                                                                         Goldstein deposition transcripts and the Seventh Circuit appendix have\n                                                                                                                                                                                         been produced.\n\f14   DOC000031 (email 1 of 3) 8/4/2025               Email (PDF)                John Sepehri* (Foley & Lardner,     William Wassdorf*; Lee Winkelman*;        Originating email coordinating the defense of S.B. 2337 among Office          WP; CI   Withhold\n                                                                                counsel for the Alliance for        Abhishek Kambli* (U.S. DOJ); cc Ketan     counsel, U.S. Department of Justice counsel, and the Alliance's\n                                                                                Corporate Excellence)               Bhirud* (U.S. DOJ), Austin Kinghorn*,     counsel (Foley), concerning potential federal participation in the\n                                                                                                                    and other Foley & Lardner personnel       litigation and the timing of the State's responsive filings, in furtherance\n                                                                                                                    (Converse, Babcock, Burbach, Cabrales)    of a common legal interest.\n\n15   DOC000031 (email 2 of 3) 8/5/2025               Email (PDF)                Lee Winkelman*                   John Sepehri* (Foley); William            Reply to the aligned-counsel group regarding the timing of the State's WP; CI             Withhold\n                                                                                                                 Wassdorf*; Abhishek Kambli* (U.S. DOJ); responsive filings in the defense of S.B. 2337.\n                                                                                                                 cc Ketan Bhirud* (U.S. DOJ), Austin\n                                                                                                                 Kinghorn*, and other Foley & Lardner\n                                                                                                                 personnel\n16   DOC000031 (email 3 of 3) 8/6/2025 (two          Email (PDF)                John Sepehri* (Foley); Lee       Each other; cc Laura Hendrix (Office of   8/6/2025 exchange among aligned counsel regarding the timing of the WP; CI                Withhold\n                              messages)                                         Winkelman*                       the Attorney General staff)               State's response to the preliminary-injunction motions, in furtherance of\n                                                                                                                                                           the joint defense.\n17   DOC000032                8/6\u20138/11/2025          Email string (PDF)         Lee Winkelman*; John Sepehri*    Each other; cc Laura Hendrix (Office of   Continuation of the OAG/ DOJ / Foley coordination thread regarding        WP; CI          Withhold\n                                                                                (Foley & Lardner)                the Attorney General staff)               the schedule for, and the State's response to, the preliminary-injunction\n                                                                                                                                                           motions, in furtherance of the joint defense.\n18   DOC000038                8/4\u20138/13/2025          Email string (PDF)         John Sepehri* (Foley & Lardner,  Each other; cc Laura Hendrix (Office of   OAG / DOJ / Foley coordination thread arranging a call among aligned WP; CI               Withhold\n                                                                                counsel for the Alliance for     the Attorney General staff); the 8/4/2025 defense counsel to coordinate the joint defense of S.B. 2337 and the\n                                                                                Corporate Excellence); Lee       originating email also to William         preliminary-injunction response, in furtherance of a common legal\n                                                                                Winkelman*                       Wassdorf* and Abhishek Kambli* (U.S.      interest.\n                                                                                                                 DOJ), cc Ketan Bhirud* (U.S. DOJ),\n                                                                                                                 Austin Kinghorn*, and other Foley &\n                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n\n\n\n\n                                                                                                                 Lardner personnel\n19   DOC000036                8/8\u20138/12/2025          Email string (PDF)         Mark W. Rasmussen*, Sidney Smith Among the same OAG and Jones Day          Email thread between OAG counsel and Jones Day exchanged after            WP; CI          Withhold\n                                                                                McClung* (Jones Day); Lee        counsel; cc other Jones Day attorneys     Glass Lewis filed suit, conveying counsel's mental impressions and\n                                                                                Winkelman*, William Wassdorf*    (Ferrell Keel, Charlotte Taylor, A.J.     litigation strategy for the defense and coordinating the joint defense.\n                                                                                (Office of the Attorney General) Jeffries, John Henry Thompson, Hannah Opinion work product exchanged in furtherance of a common legal\n                                                                                                                 Templin) and Laura Hendrix (Office of the interest.\n                                                                                                                 Attorney General staff)\n20   DOC000036.0001           8/12/2025              Word memorandum            Mark W. Rasmussen* (Jones Day) Office counsel (as attachment to Entry      Counsel's memorandum conveying preliminary legal analysis of              WP; CI          Withhold\n                                                     (attachment to Entry 19)                                    19)                                       defenses to S.B. 2337; opinion work product.\n21   DOC000037                8/8\u20138/12/2025          Email string (PDF)         Office counsel (Lee Winkelman*,  Among the same counsel; cc Ferrell        Joint-defense email thread with Jones Day conveying counsel's             WP; CI          Withhold\n                                                                                William Wassdorf*) and Jones Day Keel* (Jones Day) and Laura Hendrix       litigation strategy for the S.B. 2337 defense; Counsel's mental\n                                                                                counsel (Mark W. Rasmussen*,     (Office of the Attorney General staff)    impressions and strategy; opinion work product exchanged in\n                                                                                Sidney Smith McClung*)                                                     furtherance of a common legal interest.\n                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Document 111-1\n\n\n\n\n22   DOC000039                8/8\u20138/14/2025          Email string (PDF)         Same participants as Entry 19       Same participants as Entry 19; cc         Joint-defense email thread with Jones Day conveying counsel's            WP; CI        Withhold\n                                                                                (Office and Jones Day counsel)      additional Jones Day counsel              assessment of defenses. Core opinion work product (counsel's mental\n                                                                                                                                                              impressions and legal theories) exchanged in furtherance of a common\n                                                                                                                                                              legal interest.\n23   DOC000041                8/8\u20138/14/2025 (filed   Email string (PDF)         Same participants as Entry 19       Same participants as Entry 19             Continuation of the same joint-defense thread (same participants)        WP; CI        Withhold\n                              8/19/2025)                                        (Office and Jones Day counsel)                                                conveying counsel's litigation strategy and legal analysis. Opinion work\n                                                                                                                                                              product exchanged in furtherance of a common legal interest.\n                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Filed 10/26/26\n                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Page 17 of 119\n\fCase 1:25-cv-01153-ADA   Document 111-1   Filed 10/26/26   Page 18 of 119\n\n\n\n\n                    EXHIBIT C\n\f  Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                 Document 111-1                Filed 10/26/26           Page 19 of 119\n\n\nFrom:           Troy Sager\nTo:             LeBrun, Jared; Villari, Timothy M.; Rasmussen, Mark W.; McClung, Sidney Smith\nCc:             Callahan, Bryce; Martinez, Grant; Hann, Lily; Brumbaugh, Austin; Joe Nwaokoro\nSubject:        RE: Glass Lewis v. Paxton - Defendants\" Privilege Log\nDate:           Friday, October 23, 2026 5:56:31 PM\nAttachments:    20261023_ AG\"s Supplemental Responses.pdf\n                20261023_AG\"s Second Amended Privilege Log.pdf\n                20261023_Deficiencies in Glass Lewis\" Privilege Log.pdf\n\n\nGood afternoon,\n\nPlease see the attached Defendant Ken Paxton, in his official capacity as Attorney\nGeneral of Texas Supplemental Objections and Responses to Plaintiff Glass,\nLewis & Co., LLC\u2019s Second Set of Interrogatories and Second Set of Requests for\nProduction.\n\nPlease see the attached 2nd Amended Privilege Log.\n\nFinally, please see the attached Deficiencies in Glass Lewis's October 19, 2026\nPrivilege Log/Chart.\n\nPlease let us know if you're unable to view all three PDF files.\n\n\nThank you,\n\n                 Troy Sager\n                 Legal Assistant\n                 Office of the Attorney General of Texas\n                 P.O. Box 12548\n                 Austin, TX 78711-2548\n                 (512) 475-4263\n\n\nFrom: Joe Nwaokoro\nSent: Friday, October 23, 2026 3:38 PM\nTo: LeBrun, Jared <jlebrun@yettercoleman.com>; Villari, Timothy M. <tvillari@jonesday.com>;\nRasmussen, Mark W. <mrasmussen@jonesday.com>; McClung, Sidney Smith\n<smcclung@jonesday.com>\nCc: Callahan, Bryce <bcallahan@yettercoleman.com>; Martinez, Grant\n<gmartinez@yettercoleman.com>; Hann, Lily <lhann@yettercoleman.com>; Brumbaugh, Austin\n<abrumbaugh@yettercoleman.com>\nSubject: RE: Glass Lewis v. Paxton - Defendants' Privilege Log\n\nGood afternoon, Jared,\n\nThanks for your email below. I have reviewed and offer the following response:\n\n   1. We will serve an amended privilege log this afternoon to address the concerns you raised,\n\f  Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26         Page 20 of 119\n\n\n      with each withheld item listed separately with its author, date, and recipients.\n   2. We researched further and were able to locate the first two drafts of DOC000001 and have\n      logged them individually.\n   3. We have conformed our Interrogatories 14 and 20 objections and supplemented our\n      responses to RFPs 24 and 27. We will serve our supplemental responses this afternoon.\n   4. Our supplemental responses and amended log also address the specific items you raised. On\n      the Alliance for Corporate Excellence, after a diligent search, we have no responsive, non-\n      privileged documents to produce. Our communications with the Department of Justice, the\n      Indiana Attorney General's office, and the Alliance's counsel are attorney work product, and\n      the amended log reflects that basis and provides the grounds for each. Regarding the\n      common-interest point you raised, we are not asserting it as a standalone privilege. It is on\n      the log to explain why sharing these materials with aligned, non-adverse counsel did not\n      waive the work-product protection, not as an independent ground for withholding.\n   5. Turning to Glass Lewis\u2019s own privilege log, we have identified several entries that raise the\n      same issues cited in your email. These include automated system notices, the public text of\n      S.B. 2337, an employee-only thread with no attorney on it, communications sent to outside\n      domains and personal accounts, and entries described too generally to assess. We will\n      provide, alongside our supplemental responses and amended privilege log, a chart listing the\n      entry numbers, specific deficiencies, and requested cures (produce where the material is\n      plainly not privileged; otherwise, substantiate or provide a fuller description).\n\nWe remain available to confer. Thanks, and have a nice weekend.\nJoe\n\n\n\nFrom: LeBrun, Jared <jlebrun@yettercoleman.com>\nSent: Thursday, October 22, 2026 2:35 PM\nTo: Joe Nwaokoro <Joe.Nwaokoro@oag.texas.gov>; Villari, Timothy M. <tvillari@jonesday.com>;\nRasmussen, Mark W. <mrasmussen@jonesday.com>; McClung, Sidney Smith\n<smcclung@jonesday.com>\nCc: Callahan, Bryce <bcallahan@yettercoleman.com>; Martinez, Grant\n<gmartinez@yettercoleman.com>; Hann, Lily <lhann@yettercoleman.com>; Brumbaugh, Austin\n<abrumbaugh@yettercoleman.com>\nSubject: Glass Lewis v. Paxton - Defendants' Privilege Log\n\n  CAUTION - EXTERNAL EMAIL: This message originated from outside the OAG. Do not click links, open\n  attachments, or act on requests unless you recognize the sender and can verify the request is legitimate.\n  Report suspicious emails using the Phishing Button.\n\nJoe, Mark, Tim,\n\nWe are writing to identify deficiencies in your privilege log.\n\nStarting with Intervenors, you did not serve a log at all. You claimed associational\nprivilege over whole categories of documents, but discovery closed on October 20\n\f  Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA        Document 111-1       Filed 10/26/26     Page 21 of 119\n\n\nand you have not logged any of those withheld documents. See LUPE v. Abbott,\n2022 WL 17574079, at *9 (W.D. Tex. Dec. 9, 2022) (ordering Defendant Intervenors\nto produce a document-by-document privilege log for associational privilege claims).\nPlease confirm by the end of tomorrow that you will be serving a privilege log by\nTuesday, October 27.\n\nFor the Attorney General, we will not repeat the log issues that overlap with your\ndeficient production and are the subject of our motion to compel. But we reiterate that\nit is wholly improper to assert a blanket privilege over the investigative file, and there\nis no reason those documents could not (at a minimum) be individually logged. Even\nsetting aside those deficiencies, there are four issues with your log:\n\n  1. Your privilege claims are internally inconsistent. You say that the Alliance for\n     Corporate Excellence is an informant (Rog 14), but then you state that you have\n     no responsive documents other than emails about this lawsuit (RFPs 24, 27).\n     Those cannot both be true. You also invoke the informer\u2019s privilege (Rogs 14,\n     20), but then you name the Alliance, which renders the privilege inapplicable.\n     Your log claims attorney-client privilege over emails with the Alliance, but your\n     discovery responses state that these emails are work product and common\n     interest.\n  2. Your assertion of common interest contravenes Fifth Circuit precedent.\n     Common interest applies only to \u201cpotential co-defendants.\u201d In re Santa Fe Int\u2019l\n     Corp., 272 F.3d 705, 710 (5th Cir. 2001). The Alliance, DOJ, and the Indiana\n     Attorney General are not and never have been co-defendants. In fact, the\n     Alliance explicitly told the Court that it \u201cdoes not seek leave to have the Alliance\n     become a party to the litigation\u201d and Indiana has disclaimed that its law targets\n     ESG.\n  3. Your assertions of work product are improper. To start, your log never explains\n     how most documents qualify as work product. Many are routine emails about\n     scheduling and have nothing to do with attorney impressions.\n  4. Your privilege log is incomplete. It lists 17 items, but many of those appear to be\n     logging an entire email chain with multiple parts. For example, on DOC000038,\n     your October 16 log lists at least six different exchanges. DOC000001 lists\n     \u201cversion 3\u201d of a memo, but you never logged previous versions. It does not give\n     the author, date, and recipients of each email. It is improper to only log the last\n     message in an email chain or the final version of a document. Each responsive,\n     withheld document must be separately logged.\n\nPlease confirm by the end of tomorrow that you will: (1) produce your\ncommunications with the Alliance for Corporate Excellence; (2) produce your\ncommunications with the Department of Justice and the Indiana Attorney General\u2019s\noffice; and (3) withdraw your unsupported assertions of attorney work product; and (4)\nindividually log each document that is being withheld.\n\nBest,\nJared\n\nJared LeBrun | Associate | Yetter Coleman\n\f    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                              Document 111-1                       Filed 10/26/26                  Page 22 of 119\n\n\n600 Travis Street, Suite 5400, Houston, Texas 77002\n(D) 713.457.3093 | (O) 713.632.8000\nBio | vCard | www.yettercoleman.com\nThis transmission is confidential and intended solely for the person or organization to which it is addressed. It may contain privileged and confidential\ninformation. If you are not the intended recipient, you should not copy, distribute, or take any action in reliance on it. If you have received this\ntransmission in error, please notify the sender at the e-mail address above.\n\fCase 1:25-cv-01153-ADA   Document 111-1   Filed 10/26/26   Page 23 of 119\n\n\n\n\n                    EXHIBIT D\n\f                           Comprehensive Deficiencies in Glass Lewis's October 19, 2026 Privilege Log\n\n\n\n\n        Category                     Entries (by Glass Lewis's Log No.)                                 Deficiency\n\n\nBoilerplate, uniform          Substantially all 109 entries; e.g., 1, 2, 4\u20137, 29\u201337,   Nearly every entry recites one of a handful of\n\"reasons\"                     41\u201351, 58\u201365, 101                                        canned descriptions (\"Privileged communication\n                                                                                       to in-house counsel seeking legal advice\";\n                                                                                                                                        Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n\n\n\n\n                                                                                       \"...providing legal advice\"; \"Attorney work\n                                                                                       product ... regarding regulatory updates\"),\n                                                                                       without the subject matter needed to test the\n                                                                                       claim. Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(5)(A).\n\n\nNo attorney identified /      1, 2, 4\u20137, 11, 14, 15, 66, 70                            The From/To fields show only Glass Lewis\nemployee-to-employee                                                                   business personnel, with no attorney named;\n                                                                                                                                        Document 111-1\n\n\n\n\n                                                                                       entries 14\u201315 are expressly logged as a\n                                                                                       \"communication between employees regarding\n                                                                                       review by in-house counsel.\" A communication\n                                                                                       among non-lawyers is not privileged merely\n                                                                                       because it mentions counsel.\n                                                                                                                                        Filed 10/26/26\n\n\n\n\nAutomated system              26, 82, 85, 86                                           Machine-generated alerts logged as privileged\u2014\nnotifications                                                                          a Slack \"You've got 3 unread messages\" notice\n                                                                                       (26) and SharePoint \"Administrator has\n                                                                                       responded\"/\"replied to a comment\" notices (82,\n                                                                                       85, 86). These carry no legal advice and no\n                                                                                       attorney input.\n                                                                                                                                        Page 24 of 119\n\fPublic statute attachment   53, 55, 72                                       \"Texas Bill_SB02337F.pdf\"\u2014the enacted public\n                                                                             text of S.B. 2337\u2014withheld as attorney-client\n                                                                             privileged. Attaching a public statute to an email\n                                                                             does not make it privileged.\n\n\nWork product with no        3, 8, 9, 10, 16\u201325                               Materials from November 2020, October 2021,\nlitigation anticipated                                                       March 2024, and April 2025\u2014all predating the\n                                                                             CID (August 2025) and the State DTPA Action\n                                                                             (July 2026)\u2014logged as \"attorney work product,\"\n                                                                                                                                  Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n\n\n\n\n                                                                             several as routine \"regulatory update\" briefings.\n                                                                             Work product requires that the document be\n                                                                             prepared because of anticipated litigation.\n\n\nDisclosure to outside       16, 18, 24, 40, 104, 106, 107                    Materials sent to non-Glass Lewis domains\ndomains / personal                                                           (firstnational.ca, smithfc.ca, pelotoncm.com)\naccounts                                                                     and personal accounts (kcameron@gmail.com; a\n                                                                                                                                  Document 111-1\n\n\n\n\n                                                                             yahoo.com account), with nothing on the log\n                                                                             showing a common interest or that\n                                                                             confidentiality was maintained. Disclosure to\n                                                                             third parties ordinarily waives the privilege.\n\n\nDrafts for publication or   27\u201345 (incl. \"GL Blog Post \u2013 DRAFT.docx,\" 39),   Press-query, blog-post, and client-\n                                                                                                                                  Filed 10/26/26\n\n\n\n\nclient distribution         73\u201381, 87\u2013104                                    communication drafts (\"Draft response for client\n                                                                             inquiries,\" \"Client Communication Pertaining to\n                                                                             Texas Legislation,\" \"Glass Lewis Client\n                                                                             Communication: Texas Senate Bill 2337\").\n                                                                             Material prepared for public or client\n                                                                             dissemination is not privileged as to its\n                                                                             intended-to-be-disclosed content.\n                                                                                                                                  Page 25 of 119\n\f Factual status broadcast to   52, 54, 56\u201366                                           \"Texas Proxy Advisor Bill \u2013 Final Legislative\n wide internal lists                                                                   Step Completed,\" a factual status email blasted\n                                                                                       to eleven-plus executives, logged as privileged\n                                                                                       along with its public-statute attachment.\n\n\n Missing metadata (Rule        e.g., 3, 9, 10, 27, 63, 67\u201369, 74, 77\u201380, 90, 92, 94,   Numerous entries omit author, recipients, and/or\n 26(b)(5)(A))                  95, 98, 99                                              Bates numbers, making it impossible to assess\n                                                                                       the claim or even confirm the document's\n                                                                                       participants.\n                                                                                                                                          Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n\n\n\n\n       Note: This exhibit shows the deficiencies in Glass Lewis's own log comprehensively. Exhibit ( is the narrower, category-\n\nby-category deficiency chart the Attorney General served on Glass Lewis on October 23, 2026.\n                                                                                                                                          Document 111-1\n                                                                                                                                          Filed 10/26/26\n                                                                                                                                          Page 26 of 119\n\fCase 1:25-cv-01153-ADA   Document 111-1   Filed 10/26/26   Page 27 of 119\n\n\n\n\n                    EXHIBIT E\n\fENCLOSURE \u2014 Deficiencies in Glass Lewis's October 19, 2026 Privilege Log\nGlass, Lewis & Co. v. Paxton, No. 1:25-cv-01153-ADA (W.D. Tex.)\nThe entries are grouped by the problems they share. The OAG asks Glass Lewis to produce each document or back up the claim, entry by entry, as Glass Lewis has asked of the OAG. Where the\n\nCategory 1 \u2014 Automated notifications (Produce)\nEntry No(s).      Document / Subject                                        Problem                                                Our ask\n26                Slack alert, \"You've got 3 unread messages,\" from         A system-generated alert is not a request for or a     Produce. If any attorney text is embedded, redact and\n                  notification@slack.com to C. Gustitus; logged             delivery of legal advice, and it carries no attorney   produce the rest.\n                  Attorney-Client                                           input.\n82, 85, 86        SharePoint \"no-reply@sharepointonline.com\"                Machine-generated access and comment alerts are        Produce. Redact any embedded attorney comment rather\n                  notices (\"Administrator has responded to your             not privileged communications.                         than withhold the entire notice.\n                  request\"; \"Gordon Seymour replied to a comment\");\n                  logged Work Product and Attorney-Client\n                                                                                                                                                                                                  Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n\n\n\n\nCategory 2 \u2014 Public statute attachments (Produce)\nEntry No(s).         Document / Subject                                     Problem                                                Our ask\n53, 55, 72           \"Texas Bill_SB02337F.pdf\"; logged Attorney-Client      This is the enacted text of S.B. 2337. Attaching a     Produce, or stipulate that the attachment is the public bill\n                                                                            public statute to an email does not make it            and drop it from the log.\n                                                                            privileged.\n\nCategory 3 \u2014 Business emails with no lawyer on them (Produce)\nEntry No(s).        Document / Subject                                      Problem                                             Our ask\n                                                                                                                                                                                                  Document 111-1\n\n\n\n\n14, 15              \"Tesla Response to Proxy Paper\" (Lili Mehta and         Both are employees, no lawyer is on the thread, and Produce. If attorney text was added later in the chain, redact.\n                    Brianna Castro); logged Attorney-Client / Privileged-   the log itself calls them a \"communication between\n                    Redacted                                                employees regarding review by in-house counsel.\"\n\n\n\nCategory 4 \u2014 Sent to outside domains and personal accounts\nEntry No(s).         Document / Subject                                     Problem                                              Our ask\n16, 18               \"Regulatory Update\" from N. Garzon to outside          Sent to non-Glass Lewis domains (firstnational.ca,   Identify who each outside recipient is and why they are inside\n                                                                                                                                                                                                  Filed 10/26/26\n\n\n\n\n                    recipients; logged Attorney Work Product and            smithfc.ca, pelotoncm.com) and a personal account, the privilege, or produce.\n                    Attorney-Client                                         with nothing in the log showing a common interest or\n                                                                            that confidentiality was kept.\n\n106, 107             \"FW: Glass Lewis Client Communication: Texas Senate Forwarded to pelotoncm.com, firstnational.ca,             Same: identify the recipients and the basis, or produce.\n                     Bill 2337\" from B. Mann to outside recipients       smithfc.ca, a yahoo.com account, and\n                     (PLF0010753-56, PLF0010765-68); logged Attorney- kcameron@gmail.com, again with no common-\n                     Client / Privileged-Redacted                        interest or confidentiality showing.\n                                                                                                                                                                                                  Page 28 of 119\n\n\n\n\n24, 25               \"FW: Regulatory Update\" and its attachment, from       Counsel's analysis was forwarded to an executive's     Confirm that the account belongs to Kevin Cameron and that\n                     President C. Busch to kcameron@gmail.com; logged       personal Gmail account.                                the personal account was used consistent with Glass Lewis's\n                     Attorney-Client                                                                                               confidentiality practices. If not, produce.\n\fCategory 5 \u2014 Work product with no litigation in sight\nEntry No(s).       Document / Subject                                        Problem                                                 Our ask\n3, 8, 9            \"GL RAC Policy Meeting\" materials about regulatory        These are from 2020 and 2021, well before any           Withdraw the work-product claim, or produce the factual\n                   updates (Nov. 2020 and Oct. 2021); logged Work            litigation, and read as routine regulatory briefings.   portions.\n                   Product                                                   Work product requires that the document be\n                                                                             prepared because of litigation.\n16-23                April 2025 \"Regulatory Update\" and \"Regulatory          The log does not show that these were prepared          Establish that litigation was anticipated (dates, the claims\n                     Updated.pptx\" to the board and executive team;          because of anticipated litigation.                      expected, and that the documents were prepared because of\n                     logged Work Product and Attorney-Client                                                                         it), or drop the work-product claim and produce the factual\n                                                                                                                                     portions.\n\nCategory 6 \u2014 Drafts for publication or clients, and status emails\nEntry No(s).         Document / Subject                                      Problem                                               Our ask\n                                                                                                                                                                                                     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n\n\n\n\n27-45                \"press query - Texas SB 2337\" chain and the \"Blog       These look like public-relations and drafting work,   State whether the drafts were meant for publication or for\n                     Post on Texas Proxy Advisor Bill?\" thread and draft     and some of the drafts appear meant for publication. clients, and produce the business and PR text with narrow\n                     (\"GL Blog Post - DRAFT.docx,\" #39); logged Attorney-                                                          redactions for actual legal advice.\n                     Client, some Work Product\n73-81; 89-97; 102- \"Texas write up,\" \"Client note,\" \"Client                  These read as client-facing material, where privilege Segregate and produce the parts meant for clients; log\n104                  Communication Pertaining to Texas Legislation,\" and is thin as to what was meant to go out.                   counsel's input separately with a real basis.\n                     \"Draft response for client inquiries\"; logged Attorney-\n                     Client / Work Product\n52-65                \"Texas Proxy Advisor Bill - Final Legislative Step   This is a factual status email to a wide internal list,    Produce the status text and the public attachment; redact any\n                                                                                                                                                                                                     Document 111-1\n\n\n\n\n                     Completed\" broadcast and its bill attachment; logged and the attachment is public.                              attorney opinion.\n                     Attorney-Client, some Work Product\n\n\nCategory 7 \u2014 Entries too thin to evaluate (Rule 26(b)(5)(A))\nEntry No(s).         Document / Subject                                      Problem                                                 Our ask\n4-7; 12-13; 105-109 Repeated one-liners such as \"Privileged                  These say nothing about the subject, so we cannot       Add the subject of the advice (for example, \"legal advice on\n                     communication to in-house counsel seeking legal         test the claim; some leave out the attorney's role.     S.B. 2337 compliance as to [topic]\") and name the attorney by\n                                                                                                                                                                                                     Filed 10/26/26\n\n\n\n\n                     advice\" and \"Privileged-Redacted\"                                                                               role. We are not asking you to combine duplicates.\n                                                                                                                                                                                                     Page 29 of 119\n\fCase 1:25-cv-01153-ADA   Document 111-1   Filed 10/26/26   Page 30 of 119\n\n\n\n\n                    EXHIBIT F\n\f                        Glass Lewis's Second-Set Discovery Requests That Duplicate Its First Set\n\n                                                                                               Nature of Duplication (per the\n Second-Set                                          Duplicative First-Set Request\n                           Subject                                                              Attorney General's served\n  Request                                           (served/answered Oct. 31, 2025)\n                                                                                                         objection)\n\n\n                Identify each Texas person\n                                                                                             Objected as \"cumulative of First Set\n                the Attorney General              First Set Interrogatory No. 11 (persons\nInterrogatory                                                                                Interrogatory No. 11, answered\n                contends Glass Lewis              who complained about Glass Lewis's\n                                                                                                                                    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n\n\n\n\nNo. 14                                                                                       October 31, 2025,\" citing Rule\n                \"deceived or misled,\" and         statements)\n                                                                                             26(b)(2)(C)(i).\n                describe the statement.\n\n\n                Identify communications\n                                                  First Set Request for Production No.       Objected as cumulative of First Set\n                with other States' attorneys\n                                                  21 (communications with other state        RFP No. 21; the answer expressly\nInterrogatory   general, the SEC, FTC, or\n                                                  attorney general offices re S.B. 2337,     \"supplements Defendant's October\n                                                                                                                                    Document 111-1\n\n\n\n\nNo. 16          DOL concerning proxy\n                                                  Glass Lewis, or proxy advisory             31, 2025 response to First Set\n                advisors, Glass Lewis, ESG,\n                                                  services)                                  Request for Production No. 21.\"\n                DEI, or S.B. 2337.\n\n\n                Identify each statement by                                                   Objected as \"cumulative of First Set\n                                                  First Set Interrogatory No. 1 (all false\nInterrogatory   which Glass Lewis represents                                                 Interrogatory No. 1, answered\n                                                                                                                                    Filed 10/26/26\n\n\n\n\n                                                  or misleading statements the Attorney\nNo. 17          its advice is made in its                                                    October 31, 2025,\" citing Rule\n                                                  General asserts Glass Lewis made)\n                customers' financial interests.                                              26(b)(2)(C)(i).\n\n\nInterrogatory   Identify each Texas-based         First Set Interrogatory No. 11 (persons    In the Oct. 23 Supplemental\nNo. 20          Glass Lewis client that           who complained about Glass Lewis's         Response, objected as \"cumulative\n                complained to the Attorney        statements, with dates and                 and duplicative of First Set\n                                                                                                                                    Page 31 of 119\n\f                                                                                            Nature of Duplication (per the\n Second-Set                                         Duplicative First-Set Request\n                           Subject                                                           Attorney General's served\n  Request                                          (served/answered Oct. 31, 2025)\n                                                                                                      objection)\n\n\n                General, with date, person,      descriptions); and Second-Set            Interrogatory No. 11 and of\n                manner, and substance.           Interrogatory No. 14                     Interrogatory No. 14 of this Set,\"\n                                                                                          citing Rule 26(b)(2)(C)(i) \u2014 i.e.,\n                                                                                          duplicative of both a first-set\n                                                                                          request and another second-set\n                                                                                                                                  Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n\n\n\n\n                                                                                          request.\n\n\n                Identify each investigative or                                            Objected that, as to S.B. 2337, the\n                                                 First Set Interrogatory Nos. 7 and 8\nInterrogatory   enforcement step concerning                                               interrogatory is \"cumulative of First\n                                                 (steps taken before and after Sept. 1,\nNo. 22          Glass Lewis between Jan. 1,                                               Set Interrogatory Nos. 7 and 8,\n                                                 2025 to enforce S.B. 2337)\n                2023 and July 24, 2026.                                                   answered October 31, 2025.\"\n                                                                                                                                  Document 111-1\n\n\n\n\n                Identify each Texas\n                                                 First Set Request for Production No.\n                consumer or company that\nInterrogatory                                    13 (documents showing harm to Texas      Objected as \"cumulative of First Set\n                allegedly suffered monetary\nNo. 24                                           companies/shareholders from Glass        Request for Production No. 13.\"\n                harm from a Glass Lewis\n                                                 Lewis's statements)\n                                                                                                                                  Filed 10/26/26\n\n\n\n\n                statement.\n\n\n                                                 First Set Requests Nos. 3, 11, and 12\nRequest for     All documents concerning         (CIDs to proxy advisors; documents       Objected as \"cumulative of First Set\nProduction      any investigation, CID, or       evidencing Glass Lewis's alleged false   Request Nos. 3, 11, and 12.\"\nNo. 22          inquiry concerning Glass         statements)\n                                                                                                                                  Page 32 of 119\n\f                                                                                        Nature of Duplication (per the\n Second-Set                                     Duplicative First-Set Request\n                        Subject                                                          Attorney General's served\n  Request                                      (served/answered Oct. 31, 2025)\n                                                                                                  objection)\n\n\n              Lewis, including the\n              investigative file.\n\n\n              All documents concerning\n                                                                                                                             Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n\n\n\n\n              any complaint or               First Set Requests Nos. 11, 12, and 13\nRequest for\n              communication that Glass       (documents evidencing                    Objected as \"cumulative of First Set\nProduction\n              Lewis made a false or          false/misleading statements and          Request Nos. 11, 12, and 13.\"\nNo. 24\n              misleading statement, and      resulting harm)\n              resulting harm.\n\n\n              All documents supporting the\n                                                                                                                             Document 111-1\n\n\n\n\n                                             First Set Requests Nos. 9, 10, 11, and\n              contention that Glass Lewis\nRequest for                                  12 (documents supporting the\n              represents its                                                          Objected as \"cumulative of First Set\nProduction                                   \"maximize returns / minimize risks\"\n              recommendations are made                                                Request Nos. 9, 10, 11, and 12.\"\nNo. 30                                       assertions and the false-statement\n              in its customers' financial\n                                             contentions)\n              interests.\n                                                                                                                             Filed 10/26/26\n\n\n\n\nRequest for   All documents prepared by      First Set Requests Nos. 1, 5, and 6      Objected that, as to S.B. 2337, the\nProduction    Division investigators         (documents re S.B. 2337 and its          request is \"cumulative of First Set\nNo. 32        McDonald, Hanlan, or           interpretation/enforcement)              Request Nos. 1, 5, and 6.\"\n              Vasquez concerning proxy\n                                                                                                                             Page 33 of 119\n\f                                                                                      Nature of Duplication (per the\n Second-Set                                   Duplicative First-Set Request\n                        Subject                                                        Attorney General's served\n  Request                                    (served/answered Oct. 31, 2025)\n                                                                                                objection)\n\n\n              advisors, Glass Lewis, or\n              S.B. 2337.\n\n\n              All documents reviewed by    First Set Requests Nos. 3, 11, and 12\nRequest for\n                                                                                                                           Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n\n\n\n\n              McDonald, Hanlan, or         (CIDs to proxy advisors; documents       Objected as \"cumulative of First Set\nProduction\n              Vasquez in investigating     evidencing Glass Lewis's alleged false   Request Nos. 3, 11, and 12.\"\nNo. 34\n              Glass Lewis.                 statements)\n\n\n              All documents concerning\n              any statement of intent to\nRequest for                                First Set Request No. 18 (documents\n              investigate, sue, or take                                             Objected as \"cumulative of First Set\n                                                                                                                           Document 111-1\n\n\n\n\nProduction                                 showing statements of any intent to\n              enforcement action against                                            Request No. 18.\"\nNo. 36                                     enforce against proxy advisors)\n              Glass Lewis or any proxy\n              advisor.\n                                                                                                                           Filed 10/26/26\n                                                                                                                           Page 34 of 119\n\fCase 1:25-cv-01153-ADA   Document 111-1   Filed 10/26/26   Page 35 of 119\n\n\n\n\n                    EXHIBIT G\n\f       The Requests Glass Lewis Claims the Attorney General \u201cRefused,\u201d and the Attorney General\u2019s Actual Responses\n\n       Glass Lewis\u2019s Motion color-codes the Attorney General\u2019s Second-Set Interrogatories 14\u201325 and Requests for Production 22\u201336\n\nas \u201csubstantive refusal[s]\u201d and claims that he \u201csubstantively answered none\u201d of his interrogatories and produced only Glass Lewis\u2019s and\n\nISS\u2019s own documents. Dkt. 109 at 2\u20134.\n\n       The chart below pairs each request with the Attorney General\u2019s operative responses: his First Amended Objections and\n\nResponses served October 16, 2026, as superseded by his Second Amended Responses on October 20 and supplemented on October 23,\n                                                                                                                                          Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n\n\n\n\n2026. Dkt. 109-3 (Ex. 2); Nwaokoro Resp. Decl. Ex. A (Oct. 23 Supplemental Responses). The rows for Interrogatories 14 and 20 and\n\nRequests for Production 24 and 27 reflect the October 23 Supplemental Responses, which supersede those four responses; the remaining\n\nrows reflect the October 16 responses carried forward on October 20. Together they answer the relevant interrogatories, state for each\n                                                                                                                                          Document 111-1\n\n\n\n\nrequest whether material is withheld and why, and produce responsive, non-privileged documents at Bates range AG 002090\u2013AG\n\n003289 (the ~1,200-page October 16 production). Only the separate DTPA investigative file and enforcement-motive material is\n\nwithheld, on stated grounds.\n\n                                   Glass Lewis\u2019s       The Attorney General\u2019s Operative Response (Second              Answered /\n                                                                                                                                          Filed 10/26/26\n\n\n\n\n           Request\n                                      Claim                  Amended, Oct. 20; Supplemented Oct. 23)                  Produced\n Interrog. 14 (persons             \u201cSubstantively      (Oct. 23 Suppl.) Identifies the Alliance for Corporate          Answered\n deceived)                        answered none.\u201d      Excellence and states that, besides the Alliance, no other\n                                                       person furnished the Division information about Glass\n                                                       Lewis\u2019s statements; refers to the verified DTPA petition\n                                                       \u00b6\u00b6 13\u201338 and the thirteen statements quoted in\n                                                                                                                                          Page 36 of 119\n\n\n\n\n                                                       Interrogatory 17. Suppl. Resp.; Resp. Decl. Ex. A.\n\fInterrog. 15 (decision to file   Refusal   States the fact and date of filing on the public Collin    Answered, in part\nDTPA suit)                                 County docket; withholds only privileged charging\n                                           deliberations. Ex. 2 at 4.\nInterrog. 16                     Refusal   States that a diligent search identified no responsive,       Answered\n(communications with other                 non-privileged SEC, FTC, or DOL communications and\nAGs/SEC/FTC/DOL)                           that none are known; any AG-to-AG coordination is\n                                           withheld as work product/common-interest. Ex. 2 at 5.\nInterrog. 17 (statements re      Refusal   Identifies thirteen specific, quoted Glass Lewis public    Answered in full\nfinancial-interest                         statements. Ex. 2 at 5\u20136.\n                                                                                                                          Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n\n\n\n\nrepresentations)\nInterrog. 18 (Texas-directed     Refusal   States the contention is at issue in the Collin County      Answered by\nconduct)                                   DTPA action (personal jurisdiction). Ex. 2 at 7.               reference\nInterrog. 19 (investigative      Refusal   Withholds the Division\u2019s DTPA investigative steps as       Withheld, grounds\nsteps)                                     privileged and outside scope. Ex. 2 at 7.                        stated\nInterrog. 20 (Texas clients      Refusal   (Oct. 23 Suppl.) States the Attorney General has not       Answered in full\nwho complained)                            received a complaint about Glass Lewis from any\n                                                                                                                          Document 111-1\n\n\n\n\n                                           person he knows to be a Texas-based client of Glass\n                                           Lewis. Suppl. Resp.; Resp. Decl. Ex. A.\nInterrog. 21 (acts violating     Refusal   States the contentions are set out in the State\u2019s Collin    Answered by\nDTPA)                                      County petition. Ex. 2 at 8.                                  reference\nInterrog. 22                     Refusal   States the Office has taken no step to enforce S.B. 2337   Answered, in part\n(investigative/enforcement                 since the injunction; withholds DTPA-matter steps as\n                                                                                                                          Filed 10/26/26\n\n\n\n\nsteps 2023\u20132026)                           privileged/outside scope. Ex. 2 at 8.\nInterrog. 23 (timing of the      Refusal   States the CID\u2019s issuance and date appear in the CID          Answered\nCID)                                       itself, which Glass Lewis already introduced into the\n                                           record; Division\u2019s CID authority predates S.B. 2337.\n                                           Ex. 2 at 8\u20139.\nInterrog. 24 (monetary           Refusal   States DTPA harm and damages are at issue in Collin        Withheld, grounds\n                                                                                                                          Page 37 of 119\n\n\n\n\nharm)                                      County, not in the as-applied challenge. Ex. 2 at 9.            stated\n\fInterrog. 25 (basis for          Refusal          Declines a narrative of enforcement/political motive as           Answered by\npublic statements)                                irrelevant to the as-applied challenge; any factual basis          reference\n                                                  is in the public record. Ex. 2 at 9.\nRFP 22 (investigative          \u201cWithholds         Produces responsive non-privileged documents at AG                Produced +\nfile/CID)                   investigative file    002090\u2013AG 003289; states it is withholding the DTPA              withhold stated\n                            wholesale \u2026 does      investigative file and CID materials on scope grounds.\n                             not list it on his   Ex. 2 at 10.\n                             privilege log.\u201d\nRFP 23 (ISS investigative        Refusal          States it will not produce; the ISS file belongs to the         Withheld, grounds\n                                                                                                                                      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n\n\n\n\nfile)                                             separate DTPA matter and a co-plaintiff, and is not the              stated\n                                                  Office\u2019s to produce absent consent/order under \u00a7\n                                                  17.61(f). Ex. 2 at 10.\nRFP 24 (consumer                 Refusal          (Oct. 23 Suppl.) Refers to the Alliance and to                  Answered (none\ncomplaints)                                       Interrogatory 14; states that, after a diligent search, there       exist)\n                                                  are no documents to produce. Suppl. Resp.; Resp. Decl.\n                                                  Ex. A.\n                                                                                                                                      Document 111-1\n\n\n\n\nRFP 25 (public statements        Refusal          Produces post-June 20, 2025 public statements at AG                 Produced\nre Glass Lewis)                                   002090\u2013AG 003289; notes they are public and already\n                                                  in the record. Ex. 2 at 11.\nRFP 26 (pre-suit                 Refusal          Produces responsive non-privileged documents at AG                  Produced\ncommunications with                               002090\u2013AG 003289. Ex. 2 at 11\u201312.\nTAB/TXSE/Jones Day)\n                                                                                                                                      Filed 10/26/26\n\n\n\n\nRFP 27 (communications           Refusal          (Oct. 23 Suppl.) States it is withholding the logged            Withhold stated +\nwith the                                          communications with counsel for the Alliance and has                logged\nAlliance/Foley/Loh)                               located no other responsive communications. Suppl.\n                                                  Resp.; Resp. Decl. Ex. A & Ex. B (log).\nRFP 28 (June 23, 2026            Refusal          Refers to the public hearing record, equally available to         Answered by\nSenate hearing)                                   Glass Lewis. Ex. 2 at 12.                                          reference\n                                                                                                                                      Page 38 of 119\n\fRFP 29 (campaign               Refusal   States public campaign-finance filings are equally         Withheld, grounds\ncontributions)                           available; will not produce (political motive,                  stated\n                                         irrelevant/overbroad). Ex. 2 at 12\u201313.\nRFP 30 (financial-interest-    Refusal   States the documents are equally available in Glass          Answered by\nrepresentation documents)                Lewis\u2019s own materials and website; refers to the              reference\n                                         statements identified in Interrogatory 17. Ex. 2 at 13.\nRFP 31 (Texas-contacts         Refusal   Refers to the record, including Glass Lewis\u2019s own            Produced by\ndocuments)                               Second Amended Complaint \u00b6\u00b6 33\u201334; produces any               reference\n                                         additional responsive non-privileged documents at AG\n                                                                                                                        Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n\n\n\n\n                                         002090\u2013AG 003289. Ex. 2 at 13.\nRFP 32 (investigator-          Refusal   Withholds the DTPA investigative file on scope;            Produced, in part\nprepared documents)                      produces responsive non-privileged S.B. 2337\n                                         documents, if any, at AG 002090\u2013AG 003289. Ex. 2 at\n                                         14.\nRFP 33 (investigator           Refusal   Will not produce; directed at the separate Collin County   Withheld, grounds\ndocuments re the DTPA                    action and privileged. Ex. 2 at 14.                             stated\n                                                                                                                        Document 111-1\n\n\n\n\nsuit)\nRFP 34 (documents              Refusal   Produces responsive non-privileged S.B. 2337               Produced, in part\ninvestigators reviewed)                  documents, if any, at AG 002090\u2013AG 003289;\n                                         withholds the DTPA investigative file. Ex. 2 at 14.\nRFP 35 (press/social-media     Refusal   Produces responsive documents at AG 002090\u2013AG                  Produced\nre Glass Lewis)                          003289; notes they are public and already in the record;\n                                                                                                                        Filed 10/26/26\n\n\n\n\n                                         duplicative of RFP 25. Ex. 2 at 15.\nRFP 36 (statements of intent   Refusal   Produces responsive documents at AG 002090\u2013AG                  Produced\nto investigate/sue)                      003289; notes public statements already in the record.\n                                         Ex. 2 at 15.\n                                                                                                                        Page 39 of 119\n\fCase 1:25-cv-01153-ADA   Document 111-1   Filed 10/26/26   Page 40 of 119\n\n\n\n\n                    EXHIBIT H\n\f         Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA             Document 111-1          Filed 10/26/26       Page 41 of 119\n\n\n\n\n                                             CAUSE NO: 471-04895-2026\n\n    STATE OF TEXAS,                                      \u00a7               IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF\n                                                         \u00a7\n                        Plaintiff,                       \u00a7\n                                                         \u00a7\n    v.                                                   \u00a7                   COLLIN COUNTY, TEXAS\n                                                         \u00a7\n    GLASS, LEWIS & CO., LLC,                             \u00a7\n                                                         \u00a7\n                        Defendant.                       \u00a7                   471ST JUDICIAL DISTRICT\n\n                  TEXAS\u2019S SECOND AMENDED VERIFIED PETITION AND\n              APPLICATION FOR TEMPORARY AND PERMANENT INJUNCTION\n\n             \u201c[R]eflects broad investor opinion and widely accepted governance principles . . . .\u201d\n\n             \u201c[R]eflects the current, predominant views of our institutional investor clients on corporate\n             governance best practices.\u201d\n\n             \u201c[I]ndependent corporate governance research.\u201d\n\n             \u201c[O]bjective, reliable, and timely advice.\u201d 1\n\n             Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC (\u201cGlass Lewis\u201d) makes these types of representations about itself\n\nand its Benchmark Policy, the ready-made voting rules it sells to investors. 2 Yet they are all false,\n\ndeceptive, and misleading.\n\n             Glass Lewis is one of two firms that dominate the business of advising big investors how to\n\nvote at shareholder meetings. Its clients include pension plans and mutual funds that hold the\n\nsavings of ordinary Texans. It sends Benchmark recommendations to every client that receives its\n\nresearch. 3\n\n\n\n\n1\n         See infra \u00b6\u00b6 58, 60, 95.\n2\n         See infra \u00b6\u00b6 49\u201350, 58.\n3\n         See infra \u00b6\u00b6 38, 42, 50.\n\n\n                                                             1\n\f    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 111-1        Filed 10/26/26      Page 42 of 119\n\n\n\n\n        But the Benchmark Policy did not reflect broad investor opinion. For years, its rules called\n\nfor recommending votes against directors because of a board\u2019s gender makeup. Other rules turned\n\non whether a board had a director \u201cfrom an underrepresented community,\u201d or on a company\u2019s\n\nclimate or social-oversight disclosures. Its 30% gender threshold was the same one Glass Lewis\n\nused in its separate ESG and Climate policies. Year after year, shareholders voted down almost\n\nevery environmental and social proposal. And Glass Lewis admitted that the evidence \u201ccannot\n\ndetermine the effect\u201d of the climate and diversity proposals it backed on any individual company. 4\n\n        Glass Lewis knew its statements were false, deceptive, and misleading. In a January 2023\n\nletter to the attorneys general of Texas and other States, Glass Lewis claimed the Benchmark\n\nPolicy reflects its clients\u2019 \u201cpredominant views.\u201d But in the same letter it said that \u201ca significant\n\nmajority of our clients have elected to simply not follow any Glass Lewis policy.\u201d Then in October\n\n2025, Glass Lewis admitted that \u201cthe traditional one-size-fits-all model of proxy advice no longer\n\nmeets the needs of a diverse client base.\u201d It then published new Benchmark guidelines claiming\n\nthe policy \u201creflects broad investor opinion.\u201d 5 Both things cannot be true.\n\n        Glass Lewis also told investors its advice was independent. Its October 2025 report on\n\nTesla, a Texas company, listed Glass Lewis\u2019s \u201cPotential Conflicts.\u201d The list left out that Glass\n\nLewis was then suing the Texas Attorney General over a Texas law that regulates proxy advisors.\n\nIn 2026, Glass Lewis urged the shareholders of Exxon Mobil Corporation (\u201cExxon\u201d) to vote\n\nagainst making Texas the company\u2019s legal home. Exxon publicly said that Glass Lewis \u201cfailed to\n\ndisclose an obvious conflict of interest resulting from its ongoing litigation with the Texas Attorney\n\n\n\n\n4\n    See infra \u00b6\u00b6 64\u201369, 102.\n5\n    See infra \u00b6\u00b6 58, 61, 83, 85\u201386.\n\n\n                                                  2\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26       Page 43 of 119\n\n\n\n\nGeneral.\u201d 6 Exxon\u2019s shareholders approved the move anyway, as Tesla\u2019s had in 2024 over Glass\n\nLewis\u2019s opposition. 7\n\n         Glass Lewis made these statements to Texans on its website, in its reports, and to the Texas\n\ninvestors who pay for its services. Glass Lewis may hold any view it wants about board diversity,\n\nclimate change, or anything else. But when a business tells customers what its product is and whose\n\nviews it reflects, those statements must be true. 8\n\n         The Texas Deceptive Trade Practices\u2013Consumer Protection Act (\u201cDTPA\u201d) forbids\n\n\u201c[f]alse, misleading, or deceptive acts or practices in the conduct of any trade or commerce.\u201d 9 The\n\nState of Texas, acting through Attorney General Ken Paxton, brings this suit to stop Glass Lewis\u2019s\n\ndeception.\n\n                              I.      DISCOVERY CONTROL PLAN\n\n         1.      The State intends to conduct discovery under Level 3 and asks the Court to enter a\n\nLevel 3 discovery control plan. Tex. R. Civ. P. 190.4. The expedited-actions process does not apply\n\nbecause the State does not seek only monetary relief of $325,000 or less. Tex. R. Civ. P. 169(a).\n\n                                           II.     PARTIES\n\n         2.      Defendant Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC is a Delaware limited liability company with its\n\nprincipal place of business in California. 10 Glass Lewis has been registered with the Texas Secretary\n\n\n\n\n6\n     See infra \u00b6\u00b6 77, 99.\n7\n     See infra \u00b6\u00b6 74, 77, 99, 101.\n8\n     See infra \u00b6\u00b6 134\u2013137.\n9\n     Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.46(a).\n10\n     Decl. of John Wieck \u00b6 4 (Aug. 9, 2026), filed with Def. Glass Lewis\u2019 Verified Special Appearance and,\n     Alternatively, Mot. to Transfer Venue (Aug. 10, 2026) [hereinafter Wieck Decl.].\n\n\n                                                    3\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26         Page 44 of 119\n\n\n\n\nof State to do business in Texas since November 19, 2003. 11 It applied for its certificate of authority\n\nto pursue the \u201c[t]ransaction of lawful business\u201d in Texas, and it appointed a registered agent in\n\nAustin. 12 It has filed public information reports with the State, most recently for 2024. 13\n\n         3.       Glass Lewis has appeared in this suit through counsel, subject to its special\n\nappearance, and may be served through its attorneys of record. Tex. R. Civ. P. 21a.\n\n                                 III.     JURISDICTION AND VENUE\n\nA.       The DTPA authorizes this suit.\n\n         4.       The Attorney General brings this suit through the Consumer Protection Division,\n\nin the name of the State and in the public interest. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.47(a). The DTPA\n\nallows the Division to sue whenever it has reason to believe two things. First, a person \u201cis engaging\n\nin, has engaged in, or is about to engage in\u201d an unlawful act or practice. Second, the suit would be\n\nin the public interest. Id. The State alleges that Glass Lewis is engaging in, has engaged in, and is\n\nabout to engage in false, misleading, or deceptive acts or practices in trade and commerce. Id. \u00a7\u00a7\n\n17.46(a)\u2013(b), 17.47(a).\n\n         5.       In a suit under section 17.47, the Court may grant temporary and permanent\n\ninjunctions that restrain unlawful acts and practices. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.47(a)\u2013(b). The\n\ntrier of fact may award civil penalties of up to $10,000 for each violation. Id. \u00a7 17.47(c)(1). It may\n\naward up to $250,000 more for each violation when the act or practice was calculated to acquire\n\nor deprive money or other property from a consumer 65 or older. Id. \u00a7 17.47(c)(2). The Court may\n\n\n\n11\n     Wieck Decl. \u00b6 11; Tex. Sec\u2019y of State, Business Organizations Inquiry, Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC, File No.\n     800270189, Filing History (viewed Apr. 24, 2026).\n12\n     Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC, Application for Certificate of Authority 1\u20132 (filed Nov. 19, 2003), Tex. Sec\u2019y of State\n     File No. 800270189.\n13\n     Tex. Sec\u2019y of State, Filing History, supra.\n\n\n                                                          4\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26         Page 45 of 119\n\n\n\n\nalso award civil penalties against a defendant that violates an injunction. Id. \u00a7 17.47(e). And the\n\nState may recover reasonable attorney\u2019s fees and court costs. Tex. Gov\u2019t Code \u00a7 402.006(c).\n\nB.        Glass Lewis is subject to personal jurisdiction in Texas.\n\n          6.      A Texas court may exercise personal jurisdiction over a nonresident when the\n\nTexas long-arm statute allows it and doing so is consistent with due process. 14 A nonresident does\n\nbusiness in Texas if it contracts with a Texas resident and either party is to perform the contract\n\nin whole or in part in Texas. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code \u00a7 17.042(1). It also does business in\n\nTexas if it commits a tort in whole or in part here. Id. \u00a7 17.042(2). That list is not exclusive. Id. \u00a7\n\n17.042.\n\n          7.      Due process requires that the nonresident have minimum contacts with Texas, and\n\nthat the suit not offend traditional notions of fair play and substantial justice. 15 Purposeful\n\navailment asks whether the nonresident sought \u201csome benefit, advantage, or profit\u201d by availing\n\nitself of Texas. 16 Sellers that \u201creach out beyond one state and create continuing relationships and\n\nobligations with citizens of another state\u201d may be sued there on claims based on those activities. 17\n\nThe United States Supreme Court has listed soliciting business \u201cthrough advertising reasonably\n\ncalculated to reach the State\u201d among the \u201caffiliating circumstances\u201d that support jurisdiction. 18\n\n          8.      Targeting Texas is the touchstone. 19 \u201c[A] nonresident that directs marketing\n\nefforts to Texas in the hope of soliciting sales is subject to suit here in disputes arising from that\n\n\n\n\n14\n     Moki Mac River Expeditions v. Drugg, 221 S.W.3d 569, 574 (Tex. 2007); State v. Yelp, Inc., 725 S.W.3d 170, 176,\n     180 (Tex. App.\u201415th Dist. 2025, pet. denied).\n15\n     Int\u2019l Shoe Co. v. Washington, 326 U.S. 310, 316 (1945).\n16\n     Michiana Easy Livin\u2019 Country, Inc. v. Holten, 168 S.W.3d 777, 784\u201385 (Tex. 2005).\n17\n     Id. (quoting Burger King Corp. v. Rudzewicz, 471 U.S. 462, 473 (1985)).\n18\n     Id. at 786\u201387 (quoting World-Wide Volkswagen Corp. v. Woodson, 444 U.S. 286, 295 (1980)).\n19\n     BRP-Rotax GmbH & Co. KG v. Shaik, 716 S.W.3d 98, 108 (Tex. 2025).\n\n\n                                                         5\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26         Page 46 of 119\n\n\n\n\nbusiness.\u201d 20 \u201c[C]ertain activities over the Internet\u201d meet that standard. 21 A defendant \u201cneed not\n\nsingle Texas out in some unique way to satisfy constitutional dictates.\u201d 22 This is so because\n\ndirecting activity to every State \u201cis no less a targeting of Texas as to whatever activity occurred\n\nwithin Texas.\u201d 23 That rule has added force when the State sues to enforce its own law. 24 And \u201ca\n\ntruly interstate business may not shield itself from suit by a careful, but formalistic structuring of\n\nits business dealings.\u201d 25 That includes \u201cexplicitly structuring its transactions with Texans to take\n\nplace outside Texas while directly marketing those transactions inside Texas to Texans.\u201d 26\n\nConduct that shows an intent to serve the Texas market includes \u201cestablishing channels for\n\nproviding regular advice to customers in the forum State.\u201d 27\n\n         9.       Glass Lewis has purposeful contacts with Texas, and the State\u2019s claims arise out of\n\nand relate to them. \u00b6\u00b6 10\u201319. The State adopts and incorporates by reference into this section the\n\nfacts alleged in Sections V and VI, which describe what Glass Lewis sold and what it told Texans.\n\n\u00b6\u00b6 30\u2013138.\n\n\n\n\n20\n     Michiana, 168 S.W.3d at 785.\n21\n     Id.\n22\n     State v. Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft, 669 S.W.3d 399, 420 (Tex. 2023); Yelp, 725 S.W.3d at 185 (applying that\n     rule in the State\u2019s DTPA suit).\n23\n     BRP-Rotax, 716 S.W.3d at 110.\n24\n     See id. (contrasting a case \u201cwhere no sovereign is prosecuting any case against [the defendant] for purposefully\n     violating Texas law inside Texas\u201d); Volkswagen, 669 S.W.3d at 432 (relying on \u201cTexas\u2019s strong interest in\n     protecting its regulatory scheme, which includes ensuring faithful observance by nonresidents and vindicating\n     violations of its own laws in its own courts\u201d).\n25\n     BRP-Rotax, 716 S.W.3d at 107 (quoting Siskind v. Villa Found. for Educ., Inc., 642 S.W.2d 434, 437 (Tex. 1982)).\n26\n     Id.\n27\n     TV Azteca, S.A.B. de C.V. v. Ruiz, 490 S.W.3d 29, 54 (Tex. 2016) (quoting Spir Star AG v. Kimich, 310 S.W.3d\n     868, 873 (Tex. 2010)).\n\n\n                                                          6\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26         Page 47 of 119\n\n\n\n\n                i.          Glass Lewis markets and advertises its services to Texans.\n\n         10.         Glass Lewis advertises its services on its website to investors across the United\n\nStates, including in Texas. 28 Its web pages are sales pages. They invite visitors to \u201cRequest More\n\nInformation,\u201d \u201cDownload Brochure,\u201d and \u201cContact Us.\u201d 29 One tells visitors, \u201cContact us to\n\nlearn how we can help you make informed decisions with confidence.\u201d 30\n\n\n\n\n                         Figure 1: Glass Lewis web page inviting visitors to contact Glass Lewis\n\n         11.         Glass Lewis asks visitors to fill out forms to download some of its materials or to\n\nhave its team contact them. 31 Its privacy statement says it may collect a visitor\u2019s name, email\n\naddress, employer\u2019s name, and title when the visitor contacts it or completes a registration form. 32\n\nIt may also collect visitors\u2019 IP addresses and \u201cgeolocation information,\u201d and it uses cookies to\n\nlearn \u201cwhere a user is located.\u201d 33 Its marketing cookies \u201ctrack your activity on Our Platforms and\n\n\n28\n     Glass Lewis, Proxy Voting Policies, https://www.glasslewis.com/investor-solutions/proxy-voting-policies (last\n     visited Oct. 18, 2026); Glass Lewis, Thematic Voting Policies, https://www.glasslewis.com/investor-\n     solutions/thematic-voting-policies (last visited Oct. 18, 2026); Glass Lewis, Corporate Governance and ESG Data,\n     https://www.glasslewis.com/investor-solutions/corporate-governance-and-esg-data (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n29\n     Glass Lewis, Proxy Voting Policies, supra; Glass Lewis, About Us, https://www.glasslewis.com/about-us (last\n     visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n30\n     Glass Lewis, Corporate Governance and ESG Data, supra.\n31\n     Glass Lewis, Download Your Copy of the Proxy Season Briefing for the United States,\n     https://grow.glasslewis.com/download-season-briefing-us-0 (last visited Oct. 18, 2026); Glass Lewis, Contact Us,\n     https://www.glasslewis.com/contact-us (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n32\n     Glass Lewis, Privacy Statement (eff. June 1, 2026), https://www.glasslewis.com/privacy (last visited Oct. 18,\n     2026).\n33\n     Id.\n\n\n                                                          7\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26        Page 48 of 119\n\n\n\n\nother websites you visit.\u201d 34 Glass Lewis says the traffic data it gathers \u201cmay be helpful for\n\nmarketing purposes.\u201d 35 It uses personal information for \u201c[p]roviding promotional material or\n\nother marketing materials.\u201d 36 Glass Lewis can thus tell when Texans visit its website, and it\n\nmarkets to them. On information and belief, visitors from Texas, including from Collin County,\n\nhave visited Glass Lewis\u2019s website and read and downloaded its guidelines, reports, and marketing\n\nmaterials.\n\n         12.      Glass Lewis currently has at least 27 clients with billing addresses in Texas. 37 On\n\ninformation and belief, it has had other Texas clients in past years. It told the federal district court\n\nin Austin that it \u201cserves over a dozen institutional investors in Texas.\u201d 38 Glass Lewis did not\n\nidentify those clients in the declaration it filed with its special appearance. 39 Texas public funds\n\nbuy proxy advice. \u00b6 37. A Texas Senate committee has reported that Glass Lewis and one other\n\nfirm \u201ccontrol an estimated 97% of the market\u201d for that advice. 40 On information and belief, Texas\n\npublic funds use, or have used, Glass Lewis\u2019s services. \u00b6\u00b6 37, 42. Glass Lewis says that 95% of its\n\ninstitutional clients renew each year. 41 Each renewal is a new sale that Glass Lewis solicits and\n\nmakes to a Texas client.\n\n\n\n\n34\n     Id.\n35\n     Id.\n36\n     Id.\n37\n     Wieck Decl. \u00b6 22.\n38\n     First Am. Compl. \u00b6 33, Glass, Lewis & Co. v. Paxton, No. 1:25-cv-01153-ADA (W.D. Tex. Sept. 9, 2025), ECF No.\n     40 [hereinafter Glass Lewis Am. Compl.].\n39\n     Wieck Decl. \u00b6 22.\n40\n     S.     Comm.       on     State     Affs.,    Tex.     Senate,      Interim  Report    34      (Jan.    2025),\n     https://senate.texas.gov/cmtes/89/c570/c570_InterimReport_2024.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n41\n     Glass Lewis, About Us, supra.\n\n\n                                                         8\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1             Filed 10/26/26   Page 49 of 119\n\n\n\n\n               ii.           Glass Lewis contracts with Texans and profits from Texas.\n\n         13.          Glass Lewis has contracts with its Texas clients to provide its proxy advisory\n\nservices. 42 Those clients pay Glass Lewis by ACH transfer, an electronic payment drawn from the\n\nclient\u2019s bank account. 43 Each payment moves money from a Texas client to Glass Lewis for the\n\nservices this suit concerns. Through these contracts and payments, Glass Lewis has created\n\ncontinuing relationships and obligations with Texas residents, and it profits from Texas year after\n\nyear.\n\n         14.          Glass Lewis says it did not sign these contracts in Texas, that its bank accounts are\n\nelsewhere, and that its online systems are hosted in Virginia and Iowa. 44 That is the kind of\n\n\u201cformalistic structuring\u201d that cannot shield a business that markets its services to Texans. 45\n\n               iii.          Glass Lewis delivers its reports and recommendations into Texas.\n\n         15.          Glass Lewis\u2019s chief operating officer has sworn that its advice \u201ccomes in the form\n\nof a detailed report sent to clients before a shareholder meeting.\u201d He has also sworn that every\n\nclient who receives research gets a \u201cProxy Paper,\u201d Glass Lewis\u2019s report on a shareholder meeting.\n\nEach Proxy Paper \u201csets out voting recommendations under Glass Lewis\u2019 Benchmark Policy.\u201d 46\n\nEach of Glass Lewis\u2019s Texas clients that receives research thus receives the Benchmark\n\nrecommendations this suit concerns. Those clients receive the reports and recommendations by\n\n\n\n\n42\n     Wieck Decl. \u00b6 18 (describing \u201cits contracts with Texas-based clients\u201d).\n43\n     Id. \u00b6 20.\n44\n     Id. \u00b6\u00b6 16, 18\u201320.\n45\n     BRP-Rotax, 716 S.W.3d at 107.\n46\n     Wieck Decl. \u00b6 7.\n\n\n                                                          9\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 111-1           Filed 10/26/26        Page 50 of 119\n\n\n\n\naccessing Glass Lewis\u2019s online systems from Texas. 47 Glass Lewis also casts votes for clients who\n\nask it to, under the voting policy each client chooses. 48\n\n         16.         Glass Lewis issues advice on the shareholder meetings of \u201chundreds of companies\u201d\n\norganized under Texas law or based in Texas. 49 In September 2025 alone, it expected to send its\n\nmore than 1,300 clients about 10 reports on Texas companies\u2019 meetings. 50 Glass Lewis knows its\n\nwork reaches Texas. It told the federal district court in Austin that it had \u201caccelerated the issuance\n\nof reports into August\u201d because of a Texas law. 51\n\n               iv.          Glass Lewis works with Texas investment firms and directs its\n                            statements to Texas.\n\n         17.         Charles Schwab Investment Management, part of The Charles Schwab\n\nCorporation of Westlake, Texas, has retained Glass Lewis for research, voting recommendations,\n\nand vote execution. 52 Schwab lets shareholders of its Schwab 1000 Index Fund choose to have their\n\nshares voted under the \u201cGlass Lewis Benchmark\u201d policy. 53\n\n         18.         A Dallas investment firm, Westwood Holdings Group, says it uses Glass Lewis\u2019s\n\nguidelines and \u201cgenerally follow[s]\u201d Glass Lewis\u2019s recommendations when it votes its clients\u2019\n\n\n\n\n47\n     Id. \u00b6\u00b6 16, 18.\n48\n     Compl. \u00b6 38, Glass, Lewis & Co. v. Paxton, No. 1:25-cv-01153-ADA (W.D. Tex. July 24, 2025), ECF No. 1\n     [hereinafter Glass Lewis Compl.].\n49\n     Glass Lewis Am. Compl. \u00b6 34.\n50\n     Id. \u00b6 71.\n51\n     Id. \u00b6 73.\n52\n     Schwab Asset Mgmt., Proxy Voting Policy Options, https://www.schwabassetmanagement.com/proxy-\n     voting/policy-options (last visited Oct. 18, 2026); Charles Schwab Corp., Annual Report (Form 10-K) (Feb. 25,\n     2026), https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/316709/000031670926000009/schw-20251231.htm (last\n     visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n53\n     Schwab Asset Mgmt., Proxy Voting Choice FAQ, https://www.schwabassetmanagement.com/proxy-voting/faq\n     (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n\n\n                                                        10\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 111-1           Filed 10/26/26        Page 51 of 119\n\n\n\n\nshares. 54 Westwood has also adopted the Glass Lewis voting guidelines for a mutual fund it helps\n\nmanage for American Beacon Funds, a fund company based in Irving, Texas. 55\n\n         19.      Glass Lewis has directed statements about its Benchmark Policy to the Texas\n\nAttorney General, and it posted those statements on its website for investors to read. 56\n\n               v.         The State\u2019s claims arise from these contacts.\n\n         20.      Specific jurisdiction requires \u201ca substantial connection between [the defendant\u2019s]\n\ncontacts and the operative facts of the litigation.\u201d 57 It \u201cdoes not necessarily require proof of\n\ncausation.\u201d 58 The United States Supreme Court asks whether a suit \u201carise[s] out of or relate[s] to\n\nthe defendant\u2019s contacts with the forum.\u201d 59 The back half of that test, after the \u201cor,\u201d\n\n\u201ccontemplates that some relationships will support jurisdiction without a causal showing.\u201d 60\n\nWhen all claims arise from the same forum contacts, a court need not analyze them claim by\n\nclaim. 61 The operative facts here are what Glass Lewis told people in Texas about its services and\n\nits sale of those services to Texas clients. \u00b6\u00b6 56\u2013138. The statements describe the very product\n\nthat Glass Lewis markets in Texas, sells in Texas, and delivers to each of its Texas clients. \u00b6\u00b6 10\u2013\n\n19. When a nonresident\u2019s actionable statements are received and cause harm in Texas, the\n\n\n\n\n54\n      Westwood        Holdings     Grp.,    Inc.,     Annual     Report     (Form  10-K)     (Mar.     4,   2026),\n     https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1165002/000116500226000020/whg-20251231.htm (last visited\n     Oct. 18, 2026).\n55\n     Am. Beacon Funds, Supplement to Statement of Additional Information (Form 497) app. B, at B-43 (Mar. 7,\n     2025),       https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/809593/000113322825002276/abscf-efp14988_497.htm\n     (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n56\n     Letter from Kevin Cameron, Exec. Chair, Glass Lewis, to State Attorneys General 1\u20132 (Jan. 31, 2023),\n     https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/Compliance/2023%20Letter%20to%20State%20AGs.pdf (last visited\n     Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter Glass Lewis Reply to Attorneys General].\n57\n     Moki Mac, 221 S.W.3d at 585.\n58\n     Volkswagen, 669 S.W.3d at 431; Luciano v. SprayFoamPolymers.com, LLC, 625 S.W.3d 1, 16\u201317 (Tex. 2021).\n59\n     Ford Motor Co. v. Mont. Eighth Jud. Dist. Ct., 592 U.S. 351, 362 (2021).\n60\n     Id.\n61\n     Moncrief Oil Int\u2019l Inc. v. OAO Gazprom, 414 S.W.3d 142, 150\u201351 (Tex. 2013); Luciano, 625 S.W.3d at 18.\n\n\n                                                        11\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1             Filed 10/26/26         Page 52 of 119\n\n\n\n\nactionable conduct occurs in Texas, even if the statements come from elsewhere. 62 By enacting the\n\nDTPA, Texas \u201chas demonstrated a special interest in protecting its citizens from the sort of\n\nactivity\u201d alleged here. 63 Texas has a \u201cstrong interest in exercising jurisdiction to protect its citizens\n\nfrom activities that may violate the Deceptive Trade Practices Act.\u201d 64\n\n               vi.          In the alternative, Glass Lewis is subject to general jurisdiction in\n                            Texas.\n\n         21.         In the alternative, the Court has general jurisdiction over Glass Lewis. General\n\njurisdiction exists when a defendant\u2019s contacts with Texas are so \u201ccontinuous and systematic\u201d\n\nthat it is \u201cessentially at home\u201d here. 65 Glass Lewis has marketed, offered, and sold its proxy\n\nadvisory services to Texans for decades. \u00b6\u00b6 10\u201319. It also consented to general jurisdiction in Texas\n\nby registering with the Texas Secretary of State to do business here. \u00b6 2. 66\n\nC.       Venue is proper in Collin County.\n\n         22.         Venue is proper in Collin County. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.47(b); Tex. Civ.\n\nPrac. & Rem. Code \u00a7 15.002(a)(1). The DTPA allows the State to sue in any county where the\n\ndefendant \u201chas done business\u201d or \u201cwhere the transaction occurred.\u201d Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7\n\n17.47(b).\n\n         23.         Glass Lewis has done business in Collin County. It markets its services to investors\n\nthere through its website. On information and belief, Collin County residents and businesses visit\n\nthat website and read the statements alleged in this petition there and in Glass Lewis\u2019s guidelines,\n\nreports, and marketing materials. \u00b6 11. On information and belief, Glass Lewis has clients or\n\n\n62\n     TV Azteca, 490 S.W.3d at 54.\n63\n     Siskind, 642 S.W.2d at 437.\n64\n     Yelp, 725 S.W.3d at 187.\n65\n     Yelp, 725 S.W.3d at 176 (quoting Volkswagen, 669 S.W.3d at 412).\n66\n     See Mallory v. Norfolk S. Ry. Co., 600 U.S. 122, 134\u201336 (2023); Acacia Pipeline Corp. v. Champlin Expl., Inc., 769\n     S.W.2d 719, 720 (Tex. App.\u2014Houston [1st Dist.] 1989, no writ).\n\n\n                                                          12\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA              Document 111-1           Filed 10/26/26        Page 53 of 119\n\n\n\n\nsubscribers in Collin County, who receive its reports and Benchmark recommendations there. \u00b6\u00b6\n\n12, 15. On information and belief, Collin County residents also receive those reports and\n\nrecommendations indirectly, through the funds, advisers, and voting-choice programs that use\n\nthem. \u00b6\u00b6 17\u201318, 134\u2013135. And on information and belief, Collin County residents invest in funds\n\nand plans, wherever based, that receive Glass Lewis\u2019s reports or vote on its recommendations. \u00b6\u00b6\n\n36, 44\u201345. Each of these is an act or practice in Collin County and business Glass Lewis has done\n\nthere. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7\u00a7 17.45(6), 17.46(a), 17.47(b). On information and belief,\n\ntransactions at issue occurred there. \u00b6 12. A substantial part of the events giving rise to the State\u2019s\n\nclaims occurred in Collin County. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code \u00a7 15.002(a)(1).\n\n         24.     Glass Lewis also issues reports and recommendations on the shareholder meetings\n\nof public companies based in Collin County, and its clients use them to vote at those meetings. For\n\nexample, Glass Lewis issued reports recommending how to vote at the 2018, 2019, and 2021 annual\n\nmeetings of Denbury Inc., an oil company then based in Plano. 67 In 2017, Glass Lewis\n\nrecommended that shareholders of Rent-A-Center, Inc., a Plano company, elect two directors\n\nnominated by an activist investor. Shareholders elected both. 68 Tyler Technologies, Inc., also\n\n\n67\n     Denbury      Res.    Inc.,  Additional   Proxy    Materials    (Schedule     14A)   (May     16,   2018),\n     https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/945764/000094576418000069/dnr-2018xproxyamiss.htm             (last\n     visited Oct. 18, 2026); Denbury Res. Inc., Additional Proxy Materials (Schedule 14A) (May 14, 2019),\n     https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/945764/000094576419000063/dnr-2019xproxysupplementam.htm\n     (last visited Oct. 18, 2026); Denbury Inc., Additional Proxy Materials (Schedule 14A) (May 13, 2021),\n     https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/945764/000094576421000070/den-2021xproxysupplement.htm\n     (last visited Oct. 18, 2026); Denbury Inc., Annual Report (Form 10-K) (Mar. 5, 2021),\n     https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/945764/000094576421000022/den-20201231.htm (last visited Oct.\n     18, 2026).\n68\n     Press Release, Rent-A-Center, Inc., Rent-A-Center Comments on Glass Lewis Report (June 1, 2017),\n     https://investor.upbound.com/node/10946/pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026); Engaged Capital, LLC, Additional\n     Proxy             Materials         (Schedule           14A)            (June          1,          2017),\n     https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/0000933036/000092189517001689/dfan14a09455023_06012017.h\n     tm (last visited Oct. 18, 2026); Rent-A-Center, Inc., Current Report (Form 8-K) ex. 99.1 (June 8, 2017),\n     https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/933036/000119312517202205/d404599dex991.htm (last visited\n     Oct. 18, 2026).\n\n\n                                                       13\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 111-1          Filed 10/26/26       Page 54 of 119\n\n\n\n\nbased in Plano, told its shareholders that votes on two of its directors in 2023 \u201cwere influenced by\n\ncommentary from Glass Lewis.\u201d 69 Cinemark Holdings, Inc., another Plano company, has met with\n\nrepresentatives of Glass Lewis. 70 Glass Lewis also sells services to public companies, including\n\nconsulting and the right to send \u201cReport Feedback Statements\u201d to its clients. \u00b6\u00b6 47, 101, 104. On\n\ninformation and belief, public companies based in Collin County have been solicited for Glass\n\nLewis\u2019s services and some have purchased them. Each such solicitation and sale is business Glass\n\nLewis has done in Collin County. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.47(b).\n\n                   IV.     PUBLIC INTEREST, TRADE, AND COMMERCE\n\n         25.     The State adopts and incorporates by reference all preceding paragraphs and\n\nallegations of this petition.\n\n         26.     The Consumer Protection Division has reason to believe that Glass Lewis is\n\nengaging in, has engaged in, or is about to engage in acts and practices the DTPA forbids. Tex. Bus.\n\n& Com. Code \u00a7 17.47(a). They are false, misleading, or deceptive acts or practices in the conduct\n\nof trade and commerce. Id. \u00a7 17.46(a). Those acts and practices have directly or indirectly affected\n\nthe people of Texas. See id. \u00a7 17.45(6). The Division believes that this suit is in the public interest.\n\nId. \u00a7 17.47(a). The State may bring it whether or not any consumer has complained or been injured.\n\nSee id. \u00a7 17.47(a), (c); \u00b6 187.\n\n         27.     The DTPA defines \u201ctrade\u201d and \u201ccommerce\u201d this way. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7\n\n17.45(6).\n\n\n69\n     Tyler      Techs.,      Inc.,      Proxy     Statement     (Schedule    14A)    (Mar.   29,    2024),\n     https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/860731/000086073124000015/tyl-20240329.htm (last visited Oct.\n     18, 2026).\n70\n     Cinemark       Holdings,      Inc.,    Proxy     Statement    (Schedule    14A)   (Apr.  6,    2022),\n     https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1385280/000114036122013386/ny20002675x1_def14a.htm       (last\n     visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n\n\n                                                    14\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                  Document 111-1             Filed 10/26/26          Page 55 of 119\n\n\n\n\n         \u201cTrade\u201d and \u201ccommerce\u201d mean the advertising, offering for sale, sale, lease, or\n         distribution of any good or service, of any property, tangible or intangible, real,\n         personal, or mixed, and any other article, commodity, or thing of value, wherever\n         situated, and shall include any trade or commerce directly or indirectly affecting the\n         people of this state.\n\n         28.       Glass Lewis advertises, offers for sale, sells, and distributes proxy research, voting\n\nrecommendations, voting policies, and vote-casting services. 71 Its website is a place where it\n\nadvertises and offers those services. That is why its pages invite visitors to \u201cRequest More\n\nInformation\u201d and to \u201cDownload Brochure.\u201d \u00b6\u00b6 10\u201311. Glass Lewis has engaged in trade and\n\ncommerce directly and indirectly affecting the people of Texas at all times relevant to this suit.\n\n         29.       The DTPA defines a \u201cconsumer\u201d as one who \u201cseeks or acquires by purchase or\n\nlease, any goods or services.\u201d Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.45(4). A consumer may be an\n\nindividual, partnership, or corporation. It may also be this State or a subdivision or agency of this\n\nState. Id. The term excludes a \u201cbusiness consumer\u201d with assets of $25 million or more. Id. That\n\nlimit governs who may sue under section 17.50. It does not limit the State\u2019s power to sue over \u201cany\n\nact or practice declared to be unlawful\u201d by the DTPA. 72 Nor does it limit the civil penalties that\n\nsection 17.47(c)(1) allows. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.47(c)(1). Where a DTPA provision itself\n\nuses the word \u201cconsumer,\u201d the State pleads consumers who meet the definition. \u00b6\u00b6 129, 152. A\n\nperson who acquires services that someone else buys for that person\u2019s benefit is a consumer. 73\n\n\n\n71\n     Glass Lewis, About Us, supra; Glass Lewis, Proxy Voting Policies, supra; Glass Lewis Compl. \u00b6 38.\n72\n     Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.47(a); Cameron v. Terrell & Garrett, Inc., 618 S.W.2d 535, 541 (Tex. 1981) (explaining\n     that section 17.45(4) \u201cdoes nothing more than describe the class of persons who can bring a suit for treble damages\n     under section 17.50\u201d); Flenniken v. Longview Bank & Tr. Co., 661 S.W.2d 705, 706 (Tex. 1983) (explaining that\n     section 17.45(4) \u201conly describes the class of persons entitled to bring suit under section 17.50\u201d); Bourland v. State,\n     528 S.W.2d 350, 358 (Tex. Civ. App.\u2014Austin 1975, writ ref\u2019d n.r.e.) (explaining that private suits, not the State\u2019s,\n     restrict claimants to \u201cconsumers\u201d); Texas v. Colony Ridge, Inc., No. H-24-0941, 2024 WL 4553111, at *7 n.4 (S.D.\n     Tex. Oct. 11, 2024), report and recommendation adopted, No. H-24-0941 (S.D. Tex. Nov. 26, 2024).\n73\n     Kennedy v. Sale, 689 S.W.2d 890, 892 (Tex. 1985) (holding that an employee covered by a group policy his\n     employer bought was a consumer); Arthur Andersen & Co. v. Perry Equip. Corp., 945 S.W.2d 812, 815 (Tex. 1997)\n\n\n                                                            15\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1           Filed 10/26/26         Page 56 of 119\n\n\n\n\nGlass Lewis\u2019s Texas consumers still include individuals who seek or acquire its services through\n\nfunds, advisers, and others who buy them. \u00b6\u00b6 10\u201319, 135. This State and its agencies are never\n\n\u201cbusiness consumers\u201d subject to exclusion from the DTPA\u2019s protections. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code\n\n\u00a7 17.45(10). So a state pension fund that buys proxy advice, as the Teacher Retirement System\u2019s\n\npolicy requires, is a consumer of that advice. \u00b6\u00b6 36\u201337. On information and belief, such funds are\n\nor have been among Glass Lewis\u2019s Texas clients. \u00b6 12.\n\n               V.      BACKGROUND: HOW SHAREHOLDER VOTING WORKS\n\n         30.        The State adopts and incorporates by reference all preceding paragraphs and\n\nallegations of this petition.\n\nA.       Shareholders own public companies and vote on how they are run.\n\n         31.        A share of stock is a piece of ownership in a company. As the investor website of\n\nthe Securities and Exchange Commission (\u201cSEC\u201d) puts it, \u201cWhen you own a share of stock, you\n\nown part of a company.\u201d 74 Large companies whose shares anyone can buy on a stock exchange are\n\ncalled public companies. Their owners are called shareholders. Shareholders do not run the\n\ncompany day to day. Under Texas law, a corporation\u2019s board of directors directs \u201cthe management\n\nof the business and affairs of the corporation.\u201d 75 Shareholders elect the directors, usually at an\n\n\n\n\n     (holding that a buyer that required an audit was a consumer of the auditor\u2019s services, though the company being\n     sold paid for them).\n74\n     Investor.gov, U.S. Sec. & Exch. Comm\u2019n, Stocks FAQs, https://www.investor.gov/introduction-\n     investing/investing-basics/investment-products/stocks (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n75\n     Tex. Bus. Orgs. Code \u00a7 21.401(a)(2).\n\n\n                                                         16\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26          Page 57 of 119\n\n\n\n\nannual meeting. 76 Each share usually carries one vote, so the more shares an investor owns, the\n\nmore votes it casts. 77\n\n         32.      Voting gives shareholders the power to elect directors and to make their views\n\nknown \u201con significant issues that may affect the value of [their] shares.\u201d 78 Shareholders may also\n\nput their own proposals on a company\u2019s ballot. A shareholder \u201cowning a relatively small amount\n\nof a company\u2019s securities\u201d can have a proposal \u201cplaced alongside management\u2019s proposals\u201d for a\n\nvote. 79 Some proposals deal with how a company is run, such as proposals to elect all directors\n\nevery year or to make it easier for shareholders to call a special meeting. 80 Other proposals push a\n\ncompany on environmental or social issues. At Amazon\u2019s 2025 annual meeting, for example,\n\nshareholders voted on proposals asking for reports on plastic packaging, greenhouse-gas emissions,\n\nand warehouse working conditions. 81\n\n         33.      The number of these votes has exploded. Elizabeth Ising, a securities lawyer,\n\ntestified to Congress that \u201cthe number of items voted on increased approximately 730% between\n\n2000 and 2024 at Russell 3000 companies.\u201d 82 The Russell 3000 is a stock index made up of\n\n\n76\n     Tex. Bus. Orgs. Code \u00a7 21.405(a); Investor.gov, U.S. Sec. & Exch. Comm\u2019n, Annual Meeting (glossary),\n     https://www.investor.gov/introduction-investing/investing-basics/glossary/annual-meeting (last visited Oct.\n     18, 2026).\n77\n     Tex. Bus. Orgs. Code \u00a7 21.366(a).\n78\n     Investor.gov, U.S. Sec. & Exch. Comm\u2019n, Shareholder Voting, https://www.investor.gov/research-before-you-\n     invest/research/shareholder-voting (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n79\n     U.S. Sec. & Exch. Comm\u2019n, Div. of Corp. Fin., Staff Legal Bulletin No. 14, \u00a7 B.1 (July 13, 2001),\n     https://www.sec.gov/interps/legal/cfslb14.htm (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n80\n     Investor.gov, U.S. Sec. & Exch. Comm\u2019n, Investor Bulletin: Voting in Annual Shareholder Meetings\u2014What\u2019s New\n     in 2012 (Mar. 28, 2012), https://www.investor.gov/news-alerts/investor-bulletins/voting-annual-shareholder-\n     meetings-what-s-new-2012 (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n81\n     Glass        Lewis,      Proxy        Paper:      Amazon.com,        Inc.      2       (May        1,      2025),\n     https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/Northern%20Trust/Amazon_PP25.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026)\n     [hereinafter Amazon Proxy Paper]; Amazon.com, Inc., Current Report (Form 8-K) Item 5.07 (May 22, 2025),\n     https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1018724/000110465925052014/tm2515134d1_8k.htm (last visited\n     Oct. 18, 2026).\n82\n     Exposing the Proxy Advisory Cartel: How ISS & Glass Lewis Influence Markets: Hearing Before the Subcomm. on Cap.\n     Mkts. of the H. Comm. on Fin. Servs., 119th Cong. (2025) (statement of Elizabeth A. Ising, Partner, Gibson, Dunn\n     & Crutcher LLP), reprinted in Harv. L. Sch. F. on Corp. Governance (May 5, 2025),\n\n\n                                                          17\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA             Document 111-1           Filed 10/26/26       Page 58 of 119\n\n\n\n\nroughly the 3,000 largest U.S. public companies. The 1,000 largest of them make up the \u201cRussell\n\n1000.\u201d These votes matter to every investor. They decide who sits on a company\u2019s board, and they\n\ntell directors what shareholders want the company to do with its money.\n\n         34.     Environmental and social issues, together with governance, are often called\n\n\u201cESG,\u201d short for \u201cenvironmental, social, and governance.\u201d A related term, \u201cDEI,\u201d stands for\n\n\u201cdiversity, equity, and inclusion.\u201d The President\u2019s December 2025 order on proxy advisors treats\n\nboth as \u201cnon-pecuniary factors in investing.\u201d 83 It states that some proxy advisors use their power\n\nto advance DEI and ESG agendas \u201ceven though investor returns should be the only priority.\u201d 84\n\nB.       Institutional investors cast most of the votes.\n\n         35.     Millions of Americans hold stock through mutual funds and exchange-traded\n\nfunds. 85 The pension plans, mutual funds, and asset managers that invest other people\u2019s money\n\nare called institutional investors. 86 They vote the shares they hold, and many of them owe a\n\n\u201cfiduciary duty to cast informed votes.\u201d 87 Institutional investors hold most of the stock in\n\nAmerica. The SEC has cited an estimate that they \u201chold around 72% of the domestic stock market\n\nvalue.\u201d 88 In other words, about $7 of every $10 invested in U.S. stocks is held by institutional\n\ninvestors. Because each share carries a vote, they cast most of the votes at shareholder meetings.\n\n\n\n\n     https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2025/05/05/testimony-in-house-hearing-exposing-the-proxy-advisory-cartel-\n     how-iss-glass-lewis-influence-markets-3/ (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter Ising Testimony].\n83\n     Exec. Order No. 14,366, 90 Fed. Reg. 58,503, 58,504 (Dec. 16, 2025).\n84\n     Id. at 58,503.\n85\n     Exec. Order No. 14,366, 90 Fed. Reg. at 58,503.\n86\n     Glass Lewis Compl. \u00b6 32; Def. Glass Lewis\u2019 Mot. to Dismiss Am. Pet. Under Rule 91a 1\u20132 (Sept. 14, 2026)\n     [hereinafter Glass Lewis Rule 91a Mot.].\n87\n     Glass Lewis Compl. \u00b6 30.\n88\n     Exemptions From the Proxy Rules for Proxy Voting Advice, 85 Fed. Reg. 55,082, 55,085 n.36 (Sept. 3, 2020)\n     (quoting A. De La Cruz et al., OECD, Owners of the World\u2019s Listed Companies 22 (2019)).\n\n\n                                                      18\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1             Filed 10/26/26         Page 59 of 119\n\n\n\n\n         36.      Texas is home to some of the largest institutional investors in the country. The\n\nTeacher Retirement System of Texas managed a fund worth about $225 billion as of August 2025,\n\nand it serves more than two million Texans. 89 The Employees Retirement System of Texas\n\nmanaged a fund worth about $40 billion as of August 2024. It serves more than 400,000 members,\n\nretirees, and beneficiaries. 90 The Texas Permanent School Fund, which helps pay for Texas public\n\nschools, has more than $64 billion in investments. It calls itself \u201cthe nation\u2019s oldest and largest\n\neducational endowment.\u201d 91 The University of Texas/Texas A&M Investment Management\n\nCompany (\u201cUTIMCO\u201d) manages about $92 billion for the University of Texas and Texas A&M\n\nsystems. 92\n\n         37.      Texas public funds buy proxy advice. The Teacher Retirement System\u2019s policy\n\nrequires its board to \u201cretain a reputable, independent proxy advisory service.\u201d 93 The Texas\n\nPermanent School Fund uses an \u201cexternal proxy voting manager,\u201d and its \u201cESG skeptical\u201d voting\n\npolicy \u201cis offered through Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS).\u201d 94 UTIMCO\u2019s policy names\n\n\n\n\n89\n     Teacher Ret. Sys. of Tex., 2025 Popular Annual Financial Report 1 (Nov. 2025),\n     https://www.trs.texas.gov/sites/default/files/2025-11/2025-Popular-Annual-Financial-Report.pdf (last visited\n     Oct. 18, 2026).\n90\n     Emps. Ret. Sys. of Tex., Serving Texans: Fiscal Year 2024 at a Glance (Dec. 6, 2024), https://ers.texas.gov/about-\n     ers/reports-and-studies/reports-on-overall-ers-operations-and-financial-ma/2024-at-a-glance (last visited Oct.\n     18, 2026).\n91\n     Tex. Permanent Sch. Fund Corp., Legislative Appropriations Request for Fiscal Years 2028 and 2029 1 (Aug. 2026),\n     https://texaspsf.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/706-Texas-PSF-2028-29-LAR.pdf (last visited Oct. 18,\n     2026).\n92\n     Univ. of Tex./Tex. A&M Inv. Mgmt. Co., Assets Under Management (July 31, 2026),\n     https://www.utimco.org/media/qzrfrsk1/fye2026oamassets.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n93\n      Teacher     Ret.    Sys.    of    Tex.,     Proxy    Voting     Policy   \u00a7     2    (rev.    Dec.     5,   2025),\n     https://www.trs.texas.gov/files/migrated/proxy_voting_policy.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n94\n     News Release, Tex. Permanent Sch. Fund Corp., Texas PSF Corporation Implements Proxy Voting Directives\n     Focused on Fiduciary Responsibility, Not Political Activism (Apr. 15, 2024), https://texaspsf.org/wp-\n     content/uploads/2024/10/Proxy-Voting-News-Release_04152024_a11y.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n\n\n                                                          19\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA              Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26        Page 60 of 119\n\n\n\n\nGlass Lewis\u2019s \u201cGovernance-Focused\u201d guidelines as an example of guidelines \u201cthat prioritize\n\neffective corporate governance and align with board recommendations.\u201d 95\n\n          38.     Investors like these must vote in the financial interest of the people they serve. The\n\nTeacher Retirement System, for example, requires that its proxies be voted \u201cin the best economic\n\ninterests of the pension plan.\u201d 96 The federal Employee Retirement Income Security Act\n\n(\u201cERISA\u201d) imposes a similar duty on many private retirement plans, whose managers must act\n\nfor the exclusive purpose of \u201cproviding benefits to participants and their beneficiaries.\u201d 97 When\n\nthose plans vote, federal rules require their fiduciaries to \u201c[a]ct solely in accordance with the\n\neconomic interest of the plan and its participants and beneficiaries.\u201d 98 A fiduciary \u201cmay not adopt\n\na practice of following the recommendations of a proxy advisory firm\u201d without first deciding that\n\nthe firm\u2019s voting guidelines are consistent with those duties. 99 Glass Lewis has told the federal\n\ndistrict court in Austin that \u201c[m]any Glass Lewis clients are asset managers to employee\n\nretirement plans governed by ERISA.\u201d 100\n\nC.        Most shareholders vote by proxy, and many large investors rely on proxy advisors.\n\n          39.     Few shareholders attend shareholder meetings. Most vote by \u201cproxy,\u201d which\n\nmeans \u201cauthorizing someone . . . to vote according to your wishes\u201d at the meeting. 101 Texas law\n\n\n\n\n95\n      Univ. of Tex./Tex. A&M Inv. Mgmt. Co., Proxy Voting Policy (Sept. 17, 2024),\n      https://fas.utimco.org/media/4413/final-utimco-proxy-voting-policy-9172024.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n96\n      Teacher Ret. Sys. of Tex., Proxy Voting Policy, supra, \u00a7 1.\n97\n      29 U.S.C. \u00a7 1104(a)(1)(A)(i).\n98\n      29 C.F.R. \u00a7 2550.404a-1(d)(2)(ii)(A) (2025).\n99\n      Id. \u00a7 2550.404a-1(d)(2)(iii).\n100\n      Glass Lewis Am. Compl. \u00b6 68.\n101\n      Investor.gov, U.S. Sec. & Exch. Comm\u2019n, How Do I Vote at a Corporate Election?,\n      https://www.investor.gov/research-before-you-invest/research/shareholder-voting/how-do-i-vote-corporate-\n      election (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n\n\n                                                        20\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA             Document 111-1          Filed 10/26/26       Page 61 of 119\n\n\n\n\nallows shareholders to vote by proxy. 102 Before each meeting, the company sends shareholders a\n\n\u201cproxy statement.\u201d Proxy statements \u201cdescribe matters up for shareholder vote.\u201d 103\n\n          40.     A large institutional investor may own stock in hundreds or thousands of\n\ncompanies. Glass Lewis agrees that \u201c[b]ecause institutional investors may own hundreds or\n\nthousands of stocks, they rely on proxy advisors to provide advice about upcoming shareholder\n\nvotes.\u201d 104 A proxy advisor is a business that researches the matters up for a vote and recommends\n\nhow its clients should vote. Some investors go further and give proxy advisors \u201cauthority to\n\nexecute votes\u201d for them. 105 Proxy advisors also sell ready-made voting policies, such as Glass\n\nLewis\u2019s Benchmark Policy and its \u201cthematic\u201d policies, and they apply custom policies that clients\n\nwrite themselves. \u00b6\u00b6 49, 51, 82.\n\n          41.     Proxy advisors sell this as a way to save time and money. Glass Lewis, for example,\n\nadvertises \u201cready-to-use guidelines that eliminate the need for in-house development and\n\nmanagement of voting policies.\u201d 106 The SEC has stated that proxy advisors are \u201cuniquely situated\n\nin today\u2019s market to influence, and in many cases directly execute, these investors\u2019 voting\n\ndecisions.\u201d 107\n\n          42.     A 2016 federal report found five firms in the industry, \u201ctwo of which are the largest\n\nand most dominant proxy advisory firms.\u201d Those two firms are Glass Lewis and Institutional\n\n\n\n\n102\n      Tex. Bus. Orgs. Code \u00a7 21.367(a).\n103\n      U.S. Sec. & Exch. Comm\u2019n, Annual Meetings and Proxy Requirements (June                       6,   2024),\n      https://www.sec.gov/smallbusiness/goingpublic/annualmeetings (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n104\n      Glass Lewis Rule 91a Mot. at 2.\n105\n      85 Fed. Reg. at 55,083.\n106\n      Glass Lewis, Proxy Voting Policies, supra.\n107\n      85 Fed. Reg. at 55,083.\n\n\n                                                      21\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                  Document 111-1             Filed 10/26/26           Page 62 of 119\n\n\n\n\nShareholder Services Inc. (\u201cISS\u201d). 108 As of 2021, ISS held 48% and Glass Lewis held 42% of the\n\nproxy advisory market for U.S. mutual funds, measured by the assets they advise on. 109 The State\n\nhas also sued ISS under the DTPA. That suit is also pending before this Court. 110\n\nD.        Proxy advisors shape how shareholders vote.\n\n          43.       Ising testified to Congress that ISS and Glass Lewis \u201cexercise significant influence\n\nover the voting outcomes\u201d on thousands of proposals. 111 Georgeson, a firm that helps companies\n\nwin shareholder votes, measured that influence. In 2025, environmental proposals that both ISS\n\nand Glass Lewis supported received, on average, 31% of the votes cast. Proposals that both opposed\n\nreceived, on average, 12%. 112 One study of votes on executive pay found that a negative Glass Lewis\n\nrecommendation was associated with 12.9% more votes against the pay plan. 113\n\n          44.       Some investors follow a proxy advisor\u2019s recommendations automatically. This is\n\ncalled \u201crobo-voting.\u201d 114 One study found that 114 institutional investors managing more than $5\n\ntrillion voted in lockstep with ISS or Glass Lewis in 2020. About one in seven of them followed\n\n\n\n\n108\n      U.S. Gov\u2019t Accountability Off., GAO-17-47, Corporate Shareholder Meetings: Proxy Advisory Firms\u2019 Role in Voting\n      and Corporate Governance Practices i, 7\u20138 (2016), https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-17-47.pdf (last visited Oct. 18,\n      2026).\n109\n      Chong Shu, The Proxy Advisory Industry: Influencing and Being Influenced, 154 J. Fin. Econ. 103810 (2024),\n      summarized       at      Harv.       L.     Sch.     F.      on      Corp.    Governance      (May       2,     2024),\n      https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2024/05/02/the-proxy-advisory-industry-influencing-and-being-influenced\n      (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n110\n      Pl.\u2019s Original Pet., State v. Institutional S\u2019holder Servs., Inc., No. 471-03459-2026 (471st Dist. Ct., Collin County,\n      Tex. filed May 20, 2026).\n111\n      Ising Testimony, supra.\n112\n      Georgeson,          Full       Season        Report       19        (Sept.     29,      2025),       https://content-\n      assets.computershare.com/eh96rkuu9740/6JRQJDMCnAm6pCXhn5v1zy/5e1a1f8f1fd06b0d8f841cc12479dbba\n      /Georgeson_Full_Season_Report_FINAL_9.29.2025.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter Georgeson\n      2025].\n113\n      Fabrizio Ferri, Shareholder Votes and Proxy Advisors: Evidence from Say on Pay, Harv. L. Sch. F. on Corp.\n      Governance (Apr. 9, 2012), https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2012/04/09/shareholder-votes-and-proxy-\n      advisors/ (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n114\n      Shu, supra.\n\n\n                                                             22\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                 Document 111-1              Filed 10/26/26          Page 63 of 119\n\n\n\n\nGlass Lewis. 115 Ising testified that she routinely sees \u201ca flood of votes\u201d cast \u201cstrictly in line with\n\nthe advisory firm\u2019s recommendations\u201d soon after the recommendations come out. 116 For a robo-\n\nvoting investor, the proxy advisor\u2019s recommendation is the vote. The rules the advisor writes\n\ndecide how that investor\u2019s shares are cast.\n\n          45.       Glass Lewis\u2019s voting platform makes lockstep robo-voting easier. One study looked\n\nat funds that subscribe to both ISS and Glass Lewis. Those using Glass Lewis\u2019s platform \u201ctend to\n\nvote 19 percentage points more consistently with Glass Lewis\u2019s advice.\u201d 117 Glass Lewis\u2019s voting\n\nplatform is called Viewpoint. Glass Lewis says investors \u201cdepend on Glass Lewis\u2019 Viewpoint\n\nplatform to manage their proxy voting,\u201d and Viewpoint offers clients \u201cpre-populated\u201d votes. 118 A\n\nDallas investment firm, for example, says it \u201cgenerally follow[s]\u201d Glass Lewis\u2019s\n\nrecommendations. \u00b6 18.\n\n          46.       Glass Lewis has taken sides in real contests at Texas companies, and its side has\n\noften won. In 2021, an activist fund ran a proxy fight at Exxon, then based in Irving, Texas. Glass\n\nLewis backed two of the fund\u2019s nominees, Gregory Goff and Alexander Karsner. It wrote that\n\nExxon \u201chas not effectively communicated a compelling overall strategy and capital spending\n\nprogram that is indicative of a clear, cohesive plan for Exxon in a lower-carbon world.\u201d 119 The fund\n\n\n115\n      Paul Rose, Proxy Advisors and Market Power: A Review of Institutional Investor Robovoting, Harv. L. Sch. F. on Corp.\n      Governance (May 27, 2021), https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2021/05/27/proxy-advisors-and-market-power-\n      a-review-of-institutional-investor-robovoting/ (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n116\n      Ising Testimony, supra.\n117\n      Shu, supra.\n118\n      Glass Lewis, Due Diligence: A Resource for Investment Advisers on Glass Lewis Policies and Procedures 4, 7 n.10 (Oct.\n      2025),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/Compliance/2025%20Due%20Diligence%20Resource%20Guide.pdf\n      (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter 2025 Due Diligence Guide].\n119\n      Engine No. 1 LLC, Additional Proxy Materials (Schedule 14A) (May 20, 2021),\n      https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/34088/000090266421002867/p21-1450dfan14a.htm (last visited\n      Oct. 18, 2026); Rob Ball et al., Was the Exxon Fight a Bellwether?, Harv. L. Sch. F. on Corp. Governance (July 24,\n      2021), https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2021/07/24/was-the-exxon-fight-a-bellwether/ (last visited Oct. 18,\n      2026).\n\n\n                                                            23\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 111-1          Filed 10/26/26      Page 64 of 119\n\n\n\n\nwon three seats, including both of Glass Lewis\u2019s picks. Mr. Karsner drew the fewest votes of the\n\nfund\u2019s three winners. He still received about 73 million more votes than the Exxon nominee with\n\nthe most votes who was not elected. 120 In Collin County, Glass Lewis backed two activist nominees\n\nat Rent-A-Center, and both won. Tyler Technologies told its shareholders that votes on two of its\n\ndirectors \u201cwere influenced by commentary from Glass Lewis.\u201d \u00b6 24.\n\nE.        Glass Lewis sells research, voting policies, and a voting platform.\n\n          47.     Glass Lewis was founded in 2003. It says it serves more than 1,300 investors, covers\n\nmore than 30,000 shareholder meetings a year, and has clients who manage about $40 trillion. 121\n\nIt also sells services to more than 2,300 public companies, the same kind of companies on whose\n\nvotes it advises investors. 122\n\n          48.     Glass Lewis sells three main things to investors. They are research reports called\n\nProxy Papers, voting policies, and its Viewpoint voting platform. Each Proxy Paper analyzes each\n\nitem on a meeting\u2019s ballot and recommends how to vote. 123 A voting policy is a set of rules that\n\nturns Glass Lewis\u2019s research into \u201cfor\u201d and \u201cagainst\u201d recommendations. 124\n\n          49.     Glass Lewis\u2019s own standard policy is called the Benchmark Policy. It is Glass\n\nLewis\u2019s \u201chouse\u201d policy. 125 Glass Lewis writes a version of the Benchmark Policy for each country\n\nor region, such as the United States or Canada. These are its \u201cregional benchmark guidelines\u201d or\n\n\n120\n      Ball et al., supra; Exxon Mobil Corp., Current Report (Form 8-K/A) Item 5.07 (June 21, 2021),\n      https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/34088/000003408821000037/xom-20210526.htm (last visited Oct.\n      18, 2026).\n121\n      Glass Lewis, About Us, supra.\n122\n      Id.\n123\n      Wieck Decl. \u00b6 7.\n124\n      See 85 Fed. Reg. at 55,083.\n125\n      Glass        Lewis,      Benchmark        Policy      Guidelines 2027:      Canada     7      (2026),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/Policy%20Guidelines/2027%20Guidelines/Benchmark%20Policy%20G\n      uidelines%202027%20-%20Canada.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) (\u201cGlass Lewis\u2019 single house policy has\n      traditionally anchored the regional benchmark guidelines.\u201d).\n\n\n                                                     24\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                  Document 111-1             Filed 10/26/26           Page 65 of 119\n\n\n\n\n\u201cmarket-specific\u201d policies. 126 Glass Lewis publishes new Benchmark guidelines on its website late\n\neach year. They apply to meetings held from the following January. 127\n\n          50.       Every Glass Lewis client that receives research gets a Proxy Paper with Benchmark\n\nrecommendations, no matter which policy the client chose. 128 Even clients with their own custom\n\npolicies receive Proxy Papers \u201cwhich feature analysis and recommendations based on the Glass\n\nLewis benchmark policy.\u201d 129 A client may also pay for recommendations under its own \u201ccustom\u201d\n\npolicy or one of Glass Lewis\u2019s \u201cthematic\u201d policies. 130 Glass Lewis says it tailors those\n\nrecommendations \u201cto each client\u2019s specific voting policy.\u201d 131 In this petition, \u201cBenchmark\n\nservices\u201d means the Benchmark Policy, its guidelines, and the Benchmark recommendations Glass\n\nLewis delivers to clients in Proxy Papers and through Viewpoint.\n\nF.        Glass Lewis sells separate policies for investors who want different things.\n\n          51.       Glass Lewis also sells \u201cthematic\u201d policies, which are ready-made rules built around\n\na theme. It tells buyers to \u201c[c]hoose a thematic policy that reflects your goals and values.\u201d 132 Its\n\nmenu runs from one end to the other. Its ESG Policy \u201c[s]upports investors focused on\n\nenvironmental and social issues.\u201d 133 Its Climate Policy \u201cwas designed for clients with a strong\n\nfocus on environmental risk mitigation.\u201d 134 Its Corporate Governance Focused Policy generally\n\n\n126\n      Glass Lewis, Benchmark Policy Guidelines 2027: Canada, supra, at 7; Glass Lewis, Policy Guidelines,\n      https://www.glasslewis.com/policy-guidelines (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n127\n      Glass Lewis, Policy Guidelines, supra; Glass Lewis, Proxy Voting Policies, supra.\n128\n      Wieck Decl. \u00b6 7.\n129\n      Glass Lewis, Best Practice Principles for Providers of Shareholder Voting Research & Analysis: Statement of Compliance\n      10 (2025) (covering 2024), https://bppgrp.info/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/Glass-Lewis-BPP-Report-\n      2024.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter 2024 Compliance Statement].\n130\n      Wieck Decl. \u00b6 7; Glass Lewis Am. Compl. \u00b6\u00b6 41\u201342, 44.\n131\n      Glass Lewis Am. Compl. \u00b6 40.\n132\n      Glass Lewis, Thematic Voting Policies, supra.\n133\n      Id.\n134\n      Glass       Lewis,         Climate          Thematic         Voting       Policy      Guidelines        2026        6,\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/2026%20Guidelines/Thematic/Thematic%20Voting%20Policy%20202\n      6%20-%20Climate.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter 2026 Climate Policy].\n\n\n                                                             25\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA              Document 111-1           Filed 10/26/26         Page 66 of 119\n\n\n\n\nrecommends \u201cin line with management on environmental and social issues.\u201d 135 And its Bowyer\n\nResearch Policy is sold \u201cfor investors skeptical of politicized ESG and DEI initiatives.\u201d 136\n\n          52.     The policy a client picks changes the advice it gets. Under the Climate Policy, for\n\nexample, Glass Lewis will oppose the chair of the board committee that oversees environmental\n\nand social issues if the company has not disclosed its greenhouse-gas emissions. 137 Glass Lewis has\n\nsaid that an emissions-target proposal \u201cis far more likely to be supported under our Climate Policy\n\nthan our Governance-Focused Policy.\u201d 138\n\n          53.     This menu is Glass Lewis\u2019s own admission that investors do not share one view on\n\nenvironmental and social issues. It sells one policy for investors who want those priorities and\n\nanother for investors who reject them. A firm would not need both unless its clients disagreed. \u00b6\n\n51.\n\n          54.     The menu also tells buyers where the Benchmark Policy sits. With an ESG Policy\n\non one side and an ESG-skeptic policy on the other, the Benchmark reads as the mainstream\n\nmiddle. Glass Lewis says as much when it describes the Benchmark as reflecting \u201cbroad investor\n\nopinion.\u201d \u00b6 58. A buyer who wants mainstream advice focused on shareholder value has every\n\nreason to choose the Benchmark Policy. A buyer who wants an ESG focus has reason to choose the\n\nESG Policy. 139\n\n\n\n135\n      Glass Lewis Compl. \u00b6 43.\n136\n      Glass Lewis, Thematic Voting Policies, supra.\n137\n      2026 Climate Policy at 5.\n138\n      Letter from Kevin Cameron, Exec. Chair, Glass Lewis, to State Treasurers and Financial Officers 4 (June 29,\n      2023),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/Compliance/State%20Treasurers%20Group%20Response%20Letter.pd\n      f (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter 2023 Treasurers Letter].\n139\n      See Glass Lewis, Thematic Voting Policies, supra; Glass Lewis, ESG Thematic Voting Policy Guidelines 2026 7,\n      https://corporate.vanguard.com/content/dam/corp/advocate/investment-stewardship/pdf/investor-\n      choice/esg_policy_by_glass_lewis.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter 2026 ESG Policy].\n\n\n                                                        26\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 111-1          Filed 10/26/26         Page 67 of 119\n\n\n\n\n  VI.       GLASS LEWIS\u2019S FALSE, MISLEADING, AND DECEPTIVE STATEMENTS\n\n          55.         The State adopts and incorporates by reference all preceding paragraphs and\n\nallegations of this petition.\n\n          56.         Since at least 2016, Glass Lewis has made false, misleading, and deceptive\n\nstatements about its proxy advice and voting policies, above all its Benchmark Policy. The\n\nstatements concern the nature, basis, purpose, and quality of what Glass Lewis sells. Glass Lewis\n\nmade them in its guidelines, compliance statements, website, survey reports, Proxy Papers,\n\nmarketing materials, and letters it posted online for investors. It also made them in its dealings with\n\nclients and prospective clients.\n\n          57.         The statements fall into four groups. Glass Lewis said its Benchmark Policy reflects\n\nbroad investor opinion and its clients\u2019 predominant views. It said the policy reflects best practices\n\nand widely accepted governance principles. It said its advice is independent, objective, and aimed\n\nat long-term shareholder value. And it said its policies are built from the bottom up, on client input.\n\nGlass Lewis also kept from investors facts that showed these statements were false or misleading.\n\nIt made these statements far more often than the examples below.\n\nA.        Glass Lewis said the Benchmark Policy reflects \u201cbroad investor opinion.\u201d\n\n                 i.          Glass Lewis made this statement in its guidelines, compliance\n                             statements, and published letters.\n\n          58.         Glass Lewis\u2019s 2026 Benchmark guidelines for the United States describe the\n\nBenchmark Policy this way. 140\n\n\n\n\n140\n      Glass      Lewis,      Benchmark     Policy   Guidelines      2026:      United     States    7      (2025),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/2026%20Guidelines/Benchmark/Benchmark%20Policy%20Guidelines%\n      202026%20-%20United%20States.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter 2026 Benchmark Guidelines].\n\n\n                                                        27\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                  Document 111-1             Filed 10/26/26           Page 68 of 119\n\n\n\n\n          The Benchmark Policy reflects broad investor opinion and widely accepted\n          governance principles and is intended to provide clients with nuanced analysis\n          informed by market best practice, regulation, and prevailing investor sentiment.\n\n          59.       Glass Lewis\u2019s 2026 guidelines on shareholder proposals say the same thing. 141 Glass\n\nLewis has said that its 2026 guidelines \u201cwill remain static for 2027,\u201d so the same description\n\napplies to meetings in 2027. 142\n\n          60.       Glass Lewis\u2019s compliance statements for 2023 and 2024 each say that \u201cthe\n\nbenchmark policy reflects the current, predominant views of our institutional investor clients on\n\ncorporate governance best practices.\u201d The same sentence ends, \u201cwe recognize that our clients\n\nhave differing needs and views.\u201d 143 Its 2024 policy-survey report says the guidelines \u201cgenerally\n\nreflect the current, predominant views of institutional investor clients on corporate governance\n\nbest practices.\u201d 144 For years before that, its compliance statements explained how clients choose a\n\npolicy. Those for 2016, 2018, and 2020 through 2022 said that clients who adopt its policies\n\n\u201cgenerally do so after determining that the Glass Lewis approach closely reflects their own\n\nview.\u201d 145\n\n\n141\n      Glass Lewis, Benchmark Policy Guidelines 2026: Shareholder Proposals & ESG-Related Issues 7 (2025),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/2026%20Guidelines/Benchmark/Benchmark%20Policy%20Guidelines%\n      202026%20-%20Shareholder%20Proposals.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter 2026 Shareholder Proposal\n      Guidelines].\n142\n      Glass       Lewis,      Benchmark         Policy      Guidelines     2027:       United      States     7      (2026),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/Policy%20Guidelines/2027%20Guidelines/Benchmark%20Policy%20G\n      uidelines%202027%20-%20United%20States.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter 2027 Benchmark\n      Guidelines].\n143\n      Glass Lewis, Best Practice Principles for Providers of Shareholder Voting Research & Analysis: Statement of Compliance\n      13 (covering 2023), https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/Compliance/2023%20BPP%20Statement.pdf (last\n      visited Oct. 18, 2026); 2024 Compliance Statement at 13.\n144\n      Glass Lewis, Glass Lewis Policy Survey 2024: Results & Key Findings 5 (2024),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/2024%20Policy%20Survey/2024%20Glass%20Lewis%20Policy%20Surv\n      ey%20Results.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter 2024 Survey Report].\n145\n      Glass Lewis, Best Practice Principles for Providers of Shareholder Voting Research & Analysis: Statement of Compliance\n      12 (covering 2016), https://bppgrp.info/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/GL_BPP_Compliance_Statement_FY-\n      2016_0317.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter 2016 Compliance Statement]; Glass Lewis, Best Practice\n      Principles for Providers of Shareholder Voting Research & Analysis: Statement of Compliance 13 (covering 2018),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/Compliance/2019%20BPP%20Statement.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026)\n\n\n                                                             28\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                 Document 111-1             Filed 10/26/26          Page 69 of 119\n\n\n\n\n          61.      In January 2023, Glass Lewis wrote to the attorneys general of Texas and other\n\nStates. It said its Benchmark Policy \u201cgenerally reflects the current, predominant views of our\n\ninstitutional investor clients on corporate governance best practices.\u201d 146 In June 2023, it told state\n\ntreasurers the same thing. Glass Lewis posted both letters on its website for investors to read. 147\n\n          62.      Glass Lewis said the same thing to the federal district court in Austin. It said the\n\nfactors its Benchmark Policy considers \u201creflect the consensus views of Glass Lewis\u2019 1300+\n\ninstitutional investor clients.\u201d 148 In June 2025, it told United States Senators that its Benchmark\n\nboard-diversity policy \u201creflects an emerging consensus over recent years in the business and\n\ninvestor community.\u201d 149 Glass Lewis posted that letter on its website and encouraged \u201cour clients\n\nand anyone else interested in these issues to check the facts.\u201d 150 It made similar claims to the SEC.\n\nIn 2020, it said it \u201caims to have policies that reflect the views of its clients.\u201d 151 In 2021, it said that\n\n\n\n\n      [hereinafter 2018 Compliance Statement]; Glass Lewis, Best Practice Principles for Providers of Shareholder Voting\n      Research       &        Analysis:       Statement        of        Compliance        11      (covering        2020),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/Compliance/2020%20Best%20Practice%20Principles%20for%20Shareh\n      older%20Voting%20Research%20Analysis.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter 2020 Compliance\n      Statement]; Glass Lewis, Best Practice Principles for Providers of Shareholder Voting Research & Analysis: Statement\n      of                     Compliance                       11                      (covering                     2021),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/Compliance/2021%20BPP%20Statement.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026)\n      [hereinafter 2021 Compliance Statement]; Glass Lewis, Best Practice Principles for Providers of Shareholder Voting\n      Research & Analysis: Statement of Compliance 12\u201313 (covering 2022), https://www.glasslewis.com/wp-\n      content/uploads/2024/04/Glass-Lewis-BPP-Statement-2022.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter 2022\n      Compliance Statement].\n146\n      Glass Lewis Reply to Attorneys General at 1\u20132.\n147\n      2023 Treasurers Letter at 2.\n148\n      Glass Lewis Am. Compl. \u00b6 40.\n149\n      Letter from Bob Mann, CEO, Glass Lewis, to Sens. Tim Scott, Bill Hagerty & M. Michael Rounds 7 (June 10,\n      2025),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/Client%20Communication/Glass%20Lewis%20Letter%20to%20Senate%\n      20Banking%20Members%20-%20June%202025.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter Senate Letter].\n150\n      Glass Lewis, Glass Lewis Letter to Senate Banking Committee Members (June 11, 2025),\n      https://www.glasslewis.com/article/glass-lewis-letter-to-senate-banking-committee-members (last visited Oct.\n      18, 2026).\n151\n      Letter from Glass, Lewis & Co. to Vanessa A. Countryman, Sec\u2019y, SEC 3 (Feb. 3, 2020) (File No. S7-22-19),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/Compliance/Comment%20Letter%20Final.pdf (last visited Oct. 18,\n      2026) [hereinafter 2020 SEC Comment Letter].\n\n\n                                                            29\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 111-1          Filed 10/26/26        Page 70 of 119\n\n\n\n\n\u201con many issues, our recommendations are based on corporate governance best practices that\n\nreflect the consensus view of most institutional investors.\u201d 152\n\n          63.         In its 2026 guidelines, Glass Lewis also changed its voice. The 2025 guidelines said,\n\n\u201cWe believe part of the board\u2019s role is to ensure that management conducts a complete risk\n\nanalysis . . . .\u201d 153 Now they say, \u201cThe Benchmark Policy is of the view that part of the board\u2019s role\n\nis to ensure that management conducts a complete risk analysis . . . .\u201d 154 The view did not change.\n\nOnly the label did. Glass Lewis\u2019s own views now appear as the views of a policy that Glass Lewis\n\nsays reflects broad investor opinion.\n\n                ii.          The Benchmark Policy carries voting rules that most investors do not\n                             share.\n\n          64.         The 2026 Benchmark guidelines contain voting rules on board diversity, board\n\noversight of environmental and social issues, and climate disclosure. 155 The nominating committee\n\npicks a company\u2019s director candidates. For that committee, the Benchmark Policy \u201cwill consider\n\nrecommending that shareholders vote against\u201d three kinds of directors. The first is the committee\n\nchair at a Russell 3000 company whose board \u201cis not at least 30% gender diverse.\u201d The second is\n\nevery committee member at a Russell 3000 company with \u201cno gender diverse directors.\u201d The\n\nthird is the committee chair at a Russell 1000 company with \u201cfewer than one director from an\n\nunderrepresented community on the board.\u201d 156 Outside the Russell 3000, the policy \u201cwill\n\n\n152\n      Letter from Nichol Garzon-Mitchell, Gen. Counsel, Glass Lewis, to Vanessa A. Countryman, Sec\u2019y, SEC 3 (Dec.\n      27, 2021) (File No. S7-17-21), https://www.sec.gov/comments/s7-17-21/s71721-20110796-264649.pdf (last\n      visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n153\n      Glass Lewis, 2025 Benchmark Policy Guidelines: Shareholder Proposals & ESG-Related Issues 26 (2024),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/2025%20Guidelines/2025%20Shareholder%20Proposals%20&%20ESG\n      %20Benchmark%20Policy%20Guidelines.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter 2025 Shareholder Proposal\n      Guidelines].\n154\n      2026 Shareholder Proposal Guidelines at 26.\n155\n      2026 Benchmark Guidelines at 27, 29, 33.\n156\n      Id. at 27.\n\n\n                                                        30\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA              Document 111-1           Filed 10/26/26         Page 71 of 119\n\n\n\n\nrecommend voting against the chair of the nominating committee if there are no gender diverse\n\ndirectors.\u201d 157\n\n          65.     The Benchmark Policy also targets the governance committee chair of a large\n\ncompany that does not disclose the board\u2019s role in overseeing environmental and social issues. 158\n\nFor certain companies, it checks whether climate disclosures follow outside frameworks, such as\n\nthe one published by the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures. If those disclosures\n\nfall short, the policy \u201cmay recommend voting against the chair of the committee\u201d that oversees\n\nclimate issues. 159\n\n          66.     Glass Lewis has applied rules like these since 2019. Its 2018 guidelines announced\n\nthat, \u201c[b]eginning in 2019,\u201d it \u201cwill generally recommend voting against the nominating\n\ncommittee chair of a board that has no female members.\u201d 160 Its 2020 guidelines repeated that\n\nrule. 161 Its 2021 guidelines announced that, starting in 2022, it would \u201cgenerally recommend voting\n\nagainst the nominating committee chair of a board with fewer than two female directors.\u201d 162 They\n\nalso announced a rule for the governance chair of an S&P 500 company that \u201cfails to provide\n\nexplicit disclosure concerning the board\u2019s role in overseeing these issues.\u201d Those issues are\n\nenvironmental and social issues, and Glass Lewis would generally recommend voting against that\n\n\n157\n      Id.\n158\n      Id. at 29 (\u201c[T]he Benchmark Policy will generally recommend voting against the governance committee chair of\n      a company in the Russell 1000 index that fails to provide explicit disclosure concerning the board\u2019s role in\n      overseeing these issues.\u201d).\n159\n      Id. at 33.\n160\n      Glass       Lewis,      2018      Proxy       Paper       Guidelines:     United   States     2      (2017),\n      https://www.faegredrinker.com/webfiles/5%202018_proxy.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter 2018\n      Guidelines].\n161\n      Glass       Lewis,      2020      Proxy       Paper      Guidelines:      United  States     25      (2019),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/2020%20Guidelines/2020%20United%20States%20Benchmark%20Poli\n      cy%20Guidelines.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter 2020 Guidelines].\n162\n      Glass       Lewis,      2021      Proxy       Paper       Guidelines:     United   States     1     (2020),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/2021%20Guidelines/2021%20United%20States%20Benchmark%20Polic\n      y%20Guidelines.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter 2021 Guidelines].\n\n\n                                                        31\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26         Page 72 of 119\n\n\n\n\nchair. 163 Its 2022 guidelines adopted the 30% gender rule for 2023. 164 They also announced a racial-\n\ndisclosure rule for 2023. If an S&P 500 company had not disclosed \u201cindividual or aggregate\n\nracial/ethnic minority demographic information,\u201d Glass Lewis would generally recommend voting\n\nagainst its governance committee chair. 165 The 2023, 2024, and 2025 editions each said Glass\n\nLewis \u201cwill generally recommend voting against\u201d the nominating committee chair of a board that\n\nis not at least 30% gender diverse. 166 The 2027 guidelines keep the same 30% rule. 167\n\n          67.      Since March 2025, Glass Lewis has flagged director recommendations that rest on\n\nboard diversity, and it offers clients a second recommendation that ignores diversity. 168 But the\n\nBenchmark recommendation itself still applies the diversity rules. 169 The flag covers only board\n\ndiversity. It does not mark recommendations driven by the oversight or climate rules. And it sits\n\nbeside guidelines that still say the policy reflects broad investor opinion. \u00b6 58. In its March 2025\n\nstatement, Glass Lewis said it \u201ccontinue[s] to believe that diversity contributes to improved\n\ncompany performance and long-term shareholder value.\u201d 170 It had told state treasurers in June\n\n\n163\n      Id. at 2.\n164\n      Glass         Lewis,         2022        Policy       Guidelines:      United        States      7      (2021),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/2022%20Guidelines/2022%20United%20States%20Benchmark%20Poli\n      cy%20Guidelines.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter 2022 Guidelines].\n165\n      Id. at 8.\n166\n      Glass         Lewis,         2023        Policy      Guidelines:     United         States      42      (2022),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/2023%20Guidelines/2023%20United%20States%20Benchmark%20Polic\n      y%20Guidelines.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter 2023 Benchmark Guidelines]; Glass Lewis, 2024\n      Benchmark              Policy           Guidelines:          United          States          43         (2023),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/2024%20Guidelines/2024%20US%20Benchmark%20Policy%20Guideli\n      nes.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter 2024 Benchmark Guidelines]; Glass Lewis, 2025 Benchmark Policy\n      Guidelines:                      United                    States                   41                  (2024),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/2025%20Guidelines/2025%20US%20Benchmark%20Policy%20Guidelin\n      es.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter 2025 Benchmark Guidelines].\n167\n      2027 Benchmark Guidelines at 25.\n168\n      Glass Lewis, Supplemental Statement on Diversity Considerations at U.S. Companies 2 (Mar. 2025),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/Supplementary%20Guidance/2025%20Supplemental%20Statement%20\n      on%20Diversity%20Consideration%20at%20US%20Companies.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter\n      Diversity Statement].\n169\n      Senate Letter at 8; 2026 Benchmark Guidelines at 27.\n170\n      Diversity Statement at 2.\n\n\n                                                          32\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 111-1        Filed 10/26/26        Page 73 of 119\n\n\n\n\n2023 that the evidence could not determine the effect of the board-diversity proposals it backed. \u00b6\n\n102.\n\n          68.          These are the same kinds of rules found in the thematic policies Glass Lewis sells\n\nto ESG-focused clients. Its ESG Policy and its Climate Policy use the same 30% gender-diversity\n\nthreshold. 171 So a buyer who chose the mainstream middle got the same gender threshold that Glass\n\nLewis uses for ESG-focused clients. \u00b6\u00b6 51, 54.\n\n                iii.          Investors voted against the positions those rules produced.\n\n          69.          Shareholders voted down almost every environmental and social proposal. In the\n\n2023 proxy season, only 4 of 86 environmental proposals and 5 of 207 social proposals at Russell\n\n3000 companies won majority support. 172 In 2024, only 2 of 83 environmental proposals and 1 of\n\n220 social proposals won majority support. 173 In 2025, none of the 72 environmental proposals that\n\ncame to a vote won majority support. 174 Average shareholder support for environmental proposals\n\nfell from 39% in 2022 to 15% in 2025. 175 State Street reported that, \u201c[f]or the third consecutive\n\nyear,\u201d overall support for environmental and social proposals fell. 176\n\n          70.          Glass Lewis backed these proposals far more often. By its own count, its Benchmark\n\nPolicy supported \u201croughly 30% of all environmental and social shareholder proposals in both 2023\n\n\n\n\n171\n      2026 ESG Policy at 6, 11; 2026 Climate Policy at 10.\n172\n      Georgeson,        A    Look      at     the      2024  Proxy    Season     7,    15\u201316,     22   (2024),\n      https://images.info.computershare.com/Web/CMPTSHR1/%7B2a45ede2-ccec-45da-968e-\n      a8d7cb082e30%7D_Georgeson_2024_Proxy_Season_Review.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter\n      Georgeson 2024].\n173\n      Id. at 15\u201316, 18, 21.\n174\n      Georgeson 2025 at 16.\n175\n      Georgeson 2024 at 18; Georgeson 2025 at 18.\n176\n      State Street Glob. Advisors, Stewardship Report 2025 (Apr. 2026), https://ssga.com/library-\n      content/assets/pdf/global/asset-stewardship/introduction-to-2025-proxy-season.pdf (last visited Oct. 20,\n      2026).\n\n\n                                                       33\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1             Filed 10/26/26         Page 74 of 119\n\n\n\n\nand 2024.\u201d 177 Georgeson reported the figures by category. It found that in 2023, Glass Lewis\n\nrecommended voting for 30% of environmental proposals and 43% of social proposals. In 2024, it\n\nrecommended voting for 25% and 43%. 178 These votes show where investors stand on the same\n\nenvironmental and social issues that drive the Benchmark\u2019s rules for directors. Votes on directors\n\nshow the same gap. When Glass Lewis opposed directors at Texas companies, shareholders re-\n\nelected them. \u00b6\u00b6 73, 75.\n\n          71.      Glass Lewis\u2019s support moves votes, but it rarely wins them. Environmental\n\nproposals that both major advisors backed drew 31% support, while those both opposed drew 12%.\n\n\u00b6 43. Some of those votes come from investors who follow Glass Lewis automatically. \u00b6\u00b6 44\u201345.\n\nBut most of the market votes on its own judgment, and it votes the other way. So Glass Lewis\u2019s\n\nenvironmental and social recommendations shift a bloc of votes yet rarely carry a majority. A bloc\n\ncan make the difference in a close contest, such as the 2021 fight at Exxon. \u00b6 46. It cannot carry a\n\nvote most investors oppose. A policy that moves a bloc but loses the market does not reflect \u201cbroad\n\ninvestor opinion.\u201d\n\n          72.      Glass Lewis\u2019s recommendations at Texas companies are illustrative. In 2023, Glass\n\nLewis backed a proposal asking Exxon to report on the cost of retiring its assets under a \u201cnet zero\u201d\n\nemissions scenario. It also backed a proposal asking Exxon to study a worst-case oil spill at its\n\n\n\n\n177\n      Glass Lewis, Glass Lewis Letter to Senate Banking Committee Members, supra; Senate Letter at 3.\n178\n      Georgeson 2024 at 18, 23.\n\n\n                                                           34\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26          Page 75 of 119\n\n\n\n\noffshore platforms. 179 Exxon\u2019s shareholders rejected both. The net-zero proposal received 16.0%\n\nof the votes cast for or against it, and the oil-spill proposal received 13.3%. 180\n\n          73.      In 2024, Glass Lewis recommended voting against Joseph Hooley, Exxon\u2019s lead\n\ndirector. Exxon wrote to Glass Lewis and filed the letter with its proxy materials. It said Glass\n\nLewis \u201cappears to be recommending that shareholders vote against Mr. Hooley for no other reason\n\nthan the company\u2019s decision to seek clarity\u201d on the shareholder-proposal rules. 181 Shareholders\n\nre-elected Mr. Hooley with 87.1% of the votes cast for or against him. 182\n\n          74.      Also in 2024, Glass Lewis recommended that Tesla\u2019s shareholders vote against\n\nmoving the company\u2019s legal home from Delaware to Texas. It also recommended against ratifying\n\nthe pay package of Tesla\u2019s chief executive. 183 Tesla told its shareholders that Glass Lewis had\n\n\u201crecognized that the \u2018changes to shareholder rights are technically positive.\u2019\u201d Tesla added that\n\nGlass Lewis \u201cis on record as recommending FOR 3 other recent reincorporations from Delaware\n\n\n\n\n179\n      Sabrina Valle, Exxon Rebuts Proxy Advisor, Says Net Zero Emissions Scenario Unlikely, Reuters (May 18, 2023),\n      reprinted at https://boereport.com/2023/05/18/exxon-rebuts-proxy-advisor-says-net-zero-emissions-scenario-\n      unlikely/ (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n180\n      Exxon       Mobil     Corp.,      Current   Report    (Form       8-K)     Item     5.07    (June     6,   2023),\n      https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/34088/000003408823000036/xom-20230531.htm (last visited Oct.\n      18, 2026).\n181\n      Exxon      Mobil Corp., Additional Proxy               Materials     (Schedule 14A)         (May 15,       2024),\n      https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/34088/000119312524139185/d822081ddefa14a.htm (last visited\n      Oct. 18, 2026).\n182\n      Exxon       Mobil     Corp.,     Current    Report    (Form      8-K)     Item     5.07    (May      31,   2024),\n      https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/34088/000003408824000036/xom-20240529.htm (last visited\n      Oct. 18, 2026).\n183\n      Dana Hull, Tesla Shareholders Should Reject Elon Musk\u2019s \u2018Excessive\u2019 Pay Package, Proxy Advisor Says, Fortune (May\n      25, 2024), https://fortune.com/2024/05/25/tesla-shareholders-elon-musk-pay-package-proxy-advisor-glass-\n      lewis (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n\n\n                                                           35\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26         Page 76 of 119\n\n\n\n\nto Texas.\u201d 184 Tesla\u2019s shareholders approved the move to Texas with about 87% of the votes cast\n\nfor or against it. They approved the pay package with about 77%. 185\n\n          75.      In 2025, Glass Lewis recommended voting against Ira Ehrenpreis, a Tesla director\n\nwho chairs the board committee that picks directors. Among its reasons, Glass Lewis listed\n\n\u201c[i]nsufficient board gender diversity,\u201d because Tesla\u2019s board would be only \u201c22.2% gender\n\ndiverse.\u201d 186 Tesla\u2019s shareholders re-elected Mr. Ehrenpreis. About 65% of the votes cast for or\n\nagainst him were in his favor. 187\n\n          76.      The same gap appeared elsewhere. In 2025, Glass Lewis backed proposals asking\n\nAmazon to report on its warehouse working conditions and on the risks of how it gets data for\n\nartificial intelligence. 188 Amazon\u2019s shareholders rejected both. The working-conditions proposal\n\nreceived about 23% of the votes cast for or against it, and the data proposal received about 11%. 189\n\nGlass Lewis also backed a proposal asking Dollar General to adopt a human-rights policy. 190 Dollar\n\nGeneral\u2019s shareholders rejected it with about 23% support. 191\n\n\n\n\n184\n      Tesla,      Inc.,    Additional      Proxy       Materials      (Schedule     14A)       (May     29,    2024),\n      https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1318605/000110465924066122/tm2413800d12_defa14a.htm (last\n      visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n185\n      Tesla,      Inc.,    Current       Report       (Form       8-K)     Item      5.07      (June     14,   2024),\n      https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1318605/000110465924071439/tm2413800d31_8k.htm (last visited\n      Oct. 18, 2026).\n186\n      Glass       Lewis,       Proxy      Paper:       Tesla,      Inc.     13,     20        (Oct.     17,    2025),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/Glass%20Lewis%202025%20Tesla%20Proxy%20Paper.pdf (last visited\n      Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter Tesla Proxy Paper].\n187\n      Tesla,      Inc.,     Current      Report       (Form       8-K)      Item      5.07      (Nov.     7,   2025),\n      https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1318605/000110465925108507/tm2530590d1_8k.htm (last visited\n      Oct. 18, 2026).\n188\n      Amazon Proxy Paper at 2.\n189\n      Amazon.com, Inc., Form 8-K, supra.\n190\n      Glass      Lewis,       Proxy      Paper:     Dollar       General      Corp.      1      (May      7,   2025),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/Northern%20Trust/Dollar%20General.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n191\n      Dollar     Gen.     Corp.,     Current     Report       (Form     8-K)    Item      5.07    (June     3, 2025),\n      https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/29534/000110465925055706/tm2516684d1_8k.htm (last visited\n      Oct. 18, 2026).\n\n\n                                                          36\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26         Page 77 of 119\n\n\n\n\n          77.      In 2026, Glass Lewis recommended that Exxon\u2019s shareholders vote against moving\n\nthe company\u2019s legal home from New Jersey to Texas. Exxon, now based in Spring, Texas, said the\n\nrecommendation rested on \u201cmisunderstandings, speculation, and immaterial factors.\u201d 192\n\nShareholders approved the move. It received 71.2% of the votes cast for or against it. 193\n\n          78.      BlackRock, Vanguard, and State Street are among the largest investment managers\n\nin the world. The index equity assets eligible for their voting-choice programs alone total nearly\n\n$10 trillion. 194 BlackRock supported only 7 of 358 environmental and social proposals around the\n\nworld from July 2024 through June 2025. 195 Vanguard\u2019s U.S. funds supported none of the 241\n\nenvironmental and social proposals they reviewed in 2025. 196 The votes of these large investors are\n\na large part of what investor opinion is. They did not support the positions the Benchmark rules\n\nproduced.\n\n          79.      In February 2025, ISS announced that it would no longer consider the gender and\n\nracial or ethnic diversity of U.S. boards in its vote recommendations. 197 In early 2025, BlackRock\n\n\n192\n      Exxon       Mobil     Corp., Additional Proxy Materials (Schedule                14A)     (May 12,       2026),\n      https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/34088/000119312526219320/d121241ddefa14a.htm (last visited\n      Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter Exxon 2026 Proxy Supplement].\n193\n      Exxon       Mobil      Corp.,   Current     Report     (Form    8-K)    Item     5.07    (May     29,    2026),\n      https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/34088/000003408826000078/xom-20260527.htm (last visited Oct.\n      18, 2026); Matthew Fazelpoor, ExxonMobil Shareholders Approve Redomicile Plan, NJBIZ (May 28, 2026),\n      https://njbiz.com/exxonmobil-texas-redomiciliation-approved/ (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n194\n      BlackRock,      BlackRock     Voting     Choice,    https://www.blackrock.com/corporate/about-us/investment-\n      stewardship/blackrock-voting-choice (last visited Oct. 18, 2026); Vanguard, Vanguard Investor Choice,\n      https://corporate.vanguard.com/content/corporatesite/us/en/corp/how-we-advocate/investment-\n      stewardship/investor-choice.html (last visited Oct. 18, 2026); State Street Glob. Advisors, Proxy Voting Choice,\n      https://www.ssga.com/us/en/intermediary/etfs/about-us/what-we-do/asset-stewardship/proxy-voting-choice\n      (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n195\n      BlackRock Inv. Stewardship, 2025 Global Voting Spotlight, Harv. L. Sch. F. on Corp. Governance (Dec. 9, 2025),\n      https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2025/12/09/2025-global-voting-spotlight/ (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n196\n      Vanguard,           2025       Investment         Stewardship      Annual         Report       4        (2026),\n      https://corporate.vanguard.com/content/dam/corp/advocate/investment-stewardship/pdf/policies-and-\n      reports/2025_investment_stewardship_annual_report.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n197\n      Debevoise & Plimpton LLP, Proxy Advisors and Institutional Shareholders Revise Voting Guidelines on Board\n      Diversity (Feb. 24, 2025), https://www.debevoise.com/insights/publications/2025/02/proxy-advisors-and-\n      institutional-shareholders (last visited Oct. 18, 2026); Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP, ISS Indefinitely\n\n\n                                                          37\n\f    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                 Document 111-1             Filed 10/26/26          Page 78 of 119\n\n\n\n\nand State Street removed numeric board-diversity targets from their U.S. voting policies. 198\n\nVanguard dropped its statement that boards should, \u201cat a minimum, represent a diversity of\n\npersonal characteristics.\u201d 199 Its 2026 policy \u201cno longer identifies personal characteristics (such as\n\nage, gender or race/ethnicity) as a relevant consideration\u201d in judging a board. 200\n\n         80.      Glass Lewis kept its board-diversity rules in its Benchmark Policy anyway, and it\n\nplans to keep them in 2027. \u00b6\u00b6 64\u201368. In December 2025, a presidential executive order noted that\n\none of the two major proxy advisors \u201ccontinues to provide guidance based on the racial or ethnic\n\ndiversity of corporate boards.\u201d ISS had stopped. Glass Lewis had not. 201\n\n         81.      Glass Lewis\u2019s own 2025 survey found \u201csignificant divergences between U.S. and\n\nnon-U.S. investor views\u201d on board diversity, climate, and other topics. 202 U.S. investors were \u201cfar\n\nmore likely to report ignoring diversity factors in their evaluation of boards (42%)\u201d than investors\n\nelsewhere (6%). 203 Glass Lewis published those results in October 2025. It then kept its board-\n\ndiversity and climate rules in its 2026 U.S. Benchmark guidelines. 204 By Glass Lewis\u2019s own count,\n\n\n    Halts Consideration of Diversity Factors When Making Proxy Voting Recommendations (Feb. 13, 2025),\n    https://www.akingump.com/en/insights/alerts/iss-indefinitely-halts-consideration-of-diversity-factors-when-\n    making-proxy-voting-recommendations (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n198\n    Cooley LLP, Board Diversity: Policy Updates and Considerations for Proxy Season (Feb. 28, 2025),\n    https://cooley.com/news/insight/2025/2025-02-28-board-diversity-policy-updates-and-considerations-for-\n    proxy-season (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n199\n    Debevoise & Plimpton LLP, supra.\n200\n    Cooley LLP, Key Updates in BlackRock\u2019s and Vanguard\u2019s 2026 US Proxy Voting Guidelines (Jan. 22, 2026),\n    https://www.cooley.com/news/insight/2026/2026-01-22-key-updates-in-blackrocks-and-vanguards-2026-us-\n    proxy-voting-guidelines (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n201\n    Exec. Order No. 14,366, 90 Fed. Reg. at 58,503; Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP, supra; 2026 Benchmark\n    Guidelines at 27.\n202\n    Glass Lewis, 2025 Policy Survey Results (2025), https://grow.glasslewis.com/2025-policy-survey-results (last\n    visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n203\n    Brianna Castro et al., Policy Survey Shows a Shifting Stewardship Landscape, and Diverging Investor Views Across\n    Regions,      Harv.       L.     Sch.       F.     on      Corp.       Governance        (Oct.      31,      2025),\n    https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2025/10/31/policy-survey-shows-a-shifting-stewardship-landscape-and-\n    diverging-investor-views-across-regions/ (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n204\n    Glass Lewis, Policy Survey Shows a Shifting Stewardship Landscape, and Diverging Investor Views Across Regions (Oct.\n    22, 2025), https://www.glasslewis.com/article/policy-survey-shows-a-shifting-stewardship-landscape-and-\n    diverging-investor-views-across-regions (last visited Oct. 18, 2026); 2026 Benchmark Guidelines at 27, 33.\n\n\n                                                          38\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA              Document 111-1          Filed 10/26/26       Page 79 of 119\n\n\n\n\nU.S. investors split sharply on whether board diversity matters at all. A rule that votes against\n\ndirectors on that factor takes one side of the divide in opinion. It does not reflect \u201cbroad investor\n\nopinion.\u201d\n\n                iv.          Most of Glass Lewis\u2019s own clients do not use the Benchmark Policy.\n\n          82.         Glass Lewis has long known that most of its clients vote under custom policies\n\nrather than its house policy. Its compliance statements for 2016, 2018, and 2020 through 2022 each\n\nsaid that \u201c[t]he supermajority\u201d of its clients \u201cvote according to a custom policy or via a custom\n\nprocess.\u201d 205 In 2018, it told the SEC that adopting a proxy advisor\u2019s house policy \u201cis by no means\n\nthe norm.\u201d 206 In 2020, it told the SEC again that \u201ca significant majority of Glass Lewis\u2019 clients\n\nhave their own custom voting policies.\u201d 207\n\n          83.         In January 2023, Glass Lewis told the attorneys general that the Benchmark Policy\n\nreflects its clients\u2019 \u201cpredominant views.\u201d \u00b6 61. In the same letter, it said that \u201ca significant\n\nmajority of our clients have elected to simply not follow any Glass Lewis policy.\u201d 208 In June 2023,\n\nit told state treasurers that \u201cmost Glass Lewis clients have not adopted our Benchmark Policy.\u201d 209\n\nIn September 2025, it admitted to the federal district court in Austin that \u201c[a] significant majority\u201d\n\nof its clients \u201cvote according to a custom policy or via a custom process.\u201d 210 And on October 15,\n\n\n\n\n205\n      2016 Compliance Statement at 9; 2018 Compliance Statement at 10; 2020 Compliance Statement at 10; 2021\n      Compliance Statement at 9; 2022 Compliance Statement at 10.\n206\n      Letter from Katherine H. Rabin, CEO, Glass Lewis, to Jay Clayton, Chairman, SEC, File No. 4-725 (Nov. 14,\n      2018), https://www.sec.gov/comments/4-725/4725-4649188-176490.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n207\n      2020 SEC Comment Letter at 3.\n208\n      Glass Lewis Reply to Attorneys General at 2.\n209\n      2023 Treasurers Letter at 4.\n210\n      Glass Lewis Am. Compl. \u00b6 42.\n\n\n                                                       39\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 111-1           Filed 10/26/26        Page 80 of 119\n\n\n\n\n2025, it announced that \u201c[a] majority of the firm\u2019s clients already use their own custom policy\n\nguidelines or a specific thematic policy.\u201d 211\n\n          84.      Glass Lewis has said how clients pick a policy. Those who adopt one \u201cgenerally do\n\nso after determining that the Glass Lewis approach closely reflects their own view.\u201d \u00b6 60. The\n\nBenchmark Policy is ready to use and spares a client the cost of writing its own rules. \u00b6 41. Yet\n\nmost of its clients have not adopted it. \u00b6\u00b6 82\u201383. The reasonable inference is that it does not closely\n\nreflect most of its clients\u2019 views. Glass Lewis left those facts out of its Benchmark guidelines, sales\n\npages, and Proxy Papers. \u00b6\u00b6 58\u201359, 89\u201390, 111. Without them, the claim that the policy reflects\n\n\u201cbroad investor opinion\u201d and its clients\u2019 \u201cpredominant views\u201d misled buyers. \u00b6\u00b6 58\u201360.\n\n          85.      In the same October 2025 announcement, Glass Lewis said it would end its one-\n\nsize-fits-all approach, citing \u201c[d]iverging investor priorities.\u201d Its chief executive explained that\n\n\u201cthe traditional one-size-fits-all model of proxy advice no longer meets the needs of a diverse client\n\nbase.\u201d 212 Its chief operating officer has since sworn that Glass Lewis \u201chas announced that it will\n\nmove all clients off the Benchmark Policy by the end of 2027.\u201d 213 Glass Lewis thus admitted that\n\ninvestors do not share one view.\n\n          86.      On November 25, 2025, Glass Lewis\u2019s chief executive wrote that it would \u201cmove\n\naway from a single house view.\u201d 214 He wrote that it would offer recommendations \u201cthat reflect the\n\nvarying viewpoints of our institutional clients.\u201d 215 Soon after, in early December 2025, Glass Lewis\n\n\n211\n      Press Release, Glass Lewis, Glass Lewis Leads Change in Proxy Voting Practices (Oct. 15, 2025),\n      https://www.glasslewis.com/news-release/glass-lewis-leads-change-in-proxy-voting-practices (last visited Oct.\n      18, 2026) [hereinafter Oct. 15, 2025 Press Release].\n212\n      Oct. 15, 2025 Press Release.\n213\n      Wieck Decl. \u00b6 7.\n214\n      Bob Mann, A Personal Commitment to Change Proxy Voting Practices, Glass Lewis (Nov. 25, 2025),\n      https://www.glasslewis.com/article/personal-commitment-change-proxy-voting-practices (last visited Oct. 18,\n      2026).\n215\n      Id.\n\n\n                                                         40\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 111-1           Filed 10/26/26        Page 81 of 119\n\n\n\n\npublished its 2026 Benchmark guidelines. They told investors that the Benchmark Policy \u201creflects\n\nbroad investor opinion.\u201d 216 In September 2026, Glass Lewis cited \u201cthe growing divergence in how\n\ninvestors, particularly those in Europe and the U.S., approach fiduciary duty and stewardship.\u201d 217\n\nGlass Lewis was telling the market that investors\u2019 views were diverging and that one policy could\n\nnot serve them all. It could not, at the same time, truthfully tell investors that its single house policy\n\nreflected \u201cbroad investor opinion.\u201d\n\n              v.         The statement tells buyers whose views the policy reflects.\n\n        87.      Whose views a policy reflects is a central fact about the product. \u00b6\u00b6 54, 58. A buyer\n\nthat wants mainstream advice, reflecting what most investors think rather than an ESG focus,\n\nwould choose the Benchmark Policy because of this statement. Glass Lewis sells its policies as\n\n\u201cready-to-use guidelines that eliminate the need for in-house development,\u201d so buyers rely on the\n\nlabel in place of studying each rule. \u00b6 41. The Federal Trade Commission (\u201cFTC\u201d) presumes that\n\nexpress claims like this one are material. 218 The federal district court in Tyler has held it plausible\n\nthat a misstatement about a fund\u2019s ESG involvement is important to a reasonable investor. 219\n\nInvestors may avoid ESG for political reasons, for performance reasons, or both. 220\n\n        88.      A client on the Benchmark Policy that follows its recommendations automatically,\n\nor that uses Glass Lewis\u2019s pre-populated votes, casts votes under rules it was told reflect broad\n\n\n\n\n216\n     Glass Lewis, Proxy Voting Policies, supra; 2026 Benchmark Guidelines at 7; Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton &\n     Garrison LLP, Glass Lewis Releases 2026 Benchmark Policy Guidelines (Dec. 8, 2025),\n     https://www.paulweiss.com/insights/client-memos/glass-lewis-releases-2026-benchmark-policy-guidelines\n     (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n217\n     Glass Lewis, Research Methodology Comment Period (Sept. 2026), https://www.glasslewis.com/landing-\n     page/research-methodology-comment-period (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n218\n     Cliffdale Assocs., Inc., 103 F.T.C. 110, 1984 WL 565319, at *49 (1984) (appending FTC Policy Statement on\n     Deception (Oct. 14, 1983)) [hereinafter FTC Deception Statement].\n219\n     Texas v. BlackRock, Inc., No. 6:24-cv-00437-JDK, 2025 WL 2201071, at *24 (E.D. Tex. Aug. 1, 2025).\n220\n    Id.\n\n\n                                                      41\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                  Document 111-1        Filed 10/26/26       Page 82 of 119\n\n\n\n\ninvestor opinion. \u00b6\u00b6 44\u201345. And because every client receives Benchmark recommendations, the\n\nstatement shapes how every client views them, even clients that chose a different policy. \u00b6 50.\n\nB.        Glass Lewis said the Benchmark Policy reflects \u201cbest practices\u201d and \u201cwidely\n          accepted governance principles.\u201d\n\n                  i.          Glass Lewis made this statement on its website and in its guidelines.\n\n          89.          Glass Lewis tells buyers to \u201c[e]nsure your governance decisions reflect industry\n\nbest practices with Glass Lewis\u2019 Proxy Voting Policies.\u201d 221\n\n\n\n\n                         Figure 2: Glass Lewis web page advertising its proxy voting policies\n\n          90.          It says its policies are \u201ctailored to industry standards and local market best\n\npractices,\u201d and that \u201c[a] comprehensive voting policy underpins consistent and transparent\n\ngovernance decisions.\u201d 222 It says its policies help investors \u201cmeet fiduciary obligations and\n\nregulatory requirements.\u201d 223\n\n          91.          Its 2026 Benchmark guidelines say the Benchmark Policy reflects \u201cwidely accepted\n\ngovernance principles\u201d and is meant to provide analysis \u201cinformed by market best practice.\u201d 224\n\n\n\n221\n      Glass Lewis, Proxy Voting Policies, supra.\n222\n      Id.\n223\n      Id.\n224\n      2026 Benchmark Guidelines at 7.\n\n\n                                                         42\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26          Page 83 of 119\n\n\n\n\nIts guidelines on shareholder proposals and ESG issues for 2023, 2024, and 2025 each said that\n\n\u201cGlass Lewis\u2019 proxy voting guidelines are grounded in corporate governance best practices.\u201d 225\n\nIts 2022 compliance statement said that its content \u201cis grounded in corporate governance best\n\npractices.\u201d 226 Its compliance statements, survey report, and letters described the Benchmark\n\nPolicy as reflecting \u201ccorporate governance best practices.\u201d \u00b6\u00b6 60\u201361.\n\n                ii.          Rules that most investors reject are not widely accepted.\n\n          92.         A voting rule is not a \u201cbest practice\u201d or a \u201cwidely accepted\u201d principle when most\n\ninvestors, the largest investment managers, and the other major proxy advisor reject it. \u00b6\u00b6 69\u201386.\n\nIn March 2025, Glass Lewis admitted that institutional investors \u201chave different perspectives\u201d\n\nand \u201cmay also choose to take different approaches to voting on diversity matters.\u201d 227 In December\n\n2024, the Fifth Circuit, sitting en banc, vacated the SEC\u2019s approval of Nasdaq\u2019s board-diversity\n\nrule. That rule required listed companies to have two \u201cdiverse\u201d directors or explain why they did\n\nnot. 228 The court found that Nasdaq \u201coffered little support\u201d for a link \u201cbetween the racial, gender,\n\nand sexual composition of a company\u2019s board and the quality of its governance.\u201d The SEC itself\n\nhad found Nasdaq\u2019s evidence \u201cmixed.\u201d 229 The Fifth Circuit observed that it could \u201cthink of few\n\nmore politically divisive issues in the Nation.\u201d 230 On that divisive issue, Glass Lewis\u2019s rules are\n\n\n\n\n225\n      Glass         Lewis,       2023        Policy      Guidelines:       ESG         Initiatives   [43]       (2022),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/2023%20Guidelines/2023%20ESG%20Initiatives%20Benchmark%20Pol\n      icy%20Guidelines.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter 2023 ESG Guidelines]; Glass Lewis, 2024 Benchmark\n      Policy       Guidelines:     Shareholder      Proposals      &       ESG-Related        Issues  [44]      (2023),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/2024%20Guidelines/2024%20Shareholder%20Proposals%20ESG%20Be\n      nchmark%20Policy%20Guidelines.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter 2024 Shareholder Proposal\n      Guidelines]; 2025 Shareholder Proposal Guidelines at 43.\n226\n      2022 Compliance Statement at 47.\n227\n      Diversity Statement at 2.\n228\n      All. for Fair Bd. Recruitment v. SEC, 125 F.4th 159, 164, 166, 185 (5th Cir. 2024) (en banc).\n229\n      Id. at 179.\n230\n      Id. at 181.\n\n\n                                                           43\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26       Page 84 of 119\n\n\n\n\nlike Nasdaq\u2019s. \u00b6\u00b6 64, 66. Glass Lewis has also admitted that its 2024 survey focused in part on\n\ntopics where its talks with investors and others \u201chave not yielded a clear consensus.\u201d 231 Glass\n\nLewis\u2019s own menu admits as much. It sells a separate policy for investors \u201cskeptical of politicized\n\nESG and DEI initiatives.\u201d \u00b6\u00b6 51\u201353. A rule on a topic without a clear consensus is not a widely\n\naccepted principle. Yet Glass Lewis put such rules in its Benchmark Policy and called the result\n\n\u201cwidely accepted.\u201d\n\n                iii.          The statement tells buyers that the policy is the safe choice.\n\n          93.          Calling a policy \u201cbest practice\u201d and \u201cwidely accepted\u201d tells buyers about its\n\nstandard, quality, and grade. It tells them that following the policy is the safe and prudent choice.\n\nThat message matters most to fiduciaries, who must vote prudently for the people they serve. Glass\n\nLewis markets its policies to them as a way to \u201cmeet fiduciary obligations.\u201d \u00b6\u00b6 38, 90.\n\nC.        Glass Lewis said its advice is \u201cindependent,\u201d \u201cobjective,\u201d and focused on\n          \u201cshareholder value.\u201d\n\n                 i.           Glass Lewis has made this statement since at least 2016.\n\n          94.          Glass Lewis has called itself independent and objective for at least a decade. Its 2016\n\ncompliance statement called it \u201ca leading, independent governance services firm,\u201d and its 2018\n\nstatement did the same. 232 Both described its mission as serving investors \u201cwith objective advice\n\nand services.\u201d 233 Its new owners\u2019 March 2021 press release called Glass Lewis \u201cthe leading\n\nprovider of independent global governance solutions,\u201d with \u201cunbiased research reports.\u201d 234 Its\n\n\n\n\n231\n      2024 Survey Report at 5.\n232\n      2016 Compliance Statement at 5; 2018 Compliance Statement at 6.\n233\n      2016 Compliance Statement at 16; 2018 Compliance Statement at 17.\n234\n      Press Release, Peloton Capital Mgmt., Peloton Capital Management and Stephen Smith Acquire Glass Lewis\n      (Mar.     16,    2021),    https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20210316005393/en/Peloton-Capital-\n      Management-and-Stephen-Smith-Acquire-Glass-Lewis (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n\n\n                                                         44\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                  Document 111-1             Filed 10/26/26           Page 85 of 119\n\n\n\n\ncompliance statements for 2020 through 2022 each said that its research \u201cmeets the highest\n\nstandards of quality, objectivity, and independence.\u201d 235\n\n          95.       Today, Glass Lewis calls itself \u201ca leading global provider of independent corporate\n\ngovernance research.\u201d Its \u201cAbout Us\u201d page carries the heading, \u201cTrusted by Investors, Informed\n\nby Research and Data.\u201d 236 Its compliance statement says, \u201cOur role is to provide objective\n\nresearch and other tools to help our clients vote as they see fit.\u201d 237 In 2023, it told state treasurers,\n\n\u201cOur research and recommendations are made independently, based on the best interests of our\n\nclients.\u201d 238 In 2025, it told the public that it is \u201ccommitted to serving our clients and providing\n\nthem with objective, reliable, and timely advice.\u201d 239\n\n          96.       Glass Lewis has also long tied its advice to shareholder value. Its compliance\n\nstatements for 2016, 2018, and 2020 through 2022 each said that Glass Lewis \u201cis dedicated to\n\nsupporting the creation and preservation of long-term shareholder value.\u201d 240 Its U.S. guidelines\n\nfor 2018 and for 2020 through 2025 each described the purpose of its advice this way. 241\n\n          The purpose of Glass Lewis\u2019 proxy research and advice is to facilitate shareholder\n          voting in favor of governance structures that will drive performance, create\n          shareholder value and maintain a proper tone at the top.\n\n          97.       Glass Lewis has said many times that it \u201cevaluates all environmental and social\n\nissues through the lens of long-term shareholder value.\u201d 242 Its guidelines said that it weighs\n\n\n235\n      2020 Compliance Statement at 18; 2021 Compliance Statement at 19; 2022 Compliance Statement at 23.\n236\n      Glass Lewis, About Us, supra.\n237\n      2024 Compliance Statement at 14.\n238\n      2023 Treasurers Letter at 10.\n239\n      Glass Lewis, Glass Lewis Letter to Senate Banking Committee Members, supra.\n240\n      2016 Compliance Statement at 6\u20137; 2018 Compliance Statement at 7; 2020 Compliance Statement at 7; 2021\n      Compliance Statement at 7; 2022 Compliance Statement at 8.\n241\n      2018 Guidelines at 3; 2020 Guidelines at 3; 2021 Guidelines at 5; 2022 Guidelines at 13; 2023 Benchmark Guidelines\n      at 12; 2024 Benchmark Guidelines at 12; 2025 Benchmark Guidelines at 9.\n242\n      2022 Guidelines at 10; 2023 Treasurers Letter at 5; Glass Lewis Reply to Attorneys General at 4, 7; Glass Lewis, Glass\n      Lewis Letter to Senate Banking Committee Members, supra.\n\n\n                                                             45\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26         Page 86 of 119\n\n\n\n\nenvironmental and social proposals \u201cin the context of the financial materiality of the issue to the\n\ncompany\u2019s operations.\u201d 243\n\n          98.          Glass Lewis\u2019s description reaches individual investors through the firms that use\n\nits policies. Schwab, a Texas company, tells its fund shareholders that Glass Lewis describes the\n\nBenchmark Policy as having \u201cthe objective of enhancing long-term shareholder value.\u201d 244\n\n                 ii.          Glass Lewis did not disclose conflicts that bear on its independence.\n\n          99.          In 2026, Glass Lewis urged Exxon\u2019s shareholders to vote against moving to Texas.\n\n\u00b6 77. At the time, Glass Lewis was suing the Texas Attorney General in the federal district court\n\nin Austin over a Texas law that regulates proxy advisors. 245 Exxon wrote to Glass Lewis and filed\n\nthe letter with its proxy materials. It said Glass Lewis \u201cfailed to disclose an obvious conflict of\n\ninterest resulting from its ongoing litigation with the Texas Attorney General.\u201d That litigation,\n\nExxon said, \u201cdirectly relates to a law affecting its business interests.\u201d Exxon added that \u201cit would\n\nhave been relevant for investors who rely on its assertions of impartiality to know\u201d of that\n\nconflict. 246\n\n          100.         Exxon raised a similar concern in 2024. It asked Glass Lewis to \u201camend its report\n\nto make clear its relationships with the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility (ICCR) and\n\nArjuna Capital.\u201d 247 Ising testified to Congress about the same kind of problem. At one company,\n\n\n\n243\n      Glass Lewis, 2022 Policy Guidelines: ESG Initiatives 25 (2021), https://www.skadden.com/-\n      /media/files/publications/2022/03/annual-meeting-filing-and-disclosure-\n      reminders/esginitiativesvotingguidelinesgl2022.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026); 2023 ESG Guidelines at 27; 2024\n      Shareholder Proposal Guidelines at 27; 2025 Shareholder Proposal Guidelines at 26.\n244\n      Schwab Asset Mgmt., Proxy Voting Policy Options, supra; Charles Schwab Corp., Form 10-K, supra.\n245\n      See generally Glass Lewis Am. Compl.\n246\n      Exxon 2026 Proxy Supplement.\n247\n      Exxon Mobil Corp., Additional Proxy Materials (Schedule 14A) (May 28, 2024),\n      https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/34088/000119312524147226/d717960ddefa14a.htm (last visited\n      Oct. 18, 2026).\n\n\n                                                          46\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                  Document 111-1      Filed 10/26/26     Page 87 of 119\n\n\n\n\nGlass Lewis \u201crepeated in its proxy report the viewpoint of a shareholder organization\u201d without\n\ndisclosing that Glass Lewis was a member of that organization. 248\n\n          101.          Ising also testified that \u201cGlass Lewis previously touted that it did not provide\n\n\u2018consulting services\u2019 to public companies.\u201d Today, she testified, it sells consulting that helps\n\ncompanies \u201cunderstand how their compensation programs will be evaluated and rated by Glass\n\nLewis.\u201d 249 Glass Lewis sells services to more than 2,300 public companies, the same kind of\n\ncompanies on whose votes it advises investors. \u00b6 47. Its Proxy Papers say that an affiliate sells\n\n\u201cEquity Plan Advisory services\u201d to public companies. 250 But they do not say whether the company\n\nthe report covers bought those services. A client must look that up on Glass Lewis\u2019s Viewpoint\n\nplatform or email its compliance staff. 251 Similarly, Glass Lewis\u2019s October 2025 Proxy Paper on\n\nTesla, a Texas company, lists its \u201cPotential Conflicts.\u201d That list does not mention that Glass\n\nLewis was then suing the Texas Attorney General over a Texas law that regulates proxy advisors. 252\n\nThe report a client reads before it votes thus leaves out facts that bear on Glass Lewis\u2019s\n\nindependence. \u00b6 95.\n\n                 iii.          Glass Lewis could not tie its diversity and climate rules to shareholder\n                               value.\n\n          102.          State treasurers asked Glass Lewis whether it knew of any \u201cempirical evidence that\n\nany climate report or audit that your firm recommended supporting has in fact increased\n\nshareholder value.\u201d 253 Glass Lewis answered that \u201cthe empirical evidence on this issue cannot\n\ndetermine the effect of climate reporting on an individual company.\u201d It added that it had\n\n\n248\n      Ising Testimony, supra.\n249\n      Id.\n250\n      Tesla Proxy Paper at 2; Amazon Proxy Paper at 2.\n251\n      Tesla Proxy Paper at 2.\n252\n      Tesla Proxy Paper at 2; see generally Glass Lewis Compl.\n253\n      2023 Treasurers Letter at 10.\n\n\n                                                             47\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1          Filed 10/26/26         Page 88 of 119\n\n\n\n\nconsidered the available evidence in developing its policies. 254 It gave the same answer about the\n\nboard-diversity proposals it recommended supporting. 255 Glass Lewis told buyers it applies these\n\nrules for shareholder value. It told state treasurers that the evidence could not show their effect on\n\nany individual company. But it never said so in its guidelines, sales pages, or Proxy Papers. After a\n\nbench trial, the federal district court in Fort Worth found that, \u201c[a]bsent a cognizable basis,\u201d\n\nasserting that an ESG factor captures financial risk \u201cserves as mere pretext.\u201d 256\n\n          103.         Glass Lewis also tied its climate rule to an outside advocacy group. In 2023, the U.S.\n\nBenchmark Policy pointed to an outside list to identify the companies its climate rule covered. Its\n\nexamples were \u201cthose companies identified by groups including Climate Action 100+.\u201d 257 Climate\n\nAction 100+ is a group of investors focused on climate change. Vanguard agreed, in its settlement\n\nwith Texas and other States, to stay out of Climate Action 100+ and similar groups. Those groups\n\nadvocate for \u201cthe setting of specific output or emissions targets.\u201d 258 Tying a voting rule to an\n\nadvocacy group\u2019s list is not independent analysis of shareholder value.\n\n                 iv.          Glass Lewis\u2019s advice was not as reliable as it claimed.\n\n          104.         Ising testified to Congress that \u201c[a] company\u2019s Glass Lewis report indicated that\n\nits board does not oversee cybersecurity risk.\u201d The company pointed Glass Lewis to its disclosures\n\nabout the board\u2019s oversight. Even so, \u201cGlass Lewis failed to correct this error.\u201d 259 She also\n\ntestified that companies may send \u201cReport Feedback Statements\u201d to Glass Lewis\u2019s clients only\n\n\n\n254\n      Id. at 10\u201311.\n255\n      Id. at 14.\n256\n      Spence v. Am. Airlines, Inc., 775 F. Supp. 3d 963, 992 (N.D. Tex. 2025).\n257\n      2023 Benchmark Guidelines at 32.\n258\n      Settlement Agreement \u00a7 5.6, Texas v. BlackRock, Inc., No. 6:24-cv-00437-JDK (E.D. Tex. Feb. 25, 2026),\n      https://www.texasattorneygeneral.gov/sites/default/files/images/press/Settlement_1.pdf (last visited Oct. 18,\n      2026) [hereinafter Vanguard Settlement].\n259\n      Ising Testimony, supra.\n\n\n                                                         48\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 111-1        Filed 10/26/26       Page 89 of 119\n\n\n\n\nafter buying the report, which can cost several thousand dollars. Companies have described this\n\napproach as \u201cpay to play.\u201d 260 Advice that stays wrong after the error is pointed out, and that a\n\ncompany must pay Glass Lewis to correct, is not the \u201cobjective, reliable, and timely advice\u201d Glass\n\nLewis promised. \u00b6 95.\n\n                 v.          The statement matters most to investors who must vote for financial\n                             returns.\n\n          105.        Many of Glass Lewis\u2019s clients must vote only for the financial benefit of the people\n\nthey serve. \u00b6 38. For them, a promise that advice is objective and aimed at shareholder value is the\n\nreason to buy it. An ERISA fiduciary may follow a proxy advisor\u2019s guidelines only after deciding\n\nthat they serve the plan\u2019s economic interest, the very thing Glass Lewis promises. \u00b6\u00b6 38, 96. A\n\nDallas investment firm shows how this works. Westwood says it uses Glass Lewis guidelines \u201cthat\n\nwe believe create value for our clients.\u201d It explains, \u201cThe Glass Lewis policy states that it will vote\n\nin favor when there is a clear link between the proposal and value enhancement or risk\n\nmitigation.\u201d 261\n\nD.        Glass Lewis said its policies are built from the bottom up on client input.\n\n                 i.          Glass Lewis has made this statement since at least 2016.\n\n          106.        Its compliance statements for 2016, 2018, and 2020 through 2022 each said that\n\n\u201cGlass Lewis policies are formulated via a bottom-up approach.\u201d That approach, they said,\n\n\u201cinvolves extensive discussions with a wide range of market participants.\u201d 262 Its 2023 and 2025\n\nguides for investment advisers said the same, describing \u201ca bottoms-up approach that involves\n\n\n\n\n260\n      Id.\n261\n      Westwood Holdings Grp., Inc., Form 10-K, supra.\n262\n      2016 Compliance Statement at 11; 2018 Compliance Statement at 12; 2020 Compliance Statement at 11; 2021\n      Compliance Statement at 11; 2022 Compliance Statement at 12.\n\n\n                                                       49\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                  Document 111-1             Filed 10/26/26           Page 90 of 119\n\n\n\n\nextensive discussions with a wide range of market participants, including investor clients.\u201d 263 In\n\n2023, it told state treasurers that its voting policies are formulated through a \u201c\u2018bottom-up\u2019\n\napproach.\u201d 264\n\n          107.         Its compliance statement says it uses its annual policy survey \u201cto best align our\n\nbenchmark guidelines to our clients\u2019 expectations.\u201d 265 Its website says it updates its policies each\n\nyear by \u201cincorporating input from issuer engagement, client calls and roundtables.\u201d 266\n\n                 ii.          Few of Glass Lewis\u2019s clients gave that input.\n\n          108.         In 2025, Glass Lewis\u2019s survey \u201creceived 76 responses from investors and 310\n\nresponses from non-investors.\u201d 267 Glass Lewis says it has more than 1,300 investor clients. So the\n\ninvestor answers equaled fewer than 6% of that number, and most of the answers came from\n\ncompanies and other non-investors. \u00b6 47. The 2024 survey was similar. It drew 113 responses from\n\ninvestors and 374 from non-investors. 268 Glass Lewis opened the survey in 2024 to \u201cnot just Glass\n\nLewis clients, but also other institutional investors, companies, corporate advisors, and other\n\nstakeholders.\u201d 269\n\n          109.         So most of the survey answers Glass Lewis used to \u201calign\u201d its Benchmark\n\nguidelines with its clients\u2019 expectations did not come from its clients, or from investors at all. Glass\n\nLewis also does not say whose input shaped its rules. Ising testified that \u201cneither ISS nor Glass\n\n\n\n\n263\n      Glass Lewis, Due Diligence: A Resource for Investment Advisers on Glass Lewis Policies and Procedures 8\u20139 (Oct. 2023),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/Compliance/2023%20Due%20Diligence%20Resource%20Guide.pdf\n      (last visited Oct. 18, 2026); 2025 Due Diligence Guide at 8\u20139.\n264\n      2023 Treasurers Letter at 6.\n265\n      2024 Compliance Statement at 11.\n266\n      Glass Lewis, Proxy Voting Policies, supra.\n267\n      Castro et al., supra.\n268\n      2024 Survey Report at 7.\n269\n      2025 Due Diligence Guide at 8.\n\n\n                                                             50\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1       Filed 10/26/26    Page 91 of 119\n\n\n\n\nLewis disclose information about which commenters most influenced their voting policy\n\npositions.\u201d 270\n\n                 iii.          The statement tells buyers that the rules came from investors like them.\n\n          110.          \u201cBottom-up\u201d tells buyers that the Benchmark rules reflect the views of investors\n\nlike them. That is why a buyer would trust the rules without writing its own. \u00b6 41. The rules do not\n\nreflect those views. The statement is false, misleading, and deceptive.\n\nE.        Glass Lewis omits facts that undercut its claims in its guidelines and sales pages.\n\n          111.          Glass Lewis knew the facts below. It mentioned some of them in letters, court\n\nfilings, compliance statements, press releases, and survey reports. It never put them next to the\n\nclaims they undercut, in the guidelines, sales pages, and Proxy Papers where it described the\n\nBenchmark services to buyers. \u00b6\u00b6 58\u2013110. A true fact in one place does not cure a false impression\n\nmade in another. In suits like this one, Texas courts construe section 17.46(a) in light of the FTC\n\nAct. They are to be guided, to the extent possible, by how the FTC and the federal courts have\n\nread section 5(a)(1) of that Act. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.46(c)(1). The FTC has long\n\nrecognized that \u201c[w]ritten disclosures or fine print may be insufficient to correct a misleading\n\nrepresentation.\u201d 271\n\n          112.          Client choices. Most of Glass Lewis\u2019s own clients do not use the Benchmark\n\nPolicy, and Glass Lewis has said so since 2016. \u00b6\u00b6 82\u201384.\n\n          113.          Survey results and response. Glass Lewis\u2019s own survey showed that U.S.\n\ninvestors were far more likely than others to report ignoring board diversity. Few investors\n\nanswered that survey, and most answers came from non-investors. \u00b6\u00b6 81, 108\u2013109.\n\n\n270\n      Ising Testimony, supra.\n271\n      FTC Deception Statement, 1984 WL 565319, at *48.\n\n\n                                                         51\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA              Document 111-1           Filed 10/26/26        Page 92 of 119\n\n\n\n\n          114.    How often the rules drove its advice. Glass Lewis knew how often its board-\n\ndiversity, oversight, and climate rules caused it to recommend votes against directors. It does not\n\nput those totals in its guidelines or sales pages. Before March 2025, it flagged none of those\n\nrecommendations. It still does not flag those driven by the oversight or climate rules. \u00b6 67.\n\n          115.    How shareholders voted. Glass Lewis knew how often shareholders rejected the\n\npositions its Benchmark recommendations took. It tracks how often its Benchmark Policy supports\n\nenvironmental and social proposals, and it publishes yearly reviews of each proxy season. 272\n\n          116.    The evidence. By Glass Lewis\u2019s own account, the evidence could not determine\n\nthe effect of climate-reporting and board-diversity proposals on an individual company. \u00b6 102.\n\n          117.    Conflicts. Glass Lewis had business and legal interests that bore on its advice. They\n\nincluded services it sold to the companies it covered and its suit against the Texas Attorney\n\nGeneral. \u00b6\u00b6 99\u2013101.\n\n          118.    Glass Lewis withheld these facts to induce Texas consumers to buy and renew its\n\nservices and to rely on its Benchmark recommendations. \u00b6\u00b6 88, 93, 105, 110. Many Texas\n\nconsumers wanted advice that reflected broad investor opinion and focused on shareholder value.\n\nHad they known these facts, they would not have bought or renewed the Benchmark services, or\n\nrelied on Benchmark recommendations. Some would have chosen a different policy or a different\n\nprovider.\n\n\n\n\n272\n      Senate Letter at 3; Glass Lewis, Season Reviews, https://www.glasslewis.com/resources-content-types/season-\n      reviews (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n\n\n                                                        52\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26         Page 93 of 119\n\n\n\n\nF.        Glass Lewis knew its statements were false and misleading, and it kept making them.\n\n          119.     Glass Lewis writes the Benchmark guidelines and updates them each year. 273 It\n\ntracks how often its Benchmark Policy supports shareholder proposals, and it surveys investors on\n\ngovernance topics, including board diversity and climate. 274 Glass Lewis itself stated many of the\n\nfacts that show its statements were false or misleading. \u00b6\u00b6 81\u201383, 102.\n\n          120.     In January 2023, the attorneys general of Texas and 20 other States wrote to Glass\n\nLewis. They pointed out that \u201cmany States have prohibitions on unfair or deceptive trade\n\npractices.\u201d 275 They also told Glass Lewis that it appeared to have \u201cpromoted and relied upon false\n\nor misleading statements.\u201d 276 Glass Lewis answered that letter. 277 It then kept making the same\n\nstatements. \u00b6\u00b6 58\u201363.\n\n          121.     In September 2025, the Texas Attorney General announced that he had issued civil\n\ninvestigative demands to Glass Lewis. Their purpose was to learn whether Glass Lewis had\n\n\u201cviolated Texas consumer protection laws, including those prohibiting nondisclosures of material\n\nfacts.\u201d 278 In November 2025, Florida sued Glass Lewis, alleging that it had deceived Florida\n\nconsumers. \u00b6 123. In December 2025, the President directed the Federal Trade Commission to\n\ninvestigate proxy advisors. The FTC is to determine whether they engage in \u201cunfair or deceptive\n\n\n\n\n273\n      2026 Benchmark Guidelines at 7.\n274\n      Senate Letter at 3; Castro et al., supra.\n275\n      Letter from Sean D. Reyes, Utah Att\u2019y Gen., Ken Paxton, Tex. Att\u2019y Gen., et al., to Gary Retelny, President &\n      CEO, Institutional S\u2019holder Servs. Inc., and Kevin Cameron, Exec. Chairman, Glass, Lewis & Co. 3 (Jan. 17,\n      2023),       https://attorneygeneral.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/2023-01-17-Utah-Texas-Letter-to-\n      Glass-Lewis-ISS.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n276\n      Id. at 4.\n277\n      Glass Lewis Reply to Attorneys General at 1\u20132.\n278\n      Press Release, Off. of the Tex. Att\u2019y Gen., Attorney General Ken Paxton Investigates Proxy Advisors Glass Lewis\n      and ISS for Misleading Public Companies to Push Radical Agenda (Sept. 16, 2025),\n      https://texasattorneygeneral.gov/news/releases/attorney-general-ken-paxton-investigates-proxy-advisors-\n      glass-lewis-and-iss-misleading-public (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n\n\n                                                          53\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                   Document 111-1              Filed 10/26/26           Page 94 of 119\n\n\n\n\nacts or practices that harm United States consumers,\u201d including by \u201cproviding misleading or\n\ninaccurate information.\u201d 279\n\n          122.      Glass Lewis kept making its statements after each of these warnings, and even after\n\nthis suit was filed. Its 2026 guidelines say the Benchmark Policy \u201creflects broad investor opinion,\u201d\n\nand Glass Lewis has said those guidelines will stay the same for 2027. \u00b6\u00b6 58\u201359. As of the date of\n\nthis petition, Glass Lewis\u2019s website still makes the statements alleged above.\n\nG.        Other States and the federal government have acted against similar conduct.\n\n          123.      On November 20, 2025, the Florida Attorney General sued Glass Lewis and ISS in\n\nthe circuit court for Gulf County, Florida, under Florida\u2019s consumer protection and antitrust\n\nlaws. 280 Florida alleges that \u201cDefendants have deceived Florida consumers through their\n\nstatements, acts, practices, and material omissions.\u201d 281 ISS removed the case to the federal district\n\ncourt in Panama City, with Glass Lewis\u2019s consent. Florida then dropped its antitrust claim, and\n\nthe federal court remanded the case. 282 In July 2025, the Missouri Attorney General sued Glass\n\nLewis and ISS in the Cole County Circuit Court to enforce civil investigative demands under\n\nMissouri\u2019s consumer protection law. 283\n\n\n\n\n279\n      Exec. Order No. 14,366, 90 Fed. Reg. at 58,504.\n280\n      Complaint, Office of the Att\u2019y Gen. v. Institutional S\u2019holder Servs. Inc. (Fla. Cir. Ct. Gulf Cnty. filed Nov. 20, 2025),\n      https://www.myfloridalegal.com/sites/default/files/complaint.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026) [hereinafter\n      Florida Compl.]; Press Release, Fla. Off. of the Att\u2019y Gen., Attorney General James Uthmeier Sues Proxy Advisory\n      Giants for Deceiving Investors and Manipulating Corporate Governance (Nov. 20, 2025),\n      https://www.myfloridalegal.com/node/28054 (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n281\n      Florida Compl. \u00b6 144; First Am. Compl. \u00b6 121, Office of the Att\u2019y Gen. v. Institutional S\u2019holder Servs. Inc., No. 5:26-\n      cv-00026-MW-MJF (N.D. Fla. Feb. 26, 2026), ECF No. 40.\n282\n      Pl.\u2019s Consol. Resp. Mem. to Defs.\u2019 Mots. to Dismiss 12, Office of the Att\u2019y Gen., No. 5:26-cv-00026-MW-MJF\n      (N.D. Fla. May 8, 2026), ECF No. 63.\n283\n      Press Release, Mo. Att\u2019y Gen., Attorney General Bailey Leads Fight Against Hidden ESG and DEI Agendas in\n      Corporate America (July 11, 2025), https://ago.mo.gov/attorney-general-bailey-leads-fight-against-hidden-esg-\n      and-dei-agendas-in-corporate-america/ (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n\n\n                                                              54\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                  Document 111-1              Filed 10/26/26           Page 95 of 119\n\n\n\n\n          124.      On May 20, 2026, Texas, Nebraska, Iowa, and West Virginia each sued ISS under\n\ntheir consumer protection laws. 284 Iowa\u2019s petition, filed in the Polk County District Court, alleges\n\nthat \u201cISS advertised to its Iowa clients that it would provide objective and impartial investment\n\nadvice.\u201d 285\n\n          125.      Texas and 12 other States have also sued BlackRock, State Street, and Vanguard in\n\nthe federal district court in Tyler, Texas. There, the States allege that BlackRock advertised certain\n\nfunds as not following an \u201cESG investment strategy\u201d while \u201cusing the funds to pursue an ESG\n\nagenda through engagements and proxy voting.\u201d 286 That court refused to dismiss most of the\n\nStates\u2019 consumer protection claims against BlackRock, including their claim under the DTPA. 287\n\n          126.      In February 2026, Vanguard settled with Texas and the other States and agreed to\n\npay $29.5 million. 288 Vanguard also agreed to vote and engage with companies \u201csolely to further\n\nthe financial interests of investors\u201d in its funds. 289 It agreed to use commercially reasonable efforts,\n\nby June 2027, to offer a choice of voting policies in funds holding at least half of its U.S. stock-fund\n\nassets. The choices must include voting with company management. 290 And it agreed not to\n\n\n\n\n284\n      State v. Institutional S\u2019holder Servs., Inc., No. 471-03459-2026; State ex rel. Hilgers v. Institutional S\u2019holder Servs.\n      Inc., No. D02CI260001712 (Neb. Dist. Ct. filed May 20, 2026); Petition, State ex rel. Bird v. Institutional S\u2019holder\n      Servs.,       Inc.      (Iowa       Dist.       Ct.      Polk       Cnty.        filed      May        20,       2026),\n      https://www.iowaattorneygeneral.gov/media/cms/5_ECAAEB881A444.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026)\n      [hereinafter Iowa Pet.]; State ex rel. McCuskey v. Institutional S\u2019holder Servs. Inc., No. CC-17-2026-C-113 (W. Va.\n      Cir. Ct. filed May 20, 2026); Ballotpedia News, Texas, Nebraska, Iowa, West Virginia Sue ISS over ESG Disclosures\n      (June 3, 2026), https://news.ballotpedia.org/2026/06/03/texas-nebraska-iowa-west-virginia-sue-iss-over-esg-\n      disclosures-2/ (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n285\n      Iowa Pet. \u00b6 4.\n286\n      BlackRock, 2025 WL 2201071, at *1.\n287\n      Id. at *22, *24.\n288\n      Press Release, Off. of the Tex. Att\u2019y Gen., Attorney General Paxton Secures Historic, Industry-Changing\n      Agreement with Vanguard to Protect the Coal Industry and Empower Investors (Feb. 26, 2026),\n      https://www.texasattorneygeneral.gov/news/releases/attorney-general-paxton-secures-historic-industry-\n      changing-agreement-vanguard-protect-coal-industry (last visited Oct. 18, 2026); Vanguard Settlement \u00a7 1.12.\n289\n      Vanguard Settlement \u00a7 5.\n290\n      Id. \u00a7\u00a7 4.1\u20134.2.\n\n\n                                                              55\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 111-1           Filed 10/26/26         Page 96 of 119\n\n\n\n\nparticipate in Climate Action 100+ or similar climate groups, and to publish its votes at least four\n\ntimes a year. 291\n\n          127.     In December 2025, the President also directed the SEC to enforce anti-fraud law\n\n\u201cwith respect to material misstatements or omissions contained in proxy advisors\u2019 proxy voting\n\nrecommendations.\u201d 292\n\nH.        Glass Lewis\u2019s statements affected Texas consumers.\n\n          128.     The State need not allege that any Texan was harmed. \u00b6 187. But Glass Lewis\u2019s\n\nstatements did affect Texas consumers. Texas clients bought and renewed Glass Lewis\u2019s\n\nBenchmark services, and they received Benchmark recommendations under a policy Glass Lewis\n\nhad misdescribed. \u00b6\u00b6 12, 15. Clients who relied on Glass Lewis\u2019s statements cast votes based on\n\nthose recommendations, including diversity-based recommendations against directors at Texas\n\ncompanies. \u00b6\u00b6 44\u201345, 75.\n\n          129.     Many of the Texans affected are 65 or older. The Teacher Retirement System pays\n\npensions to more than 500,000 retirees. 293 The Employees Retirement System serves more than\n\n125,000 retirees and beneficiaries. 294 And about a third of U.S. households that own mutual funds\n\nare headed by someone 65 or older. 295 Glass Lewis sells its policies through the funds and voting-\n\nchoice programs that serve these older investors. \u00b6\u00b6 134\u2013135. Older Texans in those funds and\n\nprograms are consumers. They seek or acquire Glass Lewis\u2019s services by purchase, through the\n\nfunds and advisers that buy those services for them. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.45(4); \u00b6 29. 296\n\n\n291\n      Id. \u00a7\u00a7 5.4, 5.6.\n292\n      Exec. Order No. 14,366, 90 Fed. Reg. at 58,503.\n293\n      Teacher Ret. Sys. of Tex., 2025 Popular Annual Financial Report, supra, at 1.\n294\n      Emps. Ret. Sys. of Tex., Serving Texans, supra.\n295\n      Daniel Schrass & Michael Bogdan, Inv. Co. Inst., Profile of Mutual Fund Shareholders, 2025, at 4 (Nov. 2025),\n      https://www.ici.org/system/files/2025-11/25-rpt-profiles.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n296\n      Kennedy, 689 S.W.2d at 892; Arthur Andersen, 945 S.W.2d at 815.\n\n\n                                                         56\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA             Document 111-1           Filed 10/26/26       Page 97 of 119\n\n\n\n\nGlass Lewis knows that those funds and advisers buy its services to vote for their investors, to\n\nwhom many owe a \u201cfiduciary duty to cast informed votes.\u201d \u00b6 35. Glass Lewis\u2019s acts and practices\n\nwere calculated to acquire or deprive money or other property from consumers who were 65 or\n\nolder when the acts occurred. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.47(c)(2).\n\n          130.    Texans\u2019 retirement savings are invested in the companies whose votes Glass Lewis\n\nshapes. \u00b6\u00b6 36, 38. When advice sold as value-focused pushes companies toward measures with no\n\nproven link to value, those companies spend money and management time that could have gone to\n\ntheir business. That affects the returns of the pension plans and funds that own those companies,\n\nand of the Texans whose savings they hold. The research in \u00b6\u00b6 131\u2013133 bears on whether these\n\nrules serve investors. A fiduciary that must vote for returns would want to know where a policy\n\nsold as value-focused stands on that question. \u00b6\u00b6 38, 87, 105.\n\n          131.    Investors who follow ESG strategies have often paid a price. The federal district\n\ncourt in Fort Worth found that \u201cESG investments often underperform traditional investments by\n\napproximately 10%.\u201d In 2023, it found, ESG funds returned about 8%, compared with about 14%\n\nfor the S&P 500 and Russell 1000 indexes. 297 Oliver Wyman reported that \u201c[m]any ESG funds\n\nsuffered a roughly three to four percentage-point underperformance\u201d compared with broad stock\n\nmarkets in 2022. 298 Morgan Stanley reported that in the second half of 2024, sustainable funds\n\n\n\n\n297\n      Spence, 775 F. Supp. 3d at 985.\n298\n      Huw van Steenis, The Next Phase of Climate-Aware Investing, Oliver Wyman (Oct. 31, 2023),\n      https://www.oliverwyman.com/our-expertise/journals/energy-and-natural-resources-journal/2024/the-next-\n      phase-of-climate-aware-investing.html (last   visited   Oct.     18,    2026),     also   available    at\n      https://www.oliverwyman.com/content/dam/oliver-\n      wyman/v2/publications/2023/september/Oliver_Wyman_The_Next_Phase_of_Climate_Aware_Investing.p\n      df.\n\n\n                                                       57\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26         Page 98 of 119\n\n\n\n\nposted a median return of 0.4%, compared with 1.7% for traditional funds. 299 The same report found\n\nthat, over a longer period, sustainable funds had done slightly better. A $100 investment made in\n\nDecember 2018 would have grown to $136 in a sustainable fund, against $131 in a traditional\n\nfund. 300 A peer-reviewed study found that \u201cESG funds appear to underperform financially relative\n\nto other funds within the same asset manager and year, and to charge higher fees.\u201d 301 Another did\n\n\u201cnot find evidence that high sustainability funds outperform low sustainability funds.\u201d 302\n\nInvestors have pulled their money out. U.S. sustainable funds had net outflows of $21 billion in\n\n2025, after outflows of $20 billion in 2024. 303\n\n          132.     Research on diversity training reports that it often fails to reduce bias and can\n\nincrease it. 304 Sociologists Frank Dobbin and Alexandra Kalev report that \u201chundreds of studies\n\ndating back to the 1930s suggest that antibias training does not reduce bias.\u201d 305 They also report\n\nthat \u201ctraining alone does not change attitudes or behavior, or not by much and not for long.\u201d 306\n\nAnd \u201casking people to suppress stereotypes tends to reinforce them.\u201d 307 A 2024 study by\n\nresearchers at Rutgers University and the Network Contagion Research Institute found that DEI\n\n\n299\n      Morgan Stanley Inst. for Sustainable Investing, Sustainable Fund Returns Lag Peers\u2019 in Second Half of 2024 (Mar.\n      4, 2025), https://www.morganstanley.com/insights/articles/sustainable-funds-performance-second-half-2024\n      (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n300\n      Id.\n301\n      Aneesh Raghunandan & Shivaram Rajgopal, Do ESG Funds Make Stakeholder-Friendly Investments?, 27 Rev. Acct.\n      Stud. 822, 822 (2022).\n302\n      Samuel M. Hartzmark & Abigail B. Sussman, Do Investors Value Sustainability? A Natural Experiment Examining\n      Ranking and Fund Flows, 74 J. Fin. 2789, 2789 (2019).\n303\n      Morningstar Sustainalytics, Global Sustainable Fund Flows: Q4 and Full-Year 2025 in Review 22, 24 (2026),\n      https://www.morningstar.com/content/cs-\n      assets/v3/assets/blt9415ea4cc4157833/blt1d54e64f88b82b3b/Global_ESG_Flows_Q4_2025_Report.pdf (last\n      visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n304\n      Frank Dobbin & Alexandra Kalev, Why Doesn\u2019t Diversity Training Work? The Challenge for Industry and Academia,\n      10 Anthropology Now 48, 48\u201350 (2018); Network Contagion Rsch. Inst., Instructing Animosity: How DEI Pedagogy\n      Produces      the    Hostile  Attribution   Bias     3    (Nov.    2024),     https://networkcontagion.us/wp-\n      content/uploads/Instructing-Animosity_11.13.24.pdf (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n305\n      Dobbin & Kalev, supra, at 48.\n306\n      Id. at 49.\n307\n      Id. at 50.\n\n\n                                                          58\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26         Page 99 of 119\n\n\n\n\ntraining content, \u201cinstead of reducing bias,\u201d produced \u201ca hostile attribution bias.\u201d 308 Students\n\nwho read it saw about 21% more discrimination in an admissions scenario that showed none, and\n\nthey were more willing to punish the admissions officer. 309\n\n          133.     Several studies have found that board-gender quotas or added board-gender\n\ndiversity cut company value or profits. One study of Norway\u2019s law requiring women on corporate\n\nboards found that the quota \u201ccaused a significant drop in the stock price at the announcement of\n\nthe law.\u201d It also found \u201ca large decline in Tobin\u2019s Q,\u201d a common measure of company value, in\n\nthe years that followed. 310 A study of California\u2019s board-gender law found that its announcement\n\ncut company stock prices by an average of 1.2%. 311 Another study of Norway\u2019s quota found that\n\naffected firms made fewer layoffs, \u201cincreasing relative labor costs and employment levels and\n\nreducing short-term profits.\u201d 312 A study of U.S. boards found that \u201cthe average effect of gender\n\ndiversity on firm performance is negative.\u201d It concluded that \u201cmandating gender quotas for\n\ndirectors can reduce firm value for well-governed firms.\u201d 313\n\nI.        Glass Lewis made these statements to Texans again and again.\n\n          134.     Glass Lewis made its statements to every person who visited its website,\n\ndownloaded its guidelines or reports, received its Proxy Papers, read its marketing materials, or\n\nbought its services. That includes ordinary Texans. Schwab, based in Westlake, lets shareholders\n\n\n\n308\n      Network Contagion Rsch. Inst., supra, at 3.\n309\n      Id. at 6\u20138.\n310\n      Kenneth R. Ahern & Amy K. Dittmar, The Changing of the Boards: The Impact on Firm Valuation of Mandated\n      Female Board Representation, 127 Q.J. Econ. 137, 137 (2012).\n311\n      Daniel Greene, Vincent J. Intintoli & Kathleen M. Kahle, Do Board Gender Quotas Affect Firm Value? Evidence\n      from California Senate Bill No. 826, 60 J. Corp. Fin. 101526 (2020).\n312\n      David A. Matsa & Amalia R. Miller, A Female Style in Corporate Leadership? Evidence from Quotas, 5 Am. Econ. J.:\n      Applied Econ. 136, 136 (2013).\n313\n      Ren\u00e9e B. Adams & Daniel Ferreira, Women in the Boardroom and Their Impact on Governance and Performance, 94\n      J. Fin. Econ. 291, 291 (2009).\n\n\n                                                          59\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA             Document 111-1           Filed 10/26/26        Page 100 of 119\n\n\n\n\nof its Schwab 1000 Index Fund vote under the \u201cGlass Lewis Benchmark\u201d policy. 314 Schwab also\n\nrepeats Glass Lewis\u2019s description of that policy to them. \u00b6\u00b6 17, 98. BlackRock offers individual\n\ninvestors in certain U.S. funds the choice to have their shares voted under Glass Lewis\u2019s\n\n\u201cBenchmark Policy.\u201d 315 Many of the individual investors in these funds and programs live in\n\nTexas.\n\n          135.    Glass Lewis says it \u201cdoes not serve retail investors.\u201d 316 But its policies and\n\nstatements reach individual investors through the investment firms and funds that use them. \u00b6 134.\n\nWestwood, the Dallas firm, uses Glass Lewis\u2019s guidelines and generally follows its\n\nrecommendations when it votes its clients\u2019 shares. That includes a mutual fund offered by\n\nAmerican Beacon Funds of Irving, Texas. \u00b6 18.\n\n          136.    Glass Lewis delivers Proxy Papers with Benchmark recommendations to each of its\n\nTexas clients that receives research. \u00b6\u00b6 12, 15. A Texas client that owns stock in hundreds of\n\ncompanies receives hundreds of Proxy Papers each year, each with Benchmark recommendations.\n\nGlass Lewis also posts full Proxy Papers on its website, where anyone can download them. It uses\n\nthem to show \u201chow Glass Lewis\u2019 insights can advance\u201d a client\u2019s stewardship program. 317\n\n          137.    Texans visit Glass Lewis\u2019s website. They download its guidelines, compliance\n\nstatements, survey reports, posted letters, and other materials. \u00b6 11. Glass Lewis also markets,\n\n\n\n\n314\n      Schwab Asset Mgmt., Proxy Voting Choice FAQ, supra.\n315\n      BlackRock,           BlackRock      U.S.      Retail       Program         FAQs         (Apr.       2026),\n      https://www.blackrock.com/corporate/literature/publication/voting-choice-usretailprogramfaqs.pdf      (last\n      visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n316\n      Wieck Decl. \u00b6 8.\n317\n      Glass Lewis, Northern Trust, https://www.glasslewis.com/northern-trust (last visited Oct. 18, 2026); Glass\n      Lewis,            Proxy        Paper:      Alphabet          Inc.         (May           16,        2025),\n      https://resources.glasslewis.com/hubfs/Sample%20Proxy%20Papers/Alphabet%202025%20Proxy%20Paper.pdf\n      (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n\n\n                                                        60\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26       Page 101 of 119\n\n\n\n\nsells, and renews its services through communications with Texas clients and prospective clients.\n\nEach of these channels carries Glass Lewis\u2019s policies, and its descriptions of them, to Texans.\n\nJ.       Each statement to a person in Texas is a separate violation.\n\n         138.    Each time Glass Lewis made a false, misleading, or deceptive statement to a person\n\nin Texas, it committed a separate violation of the DTPA. A statement on a Glass Lewis web page\n\nor document is made to each person in Texas who views or downloads it. So each such visit or\n\ndownload is a separate violation. The State pleads what Glass Lewis told courts, Congress,\n\nregulators, and other officials as admissions, not as violations. \u00b6\u00b6 61\u201362, 82\u201383. But when Glass\n\nLewis posted such a letter on its website for investors, the posting is a statement to each person in\n\nTexas who read it there. \u00b6 61. Each Proxy Paper with Benchmark recommendations that Glass\n\nLewis delivered or made available to a person in Texas, directly or indirectly, is a separate violation.\n\nEach presented recommendations under a misdescribed policy without disclosing the facts alleged\n\nabove. Each marketing, sales, or renewal communication with a person in Texas that carried or\n\nrelied on these statements is a separate violation. So is each sale or renewal of Glass Lewis\u2019s\n\nservices to a person in Texas. So is each vote that Glass Lewis cast or pre-populated for a person\n\nin Texas under Benchmark recommendations.\n\n                                  VII.    CAUSES OF ACTION\n\n         139.    The State adopts and incorporates by reference all preceding paragraphs and\n\nallegations of this petition.\n\n     Count 1: Glass Lewis engaged in false, misleading, or deceptive acts and practices (Tex.\n                                Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.46(a)).\n\n         140.    The DTPA prohibits \u201c[f]alse, misleading, or deceptive acts or practices in the\n\nconduct of any trade or commerce.\u201d Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.46(a). Glass Lewis engaged in\n\n\n                                                  61\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 111-1             Filed 10/26/26          Page 102 of 119\n\n\n\n\ntrade and commerce when it advertised, offered, sold, and distributed its proxy advisory services.\n\n\u00b6 28. In doing so, it made false, misleading, and deceptive statements about its services, and each\n\nhad the capacity to deceive. \u00b6\u00b6 56\u2013110.\n\n          141.     An act is false, misleading, or deceptive if it \u201chas the capacity or tendency to\n\ndeceive an average or ordinary person.\u201d 318 That is so \u201ceven though that person may have been\n\nignorant, unthinking or credulous.\u201d319 In a suit like this one, Texas courts also look to the Federal\n\nTrade Commission. It asks \u201cwhether the act or practice is likely to mislead, rather than whether it\n\ncauses actual deception.\u201d 320 The FTC judges a claim by \u201cthe net impression that it is likely to\n\nmake.\u201d 321\n\n          142.     These are statements of fact about whose views the Benchmark Policy reflects, how\n\nit was built, and what it aims to do. Glass Lewis measures those facts itself, through its clients\u2019\n\npolicy elections and its own surveys. \u00b6\u00b6 82\u201383, 108. A statement framed as opinion is still\n\nactionable when the speaker has superior knowledge of the facts behind it. 322 Under the FTC\u2019s\n\nview, an opinion claim is also actionable if it misrepresents \u201cthe basis of [the] opinion.\u201d 323 Glass\n\nLewis alone knew how many of its clients chose the Benchmark Policy, who answered its surveys,\n\nand how often its rules drove its recommendations. \u00b6\u00b6 67, 82\u201383, 108.\n\n          143.     The net impression of Glass Lewis\u2019s statements was that the Benchmark Policy\n\nreflected what investors broadly think and focused on shareholder value. Glass Lewis\u2019s policy\n\nmenu reinforced that impression. It placed an ESG Policy on one side and a policy for ESG skeptics\n\n\n318\n      Spradling v. Williams, 566 S.W.2d 561, 562 (Tex. 1978).\n319\n      Spradling, 566 S.W.2d at 562, 564 (approving that definition); accord Doe v. Boys Clubs of Greater Dallas, Inc., 907\n      S.W.2d 472, 479\u201380 (Tex. 1995).\n320\n      Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.46(c)(1); FTC Deception Statement, 1984 WL 565319, at *46.\n321\n      FTC Deception Statement, 1984 WL 565319, at *47.\n322\n      Italian Cowboy Partners, Ltd. v. Prudential Ins. Co. of Am., 341 S.W.3d 323, 337\u201339 (Tex. 2011).\n323\n      FTC Deception Statement, 1984 WL 565319, at *48.\n\n\n                                                            62\n\f   Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA             Document 111-1          Filed 10/26/26       Page 103 of 119\n\n\n\n\non the other. \u00b6\u00b6 51, 54. But the Benchmark Policy used the same 30% gender threshold as the ESG\n\nand Climate policies. \u00b6\u00b6 64\u201368. Glass Lewis invited buyers to rely on that impression in place of\n\nstudying each rule. \u00b6 41.\n\n        144.    Glass Lewis also engaged in a deceptive practice when it delivered Benchmark\n\nrecommendations to Texas clients under a policy it had misdescribed. It did so without disclosing\n\nthe facts that showed its descriptions were false or misleading. \u00b6\u00b6 50, 111\u2013118. It made these\n\nstatements, and engaged in these practices, in its dealings with people in Texas. \u00b6\u00b6 134\u2013137.\n\n        145.    Each false, misleading, or deceptive statement or practice directed to a person in\n\nTexas is a separate violation of section 17.46(a). \u00b6 138. Glass Lewis is engaging in, has engaged in,\n\nand is about to engage in these acts and practices. \u00b6 122.\n\nCount 2: Glass Lewis misrepresented its services and advertised them with intent not to sell\n           them as advertised (Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.46(b)(5), (7), (9)).\n\n        146.    The DTPA\u2019s list of false, misleading, or deceptive acts or practices includes three\n\nthat apply here. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.46(b). The first is \u201crepresenting that goods or\n\nservices have sponsorship, approval, characteristics, ingredients, uses, benefits, or quantities\n\nwhich they do not have . . . .\u201d Id. \u00a7 17.46(b)(5). The second is \u201crepresenting that goods or services\n\nare of a particular standard, quality, or grade . . . if they are of another.\u201d Id. \u00a7 17.46(b)(7). The third\n\nis \u201cadvertising goods or services with intent not to sell them as advertised.\u201d Id. \u00a7 17.46(b)(9).\n\n        147.    Glass Lewis represented that its Benchmark services have characteristics and\n\nbenefits they do not have. It said they reflect broad investor opinion and its clients\u2019 predominant\n\nviews, and that they are built from the bottom up on client input. It also said they are independent\n\nand objective, and that they judge every environmental and social issue by its effect on shareholder\n\nvalue. \u00b6\u00b6 56\u2013110. This violates section 17.46(b)(5).\n\n\n\n                                                    63\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26         Page 104 of 119\n\n\n\n\n          148.     Glass Lewis represented that its Benchmark services meet a particular standard,\n\nquality, or grade when they are of another. It said its research \u201cmeets the highest standards of\n\nquality, objectivity, and independence.\u201d \u00b6 94. It said its policies are \u201ctailored to industry standards\n\nand local market best practices.\u201d \u00b6 90. It said the Benchmark Policy reflects \u201cwidely accepted\n\ngovernance principles.\u201d \u00b6 58. And it called its advice \u201cindependent,\u201d \u201cobjective,\u201d and \u201creliable.\u201d\n\n\u00b6\u00b6 94\u201395, 104. This violates section 17.46(b)(7).\n\n          149.     Since October 15, 2025, Glass Lewis has advertised its Benchmark services with\n\nintent not to sell them as advertised. \u00b6\u00b6 85\u201386. An advertisement includes \u201c[a]ny oral, written, or\n\ngraphic statement made by the seller in any manner in connection with the solicitation of\n\nbusiness.\u201d 324 Glass Lewis\u2019s guidelines, sales pages, and compliance statements are such\n\nstatements, made to win and keep clients. \u00b6\u00b6 10, 41, 56. Intention may be \u201cinferred from objective\n\nmanifestations that indicate that the person acted intentionally.\u201d Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7\n\n17.45(13). A federal magistrate judge in Houston, in a recommendation the district court adopted,\n\nupheld the State\u2019s (b)(9) claim against a land developer. The State had alleged a plan to cut services\n\nwhile the developer kept advertising property owners\u2019 associations it had dissolved.325 In October\n\n2025, Glass Lewis announced that one policy could no longer serve a diverse client base. \u00b6 85. On\n\nNovember 25, 2025, its chief executive wrote that it would \u201cmove away from a single house view.\u201d\n\n\u00b6 86. Soon after, it published 2026 guidelines that sold the Benchmark Policy as reflecting \u201cbroad\n\ninvestor opinion.\u201d \u00b6 86. What it delivered was its own house view, relabeled as the policy\u2019s view.\n\n\u00b6 63. Glass Lewis thus advertised a consensus product while intending to deliver something else.\n\n\n\n\n324\n      Smith v. Baldwin, 611 S.W.2d 611, 614\u201315 (Tex. 1980) (quoting Black\u2019s Law Dictionary 50 (5th ed. 1979)).\n325\n      Colony Ridge, 2024 WL 4553111, at *9\u201310.\n\n\n                                                          64\n\f   Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 111-1           Filed 10/26/26   Page 105 of 119\n\n\n\n\nIt also knew the policy carried rules it could not tie to shareholder value. \u00b6\u00b6 64\u201368, 102. This\n\nviolates section 17.46(b)(9).\n\n        150.    Each such representation or advertisement directed to a person in Texas is a\n\nseparate violation. \u00b6 138.\n\n  Count 3: Glass Lewis failed to disclose information to induce transactions (Tex. Bus. &\n                                Com. Code \u00a7 17.46(b)(24)).\n\n        151.    The DTPA prohibits the following act. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.46(b)(24).\n\n        [F]ailing to disclose information concerning goods or services which was known at\n        the time of the transaction if such failure to disclose such information was intended\n        to induce the consumer into a transaction into which the consumer would not have\n        entered had the information been disclosed[.]\n\n        152.    Each time Glass Lewis sold or renewed its services with a Texas consumer, it knew\n\nthe information alleged in \u00b6\u00b6 112\u2013117. Glass Lewis did not disclose that information in the\n\nguidelines, sales pages, and Proxy Papers where it described its services to buyers. \u00b6 111. It failed\n\nto disclose that information to induce Texas consumers to buy and renew its services. Texas\n\nconsumers would not have entered those transactions had the information been disclosed. \u00b6 118.\n\n        153.    Each such failure to disclose, in connection with a transaction with a Texas\n\nconsumer, is a separate violation of section 17.46(b)(24).\n\n     VIII. APPLICATION FOR TEMPORARY AND PERMANENT INJUNCTION\n\n        154.    The State adopts and incorporates by reference all preceding paragraphs and\n\nallegations of this petition.\n\n        155.    An applicant for a temporary injunction generally must plead and prove three\n\nelements. They are a cause of action against the defendant, a probable right to the relief sought,\n\n\n\n\n                                                 65\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 111-1          Filed 10/26/26        Page 106 of 119\n\n\n\n\nand a probable, imminent, and irreparable injury in the interim. 326 But when an injunction rests on\n\na statute, the statute\u2019s express language supersedes common-law elements \u201csuch as imminent\n\nharm or irreparable injury.\u201d 327 When a statute authorizes injunctive relief and the statute is being\n\nviolated, the court may restrain the violation without balancing the equities. 328\n\n          156.    Under the DTPA, the State may obtain an injunction on two showings. First, the\n\nConsumer Protection Division has reason to believe that a person is engaging in, has engaged in,\n\nor is about to engage in an unlawful act or practice. Second, the proceeding is in the public\n\ninterest. 329 The list of deceptive acts in section 17.46(b) is not exclusive. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code\n\n\u00a7 17.46(b). Whether to grant a temporary injunction rests in the trial court\u2019s sound discretion. 330\n\n          157.    The Division has reason to believe that Glass Lewis is engaging in, has engaged in,\n\nand is about to engage in acts and practices that the DTPA declares unlawful. \u00b6\u00b6 56\u2013122. Glass\n\nLewis continues to make its statements on its website and in its guidelines, and it has said its 2026\n\nguidelines will remain in effect for 2027. \u00b6\u00b6 59, 122. Glass Lewis also plans to move all clients off\n\nthe Benchmark Policy by the end of 2027 and to offer recommendations that reflect varying\n\ninvestor views. \u00b6\u00b6 85\u201386. Without an injunction, nothing will stop it from describing those new\n\nofferings the same way. Nor would it matter if Glass Lewis stopped. Under the DTPA, stopping\n\nafter the Division\u2019s prior contact does not moot the suit \u201cunder any circumstances.\u201d Tex. Bus. &\n\nCom. Code \u00a7 17.47(a).\n\n\n\n\n326\n      Butnaru v. Ford Motor Co., 84 S.W.3d 198, 204 (Tex. 2002); Polston v. State, No. 03-20-00130-CV, 2022 WL\n      91974, at *3 (Tex. App.\u2014Austin Jan. 6, 2022, no pet.) (mem. op.).\n327\n      David Jason West and Pydia, Inc. v. State, 212 S.W.3d 513, 519 (Tex. App.\u2014Austin 2006, no pet.).\n328\n      State v. Tex. Pet Foods, Inc., 591 S.W.2d 800, 805 (Tex. 1979).\n329\n      Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.47(a); West, 212 S.W.3d at 519\u201321.\n330\n      Butnaru, 84 S.W.3d at 204; West, 212 S.W.3d at 516\u201317.\n\n\n                                                      66\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26       Page 107 of 119\n\n\n\n\n        158.    An injunction is in the public interest. Texas investors, and the Texans whose\n\nsavings they manage, continue to receive Benchmark recommendations under a policy that Glass\n\nLewis has misdescribed. \u00b6\u00b6 128, 134\u2013137. The State asks the Court to set a hearing on its\n\napplication for a temporary injunction.\n\n        159.    In the terms below, \u201cclearly and conspicuously\u201d means in a way that an ordinary\n\nreader can easily notice, read, and understand, in the same place as any statement it accompanies.\n\nAn \u201cenvironmental or social rule\u201d is a voting rule that turns on the gender, racial, or ethnic makeup\n\nof a board. It also includes a rule that turns on board oversight of environmental or social issues, or\n\non climate disclosure or emissions. And it includes a rule that relies on an outside group\u2019s list,\n\nframework, or standard on those topics. Glass Lewis makes a statement to a person in Texas when\n\nit sends the statement to that person or posts it where that person can view or download it. A\n\nstatement made in litigation, or to a legislature or government official, is not a statement to a person\n\nin Texas under these terms. \u00b6 138. The \u201cBenchmark Policy\u201d includes any policy that succeeds or\n\nreplaces it as Glass Lewis\u2019s standard or default policy.\n\nA.      The Court should enjoin Glass Lewis pending trial.\n\n        160.    After notice and hearing, the State asks the Court to order Glass Lewis, pending\n\ntrial, to do the following in its proxy advisory services to people in Texas. The State seeks the Proxy\n\nPaper terms in \u00b6\u00b6 167 and 169 only in the permanent injunction.\n\n        161.    Preserve evidence. Preserve all documents and data relevant to this suit, from\n\nJanuary 1, 2016, forward. They include its guidelines, website content, marketing materials, survey\n\ndata, client policy elections, Proxy Papers, and communications with Texas clients and prospective\n\nclients. Do not destroy, delete, or alter them.\n\n\n\n\n                                                  67\n\f   Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA             Document 111-1       Filed 10/26/26     Page 108 of 119\n\n\n\n\n        162.       Investor-opinion claims. Do not tell any person in Texas that a voting policy\n\nreflects \u201cbroad investor opinion,\u201d \u201cwidely accepted governance principles,\u201d or the\n\n\u201cpredominant\u201d or \u201cconsensus\u201d views of clients or investors. Glass Lewis may make such a\n\nstatement only if, in the same place, it clearly and conspicuously discloses the share of its clients\n\nthat vote under that policy. \u00b6 168.\n\n        163.       Best-practice claims. Do not tell any person in Texas that the Benchmark Policy\n\nreflects \u201cbest practices,\u201d \u201cindustry best practices,\u201d or \u201cindustry standards.\u201d Glass Lewis may\n\nmake such a statement only if the list of environmental or social rules required below appears in\n\nthe same place. \u00b6 166.\n\n        164.       Shareholder-value claims. Do not tell any person in Texas that Glass Lewis\n\nevaluates environmental and social issues \u201cthrough the lens of long-term shareholder value\u201d or by\n\ntheir \u201cfinancial materiality.\u201d Glass Lewis may make such a statement only if it then has competent\n\nand reliable evidence that substantiates the statement. It must keep that evidence and produce it\n\nto the Division on request.\n\n        165.       Independence claims. Do not tell any person in Texas that Glass Lewis\u2019s research\n\nor advice is \u201cindependent,\u201d \u201cobjective,\u201d or \u201cimpartial.\u201d Glass Lewis may make such a statement\n\nonly if, in the same place, it clearly and conspicuously discloses the business and legal interests\n\nlisted in \u00b6 169.\n\n        166.       Disclose the environmental and social rules. On its website and at the start of\n\neach set of Benchmark guidelines, clearly and conspicuously list each environmental or social rule\n\nin the Benchmark Policy. Name any outside group whose list, framework, or standard a rule relies\n\non.\n\n\n\n\n                                                  68\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 111-1        Filed 10/26/26      Page 109 of 119\n\n\n\n\n        167.    Flag the recommendations. In each Proxy Paper given to a client in Texas, clearly\n\nand conspicuously identify each Benchmark recommendation that would have been different\n\nwithout an environmental or social rule. Glass Lewis already flags recommendations that rest on\n\nboard diversity. \u00b6 67.\n\n        168.    Disclose client use and survey responses. On its website and in its Benchmark\n\nguidelines, clearly and conspicuously disclose the share of its clients that vote under the\n\nBenchmark Policy. Also disclose the number of investors and non-investors who answered any\n\nsurvey it cites as support for a policy.\n\n        169.    Disclose conflicts. In each Proxy Paper given to a client in Texas, clearly and\n\nconspicuously disclose any business or legal interest Glass Lewis has in the matter. That includes\n\nlitigation with the company or with a government official whose law bears on the vote. It also\n\nincludes membership in any organization whose views the report repeats, and consulting or other\n\nservices sold to the company. And it includes any interest Glass Lewis\u2019s owners have in the matter\n\nand any fees the company paid Glass Lewis or its affiliates in the prior three years.\n\n        170.    Disclose its track record. On its website, clearly and conspicuously disclose each\n\nyear how often the Benchmark Policy supported environmental and social shareholder proposals\n\nin the prior year. Show that figure next to the average shareholder support those proposals\n\nreceived.\n\nB.      After trial, the Court should permanently enjoin Glass Lewis for 10 years.\n\n        171.    After trial, the State asks the Court to enjoin Glass Lewis permanently, for 10 years.\n\nThe injunction should bar the acts and practices the trier of fact finds unlawful in Glass Lewis\u2019s\n\n\n\n\n                                                  69\n\f   Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26      Page 110 of 119\n\n\n\n\nproxy advisory services to people in Texas. The permanent injunction should include each term in\n\n\u00b6\u00b6 160\u2013170 and the terms below.\n\n       172.    Independent auditor. Glass Lewis should retain, at its own expense, an\n\nindependent auditor approved by the Consumer Protection Division. Each year, the auditor should\n\nreview Glass Lewis\u2019s compliance and report its findings to the Court and the Division. For each\n\nviolation of the injunction, Glass Lewis should pay the civil penalties that section 17.47(e) allows.\n\nTex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.47(e).\n\n       173.    Right to cancel. Glass Lewis should allow each Texas client to cancel its contract\n\nwithout penalty at any time during the first year after judgment.\n\n       174.    Compliance officer. Glass Lewis should designate a compliance officer who\n\nreports to its chief executive and is responsible for its compliance with the judgment.\n\n       175.    Compliance records. For the 10-year term, Glass Lewis should keep records\n\nsufficient to show its compliance. They should include the support for any statement covered by\n\nthe judgment, its survey data, counts of the clients that vote under each policy, and its Proxy Paper\n\nflags. Glass Lewis should produce them to the Division on request.\n\n       176.    Compliance reports. Each year of the term, Glass Lewis should file with the\n\nDivision a written compliance report signed by its compliance officer.\n\n       177.    Corrective notice. Within 30 days of judgment, Glass Lewis should send a court-\n\napproved notice to each current and former Texas client it has served since January 1, 2016. It\n\nshould send the same notice to each investment firm or fund sponsor that offers a Glass Lewis\n\npolicy to Texas investors. The notice should describe the statements the Court found false,\n\nmisleading, or deceptive, the facts Glass Lewis failed to disclose, and the right to cancel.\n\n\n\n\n                                                 70\n\f   Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 111-1       Filed 10/26/26     Page 111 of 119\n\n\n\n\n       178.    Website notice. Glass Lewis should post the same notice prominently on its home\n\npage and its voting-policy web pages for at least one year.\n\n       179.    Show the effect of each rule. Some Benchmark recommendations turn on an\n\nenvironmental or social rule. For each one in a Proxy Paper given to a client in Texas, Glass Lewis\n\nshould state what the recommendation would be without that rule. Glass Lewis already does this\n\nfor board diversity. \u00b6 67.\n\n       180.    Automatic votes. For each Texas client that uses pre-populated or automatic\n\nvoting under the Benchmark Policy, Glass Lewis should flag each vote that turns on an\n\nenvironmental or social rule. It should let the client choose whether those votes are cast\n\nautomatically or held for its confirmation.\n\n       181.    Free switching. Glass Lewis should let each Texas client switch to any other Glass\n\nLewis policy, or to its own custom policy, at no added charge.\n\n       182.    New policy descriptions. Glass Lewis should file with the Division a copy of each\n\nnew or revised description of a voting policy offered to people in Texas. It should file each copy\n\nwithin 10 days after publishing the description.\n\n       183.    The injunctions should bind Glass Lewis and its officers, agents, servants,\n\nemployees, and attorneys. They should also bind all persons in active concert or participation with\n\nany of them who receive actual notice of the order. Tex. R. Civ. P. 683. That includes any company\n\nformed through Glass Lewis\u2019s combination with Clarity AI that acts in concert with Glass Lewis\n\nand receives actual notice. \u00b6 195.\n\n       184.    Each term targets the statements and omissions alleged above. \u00b6\u00b6 56\u2013118. None\n\nbars Glass Lewis from making any statement. The terms on claims let Glass Lewis make each claim\n\n\n\n\n                                                   71\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA             Document 111-1           Filed 10/26/26        Page 112 of 119\n\n\n\n\nwith the facts that keep it from misleading, or with evidence that backs it. \u00b6\u00b6 160\u2013170. The\n\nsubstantiation term tracks the FTC\u2019s rule that objective claims represent \u201cthat the advertiser has\n\na reasonable basis supporting these claims.\u201d 331 The federal district court in Fort Worth has ordered\n\na similar disclosure of group memberships. It required a retirement plan\u2019s sponsor to publish its\n\nmanagers\u2019 memberships in any organization \u201cprincipally devoted to achieving DEI, ESG, climate-\n\nfocused investment or stewardship objectives.\u201d 332 The State asks the Clerk to issue writs of\n\ninjunction without bond, because the State is not required to post bond under the DTPA. Tex.\n\nBus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.47(b).\n\n                                        IX.      CIVIL PENALTIES\n\n          185.    The State adopts and incorporates by reference all preceding paragraphs and\n\nallegations of this petition.\n\n          186.    The State may recover a civil penalty of up to $10,000 for each violation of the\n\nDTPA. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.47(c)(1). It may recover up to $250,000 more for each\n\nviolation when the act or practice was calculated to acquire or deprive money or other property\n\nfrom a consumer 65 or older. Id. \u00a7 17.47(c)(2). Glass Lewis\u2019s acts and practices were so calculated.\n\n\u00b6 129.\n\n          187.    The State need not allege injury to recover civil penalties under the DTPA. The\n\nThirteenth Court of Appeals in Corpus Christi said so in Holzman v. State, a suit over discarded\n\n\n\n\n331\n      FTC Policy Statement Regarding Advertising Substantiation, appended to Thompson Med. Co., 104 F.T.C. 648,\n      839 (1984), aff\u2019d, 791 F.2d 189 (D.C. Cir. 1986).\n332\n      Spence v. Am. Airlines, Inc., No. 4:23-cv-00552-O, 2025 WL 3537280, at *2 (N.D. Tex. Sept. 30, 2025) (final\n      judgment).\n\n\n                                                        72\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                  Document 111-1              Filed 10/26/26           Page 113 of 119\n\n\n\n\npatient files. 333 A federal magistrate judge in Houston, relying on Holzman, reached the same\n\nconclusion and added that the State need not allege consumer status. 334\n\n          188.      Each false, misleading, or deceptive statement Glass Lewis made to a person in\n\nTexas, and each failure to disclose, is a separate violation. \u00b6 138. In setting the amount of penalties,\n\nthe trier of fact must consider the following factors. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.47(g).\n\n               (1) The seriousness of the violation, including the nature, circumstances, extent, and\n                   gravity of any prohibited act or practice;\n\n               (2) The history of previous violations;\n\n               (3) The amount necessary to deter future violations;\n\n               (4) The economic effect on the person against whom the penalty is to be assessed;\n\n               (5) Knowledge of the illegality of the act or practice; and\n\n               (6) Any other matter that justice may require.\n\nA.        The violations are serious.\n\n          189.      Nature. Glass Lewis misrepresented the core features of its product, namely whose\n\nviews it reflects, what standard it meets, and what goal it serves. \u00b6\u00b6 56\u2013110.\n\n          190.      Circumstances. Glass Lewis made these statements to fiduciaries who manage the\n\nsavings of millions of people and who must vote for those people\u2019s financial benefit. \u00b6 38.\n\n          191.      Extent. Glass Lewis made these statements for a decade, from at least 2016 to\n\ntoday. It made them on its website, in its guidelines, compliance statements, and survey reports,\n\nand in letters it posted online. It made them to all of its clients and to everyone who visited its\n\nwebsite. \u00b6\u00b6 58\u201363, 94\u201396, 106, 134\u2013137.\n\n\n333\n      Holzman v. State, No. 13-11-00168-CV, 2013 WL 398935, at *3 (Tex. App.\u2014Corpus Christi Jan. 31, 2013, pet.\n      denied) (mem. op.) (\u201c[I]t is not necessary for the State to allege any injury to a patient to recover the civil penalties\n      it seeks in its live petition.\u201d (citing Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.47(c))).\n334\n      Colony Ridge, 2024 WL 4553111, at *7\u20138 & n.4.\n\n\n                                                              73\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA              Document 111-1    Filed 10/26/26       Page 114 of 119\n\n\n\n\n          192.     Gravity. Glass Lewis is one of two firms that dominate its industry, and some\n\ninvestors follow its recommendations automatically. Its statements shaped votes at public\n\ncompanies, including Texas companies. \u00b6\u00b6 42\u201346.\n\nB.        Glass Lewis has faced repeated government action over similar conduct.\n\n          193.     In 2023, the attorneys general of Texas and 20 other States wrote to Glass Lewis\n\nabout its conduct. In 2025, Texas investigated it, Missouri went to court to enforce its investigative\n\ndemands, Florida sued it, and the President directed federal agencies to examine proxy advisors.\n\n\u00b6\u00b6 120\u2013127. Glass Lewis kept making the statements alleged above after each of them. \u00b6 122.\n\nC.        Only a substantial penalty will deter future violations.\n\n          194.     A small penalty would be a cost of doing business. Glass Lewis kept making its\n\nstatements after the 2023 letter, after Texas\u2019s investigation, after Florida\u2019s suit, and after this suit\n\nwas filed. \u00b6 122. It now plans new voting offerings for 2027. \u00b6 85. A substantial penalty will help\n\nensure that it describes them truthfully.\n\nD.        Glass Lewis can pay a substantial penalty.\n\n          195.     Glass Lewis is a large, sophisticated company. It serves more than 1,300 investors\n\nand more than 2,300 companies, and 95% of its institutional clients renew each year. \u00b6\u00b6 12, 47.\n\nGlass Lewis is privately owned. In 2021, Peloton Capital Management and Stephen Smith bought\n\nit from the Ontario Teachers\u2019 Pension Plan Board and the Alberta Investment Management\n\nCorporation. 335 Glass Lewis does not publish its revenue or its value, and the price of the 2021 sale\n\nwas not disclosed. For comparison, in 2021 Deutsche B\u00f6rse bought an 81% stake in Glass Lewis\u2019s\n\n\n\n\n335\n      Press Release, Peloton Capital Mgmt., supra.\n\n\n                                                     74\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA              Document 111-1            Filed 10/26/26         Page 115 of 119\n\n\n\n\nmain rival, ISS, for about $1.8 billion. 336 In September 2026, Glass Lewis combined with another\n\ncompany, Clarity AI. The combined company has \u201cmore than 900 professionals\u201d in 20 offices\n\naround the world. 337\n\nE.        Glass Lewis knew its conduct was unlawful.\n\n          196.     In January 2023, the attorneys general of Texas and 20 other States told Glass Lewis\n\nthat state laws prohibit deceptive trade practices. They also said it appeared to have relied on false\n\nor misleading statements. \u00b6 120. Glass Lewis went forward anyway. It kept making the same\n\nstatements through 2023, 2024, 2025, and 2026, even after Texas opened its investigation and\n\nFlorida sued. \u00b6 122.\n\nF.        Justice requires a substantial penalty.\n\n          197.     Glass Lewis\u2019s statements affected Texas consumers. Texas clients bought,\n\nrenewed, and received Benchmark services that Glass Lewis had misdescribed, and they voted\n\nTexans\u2019 savings on that advice. \u00b6\u00b6 128\u2013133. Glass Lewis profited from Texas while doing so. \u00b6\u00b6\n\n12\u201313.\n\n          198.     Glass Lewis\u2019s statements also reached Texans who never dealt with Glass Lewis\n\ndirectly, through the investment firms, funds, and voting-choice programs that use its policies. \u00b6\u00b6\n\n134\u2013135. And they harm the shareholder vote itself. Shareholders hold companies accountable\n\nthrough their votes, and advice that misdescribes itself distorts those votes.\n\n\n\n336\n      Canadian Pension Fund Managers Selling Proxy Advisor Glass Lewis, Globe & Mail (Mar. 15, 2021) (with a report\n      from Reuters), https://www.theglobeandmail.com/business/article-canadian-pension-fund-managers-selling-\n      proxy-advisor-glass-lewis-to/ (last visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n337\n      Press Release, Glass Lewis, Glass Lewis and Clarity AI Join Forces to Integrate Sustainability, Governance, and\n      Stewardship (Sept. 24, 2026), https://www.glasslewis.com/news-release/glass-lewis-and-clarity-ai-join-forces-\n      to-integrate-sustainability-governance-and-stewardship (last visited Oct. 18, 2026); Glass Lewis and Clarity AI\n      Merge, NordSIP (Sept. 25, 2026), https://nordsip.com/2026/09/25/glass-lewis-and-clarity-ai-merge/ (last\n      visited Oct. 18, 2026).\n\n\n                                                          75\n\f   Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 111-1         Filed 10/26/26      Page 116 of 119\n\n\n\n\n       199.    The State asks the trier of fact to assess civil penalties of up to $10,000 for each\n\nviolation, and up to $250,000 more for each violation under section 17.47(c)(2).\n\n                            X.      DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL\n\n       200.    The State demands a jury trial and tenders the jury fee. Tex. R. Civ. P. 216.\n\n                                   XI.     RELIEF SOUGHT\n\n       201.    The relief the State seeks is within the jurisdictional limits of this Court. Tex. R.\n\nCiv. P. 47(b). The State seeks monetary relief over $1,000,000, including civil penalties,\n\nreasonable attorney\u2019s fees, and court costs, and nonmonetary relief, including injunctive relief.\n\nTex. R. Civ. P. 47(c)(4).\n\n                                         XII.   PRAYER\n\n       The State asks the Court to grant the following relief:\n\n       a.      Set a hearing on the State\u2019s application for a temporary injunction;\n\n       b.      After notice and hearing, temporarily enjoin Glass Lewis, pending trial, as\n               requested in paragraphs 160\u2013170, except paragraphs 167 and 169;\n\n       c.      Enter a final judgment finding that Glass Lewis violated sections 17.46(a) and\n               17.46(b)(5), (7), (9), and (24) of the DTPA;\n\n       d.      Permanently enjoin Glass Lewis for 10 years, including by the terms requested in\n               paragraphs 160\u2013183, Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.47(a);\n\n       e.      Issue the temporary and permanent injunctions without bond, Tex. Bus. & Com.\n               Code \u00a7 17.47(b);\n\n       f.      Order Glass Lewis to pay civil penalties of up to $10,000 for each violation of the\n               DTPA, Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.47(c)(1);\n\n       g.      Order Glass Lewis to pay an additional amount of up to $250,000 for each violation\n               where its acts and practices were calculated to acquire or deprive money or other\n               property from consumers 65 or older, Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.47(c)(2);\n\n\n\n\n                                                76\n\fCase 1:25-cv-01153-ADA        Document 111-1          Filed 10/26/26   Page 117 of 119\n\n\n\n\n   h.    Order Glass Lewis to pay the State\u2019s reasonable attorney\u2019s fees and court costs,\n         Tex. Gov\u2019t Code \u00a7 402.006(c);\n\n   i.    Award pre- and post-judgment interest as allowed by law; and\n\n   j.    Award the State all other relief to which it is entitled.\n\n\n\n                                         Respectfully submitted,\n\n                                         KEN PAXTON\n                                         Attorney General of Texas\n\n                                         BRENT WEBSTER\n                                         First Assistant Attorney General\n\n                                         RALPH MOLINA\n                                         Deputy First Assistant Attorney General\n\n                                         WILLIAM D. WASSDORF\n                                         Deputy Attorney General for Civil Litigation\n\n                                         /s/ Johnathan Stone\n                                         JOHNATHAN STONE\n                                         Chief, Consumer Protection Division\n                                         State Bar No. 24071779\n\n                                         LAUREN MCGEE\n                                         Assistant Attorney General\n                                         State Bar No. 24128835\n\n                                         Office of the Attorney General of Texas\n                                         Consumer Protection Division\n                                         P.O. Box 12548, MC-010\n                                         Austin, Texas 78711-2548\n                                         Telephone: (512) 463-2185\n                                         Facsimile: (512) 473-8301\n                                         Johnathan.stone@oag.texas.gov\n                                         Lauren.Mcgee@oag.texas.gov\n\n                                         ATTORNEYS FOR TEXAS\n\n\n\n\n                                            77\n\f   Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA         Document 111-1        Filed 10/26/26     Page 118 of 119\n\n\n\n\n                               CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\n       I certify that on October 20, 2026, a true and correct copy of this document was served on\n\nall counsel of record through the electronic filing manager under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure\n\n21a.\n\n\n\n                                            /s/ Johnathan Stone\n                                            JOHNATHAN STONE\n                                            Chief, Consumer Protection Division\n                                            State Bar No. 24071779\n\n\n\n\n                                               78\n\f   Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA             Document 111-1          Filed 10/26/26       Page 119 of 119\n\n\n\n\n                            DECLARATION OF AARON AGUILAR\n\n        Pursuant to Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code \u00a7 132.001(f), I, Aaron Aguilar, submit this\n\n0).2*-)\u0003 \u001f \u001e'\u001c-\u001c/$*)\u0003 $)\u0003 '$ 0\u0003 *!\u0003 \u001c\u0003 2-$// )\u0003 .2*-)\u0003 \u001f \u001e'\u001c-\u001c/$*)6\u0003 1 -$\u0080\u001e\u001c/$*)6\u0003 \u001e -/$\u0080\u001e\u001c/$*)6\u0003 *\u001c/#6\u0003 *-\u0003\n\n\u001c\u0084\u001f\u001c1$/7\u0003\n\n\n        1. My name is Aaron Aguilar. I am over 18 years of age, of sound mind, and capable of\n           making this declaration.\n\n\n        2. The facts stated within this declaration are within my personal knowledge and are true\n           and correct.\n\n\n        3.    \u00032*-&\u0003\u001c.\u0003\u001c)\u0003$)1 ./$\"\u001c/*-\u0003$)\u0003/# \u0003\u0010\u0084\u001e \u0003*!\u0003/# \u0003\u0015 3\u001c.\u0003\u0289//*-) 4\u0003\b ) -\u001c'7\u0003 )\u0003(4\u0003\u001e\u001c+\u001c\u001e$/4\u0003\u001c.\u0003\n             an investigator, I have read the foregoing document titled \u201cTexas\u2019s Second Amended\n             \u0017 -$\u0080 \u001f\u0003\u0011 /$/$*)\u0003\u001c)\u001f\u0003\u0289++'$\u001e\u001c/$*)\u0003!*-\u0003\u0015 (+*-\u001c-4\u0003\u001c)\u001f\u0003\u0011 -(\u001c) )/\u0003 )%0)\u001e/$*)E\u0003\u001c)\u001f\u0003/# \u0003\n             factual allegations stated therein are true and correct. Some allegations are stated on\n             information and belief, and some describe what Glass Lewis knew or intended. Those\n             allegations are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information, and belief,\n             based on the sources the petition cites.\n\n\n        4. My name is Aaron Aguilar, and I am an employee of the following governmental agency:\n           \u0015 3\u001c.\u0003 \u0010\u0084\u001e \u0003 *!\u0003 /# \u0003 \u0289//*-) 4\u0003 \b ) -\u001c'7\u0003 \u0003 \u001c(\u0003 3 \u001e0/$)\"\u0003 /#$.\u0003 \u001f \u001e'\u001c-\u001c/$*)\u0003 \u001c.\u0003 +\u001c-/\u0003 *!\u0003 (4\u0003\n           assigned duties and responsibilities. I declare under penalty of perjury that the factual\n           statements in the foregoing are true and correct.\n\n\nExecuted in Dallas County, State of Texas, on the 20th day of October 2026.\n\n\n                                                 /s/ Aaron Aguilar\n                                                 Aaron Aguilar\n                                                 Investigator\n\n\n\n\n                                                    79\n\f","ocr_status":1,"date_upload":"2026-10-27T08:14:09.174230-07:00","document_number":"111","attachment_number":1,"pacer_doc_id":"181037687572","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"DECLARATION OF JOE NWAOKORO WITH EXHIBITS","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/498771589/","id":498771589,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/111/2/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-27T08:13:40.561961-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-27T08:13:40.561985-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":2,"file_size":140048,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"111","attachment_number":2,"pacer_doc_id":"181037687573","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Proposed Order","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-26T18:03:50.883365-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-26T18:03:50.890293-07:00","date_filed":"2026-10-26","time_filed":"19:19:24","entry_number":111,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-10-26.001","pacer_sequence_number":418,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/482903665/","id":482903665,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/498699561/","id":498699561,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/112/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-26T18:03:45.066751-07:00","date_modified":"2026-11-03T03:32:25.342158-08:00","sha1":"00125d4ec562f1a9e3a6ebefc29d20d751a6a96e","page_count":12,"file_size":224460,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.112.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.112.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 112     Filed 10/26/26    Page 1 of 12\n\n\n\n                           UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                            WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS\n                                 AUSTIN DIVISION\n\nGLASS, LEWIS & CO., LLC,                      )\n                                              )\n              Plaintiff,                      )\n                                              )\n       v.                                     )\n                                              )\nKEN PAXTON, in his Official Capacity as       )\nAttorney General of Texas,                    )\n                                              )       Civil Action No. 25-cv-01153-ADA\n              Defendant;                      )\n                                              )\nTHE TEXAS STOCK EXCHANGE and                  )\nTHE TEXAS ASSOCIATION OF                      )\nBUSINESS,                                     )\n                                              )\n              Intervenor-Defendants.          )\n                                              )\n\n   INTERVENOR-DEFENDANTS\u2019 RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF\n       GLASS LEWIS\u2019S MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY RESPONSES\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA             Document 112         Filed 10/26/26       Page 2 of 12\n\n\n\n        Intervenor-Defendants the Texas Stock Exchange (\u201cTXSE\u201d) and the Texas Association of\n\nBusiness (\u201cTAB\u201d) (together, \u201cIntervenors\u201d) oppose Plaintiff Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC\u2019s (\u201cGlass\n\nLewis\u201d) Motion to Compel Discovery Responses, Dkt. 109 (the \u201cMotion\u201d). Through its Motion, Glass Lewis\n\nseeks to eviscerate the well-established First Amendment associational privilege to force TAB to reveal\n\nthe identities of its members and seeks discovery into issues that have no relation to SB 2337\u2019s\n\nconstitutionality. This stands in stark contrast to Glass Lewis\u2019s prior representations to the Court that\n\n\u201c[f]urther discovery is not needed\u201d when it opposed Defendants\u2019 request for additional time to\n\ncomplete discovery into Glass Lewis\u2019s practices pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 56(d). Yet now, a day\n\nbefore the end of fact discovery, Glass Lewis filed a motion that says the opposite.\n\n        As explained below, TAB meets its initial \u201clight\u201d burden to gain the protections of the\n\nassociational privilege because disclosure of its members and their association-related activities may\n\nhave a chilling effect on the freedom to associate given Glass Lewis\u2019s dominant market power, its\n\ninfluence on investor voting, and the subjective nature of its recommendations along with its\n\ndemonstrated bias. And Glass Lewis has not explained (and cannot show) why it needs this\n\ninformation or why it is relevant to the claims or defenses, which focus on the constitutionality of SB\n\n2337. The information it seeks has no bearing on SB 2337\u2019s constitutionality. Indeed, with the law\n\nfirmly against Glass Lewis, there is only one possible explanation for motivation here. It seeks\n\nretribution against those companies that have dared to stand up to the proxy advisory duopoly by\n\nsupporting a law that commands transparency to benefit the everyday investors who are ultimately\n\nimpacted by Glass Lewis\u2019s proxy advisory services. This motive is improper, and the Motion should\n\nbe denied.\n\n                                          BACKGROUND\n\n        Over the past 13 months, Intervenors have responded to numerous discovery requests from\n\nGlass Lewis and objected to some where appropriate. Yet in the Motion, Glass Lewis falsely suggests\n\f       Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 112         Filed 10/26/26       Page 3 of 12\n\n\n\nthat Intervenors ignored nearly all of Glass Lewis\u2019s discovery requests, writing that \u201cIntervenors have\n\nproduced zero documents in response to 25 requests\u201d and accusing Defendants of \u201cwholesale refusal\n\nto participate in written discovery.\u201d Motion at 1; see also Dkt. 109-1 \u00b6 6 (counsel declaration stating,\n\n\u201cTAB and TXSE produced zero documents in response to Glass Lewis\u2019 twenty-five requests for\n\nproduction.\u201d). Contrary to these false statements, Intervenors produced over 4,000 pages of materials\n\nin this case and substantively responded to 52 of Glass Lewis\u2019s requests for production and responded\n\nto 29 of its interrogatories.\n\n        Indeed, Intervenors responded to Glass Lewis\u2019s first set of written discovery requests on\n\nOctober 31, 2025.        Those requests included (a) 28 requests for production (\u201cRFP\u201d) and 15\n\ninterrogatories (\u201cROG\u201d) to TXSE and (b) 27 RFPs and 13 ROGs to TAB. TXSE substantively\n\nresponded to all but one RFP, stating that it (1) would search for and produce any responsive\n\ndocuments it had, (2) had no responsive documents, or (3) expected such documents to be within\n\nGlass Lewis\u2019s possession, since this case is about a law that regulates the conduct of Glass Lewis and\n\nother proxy advisors like it. See Rasmussen Declaration (\u201cRasmussen Decl.\u201d) at Ex. 1. TXSE objected\n\nto 1 RFP as irrelevant to SB 2337\u2019s constitutionality. TXSE also substantively responded to all\n\ninterrogatories. See id. at Ex. 2.\n\n        For its part, TAB substantively responded to 20 RFPs, stating that it (1) would search for and\n\nproduce any responsive documents it had (some of which were already included in pleadings, which\n\nTAB identified), (2) had no responsive documents, or (3) expected such documents to be within Glass\n\nLewis\u2019s possession as opposed to its own. See id. at Ex. 3. TAB stood on its objections for the\n\nremaining 7 RFPs, which sought disclosure of TAB\u2019s members or other information not relevant to\n\nSB 2337\u2019s constitutionality. 1 Id. TAB also substantively responded to 9 interrogatories. TAB objected\n\n\n        1\n          This includes requests for information that plainly have no bearing on the issues in this case,\nincluding documents regarding the resignation of TAB\u2019s prior President and CEO, an unrelated\nlawsuit in which TAB is a defendant, and TAB political donations.\n\n\n                                                   2\n\f       Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA             Document 112          Filed 10/26/26       Page 4 of 12\n\n\n\nto the remainder because three sought member identities and one had no bearing on SB 2337\u2019s\n\nconstitutionality. Id. at Ex. 4.\n\n        Nearly a year later, and ten months after moving for summary judgment, Glass Lewis served\n\nits second set of written discovery requests on September 18, 2026, including an additional (a) 11 RFPs\n\nand 7 ROGs to TXSE and (b) 14 RFPs and 7 ROGs to TAB. TXSE substantively responded to 4\n\nRFPs and objected to the others either as duplicative of prior requests or because they have no bearing\n\non the issues related to Glass Lewis\u2019s motion for summary judgment, such as requests concerning\n\nTXSE\u2019s intervention or its political donations. 2 Id. at Ex. 5. TXSE also substantively responded to 4\n\nROGs and objected to 3 others as duplicative of prior requests or irrelevant to this case. Id. at Ex. 6.\n\n        TAB substantively responded to 1 RFP, objected to five others as duplicative of prior requests,\n\nand objected to the remaining requests that either sought member information or information with\n\nno bearing on SB 2337\u2019s constitutionality, such as the resignation of TAB\u2019s prior President and CEO,\n\na lawsuit in which TAB is a defendant, and TAB political donations. Id. at Ex. 7. TAB also\n\nsubstantively responded to one interrogatory and objected to the remainder as either privileged,\n\nirrelevant to SB 2337\u2019s constitutionality, or outside of its possession. Id. at Ex. 8.\n\n        On October 15, 2026, Glass Lewis asked to meet and confer regarding Intervenors\u2019 discovery\n\nresponses and objections. See id. at Ex. 9. Yet Glass Lewis did not identify any specific discovery\n\nrequests it wanted to discuss and only identified a single objection Intervenors had made\u2014the\n\nassociational privilege objection. Intervenors\u2019 counsel offered availability for a meet and confer call\n\nwhile also asking Glass Lewis to identify specific issues to discuss, including the basis for its privilege\n\nchallenge. Glass Lewis instead responded on October 16 by asking for Intervenors to \u201cconfirm by\n\n\n\n        2\n         TXSE inadvertently omitted two RFP responses from its initially-served responses. Glass\nLewis never raised this before filing the Motion. Upon learning this when reviewing the Motion,\nIntervenors promptly supplemented their responses on October 19, 2026, which was within the\npermitted time to respond to Glass Lewis\u2019s second set of written discovery requests. Id. at Ex. 10.\n\n\n                                                     3\n\f       Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 112         Filed 10/26/26       Page 5 of 12\n\n\n\n5:00 pm today, October 16, whether you will substantively answer our interrogatories and produce\n\nresponsive documents to our RFPs.\u201d Id. After Intervenors\u2019 counsel responded and again offered a\n\ntime to meet and confer, Glass Lewis sent an email declaring an impasse.\n\n        Even now, the only specific issue that Glass Lewis raises with respect to Intervenors is the\n\nassociational privilege objection. It does not list a single specific discovery response that is deficient\n\nand rests instead on broad accusations aimed at \u201cDefendants\u201d collectively.\n\n                                            ARGUMENT\n\n        The Motion should be denied. First, Glass Lewis seeks the identities of Intervenors\u2019 members\n\nand information on their support for intervention here (RFPs 35-38 & Interrogatories 14-15). This\n\ninformation is shielded from disclosure by the First Amendment\u2019s associational privilege. Second,\n\nGlass Lewis has waived any argument it may have by failing to timely raise their concerns despite\n\nknowing the nature of Intervenors\u2019 objections for nearly a year.\n\nI.      The First Amendment Protects Against Disclosure of TAB\u2019s Membership Lists, Which\n        Are Irrelevant to the Claims and Defenses in This Litigation.\n\n        Glass Lewis seeks detailed information about TAB\u2019s members and association-related\n\nactivities, including their identities and support for intervention (RFP 35 & ROGs 14 & 15), and\n\ncontributions to TAB (RFB 36). The First Amendment shields TAB\u2019s members from these discovery\n\nrequests. 3\n\n        A.      The Relevant Standard Favors Upholding the Privilege.\n\n        The First Amendment secures a \u201cright to associate with others,\u201d including the right to do so\n\n\n\n        3\n           Glass Lewis did not identify specific discovery responses from Intervenors with which it\ntakes issue beyond the associational privilege. Thus, there are no other disputes before the Court.\nNevertheless, to the extent that Glass Lewis is moving to compel Intervenors to respond to any of\nthe irrelevant requests that Glass Lewis made, then that request should be denied. Rule 26(b)(1)\ncommands that discovery \u201cnot only be relevant but also proportional to the needs of the case.\u201d Lopez\nv. State Farm Lloyds, 348 F.R.D. 419, 428 (W.D. Tex. 2025). Glass Lewis\u2019s requests on irrelevant topics\nare neither. Indeed, Glass Lewis\u2019s inquiries into a workplace human resources lawsuit, political\ndonations, and TAB\u2019s own internal policies are far afield of the issues in this case.\n\n\n                                                    4\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA             Document 112         Filed 10/26/26       Page 6 of 12\n\n\n\nprivately. Americans for Prosperity Foundation v. Bonta, 594 U.S. 595, 606-07 (2021). Accordingly, the\n\nSupreme Court has recognized an associational privilege that protects against the compelled disclosure\n\nof one\u2019s affiliation with advocacy groups when such disclosure would disturb the \u201cvital relationship\n\nbetween freedom to associate and privacy in one\u2019s associations\u201d and risk a \u201cchilling effect.\u201d Id. The\n\nprivilege applies to \u201cdiscovery orders even if all the litigants are private entities.\u201d Heartland Surgical\n\nSpecialty Hosp., LLC v. Midwest Div., Inc., 2007 WL 852521, at *3 (D. Kan. Mar. 16, 2007).\n\n        Courts in the Fifth Circuit employ a balancing test to evaluate the privilege. Hastings v. N.E.\n\nIndep. Sch. Dist., 615 F.2d 628, 631-32 (5th Cir. 1980). Thereunder, a party must first demonstrate a\n\nreasonable probability that disclosure may expose its \u201cmembers to economic reprisal, loss of\n\nemployment, threat of physical coercion, [or] other manifestations of public hostility.\u201d Id. at 631. The\n\nburden then shifts to the party seeking discovery to show \u201ca compelling justification\u201d to intrude upon\n\nthe First Amendment right. ACLU v. Martinez-Rivera, 2015 WL 13650010, at *3 (W.D. Tex. Sept. 10,\n\n2015). In applying this balancing test, courts often consider: \u201c(1) the importance of the information\n\nsought to the interests in the case, (2) the availability of the information from alternative sources, (3)\n\nthe substantiality of the First Amendment interests at stake, and (4) whether the request is carefully\n\ntailored to avoid unnecessary interference with protected activities.\u201d Young Conservatives of Tex.\n\nFoundation v. Univ. of N. Texas, 2022 WL 2901007, at *3 (E.D. Tex. Jan. 11, 2022).\n\n        These factors weigh heavily in favor of upholding the associational privilege here.\n\n        B.      TAB Has Met Its \u201cLight\u201d Burden.\n\n        TAB\u2019s burden is \u201clight\u201d\u2014no \u201cconcrete showing\u201d is required. Id. at *2; accord Bonta, 594 U.S.\n\nat 616 (explaining \u201c[e]xacting scrutiny\u201d applied when action \u201cmay have the effect of curtailing the\n\nfreedom to associate\u201d and may have a \u201cpossible deterrent effect\u201d). TAB easily makes that showing.\n\n        Glass Lewis is part of a duopoly with the other plaintiff in this case\u2014Institutional Shareholder\n\nServices Inc.\u2014that controls 90-97% of the market for proxy advisory services. Glass Lewis makes\n\n\n\n                                                    5\n\f       Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA              Document 112          Filed 10/26/26        Page 7 of 12\n\n\n\nrecommendations over proxy voting matters at Texas companies that carry considerable influence\n\nwith investors in those companies. See Dkt. 22-5 at pgs. 10, 18. The nature of Glass Lewis\u2019s business\n\nmodel and the central question of this case\u2014the constitutionality of a law regulating that business\u2014\n\nmakes Glass Lewis\u2019s bizarre quest for TAB\u2019s member information suspicious. How will Glass Lewis\n\nuse this information when it provides voting recommendations on issues affecting these very\n\ncompanies? Will it, for example, use its power to target members by recommending against board\n\nmembers up for election at TAB member companies on the flimsy notion that supporting SB 2337 is\n\nsupposedly bad governance? Will it use the information to target member companies in making\n\nrecommendations about dubious shareholder proposals that do little, if anything, to promote the\n\ncompany\u2019s value? These are not remote possibilities\u2014Glass Lewis\u2019s recommendations are highly\n\nsubjective and it has already demonstrated arbitrariness and bias in making them 4\u2014and they have\n\ndirect economic impact on the companies that are threatened by Glass Lewis\u2019s demand for\n\nmembership records.\n\n        Indeed, Glass Lewis seeks protected documents containing a roster of TAB\u2019s members and\n\ntheir association-related activities\u2014information that, to date, has not been disclosed. Moreover, if a\n\ncompany believes that there is a risk that their association with TAB will become public, then they\n\nmay be reluctant to associate in the first instance. This creates precisely the chilling effect that the\n\nprivilege is meant to prevent. TAB easily satisfies its burden.\n\n        C.       Glass Lewis Fails to Meet Its Burden.\n\n        The burden shifts to Glass Lewis to demonstrate a \u201ccompelling need\u201d for the discovery. Young\n\nConservatives, 2022 WL 2901007, at *3. A compelling need \u201cgoes to the heart of the claims,\u201d is \u201cdirectly\n\nrelevant,\u201d or is one that is \u201ccrucial to the party\u2019s case.\u201d Int\u2019l Soc\u2019y for Krishna Consciousness, Inc. v. Lee,\n\n\n\n        4\n          See, e.g., Dkt. 72, Ex. A at 2 (Glass Lewis employee Slack messages demonstrating bias and\narbitrary decision-making, filed under seal).\n\n\n                                                      6\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA             Document 112         Filed 10/26/26       Page 8 of 12\n\n\n\n1985 WL 315, at *8 (S.D.N.Y. Feb. 28, 1985) (quotations omitted). This is a \u201cmore demanding\n\nstandard of relevance\u201d than under Rule 26(b)(1). Perry v. Schwarzenneger, 591 F.3d 1147, 1162 (9th Cir.\n\n2010). Glass Lewis cannot carry that burden.\n\n        First, whether SB 2337 is constitutional or not has nothing to do with the identities of TAB\u2019s\n\nmembers. Second, Glass Lewis has repeatedly represented that it needed no further discovery to make\n\nits case. Specifically, Glass Lewis told the Court in December of 2025 that, \u201cFurther discovery is not\n\nneeded to resolve this case,\u201d (Dkt. 74, at p. 1) and doubled-down in January 2026, stating, \u201cFurther\n\ndiscovery is not going to change the Court\u2019s analysis,\u201d (Jan. 22, 2026, Hearing Tr. at 29:5-6). The\n\npurpose of the discovery being taken pursuant to Defendants\u2019 Rule 56(d) motions is to enable\n\nDefendants to rebut Glass Lewis\u2019s arguments about why SB 2337 is unconstitutional and to give\n\nDefendants a view into whether Glass Lewis is making false statements about its proxy advisory\n\nservices that SB 2337 is designed to address. Accordingly, when Judge Albright granted Intervenors\u2019\n\n56(d) motion, he explained that the parties should \u201cmeet and confer about what specific discovery the\n\ndefendant believes it\u2019s entitled to and whether or not plaintiff will \u2026 provide it.\u201d Tr. at 35:16-20\n\n(emphasis added).\n\n        When Glass Lewis insists that \u201cTAB put its members\u2019 harm at issue,\u201d Mot. 8, it badly\n\nmisconstrues both TAB\u2019s role in this case and the issues involved. TAB did not intervene as a plaintiff,\n\nand it does not bring claims against Glass Lewis on behalf of its members or press any member-\n\nspecific arguments. Rather, TAB intervened to \u201cdefend against Plaintiff\u2019s [as-applied] claim,\u201d Doc. 22,\n\nat 17, which asks whether SB 2337 can be constitutionally applied against any of Glass Lewis\u2019s activities.\n\nSee Doc. 69, at 10-15 (explaining why facts about Glass Lewis\u2019s conduct are necessary to resolve as-\n\napplied challenge). Defendants argue that SB 2337\u2019s applications to Glass Lewis are permissible to\n\nremedy Glass Lewis\u2019s false and misleading speech. It is of no consequence whether the misleading\n\nconduct relates to a TAB member or to a Texas public company that is not a TAB member. Contra\n\n\n\n                                                    7\n\f       Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 112          Filed 10/26/26       Page 9 of 12\n\n\n\nMot. 9. Tellingly, neither Intervenors\u2019 response in opposition to Glass Lewis\u2019s preliminary injunction\n\nnor its Rule 56(d) briefing make any reference to the identities of TAB\u2019s members or any arguments based\n\non members\u2019 injuries. And Glass Lewis identifies no such issues or arguments in its motion to compel.\n\n        Instead, Glass Lewis invokes Intervenors\u2019 motion for intervention as the primary hook for\n\nassociational discovery. See, e.g., Mot. 8 (quoting Dkt. 22). But this fails many times over. TAB was\n\nallowed to intervene more than a year ago; Glass Lewis cannot relitigate the issue now and requires\n\nno discovery ex post. And even if discovery into TAB\u2019s allegations at intervention were proper, TAB did\n\nnot claim an injury exclusive to its members but rather that its members are harmed when proxy advisors\n\ndisseminate false and misleading advice about any Texas company because this advice \u201cdegrades\n\nTexas\u2019s business environment\u201d and \u201cimpedes [Intervenors\u2019] efforts to attract companies to Texas.\u201d\n\nDoc. 22, at 1. 5\n\n        This case thus stands in sharp contrast to many of the associational privilege cases Glass Lewis\n\nrelies upon (at Mot. 8-10), which granted narrow discovery into the identities of a plaintiff\u2019s members\n\nonly to the extent the plaintiff placed their identities at issue. For instance, National Organization for\n\nWomen v. Sperry Rand Corp. (NOW), 88 F.R.D. 272 (D. Conn. 1980) allowed limited discovery into a\n\nplaintiff\u2019s membership when the plaintiff brought claims on behalf of \u201ca number of its members \u2026\n\naggrieved by certain practices followed by\u201d the defendant. Id. at 273. 6 The court emphasized that this\n\nturned in large part on the association\u2019s status as a plaintiff; where (as here) the association \u201cis more\n\n\n        5\n          Indeed, when Glass Lewis writes that, \u201cTAB claimed its members were \u2018harmed by false and\nmisleading proxy advice.\u2019\u201d Mot. 9, it truncates the relevant sentence, which explained that, absent SB\n2337\u2019s requirements, \u201cTexas public companies\u201d that happen to include TAB members, \u201cwill continue\nto be harmed by false and misleading proxy advice.\u201d Doc. 22, at 11.\n        6\n          Likewise, ERISA Industry Committee v. Asaro-Angelo, 2023 WL 2808105 (D.N.J. Apr. 6, 2023),\nheld that a plaintiff asserting associational standing would not be harmed by disclosing \u201cthe identity\nof a single, injured member for the purposes [of] supporting [its] standing to bring its claim.\u201d Id. at *7.\nAnd NIACCF, Inc. v. Cold Stone Creamery, Inc., held that a plaintiff\u2019s membership list was disclosable\nwhen plaintiff sought to compel the defendant to disclose certain information to those members. Id.\nat *2.\n\n\n                                                    8\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA             Document 112          Filed 10/26/26          Page 10 of 12\n\n\n\nanalogous to a defendant than to a plaintiff,\u201d associational rights receive their \u201cfullest protection.\u201d Id.\n\nat 275 (quoting Familias Unidas v. Briscoe, 544 F.2d 182, 192 (5th Cir. 1976)) (punctuation omitted).\n\nSimilarly, La Union del Pueblo Entero v. Abbot, 2022 WL 17574079 (W.D. Tex. Dec. 9, 2022) offers no\n\nsupport for Glass Lewis\u2019s position. There, the Court was dealing with communications between an\n\nassociation and unrelated third-parties. Yet it explicitly pointed to member lists and participation in\n\nassociation activities as information covered by the privilege. See id. at *6, 8, 9.\n\nII.     Glass Lewis Has Waived its Argument as to Associational Privilege.\n\n        Glass Lewis waived its argument against TAB\u2019s assertion of associational privilege by failing\n\nto raise it for approximately a year. The Motion addresses requests that Glass Lewis made in its first\n\nset of written discovery requests. Yet Intervenors served their responses and objections to Glass\n\nLewis\u2019s first set of written discovery requests on October 31, 2025, wherein TAB explicitly asserted\n\nthe First Amendment associational privilege. Glass Lewis never engaged with that objection and never\n\nraised it through a prior motion.\n\n        Accordingly, it has waived any argument challenging the associational privilege claim by failing\n\nto raise it for nearly a year after TAB first asserted it and after it already filed for summary judgment\n\n(telling this Court it needed nothing more). See, e.g., Tim W. Koerner & Assocs., Inc. v. Aspen Labs, Inc.,\n\n492 F. Supp. 294 (S.D. Tex. 1980), aff'd sub nom. Koerner & Assoc. v. Aspen Labs, 683 F.2d 416 (5th Cir.\n\n1982) (denying plaintiff\u2019s motion to compel and noting that \u201cPlaintiff has been inexcusably dilatory in\n\nits efforts to pursue an order to compel discovery\u201d when it \u201cfiled [its discovery motion] nine months\n\nafter [Defendant\u2019s] responses to Plaintiff\u2019s third request for production of documents and almost two\n\nmonths after Defendants\u2019 motion for summary judgment.\u201d). Glass Lewis\u2019s conduct here is even more\n\ninexcusable than in Koerner given that Glass Lewis itself moved for summary judgment.\n\n                                                CONCLUSION\n\n        For the foregoing reasons, the Court should deny Glass Lewis\u2019s Motion.\n\n\n\n                                                     9\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA   Document 112      Filed 10/26/26       Page 11 of 12\n\n\n\nDated: October 26, 2026                Respectfully submitted,\n\n\n\n                                       By: /s/ Mark W. Rasmussen\n                                            Mark W. Rasmussen\n                                            Attorney-in-charge\n                                            Texas State Bar No. 24086291\n                                            Sidney Smith McClung\n                                            Texas State Bar No. 24083880\n                                            Timothy M. Villari\n                                            Texas State Bar No. 24125870\n                                            JONES DAY\n                                            2727 N. Harwood St., Suite 500\n                                            Dallas, Texas 75201\n                                            mrasmussen@jonesday.com\n                                            smcclung@jonesday.com\n                                            tvillari@jonesday.com\n                                            Telephone: +1.214.220.3939\n                                            Facsimile: +1.214.969.5100\n\n                                             Noel J. Francisco (admitted pro hac vice)\n                                             D.C. Bar No. 464752\n                                             Brinton Lucas (admitted pro hac vice)\n                                             D.C. Bar No. 1015185\n                                             JONES DAY\n                                             51 Louisiana Avenue, N.W.\n                                             Washington, D.C. 20001-2113\n                                             njfrancisco@jonesday.com\n                                             blucas@jonesday.com\n                                             Telephone: +1.202.879.3939\n                                             Facsimile: +1.602.626.1700\n\n                                             Attorneys for Intervenors the Texas Stock\n                                             Exchange and the Texas Association of Business\n\n\n\n\n                                     10\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 112         Filed 10/26/26      Page 12 of 12\n\n\n\n                                  CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\n\n         I certify that on October 26, 2026, I caused a copy of the foregoing document to be served by\n\nthe Electronic Case Filing System for the United States District Court for the Western District of\n\nTexas.\n\n\n                                               /s/ Mark W. Rasmussen\n                                               Mark W. Rasmussen\n\n\n\n\n                                                  11\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2026-10-27T08:15:57.249037-07:00","document_number":"112","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"181037687715","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Response in Opposition to Motion","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-26T18:03:45.036656-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-26T18:03:45.044528-07:00","date_filed":"2026-10-26","time_filed":"19:55:31","entry_number":112,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-10-26.001","pacer_sequence_number":421,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/482406126/","id":482406126,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/498179533/","id":498179533,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/110/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-21T16:17:07.757881-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-26T14:58:17.296730-07:00","sha1":"1645ec28677d95d5444c8bb2a026b0b95d575168","page_count":7,"file_size":274302,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.110.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.110.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA         Document 110      Filed 10/21/26     Page 1 of 7\n\n\n\n\n                     IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                      FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS\n                               AUSTIN DIVISION\nGLASS, LEWIS & CO., LLC                  \u00a7\n     Plaintiff,                          \u00a7\n                                         \u00a7\n v.                                      \u00a7\n                                         \u00a7\n KEN PAXTON, in his Official Capacity as \u00a7\n                                                  Civil Action No.\n Attorney General of Texas               \u00a7\n                                                1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n        Defendant,                       \u00a7\n                                         \u00a7\n THE TEXAS STOCK EXCHANGE LLC            \u00a7\n and THE TEXAS ASSOCIATION OF            \u00a7\n BUSINESS,                               \u00a7\n        Intervenor-Defendants.           \u00a7\n______________________________________________________________________________\n\n   DEFENDANT\u2019S REPLY IN SUPPORT OF OPPOSED EXPEDITED MOTION FOR\n            PROTECTIVE ORDER AND TO STAY RULE 30(b)(6) DEPOSITION\n______________________________________________________________________________\n\nKEN PAXTON                                     KIMBERLY GDULA\nAttorney General of Texas                      Chief, General Litigation Division\n\nBRENT WEBSTER                                  JOE NWAOKORO\nFirst Assistant Attorney General               Attorney-in-Charge\n                                               Texas Bar No. 24032916\nRALPH MOLINA                                   Assistant Attorney General\nDeputy First Assistant Attorney General        P.O. Box 12548, Capitol Station\n                                               Austin, Texas 78711-2548\nWILLIAM D. WASSDORF                            (512) 979-5382 | FAX: (512) 320-0667\nDeputy Attorney General for Civil Litigation   Joe.Nwaokoro@oag.texas.gov\n\n\n DEFENDANT KEN PAXTON, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS ATTORNEY GENERAL\n                              OF TEXAS\n\f       Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 110         Filed 10/21/26      Page 2 of 7\n\n\n\n\n       Defendant, Ken Paxton, in his official capacity as Attorney General of Texas (\u201cDefendant\u201d\n\nor \u201cAttorney General\u201d), files this Reply to Plaintiff\u2019s Response (Dkt. 107) in support of his Motion\n\n(Dkt. 101), with the Declaration of Joe Nwaokoro (Ex. A, \u201cReply Decl.\u201d).\n\n                                        INTRODUCTION\n\n       Plaintiff has repeatedly told this Court that it \u201ccan decide this case based on the plain terms\n\nof the Act,\u201d Dkt. 54 at 4, and that whether S.B. 2337 is constitutional \u201cturn[s] on the law\u2019s text\n\nand operation,\u201d id. at 1. It stated in its motion for summary judgment that, \u201cThe following analysis\n\nturns on the statutory text and legislative history of the Act, with few material facts required. As\n\nto those few facts, there is no genuine dispute.\u201d Dkt. 60 at 1. And it stated in its response to\n\nDefendant and Intervenor-Defendant\u2019s Rule 56(d) motion that \u201c[t]he requested discovery is\n\nimmaterial,\u201d Dkt. 74 at 2, and \u201c[f]urther discovery is not needed to resolve the case.\u201d Id. at 1. Yet\n\nit seeks discovery inconsistent with those positions. In this official-capacity challenge to the Act,\n\nPlaintiff probes the Attorney General\u2019s personal and political capacity, including his campaign\n\nfunds, and seeks to use this case as a vehicle for discovery in the State\u2019s DTPA action in Collin\n\nCounty (the \u201cState DTPA Action\u201d), Dkt. 101-1 (\u201cNwaokoro Decl.\u201d) \u00b6 2, where the court ordered\n\njurisdictional discovery of Glass Lewis and, as Plaintiff itself represents, \u201cmerits discovery \u2018is not\n\nopen\u2019 and would effectively be stayed pending disposition of Glass Lewis\u2019 special appearance.\u201d\n\nDkt. 109-1 \u00b6 7; Reply Decl. \u00b6 5 & Ex. D. Plaintiff seeks to circumvent that order by demanding\n\nDefendant\u2019s investigative file, deliberations, coordination, and motive in enforcing a different law\n\nin that separate suit. The Motion should be granted.\n\n                                           ARGUMENT\n\nI.     Rule 26(c) authorizes topic-specific relief.\n\n\n\n\n                                                  1\n\f       Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 110        Filed 10/21/26       Page 3 of 7\n\n\n\n\n       Plaintiff invokes the \u201cextraordinary circumstances\u201d standard for \u201cprohibit[ing] the taking\n\nof a deposition altogether.\u201d Dkt. 107 at 3 (citing Salter v. Upjohn Co., 593 F.2d 649 (5th Cir.\n\n1979)). But Defendant\u2019s Motion asks the Court to bar inquiry into specific, identified topics, and\n\nlimit Topic 6 to authentication. Dkt. 101 at 10. He will designate a witness on any topic the Court\n\npermits. Rule 26(c)(1)(D) authorizes \u201cforbidding inquiry into certain matters,\u201d and Rule\n\n26(b)(2)(C)(iii) requires the Court to limit discovery \u201coutside the scope permitted by Rule\n\n26(b)(1).\u201d Salter concerned barring a deponent with relevant information, not irrelevant and\n\nprivileged inquiry.\n\nII.    Topics 4, 5, 6, and 8 seek the Attorney General\u2019s file, deliberations, coordination, and\n       motive, which are irrelevant to the as-applied question.\n\n       Discovery must relate to a claim or defense. Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(1). Plaintiff fails to\n\nidentify any count in its Second Amended Complaint for which motive is an element; its \u201cpretext\u201d\n\ntheory is an unpleaded retaliation claim. Dkt. 107 at 5. Defendant\u2019s Motion addressed the pretext\n\ntheory with United States v. O\u2019Brien, 391 U.S. 367 (1968), Frederick Douglass Foundation, Inc.\n\nv. District of Columbia, 82 F.4th 1122 (D.C. Cir. 2023), and Penthouse International, Ltd. v. Meese,\n\n939 F.2d 1011 (D.C. Cir. 1991), all First Amendment cases. Dkt. 101 at 5. Penthouse permits\n\nmotive discovery only when the violation \u201cturns on an unconstitutional motive.\u201d Id. at 1020.\n\nPlaintiff ignores all three. Its footnote distinguishes Morgan, F.D.I.C., and Inspector General as\n\nnon-First Amendment cases, Dkt. 107 at 6 n.1, but the bar on probing executive decision-makers\u2019\n\nmental processes absent \u201ca strong showing of bad faith or improper behavior\u201d does not depend on\n\nthe right asserted. Citizens to Preserve Overton Park, Inc. v. Volpe, 401 U.S. 402, 420 (1971).\n\nPlaintiff makes no such showing. Nor does it answer La Uni\u00f3n del Pueblo Entero v. Abbott, 68\n\nF.4th 228, 239 (5th Cir. 2023) (legislative purpose is off limits \u201ceven when constitutional rights\n\nare at stake\u201d). Defendant did not enact S.B. 2337, so its legislative purpose is not his to explain. In\n\n\n\n                                                  2\n\f       Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 110         Filed 10/21/26       Page 4 of 7\n\n\n\n\nany event, the merits are not motive-dependent: \u201cIllicit legislative intent is not the sine qua non of\n\na violation of the First Amendment,\u201d Time Warner Cable, Inc. v. Hudson, 667 F.3d 630, 640 n.15\n\n(5th Cir. 2012).\n\n       The preliminary injunction bars enforcement of S.B. 2337 only, and the Court has\n\nconfirmed that it does not bar the Attorney General \u201cfrom enforcing other provisions of the law.\u201d\n\nDkt. 107 at 2. The DTPA petition asserts no claim under S.B. 2337. Nwaokoro Decl. \u00b6 2.\n\nWhether that petition is baseless or retaliatory is for the state court to decide, and Plaintiff has\n\nagreed there that merits discovery would wait. Dkt. 109-1 \u00b6 7; Reply Decl. Ex. D. As Plaintiff\n\nconcedes, the Rule 56(d) deferral reaches \u201cissues that are covered by the summary judgment\n\nmotions,\u201d not the State DTPA Action. Dkt. 107 at 1.\n\n       Plaintiff does not address the legislative privilege, the common-interest privilege, or\n\nTopic 5\u2019s cumulative nature, Dkt. 101 at 6\u20137, 9, or dispute that Defendant has no non-privileged\n\nTopic 5 witness who is not also counsel. Nwaokoro Decl. \u00b6 8. Plaintiff disclaims any deposition\n\nof the Attorney General, Dkt. 107 at 9, yet its Request No. 29 seeks his campaign-contribution\n\nand legal-defense-fund records. Dkt. 109-3 at 13\u201314. An official-capacity suit is \u201cnot a suit\n\nagainst the official personally.\u201d Kentucky v. Graham, 473 U.S. 159, 166 (1985). Topics 4, 5, 6,\n\nand 8 fare no better, because a designee could answer them only by reporting what the Attorney\n\nGeneral and his closest advisers weighed and decided. In re F.D.I.C., 58 F.3d 1055, 1060 (5th\n\nCir. 1995).\n\nIII.   Topics 1, 2, 3, 7, and 9 seek work product, protected sources, and information that\n       Plaintiff already has.\n\n       Under Edenfield v. Fane, 507 U.S. 761, 770\u201371 (1993), the burden to show real harm is on\n\nthe State, so Plaintiff needs nothing from the investigative file to argue the State has not carried it.\n\nWhether a statement is misleading depends on the statement and its audience, not on who\n\n\n\n                                                   3\n\f        Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 110            Filed 10/21/26         Page 5 of 7\n\n\n\n\ncomplained. Topics 1 and 9 probe statements Defendant identifies as misleading, and he has\n\nprovided a written response. Reply Decl. Ex. E (Interrog. No. 17). Anything more is counsel\u2019s\n\nselection and opinion work product, which is not limited to documents. Hickman v. Taylor, 329\n\nU.S. 495, 510\u201311 (1947); Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(3)(B). Topic 7 asks about Glass Lewis\u2019s own Texas\n\ncontacts, the subject of the jurisdictional discovery ordered against it in Collin County. Dkt. 109-\n\n1 \u00b6 7; Reply Decl. Ex. D. Topics 2 and 3 seek the investigative-file and privileged material\n\naddressed in the Motion. Dkt. 101 at 7\u20139.\n\nIV.     The privilege showing is specific, and Plaintiff responds with state-law authority.\n\n        The Stone Declaration is not a blanket assertion; it identifies the categories of material and\n\nthe basis for each privilege. 1 Stone Decl. \u00b6\u00b6 1\u20135. Privilege has been sustained over an agency\u2019s\n\ninvestigative file. De La Cruz v. Blinken, No. 2:19-CV-22-AM-CW, 2021 WL 2709679, at *2\u20133\n\n(W.D. Tex. Mar. 19, 2021). The law-enforcement privilege\u2019s purpose does not depend on whether\n\nthe pending action is civil or criminal. In re City of New York, 607 F.3d 923, 941 (2d Cir. 2010).\n\nPlaintiff\u2019s state-law authorities do not control; federal common law governs privilege in this\n\nfederal-question case. Fed. R. Evid. 501.\n\n        Plaintiff\u2019s \u201cunlogged\u201d charge fails. Defendant has provided a privilege log, as Plaintiff\u2019s\n\nown motion to compel acknowledges, Dkt. 109 at 7, along with 39 records, not the \u201conly five\n\ndocuments\u201d Plaintiff claims. Id. at 1, 3; Dkt. 107 at 4. Moreover, Rule 26(b)(5)(A) reaches only\n\n\u201cotherwise discoverable\u201d information, so the duty to log attaches to relevant material withheld as\n\nprivileged, not material outside the scope of the action. Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co. v. CEVA\n\nLogistics Singapore, Ltd., 348 F.R.D. 54, 83 (E.D. La. 2024). Defendant\u2019s investigative file is not\n\n\n1\n Plaintiff responds by citing state-law authority. See Dkt. 107 at 9, relying on Borden, Inc. v. Valdez, 773 S.W.2d\n718, 720-21 (Tex. App. \u2013 Corpus Christi-Edinburg 1989, no writ), West v. Solito, 563 S.W.2d 240, 246 (Tex. 1978),\nCity of Garland v. Dallas Morning News, 22 S.W.3d 351, 364 (Tex. 2000), and an Attorney General Opinion\napplying the Texas Open Records Act \u2013 Att\u2019y Gen. Op. Ord. 615, 1993 WL 720210, at *4 (June 29, 1993).\n\n\n                                                         4\n\f       Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 110         Filed 10/21/26      Page 6 of 7\n\n\n\n\n\u201cotherwise discoverable.\u201d      Defendant nonetheless served an itemized log of its relevant\n\nwithholdings at 4:42 p.m. on October 16, ahead of the October 19 date Plaintiff accepted, and\n\nsupplemented it on October 20. Reply Decl. \u00b6 7 & Ex. B; Dkt. 107-6 at 2\u20133. Plaintiff filed its\n\nResponse, charging \u201cunlogged\u201d withholdings, at 6:28 p.m. that same day. Reply Decl. \u00b6 7. Plaintiff\n\nserved its first log on October 19, after Defendant asked for one on October 15. Id. \u00b6 8 & Ex. F.\n\nPlaintiff\u2019s accusation of bad faith, Dkt. 107 at 4, cannot be squared with that record.\n\nV.     The conferral record does not support denial.\n\n       Plaintiff\u2019s September 30 email asked Defendant to identify a representative, or confirm it\n\nwould offer none, \u201cno later than Friday, October 9.\u201d Dkt. 101 at 12; Dkt. 107-6 at 3; Reply Decl.\n\n\u00b6 2 & Ex. A. Defendant served objections on October 8 and proposed three resolutions and three\n\nwindows to confer. Dkt. 107-6 at 5\u20136; Reply Decl. \u00b6 4 & Ex. C. Plaintiff\u2019s October 9 reply\n\naccepted none, did not offer to narrow the topics, and declared that Defendant had \u201calready said\n\nplainly\u201d it would not produce a witness. Id. at 5. Rule 26(c)(1) requires only a certification that\n\nthe movant \u201cconferred or attempted to confer,\u201d and Defendant did both. Defendant also offered\n\nto authenticate identified public statements by stipulation or declaration. Dkt. 101 at 11.\n\n                                             PRAYER\n\n       Defendant asks the Court to grant the Motion and enter the proposed order (Dkt. 101-3),\n\nbarring inquiry into Topics 1\u20135 and 7\u20139, confining Topic 6 to authentication. Alternatively,\n\nDefendant asks the Court to limit any examination to non-privileged facts bearing on the as-applied\n\nquestion and to a reasonable duration. Dkt. 101 at 10\u201311. Defendant asks that, if the Court denies\n\nthe Motion in any part, the stay remain in place briefly to permit objections under Rule 72(a).\n\n\n\n\n                                                  5\n\f       Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA         Document 110       Filed 10/21/26        Page 7 of 7\n\n\n\n\nDated: October 21, 2026.                    Respectfully submitted,\n\n                                            KEN PAXTON\n                                            Attorney General of Texas\n\n                                            BRENT WEBSTER\n                                            First Assistant Attorney General\n\n                                            RALPH MOLINA\n                                            Deputy First Assistant Attorney General\n\n                                            WILLIAM D. WASSDORF\n                                            Deputy Attorney General for Civil Litigation\n\n                                            KIMBERLY GDULA\n                                            Chief, General Litigation Division\n\n                                            /s/ Joe Nwaokoro\n                                            JOE NWAOKORO\n                                            Attorney-in-Charge\n                                            Texas Bar No. 24032916\n                                            Assistant Attorney General\n                                            P.O. Box 12548, Capitol Station\n                                            Austin, Texas 78711-2548\n                                            (512) 979-5382 | FAX: (512) 320-0667\n                                            Joe.Nwaokoro@oag.texas.gov\n\n                                            Defendant Ken Paxton, in his official capacity as\n                                            Attorney General of Texas\n\n                               CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\n\n       I certify that on October 21, 2026, a true and correct copy of the foregoing was filed\n\nelectronically through the Court\u2019s CM/ECF system, which will send notice of electronic filing to\n\nall counsel of record.\n\n\n                                            /s/ Joe Nwaokoro\n                                            JOE NWAOKORO\n                                            Assistant Attorney General\n\n\n\n\n                                               6\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2026-10-23T06:23:14.760792-07:00","document_number":"110","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"181037658346","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Reply to Response to Motion","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/498362223/","id":498362223,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/110/1/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-23T06:23:02.129104-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-23T06:23:02.129117-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":67,"file_size":3730661,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"110","attachment_number":1,"pacer_doc_id":"181037658347","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit A - Declaration of Joe Nwaokoro","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-21T16:17:07.714550-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-21T16:17:07.723701-07:00","date_filed":"2026-10-21","time_filed":"18:01:30","entry_number":110,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-10-21.001","pacer_sequence_number":414,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/482030399/","id":482030399,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497796165/","id":497796165,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/109/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-19T15:18:12.342024-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-26T02:36:07.515307-07:00","sha1":"5f06d563ad2192a3fb699b6b673131e8abb6b430","page_count":13,"file_size":358113,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.109.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.109.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA     Document 109     Filed 10/19/26    Page 1 of 13\n\n\n\n\n                          UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                           WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS\n                                 AUSTIN DIVISION\n\nGLASS, LEWIS & CO., LLC,                  )\n                                          )\n             Plaintiff,                   )\n                                          )\nv.                                        )\n                                          )\nKEN PAXTON, in his Official Capacity as   )\nAttorney General of Texas,                )\n                                          )\n                                          )     Civil Action No. 1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n             Defendant,                   )\n                                          )\nTHE TEXAS STOCK EXCHANGE LLC              )\nand THE TEXAS ASSOCIATION OF              )\nBUSINESS,                                 )\n             Intervenor-Defendants.       )\n\n\n     PLAINTIFF GLASS LEWIS\u2019 MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY RESPONSES\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 109        Filed 10/19/26      Page 2 of 13\n\n\n\n\n       This motion presents a simple question: is discovery a one-way proposition? Defendants\n\nwrongly think so. When Defendants sought Rule 56(d) discovery to test whether Glass Lewis\n\nsupposedly misleads its clients, Glass Lewis provided documents in good faith. But when Glass\n\nLewis asked for evidentiary support for Defendants\u2019 defenses, Defendants refused to answer 64 of\n\n66 requests. The result is below: Glass Lewis has produced 4,135 documents; the Attorney General\n\n39. LeBrun Decl. \u00b6\u00b6 4-5. Intervenors have produced zero documents in response to 25 requests.\n\n\n\n\n       Such lopsided participation flouts the rule that discovery \u201cmust be a two-way street.\u201d\n\nWardius v. Oregon, 412 U.S. 470, 475 (1973). And Defendants\u2019 wholesale refusal to participate\n\nin written discovery has no basis. Their responses ignore the Rules by rattling off boilerplate\n\nobjections and refusing to state the basis for their withholding. They explain only two objections:\n\nrelevance and privilege, and neither survives scrutiny. Defendants put consumer deception at issue,\n\nwhich is the entire reason for the Rule 56(d) discovery. And their privilege objections fare no\n\nbetter: the Attorney General improperly withholds his entire investigative file on a blanket\n\nprivilege claim, while the Texas Association of Business (\u201cTAB\u201d) uses associational privilege to\n\nhide the purported member harm it explicitly invoked to intervene.\n\n       The Court should find Defendants\u2019 boilerplate objections waived, order compliant\n\nresponses under Rules 33 and 34, overrule the relevance objection, reject the Attorney General\u2019s\n\nblanket privilege claim, and overrule TAB\u2019s associational privilege objection.\n\n\n\n                                               -1-\n\f       Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 109           Filed 10/19/26   Page 3 of 13\n\n\n\n\n                                              BACKGROUND\n\n        Since this case began, Defendants have insisted that the Court must allow full discovery.\n\nIntervenors told the Court that \u201cTAB\u2019s members are the same Texas public companies who are\n\nthe subject of the proxy advisors\u2019 misleading statements\u201d and were \u201cin a unique position to assist\n\nthe Court . . . in discovering the facts required to defend against Plaintiff\u2019s claims.\u201d Dkt. 22 at 17.\n\n        So after Glass Lewis moved for summary judgment, Defendants moved to defer ruling\n\nunder Rule 56(d). Intervenors argued that consumer deception was critical to the case because \u201c[i]f\n\nGlass Lewis is misleading its clients, . . . that false commercial speech would not receive First\n\nAmendment protection.\u201d Dkt. 69 at 14. The Attorney General joined that motion in full. Dkt. 70\n\nat 2. The Court granted the motions, allowing discovery into Defendants\u2019 claims that Glass Lewis\n\nhad engaged in supposedly \u201cdeceptive\u201d speech. Dkt. 90. On August 11, 2026, the Court clarified\n\nthat \u201c[a]ll parties reserve rights to make further discovery requests and objections.\u201d Ex. 1 at 1.\n\n        Following that Order, Glass Lewis sought discovery to uncover the basis for Defendants\u2019\n\nfar-fetched claim that Glass Lewis deceives its clients. It served a second set of interrogatories and\n\nrequests for production and noticed Rule 30(b)(6) depositions. See Exs. 2-8; LeBrun Decl. \u00b6 2-3.\n\nOf these sixty-six requests, Defendants substantively answered only two:\n\n\n\n\nRed marks a substantive refusal; dashed red boxes were ignored entirely.\n\n\n\n\n                                                       -2-\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA              Document 109          Filed 10/19/26        Page 4 of 13\n\n\n\n\n        TAB answered zero interrogatories. The Texas Stock Exchange LLC (\u201cTXSE\u201d) answered\n\nonly two. 1 They produced no documents in response to any of Glass Lewis\u2019 25 second requests\n\nfor production, without identifying why they were withholding documents or the basis for doing\n\nso. LeBrun Decl. \u00b6 6; Exs. 3-6. TXSE skipped Requests 36 and 37 entirely (which sought\n\ncommunications with listees). Compare Ex. 8 at 7 (RFP Nos. 36-39), with Ex. 5 at 7-8. And TAB\n\nrefused to designate a witness on four of nine 30(b)(6) topics. Ex. 7.\n\n        The Attorney General substantively answered none of his twelve interrogatories. Ex. 2 at\n\n4-9. Many of his responses say \u201cDefendant will not disclose,\u201d \u201cDefendant will not provide,\u201d or\n\n(without explaining why) that he \u201cwithholds responsive information.\u201d Id. at 4, 7, 9. On October\n\n16, he served 34 documents, but the majority of them were Glass Lewis and ISS\u2019s own documents.\n\nLeBrun Decl. \u00b6 5. Symbolic of this lopsided discovery, the Attorney General\u2019s four internal\n\ndocuments redact every word written by his staff except the portion of his email written by Glass\n\nLewis. Id.\n\n                                         LEGAL STANDARD\n\n        Discovery reaches \u201cany nonprivileged matter that is relevant to any party\u2019s claim or\n\ndefense.\u201d Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(1). Accordingly, the scope of discovery is broad. Crosby v. La.\n\nHealth Serv. & Indem. Co., 647 F.3d 258, 262 (5th Cir. 2011). A party resisting discovery \u201cmust\n\nshow specifically how each [request] is not relevant or how each question is overly broad,\n\nburdensome or oppressive.\u201d McLeod, Alexander, Powel & Apffel, P.C. v. Quarles, 894 F.2d 1482,\n\n1485 (5th Cir. 1990) (internal quotation omitted).\n\n\n\n\n1\n  TXSE\u2019s two answers (1) identify its public listees and (2) admit that it \u201chas not communicated with listees\nabout its decision to intervene.\u201d Ex. 6 at 4-5. Yet TXSE\u2019s entire basis for intervening was that its \u201clistees\nwill be harmed if [Glass Lewis] obtains its requested relief.\u201d Dkt. 22-1 at 2. In other words, TXSE\u2019s answer\nto Interrogatory No. 18 confirms its justification for intervention was invented out of whole cloth.\n\n\n                                                    -3-\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 109         Filed 10/19/26       Page 5 of 13\n\n\n\n\n                                            ARGUMENT\n\nI.     Defendants must answer Glass Lewis\u2019 requests as the Rules require.\n\n       Defendants\u2019 wholesale objections violate the plain language of the Federal Rules. An\n\ninterrogatory \u201cmust, to the extent it is not objected to, be answered separately and fully in writing\n\nunder oath.\u201d Fed. R. Civ. P. 33(b)(3). \u201cThe person who makes the answers must sign them.\u201d Fed.\n\nR. Civ. P. 33(b)(5). Objections must be stated \u201cwith specificity.\u201d Fed. R. Civ. P. 33(b)(4),\n\n34(b)(2)(B). Objections to document requests \u201cmust state whether any responsive materials are\n\nbeing withheld on the basis of that objection.\u201d Fed. R. Civ. P. 34(b)(2)(C). And an \u201cevasive or\n\nincomplete\u201d answer \u201cmust be treated as a failure to . . . answer.\u201d Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(a)(4).\n\n        Defendants ignore these requirements. Nine of Intervenors\u2019 twelve unanswered\n\ninterrogatories list objections and nothing else. Ex. 4 at 4-6; Ex. 6 at 4-6. There is no answer, no\n\nexplanation of which objection applies, no statement that nothing responsive exists, and no\n\nverification. On the requests for production, 18 of their 23 document responses say only that they\n\n\u201cwill not produce,\u201d without saying whether responsive documents exist or the reason for the\n\nwithholding. Exs. 3, 5. The responses raise a blanket relevance objection each time, stating merely\n\nthe request is \u201cnot relevant to the claims and defenses in this action[.]\u201d E.g., Ex. 4 at 4-6; Heller v.\n\nCity of Dallas, 303 F.R.D. 466, 483-84 (N.D. Tex. 2014) (boilerplate objections are \u201cimproper and\n\nineffective\u201d). TXSE does not respond at all to two requests. Exs. 5, 8. See In re United States, 864\n\nF.2d 1153, 1156 (5th Cir. 1989) (\u201c[W]hen a party fails to object timely to interrogatories,\n\nproduction requests, or other discovery efforts, objections thereto are waived.\u201d).\n\n        The Attorney General\u2019s responses are no better. He objects that many requests are outside\n\nthe \u201cscope\u201d of this case and that he \u201cwill not disclose,\u201d \u201cwill not provide,\u201d or \u201cotherwise withholds\n\nresponsive information.\u201d Ex. 2 at 4, 7, 9. For most document requests, he says only that \u201cany\n\nresponsive document will be produced\u201d somewhere in his October 16 production, without saying\n\n\n                                                 -4-\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 109         Filed 10/19/26       Page 6 of 13\n\n\n\n\nwhat he withheld or why. Id. at 10-15. He withholds his investigative file wholesale and does not\n\nlist it on his privilege log, apparently because he has unilaterally decided it is irrelevant. Ex. 9.\n\n        These objections are improper. \u201cIn the face of such objections, it is impossible to know\n\nwhether information has been withheld and, if so, why.\u201d Heller, 303 F.R.D. at 483 (quotation\n\nomitted). In LUPE, the intervenors \u201chad not produced a single document . . . or substantively\n\nanswered a single interrogatory.\u201d La Union del Pueblo Entero v. Abbott, 2022 WL 17574079, at\n\n*3 (W.D. Tex. 2022) (\u201cLUPE\u201d). The Court held that their \u201cboilerplate, and unsupported\n\nobjections\u201d were \u201cimproper and result in waiver of those objections,\u201d and it ordered them to\n\nproduce documents, supplement their answers, and log what they withheld. Id. at *4, *10\n\n(quotation omitted); see also Ambler v. Nissen, 2023 WL 443806, at *7 (W.D. Tex. Jan. 26, 2023)\n\n(Hightower, M.J.) (ordering amended responses stating \u201cwhether any responsive materials are\n\nbeing withheld on the basis of each\u201d objection).\n\n        As in LUPE, the Court should hold that Defendants have waived their boilerplate\n\nobjections. It should then order each Defendant to serve responses that comply with Rules 33 and\n\n34: answer each interrogatory fully and under oath, state for each request whether responsive\n\ndocuments are being withheld and why, and log any document withheld as privileged.\n\nII.     Defendants\u2019 relevance and privilege objections fail.\n\n        Beyond boilerplate, Defendants make only two objections: relevance and privilege. Both\n\nfail. Unless the Court overrules them, Defendants\u2019 amended responses will simply repeat them.\n\n        A.      The requests test the deception theory Defendants used to obtain discovery.\n\n        Start with relevance. Glass Lewis\u2019 requests seek information on whether anyone was\n\nactually deceived by Glass Lewis\u2019 statements and Defendants\u2019 basis for claiming Glass Lewis has\n\nengaged in deceptive speech. Resp., Dkt. 107, at 5. That is exactly the issue presented in Rule\n\n56(d) discovery. Intervenors told the Court that \u201coutstanding discovery will indicate whether Glass\n\n\n                                                 -5-\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 109        Filed 10/19/26      Page 7 of 13\n\n\n\n\nLewis makes false or misleading representations in the context of a commercial transaction,\u201d and\n\n\u201cdiscovery will confirm that Glass Lewis is misleading customers.\u201d Dkt. 79 at 7; Dkt. 69 at 15.\n\nJust as Defendants obtained discovery testing whether Glass Lewis\u2019 speech is deceptive, Glass\n\nLewis can seek discovery showing that their allegations of deception are specious and pretextual.\n\n       In its supplement to its motion for summary judgment, Glass Lewis intends to show that\n\nneither the Attorney General nor Intervenors can identify Glass Lewis clients who have been\n\ndeceived. Such an omission would be critical, because a government restriction on speech \u201cmust\n\ndemonstrate that the harms it recites are real.\u201d Edenfield v. Fane, 507 U.S. 761, 770-71 (1993). By\n\nwithholding discovery, Defendants make it impossible to know whether such documents do not\n\nexist or are simply being withheld. The record so far shows the Attorney General sued for\n\ndeceptive trade practices without contacting a single Glass Lewis client. It also suggests that\n\nTAB\u2019s members are not Glass Lewis\u2019 clients at all, but companies that dislike its\n\nrecommendations. Either fact would show that the recited harms are not real. Indeed, such facts\n\nshow that the interventions themselves were based on false pretenses.\n\n       The Attorney General\u2019s claim that such discovery belongs in state court is confused on\n\nmultiple levels. At the request of the Attorney General, merits discovery in state court \u201cis not\n\nopen,\u201d and will not be for several months, if ever. Ex. 10; LeBrun Decl. \u00b6 7. The possibility that\n\nGlass Lewis might one day obtain similar discovery in a different case has zero bearing on whether\n\nit is relevant to this case now. And the Attorney General must have thought state investigations\n\nare relevant, having sought and obtained the documents Glass Lewis produced to the Missouri and\n\nFlorida Attorneys General. Ex. 11 at 7 (RFP No. 23); LeBrun Decl. \u00b6 8; see Resp., Dkt. 107, at 7.\n\nDefendants apparently contend that Missouri\u2019s investigation is relevant, but the Texas Attorney\n\n\n\n\n                                               -6-\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 109        Filed 10/19/26      Page 8 of 13\n\n\n\n\nGeneral\u2019s own investigation is not. That is implausible, and the Court should overrule the\n\nrelevance objection.\n\n       B.       The Attorney General\u2019s blanket privilege claim fails.\n\n       The Attorney General\u2019s blanket privilege assertions also fail. He bears the burden of\n\nproving each privilege he asserts, and \u201c[a]mbiguities as to whether the elements of a privilege\n\nclaim have been met are construed against the proponent.\u201d EEOC v. BDO USA, 876 F.3d 690, 695\n\n(5th Cir. 2017).\n\n       There are multiple problems with his approach. First, a \u201cblanket assertion of the privilege\u201d\n\nis \u201csimply inadequate.\u201d United States v. El Paso Co., 682 F.2d 530, 541 (5th Cir. 1982). Yet he\n\nhas done just that\u2014asserting that the investigative file is both blanket privileged and blanket\n\nirrelevant. Ex. 2. Second, he does not log a single document from the investigative file, as Rule\n\n26(b)(5)(A) requires. Ex. 9. Third, the facts Glass Lewis seeks\u2014who was deceived, who\n\ncomplained, and what the investigators did\u2014are not privileged. Work product, if it applies,\n\n\u201cprotects only the documents themselves and not the underlying facts.\u201d In re Int\u2019l Sys. & Controls\n\nCorp. Sec. Litig., 693 F.2d 1235, 1240 (5th Cir. 1982). The identities of any Glass Lewis clients\n\nwho complained have nothing to do with attorney impressions. They are facts, and those facts are\n\ndiscoverable.\n\n       Nor does the investigative/law-enforcement privilege apply. See Resp., Dkt. 107, at 9-10.\n\nThat qualified privilege protects \u201cinvestigative files in an ongoing criminal investigation.\u201d In re\n\nU.S. Dep\u2019t of Homeland Sec., 459 F.3d 565, 569 (5th Cir. 2006) (internal quotation omitted); SEC\n\nv. Cuban, 2013 WL 1091233, at *8 (N.D. Tex. 2013) (the privilege \u201cdoes not extend to . . . civil\n\ninvestigations\u201d). The Attorney General\u2019s investigation is neither criminal nor ongoing.\n\n       Finally, the deliberative process privilege and Section 17.61(f) have no application. The\n\ndeliberative process privilege applies only to policymaking decisions, not investigations. Resp.,\n\n\n                                               -7-\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 109         Filed 10/19/26      Page 9 of 13\n\n\n\n\nDkt. 107, at 9; La Union del Pueblo Entero v. Abbott, 2023 WL 4923947, at *4 (W.D. Tex. 2023)\n\n(state failed to show investigative documents were \u201cinextricably intertwined with agency decision-\n\nmaking\u201d); Cuban, 2013 WL 1091233, at *9 (deliberative process privilege \u201cdoes not protect pure\n\nfacts\u201d). As to Section 17.61(f), the only party to receive a Civil Investigative Demand is Glass\n\nLewis and, as this Court has recognized, state laws restricting the disclosure of investigative\n\nmaterial \u201cdo[] not apply in federal court.\u201d Ambler, 2023 WL 443806, at *2; Resp., Dkt. 107, at 8.\n\nThe Court should therefore reject the Attorney General\u2019s blanket assertion and order him to answer\n\nthe interrogatories and either produce the investigative file or log each withheld document.\n\n       C.      TAB cannot use associational privilege to hide the member harm it invoked to\n               intervene.\n\n               1.      TAB put its members\u2019 harm at issue.\n\n       TAB\u2019s privilege assertion is even more speculative, claiming \u201cassociational privilege\u201d over\n\nthe very claims it used to intervene in this case. TAB is a party precisely because it told the Court\n\nthat its members were harmed. It moved \u201con behalf of its Texas public-company members,\u201d and\n\nsaid those members \u201cwill continue to be harmed by false and misleading proxy advice.\u201d Dkt. 22\n\nat 1, 10. When Intervenors later sought Rule 56(d) discovery, they argued that Glass Lewis\u2019 claims\n\nshould face \u201cthe crucible of meaningful discovery.\u201d Dkt. 69 at 12. TAB\u2019s own claims deserve that\n\nsame test. So, Glass Lewis asked TAB to identify the members it contends were deceived and the\n\nmembers that asked it to intervene, and to produce documents reflecting the harm. Ex. 3 at 5-6, 8-\n\n9 (RFP Nos. 29-30, 37-38); Ex. 4 at 4 (Interrogatory Nos. 14-15). TAB refused every request and\n\ninvoked associational privilege to avoid naming any member. See Ex. 3 at 8-9; Ex. 4 at 4.\n\n       Having intervened based on harm to their members, Intervenors cannot now claim that\n\ninformation is off-limits. Once it joins, a party \u201ccannot realistically hope to pursue [the] suit in a\n\nrisk-free atmosphere.\u201d Nat\u2019l Org. for Women v. Sperry Rand Corp., 88 F.R.D. 272, 275 (D. Conn.\n\n\n\n                                                -8-\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 109       Filed 10/19/26      Page 10 of 13\n\n\n\n\n1980). A plaintiff is \u201cplainly entitled to discovery as to the Defendant Intervenors\u2019 defenses.\u201d\n\nLUPE, 2022 WL 17574079, at *5. Intervenors used their membership as a sword to thrust\n\nthemselves into the case; they cannot use that same membership as a shield to resist discovery.\n\n       The need for discovery is greatest when, as here, the party claiming the privilege \u201chas\n\nplaced certain information into issue.\u201d Grandbouche v. Clancy, 825 F.2d 1463, 1467 (10th Cir.\n\n1987); see In re Motor Fuel Temperature Sales Pracs. Litig., 707 F. Supp. 2d 1145, 1162 (D. Kan.\n\n2010) (factor \u201cweighs strongly in favor of disclosure\u201d). So when an association sues on behalf of\n\nits members, courts may properly order it to identify those members and answer interrogatories\n\nabout their harm. NIACCF, Inc. v. Cold Stone Creamery, Inc., 2014 WL 4545918, at *4-5 (S.D.\n\nFla. Sept. 12, 2014). Such information goes \u201cto the heart of this case\u201d and parties have \u201ca right to\n\ninvestigate the factual assertions made.\u201d Id. at *4.\n\n       TAB claimed its members were \u201charmed by false and misleading proxy advice.\u201d Dkt. 22\n\nat 1. TAB cannot make that claim and then refuse to say who was harmed, when, and how. By\n\nTAB\u2019s own account, its members are \u201cthe subjects and recipients\u201d of the proxy advice at issue.\n\nDkt. 22-2 \u00b6 7. If they cannot identify a single misleading statement or resulting harm, then the\n\nharms Defendants recite are not \u201creal,\u201d and their deception theory fails. See Edenfield, 507 U.S. at\n\n770-71. Glass Lewis cannot test that question while TAB withholds even the identities of the\n\nmembers it says were injured.\n\n               2.      TAB has not shown that disclosure would chill anyone.\n\n       Nor have Intervenors substantiated their associational privilege claim. Parties claiming the\n\nprivilege must make a prima facie showing of \u201can objectively reasonable probability of a chilling\n\neffect.\u201d Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Tex. Alcoholic Beverage Comm\u2019n, 2016 WL 5922315, at *6\n\n(W.D. Tex. 2016) (Austin, M.J.). That showing must rest on \u201cobjective and articulable facts.\u201d In\n\nre Motor Fuel Temperature Sales Pracs. Litig., 641 F.3d 470, 489 (10th Cir. 2011) (quotation\n\n\n                                                -9-\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 109           Filed 10/19/26    Page 11 of 13\n\n\n\n\nomitted). Intervenors offer a one-sentence objection and no evidence of chill. Ex. 4 at 4. Further,\n\nconfidentiality concerns can be addressed via the Court\u2019s protective order. See Dkt. 56 \u00b6 2(a). TAB\n\nhas not articulated any discrete harm to its members from public disclosure, much less an\n\nattorneys\u2019-eyes-only disclosure. A trade association that offers no evidence of \u201chostility related to\n\nassociating with\u201d it cannot use the privilege to avoid identifying its members. ERISA Indus. Comm.\n\nv. Asaro-Angelo, 2023 WL 2808105, at *7 (D.N.J. 2023). Indeed, TAB\u2019s website publicly names\n\nseveral members, including Texas Mutual, JPMorgan Chase, and Amazon. Ex. 12.\n\n       Moreover, Glass Lewis\u2019 requests are narrow. It asks TAB to identify only the members it\n\ncontends were deceived, harmed, or involved with S.B. 2337, and to produce documents reflecting\n\nthat harm. The disclosure of member identities extends only to those facts directly relevant to\n\nTAB\u2019s defense.\n\n                                          *      *       *\n\n       Intervenors joined the case promising to help in \u201cdiscovering the facts required to defend\n\nagainst Plaintiff\u2019s claims.\u201d Dkt. 22 at 17. The Court should hold Intervenors to that promise and\n\norder them to produce the evidence of member harm they put at issue.\n\n                                         CONCLUSION\n\n       Defendants have wholesale refused to engage in Rule 56(d) discovery. The Court should\n\n(1) order that Defendants\u2019 boilerplate objections are waived; (2) order each Defendant to serve\n\nresponses that comply with Rules 33 and 34 within seven days; (3) overrule Defendants\u2019 relevance\n\nobjections; (4) hold that the Attorney General may not withhold his investigative file on a blanket\n\nprivilege assertion; and (5) overrule TAB\u2019s associational privilege objection and order TAB to\n\npresent a Rule 30(b)(6) designee on TAB\u2019s members.\n\n\n\n\n                                               - 10 -\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA   Document 109     Filed 10/19/26     Page 12 of 13\n\n\n\n\nDated: October 19, 2026             Respectfully submitted,\n\n                                    YETTER COLEMAN LLP\n\n                                    /s/ Bryce L. Callahan\n                                    Bryce L. Callahan\n                                    State Bar No. 24055248\n                                    bcallahan@yettercoleman.com\n                                    Grant B. Martinez\n                                    State Bar No. 24104118\n                                    gmartinez@yettercoleman.com\n                                    Lily E. Hann\n                                    State Bar No. 24133836\n                                    lhann@yettercoleman.com\n                                    Jared LeBrun\n                                    State Bar No. 24144647\n                                    jlebrun@yettercoleman.com\n                                    600 Travis Street, Suite 5400\n                                    Houston, Texas 77002\n                                    (713) 632-8000\n                                    (713) 632-8002 (fax)\n\n                                    Attorneys for Plaintiff Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC\n\n\n\n\n                                    - 11 -\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 109          Filed 10/19/26   Page 13 of 13\n\n\n\n\n                                   Certificate of Conference\n\n       The parties conferred on these requests several times and did not reach agreement. On\n\nSeptember 29, 2026, the parties conferred on upcoming depositions, where counsel for Glass\n\nLewis informed Defendants that it would likely need to move to compel if Defendants continued\n\nto resist discovery. On October 8 and 9, counsel for Glass Lewis discussed the associational\n\nprivilege objections with counsel for Intervenors, who stated that they would not withdraw the\n\nobjection. Separately on October 8 and 9, counsel for Glass Lewis emailed the Attorney General\n\nto confer on his privilege and relevance objections. On October 15 and 16, counsel for Glass Lewis\n\nagain emailed Defendants to ask if they would (1) withdraw their associational privilege assertions\n\nand (2) respond in substance to Glass Lewis\u2019 discovery requests. Defendants would not agree to\n\neither request.\n\n                                                       /s/ Jared LeBrun\n                                                       Jared LeBrun\n\n\n                                      Certificate of Service\n\n       I certify that on October 19, 2026, a copy of this document was served on all counsel of\n\nrecord using the Court\u2019s e-filing system.\n\n\n\n                                                       /s/ Jared LeBrun\n                                                       Jared LeBrun\n\n\n\n\n                                              - 12 -\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2026-10-20T06:13:28.335916-07:00","document_number":"109","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"181037636576","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Compel","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497852432/","id":497852432,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/109/1/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-20T06:13:00.643590-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-20T06:13:00.643609-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":4,"file_size":178700,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"109","attachment_number":1,"pacer_doc_id":"181037636577","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Declaration of Jared LeBrun","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497852433/","id":497852433,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/109/2/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-20T06:13:00.715214-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-20T06:13:00.715234-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":6,"file_size":261301,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"109","attachment_number":2,"pacer_doc_id":"181037636578","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit 1","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497852434/","id":497852434,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/109/3/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-20T06:13:00.736599-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-20T06:13:00.736617-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":17,"file_size":266431,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"109","attachment_number":3,"pacer_doc_id":"181037636579","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit 2","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497852435/","id":497852435,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/109/4/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-20T06:13:00.761703-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-20T06:13:00.761725-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":13,"file_size":209543,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"109","attachment_number":4,"pacer_doc_id":"181037636580","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit 3","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497852436/","id":497852436,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/109/5/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-20T06:13:02.023637-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-20T06:13:02.023663-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":9,"file_size":182652,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"109","attachment_number":5,"pacer_doc_id":"181037636581","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit 4","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497852437/","id":497852437,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/109/6/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-20T06:13:02.394563-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-20T06:13:02.394591-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":11,"file_size":219385,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"109","attachment_number":6,"pacer_doc_id":"181037636582","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit 5","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497852438/","id":497852438,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/109/7/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-20T06:13:02.656826-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-20T06:13:02.656853-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":9,"file_size":202179,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"109","attachment_number":7,"pacer_doc_id":"181037636584","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit 6","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497852439/","id":497852439,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/109/8/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-20T06:13:02.851917-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-20T06:13:02.851937-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":11,"file_size":213687,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"109","attachment_number":8,"pacer_doc_id":"181037636585","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit 7","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497852440/","id":497852440,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/109/9/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-20T06:13:03.070550-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-20T06:13:03.070569-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":8,"file_size":186996,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"109","attachment_number":9,"pacer_doc_id":"181037636586","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit 8","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497852441/","id":497852441,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/109/10/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-20T06:13:03.256288-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-20T06:13:03.256307-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":3,"file_size":119126,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"109","attachment_number":10,"pacer_doc_id":"181037636588","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit 9","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497852442/","id":497852442,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/109/11/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-20T06:13:03.443136-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-20T06:13:03.443155-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":3,"file_size":66433,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"109","attachment_number":11,"pacer_doc_id":"181037636590","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit 10","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497852443/","id":497852443,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/109/12/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-20T06:13:03.556121-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-20T06:13:03.556148-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":12,"file_size":232851,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"109","attachment_number":12,"pacer_doc_id":"181037636591","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit 11","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497852444/","id":497852444,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/109/13/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-20T06:13:03.678203-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-20T06:13:03.678222-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":3,"file_size":1870189,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"109","attachment_number":13,"pacer_doc_id":"181037636592","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit 12","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497852445/","id":497852445,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/109/14/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-20T06:13:03.804290-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-20T06:13:03.804316-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":2,"file_size":116353,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"109","attachment_number":14,"pacer_doc_id":"181037636593","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Proposed Order","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-19T15:18:12.322961-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-21T09:33:32.846264-07:00","date_filed":"2026-10-19","time_filed":"17:11:24","entry_number":109,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-10-19.002","pacer_sequence_number":412,"description":"MOTION to Compel Discovery Responses by Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Declaration of Jared LeBrun, # 2 Exhibit 1, # 3 Exhibit 2, # 4 Exhibit 3, # 5 Exhibit 4, # 6 Exhibit 5, # 7 Exhibit 6, # 8 Exhibit 7, # 9 Exhibit 8, # 10 Exhibit 9, # 11 Exhibit 10, # 12 Exhibit 11, # 13 Exhibit 12, # 14 Proposed Order)(Callahan, Bryce) (Entered: 10/19/2026)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/481974605/","id":481974605,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497739586/","id":497739586,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/108/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-19T11:07:01.428898-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-19T11:07:01.447686-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"108","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"181037632579","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Transcript Request (Miscellaneous)","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-19T11:07:01.380605-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-21T09:33:32.827385-07:00","date_filed":"2026-10-19","time_filed":"12:37:25","entry_number":108,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-10-19.001","pacer_sequence_number":410,"description":"TRANSCRIPT REQUEST by Ken Paxton for proceedings held on 10/13/2026. Proceedings Transcribed: Status Conference. Court Reporter: Zoom (Unknown Court Reporter). (Nwaokoro, Joseph) (Entered: 10/19/2026)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/481881112/","id":481881112,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497640549/","id":497640549,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/107/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-16T17:06:05.458913-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-20T19:46:05.557516-07:00","sha1":"4b60a53eb27b7fa135cf28885bfedf5b51f997e1","page_count":12,"file_size":309598,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.107.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.107.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA     Document 107       Filed 10/16/26     Page 1 of 12\n\n\n\n\n                          UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                           WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS\n                                 AUSTIN DIVISION\n\nGLASS, LEWIS & CO., LLC,                   )\n                                           )\n             Plaintiff,                    )\n                                           )\nv.                                         )\n                                           )\nKEN PAXTON, in his Official Capacity as    )\nAttorney General of Texas,                 )\n                                           )\n                                           )     Civil Action No. 1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n             Defendant,                    )\n                                           )\nTHE TEXAS STOCK EXCHANGE LLC               )\nand THE TEXAS ASSOCIATION OF               )\nBUSINESS,                                  )\n             Intervenor-Defendants.        )\n\n\n     PLAINTIFF\u2019S RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT\u2019S OPPOSED EXPEDITED MOTION\n       FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND TO STAY RULE 30(b)(6) DEPOSITION\n\n\n\n\n                                          YETTER COLEMAN LLP\n                                          Bryce L. Callahan\n                                          bcallahan@yettercoleman.com\n                                          Grant B. Martinez\n                                          gmartinez@yettercoleman.com\n                                          Lily E. Hann\n                                          lhann@yettercoleman.com\n                                          Jared LeBrun\n                                          jlebrun@yettercoleman.com\n                                          600 Travis Street, Suite 5400\n                                          Houston, Texas 77002\n\n                                 Attorneys for Plaintiff Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 107        Filed 10/16/26     Page 2 of 12\n\n\n\n\n       The Attorney General\u2019s motion is a thinly veiled attempt to freeze Glass, Lewis & Co.,\n\nLLC out of discovery. It should be denied because he has not established the extraordinary\n\ncircumstances required to completely prohibit a party\u2019s deposition.\n\n                                       BACKGROUND\n\nI.     The Court Deferred Ruling on Glass Lewis\u2019 Motion for Summary Judgment to Allow\n       Limited Additional Discovery.\n       The Court has preliminarily enjoined the Attorney General \u201cfrom taking any action to\n\nenforce S.B. 2337 against [Glass Lewis.]\u201d Aug. 29, 2025 Minute Entry. In November 2025, Glass\n\nLewis moved for summary judgment to obtain permanent injunctive relief, Dkt. 60; the Court\n\ndeferred ruling under Rule 56(d) to allow sufficient discovery with respect to the issues that are\n\ncovered by the summary judgment motions. Dkt. 90; see also Dkt. 69, 70 (defendants\u2019 Rule 56(d)\n\nmotions). By email, the Court later ordered that \u201c[a]ll parties reserve rights to make further\n\ndiscovery requests.\u201d Ex. 1.\n\nII.    The Attorney General Sues Glass Lewis to Enforce a Civil Investigative Demand.\n       Just a few weeks after Glass Lewis filed this action to enjoin S.B. 2337, the Attorney\n\nGeneral served Glass Lewis with a civil investigative demand (\u201cCID\u201d) relating \u201cto the\n\ninvestigation of representations by proxy advisors that may violate [the Texas Deceptive Trade\n\nPractices Act (\u201cDTPA\u201d)].\u201d Ex. 2 at 10. The CID, like S.B. 2337, targeted Glass Lewis for\n\nconsidering environmental, social, and governance (\u201cESG\u201d) factors in its proxy advice. Compare\n\nEx. 2 at 11-12, 15 with S.B. 2337 \u00a7\u00a7 1(3)(A), 2(B)(1)(A); see Ex. 3 at 9:14-10:4 (explaining\n\noverlap). The materials sought in the CID overlapped with the Attorney General\u2019s discovery\n\nrequests in this case, showing that the CID was an S.B. 2337 enforcement action. See Dkt. 95 at\n\n6-7, 10.\n\n\n\n\n                                              -1-\n\f       Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 107         Filed 10/16/26      Page 3 of 12\n\n\n\n\n        Seven months after the preliminary injunction issued, the Attorney General moved for\n\nclarification whether it prohibited enforcement of the CID. Dkt. 94. Agreeing with Glass Lewis,\n\nthe Court denied the motion, explaining \u201cthe injunction order is clear\u201d and \u201cplainly\u201d prohibits the\n\nAttorney General \u201cfrom taking any action to enforce S.B. 2337,\u201d but does not bar him \u201cfrom\n\nenforcing other provisions of the law against [Glass Lewis] at this time.\u201d May 15, 2026 Text Order.\n\n        A week later, the Attorney General filed an action in Collin County District Court to\n\nenforce the CID. State of Tex. v. Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC, Case No. 471-03524-2026 (Collin Cnty.\n\n471st JDC). The petition sought to compel information relevant to \u201can investigation of Glass\n\nLewis\u2019s possible violation of DTPA Sections 17.46(a) and (b) in its provision of proxy advising\n\nservices.\u201d Ex. 2 at 4 \u00b6 11.\n\n        In July 2026, the Attorney General nonsuited the CID enforcement action. A few days later,\n\nhe filed a new state court action, alleging Glass Lewis makes \u201cfalse representations . . . to investors\n\n. . . about [its] investment advice\u201d and \u201cprioritizes its own [ESG] agenda over the fiscal well-being\n\nof its clients,\u201d in violation of the DTPA. Ex. 4 at 1.\n\nIII.    Glass Lewis Serves a Rule 30(b)(6) Deposition Notice.\n        On September 18, 2026, Glass Lewis noticed a Rule 30(b)(6) deposition of the Attorney\n\nGeneral for October 13, identifying nine topics. Dkt. 103-1. At a September 29 meet-and-confer,\n\nthe Attorney General raised no objections based on privilege, confidentiality, or relevance, saying\n\nonly that he needed time to decide whether to take the position that he was not required to designate\n\na Rule 30(b)(6) representative. LeBrun Decl. \u00b6 4.\n\nIV.     The Attorney General Objects to All Topics and Refuses to Produce a Live\n        Representative for Deposition.\n        On October 8, the Attorney General objected that eight of nine deposition topics (1) \u201care\n\noutside the scope of this as-applied challenge and confidential under Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7\n\n\n\n\n                                                 -2-\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 107         Filed 10/16/26      Page 4 of 12\n\n\n\n\n17.61(f)\u201d; (2) \u201cseek the Office\u2019s motive and internal deliberations, which are irrelevant to whether\n\nS.B. 2337 is unconstitutional as applied to Glass Lewis\u201d; and (3) \u201cseek privileged and protected\n\nmaterial.\u201d Ex. 5 at 5-6. On the remaining topic (No. 6), the Attorney General refused to designate\n\na representative, offering instead to \u201cauthenticate identified public statements by stipulation or\n\nsworn declaration.\u201d Id. at 6. He also threatened to move for protection to prohibit the deposition.\n\nId.\n\n       Eight minutes later, the Attorney General served objections and responses to the deposition\n\nnotice that referenced the then-unfiled \u201cMotion for Protective Order\u201d and stated: \u201cDefendant will\n\npromptly move for a protective order as to the Topics to which he objects.\u201d LeBrun Decl. \u00b6 5; Ex.\n\n6 at 5, 7, 10. He had already decided to move without conferring.\n\n       Glass Lewis responded the following day, (1) informing the Attorney General that he failed\n\nto confer under Local Rule CV-7(g) and Rule 30(b)(6); (2) offering to meet and confer on October\n\n12; and (3) requesting confirmation \u201cby the end of today that you will serve a privilege log by\n\nOctober 16, 2026.\u201d Ex. 5 at 4-5.\n\nV.     The Attorney General Moves for a Protective Order.\n       On October 9\u2014without conferring and just one business day before the scheduled\n\ndeposition\u2014the Attorney General moved for a protective order and to stay the deposition. Dkt.\n\n101. The Court held a status conference, ordering Glass Lewis to respond by October 16 and\n\nstaying the deposition \u201cpending further order of the Court.\u201d Dkt. 106.\n\n                                      LEGAL STANDARD\n\n       Because the Attorney General seeks to \u201cprohibit the taking of a deposition altogether,\u201d he\n\nfaces the \u201cheavy burden\u201d of showing \u201cextraordinary circumstances.\u201d Salter v. Upjohn Co., 593\n\nF.2d 649, 651 (5th Cir. 1979); Bucher v. Richardson Hosp. Auth., 160 F.R.D. 88, 92 (N.D. Tex.\n\n1994). \u201cDue to th[is] high burden[,] . . . courts will rarely grant a protective order that completely\n\n\n                                                -3-\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 107          Filed 10/16/26    Page 5 of 12\n\n\n\n\nprohibits a deposition.\u201d Campos v. Webb Cnty., Tex., 288 F.R.D. 134, 137 (S.D. Tex. 2012) (citing\n\nSalter, 593 F.2d at 650). \u201cThe movant must show a particular and compelling need for such an\n\norder,\u201d so that \u201ccourts only grant as narrow a protective order as is necessary under the facts.\u201d\n\nBucher, 160 F.R.D. at 92.\n\n       That burden is heavier still when a party seeks to \u201cprohibit his [] own deposition,\u201d given\n\n\u201cthe non-movant\u2019s legitimate interest in trial preparation and the discernable importance of the\n\nwitness whose deposition is at issue.\u201d Campos, 288 F.R.D. at 138. In that circumstance, \u201ccourts\n\nhave refused to issue a blanket prohibition on the deposition, and instead have imposed safeguards\n\nand conditions on said deposition.\u201d Id.\n\n                                          ARGUMENT\n\n       Since this case began, Glass Lewis has produced 4,135 documents (more than 800 times\n\nthe Attorney General) and made its corporate representative available for deposition. LeBrun Decl.\n\n\u00b6 8. Despite the Court\u2019s assurance that \u201c[a]ll parties reserve rights to make further discovery\n\nrequests,\u201d Ex. 1, the Attorney General treats discovery as a one-way street\u2014he has produced only\n\nfive documents and refuses to make a corporate representative available on any of the nine noticed\n\ntopics. LeBrun Decl. \u00b6 8.\n\n       The Attorney General veils this bad faith strategy with thin arguments, including unlogged,\n\nspaghetti-on-the-wall privilege assertions. The Court should deny the motion and order him to\n\nmake a corporate representative available for deposition.\n\nI.     Each Deposition Topic Is Relevant.\n       S.B. 2337 is unconstitutional as a matter of law. It compels speech based on viewpoint and\n\nis therefore subject to strict scrutiny, which the Attorney General does not argue it survives. See\n\nDkt. 17. But the defendants convinced the Court to permit additional discovery on the premise that\n\nsome potentially discoverable fact might be material to the summary judgment inquiry. This\n\n\n                                               -4-\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 107        Filed 10/16/26      Page 6 of 12\n\n\n\n\nopened discovery not just for themselves, but also for Glass Lewis. See Ex. 1; see Dkt. 99 at 2\n\n(October 20, 2026 discovery deadline).\n\n       Nonetheless, the Attorney General seeks to foreclose the deposition altogether with blanket\n\nrelevance objections. Those objections fail because relevance is no basis to prohibit a deposition\n\nunder Rule 26(c), see Keplar v. Google, LLC, 346 F.R.D. 41, 51 (N.D. Tex. 2024), and in any\n\nevent, each topic is plainly relevant to his summary judgment defense.\n\n       A.      The deposition topics are relevant to counter the Attorney General\u2019s summary\n               judgment opposition.\n       The Attorney General opposes summary judgment on the ground that \u201cGlass Lewis\u2019s\n\nrepresentations that it offers objective, financially-driven advice rather than an ideological agenda\n\nis the kind of commercial deception that is unprotected by the First Amendment.\u201d Dkt. 70 at 3.\n\nNaturally then, Glass Lewis seeks to inquire about this alleged \u201ccommercial deception,\u201d including\n\nthe \u201cstatement[s] by Glass Lewis\u201d that the Attorney General \u201chas identified as purportedly false\n\nor misleading\u201d; \u201c[t]he identity of any person . . . who has complained . . . concerning any statement\n\nby Glass Lewis\u201d; and \u201c[a]ny complaint, report, referral, tip, or inquiry received by the Office\n\nconcerning Glass Lewis.\u201d Dkt. 103-1 (Topics 1-3 & 9). Since the Attorney General\u2019s defense is\n\nbased on Glass Lewis\u2019 supposedly deceptive speech, Glass Lewis is entitled to discover the factual\n\nbases for his allegations.\n\n       Glass Lewis is also entitled to discover evidence that the Attorney General\u2019s deception\n\nallegations are pretext for viewpoint discrimination (Topics 4-6 & 8). His defense is undermined\n\nif his investigation and enforcement actions against Glass Lewis are motivated by viewpoint\n\nanimus, not actual consumer deception. See Edenfield v. Fane, 507 U.S. 761, 770-71 (1993) (\u201c[A]\n\ngovernmental body seeking to sustain a restriction on commercial speech must demonstrate that\n\nthe harms it recites are real\u201d and not \u201cmere speculation or conjecture\u201d).\n\n\n\n                                                -5-\n\f       Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA              Document 107          Filed 10/16/26        Page 7 of 12\n\n\n\n\n        The Attorney General would place bulkheads between the Legislature\u2019s motives for\n\nenacting S.B. 2337 and his own motives for investigating and enforcing the DTPA against Glass\n\nLewis, but they dissolve under scrutiny. Coinciding with his service of the CID, the Attorney\n\nGeneral issued a press release oozing with viewpoint animus:\n\n        Attorney General Ken Paxton is defending a new Texas state law that requires\n        proxy advisors to disclose when they\u2019re pushing left-wing goals as opposed to\n        making recommendations solely on financial considerations. . . .\n        . . . S.B. 2337 would prevent companies from secretly trying to push a woke agenda\n        in corporate America by forcing them to disclose if their motivations are aimed at\n        promoting political goals, including DEI and ESG.\n        \u201cThe role of a proxy advisor is to provide sound guidance based on financial\n        considerations, not use their position to promote woke, left-wing ideology,\u201d said\n        Attorney General Paxton. \u201cS.B. 2337 stops liberal activists posing as proxy\n        advisors from giving guidance based on their ideological goals without making\n        that clear to their clients. The new law is critical for promoting transparency in\n        corporate America, and I will continue to defend it aggressively in the courts.\u201d\nDkt. 59 at \u00b6 94 (emphasis added).\n\n        This statement\u2014and others like it that Glass Lewis may discover\u2014show that the Attorney\n\nGeneral\u2019s anti-deception defense is inextricably intertwined with viewpoint animus, such that one\n\ncan see deception or fraud in Glass Lewis\u2019 representations only through an anti-woke, anti-left-\n\nwing ideological lens. Such statements are also directly relevant to Glass Lewis\u2019 vagueness\n\nchallenge, since they show the law in fact \u201clends itself to selective enforcement against unpopular\n\ncauses.\u201d NAACP v. Button, 371 U.S. 415, 435 (1963) (cited in Dkt. 60 at 35). 1\n\n\n\n1\n The Attorney General cites several cases for the argument that discovery into the \u201cmental processes\u201d of\ngovernment officials is generally not permitted, Dkt. 101 at 7, but none involved First Amendment claims.\nUnited States v. Morgan, 313 U.S. 409, 422 (1941), and In re F.D.I.C., 58 F.3d 1055, 1061-62 (5th Cir.\n1995), concerned depositions of \u201chigh-level government officers,\u201d id., and In re Office of Inspector\nGeneral, 933 F.2d 276 (5th Cir. 1991), was a subpoena enforcement action where the subpoena target\nsought counter-discovery from the agency. Ironically, the Attorney General cites Reed v. Town of Gilbert,\n576 U.S. 155, 165-66 (2015), to argue that the government\u2019s motive is irrelevant in First Amendment\nchallenges, Dkt. 101 at 4-5, but Reed holds the opposite: \u201cstrict scrutiny applies either when a law is content\nbased on its face or when the purpose and justification for the law are content based, a court must evaluate\neach question before it concludes that the law is content neutral.\u201d 576 U.S. at 165-66 (emphasis added).\n\n\n                                                     -6-\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 107         Filed 10/16/26       Page 8 of 12\n\n\n\n\n        The Attorney General raises no objection to Topic No. 7 (\u201cGlass Lewis\u2019 alleged contacts\n\nwith Texas . . .\u201d), which is \u201ctantamount to not filing a motion for protective order on th[at] topic[].\u201d\n\nFerko v. Nat\u2019l Ass\u2019n for Stock Car Auto Racing, Inc., 218 F.R.D. 125, 143 (E.D. Tex. 2003).\n\n        B.      The Attorney General\u2019s relevance objections are undermined by his own\n                discovery requests.\n        The Attorney General argues that the DTPA action is not relevant because it is brought by\n\na separate division of the Attorney General\u2019s Office \u201cby counsel who are not on this S.B. 2337\n\ndefense team.\u201d Dkt. 101 at 3. But the Attorney General sought discovery from Glass Lewis in this\n\ncase about Florida and Missouri\u2019s investigations of Glass Lewis:\n\n\n\n\nEx. 7 at 7.\n\n        So, the Attorney General contends that his own Consumer Protection Division\u2019s\n\ninvestigation, launched just after Glass Lewis filed this action, is too far afield, but other states\u2019\n\nsimilar investigations are relevant to the claims and defenses here. That\u2019s implausible.\n\n        C.      Glass Lewis is not barred from discovery merely because it believes the case\n                can be resolved as a matter of law.\n        The Attorney General argues Glass Lewis should be barred from taking discovery because\n\n\u201c[b]y Glass Lewis\u2019s own account, this case turns on questions of law.\u201d Dkt. 101 at 3-4. But he\n\ncites no authority holding that a party forfeits discovery by arguing its case should be resolved as\n\na matter of law. Having successfully argued that additional discovery was needed before Glass\n\nLewis\u2019 motion for summary judgment becomes ripe, he cannot make that discovery unilateral just\n\nbecause Glass Lewis believes the case can be resolved as a matter of law.\n\n\n\n\n                                                 -7-\n\f       Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 107         Filed 10/16/26       Page 9 of 12\n\n\n\n\nII.     There Is No Apex Issue.\n\n        The deposition notice states Glass Lewis \u201cwill take the . . . deposition of the Office of the\n\nAttorney General . . . , who shall designate one or more officers, agents, or other persons who\n\nconsent to testify on its behalf regarding the matters set out in Exhibit A.\u201d Dkt. 103-1 at 1. Glass\n\nLewis does not insist that the Attorney General himself sit for the deposition, so his opposition to\n\nan inquiry into his own \u201cpersonal thoughts and statements\u201d is a red herring. Dkt. 101 at 7.\n\nIII.    There Is No Confidentiality or Privilege Issue.\n        The Attorney General invokes\u2014or purports to have a non-party, non-counsel declarant\n\ninvoke\u2014at least six different privilege doctrines, hoping one will stick. None does.\n\n        Texas Business and Commerce Code Section 17.61(f). The Attorney General does not\n\nidentify any deposition topics that implicate Section 17.61(f), and it is unclear how any could. The\n\nnotice seeks oral testimony, not \u201cdocumentary material.\u201d And Section 17.61(f) covers only\n\nmaterial \u201cproduced pursuant to a demand,\u201d but the only CID the Attorney General identifies is the\n\nCID to Glass Lewis. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.61(f). Showing material to the party that\n\nproduced it raises no confidentiality concern.\n\n        Attorney-Client Privilege. The Attorney General argues that \u201ctestimony on Topic Nos. 2,\n\n3, 4 and 8 . . . would necessarily disclose [] privileged materials.\u201d Dkt. 101-2 at \u00b6 1 (J. Stone Decl.).\n\nBut those topics do not implicate privileged materials or communications even prima facie\u2014they\n\nconcern the \u201cidentity\u201d of alleged complainants (Topic 2), the substance of such complaints from\n\nthird parties (Topic 3), and the details of the DTPA investigation (Topics 4 & 8). These are factual\n\nmatters, and the attorney-client privilege \u201cprotects only communications, not the underlying facts.\u201d\n\nLeague of United Latin Am. Citizens v. Abbott, 342 F.R.D. 227, 232 (W.D. Tex. 2022).\n\n        The Stone declaration merely asserts that the Consumer Protection Division\u2019s investigative\n\nfile contains \u201c[m]any . . . materials [that] are attorney-client communications between Division\n\n\n                                                  -8-\n\f       Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 107         Filed 10/16/26      Page 10 of 12\n\n\n\n\nattorneys and Division personnel[.]\u201d Dkt. 101-2 \u00b6\u00b6 1-2. Such \u201cblanket assertion[s] of privilege\u201d\n\nare \u201csimply inadequate,\u201d U.S. v. El Paso Co., 682 F.2d 530, 541 (5th Cir. 1982), and do not\n\nestablish the \u201cextraordinary circumstances\u201d required to bar the deposition. Salter, 593 F.2d at 651;\n\nsee also Blockbuster Entm\u2019t Corp. v. McComb Video, Inc., 145 F.R.D. 402, 404 (M.D. La. 1992)\n\n(holding an \u201cunsupported assertion of [] privilege is not sufficient to support either quashing the\n\nnotice of deposition or a protective order\u201d). Instead, the Attorney General must object to particular\n\nquestions during the deposition. See Borden, Inc. v. Valdez, 773 S.W.2d 718, 720-21 (Tex. App.\u2014\n\nCorpus Christi-Edinburg 1989, no writ) (a deposition may not be avoided \u201cin its entirety merely\n\nbecause some matters may be privileged, but [the defending attorney] must object when those\n\ninquiries are raised during the deposition\u201d); West v. Solito, 563 S.W.2d 240, 246 (Tex. 1978)\n\n(same); see also League of United Latin Am. Citizens, 342 F.R.D. at 232 (following this approach\n\nand noting: \u201cWhether the attorney-client privilege attaches to an answer [] is fact-specific. In this\n\ncontext, that also means the applicability of the privilege is statement-specific\u201d) (citation omitted).\n\n        The Attorney General\u2019s remaining arguments are a dog\u2019s breakfast. Each fails:\n\n   \u2022    Work Product Doctrine. The work product doctrine is inapplicable because it \u201conly\n        protects documents and tangible things . . . and [] does not protect the disclosure of\n        underlying relevant facts.\u201d Blockbuster, 145 F.R.D. at 403; Ferko, 218 F.R.D. at 136; Fed.\n        R. Civ. P. 26(b)(3)(A).\n   \u2022    Deliberative Process Privilege. This \u201cprotects only those agency communications or parts\n        of agency communications that relate to the agency\u2019s policymaking\u201d as opposed to\n        investigative or enforcement decisions targeting a particular individual. City of Garland v.\n        Dallas Morning News, 22 S.W.3d 351, 364 (Tex. 2000) (emphasis added); accord Tex.\n        Att\u2019y Gen. Op. Ord. 615, 1993 WL 720210, at *4 (June 29, 1993). The Stone Declaration\n        describes \u201cinternal assessments of enforcement options,\u201d \u201cpre-decisional deliberations\n        about whether and how to investigate, charge, and resolve the matter,\u201d and \u201cinternal\n        evaluation of the evidence\u201d\u2014decidedly not policy matters. Dkt. 101-2 at 2 \u00b6\u00b6 2-3.\n   \u2022    Informer\u2019s Privilege. This privilege is \u201cnot absolute,\u201d United States v. Ortega, 854 F.3d\n        818, 824 (5th Cir. 2017), and \u201cmust give way when disclosure is essential to a fair\n        determination of a cause,\u201d balancing \u201cthe government\u2019s interest in nondisclosure against\n        the private litigant\u2019s interest in disclosure.\u201d In re Kleberg Cnty., Tex., 86 F. App\u2019x 29, 33\n        (5th Cir. 2004) (cleaned up). Here, where the investigation is civil, potential informants are\n\n\n\n                                                 -9-\n\f          Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 107        Filed 10/16/26      Page 11 of 12\n\n\n\n\n           institutional shareholders, and the investigation\u2019s target is Glass Lewis, the \u201csafety of the\n           informant\u201d is a non-issue, so the government\u2019s interest against disclosure is null. Id. at 34.\n           Meanwhile, discovery on Topic No. 2 is essential because Glass Lewis suspects no person\n           has complained about \u201cany statement by Glass Lewis.\u201d Dkt. 103-1 at 3. The Attorney\n           General may not use the privilege to hide that S.B. 2337 is based on \u201cmere speculation or\n           conjecture\u201d rather than \u201creal\u201d harms. Edenfield, 507 U.S. at 770-71.\n      \u2022    Law Enforcement and Investigative Privilege. This privilege \u201cprotect[s] government\n           documents relating to an ongoing criminal investigation.\u201d In re U.S. Dep\u2019t of Homeland\n           Sec., 459 F.3d 565, 570 (5th Cir. 2006). The DTPA suit against Glass Lewis is a civil\u2014\n           not criminal\u2014proceeding, and the Attorney General does not allege there is any related\n           criminal investigation. See Dkt. 101-2 at 3 \u00b6 5.\nIV.        The Attorney General Flouted Multiple Conference Requirements.\n           The Attorney General falsely certifies that he conferred in good faith as Local Rule CV-\n\n7(g) requires. Dkt. 101 at 12. In fact, he decided to file before there had been any opportunity to\n\nsubstantively confer. See LeBrun Decl. \u00b6\u00b6 4-7; Ex. 6 at 5, 7, 10. And, instead of conferring \u201cin\n\ngood faith about the matters for examination\u201d \u201c[b]efore or promptly after the notice . . . is served,\u201d\n\nFed. R. Civ. P. 30(b)(6), the Attorney General sandbagged, revealing his objections 20 days after\n\nservice and two business days before the deposition. LeBrun Decl. \u00b6\u00b6 4-5. This is an independent\n\nreason to deny the motion.\n\n                                             CONCLUSION\n\n           Glass Lewis requests that the Court deny the motion for protection, order the Attorney\n\nGeneral to make a representative available for deposition, and grant all other relief to which Glass\n\nLewis may be entitled.\n\n\n\n\n                                                   - 10 -\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 107           Filed 10/16/26   Page 12 of 12\n\n\n\n\nDated: October 16, 2026                      Respectfully submitted,\n\n                                             YETTER COLEMAN LLP\n\n                                             /s/ Bryce L Callahan\n                                             Bryce L. Callahan\n                                             State Bar No. 24055248\n                                             bcallahan@yettercoleman.com\n                                             Grant B. Martinez\n                                             State Bar No. 24104118\n                                             gmartinez@yettercoleman.com\n                                             Lily E. Hann\n                                             State Bar No. 24133836\n                                             lhann@yettercoleman.com\n                                             Jared LeBrun\n                                             State Bar No. 24144647\n                                             jlebrun@yettercoleman.com\n                                             600 Travis Street, Suite 5400\n                                             Houston, Texas 77002\n                                             (713) 632-8000\n                                             (713) 632-8002 (fax)\n\n                                             Attorneys for Plaintiff Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC\n\n\n                                      Certificate of Service\n\n       I certify that on October 16, 2026, a copy of this document was served on all counsel of\n\nrecord using the Court\u2019s e-filing system.\n\n\n\n                                                       /s/ Jared LeBrun\n                                                       Jared LeBrun\n\n\n\n\n                                              - 11 -\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2026-10-19T13:24:53.017154-07:00","document_number":"107","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"181037628727","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Response in Opposition to Motion","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497770991/","id":497770991,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/107/1/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-19T13:24:25.917091-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-19T13:24:25.917112-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":4,"file_size":201896,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"107","attachment_number":1,"pacer_doc_id":"181037628728","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Declaration of Jared LeBrun","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497770992/","id":497770992,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/107/2/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-19T13:24:26.028841-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-19T13:24:26.028862-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":6,"file_size":238107,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"107","attachment_number":2,"pacer_doc_id":"181037628729","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit 1","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497770993/","id":497770993,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/107/3/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-19T13:24:26.046109-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-19T13:24:26.046123-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":29,"file_size":1559733,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"107","attachment_number":3,"pacer_doc_id":"181037628730","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit 2","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497770994/","id":497770994,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/107/4/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-19T13:24:26.080423-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-19T13:24:26.080438-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":139,"file_size":792171,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"107","attachment_number":4,"pacer_doc_id":"181037628731","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit 3","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497770995/","id":497770995,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/107/5/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-19T13:24:26.988918-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-19T13:24:26.988933-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":21,"file_size":446341,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"107","attachment_number":5,"pacer_doc_id":"181037628732","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit 4","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497770996/","id":497770996,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/107/6/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-19T13:24:27.261695-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-19T13:24:27.261716-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":6,"file_size":171670,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"107","attachment_number":6,"pacer_doc_id":"181037628733","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit 5","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497770997/","id":497770997,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/107/7/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-19T13:24:27.482923-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-19T13:24:27.482943-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":11,"file_size":306912,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"107","attachment_number":7,"pacer_doc_id":"181037628734","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit 6","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497770998/","id":497770998,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/107/8/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-19T13:24:27.634722-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-19T13:24:27.634738-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":12,"file_size":271453,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"107","attachment_number":8,"pacer_doc_id":"181037628735","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit 7","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497770999/","id":497770999,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/107/9/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-19T13:24:27.780771-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-19T13:24:27.780785-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":1,"file_size":114557,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"107","attachment_number":9,"pacer_doc_id":"181037628736","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Proposed Order","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-16T17:06:05.409252-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-21T09:33:32.780192-07:00","date_filed":"2026-10-16","time_filed":"18:28:19","entry_number":107,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-10-16.001","pacer_sequence_number":406,"description":"Response in Opposition to Motion, filed by Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC, re 101 MOTION for Confidentiality/Protective Order MOTION to Stay RULE 30(b)(6) DEPOSITION filed by Defendant Ken Paxton (Attachments: # 1 Declaration of Jared LeBrun, # 2 Exhibit 1, # 3 Exhibit 2, # 4 Exhibit 3, # 5 Exhibit 4, # 6 Exhibit 5, # 7 Exhibit 6, # 8 Exhibit 7, # 9 Proposed Order)(Callahan, Bryce) (Entered: 10/16/2026)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/481453508/","id":481453508,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497197683/","id":497197683,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"","date_created":"2026-10-14T07:42:05.370931-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-14T07:42:05.370947-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-14T07:42:05.322852-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-14T07:42:05.322869-07:00","date_filed":"2026-10-12","time_filed":null,"entry_number":null,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-10-12.001","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"Text Order GRANTING IN PART AND DENYING IN PART 102 Defendant's Notice of Filing and Request for Expedited Consideration entered by Judge Susan Hightower. The Court ORDERS Plaintiff Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC and Defendant Ken Paxton, in his Official Capacity as Attorney General of Texas, to appear by Zoom at 9 a.m. Tuesday, October 13, 2026 for a status conference on Defendant's Opposed Expedited Motion for Protective Order and to Stay Rule 30(b)(6) Deposition. Counsel of record will receive a link to join the hearing from Courtroom Deputy Kyra Kelley. (This is a text-only entry generated by the court. There is no document associated with this entry.) (SH)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/481453505/","id":481453505,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497197680/","id":497197680,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"","date_created":"2026-10-14T07:42:05.052043-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-14T07:42:05.052059-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-14T07:42:05.018594-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-14T07:42:05.018612-07:00","date_filed":"2026-08-12","time_filed":null,"entry_number":null,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-08-12.001","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"Text Order GRANTING 98 Motion to Withdraw as Attorney; GRANTING 98 Motion to Substitute Attorney entered by Judge Alan D Albright. Before the court is Defendant's Unopposed Motion to Withdraw and Substitute Counsel. Upon due consideration of the motion, the Court is of the opinion that said motions is meritorious. IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that Defendant's Unopposed Motion to Withdraw and Substitute Counsel is GRANTED. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Charles Lee Winkelman be withdrawn as counsel and Joe Nwaokoro be substituted as lead counsel on behalf of Defendant. The Clerk is hereby directed to remove Mr. Winkelman from the service list in this matter and add Mr. Nwaokoro to same. (This is a text-only entry generated by the court. There is no document associated with this entry.) (BBlc)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/481364224/","id":481364224,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497104703/","id":497104703,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/105/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-13T13:10:50.089011-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-13T13:10:50.096590-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"105","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"181037590208","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Status Conference","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-13T13:10:50.067294-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-14T07:42:05.388806-07:00","date_filed":"2026-10-13","time_filed":"14:42:59","entry_number":105,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-10-13.001","pacer_sequence_number":402,"description":"Minute Entry for proceedings held before Judge Susan Hightower: Status Conference held on 10/13/2026 (Minute entry documents are not available electronically.). (Court Reporter zoon.)(pg) (Entered: 10/13/2026)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/481364205/","id":481364205,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/497104685/","id":497104685,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/106/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-13T13:10:49.280701-07:00","date_modified":"2026-11-13T19:03:08.752575-08:00","sha1":"754a96aea7bf467e3d9a140d3bffe46861e24e85","page_count":2,"file_size":94913,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.106.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.106.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"            Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 106     Filed 10/13/26      Page 1 of 2\n\n\n\n\n                       IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                        FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS\n                                  AUSTIN DIVISION\n\n    Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC,                          \u00a7\n                   Plaintiff                          \u00a7\n    v.                                                \u00a7               No. 1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n                                                      \u00a7\n    Ken Paxton, in his Official Capacity as           \u00a7\n    Attorney General of Texas,                        \u00a7\n                   Defendant\n                                                      \u00a7\n    The Texas Stock Exchange LLC and                  \u00a7\n    The Texas Association of Business,                \u00a7\n                  Intervenor-Defendants               \u00a7\n                                                      \u00a7\n                                                      \u00a7\n    Institutional Shareholder Services Inc.,          \u00a7\n                    Plaintiff                         \u00a7\n                                                      \u00a7               No. 1:25-cv-01160-ADA\n    v.\n                                                      \u00a7\n    Ken Paxton, in his Official Capacity as           \u00a7\n    Attorney General of Texas,                        \u00a7\n                   Defendant                          \u00a7\n    The Texas Stock Exchange LLC and                  \u00a7\n    The Texas Association of Business,                \u00a7\n                  Intervenor-Defendant                \u00a7\n\n                                                 ORDER\n\n         Before the Court is Defendant\u2019s Opposed Expedited Motion for Protective Order and to Stay\n\nRule 30(b)(6) Deposition, filed October 9, 2026 (Dkt. 101 in Case No. 1:25-cv-01153-ADA).1\n\n         On this day, the Court held a hearing on the motion at which Plaintiffs and Defendants in both\n\nconsolidated cases appeared through counsel.\n\n\n\n\n1\n The Honorable Robert Pitman referred the motion to this Magistrate Judge for disposition, pursuant to\n28 U.S.C. \u00a7 636(b)(1)(A), Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 72, and Rule 1(C) of Appendix C of the Local\nRules of the United States District Court for the Western District of Texas. Dkt. 104.\n\n\n                                                       1\n\f       Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 106      Filed 10/13/26      Page 2 of 2\n\n\n\n\n   As stated from the bench during the hearing, the Court ORDERS that Plaintiff Glass, Lewis\n\n& Co., LLC has until October 16, 2026 to file a response to the motion for protective order, and\n\nthat Defendant Ken Paxton, in his official capacity as Attorney General of Texas, has until\n\nOctober 21, 2026 to file a reply, if any.\n\n   The Court FURTHER ORDERS that the Deposition of the Office of the Attorney General\n\npursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 30(b)(6) and the deadline for Plaintiffs to supplement\n\ntheir motions for summary judgment are STAYED pending further order of the Court. The\n\ndeadline for all other Rule 56(d) discovery remains October 20, 2026. Dkt. 99 in Case No. 1:25-\n\ncv-01153-ADA; Dkt. 112 in Case No. 1:25-cv-01160-ADA.\n\n   SIGNED on October 13, 2026.\n\n                                                      SUSAN HIGHTOWER\n                                                      UNITED STATES MAGISTRATE JUDGE\n\n\n\n\n                                                  2\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2026-10-14T07:42:28.131289-07:00","document_number":"106","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"181037590224","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":true,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Order","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-13T13:10:49.255721-07:00","date_modified":"2026-11-13T19:03:08.731930-08:00","date_filed":"2026-10-13","time_filed":"14:43:41","entry_number":106,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-10-13.002","pacer_sequence_number":404,"description":"ORDER.  Signed by Judge Susan Hightower.  (pg)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/481240535/","id":481240535,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/496969760/","id":496969760,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"","date_created":"2026-10-12T12:17:54.648614-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-12T12:17:54.648626-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Order on Motion to Expedite","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-12T12:17:54.639431-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-12T12:17:54.639446-07:00","date_filed":"2026-10-12","time_filed":"14:12:44","entry_number":null,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-10-12.001","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/481173492/","id":481173492,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/496898621/","id":496898621,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/104/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-09T17:04:54.054202-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-09T17:04:54.073613-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"104","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"181037584304","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Order Referring Motion","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-09T17:04:54.017404-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-14T07:42:05.272717-07:00","date_filed":"2026-10-09","time_filed":"18:30:36","entry_number":104,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-10-09.004","pacer_sequence_number":396,"description":"ORDER REFERRING MOTION: 101 MOTION for Confidentiality/Protective Order MOTION to Stay RULE 30(b)(6) DEPOSITION filed by Ken Paxton. Signed by Judge Robert Pitman. Referral Magistrate Judge: Susan Hightower. (mlg) (Entered: 10/09/2026)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/481153254/","id":481153254,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/496877911/","id":496877911,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/103/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-09T14:07:46.530023-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-09T14:07:46.538328-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"103","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"181037582681","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Notice","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-09T14:07:46.498549-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-14T07:42:05.232501-07:00","date_filed":"2026-10-09","time_filed":"15:15:53","entry_number":103,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-10-09.003","pacer_sequence_number":392,"description":"NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT by Ken Paxton re 101 MOTION for Confidentiality/Protective Order MOTION to Stay RULE 30(b)(6) DEPOSITION (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit Plaintiffs Notice of Deposition of the Office of the Attorney General Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 30(b)(6))(Nwaokoro, Joseph) (Entered: 10/09/2026)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/481141055/","id":481141055,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/496865246/","id":496865246,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/101/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-09T13:07:18.936192-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-13T03:01:34.857208-07:00","sha1":"f4e18c5f219b81d28e1815bca258c7076abdae30","page_count":13,"file_size":262247,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.101.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.101.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 101        Filed 10/09/26      Page 1 of 13\n\n\n\n\n                            UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                             WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS\n                                   AUSTIN DIVISION\n\n GLASS, LEWIS & CO., LLC                 \u00a7\n      Plaintiff,                         \u00a7\n                                         \u00a7\n v.                                      \u00a7\n                                         \u00a7\n KEN PAXTON, in his Official Capacity as \u00a7\n                                                  Civil Action No.\n Attorney General of Texas               \u00a7\n                                                1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n        Defendant,                       \u00a7\n                                         \u00a7\n THE TEXAS STOCK EXCHANGE LLC            \u00a7\n and THE TEXAS ASSOCIATION OF            \u00a7\n BUSINESS,                               \u00a7\n        Intervenor-Defendants.           \u00a7\n______________________________________________________________________________\n\n DEFENDANT\u2019S OPPOSED EXPEDITED MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND\n                        TO STAY RULE 30(b)(6) DEPOSITION\n______________________________________________________________________________\n\n       Defendant Ken Paxton, in his official capacity as Attorney General of Texas, moves under\n\nFederal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(c) for a protective order relieving him of the obligation to\n\nrespond to Plaintiff Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC\u2019s (\u201cGlass Lewis\u201d) Rule 30(b)(6) deposition notice\n\nto the Office of the Attorney General (the \u201cOffice\u201d) on topics that seek the Office\u2019s investigation,\n\nits charging decision in a separate state enforcement action, its internal deliberations, and its\n\nenforcement motives. Defendant also asks the Court to rule on this motion before the noticed\n\nOctober 13, 2026 deposition date or, failing that, to stay the deposition pending its ruling. The\n\nmotion is supported by the accompanying declarations of Joe Nwaokoro (\u201cNwaokoro Decl.\u201d) and\n\nJohnathan Stone, Chief of the Consumer Protection Division (\u201cStone Decl.\u201d).\n\n                                       INTRODUCTION\n\n       Glass Lewis brought an as-applied First Amendment challenge to Senate Bill 2337, stating\n\nin its discovery objections that \u201c[e]xtensive discovery is neither warranted nor necessary\u201d to\n\n\n\nDefendant\u2019s Motion for Protective Order                                                          1\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 101        Filed 10/09/26      Page 2 of 13\n\n\n\n\nresolve it because the case turns on questions of law. (Pl.\u2019s Objs. & Resps. to Rule 30(b)(6) Notice\n\n2.) It then moved for summary judgment on that premise. (Pl.\u2019s Combined 56(d) Resp. 1.) Yet\n\nGlass Lewis now demands a corporate deposition of the Office into why the Attorney General\n\nacted, what he said publicly, whom he spoke with, and how he exercised his enforcement\n\ndiscretion. That discovery is improper for several independent reasons.\n\n       First, Glass Lewis itself maintains that this case turns on questions of law. Second, the\n\nOffice did not enact S.B. 2337 and has been enjoined from enforcing it against Glass Lewis since\n\nAugust 29, 2025, so the Office\u2019s motive and enforcement conduct cannot bear on the statute\u2019s\n\nvalidity. Third, governmental motive and enforcement process are irrelevant to an as-applied\n\nchallenge, and the communications sought are cumulative of discovery Glass Lewis has already\n\ntaken from the Intervenor-Defendants. Fourth, to the extent any topic could be answered only by\n\nthe Attorney General personally, it is an impermissible apex end-run that the Fifth Circuit has\n\nalready forbidden. Fifth, many of the topics do not seek S.B. 2337 material at all, but instead the\n\nconfidential civil-investigative-demand file and charging decision in a separate Deceptive Trade\n\nPractices Act action; and any remaining material tied to this case is privileged.\n\n                                        BACKGROUND\n\n       Glass Lewis challenges S.B. 2337 as unconstitutional as applied to its speech and has\n\nmoved for summary judgment. Defendant moved under Rule 56(d) to defer or deny that motion\n\npending discovery, and the Court deferred ruling so that limited discovery could proceed. (Order\n\n[Dkt. 90].) Discovery closes October 20, 2026, with supplemental summary-judgment briefing due\n\nOctober 30, 2026.\n\n       Glass Lewis has noticed a Rule 30(b)(6) deposition of the Office for October 13, 2026,\n\ndirected at the Attorney General\u2019s investigation of proxy advisors, his charging decision in the\n\n\n\n\nDefendant\u2019s Motion for Protective Order                                                          2\n\f       Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 101        Filed 10/09/26      Page 3 of 13\n\n\n\n\nparallel state action, his communications with the Legislature and third parties, and his public\n\nstatements. The topics include the Office\u2019s investigative file and civil investigative demand\n\n(\u201cCID\u201d) to Glass Lewis and the decision to file the state action.\n\n        The separate state action is State v. Glass, Lewis & Co., No. 471-04895-2026 (471st Dist.\n\nCt., Collin County), brought by the Consumer Protection Division under the Texas Deceptive\n\nTrade Practices Act (\u201cDTPA\u201d) by counsel who are not on this S.B. 2337 defense team. (Nwaokoro\n\nDecl. \u00b6\u00b6 2\u20133 & Ex. 1 (\u201cState Pet.\u201d) at 2, 12\u201313, 18.) The DTPA petition never pleads, cites, or\n\nrelies on S.B. 2337 and sets its own discovery-control plan and Collin County venue. (State Pet.\n\nat 1, 4.)\n\n                                      LEGAL STANDARD\n\n        Rule 26(c) authorizes the Court, for good cause, to issue an order protecting a party from\n\nannoyance, oppression, or undue burden or expense, including by forbidding the discovery or\n\nspecifying its terms. Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(c). Discovery is limited to matters relevant to a claim or\n\ndefense and proportional to the needs of the case. Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(1). The movant must make\n\n\u201ca particular and specific demonstration of fact\u201d in support of the order. Homeland Ins. Co. of N.Y.\n\nv. Clinical Pathology Lab\u2019ys, Inc., No. 1:20-CV-783-RP, 2022 WL 17421132 (W.D. Tex. Dec. 5,\n\n2022). Defendant makes that showing below and in the accompanying declarations.\n\nI.      By Glass Lewis\u2019s own account, this case turns on questions of law, and the deposition\n        it seeks is neither relevant nor proportional.\n\n        Glass Lewis has stated that \u201c[e]xtensive discovery is neither warranted nor necessary\u201d to\n\nresolve this as-applied challenge. (Pl.\u2019s Objs. & Resps. to Rule 30(b)(6) Notice 2.) On Glass\n\nLewis\u2019s own account, a deposition of the Office into the Attorney General\u2019s investigation,\n\ndeliberations, and motives is irrelevant to the legal questions presented and disproportionate to the\n\nneeds of the case. Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(1), (b)(2)(C). Defendants\u2019 own discovery from Glass Lewis\n\n\n\nDefendant\u2019s Motion for Protective Order                                                           3\n\f       Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 101         Filed 10/09/26      Page 4 of 13\n\n\n\n\n(Dkt. 52 & Ex. A) is not to the contrary: it seeks facts about Glass Lewis\u2019s reports and methods\n\nthat are uniquely in its possession, not the Office\u2019s deliberations.\n\nII.     The Office did not enact S.B. 2337 and has been enjoined from enforcing it, so the\n        Office\u2019s motive and enforcement conduct are irrelevant.\n\n        Glass Lewis\u2019s claim that S.B. 2337 is unconstitutional turns on the statute\u2019s requirements\n\nand operation as applied to Glass Lewis, not on the Office\u2019s conduct. The Office\u2019s motive and\n\nenforcement process are irrelevant as a matter of law because (i) the Office did not enact S.B.\n\n2337; the Texas Legislature did; and (ii) the Office has been enjoined from enforcing S.B. 2337\n\nagainst Glass Lewis since August 29, 2025. (Prelim. Inj. Order; Nwaokoro Decl. \u00b6 4.) The validity\n\nof S.B. 2337 as applied to Glass Lewis is tested by the statute\u2019s text and operation, not by the\n\nOffice\u2019s reasons for acting. Courts do not permit discovery that probes the reasons and \u201cmental\n\nprocesses\u201d of government decision-makers: \u201ctop executive department officials should not, absent\n\nextraordinary circumstances, be called to testify regarding their reasons for taking official actions,\u201d\n\nand agency decision-makers \u201cdo not subject themselves to discovery\u201d into those reasons \u201c[a]bsent\n\na strong showing of bad faith or improper behavior.\u201d United States v. Morgan, 313 U.S. 409, 422\n\n(1941); In re Off. of Inspector Gen., 933 F.2d 276, 278 (5th Cir. 1991); In re F.D.I.C., 58 F.3d\n\n1055, 1061 (5th Cir. 1995). Glass Lewis makes no such showing. Its discovery into why the Office\n\nacted and how it exercised enforcement discretion is therefore irrelevant to the as-applied question\n\nand disproportionate under Rule 26(b)(1), without regard to any privilege. Glass Lewis\u2019s contrary\n\ncharacterization of the CID is addressed in Part V below.\n\nIII.    Governmental motive and process are, in any event, irrelevant to an as-applied\n        challenge, and the communications sought are cumulative.\n\n        Glass Lewis\u2019s First Amendment challenge is resolved on the statute\u2019s requirements and\n\noperation as applied to Glass Lewis, not on the subjective motives or enforcement conduct of the\n\nOffice. The First Amendment \u201ctargets the operation of the laws . . . rather than merely the motives\n\n\nDefendant\u2019s Motion for Protective Order                                                             4\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 101        Filed 10/09/26      Page 5 of 13\n\n\n\n\nof those who enacted them,\u201d and \u201c[i]nnocent motives do not eliminate the danger of censorship.\u201d\n\nReed v. Town of Gilbert, 576 U.S. 155, 165, 167 (2015); see United States v. O\u2019Brien, 391 U.S.\n\n367, 383\u201384 (1968) (\u201cthis Court will not strike down an otherwise constitutional statute on the\n\nbasis of an alleged illicit legislative motive\u201d). Critically, motive is a dead end for Glass Lewis in\n\nboth directions: discriminatory motive \u201cis not an element\u201d of a First Amendment viewpoint claim,\n\nand the government\u2019s \u201cmotive for discriminating based on viewpoint is irrelevant.\u201d Frederick\n\nDouglass Found., Inc. v. District of Columbia, 82 F.4th 1122, 1144\u201345 (D.C. Cir. 2023). Because\n\nGlass Lewis need not\u2014and cannot\u2014prove the Office\u2019s motive to prevail, that motive is not a\n\nproper subject of discovery. \u201cDiscovery into motive is permissible only when the alleged . . .\n\nconstitutional violation turns on an unconstitutional motive.\u201d Penthouse Int\u2019l, Ltd. v. Meese, 939\n\nF.2d 1011, 1020 (D.C. Cir. 1991). Courts therefore enter protective orders barring depositions into\n\nthe government\u2019s reasons where, as here, \u201cthe personal views, intentions, etc.\u201d of the decision-\n\nmakers \u201cfall well outside the scope of appropriate discovery under [Rule] 26(b)(1).\u201d Evergreen\n\nTrading, LLC ex rel. Nussdorf v. United States, 75 Fed. Cl. 730, 730\u201331 (2007); cf. MC Trilogy\n\nTex., LLC v. City of Heath, No. 3:22-CV-2154-D, 2023 WL 8569018, at *5\u20136 (N.D. Tex. Dec. 11,\n\n2023).\n\n         Glass Lewis\u2019s own pleading confirms the point. It alleges viewpoint discrimination by\n\nreference to the Legislature\u2019s purposes, which the public legislative record answers (Second\n\nAmended Complaint (\u201cSAC\u201d) \u00b6\u00b6 109, 117), and it invokes the Attorney General\u2019s public\n\nstatements and the CID to establish standing, the Ex parte Young connection, vagueness, and its\n\nDormant Commerce Clause theory (SAC \u00b6\u00b6 87\u201399, 171, 178, 201). These uses depend on what\n\nthe statements and the CID say, not on why or how the Office produced them. Glass Lewis does\n\nnot identify any count on which the Office\u2019s internal deliberations are an element. Even if\n\n\n\n\nDefendant\u2019s Motion for Protective Order                                                           5\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 101         Filed 10/09/26      Page 6 of 13\n\n\n\n\nexecutive motive mattered, it would be shown, if at all, from the statements themselves, which\n\nDefendant has offered to authenticate, not through a deposition into the Office\u2019s deliberations.\n\n       The topics regarding why the Office acted, what it said publicly, whom it spoke with, and\n\nhow it exercised enforcement discretion do not seek information relevant to S.B. 2337\u2019s validity\n\nas applied to Glass Lewis, and are disproportional to the needs of this case. Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(1);\n\nUMG Recordings, Inc. v. Grande Commc\u2019ns Networks, LLC, No. A-17-CA-365-LY, 2018 WL\n\n4627276 (W.D. Tex. Sept. 26, 2018).\n\n       The coordination communications that Glass Lewis seeks from the Office are also\n\ncumulative. Glass Lewis served parallel Rule 30(b)(6) notices on the Office and on both\n\nIntervenor-Defendants, and both Intervenor-Defendants have agreed to designate a corporate\n\nwitness on the overlapping topic\u2014communications and coordination, before August 22, 2025,\n\namong the Intervenor-Defendants, the Office, Jones Day, the Alliance for Corporate Excellence,\n\nand any legislator concerning Glass Lewis or S.B. 2337. (TXSE Resps. & Objs. to Rule 30(b)(6)\n\nNotice, Topic 6; TAB Resps. & Objs. to Rule 30(b)(6) Notice, Topic 5.) Glass Lewis deposed the\n\nTexas Stock Exchange\u2019s designee on October 8, 2026, and noticed the Texas Association of\n\nBusiness\u2019s designee for October 9, 2026. Glass Lewis has had, or by the date of the noticed Office\n\ndeposition will have had, a full opportunity to examine both Intervenor-Defendants on the\n\noverlapping topic. Discovery that is \u201cunreasonably cumulative or duplicative\u201d or obtainable from\n\na more convenient or less burdensome source must be limited. Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(2)(C)(i). Glass\n\nLewis had the opportunity to obtain the substance of those communications from those witnesses\n\nand does not need a duplicative account from the Office. In any event, after reasonable inquiry the\n\nOffice is unaware of a person with non-privileged, personal knowledge of those communications\n\nwho is not also litigation counsel; the information reasonably available to the Office is held by\n\n\n\n\nDefendant\u2019s Motion for Protective Order                                                             6\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 101        Filed 10/09/26      Page 7 of 13\n\n\n\n\ncounsel in that capacity and is privileged or protected work product, so a designee could not testify\n\nto it without violating those protections. (Nwaokoro Decl. \u00b6\u00b6 7\u20138.) See Brazos River Auth. v. GE\n\nIonics, Inc., 469 F.3d 416 (5th Cir. 2006).\n\nIV.    To the extent the Notice seeks the Attorney General\u2019s personal motive and mental\n       impressions, it is an impermissible apex end-run.\n\n       \u201c[E]xceptional circumstances must exist before the involuntary depositions of high agency\n\nofficials are permitted.\u201d In re F.D.I.C., 58 F.3d 1055, 1060 (5th Cir. 1995). State attorneys general\n\nare high-ranking officials shielded from such burdens, and the Fifth Circuit has already granted\n\nmandamus barring an order compelling this Attorney General to testify. In re Paxton, 60 F.4th 252\n\n(5th Cir. 2023). Apex testimony is justified only where the information is unavailable from an\n\nalternate source, and even then only in the \u201crarest of cases.\u201d In re F.D.I.C., 58 F.3d at 1062; In re\n\nBryant, 745 F. App\u2019x 215 (5th Cir. 2018). Glass Lewis cannot carry that burden. The Office\u2019s non-\n\nprivileged legal positions are publicly available and can be articulated by counsel or an Office\n\nrepresentative on the Attorney General\u2019s behalf; his personal \u201cthoughts and statements\u201d about a\n\nmatter of public concern do not supply the unique knowledge that exceptional circumstances\n\nrequire. In re Paxton, 60 F.4th 252 (5th Cir. 2023). The apex doctrine\u2014reinforced by the settled\n\nrule that a court may not \u201cprobe the mental processes\u201d of a government decision-maker\u2014\n\nindependently bars what could come only from the Attorney General himself: his subjective\n\nenforcement motive and mental impressions. United States v. Morgan, 313 U.S. 409, 422 (1941).\n\nV.     The DTPA-action discovery is outside the scope of this case, confidential under Texas\n       law, and available only in the enforcement forum.\n\n       Several topics do not relate to S.B. 2337 material but instead seek testimony on the\n\nConsumer Protection Division\u2019s CID file, its investigators\u2019 work, and the chronology and charging\n\ndecision of the separate Collin County DTPA action. As stated above, whether S.B. 2337 is\n\nunconstitutional as applied to Glass Lewis turns on the statute\u2019s requirements and operation, not\n\n\nDefendant\u2019s Motion for Protective Order                                                           7\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA             Document 101      Filed 10/09/26      Page 8 of 13\n\n\n\n\non the existence, timing, scope, or results of a DTPA investigation. O\u2019Brien, 391 U.S. at 383; cf.\n\nMC Trilogy, 2023 WL 8569018, at *5.\n\n       Glass Lewis\u2019s pleading does not change the analysis. It alleges that the CID was an attempt\n\nto enforce S.B. 2337, relying on the CID for its vagueness and Dormant Commerce Clause\n\ntheories. (SAC \u00b6\u00b6 93, 171, 201.) But the CID is already in Glass Lewis\u2019s hands and in the record\n\n(Dkt. 31-1), and its content, on which all those theories depend, does not require anything from\n\nthe Division\u2019s investigative file. The CID issued on August 22, 2025, before S.B. 2337 took effect\n\non September 1, 2025, under Section 17.61 of the DTPA, an authority that predates S.B. 2337 by\n\ndecades (Nwaokoro Decl. \u00b6 5), and the Court\u2019s injunction relates solely to the enforcement of S.B.\n\n2337; it does not bar enforcement of other laws. (Order on Mot. for Clarification of May 15, 2026).\n\nGlass Lewis\u2019s characterization can be tested against the CID itself and the State\u2019s petition without\n\ndiscovery into the Division\u2019s file.\n\n       DTPA CID materials are confidential by statute. Material produced under a CID may not\n\nbe disclosed absent the producing person\u2019s consent or a court order for good cause. Tex. Bus. &\n\nCom. Code \u00a7 17.61(f). Federal common law governs privilege here, Fed. R. Evid. 501, but the\n\nstatute's confidentiality protection remains relevant to the Court's proportionality analysis under\n\nRule 26(b)(1). The Texas Supreme Court has recently reaffirmed the Attorney General\u2019s authority\n\nto investigate under the DTPA and the deference owed to that investigative process. Off. of Att\u2019y\n\nGen. v. PFLAG, Inc., 731 S.W.3d 301 (Tex. 2026). The producer-consent exception does not help\n\nGlass Lewis: it already possesses the CID, and what it seeks is the Office\u2019s investigative file and\n\nthird-party material. Glass Lewis is the defendant in the Collin County action and can avail itself\n\nof the discovery process in that case.\n\n\n\n\nDefendant\u2019s Motion for Protective Order                                                          8\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 101        Filed 10/09/26      Page 9 of 13\n\n\n\n\nVI.    The remaining sensitive material is privileged.\n\n       To the extent any topic reaches material genuinely tied to this case, it is privileged. The\n\nOffice\u2019s internal charging and policy deliberations fall within the deliberative-process privilege,\n\nwhich protects predecisional and deliberative executive materials and which courts in this District\n\nhave sustained over an agency\u2019s investigative and adjudicative file. De La Cruz v. Blinken, No.\n\n2:19-CV-22-AM-CW, 2021 WL 2709679, at *2\u20133 (W.D. Tex. Mar. 19, 2021). The Division\u2019s\n\ninvestigative file is separately protected by the law-enforcement privilege, which \u201c[f]ederal\n\ncommon law recognizes\u201d as \u201ca qualified privilege protecting investigative files in an ongoing . . .\n\ninvestigation.\u201d In re U.S. Dep\u2019t of Homeland Sec., 459 F.3d 565, 569 (5th Cir. 2006); Coughlin v.\n\nLee, 946 F.2d 1152, 1159\u201360 (5th Cir. 1991). These privileges, together with the informer\u2019s\n\nprivilege, are invoked through the Chief of the Consumer Protection Division. (Stone Decl. \u00b6\u00b6 2\u2013\n\n5.) The sponsor-communication topics intrude on the legislative privilege, which is \u201cnecessarily\n\nbroad,\u201d belongs to the legislators, and forecloses any judicial \u201cexpedition seeking to uncover a\n\nlegislator\u2019s subjective intent,\u201d \u201ceven when constitutional rights are at stake.\u201d La Uni\u00f3n del Pueblo\n\nEntero v. Abbott, 68 F.4th 228, 236, 239 (5th Cir. 2023). The Office neither waives nor asserts that\n\nprivilege for the legislators; it objects that these topics seek material the legislators alone may\n\ndisclose and that the Fifth Circuit has placed beyond discovery. Litigation strategy and\n\ncommunications among counsel for aligned parties, once litigation was anticipated, in furtherance\n\nof a common legal defense of S.B. 2337 are protected work product and subject to the common-\n\nlegal-interest privilege. Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(3); In re Santa Fe Int\u2019l Corp., 272 F.3d 705, 710\u201311\n\n(5th Cir. 2001). And contention-style topics improperly seek counsel\u2019s legal theories and mental\n\nimpressions rather than fact. Homeland Ins. Co., 2022 WL 17421132.\n\n\n\n\nDefendant\u2019s Motion for Protective Order                                                          9\n\f       Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA             Document 101       Filed 10/09/26    Page 10 of 13\n\n\n\n\nVII.    Good cause exists.\n\n        The Office\u2019s requested order is narrow and fact-specific. Specifically, Defendant requests\n\nan order (i) forbidding any deposition on Topics 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, and 9, which seek the Office\u2019s\n\nmotive, deliberations, third-party coordination communications, and the Consumer Protection\n\nDivision\u2019s confidential investigative and charging decisions; (ii) limiting Topic 6 to authentication\n\nof identified, non-privileged public materials by stipulation or sworn declaration under Rule\n\n26(c)(1)(C); and (iii) staying the noticed deposition until the Court rules. Any such authentication\n\nshall not waive, and shall be without prejudice to, any privilege or objection, including the\n\nattorney-client,   work-product,     deliberative-process,    common-interest,    law-enforcement,\n\ninformer\u2019s, and legislative privileges.\n\n        The requested order is narrow: it bars discovery into the Attorney General\u2019s personal\n\nmotive and mental impressions and confines discovery to the as-applied question actually\n\npresented, while leaving Glass Lewis free to pursue DTPA discovery in the appropriate forum. In\n\nthe alternative, and at a minimum, Defendant requests that the Court limit any deposition to non-\n\nprivileged facts bearing on the as-applied question; exclude the Attorney General\u2019s personal\n\nmotive and mental impressions and the Consumer Protection Division\u2019s investigative file and\n\ncharging decision; preserve the Office\u2019s privilege and statutory-confidentiality objections; and set\n\na reasonable limit on the duration of the examination. The accompanying declarations provide the\n\nparticular and specific showing Rule 26(c) requires: the separation of the DTPA matter and its\n\npersonnel, the impossibility of preparing a designee without disclosing the confidential\n\ninvestigative file and the Office\u2019s internal deliberations, the absence of any non-privileged\n\npercipient witness who is not also counsel, and formal invocation of the applicable privileges.\n\n(Nwaokoro Decl. \u00b6\u00b6 2\u20139; Stone Decl. \u00b6\u00b6 1\u20135.)\n\n\n\n\nDefendant\u2019s Motion for Protective Order                                                           10\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 101        Filed 10/09/26      Page 11 of 13\n\n\n\n\n       Defendant has offered to authenticate identified public statements by stipulation or sworn\n\ndeclaration and will confer in good faith on any residual scope. Because the noticed deposition\n\ndate falls before the October 20 close of discovery, Defendant asks the Court to stay it pending its\n\nruling under Rule 26(c) and requests a ruling, or an interim stay, before the October 13, 2026\n\ndeposition date. Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(c); see also Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(d)(2) (a party\u2019s failure to appear\n\nfor a noticed deposition is not sanctionable while its motion for a protective order is pending).\n\n                                          CONCLUSION\n\n       For these reasons, Defendant respectfully requests that the Court rule on this motion before\n\nthe October 13, 2026 deposition date or enter an interim stay of the deposition pending its ruling;\n\ngrant the motion and enter the accompanying proposed order; or, in the alternative, limit the\n\ndeposition as set forth above. Defendant further requests such other relief as the Court deems just.\n\n\nDated: October 9, 2026.                        Respectfully submitted,\n\n                                               KEN PAXTON\n                                               Attorney General of Texas\n\n                                               BRENT WEBSTER\n                                               First Assistant Attorney General\n\n                                               RALPH MOLINA\n                                               Deputy First Assistant Attorney General\n\n                                               WILLIAM D. WASSDORF\n                                               Deputy Attorney General for Civil Litigation\n\n                                               KIMBERLY GDULA\n                                               Chief, General Litigation Division\n\n                                               /s/ Joe Nwaokoro\n                                               JOE NWAOKORO\n                                               Attorney-in-Charge\n                                               Texas Bar No. 24032916\n                                               Assistant Attorney General\n                                               P.O. Box 12548, Capitol Station\n                                               Austin, Texas 78711-2548\n\n\nDefendant\u2019s Motion for Protective Order                                                             11\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 101          Filed 10/09/26    Page 12 of 13\n\n\n\n\n                                              (512) 979-5382 | FAX: (512) 477-2348\n                                              Joe.Nwaokoro@oag.texas.gov\n\n                                              Defendant Ken Paxton, in his official capacity as\n                                              Attorney General of Texas\n\n\n                             CERTIFICATE OF CONFERENCE\n\n       I certify that counsel for Defendant has conferred with counsel for Plaintiff regarding the\n\nsubject matter of this Motion in a good-faith attempt to resolve the dispute by agreement, as\n\nrequired by Local Rule CV-7(g).\n\n       Counsel for the parties conferred on September 29, 2026, regarding the scheduling and\n\nscope of the Rule 30(b)(6) deposition of the Office of the Attorney General. During that\n\nconference, counsel for Defendant advised that the Office had not committed to designating a\n\nwitness and would advise Plaintiff of its position during the week of October 9, 2026. By email\n\ndated September 30, 2026, counsel for Plaintiff confirmed that understanding, requesting that the\n\nOffice identify its representative, or confirm that it would not offer one, as soon as possible and\n\nno later than Friday, October 9.\n\n       On October 8, 2026, Defendant served its topic-by-topic objections and responses to the\n\ndeposition notice, and counsel for Defendant wrote to counsel for Plaintiff the same day identifying\n\neach topic at issue and the grounds for objection, and proposing several specific times to confer\n\non October 9, 2026. Plaintiff did not respond.\n\n       Despite these good-faith efforts, the parties have been unable to resolve the dispute, and\n\nthe relief requested in this Motion is therefore opposed.\n\n                                              /s/ Joe Nwaokoro\n                                              JOE NWAOKORO\n                                              Assistant Attorney General\n\n\n\n\nDefendant\u2019s Motion for Protective Order                                                          12\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA         Document 101        Filed 10/09/26     Page 13 of 13\n\n\n\n\n                               CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\n\n       I certify that on October 9, 2026, a true and correct copy of the foregoing was filed\n\nelectronically through the Court\u2019s CM/ECF system, which will send notice of electronic filing to\n\nall counsel of record.\n\n                                            /s/ Joe Nwaokoro\n                                            JOE NWAOKORO\n                                            Assistant Attorney General\n\n\n\n\nDefendant\u2019s Motion for Protective Order                                                      13\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2026-10-12T09:01:04.450833-07:00","document_number":"101","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"181037582015","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Protective Order AND Stay","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/496952130/","id":496952130,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/101/1/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-12T09:00:47.045534-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-13T03:53:37.270893-07:00","sha1":"1038a2b6cda113792ecc21e7c2e0d00795884ca3","page_count":25,"file_size":599709,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.101.1.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.101.1.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 101-1       Filed 10/09/26     Page 1 of 25\n\n\n\n\n                            UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                             WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS\n                                   AUSTIN DIVISION\n\n GLASS, LEWIS & CO., LLC                 \u00a7\n      Plaintiff,                         \u00a7\n                                         \u00a7\n v.                                      \u00a7\n                                         \u00a7\n KEN PAXTON, in his Official Capacity as \u00a7\n                                                     Civil Action No.\n Attorney General of Texas               \u00a7\n                                                   1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n        Defendant,                       \u00a7\n                                         \u00a7\n THE TEXAS STOCK EXCHANGE LLC            \u00a7\n and THE TEXAS ASSOCIATION OF            \u00a7\n BUSINESS,                               \u00a7\n        Intervenor-Defendants.           \u00a7\n______________________________________________________________________________\n\n DECLARATION OF JOE NWAOKORO IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT\u2019S MOTION\n                             FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER\n______________________________________________________________________________\n\n       I, Joe Nwaokoro, declare as follows:\n\n       1.      I am an Assistant Attorney General in the General Litigation Division of the Office\n\nof the Attorney General of Texas (the \u201cOffice\u201d) and counsel of record for Defendant. I am over\n\neighteen and competent to make this declaration. The facts below are based on my personal\n\nknowledge and on my review of Office records and inquiry of Office personnel in the course of\n\nmy duties. I make this declaration solely in support of Defendant\u2019s Motion for Protective Order;\n\nnothing in it waives any privilege or protection.\n\n       2.      The separate state action. The State of Texas, acting through the Consumer\n\nProtection Division of the Office (the \u201cDivision\u201d), filed State v. Glass, Lewis & Co., No. 471-\n\n04895-2026, in the 471st District Court of Collin County, Texas (the \u201cState DTPA Action\u201d). It\n\nasserts claims under Sections 17.46(a), (b)(5), (b)(7), and (b)(24) of the Texas Deceptive Trade\n\n\n\n\nDeclaration of Joe Nwaokoro ISO Defendant\u2019s Motion for Protective Order                        1\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 101-1         Filed 10/09/26    Page 2 of 25\n\n\n\n\nPractices Act, seeks relief under Section 17.47, and pleads no claim under Senate Bill 2337. A true\n\nand correct copy of the State\u2019s petition is attached as Exhibit 1.\n\n       3.      Separate counsel. The attorneys prosecuting the State DTPA Action are Assistant\n\nAttorneys General in the Division. None of them is counsel of record in this action or in No. 1:25-\n\ncv-01160-ADA, and none participates in the defense of S.B. 2337.\n\n       4.      No enforcement of S.B. 2337. S.B. 2337 took effect on September 1, 2025. The\n\nCourt\u2019s preliminary injunction issued on August 29, 2025. Since the injunction issued, the Office\n\nhas taken no step to enforce S.B. 2337 against Glass Lewis. I know this from my review of Office\n\nrecords and my inquiry of Division personnel.\n\n       5.      The CID. On August 22, 2025, the Division issued a civil investigative demand\n\n(the \u201cCID\u201d) to Glass Lewis. The Division\u2019s authority to issue civil investigative demands arises\n\nunder Section 17.61 of the Texas Business and Commerce Code and has existed for decades. The\n\nCID issued before S.B. 2337 took effect. Glass Lewis responded and produced materials, so it\n\nalready has the CID and its own production.\n\n       6.      The investigative file. The Division\u2019s investigative file concerning Glass Lewis\n\nconsists of internal investigative memoranda, the mental impressions and work product of Division\n\nattorneys and investigators, internal communications about enforcement and charging decisions,\n\nand information provided by third parties. It is maintained as confidential, and material produced\n\nunder the CID is held subject to Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.61(f). I describe the file based on\n\nmy review of Office records and my inquiry of Division personnel.\n\n       7.      Preparing a designee. Topic Nos. 2, 3, 4, and 8 of Plaintiff\u2019s Rule 30(b)(6) notice\n\nconcern complaints and referrals received, the Office\u2019s investigation of Glass Lewis, and the\n\nevents preceding the State DTPA Action. A designee could be prepared on those topics only by\n\n\n\n\nDeclaration of Joe Nwaokoro ISO Defendant\u2019s Motion for Protective Order                         2\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 101-1        Filed 10/09/26      Page 3 of 25\n\n\n\n\nreviewing the file described in Paragraph 6 and the Office\u2019s internal deliberations, and could not\n\ntestify to them without disclosing privileged and protected material.\n\n       8.      No non-privileged witness. Topic No. 5 seeks the Office\u2019s communications and\n\ncoordination with the Intervenor-Defendants, their counsel, and the Legislature concerning Glass\n\nLewis or S.B. 2337. Based on my inquiry, I am not aware of any person in the Office who holds\n\nnon-privileged personal knowledge of those communications and who is not also counsel for\n\nDefendant in this action or the State DTPA Action.\n\n       9.      Public statements. The public statements referenced in the notice are public\n\nrecords equally available to Plaintiff. The Office will authenticate identified statements by\n\nstipulation or sworn declaration.\n\n       10.     Privileges. The Office formally asserts the deliberative-process, informer\u2019s, and\n\nlaw-enforcement and investigative privileges over the material described in Paragraph 6 through\n\nthe accompanying Declaration of Johnathan Stone, the Chief of the Division, who is authorized to\n\ninvoke those privileges on the Office\u2019s behalf and has personally considered the file.\n\n       I declare under penalty of perjury under 28 U.S.C. \u00a7 1746 that the foregoing is true and\n\ncorrect.\n\n       Executed on October 9, 2026, in Houston, Texas.\n\n\n\n                                             /s/ Joe Nwaokoro________________\n                                             JOE NWAOKORO\n                                             Assistant Attorney General\n                                             Office of the Attorney General of Texas\n\n\n\n\nDeclaration of Joe Nwaokoro ISO Defendant\u2019s Motion for Protective Order                        3\n\fCase 1:25-cv-01153-ADA   Document 101-1   Filed 10/09/26   Page 4 of 25\n\n\n\n\n                   EXHIBIT 1\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 101-1         Filed 10/09/26 Filed:\n                                                                                 Page     5 of8:50\n                                                                                    7/13/2026   25AM\n                                                                               Michael Gould\n                                                                               District Clerk\n                                                                               Collin County, Texas\n                                                                               By Darcey Bursik Deputy\n                                                                               Envelope ID: 117238012\n                                       CAUSE NO:471-04895-2026\n                                                 _______\n\n STATE OF TEXAS,                                  \u00a7             IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF\n                                                  \u00a7\n                 Plaintiff,                       \u00a7\n                                                  \u00a7\n v.                                               \u00a7                  COLLIN COUNTY, TEXAS\n                                                  \u00a7\n GLASS, LEWIS & CO., LLC,                         \u00a7\n                                                  \u00a7\n                 Defendant.                       \u00a7             ________ JUDICIAL DISTRICT\n\n\nSTATE\u2019S ORIGINAL VERIFIED PETITION AND APPLICATION FOR TEMPORARY\n             RESTRAINING ORDER AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF\n\n\n        \u201c[C]onsistent and transparent governance decisions.\u201d Helping consumers make \u201cinformed\n\ndecisions with confidence.\u201d These are just some of the false representations Glass, Lewis & Co.,\n\nLLC (\u201cGlass Lewis\u201d) made to investors across the county, including investors in Texas, about\n\nGlass Lewis\u2019s investment advice. In fact, Glass Lewis prioritizes its own environmental, social,\n\nand governance (\u201cESG\u201d) agenda over the fiscal well-being of its clients. These false, deceptive,\n\nand misleading practices of advertising independent and objective advice while secretly\n\nprioritizing a private agenda violate the laws of Texas. As such, Plaintiff, the State of Texas, acting\n\nby and through the Attorney General of Texas, Ken Paxton, brings this action against Defendant\n\nGlass, Lewis & Co., LLC for violations of the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act-Consumer\n\nProtection Act, Texas Business & Commerce Code \u00a7\u00a717.41-17.63.\n\n                              I.    DISCOVERY CONTROL PLAN\n\n       1.      Discovery in this case should be conducted under Level 3 pursuant to Texas Rule\n\nof Civil Procedure 190.4. Restrictions concerning expedited discovery under Texas Rule of Civil\n\nProcedure 169 do not apply because Texas seeks non-monetary injunctive relief, and claims for\n\nmonetary relief including penalties, attorneys\u2019 fees and costs in excess of $1,000,000.\n\n\n                                                  1\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 101-1         Filed 10/09/26      Page 6 of 25\n\n\n\n\n                                        II.     PARTIES\n\n       2.      Plaintiff is the State of Texas, by and through the Consumer Protection Division of\n\nthe Office of the Attorney General of Texas.\n\n       3.      Defendant Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC (\u201cGlass Lewis\u201d) is a limited liability company\n\nwith its headquarters in San Francisco, California. The company is registered to do business in\n\nTexas with the Texas Secretary of State. Glass Lewis is one of two companies that possess a\n\ncombined share of greater than 90% of the proxy advisory market. Glass Lewis can be served\n\nthrough its registered agent for service of process located at 211 E. 7th Street, Suite 620, Austin,\n\nTexas 78701.\n\n                            III.    JURISDICTION AND VENUE\n\n       4.      This enforcement action is brought by the Attorney General of Texas, Ken Paxton,\n\nthrough his Consumer Protection Division in the name of the State and in the public interest,\n\npursuant to the authority granted to him by Section 17.47 of the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices\n\nAct (\u201cDTPA\u201d), on the ground that Glass Lewis has engaged in false, deceptive, and misleading\n\nacts and practices in the course of trade and commerce, as defined in and declared unlawful by,\n\nsections 17.46(a) and (b) of the DTPA. In enforcement suits filed under section 17.47 of the DTPA,\n\nthe Attorney General is authorized to seek civil penalties, redress for consumers, and equitable\n\nrelief in accordance with Texas Government Code Section 402.006(c).\n\n       5.      Texas courts may exercise personal jurisdiction over a nonresident entity if the\n\nTexas long-arm statute authorizes the exercise of personal jurisdiction and the exercise is\n\nconsistent with federal, and state constitutional due-process guarantees. State v. Yelp, Inc., 725\n\nS.W.3d 170, 181\u201387 (Tex. App.\u201415th Dist. 2025, pet. filed), Moki Mac Rivr Expeditions v.\n\n\n\n\n                                                 2\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 101-1         Filed 10/09/26      Page 7 of 25\n\n\n\n\nDrugg, 221 S.W.3d 569, 574 (Tex. 2007); see also Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code \u00a7 17.042 (Texas\n\nlong-arm statute).\n\n       6.      Jurisdiction is proper because Glass Lewis has established minimum contacts in\n\nTexas such that maintenance of this suit does not offend traditional notions of fair play and\n\nsubstantial justice. see Int\u2019l Shoe Co. v. State of Wash., Off. of Unemployment Comp. & Placement,\n\n326 U.S. 310, 316 (1945). Glass Lewis purposefully directs its activities toward Texas residents\n\nand purposefully avails itself of the benefits and protections of Texas law, by providing proxy\n\nadvisory services to Texas consumers; allowing access to its online platform in Texas; collecting\n\ndata and payments from Texas users; and otherwise entering into ongoing electronic transactions\n\nwith Texas residents. Texas\u2019 claims arise out of and relate to these contacts, including Glass\n\nLewis\u2019s deceptive and unfair practices that have injured Texas consumers.\n\n       7.      The Court has general jurisdiction over Glass Lewis because its contacts and\n\naffiliations with Texas are so continuous and systematic as to render them essentially at home in\n\nTexas. BMC Software Belg., N.V. v. Marchand, 83 S.W.3d 789, 797 (Tex. 2002). Glass Lewis has\n\nengaged in continuous and systematic business contacts with Texas, including by offering proxy\n\nadvisory services to Texas-based consumers.\n\n       8.      Additionally, the Court has jurisdiction over Glass Lewis because it consented to\n\npersonal jurisdiction by registering with the Texas Secretary of State for the transaction of business\n\nin Texas. See Mallory v. Norfolk S. Ry. Co., 600 U.S. 122 (2023); see also Acacia Pipeline Corp.\n\nv. Champlin Expl., Inc., 769 S.W.2d 719, 720 (Tex. App.\u2014Houston [1st Dist.] 1989, no writ) (\u201cIn\n\nreturn for the privilege of doing business in Texas, and enjoying the same rights and privileges as\n\na domestic corporation, Champlin has consented to amenability to jurisdiction for purposes of all\n\nlawsuits within the state.\u201d).\n\n\n\n\n                                                  3\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 101-1         Filed 10/09/26      Page 8 of 25\n\n\n\n\n       9.      Venue is proper in Collin County, Texas, under section 17.47(b) of the DTPA and\n\nTex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code \u00a7 15.002. Specifically, venue is proper because upon information\n\nand belief the cause of action arose, in substantial part, in this County and throughout Texas.\n\nDefendant\u2019s conduct \u2013 including offering its proxy advising services \u2013 constitutes transactions and\n\nevents occurring in this State, including within Collin County. See Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7\n\n17.47(b). In the alternative, because Defendant is a nonresident corporation, venue is proper in any\n\nTexas County under \u00a7 15.002.\n\n                                   IV.     PUBLIC INTEREST\n\n       10.     The State has reason to believe that Defendant has engaged in, and continues to\n\nengage in, the unlawful acts and practices described below. In addition, the State has reason to\n\nbelieve that Defendant has caused injury, loss, and damage to the State, and has caused adverse\n\neffects to the lawful conduct of trade and commerce, thereby directly or indirectly affecting the\n\npeople of this State. Therefore, the Consumer Protection Division of the Office of the Attorney\n\nGeneral initiates this proceeding in the public interest. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code Ann. \u00a7 17.47.\n\n                              V.         TRADE AND COMMERCE\n\n       11.     At all times described below, Glass Lewis and its agents have engaged or continue\n\nto engage in conduct that constitutes \u201ctrade\u201d and \u201ccommerce\u201d as defined in Section 17.45(6) of\n\nthe Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act as follows:\n\n       \u201cTrade\u201d and \u201ccommerce\u201d mean the advertising, offering for sale, sale, lease, or\n       distribution of any good or service, of any property, tangible or intangible, real,\n       personal, or mixed, and any other article, commodity, or thing of value, wherever\n       situated, and shall include any trade or commerce directly or indirectly affecting\n       the people of this state.\n\n\n\n\n                                                 4\n\f        Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                 Document 101-1           Filed 10/09/26    Page 9 of 25\n\n\n\n\n                                             VI.     ACTS OF AGENTS\n\n           12.      Whenever in this Petition it is alleged that Defendant did any act, it is meant that\n\nDefendant performed or participated in the act or Defendant\u2019s officers, agents, or employees\n\nperformed or participated in the act on behalf of and under the authority of Defendant.\n\n                                      VII.     FACTUAL ALLEGATIONS\n\nA.         Proxy Advising Companies Background\n\n           13.      This is a DTPA action against Glass Lewis, a highly influential proxy advisor, for\n\nmisrepresentations to its shareholder clients.                  Instead of providing objective and impartial\n\ninvestment advice, as advertised, Glass Lewis provides advice influenced by its own\n\nEnvironmental, Social, and Governance (\u201cESG\u201d) ideological considerations, apart from its clients\u2019\n\nbest financial interests.\n\n           14.      As owners of the companies in which they invest, shareholders possess governance\n\nrights permitting them to vote on important corporate decisions, such as executive compensation,\n\nelecting directors to the board, and ruling on proposals put forth by other shareholders. Harvard\n\nLaw School reports that the number of proposals presented to shareholders of Russell 3000\n\ncompanies increased approximately 730 percent between 2000 and 2024. 1\n\n           15.      Institutional investors\u2014such as pension plans, universities, mutual funds, or other\n\nasset managers who invest on behalf of some principal beneficiary\u2014must sift through the ever-\n\nincreasing amount of shareholder proposals and determine how to vote in their beneficiaries\u2019\n\nfinancial interest.\n\n           16.      These institutional investors hold approximately 70 percent of all public shares in\n\nthe United States, which typically makes their votes outcome determinative.                      Given that\n\n\n1\n    https://tinyurl.com/5f5v85yp (last visited June 30, 2026)\n\n\n                                                            5\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA          Document 101-1         Filed 10/09/26      Page 10 of 25\n\n\n\n\ninstitutional investors regularly hold shares in hundreds of companies, most become clients of a\n\nproxy advisor, such as Glass Lewis, who recommends how they should vote on the many\n\nshareholder voting proposals. Additionally, Glass Lewis offers a service whereby institutional\n\ninvestors can delegate voting authority to it based on its recommendations\u2014known as \u201crobo-\n\nvoting.\u201d\n\n       17.     Glass, Lewis, together with Institutional Shareholder Services, Inc., have a\n\ncombined share of greater than 90% of the proxy advisory market, making Glass Lewis half of a\n\nproxy advisor duopoly. These companies\u2019 recommendations, therefore, carry immense influence\n\nand the two companies sit at a center of power in terms of their ability to influence corporate\n\nbehavior.\n\n       18.     Glass Lewis\u2019s client base is vast and wields much power on shareholder votes. This\n\nclient base includes Texas residents\u2014both those who subscribe directly to Glass Lewis\u2019s services\n\nand those who receive such services through investment in funds and other vehicles, whose\n\nadvisors subscribe to Glass Lewis\u2019s services.\n\nB.     Glass Lewis\u2019s false, misleading, and deceptive representations regarding its proxy\n       voting guidelines\n\n       19.     Glass Lewis\u2019s advertising is deceptive as it fails to adequately inform clients of its\n\nESG initiatives. Specifically, the company incorporates these financially imprudent ideologies\n\ninto its \u201cBenchmark\u201d objective analyses, without providing empirical support for its preferences\n\nor emphasizing the opportunity costs to the investor\u2019s bottom line. By excluding financial analyses\n\nin these benchmark reports, Glass Lewis fails to show whether the ESG-oriented advice given was\n\nin clients\u2019 best financial interests. This is a violation of Glass Lewis\u2019s fiduciary duty as a proxy\n\nadvisor to provide such advice, as well as to Texas consumers who depend on such advice to grow\n\n\n\n\n                                                 6\n\f       Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                Document 101-1            Filed 10/09/26         Page 11 of 25\n\n\n\n\ntheir pensions and other investment accounts. It also stands in contrast to current financial market\n\nand political trends regarding ESG.\n\n\n\n\n                                   Figure 1: Screenshot from Glass Lewis\u2019s website\n\n           20.      Glass Lewis represents that it is \u201ca leading global provider of independent corporate\n\ngovernance research\u201d and that its policy recommendations are \u201cInformed by Research and Data.\u201d 2\n\nThe company boasts that it will help consumers \u201cEnhance Decision-Making with Consistent Proxy\n\nVoting Policies\u201d and make \u201cconsistent and transparent governance decisions.\u201d 3\n\n\n\n\n                               Figure 2: Screenshot from Glass Lewis\u2019s website\n\n           21.      But Glass Lewis\u2019s Benchmark Proxy Voting Guidelines tell a different story. Glass\n\nLewis states that its Benchmark policy \u201creflects broad investor opinion and widely accepted\n\n\n2\n    https://www.glasslewis.com/about-us (last visited June 30, 2026)\n3\n    https://www.glasslewis.com/investor-solutions/proxy-voting-policies (last visited June 30, 2026)\n\n\n                                                           7\n\f    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 101-1          Filed 10/09/26   Page 12 of 25\n\n\n\n\ngovernance principles and is intended to provide clients with nuanced analysis formation by\n\nmarket best practice, regulation, and prevailing investor sentiment.\u201d 4           While ESG-minded\n\nconsumers have the option to incorporate Glass Lewis\u2019s ESG and Climate Thematic Voting Policy\n\nGuidelines into their investment processes, the Benchmark analyses are apparently geared toward\n\nthe average consumer interested in pure financial gain. However, these \u201cBenchmark\u201d analyses\u2014\n\nsupposedly the most objective and ideologically neutral of all the company\u2019s sets of proxy voting\n\nguidelines\u2014incorporate financially imprudent ideologies without providing empirical support for\n\ntheir ESG-focused goals.\n\n        22.      For example, Glass Lewis claims in its Benchmark Proxy Voting Guidelines that\n\n\u201c[c]ompanies face significant financial, legal and reputational risks resulting from poor\n\nenvironmental and social practices,\u201d so \u201cin cases where the board or management neglected to\n\ntake action on a pressing issue that could negatively impact shareholder value, we believe that\n\nshareholders should take the necessary action in order to effect changes that will safeguard their\n\nfinancial interests.\u201d 5\n\n        23.      Glass Lewis\u2019s guidelines call for every board to establish a \u201cnominating and\n\ngovernance committee\u201d that is \u201creasonably diverse on the basis of age, race, gender, and\n\nethnicity.\u201d 6 Glass Lewis recommends voting against the entire board of directors and all director\n\nnominees up for election if the board does not have such a committee and \u201cthe board did not\n\nimplement a shareholder proposal that received requisite support.\u201d 7\n\n        24.      If a board has a nominating committee, Glass Lewis will continue to vote against\n\nthe chair of the nominating committee if the board is less than 30% gender diverse, or all members\n\n\n4\n  Glass Lewis 2026 Benchmark Policy Guidelines at page 7.\n5\n  See Glass Lewis 2025 Benchmark Policy Guidelines at page 84.\n6\n  See id. at page 23.\n7\n  See id. at pages 23-24, n.21.\n\n\n                                                      8\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 101-1        Filed 10/09/26   Page 13 of 25\n\n\n\n\nof the nominating committee of a board with no gender diverse directors. 8 For companies outside\n\nthe Russell 3000 index, Glass Lewis recommends voting against the chair of the nominating\n\ncommittee if there are no gender diverse directors. 9 Glass Lewis will also recommend opposing\n\nthe chair of the nominating committee unless the board includes a \u201cdirector from an unrepresented\n\ncommunity.\u201d 10\n\n        25.      Glass Lewis also typically recommends voting against the chair of a nominating or\n\ngovernance committee if the company\u2019s proxy statement fails to mention any of the following: (a)\n\nthe board\u2019s current percentage of racial and ethnic diversity; (b) whether the board\u2019s definition of\n\ndiversity fails to explicitly include gender and/or race and ethnicity; and (c) whether the board has\n\nfailed to adopt a policy requiring women and minorities to be included in the initial pool of\n\ncandidates when selecting new director nominees. 11\n\n        26.      On the environmental side of its ESG initiative, Glass Lewis also \u201cviews climate\n\nrisk as a material risk for all companies\u201d 12 and states that climate change \u201chas quickly become one\n\nof the most pressing issues facing companies and investors.\u201d 13 Accordingly, if a company does\n\nnot disclose oversight responsibility for \u201cclimate-related issues,\u201d Glass Lewis will recommend\n\nvoting against the chair of the governance committee. 14\n\n        27.      Glass Lewis\u2019s guidelines also lack transparency.        For example, Glass Lewis\n\nvaguely defines \u201csocial risk\u201d to include \u201cissues that adversely affect the company\u2019s\n\nstakeholders.\u201d 15 Glass Lewis states that it may recommend opposing the board \u201cwhen companies\n\n\n\n8\n  Id. at page 26.\n9\n  Id.\n10\n   Id. at page 41.\n11\n   Id. at page 42.\n12\n   Id. at page 30.\n13\n   Glass Lewis Scope 3 Emissions \u2013 Investor Primer at page 4.\n14\n   Glass Lewis 2025 Benchmark Policy Guidelines at page 30.\n15\n   See id. at 84-85.\n\n\n                                                        9\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 101-1           Filed 10/09/26        Page 14 of 25\n\n\n\n\nhave not provided for explicit, board-level oversight of environmental and social matters and/or\n\nwhen a substantial environmental or social risk has been ignored or inadequately addressed.\u201d16\n\nThe inclusion this subjective catch-all category as a means for complete opposition of a company\u2019s\n\nboard illustrates just one way in which Glass Lewis\u2019s guidelines lack transparency and can be used\n\nto further its own ESG-focused agenda. This is a far cry from the \u201cConsistent Proxy Voting\n\nPolicies\u201d that Glass Lewis advertises.\n\n        28.      But Glass Lewis\u2019s ESG-focused initiatives are distinctly different from current\n\nfinancial market trends. According to Oliver Wyman, a leading global management consulting\n\nfirm, in 2022, many ESG funds suffered a 3 to 4 percent underperformance compared with broad\n\nequity markets. 17 Yahoo Finance reported that in 2023, ESG funds faced their worst year on\n\nrecord. 18 Morgan Stanley reported that in 2024, traditional funds offered four times the return of\n\nsustainable funds. 19 In 2025, Europe saw a net withdrawal from ESG funds, with a $1.2 billion\n\noutflow in Q1, according to Morningstar. 20 Globally, sustainable funds recorded $8.6 billion in\n\nnet outflows in Q1 2025. 21\n\n        29.      What is more, Glass Lewis\u2019s ESG initiatives stand in contrast to current political\n\ntrends. For example, in January 2026, the United States withdrew from the Paris Agreement,\n\nwhich required signatories to publish and update emissions-cutting targets. 22 The United States\n\nhas also rescinded the Environmental Protection Agency\u2019s long-standing findings of contribution\n\nand endangerment, along with motor vehicle emissions standards based on those findings. 23 And\n\n\n\n16\n    Id.\n17\n    https://tinyurl.com/4b9unerv (last visited June 30, 2026)\n18\n    https://tinyurl.com/3fe85b3n (last visited June 30, 2026)\n19\n   https://tinyurl.com/43sfb344 (last visited June 30, 2026)\n20\n    https://tinyurl.com/yp9ewxwy (last visited June 30, 2026)\n21\n    Id.\n22\n    https://www.cfr.org/articles/united-states-exits-paris-agreement (last visited June 30, 2026)\n23\n    https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2026-02-18/pdf/2026-03157.pdf (last visited June 30, 2026)\n\n\n                                                       10\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA                 Document 101-1             Filed 10/09/26         Page 15 of 25\n\n\n\n\nthe United States Department of Energy reported in January 2026 that it had \u201cachieved record-\n\nhigh levels of output\u201d of domestic oil and gas production. 24 The United States has also issued\n\nstricter policies and regulations related to wind and solar power, such as pausing the leases for all\n\nlarge-scale offshore wind projects under construction 25 and eliminating subsidies for wind and\n\nsolar sources. 26\n\n         30.      It is clear from the aforementioned examples that Glass Lewis\u2019s commitment to\n\nESG initiatives goes against both financial market trends and political trends and is not made in\n\nthe best fiscal interests of its clients. Instead of basing its Benchmark guidelines on a rational\n\nanalysis of the effects that anticipated changes to government policy would have on any given\n\ncompany, Glass Lewis\u2019s actions resemble those of an ESG activist forcing companies to comply\n\nwith rules that governments will not otherwise adopt and that instead align with Glass Lewis\u2019s\n\nown views on society\u2019s environmental and social needs. And instead of fulfilling its duty to focus\n\non a client\u2019s financial interests, Glass Lewis incorporates these ESG initiatives into its Benchmark\n\nguidelines without sufficiently disclosing its agenda to the average company in search of pure\n\nfinancial gain.\n\n         31.      Glass Lewis\u2019s agenda becomes even more harmful in instances of \u201crobo-voting,\u201d a\n\nservice in which institutional investors follow the voting recommendations of a proxy advisor\n\nwithout engaging in an independent review of those recommendations. Glass Lewis\u2019s Benchmark\n\nPolicy Guidelines demonstrate why robo-voting cannot reflect a meaningful consideration of the\n\nproxy advisory firms\u2019 analyses. As stated above, vague definitions like \u201csocial risk\u201d can lead to\n\n\n\n\n24\n   https://www.energy.gov/articles/fact-sheet-delivering-us-oil-and-natural-gas-production (last visited June 30, 2026)\n25\n        https://www.doi.gov/pressreleases/trump-administration-protects-us-national-security-pausing-offshore-wind-\nleases (last visited June 30, 2026)\n26\n        https://www.whitehouse.gov/fact-sheets/2025/07/fact-sheet-president-donald-j-trump-ends-market-distorting-\nsubsidies-for-unreliable-foreign-controlled-energy-sources/ (last visited June 30, 2026).\n\n\n                                                         11\n\f       Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 101-1            Filed 10/09/26   Page 16 of 25\n\n\n\n\ncomplete opposition of a company\u2019s board. Moreover, the guidelines repeatedly reference that\n\nGlass Lewis makes some recommendations on a \u201ccase-by-case basis,\u201d without sufficiently\n\ndetailing the considering factors and how much weight is given to each considering factor. 27 Glass\n\nLewis does not sufficiently disclose to its clients the irreconcilable conflict between automated\n\nrobo-voting in accordance with the advisors\u2019 guidelines and \u201ccase-by-case\u201d assessments.\n\n                                        VIII. CAUSES OF ACTION\n\n     Violation of the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act, Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7\u00a7 17.46 et\n                                         seq. (\u201cDTPA\u201d)\n\n           32.       Texas incorporates the forgoing allegations as set forth fully herein.\n\n           33.       The Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act prohibits false, misleading, or deceptive\n\nacts or practices in the conduct of trade and commerce. As alleged herein and detailed above, Glass\n\nLewis has in the course and conduct of trade and commerce engaged in false, misleading, or\n\ndeceptive acts or practices declared unlawful by and in violation of Section 17.46(a) and (b) of the\n\nDTPA.\n\n Count 1: False, Misleading, or Deceptive Acts Regarding Glass Lewis\u2019s Representations to\n                         Consumers Regarding its ESG Initiatives\n\n           34.       Through false, misleading, or deceptive acts, either expressly or by implication,\n\nGlass Lewis misrepresents to Texas consumers advice influenced by its own ESG ideological\n\nconsiderations and apart from its clients\u2019 best financial interests.\n\n           35.       Through their false, misleading, or deceptive acts, Glass Lewis violated the\n\nfollowing DTPA sections:\n\n                 \u2022   17.46(a) which prohibits \u201c[f]alse, misleading, or deceptive acts or practices in the\n                     conduct of any trade or commerce;\u201d\n\n\n\n27\n     See, e.g., Glass Lewis 2025 Benchmark Policy Guidelines at 26 and 73.\n\n\n                                                         12\n\f    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 101-1         Filed 10/09/26      Page 17 of 25\n\n\n\n\n               \u2022   17.46(b)(5) which prohibits \u201crepresenting that goods or services have sponsorship,\n                   approval, characteristics, ingredients uses, benefits, or quantities which they do not\n                   have or that a person has a sponsorship, approval, status, affiliation, or connection\n                   which the person does not;\u201d\n\n               \u2022   17.46(b)(7) which prohibits \u201crepresenting that goods or services are of a particular\n                   standard, quality, or grade, or that goods are of a particular style or model, if they\n                   are of another; and\n\n               \u2022   17.46(b)(24) which prohibits \u201cfailing to disclose information concerning goods or\n                   services which was known at the time of the transaction if such failure to disclose\n                   such information was intended to induce the consumer into a transaction which the\n                   consumer would not have entered had the information been disclosed\u201d.\n\nCount 2: Failure to Disclose that Its ESG Initiatives are Not in Consumers\u2019 Best Financial\n                                         Interests\n\n         36.       Texas Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.46(b)(24) provides that \u201cfalse, misleading, or\n\ndeceptive acts or practices\u201d includes \u201cfailing to disclose information concerning goods or services\n\nwhich was known at the time of the transaction if such failure to disclose such information was\n\nintended to induce the consumer into a transaction into which the consumer would not have entered\n\nhad the information been disclosed.\u201d\n\n         37.       Glass Lewis engaged and continues to engage in false, misleading, and deceptive\n\nacts when it fails to disclose to Texas consumers that the ESG initiatives it prioritizes are not in its\n\ncustomers\u2019 best financial interests. By withholding this information, Glass Lewis intends to induce\n\nTexas consumers into transactions they would not have entered had Glass Lewis disclosed this\n\ninformation.\n\n         38.       In doing so, Glass Lewis violated Section 17.46(b)(24) of the DTPA.\n\n   IX.     TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER AND TEMPORARY INJUNCTION\n\n         39.       Texas incorporates the foregoing allegations as if set forth fully herein.\n\n\n\n\n                                                    13\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA              Document 101-1           Filed 10/09/26        Page 18 of 25\n\n\n\n\n         40.     Generally, an applicant for a temporary restraining order or temporary injunction\n\nmust plead and prove (1) a cause of action against the defendant; (2) a probable right to the relief\n\nsought; and (3) a probable, imminent, and irreparable injury in the interim. 28\n\n         41.     However, \u201c[w]hen an applicant relies upon a statutory source for injunctive relief .\n\n. . the statute\u2019s express language supersedes the common law injunctive relief elements such as\n\nimminent harm or irreparable injury and lack of an adequate remedy at law.\u201d 29\n\n         42.     The Texas Supreme Court has held that \u201cwhen it is determined that [a] statute is\n\nbeing violated, it is within the province of the district court to restrain it\u201d so \u201c[t]he doctrine of\n\nbalancing the equities has no application to this statutorily authorized injunctive relief.\u201d 30\n\n         43.     Under the DTPA, Texas need only prove the following to obtain a temporary\n\nrestraining order and temporary injunction against Glass Lewis: (1) that the Attorney General has\n\nreason to believe it is engaging in, has engaged in, or is about to engage in any act or practice\n\ndeclared to be unlawful by the DTPA, and (2) that proceedings would be in the public interest. 31\n\n         44.     This Court may issue a temporary restraining order with or without notice to the\n\nopposing party. 32\n\n         45.     Whether to grant a temporary restraining order or temporary injunction rests with\n\na trial court\u2019s sound discretion. 33\n\n\n\n\n28\n     Butnaru v. Ford Motor Co., 84 S.W.3d 198, 204 (Tex. 2002); Polston v. State, No. 03-20-00130-CV, 2022 WL\n     91974, at *3 (Tex. App.\u2014Austin Jan. 6, 2022, no pet.); Trove v. Scott, No. 03-99-00118-CV, 1999 WL 546997,\n     at *1 (Tex. App.\u2014Austin July 29, 1999, no pet.) (not designated for publication); Tex. R. Civ. P. 680.\n29\n     West v. State, 212 S.W.3d 513, 519 (Tex.App.\u2014Austin 2006, no pet.).\n30\n     State v. Texas Pet Foods, Inc., 591 S.W.2d 800, 805 (Tex. 1979).\n31\n     Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.47(a).\n32\n     See Tex. R. Civ. P. 680-81.\n33\n     In re MetroPCS Communications, Inc., 391 S.W.3d 329, 336 (Tex. App.\u2014Dallas 2013, no pet.); Butnaru, 84\n     S.W.3d at 204.\n\n\n                                                      14\n\f     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 101-1       Filed 10/09/26      Page 19 of 25\n\n\n\n\n         46.      The Attorney General is charged with pursuing an action for a temporary\n\nrestraining order, temporary injunction, or permanent injunction to prevent and restrain any\n\nviolations of DTPA section 17.46(a)\u2013(b).\n\n         47.      The list of deceptive acts in section 17.46(b) is non-exhaustive and a restraining\n\norder is appropriate if Defendant engaged in any \u201c[f]alse, misleading, or deceptive act[] or\n\npractice[].\u201d 34\n\n         48.      The Attorney General has reason to believe that Glass Lewis is engaging in, has\n\nengaged in, or is about to engage in any act or practice declared to be unlawful by the DTPA and\n\nthat a temporary restraining order and thereafter temporary injunction would be in the public\n\ninterest. Consequently, this Court should immediately enter a temporary restraining order\n\nenjoining Glass Lewis from failing to disclose its ESG initiatives to Texas consumers.\n\n         49.      The State requests the Court set a hearing for a temporary injunction and that, after\n\nnotice and hearing, Glass Lewis be temporarily enjoined from continuing the alleged violative\n\nconduct detailed herein pending a final trial.\n\n         50.      The State requests that the Clerk of the court issue such Writs of Injunction pursuant\n\nto any injunctive order issued by this Court in conformity with the law, and that the same be issued\n\nand be effective without the execution and filing of a bond, as the State is exempt from such bonds\n\nunder Texas Business and Commerce Code \u00a7 17.47(b).\n\n                                         X.   CIVIL PENALTIES\n\n         51.      Texas incorporates the foregoing allegations as if set forth fully herein.\n\n         52.      The State of Texas is entitled to recover up to $10,000 for each violation of the\n\nDTPA. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.47(c)(1).\n\n\n34\n     Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.46(a).\n\n\n                                                   15\n\f    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 101-1          Filed 10/09/26     Page 20 of 25\n\n\n\n\n       53.      Section 17.47(g) of the Texas Business & Commerce Code describes six factors\n\nthat the trier of fact \u201cshall consider\u201d when determining the amount of civil penalties to impose:\n\n             (1) The seriousness of the violation, including the nature, circumstances, extent, and\n\n                gravity of any prohibited act or practice;\n\n             (2) The history of previous violations;\n\n             (3) The amount necessary to deter future violations;\n\n             (4) The economic effect on the person against whom the penalty is to be assessed;\n\n             (5) Knowledge of the illegality of the act or practice; and\n\n             (6) Any other matter that justice may require.\n\n       54.      Glass Lewis\u2019s current financial situation must also be considered by the jury when\n\ndetermining civil penalties to impose. See Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.47(g)(3)\u2013(4), (6).\n\n       55.      Texas is not required to allege injuries to bring claims seeking civil penalties under\n\nthe DTPA. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.47(a) (creating a cause of action \u201c[w]henever the\n\nconsumer protection division has reason to believe that any person is engaging in, has engaged in,\n\nor is about to engage in any act or practice declared to be unlawful by [the DTPA]\u2026\u201d); see e.g.\n\nHolzman v. State, No. 13-11-00168-CV, 2013 WL 398935, at *3 (Tex. App.\u2014Corpus Christi\n\n2013, pet. denied) (\u201cMoreover, it is not necessary for the State to allege any injury to a [consumer]\n\nto recover the civil penalties it seeks in its live petition.\u201d); see also Texas v. Colony Ridge, Inc.,\n\nCivil Case No. CV-H-24-0941, 2024 WL 4553111, at *8 (S.D. Tex. 2024) (same).\n\n                            XI.     DEMAND FOR TRIAL BY JURY\n\n       56.      The State demands a jury trial and tenders the appropriate fee with this petition.\n\n\n\n\n                                                  16\n\f    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA               Document 101-1      Filed 10/09/26         Page 21 of 25\n\n\n\n\n                                  XII.     PRAYER FOR RELIEF\n\n       57.      In addition to a temporary restraining order, temporary injunction, and permanent\n\ninjunction, Texas claims entitlement to monetary relief in an amount greater than $1,000,000.00,\n\nincluding civil penalties, reasonable attorneys\u2019 fees, litigation expenses, and costs.\n\n\n                          XIII. RIGHT TO ISSUE WITHOUT BOND\n\n       58.      The State requests that the Clerk of the Court issue such Writs of Injunction\n\npursuant to any Injunction issued by this Court in conformity with the law, and that the same be\n\nissued and be effective without the execution and filing of a bond, as the State is exempt from such\n\nbonds under \u00a7 17.47(b) of the Texas Business and Commerce Code.\n\n\n                                           XIV. PRAYER\n\n       The State respectfully requests that the Court enter a final judgment in its favor and issue\n\nan order for the following:\n\n       a. Finding that Defendant has violated \u00a7\u00a7 17.46(a) and (b) of the DTPA by engaging in\n\n             the false, misleading, or deceptive acts or practices alleged above;\n\n       b. Requiring Defendant to pay civil penalties of up to $10,000 per violation of the DTPA\n\n             as authorized by Tex. Bus. & Com. Code \u00a7 17.47 (c)(1);\n\n       c. Enter a temporary restraining order prohibiting Glass Lewis from continuing to provide\n\n             proxy advising service that are made by considering ESG initiatives;\n\n       d. Enter a temporarily and thereafter permanently enjoining Defendant from engaging in\n\n             the above acts, practices, and conduct in trade or any other practice in violation of the\n\n             DTPA, such injunctive relief being authorized by \u00a7 17.47 of the DTPA; including but\n\n             not limited to:\n\n\n\n                                                  17\n\fCase 1:25-cv-01153-ADA       Document 101-1        Filed 10/09/26        Page 22 of 25\n\n\n\n\n     1) Order Glass Lewis to make clear and conspicuous representations to U.S.\n\n        consumers that its proxy advising services are not made from a purely financial\n\n        standpoint and focus heavily on ESG initiatives;\n\n     2) Enjoin Glass Lewis from providing proxy advisory services without providing\n\n        customers with a clear and conspicuous notice of Glass Lewis\u2019s focus on ESG\n\n        initiatives;\n\n  e. Requiring Defendant to pay all attorneys\u2019 fees and costs for the prosecution and\n\n     investigation of this action, as authorized by Tex. Gov\u2019t Code Ann. \u00a7402.006(c); and\n\n  f. Ordering that the State be awarded any further relief to which it demonstrates\n\n     entitlement under the law.\n\n\n                                      Respectfully submitted,\n\n                                      KEN PAXTON\n                                      Attorney General of Texas\n\n                                      BRENT WEBSTER\n                                      First Assistant Attorney General\n\n                                      RALPH MOLINA\n                                      Deputy First Assistant Attorney General\n\n                                      AUSTIN KINGHORN\n                                      Deputy Attorney General for Civil Litigation\n\n                                      JOHNATHAN STONE\n                                      Chief, Consumer Protection Division\n\n                                      /s/Scott Froman\n                                      LAUREN MCGEE\n                                      State Bar No. 24128835\n                                      Assistant Attorney General\n                                      Tel: (512) 475-3203\n                                      Lauren.Mcgee@oag.texas.gov\n                                      SCOTT FROMAN\n                                      State Bar No. 24122079\n\n\n                                        18\n\fCase 1:25-cv-01153-ADA   Document 101-1   Filed 10/09/26   Page 23 of 25\n\n\n\n\n                               Assistant Attorney General\n                               Tel: (512) 463-1264\n                               Scott.Froman@oag.texas.gov\n                               Office Of The Attorney General Of Texas\n                               Consumer Protection Division\n                               P.O. Box 12548, MC-010\n                               Austin, Texas 78711-2548\n                               Tel: (512) 463-2185\n                               Fax: (512) 473-8301\n\n                               ATTORNEYS FOR THE STATE OF TEXAS\n\n\n\n\n                                 19\n\f    Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA              Document 101-1     Filed 10/09/26      Page 24 of 25\n\n\n\n\n                                          VERIFICATION\n\n       Pursuant to Tex. Civ. Rem. & Prac. Code \u00a7 132.001(f), Scott Froman submits this unsworn\n\ndeclaration in lieu of a written sworn declaration, verification, certification, oath, or affidavit\n\nrequired by Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 682. I am an employee of the following governmental\n\nagency: Texas Office of the Attorney General. I am executing this declaration as part of my\n\nassigned duties and responsibilities.\n\n       I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.\n\n       Executed in Travis County, State of Texas, on the 10th day of July, 2026.\n\n\n\n                                               /s/ Scott Froman\n                                               Scott Froman\n\n\n\n\n                                                20\n\f        Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA       Document 101-1           Filed 10/09/26    Page 25 of 25\n\n                         Automated Certificate of eService\nThis automated certificate of service was created by the efiling system.\nThe filer served this document via email generated by the efiling system\non the date and to the persons listed below. The rules governing\ncertificates of service have not changed. Filers must still provide a\ncertificate of service that complies with all applicable rules.\n\nZoann Willis on behalf of Scott Froman\nBar No. 24122079\nzoann.willis@oag.texas.gov\nEnvelope ID: 117238012\nFiling Code Description: Plaintiff's Original Petition (OCA)\nFiling Description: State's Original Verified Petition and Application for\nTemporary Restraining Order and Injunctive Relief\nStatus as of 7/13/2026 9:15 AM CST\n\nCase Contacts\n\nName               BarNumber Email                             TimestampSubmitted     Status\n\nScott Froman                 scott.froman@oag.texas.gov        7/13/2026 8:50:45 AM   SENT\n\nLauren McGee                 lauren.mcgee@oag.texas.gov        7/13/2026 8:50:45 AM   SENT\n\nLupita Rodriguez             lupita.rodriguez@oag.texas.gov    7/13/2026 8:50:45 AM   SENT\n\nMelinda Pate                 melinda.pate@oag.texas.gov        7/13/2026 8:50:45 AM   SENT\n\nZoann Willis                 zoann.willis@oag.texas.gov        7/13/2026 8:50:45 AM   SENT\n\nJohnathan Stone              johnathan.stone@oag.texas.gov     7/13/2026 8:50:45 AM   SENT\n\nJerry Bergman                jerry.bergman@oag.texas.gov       7/13/2026 8:50:45 AM   SENT\n\f","ocr_status":1,"date_upload":"2026-10-12T09:01:05.568976-07:00","document_number":"101","attachment_number":1,"pacer_doc_id":"181037582016","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit DECLARATION OF JOE NWAOKORO IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR PROTECTI","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/496952131/","id":496952131,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/101/2/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-12T09:00:47.154748-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-13T03:53:47.559331-07:00","sha1":"db6ccb81ba79b77df3a24e6e3dab5876b8604e28","page_count":3,"file_size":167855,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.101.2.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.101.2.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA            Document 101-2        Filed 10/09/26      Page 1 of 3\n\n\n\n\n                            UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                             WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS\n                                   AUSTIN DIVISION\n\n GLASS, LEWIS & CO., LLC                 \u00a7\n      Plaintiff,                         \u00a7\n                                         \u00a7\n v.                                      \u00a7\n                                         \u00a7\n KEN PAXTON, in his Official Capacity as \u00a7\n                                                      Civil Action No.\n Attorney General of Texas               \u00a7\n                                                    1:25-cv-01153-ADA\n        Defendant,                       \u00a7\n                                         \u00a7\n THE TEXAS STOCK EXCHANGE LLC            \u00a7\n and THE TEXAS ASSOCIATION OF            \u00a7\n BUSINESS,                               \u00a7\n        Intervenor-Defendants.           \u00a7\n______________________________________________________________________________\n\n DECLARATION OF JOHNATHAN STONE ASSERTING PRIVILEGES IN SUPPORT\n                OF DEFENDANT\u2019S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER\n______________________________________________________________________________\n\n       I, Johnathan Stone, declare as follows:\n\n       1.      I am the Chief of the Consumer Protection Division of the Office of the Attorney\n\nGeneral of Texas (the \u201cOffice\u201d and the \u201cDivision\u201d). I am over eighteen and competent to make\n\nthis declaration. The Attorney General has authorized me to assert, on the Office\u2019s behalf, the\n\nprivileges stated below. I make this declaration from personal knowledge and my personal review\n\nof the Division\u2019s investigative file concerning Glass, Lewis & Co., LLC (\u201cGlass Lewis\u201d) and of\n\nthe topics in Plaintiff\u2019s Rule 30(b)(6) notice. Production of these materials, or testimony on Topic\n\nNos. 2, 3, 4, and 8 of that notice, would necessarily disclose the privileged materials described\n\nbelow, and no non-privileged percipient witness outside counsel could testify on those subjects\n\nwithout revealing the Division\u2019s deliberations, informant identities, or investigative strategy.\n\n       2.      The materials over which I assert these privileges are the Division\u2019s investigative\n\nfile concerning Glass Lewis and the Division\u2019s internal deliberations about it. The file consists of\n\n\nDeclaration of Johnathan Stone Asserting Privileges ISO Defendant\u2019s Motion for Protective          1\nOrder\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 101-2         Filed 10/09/26      Page 2 of 3\n\n\n\n\ninternal investigative memoranda; the mental impressions, analyses, and work product of Division\n\nattorneys and investigators; records of the Division\u2019s pre-decisional deliberations about whether\n\nand how to investigate, charge, and resolve the matter; and information furnished by third parties,\n\ntogether with documents that would tend to identify them. Many of these materials are attorney-\n\nclient communications between Division attorneys and Division personnel, and attorney work\n\nproduct prepared in anticipation of enforcement and litigation. The Division maintains these\n\nmaterials as confidential, and material produced under its civil investigative demand is held subject\n\nto Section 17.61(f) of the Texas Business and Commerce Code, which permits disclosure only\n\nwith the producing party\u2019s consent or on a court order for good cause. The Division has not\n\nreceived such consent for disclosure in this action.\n\n       3.      I assert the deliberative-process privilege over the materials described in Paragraph\n\n2 that are both pre-decisional and deliberative, including internal assessments of enforcement\n\noptions and recommendations preceding the Division\u2019s decisions. Compelled disclosure would\n\nreveal the Division\u2019s decision paths, the options it weighed and rejected, and its internal evaluation\n\nof the evidence, and would chill the candid, pre-decisional analysis on which sound enforcement\n\nand charging decisions depend.\n\n       4.      I assert the informer\u2019s privilege over the identities of persons who furnished\n\ninformation to the Division about Glass Lewis, and over documents that would tend to reveal them.\n\nThis assertion does not extend to the Alliance for Corporate Excellence, whose identity the Office\n\nhas disclosed; that disclosure does not waive the privilege as to any other informant or as to the\n\ncontent of any communication, including communications whose content reflects the Division\u2019s\n\nwork product or investigative strategy.\n\n\n\n\nDeclaration of Johnathan Stone Asserting Privileges ISO Defendant\u2019s Motion for Protective          2\nOrder\n\f      Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA           Document 101-2          Filed 10/09/26      Page 3 of 3\n\n\n\n\n       5.      I assert the law-enforcement and investigative privilege over the materials\n\ndescribed in Paragraph 2. State v. Glass, Lewis & Co., No. 471-04895-2026 (471st Dist. Ct., Collin\n\nCounty), is pending, and disclosure would reveal the Division\u2019s investigative scope, priorities, and\n\ntechniques, and its cooperating sources, would prejudice that pending action, and would deter\n\nfuture informants and third-party cooperation, impairing the Division\u2019s law-enforcement function.\n\nI have considered whether any reasonably segregable, non-privileged factual portions could be\n\nproduced; in this file, factual material is intertwined with the attorneys\u2019 evaluative analysis and the\n\nDivision\u2019s investigative strategy, such that producing it would reveal protected deliberation or\n\nenforcement direction.\n\n       6.      The Office has not waived and does not waive these privileges, and nothing\n\nproduced or stated in this action is intended to do so.\n\n       I declare under penalty of perjury under 28 U.S.C. \u00a7 1746 that the foregoing is true and\n\ncorrect.\n\n       Executed on October 8, 2026, in Austin, Texas.\n\n\n\n                                               /s/ Johnathan Stone\n                                               Johnathan Stone\n                                               Chief\n                                               Consumer Protection Division\n                                               Office of the Attorney General of Texas\n\n\n\n\nDeclaration of Johnathan Stone Asserting Privileges ISO Defendant\u2019s Motion for Protective           3\nOrder\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2026-10-12T09:01:06.192836-07:00","document_number":"101","attachment_number":2,"pacer_doc_id":"181037582017","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit DECLARATION OF JOHNATHAN STONE ASSERTING PRIVILEGES IN SUPPORT OF DEFEND","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/496952132/","id":496952132,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/101/3/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-12T09:00:47.177883-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-12T09:00:47.177898-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":2,"file_size":137161,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"101","attachment_number":3,"pacer_doc_id":"181037582018","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Proposed Order","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-09T13:07:18.912550-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-14T07:42:05.146005-07:00","date_filed":"2026-10-09","time_filed":"14:27:24","entry_number":101,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-10-09.001","pacer_sequence_number":386,"description":"MOTION for Confidentiality/Protective Order, MOTION to Stay RULE 30(b)(6) DEPOSITION by Ken Paxton. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit DECLARATION OF JOE NWAOKORO IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER, # 2 Exhibit DECLARATION OF JOHNATHAN STONE ASSERTING PRIVILEGES IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER, # 3 Proposed Order)(Nwaokoro, Joseph) (Entered: 10/09/2026)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/481140843/","id":481140843,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/496865035/","id":496865035,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/102/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-10-09T13:07:02.040633-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-09T14:07:47.412270-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"102","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"181037582334","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Expedite","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-10-09T13:07:01.992870-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-14T07:42:05.202312-07:00","date_filed":"2026-10-09","time_filed":"14:53:01","entry_number":102,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-10-09.002","pacer_sequence_number":389,"description":"Notice of Filing and Request for Expedited Consideration by Ken Paxton (Nwaokoro, Joseph) Modified on 10/9/2026 (cnr). (Entered: 10/09/2026)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/476858348/","id":476858348,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/70904232/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/492433281/","id":492433281,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/70904232/100/glass-lewis-co-llc-v-paxton/","date_created":"2026-09-03T12:05:30.483168-07:00","date_modified":"2026-09-09T07:57:30.805702-07:00","sha1":"533fa3ce821bb13e3af70aec7a965189ea5eaf9a","page_count":1,"file_size":154624,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.100.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172856380.100.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"     Case 1:25-cv-01153-ADA      Document 100      Filed 09/02/26    Page 1 of 1\n\n\n\n\n               IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS\n                                \u00a7\n                                \u00a7\n                                \u00a7\n    ORDER REGARDING CASE ADMINISTRATION IN THE AUSTIN\n                       DIVISION\nTo facilitate the orderly administration and reassignment of cases on the docket\nassigned to Judge Alan Albright in the Austin Division (the \u201cADA docket\u201d) and to\nprovide clarity regarding the status of those cases during the reassignment process,\nthe Court issues the following Order. The Court anticipates that cases assigned to\nthe ADA docket will be reassigned to another district judge in the near term.\nPending reassignment, the Court ORDERS:\n   1. Unless otherwise ordered, all deadlines, scheduling orders, and obligations\n      previously established in this matter shall remain in full force and effect\n      pending reassignment. The parties shall continue to prosecute and defend\n      this matter, including conducting discovery and abiding by the scheduling\n      order or proposed scheduling order in this matter.\n   2. All hearings, conferences, and other proceedings including jury selection\n      and trial settings currently scheduled on the ADA docket are VACATED and\n      will be reset, as appropriate, by the judge to whom this matter is reassigned.\n   3. Pending motions and requests to the Court remain pending and may be\n      addressed by a district judge or magistrate judge, as appropriate, until the\n      case is reassigned.\n   4. Nothing in this order precludes the assigned magistrate judge from\n      continuing to preside over the case as permitted by law or court order.\n             SIGNED and ENTERED on this 2nd day of September 2026.\n\n\n\n\n                                       ______________________________________\n                                       ALIA MOSES\n                                       Chief United States District Judge\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2026-09-03T12:10:39.583272-07:00","document_number":"100","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"181037338523","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Order","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2026-09-03T12:05:30.453166-07:00","date_modified":"2026-10-14T07:42:05.105190-07:00","date_filed":"2026-09-02","time_filed":null,"entry_number":100,"recap_sequence_number":"2026-09-02.001","pacer_sequence_number":384,"description":"Order Regarding Case Administration in the Austin Division. Signed by Chief Judge Alia Moses. (r013) (Entered: 09/03/2026)","tags":[]}],"entries_total":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/?count=on&docket=70904232&page_size=40"}