{"cached_at":"2026-11-13T11:46:33.568454+00:00","cl_docket_id":"4236813","docket":{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","id":4236813,"court":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/courts/flsd/","court_id":"flsd","original_court_info":null,"idb_data":{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/fjc-integrated-database/24163809/","date_created":"2018-11-21T09:03:48.073528-08:00","date_modified":"2022-01-28T04:49:11.501943-08:00","dataset_source":9,"office":"1","docket_number":"1522134","origin":1,"date_filed":"2015-06-04","jurisdiction":3,"nature_of_suit":820,"title":"","section":"1338","subsection":"","diversity_of_residence":null,"class_action":null,"monetary_demand":0,"county_of_residence":12086,"arbitration_at_filing":"","arbitration_at_termination":"","multidistrict_litigation_docket_number":"","plaintiff":"HYDENTRA HLP INT. LIMITED","defendant":"LUCHIAN, ET AL","date_transfer":null,"transfer_office":"","transfer_docket_number":"","transfer_origin":"","date_terminated":"2016-06-07","termination_class_action_status":null,"procedural_progress":4,"disposition":12,"nature_of_judgement":0,"amount_received":0,"judgment":0,"pro_se":0,"year_of_tape":2016,"nature_of_offense":"","version":null,"circuit":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/courts/ca11/","district":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/courts/flsd/"},"clusters":[],"audio_files":[],"assigned_to":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/people/3289/","referred_to":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/people/9177/","bankruptcy_information":null,"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2016-08-20T14:41:35.350182-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-29T13:37:57.804500-07:00","source":9,"appeal_from_str":"","assigned_to_str":"Ursula Ungaro","referred_to_str":"Alicia M. Otazo-Reyes","panel_str":"","date_last_index":"2024-06-29T11:55:14.661950-07:00","date_cert_granted":null,"date_cert_denied":null,"date_argued":null,"date_reargued":null,"date_reargument_denied":null,"date_filed":"2015-06-04","date_terminated":"2016-06-07","date_last_filing":"2017-03-10","case_name_short":"Luchian","case_name":"Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Luchian","case_name_full":"","slug":"hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian","docket_number":"1:15-cv-22134","docket_number_core":"1522134","docket_number_raw":"1:15-cv-22134","docket_number_source":0,"federal_dn_office_code":"","federal_dn_case_type":"","federal_dn_judge_initials_assigned":"","federal_dn_judge_initials_referred":"","federal_defendant_number":null,"pacer_case_id":"464575","cause":"28:1338 Copyright Infringement","nature_of_suit":"820 Copyright","jury_demand":"Defendant","jurisdiction_type":"Federal Question","appellate_fee_status":"","appellate_case_type_information":"","mdl_status":"","filepath_ia":"https://www.archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.docket.xml","filepath_ia_json":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.docket.json","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"ia_needs_upload":true,"ia_date_first_change":"2018-09-30T00:00:00-07:00","date_blocked":null,"blocked":false,"appeal_from":null,"parent_docket":null,"tags":[],"panel":[]},"parties":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/327669/","id":327669,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/907368/","attorney_id":907368,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/907368/","attorney_id":907368,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":1}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2017-02-18T10:25:58.414429-08:00","date_modified":"2017-02-18T10:25:58.414463-08:00","name":"Peekvids.Com","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/327668/","id":327668,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/907368/","attorney_id":907368,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/907368/","attorney_id":907368,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":1}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2017-02-18T10:25:58.408177-08:00","date_modified":"2017-02-18T10:25:58.408211-08:00","name":"Playvids.Com","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/327667/","id":327667,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/907368/","attorney_id":907368,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/907368/","attorney_id":907368,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":1}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2017-02-18T10:25:58.401772-08:00","date_modified":"2017-02-18T10:25:58.401805-08:00","name":"Feedvid.Com","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/327666/","id":327666,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/907368/","attorney_id":907368,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/907368/","attorney_id":907368,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":1}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2017-02-18T10:25:58.395382-08:00","date_modified":"2017-02-18T10:25:58.395415-08:00","name":"Playvid.Com","extra_info":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/327665/","id":327665,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/907368/","attorney_id":907368,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/907368/","attorney_id":907368,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/9649531/","attorney_id":9649531,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/9649531/","attorney_id":9649531,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/9649531/","attorney_id":9649531,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":4}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"a corporation, individually\ndoing business as\nPlayvid.Com, Feedvid.Com, Playvids.Com, and Peekvids.Com","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2017-02-18T10:25:58.388658-08:00","date_modified":"2017-02-18T10:25:58.388691-08:00","name":"Sun Social Media, Inc.","extra_info":"a corporation, individually\n\ndoing business asPlayvid.Com, Feedvid.Com, Playvids.Com, and Peekvids.Com"},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/327664/","id":327664,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/907368/","attorney_id":907368,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/907368/","attorney_id":907368,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/9649531/","attorney_id":9649531,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/9649531/","attorney_id":9649531,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/9649531/","attorney_id":9649531,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":4}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"an individual","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2017-02-18T10:25:58.381990-08:00","date_modified":"2017-02-18T10:25:58.382023-08:00","name":"Konstantin Bolotin","extra_info":"an individual"},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/327663/","id":327663,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/907368/","attorney_id":907368,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/907368/","attorney_id":907368,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/9649531/","attorney_id":9649531,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/9649531/","attorney_id":9649531,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/9649531/","attorney_id":9649531,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":4}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"an individual","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2017-02-18T10:25:58.368653-08:00","date_modified":"2017-02-18T10:25:58.368686-08:00","name":"Constantin Luchian","extra_info":"an individual"},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/64628/","id":64628,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/1006494/","attorney_id":1006494,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4327205/","docket_id":4327205,"role":10},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/897801/","attorney_id":897801,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4227648/","docket_id":4227648,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/897801/","attorney_id":897801,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4227648/","docket_id":4227648,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/821244/","attorney_id":821244,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6084391/","docket_id":6084391,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/821244/","attorney_id":821244,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6084391/","docket_id":6084391,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/521707/","attorney_id":521707,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6084391/","docket_id":6084391,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/521707/","attorney_id":521707,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6084391/","docket_id":6084391,"role":4},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/521707/","attorney_id":521707,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6084391/","docket_id":6084391,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/521708/","attorney_id":521708,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6084391/","docket_id":6084391,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/677319/","attorney_id":677319,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6149903/","docket_id":6149903,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/677319/","attorney_id":677319,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6149903/","docket_id":6149903,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/765245/","attorney_id":765245,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4234510/","docket_id":4234510,"role":10},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/2815915/","attorney_id":2815915,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4237280/","docket_id":4237280,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/853852/","attorney_id":853852,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4358340/","docket_id":4358340,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/853852/","attorney_id":853852,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4358340/","docket_id":4358340,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/1004937/","attorney_id":1004937,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4358340/","docket_id":4358340,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/1004937/","attorney_id":1004937,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4358340/","docket_id":4358340,"role":4},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/854254/","attorney_id":854254,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4358340/","docket_id":4358340,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/854254/","attorney_id":854254,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4358340/","docket_id":4358340,"role":4},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/980431/","attorney_id":980431,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4358340/","docket_id":4358340,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/980431/","attorney_id":980431,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4358340/","docket_id":4358340,"role":4},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/195950/","attorney_id":195950,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4247435/","docket_id":4247435,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/195950/","attorney_id":195950,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4247435/","docket_id":4247435,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/195949/","attorney_id":195949,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4247435/","docket_id":4247435,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/996989/","attorney_id":996989,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4259400/","docket_id":4259400,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/996989/","attorney_id":996989,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4259400/","docket_id":4259400,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/756485/","attorney_id":756485,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4259400/","docket_id":4259400,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/828410/","attorney_id":828410,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4259400/","docket_id":4259400,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/210262/","attorney_id":210262,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4259400/","docket_id":4259400,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/261660/","attorney_id":261660,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4285734/","docket_id":4285734,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/261660/","attorney_id":261660,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4285734/","docket_id":4285734,"role":4},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/261661/","attorney_id":261661,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4285734/","docket_id":4285734,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/261662/","attorney_id":261662,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4285734/","docket_id":4285734,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/261662/","attorney_id":261662,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4285734/","docket_id":4285734,"role":4},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/261663/","attorney_id":261663,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4285734/","docket_id":4285734,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/261663/","attorney_id":261663,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4285734/","docket_id":4285734,"role":4},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/261664/","attorney_id":261664,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4285734/","docket_id":4285734,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/261664/","attorney_id":261664,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4285734/","docket_id":4285734,"role":4},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/261659/","attorney_id":261659,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4285734/","docket_id":4285734,"role":10},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/600312/","attorney_id":600312,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4398249/","docket_id":4398249,"role":10},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/3031295/","attorney_id":3031295,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6120313/","docket_id":6120313,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/3031295/","attorney_id":3031295,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6120313/","docket_id":6120313,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/3031296/","attorney_id":3031296,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6120313/","docket_id":6120313,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/3031297/","attorney_id":3031297,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6120313/","docket_id":6120313,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/3031298/","attorney_id":3031298,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6120313/","docket_id":6120313,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/286700/","attorney_id":286700,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4301646/","docket_id":4301646,"role":10},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/6163075/","attorney_id":6163075,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4496973/","docket_id":4496973,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/907368/","attorney_id":907368,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/907368/","attorney_id":907368,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/271415/","attorney_id":271415,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4292338/","docket_id":4292338,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/795793/","attorney_id":795793,"date_action":"2008-06-05","docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4268593/","docket_id":4268593,"role":6},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/795793/","attorney_id":795793,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4268593/","docket_id":4268593,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/795793/","attorney_id":795793,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4268593/","docket_id":4268593,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/235258/","attorney_id":235258,"date_action":"2008-06-05","docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4268593/","docket_id":4268593,"role":6},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/235258/","attorney_id":235258,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4268593/","docket_id":4268593,"role":4},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/235258/","attorney_id":235258,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4268593/","docket_id":4268593,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/235258/","attorney_id":235258,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4268593/","docket_id":4268593,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/235259/","attorney_id":235259,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4268593/","docket_id":4268593,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/235259/","attorney_id":235259,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4268593/","docket_id":4268593,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/235261/","attorney_id":235261,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4268593/","docket_id":4268593,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/235261/","attorney_id":235261,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4268593/","docket_id":4268593,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/891587/","attorney_id":891587,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4268593/","docket_id":4268593,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/891587/","attorney_id":891587,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4268593/","docket_id":4268593,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/235262/","attorney_id":235262,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4268593/","docket_id":4268593,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/235262/","attorney_id":235262,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4268593/","docket_id":4268593,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/890786/","attorney_id":890786,"date_action":"2008-06-05","docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4268593/","docket_id":4268593,"role":6},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/890786/","attorney_id":890786,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4268593/","docket_id":4268593,"role":4},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/890786/","attorney_id":890786,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4268593/","docket_id":4268593,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/890786/","attorney_id":890786,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4268593/","docket_id":4268593,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/235260/","attorney_id":235260,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4268593/","docket_id":4268593,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/2838269/","attorney_id":2838269,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4267656/","docket_id":4267656,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/2838269/","attorney_id":2838269,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4267656/","docket_id":4267656,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/232406/","attorney_id":232406,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4267656/","docket_id":4267656,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/232406/","attorney_id":232406,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4267656/","docket_id":4267656,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/723654/","attorney_id":723654,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/5638483/","docket_id":5638483,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/350505/","attorney_id":350505,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4345745/","docket_id":4345745,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/350505/","attorney_id":350505,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4345745/","docket_id":4345745,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/373381/","attorney_id":373381,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4345745/","docket_id":4345745,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/373381/","attorney_id":373381,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4345745/","docket_id":4345745,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/1000981/","attorney_id":1000981,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4345745/","docket_id":4345745,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/1000981/","attorney_id":1000981,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4345745/","docket_id":4345745,"role":4},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/651370/","attorney_id":651370,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4345745/","docket_id":4345745,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/901992/","attorney_id":901992,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4345745/","docket_id":4345745,"role":1}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4543254/","docket_id":4543254,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":"2009-06-01","extra_info":"TERMINATED: 06/01/2009","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4347869/","docket_id":4347869,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4327205/","docket_id":4327205,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4353748/","docket_id":4353748,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4556661/","docket_id":4556661,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4196096/","docket_id":4196096,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4496973/","docket_id":4496973,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":"2017-05-26","extra_info":"TERMINATED: 05/26/2017","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4352398/","docket_id":4352398,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4353571/","docket_id":4353571,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4226412/","docket_id":4226412,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4233794/","docket_id":4233794,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4346187/","docket_id":4346187,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4523126/","docket_id":4523126,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":"2016-10-24","extra_info":"TERMINATED: 10/24/2016","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4285520/","docket_id":4285520,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4286329/","docket_id":4286329,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4295704/","docket_id":4295704,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4302885/","docket_id":4302885,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4505907/","docket_id":4505907,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4319056/","docket_id":4319056,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4521404/","docket_id":4521404,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4346774/","docket_id":4346774,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4347364/","docket_id":4347364,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4348257/","docket_id":4348257,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4522674/","docket_id":4522674,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4522874/","docket_id":4522874,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4353350/","docket_id":4353350,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4391360/","docket_id":4391360,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4514924/","docket_id":4514924,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4363136/","docket_id":4363136,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4363428/","docket_id":4363428,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4365840/","docket_id":4365840,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4383482/","docket_id":4383482,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4532864/","docket_id":4532864,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4400131/","docket_id":4400131,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4583001/","docket_id":4583001,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":"2012-12-25","extra_info":"TERMINATED: 12/25/2012","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4937031/","docket_id":4937031,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":"2015-12-14","extra_info":"TERMINATED: 12/14/2015","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6077656/","docket_id":6077656,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"Inclusive","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6150129/","docket_id":6150129,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6163620/","docket_id":6163620,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6171510/","docket_id":6171510,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6182745/","docket_id":6182745,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"fictitious","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6218928/","docket_id":6218928,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"Inclusive","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6187444/","docket_id":6187444,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4358340/","docket_id":4358340,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6230572/","docket_id":6230572,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4242383/","docket_id":4242383,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4246492/","docket_id":4246492,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"In Personam","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4144731/","docket_id":4144731,"name":"Counter Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4144731/","docket_id":4144731,"name":"Third Party Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4286625/","docket_id":4286625,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":"2014-01-24","extra_info":"TERMINATED: 01/24/2014","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4301684/","docket_id":4301684,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":"2009-01-13","extra_info":"TERMINATED: 01/13/2009","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4302433/","docket_id":4302433,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4401217/","docket_id":4401217,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4320981/","docket_id":4320981,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4408812/","docket_id":4408812,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4411804/","docket_id":4411804,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4350539/","docket_id":4350539,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":"2012-09-28","extra_info":"TERMINATED: 09/28/2012","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4285509/","docket_id":4285509,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6283289/","docket_id":6283289,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4227648/","docket_id":4227648,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4336034/","docket_id":4336034,"name":"Consolidated Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4390477/","docket_id":4390477,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4398249/","docket_id":4398249,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4234510/","docket_id":4234510,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4247435/","docket_id":4247435,"name":"Plaintiff","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4237280/","docket_id":4237280,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4362802/","docket_id":4362802,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4259400/","docket_id":4259400,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6243430/","docket_id":6243430,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4274099/","docket_id":4274099,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4300315/","docket_id":4300315,"name":"Consolidated Filer Defendant","date_terminated":"2009-06-26","extra_info":"TERMINATED: 06/26/2009","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4301646/","docket_id":4301646,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"John Does 1-20","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4302036/","docket_id":4302036,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6302404/","docket_id":6302404,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6076771/","docket_id":6076771,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6120313/","docket_id":6120313,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/5308657/","docket_id":5308657,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":"2013-12-24","extra_info":"TERMINATED: 12/24/2013","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4523896/","docket_id":4523896,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4349806/","docket_id":4349806,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"Defendants being unknown to Plaintiff and having or claiming an interest in the claim herein","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4292338/","docket_id":4292338,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6203788/","docket_id":6203788,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6149903/","docket_id":6149903,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":"2017-07-31","extra_info":"TERMINATED: 07/31/2017","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4349585/","docket_id":4349585,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"fictitious persons","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4258858/","docket_id":4258858,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":"2009-07-16","extra_info":"TERMINATED: 07/16/2009","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4340836/","docket_id":4340836,"name":"Consolidated Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4324076/","docket_id":4324076,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"being the fictitious names of the New York City Police Officers whose names are not known to Plaintiff, individually and in their official capacities","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4268593/","docket_id":4268593,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"Member Defendant from 3:08cv-211-H; 3:08cv-236-H and 3:08cv-304-H","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4400263/","docket_id":4400263,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"supervisory and other officers of the Austin Police Department, in their individual and official capacities","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4301434/","docket_id":4301434,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"individually","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4285734/","docket_id":4285734,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4526868/","docket_id":4526868,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6184950/","docket_id":6184950,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6249653/","docket_id":6249653,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/5638483/","docket_id":5638483,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4345745/","docket_id":4345745,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4326331/","docket_id":4326331,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"said John Does being New York State police troopers and agents servants and/or employees of Erie County, Schenectady County, the Erie County Sheriff's Office and/or the Schenectady County Sheriff's Office","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4243009/","docket_id":4243009,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":"2019-03-28","extra_info":"TERMINATED: 03/28/2019","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4350021/","docket_id":4350021,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/5626018/","docket_id":5626018,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"in their individual capacities","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4267656/","docket_id":4267656,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":"2010-04-01","extra_info":"TERMINATED: 04/01/2010","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4506104/","docket_id":4506104,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6147747/","docket_id":6147747,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/6150663/","docket_id":6150663,"name":"Defendant","date_terminated":"2016-06-17","extra_info":"TERMINATED: 06/17/2016","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2017-02-16T23:20:49.469152-08:00","date_modified":"2018-03-06T11:23:19.735762-08:00","name":"John Does 1-20","extra_info":"in their individual capacities"},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/parties/32734/","id":32734,"attorneys":[{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/983890/","attorney_id":983890,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4237280/","docket_id":4237280,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/983890/","attorney_id":983890,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4237280/","docket_id":4237280,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/1980128/","attorney_id":1980128,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4237280/","docket_id":4237280,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/1980128/","attorney_id":1980128,"date_action":"2016-02-04","docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4237280/","docket_id":4237280,"role":6},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/1980128/","attorney_id":1980128,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4237280/","docket_id":4237280,"role":4},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/1980128/","attorney_id":1980128,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4237280/","docket_id":4237280,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/178172/","attorney_id":178172,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4237280/","docket_id":4237280,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/1217261/","attorney_id":1217261,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4152922/","docket_id":4152922,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/1217261/","attorney_id":1217261,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4152922/","docket_id":4152922,"role":4},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/57667/","attorney_id":57667,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4152922/","docket_id":4152922,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/1282552/","attorney_id":1282552,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/1282552/","attorney_id":1282552,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/177654/","attorney_id":177654,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/177654/","attorney_id":177654,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/9649530/","attorney_id":9649530,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/9649530/","attorney_id":9649530,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/9649530/","attorney_id":9649530,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"role":4},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/9636297/","attorney_id":9636297,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4134482/","docket_id":4134482,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/9636297/","attorney_id":9636297,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4134482/","docket_id":4134482,"role":4},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/9636297/","attorney_id":9636297,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4134482/","docket_id":4134482,"role":2},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/9636298/","attorney_id":9636298,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4134482/","docket_id":4134482,"role":1},{"attorney":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/attorneys/9636298/","attorney_id":9636298,"date_action":null,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4134482/","docket_id":4134482,"role":2}],"party_types":[{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4152922/","docket_id":4152922,"name":"Plaintiff","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"a foreign corporation\n\ndoing business asMetart\ndoing business asSexart\ndoing business asThe MetArt Network","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4237280/","docket_id":4237280,"name":"Plaintiff","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"a foreign corporation\ndoing business as\nMetart\ndoing business as\nSexart","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4134482/","docket_id":4134482,"name":"Plaintiff","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"a foreign corporation\ndoing business as\nMetart\ndoing business as\nSexart","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]},{"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","docket_id":4236813,"name":"Plaintiff","date_terminated":null,"extra_info":"a foreign corporation\ndoing business as\nMetart\ndoing business as\nSexart","highest_offense_level_opening":"","highest_offense_level_terminated":"","criminal_counts":[],"criminal_complaints":[]}],"date_created":"2017-02-16T19:23:35.989582-08:00","date_modified":"2017-07-06T22:36:17.487059-07:00","name":"Hydentra HLP Int. Limited","extra_info":"a foreign corporation\n\ndoing business asMetart\ndoing business asSexart"}],"entries":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/395125469/","id":395125469,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/404233309/","id":404233309,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"","date_created":"2024-06-29T11:54:16.403807-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-29T11:54:16.410066-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2024-06-29T11:54:16.395738-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-29T11:54:16.395748-07:00","date_filed":"2015-08-28","time_filed":null,"entry_number":null,"recap_sequence_number":"2015-08-28.002","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"Set/Reset Deadlines/Hearings -Joint Scheduling Report due by 9/1/2015. per DE 30 (cbr)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/281501800/","id":281501800,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/287711772/","id":287711772,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"","date_created":"2023-04-18T08:23:42.445015-07:00","date_modified":"2023-04-18T08:23:42.445020-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Order Setting Hearing on Motion","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2023-04-18T08:23:42.367975-07:00","date_modified":"2023-04-18T08:23:42.367979-07:00","date_filed":"2016-02-16","time_filed":"13:57:42","entry_number":null,"recap_sequence_number":"2016-02-16.001","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/280945290/","id":280945290,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/287154687/","id":287154687,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"","date_created":"2023-04-18T00:31:07.453524-07:00","date_modified":"2023-04-18T00:31:07.453528-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Order Setting Hearing on Motion","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2023-04-18T00:31:07.412571-07:00","date_modified":"2023-04-18T00:31:07.412574-07:00","date_filed":"2016-02-09","time_filed":"14:20:39","entry_number":null,"recap_sequence_number":"2016-02-09.001","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/275150550/","id":275150550,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/281357595/","id":281357595,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"","date_created":"2023-04-14T21:36:18.204713-07:00","date_modified":"2023-04-14T21:36:18.204722-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Order Setting Hearing on Motion","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2023-04-14T21:36:18.159908-07:00","date_modified":"2023-04-14T21:36:18.159916-07:00","date_filed":"2015-12-04","time_filed":"11:24:28","entry_number":null,"recap_sequence_number":"2015-12-04.001","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/255985852/","id":255985852,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/262159617/","id":262159617,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"","date_created":"2023-03-23T15:06:00.487568-07:00","date_modified":"2023-03-23T15:06:00.487572-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Judge Assignment","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2023-03-23T15:06:00.460134-07:00","date_modified":"2023-03-23T15:06:00.460137-07:00","date_filed":"2015-06-05","time_filed":"09:08:03","entry_number":null,"recap_sequence_number":"2015-06-05.001","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/255985850/","id":255985850,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/262159615/","id":262159615,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"","date_created":"2023-03-23T15:06:00.487495-07:00","date_modified":"2023-03-23T15:06:00.487499-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Clerks Notice of Docket Correction - ELECTRONIC CASE","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2023-03-23T15:06:00.460101-07:00","date_modified":"2023-03-23T15:06:00.460105-07:00","date_filed":"2015-06-05","time_filed":"09:12:10","entry_number":null,"recap_sequence_number":"2015-06-05.001","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/171244040/","id":171244040,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/176529111/","id":176529111,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/159/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.614831-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-30T02:07:15.546723-07:00","sha1":"013bcf9aebaa90cb953e2d5f4c560de3c278fca1","page_count":2,"file_size":48965,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.159.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.159.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 159 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/10/2017 Page 1 of 2\n\n\n\n\n                             UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                             SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA\n\n                                    Case No. 1:15-cv-22134-UU\n\n  HYDENTRA HLP INT. LIMITED,\n\n         Plaintiff,\n\n  v.\n\n  CONSTANTIN LUCHIAN, et al.,\n\n        Defendants.\n  ___________________________________/\n\n                      ORDER AFFIRMING MAGISTRATE JUDGE\u2019S REPORT\n\n         THIS CAUSE is before the Court upon Defendants Constantin Luchian (\u201cLuchian\u201d),\n\n  Konstantin Bolotin (\u201cBolotin\u201d), and Sun Social Media, Inc.\u2019s (\u201cSSM\u201d) (collectively,\n\n  \u201cDefendants\u201d) Motion for Attorney\u2019s Fees. D.E. 148. The Honorable Alicia M. Otazo-Reyes,\n\n  United States Magistrate Judge, issued a Report and Recommendation, (D.E. 157), on February\n\n  23, 2017, recommending that Defendants\u2019 Motion for Attorney\u2019s Fees be DENIED. Defendants\n\n  filed objections to Judge Otazo-Reyes\u2019s Report and Recommendation (\u201cObjections\u201d). D.E. 158.\n\n         THE COURT has made a de novo review of the entire file and record herein, and, is\n\n  otherwise fully advised in the premises.\n\n          Upon de novo review, the Court agrees with Magistrate Judge Otazo-Reyes\u2019s\n\n  recommendation and concurs in all of her findings. Defendants\u2019 objections to the Report and\n\n  Recommendation are without merit, were word-for-word regurgitations of the legal analysis\n\n  provided in their Motion for Attorney\u2019s Fees, and were previously raised in Defendants\u2019 Motion\n\n  for Attorney\u2019s Fees. In addition, these arguments were thoroughly analyzed by Magistrate Judge\n\n  Otazo-Reyes in her analysis. Accordingly, it is\n\n\n\n                                                    1\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 159 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/10/2017 Page 2 of 2\n\n\n\n\n          ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that the Report of the Magistrate Judge, D.E. 157, is\n\n  RATIFIED, ADOPTED, and AFFIRMED. It is further\n\n          ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that Defendants\u2019 Motion for Attorney\u2019s Fees (D.E. 148)\n\n  is DENIED.\n\n          DONE AND ORDERED in Chambers at Miami, Florida, this _10th_ day of March,\n\n  2017.\n\n\n\n                                               _______________________________\n                                               UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE\n\n  cc:\n  counsel of record via cm/ecf\n\n\n\n\n                                           2\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2024-06-29T12:28:19.275435-07:00","document_number":"159","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"051017666571","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Order Adopting Report and Recommendations","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.602148-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-29T11:54:26.199089-07:00","date_filed":"2017-03-10","time_filed":null,"entry_number":159,"recap_sequence_number":"2017-03-10.001","pacer_sequence_number":481,"description":"ORDER AFFIRMING MAGISTRATE JUDGE'S REPORT re 157 Report and Recommendations Defendant's Motion for Attorney's Fees DE 148 is DENIED. Signed by Judge Ursula Ungaro on 3/10/2017. (mc) (Entered: 03/10/2017)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/171244039/","id":171244039,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/176529110/","id":176529110,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/158/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.589705-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-30T02:07:13.789737-07:00","sha1":"71d2314830e0cf818d4835cf2c445cc7c0c3dcfd","page_count":16,"file_size":468349,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.158.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.158.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 158 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/08/2017 Page 1 of 16\n\n\n\n\n                               UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                               SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA\n\n                                          MIAMI DIVISION\n\n\n   HYDENTRA HLP INT. LIMITED,\n   a foreign corporation d/b/a METART,\n                                                                      Case No.\n         Plaintiff,                                               1:15-cv-22134-UU\n\n   v.\n\n   CONSTANTIN LUCHIAN, an individual,\n   KONSTANTIN BOLOTIN, an individual,\n   SUN SOCIAL MEDIA, INC., a corporation,\n   individually and d/b/a PLAYVID.COM,\n   FEEDVID.COM, PLAYVIDS.COM and\n   PEEKVIDS.COM; PLAYVID.COM;\n   FEEDVID.COM; PLAYVIDS.COM;\n   PEEKVIDS.COM; and\n   John Does 1-20,\n\n         Defendants.\n\n\n             DEFENDANTS\u2019 OBJECTIONS TO MAGISTRATE\u2019S REPORTAND AND\n              RECOMMENDATION DENYING MOTION FOR ATTORNEY\u2019S FEES\n\n                                          INTRODUCTION\n\n            On June 2, 2016, this Court issued its Omnibus Order on the Motions for Summary\n  Judgment (the \u201cOmnibus Order\u201d), dismissing all of the claims against Defendant Constantin\n  Luchian (\u201cMr. Luchian\u201d) and dismissing all of the copyright claims and the state statutory claims\n  against Defendants Sun Social Media, Inc. (\u201cSun Social\u201d) and Konstantin Bolotin (\u201cMr.\n  Bolotin\u201d), finding, in each instance, that the Defendants were entitled to judgment as a matter of\n  law.\n            The Defendants moved for an award of their reasonable attorney\u2019s fees pursuant to 17\n  U.S.C., \u00a7505 and \u2013 despite finding that Defendants were prevailing parties on all of the copyright\n  claims \u2013 the magistrate denied an award of such fees based primarily on her finding that\n\n\n\n\n                                                   1\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 158 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/08/2017 Page 2 of 16\n\n\n\n\n  Plaintiff\u2019s complaint was not frivolous, a finding that was, in turn, based entirely on the\n  Magistrate\u2019s finding that the Plaintiffs held valid copyrights in the allegedly infringing materials.\n          Given this Court\u2019s findings in the Omnibus Order \u2013 both that there had never been any\n  basis for claims to be brought against Mr. Luchian and that there was no basis to find that any of\n  the Defendants infringed upon Plaintiffs\u2019 copyrights \u2013 the Magistrate\u2019s Report and\n  Recommendation (\u201cRAR\u201d) must be rejected and an order requiring the Plaintiffs to pay\n  Defendants\u2019 reasonable attorney\u2019s fees should enter.\n          In support of its objections, Defendants state as follows.\n                                        PROCEDURAL HISTORY1\n          Plaintiff filed the present action on June 5, 2015. Docket No. 1. This lawsuit was one of\n  at least 20 near-identical lawsuits filed by Plaintiff in federal courts around the country from\n  February of 2015 through May of 2016. 2\n          Plaintiff served the Defendants on July 15 and 16, 2015, Docket Nos. 11, 13, and agreed\n  to extend the time for Defendants to file their response to the Complaint. On August 6, 2015 the\n  Court sua sponte issued an Order to Show Cause as to why default should not be entered.\n  Docket No. 15. Despite having agreed to allow Defendants more time to respond, Plaintiff filed\n  a Motion for Judgment on August 19, 2015. Docket No. 20. On August 27, 2015, Defendants\n\n\n  1\n    Because the Court provided an extensive recitation of facts in its Omnibus Order, which the Defendants\n  incorporate by reference herein, a separate factual recitation is not included in this motion.\n  2\n    See Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Kporno.com et al, Case No. 2:2015-cv-00238 (D. Arizona) (filed Feb. 10, 2015),\n  Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Tubenn.com et al, Case No. 2:2015-cv-00239 (D. Arizona) (filed Feb. 10, 2015),\n  Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Pornvideoxo.com et al, Case No. 2:2015-cv-00240 (D. Arizona) (filed Feb. 10, 2015),\n  Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Spankbang.com et al, Case No. 2:2015-cv-00199 (W.D. Wash.) (filed Feb. 10, 2015),\n  Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. HDPorn1080.com et al, Case No. 2:2015-cv-00442 (D. Arizona) (filed March 11,\n  2015), Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Pornburst.xxx et al, Case No. 2:2015-cv-00443 (D. Arizona) (filed March 11,\n  2015), Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Pornowow.com et al, Case No. 2:2015-cv-00444 (D. Arizona) (filed March 11,\n  2015), Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Seesexvideo.net et al, Case No. 2:2015-cv-00371 (W.D. Wash.) (filed March\n  11, 2015), Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Sextvx.com, Case No. 2:2015-cv-00372 (W.D. Wash.) (filed March 11,\n  2015), Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Porn69.org et al, Case No. 2:2015-cv-00451 (D. Arizona) (filed March 12,\n  2015), Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Motherless, Inc. et al, Case No. 2:2015-cv-03834 (C.D. Cal.) (filed May 20,\n  2015), Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Jojobaa.net, Case No. 2:2015-cv-03904 (C.D. Cal.) (filed May 22, 2015),\n  Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Adultpornvideoxx.com et al, Case No. 2:2015-cv-03950 (C.D. Cal.) (filed May 25,\n  2015), Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Luchian et al, Case No. 1:2015-cv-22134 (S.D. Fla.) (filed June 4, 2015),\n  Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Maximum Apps Inc. et al, Case No. 1:2015-cv-22463 (S.D. Fla.) (filed June 30, 2015),\n  Hydentra, L.P. HLP General Partner, Inc. et al v. Mindgeek USA Inc. et al, Case No. 1:2015-cv-23230 (S.D. Fla.)\n  (filed August 27, 2015), Hydentra, L.P. HLP General Partner, Inc. et al v. Era Technologies, Ltd. et al, Case No.\n  1:2015-cv-24293 (S.D. Fla.) (filed November 18, 2015), Hydentra, L.P. HLP General Partner, Inc. et al v. Siracusa\n  Management S.A. et al, Case No. 1:2016-cv-20191 (S.D. Fla.) (filed January 15, 2016), Hydentra HLP Int. Limited\n  v. Stach et al, Case No. 2:2016-cv-00120 (E.D. Wash.) (filed April 15, 2016), Hydentra HLP Int. Limited et al v.\n  Sagan Limited et al, Case No. 2:2016-cv-01494 (D. Ariz.) (filed May 16, 2016).\n\n                                                          2\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 158 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/08/2017 Page 3 of 16\n\n\n\n\n  filed a Motion to Set Aside Default, Docket No. 26, which the Court granted on August 28,\n  2015. Docket No. 30.\n         Defendants filed their Answer to the Complaint on September 1, 2015. Docket No. 32.\n  Shortly thereafter, Plaintiff\u2019s counsel met and conferred with Defendant\u2019s counsel about its\n  intention to file a Motion to Strike the Affirmative Defenses set forth in the Answer. In response\n  thereto, Defendants filed a Motion to Amend the Answer and Affirmative Defenses resolving all\n  the issues raised by Plaintiffs in the proposed Motion to Strike on October 15, 2015. Docket No.\n  38. The Court allowed Defendants\u2019 Motion to Amend on October 16, 2015. Despite the\n  Amended Answer resolving all of the issues raised by Plaintiff in the proposed motion, Plaintiff\n  filed its Motion to Strike anyway on October 29, 2015, seeking to strike every single affirmative\n  defense. Docket No. 41. After briefing, the Motion to Strike was denied virtually in its entirety.\n  Docket No. 53.\n         Thereafter, Plaintiff began a steady and consistent course of filing frivolous motion after\n  frivolous motion against Defendants. On December 1, 2015, Plaintiff filed a Motion to Compel\n  Answers to Requests for Production, Docket No. 51, which was denied almost in its entirety.\n  Docket No. 58. On February 10, 2016, Plaintiff filed a Motion for Sanctions for Unlicensed\n  Practice of Law, Docket No. 69, which was denied. Docket No. 135. Also on February 10,\n  2016, Plaintiff filed a Motion for Sanctions for Failure to Comply with Rule 30(b)(6), Docket\n  No. 70, which was denied on February 23, 2016. Docket No. 107. On February 12, 2016,\n  Plaintiff filed a Motion to Compel Arising From Instructions Not to Answer, and Refusal to\n  Answer, Deposition Questions, Docket No. 71, which was denied on February 23, 2016. Docket\n  No. 107.\n         On February 5, 2016 the parties attended a mediation before Mr. John S. Freud. Docket\n  No. 63. The mediation ended when Plaintiff and Plaintiff\u2019s counsel left shortly after its start.\n         On February 12, 2016, the parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment. Docket\n  Nos. 72, 73, 86.\n         On February 26, 2016, Defendants\u2019 Counsel Val Gurvits filed a Motion to Appear Pro\n  Hac Vice. Docket No. 110. Despite having complained about Attorney Gurvits not having yet\n  moved for admission, plaintiffs opposed the motion, Docket No. 114, and Defendants were\n  required to reply to the opposition. Docket No. 117. The Court granted Mr. Gurvits\u2019 Motion to\n  Appear Pro Hac Vice on February 29, 2016. Docket No. 118.\n\n\n                                                   3\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 158 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/08/2017 Page 4 of 16\n\n\n\n\n         After briefing the Motions for Summary Judgment, but before the issuance of the order\n  thereon, the Parties began their pre-trial preparation. Defendants did not file Motions in Limine,\n  but Plaintiff\u2019s filed an omnibus Motion in Limine on February 19, 2016 (Docket No. 98), which\n  Defendants opposed. After full briefing, the Court denied 7 out of 10 parts of Plaintiff\u2019s Motion\n  in Limine in their entirety. Docket No. 137. On February 26, 2016, the Parties filed their\n  proposed jury instructions, pretrial stipulations and trial exhibit lists in accordance with the\n  Court\u2019s scheduling order. Docket Nos. 111-113, 115-116.\n         On June 2, 2016, this Court issued the Omnibus Order. Docket No. 138. Defendant\n  Constantin Luchian\u2019s Motion for Summary Judgment was granted in its entirety, dismissing him\n  from the case. Defendants Sun Social Media, Inc. and Konstantin Bolotin\u2019s Motion for\n  Summary Judgement was granted, resulting in the dismissal of all of the copyright claims and the\n  state statutory claims against both defendants. Plaintiff\u2019s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment\n  was denied in its entirety.\n         Following the issuance of the Omnibus Order, the Court ordered the parties to engage in\n  a second mediation, which the parties held on June 6, 2016 before Mr. Mark A. Buckstein. The\n  mediation resulted in an impasse after approximately two hours of discussion. Docket No. 143.\n         The day after the mediation, on June 7, 2016, Plaintiff filed a Motion to Dismiss all\n  remaining claims in the litigation. Docket No. 140. The Court granted the Motion the same day,\n  closing the case. Docket No. 141. The Court\u2019s order closing the case constituted the final\n  judgment in this matter.\n         On July 1, 2016, Plaintiff filed a Notice of Appeal to appeal the Court\u2019s Omnibus Order\n  on the Motions for Summary Judgment, noting that the order became a final judgment on June 7,\n  2016, upon the Court issuing its order on that date, closing the case. Docket No. 144.\n         On July 26, 2016, Plaintiff voluntarily dismissed its complaint in Hydentra, L.P. HLP\n  General Partner, Inc. et al v. ERA Technologies, Ltd. et al, Case No. 1:15-cv-24293-MGC (S.D.\n  Fla.) and in Hydentra, L.P. HLP General Partner, Inc. et al v. Siracusa Management S.A. et al,\n  Case No. 1:16-cv-20191-RNS (S.D. Fla.). In both cases, Plaintiff explicitly referenced the\n  adverse decisions in this case for the basis of its dismissal.\n\n\n\n\n                                                     4\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 158 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/08/2017 Page 5 of 16\n\n\n\n\n           On August 8, 2016, Plaintiff moved to voluntarily dismiss its appeal of the Omnibus\n  Order and, on August 18, 2016, the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals dismissed the appeal. 3\n                                                    ARGUMENT\n           I.       Standard of Review\n           This Court \u201cmust review the Report and Recommendation's legal conclusions, as well as\n  those objected to portions, de novo. SEC v. Greenberg, 105 F. Supp. 3d 1342, 1346, 2015 U.S.\n  Dist. LEXIS 66486, *6 (S.D. Fla. 2015). See also Furcron v. Mail Ctrs. Plus, LLC, 843 F.3d\n  1295, 1308 (11th Cir. 2016)(\u201cA timely objection to a Magistrate Judge's Report and\n  Recommendation requires a district court to review the objected-to findings or recommendations\n  de novo\u201d); Willis v. United States, 346 Fed. Appx. 404, 406 (11th Cir. 2009)(\u201cWhen a party\n  objects to the findings contained in a magistrate judge's report and recommendation, the district\n  court must conduct a de novo review of those findings.\u201d)\n           II.      Section 505 of the Copyright Act Authorizes an Award of Costs and Attorney\u2019s\n                    Fees.\n           \u201cUnder the Copyright Act, courts may award reasonable attorney\u2019s fees and costs to the\n  prevailing party in a copyright infringement claim.\u201d Katz v. Chevaldina, 127 F. Supp. 3d 1285\n  (S.D. Fla. 2015). In the present case, it is undisputed that Defendants were \u201cprevailing parties\u201d\n  as defined by the statute. See RAR, p. 7 (\u201cDefendants prevailed at summary judgment on\n  Plaintiff\u2019s Copyright Act Counts, and Plaintiff concedes that Defendants are the prevailing\n  parties as to those Counts.\u201d).\n           \u201cSection 505 of the Copyright Act contains only two requirements for awarding\n  attorneys\u2019 fees: (1) the fees must be awarded to the prevailing party, and (2) the amount of fees\n  awarded must be reasonable.\u2026 A showing of bad faith or frivolity is not a precondition to\n  awarding attorney's fees.\u201d Pronman v. Styles, 2017 U.S. App. LEXIS 824, *6-7 (11th Cir.\n  2017).\n           The case law in this Court and in the Eleventh Circuit is consistent and clear on three\n  crucial and relevant points: (1) an award of attorney\u2019s fees to a prevailing party is the rule, rather\n  than the exception; (2) where the Defendants are the prevailing party, there is a \u201cvery strong\u201d\n\n\n  3\n   In yet another case in this court, Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Maximum Apps Inc. et al, Case No. 1:2015-cv-\n  22463 (S.D. Fla.), the case was dismissed for lack of personal jurisdiction over any of the Defendants; the Plaintiffs\n  appealed to the Eleventh Circuit, and the case was dismissed when Plaintiffs did not even bother to file a brief.\n  Eleventh Circuit, Case No. 16-14813.\n\n                                                             5\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 158 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/08/2017 Page 6 of 16\n\n\n\n\n  presumption in favor of an award of attorney\u2019s fees; and (3) an award of attorney\u2019s fees does not\n  require a showing that the Plaintiff\u2019s claims were frivolous or brought in bad faith. See, e.g.,\n  Pronman, supra at *7 (\u201cIn any case, even in cases where a plaintiff had a reasonable basis to file\n  suit, the award of attorney\u2019s fees to a successful defendant is \u2018the rule rather than the exception,\u2019\n  and \u2018a finding of bad faith or frivolity is not required for an award.\u2019\u201d (citations omitted));\n  Original Appalachian Artworks, Inc. v. McCall Pattern Co., 825 F.2d 355, 356-57 (11th\n  Cir.1987) (\u201cPrevailing defendants who are seeking attorney's fees under the Copyright Act need\n  not show that the plaintiff pursued the case in bad faith or that the claims were frivolous.\u201d);\n  Strategic Mktg. v. Great Blue Heron Software, LLC, 2017 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 23365, *5 (S.D. Fla.\n  Feb. 16, 2017) (\u201c[I]n copyright cases, \u2018although attorneys' fees are awarded in the trial court's\n  discretion, they are the rule rather than the exception and should be awarded routinely.\u2019\u201d); Katz\n  v. Chevaldina, 127 F. Supp. 3d 1285, 1297 (S.D. Fla. 2015) (\u201c[A] finding of bad faith or frivolity\n  is not required for an award. Where a defendant is the prevailing party in a copyright case, the\n  presumption in favor of awarding fees to the defendant is very strong.\u201d); Olem Shoe Corp. v.\n  Wash. Shoe Co., 2015 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 186041, *21-22 (S.D. Fla. Oct. 5, 2015) (\u201cA prevailing\n  party in a copyright action need not prove blameworthiness or exceptional circumstances to be\n  awarded attorneys\u2019 fees.\u201d); Hermosilla v. Coca-Cola Co., 2011 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 156499, *9\n  (S.D. Fla. July 15, 2011) (\u201cWhile the award of attorneys' fees under Section 505 lies within the\n  discretion of the District Court, where a defendant is the prevailing party in a copyright case, the\n  presumption in favor of awarding fees is very strong.\u201d); Lil' Joe Wein Music, Inc. v. Jackson,\n  2008 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 112730, *12-13 (S.D. Fla. June 6, 2008) (\u201cA prevailing party in a\n  copyright action need not prove blameworthiness or exceptional circumstances to be awarded\n  attorney's fees.\u2026 While the award of attorney's fees under Section 505 lies within the discretion\n  of the District Court, where a defendant is the prevailing party in a copyright case, the\n  presumption in favor of awarding fees is very strong.\u201d); Arista Records, Inc. v. Beker Enters.,\n  Inc., 298 F. Supp. 2d 1310, 1316 (S.D. Fla. 2003) (\u201cIn copyright cases, although attorneys\u2019 fees\n  are awarded in the trial court\u2019s discretion, they are the rule rather than the exception and should\n  be awarded routinely.\u201d). See, also, Woodhaven Homes & Realty, Inc. v. Hotz, 396 F.3d 822, 824\n  (7th Cir. 2005) (\u201cWhen the prevailing party is the defendant\u2026the presumption in favor of\n  awarding fees is very strong. For without the prospect of such an award, the party might be\n  forced into a nuisance settlement or deterred all together from exercising his rights.\u201d);\n\n\n                                                    6\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 158 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/08/2017 Page 7 of 16\n\n\n\n\n  Assessment Technologies of WI, LLC v. WIREdata, Inc., 361 F.3d 434, 436 (7th Cir. 2004)\n  (same).\n            In the context of this caselaw and the framework under which the Magistrate should have\n  considered Defendants\u2019 Motion, the Court should reject the RAR\u2019s denial of the Plaintiff\u2019s\n  Motion for Attorney\u2019s Fees.\n            III.   Consideration of the Applicable Factors Justifies an Award of Attorney\u2019s Fees\n            While \u201c[t]here is no precise rule or formula\u201d for determining whether the Court, in its\n  discretion, should award attorney\u2019s fees to a prevailing party, the Supreme Court has identified\n  the following nonexclusive factors, any of which the Court may consider: (1) the degree of\n  success obtained; (2) frivolousness; (3) motivation; (4) objective unreasonableness (both in the\n  factual and in the legal components of the case); and (5) the need in particular circumstances to\n  advance considerations of compensation and deterrence. Fogerty v. Fantasy, Inc., 510 U.S. 517,\n  534 n.19 (1994); Mitek v. Holdings, Inc. v. Arce Engineering Co., 198 F.3d 840, 842 (11th Cir.\n  1999) (enumerating Fogerty factors). See, also, Katz, 127 F. Supp. 3d at 1297 (same).\n  Consideration of these factors demonstrates the appropriateness of a fee award to Defendants.\n                   A. Degree of Success Obtained\n            In its odd zeal to deny Defendants an attorney\u2019s fees award to which there exists a strong\n  presumption of entitlement, the RAR ignores entirely this first factor.\n            In its Complaint, Plaintiff sought, among other things, over $5.5 million in damages and\n  the forfeiture of the Defendants\u2019 internet domains. Instead, all of Plaintiff\u2019s copyright claims\n  were resolved in favor of Defendants. Defendants\u2019 success in this action was total and complete.\n  See Maljack Prods., Inc. v. Goodtimes Home Video Corp., 81 F.3d 881, 890 (9th Cir. 1996)\n  (award of attorney\u2019s fees proper where defendant, for which summary judgment was granted,\n  \u201cobtained total success in defending against [plaintiff\u2019s] copyright claims.\u201d). On June 7, 2016,\n  Plaintiff voluntarily dismissed the remaining claims in the litigation. Docket No. 140. And, on\n  August 8, 2016, Plaintiffs voluntarily dismissed their appeal to the Eleventh Circuit without ever\n  having filed a brief \u2013 apparently recognizing that this Court\u2019s Omnibus Order stood squarely on\n  a solid legal foundation.    Accordingly, an award of fees is warranted.\n\n\n\n\n                                                     7\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 158 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/08/2017 Page 8 of 16\n\n\n\n\n                    B. Frivolousness and Objective Unreasonableness 4\n           As is outlined in detail above, although a party\u2019s bad faith and/or the frivolousness of a\n  party\u2019s claims may factor into the Court\u2019s decision to award fees, a finding of bad faith or\n  frivolity is not required for an award. Supra, pp. 6-7. Indeed, the United States Supreme Court\n  has recently reaffirmed the proposition that a fee award can be appropriate even when the losing\n  party\u2019s position was objectively reasonable:\n           This means in any given case a court may award fees even though the losing party\n           offered reasonable arguments (or conversely, deny fees even though the losing\n           party made unreasonable ones). For example, a court may order fee-shifting\n           because a party\u2019s litigation misconduct, whatever the reasonableness of his claims\n           or defenses.\u2026 Or, a court may do so to deter repeated instances of copyright\n           infringement or overaggressive assertions of copyright claims, again even if the\n           losing position was reasonable in a particular case.\n\n  Kirtsaeng v. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 136 S. Ct. 1979, 1988-89 (2016). See, also, Cable/Home\n  Communication v. Network Productions, Inc., 902 F.2d 829, 853 (11th Cir. 1990) (\u201c[A] showing\n  of bad faith or frivolity is not a precondition to awarding attorney\u2019s fees.\u201d); Casella v. Morris,\n  820 F.2d 362, 366 (11th Cir. 1987); Matthews v. Freedman, 157 F.3d 25, 29 (1st Cir. 1998)\n  (\u201cDepending on other circumstances, a district court could conclude that the losing party should\n  pay even if all of the arguments it made were reasonable.\u201d).\n           In the present case, however, regardless of how the Court conceptualizes this factor \u2013\n  unreasonableness, frivolousness, or bad faith \u2013 the facts counsel in favor of an award of fees. As\n  a starting point, and as this Court properly recognized in the Omnibus Order, even at the\n  summary judgment stage it was wholly unclear why the individual defendants were named as\n  defendants in this case. See Omnibus Order, p. 13, fn. 4. With respect to Defendant Luchian,\n  this Court concluded:\n           There is no record evidence whatsoever to establish that Luchian had any\n           involvement with the facts of this case, other than being listed as the Designated\n           DMCA Agent on the United States Copyright Office\u2019s database. The Court finds\n           Plaintiff has failed to meet its burden in establishing that there is a genuine dispute\n           as to Luchian\u2019s liability for the claims being asserted against him.\n\n  Omnibus Order, p. 36.\n\n\n\n  4\n    Although Fogerty listed these two factors separately, Courts frequently collapse the inquiry into one factor. See,\n  e.g., Katz, 127 F. Supp. 3d at 1298-99.\n\n                                                            8\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 158 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/08/2017 Page 9 of 16\n\n\n\n\n         Similarly, the Court found that there were no allegations as to Defendant Bolotin, but\n  rather that the Plaintiff lumped Mr. Bolotin together with corporate defendant Sun Social Media\n  Inc., without actually articulating or proving any claims against Mr. Bolotin. Omnibus Order, p.\n  13, fn. 4. Without question, the claims brought against the individual defendants could not be\n  considered anything other than frivolous.\n         Nor do the claims against Sun Social fare any better. In its exhaustive Omnibus Order,\n  this Court fully examined \u2013 and rejected \u2013 each of Plaintiff\u2019s theories of liability against Sun\n  Social. In brief, this Court rejected Plaintiff\u2019s claims for direct copyright infringement, agreeing\n  with the Defendants that the Plaintiff had failed to plead or prove any volitional conduct on the\n  Defendants\u2019 part that would subject it to direct liability:\n         The Court agrees with Defendants that in imposing liability upon an internet service\n         provider for third-party users\u2019 uploading of copyrighted material, Plaintiff must\n         establish that Defendants engaged in a volitional act to cause the illegal copying.\n         To find otherwise would impose liability upon an otherwise passive internet service\n         provider for conduct that is simply out of its control.\n\n  Omnibus Order, p. 17.\n         The Court rejected Plaintiff\u2019s claim of contributory infringement, finding that Sun\n  Social\u2019s websites were capable of substantial non-infringing uses:\n         Defendants have demonstrated that their Websites are capable of substantial\n         noninfringing uses, notwithstanding that copyrighted material is, at times, located\n         on their Websites. The Court is satisfied that Defendants have met their burden in\n         establishing that its Websites are capable of substantial, noninfringing purposes,\n         which are legitimate and unobjectionable.\n\n  Omnibus Order, p. 28.\n         The Court rejected Plaintiff\u2019s claims of vicarious copyright infringement, finding that the\n  Plaintiff had failed to demonstrate that the Defendants received any direct financial benefit as a\n  result of the infringement:\n         The Court agrees with Defendants that there is no record evidence to substantiate\n         that Defendants have received a direct financial benefit from the uploading of\n         Plaintiff\u2019s videos.\u2026 It is undisputed that Defendants\u2019 revenues stem solely from\n         advertising. There is no evidence that Plaintiff\u2019s copyrighted videos drew\n         additional traffic to Defendants\u2019 Websites. Plaintiff\u2019s argument that the infringed\n         videos somehow attracted and drew more visitors to Defendants\u2019 Websites, which\n         allowed Defendants to receive more revenue in advertisements, is not supported by\n         record evidence and highly speculative.\n\n\n                                                     9\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 158 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/08/2017 Page 10 of 16\n\n\n\n\n   Omnibus Order, pp. 29-30.\n          And, finally, the Court rejected Plaintiff\u2019s claims of copyright inducement, not only\n   because the Plaintiff did not even bother to present argument in favor of its claim, but also\n   because of a wholesale lack of record evidence to support such a claim:\n          Defendants argue that they cannot be liable for inducement of copyright\n          infringement because SSM has not induced or encouraged any user to engage in\n          direct infringement. Bolotin Decl. \u00b6 40. Plaintiff neither responds to Defendants\u2019\n          arguments as they pertain to Count IV, nor does Plaintiff move for summary\n          judgment as to Count IV in its briefing. Aside from Plaintiff\u2019s failure to respond to\n          Defendants\u2019 arguments, the Court agrees with Defendants that there is no record\n          evidence that Defendants induced the third-party users\u2019 into uploading copyrighted\n          material.\n\n   Omnibus Opposition, p. 30.\n          Despite this Court\u2019s comprehensive findings, the Magistrate found that the Plaintiff\u2019s\n   claims were not frivolous based on a single finding: \u201cDefendants conceded that Plaintiff owned\n   valid copyrights to the videos at issue in this case. Thus, the undersigned that Plaintiff\u2019s case\n   was not frivolous.\u201d RAR, p. 8.\n          It would be hard to overstate just how erroneous this conclusion is or how it would upend\n   the legion of caselaw supporting attorney\u2019s fees awards for successful defendants. It would, for\n   example, mean that every defendant who succeeded on copyright claims with defenses of: fair\n   use; DMCA safe harbor; lack of volitional behavior, license or consent; parody; de minimus use;\n   or copyright misuse would all be denied recovery of attorney\u2019s fees because \u2013 in each instance \u2013\n   although the defendant was successful in defeating the claims, the Plaintiff held a valid\n   copyright. This is simply not the law.\n          Moreover, with respect to the individual defendants, the RAR\u2019s conclusion is all the more\n   absurd. This Court found no basis whatsoever for the allegations made against the individuals\n   and yet the RAR would deny them recovery of attorney\u2019s fees simply because the Plaintiffs hold\n   valid copyrights. Under this theory, a copyright holder could sue every single individual within\n   the United States (without any evidence that any of them infringed the Plaintiff\u2019s works), but the\n   cases would still not be frivolous because \u201cPlaintiff owned valid copyrights.\u201d\n          This conclusion recalls the old legal saw that: \u201cto state the argument is to refute it.\u201d As\n   the Court\u2019s findings in the Omnibus Order indicate, each of Plaintiff\u2019s copyright claims were\n   frivolous or, at a minimum, objectively unreasonable and brought in bad faith. Indeed, because\n\n\n                                                    10\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 158 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/08/2017 Page 11 of 16\n\n\n\n\n   the Plaintiff\u2019s claims were so lacking, the Court was never required to consider the other\n   affirmative basis for the Defendants\u2019 Motion for Summary Judgment, namely that the\n   Defendants were entitled to safe harbor under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. In other\n   words, even if the Plaintiffs had managed to meet their burdens of proof under their copyright\n   claims, they would nonetheless have failed. As such, an award of fees is warranted. 5\n                     C. Motivation\n            Defendants have long argued that the Plaintiff in this case has not acted in a manner\n   consistent with a party legitimately looking to protect its intellectual property rights, but rather\n   that the Plaintiff \u2013 which filed at least 20 boilerplate complaints in a 15-month timeframe \u2013\n   simply decided to exploit a new revenue stream, namely, wresting nuisance settlements from\n   defendants who were otherwise faced with mounting legal fees. Indeed, this case, and the others\n   filed by the Plaintiff, have always been about one thing: forcing defendants to settle frivolous\n   cases or face the pressure of ever-mounting legal bills.6 It is an understandable (if ethically\n   questionable) tactic for the Plaintiff \u2013 which ordinarily relies on monthly subscriptions of $8.33\n   per user \u2013 to take. Every $50,000 settlement that the Plaintiff extorts represents 6,000 monthly\n   subscriptions that the Plaintiff need not sell. It is, if one has no concern about the misuse of legal\n   process, an excellent revenue model. It is also precisely the type of lawsuit that Section 505 of\n   the Copyright Act is intended to deter:\n            [A]ttorney\u2019s fees should be awarded to deter plaintiffs from \u2018bringing unreasonable\n            claims based on a cost/benefit analysis that tells such plaintiffs that they can score big if\n            they win and that there will be no adverse consequences for losing.\n\n   Lil\u2019 Joe Wein Music, Inc. v. Jackson, 2008 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 112730, *21-22 (S.D. Fla. 2008).\n\n\n\n\n   5\n     It is worth noting that, following the dismissal of the Plaintiff\u2019s copyright claims in this case, the Defendants also\n   voluntarily dismissed two other actions filed in this Court. Plaintiff voluntarily dismissed its complaint in Hydentra,\n   L.P. HLP General Partner, Inc. et al v. ERA Technologies, Ltd. et al, Case No. 1:15-cv-24293-MGC (S.D. Fla.) and\n   in Hydentra, L.P. HLP General Partner, Inc. et al v. Siracusa Management S.A. et al, Case No. 1:16-cv-20191-RNS\n   (S.D. Fla.). In both cases, Plaintiff explicitly referenced the adverse decisions in this case and the case in support of\n   its dismissal. Presumably, if the Plaintiff\u2019s cases were based on actual facts, the dismissal of one case would not\n   mandate the dismissal of the other cases brought by the Plaintiff.\n   6\n     Indeed, in this particular case, the Defendants (who had always been responsive to takedown notices received from\n   the Plaintiff) pushed for an early mediation, hoping that the matter could be quickly and amicably resolved before\n   either party was required to expend significant amounts on attorney\u2019s fees. The Plaintiff refused all such overtures,\n   insisting that they would not mediate until after all discovery had been completed, ensuring that a voluntary\n   resolution was less likely to occur. This was a perfect example of the old adage that pigs get fat and hogs get\n   slaughtered.\n\n                                                              11\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 158 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/08/2017 Page 12 of 16\n\n\n\n\n            Here, too, the rationale of the RAR is flawed. The RAR, in essence, found that because\n   the Plaintiffs were copyright holders whose videos had been allegedly been infringed, that the\n   present action was, by necessity, brought in good faith. In reaching this conclusion, the RAR\n   seemingly ignored entirely: (a) the Parties\u2019 prior dealings (and Defendants\u2019 willingness to\n   remove infringing content)7; (b) the Plaintiffs\u2019 conduct in numerous other litigations; (c) the\n   Plaintiffs\u2019 conduct in this litigation; and (d) the Plaintiffs\u2019 post-litigation conduct.\n            The Plaintiff\u2019s actions in this litigation (and others) paint a picture of a Plaintiff willing to\n   file frivolous motion after frivolous motion in an attempt to ratchet up Defendant\u2019s costs (and,\n   thereby, the likelihood of settlement). Because the Plaintiff\u2019s motivation was not the legitimate\n   protection of its intellectual property, this factor, too, favors an award of fees.\n                     D. Compensation and Deterrence\n            \u201cThe touchstone of attorney\u2019s fees under Section 505 is whether imposition of attorney\u2019s\n   fees will further the interests of the Copyright Act.\u201d Kernel Records Oy v. Mosley, 2013 U.S.\n   Dist. LEXIS 99094 (S. D. Fla. July 16, 2013) (finding that defendants\u2019 success weighed heavily\n   in favor of an award of attorney\u2019s fees). \u201cDefendants\u2019 efforts in pursuit of this successful\n   defense should be compensated in order to encourage further meritorious defenses.\u201d Id. at *32.\n   See, also, Mitchell-Proffitt Company v. Eagle Crest, Inc., 2005 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 33535, *7-8\n   (M.D. Fla. Nov. 28, 2005) (\u201cBecause copyright law ultimately serves the purpose of enriching\n   the general public through access to creative works, it is peculiarly important that the boundaries\n   of copyright law be demarcated as clearly as possible. To that end, defendants who seek to\n   advance a variety of meritorious copyright defenses should be encouraged to litigate them to the\n   same extent plaintiff are encouraged to litigate meritorious claims of infringement.\u2026 Defendant\n\n\n   7\n     Defendants also note that Plaintiff\u2019s pre-litigation conduct demonstrates that the Plaintiff was not looking to\n   legitimately protect its intellectual property rights. Rather than sending its takedown notices via email (enabling the\n   infringing content to be removed more expeditiously and more accurately), Plaintiff\u2019s sent hard copy takedown\n   notices. It is extremely unusual for studios that are actually interested in protecting their content to send such hard-\n   copy takedown notices because sending such notices drastically decreases the likelihood that infringing content will\n   be taken down. This is true because the relevant links usually contain extremely long and random strings of\n   characters. When studios send electronic notices (as they usually do) a site can simply click on the allegedly\n   infringing link (or cut and paste the link into a browser). When a hard copy is sent, someone must manually type the\n   long random string of characters into a web browser, increasing the possibility of error. Sending hard copy notices\n   is an attempt to create a forced error so that Hydentra can then initiate a frivolous suit. Additionally, as this Court\n   found, Sun Social had consistently and expeditiously removed infringing content from its sites when it received\n   takedown notices from the Plaintiff. Sun Social argued throughout the litigation that it had not received the\n   takedown notices in issue in this litigation and, as the Court found, Sun Social promptly removed the allegedly\n   infringing materials upon receiving the Complaint in this case. Omnibus Order, p. 10.\n\n                                                             12\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 158 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/08/2017 Page 13 of 16\n\n\n\n\n   should be compensated for its vigorous defense of the boundaries of copyright law.\u201d); Katz, 127\n   F. Supp. 3d at 1300 (\u201cJust as when plaintiffs succeed on their claims, a successful defense also\n   helps define the boundaries of copyright infringement law. It also continues to allow the public\n   to have access to creative elements and ideas.\u2026 Under this last factor of compensation and\n   deterrence, an award of attorney's fees furthers the goals of the Copyright Act and Fogerty by\n   encouraging defendants to pursue their meritorious defenses to copyright infringement claims.\u201d);\n   Lil\u2019 Joe Wein Music, Inc., supra, at *21-22 (\u201c[A]ttorney\u2019s fees should be awarded to deter\n   plaintiffs from \u2018bringing unreasonable claims based on a cost/benefit analysis that tells such\n   plaintiffs that they can score big if they win and that there will be no adverse consequences for\n   losing.\u2019\u201d (quoting Baker v. Urban Outfitters, Inc., 431 F. Supp. 2d 351, 359 (S.D.N.Y. 2006))).\n           Here, the RAR engaged in circular logic to find that an award of attorney\u2019s fees would\n   not serve the goals of compensation and deterrence: basing its findings on its earlier (flawed)\n   conclusions that the Plaintiffs\u2019 case was not frivolous and not brought in bad faith.\n           In truth, in the present case, the Defendants have \u2013 at great cost \u2013 defended an action that\n   should never have been initiated and which Plaintiff litigated in a manner calculated to ensure\n   that Defendants would incur the maximum amounts of costs and fees possible (going so far as to\n   spurn efforts at earlier mediation). The Court\u2019s extensive Order has helped to define the\n   contours of copyright liability. Indeed, there is no need to speculate as to whether the decision in\n   this case will deter the Plaintiff from bringing other frivolous actions: since the Court\u2019s Order,\n   the Plaintiff has already dismissed two other near-identical actions against other defendants,\n   citing the Court\u2019s decision in this matter.8\n           For this reason as well, Defendants are entitled to an award of attorney\u2019s fees.\n           IV.      The Fees Sought By The Defendants Are Reasonable.\n           In Katz, this Court discussed in detail the considerations for the District Court in\n   determining the proper amounts of attorney\u2019s fees to be awarded:\n           Having determined that Defendant is entitled to fees and costs, the Court must next\n           determine what amount is reasonable. The Supreme Court has stressed that the\n           determination of fees \u201cshould not result in a second major litigation.\u201d\u2026 Fee\n           applicants must submit appropriate documentation to meet \u201cthe burden of\n           establishing entitlement to an award.\u201d\u2026 \u201cBut trial courts need not, and indeed\n           should not, become green-eyeshade accountants. The essential goal in shifting fees\n   8\n    The Plaintiff in another case (who is represented by the same counsel) also dismissed its action, citing to the\n   Court\u2019s decision in this matter. See AMA Multimedia, LLC v. ERA Technologies, Ltd., Case No. 1:15-cv-24289-\n   FAM (S.D. Fla.), Docket No. 54, July 25, 2016.\n\n                                                           13\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 158 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/08/2017 Page 14 of 16\n\n\n\n\n          (to either party) is to do rough justice, not to achieve auditing perfection. So trial\n          courts may take into account their overall sense of a suit, and may use estimates in\n          calculating and allocating an attorney's time.\u201d\n                  The existing settled law in this Circuit mandates calculating a reasonable\n          attorney's fee by using the Lodestar method, which requires this Court to multiply\n          counsel's reasonable hourly rate by the reasonable hours expended. \u2026Defendant\n          bears the burden of documenting reasonable hourly rates and reasonable hours\n          expended.\n\n   Katz, 127 F. Supp. 3d at 1031.\n          In the present case, the fees sought by the defendants are eminently reasonable: counsel\u2019s\n   rates range from $300 per hour to $450 per hour, consistent with (if not lower than) the\n   reasonable hourly rate charged by \u201clawyers of reasonably comparable skills, experience, and\n   reputation.\u201d Norman v. Housing Authority of Montgomery, 836 F.2d 1292, 1299 (11th Cir.\n   1988). All counsel have submitted affidavits in connection with this Motion in support of the\n   hourly rates charged.\n          Plaintiff would be hard-pressed to complain that the hourly rates charged are\n   unreasonable: in a similar case (in which the Plaintiff obtained a default judgment), Hydentra\u2019s\n   lead attorney, Spencer Freeman (lead counsel in this case as well), who has comparable\n   experience as Attorneys Gurvits and Fray-Witzer, billed at $450 an hour, a rate that he\n   represented to the Court was a reasonable one. See Exhibit 1 to Defendants\u2019 Motion for\n   Attorney\u2019s Fees.\n          Similarly, the hours expended were reasonable given the complexities of the case, the\n   number of motions filed by the Plaintiff, and the fact that the Defendants had already completed\n   most of the trial preparations when the Court\u2019s Order was issued. A precise breakdown of the\n   hours expended, sorted first by attorney and then by date, is attached as Exhibit 3 to Defendants\u2019\n   Reply in Support of Motion for Attorney\u2019s Fees (Docket No. 155-3) and is incorporated herein,\n   by reference.\n                                            CONCLUSION\n          For the reasons stated hereinabove and in the Declarations of Brady Cobb, Val Gurvits,\n   Matthew Shayefar, and Evan Fray-Witzer, filed with Defendants\u2019 Motion for Attorney\u2019s Fees,\n   and the reply in support thereof, Defendants respectfully object to the Magistrate\u2019s Report and\n   Recommendation and request that the Court reject the RAR and, instead, allow Defendants\u2019\n   Motion for Attorney\u2019s Fees in the amount of $151,902.50.\n\n\n                                                   14\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 158 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/08/2017 Page 15 of 16\n\n\n\n\n         Respectfully submitted this 8th day of March, 2017.\n\n                                             COBB EDDY, PLLC\n                                             642 Northeast Third Avenue\n                                             Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33304\n                                             Telephone (954) 527-4111\n                                             Facsimile (954) 900-5507\n\n                                             By: ___/s/ BRADY J. COBB_______\n                                             BRADY J. COBB, ESQUIRE\n                                             Florida Bar No. 031018\n                                             bcobb@cobbeddy.com\n                                             Attorney for Defendants Constantin\n                                             Luchian, Konstantin Bolotin, and Sun\n                                             Social Media Inc.\n\n\n\n\n                                                15\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 158 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/08/2017 Page 16 of 16\n\n\n\n\n                                   CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\n\n          I hereby certify that a true and correct copy of the foregoing was served electronically\n   via the CM/ECF electronic filing system on all counsel or parties of record on the service list\n   below this 8th day of March, 2017.\n\n                                                        /s/ Brady J. Cobb\n                                                        Brady J. Cobb\n\n\n\n\n                                           SERVICE LIST\n\n   Aaron Behar, Esquire\n   Jaclyn Behar, Esquire\n   BEHARBEHAR\n   1840 North Commerce Parkway\n   Suite One\n   Weston, Florida 33326\n   Telephone: (954) 688-7642\n   Facsimile: (954) 332-9260\n   AB@BeharBehar.com\n   JB@BeharBehar.com\n   Spencer D. Freeman\n   Freeman Law Firm, Inc.\n   1107 1/2 Tacoma Avenue South\n   Tacoma, Washington 98402\n   Telephone: (206) 516-3800\n   Facsimile: (206) 516-3888\n   sfreeman@freemanlawfirm.org\n\n\n\n\n                                                   16\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2024-06-29T12:28:32.947102-07:00","document_number":"158","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"051017657381","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Objections to Report and Recommendations","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.577441-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-29T11:54:26.171508-07:00","date_filed":"2017-03-08","time_filed":null,"entry_number":158,"recap_sequence_number":"2017-03-08.001","pacer_sequence_number":478,"description":"OBJECTIONS to 157 Report and Recommendations by Konstantin Bolotin, Constantin Luchian, Sun Social Media, Inc.. (Cobb, Brady) (Entered: 03/08/2017)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/171244038/","id":171244038,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/176529109/","id":176529109,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/157/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.563681-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-29T11:54:26.157745-07:00","sha1":"fb6c55c3dfaa8c42e0a79bafe8c6c5201f43de36","page_count":12,"file_size":620890,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.157.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.157.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 1 of 12\n\n\n\n\n                            UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                            SO U TH ER N D ISTR ICT O F FLO R IDA\n\n                      CASE NO.:15-22134-ClV-UNGARO/OTAZO-% YES\n\n  H YDEN TM H LP IN T.LIM ITED ,\n  a foreign colw ration d/b/a M ETA R T,\n\n         Plaintiff,\n\n\n\n  CON STA N TIN LU CH IA N ,an individual,\n  KON STANTW BOLOTIN,an individual,\n  SUN SOC IA L M ED IA ,IN C .,a corporation,\n  individually and d/b/aPLAYVID.COM ,\n  FEEDV ID .CO M ,PLAY V ID S.COM ,and\n  PEEKV ID S.CO M ;PLA YV ID .CO M ;\n  FEED V ID .CO M ;PLA YV ID S.CO M ;\n  PEEK V ID S.CO M ;and\n  Jolm Does 1-20,\n\n         Defendants.\n                                                      /\n\n                            REPORT AND RECOM M ENDATION\n\n         THIS CAUSE cnmebeforethe Courtupon DefendantsConstantin Luchian (1$Luchian''),\n  Konstantin Bolotin (d1Bolotin''), and Sun Social M edia, lnc.'s (\u00fb$SSM '') (collectively,\n  ir efendants'')M otion forAttorney's Fees (hereafter,\u00e7fM otion for Fees'') (D.E.1481. This\n  matterwasreferred to the undersigned pursuantto 28 U.S.C.j 636 by the HonorableUrsula\n  Ungaro,United States District Judge (D.E. 1511. For the reasons discussed below,the\n  undersigned respectfully recomm endsthatDefendants'M otion forFeesbeDENIED.\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 2 of 12\n\n\n\n\n                       FA CT UA L A N D PR O C EDU R AL BA C K G R O U N D\n\n         Plaintiff Hydentra HLP lnt. Limited (sll-lydentra'' or i\u00e7plaintiff') produced or held\n  licensing rights to adult-content videos,which were displayed on Hydentra's websites. See\n\n  OmnibusOrder(D.E.138at1-21.1\n         Defendant SSM developed the following video-sharing websites through which users\n\n  could upload adult-contentvideos:Playvid.com ,Playvids.com ,Peekvids.com ,and Feedvid.com\n\n  (collectively,\u00e7iW ebsites''). ld.at3-4.Videosavailable on SSM 'SW ebsiteswereuploaded by\n  SSM 'Susers,notby SSM oritsagentsorcontractors.Id.at3.\n\n         DefendantBolotin wasthedirectorofoperationsatSSM .Ld.aat4.\n         SSM designated Defendant Luchian as its agent to receive notitications of claim ed\n\n  infringement(hereafter,i\u00e7takedown notices''),pursuanttotheDigitalM illennium CopyrightAct\n  (\u00e7$DM cA''). Id.at5.2 On its W ebsites,SSM provided a number of methods for sending\n  takedow n notices to Luchian,including via em ail or physicaldelivery. Id.at 5-6. G enerally,\n\n  within 48 hours of receiving a takedown notice via physicaldelivery,Luchian scanned itand\n\n  emailed itto SSM . 1d.at7. Under SSM 'S procedures,upon receiving a takedown notice,it\n\n  acted to removetheinfringing videos. Id.at6.\n\n         HydentrahiredJasonTucker($1Tucker'')toinvestigateinfringementofitscopyrightsand\n  to sendtakedownnoticesfordetected infringements.J#-,at9.Tuckerdiscovered thatanumber\n  ofHydentra'scopyrighted videoswere displayed on Playvid.com. Ld.a On January 15,2015,\n  Tucker senta package containing takedown noticesto Luchian via U .S.m ail,using a tracking\n\n\n\n\n  1The Om nibusOrderhas been published atHydentra HLP lnt. Ltd.v.Luchian,No.1:15-cv-22134-UU,\n  2016W L 5951808(S.D.Fla.June2,2016).\n  2The DM CA shieldsservice providersfrom liability forthe actsofthird-party users, where theproviders\n  meetcertain criteriasuchasdesignatinganagentto receivetakedown notices. See l7U.S.C.j 512(c)(2).\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 3 of 12\n\n\n\n\n   numberto confinn thatthe package wasreceived. J\n                                                 i.at9-10.3 On January 20,2015,Carmen\n                                                 .\n   Jusino (s1Jusino'')signed forthepackage on Luchian'sbehalf. Id.at10. However,liLuchian\n   neverpersonally received thepackage ...and claimged)thatitwaslostaherJusino signed for\n   gitq.'' 1d.'CSSM claimledjthatitneverreceivedthesetakedownnoticesand wasunawareofthe\n   allegedly infringing filesuntilthis lawsuit.'' 1d. Priorto the filing ofthislawsuit,SSM did not\n\n   removeHydentra'scopyrightedvideosfrom Playvid.com (D.E.155at2).\n          On June 4, 2015, Hydentra filed this action asserting the following claim s against\n\n   Defendants:\n\n          Count1:       DirectCopyrightInfringementUndertheCopyrightAct,17U.S.C.jj101\n                        etseg.(hereaher,\u00e7icopyrightAct'');\n          CountlI:      Contributory CopyrightInfringem ent;\n\n          Count111:     VicariousCopyrightInfringement;\n\n          Count1V:      Inducement of Copyright Infringement (Counts I-IV collectively,\n                        iscopyrightActCounts'');\n          CountV:       Unauthorized Publication ofN ame and Likeness in Violation of Florida\n                        Statutej540.08;\n          CountVI:      TrademarklnfringementUndertheLanham Act,15U.S.C.j1114;\n          CountVlI:     Contributory Trademark lnfringement;\n\n          CountV1l1: FalseDesignationofOriginUndertheLanhnm Act,15U.S.C.j 1125.\n   SeeCompl.(D.E.1at14-381.Hydentrasought,interalia,damagesSsfora11infringingactivities''\n   from the date on which its copyrights were first infringed;and to enjoin Defendants from\n   engaging in further infringing activities. ld.at 17-18,20-21,23-24,26-27. Hydentra attached to\n\n  the Com plainta listidentifying its copyrighted videos thatw ere displayed on the W ebsites. Id.\n\n\n\n  3 Later, Tucker discovered more of Hydentra's copyrighted videos displayed on Playvids.com ,\n  Peekvids.com,and Feedvid.com ;buthedid notsend takedown noticesasto these videos. Id.at 2,9.\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 4 of 12\n\n\n\n\n  at41-46. Upon receiving the Com plaint,'tSSM disabled access to and/orrem oved''the listed\n\n  videos.SeeOmnibusOrder(D.E.138at10j.\n         On February 12, 2016, Hydentra and Defendants filed Cross M otions for Summary\n\n  Judgment(D.E.72,73 & 861.4 On June2,2016,theCourtissuedan OmnibusOrderruling on\n\n  thesummaryjudgmentmotions.SeeOmnibusOrder(D.E.1381.\n         Regarding Count 1,Hydentra needed to establish thatit owned valid copyrights to the\n\n  videosatissueand thatDefendantscopiedthevideos. J/..Sat14-15. Defendantsconceded that\n  H ydentra owned valid copyrights to the videos at issue. 1d. at 15. Thus,the Court had to\n\n  determine S\u00e7whetherDefendantsmay beheld liable fordirectinfringem entbased upon third-party\n\n  users'uploading of gldydentra's)copyrighted videos onto Defendants'W ebsites-'' Id. ln its\n  analysis,the Courtnoted that,to establish such liability,Hydentra had to provef\u00e7thatDefendants\n\n  engaged in a volitionalactto cause the illegalcopying'';butacknowledged thatthe Eleventh\n\n  Circuithad k%notconsidered whether volitional conductis a necessary elem entfor inding an\n\n  internetcompany liable fordirectcopyrightinfringement,'' Id.at 15,17. Hydentra argued that\n\n  Dtfendants engaged in volitionalacts by em ploying a m oderator to screen videos thatwere\n\n  uploaded to,but not yet displayed on, their W ebsites showing S\u00e7child pornography,animal\n\n  pornography,spam,and to ensure thatthevideo constitutegd)adultentertainment.'' 1d.at18.\n  However, the Court disagreed that such m onitoring constituted volitional acts. 1d. at 20.\n\n  Accordingly,the Courtgranted SSM and Bolotin'sM otion forSum mary Judgm entand denied\n\n  Hydentra'sM otion forSummaryJudgmentastoCount1.J#a.\n        Regarding Count11,Hydentra needed to establish:thatD efendants knew orhad reason to\n\n  know aboutthe infringing activity;thatDefendants induced,caused,orm aterially contributed to\n\n\n  4 SSM and Bolotin filed ajointM otion forSummary Judgment,while Luchian moved for summary\n  judgmentindependently.\n                                               4\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 5 of 12\n\n\n\n\n  the infringing conductof another; and that ilthe product in question (was not) capable of\n  Ssubstantialnoninfringing uses.''' Id.at24,26. Afterdetennining thata question offactexisted\n\n  as to whether Defendants had constructive knowledge of the infringing activities,the Court\n\n  proceeded to discuss the noninfringing-use requirem ent. 1d. at 26. W ith respect to the\n\n  noninfringing-use requirement,Hydentra argued thattherequirementapplied only to the sale of\n\n  products,notto casesinvolving the use ofa website;and that\u00e7ithere(was)nothing aboutthe\n  infringing videosthathaldqanon-infringingpurpose.'' Id.at27. TheCourtrecognized thatthe\n  noninfringing-use requirementoriginally addressed only the sale ofproducts;butexplained that\n\n  the requirement predated the Internet and found that it applied in this case. 1d. Further,\n\n  Deftndants dem onstrated thattheW ebsiteswere capable ofsubstantialnoninfringing usessince\n\n  SSM started as an online dating website;and the W ebsites hosted videos and allow ed usersto\n\n  upload,playback,and organize videos. Ld..\n                                          a at 27-28. Hence,the Courtgranted SSM and\n  Bolotin'sM otionforSummaryJudgmentastoCountl1.J.Z at28.\n         Regarding Count111,Hydentra needed to establish thatDefendantsprofited directly from\n\n  theinfringementandthatthey declined to exercisearightto stop orlimittheinfringement Ld-a\n  at28-29. Hydentra argued thatSSM was compensated by advertisersbased on the am ountof\n\n  lnternettraffic thatwasdirected to the advertisers'websitesfrom SSM 'SW ebsites. Ld.aat29.\n  Therefore, Hydentra argued thatthe existence of its copyrighted videos on SSM 'S W ebsites\n\n  dlfinancially benefitgedj Defendants''because \u00e7ithe attractiveness of the content''on SSM 'S\n  W ebsiteswould increasetrafscto theadvertisers'websites. J#a However,theCourtfoundthat\n  there was iino evidence that (Hydentra'sl copyrighted videos drew additional traffic to\n  Defendants' W ebsitess''so Hydentra could not establish that Defendants \u00fbtreceived a direct\n\n\n\n\n                                              5\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 6 of 12\n\n\n\n\n  snancialbenefitfrom theuploading of(Hydentra'sjvideos.'' Ld-us Thus,theCourtgrantedSSM\n  andBolotin'sM otion forSummaryJudgmentastoCount111.J#.,at30.\n         Regarding Count 1V,the Courtnoted that Hydentra neither responded to Defendants'\n\n  arguments,normoved forsummaryjudgmentastothisCount. Ld= The Courtfoundthatthere\n  wasno evidence thatDefendantsinduced users to upload copyrighted videos because they acted\n\n  as ilpassive intenwt service providers.'' ld. Therefore,the Courtgranted SSM and Bolotin's\n\n  M otionforSummaryJudgmentastoCountIV.l/s\n         A dditionally,the Courtgranted SSM and Bolotin's M otion for Sum m ary Judgm entasto\n\n  CountV;denied itasto CountsVI-VII1;and denied Hydentra'sM otion forSumm ary Judgment.\n  ld. at37.5\n\n         On June7,2016,Hydentrafiled aM otion to DismisswithoutprejudiceCountsVI-Vll1\n  which the Courtgranted,thereby dismissing the remaining Countsand closing the case (D.E.\n  140& 141).\n         On August2,2016,Defendantsfiled the instantM otion forFees seeking $162,165.00 in\n\n  attomey'sfeespursuanttotheCopyrightAct. See Motion forFees(D.E.148j. OnAugust19,\n  2016,Hydentra tsled itsOpposition to Defendants'M otion for Fees (hereafter,diplaintiff's\n  Response'')(D.E.154j. On August26,2016,Defendantsfiled theirReply in Supportoftheir\n  M otion for Fees (hereafter,SsDefendants'Reply'') ED.E.155) in which Defendants corrected\n  errors in theirinitialfee calculation and soughtan amended totalof$151,902.50 in attorney's\n\n  fees.1d.at5.\n\n                                       APPLICA BLE LA W\n\n         In copyright infringem entactions,Section 505 of the Copyright A ctauthorizes courts to\n\n  dlaward areasonableattorney'sfeetotheprevailingpartyaspartofthecosts.'' 17 U.S.C.j505,\n  5The Courtalso granted Luchian'sM otion forSum mary Judgment. J-1J.Sat36.\n                                                  6\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 7 of 12\n\n\n\n\n  Generally,the prevailing party is S\u00e7the party succeeding on a signifkant litigated issue that\n\n  achievessom eofthe benefitssoughtby thatparty in initiating the suit.'' Cable/Home Comm c'n\n\n  Corp.v.Network Prods..lnc.,902 F.2d 829,853 (11th Cir.1990). Here,Defendantsprevailed\n  at summary judgment on Plaintiffs Copyright Act Counts, and Plaintiff concedes that\n  Defendantsaretheprevailing partiesastothose Counts. SeePlaintiffsResponse ED.E.154 at\n  10).\n         Asprevailingparties,Defendantsbeartheburden ofestablishing entitlementto attom ey's\n\n  fees. Katzv.Chevaldina,127 F.Supp.3d 1285,1296(S.D.Fla.2015). Thedecision to award\n  attom ey'sfeesfallswithin thecourt'ssound discretion. Klein & Heuchan.Inc.v.CostarRealtv\n\n  lnfo..lnc.,No.8:08-cv-l227-T-30EAJ,2011W L 6097980,at*2 (M .D.Fla.Dec.7,2011). In\n  exercisingtheirdiscretion,courtsconsiderthefollowingnon-exclusivefactors:(1)frivolousness;\n (2)motivation;(3)objective urtreasonablenessofthe non-prevailing party'spositions;and (4)\n the need to advance considerations ofcompensation and deterrence. Foaerty v.Fantasy.lnc.,\n\n  510 U .S.517,534n.19(1994).6\n\n                                          DISCU SSIO N\n\n     (1)Frivolousness\n         ikFrivolousness,incopyrightcases,isusually foundin casesinwhichthe(plaintiffjdoes\n noteven own the copyrightin question orhasgranted a licenseto the alleged infringerbutsues\n\n forinfringem entnonetheless.'' M edallion HomesGulfCoast.lnc.v.TivoliHom esofSarasota.\n\n Inc.,No.8:14-cv-3117-T-33JSS,2016 W L 5870215,at*2 (M .D.Fla.Oct.7,2016)(citations\n omitted);ProflLED Lichtinc.Ltd.v.AAdvn Tech..LLC,88 F.Supp.3d 1356,1375 (S.D.Fla.\n 2015)(same). Defendantsarguethatt'the claimsbroughtagainst(Bolotin and Luchian)could\n\n 6Thesearegenerally called the ddFogertv''factors. M alibu M edia.LLC v.Pelizzos604 F.App'x 879 881\n (11thCir.2015).\n\f'\n\n\n\n\nl\n.\n    Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 8 of 12\n\u00e8\n\n\n\n      notbe eonsidered anything other than frivolous.'' See Motion for Fees CD.E. 148 at 9).\n      However,Defendantsconceded thatPlaintiffowned valid copyrightsto thevideosatissue in this\n\n      case.Thus,the undersigned concludesthatPlaintiffscase wasnotfrivolous. M edallion Homes\n\n      GulfCoast,2016 W L 5870215,at*2;Pm flLED Lighting,88 F.Supp.3d at 1375. Therefore,\n\n      thisfactormilitatesagainstawarding attorney'sfeestoDefendants.\n\n         (2)M otivation\n            In evaluating this factor,courts considerwhether the non-prevailing \u00e9sparty litigated in\n\n      good orbad faith.'' Klein & Heuchan,2011 W L 6097980,at#5. Thisdetennination may turn\n\n      on a num berofconsiderations,including whetherthe non-prevailing party initiated the lawsuit\n\n      foran impropermotive. ld.;see Luken v.lnt'lYachtCouncil.Ltd.,581 F.Supp.2d 1226,1245\n\n      (S.D.Fla.2008)(consideringthenon-prevailingparty'smotivationforbringingthelawsuit).\n            Defendants argue that Plaintiff brought this action in bad faith for the pumose of\n\n      achieving awindfallby forcingasettlement.SeeMotionforFees(D.E.148 at11). Tosupport\n      thisposition,Defendantsarguethat:(1)Plaintiff'slawsuitshould neverhavebeen initiated;(2)\n      Plaintiffsentthe takedown noticesvia U.S.mail,ratherthan em ail,to m anufacture Defendants'\n\n      error;and (3)Plaintiff did notdismissthislawsuitafter Defendantsremoved its copyrighted\n      videos from the W ebsites. Id.at2,11 n.7,13;Defendants'Reply (D.E.155 at2-31. The\n      undersigned findsno meritin theseargum ents.\n            First,Plaintiffonly fled this lawsuitafter:Plaintiffdiscovered its copyrighted videoson\n\n      Playvid.com ;PlaintiffsentLuchian takedown notices via U.S.m ail;the takedown noticeswere\n      delivered to,and accepted by,Jusino on Luchian's behalf;and Plaintiff's copyrighted videos\n\n      werenotrem oved from Playvid.vom .Given thispre-suithistory,theundersigned concludesthat\n\n      Plaintifffiledthisaction in good faith to protectitscopyrighted videos. S4\u00e7 Luken,581F.Supp.\n\n\n                                                     8\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 9 of 12\n\n\n\n\n  2d at1245 (ltltgoeswithoutsaying thatprotection ofone'scopyrightconstitutesapermissible\n  m otivation in sling a copyright infringement case against one whom the copyright holder\n\n  believesingoodfaithtohaveinfringedthecopyright.'').\n         Second,pursuantto inform ation on SSM 'S W ebsites,takedown notices could be sentto\n\n  Luchian viaem ailorphysicaldelivery,so Plaintiffsentthetakedown noticesin accordance with\n\n  SSM 'Sinstructions.Therefore,the method ofdelivery isnotevidenceofimproperm otivation.\n\n         Third,although Defendants removed Plaintiffs copyrighted videos from the W ebsites\n\n  afterbeing served with theComplaint,such removaldid notobligePlaintiffto dismissthisaction\n\n  given thatPlaintiffsoughtto recoverdamagesfrom the date on which its copyrightswere frst\n\n  infringed.\n\n        Therefore,the undersigned concludesthatPlaintiffbroughtthisaction in good faith,and\n\n  notforan impropermotive. Klein & Heuchan,2011W L 6097980,at*5;Luken,581 F.Supp.\n\n 2d at1245. Thus,thisfactormilitatesagainstawarding attorney'sfeesto Defendants.\n\n     (3)ObjectiveUnreasonableness\n        To detenninewhetherthe non-prevailing party'sposition wasobjectively unreasonable,\n courts consider\u00fbithe clarity ofthe law w ith respectto the losing party's position atthe tim e that\n\n the losing party pressed itsargum ent.'' Luken,581 F.Supp.2d at 1240. To thatend,courts\n\n consider whether the unsuccessful lfposition was patently without m erit or otherw ise clearly\n\n  lacking alegalorfactualbasis.''Klein & Heuchan,2011W L 6097980,at*2 (citation omitted).\n The Supreme Courthas recently cautioned that \u00e7lobjective reasonableness can be only an\n  im portant factor in assessing fee applications not the controlling one.'' K irtsaeng v. John\n\n  W iley& Sons.Inc.,136S.Ct.1979,1988(2016).\n\n\n\n\n                                                 9\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 10 of 12\n\n\n\n\n        Defendants argue that Plaintiffs positions were objectively unreasonable because the\n  i\u00e9courtfully examined - and rejected - each ofPlaintiff'stheoriesofliability against(SSM I.''\n  SeeM otionforFees(D.E.148at9).However,thefactthatPlaintifflostatsummaryjudgement\n  isinsuffcienttoestablishthatPlaintiffspositionswereobjedivelyunreasonable.SeeCorwinv.\n  W altDisnevW orldCo.,No.6:02-cv-1377-Orl-19KRS,2008 W L 754697,at*7(M .D.Fla.Mar.\n  18,2008)(li-\n             f'hemerefactthatsummaryjudgmentwasgranted to W orldco,inand ofitself,also\n  doesnotspeak to whetherPlaintifpsclaimswere lobjectively unreasonable.'''). M oreover,in\n  sum marizing the Court's fndings in its Omnibus Order,Defendants simply m ade conclusory\n\n  statementsthatPlaintiffsclaimswereobjectively unreasonable.SeeMotion forFees(D.E.148\n  at8-10J. However,a review oftheCourt'sOmnibusOrderon the CopyrightActCountsdoes\n  notsupportDefendants'conclusion thatPlaintiffspositionswereobjectively unreasonable. As\n  to Counts 1-111,the Court's determ inations turned on close questions of factand law. As to\n\n  Count1V,PlaintiffdidnotrespondtoDefendants'argumentsormoveforsummaryjudgment.\n         Therefore,the undersigned finds no supportfor Defendants'argument that Plaintiff's\n\n  positionswere objectively unreasonable. Klein & Heuchan,2011W L 6097980,at#2;Luken,\n  581 F. Supp.2d at 1240. Hence, this factor militates against awarding attorney's fees to\n\n  Defendants.\n\n     (4)ConsiderationsofCompensationandDeterrence\n         In evaluating thisfactor,courtsconsiderwhetherawarding attorney'sfeeswould further\n\n  the purposesofthe CopyrightAd,Luken,581F.Supp.2d at1246,by looking to theirfindings\n\n  with respect to the frivolousness, motivation, and objective unreasonableness of the non-\n  prevailing party's positions. See K lein & H euchan,2011 W L 6097980,at*6;see also M alibu\n                                            -\n\n\n\n\n   M edias604F.App'xat881(\u00e7$Asforconsiderationsofcompensationand deterrence,weevaluate\n\n\n                                                10\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 11 of 12\n\n\n\n\n   those factors as iinextricably intertwined'with the reasonableness and frivolity of M alibu's\n\n   claims.'').\n          Here,the undersigned has already found that Plaintiffs case was not frivolous;that\n\n   Plaintiffinitiated thisaction in good faith, and notforan improperm otive;and thatthere isno\n\n   supportfor finding Plaintiffs positions to have been objectively unreasonable. Given these\n\n   findingsand the pre-suithistory ofthiscase, Plaintiffs claim sproperly served the purposesof\n\n   the CopyrightAct. See M alibu M edia, 604 F.App'x at881('t\n                                                            IfM alibu'sclaimswereproperly\n   broughtand properlym aintained,thenthey properly served thepurposesofthe CopyrightAct.'\n                                                                                         ').\n   Putanotherway,awarding attorney's feeswould frustratethepurposesofthe CopyrightActifit\n\n   detersplaintiffsfrom bringing reasonable actions in good faith to protecttheircopyrights. Klein\n\n   & Heuzhan,2011W L 6097980,at*6;see Luken,581 F.Supp.2d at 1246 (lsconsistentwith\n   furthering the pum osesofthe CopyrightAct,aparty thatadvancesareasonableposition should\n\n   notbedeterred from doingsoforfearthatitwillhavetopay attolmey'sfeesifitloses.''(citation\n   omittedl).Hence,thisfactoralsomilitatesagainstawardingattomey'sfeesto Defendants.\n                                         C O N CLU SIO N\n\n          The undersigned hasconsidered a11ofthe Fogerty factorsand hasconcluded thateach of\n\n   them   militates against awarding attorney's fees to Defendants.            Therefore, it is\n\n   RESPECTFULLY RECOM M ENDED that Defendants' M otion for Fees (D.E. 148) be\n   DEN IED .\n\n          Pursuantto LocalM agistrate Judge Rule 4(b),the partieshavefourteen daysfrom the\n   dateofthisReportand Recommendation to file written objections,ifany,with theHonorable\n   UrsulaUngaro. Failureto timely file objectionsshallbarthepartiesfrom attacking on appeal\n  the factualfindings contained herein. See Rqsolution Tr.Corp.v.Hallm ark Builders.lnc.,996\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 157 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/23/2017 Page 12 of 12\n\n\n\n\n  F.2d 1144,1149 (11th Cir.1993). Further,\u00e7ifailureto objectin accordancewith theprovisions\n  of(28U.S.C.)j636(b)(1)waivestherighttochallengeon appealthedistrictcourt'sorderbased\n  onunobjected-tofactualandlegalconclusions.''See11th Cir.R.3-1(I.O.P.-3).\n        RESPECTFULLY SUBM ITTED in Cham bers at M iam i, Florida, this 23'd day of\n\n  February,2017.\n                                                 <\n\n\n                                          ALICIA M .O ZO     YES\n                                          UN ITED STATES M AGISTM TE JUDGE\n\n  cc:   United StatesDistrictJudgeUrsulaUngaro\n        CounselofRecord\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2021-07-30T19:33:06.674854-07:00","document_number":"157","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"051017605347","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Report and Recommendations","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.551313-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-29T11:54:26.141121-07:00","date_filed":"2017-02-23","time_filed":null,"entry_number":157,"recap_sequence_number":"2017-02-23.001","pacer_sequence_number":475,"description":"REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION re 148 MOTION for Attorney Fees. Recommending that the MOTION for Attorney Fees be DENIED. Objections to R&R due by 3/9/2017. Signed by Magistrate Judge Alicia M. Otazo-Reyes on 2/23/2017. (ear) (Entered: 02/23/2017)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/171244037/","id":171244037,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/176529108/","id":176529108,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/156/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.538618-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-30T02:06:46.962839-07:00","sha1":"e54d0e29f50502980add75a9e833ab04c69b4692","page_count":2,"file_size":77443,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.156.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.156.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 156 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/31/2016 Page 1 of 2\n\n\n\n\n                          UNITED STATES DISTRICT CO URT\n                          SOUTH ERN DISTRICT O F FLORIDA\n\n                     CASE NO.:15-22134-CIV-UNGARO/OTAZO-% YES\n\n HYDENTRA HLP INT.LIM ITED\n a foreign com oration\n d/b/aM etartd/b/a Sexart,\n\n        Plaintiff,\n\n\n\n CONSTANTIN LUCHIAN,an indivitlual,\n KON STANTIN BOLOTIN ,an indivitlual,\n SUN SOCIAL M EDIA,INC.,a corporation,\n individually and d/b/a PLAYVID.COM ,\n FEEDVID.COM ,PLAYVID S.COM ,and\n PEEKVIDS.COM ;PLAYVID .COM ;\n FEEDVID.COM ;PLAYVIDS.COM ;\n PEEKVIDS.COM ;and\n John Does 1-20,\n\n        D efendants.\n                                                     /\n\n                                         O R DE R\n\n        THIS CAUSE cam e before the Court upon Defendants Stm Social M edia, Inc.,\n\n Constantin Luchian,and Konstantin Bolotin's (lsDefendants'')M otion for an Enlargementof\n Time forthe Filing and/orConsideration ofitsM otion forAttom ey'sFeesorin the Alternative\n\n M otion forLeave to File an Amended M otion forAttorney'sFees(hereafter,\u00e7iM otion foran\n EnlargementofTime'')(D.E.1471. Thismatterwasreferred to theundersigned pursumztto 28\n U.S.C.j636 by theHonorableUrsulaUngaro,United StatesDistrictJudge gD.E.150j. Upon\n due consideration,itis\n\n        ORDERED AND ADJUDGED thatDefendants'M otion forEnlargementofTime(D.E.\n 1471isGRANTED.Defendants'M otionforAttorney'sFees(D.E.1481isdeemedtimelyfiled.\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 156 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/31/2016 Page 2 of 2\n\n\n\n                                                                sf\n       ooxs Axo oltosltso inchambersatMiami,Florida,this7/. dayoraugust,2016.\n\n                                                  .   p\n\n                                                            X\n                                           ALICIA M .OTAZO-REYES\n                                           UNITED STATES M AGISTM TE JUDGE\n\n cc:   United StatesDistrictUrsulaUngaro\n       CounselofRecord\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2024-06-29T12:27:50.634937-07:00","document_number":"156","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"051016929696","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Order on Motion for Extension of Time","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.525843-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-29T11:54:26.106417-07:00","date_filed":"2016-08-31","time_filed":null,"entry_number":156,"recap_sequence_number":"2016-08-31.001","pacer_sequence_number":472,"description":"ORDER granting 147 MOTION for Extension of Time. Signed by Magistrate Judge Alicia M. Otazo-Reyes on 8/31/2016. (ear) (Entered: 08/31/2016)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/171244036/","id":171244036,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/176529107/","id":176529107,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/155/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.510331-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-30T02:06:30.605091-07:00","sha1":"41709d83bdc763889e5982a8f87968499cb2822f","page_count":7,"file_size":440839,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.155.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.155.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 155 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/26/2016 Page 1 of 7\n\n\n\n\n                                   UNITED \u00a0STATES \u00a0DISTRICT \u00a0COURT \u00a0\n                                   SOUTHERN \u00a0DISTRICT \u00a0OF \u00a0FLORIDA \u00a0\n                                                    \u00a0\n                                           MIAMI \u00a0DIVISION \u00a0\n                                                    \u00a0\n        \u00a0                                                                                 \u00a0\n       HYDENTRA \u00a0HLP \u00a0INT. \u00a0LIMITED, \u00a0                                                    \u00a0\n       a \u00a0foreign \u00a0corporation \u00a0d/b/a \u00a0METART, \u00a0                                          \u00a0\n        \u00a0                                                                          Case \u00a0No. \u00a0\n        \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0Plaintiff, \u00a0                                                 1:15-\u00adcv-\u00ad22134-\u00adUU \u00a0\n        \u00a0\n       v. \u00a0\n        \u00a0\n       CONSTANTIN \u00a0LUCHIAN, \u00a0an \u00a0individual, \u00a0\n       KONSTANTIN \u00a0BOLOTIN, \u00a0an \u00a0individual, \u00a0\n       SUN \u00a0SOCIAL \u00a0MEDIA, \u00a0INC., \u00a0a \u00a0corporation, \u00a0\n       individually \u00a0and \u00a0d/b/a \u00a0PLAYVID.COM, \u00a0\n       FEEDVID.COM, \u00a0PLAYVIDS.COM \u00a0and \u00a0\n       PEEKVIDS.COM;\u037e \u00a0PLAYVID.COM;\u037e \u00a0\n       FEEDVID.COM;\u037e \u00a0PLAYVIDS.COM;\u037e \u00a0\n       PEEKVIDS.COM;\u037e \u00a0and \u00a0\n       John \u00a0Does \u00a01-\u00ad20, \u00a0\n        \u00a0\n        \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0Defendants. \u00a0\n        \u00a0\n   \u00a0\n                                   DEFENDANTS\u2019 \u00a0REPLY \u00a0IN \u00a0SUPPORT \u00a0OF \u00a0\n                                       MOTION \u00a0FOR \u00a0ATTORNEY\u2019S \u00a0FEES \u00a0\n                                                               \u00a0\n                         \u201cThe \u00a0First \u00a0Rule \u00a0of \u00a0Holes: \u00a0When \u00a0you\u2019re \u00a0in \u00a0one, \u00a0stop \u00a0digging.\u201d \u00a0\n                                               \u00a0        \u00a0        -\u00ad \u00a0Molly \u00a0Ivins \u00a0\n                                                               \u00a0\n   \u00a0         If \u00a0one \u00a0were \u00a0to \u00a0read \u00a0only \u00a0Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0Opposition \u00a0to \u00a0Defendants\u2019 \u00a0Motion \u00a0for \u00a0Attorney\u2019s \u00a0\n  Fees, \u00a0one \u00a0might \u00a0be \u00a0tempted \u00a0to \u00a0believe \u00a0that \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0was \u00a0actually \u00a0successful \u00a0in \u00a0the \u00a0present \u00a0\n  litigation. \u00a0 \u00a0In \u00a0Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0alternate \u00a0universe, \u00a0the \u00a0Court \u00a0never \u00a0made \u00a0factual \u00a0findings \u00a0supporting \u00a0\n  Defendants\u2019 \u00a0positions, \u00a0never \u00a0ruled \u00a0against \u00a0Defendants\u2019 \u00a0legal \u00a0positions, \u00a0and, \u00a0instead, \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0was \u00a0\n  actually \u00a0successful \u00a0with \u00a0its \u00a0frivolous \u00a0claims. \u00a0 \u00a0Undoubtedly, \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0enjoys \u00a0that \u00a0alternate \u00a0\n  universe \u00a0more \u00a0than \u00a0the \u00a0one \u00a0the \u00a0rest \u00a0of \u00a0us \u00a0occupy. \u00a0 \u00a0In \u00a0this \u00a0reality, \u00a0however, \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0knowingly \u00a0\n  filed \u00a0frivolous \u00a0claims \u00a0against \u00a0a \u00a0corporate \u00a0entity \u00a0that \u00a0had \u00a0historically \u00a0responded \u00a0fully \u00a0and \u00a0\n  expeditiously \u00a0to \u00a0DMCA \u00a0takedown \u00a0notices, \u00a0and \u00a0against \u00a0individuals \u00a0against \u00a0whom \u00a0they \u00a0had \u00a0no \u00a0\n  viable \u00a0(or \u00a0even \u00a0articulable) \u00a0claims. \u00a0 \u00a0\n\n\n\n                                                           1 \u00a0\n   \u00a0\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 155 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/26/2016 Page 2 of 7\n\n\n\n\n   \u00a0                      Unsurprisingly \u00a0\u2013 \u00a0given \u00a0the \u00a0history \u00a0of \u00a0this \u00a0case \u00a0and \u00a0the \u00a0near-\u00adidentical \u00a0cases \u00a0filed \u00a0by \u00a0the \u00a0\n  Plaintiff \u00a0in \u00a0this \u00a0Court \u00a0and \u00a0around \u00a0the \u00a0country \u00a0\u2013 \u00a0Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0opposition \u00a0to \u00a0Defendants\u2019 \u00a0Motion \u00a0for \u00a0\n  Attorney\u2019s \u00a0Fees \u00a0only \u00a0helps \u00a0prove \u00a0why \u00a0Defendants \u00a0should \u00a0be \u00a0awarded \u00a0their \u00a0attorney\u2019s \u00a0fees \u00a0in \u00a0this \u00a0\n  matter. \u00a0 \u00a0Despite \u00a0having \u00a0had \u00a0judgment \u00a0entered \u00a0against \u00a0it \u00a0on \u00a0all \u00a0of \u00a0its \u00a0copyright \u00a0claims, \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0\n  has \u00a0the \u00a0moxie \u00a0to \u00a0claim \u00a0that \u00a0its \u00a0\u201cprimary \u00a0purpose \u00a0of \u00a0copyright \u00a0enforcement \u00a0was \u00a0met.\u201d \u00a0 \u00a0As \u00a0is \u00a0\n  discussed \u00a0below, \u00a0even \u00a0if \u00a0\u201ccopyright \u00a0enforcement\u201d \u00a0was \u00a0Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0\u201cprimary \u00a0purpose\u201d \u00a0in \u00a0the \u00a0\n  litigation \u00a0(which \u00a0it, \u00a0clearly, \u00a0was \u00a0not), \u00a0it \u00a0only \u00a0underscores \u00a0that \u00a0the \u00a0litigation \u00a0itself \u00a0was \u00a0needless. \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0\n                          In \u00a0Reply \u00a0to \u00a0Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0Opposition \u00a0and \u00a0in \u00a0support \u00a0of \u00a0Defendants\u2019 \u00a0Motion \u00a0for \u00a0Attorney\u2019s \u00a0\n  fees, \u00a0Defendants \u00a0state \u00a0as \u00a0follows: \u00a0\n                          1. \u00a0                    Preliminarily, \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0spends \u00a0a \u00a0significant \u00a0portion \u00a0of \u00a0its \u00a0Opposition \u00a0bemoaning \u00a0\n  the \u00a0supposed \u00a0difficulty \u00a0of \u00a0enforcing \u00a0copyrights \u00a0online \u00a0in \u00a0general. \u00a0 \u00a0However, \u00a0that \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0does \u00a0\n  not \u00a0like \u00a0the \u00a0enforcement \u00a0scheme \u00a0set \u00a0forth \u00a0by \u00a0Congress \u00a0under \u00a0the \u00a0Digital \u00a0Millennium \u00a0Copyright \u00a0\n  Act \u00a0does \u00a0not \u00a0mean \u00a0that \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0is \u00a0empowered \u00a0to \u00a0misuse \u00a0the \u00a0courts \u00a0to \u00a0baselessly \u00a0bully \u00a0and \u00a0\n  bludgeon \u00a0Defendants \u00a0into \u00a0submission. \u00a0 \u00a0In \u00a0truth, \u00a0and \u00a0as \u00a0this \u00a0Court \u00a0found, \u00a0the \u00a0statutory \u00a0scheme \u00a0\n  actually \u00a0worked \u00a0quite \u00a0well \u00a0right \u00a0up \u00a0until \u00a0the \u00a0point \u00a0in \u00a0time \u00a0that \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0undertook \u00a0steps \u00a0almost \u00a0\n  guaranteed \u00a0to \u00a0derail \u00a0it. \u00a0\n                          2. \u00a0                    In \u00a0any \u00a0event, \u00a0Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0\u201cprimary \u00a0purpose\u201d \u00a0in \u00a0this \u00a0litigation \u00a0was \u00a0not \u00a0\u201ccopyright \u00a0\n  enforcement,\u201d \u00a0as \u00a0is \u00a0evidenced \u00a0by \u00a0its \u00a0own \u00a0actions. \u00a0 \u00a0First, \u00a0if \u00a0Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0purpose \u00a0was \u00a0actually \u00a0to \u00a0\n  make \u00a0sure \u00a0that \u00a0its \u00a0works \u00a0were \u00a0removed \u00a0from \u00a0Sun \u00a0Social \u00a0Media\u2019s \u00a0websites, \u00a0that \u00a0goal \u00a0was \u00a0\n  accomplished \u00a0immediately \u00a0after \u00a0Defendants \u00a0were \u00a0served \u00a0with \u00a0the \u00a0Complaint. \u00a0 \u00a0Indeed, \u00a0that \u00a0goal \u00a0\n  could \u00a0have \u00a0been \u00a0accomplished \u00a0without \u00a0litigation \u00a0in \u00a0the \u00a0first \u00a0place \u00a0if \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0had \u00a0emailed \u00a0the \u00a0\n  misplaced \u00a0paper \u00a0DMCA \u00a0notices1 \u00a0to \u00a0Sun \u00a0Social \u00a0Media, \u00a0as \u00a0it \u00a0had \u00a0with \u00a0hundreds \u00a0of \u00a0other \u00a0notices \u00a0in \u00a0\n  the \u00a0past \u00a0and \u00a0afterwards, \u00a0to \u00a0which \u00a0Sun \u00a0Social \u00a0Media \u00a0promptly \u00a0and \u00a0appropriately \u00a0responded. \u00a0 \u00a0As \u00a0\n  this \u00a0Court \u00a0found \u00a0in \u00a0its \u00a0order \u00a0on \u00a0the \u00a0Motions \u00a0for \u00a0Summary \u00a0Judgment, \u00a0Sun \u00a0Social \u00a0Media \u00a0\n  expeditiously \u00a0acted \u00a0on \u00a0thousands \u00a0of \u00a0Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0DMCA \u00a0notices \u00a0when \u00a0they \u00a0were \u00a0sent \u00a0by \u00a0email \u00a0and \u00a0\n  only \u00a0failed \u00a0to \u00a0act \u00a0on \u00a0the \u00a0DMCA \u00a0notices \u00a0sent \u00a0by \u00a0paper \u00a0because \u00a0those \u00a0notices \u00a0were \u00a0lost \u00a0before \u00a0they \u00a0\n  could \u00a0reach \u00a0Sun \u00a0Social \u00a0Media. \u00a0 \u00a0In \u00a0short, \u00a0Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0supposed \u00a0\u201cprimary \u00a0purpose\u201d \u00a0could \u00a0have \u00a0been \u00a0\n  accomplished \u00a0with \u00a0a \u00a0single \u00a0email, \u00a0not \u00a0hundreds \u00a0of \u00a0thousands \u00a0of \u00a0dollars \u00a0of \u00a0litigation \u00a0costs. \u00a0 \u00a0Or, \u00a0at \u00a0\n\n\n   \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0\n  1\n    \u00a0Defendants \u00a0note \u00a0once \u00a0again \u00a0that \u00a0only \u00a0some \u00a0of \u00a0the \u00a0works-\u00adin-\u00adsuit \u00a0were \u00a0referenced \u00a0in \u00a0the \u00a0misplaced \u00a0paper \u00a0DMCA \u00a0\n  notices. \u00a0 \u00a0For \u00a0other \u00a0works-\u00adin-\u00adsuit, \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0took \u00a0not \u00a0a \u00a0single \u00a0iota \u00a0of \u00a0effort \u00a0prior \u00a0to \u00a0filing \u00a0suit \u00a0to \u00a0have \u00a0those \u00a0works \u00a0\n  removed \u00a0from \u00a0Sun \u00a0Social \u00a0Media\u2019s \u00a0website. \u00a0\n\n                                                                                                       2 \u00a0\n   \u00a0\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 155 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/26/2016 Page 3 of 7\n\n\n\n\n  a \u00a0minimum, \u00a0having \u00a0apparently \u00a0\u201caccomplished\u201d \u00a0its \u00a0\u201cprimary \u00a0purpose\u201d \u00a0as \u00a0soon \u00a0as \u00a0the \u00a0litigation \u00a0\n  was \u00a0filed, \u00a0it \u00a0could \u00a0have \u00a0immediately \u00a0dismissed \u00a0the \u00a0case. \u00a0 \u00a0That \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0did \u00a0not \u00a0do \u00a0so \u00a0puts \u00a0the \u00a0lie \u00a0\n  to \u00a0its \u00a0current \u00a0claim \u00a0that \u00a0the \u00a0removal \u00a0of \u00a0infringing \u00a0content \u00a0was \u00a0ever \u00a0its \u00a0primary \u00a0goal. \u00a0\n                          3. \u00a0                    In \u00a0reality, \u00a0as \u00a0Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0actions \u00a0demonstrate, \u00a0its \u00a0true \u00a0goal \u00a0in \u00a0filing \u00a020 \u00a0lawsuits \u00a0in \u00a0a \u00a0\n  15-\u00admonth \u00a0period \u00a0was \u00a0economics, \u00a0i.e., \u00a0that \u00a0it \u00a0was \u00a0seeking \u00a0a \u00a0monetary \u00a0payout \u00a0from \u00a0defendants \u00a0\n  willing \u00a0to \u00a0pay \u00a0settlements \u00a0rather \u00a0than \u00a0defend \u00a0frivolous \u00a0litigations. \u00a0 \u00a0Surely \u00a0this \u00a0point \u00a0is \u00a0driven \u00a0\n  home \u00a0by \u00a0the \u00a0fact \u00a0that, \u00a0following \u00a0this \u00a0Court\u2019s \u00a0Order \u00a0on \u00a0Summary \u00a0Judgment, \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0moved \u00a0to \u00a0\n  voluntarily \u00a0dismiss \u00a0its \u00a0complaints \u00a0in \u00a0Hydentra, \u00a0L.P. \u00a0HLP \u00a0General \u00a0Partner, \u00a0Inc. \u00a0et \u00a0al \u00a0v. \u00a0ERA \u00a0\n  Technologies, \u00a0Ltd. \u00a0et \u00a0al, \u00a0Case \u00a0No. \u00a01:15-\u00adcv-\u00ad24293-\u00adMGC \u00a0(S.D. \u00a0Fla.) \u00a0and \u00a0Hydentra, \u00a0L.P. \u00a0HLP \u00a0\n  General \u00a0Partner, \u00a0Inc. \u00a0et \u00a0al \u00a0v. \u00a0Siracusa \u00a0Management \u00a0S.A. \u00a0et \u00a0al, \u00a0Case \u00a0No. \u00a01:16-\u00adcv-\u00ad20191-\u00adRNS \u00a0\n  (S.D. \u00a0Fla.). \u00a0 \u00a0Had \u00a0Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0true \u00a0goal \u00a0been \u00a0\u201ccopyright \u00a0enforcement,\u201d \u00a0surely \u00a0it \u00a0would \u00a0have \u00a0\n  continued \u00a0those \u00a0actions. \u00a0 \u00a0Instead, \u00a0in \u00a0its \u00a0voluntary \u00a0motions \u00a0to \u00a0dismiss, \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0noted \u00a0as \u00a0follows: \u00a0 \u00a0\n                          In \u00a0 Hydentra \u00a0 v \u00a0 Luchian, \u00a0 et \u00a0 al., \u00a0 United \u00a0 States \u00a0 District \u00a0 Court \u00a0 Southern \u00a0 District \u00a0 of \u00a0\n                          Florida \u00a0Cause \u00a0No. \u00a01:15-\u00adcv-\u00ad22134-\u00adUU, \u00a0similar \u00a0claims \u00a0based \u00a0upon \u00a0similar \u00a0facts \u00a0were \u00a0\n                          asserted. \u00a0 \u00a0On \u00a0June \u00a02, \u00a02016, \u00a0the \u00a0copyright \u00a0claims \u00a0in \u00a0those \u00a0matters \u00a0were \u00a0dismissed \u00a0on \u00a0\n                          summary \u00a0judgment. \u00a0 \u00a0Such \u00a0dismissal \u00a0is \u00a0now \u00a0on \u00a0appeal. \u00a0 \u00a0Unless \u00a0and \u00a0until \u00a0those \u00a0issues \u00a0\n                          are \u00a0resolved \u00a0in \u00a0Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0favor, \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0believes \u00a0that \u00a0continued \u00a0litigation \u00a0in \u00a0this \u00a0\n                          instant \u00a0matter \u00a0to \u00a0now \u00a0lack \u00a0economical \u00a0feasibility. \u00a0 \u00a0Accordingly, \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0seeks \u00a0to \u00a0\n                          dismiss \u00a0these \u00a0claims \u00a0against \u00a0Defendants, \u00a0hereby \u00a0concluding \u00a0this \u00a0lawsuit. 2 \u00a0\n                           \u00a0\n                          4. \u00a0     In \u00a0short, \u00a0by \u00a0word \u00a0and \u00a0deed, \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0has \u00a0shown \u00a0that \u00a0its \u00a0current \u00a0position \u00a0before \u00a0this \u00a0\n  Court \u00a0is \u00a0flat \u00a0out \u00a0nonsense. \u00a0 \u00a0Indeed, \u00a0if \u00a0Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0\u201cprimary \u00a0purpose\u201d \u00a0in \u00a0this \u00a0litigation \u00a0was \u00a0in \u00a0fact \u00a0\n  \u201ccopyright \u00a0enforcement,\u201d \u00a0and \u00a0not \u00a0economics, \u00a0then \u00a0Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0actions \u00a0in \u00a0this \u00a0litigation \u00a0made \u00a0no \u00a0\n  sense. \u00a0 \u00a0For \u00a0a \u00a0large \u00a0number \u00a0of \u00a0the \u00a0works \u00a0that \u00a0it \u00a0filed \u00a0suit, \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0made \u00a0no \u00a0effort \u00a0whatsoever \u00a0to \u00a0\n  send \u00a0DMCA \u00a0take-\u00addown \u00a0notices \u00a0prior \u00a0to \u00a0filing \u00a0suit. \u00a0 \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0took \u00a0no \u00a0effort \u00a0to \u00a0sit \u00a0down \u00a0and \u00a0\n  resolve \u00a0the \u00a0issues \u00a0between \u00a0the \u00a0parties \u00a0in \u00a0an \u00a0early \u00a0mediation. \u00a0 \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0engaged \u00a0in \u00a0litigation \u00a0tactics \u00a0\n  that \u00a0were \u00a0clearly \u00a0intended \u00a0to \u00a0drive \u00a0up \u00a0legal \u00a0costs, \u00a0in \u00a0the \u00a0hopes \u00a0of \u00a0forcing \u00a0an \u00a0unwarranted \u00a0\n  financial \u00a0settlement. \u00a0 \u00a0None \u00a0of \u00a0these \u00a0acts \u00a0are \u00a0consistent \u00a0with \u00a0a \u00a0party \u00a0that \u00a0is \u00a0seeking \u00a0to \u00a0enforce \u00a0its \u00a0\n  copyrights. \u00a0 \u00a0\n                          5. \u00a0                    Given \u00a0that \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0has \u00a0already \u00a0dismissed \u00a0other \u00a0lawsuits \u00a0as \u00a0a \u00a0result \u00a0of \u00a0this \u00a0court\u2019s \u00a0\n  dismissal \u00a0of \u00a0Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0claims, \u00a0it \u00a0is \u00a0clear \u00a0that \u00a0the \u00a0award \u00a0of \u00a0attorney\u2019s \u00a0fees \u00a0would \u00a0in \u00a0fact \u00a0serve \u00a0the \u00a0\n  Copyright \u00a0Act\u2019s \u00a0interest \u00a0to \u00a0encourage \u00a0meritorious \u00a0defenses \u00a0and \u00a0discourage \u00a0frivolous \u00a0claims. \u00a0 \u00a0See \u00a0\n\n\n   \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0\n  2\n        \u00a0Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0two \u00a0motions \u00a0to \u00a0dismiss \u00a0are \u00a0attached \u00a0hereto \u00a0as \u00a0Exhibit \u00a01 \u00a0and \u00a0Exhibit \u00a02. \u00a0\n\n                                                                                                       3 \u00a0\n   \u00a0\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 155 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/26/2016 Page 4 of 7\n\n\n\n\n  Kernel \u00a0Records \u00a0Oy \u00a0v. \u00a0Mosley, \u00a02013 \u00a0U.S. \u00a0Dist. \u00a0LEXIS \u00a099094 \u00a0*32 \u00a0(S.D. \u00a0Fla. \u00a0July \u00a016, \u00a02013). \u00a0 \u00a0That \u00a0\n  the \u00a0Defendants \u00a0in \u00a0this \u00a0case \u00a0stood \u00a0their \u00a0ground \u00a0(at \u00a0a \u00a0high \u00a0cost) \u00a0means \u00a0that \u00a0other \u00a0defendants \u00a0do \u00a0not \u00a0\n  have \u00a0to. \u00a0 \u00a0This \u00a0is \u00a0precisely \u00a0the \u00a0kind \u00a0of \u00a0outcome \u00a0the \u00a0Copyright \u00a0Act \u00a0and \u00a0its \u00a0attorney\u2019s \u00a0fees \u00a0provision \u00a0\n  seeks \u00a0to \u00a0reward. \u00a0\n           6. \u00a0     It \u00a0should \u00a0also \u00a0be \u00a0noted \u00a0that, \u00a0although \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0claimed \u00a0in \u00a0its \u00a0motions \u00a0to \u00a0dismiss \u00a0in \u00a0\n  the \u00a0ERA \u00a0Technologies, \u00a0Ltd. \u00a0and \u00a0Siracusa \u00a0Management \u00a0S.A. \u00a0cases \u00a0that \u00a0it \u00a0was \u00a0pursuing \u00a0an \u00a0appeal \u00a0\n  in \u00a0this \u00a0matter, \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0shortly \u00a0thereafter \u00a0voluntarily \u00a0dismissed \u00a0with \u00a0prejudice \u00a0its \u00a0appeal \u00a0as \u00a0well. \u00a0\n           7. \u00a0     Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0attempts \u00a0to \u00a0re-\u00adlitigate \u00a0the \u00a0substantive \u00a0factual \u00a0and \u00a0legal \u00a0issues \u00a0in \u00a0this \u00a0\n  case \u00a0fall \u00a0flat. \u00a0 \u00a0First, \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0introduces \u00a0\u201cevidence\u201d \u00a0for \u00a0the \u00a0very \u00a0first \u00a0time \u00a0that \u00a0supposedly \u00a0\n  supports \u00a0its \u00a0already \u00a0rejected \u00a0arguments. \u00a0 \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0also \u00a0reiterates \u00a0its \u00a0failed \u00a0arguments \u00a0from \u00a0its \u00a0\n  motion \u00a0for \u00a0summary \u00a0judgment. \u00a0 \u00a0None \u00a0of \u00a0the \u00a0arguments \u00a0put \u00a0forward \u00a0by \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0demonstrate \u00a0that \u00a0\n  the \u00a0litigation \u00a0wasn\u2019t \u00a0frivolous \u00a0in \u00a0its \u00a0first \u00a0instance \u00a0in \u00a0part \u00a0because \u00a0the \u00a0information \u00a0put \u00a0forth \u00a0by \u00a0\n  Plaintiff \u00a0in \u00a0its \u00a0Opposition \u00a0was \u00a0not \u00a0known \u00a0by \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0when \u00a0it \u00a0filed \u00a0its \u00a0speculative \u00a0and \u00a0frivolous \u00a0\n  Complaint. \u00a0 \u00a0In \u00a0any \u00a0case, \u00a0even \u00a0in \u00a0cases \u00a0where \u00a0a \u00a0plaintiff \u00a0had \u00a0a \u00a0reasonable \u00a0basis \u00a0to \u00a0file \u00a0suit, \u00a0the \u00a0\n  award \u00a0of \u00a0attorney\u2019s \u00a0fees \u00a0to \u00a0a \u00a0successful \u00a0defendant \u00a0is \u00a0\u201cthe \u00a0rule \u00a0rather \u00a0than \u00a0the \u00a0exception,\u201d \u00a0and \u00a0\u201ca \u00a0\n  finding \u00a0of \u00a0bad \u00a0faith \u00a0or \u00a0frivolity \u00a0is \u00a0not \u00a0required \u00a0for \u00a0an \u00a0award.\u201d \u00a0 \u00a0Professional \u00a0LED \u00a0Lighting, \u00a0Ltd. \u00a0v. \u00a0\n  Aadyn \u00a0Technology, \u00a0LLC, \u00a088 \u00a0F. \u00a0Supp. \u00a03d \u00a01356, \u00a01376 \u00a0(S.D. \u00a0Fla. \u00a02015);\u037e \u00a0Maljack \u00a0Prods., \u00a0Inc. \u00a0v. \u00a0\n  Goodtimes \u00a0Home \u00a0Video \u00a0Corp., \u00a081 \u00a0F.3d \u00a0881, \u00a0890 \u00a0(9th \u00a0Cir. \u00a01996). \u00a0\n           8. \u00a0     Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0claims \u00a0against \u00a0the \u00a0individual \u00a0defendants \u00a0Constantin \u00a0Luchian \u00a0and \u00a0\n  Konstantin \u00a0Bolotin \u00a0were \u00a0both \u00a0objectively \u00a0and \u00a0subjectively \u00a0frivolous. \u00a0 \u00a0This \u00a0court \u00a0found \u00a0that \u00a0Mr. \u00a0\n  Luchian \u00a0in \u00a0no \u00a0way \u00a0controlled \u00a0the \u00a0content \u00a0on \u00a0Sun \u00a0Social \u00a0Media\u2019s \u00a0websites. \u00a0 \u00a0The \u00a0only \u00a0evidence \u00a0on \u00a0\n  which \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0relies \u00a0is \u00a0Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0claim \u00a0that, \u00a0prior \u00a0to \u00a0the \u00a0litigation, \u00a0it \u00a0found \u00a0on \u00a0\u201cwebsites\u201d \u00a0that \u00a0\n  Mr. \u00a0Luchian \u00a0was \u00a0listed \u00a0as \u00a0a \u00a0Director \u00a0of \u00a0Sun \u00a0Social \u00a0Media. \u00a0 \u00a0Mr. \u00a0Luchian \u00a0is \u00a0not \u00a0in \u00a0fact \u00a0a \u00a0Director \u00a0\n  of \u00a0Sun \u00a0Social \u00a0Media \u00a0and \u00a0even \u00a0if \u00a0he \u00a0was, \u00a0that \u00a0assertion \u00a0alone \u00a0would \u00a0not \u00a0support \u00a0filing \u00a0suit \u00a0against \u00a0\n  Mr. \u00a0Luchian \u00a0personally. \u00a0 \u00a0In \u00a0any \u00a0case, \u00a0after \u00a0conducting \u00a0thorough \u00a0discovery \u00a0during \u00a0litigation, \u00a0\n  Plaintiff \u00a0could \u00a0not \u00a0find \u00a0a \u00a0single \u00a0shred \u00a0of \u00a0evidence \u00a0that \u00a0would \u00a0implicate \u00a0liability \u00a0against \u00a0Mr. \u00a0\n  Luchian. \u00a0 \u00a0But, \u00a0instead \u00a0of \u00a0dismissing \u00a0the \u00a0suit \u00a0against \u00a0him \u00a0as \u00a0it \u00a0was \u00a0obligated \u00a0to \u00a0do \u00a0pursuant \u00a0to \u00a0the \u00a0\n  Federal \u00a0Rules \u00a0of \u00a0Civil \u00a0Procedure, \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0had \u00a0the \u00a0audacity \u00a0to \u00a0move \u00a0for \u00a0summary \u00a0judgment \u00a0\n  against \u00a0Mr. \u00a0Luchian. \u00a0\n           9. \u00a0     Additionally, \u00a0as \u00a0this \u00a0Court \u00a0found \u00a0(but \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0ignores), \u00a0Mr. \u00a0Bolotin \u00a0could \u00a0not, \u00a0by \u00a0\n  simple \u00a0virtue \u00a0of \u00a0owning \u00a0and \u00a0managing \u00a0Sun \u00a0Social \u00a0Media, \u00a0be \u00a0liable \u00a0for \u00a0the \u00a0claims \u00a0alleged \u00a0by \u00a0\n\n                                                              4 \u00a0\n   \u00a0\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 155 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/26/2016 Page 5 of 7\n\n\n\n\n  Plaintiffs. \u00a0 \u00a0As \u00a0such, \u00a0Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0claims \u00a0against \u00a0Mr. \u00a0Bolotin \u00a0were \u00a0also \u00a0frivolous. \u00a0 \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0had \u00a0no \u00a0\n  real \u00a0basis \u00a0for \u00a0piercing \u00a0the \u00a0corporate \u00a0veil \u00a0as \u00a0against \u00a0Mr. \u00a0Bolotin \u00a0and \u00a0after \u00a0extensive \u00a0discovery \u00a0it \u00a0\n  was \u00a0clear \u00a0that \u00a0Mr. \u00a0Bolotin \u00a0did \u00a0not \u00a0cause \u00a0Sun \u00a0Social \u00a0Media \u00a0to \u00a0display \u00a0Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0content \u00a0on \u00a0the \u00a0\n  websites. \u00a0 \u00a0However, \u00a0instead \u00a0of \u00a0dismissing \u00a0the \u00a0suit \u00a0against \u00a0him \u00a0as \u00a0it \u00a0was \u00a0obligated \u00a0to \u00a0do \u00a0pursuant \u00a0\n  to \u00a0the \u00a0Federal \u00a0Rules \u00a0of \u00a0Civil \u00a0Procedure, \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0moved \u00a0for \u00a0summary \u00a0judgment \u00a0against \u00a0Mr. \u00a0\n  Bolotin. \u00a0\n                          10. \u00a0                   Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0litigation \u00a0history \u00a0around \u00a0the \u00a0country \u00a0demonstrates \u00a0the \u00a0true \u00a0reason \u00a0why \u00a0\n  Mr. \u00a0Luchian \u00a0and \u00a0Mr. \u00a0Bolotin \u00a0were \u00a0named \u00a0defendants \u00a0in \u00a0this \u00a0action: \u00a0it \u00a0was \u00a0a \u00a0litigation \u00a0tactic \u00a0to \u00a0\n  scare \u00a0and \u00a0pressure \u00a0individuals \u00a0into \u00a0settling \u00a0on \u00a0behalf \u00a0of \u00a0corporate \u00a0entities. \u00a0 \u00a0In \u00a0many \u00a0if \u00a0not \u00a0all \u00a0of \u00a0\n  the \u00a020 \u00a0cases \u00a0filed \u00a0by \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0around \u00a0the \u00a0country, \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0named \u00a0individual \u00a0defendants \u00a0in \u00a0\n  addition \u00a0to \u00a0the \u00a0corporate \u00a0entity \u00a0that \u00a0it \u00a0knew \u00a0actually \u00a0operated \u00a0the \u00a0relevant \u00a0websites. 3 \u00a0 \u00a0This \u00a0is \u00a0\n  simply \u00a0part \u00a0of \u00a0Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0litigation \u00a0strategy \u00a0and \u00a0could \u00a0not \u00a0possibly \u00a0be \u00a0in \u00a0conformity \u00a0with \u00a0\n  Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0purported \u00a0\u201cprimary \u00a0purpose \u00a0of \u00a0copyright \u00a0enforcement.\u201d \u00a0\n                          11. \u00a0                   In \u00a0its \u00a0opposition, \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0hypocritically \u00a0criticizes \u00a0Defendants\u2019 \u00a0Motion \u00a0for \u00a0not \u00a0\n  separating \u00a0fees \u00a0out \u00a0as \u00a0between \u00a0the \u00a0separate \u00a0Defendants \u00a0when \u00a0Plaintiff, \u00a0at \u00a0no \u00a0time \u00a0during \u00a0this \u00a0\n  litigation, \u00a0ever \u00a0made \u00a0a \u00a0single \u00a0attempt \u00a0to \u00a0separate \u00a0out \u00a0the \u00a0three \u00a0Defendants. \u00a0 \u00a0Even \u00a0in \u00a0its \u00a0\n  Opposition \u00a0to \u00a0the \u00a0instant \u00a0Motion, \u00a0after \u00a0this \u00a0Court \u00a0found \u00a0that \u00a0Mr. \u00a0Luchian \u00a0had \u00a0no \u00a0ownership \u00a0or \u00a0\n  control \u00a0over \u00a0Sun \u00a0Social \u00a0Media \u00a0and \u00a0its \u00a0websites \u00a0and \u00a0that \u00a0Mr. \u00a0Bolotin \u00a0did \u00a0not \u00a0personally \u00a0own \u00a0or \u00a0\n  operate \u00a0the \u00a0websites, \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0still \u00a0repeatedly \u00a0refers \u00a0to \u00a0the \u00a0websites \u00a0at \u00a0issue \u00a0in \u00a0this \u00a0litigation \u00a0as \u00a0\n  \u201cDefendants\u2019 \u00a0sites\u201d \u00a0and \u00a0intentionally \u00a0makes \u00a0no \u00a0effort \u00a0to \u00a0separate \u00a0out \u00a0the \u00a0Defendants. \u00a0 \u00a0In \u00a0any \u00a0\n  event, \u00a0all \u00a0three \u00a0Defendants \u00a0were \u00a0successful \u00a0and \u00a0all \u00a0three \u00a0are \u00a0entitled \u00a0to \u00a0an \u00a0award \u00a0of \u00a0fees. \u00a0\n                          12. \u00a0                   After \u00a0Defendants \u00a0filed \u00a0their \u00a0Motion, \u00a0Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0counsel \u00a0brought \u00a0to \u00a0the \u00a0attention \u00a0of \u00a0\n  Defendants\u2019 \u00a0counsel \u00a0some \u00a0unintentional \u00a0errors \u00a0in \u00a0the \u00a0breakdown \u00a0of \u00a0hours \u00a0expended \u00a0by \u00a0attorneys \u00a0\n  attached \u00a0as \u00a0Exhibit \u00a02 \u00a0to \u00a0the \u00a0Motion. \u00a0 \u00a0Defendants \u00a0apologize \u00a0for \u00a0the \u00a0errors \u00a0and \u00a0have \u00a0corrected \u00a0\n  them \u00a0in \u00a0the \u00a0attached \u00a0hereto \u00a0Exhibit \u00a03. \u00a0 \u00a0The \u00a0corrected \u00a0grand \u00a0total \u00a0of \u00a0attorney\u2019s \u00a0fees \u00a0sought \u00a0by \u00a0\n  Defendants \u00a0is \u00a0$151,902.50. \u00a0\n\n   \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0\n  3\n    \u00a0See, \u00a0e.g., \u00a0Hydentra, \u00a0L.P. \u00a0HLP \u00a0General \u00a0Partner, \u00a0Inc. \u00a0et \u00a0al \u00a0v. \u00a0ERA \u00a0Technologies, \u00a0Ltd. \u00a0et \u00a0al, \u00a0Case \u00a0No. \u00a01:15-\u00adcv-\u00ad24293-\u00ad\n  MGC \u00a0(S.D. \u00a0Fla.) \u00a0(includes \u00a0claim \u00a0against \u00a0the \u00a0individual \u00a0Igor \u00a0Kovalchuck);\u037e \u00a0Hydentra, \u00a0L.P. \u00a0HLP \u00a0General \u00a0Partner, \u00a0\n  Inc. \u00a0et \u00a0al \u00a0v. \u00a0Siracusa \u00a0Management \u00a0S.A. \u00a0et \u00a0al, \u00a0Case \u00a0No. \u00a01:16-\u00adcv-\u00ad20191-\u00adRNS \u00a0(S.D. \u00a0Fla.) \u00a0(includes \u00a0claims \u00a0against \u00a0the \u00a0\n  individual \u00a0Anton \u00a0Titov);\u037e \u00a0Hydentra \u00a0HLP \u00a0Int. \u00a0Limited \u00a0v. \u00a0Maximum \u00a0Apps \u00a0Inc. \u00a0et \u00a0al, \u00a0Case \u00a0No. \u00a01:2015-\u00adcv-\u00ad22463 \u00a0(S.D. \u00a0\n  Fla.) \u00a0(includes \u00a0claims \u00a0against \u00a0the \u00a0individual \u00a0Frederic \u00a0Valiquette);\u037e \u00a0Hydentra \u00a0HLP \u00a0Int. \u00a0Limited \u00a0et \u00a0al \u00a0v. \u00a0Sagan \u00a0Limited \u00a0\n  et \u00a0al, \u00a0Case \u00a0No. \u00a02:2016-\u00adcv-\u00ad01494 \u00a0(D. \u00a0Ariz.) \u00a0(includes \u00a0claims \u00a0against \u00a0the \u00a0individual \u00a0David \u00a0Koonar);\u037e \u00a0Hydentra, \u00a0L.P. \u00a0\n  HLP \u00a0General \u00a0Partner, \u00a0Inc. \u00a0et \u00a0al \u00a0v. \u00a0Mindgeek \u00a0USA \u00a0Inc. \u00a0et \u00a0al, \u00a0Case \u00a0No. \u00a01:2015-\u00adcv-\u00ad23230 \u00a0(S.D. \u00a0Fla.) \u00a0(includes \u00a0claims \u00a0\n  against \u00a0the \u00a0individuals \u00a0Feras \u00a0Antoon \u00a0and \u00a0Ouissam \u00a0Yousef). \u00a0\n\n                                                                                                       5 \u00a0\n   \u00a0\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 155 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/26/2016 Page 6 of 7\n\n\n\n\n           In \u00a0conclusion, \u00a0Plaintiff\u2019s \u00a0Opposition \u00a0constitutes \u00a0a \u00a0borderline \u00a0admission \u00a0that \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0first \u00a0\n  brought \u00a0a \u00a0frivolous \u00a0action \u00a0whose \u00a0primary \u00a0goal \u00a0was \u00a0not \u00a0the \u00a0relief \u00a0claimed \u00a0in \u00a0the \u00a0Complaint \u00a0\n  (which \u00a0was \u00a0eventually \u00a0denied \u00a0by \u00a0this \u00a0Court), \u00a0but \u00a0instead \u00a0the \u00a0extra-\u00adjudicial \u00a0intention \u00a0to \u00a0get \u00a0\n  Defendants \u00a0to \u00a0pay \u00a0unwarranted \u00a0amounts \u00a0to \u00a0settle \u00a0frivolous \u00a0claims \u00a0or \u00a0face \u00a0mounting \u00a0legal \u00a0costs. \u00a0 \u00a0\n  Even \u00a0after \u00a0filing \u00a0the \u00a0complaint, \u00a0Plaintiff \u00a0conducted \u00a0the \u00a0litigation \u00a0so \u00a0as \u00a0to \u00a0intentionally \u00a0and \u00a0\n  unnecessarily \u00a0increase \u00a0Defendants\u2019 \u00a0litigation \u00a0expenses \u00a0and \u00a0fees. \u00a0 \u00a0Accordingly, \u00a0for \u00a0the \u00a0reasons \u00a0\n  stated \u00a0herein \u00a0and \u00a0in \u00a0Defendants\u2019 \u00a0Motion \u00a0for \u00a0Attorney\u2019s \u00a0Fees, \u00a0Defendants \u00a0respectfully \u00a0request \u00a0\n  that \u00a0the \u00a0Court \u00a0allow \u00a0Defendants\u2019 \u00a0Motion \u00a0for \u00a0Attorney\u2019s \u00a0Fees \u00a0in \u00a0the \u00a0amount \u00a0of \u00a0$151,902.50. \u00a0\n            \u00a0\n  Respectfully \u00a0submitted \u00a0this \u00a026th \u00a0day \u00a0of \u00a0August, \u00a02016. \u00a0 \u00a0\n   \u00a0\n                                                       COBB \u00a0EDDY, \u00a0PLLC \u00a0\n   \u00a0     \u00a0         \u00a0        \u00a0       \u00a0        \u00a0         642 \u00a0Northeast \u00a0Third \u00a0Avenue \u00a0\n   \u00a0     \u00a0         \u00a0        \u00a0       \u00a0        \u00a0         Fort \u00a0Lauderdale, \u00a0Florida \u00a033304 \u00a0\n   \u00a0     \u00a0         \u00a0        \u00a0       \u00a0        \u00a0         Telephone \u00a0(954) \u00a0527-\u00ad4111 \u00a0\n   \u00a0     \u00a0         \u00a0        \u00a0       \u00a0        \u00a0         Facsimile \u00a0 \u00a0(954) \u00a0900-\u00ad5507 \u00a0\n   \u00a0\n   \u00a0     \u00a0         \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0  \u00a0       \u00a0        \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0 By: \u00a0___/s/ \u00a0BRADY \u00a0J. \u00a0COBB_______ \u00a0\n   \u00a0     \u00a0         \u00a0        \u00a0       \u00a0        \u00a0         BRADY \u00a0J. \u00a0COBB, \u00a0ESQUIRE \u00a0\n   \u00a0     \u00a0         \u00a0        \u00a0       \u00a0        \u00a0         Florida \u00a0Bar \u00a0No. \u00a0031018 \u00a0\n   \u00a0     \u00a0         \u00a0        \u00a0       \u00a0        \u00a0         bcobb@cobbeddy.com \u00a0\n   \u00a0     \u00a0         \u00a0        \u00a0       \u00a0        \u00a0         Attorney \u00a0for \u00a0Defendants \u00a0Constantin \u00a0 \u00a0  \u00a0\n   \u00a0     \u00a0         \u00a0        \u00a0       \u00a0        \u00a0         Luchian, \u00a0Konstatin \u00a0Bolotin, \u00a0and \u00a0Sun \u00a0 \u00a0\n   \u00a0     \u00a0         \u00a0        \u00a0       \u00a0        \u00a0         Social \u00a0Media \u00a0Inc. \u00a0\n   \u00a0\n\n   \u00a0\n   \u00a0\n   \u00a0\n   \u00a0\n   \u00a0                                   \u00a0\n\n\n\n\n                                                           6 \u00a0\n   \u00a0\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 155 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/26/2016 Page 7 of 7\n\n\n\n\n                                        CERTIFICATE \u00a0OF \u00a0SERVICE \u00a0\n   \u00a0       I \u00a0hereby \u00a0certify \u00a0that \u00a0a \u00a0true \u00a0and \u00a0correct \u00a0copy \u00a0of \u00a0the \u00a0foregoing \u00a0was \u00a0served \u00a0electronically \u00a0\n\n  via \u00a0the \u00a0CM/ECF \u00a0electronic \u00a0filing \u00a0system \u00a0on \u00a0all \u00a0counsel \u00a0or \u00a0parties \u00a0of \u00a0record \u00a0on \u00a0the \u00a0service \u00a0list \u00a0\n\n  below \u00a0this \u00a026th \u00a0day \u00a0of \u00a0August, \u00a02016. \u00a0\n\n   \u00a0                                                              /s/ \u00a0Brady \u00a0J. \u00a0Cobb \u00a0     \u00a0        \u00a0\n   \u00a0                                                              Brady \u00a0J. \u00a0Cobb \u00a0\n   \u00a0\n   \u00a0\n                                                  SERVICE \u00a0LIST \u00a0\n                                                         \u00a0\n  Aaron \u00a0Behar, \u00a0Esquire \u00a0\n  Jaclyn \u00a0Behar, \u00a0Esquire \u00a0\n  BEHARBEHAR \u00a0\n  1840 \u00a0North \u00a0Commerce \u00a0Parkway \u00a0\n  Suite \u00a0One \u00a0\n  Weston, \u00a0Florida \u00a033326 \u00a0\n  Telephone: \u00a0(954) \u00a0688-\u00ad7642 \u00a0\n  Facsimile: \u00a0(954) \u00a0332-\u00ad9260 \u00a0\n  AB@BeharBehar.com \u00a0\n  JB@BeharBehar.com \u00a0\n  Spencer \u00a0D. \u00a0Freeman \u00a0\n  Freeman \u00a0Law \u00a0Firm, \u00a0Inc. \u00a0\n  1107 \u00a01/2 \u00a0Tacoma \u00a0Avenue \u00a0South \u00a0\n  Tacoma, \u00a0Washington \u00a098402 \u00a0\n  Telephone: \u00a0(206) \u00a0516-\u00ad3800 \u00a0\n  Facsimile: \u00a0(206) \u00a0516-\u00ad3888 \u00a0\n  sfreeman@freemanlawfirm.org \u00a0\n   \u00a0\n   \u00a0\n\n\n\n\n                                                            7 \u00a0\n   \u00a0\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2024-06-29T12:29:43.341965-07:00","document_number":"155","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"051016915031","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Reply to Response to Motion","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/404233399/","id":404233399,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/155/1/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2024-06-29T11:54:26.005357-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-30T02:06:48.575168-07:00","sha1":"23011e5d7166282d5792ffd719287e7ca43cd55f","page_count":5,"file_size":696043,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.155.1.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.155.1.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"Case\n Case1:15-cv-22134-UU\n      1:16-cv-20191-RNSDocument 155-1\n                         Document     Enteredon\n                                  38 Entered  onFLSD\n                                                 FLSDDocket\n                                                      Docket07/26/2016\n                                                             08/26/2016 Page\n                                                                         Page11ofof55\n\fCase\n Case1:15-cv-22134-UU\n      1:16-cv-20191-RNSDocument 155-1\n                         Document     Enteredon\n                                  38 Entered  onFLSD\n                                                 FLSDDocket\n                                                      Docket07/26/2016\n                                                             08/26/2016 Page\n                                                                         Page22ofof55\n\fCase\n Case1:15-cv-22134-UU\n      1:16-cv-20191-RNSDocument 155-1\n                         Document     Enteredon\n                                  38 Entered  onFLSD\n                                                 FLSDDocket\n                                                      Docket07/26/2016\n                                                             08/26/2016 Page\n                                                                         Page33ofof55\n\fCase\n Case1:15-cv-22134-UU\n      1:16-cv-20191-RNSDocument 155-1\n                         Document     Enteredon\n                                  38 Entered  onFLSD\n                                                 FLSDDocket\n                                                      Docket07/26/2016\n                                                             08/26/2016 Page\n                                                                         Page44ofof55\n\fCase\n Case1:15-cv-22134-UU\n      1:16-cv-20191-RNSDocument 155-1\n                         Document     Enteredon\n                                  38 Entered  onFLSD\n                                                 FLSDDocket\n                                                      Docket07/26/2016\n                                                             08/26/2016 Page\n                                                                         Page55ofof55\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2024-06-29T12:29:44.011629-07:00","document_number":"155","attachment_number":1,"pacer_doc_id":"051016915032","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/404233400/","id":404233400,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/155/2/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2024-06-29T11:54:26.034747-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-30T02:06:54.604558-07:00","sha1":"aadc7f625447ce78cfad5cfcf093ab5731e5c45d","page_count":5,"file_size":693387,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.155.2.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.155.2.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"Case\nCase1:15-cv-22134-UU\n     1:15-cv-24293-MGCDocument 155-2\n                        Document     Enteredon\n                                 39 Entered  onFLSD\n                                               FLSDDocket\n                                                    Docket07/26/2016\n                                                           08/26/2016 Page\n                                                                      Page11of\n                                                                             of55\n\fCase\nCase1:15-cv-22134-UU\n     1:15-cv-24293-MGCDocument 155-2\n                        Document     Enteredon\n                                 39 Entered  onFLSD\n                                               FLSDDocket\n                                                    Docket07/26/2016\n                                                           08/26/2016 Page\n                                                                      Page22of\n                                                                             of55\n\fCase\nCase1:15-cv-22134-UU\n     1:15-cv-24293-MGCDocument 155-2\n                        Document     Enteredon\n                                 39 Entered  onFLSD\n                                               FLSDDocket\n                                                    Docket07/26/2016\n                                                           08/26/2016 Page\n                                                                      Page33of\n                                                                             of55\n\fCase\nCase1:15-cv-22134-UU\n     1:15-cv-24293-MGCDocument 155-2\n                        Document     Enteredon\n                                 39 Entered  onFLSD\n                                               FLSDDocket\n                                                    Docket07/26/2016\n                                                           08/26/2016 Page\n                                                                      Page44of\n                                                                             of55\n\fCase\nCase1:15-cv-22134-UU\n     1:15-cv-24293-MGCDocument 155-2\n                        Document     Enteredon\n                                 39 Entered  onFLSD\n                                               FLSDDocket\n                                                    Docket07/26/2016\n                                                           08/26/2016 Page\n                                                                      Page55of\n                                                                             of55\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2024-06-29T12:29:44.572368-07:00","document_number":"155","attachment_number":2,"pacer_doc_id":"051016915033","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/404233401/","id":404233401,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/155/3/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2024-06-29T11:54:26.062246-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-30T02:06:48.807569-07:00","sha1":"af905c76868dc9d82f34a66d23a975a928295ba0","page_count":7,"file_size":133464,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.155.3.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.155.3.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"                Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 155-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/26/2016 Page 1 of 7\n\n\n\n\n                                       COBB EDDY, PLLC\n                                         642 N.E. 3rd Avenue\n                                    Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33304\n                                        (954) 527-4111 (office)\n                                        (954) 900-5507 (facsimile)\n                                                 www.cobbeddy.com\nClient: Konstantin Bolotin, Constantin Luchian and Sun Social Media, Inc.\nMatter: Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Luchian, et al: Case No. 2015-cv-22134-UU\n\n Attorney    Date                                      Description                Quantity      Rate        Total\nBrady Cobb\nBC        8/31/2015   Review of Complaint, preparation and filing of Notice of    1.00       $350.00   $350.00\n                      Appearance and Motion to Set Aside default\nBC         8/31/2015 Review of Order granting Motion to set Aside Default,        1.00       $350.00   $350.00\n                      and review of proposed answer and affirmative\n                      defenses\nBC         9/1/2015   Review preparation and filing of Answer and Affirmative     1.00       $350.00   $350.00\n                      Defenses to Plaintiff's Complaint\nBC         9/1/2015   Review revision and approval of Joint Scheduling            1.00       $350.00   $350.00\n                      Report\nBC         9/10/2015 Review of proposed motion to strike affirmative              0.80       $350.00   $280.00\n                      defenses, and transmission of same to co-counsel\nBC         9/25/2015 Review of proposed amended affirmative defenses,             1.00       $350.00   $350.00\n                      and preparation of revisions to the same\nBC         10/6/2015 Review of initial discovery requests from Plaintiff          0.80       $350.00   $280.00\nBC         10/16/2015 Review of order granting motion for leave to file           0.20       $350.00   $70.00\n                      amended answer and affirmative defenses\nBC         11/7/2015 Preparation of response in opposition to Plaintiff's         3.00       $350.00   $1,050.00\n                      Motion to Strike Affirmative Defenses\nBC         11/7/2015 Research of case law to opposed plaintiffs motion to         1.40       $350.00   $490.00\nBC                    strike affirmative\n           11/10/2015 Review   and revisiondefenses\n                                              of response in opposition to        1.30       $350.00   $455.00\nBC                    motion to strike\n           11/12/2015 Finalization   of response in opposition to Motion to       1.20       $350.00   $420.00\n                      Strike.\nBC         11/12/2015 Review of client's responses to discovery requests          0.80       $350.00   $280.00\nBC         11/18/2015 Review and response to emails regarding scheduling of       1.00       $350.00   $350.00\n                      mediation conference\nBC         11/18/2015 review of order on mediation scheduling                     0.20       $350.00   $70.00\nBC         12/1/2015 Review of Plaintiff's Reply in Support of Motion to Strike   0.80       $350.00   $280.00\nBC         12/1/2015 Review of proposed motion to compel by Plaintiff             0.60       $350.00   $210.00\n                      regarding discovery responses.\nBC         12/2/2015 Review and response to alleged deficiencies in clients       1.10       $350.00   $385.00\n                      discovery responses\nBC         12/2/2015 Review of Plaintiff's Second Set of Interrogatories and      1.20       $350.00   $420.00\n                      First Set of Interrogatories\nBC         12/4/2015 Review of Order granting in part and denying in part         1.10       $350.00   $385.00\n                      Motion to Strike Affirmative Defenses\nBC         12/4/2015 Review of Order setting motion to compel for hearing         0.40       $350.00   $140.00\nBC         12/10/2015 Review and revision to draft response to motion to          0.80       $350.00   $280.00\n                      compel\nBC         12/10/2015 Review and revision to joint status report                  0.60       $350.00   $210.00\nBC         12/10/2015 Review of non-objection of to subpoena's                    0.50       $350.00   $175.00\nBC         12/10/2015 Review of request for production responses, and review      0.60       $350.00   $210.00\n                      of revised rules of civil procedure to prepare response\n                      to plaintiff's motion to compel\nBC         12/14/2015 Review and revision to draft response to Plaintiff's        1.10       $350.00   $385.00\n                      Motion to Compel\nBC         12/16/2015 Attendance at hearing on Plaintiff's Motion to Compel       1.10       $350.00   $385.00\nBC         12/16/2015 Review of Motion to Compel and case law to prepare          1.10       $350.00   $385.00\n                      for hearing\n\f         Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 155-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/26/2016 Page 2 of 7\n\n\n\nBC   12/20/2015 Review and response to emails with counsel for Plaintiff    0.70   $350.00   $245.00\n                regarding document production\nBC   12/20/2015 Review of additional documents to be produced               1.10   $350.00   $385.00\nBC   12/31/2015 Review and filing of Motion to Bifuricate Trial and         0.90   $350.00   $315.00\n                Discovery\nBC   1/4/2016   Review of draft interrogatory answers                       1.10   $350.00   $385.00\nBC   1/4/2016   Review of draft responses to second request for             0.80   $350.00   $280.00\n                production\nBC   1/4/2016   Review of proposed RFP to Plaintiff                         0.40   $350.00   $140.00\nBC   1/5/2016   Review of draft discovery requests, and review of order     0.90   $350.00   $315.00\n                denying motion to bifuricate\nBC   1/6/2016   Review and revision to proposed discovery responses         1.00   $350.00   $350.00\nBC   1/18/2016 Attendance at deposition of corporate representative of      7.30   $350.00   $2,555.00\n                Sun Social Media, Inc./Konstantin Bolotin\nBC   1/19/2016 Attendance at deposition of Constantin Luchian               3.40   $350.00   $1,190.00\nBC   1/19/2016 Attendance at deposition of Konstantin Bolotin, in his       3.20   $350.00   $1,120.00\n                individual capacity\nBC   1/22/2016 Review and service of discovery and expert discovery         0.80   $350.00   $280.00\n                onto Plaintiff\nBC   1/28/2016 Review of client's deposition transcripts                    1.10   $350.00   $385.00\nBC   1/29/2016 Review and revision to mediation summary                     0.70   $350.00   $245.00\nBC   2/4/2016   Review of email from counsel for Plaintiff regarding        0.40   $350.00   $140.00\n                mediation and extension of time to produce documents,\n                and preparation of responsive email\nBC   2/5/2016   Review and response to emails regarding discovery           1.00   $350.00   $350.00\n                responses and motions for protective order\nBC   2/5/2016   Review of proposed motion to amend scheduling order         0.80   $350.00   $280.00\n                and proposed counterclaim, and revisions to same\nBC   2/5/2016   Review, revision and filing of motion to amend              1.10   $350.00   $385.00\n                scheduling order\nBC   2/9/2016   Review and response to emails from counsel for              0.90   $350.00   $315.00\n                Plaintiff regarding outstanding discovery requests,\n                production of documents and mediation issues\nBC   2/9/2016   Review of Motion for Protective Order filed by Plaintiffs   1.00   $350.00   $350.00\nBC   2/9/2016   Review of notices of withdrawal of discovery requests       1.10   $350.00   $385.00\n                by Plaintiff\nBC   2/10/2016 Review of motion for sanctions against Val Gurvits, and      2.00   $350.00   $700.00\n                Defendants for failure to appear at mediation and for\n                not complying with Rule 30(b)(6)\nBC   2/12/2016 Review of draft declarations for clients in support of       1.30   $350.00   $455.00\n                MSJ's\nBC   2/12/2016 Review of Plaintiff's Motion to Compel Deposition            1.40   $350.00   $490.00\n                Questions, and preparation of responsive email to\n                Plaintiff's regarding objection to relief sought in the\n                motion.\nBC   2/12/2016 Review, revision and filing of clients' Motions for          1.80   $350.00   $630.00\n                Summary Judgment\nBC   2/13/2016 Review of Plaintiffs Motions for Summary Judgment            2.10   $350.00   $735.00\n                and all attachments thereto\nBC   2/16/2016 Preparation of response to Plaintiffs Motion for             1.10   $350.00   $385.00\n                Protective Order\nBC   2/16/2016 Review of Court orders on telephonic hearings on             0.80   $350.00   $280.00\n                motions to compel\nBC   2/18/2016 Review and revision to declaration and motion in             1.10   $350.00   $385.00\n                opposition to Gurvits motion for sanctions\nBC   2/19/2016 Review approval and filing of response in opposition to      0.90   $350.00   $315.00\n                motion for sanctions\nBC   2/20/2016 Review and response to emails with Plaintiff's counsel       0.40   $350.00   $140.00\n                regarding pre trial stipulation and jury instructions\nBC   2/20/2016 Review of Plaintiff's Motion in Limine                       1.10   $350.00   $385.00\n\f               Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 155-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/26/2016 Page 3 of 7\n\n\n\nBC         2/20/2016   Review revision and filing of Motion to Consolidate                          0.90    $350.00   $315.00\n                       Hearings, Response to Motion for Sanctions and/or to\n                       Compel Deposition testimony\nBC         2/22/2016   Review and filing of opposition to 30b6 motion                               0.60    $350.00   $210.00\nBC         2/23/2016   Preparation, revision and filing of response to Plaintiff's                  1.40    $350.00   $490.00\n                       motion for protective order\nBC         2/23/2016   Review Plaintiff's Motions for Sanctions and Motion for                      1.60    $350.00   $560.00\n                       Protective Order to prepare for telephonic hearing on\n                       the same\nBC         2/26/2016   Review of proposed jury instructions, exhibit list, pretrial                 2.50    $350.00   $875.00\n                       stipulation and objections to Plaintiff's exhibits, and\n                       filing of the same\nBC         2/29/2016   Review, revision and filing of proposed jury instructions                    0.80    $350.00   $280.00\n                       and exhibit list\nBC         2/29/2016   revision and filing of reply in support of pro hac vice                      1.10    $350.00   $385.00\n                       admission\nBC         3/1/2016    Review of Plaintiff's Oppositions to defendants MSJ                          1.10    $350.00   $385.00\nBC         3/2/2016    Review of Plaintiff's objections to Defendants trial                         1.40    $350.00   $490.00\n                       exhibits\nBC         3/15/2016   Review of Plaintiff's Reply brief in support of their                        0.40    $350.00   $140.00\n                       motion in limine\nBC         3/16/2016   Review and response to emails from counsel for                               0.50    $350.00   $175.00\n                       Plaintiff regarding objections to their Motion to Strike\n                       Witnesses\nBC         3/16/2016   Review of Plaintiff's Motion to Strike Witnesses                             0.60    $350.00   $210.00\nBC         5/25/2016   Review of Court's Order denying motion for sanctions                         1.10    $350.00   $385.00\n                       and ordering mediation, and review and response to\n                       emails regarding scheduling of mediation\nBC         5/31/2016   Review and response to emails from client and                                0.50    $350.00   $175.00\n                       opposing counsel regarding mediation scheduling\nBC         5/31/2016   Review of order on Plaintiff's Motion in limine                              0.80    $350.00   $280.00\n\nBC         6/2/2016    Review of Court's Order granting in part Defendants                          1.10    $350.00   $385.00\n                       Motion for Summary Judgment, and denying Plaintiff's\n                       Motion for Summary Judgment\nBC         6/6/2016    Attendance at mediation conference with Mark                                 3.00    $350.00   $1,050.00\n                       Buckstein\nBC         6/6/2016    Review of Plaintiff's Motion for Dismissal under 41(a),                      1.30    $350.00   $455.00\n                       and review of case law regarding same\nBC         6/6/2016    review of revised joint pretrial stipulation, revisions to                   1.30    $350.00   $455.00\n                       same\nBC         6/7/2016    Review of order dismissing Counts VI-VIII                                    0.40    $350.00   $140.00\nBC         6/7/2016    Review of Plaintiffs Rule 41 Motion for Dismissal of                         0.60    $350.00   $210.00\n                       Trademark Claims\n\n                       Total BC:                                                                    93.40             $32,690.00\n\nValentin Gurvits\n\nVG         8/26/2015   Review Complaint; tel conf/w clients; tel conf w/Spencer Freeman, tel conf   3.00    $450.00   $1,350.00\n                       w/Evan and Matt;!attenton to Motion to Remove Default.\nVG         9/1/2015    Attention to Answer and counterclaims                                        3.00    $450.00   $1,350.00\nVG         11/9/2015   Attention to discovery requests.                                             2.75    $450.00   $1,237.50\nVG         2/5/2016    Attention to discovery requests.                                             3.50    $450.00   $1,575.00\nVG         2/12/2016   Attention to Motions for Summary Judgment; layout strategy; preliminary      6.50    $450.00   $2,925.00\n                       research; review undisputed facts; discuss with team; discuss with client.\n\nVG         2/18/2016   Attention to motion for sanctions; research and opposition                   3.75    $450.00   $1,687.50\nVG         3/10/2016   Attention to MSJ; attention to reply.                                        3.50    $450.00   $1,575.00\nVG         6/2/2016    Review the Order on MSJ.                                                     1.00    $450.00   $450.00\nVG         6/5/2016    Travel to Miami for court-ordered mediation.                                 7.00    $450.00   $3,150.00\n\f              Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 155-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/26/2016 Page 4 of 7\n\n\n\nVG        6/6/2016    Meeting with clients re mediation. Attend mediation. Travel to Boca Raton for 5.00   $450.00   $2,250.00\n                      mediation.\nVG        6/7/2016    Travel from court-orders mediation in Miami to Boston.                        7.00   $450.00   $3,150.00\n\n                      Total VG:                                                                    46.00             $20,700.00\n\nEvan Fray-Witzer\nEFW       8/5/2015    Copyright misuse legal research                                              2.25    $450      $1,012.50\nEFW       8/15/2015   Emails and calls with Val and Matt re: potential                             1.00    $450      $450.00\n                      default in Sun Social\nEFW       8/17/2015   Reviewing court order re: default; emails to and                             1.00    $450      $450.00\n                      from Val; call with Val\nEFW       8/25/2015   Legal research re: motion to set aside default -                             7.00    $450      $3,150.00\n                      Florida standards; research re: good cause\n                      standards; research for meritorious defenses;\n                      drafting motion to set aside default\nEFW       8/27/2015   Reviewing sun social complaint, reviewing and                                8.00    $450      $3,600.00\n                      editing timeline; continued drafting of motion to\n                      set aside default; reviewing MetArt's response to\n                      court's show cause order; reviewing proposed\n                      order; emails to and from Matt and Brady\nEFW       8/31/2015   Reviewing answer to complaint                                                2.25    $450      $1,012.50\nEFW       9/1/2015    Drafting counterclaim and research for same;                                 8.75    $450      $3,937.50\n                      editing answer and affirmative defenses; multiple\n                      emails and calls with Val and Matt\nEFW       9/10/2015   Reviewing motion to strike affirmative defenses;                             1.25    $450      $562.50\n                      reviewing cases cited in motion, emails to Brady,\n                      Val, and Matt\nEFW       9/24/2015   Editing and redlining affirmative defenses                                   1.75    $450      $787.50\nEFW       9/25/2015   Reviewing and editing revised affirmative                                    1.75    $450      $787.50\n                      defenses\nEFW       9/25/2015   Emails with Matt and Brady; reviewing amended                                1.00    $450      $450.00\n                      complaint\nEFW       1/22/2016   Reviewing and redlining expert discovery                                     2.00    $450      $900.00\n                      requests\nEFW       1/26/2016   Emails to and from Val, Brady, and Matt                                      1.00    $450      $450.00\nEFW       1/29/2016   Reviewing and redlining mediation statement                                  2.00    $450      $900.00\nEFW       2/5/2016    Reviewing request for supplemental document                                  7.25    $450      $3,262.50\n                      production, reviewing and redlining motion to\n                      amend scheduling order to allow for\n                      counterclaims, legal research for counterclaims,\n                      multiple emails with Matt and Val\nEFW       2/8/2016    Multiple emails with Val, Matt, and Brady                                    0.50    $450      $225.00\nEFW       2/9/2016    Reviewing supplemental documents, reviewing                                  1.50    $450      $675.00\n                      plaintiff's draft motion for sanctions\nEFW       2/11/2016   Multiple emails with Matt and Val, calls with                                8.75    $450      $3,937.50\n                      Matt, Val, and Brady, reviewing and redlining SJ\n                      drafts for SSM, legal research re: trademark\n                      claims, legal research for Luchien SJ motion\nEFW       2/12/2016   Drafting Luchien SJ motion, reviewing and                                    9.25    $450      $4,162.50\n                      redlining declarations, reviewing and redlining\n                      multiple SJ motion drafts, reviewing Plaintiff's\n                      motion for SJ\nEFW       2/18/2016   Reviewing and redlining opposition to motion for                             11.50   $450      $5,175.00\n                      sanctions against V. Gurvits, reviewing and\n                      revising opposition to motion for sanctions re\n                      Bolotin, redlining and revising opposition to\n                      motion for sanctions re: deposition questions,\n                      redlining and revising declarations\n\f              Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 155-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/26/2016 Page 5 of 7\n\n\n\nEFW       2/19/2016   Drafting insert for 30(b)(6) sanctions opposition                           6.50     $450   $2,925.00\n                      and legal research for same, legal research for all\n                      sanctions motions, reviewing and revising draft\n                      oppositions, reviewing data and documents from\n                      clients, reviewing deposition transcripts for use in\n                      oppositions\nEFW       2/22/2016   Revising and redlining opposition to motion for                             1.75     $450   $787.50\n                      protective order\nEFW       2/25/2016   Reviewing errata sheets, reviewing proposed trial                           5.25     $450   $2,362.50\n                      exhibits, reviewing plaintiff's trial exhibits and\n                      objections thereto\nEFW       2/26/2016   Reviewing plaintiff's proposed jury instructions                            6.50     $450   $2,925.00\n                      and verdict form, copyright office research re:\n                      registrations, reviewing proposed trial\n                      stipulations, redlining stipulations, redlining\n                      proposed verdict form, reviewing defendants'\n                      proposed jury instructions\nEFW       2/27/2016   Drafting reply to Plaintiff's Opposition to admit                           1.50     $450   $675.00\n                      Val Gurvits pro hac vice\nEFW       2/29/2016   Redlining opposition to motion for summary                                  5.75     $450   $2,587.50\n                      judgment, reviewing and redlining declarations,\n                      redlining opposition to statement of material facts\nEFW       3/4/2016    Redlining opposition to motions in limine                                   2.25     $450   $1,012.50\nEFW       3/9/2016    Reviewing declarations and first draft of reply to                          2.25     $450   $1,012.50\n                      opposition to motions for summary judgment\nEFW       3/10/2016   Drafting Luchien's SJ reply brief                                           3.5      $450   $1,575.00\nEFW       6/6/2016    Drafting sections of amended joint pre-trial                                5.25     $450   $2,362.50\n                      stipulations, reviewing plaintiff's motion to\n                      dismiss, calls with Val, legal research re:\n                      opposition to motion to dismiss without prejudice\n\n                      Total EFW:                                                                  120.25          $54,112.50\n\nMatthew Shayefar\nMS        7/30/2015  Attn to DMCA form; emails w opp counsel re service of process and response 0.25       $300   $75\n                     deadlines\nMS        8/7/2015   Calls w Spencer and cocounsel re order to show cause                       0.25       $300   $75\nMS        8/17/2015 attn to service and default issues; emails re same                          0.50       $300   $150\nMS        8/26/2015 Attn to motion to vacate default                                            3.50       $300   $1,050\nMS        8/27/2015 Attn to filing of motion to set aside default                               0.50       $300   $150\nMS        8/31/2015 Drafting answer to complaint; multiple emails and conference calls; attn to 3.50       $300   $1,050\n                     SJR\nMS        9/1/2015   Attn to joint scheduling motion; drafting and filing answer                4.25       $300   $1,275\nMS        9/16/2015 Attn to scheduling order; calendaring deadlines                             0.25       $300   $75\nMS        9/17/2015 Drafting amended affirmative defenses                                       1.25       $300   $375\nMS        9/21/2015 Attn to PHV Applications                                                    0.25       $300   $75\nMS        9/25/2015 Attn to amended answerand amended affirmative defenses                      0.75       $300   $225\nMS        9/29/2015 Completing PHV applications                                                 0.50       $300   $150\nMS        10/6/2015 Attn to discovery requests and email to client re same                      0.25       $300   $75\nMS        10/14/2015 Drafting motion to amend answer                                            1.00       $300   $300\nMS        10/15/2015 Drafting and filing motion to amend answer                                 0.25       $300   $75\nMS        11/9/2015 Conference re outstanding discover                                          0.25       $300   $75\nMS        11/11/2015 Preparing and serving document responses                                   3.50       $300   $1,050\nMS        11/12/2015 Review documents for production; drafting opposition to motion to strike   1.75       $300   $525\n\nMS        11/13/2015 attn document production                                                      0.50    $300   $150\nMS        11/16/2015 Review and redraft opposition to motion to strike; Skype and chat w client re 0.75    $300   $225\n                     document production\nMS        11/17/2015 Emails and skype w client re document production; preparation and serving of 1.25     $300   $375\n                     supplemental documents\n\f         Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 155-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/26/2016 Page 6 of 7\n\n\n\nMS   12/2/2015   Review and attn to motion to compel; Calls w client re discovery requests           0.75      $300   $225\n\nMS   12/7/2015  Review mediation documents; review subpoenas; review client emails and         0.25            $300   $75\n                discovery issues\nMS   12/10/2015 Drafting opposition to motion to compel                                        3.00            $300   $900\nMS   12/16/2015 Preparation for hearing on motion to compel                                    0.25            $300   $75\nMS   12/18/2015 Attn to documents from florida and delaware; emails w clients and cocounsel 0.50               $300   $150\n                re same\nMS   12/28/2015 Attn to deposition notices; attn to outstanding discovery; research for motion 5.25            $300   $1,575\n                to bifurcate; drafting motion to bifurcate\nMS   12/29/2015 research and drafting of motion to bifurcate                                   1.50            $300   $450\nMS   12/31/2015 emails and skype w client re outstanding discovery requests                    0.25            $300   $75\nMS   1/4/2016   Drafting responses to 2nd set of RFPs; Drafting RFPs to Hydentra; many calls 2.75              $300   $825\n                and emails w client re discovery responses\nMS   1/5/2016   drafting interrogatory responses; many emails skype and calls w client and     5.75            $300   $1,725\n                cocounsel re same\nMS   1/6/2016   drafting interrogatory responses; preparing document responses; preparing      4.00            $300   $1,200\n                discovery requests; many calls emails and skype w client re same\n\nMS   1/7/2016    Attn to updated depo notice; emails w cocounsel re same                             0.25      $300   $75\nMS   1/8/2016    Emails and skype with client re user email                                          0.25      $300   $75\nMS   1/12/2016   Email to clients w deposition notices; email to clients re preparation for          0.25      $300   $75\n                 depositions\nMS   1/21/2016   Call w co-counsel re DMCA notification issues; research on same; Drafting           1.25      $300   $375\n                 additional discovery requests to Hydentra\nMS   1/25/2016   Attn to premediation deadlines and requirements                                     0.25      $300   $75\nMS   1/26/2016   Drafting Jusino affidavit                                                           0.50      $300   $150\nMS   1/29/2016   Attn to number of allegedly infringed works; drafting case summary for              2.00      $300   $600\n                 mediation\nMS   2/5/2016    Office conference re strategies and mediation; attn to suplemental documents        3.25      $300   $975\n                 production; Drafting motion to amend scheduling order; Calls and emails w\n                 client; Drafting Amended Complaint w Counterclaims\n\nMS   2/8/2016    Emails w cocounsel and opp counsel; document review re supplemtnal                    0.75    $300   $225\n                 production; communicate with client re same\nMS   2/9/2016    Review document production by Hydentra; Preparing and serve supplemental 1.75                 $300   $525\n                 document responses; preparation for motions for summary judgment; review\n                 discovery responses from hydentra\nMS   2/10/2016   Attn to motions filed by plaintiff; Preparation for motions for summary               3.25    $300   $975\n                 judgment; research and document review re same\nMS   2/11/2016   drafting and researching and preparing motions for summary judgment and               12.50   $300   $3,750\n                 related documents\nMS   2/12/2016   Drafting and researching and preparing motions for summary judgment and               6.50    $300   $1,950\n                 related documents\nMS   2/16/2016   Attn to multiple emails w cocounsel and clients re scheduling and upcoming 0.75               $300   $225\n                 deadlines and strategy\n                 Office conference regarding responses to plaintiff's motions\nMS   2/18/2016   Drafting opposition to motion for sanctions re Gurvits; Drafting opposition to 6.75           $300   $2,025\n                 for sanctions re deposition testimony\nMS   2/19/2016   Drafting and filing multiple responses to plaintiff's motions                         4.00    $300   $1,200\nMS   2/21/2016   Attn to preparing for filing responses to plaintiff's motions                         0.50    $300   $150\nMS   2/22/2016   Call w client re deposition transcripts; review filings by plaintiff and emails re 0.50       $300   $150\n                 same w cocounsel\nMS   2/24/2016   Drafting errata sheet for bolotin deposition transcripts                              1.00    $300   $300\nMS   2/25/2016   Preparing errata sheet for luchian deposition transcript; drafting pre-trial          4.00    $300   $1,200\n                 stipulations and other pretrial documents due today\nMS   2/26/2016   drafting pre-trial stipulations; jury instructions; trial exhibits and other pretrial 7.75    $300   $2,325\n                 documents due today; reviewing plaintiff's same\nMS   2/28/2016   Drafting Opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment                                    6.00    $300   $1,800\nMS   2/29/2016   Drafting and preparing for filing opposition to motion for summary judgment 8.25              $300   $2,475\n\f         Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 155-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/26/2016 Page 7 of 7\n\n\n\nMS   3/3/2016    Preparing for opposition to motions in limine                                   0.25    $300   $75\nMS   3/4/2016    Drafting opposition to motions in limine                                        5.25    $300   $1,575\nMS   3/9/2016    Drafting and researching for reply to MSJs                                      8.25    $300   $2,475\nMS   3/10/2016   Drafting reply in support of MSJs and all documents related thereto; review of 8.75     $300   $2,625\n                 plaintiff's msj reply\nMS   4/5/2016    Office conferece; review pretrial documents                                     0.25    $300   $75\nMS   6/6/2016                                                                                    3.50    $300   $1,050\n                 Review order on motions for summary judgment; conference calls re same;\n                 drafting pretrial stipulations; drafting motion for separate and final judgment\nMS   6/7/2016    Attn to motion to dismiss TM claims; various emails and calls w cocounsel re 0.25       $300   $75\n                 case\n\n\n                 Total MS:                                                                      148.25          $44,400\n\n                 TOTALS:                                                                        407.90          $151,902.50\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2024-06-29T12:29:45.201506-07:00","document_number":"155","attachment_number":3,"pacer_doc_id":"051016915034","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.499372-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-29T11:54:25.980162-07:00","date_filed":"2016-08-26","time_filed":null,"entry_number":155,"recap_sequence_number":"2016-08-26.001","pacer_sequence_number":469,"description":"REPLY to Response to Motion re 148 MOTION for Attorney Fees filed by Konstantin Bolotin. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit, # 2 Exhibit, # 3 Exhibit)(Cobb, Brady) (Entered: 08/26/2016)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/171244035/","id":171244035,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/176529106/","id":176529106,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/154/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.485743-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-30T02:06:27.077139-07:00","sha1":"b7be08f7cb7f22b5d8bcbf9ab0f7363e03db3146","page_count":21,"file_size":169212,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.154.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.154.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 1 of 21\n\n\n\n\n                               UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                               SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA\n\n                                          MIAMI DIVISION\n\n                                    CASE NO.: 1:15-cv-22134-UU\n\n  HYDENTRA HLP INT. LIMITED,\n  a foreign corporation d/b/a METART,\n\n                 Plaintiff,\n\n  vs.\n\n  CONSTANTIN LUCHIAN, et al.,\n\n              Defendants.\n  __________________________________________/\n\n    PLAINTIFF\u2019S OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS FEES\n                              I.   INTRODUCTION\n\n         The Internet presents an unfortunate and specific battle ground over intellectual property\n\n  rights. Content producers, within both mainstream and adult entertainment industry, spend\n\n  significant money on the production and protection of intellectual property with the intent (and\n\n  right) to earn money from the content. However, others have established a business model\n\n  whereby they display videos for free, often in violation of the content producer\u2019s copyrights.\n\n  Many of these operators upload the pirated videos themselves, and then fake upload data.\n\n         These Internet web sites earn money from sale of advertising space on the web sites.\n\n  Advertising sales are based on the amount of Internet traffic a site can get. Content is king in that\n\n  the better and more desirous the content, the more viewers a website can garner and retain.\n\n         Internet web sites display free content significantly damage content producers. Quite\n\n  simply, users will not pay content producers for the right to view the content when it is readily\n\n  available for free. Content producers must police their copyrights through the constraints of\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 2 of 21\n\n\n\n\n  Title II of the DMCA, the Online Copyright Infringement Liability Limitation Act. The Act\n\n  protects Internet Service Providers (ISPs) from copyright liability if, among other things, the ISP\n\n  responds appropriately to take down notices and implements a reasonable repeat infringer policy.\n\n            Hydentra HLP Int. Ltd. (\u201cHydentra\u201d) is a content producer in the adult entertainment\n\n  industry, producing content made available to view for a fee on Hydentra\u2019s paid membership\n\n  web sites. Hydentra has attempted to police and enforce its copyrights. Such attempts include\n\n  approximately 19,000 DMCA compliant take down notices sent to over 650 ISPs/web sites that\n\n  display(ed) Hydentra copyrighted content for free.\n\n            In comparison to the number of take down notices issued and the number of ISPs\n\n  contacted, there have been relatively few that fail to comply and continue to display Hydentra\u2019s\n\n  content for free. In these cases, other than allowing ISPs to continue to display its content for\n\n  free, Hydentra was left no option but to turn to the Courts to enforce its copyrights.\n\n            This instant litigation was one of those instances. While Hydentra\u2019s copyright claims\n\n  were dismissed on summary judgment, Hydentra\u2019s primary purpose of copyright enforcement\n\n  was met. The web sites at issue in this case, once rampant ground for infringement of Hydentra\u2019s\n\n  content, no longer infringe Hydentra\u2019s copyright protected works.\n\n                                                II.       FACTS\n\n            Hydentra is the producer, distributor, and exclusive licensor of its own motion pictures\n\n  that explore and deliver sensuality and sexuality through artistic photography, video, and erotic\n\n  stories. Hydentra also owns and/or operates MetArt.com, SexArt.com, and other paid\n\n  membership sites through which Hydentra offers its motion pictures to the public for a fee. Ex.\n\n  1, \u00b6 3.\n\n            Since 1999, Hydentra has grown its trademark brands into a globally recognized leader of\n\n\n                                                      2\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 3 of 21\n\n\n\n\n  sensual art garnering numerous industry awards through the use of studios around the globe,\n\n  exotic locations, high budget productions, engaging storylines, famed photographers and\n\n  directors coupled with the dedication from its artists and technicians. The MetArt library is\n\n  comprised      of    exclusive      content     that    features     over    5000     models      shot     by    250\n\n  photographers/directors including such notables as Vivian Thomas and the late Zalman King,\n\n  who also brought Hollywood films such as Wild Orchid, Two Moon Junction, 9 \u00bd Weeks, and\n\n  the Showtime network groundbreaking series Red Shoes Diaries. Ex. 1, \u00b6 4.\n\n           Hydentra prides itself on high quality movies, often spending six times more than\n\n  industry standards in production costs. Hydentra expends a significant amount of resources, in\n\n  locating and contracting actor/models, film makers, editors, producers, and locations to produce\n\n  new films monthly. The production model is a constant on-going process \u2013 and therefore\n\n  expenditure. Hydentra\u2019s effort in producing high quality content is recognized in the industry. In\n\n  fact, SexArt.com recently won 2016 XBiz Erotic Adult Site of the Year and 2016 AVN Best\n\n  Director & Film. Ex. 1, \u00b6 5.\n\n           Hydentra has spent over $45,000 registering its works with the United States Copyright\n\n  Office. Hydentra has taken industry standard steps to identify its products. Hydentra\u2019s videos are\n\n  watermarked with Hydentra\u2019s readily identifiable registered trademark. Ex. 1, \u00b6 6.\n\n           Hydentra\u2019s movies are intended to be available only through its paid membership sites or\n\n  purchase by scene, set, or asset. The Hydentra business model is simply that a user must pay\n\n  Hydentra to view Hydentra\u2019s movies. Each member of Hydentra\u2019s membership web sites has an\n\n  average value of $120. This considers that the average retention rate is three months, at $29.99\n\n  per month and the average up-sale for each member. 1 Ex. 1, \u00b6 7.\n\n\n  1\n    Defendants asserted that Hydentra\u2019s monthly memberships are worth $8.33 per month as a means to inflate their\n  assertion that Hydentra\u2019s motive for litigation is purely profit driven. In doing this, the Defendants intentionally\n                                                            3\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 4 of 21\n\n\n\n\n           Hydentra engages in extremely limited licensing of its content to other entities or\n\n  websites for viewing, in addition to the small sample of promotional materials provided to\n\n  Hydentra affiliates for the sole purpose of the affiliates\u2019 promoting Hydentra\u2019s web sites. All\n\n  licensing is done with the intent for brand exposure and is limited to a small subset of hand-\n\n  selected short format content. Ex. 1, \u00b6 9.\n\n           Numerous web sites display free copyrighted adult content without license or authority.\n\n  These video streaming sites are often portrayed as third party upload sites, analogous to\n\n  Youtube.com. The existence of video streaming sites damages paid membership sites as users\n\n  are less likely to pay a monthly membership fee when they can access a producer\u2019s movies for\n\n  free. The display and viewing of Hydentra\u2019s movies for free results in a direct loss of revenue\n\n  for Hydentra. Ex. 1, \u00b6 10.\n\n           As Hydentra\u2019s works have grown in popularity, so has the prevalence of the unlawful\n\n  display of Hydentra\u2019s videos on video streaming sites, wherein those site owners earn revenue\n\n  from advertising monies.           The prevalence of piracy seriously threatens every element of\n\n  Hydentra\u2019s business, certainly the value of the paid membership sites and licenses to distributors.\n\n  Simply put, if Hydentra videos and images are readily available for free, there is little incentive\n\n  for distributors to license the product and little incentive for an end user to pay for a membership.\n\n  \u201cFree\u201d will win, every time. Ex. 1, \u00b6\u00b6 11-12.\n\n           Given the prevalence of video streaming sites and the damage such sites do to Hydentra\u2019s\n\n  paid membership sites, Hydentra retained the services of several vendors including Takedown\n\n\n\n  overlooked ALL of the other membership options provided by Hydentra, including the standard $29.99 per month.\n  The Defendant's fail to mention that this lowest monthly price point is for members who fully pre-pay for a year's\n  subscription, or spend $100 upfront. By their own formula, if the Defendant's applied a true value of the net worth\n  of Hydentra's customers, the amount of equivalent memberships would be significantly lower, a fraction of what\n  they claimed. Of course, if the Defendant's were realistic with the numbers, it would significantly downplay their\n  reasoning. Ex. 1, \u00b6 8.\n                                                           4\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 5 of 21\n\n\n\n\n  Piracy and Battleship Stance LLC to investigate copyright infringement, send DMCA complaint\n\n  takedown notices for detected infringement of Hydentra copyrighted works, and document\n\n  infringements when takedown notices are ignored and/or the web sites are not registered as\n\n  Internet Service Providers. Ex. 1, \u00b6 13.\n\n         Since 2013, through Takedown Piracy and Battleship Stance, Hydentra has issued over\n\n  19,000 take down notices to over 650 different ISPs/ video streaming sites which have displayed\n\n  Hydentra\u2019s copyrighted works. Ex. 2, \u00b6 12; Ex. 3, \u00b6\u00b6 8-9. In addition, 2,880,299 URLs/links\n\n  were reported via DMCA notices to Google for removal from their search engines. Ex. 3, \u00b6 10.\n\n  When take down notices do not result in the termination of infringements on a video streaming\n\n  site, Hydentra has little choice in protecting its copyrights but to seek Court intervention.\n\n  Relatively speaking, with only 20 lawsuits filed, Court intervention is sought in very limited\n\n  instances.\n\n         The purpose of Hydentra\u2019s actions has been, and continues to be, to thwart infringements\n\n  of its copyrighted works. Contrary to Defendants\u2019 assertions, Hydentra\u2019s copyright enforcement\n\n  is not a business model. Hydentra has spent over $500,000 to enforce its copyrights, including\n\n  investigations, take down notices, and litigation. In contrast, Hydentra has recovered less than a\n\n  quarter of those costs from infringing ISPs. Ex. 1, \u00b6\u00b6 14-15.\n\n         Specific to the Defendants in the instant matter, investigations revealed significant\n\n  infringements on Playvid.com, Playvids.com, Peekvids.com, and Feedvid.com. Ex. 2, \u00b6 13.\n\n  Beginning in 2013, Hydentra utilized Takedown Piracy to send take down notices for\n\n  infringements on these sites. Ex. 1, \u00b6 16. These notices were sent via email. A total of 2,268\n\n  notices were sent by Takedown Piracy regarding the Defendants sites. While initial notices\n\n  resulted in the take down of infringing videos, over time these notices were increasingly ignored\n\n\n                                                  5\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 6 of 21\n\n\n\n\n  to the point where they were virtually totally ignored.     Ex. 3, \u00b6\u00b6 12-18.    Even when the\n\n  Defendants\u2019 did receive a notice, it was presented at summary judgment that many times\n\n  Hydentra\u2019s infringed videos were posted up to 1 year after a user had been purported to be\n\n  terminated in accordance with their own Repeat Infringer Policy.\n\n          Hydentra tested the sources of infringements on the Defendants Sites by blocking IP\n\n  addresses from the servers hosting Defendants\u2019 sites. This meant that persons with IP addresses\n\n  from these servers could not access Hydentra\u2019s paid membership sites. This action resulted in an\n\n  immediate decrease in the frequency of infringements of Hydentra content on the Defendants\n\n  Sites. As a result, it appeared that someone was directly downloading Hydentra\u2019 content from its\n\n  paid membership sites and posting on the Defendants Sites. Ex. 1, \u00b6\u00b6 17-18.\n\n          There were concerns that the take down notices sent via email regarding the Defendants\n\n  Sites were not actually being received, as there was no way to be sure that the notices were\n\n  actually delivered. Accordingly, Hydentra retained Battleship Stance to physically send paper\n\n  notices to the DMCA Agent which would establish the delivery of the notices. Such notices\n\n  were delivered in January 2015. Ex. 1, \u00b6 19; Ex. 2, \u00b6 15.\n\n          Five months later, Hydentra\u2019s videos that were the subject of the take down notices were\n\n  still displayed. Ex. 2, \u00b6 16. In addition, by this time TakeDown Piracy\u2019s email notices were\n\n  virtually completely ignored. Given the failure to respond to any type of take down notice, it\n\n  was determined that litigation was necessary to thwart the piracy on the Defendants sites. Ex. 1,\n\n  \u00b6 20.\n\n          While Hydentra lost its copyright claims on summary judgment, the primary purpose of\n\n  the litigation was successful. As a result of this litigation, Hydentra\u2019s works are no longer\n\n  infringed on the Defendants sites. Ex. 1, \u00b6 21. Prior to and during this litigation, an Internet\n\n\n                                                  6\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 7 of 21\n\n\n\n\n  search for MetArt or SexArt videos produced Defendants sites high in results, enabling\n\n  consumers to easily find Hydentra\u2019s content for free on Defendants sites. Since this litigation,\n\n  Defendants sites do not come up in such searches. Prior to and during this litigation, a search for\n\n  MetArt or SexArt videos using the search tool on the Defendants sites resulted in the display of\n\n  numerous Hydentra videos displayed in violation of Hydentra\u2019s copyrights. Since this litigation,\n\n  such a search on the Defendants sites results in the display of exactly zero of Hydentra\u2019s videos.\n\n  Ex. 1, \u00b6\u00b6 22-23; Ex. 2, \u00b6\u00b6 17-20.\n\n         While the Court dismissed Hydentra\u2019s copyright claims, the litigation actually served its\n\n  purpose under the Copyright Act.\n\n                                      III.   PROCEDURAL HISTORY\n\n         Defendants, in their motion, fail to provide the Court with a complete and accurate\n\n  account of each Court Order issued pursuant to the motions in this case, misleading the Court as\n\n  to the true context and meaning of the decisions of the Court.\n\n         Hydentra filed this action on June 5, 2015. Dkt. No. 1. Defendant Suns Social and\n\n  Bolotin were served on July 15 and 16, 2015. Dkt. Nos. 12 and 13. Hydentra was having\n\n  difficulty finding Luchian to serve process. Defendants\u2019 counsel requested that Hydentra agree\n\n  to an extension of time for Defendants to file a response to the complaint. Hydentra agreed in\n\n  exchange for Defendants\u2019 counsel\u2019s acceptance of service of process for Defendant Luchian.\n\n         On August 6, 2015, the Court issued an Order to Show Cause as to why default should\n\n  not be entered. Dkt. No. 15. On August 17, 2015, the Court sua sponte issued an order directing\n\n  the clerk to enter Default and directed Hydentra to file a motion for Entry of Judgment. Dkt. No.\n\n  16. Hydentra conferred with Defendants\u2019 counsel on this issue, indicating that Hydentra would\n\n  not oppose stating that a motion to vacate the default. Defendants\u2019 counsel informed Hydentra\n\n\n                                                  7\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 8 of 21\n\n\n\n\n  that they could not make any filings as they had yet to be formally retained. Hydentra filed a\n\n  motion for extension of deadline to file Motion for Entry of Judgment. Dkt. No. 18. This\n\n  Motion was denied. Dkt. No. 19. Hydentra had no choice but to file a Motion for Entry of\n\n  Judgment, or have the Court dismiss the action. Hydentra recognized that this invalidated the\n\n  acceptance of service on Defendant Luchian, and thereafter personally served him.\n\n         At no time was Hydentra attempting to back out of its agreement with Defendants\u2019\n\n  counsel. Hydentra was ordered by the Court to take action. Any argument otherwise is a wrong.\n\n         On October 29, 2015, Hydentra filed a Motion to Strike Affirmative Defenses, addressing\n\n  Defendants\u2019 Amended Answer and Affirmative Defenses, after the parties had a meet and confer\n\n  regarding Defendants\u2019 initial Affirmative Defendants. A review of the subsequent Court Order,\n\n  dated December 4, 2015, Dkt. No. 53, shows that of the sixteen affirmative defenses sought to be\n\n  stricken, one was granted outright and 6 thereafter deemed general denial, not affirmative\n\n  defenses. Such clarification was necessary for the litigation.\n\n         On December 1, 2015, Hydentra filed a Motion to Compel Answers to Requests for\n\n  Production. A review of the subsequent Court Order, dated December 17, 2016, Dkt. No. 58,\n\n  shows that Hydentra\u2019s Motion to Compel was granted relating to RFP Nos. 9 and 17; denied\n\n  relating to RFP Nos. 6-8 and 10-16, with specific instruction inquiries were permissible at\n\n  deposition; denied relating to RFP Nos. 5 and 19, because of Defendants\u2019 counsel\u2019s\n\n  representations at the hearing that no such documents existed; denied relating to RFP No. 18, it\n\n  with specific instruction that such inquiry was permissible via interrogatory; and denied relating\n\n  to RFP No. 20, because No. 9 encompassed No. 20. The denials still provided Hydentra relief.\n\n         On February 10, 2016, Hydentra filed a Motion for Sanctions for Unlicensed Practice of\n\n  Law. This Motion was denied as the Court determined it did not have jurisdiction over the issue,\n\n\n                                                   8\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 9 of 21\n\n\n\n\n  but specifically found Defendants\u2019 Counsel\u2019s Action to be \u201csuspicious.\u201d Dkt. No. 135.\n\n         On February 10, 2016, Hydentra filed a Motion for Sanctions for Failure to Comply with\n\n  Rule 30(b)(6). On February 12, 2016, Plaintiff filed a Motion to Compel Arising From\n\n  Instructions Not to Answer and Refusal to Answer Deposition Questions. The Court specifically\n\n  found that Defendants and Defendants\u2019 counsel acted wrongfully in refusing to answer\n\n  deposition questions. Dkt. No. 107.\n\n         On June 2, 2016, the Court dismissed Hydentra\u2019s copyright claims on summary\n\n  judgment. Dkt. No. 138. On June 7, 2016, Hydentra filed a motion to voluntarily dismiss its\n\n  trademark claims. Dkt. No. 140.\n\n                                            IV.     ARGUMENT\n\n         A district court may award \"a reasonable attorney's fee to the prevailing party\" in a civil\n\n  copyright-infringement action. 17 U.S.C. \u00a7 505. The district court awards \u00a7 505 attorney's fees\n\n  \"as a matter of the court's discretion.\" Fogerty v. Fantasy, Inc., 510 U.S. 517, 534, 114 S.Ct.\n\n  1023, 1033, 127 L. Ed. 2d 455 (1994). In deciding whether to make such an award, the court\n\n  considers \"whether imposition of attorney's fees will further the goals of the Copyright Act, i.e.,\n\n  by encouraging the raising of objectively reasonable claims and defenses, which may serve not\n\n  only to deter infringement but also to ensure that the boundaries of copyright law are demarcated\n\n  as clearly as possible.\" MiTek Holdings, Inc. v. Arce Eng'g Co., Inc., 198 F.3d 840, 842-43 (11th\n\n  Cir. 1999) (emphasis added).\n\n         Courts consider factors such as \"frivolousness, motivation, objective unreasonableness\n\n  (both in the factual and in the legal components of the case) and the need in particular\n\n  circumstances to advance considerations of compensation and deterrence,\" if the application of\n\n  those factors furthers the purposes of the Copyright Act. Fogerty, 510 U.S. at 534 n.19, 114\n\n\n                                                   9\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 10 of 21\n\n\n\n\n   S.Ct. at 1033 n.19 (quoting Lieb v. Topstone Indus., Inc., 788 F.2d 151, 156 (3d Cir. 1986)).\n\n           When close infringement cases are litigated, copyright law benefits from the resulting\n\n   clarification of the doctrine's boundaries. But because novel cases require a plaintiff to sue in the\n\n   first place, the need to encourage meritorious defenses is a factor that a district court may\n\n   balance against the potentially chilling effect of imposing a large fee award on a plaintiff who, in\n\n   a particular case, may have advanced a reasonable, albeit unsuccessful, claim.\" Lotus Dev. Corp.\n\n   v. Borland Int'l Inc., 140 F.3d 70, 75 (1st Cir. 1998).\n\n      A.      Award of Attorneys Fees Not Warrant In Instant Matter.\n\n              1. Prevailing Party\n\n           As Defendants were granted summary judgment, they are the prevailing party in the\n\n   litigation. However, to determine whether a fee should be awarded, the Court must also consider\n\n   the rest of the non-exclusive list of factors suggested by the Supreme Court. See Mitek Holdings,\n\n   198 F.3d at 842 (citing Fogerty, 510 U.S. at 526-27). This is especially important in the instant\n\n   case when not only were Hydentra\u2019s copyright claims reasonable and with proper motivation, the\n\n   primary purpose of the litigation was actually achieved \u2013 there are no longer infringements of\n\n   Hydentra\u2019s copyrighted works on the Defendants sites. Thus, Hydentra\u2019s effort to protect its\n\n   intellectual property rights has been ultimately successful.\n\n              2. Frivolousness\n\n           Two elements must be proven for a valid copyright infringement claim: \"(1) ownership of\n\n   a valid copyright, and (2) copying of constituent elements of the work that are original.\" Feist\n\n   Publ'ns, Inc. v. Rural Tel. Serv. Co., 499 U.S. 340, 361, 111 S. Ct. 1282, 113 L. Ed. 2d 358\n\n   (1991); Herzog v. Castle Rock Entm't, 193 F.3d 1241, 1246 (11th Cir. 1999).\n\n                                                    10\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 11 of 21\n\n\n\n\n          At summary judgment, the trial court found that, relating to the direct copyright claim,\n\n   Hydentra failed to show that the Defendants engage in volitional conduct. As noted by the trial\n\n   court, the element of volitional conduct has not yet been adopted by the Eleventh Circuit Court\n\n   of Appeals. Hydentra presented evidence that Defendants operated the site for the sole purpose\n\n   of streaming porn videos and attracted users through videos to increase site traffic in order to\n\n   raise the value of and profit from advertising space on the sites. Hydentra also presented\n\n   evidence that all videos were first kept in a holding area before public display, and displayed\n\n   only after a review process. Further, Hydentra presented evidence that the email addresses\n\n   associated with the purported uploaders of Hydentra\u2019s videos were fake email addresses, raising\n\n   the likelihood that the videos were posted by the Defendants.\n\n          There were also invalid IP addresses around uploaded videos, where a good IP existed\n\n   when that very same user signed up as a member to Defendants\u2019 websites. The invalid IPs all\n\n   started in the exact same format (0.0.x.x), even though the affected users were spread out all over\n\n   the world. This raises the likelihood that the videos were posted by the Defendants and assigned\n\n   to these users after the fact. The information in the database is controlled and can be\n\n   manipulated only by the Defendants. This evidence was disqualified by the Court merely\n\n   because it was disclosed in testimony from Jason Tucker, whom the court declared was not an\n\n   expert and therefore could not and should not opine. This information was strong evidence in\n\n   showing there was impropriety around the uploaded videos. The IP addresses that the\n\n   Defendant\u2019s identified as the IPs of users who uploaded specific infringed videos were fake.\n\n          While Hydentra\u2019s arguments were not successful with the trial court, its claims cannot be\n\n   said to be frivolous. Hydentra\u2019s content was copyrighted and was copied and publically\n\n   displayed on the Defendants sites. Moreover, Hydentra followed the DMCA requirements in\n\n\n                                                    11\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 12 of 21\n\n\n\n\n   unsuccessful attempts to have its content removed from the sites. It is noteworthy that other\n\n   Circuits have ruled that the public display of a copyrighted image stored on a computer server,\n\n   even when the image is stored at the behest of a third party, is direct infringement by the operator\n\n   of the computer. Perfect 10, Inc. v. Amazon.com, Inc., 508 F.3d 1146, 1160 (9th Cir. 2007).\n\n          Regarding Hydentra\u2019s contributory copyright claims, Hydentra needed to establish that\n\n   Defendants were in a position to control the use of copyrighted works on the sites and knew, or\n\n   had reason to know, of the infringements. Hydentra presented evidence that the Defendants were\n\n   specifically made aware of the infringements and did nothing, and that Defendants were in\n\n   control of what was displayed on the sites. The trial court noted that there was a credibility issue\n\n   with Defendant Luchian\u2019s testimony and whether he actually received the notices. The trial\n\n   court also found that Hydentra was also required to show that the web sites were not capable for\n\n   non-fringing uses and did not do so. This is the first time that this standard was applied to a\n\n   strict video streaming site, relying on Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Studios, Inc. v. Grokster, Ltd., 545\n\n   U.S. 913 (2005) (a case against the distributor of a file sharing program). In issuing the ruling,\n\n   the Court relied only on the testimony of the Defendant Bolotin who alleged that users of his\n\n   admittedly failed dating site wished to share videos, and thus the new video streaming sites were\n\n   created, on a totally separate URL that was not connected to the original dating site. Because\n\n   real users were allegedly posting videos from this alternative dating site, the Court found that the\n\n   website was capable of substantial non-infringing use, and Hydentra\u2019s contributory copyright\n\n   claims were defeated.\n\n          Regarding Hydentra\u2019s vicarious copyright infringement claims, Hydentra needed to\n\n   establish that the defendants profited from direct infringements while declining to exercise a\n\n   right to stop or limit it. Hydentra presented evidence that Defendants had the ability to stop the\n\n\n                                                    12\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 13 of 21\n\n\n\n\n   infringements and that the Defendants were made aware of the infringements and failed to act.\n\n   Hydentra further presented evidence that the revenue generated by the sites were solely\n\n   advertising revenue, the value of which was dependent upon the quality of content on the site.\n\n   The court found that Hydentra failed to establish a direct financial benefit from the videos.\n\n          Regarding Hydentra\u2019s inducement of copyright infringement claim, Hydentra needed to\n\n   establish that the web sites were promoted to infringe copyright. Hydentra presented evidence\n\n   that the web sites were operated with such anonymity that it promoted the use of the site for\n\n   infringement. Hydentra presented evidence that the Defendants purposefully failed to check\n\n   valid email addresses and failed to contact its members, at any time or for any reason, in order to\n\n   not scare the members away. Users needed to be a member to only to post videos. The trial\n\n   court found that Defendants ran a passive internet service, and did not induce uploads.\n\n          Defendants argue that the inclusion of the individual defendants requires an award of\n\n   fees. However, the inclusion of the individual defendants was not frivolous \u2013 as individuals that\n\n   control the content on a web site or have the ability to supervise the infringing activity, even if\n\n   ignorant of the infringement, may be held personally liable. Southern Bell Tel. & Tel. Co. v.\n\n   Assoc. Telephone Directory Publishers, 756 F.2d 801, 811 (11th Cir. 1985). Bolotin controlled\n\n   the content on the sites. Further, Luchian controlled the take down notices and was listed on at\n\n   least 4 directories as a Director of Defendant Sun Social Media, Inc.\n\n          In each claim, Hydentra presented evidence and facts regarding the elements of each\n\n   claim. While the trial court deemed them legally insufficient, they were not frivolous. This\n\n   factor weighs in the favor of denying Defendants motion for fees.\n\n              3. Objective Unreasonableness of Copyright Claims\n\n          The mere fact that summary judgment was granted, in and of itself, does not speak to\n\n                                                    13\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 14 of 21\n\n\n\n\n   whether Plaintiff's claims were \"objectively unreasonable.\" Indyne, Inc. v. Abacus Tech. Corp.,\n\n   No. 6:11-cv-137-Orl-22DAB, 2013 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 185422, at *17 (M.D. Fla. Dec. 6, 2013),\n\n   citing FASA Corp. v. Playmates Toys, Inc., 1 F.Supp.2d 859, 864 (N.D. Ill.1998).\n\n          In fact, as the Indyne Court listed, there are many cases in which fees were denied to a\n\n   prevailing party in copyright cases: Positive Black Talk, Inc. v. Cash Money Records, Inc., 394\n\n   F.3d 357, 382-83 (5th Cir. 2004) (affirming district court's denial of fees to prevailing defendant\n\n   where claims were not \"frivolous, objectively unreasonable, or without proper motive\" and an\n\n   award would not deter future meritless lawsuits); Lotus Dev. Corp. v. Borland Int'l, Inc., 140\n\n   F.3d 70, 74-75 (1st Cir. 1998) (in a case of first impression, denial of fees was within court's\n\n   discretion where \"both parties had important economic interests in the litigation,\" deterrence was\n\n   not a factor, and plaintiff's unsuccessful claim was reasonable); Jacob Maxwell, Inc. v. Veeck,\n\n   110 F.3d 749, 754 (11th Cir. 1997) (affirming denial of defendant's motion for fees in light of\n\n   Fogerty factors without analysis); Clark v. Hudson Bay Music, Inc., 1996 U.S. App. LEXIS\n\n   25245, 1996 WL 547186, *2 (2d Cir. 1996) (denial of plaintiff's request for fees affirmed where\n\n   damages and future royalties made considerations of deterrence and compensation irrelevant);\n\n   Johnson v. Tuff-N-Rumble Mgmt., Inc., 2000 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 12071, 2000 WL 1145748, *11\n\n   (E.D. La. 2000) (denying defendant's request for fees where plaintiff's claims were colorable and\n\n   not objectively unreasonable and where award would not deter future baseless suits); Compaq\n\n   Computer Corp. v. Procom Tech., Inc., 908 F.Supp. 1409, 1429 (S.D. Tex. 1995) (declining to\n\n   award fees to prevailing plaintiff where deterrence was served by injunctive relief and\n\n   defendant's position was not objectively unreasonable); Bourne Co. v. Walt Disney Co., 1994\n\n   U.S. Dist. LEXIS 7783, 1994 WL 263482, *2 (S.D. N.Y. 1994) (denying plaintiff's motion for\n\n   fees where case involved unsettled issues of law and defense raised by unsuccessful defendant\n\n\n                                                    14\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 15 of 21\n\n\n\n\n   was \"fair ground for litigation\" even if not accepted by jury), aff'd, 68 F.3d 621 (2nd Cir. 1995);\n\n   see also Donald Frederick Evans & Assocs. v. Continental Homes, Inc., 785 F.2d 897, 916 (11th\n\n   Cir. 1986) (in pre-Fogerty case, affirming denial of prevailing defendant's fee request where\n\n   plaintiff's claims were colorable)).\n\n          A number of cases post-Fogerty awarded fees to prevailing defendants upon a finding\n\n   that plaintiffs' claims were objectively unreasonable. See, e.g., Amadasun v. Dreamworks, LLC,\n\n   359 F.Supp.2d 1367, 1375-76 (N.D. Ga. 2005) (awarding fees for defense of screenwriter-\n\n   plaintiff's claims against two large film companies which were \"objectively unreasonable\");\n\n   Bridgeport Music, Inc. v. Diamond Time, Ltd., 371 F.3d 883, 894 (6th Cir. 2004) (awarding fees\n\n   to prevailing defendant where plaintiffs chose to sue hundreds of defendants all at the same time,\n\n   regardless of the strength of the individual claims for contributory infringement and negligence\n\n   based on shaky facts and even shakier legal arguments and inevitably swept up parties against\n\n   whom they had little or no chance of succeeding and defendants prevailed on a statute of\n\n   limitations defense).\n\n          For the reasons stated above in Section A.2., Hydentra\u2019s claims were objectively\n\n   reasonable. Further, the question must be asked: Other than this litigation, what was Hydentra\n\n   supposed to do? Hydentra retained a vendor to send electronic/email take down notices.\n\n   Contrary to Defendants\u2019 assertions, these were largely ignored. Hydentra then retained a vendor\n\n   to deliver paper take down notices to the DMCA Registered Agent listed with the United States\n\n   Copyright Office. These were ignored.\n\n          Title II of the DMCA, the Online Copyright Infringement Liability Limitation Act was\n\n   passed by Congress with two main purposes: (1) provide liability protection for Internet Service\n\n   Providers whose operations expose them to copyright infringement at the hands of others; and\n\n\n                                                   15\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 16 of 21\n\n\n\n\n   (2) provide copyright owners with specific procedures to police their own copyrighted works on\n\n   the Internet. See UMG Recordings, Inc. v. Shelter Capital Partners, LLC, 718 F.3d 1006, 1022\n\n   (9th Cir. 2011). These purposes fall hand in hand: an ISP cannot claim liability protections if\n\n   they do not follow procedures which enable copyright owners to police their works. Receipt of\n\n   and action towards take down notices is paramount.\n\n          There were simply no further steps towards policing its copyrights on the Defendants\n\n   sites other than litigation. All other avenues had been traveled without success. Absolutely clear\n\n   in this case is that Hydentra made numerous attempts via email take down notices and paper take\n\n   down notices to police the infringement of its copyrights on the Defendants sites and that these\n\n   efforts failed. Further, this litigation has succeeded in its primary purpose \u2013 the Defendants sites\n\n   are no longer infringing Hydentra\u2019s copyrighted works.\n\n          Given Hydentra\u2019s pre-litigation efforts, the evidence presented in the litigation, and the\n\n   ultimate achievement of stopping infringement on the sites, this litigation was objectively\n\n   reasonable. This factor weighs in the favor of denying Defendants motion for fees.\n\n              4. Motivation\n\n           Through the entirety of Hydentra\u2019s copyright enforcement actions, Hydentra\u2019s\n\n   motivation has been to stop the infringement of its copyright works throughout the Internet, as\n\n   the availability of its movies for free detrimentally affects revenue on its paid membership sites.\n\n   Thus, Hydentra\u2019s extensive activity sending in excess of 19,000 take down notices to over 650\n\n   ISPs. In contrast, the fact that Hydentra has only had to initiate lawsuits against 20 ISPs/entities\n\n   is testament to the select manner in which Hydentra litigates.\n\n          Defendants continue to argue that Hydentra has engaged in a business model by\n\n   generating a new revenue stream in \u201cwresting nuisance settlements.\u201d This assertion is based\n\n                                                    16\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 17 of 21\n\n\n\n\n   upon improper supposition, and must be so because the Defendants did not conduct any\n\n   discovery of Hydentra. To the contrary, Hydentra has spent in excess of $500,000 dollars in its\n\n   copyright enforcement, yet recovered far less than a quarter of that. 2 Moreover, of 650 ISPs that\n\n   have been notified of infringement of Hydentra\u2019s copyright works, only 20 have been sued.\n\n           The objective undisputed evidence is that Hydentra predominantly resolves Internet\n\n   infringement issues through issuing DMCA compliant take down notices. In those certain\n\n   instances where the take down notices fail, Hydentra is left with little choice but to seek court\n\n   intervention. In the instant case, Hydentra first attempted email take down notices and then\n\n   delivery of paper take down notices. These multiple attempts failed. In order to continue its\n\n   efforts to protect its copyright works from infringement on the Defendants sites, litigation\n\n   became the only option. While the litigation resulted in dismissal of Hydentra\u2019s copyright\n\n   claims, it also resulted in the cessation of infringement on the Defendants sites.\n\n           Hydentra\u2019s primary purpose in this litigation was to stop the infringement of its videos on\n\n   the Defendants sites. This factor weighs in the favor of denying Defendants motion for fees.\n\n                5. Need to Advance Considerations of Compensation and Deterrence\n\n           The purposes of the Copyright Act are not promoted upon an award of attorneys\u2019 fees to\n\n   a prevailing defendant when the plaintiff has advanced a reasonable, yet unsuccessful claim.\n\n   Indyne, Inc. v. Abacus Tech. Corp., No. 6:11-cv-137-Orl-22DAB, 2013 U.S. Dist. LEXIS\n\n   185422, at *37 (M.D. Fla. Dec. 6, 2013), citing See Matthew Bender & Co. v. West Publ'g Co.,\n\n   240 F.3d 116, 122 (2d Cir. 2001); see also Lotus Dev. Corp. v. Borland Int'l, Inc., 140 F.3d 70,\n\n   75 (1st Cir. 1998) (in close infringement cases, \"the need to encourage meritorious defenses is a\n\n\n   2\n     Defendants may point to multi-million dollar judgments obtained by Hydentra. These judgments were entered in\n   cases where defendants were in default. While the judgment establishing that the particular trial courts reviewed\n   Hydentra\u2019s claims and valued them seriously, these judgments are likely largely uncollectable.\n                                                          17\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 18 of 21\n\n\n\n\n   factor that a district court may balance against the potentially chilling effect of imposing a large\n\n   fee award on a plaintiff who . . . may have advanced a reasonable, albeit unsuccessful, claim\").\n\n          Hydentra\u2019s lawsuit was neither baseless nor frivolous. Rather, it was reasonable and\n\n   necessary as procedures intended for Hydentra to police its copyrights on the Defendants sites\n\n   failed. An award of Defendants\u2019 attorneys\u2019 fees will be significantly detrimental to other\n\n   copyright owners with reasonable claims. Copyright holders with reasonable claims, even ones\n\n   that have attempted to resolve the display of their works for free as dictated by Congress, will be\n\n   deterred from seeking valid Court intervention. Further, and quite importantly, it will embolden\n\n   the operators of video streaming sites displaying copyright infringed works to ignore take down\n\n   notices when it suits them to do so.\n\n          Thus, an award of attorneys\u2019 fees in this case will unfairly shift the power in the battle of\n\n   intellectual property on the Internet to those parties that are displaying infringed works without\n\n   authority. The owners and operators of such video streaming sites will have little incentive to\n\n   respond to take down notices, contrary to Congressional intent, and owners of copyrights will be\n\n   forced to sit back and suffer the damages of their content displayed for free. This factor weighs\n\n   in the favor of denying Defendants motion for fees.\n\n              6. Final Balancing\n\n          Hydentra\u2019s claims were not frivolous but were objectively reasonable. Hydentra\u2019s\n\n   motivation, consistent with the entirety of its copyright enforcement, was to stop the\n\n   infringements of its works on the Defendants sites. Hydentra attempted to police its copyrights\n\n   on the Defendants sites through procedures mandated by the DMCA. These attempts failed.\n\n   The litigation, however, did not ultimately fail as the Defendants sites no longer infringe any of\n\n   Hydentra\u2019s copyrighted works.\n\n                                                    18\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 19 of 21\n\n\n\n\n           The fact that Defendants were prevailing parties at summary judgment is not enough to\n\n   warrant an award of attorneys fees in these circumstances, as an attorneys fees award will\n\n   promote further infringements on video streaming sites and promote ISPs\u2019 failure to follow\n\n   statutory requirements in responding to take down notices while also deterring copyright owners\n\n   from seeking court intervention when DMCA mandated policing procedures fail.\n\n           In UMG Recordings, Inc. v. Shelter Capital Partners, LLC, 718 F.3d 1006. fn. 23 (2013),\n\n   the trial court declined to award the defendant attorneys fees after summary judgment under the\n\n   Fogerty factors because the plaintiff\u2019s legal challenge was not \u201cimproper, in bad faith, or\n\n   contrary to the purposes of the Copyright Act,\u201d and the manner in which the claims were pursued\n\n   was not objectively unreasonable.\n\n           An award of attorneys\u2019 fees in this case will result in even more piracy on the Internet. It\n\n   will deter copyright owners from seeking court intervention after all statutory attempts to police\n\n   their own works fail. This simply cannot be the result.\n\n      B.      Asserted Attorneys Fees.\n\n           Hydentra does not take issue with the hourly rates charged in this case. However,\n\n   Defendants can only claim those litigation tasks that were specific to the copyright claims. (This\n\n   is based upon a revised invoice prepared by defense counsel.) The copyright claims were\n\n   dismissed on June 2, 2016. Accordingly, all time entries after that date are specific to the\n\n   trademark claims. These time entries are:\n\n              \u2022   For Attorney Brady Cobb 6/6/2016, 6/6/2016, 6/6/2016, 6/7/2016, and 6/7/2016\n                  (page 5, Dkt. No. 148-2). These entries are for 6.6 hours. Total value, at $350 per\n                  hour, is $2,310.\n\n              \u2022   For Attorney Valentin Gurtvits: 6/5/2016, 6/6/2016, and 6/7/2016 (page 5, Dkt.\n                  No. 148-2). These entries are for 19 hours. Total value, at $450 per hour, is\n                  $8,550.\n\n                                                    19\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 20 of 21\n\n\n\n\n               \u2022   For Attorney Evan Fray-Witzer: 6/6/2016 (page 7, Dkt. No. 148-2). These entries\n                   are for 5.25 hours. Total value, at $450 per hour, is $2,362.50.\n\n               \u2022   Attorney Matthew Shayefar: 6/6/2016, and 6/7/2016 (page 10. Dkt. No. 148-2).\n                   These entries are for 3.75 hours. Total value, at $300 per hour, is $1,125.\n\n            In total, hours incurred after the copyright claims were dismissed equate to $14,347.50 of\n\n   the submitted fees. Should attorneys\u2019 fees be awarded, these fees should not be part of the\n\n   award.\n\n            Further, Defendants have failed to separate out what charges are specific to which\n\n   defendant. For instance, should one defendant be awarded fees, that defendant should not be\n\n   awarded fees for tasks that were specific to another defendant. It is neither the Court\u2019s job nor\n\n   Plaintiff\u2019s job to parse out these tasks. The Court may reject the entire fee submission on that\n\n   basis.\n\n                                             V.     CONCLUSION\n\n            The imposition of attorneys\u2019 fees will not further the goals of Copyright Act. The\n\n   imposition of fees in this case will discourage copyright holders from bringing objectively\n\n   reasonable claims \u2013 even once their efforts to police their copyrights under the DMCA have\n\n   failed. This will result in the rampant failure to follow DMCA take down procedures and cause\n\n   piracy to increase exponentially.\n\n            Moreover, Hydentra\u2019s claims were not frivolous, but based in actual continued display of\n\n   its copyrighted works on Defendants sites after DMCA compliant take down notices were\n\n   delivered. Hydentra\u2019s motivations were, and continue to be, to stop the infringement of its videos\n\n   on video streaming sites throughout the Internet. Relating to the Defendants sites, these efforts\n\n   have been successful.\n\n            It is respectfully requested that Defendants\u2019 Motion for Attorneys Fees be denied.\n\n\n                                                    20\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 21 of 21\n\n\n\n\n                                  CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\n\n\n          I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this 19th day of August, 2016 we served the foregoing with\n\n   the Clerk of the Court by using the CM/ECF system which will send a notice of electronic filing\n\n   to the following: Brady J. Cobb, Esq.\n\n                                                      Respectfully submitted,\n\n\n                                                      BeharBehar\n                                                      1840 North Commerce Parkway\n                                                      Suite One\n                                                      Weston, Florida 33326\n                                                      Telephone: (954) 688-7642\n                                                      Facsimile: (954) 332-9260\n                                                      E-mail: AB@BeharBehar.com\n\n                                              By:     /s/Aaron Behar, Esquire\n                                                      Aaron Behar, Esquire\n                                                      Florida Bar No.: 166286\n                                                      Jaclyn Behar, Esquire\n                                                      Florida Bar No.: 63833\n                                                      Counsel for Plaintiff\n\n                                                      And: Spencer D. Freeman\n                                                      Freeman Law Firm, Inc.\n                                                      1107 \u00bd Tacoma Avenue South\n                                                      Tacoma, WA 98402\n                                                      Telephone: (253) 383-4500\n                                                      Facsimile: (253) 383-4501\n                                                      E-mail: sfreeman@freemanlawfirm.org\n                                                      Counsel for Plaintiff\n                                                      (Pro Hac Vice)\n\n\n\n\n                                                 21\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2024-06-29T12:29:16.764845-07:00","document_number":"154","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"051016886140","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Response to Motion","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/404233396/","id":404233396,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/154/1/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2024-06-29T11:54:25.871106-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-30T02:06:50.560129-07:00","sha1":"ce1805f3b79e945f63beadb7275c66d172051734","page_count":4,"file_size":165669,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.154.1.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.154.1.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 1 of 4\n\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA\n\nMIAMI DIVISION\nCASE NO.: 1:15-cv-22134-UU\n\nHYDENTRA HLP INT. LIMITED,\na foreign corporation d/b/a METART,\n\nPlaintiff,\nVs.\n\nCONSTANTIN LUCHIAN, an individual,\nKONSTANTIN BOLOTIN, an individual,\nSUN SOCIAL MEDIA, INC.. a corporation,\nindividually and d/b/a PLAY VID.COM,\nFEEDVID.COM, PLAY VIDS.COM, and\nPEEK VIDS. COM; PLAYVID.COM;\nFEEDVID.COM; PLAYVIDS. COM;\nPEEK VIDS.COM and;\n\nand John Does 1-20.\n\nDefendants.\n/\n\nDECLARATION OF JASON TUCKER IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS MOTION\nFOR ATTORNEYS FEES\n\nI, Jason Tucker, declare:\n\n1. I am a United States Citizen, over the age of 18 years old, make this declaration\nbased upon personal knowledge and, if called to testify could and would testify competently to\nthe facts set forth herein.\n\n2. I am a director of Battleship Stance LLC, a leading intellectual property\nmanagement and anti-piracy enforcement company. Our clients include award winning adult\n\nentertainment studios.\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 2 of 4\n\n3. I have been in the business of legal adult entertainment production (both on and\noff the Internet), marketing. and management at an executive level for over ten (10) years,\nserving for over six (6) years as President of a company that owns and licenses one of the\nworld\u2019s largest libraries of erotic images.\n\n4. I have served as a consultant to Fortune 100 companies including Microsoft\nCorporation for the rollout of several versions of Windows Media and in the development and\nroll out of their Digital Rights Management technology and Akamai Technologies among others.\n\n5. As an experienced executive within the adult entertainment industry, I have been\nfeatured and quoted in publications including Newsweek, BusinessWeek, USA Today, Wired.\nand the Washington Post and frequently am requested to speak on panels and at seminars at\nindustry events on various industry related topics and trends.\n\n6. I have purchased, managed, and sold top-level adult domain names such as\nErotica.com, SexSlaves.com, Sex.tv, and Wetdreams.com.\n\n7. I have been involved in more than fifty (50) federal lawsuits brought against a\nrange of defendants for copyright infringement, and have previously served as an expert witness\nin similar proceedings.\n\n8. Hydentra retained Battleship Stance LLC to investigate copyright and trademark\nviolations and assist in certain litigation to enforce its intellectual property rights.\n\n9. I have made myself familiar with the corporate structure of Plaintiff and its\nsibling companies. and related entities.\n\n10. I have made myself familiar with the company methods, procedures, production.\n\nand ownership of copyrighted materials.\n\nNW\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 3 of 4\n\n11. I am personally aware of the methods utilized by Plaintiff and can attest to the\nfacts that Plaintiff works require and/or have required great sums of money to create story lines,\nfilm in locations; construct detailed intricate sets; employ directors, actors, and editors; use the\nhighest quality production equipment; and exceed the production value of typical adult erotic\nentertainment.\n\n12. On behalf of Hydentra, I have sent 14,347 DMCA complaint take down notices to\na total of 41 Internet Services Providers/web sites.\n\n13. \u2018I investigated and documented Hydentra movies displayed on playvid.com,\nfeedvid.com, peekvids.com, and playvids.com. My investigations revealed a significant number\nof Hydentra\u2019s copyrighted works displayed on these web sites without license or authority.\n\n14, My investigations revealed that on at least four internet directories, Constantin\nLucian was listed as a Director of Sun Social Media, Inc.\n\n15. As a result of my investigations, on behalf of Hydentra, in January 2015, I sent\npaper copies of DMCA compliant take down notices to the Defendants DMCA Registered\nAgent. These notices were sent in paper form as prior email notices from another vendor were\noften ignored and there was no way to ensure that those notices were actually delivered.\n\n16. Five months after I delivered the DMCA take down notices, Hydentra\u2019s videos\nwere still displayed on Defendants\u2019 sites.\n\n17. Prior to and during this litigation, I performed Internet search using search\nengines Google and BING for MetArt or SexArt videos. These search results included the\nDefendants sites high in the results, enabling consumers to easily find Hydentra\u2019s content for\n\nfree on Defendants sites.\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 4 of 4\n\n18. Since this litigation ended, I have performed the same Internet searches and\nDefendants sites do not come up in such searches.\n\n19. Prior to and during this litigation, I conducted a search for MetArt or SexArt\nvideos using the search tool on the Defendants sites. These searches resulted in the display of\nnumerous Hydentra videos displayed on Defendants\u2019 sites in violation of Hydentra\u2019s copyrights.\n\n20. Since this litigation, I conducted the same searches on Defendants sites. These\n\nsearches produced none of Hydentra\u2019s videos.\n\nI declare under the penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of America that\n\nthe foregoing is true and correct.\n\nExecute on the A day of August 2016 at Phoenix, Arizona.\n\nDa rhe\n\nJ\u00e9sofi Tucker\n\n","ocr_status":1,"date_upload":"2024-06-29T12:29:17.352106-07:00","document_number":"154","attachment_number":1,"pacer_doc_id":"051016886141","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Affidavit","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/404233397/","id":404233397,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/154/2/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2024-06-29T11:54:25.903838-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-30T02:06:51.097066-07:00","sha1":"b44131ccce75b0c61e5b941e20bcec5fbb6e99cc","page_count":6,"file_size":145622,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.154.2.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.154.2.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 1 of 6\n\n\n\n\n                                UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                                SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA\n\n                                          MIAMI DIVISION\n\n                                     CASE NO.: 1:15-cv-22134-UU\n\n   HYDENTRA HLP INT. LIMITED,\n   a foreign corporation d/b/a METART,\n\n                  Plaintiff,\n\n   vs.\n\n   CONSTANTIN LUCHIAN, an individual,\n   KONSTANTIN BOLOTIN, an individual,\n   SUN SOCIAL MEDIA, INC., a corporation,\n   individually and d/b/a PLAYVID.COM,\n   FEEDVID.COM, PLAYVIDS.COM, and\n   PEEKVIDS. COM; PLAYVID.COM;\n   FEEDVID.COM; PLAYVIDS. COM;\n   PEEKVIDS.COM and;\n   and John Does 1-20,\n\n               Defendants.\n   __________________________________________/\n\n    DECLARATION OF JON KROGMAN IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFF\u2019S OPPOSITION\n                    TO MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS\u2019 FEES\n\n          I, Jon Krogman, declare:\n\n          1.      I am over the age of 18, a resident of Los Angeles, California, and citizen of the\n\n   United States. I make this declaration based upon personal knowledge and, if called to testify\n\n   could and would testify competently to the facts set forth herein.\n\n          2.      I am the President of Hydentra HLP Int. Limited and its subsidiaries and am\n\n   involved in the day to day operation of the company, including the production of movies,\n\n   operation of paid membership sites, and the protection of the company\u2019s intellectual property.\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 2 of 6\n\n\n\n\n          3.      Hydentra is the producer, distributor, and exclusive licensor of its own motion\n\n   pictures that explore and deliver sensuality and sexuality through artistic photography, video, and\n\n   erotic stories. Hydentra also owns and/or operates MetArt.com and SexArt.com, and other paid\n\n   membership sites through which Hydentra offers its motion pictures to the public for a fee.\n\n          4.      Since 1999, Hydentra has grown its trademark brands into a globally recognized\n\n   leader of sensual art garnering numerous industry awards through the use of studios around the\n\n   globe, exotic locations, high budget productions, engaging storylines, famed photographers and\n\n   directors coupled with the dedication from its artists and technicians. The MetArt library is\n\n   comprised    of    exclusive   content   that   features   over   5000   models   shot   by    250\n\n   photographers/directors including such notables as Vivian Thomas and the late Zalman King,\n\n   who also brought Hollywood films such as Wild Orchid, Two Moon Junction, 9 \u00bd Weeks, and\n\n   the Showtime network groundbreaking series Red Shoes Diaries.\n\n          5.      Hydentra prides itself on high quality movies, often spending six times more than\n\n   industry standards in production costs. Hydentra expends a significant amount of resources, in\n\n   locating and contracting actor/models, film makers, editors, producers, and locations to produce\n\n   new films monthly. The production model is a constant on-going process \u2013 and therefore\n\n   expenditure. Hydentra\u2019s effort in producing high quality content is recognized in the industry. In\n\n   fact, SexArt.com recently won 2016 XBiz Erotic Adult Site of the Year and 2016 AVN Best\n\n   Director & Film.\n\n          6.      Hydentra has spent over $45,000 registering its works with the United States\n\n   Copyright Office. Hydentra has taken industry standard steps to identify its products. Hydentra\u2019s\n\n   videos are watermarked with Hydentra\u2019s readily identifiable registered trademark.\n\n\n\n\n                                                    2\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 3 of 6\n\n\n\n\n          7.      Hydentra\u2019s movies are intended to be available only through its paid membership\n\n   sites or purchase by scene, set, or asset. The Hydentra business model is simply that a user must\n\n   pay Hydentra to view Hydentra\u2019s movies. Each member of Hydentra\u2019s membership web sites\n\n   has an average value of $120. This considers that an average retention rate is three months at\n\n   $29.99 per month, the average up-sale for each member, and trial and promotional deals.\n\n          8.      I am aware that the Defendants have asserted that the value of a membership for\n\n   Hydentra is $8.33. This is an incorrect assessment. Hydentra does offer a yearly membership\n\n   for $99. Broken down, this does average to $8.33 per month. However, it requires the member\n\n   to pay $99 up front. These memberships are taken into account when Hydentra determines the\n\n   average value of its memberships. Further, most of Hydentra\u2019s members do not choose to spend\n\n   $99 up front, but chose a monthly paid membership.\n\n          9.      Hydentra engages in extremely limited licensing of its content to other entities or\n\n   websites for viewing, in addition to the small sample of promotional materials provided to\n\n   Hydentra affiliates for the sole purpose of the affiliates\u2019 promoting Hydentra\u2019s web sites. All\n\n   licensing is done with the intent for brand exposure and is limited to a small subset of hand-\n\n   selected short format content. Hydentra has issued limited exclusive licenses for cable, satellite,\n\n   and broadcast, displaying in countries that include Canada, Germany, Austria, Netherlands,\n\n   South Korea, and the United States. Specifically in the United States, Hydentra has issued a\n\n   limited broadcast distribution license to Larry Flynt Productions (LFP/Hustler).\n\n          10.     Numerous web sites display free copyrighted adult content without license or\n\n   authority. These video streaming sites are often portrayed as third party upload sites, analogous\n\n   to Youtube.com. The existence of video streaming sites damages paid membership sites as users\n\n   are less likely to pay a monthly membership fee when they can access a producer\u2019s movies for\n\n\n\n\n                                                   3\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 4 of 6\n\n\n\n\n   free. The display and viewing of Hydentra\u2019s movies for free results in a direct loss of revenue\n\n   for Hydentra.\n\n          11.      As Hydentra\u2019s works have grown in popularity, so has the prevalence of the\n\n   unlawful display of Hydentra\u2019s videos on video streaming sites, wherein those site owners earn\n\n   revenue from advertising monies. By way of example, the prevalence of the piracy of Hydentra\n\n   intellectual property has extended to the point that Hydentra images are infringed and sold as\n\n   mouse pads, and other goods, on Amazon and Ebay.\n\n          12.      The prevalence of piracy seriously threatens every element of Hydentra\u2019s\n\n   business, certainly the value of the paid membership sites and licenses to distributors. Simply\n\n   put, if Hydentra videos and images are readily available for free, there is little incentive for\n\n   distributors to license the product and little incentive for an end user to pay for a membership.\n\n   \u201cFree\u201d will win, every time.\n\n          13.      Given the prevalence of video streaming sites and the damage such sites do to\n\n   Hydentra\u2019s paid membership sites, Hydentra retained the services of several vendors including\n\n   Takedown Piracy and Battleship Stance LLC to investigate copyright infringement, send DMCA\n\n   complaint takedown notices for detected infringement of Hydentra copyrighted works, and\n\n   document infringements when takedown notices are ignored and/or the web sites are not\n\n   registered as Internet Service Providers.\n\n          14.      The purpose of Hydentra\u2019s actions has been, and continues to be, to thwart\n\n   infringements of its copyrighted works.       Contrary to Defendants\u2019 assertions, Hydentra\u2019s\n\n   copyright enforcement is not a business model.\n\n          15.      Hydentra has spent over $500,000 to enforce its copyrights, including\n\n   investigations, take down notices, and litigation. In contrast, Hydentra has recovered less than a\n\n\n\n\n                                                    4\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 5 of 6\n\n\n\n\n   quarter of those costs from infringing ISPs. Given confidentiality agreements, we are prevented\n\n   from giving specifics on these settlement terms.\n\n            16.   Specific to the Defendants in the instant matter, investigations revealed significant\n\n   infringements on Playvid.com, Playvids.com, Peekvids.com, and Feedvid.com. Beginning in\n\n   2013, Hydentra utilized Takedown Piracy to send take down notices for infringements on these\n\n   sites.\n\n            17.   Hydentra tested the sources of infringements by blocking IP addresses from the\n\n   servers hosting video streaming sites, including Defendants\u2019 sites. This meant that persons with\n\n   IP addresses from these servers could not access Hydentra\u2019s paid membership sites from those\n\n   IPs. This action resulted in an immediate decrease in the frequency of infringements of Hydentra\n\n   content and an increase in Hydentra memberships.\n\n            18.   As a result, it appeared that someone was directly downloading Hydentra\u2019 content\n\n   from its paid membership sites and posting on the Defendants Sites. For business purposes,\n\n   Hydentra could not permanently disable these IP addresses.\n\n            19.   There were concerns that the take down notices sent via email regarding the\n\n   Defendants Sites were not actually being received, as there was no return receipt and no way to\n\n   be sure that the notices were actually delivered and received. Accordingly, Hydentra retained\n\n   Battleship Stance to physically send paper notices to the DMCA Agent which would establish\n\n   the delivery of the notices. Such notices were delivered in January 2015.\n\n            20.   Given the failure to respond to any type of take down notice, it was determined\n\n   that litigation was necessary to thwart the piracy of Hydentra\u2019s works on the Defendants sites.\n\n\n\n\n                                                      5\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 6 of 6\n\n\n\n\n          21.     While Hydentra lost its copyright claims on summary judgment, the primary\n\n   purpose of the litigation was successful. As a result of this litigation, Hydentra\u2019s works are no\n\n   longer infringed on the Defendants sites.\n\n          22.     Prior to and during this litigation, an Internet search (using search engines such as\n\n   Google and BING) for MetArt or SexArt videos produced Defendants sites high in results,\n\n   enabling consumers to easily find Hydentra\u2019s content for free on Defendants sites. Since this\n\n   litigation, Defendants sites do not come up in such searches.\n\n          23.     Prior to and during this litigation, a search for MetArt or SexArt videos using the\n\n   search tool on the Defendants sites resulted in the display of numerous Hydentra videos\n\n   displayed in violation of Hydentra\u2019s copyrights. Since this litigation, such a search on the\n\n   Defendants sites results in the display of exactly zero of Hydentra\u2019s videos.\n\n\n\n\n          I declare under the penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of America that\n\n   the foregoing is true and correct.\n\n\n          Execute on the _____\n                         19th day of August, 2016 at _________,\n                                                     Santa Monica California.\n\n\n\n\n                                                _______________________\n                                                Jon Krogman\n\n\n\n\n                                                    6\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2024-06-29T12:29:17.923798-07:00","document_number":"154","attachment_number":2,"pacer_doc_id":"051016886142","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Affidavit","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/404233398/","id":404233398,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/154/3/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2024-06-29T11:54:25.934154-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-30T02:06:50.033926-07:00","sha1":"f86a880d29bb330489fe49fa149371f23b7db1c7","page_count":4,"file_size":1653014,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.154.3.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.154.3.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 1 of 4\n\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA\n\nMIAMI DIVISION\nCASE NO.: 1:15-cv-22134-UU\n\nHYDENTRA HLP INT. LIMITED,\na foreign corporation d/b/a METART,\n\nPlaintiff,\nVS.\n\nCONSTANTIN LUCHIAN, an individual,\nKONSTANTIN BOLOTIN, an individual,\nSUN SOCIAL MEDIA, INC., a corporation,\nindividually and d/b/a PLAY VID.COM,\nFEEDVID.COM, PLAY VIDS.COM, and\nPEEK VIDS. COM; PLAYVID.COM;\nFEEDVID.COM; PLAYVIDS. COM;\nPEEK VIDS.COM and;\n\nand John Does 1-20,\n\nDefendants.\n/\n\nDECLARATION OF NATHAN GLASS IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS MOTION\nFOR ATTORNEYS FEES\n\nI, Nathan Glass, declare:\n\n1. I am over the age of 18, a resident of Las Vegas, Nevada, and a citizen of the\nUnited States. I make this declaration based upon personal knowledge and, if called to testify\ncould and would testify competently to the facts set forth herein.\n\n2. I am the owner and principal of Takedown Piracy Inc., d/b/a Takedown Piracy, a\nNevada company that identifies online copyright infringements and sends take-down notices\n\npursuant to the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (\u201cDMCA\u201d), 17 U.S.C. \u00a7 512(c)(3)(A). I have\n\noperated this business for over six (6) years.\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 2 of 4\n\nBie I have sent millions of take-down notices pursuant to 17 U.S.C. \u00a7 512(c)(3)(A)\n(hereinafter \u201cDMCA notices\u201d) to sites that host or provide access to copyright infringing files.\n\n4. To date I have had over 60 Million infringing works removed from websites and\nam a leading notification service to Google. | am a member of Google\u2019s \u201cTrusted Copyright\nRemoval Program.\u201d This program streamlines our take-down requests to Google.\n\n5. In 2015 alone, I had over 700,000 pirated videos removed from hosting sites. To\nunderstand the scope, that is over 14,000,000 minutes of pirated video content.\n\n6. In 2016, I was nominated for the Progressive Leadership Award at the XBIZ\nIndustry Executive Awards.\n\nds I am a regular feature in the area of Anti-Piracy on TV and publications; media\nattention surrounding Takedown Piracy and me includes being prominently featured on ABC\u2019s\n\n\u201cNightline,\u201d as well as expert commentary in articles from Men\u2019s Health, BBC News, USA\n\nToday,Wired.com, Annenberg TV News, Huffington Post, Salon, Washington Post, Creative\n\nLoafing, and more. Earlier this year, tech website DailyDot.com referred to me as a \u201cpolarizing\n\nfigure on the Internet,\u2019 and the \u201cLuke Skywalker\u201d of piracy, though Forbes.com previously\ndubbed me the \u201cDarth Vader of porn piracy.\u201d\n\n8. Hydentra retained the services of Takedown Piracy to send DMCA complaint\ntake down notices to entities operating web sites that were displaying Hydentra\u2019s content without\nauthority.\n\n9. In total, I have sent 4,608 DMCA Notices on behalf of Hydentra to 614\nwebsites/Internet Service Providers. These notices included a total of 666,366 URLs/links with\n\nHydentra content being unlawfully displayed.\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 3 of 4\n\n10. In addition to the DMCA notices I have sent to websites/Internet Service\nProviders, I have also reported 2,880,299 URLs/Links via DMCA notices on behalf of Hydentra\nto Google for removal from their search engines.\n\nLt I am familiar with playvid.com, feedvid.com, peekvids, and playvids.com from\nmy work in locating infringements on the Internet and sending takedown notices.\n\n12. I have sent DMCA notices on behalf of Hydentra to Playvid.com and\npeekvid.com since July 2013, and playvids.com and feedvid.com later upon their inception.\nSince July 2013, I have sent 2,268 notices to report 28,245 links that contained infringing content\non playvid.com, feedvid.com, peekvids, and playvids.com. These notices were sent via email.\n\n13. Based on my experience, it appears to me that a significant amount of the video\ncontent displayed on Defendants sites - and revenue \u2014 is composed of pirated copyrighted\nmaterials.\n\n14. The Defendant has been difficult or inconsistent with its response to and\ncompliance with DMCA notices to playvid.com and peekvid.com. Monitoring the takedown\nprocess on Defendants websites has required double and tripled checking to determine if ANY\ncontent was taken down pursuant to a DMCA Notice.\n\n15. I have had to resend DMCA notices to playvid.com, fexdvid.com, peekvids, and\nplayvids.com to attempt to have content removed that had previously been noticed but ignored.\n\n16. At times, it would take Defendants weeks to respond to take down notices I sent\nto playvid.com, feedvid.com, peekvids, and playvids.com, or they would not respond at all.\n\n17. Incases when web site operators consistently fail to respond to takedown notices,\nI have found that sending takedown notices to the hosting company can be effective in getting\n\nthe infringing content removed. That is the case with Defendants websites that I sent notices to.\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 154-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 4 of 4\n\n18. By April 2015, due to little or no action by Defendants in responding to take\ndown notices, I had to resort to sending DMCA notices to Defendants hosting company,\nWebzilla, in an attempt to have infringing video content taken down. Responses by the hosting\ncompany has been inconsistent at best.\n\n19. In my experience sending millions of DMCA notices, the Defendants response (or\nlack thereof) to DMCA notices does not comport with the industry practices of companies who\nare desirous of complying with the DMCA. Typically, websites remove content within 24-48\nhours of receiving a DMCA Takedown Notice from me. Removing weeks or months later or not\nat all has me believing that the site operators do not want the content to be removed because it is\ndesirous and useful to their business.\n\n20. Any claim that the Defendants have always taken immediate or any reasonable\naction upon receiving DMCA notices from Takedown Piracy or me does not match my actual\n\nexperience in sending takedown notices to Sun Social Media, Inc.\n\nI declare under the penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of America that,\n\nto the best of my knowledge, the foregoing is true and correct.\n\ngh\nExecute on the \\4 day of August 2016 at Las Vegas, Nevada.\n\nLaike> SMann\n\nNathan Glass\n\n","ocr_status":1,"date_upload":"2024-06-29T12:29:18.542048-07:00","document_number":"154","attachment_number":3,"pacer_doc_id":"051016886143","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Affidavit","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.473252-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-29T11:54:25.838698-07:00","date_filed":"2016-08-19","time_filed":null,"entry_number":154,"recap_sequence_number":"2016-08-19.002","pacer_sequence_number":466,"description":"RESPONSE to Motion re 148 MOTION for Attorney Fees filed by Hydentra HLP Int. Limited. Replies due by 8/29/2016. (Attachments: # 1 Affidavit, # 2 Affidavit, # 3 Affidavit)(Behar, Aaron) (Entered: 08/19/2016)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/171244034/","id":171244034,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/176529105/","id":176529105,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/153/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.461496-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-30T02:06:30.404325-07:00","sha1":"a7b2599662441c3d62ec796794b496536d5614b3","page_count":2,"file_size":54265,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.153.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.153.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 153 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 1 of 2\n\n\n\n\n                               UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                               SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA\n\n                                          MIAMI DIVISION\n\n                                    CASE NO.: 1:15-cv-22134-UU\n\n  HYDENTRA HLP INT. LIMITED,\n  a foreign corporation d/b/a METART,\n\n                 Plaintiff,\n\n  vs.\n\n  CONSTANTIN LUCHIAN, et al.,\n\n              Defendants.\n  __________________________________________/\n\n  PLAINTIFF\u2019S OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR AN ENLARGEMENT\n    OF TIME FOR THE FILING AND/OR CONSIDERATION OF ITS MOTION FOR\n  ATTORNEY\u2019S FEES OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AN\n                   AMENDED MOTION FOR ATTORNEY\u2019S\n\n         Hydentra HLP Int. Limited objects to the relief sought by Defendants regarding an\n\n  enlargement of time for filing and/or consideration of its motion for attorney\u2019s fees or, in the\n\n  alternative, their motion for leave to file an amended motion for attorney\u2019s fees.\n\n         Hydentra agrees that, while not having the actual invoices, the issue of attorney\u2019s fees was\n\n  addressed through a court ordered mediation on June 6, 2016. As the actual communications in\n\n  the mediation are required to be confidential, Hydentra cannot and will not further comment on\n\n  the mediation, nor Defendants\u2019 characterization of the mediation. It is sufficient to state that the\n\n  issue of attorney\u2019s fees was a focus and resolution could not be reached.\n\n         Given the relative position of the parties, Hydentra submits that the negotiations on June 6,\n\n  2016 should be considered to satisfy Local Rule 7.3(b). Accordingly, Defendants would not be in\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 153 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/19/2016 Page 2 of 2\n\n\n\n\n  violation of Local Rule 7.3(b) and their Motion for Attorney\u2019s Fees would be both timely and in\n\n  compliance with the Local Rules.\n\n\n\n                                 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\n\n\n         I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this 19th day of August, 2016 we served the foregoing with\n\n  the Clerk of the Court by using the CM/ECF system which will send a notice of electronic filing\n\n  to the following: Brady J. Cobb, Esq.\n\n                                                     Respectfully submitted,\n\n\n                                                     BeharBehar\n                                                     1840 North Commerce Parkway\n                                                     Suite One\n                                                     Weston, Florida 33326\n                                                     Telephone: (954) 688-7642\n                                                     Facsimile: (954) 332-9260\n                                                     E-mail: AB@BeharBehar.com\n\n                                             By:     /s/Aaron Behar, Esquire\n                                                     Aaron Behar, Esquire\n                                                     Florida Bar No.: 166286\n                                                     Jaclyn Behar, Esquire\n                                                     Florida Bar No.: 63833\n                                                     Counsel for Plaintiff\n\n                                                     And: Spencer D. Freeman\n                                                     Freeman Law Firm, Inc.\n                                                     1107 \u00bd Tacoma Avenue South\n                                                     Tacoma, WA 98402\n                                                     Telephone: (253) 383-4500\n                                                     Facsimile: (253) 383-4501\n                                                     E-mail: sfreeman@freemanlawfirm.org\n                                                     Counsel for Plaintiff\n                                                     (Pro Hac Vice)\n\n\n\n                                                2\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2024-06-29T12:27:06.783283-07:00","document_number":"153","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"051016886107","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Response to Motion","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.449200-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-29T11:54:25.813206-07:00","date_filed":"2016-08-19","time_filed":null,"entry_number":153,"recap_sequence_number":"2016-08-19.001","pacer_sequence_number":462,"description":"RESPONSE to Motion re 147 MOTION for Extension of Time to File Motion for Attorney's Fees MOTION for Leave to File filed by Hydentra HLP Int. Limited. Replies due by 8/29/2016. (Behar, Aaron) (Entered: 08/19/2016)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/171244033/","id":171244033,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/176529104/","id":176529104,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/152/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.437159-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-29T11:54:25.801918-07:00","sha1":"55c3d66d39ff00d1e97f405cfb090b27efc41797","page_count":2,"file_size":56556,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.152.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.152.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 152 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/18/2016 Page 1 of HH\n                                                                               2\n                Case: 16-14813 Date Filed:\n                                     (2 of 2)\n                                           08/18/2016 Page: 1\n                                                                                        Aug 18, 2016\n                            UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS\n                                                                                                     MIAMI\n                               FOR THE ELEVENTH CIRCUIT\n                               ELBERT PARR TUTTLE COURT OF APPEALS BUILDING\n                                             56 Forsyth Street, N.W.\n                                             Atlanta, Georgia 30303\n\n  David J. Smith                                                                      For rules and forms visit\n  Clerk of Court                                                                      www.ca11.uscourts.gov\n\n\n                                           August 18, 2016\n\n  Steven M. Larimore\n  U.S. District Court\n  400 N MIAMI AVE\n  MIAMI, FL 33128-1810\n\n  Appeal Number: 16-14813-E\n  Case Style: Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Constantin Luchian, et al\n  District Court Docket No: 1:15-cv-22134-UU\n\n  The enclosed copy of this Court's Order of Dismissal is issued as the mandate of this court.\n\n  Sincerely,\n\n  DAVID J. SMITH, Clerk of Court\n\n  Reply to: Gloria M. Powell, E\n  Phone #: (404) 335-6184\n\n  Enclosure(s)\n\n                                                                  DIS-4 Multi-purpose dismissal letter\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 152 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/18/2016 Page 2 of 2\n                Case: 16-14813 Date Filed:\n                                     (1 of 2)\n                                           08/18/2016 Page: 1 of 1\n\n\n                        IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS\n\n                                 FOR THE ELEVENTH CIRCUIT\n\n\n                                          No. 16-14813-E\n\n\n  HYDENTRA HLP INT. LIMITED,\n  d.b.a. Metart,\n  d.b.a. Sexart,\n\n                                                                           Plaintiff- Appellant,\n\n                                               versus\n\n  CONSTANTIN LUCHIAN,\n  an individual,\n  KONSTANTIN BOLOTIN,\n  an individual,\n  SUN SOCIAL MEDIA, INC.,\n  a corporation, individually,\n  d. b.a. Playvid. Com, Feedvid. Com, Playvids. Com,\n  and Peekvids.Com,\n  PAYVID.COM,\n  FEEDVID.COM, et al.,\n\n                                                                           Defendants - Appellees.\n\n\n                            Appeal from the United States District Court\n                                for the Southern District of Florida\n\n\n  Before: ROSENBAUM and JILL PRYOR, Circuit Judges.\n\n  BY THE COURT:\n\n         Appellant's \"Unopposed Motion to Dismiss Appeal with Prejudice\" is GRANTED.\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2021-07-30T19:30:12.149908-07:00","document_number":"152","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"051016878049","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"USCA Order","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.424585-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-29T11:54:25.789789-07:00","date_filed":"2016-08-18","time_filed":null,"entry_number":152,"recap_sequence_number":"2016-08-18.001","pacer_sequence_number":459,"description":"ORDER of Dismissal of USCA, Appellant's \"Unopposed Motion to Dismiss Appeal with Prejudice\" is GRANTED as to 144 Notice of Appeal,, filed by Hydentra HLP Int. Limited, USCA # 16-14813-E (hh) (Entered: 08/18/2016)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/171244032/","id":171244032,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/176529103/","id":176529103,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/151/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.413685-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-30T02:07:12.684512-07:00","sha1":"757b48cc5189d990105bc76b023cdd8b35d19cec","page_count":1,"file_size":43993,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.151.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.151.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"  Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 151 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 1 of 1\n\n\n\n\n                                     UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                                     SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA\n\n                                                                          Case No. Jl;,-Q,v- ~'J..J?,LJ\n\n\n            Plaintiff,\n\n   v.\n\n\n~iln ~tu\\JUAJ...\n            Defendanib.                                      )\n   --------------------------------~/\n                                                 ORDER\n\n           PURSUANT to 28 U.S.C. \u00a7 636 and the Magistrate Rules of the Local Rules of the\n\n   Southern District of Florida, the above-captioned Cause is referred to United States Magistrate\n\n   Judge ALICIA M. OTAZO-REYES to take all necessary and proper action as required by law\n\n   with respect to M         Dt-i 0n -Pn f\\ Jill~ '4:. 'I-c.u. G>\u00b7 E. /Y                         9) ,\n   and any motions for extension or enlargement of time that relate to such motions. Pursuant to\n\n   this referral order, it is also\n\n           ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that it shall be the responsibility of the respective parties\n\n   in this case to note that courtesy copies of all materials necessary to the resolution of the referred\n\n   matter shall be directed to the magistrate judge's chambers.               J.\n           DONE AND ORDERED in Chambers at Miami, Florida, this ~day of lt'ug~H6.\n\n\n\n\n   cc:\n   counsel of record via cm/ecf\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2024-06-29T12:26:52.471056-07:00","document_number":"151","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"051016811248","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Order Referring Motion","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.401284-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-29T11:54:25.767991-07:00","date_filed":"2016-08-02","time_filed":null,"entry_number":151,"recap_sequence_number":"2016-08-02.005","pacer_sequence_number":456,"description":"ORDER REFERRING 148 MOTION for Attorney Fees filed by Konstantin Bolotin, Constantin Luchian, Sun Social Media, Inc. to Magistrate Judge Alicia M. Otazo-Reyes. Signed by Judge Ursula Ungaro on 8/2/2016. (pes) (Entered: 08/02/2016)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/171244031/","id":171244031,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/176529102/","id":176529102,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/150/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.390351-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-30T02:07:11.669262-07:00","sha1":"c4a62d46627249d2a7d8da7877259e9f32119701","page_count":1,"file_size":43679,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.150.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.150.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"       Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 150 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 1 of 1\n\n\n\n\n                                          UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                                          SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA\n\n                                                                               Case No.   fJ;,-Q..v- \u00a3,7, {3~\n    ft~A. ttcp Int. Umi0)\n\u00b7                Plaintiff,\n\n        v.\n\n\n                       h ~tl.J\\)~~.1\n                Defendan~       .\n        --------------------------------~/\n                                                      ORDER\n\n                PURSUANT to 28 U.S.C. \u00a7 636 and the Magistrate Rules of the Local Rules of the\n\n        Southern District of Florida, the above-captioned Cause is referred to United States Magistrate\n\n        Judge ALICIA M. OTAZO-REYES to take all necessary and proper action as required by law\n\n        with respect to       MA\"titfb f-t>y ~~~ l>f-Jl~, (p.f;.jll\n        and any motions for extension or enlargement of time that relate to such motions. Pursuant to\n\n        this referral order, it is also\n\n                ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that it shall be the responsibility of the respective parties\n\n        in this case to note that courtesy copies of all materials necessary to the resolution of the referred\n\n        matter shall be directed to the magistrate judge's chambers.              ~\n\n\n                DONE AND ORDERED in Chambers at Miami, Florida, this!)) day of tl\"Pj~6.\n\n\n\n\n        cc:\n        counsel of record via crnlecf\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2024-06-29T12:26:34.271083-07:00","document_number":"150","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"051016811227","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Order Referring Motion","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.376717-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-29T11:54:25.743776-07:00","date_filed":"2016-08-02","time_filed":null,"entry_number":150,"recap_sequence_number":"2016-08-02.004","pacer_sequence_number":452,"description":"ORDER REFERRING 147 MOTION for Extension of Time to File Motion for Attorney's Fees MOTION for Leave to File filed by Konstantin Bolotin, Constantin Luchian, Sun Social Media, Inc. to Magistrate Judge Alicia M. Otazo-Reyes. Signed by Judge Ursula Ungaro on 8/2/2016. (pes) (Entered: 08/02/2016)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/171244030/","id":171244030,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/176529101/","id":176529101,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/149/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.363318-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-29T11:54:25.734525-07:00","sha1":"","page_count":null,"file_size":null,"filepath_local":null,"filepath_ia":"","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"","ocr_status":null,"date_upload":null,"document_number":"149","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"","is_available":false,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Clerk's Notice of Docket Correction and Instruction to Filer - Attorney","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.349758-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-29T11:54:25.721648-07:00","date_filed":"2016-08-02","time_filed":null,"entry_number":149,"recap_sequence_number":"2016-08-02.003","pacer_sequence_number":null,"description":"Clerks Notice to Filer re 147 MOTION for Extension of Time to File Motion for Attorney's Fees . Motion with Multiple Reliefs Filed as One Relief; ERROR - The Filer selected only one relief event and failed to select the additional corresponding events for each relief requested in the motion. The docket entry was corrected by the Clerk. It is not necessary to refile this document but future filings must comply with the instructions in the CM/ECF Attorney User's Manual. (pes) (Entered: 08/02/2016)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/171244029/","id":171244029,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/176529100/","id":176529100,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/148/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.339247-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-30T02:06:30.419707-07:00","sha1":"e5eca8f36b377a86d93cf203f7a30a4767f5827d","page_count":17,"file_size":398148,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.148.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.148.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 1 of 17\n\n\n\n\n                                    UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                                    SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA\n\n                                                MIAMI DIVISION\n\n                                         CASE NO.: 1:15-cv-22134-UU\n\n  HYDENTRA HLP INT. LIMITED,\n  a foreign corporation d/b/a METART,\n\n                     Plaintiff,\n\n  vs.\n\n  CONSTANTIN LUCHIAN, an individual,\n  KONSTANTIN BOLOTIN, an individual,\n  SUN SOCIAL MEDIA, INC., a corporation,\n  individually and d/b/a PLAYVID.COM,\n  FEEDVID.COM, PLAYVIDS.COM, and\n  PEEKVIDS. COM; PLAYVID.COM;\n  FEEDVID.COM; PLAYVIDS. COM;\n  PEEKVIDS.COM and;\n  and John Does 1-20,\n\n              Defendants.\n  __________________________________________/\n                          DEFENDANTS\u2019 MOTION FOR ATTORNEY\u2019S FEES\n\n                                                INTRODUCTION\n\n             The present case \u2013 one of at least 20 near-identical cases filed by the Plaintiff against\n\n  various defendants in a variety of federal district courts \u2013 was never about enforcing legitimate\n\n  intellectual property rights. Had that been the Plaintiff\u2019s actual goal, there were numerous ways\n\n  to accomplish it. Indeed, this Court specifically found that, Defendant Sun Social Media\u2019s\n\n  general practice had been to promptly remove or disable access to allegedly infringing materials\n\n  whenever it received takedown notices from the Plaintiff (and that as soon as it was notified of\n\n  the allegedly infringing materials as a result of being served with the complaint in this case, it\n\n  removed those materials as well).1\n\n\n  1\n      See its Omnibus Order on the Motions for Summary Judgment, June 2, 2016.\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 2 of 17\n\n\n\n\n           Instead, this case, and the others filed by the Plaintiff, have always been about one thing:\n\n  forcing defendants to settle frivolous cases or face the pressure of ever-mounting legal bills.2 It\n\n  is an understandable (if unethical) tactic for the Plaintiff \u2013 which ordinarily relies on monthly\n\n  subscriptions of $8.33 per user \u2013 to take. Every $50,000 settlement that the Plaintiff extorts\n\n  represents 6,000 monthly subscriptions that the Plaintiff need not sell. It is, if one has no\n\n  concern about the misuse of legal process, an excellent revenue model. It is also precisely the\n\n  type of lawsuit that Section 505 of the Copyright Act is intended to deter:\n\n           [A]ttorney\u2019s fees should be awarded to deter plaintiffs from \u2018bringing unreasonable\n           claims based on a cost/benefit analysis that tells such plaintiffs that they can score big if\n           they win and that there will be no adverse consequences for losing.\n  Lil\u2019 Joe Wein Music, Inc. v. Jackson, 2008 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 112730, *21-22 (S.D. Fla. 2008)\n\n  (quoting Baker v. Urban Outfitters, Inc., 431 F. Supp. 2d 351, 359 (S.D.N.Y. 2006)).\n\n           In short \u2013 and as is discussed below \u2013 the present case should never have been brought.\n\n  Plaintiff\u2019s copyright claims were frivolous and unsupported from start to finish.\n\n           On June 2, 2016, this Court issued its Omnibus Order (Docket No. 138) on the Motions\n\n  for Summary Judgment (the \u201cOmnibus Order\u201d). This Order, which dismissed the Plaintiff\u2019s\n\n  copyright claims in their entirety, rendered the Defendants \u201cprevailing parties\u201d entitled to\n\n  recovery of their attorney\u2019s fees under 17 U.S.C. \u00a7505. For the reasons stated herein (and as\n\n  supported by the Affidavits of Attorneys Brady Cobb, Valentin Gurvits, Matthew Shayefar, and\n\n  Evan Fray-Witzer, the Defendants respectfully request that the Court order the Plaintiff to pay\n\n  reasonable attorney\u2019s fees in the amount of $162,165.\n\n\n\n\n  2\n    Indeed, in this particular case, the Defendants (who had always been responsive to takedown notices received from\n  the Plaintiff) pushed for an early mediation, hoping that the matter could be quickly and amicably resolved before\n  either party was required to expend significant amounts on attorney\u2019s fees. The Plaintiff refused all such overtures,\n  insisting that they would not mediate until after all discovery had been completed, ensuring that a voluntary\n  resolution was less likely to occur. This was a perfect example of the old adage that pigs get fat and hogs get\n  slaughtered.\n\n                                                            2\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 3 of 17\n\n\n\n\n                                        PROCEDURAL HISTORY3\n\n          Plaintiff filed the present action on June 5, 2015. Docket No. 1. This lawsuit was one of\n\n  at least 20 near-identical lawsuits filed by Plaintiff in federal courts around the country from\n\n  February of 2015 through May of 2016.4\n\n          Plaintiff served the Defendants on July 15 and 16, 2015, Docket Nos. 11, 13, and agreed\n\n  to extend the time for Defendants to file their response to the Complaint. On August 6, 2015 the\n\n  Court sua sponte issued an Order to Show Cause as to why default should not be entered.\n\n  Docket No. 15. Despite having agreed to allow Defendants more time to respond, Plaintiff filed\n\n  a Motion for Judgment on August 19, 2015. Docket No. 20. On August 27, 2015, Defendants\n\n  filed a Motion to Set Aside Default, Docket No. 26, which the Court granted on August 28,\n\n  2015. Docket No. 30.\n\n          Defendants filed their Answer to the Complaint on September 1, 2015. Docket No. 32.\n\n  Shortly thereafter, Plaintiff\u2019s counsel met and conferred with Defendant\u2019s counsel about its\n\n\n  3\n    Because the Court provided an extensive recitation of facts in its Omnibus Order, which the Defendants\n  incorporate by reference herein, a separate factual recitation is not included in this motion.\n  4\n    See Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Kporno.com et al, Case No. 2:2015-cv-00238 (D. Arizona) (filed Feb. 10, 2015),\n  Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Tubenn.com et al, Case No. 2:2015-cv-00239 (D. Arizona) (filed Feb. 10, 2015),\n  Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Pornvideoxo.com et al, Case No. 2:2015-cv-00240 (D. Arizona) (filed Feb. 10, 2015),\n  Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Spankbang.com et al, Case No. 2:2015-cv-00199 (W.D. Wash.) (filed Feb. 10, 2015),\n  Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. HDPorn1080.com et al, Case No. 2:2015-cv-00442 (D. Arizona) (filed March 11,\n  2015), Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Pornburst.xxx et al, Case No. 2:2015-cv-00443 (D. Arizona) (filed March 11,\n  2015), Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Pornowow.com et al, Case No. 2:2015-cv-00444 (D. Arizona) (filed March 11,\n  2015), Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Seesexvideo.net et al, Case No. 2:2015-cv-00371 (W.D. Wash.) (filed March\n  11, 2015), Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Sextvx.com, Case No. 2:2015-cv-00372 (W.D. Wash.) (filed March 11,\n  2015), Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Porn69.org et al, Case No. 2:2015-cv-00451 (D. Arizona) (filed March 12,\n  2015), Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Motherless, Inc. et al, Case No. 2:2015-cv-03834 (C.D. Cal.) (filed May 20,\n  2015), Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Jojobaa.net, Case No. 2:2015-cv-03904 (C.D. Cal.) (filed May 22, 2015),\n  Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Adultpornvideoxx.com et al, Case No. 2:2015-cv-03950 (C.D. Cal.) (filed May 25,\n  2015), Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Luchian et al, Case No. 1:2015-cv-22134 (S.D. Fla.) (filed June 4, 2015),\n  Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Maximum Apps Inc. et al, Case No. 1:2015-cv-22463 (S.D. Fla.) (filed June 30, 2015),\n  Hydentra, L.P. HLP General Partner, Inc. et al v. Mindgeek USA Inc. et al, Case No. 1:2015-cv-23230 (S.D. Fla.)\n  (filed August 27, 2015), Hydentra, L.P. HLP General Partner, Inc. et al v. Era Technologies, Ltd. et al, Case No.\n  1:2015-cv-24293 (S.D. Fla.) (filed November 18, 2015), Hydentra, L.P. HLP General Partner, Inc. et al v. Siracusa\n  Management S.A. et al, Case No. 1:2016-cv-20191 (S.D. Fla.) (filed January 15, 2016), Hydentra HLP Int. Limited\n  v. Stach et al, Case No. 2:2016-cv-00120 (E.D. Wash.) (filed April 15, 2016), Hydentra HLP Int. Limited et al v.\n  Sagan Limited et al, Case No. 2:2016-cv-01494 (D. Ariz.) (filed May 16, 2016).\n\n                                                          3\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 4 of 17\n\n\n\n\n  intention to file a Motion to Strike the Affirmative Defenses set forth in the Answer. In response\n\n  thereto, Defendants filed a Motion to Amend the Answer and Affirmative Defenses resolving all\n\n  the issues raised by Plaintiffs in the proposed Motion to Strike on October 15, 2015. Docket No.\n\n  38. The Court allowed Defendants\u2019 Motion to Amend on October 16, 2015. Despite the\n\n  Amended Answer resolving all of the issues raised by Plaintiff in the proposed motion, Plaintiff\n\n  filed its Motion to Strike anyway on October 29, 2015, seeking to strike every single affirmative\n\n  defense. Docket No. 41. After briefing, the Motion to Strike was denied virtually in its entirety.\n\n  Docket No. 53.\n\n         Thereafter, Plaintiff began a steady and consistent course of filing frivolous motion after\n\n  frivolous motion against Defendants. On December 1, 2015, Plaintiff filed a Motion to Compel\n\n  Answers to Requests for Production, Docket No. 51, which was denied almost in its entirety.\n\n  Docket No. 58. On February 10, 2016, Plaintiff filed a Motion for Sanctions for Unlicensed\n\n  Practice of Law, Docket No. 69, which was denied. Docket No. 135. Also on February 10,\n\n  2016, Plaintiff filed a Motion for Sanctions for Failure to Comply with Rule 30(b)(6), Docket\n\n  No. 70, which was denied on February 23, 2016. Docket No. 107. On February 12, 2016,\n\n  Plaintiff filed a Motion to Compel Arising From Instructions Not to Answer, and Refusal to\n\n  Answer, Deposition Questions, Docket No. 71, which was denied on February 23, 2016. Docket\n\n  No. 107.\n\n         On February 5, 2016 the parties attended a mediation before Mr. John S. Freud. Docket\n\n  No. 63. The mediation ended when Plaintiff and Plaintiff\u2019s counsel left shortly after its start.\n\n         On February 12, 2016, the parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment. Docket\n\n  Nos. 72, 73, 86.\n\n\n\n\n                                                   4\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 5 of 17\n\n\n\n\n         On February 26, 2016, Defendants\u2019 Counsel Val Gurvits filed a Motion to Appear Pro\n\n  Hac Vice. Docket No. 110. Despite having complained about Attorney Gurvits not having yet\n\n  moved for admission, plaintiffs opposed the motion, Docket No. 114, and Defendants were\n\n  required to reply to the opposition. Docket No. 117. The Court granted Mr. Gurvits\u2019 Motion to\n\n  Appear Pro Hac Vice on February 29, 2016. Docket No. 118.\n\n         After briefing the Motions for Summary Judgment, but before the issuance of the order\n\n  thereon, the Parties began their pre-trial preparation. Defendants did not file Motions in Limine,\n\n  but Plaintiff\u2019s filed an omnibus Motion in Limine on February 19, 2016 (Docket No. 98), which\n\n  Defendants opposed. After full briefing, the Court denied 7 out of 10 parts of Plaintiff\u2019s Motion\n\n  in Limine in their entirety. Docket No. 137. On February 26, 2016, the Parties filed their\n\n  proposed jury instructions, pretrial stipulations and trial exhibit lists in accordance with the\n\n  Court\u2019s scheduling order. Docket Nos. 111-113, 115-116.\n\n         On June 2, 2016, this Court issued the Omnibus Order. Docket No. 138. Defendant\n\n  Constantin Luchian\u2019s Motion for Summary Judgment was granted in its entirety, dismissing him\n\n  from the case. Defendants Sun Social Media, Inc. and Konstantin Bolotin\u2019s Motion for\n\n  Summary Judgement was granted, resulting in the dismissal of all of the copyright claims and the\n\n  state statutory claims against both defendants. Plaintiff\u2019s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment\n\n  was denied in its entirety.\n\n         Following the issuance of the Omnibus Order, the Court ordered the parties to engage in\n\n  a second mediation, which the parties held on June 6, 2016 before Mr. Mark A. Buckstein. The\n\n  mediation resulted in an impasse after approximately two hours of discussion. Docket No. 143.\n\n         The day after the mediation, on June 7, 2016, Plaintiff filed a Motion to Dismiss all\n\n  remaining claims in the litigation. Docket No. 140. The Court granted the Motion the same day,\n\n\n\n                                                    5\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 6 of 17\n\n\n\n\n  closing the case. Docket No. 141. The Court\u2019s order closing the case constituted the final\n\n  judgment in this matter.\n\n         On July 1, 2016, Plaintiff filed a Notice of Appeal to appeal the Court\u2019s Omnibus Order\n\n  on the Motions for Summary Judgment, noting that the order became a final judgment on June 7,\n\n  2016, upon the Court issuing its order on that date, closing the case. Docket No. 144.\n\n         On July 26, 2016, Plaintiff voluntarily dismissed its complaint in Hydentra, L.P. HLP\n\n  General Partner, Inc. et al v. ERA Technologies, Ltd. et al, Case No. 1:15-cv-24293-MGC (S.D.\n\n  Fla.) and in Hydentra, L.P. HLP General Partner, Inc. et al v. Siracusa Management S.A. et al,\n\n  Case No. 1:16-cv-20191-RNS (S.D. Fla.). In both cases, Plaintiff explicitly referenced the\n\n  adverse decisions in this case for the basis of its dismissal.\n\n                                             ARGUMENT\n\n         I.      Section 505 of the Copyright Act Authorizes an Award of Costs and Attorney\u2019s\n                 Fees.\n         \u201cUnder the Copyright Act, courts may award reasonable attorney\u2019s fees and costs to the\n\n  prevailing party in a copyright infringement claim.\u201d Katz v. Chevaldina, 127 F. Supp. 3d 1285\n\n  (S.D. Fla. 2015). On June 2, 2016, this Court entered Summary Judgment in the Defendants\u2019 favor,\n\n  dismissing each of the Plaintiff\u2019s copyright claims. As such, the Defendants are prevailing parties\n\n  under the Copyright Act. Katz, supra at 1298 (\u201cTo be entitled to attorney's fees under Section 505,\n\n  Defendant must show that she is the prevailing party. Defendant here prevailed on her Motion for\n\n  Summary Judgment against Plaintiff's copyright infringement claim... Therefore, it is undisputed that\n\n  Defendant is the prevailing party in this matter because she received final judgment in her favor. This\n\n  weighs heavily in favor of granting Defendant's attorney's fees \u2014 especially given the presumption\n\n  in favor of awarding prevailing defendants' fees in copyright infringement suits.\u201d); Maiden Specialty\n\n  Ins. Co. v. Three Chefs & A Chicken, Inc., 2014 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 186444, 13-14 (S.D. Fla. Jan. 28,\n\n  2014) (\u201cThe District Court granted summary judgment in favor of the defendants in this matter and\n\n\n\n                                                     6\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 7 of 17\n\n\n\n\n  Ordered that final judgment be entered in favor of the defendants in this matter, thereby making the\n\n  defendants the prevailing party\u2026.\u201d).\n\n          Although an award of attorney\u2019s fees remains entirely within this Court\u2019s discretion,\n\n  \u201cthey are the rule rather than the exception and should be awarded routinely.\u201d Professional LED\n\n  Lighting, Ltd. V. Aadyn Technology, LLC, 88 F. Supp. 3d 1356, 1376 (S.D. Fla. 2015). Indeed,\n\n  \u201cwhere a defendant is a prevailing party in a copyright case, the presumption in favor of\n\n  awarding fees is very strong.\u201d Lil\u2019 Joe Wein Music, Inc. v. Jackson, 2008 U.S. Dist. LEXIS\n\n  112730, *13 (S.D. Fla. 2008); Katz, supra at 1297 (same). See also Woodhaven Homes & Realty,\n\n  Inc. v. Hotz, 396 F.3d 822, 824 (7th Cir. 2005) (\u201cWhen the prevailing party is the defendant\u2026the\n\n  presumption in favor of awarding fees is very strong. For without the prospect of such an award, the\n\n  party might be forced into a nuisance settlement or deterred all together from exercising his rights.\u201d)\n\n  Assessment Technologies of WI, LLC v. WIREdata, Inc., 361 F.3d 434, 436 (7th Cir. 2004) (same).\n\n          II.     Consideration of the Applicable Factors Justifies an Award of Attorney\u2019s Fees\n\n          While \u201c[t]here is no precise rule or formula\u201d for determining whether the Court, in its\n\n  discretion, should award attorney\u2019s fees to a prevailing party, the Supreme Court has identified\n\n  the following nonexclusive factors: (1) the degree of success obtained; (2) frivolousness; (3)\n\n  motivation; (4) objective unreasonableness (both in the factual and in the legal components of\n\n  the case); and (5) the need in particular circumstances to advance considerations of compensation\n\n  and deterrence. Fogerty v. Fantasy, Inc., 510 U.S. 517, 534 n.19 (1994); Mitek v. Holdings, Inc. v.\n\n  Arce Engineering Co., 198 F.3d 840, 842 (11thCir. 1999) (enumerating Fogerty factors). See also\n\n  Katz, supra at 1297 (same). Consideration of these factors demonstrates the appropriateness of a fee\n\n  award to Defendants.\n\n                  A. Degree of Success Obtained\n\n          In its Complaint, Plaintiff sought, among other things, over $5.5 million in damages and the\n\n  forfeiture of the Defendants\u2019 internet domains. Instead, all of Plaintiff\u2019s copyright claims were\n\n  resolved in favor of Defendants. Defendants\u2019 success in this action was total and complete. See\n\n\n                                                     7\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 8 of 17\n\n\n\n\n  Maljack Prods., Inc. v. Goodtimes Home Video Corp., 81 F.3d 881, 890 (9th Cir. 1996) (award of\n\n  attorney\u2019s fees proper where defendant, for which summary judgment was granted, \u201cobtained total\n\n  success in defending against [plaintiff\u2019s] copyright claims.\u201d). On June 7, 2016, Plaintiff voluntarily\n\n  dismissed the remaining claims in the litigation. Docket No. 140. Accordingly, an award of fees is\n\n  warranted.\n\n                    B. Frivolousness and Objective Unreasonableness5\n\n           Although a party\u2019s bad faith and/or the frivolousness of a party\u2019s claims may factor into\n\n  the Court\u2019s decision to award fees, \u201ca finding of bad faith or frivolity is not required for an\n\n  award.\u201d Id. Indeed, the United States Supreme Court has recently reaffirmed the proposition\n\n  that a fee award may be appropriate even when the losing party\u2019s position was objectively\n\n  reasonable:\n\n           This means in any given case a court may award fees even though the losing party\n           offered reasonable arguments (or conversely, deny fees even though the losing\n           party made unreasonable ones). For example, a court may order fee-shifting\n           because a party\u2019s litigation misconduct, whatever the reasonableness of his claims\n           or defenses. \u2026Or, a court may do so to deter repeated instances of copyright\n           infringement or overaggressive assertions of copyright claims, again even if the\n           losing position was reasonable in a particular case.\n\n  Kirtsaeng v. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 136 S. Ct. 1979 (2016). See also Cable/Home\n\n  Communication v. Network Productions, Inc., 902 F.2d 829, 853 (11th Cir. 1990) (\u201ca showing of\n\n  bad faith or frivolity is not a precondition to awarding attorney\u2019s fees\u201d); Casella v. Morris, 820 F.2d\n\n  362, 366 (11th Cir. 1987); Matthews v. Freedman, 157 F.3d 25, 29 (1st Cir. 1998) (\u201cDepending on\n\n  other circumstances, a district court could conclude that the losing party should pay even if all of the\n\n  arguments it made were reasonable.\u201d).\n\n           In the present case, however, regardless of how the Court conceptualizes this factor \u2013\n\n  unreasonableness, frivolousness, or bad faith \u2013 the facts counsel in favor of an award of fees. As a\n\n\n  5\n    Although Fogerty listed these two factors separately, Courts frequently collapse the inquiry into one factor. See,\n  e.g., Katz, supra.\n\n                                                            8\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 9 of 17\n\n\n\n  starting point, and as this Court properly recognized in the Omnibus Order, even at the summary\n\n  judgment stage it was wholly unclear why the individual defendants were named as defendants in\n\n  this case. See Omnibus Order, p. 13, fn. 4. With respect to Defendant Luchian, this Court\n\n  concluded:\n\n          There is no record evidence whatsoever to establish that Luchian had any\n          involvement with the facts of this case, other than being listed as the Designated\n          DMCA Agent on the United States Copyright Office\u2019s database. The Court finds\n          Plaintiff has failed to meet its burden in establishing that there is a genuine dispute as\n          to Luchian\u2019s liability for the claims being asserted against him.\n\n  Omnibus Order, p. 36.\n\n          Similarly, the Court found that there were no allegations as to Defendant Bolotin, but rather\n\n  that the Plaintiff lumped Mr. Bolotin together with corporate defendant Sun Social Media Inc.,\n\n  without actually articulating or proving any claims against Mr. Bolotin. Omnibus Order, p. 13, fn. 4.\n\n  Without question, the claims brought against the individual defendants could not be considered\n\n  anything other than frivolous.\n\n          Nor do the claims against Sun Social fare any better. In its exhaustive Order, this Court fully\n\n  examined \u2013 and rejected \u2013 each of Plaintiff\u2019s theories of liability against Sun Social. In brief, this\n\n  Court rejected Plaintiff\u2019s claims for direct copyright infringement, agreeing with the Defendants that\n\n  the Plaintiff had failed to plead or prove any volitional conduct on the Defendants\u2019 part that would\n\n  subject it to direct liability:\n\n          The Court agrees with Defendants that in imposing liability upon an internet service\n          provider for third-party users\u2019 uploading of copyrighted material, Plaintiff must\n          establish that Defendants engaged in a volitional act to cause the illegal copying. To\n          find otherwise would impose liability upon an otherwise passive internet service\n          provider for conduct that is simply out of its control.\n\n  Omnibus Order, p. 17.\n\n          The Court rejected Plaintiff\u2019s claim of contributory infringement, finding that Sun\n\n  Social\u2019s websites were capable of substantial non-infringing uses:\n\n\n\n                                                      9\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 10 of 17\n\n\n\n          Defendants have demonstrated that their Websites are capable of substantial\n          noninfringing uses, notwithstanding that copyrighted material is, at times, located on\n          their Websites. The Court is satisfied that Defendants have met their burden in\n          establishing that its Websites are capable of substantial, noninfringing purposes,\n          which are legitimate and unobjectionable.\n\n   Omnibus Order, p. 28.\n\n          The Court rejected Plaintiff\u2019s claims of vicarious copyright infringement, finding that the\n\n   Plaintiff had failed to demonstrate that the Defendants received any direct financial benefit as a\n\n   result of the infringement:\n\n          The Court agrees with Defendants that there is no record evidence to substantiate\n          that Defendants have received a direct financial benefit from the uploading of\n          Plaintiff\u2019s videos.\u2026 It is undisputed that Defendants\u2019 revenues stem solely from\n          advertising. There is no evidence that Plaintiff\u2019s copyrighted videos drew\n          additional traffic to Defendants\u2019 Websites. Plaintiff\u2019s argument that the infringed\n          videos somehow attracted and drew more visitors to Defendants\u2019 Websites, which\n          allowed Defendants to receive more revenue in advertisements, is not supported by\n          record evidence and highly speculative.\n\n   Omnibus Order, pp. 29-30.\n\n          And, finally, the Court rejected Plaintiff\u2019s claims of copyright inducement, not only\n\n   because the Plaintiff did not even bother to present argument in favor of its claim, but also\n\n   because of a wholesale lack of record evidence to support such a claim:\n\n          Defendants argue that they cannot be liable for inducement of copyright infringement\n          because SSM has not induced or encouraged any user to engage in direct\n          infringement. Bolotin Decl. \u00b6 40. Plaintiff neither responds to Defendants\u2019 arguments\n          as they pertain to Count IV, nor does Plaintiff move for summary judgment as to\n          Count IV in its briefing. Aside from Plaintiff\u2019s failure to respond to Defendants\u2019\n          arguments, the Court agrees with Defendants that there is no record evidence that\n          Defendants induced the third-party users\u2019 into uploading copyrighted material.\n\n   Omnibus Opposition, p. 30.\n\n          As the Court\u2019s findings indicate, each of Plaintiff\u2019s copyright claims were frivolous or, at a\n\n   minimum, objectively unreasonable and brought in bad faith. Indeed, because the Plaintiff\u2019s claims\n\n   were so lacking, the Court was never required to consider the other affirmative basis for the\n\n   Defendants\u2019 Motion for Summary Judgment, namely that the Defendants were entitled to safe harbor\n\n                                                     10\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 11 of 17\n\n\n\n   under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. In other words, even if the Plaintiffs had managed to\n\n   meet their burdens of proof under their copyright claims, they would nonetheless have failed. As\n\n   such, an award of fees is warranted.6\n\n                     C. Motivation\n\n            Defendants have long argued that the Plaintiff in this case has not acted in a manner\n\n   consistent with a party legitimately looking to protect its intellectual property rights, but rather\n\n   that the Plaintiff \u2013 which filed at least 20 boilerplate complaints in a 15-month timeframe \u2013 had\n\n   simply decided to exploit a new revenue stream, namely, wresting nuisance settlements from\n\n   defendants who were otherwise faced with mounting legal fees. Plaintiff\u2019s actions in this\n\n   litigation (and others) paint a picture of a Plaintiff willing to file frivolous motion after frivolous\n\n   motion in an attempt to ratchet up Defendant\u2019s costs (and, thereby, the likelihood of settlement).7\n\n   Because the Plaintiff\u2019s motivation was not the legitimate protection of its intellectual property,\n\n   this factor, too, favors an award of fees.\n\n\n\n\n   6\n     It is worth noting that, following the dismissal of the Plaintiff\u2019s copyright claims in this case, the Defendants also\n   voluntarily dismissed two other actions filed in this Court. Plaintiff voluntarily dismissed its complaint in Hydentra,\n   L.P. HLP General Partner, Inc. et al v. ERA Technologies, Ltd. et al, Case No. 1:15-cv-24293-MGC (S.D. Fla.) and\n   in Hydentra, L.P. HLP General Partner, Inc. et al v. Siracusa Management S.A. et al, Case No. 1:16-cv-20191-RNS\n   (S.D. Fla.). In both cases, Plaintiff explicitly referenced the adverse decisions in this case and the case in support of\n   its dismissal. Presumably, if the Plaintiff\u2019s cases were based on actual facts, the dismissal of one case would not\n   mandate the dismissal of the other cases brought by the Plaintiff.\n   7\n     Defendants also note that Plaintiff\u2019s pre-litigation conduct demonstrates that the Plaintiff was not looking to\n   legitimately protect its intellectual property rights. Rather than sending its takedown notices via email (enabling the\n   infringing content to be removed more expeditiously and more accurately), Plaintiff\u2019s sent hard copy takedown\n   notices. It is extremely unusual for studios that are actually interested in protecting their content to send such hard-\n   copy takedown notices because sending such notices drastically decreases the likelihood that infringing content will\n   be taken down. This is true because the relevant links usually contain extremely long and random strings of\n   characters. When studios send electronic notices (as they usually do) a site can simply click on the allegedly\n   infringing link (or cut and paste the link into a browser). When a hard copy is sent, someone must manually type the\n   long random string of characters into a web browser, increasing the possibility of error. Sending hard copy notices\n   is an attempt to create a forced error so that Hydentra can then initiate a frivolous suit. Additionally, as this Court\n   found, Sun Social had consistently and expeditiously removed infringing content from its sites when it received\n   takedown notices from the Plaintiff. Sun Social argued throughout the litigation that it had not received the\n   takedown notices in issue in this litigation and, as the Court found, Sun Social promptly removed the allegedly\n   infringing materials upon receiving the Complaint in this case. Omnibus Order, p. 10.\n\n                                                              11\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 12 of 17\n\n\n\n\n                  D. Compensation and Deterrence\n\n          \u201cThe touchstone of attorney\u2019s fees under Section 505 is whether imposition of attorney\u2019s\n\n   fees will further the interests of the Copyright Act.\u201d Kernel Records Oy v. Mosley, 2013 U.S.\n\n   Dist. LEXIS 99094 (S. D. Fla. July 16, 2013) (finding that defendants\u2019 success weighed heavily\n\n   in favor of an award of attorney\u2019s fees). \u201cDefendants\u2019 efforts in pursuit of this successful\n\n   defense should be compensated in order to encourage further meritorious defenses.\u201d Id. at *32.\n\n   See also Mitchell-Proffitt Company v. Eagle Crest, Inc., 2005 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 33535, *7-8\n\n   (M.D. Fla. Nov. 28, 2005) (\u201cBecause copyright law ultimately serves the purpose of enriching\n\n   the general public through access to creative works, it is peculiarly important that the boundaries\n\n   of copyright law be demarcated as clearly as possible. To that end, defendants who seek to\n\n   advance a variety of meritorious copyright defenses should be encouraged to litigate them to the\n\n   same extent plaintiff are encouraged to litigate meritorious claims of infringement.\u2026 Defendant\n\n   should be compensated for its vigorous defense of the boundaries of copyright law.\u201d); Katz,\n\n   supra at 1300 (\u201cJust as when plaintiffs succeed on their claims, a successful defense also helps\n\n   define the boundaries of copyright infringement law. It also continues to allow the public to have\n\n   access to creative elements and ideas.\u2026 Under this last factor of compensation and deterrence,\n\n   an award of attorney's fees furthers the goals of the Copyright Act and Fogerty by encouraging\n\n   defendants to pursue their meritorious defenses to copyright infringement claims.\u201d); Lil\u2019 Joe\n\n   Wein Music, Inc., supra, at *21-22 (\u201c[A]ttorney\u2019s fees should be awarded to deter plaintiffs from\n\n   \u2018bringing unreasonable claims based on a cost/benefit analysis that tells such plaintiffs that they\n\n   can score big if they win and that there will be no adverse consequences for losing\u2019\u201d) (quoting\n\n   Baker v. Urban Outfitters, Inc., 431 F. Supp. 2d 351, 359 (S.D.N.Y. 2006))).\n\n\n\n\n                                                    12\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 13 of 17\n\n\n\n\n           In the present case, the Defendants have \u2013 at great cost \u2013 defended an action that should\n\n   never have been initiated and which Plaintiff litigated in a manner calculated to ensure that\n\n   Defendants would incur the maximum amounts of costs and fees possible (going so far as to\n\n   spurn efforts at earlier mediation). The Court\u2019s extensive Order has helped to define the\n\n   contours of copyright liability. Moreover, there is no need to speculate as to whether the\n\n   decision in this case will deter the Plaintiff from bringing other frivolous actions: since the\n\n   Court\u2019s Order, the Plaintiff has already dismissed two other near-identical actions against other\n\n   defendants, citing the Court\u2019s decision in this matter.8\n\n           For this reason as well, Defendants are entitled to an award of attorney\u2019s fees.\n\n           III.     The Fees Sought By The Defendants Are Reasonable.\n\n           In Katz, this Court discussed in detail the considerations for the District Court in\n\n   determining the proper amounts of attorney\u2019s fees to be awarded:\n\n           Having determined that Defendant is entitled to fees and costs, the Court must\n           next determine what amount is reasonable. The Supreme Court has stressed that\n           the determination of fees \u201cshould not result in a second major litigation.\u201d\u2026 Fee\n           applicants must submit appropriate documentation to meet \u201cthe burden of\n           establishing entitlement to an award.\u201d \u2026 \u201cBut trial courts need not, and indeed\n           should not, become green-eyeshade accountants. The essential goal in shifting\n           fees (to either party) is to do rough justice, not to achieve auditing perfection. So\n           trial courts may take into account their overall sense of a suit, and may use\n           estimates in calculating and allocating an attorney's time.\u201d\n\n           The existing settled law in this Circuit mandates calculating a reasonable\n           attorney's fee by using the Lodestar method, which requires this Court to multiply\n           counsel's reasonable hourly rate by the reasonable hours expended. \u2026Defendant\n           bears the burden of documenting reasonable hourly rates and reasonable hours\n           expended.\n\n   Katz, supra at 1031.\n\n\n\n   8\n    The Plaintiff in another case (who is represented by the same counsel) also dismissed its action, citing to the\n   Court\u2019s decision in this matter. See AMA Multimedia, LLC v. ERA Technologies, Ltd., Case No. 1:15-cv-24289-\n   FAM (S.D. Fla.), Docket No. 54, July 25, 2016.\n\n                                                           13\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 14 of 17\n\n\n\n\n          In the present case, the fees sought by the defendants are eminently reasonable: counsel\u2019s\n\n   rates range from $300 per hour to $450 per hour, consistent with (if not lower than) the\n\n   reasonable hourly rate charged by \u201clawyers of reasonably comparable skills, experience, and\n\n   reputation.\u201d Norman v. Housing Authority of Montgomery, 836 F.2d 1292, 1299 (11th Cir.\n\n   1988). All counsel have submitted affidavits in connection with this Motion in support of the\n\n   hourly rates charged.\n\n          Plaintiff would be hard-pressed to complain that the hourly rates charged are\n\n   unreasonable: in a similar case (in which the Plaintiff obtained a default judgment), Hydentra\u2019s\n\n   lead attorney, Spencer Freeman (lead counsel in this case as well), who has comparable\n\n   experience as Attorneys Gurvits and Fray-Witzer, billed at $450 an hour, a rate that he\n\n   represented to the Court was a reasonable one. See Exhibit 1.\n\n          Similarly, the hours expended were reasonable given the complexities of the case, the\n\n   number of motions filed by the Plaintiff, and the fact that the Defendants had already completed\n\n   most of the trial preparations when the Court\u2019s Order was issued. A precise breakdown of the\n\n   hours expended, sorted first by attorney and then by date, is attached hereto as Exhibit 2 and\n\n   incorporated herein, by reference. (An identical breakdown is attached to the Declaration of\n\n   Brady Cobb, submitted herewith.)\n\n                                           CONCLUSION\n\n          For the reasons stated hereinabove and in the accompanying Declarations of Brady Cobb,\n\n   Val Gurvits, Matthew Shayefar, and Evan Fray-Witzer, Defendants respectfully request that the\n\n   Court allow Defendants\u2019 Motion for Attorney\u2019s Fees in the amount of $162,165.00.\n\n\n\n\n                                                   14\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 15 of 17\n\n\n\n\n                         Certificate of Compliance with Local Rule 7.3(b)\n\n          I hereby certify that counsel for Movant conferred with Plaintiff at the mediation\n\n   conference on June 6, 2016 in regards to the relief sought herein, however the Motion was not\n\n   transmitted to Plaintiff until today. For good cause show as was stated in Defendant Motion for\n\n   Enlargement of Time for the Filing and/or Consideration of Its Motion for Attorney\u2019s Fees or in\n\n   the Alternative Motion for Leave to File an Amended Motion for Attorney\u2019s Fees (D.E. 147),\n\n   Defendants request they be granted leave to comply with Local Rule 7.3(b).\n\n                                                       /s/ Brady J. Cobb\n\n\n   Respectfully submitted this 2nd day of August, 2016.\n\n                                                COBB EDDY, PLLC\n                                                642 Northeast Third Avenue\n                                                Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33304\n                                                Telephone (954) 527-4111\n                                                Facsimile (954) 900-5507\n\n                                                By: ___/s/ BRADY J. COBB_______\n                                                BRADY J. COBB, ESQUIRE\n                                                Florida Bar No. 031018\n                                                bcobb@cobbeddy.com\n                                                Attorney for Defendants Constantin\n                                                Luchian, Konstatin Bolotin, and Sun\n                                                Social Media Inc.\n\n                                                /s/ Valentin Gurvits\n                                                Valentin D. Gurvits (pro hac vice)\n                                                BOSTON LAW GROUP, PC\n                                                825 Beacon Street, Suite 20\n                                                Newton Centre, MA 02459\n                                                Telephone: (617) 928-1804\n                                                Facsimile: (617) 928-1802\n                                                vgurvits@bostonlawgroup.com\n\n\n\n\n                                                  15\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 16 of 17\n\n\n\n\n                                           VERIFICATION\n\n          I, Brady J. Cobb, do hereby swear and affirm under penalty of perjury that I have read the\n\n   foregoing Motion and know the contents thereof, and the contents are true of my own knowledge\n\n   and belief.\n\n                                                ____________________________\n                                                BRADY J. COBB, ESQUIRE\n\n\n\n                                   CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\n          I hereby certify that a true and correct copy of the foregoing was served electronically\n\n   via the CM/ECF electronic filing system on all counsel or parties of record on the service list\n\n   below this 2nd day of August, 2016.\n\n                                                        /s/ Brady J. Cobb\n                                                        Brady J. Cobb\n\n\n\n\n                                                   16\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 17 of 17\n\n\n\n\n                                  SERVICE LIST\n\n   Aaron Behar, Esquire\n   Jaclyn Behar, Esquire\n   BEHARBEHAR\n   1840 North Commerce Parkway\n   Suite One\n   Weston, Florida 33326\n   Telephone: (954) 688-7642\n   Facsimile: (954) 332-9260\n   AB@BeharBehar.com\n   JB@BeharBehar.com\n   Spencer D. Freeman\n   Freeman Law Firm, Inc.\n   1107 1/2 Tacoma Avenue South\n   Tacoma, Washington 98402\n   Telephone: (206) 516-3800\n   Facsimile: (206) 516-3888\n   sfreeman@freemanlawfirm.org\n\n\n\n\n                                        17\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2024-06-29T12:28:03.216348-07:00","document_number":"148","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"051016810051","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Motion for Attorney Fees","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/404233390/","id":404233390,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/148/1/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2024-06-29T11:54:25.103789-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-30T02:07:13.300249-07:00","sha1":"6ce77cb014cf7a8fa98a993d28f6ecb4993116f5","page_count":3,"file_size":52944,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.148.1.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.148.1.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU   Document 148-1\n          Case 2:15-cv-00240-DJH       Entered\n                                  Document 34-4on Filed\n                                                  FLSD05/13/16\n                                                        Docket 08/02/2016\n                                                                Page 1 of 3Page 1 of 3\n\n\n\n\n     1   Spencer D. Freeman, WSBA #25069 (pro hac vice)\n         FREEMAN LAW FIRM, INC.\n     2   1107 \u00bd Tacoma Avenue South\n         Tacoma, Washington 98402\n     3   Telephone: (253) 383-4500\n         Facsimile: (253) 383-4501\n     4   Email: sfreeman@freemanlawfirm.org\n\n     5   Attorney for Plaintiff Hydentra HLP Int. Limited\n\n     6\n\n     7\n\n     8                              UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                                 IN AND FOR THE DISTRICT OF ARIZONA\n     9\n         HYDENTRA HLP INT. LIMITED, a foreign\n    10   corporation, d/b/a METART, d/b/a METART\n         FILMS                                              Case No.: 2:15-cv-0000240-DJH\n    11\n                                                            DECLARATION OF SPENCER D.\n                             Plaintiff,                     FREEMAN IN SUPPORT OF\n    12\n                       vs.                                  PLAINTIFF HYDENTRA HLP INT.\n    13                                                      LIMITED\u2019S MOTION FOR OF\n         PORNVIDEOXO.COM; ALI A-ZEN,                        DEFAULT JUDGMENT AGAINST\n    14   individually and d/b/a PORNVIDEOXO.COM;            DEFENDANTS ALI A-ZEN, MEHMET\n                                                            USTAN AND LYOSHA ANKUDINOV\n         MEHMET USTAN, individually and d/b/a\n    15\n         PORNVIDEOXO.COM; LYOSHA\n    16   ANKUDINOV, individually and d/b/a\n         PORNVIDEOXO.COM; and John Does 1-20,\n    17\n                              Defendants.\n    18\n\n    19\n\n    20          I, Spencer D. Freeman, declare as follows:\n\n    21          1.     I am an attorney at law licensed to practice before the Courts of the State of\n\n    22   Washington and the United States District Courts for the Western District of Washington,\n\n    23   Eastern District of Washington, District of Colorado and Southern District of Illinois, the\n\n    24   Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals and United States Supreme Court. I am the principal\n\n    25   attorney with the law firm of Freeman Law Firm, Inc., attorneys for Plaintiff Hydentra\n                             DECL. OF SPENCER D. FREEMAN IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFF\u2019S\n                                         MOTION FOR DEFAULT JUDGMENT\n                                                       1\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU   Document 148-1\n          Case 2:15-cv-00240-DJH       Entered\n                                  Document 34-4on Filed\n                                                  FLSD05/13/16\n                                                        Docket 08/02/2016\n                                                                Page 2 of 3Page 2 of 3\n\n\n\n\n     1   HLP Int. Limited. Unless otherwise stated, I have personal knowledge of the facts\n     2   contained in this declaration and, if called and sworn as a witness, could and would\n\n     3   competently testify thereto.\n     4          2.     I spent the following time on this litigation:\n     5                 \u2022    Draft Complaint and Initial Pleadings:                12 hours\n     6                 \u2022    Service Investigation                                 3 hours\n     7                 \u2022    Draft Motion for Early Discovery:                     6 hours\n     8                 \u2022    Draft Motion Extension of Time to serve:              3 hours\n\n     9                 \u2022    Draft Motion for Alternative Service:                 6 hours\n    10                 \u2022    Draft and Serve Subpoenas                             2 hours\n    11                 \u2022    Review Subpoena Responses                             2.1 hours\n\n    12                 \u2022    Investigate Identified Defendants                     2.0 hours\n    13                 \u2022    Draft First Amended Complaint                         1.5 hours\n    14                 \u2022    Service of Process                                    0.5 hours\n\n    15                 \u2022    Motion for Order of Default                           1.5 hours\n    16                 \u2022    Motion Default Judgment                               3 hours\n    17          3.     My hourly rate is $450 per hour.\n\n    18          4.     I have practiced law for 20 years, litigating cases at all levels in the State of\n    19   Washington, United States District Courts across the country, Ninth Circuit Court of\n    20   Appeals and United States Supreme Court. I have tried over 100 jury trials. The last 15\n\n    21   years of my practice has included intellectual property/piracy litigation. Given my level\n    22   of experience, a rate of $450 per hour is reasonable.\n    23          5.     Altogether, I have spent 42.6 hours on this matter which, at $450 per hour,\n    24   is $19,170 in fees.\n    25          6.     The filing fee for this case was $400.\n                           DECL. OF SPENCER D. FREEMAN IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFF\u2019S\n                                       MOTION FOR DEFAULT JUDGMENT\n                                                     2\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU   Document 148-1\n          Case 2:15-cv-00240-DJH       Entered\n                                  Document 34-4on Filed\n                                                  FLSD05/13/16\n                                                        Docket 08/02/2016\n                                                                Page 3 of 3Page 3 of 3\n\n\n\n\n     1          I declare under the penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of\n     2   America that the foregoing is true and correct.\n\n     3\n\n     4          Executed this 13th day of May, 2016, at Tacoma, Washington.\n     5\n\n     6                                                     /s/ Spencer D. Freeman\n                                                           Spencer D. Freeman\n     7\n\n     8\n\n     9\n\n    10\n\n    11\n                                           Certificate of Service\n    12\n                I hereby certify that on this 13th day of May, 2016, I electronically transmitted the\n    13   foregoing document as follows:\n\n    14          \u2022      to the Clerk\u2019s Office for filing, using the CM/ECF System; and\n    15\n                \u2022      to the Defendants Ali A-Zen, Mehmet Ustan and Lyosha Ankudinov for\n    16                 service, using their email addresses of aliozen2007@gmail.com,\n                       keops196@yahoo.com, and antonygeorge365@gmail.com, in accordance\n    17                 with the Court\u2019s Order granting alternate service by email dated October\n                       19, 2015 (Dkt. No. 17).\n    18\n\n    19                                                     /s/ Spencer D. Freeman\n                                                           Spencer D. Freeman\n    20\n\n    21\n\n    22\n\n    23\n\n    24\n\n    25\n\n                          DECL. OF SPENCER D. FREEMAN IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFF\u2019S\n                                      MOTION FOR DEFAULT JUDGMENT\n                                                    3\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2024-06-29T12:28:03.552609-07:00","document_number":"148","attachment_number":1,"pacer_doc_id":"051016810052","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/404233391/","id":404233391,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/148/2/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2024-06-29T11:54:25.135364-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-30T02:07:13.792525-07:00","sha1":"f306a50934d2160a67210fcb15947fbc5eef901b","page_count":20,"file_size":344209,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.148.2.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.148.2.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"  Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 1 of 20\n\n\n                                          COBB EDDY, PLLC\n                                           642 N.E. 3rd Avenue\n                                       Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33304\n                                          (954) 527-4111 (office)\n                                          (954) 900-5507 (facsimile)\n                                             www.cobbeddy.com\nClient: Konstantin Bolotin, Constantin Luchian and Sun Social Media, Inc.\nMatter: Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Luchian, et al: Case No. 2015-cv-22134-UU\n Attorney       date                             description                      quantaty    rate\nBrady Cobb\nBC          8/31/2015 Review of Complaint, preparation and filing of Notice of 1.00        $350.00\n                        Appearance and Motion to Set Aside default\nBC          8/31/2015 Review of Order granting Motion to set Aside Default,      1.00      $350.00\n                        and review of proposed answer and affirmative\n                        defenses\nBC          9/1/2015 Review preparation and filing of Answer and Affirmative 1.00          $350.00\n                        Defenses to Plaintiff's Complaint\nBC          9/1/2015 Review revision and approval of Joint Scheduling            1.00      $350.00\n                        Report\nBC          9/10/2015 Review of proposed motion to strike affirmative            0.80      $350.00\n                        defenses, and transmission of same to co-counsel\nBC          9/25/2015 Review of proposed amended affirmative defenses,           1.00      $350.00\n                        and preparation of revisions to the same\nBC          10/6/2015 Review of initial discovery requests from Plaintiff        0.80      $350.00\nBC          10/16/2015 Review of order granting motion for leave to file         0.20      $350.00\n                        amended answer and affirmative defenses\nBC          11/7/2015 Research of case law to opposed plaintiffs motion to       1.40      $350.00\n                        strike affirmative defenses\nBC          11/7/2015 Preparation of response in opposition to Plaintiff's       3.00      $350.00\nBC          11/10/2015 Review and revision of response in opposition to          1.30      $350.00\nBC          11/12/2015 Finalization of response in opposition to Motion to       1.20      $350.00\n                        Strike.\nBC          11/12/2015 Review of client's responses to discovery requests        0.80      $350.00\nBC          11/18/2015 Review and response to emails regarding scheduling of     1.00      $350.00\n                        mediation conference\nBC          11/18/2015 review of order on mediation scheduling                   0.20      $350.00\nBC          12/1/2015 Review of Plaintiff's Reply in Support of Motion to Strike 0.80      $350.00\nBC          12/1/2015 Review of proposed motion to compel by Plaintiff           0.60      $350.00\n                        regarding discovery responses.\nBC          12/2/2015 Review and response to alleged deficiencies in clients     1.10      $350.00\n                        discovery responses\nBC          12/2/2015 Review of Plaintiff's Second Set of Interrogatories and    1.20      $350.00\n                        First Set of Interrogatories\nBC          12/4/2015 Review of Order granting in part and denying in part       1.10      $350.00\n                        Motion to Strike Affirmative Defenses\nBC          12/4/2015 Review of Order setting motion to compel for hearing       0.40      $350.00\n\f Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 2 of 20\n\n\nBC      12/10/2015 Review of non-objection of to subpoena's                   0.50    $350.00\nBC      12/10/2015 Review of request for production responses, and review     0.60    $350.00\n                   of revised rules of civil procedure to prepare response\n                   to plaintiff's motion to compel\nBC      12/10/2015 Review and revision to joint status report                 0.60    $350.00\nBC      12/10/2015 Review and revision to draft response to motion to         0.80    $350.00\n                   compel\nBC      12/14/2015 Review and revision to draft response to Plaintiff's       1.10    $350.00\n                   Motion to Compel\nBC      12/16/2015 Review of Motion to Compel and case law to prepare         1.10    $350.00\n                   for hearing\nBC      12/16/2015 Attendance at hearing on Plaintiff's Motion to Compel      1.10    $350.00\nBC      12/20/2015 Review and response to emails with counsel for Plaintiff   0.70    $350.00\n                   regarding document production\n\nBC      12/20/2015 Review of additional documents to be produced              1.10    $350.00\nBC      12/31/2015 Review and filing of Motion to Bifuricate Trial and        0.90    $350.00\n                   Discovery\nBC      1/4/2016 Review of draft interrogatory answers                        1.10    $350.00\nBC      1/4/2016 Review of draft responses to second request for              0.80    $350.00\n                   production\nBC      1/4/2016 Review of proposed RFP to Plaintiff                          0.40    $350.00\nBC      1/5/2016 Review of draft discovery requests, and review of order      0.90    $350.00\n                   denying motion to bifuricate\n\nBC      1/6/2016 Review and revision to proposed discovery responses           1.00   $350.00\nBC      1/18/2016 Attendance at deposition of corporate representative of      7.30   $350.00\n                  Sun Social Media, Inc./Konstantin Bolotin\nBC      2/18/2016 Review and revision to declaration and motion in             1.10   $350.00\n                  opposition to Gurvits motion for sanctions\nBC      2/19/2016 Review approval and filing of response in opposition to 0.90        $350.00\n                  motion for sanctions\nBC      2/20/2016 Review revision and filing of Motion to Consolidate          0.90   $350.00\n                  Hearings, Response to Motion for Sanctions and/or to\n                  Compel Deposition testimony\nBC      2/20/2016 Review of Plaintiff's Motion in Limine                       1.10   $350.00\nBC      2/20/2016 Review and response to emails with Plaintiff's counsel       0.40   $350.00\n                  regarding pre trial stipulation and jury instructions\nBC      2/22/2016 Review and filing of opposition to 30b6 motion               0.60   $350.00\nBC      2/23/2016 Preparation, revision and filing of response to Plaintiff's 1.40    $350.00\n                  motion for protective order\nBC      2/23/2016 Review Plaintiff's Motions for Sanctions and Motion for 1.60        $350.00\n                  Protective Order to prepare for telephonic hearing on\n                  the same\nBC      2/26/2016 Review of proposed jury instructions, exhibit list, pretrial 2.50   $350.00\n                  stipulation and objections to Plaintiff's exhibits, and\n                  filing of the same\n\f Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 3 of 20\n\n\nBC      2/29/2016 Review, revision and filing of proposed jury instructions   0.80   $350.00\n                  and exhibit list\nBC      2/29/2016 revision and filing of reply in support of pro hac vice     1.10   $350.00\n                  admission\nBC      3/1/2016 Review of Plaintiff's Oppositions to defendants MSJ          1.10   $350.00\nBC      3/2/2016 Review of Plaintiff's objections to Defendants trial         1.40   $350.00\n                  exhibits\nBC      3/15/2016 Review of Plaintiff's Reply brief in support of their       0.40   $350.00\n                  motion in limine\nBC      3/16/2016 Review and response to emails from counsel for              0.50   $350.00\n                  Plaintiff regarding objections to their Motion to Strike\n                  Witnesses\nBC      3/16/2016 Review of Plaintiff's Motion to Strike Witnesses            0.60   $350.00\nBC      1/19/2016 Attendance at deposition of Constantin Luchian              3.40   $350.00\nBC      1/19/2016 Attendance at deposition of Konstantin Bolotin, in his      3.20   $350.00\n                  individual capacity\nBC      1/22/2016 Review and service of discovery and expert discovery        0.80   $350.00\n                  onto Plaintiff\nBC      1/28/2016 Review of client's deposition transcripts                   1.10   $350.00\nBC      1/29/2016 Review and revision to mediation summary                    0.70   $350.00\nBC      2/4/2016 Review of email from counsel for Plaintiff regarding         0.40   $350.00\n                  mediation and extension of time to produce documents,\n                  and preparation of responsive email\nBC      2/5/2016 Review and response to emails regarding discovery            1.00   $350.00\n                  responses and motions for protective order\nBC      2/5/2016 Review of proposed motion to amend scheduling order          0.80   $350.00\n                  and proposed counterclaim, and revisions to same\nBC      2/5/2016 Review, revision and filing of motion to amend               1.10   $350.00\n                  scheduling order\nBC      2/9/2016 Review and response to emails from counsel for               0.90   $350.00\n                  Plaintiff regarding outstanding discovery requests,\n                  production of documents and mediation issues\nBC      2/9/2016 Review of Motion for Protective Order filed by Plaintiffs    1.00   $350.00\nBC      2/9/2016 Review of notices of withdrawal of discovery requests        1.10   $350.00\n                  by Plaintiff\nBC      2/10/2016 Review of motion for sanctions against Val Gurvits, and     2.00   $350.00\n                  Defendants for failure to appear at mediation and for\n                  not complying with Rule 30(b)(6)\nBC      2/12/2016 Review of Plaintiff's Motion to Compel Deposition           1.40   $350.00\n                  Questions, and preparation of responsive email to\n                  Plaintiff's regarding objection to relief sought in the\n                  motion.\nBC      2/12/2016 Review, revision and filing of clients' Motions for         1.80   $350.00\n                  Summary Judgment\nBC      2/12/2016 Review of draft declarations for clients in support of      1.30   $350.00\n                  MSJ's\n\f Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 4 of 20\n\n\nBC      2/13/2016 Review of Plaintiffs Motions for Summary Judgment          2.10   $350.00\n                  and all attachments thereto\nBC      2/16/2016 Review of Court orders on telephonic hearings on           0.80   $350.00\n                  motions to compel\nBC      2/16/2016 Preparation of response to Plaintiffs Motion for           1.10   $350.00\n                  Protective Order\nBC      1/19/2016 Attendance at deposition of Constantin Luchian             3.40   $350.00\nBC      1/19/2016 Attendance at deposition of Konstantin Bolotin, in his     3.20   $350.00\n                  individual capacity\nBC      1/22/2016 Review and service of discovery and expert discovery       0.80   $350.00\n                  onto Plaintiff\nBC      1/28/2016 Review of client's deposition transcripts                  1.10   $350.00\nBC      1/29/2016 Review and revision to mediation summary                   0.70   $350.00\nBC      2/4/2016 Review of email from counsel for Plaintiff regarding        0.40   $350.00\n                  mediation and extension of time to produce documents,\n                  and preparation of responsive email\nBC      2/5/2016 Review and response to emails regarding discovery           1.00   $350.00\n                  responses and motions for protective order\nBC      2/5/2016 Review of proposed motion to amend scheduling order         0.80   $350.00\n                  and proposed counterclaim, and revisions to same\nBC      2/5/2016 Review, revision and filing of motion to amend              1.10   $350.00\n                  scheduling order\nBC      2/9/2016 Review and response to emails from counsel for              0.90   $350.00\n                  Plaintiff regarding outstanding discovery requests,\n                  production of documents and mediation issues\nBC      2/9/2016 Review of Motion for Protective Order filed by Plaintiffs   1.00   $350.00\nBC      2/9/2016 Review of notices of withdrawal of discovery requests       1.10   $350.00\n                  by Plaintiff\nBC      2/10/2016 Review of motion for sanctions against Val Gurvits, and    2.00   $350.00\n                  Defendants for failure to appear at mediation and for\n                  not complying with Rule 30(b)(6)\nBC      2/12/2016 Review of Plaintiff's Motion to Compel Deposition          1.40   $350.00\n                  Questions, and preparation of responsive email to\n                  Plaintiff's regarding objection to relief sought in the\n                  motion.\nBC      2/12/2016 Review, revision and filing of clients' Motions for        1.80   $350.00\n                  Summary Judgment\nBC      2/12/2016 Review of draft declarations for clients in support of     1.30   $350.00\n                  MSJ's\nBC      2/13/2016 Review of Plaintiffs Motions for Summary Judgment          2.10   $350.00\n                  and all attachments thereto\nBC      2/16/2016 Review of Court orders on telephonic hearings on           0.80   $350.00\n                  motions to compel\nBC      2/16/2016 Preparation of response to Plaintiffs Motion for           1.10   $350.00\n                  Protective Order\n\f  Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 5 of 20\n\n\nBC         5/25/2016 Review of Court's Order denying motion for sanctions           1.10     $350.00\n                     and ordering mediation, and review and response to\n                     emails regarding scheduling of mediation\nBC         5/31/2016 Review and response to emails from client and                  0.50     $350.00\n                     opposing counsel regarding mediation scheduling\nBC         5/31/2016 Review of order on Plaintiff's Motion in limine                0.80     $350.00\n\nBC         6/2/2016    Review of Court's Order granting in part Defendants          1.10     $350.00\n                       Motion for Summary Judgment, and denying Plaintiff's\n                       Motion for Summary Judgment\nBC         6/6/2016    Attendance at mediation conference with Mark                 3.00     $350.00\n                       Buckstein\nBC         6/6/2016    review of revised joint pretrial stipulation, revisions to   1.30     $350.00\n                       same\nBC         6/6/2016    Review of Plaintiff's Motion for Dismissal under 41(a),      1.30     $350.00\n                       and review of case law regarding same\nBC         6/7/2016    Review of Plaintiffs Rule 41 Motion for Dismissal of         0.60     $350.00\n                       Trademark Claims\nBC         6/7/2016    Review of order dismissing Counts VI-VIII                    0.40     $350.00\n\n                       Total BC:                                                    119.40\n\nValentin Gurvits\n\nVG         8/26/2015 Review Complaint; tel conf/w clients; tel conf w/Spencer 3.00           $450.00\n                     Freeman, tel conf w/Evan and Matt;!attenton to Motion to\n                     Remove Default.\nVG         9/1/2015 Attention to Answer and counterclaims                       3.00         $450.00\nVG         11/9/2015 Attention to discovery requests.                           2.75         $450.00\nVG         2/5/2016 Attention to discovery requests.                            3.50         $450.00\nVG         2/12/2016 Attention to Motions for Summary Judgment; layout          6.50         $450.00\n                     strategy; preliminary research; review undisputed facts;\n                     discuss with team; discuss with client.\nVG         2/18/2016 Attention to motion for sanctions; research and opposition 3.75         $450.00\n\nVG         3/10/2016   Attention to MSJ; attention to reply.                        3.50     $450.00\nVG         6/2/2016    Review the Order on MSJ.                                     1.00     $450.00\nVG         6/5/2016    Travel to Miami for court-ordered mediation.                 7.00     $450.00\nVG         6/6/2016    Meeting with clients re mediation. Attend mediation.         5.00     $450.00\n                       Travel to Boca Raton for mediation.\nVG         6/7/2016    Travel from court-orders mediation in Miami to Boston.       7.00     $450.00\n\n\n                       Total VG:                                                    46.00\n\nEvan Fray-Witzer\nEFW       8/5/2015     Copyright misuse legal research                              2.25     $450\n\f Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 6 of 20\n\n\nEFW     8/15/2015 Emails and calls with Val and Matt re: potential        1.00   $450\n                  default in Sun Social\nEFW     8/17/2015 Reviewing court order re: default; emails to and        1.00   $450\n                  from Val; call with Val\nEFW     8/25/2015 Legal research re: motion to set aside default -        7.00   $450\n                  Florida standards; research re: good cause\n                  standards; research for meritorious defenses;\n                  drafting motion to set aside default\nEFW     8/27/2015 Reviewing sun social complaint, reviewing and           8.00   $450\n                  editing timeline; continued drafting of motion to\n                  set aside default; reviewing MetArt's response to\n                  court's show cause order; reviewing proposed\n                  order; emails to and from Matt and Brady\nEFW     8/31/2015 Reviewing answer to complaint                           2.25   $450\nEFW     9/1/2015 Drafting counterclaim and research for same;             8.75   $450\n                  editing answer and affirmative defenses; multiple\n                  emails and calls with Val and Matt\nEFW     9/10/2015 Reviewing motion to strike affirmative defenses;        1.25   $450\n                  reviewing cases cited in motion, emails to Brady,\n                  Val, and Matt\nEFW     9/24/2015 Editing and redlining affirmative defenses              1.75   $450\nEFW     9/25/2015 Reviewing and editing revised affirmative               1.75   $450\n                  defenses\nEFW     9/25/2015 Emails with Matt and Brady; reviewing amended           1.00   $450\n                  complaint\nEFW     1/22/2016 Reviewing and redlining expert discovery                2.00   $450\n                  requests\nEFW     1/26/2016 Emails to and from Val, Brady, and Matt                 1.00   $450\nEFW     1/29/2016 Reviewing and redlining mediation statement             2.00   $450\nEFW     2/5/2016 Office conference re strategies and mediation; attn to   3.25   $450\n                  suplemental documents production; Drafting motion to\n                  amend scheduling order; Calls and emails w client;\n                  Drafting Amended Complaint w Counterclaims\n\nEFW     2/5/2016   Reviewing request for supplemental document            7.25   $450\n                   production, reviewing and redlining motion to\n                   amend scheduling order to allow for\n                   counterclaims, legal research for counterclaims,\n                   multiple emails with Matt and Val\nEFW     2/8/2016  Multiple emails with Val, Matt, and Brady               0.50   $450\nEFW     2/9/2016  Reviewing supplemental documents, reviewing             1.50   $450\n                  plaintiff's draft motion for sanctions\nEFW     2/11/2016 Multiple emails with Matt and Val, calls with           8.75   $450\n                  Matt, Val, and Brady, reviewing and redlining SJ\n                  drafts for SSM, legal research re: trademark\n                  claims, legal research for Luchien SJ motion\n\f  Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 7 of 20\n\n\nEFW        2/12/2016 Drafting Luchien SJ motion, reviewing and              9.25     $450\n                     redlining declarations, reviewing and redlining\n                     multiple SJ motion drafts, reviewing Plaintiff's\n                     motion for SJ\nEFW        2/18/2016 Reviewing and redlining opposition to motion for       11.50    $450\n                     sanctions against V. Gurvits, reviewing and\n                     revising opposition to motion for sanctions re\n                     Bolotin, redlining and revising opposition to\n                     motion for sanctions re: deposition questions,\n                     redlining and revising declarations\nEFW        2/19/2016 Drafting insert for 30(b)(6) sanctions opposition      6.50     $450\n                     and legal research for same, legal research for all\n                     sanctions motions, reviewing and revising draft\n                     oppositions, reviewing data and documents from\n                     clients, reviewing deposition transcripts for use in\n                     oppositions\nEFW        2/22/2016 Revising and redlining opposition to motion for        1.75     $450\n                     protective order\nEFW        2/25/2016 Reviewing errata sheets, reviewing proposed trial      5.25     $450\n                     exhibits, reviewing plaintiff's trial exhibits and\n                     objections thereto\nEFW        2/26/2016 Reviewing plaintiff's proposed jury instructions       6.50     $450\n                     and verdict form, copyright office research re:\n                     registrations, reviewing proposed trial\n                     stipulations, redlining stipulations, redlining\n                     proposed verdict form, reviewing defendants'\n                     proposed jury instructions\nEFW        2/27/2016 Drafting reply to Plaintiff's Opposition to admit      1.50     $450\n                     Val Gurvits pro hac vice\nEFW        2/29/2016 Redlining opposition to motion for summary             5.75     $450\n                     judgment, reviewing and redlining declarations,\n                     redlining opposition to statement of material facts\nEFW        3/4/2016 Redlining opposition to motions in limine               2.25     $450\nEFW        3/9/2016 Reviewing declarations and first draft of reply to      2.25     $450\n                     opposition to motions for summary judgment\nEFW        3/10/2016 Drafting Luchien's SJ reply brief                      3.5      $450\nEFW        6/6/2016 Drafting sections of amended joint pre-trial            5.25     $450\n                     stipulations, reviewing plaintiff's motion to\n                     dismiss, calls with Val, legal research re:\n                     opposition to motion to dismiss without prejudice\n\n                       Total EFW:                                           123.50\n\nMatthew Shayefar\nMS        7/30/2015 Attn to DMCA form; emails w opp counsel re service of   0.25     $300\n                    process and response deadlines\n\f Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 8 of 20\n\n\nMS      8/7/2015    Calls w Spencer and cocounsel re order to show cause        0.25   $300\n\nMS      8/17/2015 attn to service and default issues; emails re same            0.50   $300\nMS      8/26/2015 Attn to motion to vacate default                              3.50   $300\nMS      8/27/2015 Attn to filing of motion to set aside default                 0.50   $300\nMS      8/31/2015 Drafting answer to complaint; multiple emails and             3.50   $300\n                  conference calls; attn to SJR\nMS      9/1/2015 Attn to joint scheduling motion; drafting and filing           4.25   $300\n                  answer\nMS      10/6/2015 Attn to discovery requests and email to client re same        0.25   $300\n\nMS      10/14/2015 Drafting motion to amend answer                              1.00   $300\nMS      10/15/2015 Drafting and filing motion to amend answer                   0.25   $300\nMS      11/9/2015 Conference re outstanding discover                            0.25   $300\nMS      11/11/2015 Preparing and serving document responses                     3.50   $300\nMS      11/12/2015 Review documents for production; drafting opposition to      1.75   $300\n                   motion to strike\nMS      11/13/2015 attn document production                                     0.50   $300\nMS      11/16/2015 Review and redraft opposition to motion to strike; Skype     0.75   $300\n                   and chat w client re document production\nMS      11/17/2015 Emails and skype w client re document production;            1.25   $300\n                   preparation and serving of supplemental documents\nMS      12/2/2015 Review and attn to motion to compel; Calls w client re        0.75   $300\n                   discovery requests\nMS      12/7/2015 Review mediation documents; review subpoenas; review          0.25   $300\n                   client emails and discovery issues\nMS      12/10/2015 Drafting opposition to motion to compel                      3.00   $300\nMS      12/16/2015 Preparation for hearing on motion to compel                  0.25   $300\nMS      12/18/2015 Attn to documents from florida and delaware; emails w        0.50   $300\n                   clients and cocounsel re same\nMS      12/28/2015 Attn to deposition notices; attn to outstanding discovery;   5.25   $300\n                   research for motion to bifurcate; drafting motion to\n                   bifurcate\nMS      12/29/2015 research and drafting of motion to bifurcate                 1.50   $300\nMS      12/31/2015 emails and skype w client re outstanding discovery           0.25   $300\n                   requests\nMS      1/4/2016 Drafting responses to 2nd set of RFPs; Drafting RFPs to        2.75   $300\n                   Hydentra; many calls and emails w client re discovery\n                   responses\nMS      1/5/2016 drafting interrogatory responses; many emails skype and        5.75   $300\n                   calls w client and cocounsel re same\nMS      1/6/2016 drafting interrogatory responses; preparing document           4.00   $300\n                   responses; preparing discovery requests; many calls\n                   emails and skype w client re same\nMS      1/7/2016 Attn to updated depo notice; emails w cocounsel re same        0.25   $300\n\nMS      1/8/2016    Emails and skype with client re user email                  0.25   $300\n\f Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 9 of 20\n\n\nMS      1/12/2016 Email to clients w deposition notices; email to clients re   0.25   $300\n                  preparation for depositions\nMS      1/25/2016 Attn to premediation deadlines and requirements              0.25   $300\nMS      1/26/2016 Drafting Jusino affidavit                                    0.50   $300\nMS      1/29/2016 Attn to number of allegedly infringed works; drafting        2.00   $300\n                  case summary for mediation\nMS      2/5/2016 Office conference re strategies and mediation; attn to        3.25   $300\n                  suplemental documents production; Drafting motion to\n                  amend scheduling order; Calls and emails w client;\n                  Drafting Amended Complaint w Counterclaims\n\nMS      2/8/2016    Emails w cocounsel and opp counsel; document review re 0.75       $300\n                    supplemtnal production; communicate with client re same\n\nMS      2/9/2016    Review document production by Hydentra; Preparing and 1.75        $300\n                    serve supplemental document responses; preparation for\n                    motions for summary judgment; review discovery\n                    responses from hydentra\n\nMS      2/10/2016 Attn to motions filed by plaintiff; Preparation for motions 3.25    $300\n                  for summary judgment; research and document review re\n                  same\nMS      2/11/2016 drafting and researching and preparing motions for          12.50   $300\n                  summary judgment and related documents\nMS      2/12/2016 Drafting and researching and preparing motions for          6.50    $300\n                  summary judgment and related documents\nMS      2/16/2016 Attn to multiple emails w cocounsel and clients re          0.75    $300\n                  scheduling and upcoming deadlines and strategy\n                  Office conference regarding responses to plaintiff's\n                  motions\nMS      2/18/2016 Drafting opposition to motion for sanctions re Gurvits;     6.75    $300\n                  Drafting opposition to for sanctions re deposition\n                  testimony\nMS      2/19/2016 Drafting and filing multiple responses to plaintiff's       4.00    $300\n                  motions\nMS      2/21/2016 Attn to preparing for filing responses to plaintiff's       0.50    $300\n                  motions\nMS      2/22/2016 Call w client re deposition transcripts; review filings by 0.50     $300\n                  plaintiff and emails re same w cocounsel\nMS      2/24/2016 Drafting errata sheet for bolotin deposition transcripts    1.00    $300\n\nMS      2/25/2016 Preparing errata sheet for luchian deposition transcript;    4.00   $300\n                  drafting pre-trial stipulations and other pretrial documents\n                  due today\nMS      2/26/2016 drafting pre-trial stipulations; jury instructions; trial    7.75   $300\n                  exhibits and other pretrial documents due today;\n                  reviewing plaintiff's same\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 10 of 20\n\n\nMS     2/28/2016 Drafting Opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment        6.00     $300\n\nMS     2/29/2016 Drafting and preparing for filing opposition to motion for 8.25    $300\n                 summary judgment\nMS     3/3/2016 Preparing for opposition to motions in limine               0.25    $300\nMS     3/4/2016 Drafting opposition to motions in limine                    5.25    $300\nMS     3/9/2016 Drafting and researching for reply to MSJs                  8.25    $300\nMS     3/10/2016 Drafting reply in support of MSJs and all documents        8.75    $300\n                 related thereto; review of plaintiff's msj reply\nMS     4/5/2016 Office conferece; review pretrial documents                 0.25    $300\nMS     6/6/2016                                                             3.50    $300\n                 Review order on motions for summary judgment;\n                 conference calls re same; drafting pretrial stipulations;\n                 drafting motion for separate and final judgment\nMS     6/7/2016 Attn to motion to dismiss TM claims; various emails and 0.25        $300\n                 calls w cocounsel re case\nMS     9/16/2016 Attn to scheduling order; calendaring deadlines            0.25    $300\nMS     9/17/2016 Drafting amended affirmative defenses                      1.25    $300\nMS     9/21/2016 Attn to PHV Applications                                   0.25    $300\nMS     9/25/2016 Attn to amended answerand amended affirmative              0.75    $300\n                 defenses\nMS     9/29/2016 Completing PHV applications                                0.50    $300\n\n\n                  Total MS:                                                147.00\n\n                  TOTALS:                                                  435.90\n\f Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 11 of 20\n\n\n\n\n      total\n\n$350.00\n\n$350.00\n\n\n$350.00\n\n$350.00\n\n$280.00\n\n$350.00\n\n$280.00\n$70.00\n\n$490.00\n\n$1,050.00\n$455.00\n$420.00\n\n$280.00\n$350.00\n\n$70.00\n$280.00\n$210.00\n\n$385.00\n\n$420.00\n\n$385.00\n\n$140.00\n\f Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 12 of 20\n\n\n$175.00\n$210.00\n\n\n$210.00\n$280.00\n\n$385.00\n\n$385.00\n\n$385.00\n$245.00\n\n\n$385.00\n$315.00\n\n$385.00\n$280.00\n\n$140.00\n$315.00\n\n\n$350.00\n$2,555.00\n\n$385.00\n\n$315.00\n\n$315.00\n\n\n$385.00\n$140.00\n\n$210.00\n$490.00\n\n$560.00\n\n\n$875.00\n\f Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 13 of 20\n\n\n$280.00\n\n$385.00\n\n$385.00\n$490.00\n\n$140.00\n\n$175.00\n\n\n$210.00\n$1,190.00\n$1,120.00\n\n$280.00\n\n$385.00\n$245.00\n$140.00\n\n\n$350.00\n\n$280.00\n\n$385.00\n\n$315.00\n\n\n$350.00\n$385.00\n\n$700.00\n\n\n$490.00\n\n\n\n\n$630.00\n\n$455.00\n\f Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 14 of 20\n\n\n$735.00\n\n$280.00\n\n$385.00\n\n$1,190.00\n$1,120.00\n\n$280.00\n\n$385.00\n$245.00\n$140.00\n\n\n$350.00\n\n$280.00\n\n$385.00\n\n$315.00\n\n\n$350.00\n$385.00\n\n$700.00\n\n\n$490.00\n\n\n\n\n$630.00\n\n$455.00\n\n$735.00\n\n$280.00\n\n$385.00\n\f Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 15 of 20\n\n\n$385.00\n\n\n$175.00\n\n$280.00\n\n$385.00\n\n\n$1,050.00\n\n$455.00\n\n$455.00\n\n$210.00\n\n$140.00\n\n$41,790.00\n\n\n\n\n$1,350.00\n\n\n$1,350.00\n$1,237.50\n$1,575.00\n$2,925.00\n\n\n$1,687.50\n\n$1,575.00\n$450.00\n$3,150.00\n$2,250.00\n\n$3,150.00\n\n\n$20,700.00\n\n\n$1,012.50\n\f Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 16 of 20\n\n\n$450.00\n\n$450.00\n\n$3,150.00\n\n\n\n\n$3,600.00\n\n\n\n\n$1,012.50\n$3,937.50\n\n\n$562.50\n\n\n$787.50\n$787.50\n\n$450.00\n\n$900.00\n\n$450.00\n$900.00\n$1,462.50\n\n\n\n\n$3,262.50\n\n\n\n\n$225.00\n$675.00\n\n$3,937.50\n\f Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 17 of 20\n\n\n$4,162.50\n\n\n\n\n$5,175.00\n\n\n\n\n$2,925.00\n\n\n\n\n$787.50\n\n$2,362.50\n\n\n$2,925.00\n\n\n\n\n$675.00\n\n$2,587.50\n\n\n$1,012.50\n$1,012.50\n\n$1,575.00\n$2,362.50\n\n\n\n\n$55,575.00\n\n\n$75\n\f Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 18 of 20\n\n\n$75\n\n$150\n$1,050\n$150\n$1,050\n\n$1,275\n\n$75\n\n$300\n$75\n$75\n$1,050\n$525\n\n$150\n$225\n\n$375\n\n$225\n\n$75\n\n$900\n$75\n$150\n\n$1,575\n\n\n$450\n$75\n\n$825\n\n\n$1,725\n\n$1,200\n\n\n$75\n\n$75\n\f Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 19 of 20\n\n\n$75\n\n$75\n$150\n$600\n\n$975\n\n\n\n\n$225\n\n\n$525\n\n\n\n\n$975\n\n\n$3,750\n\n$1,950\n\n$225\n\n\n\n\n$2,025\n\n\n$1,200\n\n$150\n\n$150\n\n$300\n\n$1,200\n\n\n$2,325\n\f Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 20 of 20\n\n\n$1,800\n\n$2,475\n\n$75\n$1,575\n$2,475\n$2,625\n\n$75\n$1,050\n\n\n\n\n$75\n\n$75\n$375\n$75\n$225\n\n$150\n\n\n$44,025\n\n$162,090.00\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2024-06-29T12:28:04.004624-07:00","document_number":"148","attachment_number":2,"pacer_doc_id":"051016810053","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Exhibit","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/404233392/","id":404233392,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/148/3/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2024-06-29T11:54:25.167386-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-30T02:07:14.056921-07:00","sha1":"1951fbda6eb6c5b5ddc1bf5bd72cb55f94821271","page_count":3,"file_size":267957,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.148.3.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.148.3.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 1 of 3\n\n\n\n\n                                  UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                                  SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA\n\n                                              MIAMI DIVISION\n\n                                       CASE NO.: 1:15-cv-22134-UU\n\n   HYDENTRA HLP INT. LIMITED,\n   a foreign corporation d/b/a METART,\n\n                   Plaintiff,\n\n   vs.\n\n   CONSTANTIN LUCHIAN, an individual,\n   KONSTANTIN BOLOTIN, an individual,\n   SUN SOCIAL MEDIA, INC., a corporation,\n   individually and d/b/a PLAYVID.COM,\n   FEEDVID.COM, PLAYVIDS.COM, and\n   PEEKVIDS. COM; PLAYVID.COM;\n   FEEDVID.COM; PLAYVIDS. COM;\n   PEEKVIDS.COM and;\n   and John Does 1-20,\n\n               Defendants.\n   __________________________________________/\n\n                                 DECLARATION OF BRADY J. COBB\n\n           I, Brady J. Cobb, do hereby depose and swear as follows:\n\n           1.      I am an attorney admitted to practice and in good standing in the State of Florida.\n\n           2.      I received my B.S. degree from Florida State University in 2002 and my J.D. from Barry\n\n   University School of Law in 2006.\n\n           3.      I have been a member of the Florida Bar since 2006, a member of the bar of the United\n\n   States District Court for the Districts of Florida and the Middle District of Florida since 2007, a member\n\n   of the bar for of the First Circuit Court of Appeals since 1997, a member of the bar of the United States\n\n   District Court for the Northern District of California since 2010, a member of the bar for of the United\n\n   States District Court for the Eastern District of Wisconsin since 2013, a member of the Ninth Circuit\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 2 of 3\n\n\n\n   Court of Appeals since 2013, and a member of the bar for the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals since\n\n   2016.\n\n           4.       I have been admitted pro hac vice in cases in the Federal District Courts in the Northern\n\n   District of California, the Eastern District of Wisconsin, and the United States Bankruptcy Court for the\n\n   Northern District of Texas\n\n           5.       I have been counsel of record in forty-six (46) cases in the United States District Court\n\n   for the Southern District of Florida, in addition to dozens of cases in other District Courts, including eight\n\n   (8) copyright cases in this District, and several cases in the courts of appeal\n\n           6.       I am a co-founder of Cobb Eddy, PLLC, which began operating in 2012. Prior to that, I\n\n   was an associate and then a partner at the law firm of Tripp Scott, P.A. in Fort Lauderdale, Florida. Prior\n\n   to that, I interned during law school and ultimately was an associate with the law firm of Hilyard Bogan\n\n   & Palmer in Orlando, Florida. Prior to that, I was a summer intern in the Federal Public Defenders Office\n\n   in the Middle District of Florida.\n\n           7.       In this case, I have the primary counsel of record for Defendants, and I was joined by\n\n   Valentin Gurvits, Esquire from the Boston Law Group via his admittance pro hac vice on February 29,\n\n   2016. (D.E. 118).\n\n           8.       My hourly rate in this matter has been $350 per hour. It is my understanding that this\n\n   rate is considered to be somewhat under-market for an attorney with close to than ten (10) years of\n\n   experience, particularly for attorneys practicing in the area of high-tech copyright litigation.\n\n           9.       My firm does not typically charge for many of the overhead expenses routinely billed to\n\n   clients by other firms. For example, although I performed many hours of online database (Lexis) research\n\n   in this matter, we do not pass along the Lexis costs to the client. I have also not billed the client for any\n\n   in-house copying, mailing, or delivery costs.\n\n           10.      The present case was a time intensive one, made more so by the aggressive litigation\n\n   positions taken by the Plaintiff which included numerous (unnecessary and unsuccessful) motions\n\n   brought by the Plaintiffs throughout the case. More specifically, Plaintiff filed the following unnecessary\n\n                                                          2\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 3 of 3\n\n\n\n   motions, all of which required a substantive response: (a) Motion to Stroke Amended Affirmative\n\n   Defenses (D.E. 41), and ultimately this Court upheld fifteen of Defendants sixteen Defendants affirmative\n\n   defenses, and struck one, (b) Motion to Compel Answers to Plaintiff\u2019s Request for Production (D.E. 51),\n\n   which after a hearing was largely denied, (c) Motion for Protective Order, which was granted through\n\n   agreement of counsel after a hearing (d) Motion for Sanctions against Valentin Gurvits (D.E. 69), which\n\n   was denied after a hearing, (e) Motion for Sanctions against Defendants (D.E. 70), which was denied after\n\n   a hearing, (f) Motion to Compel Arising from Instructions Not to Answer etc (D.E. 71), which was denied\n\n   after a hearing, and (g) Plaintiff vigorously opposed the routine pro hac vice admission of Valentin\n\n   Gurvits, and said admission was ultimately granted. (D.E. 118).\n\n           11.     Despite all of this, I believe that the total amounts invoiced to the clients by the entire\n\n   litigation defense team \u2013 a total of $161,490.00\u2013 were incredibly reasonable, particularly given the work\n\n   resulted in summary judgment being granted to Defendants.\n\n           12.     It is my practice to keep contemporaneous time and expense records. I track my time and\n\n   expenses through my billing software, CLIO. Co-counsel and the litigation provided me with their time\n\n   and expense records, and the full detailed bill is attached to the Motion for Attorney\u2019s Fees filed\n\n   contemporaneously herewith.\n\n           13.     Given the complexity of the issues raised, the Plaintiffs\u2019 litigation strategy, and the\n\n   results obtained for the clients, I believe the amounts billed to be more than reasonable.\n\n           Signed under the pains and penalties of perjury this 1st day of August, 2016.\n\n\n\n\n                                                                       Brady J. Cobb, Esquire\n\n\n\n\n                                                         3\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2024-06-29T12:28:04.387664-07:00","document_number":"148","attachment_number":3,"pacer_doc_id":"051016810054","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Affidavit","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/404233393/","id":404233393,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/148/4/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2024-06-29T11:54:25.469706-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-30T02:07:14.029916-07:00","sha1":"8479f5dff5d42f82aec0fce205c52cca309daa38","page_count":9,"file_size":455020,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.148.4.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.148.4.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-4 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 1 of 9\n\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA\n\nMIAMI DIVISION\n\nCase No.\nHYDENTRA HLP INT. LIMITED, 1:15-cy-22134-UU\na foreign corporation d/b/a METART,\n\nPlaintiff,\nv.\n\nCONSTANTIN LUCHIAN, an individual,\nKONSTANTIN BOLOTIN, an individual,\nSUN SOCIAL MEDIA, INC., a corporation,\nindividually and d/b/a PLAYVID.COM,\nFEEDVID.COM, PLAY VIDS.COM and\nPEEK VIDS.COM; PLAYVID.COM;\nFEEDVID.COM; PLAYVIDS.COM;\n\nPEEK VIDS.COM; and\n\nJohn Does 1-20,\n\nDefendants.\n\nDeclaration of Valentin Gurvits\n\nI, Valentin Gurvits, do declare and state as follows:\n\n1. I am attorney licensed to practice law in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. I\nhave personal knowledge of the facts stated herein. If called upon to do so, I could and would\ntestify to the truth hereof.\n\n1. I worked as a computer programmer and in other computer-related positions from\n1985 to 1996, and I received my J.D. from the Boston University School of Law in 1999.\n\n2. I have been a member in good standing of the Massachusetts Bar since 1999,\n\n3, My practice focuses primarily on intellectual property, computer, and Internet law\n\nmatters.\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-4 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 2 of 9\n\n4, I have represented defendants in many copyright cases similar to the above\ncaptioned case around the country, including (to name just a few): Disney Enterprises, Inc. v.\n\nHotfile Corp., Case No. 1:20] 1-cv-20427 (S.D, Fla.), Fraserside IP LLC v. Youngtek Solutions\n\nLtd, 3:2011-cv-03005 (N.D. Iowa), Fraserside IP LLC v. Hammy Media Ltd, 3:2011-cv-03025\n\n(N.D. lowa); Cybernet Entertainment LLC v. Kovalchuck, 0:2012-cv-60660 (S.D. Fla.),\nCybernet Entertainment LLC v. IG Media Incorporated, 2:2012-cv-01101 (D. Ariz.), Flava\n\nWorks, Inc v, John Doe | to 26, 1:2012-cv-05844 (N.D. Ill.), Datatech Enterprises, LLC v. FF\n\nMagnat Limited, 3:2012-cv-04500 (N.D. Cal.), North Jersey Media Group Inc. v. Depositphotos.\n\nInc., 1:2014-cv-04785 (S.D.N.Y.) and AMA Multimedia, LLC v. Borjan Solutions, S.L., 2:2015-\n\ncv-01673 (D. Nev.).\n\n5, As a result of my focus on defending Internet companies in copyright litigation\nand advising Internet companies world-wide, I have served as an adjunct professor at the Boston\nUniversity School of Law where | taught two courses, E-Commerce Law and International\nIntellectual Property.\n\n6. [have also served as a co-chair of the Computer and Internet Law Committee of\nthe Boston Bar Association\u2019s Intellectual Property Section.\n\n7. [have served as Sun Social Media, Inc.\u2019s de facto outside general counsel since\nits inception.\n\n8. [have represented Constantin Luchian and Konstantin Bolotin in both litigation\nand non-litigation matters for both business and personal matters for over six years.\n\n9. Attached hereto are true copies of Boston Law Group\u2019s Engagement Letters with\nConstantin Luchian, Constantin Bolotin and SunSocial \u2014 the Defendants in the above-captioned\n\naction.\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-4 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 3 of 9\n\n10. Of the at least eighteen lawsuits filed by the Plaintiff in the above captioned\nmatter in the past approximate year around the country, I have represented defendants in at least\n\n~ nine of those cases.\n\n11. Of those nine cases, I have been instrumental in settling lawsuits for at least five\nof my clients.\n\n12. My hourly rate in this matter has been $450 per hour. It is my understanding that\nthis rate is considered under-market for an attorney with my level of experience, technical\nbackground and specialization in intellectual property and internet related law.\n\n13. The present case was a time intensive one, made more so by the aggressive\nlitigation positions taken by the Plaintiff which included numerous (unnecessary and\nunsuccessful) motions brought by Plaintiffs throughout the case.\n\n14. Despite all of this, I believe that the total amounts invoiced to the clients by the\nentire litigation defense team ~ in the neighborhood of $150,000 ~- were incredibly reasonable,\nparticularly given the results obtained.\n\n15. It is my practice to keep contemporaneous time and expense records. I track my\ntime and expenses related to this matter through the billing software Amicus Attomey. The time\nand expenses I track in Amicus Attorney are automatically incorporated into Boston Law Group,\nPC\u2019s invoices.\n\n16. Given the complexity of the issues raised, the Plaintiff's litigation strategies and\ntactics, and the results obtained for the clients, I believe the amounts billed to be more than\n\nreasonable.\n\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-4 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 4 of 9\n\nBoston Law Group, PC Terms and Conditions of Engagement\n\nThe following are Boston Law Group, PC\u2019s terms and conditions for client representation:\n\n1. Fees and Hourly Rates. Our fees are charged according to the time devoted to the\nengagement and are calculated according to hourly rates for professional services. Our current\nbilling rate is $450 per hour for senior attorneys and $300 per hour for junior attorneys, billed in\nfifteen minute increments, The time devoted to your matter for which you will be billed may\ninclude consultations, correspondence, meetings, telephone calls, negotiations, factual\ninvestigations, legal research, document preparation, travel away from the office on your behalf,\nand any other work related to your matter.\n\nOur hourly rates are subject to review and change periodically, generally at the beginning of a\nnew calendar year. The hourly rate you are charged is specified on your statement and any\nchange in the rate set forth on the statement will constitute notice of a change in rates.\n\n2. Disbursements. The performance of legal services involves certain costs and expenses\nthat you must pay, either directly or by reimbursing us. We will bill you for smaller expenses\nincurred in the normal course of work, such as filing fees, computerized research, long-distance\ntelephone charges, overnight mail charges, sending and receiving facsimiles, photocopying\ncharges, messenger services, and travel expenses (e.g., mileage, meals, parking, lodging, etc.).\nWe bill local, long distance and international faxes at $.25, $.50 and $1 per page, respectively,\nand photocopies are billed at $.15 per page. All other disbursements are billed at cost. In\ncircumstances involving larger expenses, such as IRS filing fees, specialized reports or analyses,\nairfare, or extended field expenses, we may require you to advance these sums to us before we\nincur the expenses, or we may require that you directly reimburse the vendor.\n\n3, Monthly Statements and Payment Terms. Our practice is to send monthly statements for\nservices rendered during the previous month and for any disbursements incurred for your\naccount. The monthly statements will itemize the services provided in a diary format, and they\nwill separately state the fees and disbursements incurred.\n\nOur fee structure is based upon an understanding that all statements are due and payable upon\nreceipt but, in any event, no later than thirty (30) days thereafter. We reserve the right to charge\na monthly late payment fee, at the rate of eighteen percent (18%) per year, computed from thirty\n(30) days after the statement\u2019s issuance date until paid. In the event it becomes necessary for us\nto engage a collection agency or take legal action for the collection of fees and disbursements,\nyou agree to be responsible for the costs associated with such actions, including the reasonable\nfees of outside counsel retained for the purpose of collection.\n\nWe work hard to ensure that our clients are satisfied, not just with our services but also with the\nreasonableness of our fees and the disbursements charged for those services. Thus, if you have a\nquestion about a billing statement or the basis for our fees, please raise it promptly for\ndiscussion.\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-4 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 5 of 9\n\n4. File Retention and Destruction. At the conclusion of this matter, we will retain your legal\nfiles for a period of three (3) years after we close our file. At the expiration of the three-year\nperiod, we will destroy these files unless you notify us in writing that you wish to take\npossession of them. We reserve the right to charge administrative fees and costs associated with\nresearching retrieving, copying and delivering such files.\n\n5. Retainer. It is the firm's policy to obtain a retainer before beginning work. We may\nwaive that requirement in certain circumstances while reserving the right to request a retainer in\nthe future. The amount of any retainer we request will depend on the nature and amount of\nanticipated services, but it does not necessarily represent our estimate of the total charges that\nmay be incurred. The amount of any retainer may be applied against our legal fees and\ndisbursements except to the extent otherwise agreed. We reserve the right to require that you\nrestore the retainer to its original amount if it becomes depleted or when it drops below an\nagreed-upon amount. In order to begin representation, we would require a retainer of: N/A.\n\nThe retainer will be held in our lawyer trust account and applied to our fees and\ndisbursements in the event you fail to timely pay any monthly statement. We reserve the right to\nrequest additional retainers from time to time, and will do so in the event our work for you is\nexpected to exceed this amount in any given month (e.g. if we are asked to work on substantive\nmatters including research, discovery, attend hearings, or trial). If, at the completion of the\nmatter, or upon termination of our legal services, the total of our legal fees and disbursements is\nless than the amount of any retainer, the balance will be promptly refunded to you.\n\n6. Withdrawal from Representation. The attorney-client relationship is founded upon\nmutual trust and confidence. If you have any questions about the provisions of this letter or the\nservices that we provide, please contact us for clarification or additional information. If you do\nnot meet the obligation of timely payment as set forth above, we reserve the right to withdraw\nfrom representation on that basis alone, subject, of course, to any required judicial or\nadministrative approval,\n\nOur representation may also be terminated by either party upon reasonable notice for any reason.\nUpon such termination, however, you shall remain liable for any unpaid fees and disbursements\nincurred prior to the effective date of the termination.\n\nName: Kensfoudin Bolofin BOSTO UP, PC\n\nDate: FES LOWE Date: OME [LOIS\n\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-4 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 6 of 9\n\nBoston Law Group, PC Terms and Conditions of Engagement\n\nThe following are Boston Law Group, PC\u2019s terms and conditions for client representation:\n\n1. Fees and Hourly Rates. Our fees are charged according to the time devoted to the\nengagement and are calculated according to hourly rates for professional services. Our current\nbilling rate is $450 per hour for senior attorneys and $300 per hour for junior attorneys, billed in\nfifteen minute increments. The time devoted to your matter for which you will be billed may\ninclude consultations, correspondence, meetings, telephone calls, negotiations, factual\ninvestigations, legal research, document preparation, travel away from the office on your behalf,\nand any other work related to your matter.\n\nOur hourly rates are subject to review and change periodically, generally at the beginning of a\nnew calendar year. The hourly rate you are charged is specified on your statement and any\nchange in the rate set forth on the statement will constitute notice of a change in rates.\n\n2. Disbursements. The performance of legal services involves certain costs and expenses\nthat you must pay, either directly or by reimbursing us. We will bill you for smaller expenses\nincurred in the normal course of work, such as filing fees, computerized research, long-distance\ntelephone charges, overnight mail charges, sending and receiving facsimiles, photocopying\ncharges, messenger services, and travel expenses (e.g., mileage, meals, parking, lodging, etc.).\nWe bill local, long distance and international faxes at $.25, $.50 and $1 per page, respectively,\nand photocopies are billed at $.15 per page. All other disbursements are billed at cost. In\ncircumstances involving larger expenses, such as IRS filing fees, specialized reports or analyses,\nairfare, or extended field expenses, we may require you to advance these sums to us before we\nincur the expenses, or we may require that you directly reimburse the vendor.\n\n3. Monthly Statements and Payment Terms, Our practice is to send monthly statements for\nservices rendered during the previous month and for any disbursements incurred for your\n\naccount, The monthly statements will itemize the services provided in a diary format, and they\nwill separately state the fees and disbursements incurred.\n\nOur fee structure is based upon an understanding that all statements are due and payable upon\nreceipt but, in any event, no later than thirty (30) days thereafter. We reserve the right to charge\na monthly late payment fee, at the rate of eighteen percent (18%) per year, computed from thirty\n(30) days after the statement\u2019s issuance date until paid. In the event it becomes necessary for us\nto engage a collection agency or take legal action for the collection of fees and disbursements,\nyou agree to be responsible for the costs associated with such actions, including the reasonable\nfees of outside counsel retained for the purpose of collection.\n\nWe work hard to ensure that our clients are satisfied, not just with our services but also with the\nreasonableness of our fees and the disbursements charged for those services. Thus, if you have a\nquestion about a billing statement or the basis for our fees, please raise it promptly for\ndiscussion.\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-4 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 7 of 9\n\n4, File Retention and Destruction. At the conclusion of this matter, we will retain your legal\nfiles for a period of three (3) years after we close our file. At the expiration of the three-year\nperiod, we will destroy these files unless you notify us in writing that you wish to take\npossession of them, We reserve the right to charge administrative fees and costs associated with\nresearching retrieving, copying and delivering such files.\n\n5. Retainer. Itis the firm\u2019s policy to obtain a retainer before beginning work. We may\nwaive that requirement in certain circumstances while reserving the right to request a retainer in\nthe future. The amount of any retainer we request will depend on the nature and amount of\nanticipated services, but it does not necessarily represent our estimate of the total charges that\nmay be incurred. The amount of any retainer may be applied against our legal fees and\ndisbursements except to the extent otherwise agreed. We reserve the right to require that you\nrestore the retainer to its original amount if it becomes depleted or when it drops below an\nagreed-upon amount. In order to begin representation, we would require a retainer of: N/A.\n\nThe retainer will be held in our lawyer trust account and applied to our fees and\ndisbursements in the event you fail to timely pay any monthly statement. We reserve the right to\nrequest additional retainers from time to time, and will do so in the event our work for you is\nexpected to exceed this amount in any given month (e.g. if we are asked to work on substantive\nmatters including research, discovery, attend hearings, or trial). If, at the completion of the\nmatter, or upon termination of our legal services, the total of our legal fees and disbursements is\nless than the amount of any retainer, the balance will be promptly refunded to you.\n\n6. Withdrawal from Representation. The attorney-client relationship is founded upon\nmutual trust and confidence. If you have any questions about the provisions of this letter or the\nservices that we provide, please contact us for clarification or additional information. If you do\nnot meet the obligation of timely payment as set forth above, we reserve the right to withdraw\nfrom representation on that basis alone, subject, of course, to any required judicial or\nadministrative approval.\n\nOur representation may also be terminated by either party upon reasonable notice for any reason.\nUpon such termination, however, you shall remain liable for any unpaid fees and disbursements\nincurred prior to the effective date of the termination.\n\nName: Sun Secial Media fc BOSTONTAW GROUP, PC\n\nt\n\n(ML Mil2\nDate F/46 (L008 nk \u00a5/ / \u00e9/ LOLS\n\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-4 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 8 of 9\n\nBoston Law Group, PC Terms and Conditions of Engagement\n\nThe following are Boston Law Group, PC\u2019s terms and conditions for client representation:\n\n1. Fees and Hourly Rates. Our fees are charged according to the time devoted to the\nengagement and are calculated according to hourly rates for professional services. Our current\nbilling rate is $450 per hour for senior attorneys and $300 per hour for junior attorneys, billed in\nfifteen minute increments. The time devoted to your matter for which you will be billed may\ninclude consultations, correspondence, meetings, telephone calls, negotiations, factual\ninvestigations, legal research, document preparation, travel away from the office on your behalf,\nand any other work related to your matter.\n\nOur hourly rates are subject to review and change periodically, generally at the beginning of a\nnew calendar year. The hourly rate you are charged is specified on your statement and any\nchange in the rate set forth on the statement will constitute notice of a change in rates.\n\n2. Disbursements. The performance of legal services involves certain costs and expenses\nthat you must pay, either directly or by reimbursing us. We will bill you for smaller expenses\nincurred in the normal course of work, such as filing fees, computerized research, long-distance\ntelephone charges, overnight mail charges, sending and receiving facsimiles, photocopying\ncharges, messenger services, and travel expenses (e.g., mileage, meals, parking, lodging, etc.).\nWe bill local, long distance and international faxes at $.25, $.50 and $1 per page, respectively,\nand photocopies are billed at $.15 per page. All other disbursements are billed at cost. In\ncircumstances involving larger expenses, such as IRS filing fees, specialized reports or analyses,\nairfare, or extended field expenses, we may require you to advance these sums to us before we\nincur the expenses, or we may require that you directly reimburse the vendor.\n\n3. Monthly Statements and Payment Terms. Our practice is to send monthly statements for\nservices rendered during the previous month and for any disbursements incurred for your\naccount. The monthly statements will itemize the services provided in a diary format, and they\nwill separately state the fees and disbursements incurred.\n\nOur fee structure is based upon an understanding that all statements are due and payable upon\nreceipt but, in any event, no later than thirty (30) days thereafter. We reserve the right to charge\na monthly late payment fee, at the rate of eighteen percent (18%) per year, computed from thirty\n(30) days after the statement\u2019s issuance date until paid. In the event it becomes necessary for us\nto engage a collection agency or take legal action for the collection of fees and disbursements,\nyou agree to be responsible for the costs associated with such actions, including the reasonable\nfees of outside counsel retained for the purpose of collection.\n\nWe work hard to ensure that our clients are satisfied, not just with our services but also with the\nreasonableness of our fees and the disbursements charged for those services. Thus, if you have a\nquestion about a billing statement or the basis for our fees, please raise it promptly for\ndiscussion.\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-4 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 9 of 9\n\n4. File Retention and Destruction. At the conclusion of this matter, we will retain your legal\nfiles for a period of three (3) years after we close our file. At the expiration of the three-year\nperiod, we will destroy these files unless you notify us in writing that you wish to take\npossession of them. We reserve the right to charge administrative fees and costs associated with\nresearching retrieving, copying and delivering such files.\n\n5. Retainer. It is the firm's policy to obtain a retainer before beginning work, We may\nwaive that requirement in certain circumstances while reserving the right to request a retainer in\nthe future. The amount of any retainer we request will depend on the nature and amount of\nanticipated services, but it does not necessarily represent our estimate of the total charges that\nmay be incurred. The amount of any retainer may be applied against our legal fees and\ndisbursements except to the extent otherwise agreed. We reserve the right to require that you\nrestore the retainer to its original amount if it becomes depleted or when it drops below an\nagreed-upon amount. In order to begin representation, we would require a retainer of: N/A.\n\nThe retainer will be held in our lawyer trust account and applied to our fees and\ndisbursements in the event you fail to timely pay any monthly statement. We reserve the right to\nrequest additional retainers from time to time, and will do so in the event our work for you is\nexpected to exceed this amount in any given month (e.g. if we are asked to work on substantive\nmatters including research, discovery, attend hearings, or trial). If, at the completion of the\nmatter, or upon termination of our legal services, the total of our legal fees and disbursements is\nless than the amount of any retainer, the balance will be promptly refunded to you.\n\n6. Withdrawal from Representation. The attorney-client relationship is founded upon\nmutual trust and confidence. If you have any questions about the provisions of this letter or the\nservices that we provide, please contact us for clarification or additional information. If you do\nnot meet the obligation of timely payment as set forth above, we reserve the right to withdraw\nfrom representation on that basis alone, subject, of course, to any required judicial or\nadministrative approval.\n\nOur representation may also be terminated by either party upon reasonable notice for any reason.\nUpon such termination, however, you shail remain liable for any unpaid fees and disbursements\nincurred prior to the effective date of the termination.\n\nText\nName; BOSTONTAW-GROUP, PC\n\nBy: Mav.\n\nConstantin Luchian\nDate: July 16, 2015 \u201cT\u2019 i / 6. ok\n\n","ocr_status":1,"date_upload":"2024-06-29T12:28:04.787806-07:00","document_number":"148","attachment_number":4,"pacer_doc_id":"051016810055","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Affidavit","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/404233394/","id":404233394,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/148/5/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2024-06-29T11:54:25.586345-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-30T02:07:13.021134-07:00","sha1":"25b9a670378803cedc69d6e3c66fe53038582244","page_count":3,"file_size":220632,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.148.5.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.148.5.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-5 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 1 of 3\n\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA\n\nMIAMI DIVISION\n\nHYDENTRA HLP INT. LIMITED,\na foreign corporation d/b/a METART,\n\nPlaintiff, Case No.\n1:15-cv-22134-UU\nV.\n\nCONSTANTIN LUCHIAN, an individual,\nKONSTANTIN BOLOTIN, an individual,\nSUN SOCIAL MEDIA, INC., a corporation,\nindividually and d/b/a PLAY VID.COM,\nFEEDVID.COM, PLAYVIDS.COM and\nPEEKVIDS.COM; PLAYVID.COM;\nFEEDVID.COM; PLAY VIDS.COM;\n\nPEEK VIDS.COM; and\n\nJohn Does 1-20,\n\nDefendants.\n\nDECLARATION OF MATTHEW SHAYEFAR\n\nL, Matthew Shayefar, do hereby depose and swear as follows:\n\n1. Lam an attorney admitted to practice and in good standing in the Commonwealth\nof Massachusetts and the State of California.\n\n2. Ireceived my B.A. degree in Mathematics, my B.S. degree in Computer Science\nand my MLS. degree in Computer Science from the University of California, Santa Barbara in\n2008. I received by my J.D. from the Boston University School of Law in 2012.\n\n3. Lhave been a member of the Massachusetts Bar since 2012, a member of the\nNinth Circuit Court of Appeals since 2012, a member of the California Bar since 2013, a\n\nmember of the bar of the United States District Court of Massachusetts since 2013, a member of\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-5 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 2 of 3\n\nthe bar of the United States District Court of Central California since 2014, and a member of the\nEleventh Circuit Court of Appeals since 2016.\n\n4, [have been admitted pro hac vice in cases in the Federal District Court of Eastern\nTexas, the District Court of Nevada, the Southern District Court of New York, the Northern\nDistrict Court of Illinois, the Southern District Court of Florida, the District Court of Arizona\nand the District Court of Oregon.\n\n5. [have been counsel of record in at least fifteen cases in the Federal District\nCourts, the majority of which have been copyright cases.\n\n6. From November of 2012 through December of 2015, I was an associate of Boston\nLaw Group, PC. Since December of 2015, I have been of counsel to Boston Law Group, PC.\n\n7. In my positions at Boston Law Group, PC, I have acted as outside general counsel\nfor the Defendants in the above captioned action.\n\n8. Attorney Val Gurvits of Boston Law Group, PC is counsel of record for the\nDefendants in the above captioned action.\n\n9. My hourly rate in this matter has been $300 per hour. It is my understanding that\nthis rate is considered under-market for an attorney with my technical background and\nspecialization in intellectual property and internet related law.\n\n10. The present case was a time intensive one, made more so by the aggressive\nlitigation positions taken by the Plaintiff which included numerous (unnecessary and\nunsuccessful) motions brought by Plaintiffs throughout the case.\n\n11. Despite all of this, I believe that the total amounts invoiced to the clients by the\nentire litigation defense team \u2014 in the neighborhood of $1 50,000 \u2014 were incredibly reasonable,\n\nparticularly given the results obtained.\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-5 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 3 of 3\n\n12.  Itis my practice to keep contemporaneous time and expense records. I track my\ntime and expenses related to this matter through the billing software Amicus Attorney. The time\nand expenses I track in Amicus Attorney are automatically incorporated into Boston Law Group,\nPC\u2019s invoices.\n\n13. Given the complexity of the issues raised, the Plaintiff\u2019 s litigation strategies and\ntactics, and the results obtained for the clients, I believe the amounts billed to be more than\n\nreasonable.\n\nSigned under the pains and penalties of perjury this 1st day of August, 2016.\n\nNAS\n\nMatthew Shayefar\n\n","ocr_status":1,"date_upload":"2024-06-29T12:28:05.131404-07:00","document_number":"148","attachment_number":5,"pacer_doc_id":"051016810056","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Affidavit","acms_document_guid":""},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/404233395/","id":404233395,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/148/6/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2024-06-29T11:54:25.673253-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-30T02:07:15.330906-07:00","sha1":"2b5653345c800d7d6eaa07fb9e7659bcd0f7dd56","page_count":3,"file_size":745856,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.148.6.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.148.6.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 1of3\n\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA\n\nMIAMI DIVISION\nCASE NO.: 1:15-cv-22134-UU\n\nHYDENTRA HLP INT. LIMITED,\na foreign corporation d/b/a METART,\n\nPlaintiff,\nVS.\n\nCONSTANTIN LUCHIAN, an individual,\nKONSTANTIN BOLOTIN, an individual,\nSUN SOCIAL MEDIA, INC., a corporation,\nindividually and d/b/a PLAY VID.COM,\nFEEDVID.COM, PLAYVIDS.COM, and\nPEEKVIDS. COM; PLAYVID.COM;:\nFEEDVID.COM; PLAY VIDS. COM;\nPEEKVIDS.COM and;\n\nand John Does 1-20,\n\nDefendants.\n/\n\nDECLARATION OF EVAN FRAY-WITZER\n\nI, Evan Fray-Witzer, do hereby depose and swear as follows:\n\nl. I am an attorney admitted to practice and in good standing in the Commonwealth\nof Massachusetts.\nDs I received my B.S. degree from Boston University in 1989 and my J.D. from\n\nNortheastern University School of Law in 1993,\n\n3, I have been a member of the Massachusetts Bar since 1993, a member of the New\nHampshire Bar since 1994, a member of the bar of the United States District Court for the Districts of\nMassachusetts and New Hampshire since 1995, a member of the bar for of the First Circuit Court of\n\nAppeals since 1997, a member of the bar of the United States Supreme Court since 2011, a member of the\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 2 of 3\n\nbar for of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals since 2012, and a member of the bar for the Eleventh Circuit\nCourt of Appeals since 2016.\n\n4, I have been admitted pro hac vice in cases in the Federal District Courts of Arizona, the\nNorthern District of California, the Southern District of Florida, the Northern District of Iowa, the\nNorthern District of Illinois, the District of Nevada, the Southern District of New York, and the District of\nOregon.\n\n5; I have been counsel of record in more than five dozen cases in the Federal District\nCourts, the majority of which have been copyright cases, and more than a dozen cases in the Federal\nCourts of Appeal.\n\n6. Iam a co-founder of Ciampa Fray-Witzer, LLP, which began operating in 2009. Prior to\nthat, I ran a solo practice for a decade, from 1999 to 2009. Prior to that, I had spent four years at a small\nlitigation boutique firm, Yurko & Bery, P.C., and before that I was a litigation associate with Hutchins,\nWheeler & Dittmar, P.C., a large Boston law firm. Prior to joining Hutchins, Wheeler & Dittmar, I spent\na year as a law clerk to the Justices of the Superior Court.\n\n7. ] am also of counsel to the Boston Law Group. Attorney Val Gurvits of the Boston Law\nGroup is counsel of record for the Defendants in this action.\n\n8. My hourly rate in this matter has been $450 per hour. It is my understanding that this\nrate is considered to be somewhat under-market for an attorney with more than 20 years of experience,\nparticularly for attorneys practicing in the area of high-tech copyright litigation.\n\n9. My firm does not typically charge for many of the overhead expenses routinely billed to\nclients by other firms. For example, although I performed many hours of online database (Lexis) research\nin this matter, we do not pass along the Lexis costs to the client. | have also not billed the client for any\nin-house copying, mailing, or delivery costs.\n\n10. The present case was a time intensive one, made more so by the aggressive litigation\npositions taken by the Plaintiff which included numerous (unnecessary and unsuccessful) motions\n\nbrought by the Plaintiffs throughout the case.\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 148-6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 3 of 3\n\n11. Despite all of this, | believe that the total amounts invoiced to the clients by the entire\nlitigation defense team \u2014 totaling $162,165.00 \u2014 were incredibly reasonable, particularly given the results\nobtained.\n\n12. It is my practice to keep contemporaneous time and expense records. I track my time and\nexpenses through my billing software, RTG Billing. I provided my time and expense reports to the\nBoston Law Group, which, in turn, incorporated those amounts in its invoices.\n\n13. Given the complexity of the issues raised, the Plaintiffs\u2019 litigation strategy, and the\n\nresults obtained for the clients, | believe the amounts billed to be more than reasonable.\n\nSigned under the pains and penalties of perjury this 2\"! day of August, 2016.\n\nEvan Fray-Witzg\n\n","ocr_status":1,"date_upload":"2024-06-29T12:28:05.600564-07:00","document_number":"148","attachment_number":6,"pacer_doc_id":"051016810057","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":2,"description":"Affidavit","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.323810-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-29T11:54:25.073369-07:00","date_filed":"2016-08-02","time_filed":null,"entry_number":148,"recap_sequence_number":"2016-08-02.002","pacer_sequence_number":446,"description":"MOTION for Attorney Fees by Konstantin Bolotin, Constantin Luchian, Sun Social Media, Inc.. Responses due by 8/19/2016 (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit, # 2 Exhibit, # 3 Affidavit, # 4 Affidavit, # 5 Affidavit, # 6 Affidavit)(Cobb, Brady) (Entered: 08/02/2016)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/171244028/","id":171244028,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/176529099/","id":176529099,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/147/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.309198-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-30T02:07:12.072411-07:00","sha1":"778df217b9364498c875a171482c299c9284600d","page_count":6,"file_size":168519,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.147.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.147.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 147 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 1 of 6\n\n\n\n\n                                UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                                SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA\n\n                                          MIAMI DIVISION\n\n                                                                      Case No.\n  HYDENTRA HLP INT. LIMITED,                                      1:15-cv-22134-UU\n  a foreign corporation d/b/a METART,\n\n       Plaintiff,\n\n  v.\n\n  CONSTANTIN LUCHIAN, an individual,\n  KONSTANTIN BOLOTIN, an individual,\n  SUN SOCIAL MEDIA, INC., a corporation,\n  individually and d/b/a PLAYVID.COM,\n  FEEDVID.COM, PLAYVIDS.COM and\n  PEEKVIDS.COM; PLAYVID.COM;\n  FEEDVID.COM; PLAYVIDS.COM;\n  PEEKVIDS.COM; and\n  John Does 1-20,\n\n       Defendants.\n\n\n    DEFENDANTS\u2019 MOTION FOR AN ENLARGEMENT OF TIME FOR THE FILING\n   AND/OR CONSIDERATION OF ITS MOTION FOR ATTORNEY\u2019S FEES OR IN THE\n     ALTERNATIVE MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AN AMENDED MOTION FOR\n                          ATTORNEY\u2019S FEES\n\n           Defendants Sun Social Media, Inc. (\u201cSSM\u201d), Constantin Luchian, and Konstantin Bolotin\n\n  by and through undersigned counsel and pursuant to Local Rule 7.3(b) and all authorities cited\n\n  herein respectfully move this court to enter an Order enlarging the filing and briefing schedule\n\n  by thirty (30) days on Defendants\u2019 Motion for Attorney\u2019s Fees and Costs (the \u201cMotion\u201d), which\n\n  is being filed contemporaneously herewith, and/or granting Defendants leave to file an amended\n\n  Motion for Attorney\u2019s Fees, and in support thereof state the following:\n\n           1.       On June 2, 2016, this Court entered its Order (D.E. 138) granting Defendants, Sun\n\n  Social Media, Inc. and Konstantin Bolotin\u2019s Motion for Summary Judgment as to counts I-V of\n\n                                                    1\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 147 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 2 of 6\n\n\n\n\n  Plaintiff\u2019s First Amended Complaint (which alleged copyright violations under the Digital\n\n  Millennium Copyright Act. In the same Order, the Court also granted the Motion for Summary\n\n  Judgment filed by Constantin Luchian (D.E. 72).\n\n         2.      As the prevailing parties on Plaintiffs\u2019 claims under the Digital Millennium\n\n  Copyright Act, Defendants are entitled to an award of reasonable attorney\u2019s fees from Plaintiff.\n\n  See 17 U.S.C. section 505.\n\n         3.      In accordance with Local Rule 7.3(a), Defendants\u2019 Motion must be filed within\n\n  sixty (60) days of the Court\u2019s order granting Defendants\u2019 Motion for Summary Judgment,\n\n  namely on or before August 2, 2016.\n\n         4.      Contemporaneous with the filing of this motion for enlargement of time,\n\n  Defendants are timely filing their Motion in accordance with Local Rule 7.3(a).\n\n         5.      Due to undersigned counsel and co-counsel\u2019s extremely active litigation\n\n  schedules, including being on multiple trial dockets and/or having to file and argue several\n\n  dispositive motions, a meaningful good faith conference has not occurred between Plaintiff and\n\n  Defendants with respect to the potential resolution of the specific relief sought in the Motion as\n\n  is required under Local Rule 7.3(b). Instead, due to the time constraints caused by the\n\n  aforementioned litigation schedule, Plaintiff will receive a copy of Defendant\u2019s Motion and\n\n  incorporated exhibits (which include all of the documents required by Local Rule 7.3(a)) on the\n\n  same day that the Motion is filed.\n\n         6.      Notwithstanding the foregoing, Defendants and Plaintiffs did thoroughly discuss\n\n  and attempt to negotiate Defendants entitlement to attorney\u2019s fees and the amount requested at\n\n  the court ordered mediation conference that occurred on June 6, 2016 before Mark A. Buckstein.\n\n  It is important to note that the mediation at issue occurred four (4) days after the Court entered its\n\n\n\n                                                    2\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 147 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 3 of 6\n\n\n\n\n  order granting Defendants\u2019 Motion for Summary Judgment. Suffice it to say that Plaintiff clearly\n\n  and repeatedly rejected Defendants\u2019entitlement to legal fees and the amounts requested.\n\n         7.      Nonetheless, undersigned counsel and his colleagues take the Court\u2019s Local Rules\n\n  very seriously, and more importantly ardently believe in the ability of counsel to resolve disputes\n\n  by reasonable and good faith communications. Undersigned counsel would like Plaintiff to have\n\n  the opportunity to thoroughly review the Motion and all exhibits, and thereafter for the parties to\n\n  confer in good faith to attempt to resolve the amount of attorney\u2019s fees sought in the Motion in\n\n  the spirit of Local Rule 7.3(b). Defendants sincerely apologize for the delay in providing the\n\n  Motion to Plaintiff, and further apologize to this Court for having to use the Court\u2019s time to\n\n  address this issue.\n\n         8.      Accordingly, Defendants respectfully request that this Honorable Court enter an\n\n  order enlarging the time for Plaintiff to file its Response to the Motion by thirty (30) days which\n\n  will afford Plaintiff the time delineated in Local Rule 7.3(b) to review the Motion and to confer\n\n  with Defendants regarding the potential resolution of issues raised therein. Alternatively,\n\n  Defendants request that in event that the Court finds that Defendants\u2019 did not comply with Local\n\n  Rule 7.3(b), albeit not intentionally but instead due to the aforementioned good cause, that\n\n  Defendant\u2019s Motion be stricken without prejudice, with Defendants being granted leave to re-file\n\n  an Amended Motion for Attorney\u2019s Fees on or before September 2, 2016. See Sriskada v.\n\n  Harbor Pita, Inc., 2014 WL 3908206 *2 (S.D. Fla. 2014), and I.T.N. Consolidators, Inc. v.\n\n  Northern Marine Underwriters, Ltd., 2016 WL 3892428 at *3 (S.D. Fla. 2016)(denying motion\n\n  for attorney\u2019s fees without prejudice that did not comply with the provisions of Local Rule\n\n  7.3(b), but granting leave to file an amended motion for attorney\u2019s fees that is in compliance with\n\n  Local Rule 7.3(b)).\n\n\n\n                                                   3\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 147 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 4 of 6\n\n\n\n\n         9.      This motion is not made for the purposes of delay, and no party will prejudiced by\n\n  the granting of the relief sought herein. To the contrary, Plaintiff will suffer no harm whatsoever\n\n  as Plaintiff has appealed this Court\u2019s Order (D.E. 138) granting summary judgment to\n\n  Defendants (which is the genesis of Defendants\u2019 claims for fees) to the United States Court of\n\n  Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, and said appeal is only in its preliminary stages. Thus, the\n\n  granting of additional time for the parties to review and confer in regards to Defendants Motion\n\n  will not cause Plaintiff to suffer any harm.\n\n                        Certificate of Compliance with Local Rule 7.1(a)(3)\n\n           I hereby certify that counsel for Movant has conferred with Plaintiff\u2019s counsel via email\n  in a good faith effort to resolve the issues raised in this Motion, and Plaintiff\u2019s objected to the\n  relief sought herein.\n                                                           /s/ Brady J. Cobb\n\n  Respectfully submitted this 2nd day of August, 2016.\n\n                                                 COBB EDDY, PLLC\n                                                 642 Northeast Third Avenue\n                                                 Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33304\n                                                 Telephone (954) 527-4111\n                                                 Facsimile (954) 900-5507\n\n                                                 By: ___/s/ BRADY J. COBB_______\n                                                 BRADY J. COBB, ESQUIRE\n                                                 Florida Bar No. 031018\n                                                 bcobb@cobbeddy.com\n                                                 Attorney for Defendants Constantin\n                                                 Luchian, Konstatin Bolotin, and Sun\n                                                 Social Media Inc.\n\n                                                 /s/ Valentin Gurvits\n                                                 Valentin D. Gurvits (pro hac vice)\n                                                 BOSTON LAW GROUP, PC\n                                                 825 Beacon Street, Suite 20\n                                                 Newton Centre, MA 02459\n                                                 Telephone: (617) 928-1804\n                                                 Facsimile: (617) 928-1802\n                                                 vgurvits@bostonlawgroup.com\n\n\n\n                                                    4\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 147 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 5 of 6\n\n\n\n\n                                  CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\n         I hereby certify that a true and correct copy of the foregoing was served electronically\n\n  via the CM/ECF electronic filing system on all counsel or parties of record on the service list\n\n  below this 2nd day of August, 2016.\n\n                                                       /s/ Brady J. Cobb\n                                                       Brady J. Cobb\n\n\n\n\n                                                   5\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 147 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/02/2016 Page 6 of 6\n\n\n\n\n                                 SERVICE LIST\n\n  Aaron Behar, Esquire\n  Jaclyn Behar, Esquire\n  BEHARBEHAR\n  1840 North Commerce Parkway\n  Suite One\n  Weston, Florida 33326\n  Telephone: (954) 688-7642\n  Facsimile: (954) 332-9260\n  AB@BeharBehar.com\n  JB@BeharBehar.com\n  Spencer D. Freeman\n  Freeman Law Firm, Inc.\n  1107 1/2 Tacoma Avenue South\n  Tacoma, Washington 98402\n  Telephone: (206) 516-3800\n  Facsimile: (206) 516-3888\n  sfreeman@freemanlawfirm.org\n\n\n\n\n                                       6\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2024-06-29T12:26:03.607199-07:00","document_number":"147","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"051016810025","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Motion for Extension of Time","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.294997-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-29T11:54:25.046056-07:00","date_filed":"2016-08-02","time_filed":null,"entry_number":147,"recap_sequence_number":"2016-08-02.001","pacer_sequence_number":444,"description":"MOTION for Extension of Time to File Motion for Attorney's Fees, or in the Alternative Motion for Leave to File an Amended Motion for Attorney's Fees by Konstantin Bolotin, Constantin Luchian, Sun Social Media, Inc. Responses due by 8/19/2016 (Cobb, Brady). Added MOTION for Leave to File on 8/2/2016 (pes). (Entered: 08/02/2016)","tags":[]},{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/171244027/","id":171244027,"docket":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/dockets/4236813/","recap_documents":[{"resource_uri":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/recap-documents/176529098/","id":176529098,"tags":[],"absolute_url":"/docket/4236813/146/hydentra-hlp-int-limited-v-luchian/","date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.283317-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-30T02:07:12.291993-07:00","sha1":"ec36b1be5ad3a2d8dc5793e4678fd3650ed1f0a9","page_count":3,"file_size":232261,"filepath_local":"recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.146.0.pdf","filepath_ia":"https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575/gov.uscourts.flsd.464575.146.0.pdf","ia_upload_failure_count":null,"thumbnail":null,"thumbnail_status":0,"plain_text":"Case 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 146 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/12/2016 Page 1 of 3\n                Case: 16-14813 Date Filed: 07/06/2016 Page: 1 of 2\n\n\n                             UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS                                                    ABM\n                                FOR THE ELEVENTH CIRCUIT\n                                                                                          Jul 11, 2016\n                                ELBERT PARR TUTTLE COURT OF APPEALS BUILDING\n                                              56 Forsyth Street, N.W.\n                                              Atlanta, Georgia 30303\n                                                                                                      MIA\n  David J. Smith                                                                        For rules and forms visit\n  Clerk of Court                                                                        www.ca11.uscourts.gov\n\n\n                                              July 11, 2016\n\n  Aaron Behar\n  BeharBehar\n  1840 N COMMERCE PKWY STE 1\n  WESTON, FL 33326\n\n  Jaclyn Ann Behar\n  BeharBehar\n  1840 N COMMERCE PKWY STE 1\n  WESTON, FL 33326\n\n  Spencer D. Freeman\n  Freeman Law Firm, Inc.\n  1107 1/2 TACOMA AVE S\n  TACOMA, WA 98402\n\n  Appeal Number: 16-14813-E\n  Case Style: Hydentra HLP Int. Limited v. Constantin Luchian, et al\n  District Court Docket No: 1:15-cv-22134-UU\n\n  This Court requires all counsel to file documents electronically using the Electronic Case\n  Files (\"ECF\") system, unless exempted for good cause.\n\n  The referenced case has been docketed in this court. Please use the appellate docket number\n  noted above when making inquiries.\n\n  Attorneys who wish to participate in this appeal must be properly admitted either to the bar of\n  this court or for this particular proceeding pursuant to 11th Cir. R. 46-1. In addition, all attorneys\n  (except court-appointed counsel) who wish to participate in this appeal must complete and return\n  an appearance form within fourteen (14) days. Application for Admission to the Bar and\n  Appearance of Counsel Form are available on the Internet at www.ca11.uscourts.gov. The clerk\n  may not process filings from an attorney until that attorney files an appearance form. See 11th\n  Cir. R. 46-6.\n\n  11th Cir. R. 33-1(a) requires appellant to file a Civil Appeal Statement in most civil appeals. You\n  must file a completed Civil Appeal Statement, with service on all other parties, within 14 days\n  from the date of this letter. Civil Appeal Statement forms are available on the Internet at\n\fCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU Document 146 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/12/2016 Page 2 of 3\n                Case: 16-14813 Date Filed: 07/06/2016 Page: 2 of 2\n\n\n  www.ca11.uscourts.gov, and as provided by 11th Cir. R. 33-1(a).\n\n  FRAP 26.1 and the accompanying circuit rules on the Certificate of Interested Persons and\n  Corporate Disclosure Statement (CIP) provide that: (1) every party and amicus curiae must\n  include a CIP within every motion, petition, brief, answer, response, and reply filed; (2) in\n  addition, appellants and petitioners must file a CIP within 14 days after the date the case or\n  appeal is docketed in this court; and (3) within 14 days after the filing of the appellants' and\n  petitioners' CIP, all appellees, intervenors, respondents, and all other parties to the case or appeal\n  must file a notice either indicating that the CIP is correct and complete, or adding any interested\n  persons or entities omitted from the CIP.\n\n  On the same day a party or amicus curiae first files its paper or e-filed CIP, that filer must also\n  complete the court's web-based CIP at the Web-Based CIP link on the court's website. Pro se\n  filers (except attorneys appearing in particular cases as pro se parties) are not required or\n  authorized to complete the web-based CIP.\n\n  Pursuant to Eleventh Circuit Rule 42-1(b) you are hereby notified that upon expiration of (14)\n  days from this date, this appeal will be dismissed by the clerk without further notice unless the\n  default(s) noted below have been corrected:\n\n  File a Transcript Information Form, as required by Fed.R.App.P. 10(b)(1); a Transcript\n  Information Form is available from the district court clerk. Appellant is required to file and serve\n  copies of the form in accordance with the instructions included on the form. UNLESS A\n  TRANSCRIPT IS ORDERED, APPELLANT'S BRIEF MUST BE SERVED AND FILED\n  WITHIN 40 DAYS FROM JULY 6, 2016. See 11th Cir. R. 12-1 and 31-1.\n\n\n\n  Sincerely,\n\n  DAVID J. SMITH, Clerk of Court\n\n  Reply to: Gloria M. Powell, E\n  Phone #: (404) 335-6184\n\n                                                                     DKT-2 Appeal WITH Deficiency\n\fCase\nCase 1:15-cv-22134-UU\n     1:15-cv-22134-UU Document\n                        Document 146\n                                 144 Entered\n                                     Entered on\n                                              on FLSD\n                                                 FLSD Docket\n                                                      Docket 07/12/2016\n                                                             07/01/2016 Page\n                                                                        Page 3\n                                                                             1 of\n                                                                               of 3\n                                                                                  3\n                Case: 16-14813 Date Filed: 07/06/2016 Page: 1 of 3\n\n\n                                UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\n                                SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA\n\n                                       MIAMI DIVISION\n\n                                   CASE NO.: 1:15-cv-22134-UU\n\n     HYDENTRA HLP INT. LIMITED,\n     a foreign corporation d/b/a METART,\n\n                   Plaintiff,\n\n     vs.\n\n     CONSTANTIN LUCHIAN, an individual,\n     KONSTANTIN BOLOTIN, an individual,\n     SUN SOCIAL MEDIA, INC., a corporation,\n     individually and d/b/a PLAYVID.COM,\n     FEEDVID.COM, PLAYVIDS.COM, and\n     PEEKVIDS. COM; PLAYVID.COM;\n     FEEDVID.COM; PLAYVIDS. COM;\n     PEEKVIDS.COM and;\n     and John Does 1-20,\n\n                 Defendants.\n     __________________________________________/\n\n                                PLAINTIFF\u2019S NOTICE OF APPEAL\n\n            Notice is hereby given that Hydentra HLP Int. Limited d/b/a MetArt (hereinafter\n\n     referred to as \u201cPlaintiff\u201d or \u201cAppellant\u201d), hereby appeals to the United States Court of\n\n     Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit from the United States District Court for the Southern\n\n     District of Florida\u2019s Omnibus Order, dated June 2, 2016, specifically granting\n\n     Defendant\u2019s, Constantin Luchian, Motion for Summary Judgment; granting Defendants\u2019\n\n     Sun Social Media, Inc., and Konstantin Bolotin, Motion for Summary Judgment as to\n\n     Counts I\u2013V; and denying Plaintiff\u2019s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment. [D.E. 138].\n\n     A copy of the Order is attached hereto as Exhibit \u201cA\u201d. The Omnibus Order became a\n\n     final judgment on June 7, 2016, upon the District Court granting Plaintiff\u2019s Motion to\n\n\n\n                                                1\n\f","ocr_status":2,"date_upload":"2024-06-29T12:25:47.587000-07:00","document_number":"146","attachment_number":null,"pacer_doc_id":"051016724436","is_available":true,"is_free_on_pacer":null,"is_sealed":null,"document_type":1,"description":"Acknowledgment of Receipt from USCA","acms_document_guid":""}],"date_created":"2021-07-30T19:30:01.272670-07:00","date_modified":"2024-06-29T11:54:25.019484-07:00","date_filed":"2016-07-11","time_filed":null,"entry_number":146,"recap_sequence_number":"2016-07-11.001","pacer_sequence_number":440,"description":"Acknowledgment of Receipt of NOA from USCA re 144 Notice of Appeal,, filed by Hydentra HLP Int. Limited. Date received by USCA: 7/6/2016. USCA Case Number: 16-14813-E. (amb) (Entered: 07/12/2016)","tags":[]}],"entries_total":"https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/docket-entries/?count=on&docket=4236813&page_size=40"}